Page 1


The Chronicle




Duke Dining reduces MOP delivery hours Famed author criticizes NC eugenics past by Anna Koelsch THE CHRONICLE

Next time you have a lunchtime craving for Jimmy John’s, think again—Merchants on Points can now only be used at night. The Merchants on Points program recently limited the hours when students can use food points for delivery. Students can now order from select off-campus restaurants no earlier than 7 p.m. on weekdays, said Rick Johnson, assistant vice president for housing and dining. Some eateries that cannot meet the new dining expectations may be cut from the program, though at least one eatery will be added to MOP. The newest off-campus vendor to join—Dunkin’ Donuts—should be available for students to order from within the next couple of weeks, Johnson said. For the past three years, Duke has allowed restaurants to set their own hours during weekdays for students to order and use food points, Johnson said. The change in hours officially began Monday, Aug. 29, though vendors may still set their hours for MOP deliveries on weekends. “Last year the decision was made to bring [MOP] back to its original intent—late-night dining,” Johnson said. “We didn’t get the message out to vendors.... The vendors were not ready. This year we’re implementing the changes.” Johnson said MOP brought in about $3 million in revenue last year—roughly 10 percent of the $30 million total raised by dining. Duke Dining now requires participating MOP vendors to deliver food between 7 p.m. and midnight during weekdays, though eateries may continue delivering later than midnight, Johnson said. He acknowledged that


by Chinmayi Sharma THE CHRONICLE

North Carolina holds the title of the last state to end the practice of eugenics. Edwin Black, author of “War Against the Weak,” spoke at the Freeman Center for Jewish Life Tuesday about eugenics—the pseudo-science of manipulating the genetics of a population to favor certain traits and minimize the prevalence of others for the betterment of society—and its role in North Carolina’s history. Following World War II, Edwin Black the term was applied to the Nazi goal of creating a master race. Before the practice ended, most researchers estimated 65,000 people were sterilized under mandated sterilization programs in the United States. “The concept of eugenics was conceived here, on American soil, two to three decades before Hitler rose to power,” Black said. “The local tragedy of eugenics in North Carolina is actively connected to the Nazi movement in a genocide the state committed against its own people.” Recently, North Carolina has experienced heated debates as researchers and historians are pointing fingers at the state for having


Jasmin Aldridge, a senior, picks up food from Randy’s Pizza, a Merchants on Points vendor. Under the new program policy, the time window for deliveries will not open until 7 p.m. on weekdays.


Research retractions raise Fuqua to partner with important issues for scientists Kazakhstan business school by Melissa Dalis THE CHRONICLE

Scholarly research is being questioned at unprecedented levels, due to increasingly critical review processes and recent, high-profile retractions. During the last 10 years, the number of news papers published in research journals has analysis risen 44 percent, but the number of papers retracted has skyrocketed by more than 15 times, according to a recent story published by The Wall Street Journal. “The article says that the core basis of science is trust,” said Tom Katsouleas, dean of the Pratt School of Engineering. “I would say that trust is an important piece, but the first thing is

reproducibility.... Gradually, the scientific truth comes out.” He added that retractions are the result of a more thorough review process as well as scientists replicating experiments in order to test and possibly invalidate published data. “More people are looking at other people’s work, so things are coming through the surface more often,” said Dr. Robert Califf, vice chancellor for clinical research and director of the Duke Translational Medicine Institute. “I don’t think it’s that people have gotten more dishonest.” More highly publicized retractions have shed light on questionable research and led reviewers to implement SEE RETRACTIONS ON PAGE 6

by Lauren Carroll THE CHRONICLE

The Fuqua School of Business is once again expanding its horizons—this time to Kazakhstan. Fuqua—whose presence extends from Durham to China, India, Russia and several other nations—recently entered into an agreement with Nazarbayev University in Astana, Kazakhstan. Through the partnership, Fuqua will help NU to develop the Nazarbayev Business School and its MBA program, the partnership’s developers wrote in a combined email Monday. Jennifer Francis, senior associate dean for programs and Douglas and Josie Breeden professor, and Valerie Hausman, assistant dean of global business development and executive education, are the Fuqua administra-

tors developing the program. “Fuqua believes that in order to effect change in the world, it is important to actively engage in the regions of the world that matter,” Francis and Hausman said. “We will be involved to the extent that we can help promote innovation and critical thinking around global business issues. This is consistent with our global strategy.” Fuqua administrators anticipate that the NU MBA program will begin September 2012. Graduates of the Nazarbayev Business School will be granted an NU degree—not a Duke or a joint degree, Francis and Hausman said. Fuqua will be appropriately compensated SEE KAZAKHSTAN ON PAGE 7


Duke Buzz site taken down, Page 4

“...the punch line, if there is one, is that American religiosity is either stable or slowly declining.” —Professor Mark Chaves on religion in America. See Q&A page 5

McCallie reflects on legendary coach’s illness, Page 9

2 | WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 31, 2011



Quake activates ‘citizen science’ seismometer

For geology nut Carolyn McPherson, last week’s earthquake was “better than Christmas.” For two years, a tiny seismometer on the floor of McPherson’s basement laundry room in Charlottesville, Va., sat inert next to a stack of boxes crammed with rocks and fossils. The matchbox-size white plastic box recorded nary a tremble. But at 1:51 p.m. Tuesday, the seismometer sprang to life as a magnitude-5.8 quake shuddered across the region. When McPherson and her husband, Mike, checked their computer, they saw what she called a “nice set of tracings”; spiky blue,green and yellow lines displaying the earthquake’s jostling in three dimensions. ”We let out a cheer,” said McPherson, 65, a retired English professor, who added that she would have felt differently in the end if the quake had caused more damage. Via McPherson’s computer, the device sent a signal to Stanford University.




Now You See It: The Science of Attention and the Future of Learning in a Digital Age Perkins Library Rare Book Room, 4-6p.m. Professor Cathy Davidson will sign books.

Tryout for Duke’s Novice Rowing Team

Panetta willing to review Gadhafi’s wife and three military retirement reform children flee to Algeria WASHINGTON, D.C. — Less than two months on the job and Defense Secretary Leon Panetta has put his foot on a Pentagon third-rail issue by saying he is willing to look at reform of the 100-yearold military retirement system to save money.

BENGHAZI, Libya — Moammar Gadhafi’s wife and three of his children have apparently fled across the border into Algeria, underscoring how much of Libya has slipped out of the control of the former autocrat, who ruled the country for about 42 years.

East Duke 204D, 4:30-5p.m. The Duke Women’s Rowing Team will hold their information meeting to answer questions in relation to their sport.

DukeWELL Outreach Session Duke North Cafe, 5p.m. Starting today, Duke employees with Duke Select / Duke Basic insurance who qualify can earn $150 towards their medication copays.

AFB Florida: IMMIGRATION & GENDER info session Women’s Center, 6-6:30p.m. Undergraduate women students can sign up for this program.

TODAY IN HISTORY 1888: Jack the Ripper claims first victim.

“Despite having as many as 12 scholarship players held out of practice at some points during camp, Cutcliffe mentioned that the team did not allow the injuries to affect their morale. They showed up willing and ready to work everyday due in large part to the senior leadership of the team. ” — From The Blue Zone



at Duke...

The man who never alters his opinion is like standing water, and breeds reptiles of the mind. — William Blake

on the


on the


Hero’s Day Philippines


Nizar Mhani, a 30-year-old oral surgeon and an underground activist, takes part in erecting a wall in the former Green Sqaure, now called Martyrs’ Square. People have been putting photographs on the white laminated wall, which serves as a memorial to those who died during the uprising.

In the print edition of the August 26 article “Traveling with the Blue Devils,” T.J. Parekh was incorrectly identified as a fifth grader. He is a fourth grader. The Chronicle regrets the error.

Reservations Required

Published: September 23 Advertising Deadline: September 9 919-684-3811 101 W. Union Bldg. Durham, NC 27705


WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 31, 2011 | 3

ith Edwin Black Q&A with Before speaking at the Freeman Center for Jewish Life Tuesday night, author Edwin Black sat down with The Chronicle’s Caroline Fairchild to discuss his book, “War Against the Weak: Eugenics and America’s Campaign to Create a Master Race.” Black shared with us how his book relates to compensation for state-sponsored sterilization—an issue currently being discussed by the North Carolina legislature—and how state-sponsored eugenics relates to World War II and Adolf Hitler’s campaign against the Jewish population. The Chronicle: State-sponsored eugenics and compensation for state-sponsored sterilization is now before the North Carolina legislature. Can you tell me what your book contributes to this discussion? Edwin Black: My book shows how the local atrocities in North Carolina were organically linked to Hitler, the war against the Jews and the Holocaust. It was genocide when it started—they knew [sterilization] was genocide, and it continued even after World War II. Duke is deeply implicated and vectored into this process. Ironically, the sad story of what happened in North Carolina echoes into the ovens of Auschwitz. My book documents this through a series of dismal nightmares. North Carolina was the last to stop this process, and I believe it will be the first to offer compensation. Its place in history will be transmogrified in history as one of darkness to that of light. TC: As the debate stands right now, what do you think North Carolina legislature should do to address the issue? EB: The state of North Carolina can attempt to make a down payment on compensation. There were 8,000 victims in total, but they will never be able to compensate the real victims because I am speaking for the never born. They are not with us. You will not find them. We must make compensation to show the gravity of the crime.... We want them to move forward with the legislation, but they are asking, ‘Why are we finding out about this now?’ It’s because the institutions responsible for exposing the crime were all responsible

for perpetrating the crime. This was not a crusade of men in white sheets burning crosses—this was a crusade of women and men in white lab coats in three-


Author Edwin Black delivers a speech at the Freeman Center for Jewish Life Tuesday evening, discussing his new book.

piece suits in broad daylight working not in dead light but in the bright light of legislative session. TC: The movie trailer for your book says that advocates of eugenics and sterilization consider themselves liberals, progressives and utopians who envision a world with one master race. What would the world be like if this was achieved? EB: No one would exist but people who resembled themselves. We would have arrived in utopia.... Utopia means nowhere in Greek. The Greek philosophers who originated the term knew it could never be achieved. There is no way that the men and women of eugenics could’ve achieved their goal of creating a master race in a master society by eliminating 90 percent of the war. Then who would drive them where they had to be driven? Who would give the great ideas? Where would that come from? The question of what the world would be is as fictitious as trying to get there. This is what the blind and fake science shows and history shows. Hitler could not make it happen. TC: One of the tag-lines of “War Against the Weak” is: “It began on Long Island and ended at Aushwitz... and yet it never really stopped.” What do you mean by that statement? EB: It never stopped because [of] all the organizations that sponsored eugenics. Various university departments—mainly after World War II—changed the name from eugenics to genetics, except in North Carolina where they continued to sterilize individuals into the 1970s. And it was not just sterilization—they had concentration camps, they had marriage voiding and marriage prohibition. TC: What would you like Duke undergraduate students to get out of your discussion? EB: I hope that they understand that Hitler’s war against the Jews was actually a part of a larger war against all of humanity. The austerities that affected the local people in North Carolina were connected to the Holocaust, not only in theory but in contemporaneous observation.

Exciting Courses in the

Department of Religion Sign up today! REL 136-01

Contemporary Jewish Thought (Sh. Goldman) TuTh 2:50-4:05pm REL 153AS-01

Religion in Black America (M. Peters) MW 2:50-4:05pm


REL 154S-01

Qur’an Over Time (M. Kadivar) TuTh 2:50-4:05pm REL 185S-01

Early Christians in the Pagan World (K. Olson) MW 1:15 – 2:30pm

Come see what treasures are in store!

• Flexible Schedule • Work Study/Non-Work Study Positions Available For more information, contact Don Lazaroe via phone at 684.8152 or e-mail at

One Team. One Common Goal. To Provide Quality Products and Service to the Duke University Community.

4 | WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 31, 2011


Low traffic dooms online calendar Duke Buzz by Karina Santellano THE CHRONICLE

The Buzz has gone silent. The Office of Undergraduate Education has taken down the online student calendar, Duke Buzz, due to a low rate of student use, administrators said. With the elimination of Buzz, the Office seeks to expand usage of the existing, though redesigned, Events@Duke online calendar. The new version of the calendar will be launched Sept. 7. “Last [Fall], the Office of Student Activities and Facilities collected data from students about the use of the Buzz student calendar and concluded that there was not widespread awareness or use of Buzz among Duke students,” said Deborah Johnson, the assistant vice provost and director of student administrative services. “Thus, they recommended shutting down the Buzz calendar.” The Buzz URL now redirects to Events@ Duke. Budget cuts were not the primary concern in ending Duke Buzz, said Susan Kauffman, director of communications for the office of undergraduate education. Kauffman also solicited student input for the new Events@Duke calendar. The Buzz system’s software was free, she said, adding that the operators of the site were instead just concerned that student usage did not justify the site’s maintenance. “Even the students who helped us design it didn’t use it,” Kauffman said. “Some people aren’t using it [in the age of social media].” On average, there were about 400 visits per day to the Buzz calendar website, Johnson said. There is an average of about 1,200 visits per day to Events@Duke. “I never knew about Duke Buzz,” soph-

omore Melanie Sperling said.“I do not think there was enough publicity done for this website.” Sperling noted, however, that she would have used Duke Buzz if she had known about it. “I used it once or twice,” junior Adrianna Oh said. “I felt that it was more like an independent site that no one checked.” Developed in 2009 by Duke University Union and the Office of Undergraduate Education, Buzz was an offshoot of Duke’s main events calendar, Events@Duke. It aimed to highlight events happening on campus for the student body and to allow for groups small and large to post events on a single student calendar, Kauffman said. “Duke Student Government came to Steve Nowicki, the dean and vice provost of undergraduate education and I, and said that a student-friendly calendar was needed,” she added. The new form of Events@Duke will feature several interactive changes, Kauffman said. Anyone will be able to post an event on Events@Duke and connect the calendar to Facebook, Twitter and personal calendars by pressing on the “ShareThis” widgets. The redesigned site will also offer specialized search categories, such as events with free food. The Duke University Union has adapted to the elimination of Duke Buzz by creating an online calendar at that highlights DUU events. “Ideally, the DUU calendar website will take up the void of the Duke Buzz calendar no longer existing and hopefully market our events,” DUU President Rachel Sussman, a senior, said. Student involvement remains a determining factor in the ultimate success of

Events@Duke, Kauffman noted. “Mainly, what we’re hoping is that everyone—especially students—with a Duke event will post on Events@Duke, so that

we have one centralized place to find out what’s going on,” she said. “A calendar is only as good as its content, which is why widespread participation is crucial.”

Meals on wheels


Food trucks lined the Main West Quadrangle Tuesday evening during the Welcome to West event, a part of the Sophomore Year Experience organized by Housing, Dining and Residence Life.

Fall 2011 Political Science Courses Do you want to learn about China or State Failure or Political Parties in a small-class setting? We have several courses, including: POLSCI 110 American Political Parties WF 10:05-11:20

Professor Kyle Scott

POLSCI 117 Asian Politics TTH 4:25-5:40

Professor Jae Shin

POLSCI 137 Campaigns and Elections WF 11:40-12:55

Professor Kyle Scott

POLSCI 144 Force and Statecraft MW 10:05-11:20 Professor Kristen Harkness

POLSCI 166 Congress and the President WF 11:40-12:55

Professor Daniel Magleby

POLSCI 168 Analysis of Political Decision Making TTH 10:05-11:20

Professor David Skarbek

Special Topics Courses: POLSCI 199D.02 Pirates, Privateers and Power MW 1:15-2:30 Professor Kristen Harkness This course examines the complex historical relationships between states and privatized maritime violence (piracy, privateering, and maritime terrorism). Topics include Ancient Rome and Pompey’s campaign against Mediterranean piracy, French and English privateering in the Hundred Years War, great power competition in the Caribbean, privateering and war in early America, the Barbary Wars, and modern piracy and the threat of maritime terrorism.

POLSCI 199BS Democracy and Social Choice TTH 4:25-5:40 Professor Emerson Niou This course is designed to focus on basic questions about the impact of political institutions in democratic states. The topics of interest include electoral systems, representative districting, the timing of elections, executive responsibility in presidential and parliamentary systems, party formation, etc.

POLSCI 199CS Modeling Economic and Social Systems

POLSCI 177B American Constitutional Development

TH 10:05-12:35 Professor Scott deMarchi This course will explore how to model human behavior in the substantive areas of economics, political science, and sociology. The focus will be on the skills needed to do original research.

TTH 10:05-11:20

PS299DS.05 Law and Politics in the Global Economy

Professor Guy Charles

POLSCI 179 US Comparative State Politics MW 10:05-11:20

Professor Kerry Haynie

POLSCI 182 China and the World TTH 11:40-12:55

Professor Jae Shin

M 2:50-5:20 Professor Tim Buthe Seminar for juniors and seniors. Examines the relationship between political power, economic power, and law in the world economy. Specific topics include NGOs and multinational corporations in environmental governance, the role of regulations and regulatory failure in the global financial crisis, the politics of food and food safety, antitrust enforcement and its effect on market competition. For juniors and seniors opportunity to write honors paper on any aspect of the relationship btw politics and economics. Counts for PubPol, MMS.


WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 31, 2011 | 5

ith Mark Chaves Q&A with For many Americans, religion is on the decline. According to Duke professor Mark Chaves’ new book “American Religion: Contemporary Trends,” Americans have less confidence in religious leaders and waning interest in worship—despite political rhetoric that can present a misconception about the prevalence of Christianity. The Chronicle’s Chandra Swanson spoke with Chaves, professor of sociology, religion and divinity, about the new trend in religious beliefs and why he believes faith is taking a backseat. The Chronicle: First, can you please give an overview of the argument you present in your new book? Mark Chaves: Basically, it is about what is changing and what is not changing about American religion. It’s really a factual book, but the punch line, if there is one, is that American religiosity is either stable or slowly declining. There’s a lot of discussion and debate about this. There is nothing, no indicator that traditional religiosity is going up. There are some that are stable, and some indicators are in decline. So we’re stable or in slow decline—I think it is slow decline. Of course, some people disagree. TC: Why is tracking religious trends of interest to you personally? What caused you to pursue this research question? MC: There’s a lot of misunderstanding out there about American religion, and as a sociologist and social scientist, I like to get those facts straight, and I like to think that the public is getting the facts straight. There’s a lot of misinformation out there. So through the research and the book, I am hoping to help set the public straight and to help keep the public informed. TC: You highlight the changes within

religious practice. What is an example of an important change? MC: This is a good example of ambiguity in the indicators. If you look at the basic belief in God—the people who say that they believe in a god—over 90 percent of Americans still believe in God. So for some people, this is a sign of stability, that almost everybody in the U.S. believes in God. Especially in comparison with other countries, that’s a significant percentage. In 1950s, though, that number was 99 percent. Today, it is 91 percent. Again, you

could look at that and say, “Wow. That’s almost everybody and, decline [in American religiosity] or not, that’s almost everyone, that’s stability.” I disagree, though. It is similar to the glass half-full, glass halfempty argument. You could emphasize the fact that it’s 91 percent now or emphasize the 99 percent and the decline from there. This is a pretty good example of the interpretative problem. And there are a lot of indicators of that sort. TC: What has made you take the stance that religion is in decline?

MC: All things considered, I think that religion is slowing down, in decline, because of the fact that, looking at change, everything is clearly going in the decline direction. Let me give an example: One of indicators is the 18 percent of people who say they have no religion. Ask them, “What’s your religion?” and they say, “Nothing, I have no religion.” More than 80 percent of Americans do. In comparison to the rest of the world, that’s a significant number. But in the 1950s, it was 3 percent who had no religion. Those kind of examples, wherever you look, show change in that kind of direction. It’s like global warming or climate change. Maybe one indicator you could discount, but when you take all the indicators into account, it is clearly declining. TC: Did any of your findings surprise you in particular? MC: One surprising finding was the increase in percentage of Americans who think that religious leaders should not influence politics. It’s a surprise to me because it is something that has gone on for awhile. In other words, the amount of backlash was surprising. I’ll give you some statistics—in 1991, 30 percent of Americans disapproved of religious influence in politics. In 2008, 44 percent strongly agreed that religious leaders should not be involved. The majority of Americans still agree a little bit or strongly of course, but the magnitude of the change surprised me a little bit. Another thing I think is surprising is the megachurch phenomenon. Everyone knows about it—it’s been going on since the 1970s probably.


Professor and author Mark Chaves discusses the changing American religious landscape in his book.


We’ve Moved! Now Open The Bicycle Chain at 5400 Durham Chapel Hill Blvd.


Welcome Back Sale! OFF any Adult Bike*



*Offer cannot be combined, nor used in conjunction with any other discount. Offer applies to new bicycles only. Must be paid in full at time of purchase. Expiration Date: August 31st, 2011

6 | WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 31, 2011

RETRACTIONS from page 1 more stringent policies to address fraud, said George Truskey, senior associate dean for research in Pratt and director of undergraduate studies in the Department of Biomedical Engineering. Truskey was also named chair of the department Aug. 10. “Twenty-five years ago, a scientist would probably dismiss [the idea of a retraction] and say ‘That’s impossible,’” he said. “But we’ve learned that it’s not impossible.” It is mostly incorrect data that accounts for the surge in the number of retractions—73.5 percent of the retracted papers were due to incorrect data and only 26.6 percent were a result fraudulent—or falsified—data. The high percentage of errors may be due to increasingly complicated data, Califf said, noting that small errors in computer programs can yield significant errors in the data. And though the number of retractions in the scientific community has increased overall, the number of retractions is still relatively low in comparison to the number of studies published. According to the study, among the 11,600 peer-reviewed journals considered in the study, 22 retractions occurred in 2001, 139 in 2006 and 339 last year. In the social sciences, errors often occur when models are incomplete or exclude important variables,


44% increase in research publications since 2001

1500% increase in publication retractions since 2001

73.5% of retractions are due to error, rather than intentional fraud


Dean of the Social Sciences Angela O’Rand said. Since studies in the social sciences and humanities are often more difficult to replicate and less precise, retractions are less common, O’Rand noted. “If an article is published and makes a mistake, or the model wasn’t good, often the journal publishes the criticism,” she said. “The response becomes a public discourse debate, and the response isn’t so clear cut.” Damaging data False data can be severely damaging if it is not invalidated immediately. “It’s not just an issue of ethical behavior,” Truskey said. “In the biomedical area, work can have significant consequences on health, and there have been some cases where that has happened.” Following the retractions of two papers by Dr. Anil Potti, a former Duke cancer researcher, a N.C. law firm began investigating whether the research led to faulty treatment methods for patients, The Chronicle reported in February. Although Califf said the Duke School of Medicine has had some retractions in the past, on average there are zero retractions per year at the school, Califf said, though he added that the past year was an obvious exception. “We’re amidst one of the biggest retractions in medical history,” Califf said. “[Anil Potti] was a co-author on about 40 papers that had original data that was generated at Duke, and we’re in the process of retracting about a third of those papers, and there are another third... being partially retracted.” Pressure to publish Researchers often face pressure to publish papers from their superiors, community, peers and their own expectations. Recruited faculty are expected to teach, research and be leaders in the field, Truskey said. The social sciences emphasize the quality of research produced more than the quantity of papers published, O’ Rand noted. “The pressures at a place like Duke aren’t just to do research and publish, but to publish in high-level journals or to publish books that are highly regarded,” she explained. “To get more funding, you have to publish.” Everyone with a teaching title within Pratt is required to conduct research, Katsouleas said, adding that on average, Pratt faculty members each receive about $615,032 per year in grant research funding. Research is not only part of a professor’s job description but also a key component when determining promotion, he said. “One of the pressures is not from the institution but internally from competitive researchers is the desire to

be first,” Katsouleas said. “That creates a tension between being first and being right, and unfortunately, sometimes the core values get corrupted, and it becomes more important to be first than to be right.” The “publish or perish” saying, however, is an inappropriate depiction of the Pratt research environment, he added. “Faculty here at this level are so intent on making the discovery and competing with their peers to be the group that makes the discoveries that you don’t even think about publishing,” Katsouleas said. “You just think about doing the research, and the publishing is sort of the last step in the process.” More papers are being published due to other factors as well, including greater funding for research and an increase in collaboration among researchers, which lessens an individual’s workload, he added. Preventing errors and fraud Leading administrators in Pratt and the Trinity College of Arts and Sciences said they do not even remember a Duke study that has been retracted, with the exception of the Potti papers. If a study were to be retracted, however, administrators said repercussions for the researcher would depend on whether the retraction was due to error or fraud. “If [an article] was [published] early on in the field, someone would probably retract that article and not be particularly judged because of it,” Katsouleas said. “But in cases where they should have known or should have been more careful, then the scientific community would pass judgment and their reputation would be damaged—I think the worst penalty is the damage of reputation.” Katsouleas added that a pattern of incorrect data leading to retracted papers could potentially affect a professor’s chance for promotion. The appointment committee considering promotion would seriously consider the retraction in the decision process, he said, adding that he has never seen a retraction since he came to Pratt. Fraudulent data is a more serious—and more difficult to prove—offense, Califf said. “In general, if it’s proven that you’ve committed fraud on scientific data, that’s grounds for dismissal in almost anybody’s book,” he said. “But proving fraud is a hard thing to do.” Producing fraudulent data is not only considered an academic misconduct, but it is also illegal if the research is being funded by grants or other outside resources, Califf added. “Fraud is a serious problem and one that we all have to watch out for,” he said. “It’s an unfortunate situation, and it’s also one that takes a while to correct itself. It’s something we need to pay attention to.”

Don’t want to spend sleepless nights alone? Join The Chronicle! Come visit us during our information session today on East Campus at 6 p.m. in East Duke 204B.


WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 31, 2011 | 7

KAZAKHSTAN from page 1

global business leaders to come.”

for its role with NU, Francis and Hausman said, though they declined to comment further. The partnership grew out of Fuqua’s existing relationship with Russia and the Commonwealth of Independent States—a regional group of former Soviet countries, of which Kazakhstan is the largest. Fuqua has been developing its relationship with the country since 2009, and the agreement went into effect in July. A unique opportunity Francis and Hausman said Kazakhstan could be a major player in the world economy because of its wealth of natural resources, including oil. An educational relationship between Fuqua and a country of such growing importance would be beneficial for both Duke and NU. “Fuqua has an opportunity to inform the educational model of the 9th largest nation in the world, in geographic size,” they said. “Our faculty gain access to data, organizations and opportunities that are likely to impact their own research and consequently the student experience, both at NU and here at Fuqua.” Duke faculty members will also likely teach in the program. “We have spoken in broad terms to some of our faculty members but we are still in the very early stages of designing and recommending the NU MBA program calendar and course offerings,” Hausman wrote in an email Tuesday. “It will be impossible for faculty to make firm commitments until these details are worked out.” For this reason, Hausman added that the program was not yet comfortable with releasing the names of faculty likely headed for Kazakhstan. Fuqua currently has faculty members in several countries including India, China and South Africa. As of June, the school was having difficulty organizing and finding incentives for core Fuqua faculty to teach at the developing Duke Kunshan University in Kunshan, China. “Many are likely to find the opportunity exciting, unique and a way to gain a different perspective,” Francis and Hausman said. “It is not often that a faculty member has a chance to be part of such an ambitious academic undertaking, in a way that will impact generations of

Political challenges One of the primary challenges of the program is working in a political environment so different than that of the United States, Francis and Hausman said. There have been claims that Kazakhstan’s president Nursultan Nazarbayev, who built the University in his name, has limited political freedom, freedom of speech and feigned national success in order to boost Kazakhstan’s image. Some news outlets have also deemed Nazarbayev a dictator. Francis and Hausman noted, however, that Fuqua would not have entered this partnership if they were unsure that Kazakhstan would make education and academic freedom top priorities. Kazakhstan has also sought partnerships with several of Duke’s peer institutions including the University of Pennsylvania and Carnegie Mellon University. Kazakhstan could surely benefit from a partnership with an American institution, said Dr. Michael Merson, director of the Duke Global Health Institute and interim vice president and vice provost for global strategy and programs. Merson also said that he understands why some consider the Kazakh government to be controversial. “It’s an interesting program because it is in a region of the world that has been a bit turbulent and its trying to invest in terms of human capital,” he said. Merson, who has no technical oversight over the program since it does not offer a Duke degree, added that academic freedom is one of NU’s primary concerns, though he noted that he has only heard this from Fuqua administrators. The University has, however, had prior experience with Kazakhstan and its students. Bruce Kuniholm, dean of the Sanford School of Public Policy, has worked with Kazakh scholars in recent years through Sanford’s Duke Center for International Development that focuses on international mid-career and post-graduate education. The individuals he has worked with seem dedicated to improving their nation’s outlook despite the government’s sometimes unfavorable reputation. “They’ve invested a lot in education because what they want to do is educate their people and their elite to better their community,” Kuniholm said. Duke Medicine Global has also worked in Kazakhstan, performing hospital assessments in Astana—the nation’s capital and where NU is located.

A New


Member/ since 19Owner 92

Welcome Back Students

CHAVES from page 5 What is surprising is when I looked at the concentrations in a dozen different denominations—in every denomination—this concentration is happening. The phenomenon is just the tip of the iceberg of a deeper change where people are switching from smaller churches to larger churches. I’m not certain of other areas, but in the Protestant religions, the extent is surprising. In growing denominations, shrinking denominations, in liberal, in conservative, in every one—the concentration [in megachurches] is increasing. I think part of the story is an economic story. The economics of running churches shifted in the 1970s. Essentially, it became more and more difficult for smaller churches to maintain quality programming, the quality of the music, youth programs and even preaching. I think that pushed people out of the smaller churches into the larger churches that can still afford the well-organized, quality youth programming, for instance. TC: Is the faith being lost in religious leaders also affecting the general sense of spirituality? How have you seen the differences in religion and spirituality in your research? MC: Yes. One of the things that is going up is the percentage of people who say that they are spiritual but not religious. And in this, it is difficult to know exactly what people mean. It’s still a minority. And it’s still a majority that say that they are spiritual and religious, if you give them a chance to say that. But the percentage that say that they are spiritual is still going up, especially with young people. I looked at those under 40s, and in 1998, 11 percent of 18- to 39-year-olds reported that they were spiritual. In 2008, it was 18 percent. If what people mean by that is that they don’t really like organized religion, but still think of themselves as spiritual. It’s one way to explain. TC: Are there any last comments or insights that you would like to share? MC: I’d just emphasize where we started. This research is focused on setting the record straight, trying to make it clear what is changing and not changing. It’s to put the information out there so that people who want to know will be informed.

8 | WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 31, 2011

MOP from page 1 requiring some vendors to be open during that time window may be difficult, given that many restaurants close before midnight. There are currently 19 MOP eateries listed on Duke Dining’s website. Eleven eateries do not currently offer delivery from 7 p.m. to at least midnight and thus do not yet meet the criteria established by Duke Dining. The only eateries that currently include the required hours are Domino’s Pizza, Enzo’s Pizza Co., Jimmy John’s, Junior’s Grille, Papa John’s Pizza, Randy’s Pizza, Spartacus Restaurant and T.G.I. Friday’s. Nosh, a popular eatery in Erwin Terrace, is one such eatery that may be eliminated from MOP. Previously, Nosh offered students the opportunity to order food using points from 3 to 9 p.m., when the restaurant closes. Although Johnson said Nosh was among the three top-selling vendors for the first day of the revised MOP program, it closes before midnight and thus does not meet Duke Dining’s criteria to stay in the program. Carol Reardon, manager of Nosh, said she is strongly opposed to the new time window changes, adding that Nosh would most likely not stay open until midnight just to stay in the program. She noted that Duke Dining also required off-campus eateries to purchase phones for a new system to allow students to enter their DukeCard numbers, PIN codes and a tip, in order to participate in MOP. Furthermore, she said Duke Dining does not allow vendors to accept DukeCard payments at the restaurant itself. “It’s not fair to local businesses because we depend on Duke customers for our business,” Reardon said. “We depend on people with buying power and students have buying power. [Duke] already won’t let [students] come here with food points so we have to deliver. We would be losing a huge cross-


section of customers.” Johnson said the change in the time window will allow on-campus vendors to attract more lunchtime business without competition from MOP vendors. On-campus vendors are required to be open during certain hours during the day, and if their sales decline, their businesses may lose their viability, Johnson added. Another concern, Johnson said, is that students may miss out on the opportunity to dine communally and have discussions with other students if they have food delivered. “Given that there is take-out, which does not facilitate interaction, it still seemed that returning MOP to its original intent was the right thing to do,” Johnson said. Based on her experience taking MOP orders for Duke students at Nosh, Reardon said she disagrees with the general premise that students miss out on eating as a group if they order from off-campus eateries. “I’m not sure what the deal is,” Reardon said. “[Duke Dining] said students need to communally dine, but that’s how you all order.... You all are already communally dining.” Students were consulted about the change last year and they expressed a desire for late-night eating options, Johnson said. Duke Dining will continue to consult with the Duke University Student Dining Advisory Committee to gauge which off-campus eateries are most popular with students. Several students expressed strong discontentment with the idea that some MOP vendors may no longer be offered. Sophomore Forrest Etter said he usually uses MOP to order lunch, and is upset that he will no longer have the option to order using his food points during that time. “I’ve generally been dissatisfied with dining here,” Etter said. “Duke [on-campus dining] is such a rip-off, and having MOP as an alternative makes it seem more justifiable.”


Great Food. Low Price. Open Late.

Old School Veggie Burrito Regular Chicken Burrito Cheese Quesadilla Chicken Quesadilla Veggie Nachos Chips & Salsa

$2.86 $5.65 $1.41 $3.59 $4.12 $2.06

10% off with Duke ID

1920 1/2 Perry St. at Ninth St. Just a block from East Campus.

BLACK from page 1 engaged so actively in this controversial act. Black’s book has been widely acclaimed for uncovering many perspectives on the issue that were not widely known. He said he firmly believes that the legacy of eugenics in North Carolina and nationwide stems from racism and a desire to create a utopia. Historically, others have contested this viewpoint, saying that the practice was a brainchild of good intentions. The Supreme Court confirmed the legality of eugenics for certain people in the case Buck v. Bell in 1927. North Carolina passed its first sterilization law in 1919 and strengthened the law a decade later. In 1933, the Eugenics Board of North Carolina was created. Between 1950 and 1952—when most states were repealing their sterilization laws and shutting down their eugenics programs— North Carolina saw the single most active period of sterilization in its history. “I cannot begin to fathom why it is that when most states saw the horrors of the Holocaust and took their own eugenics laws off the books, our state moved forward and gained momentum,” State Rep. Paul Luebke, D-Durham. “My guess is that influential people, the right people, were backing these programs and investing heavily in them.” Throughout the course of the practice’s history, 7,600 people were forcibly sterilized in North Carolina, Luebke said. According to the EBNC, 23.6 percent of those sterilized had mental diseases, 71.4 percent were feeble-minded and 5 percent had epilepsy. The most recent case of sterilization in both state and national history occurred in 1973. “These people were considered unfit to reproduce by these pseudo-scientists and subjected to unofficial, unreliable intelligence tests that conveniently deemed members of lower socio-economic levels and colored populations as feeble-minded,” Black said. “The words ‘idiot’, ‘moron’ and ‘imbecile’ were coined during this period as medical diagnosis to justify sterilization.” Black added that no movement can exist without proper funding and named the Carnegie Institute for Science in Washington, D.C., and the Rockefeller Foundation in New York City as two of the most staunch supporters of eugenics. These groups provided the financial means to engage in eugenics research, experimentation and proliferation of

the idea across seas, namely in Germany. In the U.S., methods such as gas chambers and euthanasia were proposed to carry out the sentences of the Eugenics Boards, Black said. Although these sentences did not pass, 27 states did have legislation allowing these boards to mandate surgical sterilization and prohibit or nullify marriages. He pointed out, however, that the United Nations classifies all of these practices as genocide. “The truly interesting thing is that the idea of genocide originated with a Duke affiliate, Raphael Lemkin, who contributed to this set of human rights regulations,” Black said. He added that Duke contributed thousands of dollars to eugenics and founded the Eugenics Quarterly, publishing through 1969 when the journal changed its name to Social Biology. “Many write this off as misguided scientists... who consider themselves liberal progressives trying to reform society and scourge it of its weaker members for the greater good,” Black said. “It was, in reality, statesponsored genocide.” The state may issue a formal apology and a possible $20,000 compensation to each of the living victims of the legacy. According to state officials, at least 1,500 people were sterilized and are still alive. In 2003, Gov. Bev Perdue commissioned a study on North Carolina’s eugenics program—the same year legislators repealed the state eugenics law. Durham Mayor Bill Bell said he believes the preliminary August report by the Eugenics Task Force in North Carolina speaks for itself and that there should be no opposition to the notion of compensating victims. “It is in the hands of the state legislature,” Bell said. “I don’t know why they haven’t done it yet.” Charmaine Cooper, executive director of the North Carolina Justice for Sterilization Victims Foundation, said that this program is moving slowly but steadily due to the fact that victims are hesitant to reveal themselves. “Their files are what deters them,” she said. “On record, they have information that claims they are feeble-minded or insane or could even reveal that they were raped or the child of incest.” Luebke and Cooper said they have both been working to clear the confusion between fact and rhetoric surrounding this debate and hope to include this information—however dark—in the public school curriculum as proper acknowledgement of this history.

Sports The Chronicle

The joys of being a loser


WEDNESDAY August 31, 2011

Check out the Blue Zone for the first wrapup of Lunch with Cut, the weekly football press conference, just in time for Saturday’s opener against Richmond.


McCallie opens up on Summitt by Andrew Beaton THE CHRONICLE

“The pleasure of rooting for Goliath is that you can expect to win. The pleasure of rooting for David is that, while you don’t know what to expect, you stand at least a chance of being inspired.” So wrote Michael Lewis in his seminal book Moneyball. The line is so good I hope Brad Pitt or Jonah Hill utters it in the upcoming film adaptation premiering soon at a Southpoint theater near you. Andy Why do I like it? Because truer words have never been written about the sports fan’s experience. There’s a certain trepidation and misery that comes with pulling for the front-runner, like the New York Yankees or, for that matter, Duke Basketball. Anything that goes wrong with the master plan, a loss before a championship, means the season is a “failure.” You know the feeling from the Blue Devils’ loss to Arizona in the Sweet Sixteen last spring—“It’s not supposed to end like this. What will my Carolina friends say?!” It’s pulling for your team, but it’s a full-time job. However, when you pull for the underdog, you’ve got it easy. There are no expectations, so when your team wins, it means a heck of a lot more than it does to the front-runners spoiled by success.




Head coach Joanne P. McCallie first met Pat Summitt as an assistant coach at Auburn from 1988-1992.

A couple weeks ago, Joanne P. McCallie’s sister, Carolyn Clement, gave her a book entitled “Still Alice,” by Lisa Genova, saying, “Joanne, you must read this.” The novel tells the tale of a 50-year-old Harvard professor who struggles to deal with her uncertain future after being diagnosed with early-onset Alzheimer’s disease. Little did Coach McCallie know how quickly the book would hit home. About a week later, head coach of the Tennessee women’s basketball team Pat Summitt announced she had been diagnosed with the same condition. Arguably the most prolific coach in the sport’s history, Summitt has been at the helm of the Lady Vols program since 1974, capturing eight national championships and becoming the first and only NCAA Division I basketball coach—either men’s or women’s—to win over 1,000 games. Now familiar with the disease from reading “Still Alice,” McCallie better understands the pain that her fellow head coach is going through. “I’ve now completed that book and found it incredibly heart wrenching,” McCallie said. “But at the same time, clarifying how that works—the process of handling that kind of disease.” Although the two coaches do not share a close personal relationship, McCallie’s few interactions with Summitt have helped define her career. McCallie first came into contact with the legendary head coach when she got her first coaching gig as an assistant at Auburn from 1988-1992. With both teams competing in the SEC, McCallie got an up-close and personal look at Summitt and her coaching style. The future head coach of the Blue Devils learned one lesson quickly—sometimes you have to watch, and inevitably lose to, the best to try and become the best. SEE SUMMITT ON PAGE 10


Duke just focused on running by Sarah Elsakr THE CHRONICLE


With expectations at an all-time low in head coach David Cutcliffe’s first year, Andy Moore writes, fans embraced the four wins.

CORRECTION An Aug. 30 article, “Duke looks to take back ACC titlefromFSU,”incorrectlystatedFloridaStatehad won the ACC volleyball title last season. It should have said that Duke won the conference title by onegameoverNorthCarolina.Aprintgraphicrepeatedthemistake.TheChronicleregretstheerror.

For the Blue Devil women this year, there is no looking back. According to head coach Kevin Jermyn, the team’s strategy this season requires not thinking about upcoming races, end results or better placement. Instead, the team will try to focus on each day as it comes without thinking too far ahead. With a mindset like this, one might expect Jermyn’s team is in rebuilding mode, trying to avoid looking back at last year’s results as a predictor of this season’s success. In fact, the opposite is true of this year’s team. “I thought we had the potential of being one of the best teams in school history last year with the group we had,” Jermyn said. “But I think we kind of pressed and forced a little bit too hard and focused on results throughout the year, to the degree that I think that probably wasn’t advantageous to that group.... With this group... we’re trying to just focus on the task at hand... and see where we end up come championship time in November.” But since the Blue Devils’ top-six runners are returning, this year’s “group” is essentially the same as last year’s, albeit with a new class of freshmen mixed in. Seniors Carly Seymour and Juliet Bottorff are at the core SEE CC PREVIEW ON PAGE 10


Head coach Kevin Jermyn stresses the importance of not succumbing to the intense rigors and pressure of the cross country season.

10 | WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 31, 2011

CC PREVIEW from page 9 of this year’s squad. Bottorff earned All-ACC honors last fall, and Seymour had the best time at the NCAA championship meet. With the talent of these incoming runners plus the team experience provided from the upperclassmen, Jermyn once again believes his squad has the potential to perform exceptionally well. Despite acknowledging the desire to improve upon last year’s performance—ending in a 17th-place finish at the NCAA championship meet after falling short of earning an expected automatic bid from the ACC meet—he quickly returned to reaffirming the team’s day-to-day approach. According to Jermyn, this strategy has been successful in producing results and encouraging his athletes in previous seasons, and according to his runners, it makes practice more enjoyable. “[Training camp] was pretty relaxed, and everyone had a lot of fun,” senior Mary Carleton Johnston said. “Like Kevin said, we’re trying to not really be comparing ourselves to last year, so each practice has been kind of fun.” Beside providing an opportunity to try out their low-key strategy, training camp in Blowing Rock, N.C., gave the freshmen runners the ability to get a feel for practice and start bonding with their older teammates. According to Chloe Maleski, a member

MOORE from page 9 For followers of Duke Football, having no expectations meant a pretty fun first year of the David Cutcliffe era—four wins, including a smashing 31-7 home opener over James Madison in front of 32,571 fans, an exciting 41-31 victory over Navy and a considerably less exciting, but no less impressive, 10-7 win over Vanderbilt. Cutcliffe’s second year brought with it five wins, the most for the Blue Devils since 1994. They won three straight in October, including one of the best football games I’ve seen in person, a 49-28 win over N.C. State in Carter-Finley Stadium in which Thad Lewis threw for 459 yards. It was quite a year, especially for a team with no expectations. Then came the beginning of last season. All of a sudden, for a team with no expectations, the ‘B’ word was tossed around casually. Bowl. Bowl. Bowl. Cutcliffe had said for two years that Duke was going to go to a bowl game in an effort to change the conversation around the team. But now everyone at the first media day from Donovan Varner—“I am expecting a bowl game this year”—to normally apathetic fans on campus boldly claimed it was expected that Duke would make a bowl. A lot of talk for something that just three years ago was be unthinkable. So when the reality hit—the 49-point loss to Alabama, the 24-19 defeat to North Carolina, the 3-9 record—it hit hard. Fans who normally had little or low expectations for the team now had to see their hopes dashed. And I think the 3-9 record would have been a lot easier to swallow if it hadn’t been preceded by a full media blitz hyping a bowl game. Duke Football seems to be committed to not going down that road again. At media day yesterday, I didn’t hear the ‘B’ word bandied around once. Not from the players, and Cutcliffe didn’t mention it in his press conference at all—though, to be fair, he wasn’t asked about it. It was an understated approach, and it was absolutely perfect going into this year.


of the new class of runners, the benefits of having a solid core of returning talent are already apparent. The freshman noted that the more relaxed atmosphere as well as the welcoming nature of returning athletes have made her transition to college life as smooth as possible, allowing her to enjoy her new team and focus on her individual goals. “As long as I’m making an improvement and I’m healthy, I’ll definitely be happy with my freshmen year,” she said. Maleski is joined on the team by classmates Carolyn Baskir, Abby Farley, Kelsey Lakowske, Julianna Miller, Lindsey Olivere, Colleen Schmidt, and Colette Whitney. The older runners are also committed to providing leadership and setting examples for their new teammates. Like Jermyn, they are not interested in looking too far into the future, and for now their only focus is their training and welcoming the new members of their team. As the women get ready to begin their season with the N.C. Central Dual in just two days, the newest Blue Devils are eagerly anticipating the official start of their collegiate cross country careers. And though Jermyn encourages his runners to focus on taking their season one day at a time, they have at least one season-long goal. “I’m most looking forward to having so many girls aiming to do one thing,” Maleski said. “Run fast.”

The Blue Devils return their top-six runners from last year’s squad and have added talented freshmen.

It provided an outlook Duke Football fans would do well to adopt going into this season—don’t expect anything. Especially not a bowl. Keep the mentality exhibited by head coach David Cutcliffe and his players on Tuesday. Because in all honesty, the situation could be worse. Duke’s neighbors across the road are expecting a pretty terrible season on the field—and probably off the field, too, without the services of the great-

est tutor in college history. Ohio State’s program is in shambles. Miami pines for the days of Luther Campbell and an NCAA that looked the other way on payouts to players. The college landscape is a wreck, filled with cheating, academic dishonesty and disgraced coaches. But Duke has a clean program and a clean slate in which anything can happen. Enjoy it.



The arrival of highly-touted recruit Sean Renfree helped escalate early expectations for Duke under Cutcliffe.

SUMMITT from page 9 “How do you even strategize? Just trying to prepare at Auburn to beat Tennessee,” McCallie said. “What that did for me as a coach, because of the excellence Coach Summitt had.... They were so unbeatable, always winning the league.”

“[Her] great convictions, great success, how do you put it into words?” — Joanne P. McCallie McCallie soon received her first head coaching job, taking over at Maine. She might not have got that job without Summitt, who agreed to be a reference for McCallie when she applied for the position. McCallie noted that the Maine athletic department likely didn’t call in the reference, but Summitt’s willingness to put in a good word symbolizes her generosity and helpfulness. “I am here today at Duke because of a gracious nature she had years ago,” McCallie said. Summitt’s influence on the sport of women’s basketball has been felt by everybody involved with the game since she first began coaching 37 years ago. And because of a book, and a small but important relationship that began 23 years ago during McCallie’s time at Auburn, the Duke head coach has nothing but an endless flow of respect for her counterpart, who now confronts not only X’s and O’s but a debilitating mental disease. “Everyone in basketball sends their prayers and good thoughts to her. It’s overwhelming to think about a woman who has led our sport for thirty-plus years to go through this,” McCallie said. “[Her] great convictions, great success, how do you put it into words?”


WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 31, 2011 | 11


The Chronicle


6YkZg i^h^c\^ I c ] Z8]gd leaves Storm c ^ XaZ\Z ndjgW ih j h^clargely Z Duke h h^ci i]Z]V cYhd[ d Vunharmed V [[ajZc ibVg` c Zi ONE HUNDRED AND SEVENTH YEAR, ISSUE 3


Angelou inspires freshman class

by Yeshwanth Kandimalla THE CHRONICLE

“[Poetry] encapsulates encaps p ul ps ulat atees so much of what at the human humaan being bein be ing in g has gone through, goes through th hro rou ugh and is yet to go through,” she ug said. “The poem is written for all of us... us. us all of the time.”

Although Hurricane Irene battered d the North Carolina coast, Duke and the Triangle came out mostly unscathed. The only damages Duke sustained during the Category 1 storm Saturday were two fallen Campus, f ll trees near East E C urce said Vice President for Human Resources Kyle Cavanaugh, who also acts as emerfo or the th he University. Univverrsi sityy. gency coordinator for ell near the th he entrance he entra raance ran nce of thee nc One tree fell st Duke Building and and another at the West i tersection in n of of Trinity Trin Trin Tr init i y Avenue Avenue and Buchintersection anan Boulevard. an Bou B ou ule levard. anan Unlike the city of of Durham, Durham, which whi hiich c numerou us power power err outages, o ou utag ut a es, experienced numerous avoideed ed large lar arge ge scale power the University avoided the fallen fall fa lleen trees did not bring ll outages, as the wn power p pow ower ow e lines affecting campus, Cadown vanaugh added. va van vanaugh T Th Thee hurricane, which made landfall Satu urd day ay, br b brou rou ought one to two inches of Saturday, brought and wind speeds ssp peeds of 35 mph to Durrain and cou o nties, said meteorolometeorol ham and Wake counties, Carroll of the National Ca gist Kathleen Carroll Servicce in in Raleigh. Ral Weather Service Most of the sttay ayed e to ed t the east of Interstate 95 storm stayed as forecasted. for or as Those areas saw as much as six inches of rain. Hurricane Irene left the state between



n i e s i t r e v d a e l o c t i s n y o a r p h It The 3CDUKE ND 1 aZ^h X ^ c d g ] 8 urges students Zto make ]ZAngelou IMaya d[the most out of their ededucational experience at Duke andndd ttoo ususee poetryy as a ““common Author and poet comm co mmon ground” with others. X g j d h  &   Z Mercola ]Z poet and author, hor, not to mention ntion a civil rights ing Duke.” byi]Jack i  g At times, she sang figurehead, spoke to the Class of 2015 poke ke o 20 015 SunS Sun unun n to the crowd and an nd proprod [ h into a time nday,# welcomingng themm to the Duke la poem Instead of entering Duk uke commuu vided anecdotes, anec ecdotes, but ec bu ut her ut he emphasis emp mp phasis siis was wa clearly Z c i ^ cap went nttyy-sse seco eco cond nd annual ann nual address, on the connecting con nnecting g power p we po werr of poetry poe oetr tryy and its tr capsule at the Martin Luther King, Jr. jc nity. In her twenty-second bmemob d what ability in particular rial dedication with theZ d students ssttud dents to remember r me re me member families of King and Angelou urged par arti ticu ticu cullar to connect conneect the Class Claass of of X  ` j Maya Angelou de- an important responsibility 9Obama, President Barack Pres respon nsibility their theiir education 2015. th 2015 20 15. TYLER TYLE ER SEUC/THE S UC/THE CHRONICLE SE


livered a heartfelt address to Duke first-year livere m at the Chapel. students stude “I’ve “I’ I v given my word to Duke, and I will bee at Duke,” Angelou said to students as a b reminder re emi m nd der of how important their entry is to to University. the U Un ni ni Angelou, A Ange An ng u, a multi-talented, award-winning awa ward wa rd-w rd d- inning ng n g

will be during the he next neext four years, yearss, emphasize ph em phas a iz as iz-ing the importance nce of o continuing conti tiinuing in i higher h education. “My Myy dears, deearrs, you’ve you’’vee already alre al read ady been paid pai aid aid for—you fo or— —yo you owe it to someone so omeone down the road to to pay it for them,” she she said before b fore an attenbe tive audience. audieencce. e. “Don’t “Do D n’t even think thi hink hi nk k about about leav-

HDRL to release house Duke remains perfect, knocks off No. 1 model plans aZ ]gdc^X by Ryan Claxton

[8 Y HILL, N.C. — After 60 minVbleak ofdplay, Z 'CHAPEL g  .utes n a theV outlook was for g a j \ Duke against No. 1 Notre Dame. The Z g  trailed 1-0aVafter n allowing a ZghDevils jhBlue e h ^ fluke goal inthe first half, and to add Y Z ^c off injury i to]insult one of their captains— h i c Z Ashley Rape—hadZjust been carted h bknee injury. ia ^right g the field with Z k Y # Duke was V But just when it looked like g Z e V e down, it turned up in a position to i]onZshut the pressure the defending national

6 THE I CHRONICLE ]Z8 YkZgi^h^c As summ summer comes to an end, \^c ] students dc^Xofa and Z[[Zin on gdetails administrators the dministrat are closing Z  ^ h Xi^kZ  house ouse model. mod lVn i]Zbdhi new residential Under the first year i]ofZthe  9j` into vari-idgZ which will group students model, w VX] Xdb ous houses across West and CentralZcampuses us hou b starting arting Fall™2012, residentially unaffiliated ( %% will be randomly jc^in# sophomores and*!juniors ophom %[V houses, said placed of 40 unaffiliated laced into™one  XforjaiHousing, , ! % % Joe Gonzalez, associate oe G nVc %\gdean V ™,Residence Dining Life. Y Members of theY h ini and j iV[[ ! % V %%will iZhthe Class during la of 2013, who jbe cYseniors Zg\gV ijYZci eshman Kelly Cobb Cob scored the second of three unanswered Duke goals in Chapel pel Hill Sunday. SEE HOUSE MODEL ON PAGE YjV14i Blueh Devil freshman Zh by Nicole Kyle


champions. No. 21 Duke (4-0) scored three unanswered goals in under 12 minutes es during


Hurr Hurricane Hu H urr rr can ne delays d ays de ys Duke Marine M Ma Mar arine ne n e Lab Lab La ab orientation, o orrie ent ntat nta ta ta attion t on, PPage 3


“...ultimately students have to decide for themselves what they choose to do.”


Duke DukeMed D Du keMe ke keM Med Me d admins admi ad dmi m ns n take tak ke ke rankings with ‘grain of salt,’ Page 5

—Tom Szigethy on orientation. See story page 3

Contact Us:

Advertising Office: 919-684-3811 * Source: Newton Marketing and Research


12 | WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 31, 2011



RESEARCH STUDIES PARTICIPANTS ARE NEEDED for studies of visual and hearing function using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). These studies are conducted at the Brain Imaging and Analysis Center (BIAC) at Duke University Medical Center. Participants should be 18 years or older and should have no history of brain injury or disease. Most studies last between 1-2 hours, and participants are paid approximately $20/hr. Please contact the BIAC volunteer coordinator at 6819344 or volunteer@biac.duke. edu for additional information. You can also visit our website at

HELP WANTED BARTENDERS ARE IN DEMAND! Earn $20-$35/hr. in a recessionproof job. 1 or 2 week classes & weekend classes. 100% job placement assistance. HAVE FUN! MAKE MONEY! MEET PEOPLE! Affordable SUMMER tuition rates. Raleigh’s Bartending School CALL NOW!! 919676-0774, www.cocktailmixer. com/duke.html

SEEKING RESPONSIBLE college student to care for/tutor two elementary school girls 3:30 to 5:30 Tuesdays and Thursdays. Our home and their school are both blocks from East Campus. Reply to brandy.salmon@gmail. com.


RESEARCH TECH I (20 hrs/wk) Assists in all areas of research support including safety and protocol compliance and ordering supplies. BS required, lab experience preferred, excellent communication and computer skills required. ADMINISTRATIVE ASSISTANT (30hrs/week)Provides general administrative support. Preferred Qualifications: Bachelor’s degree with relevant experience, excellent organizational and problem solving skills, computer skills including MS Office. Grant and website management desirable.


Duke family looking for a reliable babysitter for 2 girls, 6 & 8 years old. One evening every week, your choice which, and occasional weekend evenings. Pay negotiable. In American Village, close to West Campus. Email rj.perz-edwards@duke. edu, or call 309-0653 (h) or 6845674 (w).


Visit the Website Read the Book ISBN:9781.4620.21437 21451(ebook)


HHMI is an Equal Opportunity Employer

RESPONSIBLE, CARING INDIVIDUAL NEEDED for afterschool care for 8 year old girl. Job involves tutoring in math and reading and taking child to afterschool activities. 3:15-6 pm M-F (can negogiate days). Must have clean driving record and own transportation.



Lawn care,irrigation fix,drainage,patios,retaining walls, paint and home repairs 919-697-2641

Email rj.perz-edwards@duke. edu

TO APPLY FOR EITHER POSITION - Email cover letter, resume and salary history to employment@ Please indicate in the subject line if you are applying for “ADMIN ASST” or “RES TECH” position.





In partnership with select programs of Duke, UNC, Campbell, FSU, Meredith, and UNC-G, PrepSuccess has helped thousands of students prepare for entrance exams. Early Bird rates are only $462 to $588 for 30 - 42 hour courses that begin August 20, 21, September 6, 7, and 10. Attend classes in person throughout the Triangle or Live Online Webcast and Recordings. To visit a class or to learn more, visit or call 919-791-0810.

Honest&Reliable. Fix all car problems. 919-697-2641 jorgesgarage@

ordering food on points? read while you wait. the chronicle on-line: anytime, any place, tipping not required.

The Chronicle classified advertising rates All advertising - $6.00 for first 15 words 10¢ (per day) additional per word 3 or 4 consecutive insertions - 10 % off 5 or more consecutive insertions - 20 % off special features online and print all bold wording - $1.00 extra per day bold heading - $1.50 extra per day bold and sub headline - $2.50 extra per day online only attention getting icon - $1.00 extra per ad spotlight/feature ad - $2.00 per day website link - $1.00 per ad map - $1.00 per ad hit counter - $1.00 per ad picture or graphic - $2.50 per ad deadline 12:00 noon 1 business day prior to publication payment Prepayment is required Master Card, VISA, Discover, American Express, cash or check ad submission

online: Find houses and apartments now at

email: fax to: 919-684-8295 phone orders: (919)-684-3811 No refunds or cancellations after first insertion deadline

101 West Union Building, Box 90858 Duke University, Durham, NC 27708-0858 Phone: (919) 684-3811 | Fax: (919) 668-1247

ADVERTISERS: Please check your advertisement for errors on the first day of publication. If you find an error, please call 919-684-3811. The Chronicle only accepts responsibility for the first incorrect day for ads entered by our office staff. We cannot offer make-good runs for errors in ads placed online by the customer.

V i s i t w w w. d u k e c h r o n i c l e. c o m / c l a s s i f i e d s classifieds

10-15 hrs/week: Motivated research aide needed for data collection/analysis in studies of diet and exercise. Flexible hrs, $10/hr. Contact Dr. Bales at bales001@

OPPORTUNITIES AVAILABLE in HHMI labs at Duke. Part time positions with benefits.

In Print and Online

I am a new user of the Macbook pro and need tutoring on the basic uses of the Mac, particularly the Pages wordprocessing program. Location negotiable and transportation available if needed. Contact 713-907-0519.

PARTICIPANTS NEEDED! Duke Psychology Lab needs research participants. Studies pay $12/hour and typically last 30 minutes-2 hours. Tasks may include studying words, sentences, or pictures, and taking tests. For information about specific studies, contact Must be at least 18, a Duke Undergraduate, and a US citizen.




WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 31, 2011 | 13

Diversions Shoe Chris Cassatt and Gary Brookins

Dilbert Scott Adams

Doonesbury Garry Trudeau

The Chronicle what we wish we could get for delivery: refridgerators: ............................................................................ nick andrĂŠ [agassi]: ......................................................... nickyle, sanette loyo 24 hours per day: .....................................................loco, anna clones: ...............................................................................drewedith watchdoggers: ..................................................................... ctcusack tbk: ........................................................................ tseuc, dbb, yeo3x bigboys: ................................................................. jamesree, mdalis ap stories: ............................................................................christine Barb Starbuck delivers everyday: ............................................. Barb

Ink Pen Phil Dunlap

Student Advertising Manager: .........................................Amber Su Account Representatives: .......Cort Ahl, James Sinclair, Will Geary, Jen Bahadour, Courtney Clower, Peter Chapin, James Sinclair, Will Geary, Daniel Perlin, Emily Shiau, Andy Moore, Allison Rhyne Creative Services Student Manager ...........................Christine Hall Creative Services: .............Erica Kim, Chelsea Mayse, Megan Meza Business Assistant: ........................................................Joslyn Dunn


Fill in the grid so that every row, every column and every 3x3 box contains the digits 1 through 9. (No number is repeated in any column, row or box.)

Have something for sale? Advertise it in The Chronicle classifieds and sell it easily!

Answer to puzzle

The Independent Daily at Duke University

The Chronicle

14 | WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 31, 2011

Houses should realize identity, diversity Housing, Dining and Resi- model’s inaugural year. As dence Life has gotten down pointed out by Duke Student to the brass tacks of the house Government President Pete model. This week, HDRL an- Schork, the success of the nounced its plan to randomly model hinges on houses deplace residentially unaffiliated veloping unique personalities. sophomores Randomization editorial and juniors into in the first year 40 unaffiliated will generate dihouses across West and Central versity as well any other methcampuses in Fall 2012. od, and it is swift and simple A successful placement to boot. Compounded with structure must reconcile the highly effective, student-driven house model’s two objectives: social programming, randomhelping students build strong ized placement gives houses a communities and encouraging fair shot at creating their own them to learn from one anoth- identities. er’s differences. Community Sustaining these house culand diversity are not mutually tures will be more difficult. Afexclusive goals—the new place- ter the new house model’s first ment model must allow houses year, absolute randomization to scope for identity without in- is a poor placement strategy. sulating them from diversity. The cultures that grow within Randomization is the best the houses during a single year placement strategy in the new will be fragile. An influx of

how would the freshman know anything about losing one’s dukecard overnight? they’ve been here a week —“capitolhill” commenting on the story “Duke Card office to limit hours.” See more at

LETTERS POLICY The Chronicle welcomes submissions in the form of letters to the editor or guest columns. Submissions must include the author’s name, signature, department or class, and for purposes of identification, phone number and local address. Letters should not exceed 325 words; contact the editorial department for information regarding guest columns. The Chronicle will not publish anonymous or form letters or letters that are promotional in nature. The Chronicle reserves the right to edit letters and guest columns for length, clarity and style and the right to withhold letters based on the discretion of the editorial page editor.

randomly selected incoming sophomores will fracture these nascent identities, destroying any gains from the initial randomization. If randomization is the sole placement mechanism, then the house model will only recreate the current quad model. Blocks will be adjacent to one another, and there will be little incentive for the students within those blocks to reach out to their housemates. Especially after a year of living on East Campus, most sophomores will choose to nurture old friendships rather than to repeat the random residence hall experience of freshman year. No amount of programming, however lavish or well executed, will facilitate strong communities within houses with randomly assigned upperclassmen.

Any solution to this problem must blend randomized placement with placement based on student preference. Unaffiliated sophomores should be able to rank houses according to which houses values best reflect their own personalities. A computer algorithm ought to maximize preference satisfaction by placing as many students in their desired houses as possible. Unlike the recruitment process used by greek organizations and SLGs, unaffiliated students would not be judged on external factors like race, gender or class—only the objective fact of how well their preferences match up against the desires of others. Such a process renders students’ preferences equal and anonymous. A computerized system would also allow HDRL to in-

ject an element of randomness into house sorting if necessary. Should the preference-based system yield houses that are too homogeneous, loosening the parameters of preference adherence would immediately remedy the problem. The new house model should not be a repeat of the East Campus experience. Total randomization that occurs twice in the residential life of a Duke student is excessive. To expect that the second randomization will yield communities resembling freshmen dorms is naïve and unrealistic. Instead, the new house model should embody a fresh and uniquely upperclassmen experience, one that encourages both common interests through house preference and diversity through randomization.

My unexposed exposure


Est. 1905



Direct submissions to:

E-mail: Editorial Page Department The Chronicle Box 90858, Durham, NC 27708 Phone: (919) 684-2663 Fax: (919) 684-4696

The Chronicle

Inc. 1993

SANETTE TANAKA, Editor NICHOLAS SCHWARTZ, Managing Editor NICOLE KYLE, News Editor CHRIS CUSACK, Sports Editor MELISSA YEO, Photography Editor MEREDITH JEWITT, Editorial Page Editor CORY ADKINS, Editorial Board Chair MELISSA DALIS, Co-Managing Editor for Online JAMES LEE, Co-Managing Editor for Online DEAN CHEN, Director of Online Operations JONATHAN ANGIER, General Manager TOM GIERYN, Sports Managing Editor KATIE NI, Design Editor LAUREN CARROLL, University Editor ANNA KOELSCH, University Editor CAROLINE FAIRCHILD, Local & National Editor YESHWANTH KANDIMALLA, Local & National Editor MICHAEL SHAMMAS, Health & Science Editor JULIAN SPECTOR, Health & Science Editor TYLER SEUC, News Photography Editor CHRIS DALL, Sports Photography Editor ROSS GREEN, Recess Editor MAGGIE LOVE, Recess Managing Editor CHELSEA PIERONI, Recess Photography Editor SOPHIA PALENBERG, Online Photo Editor DREW STERNESKY, Editorial Page Managing Editor CHRISTINE CHEN, Wire Editor SAMANTHA BROOKS, Multimedia Editor MOLLY HIMMELSTEIN, Special Projects Editor for Video CHRISTINA PEÑA, Towerview Editor RACHNA REDDY, Towerview Editor NATHAN GLENCER, Towerview Photography Editor MADDIE LIEBERBERG, Towerview Creative Director TAYLOR DOHERTY, Special Projects Editor CHRISTINA PEÑA, Special Projects Editor for Online LINDSEY RUPP, Senior Editor TONI WEI, Senior Editor COURTNEY DOUGLAS, Recruitment Chair TONI WEI, Recruitment Chair MARY WEAVER, Operations Manager CHRISSY BECK, Advertising/Marketing Director BARBARA STARBUCK, Production Manager REBECCA DICKENSON, Chapel Hill Ad Sales Manager The Chronicle is published by the Duke Student Publishing Company, Inc., a non-profit corporation independent of Duke University. The opinions expressed in this newspaper are not necessarily those of Duke University, its students, faculty, staff, administration or trustees. Unsigned editorials represent the majority view of the editorial board. Columns, letters and cartoons represent the views of the authors. To reach the Editorial Office at 301 Flowers Building, call 684-2663 or fax 684-4696. To reach the Business Office at 103 West Union Building, call 684-3811. To reach the Advertising Office at 101 West Union Building call 684-3811 or fax 684-8295. Visit The Chronicle Online at © 2010 The Chronicle, Box 90858, Durham, N.C. 27708. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced in any form without the prior, written permission of the Business Office. Each individual is entitled to one free copy.


ast semester, during finals week, I might breast to a bouncer in order to get into the social have shown the entirety of the first floor of event of the season. I haven’t descended to her Perkins one of my breasts. level... at least not yet. Let me explain. While innoIf I were a celebrity, it would be cently bent over at my desk in the different. In 2004, Janet Jackson’s library, my friend spotted my expofamous Superbowl nipple fiasco sure, tapped me on the shoulder, made front-page news, and inspired and politely told me to “do better.” a short-lived trend of nipple piercConfused, I looked around—severings. In 2009, Beyonce had a similar al people were staring at me—and nipple disaster in an Oscars show finally, down at what he had noperformance with Hugh Jackman ticed. There it was, my lady part: that rocked the mainstream media. indu ramesh unrestrained, unadulterated and Yet at the end of 2009, it was Miley hooked on exposed to all of first-floor Perkins. Cyrus who had the most searched information My tank top, apparently, had veered nip slip of the year, overshadowing off to the side, giving Venus free even Beyonce. rein to unabashedly poke out and In this day and age, nipple slips declare her heady existence to the world (merci- have become relatively frequent, occurring on fully, Serena stayed hidden to Perk one through- practically a daily basis. Few female celebrities out the ordeal). Apparently, I had tried to put the out there have nipples that remain a mystery to “Perk” in Perkins, or something. the American public. Nicki Minaj had a nip slip As I wondered how long I had been working in recently on “Good Morning America;” it resulted Perkins, without anyone alerting me to my strip- in an amusing explosion on Twitter, with a bevy of per status, I came to a somewhat disconcerting tweets along the lines of “boom bodabum boom epiphany. that super baseeee, oopps. nipslip.” Even though several people had seen Venus in For me and the rest us everyday folk, howevall her glory, I realized that I didn’t care. Rather er, life goes on as usual after a nip slip—even for than deep shame or mortification, I felt, well— those who observe rather than participate. As one apathy. I wished the incident had occurred in a Twitter user put it, dismissing the potency of the more appropriate location, but the exposure ul- nip slip phenomenon “these gurls buggin bout timately made no difference to my overall daily #cameltoe and #nipslip #season but basketball life at Duke. It was but a small embarrassment, a short season almost over too so ladies stfu.” little blip in what had otherwise been a relatively Indeed, perhaps the general apathy toward productive day. And it hadn’t even been too no- every-day, non-celebrity nip slips represents a ticeable an event. Other than the several that had sort of triumph of daily routine—and, ultimatestared, most people had not even batted an eye- ly, community. It’s nice to know that when my lash, and had gone back to their work just like any left breast, Venus, hangs out in Perkins, unreother day. strained, few people notice, and those who do Indeed, my reaction to the entire ordeal—and ultimately return to their Duke daily grind. most observers’ reactions as well—was essentially Actually, in the spirit of friendship, many Unisimilar to that of my tumble down the stairs in versity students have admitted to their willingthe French Family Science Center as an overly ness to do a naked run, to streak just for giggles eager freshman. I was faintly embarrassed, but I and experience’s sake. The closeness of our didn’t even blush (qualifier: that might just be Duke community—our bond through work and because I’m Indian, and I have yet to see a brown friendship—seems to overrule the process of person visibly blush). I giggled sheepishly about judgment and restraint that comes with things the slip, used it as a humorous anecdote to tell to such as nip slips and unwanted exposure. At the friends—and by the next day, it was all but forgot- end of that long night of studying in Perkins, ten. My friend who had discovered my wardrobe punctuated by my impromptu performance, I malfunction accepted the excuse that “my life is still took my finals with the same rigor of any in shambles,” and allowed me to continue mer- Duke student. Ultimately, we are judged for who rily with my life. we are. Let me just note here that I would probably Still, I’m glad that my wardrobe malfunction not purposely engineer this performance. In the was not of the lower variety. TV show “30 Rock,” actress Jenna Maroney of the fictional sketch comedy show “TGS with Tracy Indu Ramesh is a Trinity junior. Her column runs Jordan” is perfectly comfortable with flashing her every other Wednesday.



WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 31, 2011 | 15

The illusion of safety


rriving on campus this year, I was reminded of just how quickly my first year flew by. It seems like just yesterday I was doing ice-breaking exercises with my First-Year Advisory Counselor (FAC), meeting with my RA for the first time and wandering over to West Campus with a group of two-day-old friends in search of a party. This year, there were ice breakers and RA meetings, but there was a noticeable lack of parties on West Campus. In an email sent out by Housscott briggs ing, Dining and Residential Life as i see it at the start of orientation week, fraternities and selective living groups were encouraged to “take proactive measures to discourage first-years… from [going to] section.” This alone is nothing unusual, since section parties are regularly banned until the first Friday of classes and these rules are rarely enforced. This year, though, they enforced the rules. Most section parties so far this semester have been shut down almost immediately and registered events are now banned until after the second week of classes. Couple these changes with the end of Tailgate, and it seems very apparent that Duke is tightening the reigns. Yet the question remains, with regard to these decisions, whose interests do the administrators actually have in mind? President Brodhead took the stance that these changes were necessary to protect the students. While speaking to FACs during their training, Brodhead noted that the first weeks of freshman year are the most important in shaping a student’s future decisions throughout college. This implies that habits, such as drinking heavily, are more likely to stick with students if started early during their college experience. Although this argument might have some validity, assuming that you can prevent freshmen from drinking by stomping out section parties seems shockingly narrow-minded. Many first-years come to campus with the expectation of partying, and will find a way to do so one way or another. If they can’t drink on campus, many will just as quickly look for offcampus options. Durham can be a dangerous place, even for students familiar with the city. The prospect of hoards of disoriented freshmen wandering around the dark streets of downtown Durham seems counterintuitive for an administration allegedly looking out for students’ safety and well-being. It does, on the other hand, make perfect sense for an administration looking to rid themselves of on-campus liabilities and headaches. The end of Tailgate is yet another perfect example. The basic idea of students dressing up in costumes to drink and blast music in a parking lot was not inherently a mortal sin. Nevertheless, it was extremely embarrassing to the University and to the football program to have students doing so instead of attending the football games. Tailgate was the most visible symbol of Duke’s “party school” status and a blatant reminder that most students had no interest in going to the football games, much less remembering the score. Instead of putting precautions in place to prevent the irresponsible acts that occurred at the final Tailgate, Duke took the easy way out once again. They let the situation get progressively more out of hand until something egregious enough occurred to warrant banning Tailgate altogether, replacing it with a barbecue event now known as Football Gameday. But what makes Football Gameday all that different? Of course, there will be no costumes or flying beer cans, but why is it any less likely that a minor will get blackout drunk? The main difference is that a photograph or video of a barbecue on the Main Quad can’t hurt Duke’s academic reputation quite as much as one of students in neon leggings and ballerina skirts doused in Busch Light. Despite the administrators’ decisions to perpetually wash their hands of difficult situations, there will always be a portion of students who choose Duke because they want an education of unparalleled quality and the ability to have fun. Cracking the whip on Tailgate and parties might give the illusion of a tamer student population, but it doesn’t change reality. When deciding to beef up the rules, whose interests did President Brodhead and his colleagues in the Allen Building actually have in mind? Their refusal to regulate anything and while also choosing take the easy way out would seem to suggest that the administrators were seeking fewer headaches and more free time. Instead of pushing first-years off campus, administrators should have allowed open events that could be monitored by Duke officials. Here’s how I see it: Keep your friends close, and your drunken students closer. Scott Briggs is a Trinity Sophomore. His column runs every other Wednesday.

Slash and burn


was sitting in my apartment with my roommate obvious conclusion that innovation—which could and a few of his band friends when someone turn a good artist into the best of all time—is not stated that The Beatles were the best band of all worth the risk of losing everything. So they stay stagtime. nant until they are left behind by new trends (see: Maybe it wasn’t the biggest leap, Lady Gaga) and then they change but no one objected or even brought drastically to overcompensate (see: other artists or bands into the discusSpears, Britney). sion. I had been involved in enough The same is true of our adminisof these conversations to understand tration and our University as a whole. that they were usually in jest, but I Despite having some very obvious still didn’t expect to hear such a granflaws, Duke was still consistently getdiose claim go uncontested. Calling ting ones. Applications were increasanything “the best of all time” should antonio segalini ing, our ranking was staying relatively open a moderate debate, at least. constant and Duke’s press was pretty musings Would my generation produce anypositive. For this University, things gothing to topple The Beatles or even ing well meant keeping the status quo. artists such as Chuck Berry, Bob Dylan or the Rolling Groundbreaking academic research was still being Stones? Looking for solace, I went to Rolling Stone’s done, but most University and campus issues were list of the Top 100 Artists of All Time, hoping to realize approached with a laissez-faire attitude, with silent I had overlooked someone. Instead of comfort, I got prayers that inaction would not come at great cost. confirmation: My generation has failed to produce The music industry’s stagnation led to particular serious musicians. The closest thing my lifetime has artists facing short careers and the entire industry beseen are the tail ends of U2, Michael Jackson, Bruce ing held captive by MP3 mega-stores. Duke faced an Springsteen and Nirvana. The car rides of my child- onslaught of horrible press and a dreadful reputahood featuring The Eagles, Stevie Wonder, The Beat- tion of excess and lawlessness. In response, the adles and The Rolling Stones were my only true sniff of ministration decided to slash and burn, going to the music royalty. My rebellious years of blasting The Ra- extreme instead of making modest changes and almones, Nirvana and Public Enemy (yeah, I’m hood) lowing for a gestation period. would be the end of my connection to the top 100. The extremes were, well, extreme. First, adminisThe problem I had with this was not accepting trators decided that no groups could have registered the validity of the magazine’s rankings. Despite some section parties until Sept. 9, which in layman’s terms issues with their list—namely the lack of country means “move that drinking behind closed doors music and the fact that Aerosmith is ranked higher where we can’t moderate, so that we can claim igthan both Radiohead and The Eagles—I accepted norance for the next disaster.” Then, most notably, that the majority of bands were given the appropri- the administrators completely dissociated themselves ate place amongst their peers. This means that my and the university from Tailgate (as I type this Tailgeneration’s best shot at producing a music legend gate does not have a red squiggly below it, despite it could be Jay-Z (ranked 88) or Eminem (ranked 83). not existing. Dean of Students Sue Wasiolek needs to Could I have lost 20 years to inadequate music? alert Microsoft of this). Am I going to look back and say that Lady Gaga was Either because they waited too long or because the best artist of my generation? In a period where they simply did not want to disturb something they information is easily accessible and technology turns felt was good, administrators backed themselves into any song that uses vocal synthesizers into a potential a corner. And, like the music industry, they overcomhit, musical trends have stagnated. Instead of im- pensated rather than being responsible and levelproving upon what came before them, musicians go headed. Even though much of Duke’s social scene after easy successes, and what’s easier than reproduc- was getting extreme, fighting the irresponsible acts ing what has already worked? When the best contem- of undergraduates with over-reactive punishments is porary innovation that Rolling Stone can find is de- not a solution. In fact, it causes further tension betermining that Madonna is Britney Spears’ “stylistic tween students and administrators rather than creatgodmother,” it is easy to feel like the music industry ing an open and honest dialogue and soliciting ideas has misused its abundant resources. on how to change. This funk can be explained by the music industry The music industry is dying because it decided to becoming so reliant on instant success that it cannot slash and burn rather than adapt gradually. Instead afford artistic exploration or trial-and-error by new of following in the music industry’s footsteps, Duke artists. Instead, it has become yes or no—assigning a needs to address problems as they arise rather than binary ranking of one or zero, where the first zero or (over)reacting when it’s too late. string of zeros means the end of a career. This constant demand for popularity means those Antonio Segalini is a Trinity junior. His column runs who have already found fame and fortune face the every Wednesday.

16 | WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 31, 2011


August 31, 2011 issue  
August 31, 2011 issue  

August 31st, 2011 issue of The Chronicle