Page 1

Columbus Square’s #MeToo Moment 06

Garodnick Exits Council 08

Access Affordable Care Now 10


December 14 – 27, 2017 | Vol. 03 No. 25



Columbus Square’s #MeToo Moment 06

Garodnick Exits Council 08

Access Affordable Care Now 10


Mayor Bill de Blasio spoke about the importance of saving small businesses throughout Manhattan by reforming the commercial rent tax. To his left is Natasha Amott, a local business owner, and to his right is Councilmember Dan Garodnick who sponsored the bill. Borough President Gale Brewer is at the far left and Councilmember Helen Rosenthal is at the far right.

Garodnick, Rosenthal, Mayor Cheer Commercial Rent Tax Break BY REBECCA FIORE At a City Hall press conference held on Nov. 30, East Side City Councilmember Dan Garodnick was joined by Mayor Bill de Blasio, Manhattan Borough President Gale Brewer, and Upper West Side Councilmember Helen Rosenthal in celebrating passage of Garodnick’s bill that reforms the commercial rent tax (CRT) that can often have a severely negative economic impact on local small businesses. CRT was created in 1963 as a revenue generator that charged businesses citywide paying more than $250,000 in annual rent a 3.9 percent levy on that rent. In the 1990s, it was restricted to Manhattan businesses below 96th St. The last time this tax had seen reform was in 2001, Garodnick said, when the “average ground floor commercial rent in the heart of Soho was $175 per square foot. Today that rent is more like $755 per square foot. That’s an increase of 431 percent.” The councilmember added, “You know what hasn’t TAX BREAK continued on p. 5

December 14 – 27, 2017 | Vol. 03 No. 25

Pages 2,3,4 Photo by Christian Miles

An NYPD officer guards a sealed-off entrance to the subway platforms below the Port Authority bus terminal on the morning of December 11.

NYC Parks OKs Natural History Expansion; Critics Vow Lawsuit BY PAUL SCHINDLER Achieving a significant milestone in its effort to build a 245,000-square-foot expansion devoted to science education, the American Museum of Natural History has won approval for the project from the city Department of Parks and Recreation. That approval, announced last week, was necessary since construction of the Richard Gilder Center for Science, Education, and Innovation — slated for completion in 2019, coinciding with the museum’s 150th anniversary — would seize surrounding land currently part of the Theodore Roosevelt Park. The parks department’s action drew immediate

fire from opponents of the project, with Community United to Protect Theodore Roosevelt Park issuing a blistering release charging the city with “an amazing display of indifference to and contempt for the health, well-being, and lives of tens of thousands of New Yorkers.” Working with attorney Michael Hiller, the group is threatening a lawsuit, a move supported by other critics including the Defenders of Teddy Roosevelt Park. Roughly one-quarter of the Gilder Center would be built onto land currently part of the park, which surrounds the museum in the superblock EXPANSION continued on p. 5


After Port Authority Terror Blast, Resilient Commuters Carry On BY LINCOLN ANDERSON An explosion of what police called a “low-tech” pipe bomb in a tunnel near the Port Authority early on the morning of Mon., Dec. 11, sent a shock through the city and a ripple of panic through one of the world’s busiest bus terminals. Downtowners were awakened shortly after the blast to the blare of sirens and the beat of helicopters overhead as first responders raced Uptown. Akayed Ullah, 27, was under arrest for allegedly detonating the bomb around 7:20 a.m. in an underground walkway near the Port Authority that connects the Eighth Ave. IND subway lines with the IRT lines at Times Square and the 42nd St. Shuttle. Three people had minor injuries, Fire Department Commissioner Dan Nigro said. Ullah, meanwhile, sustained serious injuries to his hands and abdomen when he detonated the device, Nigro said, and was taken to Bellevue Hospital. Mayor Bill de Blasio called it an “attempted terrorist attack.” Initially, police shut down major crosstown streets, including 14th St., so emergency vehicles could move about unimpeded. Although the attack sent a ripple of fear

Photo by Lincoln Anderson

Straphangers, undaunted, were flowing through the subway at W. 14th St. and Eighth Ave., just a few hours after Dec. 11’s Midtown blast.

through the city, it didn’t totally derail the morning commute. Three hours after the bomb blast, straphangers were busy bustling in and out of the IND subway station at Eighth Ave. and W. 14th St. “People are in the system,” an NYC Transit worker said as he emerged from the stairs at the southwest corner, on his way to buy a coffee from a nearby vendor’s cart. “People don’t stop,” he said. “It’s New York City, it’s just a blip on the screen,” he said of the incident. Frank Kulbaski, 51, a lawyer for PayPal




at its office in the West Village, had watched reports on the blast on TV before heading in to work from Long Island City, Queens. “The chance of getting hurt is like the chance of winning the lottery — and I haven’t had any luck with the lottery,” he shrugged. Instead of taking the 7 train and then switching to the IRT at 42nd St., as usual, he instead hiked over to Court Square and took the E train all the way to 14th St. “It made my commute much longer,” he said, “but I got to work.” A woman smoking a cigarette on the

sidewalk before going down into the subway said the morning’s events were shaking up her plans since she had to go all over the city. “I’m modifying everything,” she said. “I’m a dog walker, so I’m modifying everything.” She noted she was a third-generation Villager — “There are still some of us around!” she quipped — but didn’t want to give her name. Two young tourists, Vincent Schablinski, 25, and Claire Jean, 23, had just bought a $5 arepa at an openair sidewalk cooking operation on the corner, and — after Jean had taken some souvenir shots of him chowing down on it — were ready to hop into the subway. Asked if they were frightened by what had happened, they said, no. “The city is so big,” Schablinski, from Germany, said while polishing off the arepa, “that [if] it happens to you or me — the risk is really low, actually nothing.” They were staying at the Dream Downtown hotel in the Meatpacking District and, clearly undaunted, were heading up to take a look at yet another major transit hub: Grand Central Terminal.

Advent & Christmastide at St. Luke’s





CHRISTMAS EVE | SUNDAY, DEC 24TH 5:00 pm — Christmas Pageant & Eucharist 9:30 pm — Prelude of Christmas Music 10:00 pm — Festive Choral Eucharist

CHRISTMAS DAY | MONDAY, DEC 25TH 10:30 am — Choral Eucharist

NEW YEARS DAY | MONDAY, JAN. 1ST 2018 FEAST OF THE HOLY NAME 12:00 pm — Choral Eucharist

The Church of Saint Luke in the Fields | 487 Hudson Street West Village (Hudson and Grove) New York, NY 10014 www.stlukeinthefields.org | 212.924.0562 VISIT PCRICHARD.COM FOR A STORE NEAREST YOU 2

December 14, 2017

NYC Community Media

Photo by Christian Miles

The area around Eighth Ave. and W. 42nd St., blocked off on the morning of Dec. 11.

Five Federal Charges for Port Authority Bombing Suspect BY DUSICA SUE MALESEVIC The man accused of detonating a device near the Port Authority Bus Terminal during the early morning commute of Mon., Dec. 11 has been charged with five federal counts. Prosecutors charged Akayed Ullah, 27, with the use of weapons of mass destruction, bombing a place of public use, destruction of property by means of fire or explosive, provision of material support to a designated foreign terrorist organization, and the use of a destructive device during and in furtherance of a crime of violence in a criminal complaint filed in federal court on Tues., Dec. 12. The criminal complaint sheds some light on what motivated Ullah, who, according to news reports, came from Bangladesh in 2011 and lived in Brooklyn as a legal permanent resident, to carry out an attack that created commuting chaos and caused three people to sustain minor injuries. Ullah was inspired by ISIS to carry out the attack, according to the complaint. “I did it for the Islamic State,” Ullah said, as cited in the complaint. On his way to carry out the attack, the complaint states that Ullah posted on his Facebook account, “Trump you failed to protect your nation.” Ullah “chose to carry out the attack on a workday because he believed that there would be more people,” according to the complaint. NYC Community Media

Photo by Christian Miles

Just after 9:30 a.m. on Dec. 11, at W. 42nd St. and Eighth Ave., Mayor Bill de Blasio and Governor Andrew Cuomo spoke at a press briefing. NYPD, FDNY, and MTA representatives also provided information.

AP photo by A.M. Ahad

On Dec. 12, a man in Dhaka, Bangladesh reads a national paper with front-paged news, and a photo, of 27-year-old Bangladeshi Akayed Ullah, suspect in the previous day’s NYC’s subway system bombing.

Transit video shows people walking, including Ullah, who was later identified by police officers in the underground tunnel that connects the A, C, and E trains to other lines from the Times Square station on Mon., Dec. 11 at about 7:18 a.m., according to the complaint. A few seconds later, there appears to be an explosion, and Ullah seems to fall to the ground, according to the complaint. Members of the Port Authority Police Department (PAPD) found Ullah, and he was taken into custody. PAPD officers Anthony Manfredini, Jack Collins, Sean Gallagher and Drew Preston, “entered a smoke and debris-filled subway passageway, struggled with the suspect, and denied him the ability to cause further chaos and destruction,” Paul Nunziato, president of the Port Authority Police Benevolent Association, said in a statement posted to the association’s Twitter account. Law enforcement found components of an exploded pipe bomb on Ullah and in the surrounding area, a nine-volt battery inside his pants pocket, and wires connected to the battery and running underneath his jacket, according to the complaint. At a press briefing held just after 9:30 a.m. that Monday, NYPD Commissioner James O’Neill said the device was strapped to Ullah’s body with Velcro and zip ties. BOMBING continued on p. 14 December 14, 2017


Photos by Colin Mixson via Community News Group

Cops swarmed a Kensington building on Ocean Parkway between Webster and Newkirk Aves. amid their investigation into Brooklyn resident Akayed Ullah, who police accused of igniting an explosive device in Manhattan on Dec. 11.

Alleged bomber Akayed Ullah once lived with his family in a Flatlands home on E. 48th St. between avenues N and M (green-trimmed roof in this photo), but moved out years ago, according to a statement his relatives released via their lawyer following the incident.

Brooklynites Describe Bombing Suspect as ‘Shy’ and ‘Quiet’ BY COLIN MIXSON Cops busted a Brooklyn man suspected of nearly blowing himself up in a botched subway bombing on Mon., Dec. 11 that injured three straphangers and shocked residents who never considered their neighbor could be an alleged terrorist. A Flatlands local described 27-year-

old Bangladeshi immigrant Akayed Ullah, who once resided in the neighborhood at E. 48th St. between avenues M and N, as a “shy and quiet” man whose inconspicuousness may have been a warning sign of his behavior to come. “It’s the quiet ones you’ve got to watch out for,” said Alan Butrico, who



THURSDAY, DECEMBER 24 CHRISTMAS EVE 35.$!9 $%#%-"%2s#(2)34-!3%6% Candle Lighting Lighting Candle Service and Service and Reception Reception AT 4:30P.M. P.M. AT 4:30

Annual Eve 25thChristmas Anniversary Performance of Performance of Handel’s Messiah Handel’s Messiah Christmas Portion and Christmas Portion and Hallelujah Chorus Hallelujah Chorus

AT AT7:30 7:30 P.M. P.M. SUNDAY, SUNDAY,DECEMBER DECEMBER 27 31 KwanzaaCelebration Celebration Kwanzaa 11:00A.M. A.M. ATAT11:00


December 14, 2017



owns the house next door to the one Ullah lived in, as well as a hardware store at E. 48th St. and Avenue N. Authorities apprehended Ullah after a “low-tech” improvised-explosive device strapped to his body ignited at 7:20 a.m. inside an underground passage linking two busy Manhattan subway stations. The suspect lived with his parents and brother at the Flatlands home, according to Butrico, who said he never saw police at the house next to his — until Monday, when dozens of investigators swarmed the block, which they cordoned off for hours after the explosion. But Ullah’s family members claimed he moved out of the Flatlands house some time ago. “We would like to note that it has been widely misreported that Akayed Ullah resides at an address on East 48th Street, Brooklyn, NY, but this is incorrect, and he has not resided there for many years,” read a statement issued by the Council on AmericanIslamic Relations on behalf of the family. On Mon. night, speakng to the media, Albert Fox Cahn, legal director for CAIR-NY, read from that statement, noting the family is “heartbroken by the violence that was targeted at our city today and by the allegations being made against a member of our family.” But they were also “outraged by the behavior of the law enforcement officials who have held children as small as four years old out in the cold and who pulled a teenager out of high school classes to interrogate him without a lawyer, without his parents.” Butrico said that his tenant who

lives in the house next door to Ullah’s former residence recently complained of loud arguments coming from inside the home, including a shouting match that occurred the night before the alleged terrorist’s assault. There was nothing outwardly remarkable about the Bangladeshi man, according to Butrico, who said his only interaction with Ullah’s family was when they parked their car in front of his driveway. “They didn’t care,” he said. “They felt like they owned the block.” Investigators also stormed a Kensington building following Ullah’s bungled assault, alarming locals who said they never thought they could have neighbors tied to terror. “I’m really scared,” said David Scoffe, who lives a few blocks away from the crime scene 679 Ocean Pkwy. “You don’t know who your neighbors are.” Ullah caused more damage to himself in his bungled attack than he did to his intended targets, according to FDNY Commissioner Dan Nigro, who said police found the alleged terrorist with burns and lacerations to his abdomen and hands. His victims, however, suffered minor injuries in the form of ringing ears and headaches, and all three checked themselves into hospitals, Nigro said. Both NYPD Commissioner James O’Neill and Governor Andrew Cuomo described the detonation as intentional, but a New York Times report citing unnamed sources stated the device malfunctioned, and that the explosion failed to produce the shrapnel necessary to effect greater carnage. NYC Community Media

TAX BREAK continued from p. 1

changed, commercial rent tax. It has been stuck. Every year of inaction by the city has basically been a tax hike on small businesses that were never meant to be affected by this tax in the first place… We are doubling the threshold of commercial rent tax to $500,000 that will deliver relief to nearly 3,000 Manhattan businesses.” He said that out of those businesses, about 1,800 with less than $5 million in annual revenues and that pay less than $500,000 in annual rent will no longer be liable for any CRT. In addition, another 900 businesses, making up to $10 million in revenue and paying up to $550,000 per year in rent will pay a reduced tax, based on a sliding scale. The tax relief will come in the form of an offsetting credit against the CRT liability, according to a release from Garodnick’s office. Businesses that pay over $550,000 in rent would not receive any credit. The credit will be available to taxpayers Jan. 1, 2018. Both Garodnick and de Blasio said the bill was designed to ensure only small businesses would benefit from the reform. Natasha Amott, owner of a kitchen supply store, Whisk, at 933 Broadway btw. E. 21st & E. 22nd Sts., didn’t know this tax existed when she opened her store in 2012. “It was only in the beginning of 2015 that I received notification from the city that not only did I have to start paying the tax immediately but that I also had to pay the other years with interest,” she said at the press conference. Since then, Amott said, she has paid tens of thousands of dollars to the city in taxes. “My frustration led to questioning those in the government about the fairness of the tax,” she said. Working with the City Council,

politicians, and other local business owners, Amott said she finally felt heard. “Not having to pay this annual tax means that each year I can consider making needed updates in my stores, upgrades to my website, and pay increases to my staff.” “The small businesses that are going to benefit will save on average $13,000,” de Blasio said. “For a long time this was the city of small business. If you had a great idea, you could thrive. We need New York City to be the best place for small businesses in this country.” Councilmember Rosenthal said everyday she’s heard from constituents on the Upper West Side who are concerned about local businesses. “Bringing nearly a billion dollars, we have treated for far too long the tax collected from these businesses as an ATM for the rest of the city,” Rosenthal said. “But let’s be clear, the cost of this tax is felt citywide. These businesses employ residents from throughout the five boroughs, so when Manhattan small businesses close, all New Yorkers lose.” The mayor discussed the significance of small businesses, which not only serve local neighborhoods, but also bring character to communities, bringing them together. He said that everyone has seen stores leave at an alarming rate, replaced by empty window fronts or major corporate chains like Starbucks and CVS. “Anyone with eyes understands that there is a crisis with our mom and pop stores,” he said. While this bill is a step in the right direction, it’s just a first step in solving the retail crisis, de Blasio said. “Consumers have a role to play here too,” he said. “Buy local. It makes a big difference. If you love a store, patronize it. Don’t talk about patronizing it, actually patronize it. They cannot pay the bills with your good intentions.”

PUBLISHER Jennifer Goodstein jgoodstein@cnglocal.com Manhattan Express, the newspaper for Midtown and the Upper East and Upper West Sides PUBLISHED BY

NYC COMMUNITY MEDIA, LLC One Metrotech North, 10th Floor, Brooklyn, NY 11201 Phone: (212) 229-1890 | Fax: (212) 229-2790 www.manhattanexpressnews.nyc © 2017 NYC Community Media, LLC NYC Community Media

EDITOR IN-CHIEF Paul Schindler editor@manhttanexpressnews.nyc ART DIRECTOR John Napoli

EXPANSION continued from p. 1

from Central Park West to Columbus Ave. between W. 77th and W. 81st Sts. According to museum plans, the construction would alter roughly 75,000 square feet of the park and involve the destruction of more than half a dozen older trees — though the planting of 17 new trees has been offered as compensation. The $340 million dollar project — to be funded with government money perhaps up to one third of the total, with $90 million allocated to date — aims to create new exhibition and educational space and improve visitor flow throughout the museum and would create a new entrance to the institution on the Columbus Ave. side near W. 79th St. Though opposition to the Gilder Center initially focused on the ecological and pedestrian disruption to a treasured quiet neighborhood park, opponents have broadened their critique to include what they warn would be environmental dangers in the construction process and dramatically increased traffic in the area. In Community United’s release, the group’s co-president, Claudia DiSalvo, said, “The museum administration is about to dig into poisoned earth, scattering toxic substances into our air, water, and soil. It does not care that it is fueling the terrible traffic problems we already have, or about the destruction of quiet parkland for this pseudo-Disneyland building, which has nothing to do with science, education, or innovation. A major entrance on Columbus Avenue would destroy our neighborhood, and we’re going to stop it if we have to wrap ourselves around the trees or block the bulldozers.” The group charged that Parks Commissioner Mitchell Silver’s approval came after a 10-day public comment period, coinciding with Thanksgiving week, regarding the Final Environmental Impact Statement. “The FEIS is incomplete in its health and safety information despite being over 8,000 pages long,” the group charged. “Officials have also decided to ignore objections raised by the original Draft Environmental Impact Statement.” A report issued earlier this year by GHD Services, an engineering and envi-

CONTRIBUTORS Rebecca Fiore Donna Aceto Lincoln Anderson Nathan DiCamillo Bill Egbert Dusica Sue Malesevic Colin Mixson Lenore Skenazy Scott Stiffler Eileen Stukane

ADVERTISING Amanda Tarley ads@manhattanexpressnews.nyc 718-260-8340 ACCOUNT EXECUTIVES Gayle Greenberg Andrew Mark Jim Steele Julio Tumbaco

ronmental consulting firm engaged by Community United, had faulted that draft study for failing to consider “socioeconomic conditions” or to provide “sufficient information” about hazardous materials, transportation, and construction related to the project. “Commissioner Silver’s approval comes as no surprise, DiSalvo wrote in an email to Manhattan Express on December 13. “Our pleas to elected and museum officials for transparency and public hearings on the environmental impacts, plans to mitigate toxic and cancer-causing materials on the site, and the use of $140 million tax dollars committed to this project have fallen on deaf ears.” She added, “We will see the AMNH in court.” Support for Community United’s threatened lawsuit by the Defenders of Teddy Roosevelt Park suggests that the museum’s efforts to sideline critics by inviting their involvement in the planning process have not been fully successful. At the museum’s invitation, the Defenders participated in the project’s Park Working Group, but the group also continued to offer criticism at public forums. Earlier this year, Lydia Thomas, the Defenders’ president, told Manhattan Express that the Draft Environmental Impact Statement was “wide-ranging but seems to resolve every issue in the museum’s favor. From loss of parkland to increased congestion, it concludes there is ‘no significant adverse impact.’’” Responding to Community United’s charges, a museum spokesperson wrote, “Community United’s press release is unfounded and contrary to the comprehensive environmental review undertaken over the course of several years. As set forth in the Final Environmental Impact Statement, the project will not pose any public health risks with respect to hazardous materials. Materials of similar type and extent are commonly found at construction sites throughout New York City and can be controlled through the use of well-accepted remedial measures, which were reviewed and approved by the New York City Department of Environmental Protection.” The museum has not been served with a lawsuit, that spokesperson said.

Member of the New York Press Association

Send all inquiries to: Manhattan Express, One Metrotech Center North, Suite 1001, Brooklyn 11201 or call 718260-4586. Written permission of the publisher must be obtained before any of the contents of this paper, in part or whole, can be reproduced or redistributed. Manhattan Express is a registered trademark of NYC Community Media, LLC. Subscriptions: 26 issues, $49.00

December 14, 2017


‘Me Too’ Movement’s Message: Believe,

Photos by Christian Miles

Many people held up handmade signs.

BY REBECCA FIORE Call them silence breakers, call them warriors, or call them survivors — but neither snow nor wind nor hail stopped them from rallying together on the afternoon of Sat., Dec. 9, outside Trump International Hotel and Tower at Columbus Circle. United to end sexual harassment and assault for women and men of all ages and backgrounds, #MeToo Rally NYC was organized by Connie Vasquez and Annmarie Haubert, two women who faced their own experiences with sexual assault and were brought together by the ubiquitous hashtag. “I was 14 the first time. Then I was 17. Then I was 21. Even as recently as three months ago,� Haubert said. “I want to change the way that everybody looks at sexual assault. I want to stop the victim blaming.� The Me Too movement started with activist Tarana Burke and was re-popularized by actress Alyssa Milano, who used it as a hashtag in response to Hollywood producer and sexual predator Harvey Weinstein. A crowd of roughly 150 people held handmade, snow-covered signs including: “#MeToo,� “Even dogs under-

stand the concept of ‘no,’ � and “SILENT NO MORE.� Refuse Fascism handed out signs that read “The Sexual Predator-inChief and whole Trump/Pence Regime Must Go!� Some speakers pointed toward the Trump hotel during their speeches. Elizabeth Cronise McLaughlin, a woman’s leadership coach, attorney, and host of Resistance Live, a political podcast, shared her story of child sexual abuse. She said from ages 12 to 16 she was “groomed and repeatedly molested by a family therapist who also happens to be a long standing friend of my parents.� When she was 19 she took him to court, to have his practicing license removed. She lost her case, because there were no witnesses, she said. “As I lay naked under my abuser, while my soul hung out in the trees outside of his office, I suddenly knew with a force that could not be denied that a day would come when I would rise to fight,� she said. “That day, deep within my little girl soul, a warrior was born. And to this day that spirit guides everything I do, in every way I choose. So make no mistake, I’m a warrior now.� “Thanks to this,� she said, as she ges-

You are invited to spend Advent & Christmas with Historic St. Peter’s Chelsea Episcopal Church The Christmas Church

ADVENT & CHRISTMAS SERVICES Saturday, December 16, 2017 5:00pm-8:00pm Tree Lighting & Neighborhood Advent Reception

Sunday, December 17, 2017, Advent 3 9:00am Children & Family Service 10:00am Holy Eucharist 6:00pm Evening Prayer

Thursday, December 21, 2017 7:00pm Annual Community Messiah Sing

Sunday, December 24, 2017, Advent 4 & Christmas Eve 10:00am Advent Lessons & Carols 5:30pm Children & Family Christmas Eve Service 10:00pm Carols 10:30pm Mass of the Angels

Monday, December 25, 2017, Christmas Day 9:00am Children & Family Service 10:00am Holy Eucharist 6:00pm Evening Prayer

Sunday, January 7, 2018, Epiphany 9:00am Children & Family Service 10:00am Holy Eucharist 6:00pm Evening Prayer

St. Peter’s Episcopal Church 346 W. 20th St. (btwn 8th & 9th Aves.) 212.929.2390 | stpeterschelsea.org 6

December 14, 2017

                 ! ! "#$ % &%"%  ! "  %'&"' !   $ "(  !" ) %$*+ + ,&"         




  !"# $#%&&'((()(*+),-.* !!'&' '#%)!

/%!0 NYC Community Media

Don’t Blame, Survivors of Sexual Abuse

Betty Teng, licensed master social worker and a therapist specializing in trauma, explained why survivors don’t usually come out right away and how their “experiences are so overwhelming that the brain blocks these experiences to protect its own sanity.”

tured toward the high-rise overlooking Central Park, “We are all warriors now.” On Mon., Dec. 11, three of the numerous women who came forward with accusations of sexual misconduct against then-candidate Donald Trump held a press conference to reassert those charges and — emboldened by the Me Too movement — call for congressional scrutiny of the president. While the White

House has deemed these allegations as “fake news,” some members of congress, including New York State Senator Kirsten Gillibrand, called for Trump’s resignation. A mere three days after the rally, Trump tweeted about “lightweight” Gillibrand, calling her “someone who ME TOO continued on p. 12

Shaun Dougherty held up a picture of his 10-year-old self, the age at which he started being sexually abused. The Navy veteran joined the New Yorkers Against Hidden Predators, and is working on getting the Child Victims Act passed, which would eliminate the statute of limitations of child sex crimes.

(formerly known as Nancy Burner & Associates, P.C.)

Elder Law, Estate Planning, Guardianships, Trusts & Estates

Updating Your Estate Plan January 9 at 10:00 am

Caregivers’ Guide to Medicaid January 25 at 10:00 am

River Room Stuyvesant Town 545 East 14th St. (off Ave. B)

WorkHouse 21 W 46th Street (between 5th and 6th Ave)

Please RSVP at (212) 867-3520 or email info@burnerlaw.com NYC Community Media

December 14, 2017


Crowded Agenda in Garodnick’s Finish BY REBECCA FIORE In Jan. 2006, Daniel Garodnick assumed office as East Side District 4’s city councilmember and at the conclusion of a tenure spanning the 12-year maximum allowed under the city’s term limit scheme, he boasts most recently of having made affordable housing protections more transparent, providing needed tax relief to small businesses, and creating more public space and infrastructure improvements while promoting office building development in East Midtown. At the Nov. 30 Council meeting, Garodnick, along with Bronx Councilmember Ritchie Torres, steered passage of a predatory equity measure that will create a watch list of buildings purchased at higher prices than their rentregulated income can support. “We have seen over the years a significant number of predatory acts by people in real estate who borrow extraordinary sums of money to buy a building, or buildings, where the rental income does not support that level of debt,” he said. “The obvious conclusion in those scenarios is that the owners have an intention of raising revenue by jacking up rents somehow, and frequently in an unethical or illegal manner.” He said the watch list, which will be featured on the city’s Housing Preservation and Development website, will be a tool for elected officials, city agencies, advocates, and tenants themselves.

Photo by William Alatriste/ New York City Council

East Side Councilmember Dan Garodnick, who leaves office on January 1 after 12 years representing District 4, at an event promoting small businesses on Second Avenue.

Garodnick added the city still has much more progress to make in the affordable housing area. “As our population grows and the demand for housing grows, we need to move even faster to keep up with that challenge,” he said in an interview this week with NYC Community Media. Also on Nov. 30, another Garodnick bill that reforms the outdated commercial rent tax passed, bringing relief to Manhattan small businesses. The tax, created in 1963, charges a 3.9 percent levy on annual business rents over $250,000. His reform doubled the minimum threshold to $500,000 — and in some cases,

$550,000 — saving nearly 3,000 small businesses up to $13,000 annually. “We are essentially slowing the growth, modestly,” he said of the burden that tax imposes on the borough’s small businesses. “This tax should be done away with entirely. It is unfair, antiquated, and throws cold water on the local economy.” He said it took a bit of push to get Mayor Bill de Blasio on board with the plan, as the administration was concerned about its budgetary impact. “It was our job to persuade him that the unfairness of [this tax] and the benefit to small businesses far outweighed the minimal cost to the

city, and he was open to that,” Garodnick said. The city will lose an estimated $36.5 million out of roughly $900 million that the rent tax raises each year. He explained, though, that the tax couldn’t be eliminated in one fell swoop without major impact on the city budget. “I would like to see a bill that indexes the exemption in a way that phases out the tax over time,” he said, noting that there would have to be additional reforms beyond his bill because “if you do absolutely nothing, the tax on businesses will simply go up because more and more of them will go over the exemption amounts and the city will be inadvertently raising taxes on small business, and that’s not a good outcome.” Additionally, Garodnick, in partnership with Borough President Gale Brewer, helmed the effort to enact a major East Midtown Rezoning plan after a failed effort to do so under former Mayor Michael Bloomberg. The rezoning, completed this year, succeeded the second time around, he explained, because it brought greater certainty to community stakeholders regarding public infrastructure improvements. The One Vanderbilt development on E. 42nd St., based on a rezoning that preceded the East Midtown effort, he said, was the first step that facilitated the bigger agreement. “We negotiated an idea where a new GARODNICK continued on p. 11

World Music Enlivens Carnegie Family Program BY ALEXANDRA SIMON Haitian songstress Emeline Michel will perform a few of her classic hits at Carnegie Hall on Dec. 16 in a special program geared to young children. The singer is performing at “My City, My Song,” a family-oriented show that is part of Carnegie’s Musical Explorers program — an in-class musical education segment in several city schools. It is one of the few opportunities youngsters get to learn about other cultures through music and performances by singers and musicians from around the world, said Michel. “Introducing children to cultures through the music is wonderful — because we introduce them to something very different from what they might hear on the radio or on television,” she said. Michel is set to perform her hit song “A.K.I.K.O,” which students in select city kindergarten to second grade class-


December 14, 2017

Photo by Gregg Richards

Haitian singer Emeline Michel will perform at an educational series for city children at Carnegie Hall on Dec. 16.

es learn to begin exploring sound and melodies. She said the well-loved song is a must-play anywhere she performs because of how popular it is across cultural lines, and the song’s catchiness

makes it a perfect kid-friendly song. “Every time I travel or tour — whether it’s in Haiti or other countries — for some reason there’s something in that song’s composition that people love,” Michel said. “And I know that song would resonate with children because the melody is very catchy and it’s a fun song.” She will be performing with Georgian singer Ilusha Tsinadze, who will sing traditional folks songs from his European homeland as well as his own compositions, and American singer Imani Uzuri, who will offer up songs from the civil rights era plus protest anthems she has written. Each singer will perform a separate segment, accompanied by a variety of string, piano, accordion, and percussion musicians, and then the three will conclude with a mash-up, according to Michel. Every year Carnegie Hall, in collaboration with artists from all over the

world, launches its Musical Explorers program into schools to connect children with global music. In class, the youth learn about melodies, harmonies, and the lyrics of the artists in the program. It is a very important subject for school-aged children because it teaches them beneficial people-skills they need, Michel explained. “The program is necessary because it teaches children that you can come from a different culture, place, or background and still be accepting and more understanding of that,” she said. “It doesn’t mean you can’t respect each other, and this program nails that through at such an early age and opens their eyes.” “My City, My Song” is performed on Sat., Dec. 16 at noon and 3 p.m. at Carnegie Hall, 881 Seventh Ave., between W. 56th and W. 57th Sts. For more information and tickets at $10, visit carnegiehall.org or call 212-247-7800. NYC Community Media



NYC Community Media

December 14, 2017



It’s Time to Enroll in an Affordable Care Act Health Plan BY LIZ KRUEGER It would be an understatement to say that the 2018 Affordable Care Act open enrollment period began under a dark cloud of uncertainty. With the Trump administration regularly declaring that the ACA marketplace is imploding, gutting enrollment funding, and slashing cost-sharing subsidies, it is understandable that Americans have reservations about purchasing health insurance. Yet one month into open enrollment, numbers so far are higher than expected across the country. Americans are voting with their wallets and the message is clear — coverage under ACA is a good investment. I urge any New Yorker who is eligible to sign up before this open enrollment ends on January 31. High enrollment rates are no surprise when you remember what dealing with health insurance was like before the ACA. People with pre-existing conditions were excluded or priced-out of access; people with cancer and other severe health problems went bankrupt due to caps on benefits or gaps in coverage; there was no guarantee that insurance plans would cover essential care

(such as mental health and pregnancy); uninsured rates were shamefully high due to prohibitive premiums. The ACA has given us the luxury — what I would call a basic human right — of having increased peace of mind that our regular and unexpected healthcare needs will be taken care of without losing our homes or ending up on the street. For any New Yorkers who are currently deciding between purchasing an ACA plan, taking a chance on a shortterm private plan, or rolling the dice by being uninsured in 2018, there are several strong arguments for choosing an ACA plan. First, despite the current administration’s false claims, the ACA marketplace has demonstrated sustainability. In New York, we have a robust number of insurance plans to accommodate people at different income levels and with diverse healthcare needs. Although there have been increases, premiums remain lower than what New Yorkers paid prior to the ACA. Certainly the ACA marketplace needs to be strengthened and improved, and bipartisan legislation has

been drafted in the US Senate to do just that. Second, ACA policy holders benefit from several legal protections. ACA policies must cover 10 essential healthcare needs. Applicants may not be denied coverage due to a pre-existing condition. Those who qualify receive costsharing subsidies to reduce the cost of premiums. Health insurance providers may not charge higher rates to policy holders based on their age or a preexisting condition. Short-term private health insurance plans may appear at first to be an attractive alternative to ACA policies due to their lower premiums, but you get what you pay for — limited benefits with high deductibles. For example, consider a 27-year-old male who is between jobs and opts for a short-term policy. One month later, he’s hit by a car while crossing the street and needs emergency care as well as physical therapy for a full recovery. His plan does not cover physical therapy, so he must choose between going without or paying out-of-pocket. Furthermore, he has to pay the ACA tax penalty, as his short-term policy

does not qualify as minimal essential coverage. You may also be tempted to go without health insurance, believing you can do without or that you simply cannot afford coverage. But that is a gamble. Perhaps you will remain healthy while uninsured. Perhaps you will break a leg or experience cardiac arrest and have to get emergency medical care. Uninsured people tend to rely on the emergency room for their primary and emergency medical needs, straining state and federal budgets and reducing available funding for other needed programs. Not only does this redirect funding from critical programs, but it also negatively impacts health outcomes. Uninsured people are less likely to seek the preventive care necessary to maintain good health and may need to wait to go to the emergency room until their medical condition has escalated. Finally, if you fear an ACA policy will be too expensive, I highly recommend making an appointment at a Navigator Site to receive health insurance counCARE ACT continued on p. 11

  $   $    


St. Clement’s Episcopal Church

A Free Christmas Concert December 24th at 8pm at St. Clement’s Episcopal Church — “The Theater Church� — at 423 West 46th Street, New York, NY will be offered to New York City. The choir, comprised of Broadway notables, Julliard and Manhattan School of Music Students, some of the well-known singers of cabaret, and instrumentalists join under the baton of Mr. Mark Janas of Manhattan School and leadership of Mr. Darryl Curry, Minister of Music, to perform traditional and newly written music of the season.

All Are Welcome


#%$$*+  & $ !  &#$#$ !  $&$!$ !      


Lessons and Carols at 11:00am Sidewalk Caroling outside of the church from 7:00pm till 7:45pm 12/24/17 Free Choral Concert at 8:00pm Christmas Eve Service 8:45pm


December 14, 2017

)$$*/$ $'$ "$%$ "$$)((()$'$*)*$,.,$*--(   ! NYC Community Media

GARODNICK continued from p. 8

and significant office building would go up, but they had to deliver $220 million in public infrastructure improvements to Grand Central and they can’t occupy the building until those improvements are done,” he said of One Vanderbilt. “That is certainty.” The East Midtown rezoning will create 16 new public spaces fully paid for by private developers, and allows historically landmarked buildings in the area to sell 3.6 million square feet of unused development rights, with most of the proceeds going toward the preservation of those landmarks but 20 percent earmarked for public space and transportation infrastructure improvements. Overall, the rezoning is expected to deliver nearly $1 billion in public realm and transit improvements in the rezoning area from just below Grand Central north to E. 57th St. Acknowledging that much more needs to be done on transit improvements, Garodnick made clear he believes the city is paying at least its fair share to the MTA. Additional tools — most prominently congestion pricing that would raise the cost of entering Manhattan below 96th St. by car during peak hours and toll the East River bridges — must be considered, he said. “First, it would generate significant funds for mass transit but it also has the potential to reduce congestion on the streets,” he said, adding that the current flood of cars into Midtown and Downtown “is impeding our above-ground mass transit from getting anywhere. Buses can’t move if there’s too much traffic.” To ease the uncertainties facing bus commuters, Garodnick has made use of Council discretionary funds to fund 48 bus countdown clocks throughout his district. And, pointing to Asser Levy Place — green space from E. 23rd to E. 25th Sts., between the East River and First Ave. — a three block park from E. 38th to E. 41st on the East River, and Pershing Square, on the east and west sides of the Park Avenue viaduct leading to Grand Central, the councilmember said he has created roughly 150,000 square feet of new public open space during his tenure. As for his future political future, Garodnick unfortunately provided no news scoop. “I’m going to take a little break and then sort out that question,” he said. “I feel very honored to have had this opportunity, and I would like to think about ways to continue to serve the city and state.”

CARE ACT continued from p. 10

seling (call 888-614-5400 to make an appointment or visit nystateofhealth.ny.gov/aca). Or do some comparative shopping on your own. Either way, make sure to review the costs of all levels of coverage to evaluate which one will be the best match financially. In the 21st century, healthcare should be a human right, and I have long supported legislation to create a single-payer system to deliver that right to everyone. In the meantime, the Affordable Care Act lifted a burden of fear and made health insurance available to millions of Americans for the first time in their lives. If you are uninsured, give yourself and your family a gift this holiday season by signing up for coverage under the ACA.


State Senator Liz Krueger represents District 28 on Manhattan’s East Side. NYC Community Media

December 14, 2017


Dozens and dozens of Post-It notes were temporarily placed on the walls of the Columbus Circle subway station after the rally. When the NYPD took them down, citing the organize signs. ME TOO continued from p. 7

would come to my office ‘begging’ for campaign contributions not so long ago (and would do anything for them), is now in the ring fighting against Trump.” Many of the speakers, like McLaughlin, are survivors-turned-advocates, men and women, young and old, of all backgrounds and creeds. People from different organizations like the National Organization for Women (NOW), the Feminist Press, Black Women’s Blueprint, Inc., EndAbuse4Good, Protect NY Kids, and New Yorkers Against Hidden Predators (NYAHP) discussed the various aspects of the movement. Sonia Ossorio, president of NOWNY, said she wanted to have an emphasis on intersectionality at the rally and even brought her nine-year-old daughter along with her on stage. She said it was important for her to understand democracy and how she should use her voice to fight for it. She also said it was crucial for men to


December 14, 2017

start becoming part of the conversation. “We talked a lot about engaging men on the subject. This is the time to engage them,” she told this publication. Robert Ayers, a retired university professor, came as an ally for his wife, a rape survivor. He said he felt this movement was part of a larger demonstration against the Trump administration. “This is part of a resistance. The resistance to those people who have introduced a regime into this country… where the very basis of civilization is under threat,” he said. “I am here to support women. I am here to support civilized relationships between human beings. The fact that we are standing outside one of Trump’s properties makes it all the more appropriate.” Ayers brought a sign he made (reading “HER TOO”), with arrows pointed in different directions. He said he wanted to strengthen the position of the people at the rally, to further legitimize the cause. Some of the signs had a more personal

touch to them. Both Karen Levine and Shaun Dougherty held pictures of themselves as children, the age when they were first molested. Levine’s sign had a picture of her at a young age on one side and on the back a picture of the family doctor who repeatedly sexually assaulted her. This is the first #MeToo rally she’s attended. “This has been going on far too long,” she said. “[The movement] inspired me in a lot of ways. It’s inspired me to believe that I have nothing to be ashamed of. You can know that in your head but it takes a long time to know that in your heart. That’s why I appreciate all these women and this movement that helped me do that.” Dougherty held up a picture of his 10-year-old self. He said he’s been waiting 37 years for a #MeToo rally, and that it wasn’t until a couple of years ago that he finally came forward with his own experiences. “I’m a Navy veteran. I swore an oath to protect the Constitution of the United

States,” he said. “President Trump had five deferments to Vietnam. My cousin did not have a deferent to Vietnam. I’m an American veteran, I’m a child sex abuse survivor, and I’m standing outside his hotel in the snow to fight for my justice while he gets flown around on Air Force One.” Dougherty is also a member of NYAHP who is working towards getting the Child Victims Act passed in the state. This bill would eliminate the statute of limitations for sex crimes against children. The veteran added, “The most useful thing that anyone can do for a victim of sex abuse is to believe and support them. That’s what they are looking for, belief and support and understanding.” Joyce M. Short, a sexual abuse survivor, advocates for a nationwide agreement on what consent means. “It’s freely given, knowledgeable, and informed agreement,” she said, which mirrors her hashtag #FGKIA. “There are other forms of agreement and people NYC Community Media

Photos by Christian Miles

rs didn’t have MTA permission, the women started placing the notes on themselves and their

Karen Levine, a survivor of child sexual abuse, held up a picture of herself when she was younger. She said the Me Too movement inspired her to come forward about her own trauma, and taught her not to feel guilty for it.

der non-conforming persons.” Days after the rally, Republican candidate Roy Moore, who not only has been accused of sexual misconduct by nine women, many of whom were minors at the time, but who also was endorsed by President Trump, lost the Dec. 12 special election to Democrat Doug Jones. While Jones will be the first Democrat representing Alabama in the senate in the past two decades, he only won by about 20,000 votes, and in large part from the state’s heavily black-populated areas. (In the days leading up to the election, Barack Obama and Charles Barkley were among those voicing their support for Jones.) Moore’s stunning loss, widely seen as a rebuke to the moral turpitude of his candidacy, validated a predictive statement made by Dickerson at Saturday’s rally: “So speak out, sister survivors. Then our speaking out will permit other women to speak, until laws are changed and lives are saved and the world is altered forever.”

Erika Dickerson, assistant executive director of Black Women’s Blueprint Inc., said that sexual assault and harassment are just symptoms of a bigger issue: patriarchy.

will try to fool you into thinking you’ve consented when you’ve only agreed, maybe you assented, maybe you acquiesced. Those are other forms of agreement… but when you are drugged, even if you nod your head and say ‘Yes,’ are you consenting? No!” Erika Dickerson, assistant executive director of Black Women’s Blueprint Inc., a civil and human rights organization, explained that not only is the Me Too movement different for women of color, but also people dealing with poverty and varying immigration statuses. She reminded the crowd that a public “Me Too” isn’t an option for everyone. “No significant change can be made if we simply talk about the symptoms,” she said. “Sexual assault and sexual harassment are only symptoms and manifestations of the patriarchy… We can talk about rape all we want, but until we address the multiple generational trauma of patriarchy we will fall short of a goal of stopping men’s violence against each other, against women, and against genNYC Community Media

December 14, 2017


BOMBING continued from p. 3

Ullah had burns and wounds to his body and was taken to Bellevue Hospital. Three people near the explosion sustained minor injuries — ringing in the ears and headaches — with two taking themselves to Mt. Sinai West and one to Mt. Sinai Queens, FDNY Commissioner Daniel Nigro said. An FDNY spokesperson on Wed., Dec. 13 confirmed four people were injured in the attack — three with minor injuries and the suspect — but he said it was possible other people could have gone to the hospital on their own. At Monday’s press briefing, Mayor Bill de Blasio called it an “attempted terrorist attack. Thank God the perpetrator did not achieve his ultimate goals.� O’Neill said Ullah “intentionally detonated that device� and had made statements concerning ISIS, but declined to elaborate further at that point. Governor Andrew Cuomo said the news was “obviously very frightening and disturbing. When you hear about a bomb in the subway station, which is in many ways one of our worst nightmares, the reality turns out better than the initial expectation and fear.� “Let’s be clear,� de Blasio noted, “as New Yorkers, our lives revolve around the subways. When we hear of an attack on the subway, it’s incredibly unsettling.� Commuters fled after the device went off and smoke filled the passage, according to video of the event and news reports. MTA Chairman Joseph Lhota said at the press briefing the authority immediately shut down the A, C, and E lines. Several train lines bypassed the Times Square and 42nd St.-Port Authority stations until later that day. After Ullah was taken to Bellevue, he waived his Miranda rights both ver-

Photos by Christian Miles

With the evacuated Port Authority Bus Terminal now a crime scene, heavily armed police officers maintained the perimeter.

We have a HUGE selection of:  s Holiday Gifts, s

sBooks, & Cards, s Advent Calendars, Wrap & Bagss s  Gift

and a huge selection of Bibles, Fiction/Non-Fiction, Children’s Books, Events & More! Hours: M-Th 10am-9pm | Fri 10am-9pm | Sat 10am-8pm

| Sun 12pm-7pm

1575 York Ave. (btwn. 83rd/84th St.) 212-517-7292 | logosbookstorenyc.com 14

December 14, 2017

In addition to the suspect, three people sustained minor injuries from the explosion. Two took themselves to Mt. Sinai West, one to Mt. Sinai Queens.

bally and in writing, according to the complaint. He told investigators that he had built the pipe bomb in his apartment in Brooklyn, and began gathering materials needed to make it about two to three weeks before the attack, according to the complaint. While constructing the pipe bomb he filled it with metal screws, “which he believed would cause maximum damage,� according to the complaint. The complaint said Ullah carried out the attack in part because of US policies around the world and in the

Middle East. Around 2014, he was radicalized and started viewing “proISIS materials online, including a video instructing, in substance, that if supporters of ISIS were unable to travel overseas to join ISIS, they should carry out attacks in their homelands,� and began researching how to build an improvised explosive device on the Internet about a year ago, according to the complaint. Law enforcement’s search of Ullah’s BOMBING continued on p. 23 NYC Community Media

“Your Neighborhood Grocer Since 1888”

Martinelli’s Organic Sparkling Cider

Lavazza Coffee Assorted Varieties 12 oz.

25.4 oz.

$ 99


Prices Effective Friday, December 15 thru Thursday, December 28, 2017

Gristedes REWARDS are Here! Earn Points Now! Pick Up Our In-Store Circular For More Savings Assorted Varieties, 15.25 oz.

Twinings Tea Black Teas Only 20 ct.

$ 99


DeCecco Pasta



La Croix 12 Pack Sparkling Water Assorted Varieties 12 oz. Cans

Nestlé Morsels

$ 88


Nabisco Snack Crackers Assorted Varieties, 5 oz.

Deep River Potato Chips

$ 99

Chock Full O’ Nuts Coffee


Breakstone’s Sour Cream Assorted Varieties 16 oz.

$ 49


Sara Lee Oven Fresh Pie Assorted Varieties 27-34 oz.

$ 99


NYC Community Media

3 $ 99 2

Lavazza $Coffee 99


Assorted Varieties, 48 oz.

Breyers Ice Cream

$ 99


Kellogg’s Cereals Frosted Flakes Cinnamon 13.6 oz. Frosted Flakes 15 oz. Rice Krispies 12 oz. Apple Jacks 12.2 oz. Corn Flakes 18 oz. Corn Pops 12.5 oz. Froot Loops 12.2 oz.

3 $ 99 4 $ 99 4

Assorted Varieties, 64 oz.

$ 59

Traditional or Vanilla Spice, 32 oz.

Southern Comfort Assorted Varieties Egg Nog

$ 99


Excluding Decaf, 10.3-11.3 oz.

Assorted Varieties, 7.5-10 oz.

Assorted Varieties 12-16 oz.


Duncan Hines Classic Cake Mix

Assorted Varieties 10-12 oz.

$ 99

Ocean Spray Cranberry Juice Cocktail

$ 99


Assorted Varieties, 5.3 oz.

Chobani Greek Yogurt

$ 3/$99

25 for

Assorted Varieties, 19.6 oz.

Del Monte Vegetables Assorted Varieties 13.5-15.25 oz.




San Pellegrino Sparkling Water 25.3 oz. Glass or 33.8 oz. Plastic




Egg-Land’s Best Large Eggs

$ 49


Pepperidge Farm Layer Cake

$ 99


Celentano Cheese Ravioli Large or Mini 12 oz.


$ 99


December 14, 2017


Comics of ‘The Mosquito’ Fly in the Face of Convention Nancy Giles and friends fill Dixon Place lounge with laughter BY DUSICA SUE MALESEVIC Finally, there is a mosquito you will not want to squash, but rather attend. “The Mosquito,” a variety show hosted by Nancy Giles at Dixon Place, is the antidote to Monday doldrums with its offering of laugh-out-loud-worthy comedic songs and stories. Where else can one find takes on Nazis, erasers and stink bugs, a meditation on buying moisturizer at Sephora, and a “come to Jesus moment,” as Giles put it, about the flood of sexual harassment allegations? The show this reporter went to was the same day that the story broke regarding Charlie Rose. Giles, an actress, commentator, and longtime contributor to CBS News Sunday Morning, gathered the other performers for the evening — Michael Huston, Cynthia Kaplan and Susan Burns — to discuss the accusations against Louis C.K., Al Franken, Harvey Weinstein, and Rose.

“I was obviously reading the article [about Rose]… another guy walking around in a robe,” Kaplan said, who then said her husband should never wear a hotel robe. Giles chimed in that the “Grand Poobah is a predator,” referring to our current president. “We’re living in troubled times,” Giles said, adding, “Bill Clinton, you are not off the hook.” Then, at the end, she quipped, “Clearly I was grasping at a monologue.” The show takes place monthly, Monday nights, in the lounge at Dixon Place — an intimate space whose smattering of tables and chairs were filled that Nov. 20 night, with a few people also seated at the bar. Giles started off by introducing the show’s “house band” and the “nicest musician I’ve ever met,” Carmen Borgia. Borgia played the ukulele, and Giles snapped along to his song about his baby writing him a letter, “a letter not an

email, not a tweet, [an expletive] letter.” Some in the audience clapped along and hit their knees to the rhythm. First up was Huston, who is also half of the sketch comedy duo Babes in the Woods. “This just happened. This was fun,” she began. Who knew there could be such trials and tribulations to get a specific moisturizer? Step by step, Huston takes the audience along with her as she attempts, twice, to buy something at Sephora that will not wash her out, with a saleswoman who, she says, “drags me over like a seeing eye dog” to the mirror. Finally, she achieves success at a CVS that has the product she has been searching for. “What a hellish couple of weeks,” she deadpans, ending the story. Before the next performer, Giles talked about being on the TV show “China Beach” in the late 1980s. The show, set during the Vietnam War, had the makeup artists spritz the actors before

filming. While the white actors looked good, she said, giving them a bit of color, Giles and another black actor looked like runaway slaves. Giles said some would say that bit is racist or bigoted. “But I lived it,” she noted, “so screw you.” There is an ongoing debate about whether there are topics that are taboo for comics — subjects that aren’t, or can’t, be funny. Kaplan, an essayist, musician, and comedian, belies that idea. Getting onstage, Kaplan introduced herself and her band, The Cynthia Kaplan Ordeal. (She was the only one onstage.) Her first song was “You’re the Nazi,” telling the audience, “…and, Jesus, I hope you like it.” Kaplan noted that if she hit a wrong chord, she was being ironic. The song listed good things that Nazis, such as Heinrich Himmler, did. THE MOSQUITO continued on p. 18

Photo by Dusica Sue Malesevic

L to R: Cynthia Kaplan, Michael Huston, Nancy Giles and Susan Burns had an impromptu discussion about sexual harassment allegations. “House band” musician Carmen Borgia stands to the side.


December 14, 2017

NYC Community Media

Photos by R. Patrick Alberty

L to R: Radiotheatre’s Frank Zilinyi, Caitlin Boyle, R. Patrick Alberty, Alejandro Cardozo, Annemarie Hagenaars and Sarah Walker.

No Kitschy Shtick for Hitchcock Radio Plays Festival founder says they’ll stick to solid storytelling BY TRAV S.D. Sometimes, the drive into the future involves a glance into the rearview mirror. For the past 14 years, Dan Bianchi, artistic director of Radiotheatre, has been presenting theatrical productions that mix state-of-the-art audio technology and one of the oldest art forms in the world: aural storytelling. Complex electronic sound design, which interweaves original musical scores and sound effects, supports live actors who read scripts that are designed to be listened to not as a nostalgic nod to the old time radio of the 1940s, but merely as an effective means of engaging an audience in imaginative narratives. Usually, Bianchi’s bailiwick is horror and science fiction. He’s presented adaptations of works by Edgar Allen Poe, H.P. Lovecraft and H.G. Wells, and has staged, five times, a version of the 1933 RKO classic “King Kong.” On Dec. 19 at St. John’s Lutheran Church, he unveils his latest: several adaptations of famous suspense films directed by NYC Community Media

The Alfred Hitchcock Festival’s namesake looms large behind Dan Bianchi, artistic director of Radiotheatre.

Alfred Hitchcock. Bianchi is a longtime Off-Off Broadway veteran, having done his first shows in New York as early as 1971. He’s won the Beckett Prize (twice) and even gotten to work with the man himself, Samuel Beckett, at the Sorbonne. In the ’80s, with his troupe the Threepenny Theatre Company, he produced an award-winning musical about grave robbers Burke and Hare, and put on an epic spook show called “Shock Theatre” that attracted the attention of Broadway producers. But over time, conditions altered. “I used to produce large-scale shows with elaborate sets back in the ’80s,” said Bianchi, “but the economy got outrageous, and rents went up. Producers started doing shows that consisted of two people sitting around having conversations at a kitchen table or on a park bench. But I didn’t want to do that. I grew up with movies and have a background as a screenwriter. I see and think in cinematic terms: a raging river,

an intergalactic war. A radio format allows me to do that.” From the late 1920s through the late 1940s (roughly the two decades that preceded the advent of television), radio, including radio drama, was the reigning mode of home entertainment. Scripted radio shows were broadcast live from network studios, with actors reading their lines directly from scripts into microphones. In more recent decades, contemporary theatre groups have sometimes done campy recreations of the classic “Golden Age” radio productions, but according to Bianchi, his company has another approach. “We’re not into the old-time radio shtick,” said Bianchi. “I’m uninterested in creating a museum piece of the 1940s with period outfits and hairdos. In those kinds of presentations the star is usually the foley [sound effects] artist, and it usually creates a comedic effect. With the kind of suspenseful, horrific content HITCHCOCK FESTIVAL continued on p. 18 December 14, 2017


alone breaks ranks and orders fish,” according to the new book. Burns was able to swerve from the steak-fish tragedy to Charles Manson to how, the night after Trump’s election, a neighbor called the police on her. Frustration with the election flowed into frustration over not being able to watch “Jeopardy!” that turned into yelling. The police came to her door, but, no, Burns was not arrested. Burns, Kaplan and Huston have all known Giles for decades, they told this reporter after the show. All, includ-

ing Borgia, had high praise for Dixon Place and its founder Ellie Covan — Kaplan calling her “a great champion of Downtown theater,” with Huston saying she feels she can “try anything” artistically at the theater, which is “really innovative and cool.” Giles said, “I met Ellie for the first time, golly Moses, I think it was 31 years ago, so like 1986. She had a little apartment on First Ave. and First Street. And she did like this salon-type thing and invited people to perform.” But the venue didn’t have the right

type of permit or licensing so, “If it looked like the cops were coming or there was going to be any trouble, the show that was going on would stop, and everyone would start singing, ‘Happy Birthday To You,’ to pretend it was a party, which I loved,” Giles recalled. Dixon Place moved to a spot on the Bowery before making its home at 161A Chrystie St. toward the end of 2008. “Just having Nancy involved with Dixon Place is really important to me,” Covan said by phone. “She can read the phone book if she wants to.” Giles said having the monthly variety show in the lounge “mirrors more how Ellie’s apartment was.” It is important, she said, for the show to feature female performers in their 40s, 50s, and older. “What we have to say is incredibly valuable,” Giles explained. “We’ve all lived. At this point in my friends’ lives, we’ve all suffered losses, illness, all kinds of wrinkles. Our lives just make us, I think, even better artists and funnier and we bring even more to the table. I want us to have a chance to just like get our voices heard.” So where does the name of the show come from? “The joke of why I call this show ‘The Mosquito’ is a little resentment at ‘The Moth.’ I think I hosted some Moth event… and told a story, and they were like, ‘Oh, we would love to have you back,’ and then nothing ever happened,” Giles said. “Well, [expletive] this, I’ll do my own show and I can name a show after an insect as well,” she said. “And ‘The Mosquito’ was born.” The next installment is Mon., Dec. 18, 7:30pm in the front lounge space at Dixon Place (161A Chrystie St., btw. Rivington & Delancey Sts.). The show is free, but donations are welcome. Visit dixonplace.org. Nancy Giles on Twitter: @nancygilesnyc. On Facebook: facebook.com/nancygilesofficial.

the dark around a campfire,” noted Bianchi. “A narrator tells the tale as players act it out. This way we engage directly with the audience and they seem to like that. We entice their imaginations to work to supply the visuals. With traditional plays, TV or movies, [the audience] just sit back and see whatever the director gives them as he sees it... a beautiful girl, a monster, whatever. But with audio theater, if I say a beautiful girl walks into the room, I don’t need to elaborate. I get 180 versions of that in the minds of the audience.” Bianchi normally adapts the scripts themselves from works of classic fiction,

but on this occasion he found readymade scripts from radio days that were in the public domain. Back in the day, it was common practice to present radio adaptations of first run films, both to promote the movies and as entertainment in their own right. The Hitchcock stories Radiotheatre will be presenting are “Strangers on a Train,” “Suspicion,” “The Birds,” “Shadow of a Doubt,” “Rebecca,” “The Lodger,” and “The 39 Steps.” Each performance will feature a different bill, as the scripts can be up to an hour long. “Hitchcock is one of my favorites, and radio is the only way you can tell his stories in a theatre,” said Bianchi. “I’m

hoping it’ll appeal to younger audiences as well as older ones. If you know movies, you pretty much know Hitchcock. He’s still a personality.” Radiotheatre’s Alfred Hitchcock Festival plays Dec. 19-30, at St. John’s Lutheran Church (81 Christopher St., btw. Bleecker & W. Fourth Sts.). All shows at 8pm. Tickets are $24 general admission, $12 for students/seniors. For reservations, call 212-868-4444 or visit radiotheatrenyc.com (where you can also access the titles scheduled for each of the festival’s nine performances). Box office opens 30 minutes before showtime. Wheelchair accessible. Runtime: 80 minutes.

THE MOSQUITO continued from p. 16

Himmler, for instance, planted daisies. “There are some fine Nazis,” she sang. “Back the [expletive] off Nazis, okay?” And the chorus: “If you hate every Nazi, you’re the Nazi.” In her YouTube video of the song, before the music begins, there is President Donald Trump’s quote after violent clashes between white supremacists and neo-Nazis, and counterprotesters in Charlottesville, Virginia, this past summer: “But you also had people who were very fine on both sides.” After the admonition to “stop persecuting Nazis” and finishing the ditty, Kaplan said she was “very proud” of it. Her next tune, “When God Was a Student at Notre Dame,” had the chorus “Two, four, six, eight, who do we appreciate? God” and encouraged the audience to sing along, which they did. Before Burns took the stage, Giles asked the audience if they wanted a story about death or her period. Unsurprisingly, death won. Giles then performed a short piece where she envisions what her funeral would be like. “I would want tears — lots of them,” she stated, along with sobs and fake cries. The scene: a packed house at a megachurch, where The Roots would be playing, Dave Chappelle would be the MC, the paparazzi would jostle for position, and ex-boyfriends are a “mess” with “loud honks” of noses blowing. Burns, a member of the Actors Studio, began her set by talking about the allegations against Rose, and how she “used to worship Woody Allen.” She then read an excerpt from a book review in The New York Times about Ivana Trump’s book, “Raising Trump,” in an accent, pausing to say, “I don’t know if this is the right accent.” Apparently, Trump’s father, Fred, pushed Ivana to have a steak but, “Ivana

HITCHCOCK FESTIVAL continued from p. 17

we try to do, that would ruin the effect we want.” Instead of employing a foley person and live musicians, Bianchi and his collaborator, Wes Shippee, build complex tapestries of orchestrated music, peppered with recorded and synthesized sound effects, generated, mixed and amplified through the latest electronic equipment. Yet, despite all of this futuristic technology, his work also hearkens back to the most ancient human traditions. “At Radiotheatre, we’re going back to the first theater… storytelling in


December 14, 2017

Photo via facebook.com/nancygilesofficial

Nancy Giles, host of “The Mosquito” at Dixon Place.

NYC Community Media

Happy Holidays From The Moral High Ground BY MAX BURBANK At this festive time of year, I find myself wondering just how certain major power players square their moral values with the widely accepted standards embodied in the Christmas classics. Does Mitch McConnell figure Mr. Potter’s big mistake in “It’s a Wonderful Life” was not running for Senate and using raw legislative power to crush George Bailey under his boot like a Socialist roach? Does Paul Ryan role-play King Moonracer from the Rankin/Bass version of “Rudolph,” establishing an Ayn Randian objectivist paradise on the Island of Misfit Toys, furtively pleasuring himself while imagining stripping Charlie in-the-Box and Spotted Elephant of Obamacare? When the specter of Richard Nixon is standing right behind Trump, doing his best Marley’s Ghost imitation by rattling the chains he forged in life and moaning about how all mankind should have been his business, Trump is all, like, “Where the hell is my Diet Coke? I hadda push the button twice!” “No, NO!” Nixon wails. “I’m Marley. You’re Scrooge! Metaphorically! Don’t you get it?” “Not me,” says Trump. “Scrooge might have been rich, but he didn’t live rich. I got my own courses to play golf on every weekend. I get two, maybe three scoops of ice cream on the most beautiful piece of chocolate cake you’ve ever seen in a restaurant with my name in big letters on the door! I don’t need a change of heart.” It has got be downright hard to be a Republican at Christmas. It must require a mental à la carte menu featuring choice helpings of cognitive dissonance, mental compartmentalization, deep-seated selfishness, evil, and side dish of good old American “I don’t give a crap.” That well-known bastion of liberal pearl-clutchers, the Wall Street Journal’s editorial board, recently suggested there was only one way Trump and the Republican Party could reclaim that shiniest of all Christmas stars, the moral high ground: “Disown” their sexual harassers, as the Democrats are in the process of doing. I have a sack full of epithets for the Wall Street Journal, but “charmingly naive” is a new one. NYC Community Media

How do you “disown” a few congressmembers, but not the Harasserin-Chief? And are they suggesting

that a refusal to admit an institutional penchant for sexual abuse is the only morality problem they have? That’s adorable! Do they have some evidence I’m unaware of that “the moral high ground” is still even an operable concept for the Republican Party? The party currently “too busy” to even hold a hearing about renewing CHIP (Children’s Health Insurance Program), the bipartisan safety net that provides health insurance to over nine million low-income children and pregnant women? The

party whose leader took a moment out a ceremony honoring World War II Navajo code talkers to remind them he enjoys calling Elizabeth Warren “Pocahontas?” Meanwhile, Trump’s personal lawyer, desiccated-pig’s-head-on-a-stick-god-

Illustration by Max Burbank

from-“Lord of the Flies”-impersonator John Dowd recently stated the president, in his role as the nation’s chief law enforcement officer, literally cannot obstruct justice. If this line of reasoning seems somewhat familiar, it might be because it’s one of the aforementioned Richard Nixon’s greatest hits. Remember him? Our proud nation’s 37th president? A very moral gentleman who was forced to resign his office before being impeached for,

among other things, obstruction of justice? This arguable interpretation of the president’s constitutional powers might seem somewhat shaky (owing to the fact it’s in every way wrong), but no lesser a legal light than Alan Dershowitz has endorsed it. You might remember him as the stalwart defender of the rule of law who successfully defended Claus Von Bülow (who almost certainly murdered his wife), and being a part of the legal “dream team” that successfully defended O.J. Simpson (who also almost certainly murdered his… you know what, screw it, they TOTALLY murdered their wives; I can say that, this is an opinion column, and also everyone knows it.) So kudos, I guess, to the Republican Party for locking down the WIFE MURDERER vote in the finer neighborhoods of Moral High Ground Hills! It’s not that the idea of the president being incapable of obstructing justice places Trump entirely above the law, it’s that the argument makes the entire question irrelevant. Let’s extrapolate, and indulge Trump’s favorite fantasy, where he stands in the middle of Fifth Avenue and shoots somebody. No one would argue that he wasn’t guilty of murder, right? So he’s not above the law. But, according to his lawyers, he would have the constitutional authority to prevent any law enforcement agency from investigating the crime, arresting him, or bringing him to trial! There’s an essential trick to making this argument work, requiring one of two things: Either you are a tremendously bad lawyer (any of Trump’s lawyers) or you are a human-shaped, leather sack of amoral weasel bile stuffed into a lawyer suit (Dershowitz). You have to ask: What is the moral high ground worth if it’s at the top of a mound of scorched earth? I wish we could all just remember this is the season of hope, and that an omnipotent, loving being watches over us at all times. So you better watch out. ’Cause he’s got two lists. He knows if you’ve been bad or good. It’s no accident that in the last election, one of the candidates said they were bringing back coal in a big way. December 14, 2017











Men’s Champion Arctic Fleece or CB Sports Sweater Fleece Reg. $24.99–$29.99



PRICING VALID 12/15-12/17

Reg. $149.99



PRICING VALID 12/15-12/17


40% OFF



15 3





PRICING VALID 12/15-12/17


Men’s CB Sports or Champion 3-in-1 Systems Jacket



Originally $24.99




Men’s Smith’s Lined Denim Pants


Men’s Timberland 6” Padded Boot

Sizes 30–42 | Big Men’s 44–52*

*Select Modell’s locations & Modells.com. Stretch not available in big men’s lined bottoms.

Originally $59.99


PRICING VALID 12/15-12/17

While supplies last.


December 14, 2017

NYC Community Media

Being sick and hungry is an urgent crisis no one should face. Help us deliver hope, compassion and love, all wrapped up in a nutritious meal.

Volunteer. Donate. Advocate. godslovewedeliver.org

NYC Community Media

December 14, 2017



December 14, 2017

NYC Community Media

Photo by Christian Miles

Port Authority Bus Terminal was evacuated, and several lines bypassed Times Square until later that day, filling the streets with commuters and curious onlookers. BOMBING continued from p. 14

apartment in Brooklyn found metal pipes, pieces of wire, screws, and fragments of what appear to be Christmas tree lights, as well as a passport in the suspect’s name with several handwritten notations that included “O America, die in your rage,” according to the complaint. Albert Fox Cahn, legal director for New York chapter of the Council on American-Islamic Relations, read a statement on behalf of Ullah’s family Monday evening, saying, “We are heartbroken by the violence that was targeted at our city today and by the allegations being made against a member of our family.” But they were also “outraged by the behavior of the law enforcement officials who had held children as small as four years old out in the cold and who pulled a teenager out of high school classes to interrogate him without a lawyer, without his parents.” Cahn and the Council on AmericanIslamic Relations did not respond to a call and email from this publication, requesting comment. Monday’s underground incident comes on the heels of Oct. 31’s vehicular terrorist attack on a Lower Manhattan bike path that left eight killed and 11 injured, and also echoes the Chelsea bombing of Sept. 17, 2016 (for which a federal jury on Oct. 16 of this year found Ahmad Khan Rahimi guilty of a bombing and attempted bombing on, respectively, W. 23rd and W. 27th Sts.). “This is most resilient place on Earth, we’ve proven it time and time again,” de Blasio said. “We’ve proved it just over a month ago. We proved it on 9/11. We are going to prove it again today. The terrorists will not win, we are going keep being New Yorkers.” NYC Community Media

December 14, 2017



TOP DRIVER DISTRACTIONS Using mobile phones Leading the list of the top distractions behind the wheel are mobile phones. Phones now do more than just place calls, and drivers often cannot pull away from their phones, even when driving. According to the California Department of Motor Vehicles, studies have shown that driving performance is lowered and the level of distraction is higher for drivers who are heavily engaged in cell


December 14, 2017

phone conversations. The use of a hands-free device does not lower distraction levels. The percentage of vehicle crashes and nearcrashes attributed to dialing is nearly identical to the number associated with talking or listening.

Daydreaming Many people will admit to daydreaming behind the wheel or looking at a person or object outside of the car for too long. Per-

haps they’re checking out a house in a new neighborhood or thought they saw someone they knew on the street corner. It can be easy to veer into the direction your eyes are focused, causing an accident. In addition to trying to stay focused on the road, some drivers prefer the help of lane departure warning systems.

Eating Those who haven’t quite mastered walking and

chewing gum at the same time may want to avoid eating while driving. The majority of foods require a person’s hands to be taken off of the wheel and their eyes to be diverted from the road. Reaching in the back seat to share some French fries with the kids is also distracting. Try to eat meals before getting in the car. For those who must snack while en route, take a moment to pull over at

a rest area and spend 10 minutes snacking there before resuming the trip.

Reading Glancing at an advertisement, updating a Facebook status or reading a book are all activities that should be avoided when driving. Even pouring over a traffic map or consulting the digital display of a GPS system can be distracting.

NYC Community Media



Profile for Schneps Media

Manhattan Express  

December 14, 2017

Manhattan Express  

December 14, 2017