Issuu on Google+

4HE!UTHOROF THE#LOUDOF5NKNOWING AS4EACHERAND$ISCIPLE 2OBERT(ALE /3"#AM !BSTRACT 4HEAUTHOROFTHE#LOUDOF5NKNOWING DIDNOTATTACHHISNAMETO HISWORK WHICHISRECOGNIZEDASAMAJORTEXTIN#HRISTIANMYSTICISMDATING FROMFOURTEENTH CENTURY%NGLAND)TSEEMSLIKELY HOWEVER THATHEWASAMONK 4HEPAPERTHATFOLLOWSDESCRIBESSOMEOFTHERECURRENTIMAGERYANDSPIRITUAL INSTRUCTIONSFOUNDINTHISREMARKABLEANDINmUENTIALWORK 4HISPAPERWASPRESENTEDTOTHEFOURTHANNUAL.ORTHERN#ALIFORNIA#HAN:EN #ATHOLIC$IALOGUE *ANUARY

4

HE #LOUDOF5NKNOWINGISWIDELYRECOGNIZEDASACLASSICOF-EDIEVAL G #ATHOLICSPIRITUALITY#LIFTON7OLTERSHASWRITTENh4HISBOOKISONE OFTHEDEVOTIONALCLASSICSOFTHE%NGLISH#HURCH ANDPERHAPSTHE GREATESTOFTHEMALL.OONEWHOREADSITCANFAILTOCATCHSOMETHINGOFITS SPLENDOURANDCHARMv $OM$AVID+NOWLES THE"ENEDICTINESCHOLAROF%NGLISHSPIRITUALITY

WRITESOFTHEAUTHORTHATHEIShPERHAPSTHEMOSTSUBTLEANDINCISIVE ASWELLAS THEMOSTORIGINALSPIRITUALWRITERINTHE%NGLISHLANGUAGEv%VELYN5NDERHILL WRITESOFTHEWORKh)TSPRINGSFROMANAGEWHEN%NGLISHMYSTICISMWASIN FULLmOWER4HISISTHEPUREDOCTRINEOFMYSTICISMv !NDTHEOTHERWRITINGS CLEARLYBYTHESAMEAUTHORAREBECOMINGEVERMOREKNOWNANDAPPRECI ATED 7ILLIAM*OHNSTON WHOHASSPENTMOSTOFHISLIFEIN*APANENGAGEDIN THE:EN#ATHOLICDIALOGUE WROTEHISDOCTORATEONTHEMYSTICALTEACHINGOF THE #LOUD WHICHHASSIGNIlCANTLYINmUENCEDHISSUBSEQUENTWRITINGSAND DIALOGUE 4HOMAS-ERTONHIGHLYPRAISEDTHEWRITERANDWASSIGNIlCANTLY INmUENCEDBYHIM*OHNSTONWRITESTHATANEARLY ONTRANSLATIONINTO,ATINOF THE#LOUD WHICHMADEITSWAYTOTHECONTINENT MIGHTWELLHAVEINmUENCED ARANGEOFCONTINENTALCONTEMPLATIVESANDMYSTICS INCLUDING*OHNOFTHE #ROSS4HECONTEMPORARYhCENTERINGPRAYERvMOVEMENT SPREADTHROUGHOUT >HHJ: D8ID7:G




2OBERT(ALE

THE5NITED3TATESANDEVENTHEWORLD HASBEENSIGNIlCANTLYINmUENCEDBY THE #LOUD INDEED "ASIL0ENNINGTONHASAFlRMEDTHATCENTERINGPRAYERIS SIMPLYAREPACKAGINGOFTHE#LOUD4HEAUTHOROFTHE#LOUDD THUSEVIDENTLY CANBECLAIMEDTOBEASIGNIlCANTSPIRITUALTEACHER 4HISPAPERWILLBEMOREEXISTENTIALTHANRIGOROUSLYACADEMIC PROPOS INGELEMENTSOFTHEAUTHORSTEACHINGWHICHHAVEBEENVERYIMPORTANTFOR THISWRITERANDWHICHMIGHTRESONATEWITH#HAN :ENANDOTHER"UDDHIST TRADITIONS 4HEAUTHOROFTHE #LOUDSIGNIlCANTLYCHOSETOREMAINANONYMOUSˆ CERTAINLYAREmECTIONOFHISHUMILITYAVIRTUEAPPRECIATEDBYTHE#ATHOLIC ANDALSO )BELIEVE THE"UDDHISTTRADITIONS "UTBYAVERYCAREFULREADING OFHISTEXTS SCHOLARSHAVEBEENABLETODEDUCEAGREATDEALABOUTHISHISTORI CALCONTEXT HISSOURCESANDHISSPIRITUALHERITAGE#ERTAINLYTHEFOURTEENTH CENTURY INWHICHHELIVEDANDWROTE WASATROUBLEDANDDARKTIME4HERE WASTHEHORRENDOUSPLAGUE WHICHCAUSEDTHEDEATHOFATHIRDTOAHALFOF THEPOPULATIONOF%NGLAND4HE0APACYWASINTHEPERIODOFTHEh"ABYLONIAN #APTIVITYvIN!VIGNON &RANCE HATEDENEMYOF%NGLAND ANDTHISSITUATION WASACAUSEOFSCANDALFOR%NGLISH#ATHOLICS4HETERRIBLE(UNDRED9EAR 7ARBLED%NGLANDOFITSYOUTHANDBURDENEDITSECONOMY4HEREWASSOCIAL UNRESTWITH7ATT4YLERANDTHE0EASANTS2EVOLT3KEPTICISMWASCREEPING INTOPHILOSOPHYANDTHEOLOGY"ISHOP*OHN-OORMANSAYS WITH%NGLISH UNDERSTATEMENT h)TWASANUNHAPPYTIMEFORTHEPEOPLEOF%NGLANDv 3OCIAL HISTORIANSHAVEDRAWNPARALLELSWITHOUROWNSUFFERED DARKTIME /NTHEOTHERHAND ANDFASCINATINGLY ITWASANAGEMARKEDALSOBYTHE mOURISHINGOFTHECONTEMPLATIVEANDMYSTICALLIFE4HISWASTHECENTURYOF h4HE%NGLISH3CHOOL vWITH2ICHARD2OLLE THEAUTHOROFTHE #LOUD 7AL TER(ILTONAND*ULIANOF.ORWICH/NTHECONTINENT #ATHERINEOF3IENA

%CKHART 4AULER 3USOAND2UYSBROEKLIVEDANDWROTE)STHEREHOPEINOUR OWNDIFlCULTTIME BOTHFORTHE#ATHOLICANDTHE#HAN:ENHERITAGES IN THISREGARD D #ONCERNINGTHEAUTHOROFTHE#LOUDHIMSELF SEVERALSCHOLARSFEELTHERE ISSIGNIlCANTINTERNALEVIDENCETOPOINTTOHISBEINGAPRIESTANDACONTEM PLATIVEMONK LIKELYA#ARTHUSIANORA#ISTERCIAN (ECLEARLYLEARNEDAND DREW FROM SEVERAL RICH CURRENTS OF THE #ATHOLIC CONTEMPLATIVE HERITAGE PRINCIPALLYFROM3CRIPTURE4HEREAREALMOSTAHUNDREDCITATIONSORALLU SIONSTO3CRIPTUREINTHE #LOUDOF5NKNOWINGALONE INCLUDINGASIGNIlCANT NUMBERFROMTHE0SALMS UNDERSTANDABLEFORAMONKRECITINGPSALMSDAILY INTHEMONASTICOFlCE4HENALSOASIGNIlCANTNUMBERFROMTHE #ANTICLE OF #ANTICLES ALSO UNDERSTANDABLE GIVEN THE MONASTIC PREDILECTION FOR A CONTEMPLATIVEANDMYSTICALREADINGOFTHATSUBLIMEBOOK!SFORTHE.EW



G:A><>DC:6HIL:HI


4HE!UTHOROFTHE#LOUDOF5NKOWINGAS4EACHERAND$ISCIPLE

4ESTAMENT WRITINGS THEREARESOMESIXTY lVEREFERENCESTOTHE'OSPELS AND TWENTY THREEREFERENCESTOTHE0AULINE%PISTLES4HEAUTHORCERTAINLYWISHES TOBEAFAITHFULDISCIPLEOFTHE3CRIPTURES THOUGHHISINTERPRETATIONSOFTHE TEXTSTENDTOBEEMPHATICALLYCONTEMPLATIVEANDMYSTICAL4HEREAREALSO LITURGICALREFERENCESTOTHE$IVINE/FlCE ANDMANYREFERENCESTO0ATRISTIC AND-EDIEVALCONTEMPLATIVEAUTHORS SUCHAS0SEUDO $IONYSIUS "ERNARD AND 2ICHARD OF 3AINT6ICTOR INDEED HE TRANSLATED IMPORTANT WORKS OF ALLTHREEOFTHESEINTO-IDDLE%NGLISHˆAMINISTRYCERTAINLYOFADEVOTED DISCIPLE 4HEREAREALSOREFERENCESTO!UGUSTINEAND'REGORYTHE'REAT ANDSCHOLARSBELIEVETHEREISANIMPLICITUTILIZATIONOFTHECONTEMPLATIVE THEOLOGYOF4HOMASOF!QUINAS4HISEVIDENTROOTEDNESSIN#ATHOLICTRA DITIONISSUFlCIENT *OHNSTONANDOTHERSSTRESS TOREFUTE0ROGOFF STHESIS THAT#ATHOLICTHEOLOGY SACRAMENTSAND3CRIPTUREITSELFAREFORTHEAUTHOR OF THE #LOUD D MERELY PREPARATORY PRO FORMA REFERENCES NOT INTRINSICALLY CONNECTED WITH HIS MYSTICAL TEACHING ITSELF /N THE OTHERHAND *OHNSTON WHOHASSPENTMUCHOFHISLIFE 4HEAUTHOROFTHE#LOUD IN*APANENGAGEDINTHE#ATHOLIC:ENDIALOGUE ALONG WITHOTHERSCHOLARS DOESACKNOWLEDGETHEhMANYPARAL ARGUESTHATTHESACREDTREE LELSINTHOUGHTANDEXPRESSIONvˆSTRIKINGBUTOFCOURSE UNINTENDEDˆBETWEENTHEWRITINGSOFTHEAUTHOROFTHE ISWITHINEACHOFUS #LOUDANDTHETEACHINGSOF:EN WHILEURGINGCAUTION AGAINSTEXCESSIVELYFACILEEQUATIONS 7HAT THEN ARESOMEOFTHEELEMENTSOFTHEAUTHOROFTHE#LOUDWHICH SEEMTORESONATEWITH"UDDHISM!LTHOUGHVERYAPOPHATICINHISSPIRITU ALITY TOHELPTHEDISCIPLETHEAUTHOREMPLOYSASERIESOFCONCRETEIMAGES ARCHETYPALINTHEIRDEPTH THATAREALSOSHAREDBY"UDDHISM4HEIMAGE OFTHESACREDTREE FOREXAMPLE REMINDSTHE#HRISTIANOFTHETREEOFLIFEIN PARADISE WHICHWASFULlLLEDINTHETREEOFLIFEON-T#ALVARY THATIS THE CROSSWHICHTHROUGHDEATHBRINGSLIFE!NDONERECALLSTHETREETHATTHETAX COLLECTOR:ACCHAEUSCLIMBEDINORDERTOSEE*ESUSINTHEMIDSTOFACROWD /FCOURSEITISUNDERTHE"ODHITREETHAT3IDDHARTHABECOMESTHE"UDDHA

THEAWAKENEDONE!NDTREESPLAYANIMPORTANTPARTINTHEh'ANDHAVYUHA v  THEPENULTIMATECHAPTEROFTHE !VATAMSAKA3UTRA FOREXAMPLEINTHEBE JEWELEDTREESOF!SHASGARDEN ASWELLASTHETREEOFKNIVESTHATTHEPILGRIM 3UDHANAMUSTCLIMB4HEAUTHOROFTHE#LOUDARGUESTHATTHESACREDTREE ISWITHINEACHOFUS ISEACHOFUS ANDTHATWENEEDTOGODOWNINTOTHE DEEPROOTSOFOURFEAR PRINCIPALLYOURFEAROFDEATH ANDTOACKNOWLEDGEBY FAITHTHATTHE,ORDOFLIFEWILLBRINGUSTHROUGHDEATH4HEN LIKE:ACCHAEUS AND3UDHANA WESHOULDCLIMBTHETRUNKTHROUGHLIVELYHOPEANDPLUCKTHE FRUITOFLOVE WHICHISCONTEMPLATIONANDETERNALLIFE

>HHJ: D8ID7:G




2OBERT(ALE

!NOTHERARCHETYPALSYMBOLINTHE#LOUDD ISTHESACREDMOUNTAIN WHICH ISALSOPRESENTINSOMANYCURRENTSOF"UDDHISM!NDOFCOURSEITISDECISIVE FOR*EWISH#HRISTIANSALVATIONHISTORY WITH3INAI -OUNT3ION THE-OUNT OFTHE"EATITUDES THE-OUNTOFTHE4RANSlGURATION -OUNT#ALVARY THE -OUNTOFTHE!SCENSION ETC4HEAUTHOROFTHE #LOUDTEACHESTHATHERE D AGAINWEWANTTOREALIZETHATTHESACREDMOUNTAINISWITHINEACHOFUS THAT N WEARECALLEDTOASCENDFROMTHELOWERLEVELSINTOTHEMYSTERIOUShCLOUDOF UNKNOWINGvATTHESUMMIT 4HE CLOUD ITSELF IS ARCHETYPAL APPEARING IN KEY TEXTS OF THE *EWISH SCRIPTURESASATHEOPHANOUSELEMENTVEILINGANDYETREVEALINGTHE$IVINE 0RESENCESEEFORINSTANCE%XODUSFFFF0SALMS  *UDGES%ZEKIEL ETC )NTHE.EW4ESTAMENTITISFROMTHECLOUDTHAT THE&ATHERSPEAKSAT#HRISTSTRANSlGURATIONONTHEMOUNTAIN-ATTHEW -ARK,UKE AND*ESUSASCENDSINTOACLOUDATTHEENDOF HISEARTHLYMINISTRY!CTS *ESUSPREDICTSTHATHEHIMSELFWILLRETURN INTHECLOUDSOFHEAVEN-ATTHEW-ARK :ENTEACHERSHAVE MENTIONED"UDDHISTTEXTSTHATDESCRIBETHEDISCIPLEINATHICKFOG HISROBES BECOMINGDRENCHEDWITHMOISTUREFROMTHEFOG SYMBOLIZINGBEINGBATHED INENLIGHTENMENT 4HEAUTHOROFTHE #LOUD INTHEAPOPHATICTRADITION INSISTSTHATTHESE AND OTHER SUCH IMAGES ARE MERE METAPHORS INTENDED TO POINT BEYOND THEMSELVESTOTHEINEFFABLE-YSTERY4HUSHEWRITES $ONOTTHINKTHATBECAUSE)CALLITAhDARKNESSvORAhCLOUDvTHAT ITISTHESORTOFCLOUDYOUSEEINTHESKY ORTHEKINDOFDARKNESSYOU KNOWWHENTHELIGHTISOUT)DONOTMEANTHATATALL"YhDARKNESSv )MEANALACKOFKNOWING FORYOUCANNOTSEEITWITHYOURINWARD EYE&ORTHISREASONITISCALLEDACLOUD NOTOFTHESKY OFCOURSE BUT OFUNKNOWING 4HUSTHEAUTHORSTRESSESTHEPROFOUNDPARADOXOFTHECONTEMPLATIVE EXPERIENCE QUOTING0SEUDO $IONYSIUSh4HEMOSTGODLYKNOWINGOF'OD ISTHATWHICHISKNOWNBYUNKNOWINGv 4HEAUTHOROFTHE #LOUDD STRESSES THISAGAINANDAGAIN "UTNOWYOUWOULDASKMEh(OWMIGHT)THINKOF'OD OFHOWHEIS INHIMSELFv!ND)CANONLYANSWERh)HAVENOIDEAv&ORWITHYOUR QUESTIONYOUHAVEBROUGHTMEINTOTHATSAMEDARKNESS THATSAME CLOUDOFUNKNOWING WHERE)WOULDTHATYOUYOURSELFBE 'ODISINEFFABLEMYSTERYANDTHEHUMANPERSONALSO4HEAUTHORSEX HORTATIONISTHAThTHESPIRITUALWORKERSHOULDALWAYSABIDEATTHESUPREME ANDSOVEREIGNPOINTOFTHESPIRITv "UTHEIMMEDIATELYGOESONTONOTETHAT



G:A><>DC:6HIL:HI


4HE!UTHOROFTHE#LOUDOF5NKOWINGAS4EACHERAND$ISCIPLE

ONECOULDSPEAKASWELLOFTHEhDEPTHvOFTHESPIRIT hFORINTHESPIRITUALREALM HEIGHTANDDEPTH LENGTHANDBREADTHAREALLTHESAMEv(EISSIMILARLY CAUTIOUSABOUTOTHERINTERIORITYLANGUAGE IFTAKENTOOSIMPLISTICALLY )FSOMEONEWERETODIRECTYOUTOGATHERTOGETHERWITHINYOURSELFYOUR FACULTIESANDPOWERSANDWORSHIP'ODTHERE )WOULDBEUNEASYWITH SUCHCOUNSEL LESTTHESEWORDSBETAKENINABODILYWAY EVENTHOUGH THEYARETRULYSAID ANDNONEMORETRUEIFUNDERSTOODRIGHTLY-Y COUNSELISTOTAKECARETHATYOUAREINNOSENSEWITHINYOURSELF4OPUT ITBRIEmY )WOULDHAVEYOUBENEITHEROUTSIDENORABOVENORBEHIND NORONESIDEOROTHEROFYOURSELF7HERETHEN YOUMIGHTASK AM)TO BE!CCORDINGTOSUCHLANGUAGE NOWHERE4HATISWHERE)WOULDHAVE YOUBE"ECAUSENOWHEREBODILYISEVERYWHERESPIRITUALLY )NASIMILARWAY THEAUTHORQUALIlESHISOWNBASICIMAGEOFASCENDING THEMOUNTAIN WHENHEWRITESOFTHEEXPERIENCEOFUNION )FANDWHENITPLEASES'OD THOSEWHOATlRSTACHIEVEITBUTSELDOM

ANDONLYWITHGREATEFFORT SHALLAFTERWARDSHAVEITWHENTHEYWILL ANDASOFTENASTHEYLIKE-OSESAGAINISOUREXAMPLE WHOATlRST COULDONLYSEETHEARKINASORTOFWAY RARELYANDAFTERGREATEFFORT ONTHEMOUNTAIN BUTAFTERWARDS ASOFTENASHELIKED SAWITINTHE VALLEY 3OMEDISCIPLESSEEKCONSOLATIONSANDUNIONWITH'ODOR INTHE"UD DHISTTRADITION ENLIGHTENMENT WITHAHUMANCRAVINGTHATISNOTHELPFUL D )NTHISREGARD THEAUTHOROFTHE #LOUDHASADELIGHTFULRECOMMENDATION THATEXPRESSESSOMETHINGMUCHDEEPERPERHAPSTHANJUST%NGLISHRESERVE 3OBEWAREOFBEHAVINGWILDLYLIKESOMEANIMALANDLEARNTOLOVE'OD WITHQUIET EAGERJOY ATRESTINBODYANDINSOUL2EMEMBERYOUR MANNERS ANDWAITHUMBLYUPONOUR,ORDSWILL$ONOTSNATCHAT IT LIKESOMEFAMISHEDGREYHOUND HOWEVERMUCHYOUYEARNFORIT)F )MAYUSEANAMUSINGEXAMPLE )WOULDSUGGESTYOUDOALLYOUCAN TOCONCEALYOURGREATANDIMPASSIONEDSPIRITUALURGE ASTHOUGHYOU WEREALTOGETHERUNWILLINGTHAT'ODSHOULDKNOWHOWVERYMUCHYOU DESIRETOSEEANDHAVEANDEXPERIENCE'OD 4HEAUTHORDOES HOWEVER PROPOSESOMECONCRETEPRACTICESTHATWILL

IFNOTAUTOMATICALLYPOSSESS'OD ATLEASTDISPOSETHEDISCIPLEFORTHEGRACE OFUNION/NEOFTHESEISABRIEFPRAYERRECITEDAGAINANDAGAININTHEHEART /NEISREMINDEDOFTHE*ESUS0RAYER ORh0RAYEROFTHE(EARTvOFTHE%ASTERN #HRISTIANTRADITION ANDPERHAPSOFTHEMANTRATRADITIONIN(INDUISMAND "UDDHISM ANDOFTHE"UDDHISTTRADITIONOFRECITINGTHE"UDDHASNAME >HHJ: D8ID7:G




2OBERT(ALE

4HEAUTHOROFTHE #LOUDTHUSDESCRIBESHISMONOLOGISTICPRAYER D 4HINKNOTHOUGHTABOUT'OD!NAKEDINTENTIONDIRECTEDTO'ODALONE ISWHOLLYSUFlCIENT)FYOUWANTTHISINTENTIONSUMMEDUPINAWORD TORETAINITMOREEASILY TAKEASHORTWORD PREFERABLYOFONESYLLABLE TO DOSO4HESHORTERTHEBETTER MOREINACCORDWITHTHE3PIRIT!WORD LIKE'ODOR,OVE#HOOSEWHICHYOULIKE ORPERHAPSSOMEOTHER JUST SOITISSHORT ANDlXTHISWORDTOYOURHEARTSOTHATWHATEVERHAP PENSITWILLNOTGOAWAY7ITHTHISWORDYOUARETOPRESSDOWNALL THOUGHTSUNDERTHECLOUDOFFORGETTING SOTHATIFANYTHOUGHTPRESS UPONYOUANDASKWHATYOUWOULDHAVE YOURESPONDWITHNOTHING ELSETHANTHIS!NDIFYOUWOULDGOONTOANALYZELEARNEDLYTHEWORD TELLYOURSELFRATHERTHATYOUWILLSTICKWITHTHEWORDASIS ANDNOT TAKENAPARTINPIECES !MONGTHEFEWPRACTICESSUGGESTEDBYTHEAUTHOROFTHE#LOUD MORE SEVEREFORMSOFASCETICISMARE NOTNUMBERED)NFACT HEISCONCERNEDTHAT T lXATIONONSUCHTHINGShCANDESTROYCOMPLETELYANDlNALLYTHEFREEDOMOF #HRIST FOR@WHERETHE3PIRITOFTHE,ORDIS THEREISFREEDOM))#OR v (EADDRESSESSPECIlCALLYQUESTIONSABOUTFASTING VIGILSANDSILENCEINHIS SHORTWORK4HE$ISCERNMENTOF3TIRRINGS!YOUNGDISCIPLEHASWRITTENHIM ASKINGABOUTTHESEASCETICALFORMS ANDTHEAUTHORRESPONDSBYNOTINGTHAT THOSEWHOhHAVEBEENSTRICTESTvINTHESESEEMREGULARLYTOSUFFERhTHEMOST DISASTROUSFALLSv(ENOTESTHATTHESEPRACTICESCANSOMETIMES INAWISE MEASURE BEHELPFUL SOMETIMESNOT BUTTHEYAREALLONLYMEANS NOTTHE ENDINITSELF4HEYINFACThAREINTHEMSELVESUNIMPORTANTv 4HE AUTHOR HERE OFFERS A CAVEAT WHICH GIVES EVIDENCE OF HIS GREAT HUMILITYASTEACHERANDGUIDE(EWRITESTHATHEHESITATESTOGIVESPECIlC RECOMMENDATIONSTOHISDISCIPLE ANDFORTWOREASONS 4HElRSTISTHIS)DARENOTRELYONMYOWNVIEWANDASSERTTHATITIS ABSOLUTELYTRUETHEOTHERISTHATYOURINNERMAKE UPANDYOURCAPAC ITYFORALLTHETHINGSYOURLETTERSPEAKSOFARENOTASWELLKNOWNTOME ASTHEYOUGHTTOBEIF)AMTOGIVEYOUADEQUATEADVICE 7OULDTHATALLSPIRITUALDIRECTORSINALLTRADITIONSMIGHTBESOAWARE OF THEIR LIMITS 4HE AUTHOR THEN PROPOSES A GENERAL APPROACH TO ASCETIC PRACTICES(ESAYSTOLINETHEMUPONTHEONESIDE PUTTHEIROPPOSITEON THEOTHER ANDCHOOSESOMETHINGINTHEMIDDLE BETWEENFASTINGANDEATING SILENCEANDSPEAKING SOLITUDEANDCOMMUNITY ETC "UTOFCOURSEYOUWILLASKMEWHATTHAThSOMETHINGvIS)TIS'OD FOR WHOSESAKEYOUAREQUIETIFYOUSHOULDBEQUIET FORWHOSESAKEYOU



G:A><>DC:6HIL:HI


4HE!UTHOROFTHE#LOUDOF5NKOWINGAS4EACHERAND$ISCIPLE

SPEAKIFYOUHAVETOSPEAK FORWHOSESAKEYOUFASTIFYOUOUGHTTO FAST ANDSOON4HENCHOOSE'OD ANDYOUWILLSPEAKBYYOURSILENCE

ANDTHEREWILLBEASILENCEINYOURSPEECH YOUWILLBEFASTINGWHILE YOUEAT ANDEATINGWHENYOUFAST ANDALLTHEREST 4HISMIDDLEWAY ATITSDEEPEST INEFFABLE#ENTER ISTHEAUTHORSWAYhTO BE/NEDWITH'OD vTHE'ODWHOISKNOWNANDLOVEDBYUNKNOWINGs

.OTES  #LIFTON7OLTERS h)NTRODUCTION vIN#LOUDOF5NKNOWING-IDDLESEX0ENGUIN"OOKS G    $AVID+NOWLES 4HE%NGLISH-YSTICAL4RADITION.EW9ORK(ARPER    %VELYN5NDERHILL -YSTICSOFTHE#HURCH.EW9ORK3CHOCKEN"OOKS    #FFORINSTANCE'EORGE-ALONEY 3* h0REFACEvIN4HE0URSUITOF7ISDOMAND/THER 7ORKSBYTHE!UTHOROFTHE#LOUDOF5NKNOWING.EW9ORK0AULIST0RESS   G  #F7ILLIAM*OHNSTON 3* 4HE-YSTICISMOFTHE#LOUDOF5NKNOWING3T-EINRAD )NDIANA!BBEY0RESS  4HEPUBLISHEDWORKINCLUDESALAUDATORYFOREWORDBY 4HOMAS-ERTON  *OHN-OORMAN !(ISTORYOFTHE#HURCHIN%NGLAND,ONDON!#"LACK    #FFORINSTANCE"ARBARA4UCHMAN !$ISTANT-IRROR4HE#ALAMITOUS&OURTEENTH #ENTURY.EW9ORK+NOPF    #FFORINSTANCE*AMES7ALSH 3* INHISINTRODUCTIONTO4HE#LOUD   #FFORINSTANCE*OHNSTON 4HE-YSTICISMOFTHE#LOUD FF  )BID   FF ETC  #F-ALONEY 4HE0URSUITOF7ISDOM FF  #FFORINSTANCE #LOUD CHAPTER0URSUITOF7ISDOM   #LOUD CH)SHALLUSEINCITATIONSMYOWNRENDERINGOFTHECRITICALTEXTSOF0HYLLIS (ODGSON WITHTHEHELPOFTHE7OLTERSANDTHE7ALSHRENDERINGS  )BID CH  )BID CH  )BID CH  )BID  )BID CH  )BID CH  )BID CH  "ISHOP+ALLISTOS7AREHASDRAWNTHISPARALLELBETWEENMONOLOGISTICPRAYERINTHE #LOUDANDIN2ICHARD2OLLE ONTHEONEHAND ANDTHE%ASTERN#HRISTIANTRADITION D ONTHEOTHER  #LOUD CH -ALONEY 4HE0URSUITOF7ISDOM   )SHALLUSEFORPAGEREFERENCESTHEELEGANTMODERN%NGLISHREADINGBY#LIFTON7OLTERS

!3TUDYOF7ISDOM4HREE4RACTSBYTHE!UTHOROFTHE#LOUDOF5NKNOWING&AIRACRES

/XFORD3,'0RESS    )BID   )BID

>HHJ: D8ID7:G




2OBERT(ALE  )BID   )BID  4HISISTHESUBTITLEOFTHE#LOUDOF5NKNOWING THOUGHITUNFORTUNATELYISNOTINCLUDED INCONTEMPORARYVERSIONS3EE(ODGSON 



G:A><>DC:6HIL:HI


Issue6_art4