Page 1





The Paper of Record for Greenwich Village, East Village, Lower East Side, Soho, Union Square, Chinatown and Noho, Since 1933

September 3, 2015 • $1.00 Volume 85 • Number 14

Crusty punk whose pit bull terrorized East Village is dead BY LINCOLN ANDERSON


NATAS continued on p. 6

Foodies steamed after wonton rent hike, taxes force out Charlie Mom BY LINDAANN LOSCHIAVO


t was a clean, well-lit place, affordable, reliable, popular, an unpretentious spot where you could dally over the dumplings, canoodle in between mouthfuls of spicy Chinese cabbage and, most importantly, hear yourself talk in


atas, the crusty traveler whose aggressive pit bull, Jax, went on a bloody rampage in the East Village early last month — viciously attacking both a pug, which later died, and a man — has himself died, according to sources.

Jordy Trachtenberg lives in the same St. Mark’s Place building as Roberta Bayley, whose pug, Sidney, was attacked by Jax on Aug. 1 and died the next day at the vet after undergoing surgery. Trachtenberg told The Villager that on Thurs., Aug. 27, he saw a Facebook post at

between the courses of Cantonese specialties. Unfortunately, Wed., Aug. 26, was the last business day for Charlie Mom Chinese restaurant, at 464 Sixth Ave., near W. 11th St. Wayne Han, president of Chi Wan Corp., opened his 1,600-square-foot eatery in CHARLIE continued on p. 27

Speaking at Tuesday’s rally, a student who only gave her working names — “Alex or Johanna” — said she was driven into prostitution by N.Y.U.’s high tuition.

‘N.Y. Corporate U.’ is crushing us, critics cry BY LINCOLN ANDERSON


n June, the state’s highest court ruled against a community lawsuit seeking to block N.Y.U.’s massive South Village development plan, clearing the way for the nearly 2-million-squarefoot, 20-year project to finally move forward. But as disheartening as that loss was for the opponents, it hasn’t lessened their will to rail against New York University’s ongoing institutional sprawl in historic

Greenwich Village, as well as the school’s sky-high tuition costs and associations with repressive foreign regimes. About 200 people turned out for a wide-ranging rally — under the catchall banner of “fight the corporate university” — in Washington Square Park on Tuesday. Assemblymember Deborah Glick was the only elected official at the rally, since many people are now out of town on summer vacation. In her remarks, speaking from the small stage south of

the Garibaldi monument, she fired up the crowd. “We are here to continue the fight,” said Glick, who was a plaintiff in the lawsuit against the N.Y.U. 2031 project. “The fight is not over.” She said the four-building development project slated for two of the university’s superblocks first “got legs” under the Bloomberg administration, “who said N.Y.U. has raised Villagers’ property values.” N.Y.U. continued on p. 8

Cooper Union settles tuition 3 Corps to study storm-surge 4 Essex St. Market needs marketing! 10 They’re cooking in Soho 12

order to prohibit commercial activity on them — i.e. the desnudas — Cude had a flash of inspiration: Since the state’s high court refused to recognize the openspace strips along Mercer St. and LaGuardia Place as parkland, then maybe a few desnudas doing what they do there might change that perception. “I actually was ready to hire some of them for an hour or two and take their picture and send it to the Post and say, ‘We are parks,’ ” Cude told us. “I actually didn’t do it, though I was ready to.”

SHE’S NO BOOB! There’s a reason many voters — well, many, relatively speaking, for a district leader race — are gravitating toward Terri Cude. For one thing, she definitely thinks outside the box. For example, after hearing that Mayor Bill de Blasio was mulling designating the Times Square plazas as parks, in



331 East 9th Street, New York, NY 10003 Phone: 212-473-7833 / Fax: 212-673-5248

“It’s worth the trip down the street!” 2

September 3, 2015

Nadler hears it from both sides Dueling rallies near the federal building at 201 Varick St. last Friday supported and protested Congressmember Jerrold Nadler’s position on the Iran nuclear weapons deal. Older demonstrators, some of them Holocaust survivors, called on the West Side representative to buck the president’s plan, saying it poses a threat to both Israel and America. Others from and other progressive groups, above, turned out to support the pact.




*V O T E D **



* **


PIER 40 MOVES: The Real Deal recently reported that Westbrook Partners paid more than $200 million to take a majority stake in the 1.1.-million-squarefoot St. John’s Building, at Houston and West Sts., in a deal that values the property at $650 million. Westbrook bought out its partner, Fortress Investment Group, at the four-story building, which sits across from Pier 40. Atlas Capital Group still owns a minority stake in the property. According to the Real Deal, the site has an additional 280,000 square feet of unused development rights. And, as previously reported, the St. John’s owners last year were in talks with the


CONGRATS! Joseph Simonetti, the new commanding officer of the Village’s Sixth Precinct, was promoted on Monday from captain to inspector. He took over at the precinct in late June.

BRAVE NEW WORLD: Troy Masters, a founder of Gay City News and its predecessor, LGNY, recently left the publication to start a biweekly paper in Los Angeles. Gay City is a sister paper of The Villager and East Villager. Masters’s new paper, The Pride L.A., will be part of Mirror Media Group, the publisher of the Santa Monica Mirror and five other community publications focused on West L.A. neighborhoods. Surprisingly, L.A. currently has no gay paper, and Masters has always been a pioneer. The launch is planned for October. We wish Troy well.

GREEN SCENE: The Jefferson Market Garden will be celebrating its 40th anniversary with a fundraiser on Wed., Sept. 9, at The Lion restaurant, from 5:30 p.m. to 7:30 p.m. Barry Benepe, whose vision gave New York City the Greemarkets, and his son, Adrian Benepe, the former commissioner of the city’s Parks Department, will be honored. Bette Midler, who is committed to the greening of New York City, is the evening’s honorary chairperson. For tickets to attend or to contribute, email or call 212-242-2594.


COULDN’T BE SAVED: Since the Lenox Health Greenwich Village stand-alone emergency department on W. 12th St. is not a trauma center, some readers may have wondered why Idrissa Camara, the security guard who was shot at 201 Varick St. on Thurs., Aug. 20, was brought there, as opposed to, for example, Bellevue Hospital. Camara, 53, was pronounced dead at the Village E.D. Providing an explanation, Alex Hellinger, the new health hub’s executive director, told us: “EMS protocols require major-trauma patients to be taken to the closest trauma center. However, if a patient is deemed too unstable to survive the trip from the scene to a trauma center, then EMS protocols are that they go to the nearest E.D. for stabilization. CPR was performed on the patient en route to Lenox Health, but he was unresponsive. The staff at Lenox Health continued to perform standard resuscitation procedures in an attempt to stabilize and revive him. The patient received the same standard resuscitation measures that are used in all emergency rooms. However, due to the severity of his injury, all attempts to revive him were unsuccessful. The gunshot wound was to the head, and all appropriate protocols were followed.”

OH PLEASE, OBAMA: City Comptroller Scott Stringer recently wrote to President Barack Obama calling on him to designate Christopher Park, outside of the Stonewall Inn, as a national monument. Stringer has a long history of supporting L.G.B.T. rights. In 2010, he got hitched in Connecticut to protest New York’s lack of same-sex marriage. “As the birthplace of a historic fight for freedom, Stonewall is already a rallying point for the community,” Stringer said, “and once it is elevated to the status of national monument, it will also serve as a beacon of hope for all those engaged in the fight for equality.”

Hudson River Park Trust to buy $100 million worth of air rights — or 250,000 square feet — from the run-down sports pier. The owners were considering a condo project with 450,000 square feet of condo space and 100,000 square feet of retail, according to handwritten notes from a meeting between the owners and Manhattan Borough President Gale Brewer. Around 110,000 square feet of the project was being proposed as affordable housing for seniors. Asked his thoughts on the latest report, Tobi Berman, chairperson of Community Board 2, said Fortress selling its share seems to indicate that there’s some progress on the mammoth project. Under the park’s new airrights legislation, the money paid to the park for Pier 40’s surplus development rights would be funneled back into the pier for its repair.

Corne r of Jane & West 4th St. (at 8th Ave.) 212-2 42-95 02




— Recommended by Gourmet Magazine, Zagat, Crain’s NY, Playbill & The Villager —

“Gold Medal Chef of the Year”. — Chefs de Cuisine Association Northern italian Cuisine • Celebrating Over 36 Years

69 MacDougal St. (Bet. Bleeker & Houston St.) 212-673-0390 • 212-674-0320 Open Mon. - Sat. 12-11pm •

Suit settled, Cooper committee to focus on restoring free tuition BY PETER KOO


n Wednesday, the board of trustees of The Cooper Union entered into a consent agreement with the Committee to Save Cooper Union and the Office of the New York State Attorney General, according to court papers in New York State Supreme Court. The agreement ends the litigation over the new financial plan adopted by The Cooper Union’s board of trustees in 2013 and allows for the continued sliding-scale scholarship model for undergraduate students while providing for continued steps to strengthen the governance of the institution and for evaluating the possibility for a return to a full-tuition scholarship model. The accord precludes further litigation of the claims asserted in the current lawsuit. Under the agreement, which must be approved by the court, Cooper Union will increase transparency and participation by broadening the involvement of its students, alumni, faculty and staff in the school’s governance. The composition of the board of trustees will include two current students, with voting rights. Also, between five and nine of the trustees will be elected by the alumni through the Cooper Union Alumni Association, with one serving as chairperson or a vice chairperson. The board also will publish annual statements outlining fiscal-year dollar-value and percentage-change performance of Cooper Union’s non-real-estate investments. In addition, the trustees will create a new committee, to be known as the Free Education Committee, to include student and alumni trustees, with an alumni trustee serving as committee chairperson. The committee will be charged with developing a strategic plan aimed at returning The Cooper Union to a full-tuition scholarship model. The plan will be presented in January 2018, with progress reports and interim recommendations presented in January 2016 and 2017. The board of trustees will vote on the strategic plan proposed by the Free Education Committee at its regularly scheduled meeting in March 2018. The agreement acknowledges that, in undertaking a good-faith effort to determine the viability of the full-scholarship model, it is uncertain if or when it could be achieved. In a statement, the school administration said that Cooper “has experienced decades of substantial operating deficits caused by a consistent pattern of cost increases that have exceeded the growth of its revenues.” To provide support and build

New York, NY 10014

Your Neighbors, Your Voice We urge your to Village vote for the following judical delegate Independent Democrats candidates who will represent our communty at the 26 Perry Street First Judicial Convention. This nominates New York, NYconvention 10014 Democratic State Supreme Court Justices who will serve in New York City.

transparency, Attorney General Eric Schneiderman will appoint a financial monitor, responsible for evaluating and reporting on Cooper Union’s finances. The financial monitor will make recommendations to the board regarding its proposals on the financ- We urge your tovote vote the following judical delega We urge you to for for the following judicial delegate es of Cooper Union and will prepare candidates who will represent our community at the First at the who will represent our communty annual reports. In addition, the moni- candidates Judicial Convention. This convention nominates Democratic tor will provide analysis and opinion FirstState Judicial Convention. convention nominates Supreme Court Justices This who will serve in New York City. on the feasibility of the Free Education Democratic State Supreme Court Justices who Committee’s strategic plan. The settlement includes an ac- will serve in New York City. Vote for all six judicial delegate candidates knowledgment that, by entering into the agreement, Cooper Union is not þ Jennifer Hoppe þ Maria Passannante-Derr admitting any wrongdoing. Richard Lincer, chairperson of the þ Arthur Z. Schwartz þ Nadine K. Hoffmann school’s board of trustees, said, “This þ Jenifer Rajkumar þ Allen N. Roskoff agreement will enable us to turn our focus to the future of The Cooper Union in a manner that is inclusive of Democratic Primary Primary Democratic and transparent to our community. We hope that this framework will enable us THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 10, 2015 to develop and build support to sustain open 6 AM - 9 PM PollsPolls open 6 AM-9 PM the strengths of this great institution for future generations of students.” Endorsed by: In a statement, the Committe to Save Cooper Union said, “We are proud to be part of a settlement finalThe Village Reform ized today between the school, the Democratic Club Attorney General Eric Schneiderman and C.S.C.U. that aims to return Cooper Union to its tuition-free and merit-based mission; ensure the school’s fiscal recovery; and establish better governance structures.” The effort to reinstitute free tuition, provide a full accounting and implement greater oversight was initiated by a C.S.C.U. lawsuit filed in May 2014, THURSDAY SEPTEMBER 10 which was overwhelmingly supported by alumni, students and faculty. “We PledgeEndorsed To Serve The by:People… Schneiderman launched a confi…not the Real Estate Developers” dential investigation into the school, brought about by the lawsuit, which culminated in the announcement. The Village Reform Richard Emery, attorney for C.S.C.U., Democratic Club said, “A tragic chapter in this great school’s history has ended. For the past DOWNTOWN INDEPENDENT DEMOCRATS several years, a lack of fiscal restraint, conflicts of interest and a failure of educational vision banished Peter Cooper and his spirit from the school he founded. Cooper built a completely free, merit-based learning institution that encouraged free thinking and ENDORSED BY: produced some of our nation’s greatest Jenifer Rajkumar, Robert “Bo” Riccobono, Jeanne Wilcke, minds in the arts and sciences. These Democratic District Leader Faculty Against co-Chair NoHo recent years abandoned those values the Sexton (NYU) Plan* Neighborhood Association* Paul Newell, in favor of financial manipulation and Democratic District Leader Tom Goodkind, Sara Jones, debt. Because of the litigation settled founder & conductor, Chair, LaGuardia Corner Gardens* Alan Gerson, TriBattery Pops, volunteer today, Peter Cooper is back. Justice for former City Councilmember Ray Cline, community band* Resident Chair, Bleecker Area Peter Cooper and all those who beneJim Stratton, Georgette Fleischer, Merchants & Residents Association former chair, Community Board 1* fited from his great experiment is now Founder & President, (BAMRA)* Pete Davies, Friends of Petrosino Square* a promise that must be kept. Micki McGee, Founder, Downtown * = For Identification Purposes Only Co-Chair, South Village Neighbors* “Now, what Peter Cooper needs Action Coalition* is all those who share his vision for Stan Ries, co-Chair, Sean Sweeney, NoHo Neighborhood free education to come to the aid of Director, SoHo Alliance* Association* his school with their time, talent and Mark Crispin Miller, Michele Campo, Faculty Against donations,” Emery said. “We have Chair, Bowery the Sexton (NYU) Plan* Block Association* the tools to succeed but we need the support to finish the work.” Village Reform Democratic Club

Your Your Voic YourNeighbors, Neighbors, Voice Vote for all six Your judicial delegate candidates

Jennifer Hoppe Arthur Z. Schwartz Jenifer Rajkumar Maria Passannante-Derr VoteNadine for all sixmann judicial K. Hoff Allen N. Roskoff delegate candidates

Jennifer Hoppe THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 10, 2015 Arthur Z. Schwartz Jenifer Rajkumar Maria Passannante-Derr Nadine K. Hoffmann Allen N. Roskoff DOWNTOWN INDEPENDENT DEMOCRATS




September 3, 2015


Corps agrees to study surge barriers Named best weekly newspaper in New York State in 2001, 2004 and 2005 by New York Press Association Editorials, First Place, 2014 Overall Design Excellence, First Place, 2013 Best Column, First Place, 2012 Photographic Excellence, First Place, 2011 Spot News Coverage, First Place, 2010 Coverage of Environment, First Place, 2009












Member of the New York Press Association

Member of the National Newspaper Association

The Villager (USPS 578930) ISSN 0042-6202 is published every week by NYC Community Media LLC, One Metrotech North, 10th floor Brooklyn, NY 11201 (212) 229-1890. Periodicals Postage paid at New York, N.Y. Annual subscription by mail in Manhattan and Brooklyn $29 ($35 elsewhere). Single copy price at office and newsstands is $1. The entire contents of newspaper, including advertising, are copyrighted and no part may be reproduced without the express permission of the publisher - © 2011 NYC Community Media LLC. PUBLISHER’S LIABILITY FOR ERROR

The Publisher shall not be liable for slight changes or typographical errors that do not lessen the value of an advertisement. The publisher’s liability for others errors or omissions in connection with an advertisement is strictly limited to publication of the advertisement in any subsequent issue. Published by NYC Community Media, LLC One Metrotech North 10th floor Brooklyn, NY 11201 Phone: (718) 260-2500 • Fax: (212) 229-2790 On-line: E-mail: © 2012 NYC Community Media, LLC


September 3, 2015



lmost three years after Superstorm Sandy devastated parts of New York and New Jersey, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers will conduct a $3 million study of the region. The study will also analyze possible protective measures, including a storm surge barrier spanning the five miles between the Rockaways in New York and Sandy Hook in New Jersey. For Robert Trentlyon, a longtime Chelsea resident, former community newspaper publisher and waterfront and park advocate, this is welcome news. “It feels wonderful,” Trentlyon said in a recent interview. “I’m in a constant state of euphoria. I feel that something has been accomplished.” Trentlyon, who helped with the creation of Chelsea Waterside Park and Hudson River Park, has been sounding the alarm about rising sea levels and the need for storm surge barriers since 2009. He had what he termed a “moment of discovery” when he retired that year. “I said, ‘New York is going to be hit by a major, major storm and we’re not ready for it,’ ” he recalled. “ ‘What we really need are probably storm surge barriers.’ I’m not quite sure why I was so prescient.” Trentlyon, who is neither a scientist nor an engineer, embarked on a journey to learn more, and found Stony Brook University professors Douglas Hill and Malcolm J. Bowman. Both are part of the school’s Storm Surge Research Group, which was formed in 2002. While he couldn’t offer technical expertise, Trentlyon had something else to bring to the table: deep roots in the community and access to elected officials. “I had a special talent that none of them had, and that was I knew the territory,” he said. “I knew all the elected officials. I knew all the heads of community boards.” Trentlyon is also the founding president of the Chelsea Reform Democratic Club. A friend asked if he was interested in starting a political club in Chelsea, he recalled of how C.R.D.C. came to be. “I have this terrible habit of whenever I get involved in something, I immediately become the president,” Trentlyon said with a laugh. He began talking to community boards about the need for storm surge barriers, starting with Community Board 4, where he once was a public member. He also gave presentations to Community Boards 1 and 2. By spring 2012, Trentlyon went before a monthly meeting of the Manhattan Borough Board — comprised of community board chairpersons and the borough’s city councilmembers. The board passed a resolution in favor of studying the barriers. Comparing himself to Paul Revere,

A flood protection barrier similar to this one in St. Petersburg could also sport a highway or railway on top linking New York and New Jersey.

who warned the colonialists that the British were coming, Trentlyon said, “I’m telling you, ‘The storm surge is coming.’ ” In early 2012, The Villager had dubbed Trentlyon a “storm surge prophet.” Later that year, on Oct. 29, Superstorm Sandy hit the city and became the second most costly U.S. natural disaster, with some estimates putting the storm’s cost at $50 billion. The Army Corps study will cover the New York-New Jersey Harbor and will look at a variety of alternatives to reduce the risk of coastal flooding, according to an Army Corps spokesperson. The study is in its early stages and is expected to take three years, though it could take longer, as well as cost more than the $3 million estimate, given the large area and population, he said. At this time, it is unknown whether storm surge barriers will be implemented, and the study will also look at levees, floodwalls and other measures to determine which are feasible economically, and also take into account the environment and public acceptability, the spokesperson said. The Army Corps has undertaken the study, he said, as part of President Barack Obama’s fiscal year 2016 budget, which recommended doing it. The results of the North Atlantic Coast Comprehensive Study identified New York Harbor and its tributaries as an area warranting study to reduce coastal flooding risk, the spokesperson said. “I’ve been hoping that the Corps would do this for a long time now,” Bowman, a professor of physical oceanography, said. Bowman has been studying storm surge barriers since the 1990s, and after Hurricane Katrina hit New Orleans, wrote an op-ed about them in 2005 for The New York Times.

“When I wrote that, I felt something like old Noah in the Bible saying, ‘There’s a big flood coming, you better start building the ark,’ ” he said. He was also a member of the New York City Panel on Climate Change during parts of the Bloomberg administration, during which he said people were hostile to the idea of storm surge barriers, saying that they were too costly and huge. Bowman’s idea was that there would be one storm surge barrier between Sandy Hook and the Far Rockaways, rising about 20 feet above the water. The gates, Bowman said, swing open and closed like saloon doors, and would be open the majority of time, but shut tight if a storm or hurricane was on its way. Another smaller barrier would be placed on the East River, near Throggs Neck, in the Bronx, he said. Other cities, such as London and St. Petersburg, have storm barrier systems. Trentlyon has visited the Thames River Barrier. “There hasn’t been a drop of water [from flooding] in Central London since they built it,” he said. Both Trentlyon and Bowman said that the St. Petersburg system might be a good example for New York City. That city has a 16-mile flood-protection barrier that has a highway on top of it. Bowman said something similar could be created in this region. For example, the connection between the two states could also be used as an interstate toll road, he offered. Another possibility could be a train between J.F.K. and Newark airports. “It’s not a New York City problem,” Bowman said. “It’s not just a New Jersey problem. It’s a regional problem. Finally, we’re making some progress in that the Army Corps will do such a study.”


Cottages are creamed by fire A fire tore through “cottage” penthouses on the top of 203 E. 13th St. at Third Ave. last Thursday afternoon. One of the penthouses reportedly recently sold for more than $4.4 million. The building is known as Pear Tree Place, in reference to the pear tree that Peter Stuyvesant once planted at the site. Kiehl’s beauty store is on the 19-century building’s ground floor. There were no injuries and no one was home when the blaze struck. The fire’s cause is still under investigation but is not suspicious, according to a Fire Department spokesperson.

Open House | City and Country Wednesday, November 13, from 6-8pm

How a child learns to learn will impact his or her life forever. Progressive Education for Two-Year-Olds – 8th Grade

Open House | City and Country Wednesday, November 13, from 6-8pm

a child learns tolearn learnwill will HowHow a child learns to Please visit for information and application materials. impact his or her lifeTel:forever. impact his orNew her life 146 West 13th Street, York, NY 10011forever. 212.242.7802 Progressive Education for Two-Year-Olds – 8th Grade

Progressive Education for Two-Year-Olds – 8th Grade

Open House | City and Country School Wednesday, November 18, 6-8pm Wednesday, November 13, from 6-8pm

Open House | City and Country

146 West 13th Street, New York, NY 10011 Tel: 212.242.7802

Please visit for information and application materials.

146 West 13th Street, New York, NY 10011 Tel: 212.242.7802

September 3, 2015


Crusty punk whose pit terrorized E.V. is dead NATAS continued from p. 1

around 11 that morning by a young woman he knows who does outreach to the crusties and travelers. “I am very sorry to say that Natas (David McKee) passed early this morning,” the woman wrote, in part. In response to The Villager’s query, Julie Bolcer, a spokesperson for the Chief Medical Examiner’s Office, responded, “We are investigating the death of someone identified with the name you provided. The cause and manner of death are pending further studies at this time.” The Police Department’s Deputy Commissioner of Public Information did not have a record of David McKee’s death or an OD in Tompkins Square by him in August. A few days after attacking Bayley’s pug, and just a few blocks away from there, Jax attacked Michael Puzzo, an East Village man who was walking his girlfriend’s dog, Bobito, on E. Sixth St. In each of Jax’s attacks, Natas had been sleeping or passed out on substances, with the brown pit bull beside him, when the dog — reportedly unleashed each time — suddenly lunged for the smaller dogs. Puzzo managed to shield Bobito from Jax’s jaws, but got chomped on his arm. Either that same day or the next, again in the same neck of the East Village, another local man, Ed Vassilev, was savagely bitten on the arm by a different crusty pit bull as he tried to protect his puppy, Misha, from being attacked. Vassilev was left with permanent nerve damage. Trachtenberg provided a phone number for the outreach worker, Sally (not her real name), who spoke to the newspaper on condition of anonymity. Sally said she received word of Natas’s death from a worker in another local organization that does outreach and offers a needle-exchange service — providing fresh sharps to reduce the spread of infectious diseases between IV drug users. Sally said she had seen Natas recently. He told her that he was trying to get Jax back from Animal Care and Control and that his plan was then to return to New Jersey, where he is originally from. In an effort to notify his family of his death, she left a message for Natas’s sister, but has not heard back. “He wanted to get out of the city and take his dog out of the city,” she said. Sally said she didn’t know a lot about Natas, whose street name was Satan spelled backwards. His Facebook page offers a few details about him. It says he attended Rutgers University and was in the class of 2000 at Pennsauken


September 3, 2015

David McKee a.k.a. Natas, wearing a Philadelphia cap under a hoodie, in a photo from his Facebook page.

High School, which would have made him around age 33. His hometown is listed as Delair, N.J., and his current residence as Blackwood, N.J. His page’s “About” section features one statement: “what is there to say. all who know me know im highly unstable”; and one quote, attributed to “deadly dee”: “until my black heart ceases to beat in my cold dead chest, i will seek retribution or my soul will not rest.” His posts over the years alternated between laments about the state of man — and his own state — musings on death, and — befitting his devilish nickname — quotes in Latin about Satan and Lucifer. In one post, in English, he reassured that people would have nothing to worry about if he returned as the antichrist. “I don’t know if he was using when he died,” Sally said. “That’s what people just assume — us, too. I had only really just come across him in the last couple of months. I had just seen him two days before he died. He said they told him they couldn’t give his dog back to him unless he had New York State ID.” Sally considered helping him get Jax back, but said Natas hadn’t asked her directly, and that she wasn’t sure if she would do it. “If he was going to be leaving with the dog, I thought about it,” she said. “I don’t want his dog put down. Dogs are a very touchy issue, particularly with this crowd.” Basically, the travelers are very close to their dogs, most of which are “well trained,” she said. Obviously, Jax was not, though, and was extremely aggressive. As for Natas, she said, he wasn’t a fake crusty traveler — or fauxbo, as they call them in New Orleans. “He had a very difficult childhood,”

she said. “Beyond popular belief, he was not a rich trust-fund kid. He was just a homeless kid.” As to whether he died due to heroin, alcohol or a combination of them or mixed with other drugs, that will be determined by the medical examiner’s autopsy. Sally said Natas, in fact, may have been trying to get clean. “He had a bad laceration on his forehead, from falling during a seizure,” she said. “That could have been alcohol related, or he could have had a condition. Some of these kids do have conditions, but this often happens with alcohol withdrawal. Heroin and cocaine are awful to come off of — but alcohol is actually physically dangerous to come off of. I know he was saying he was trying to get clean and get off the streets. I know he did use [heroin and alcohol] at some point. I don’t know if he was using at the time he died.” The travelers will soon be leaving the city once the weather turns cool, heading for warmer climes in New Orleans and elsewhere. “Around September, they’ll start leaving, to get settled for the winter,” Sally said. However, she added, now with global warming, they’ll probably be hanging around here a bit longer. Many of them are already up in Maine now picking blueberries, she said. In fact, there were fewer crusty travelers around the East Village this summer, just as there have been in recent summers, according to her. The travelers have spread out to Brooklyn or even further Uptown in Manhattan, which actually makes it more dangerous for them, she said. “Now, I literally spend half a day walking around looking for people,” the outreach worker noted.

For example, the travelers no longer camp out in front of St. Mark’s Church, at Second Ave. and E. 10th St., after crusties there three years ago smeared graffiti in white paint all over the front of the historic house of worship. “That ruined it for everyone,” she said. “Most of them don’t hang out here anymore. They don’t feel wanted or welcome.” She can relate to that feeling, since she herself was formerly one of the homeless youth, but managed to pull her life together. “As someone who’s been homeless before, I’ve never felt such hatred as when I was homeless,” she said. “People urinating on me, pouring alcohol on me, trying to set me on fire, masturbating on me while I’m asleep. “The homeless are easy victims — people take their frustrations out on them.” She said this kind of abuse can partly explain why some crusties are obnoxious and yell at people on the street. Her organization has a client base of 300 mostly young crusties and travelers — only about 100 of whom pass through New York City each year. Last year, there were 32 deaths among this group, mostly from heroin OD’s, along with Hepatitis C, liver failure, alcohol and opiates. Mon., Aug. 31, was actually Overdose Awareness Day, she noted. Having found out about Natas’s death from Trachtenberg, Bayley, a famed punk rock photographer, said the whole experience has left her “very sad.” “I wouldn’t wish death on anybody. It’s an irresponsible person, not an evil person,” she said of Natas. “The owner fell asleep — it wasn’t intentional. I wish the dog possibly could be put down or taken away. I think it’s a very dangerous dog, so I hope it’s taken off the street.” Recovering from Sidney’s death hasn’t been easy. “I’m doing acupuncture and getting therapy. It’s just awful, it’s a big hole in my life,” she said. “But I don’t think I’ll stay this way forever. I just hope some good can come from Sidney’s death, and I think it has, in terms of raising awareness. But you have to keep the awareness up. I think I’m going to do some activism about it at the City Council.” She’s also down on the crusty travelers now, who often use their dogs as money magnets when panhandling. “We have enough real homeless,” she said, “that I don’t think we need kids thinking it’s cool to live on the street, take heroin and have a dog. Just go home. Sorry if I sound like an old NATAS continued on p. 27

POLICE BLOTTER Pickpocket socked her A 59-year-old woman was standing in the vestibule leading to her workplace at 140 W. 10th St. when a stranger snuck up from behind at about 1 p.m. on Mon., Aug. 24, police said. She soon realized he was trying to take the Samsung Note 3 cellphone in her rear pants pocket. She resisted and got a punch to the head in return — leaving her with some bruising and swelling — and the mugger fled with the $350 phone. A 55-year-old man witnessed the incident, according to a police report. Later that day, police arrested Khari Covington, 23, in connection with the incident, charging him with felony robbery.

Not-so-easy pickings Police said a thief tried to take advantage of a drunk man sleeping near the southeast corner of Grove and W. Fourth Sts. on Fri., Aug. 28, around 2:30 a.m. A police officer saw the suspect allegedly rifle the pockets of the 45-year-old man’s pants, though he found nothing of value, according to a report. Police arrested Arthur Ragin, 49, and charged him with attempted grand larceny, a felony. Meanwhile, the intoxicated man was taken to a hospital.

Taxi-hating trio For unknown reasons, a man, 22, stomped on the hood of a taxicab on Sun., Aug. 30, around 4:20 a.m. He then repeatedly punched the windshield, resulting in damage of more than $250, police said. The 44-yearold hack exited the vehicle and

confronted the younger man, who punched the cabbie in the face. Two associates of the attacker meanwhile looked on. “Oh, this ain’t happening,” said Brielle Siler, 22, according to a police report. Police soon arrived but found the alleged attacker, Vincent Hopkins, along with Siler and Elijah Shabazz, 23, who cops said were uncooperative and resisted arrest. Hopkins was charged with assault, Siler with resisting arrest and Shabazz with obstruction of government administration, all misdemeanors.

Gun search fires blanks Two men allegedly followed up on a dispute from earlier in the week with some firepower early on Sun., Aug. 30. They arrived in front of 675 Hudson St. at 6:09 a.m. and, with one of them allegedly packing a black firearm, confronted a 36-year-old man, police said. Officers found Anothony Sanders, 19, and Jonathan Sullivan, 25, nearby, but no gun was recovered, according to a report. The two men were charged with misdemeanor menacing.

Detective Diether

On October 1, HealthPlus Amerigroup will become Empire BlueCross BlueShield HealthPlus.

Veteran Village activist Doris Diether reported that she was informed by the manager of the HSBC bank branch at Washington Place and Sixth Ave. that it was hit by a robber last Wed., Aug. 26. The manager told her that two other banks in the area were also robbed that day, a Chase branch and another bank on the East Side. More details were not immediately available.

You’ll have all the same benefits you’ve always had. And you’ll work with the same people. For more information, call us toll free at 1-800-600-4441 (TTY 711).

Zach Williams and Lincoln Anderson

...but who is the subject in the painting? A piece of “street art,” literally, on a sidewalk near Beach St. in Tribeca.


His name is Earl....

Same people. Same benefits. Now better with Blue. Empire BlueCross BlueShield HealthPlus is the trade name of HealthPlus, LLC, an independent licensee of the Blue Cross and Blue Shield Association. To learn more about applying for health insurance including Child Health Plus and Medicaid through NY State of Health, The Official Health Plan Marketplace, visit or call 1-855-355-5777. September 3, 2015


Glick: We’ll block bulldozers for N.Y.U. project; N.Y.U. continued from p. 1


September 3, 2015


But Glick said the university is the one benefiting from its association with the Village, not vice versa. “N.Y.U. used its location in this iconic neighborhood to attract its student body — not the other way around,” she stressed, adding, “And upon graduation, their students learn they have a mortgage on their education and they suffer forever with a yoke of debt around their neck.” The lawsuit delayed the start of the project for three years. “We have an opportunity to continue dragging it out — by joining hands when the bulldozers come,” the assemblymember declared, to cheers from the crowd. At every turn, the community is facing overdevelopment, she said, from Gansevoort St., where developers want to raise the building heights on a historic, landmarked low-scale block, to Hudson River Park, where, she said, “an individual wants to build a new-fangled pier,” referring to Barry Diller and the Pier55 “arts island” project. Similarly, the city is trying to shoehorn residential buildings into Brooklyn Bridge Park, she said. Concluding her remarks, she told the crowd, “We’ll see you when they come with the bulldozers!” to cheers. Representatives of N.Y.U. student and faculty groups blasted the school for having, in their view, overpaid administrators and underpaid faculty, which, they charged, is hurting the students’ education. Meanwhile, tuition at the Village school now stands at more than $46,000 a year. Mark Crispin Miller, the leader of N.Y.U. Faculty Against the Sexton Plan, delivered cutting comments against outgoing president John Sexton. Miller, like many of the school’s faculty, lives in N.Y.U. housing right in the middle of the future construction zone. Meanwhile, he said of Sexton, “He’s probably on Fire Island in his beach house — built with a million-dollar loan [from N.Y.U.], built across three lots.” The British-born Andrew Hamilton will be taking over as N.Y.U. president this coming January. Contrasting him with Hamilton, Miller scoffed at Sexton — known for freely giving warm bear hugs and sporting a Yankees cap — for his effusiveness and boosterism. “I’m sure he’s got a lot more class than John Sexton,” he said of the new university head, “but that should make us uneasy, because he’s hired by the same board as Sexton, with the same program.” Next, came what was the event’s highlight — or perhaps, some might say, it’s lowlight.

Members of “STOMP” performed in support of the rally.

Finding common cause: Displacement, high rents and tuition will be the focus of a rally on the Lower East Side later this month.

A young woman walked onstage wearing an elaborate, black-feathered mask. It was modeled after the one worn by Mandy, a prostitute in “Eyes Wide Shut,” the 1999 movie starring Tom Cruise and Nicole Kidman about high-end sex parties. A rising N.Y.U. junior, she said that to afford her tuition she had to turn to working as a dominatrix in an S&M den. After the bruises became too much, she switched to being a bodyrub girl in a tantric massage house, where “happy endings” were expected. She is just one of many young college students, she said, who have had to turn to the likes of craigslist, and SeekingArrangement just to make ends meet. “Before I became a prostitute, I was

a top student,” she said, her voice trembling slightly. As a first-generation college student, she explained, she didn’t want to give up on her education. But as she continued to do sex work, her grades slipped and she found she was always handing in her papers late. Her sole living parent had expected a settlement from an accident, which was going to help fund her daughter’s education, but it never panned out, and then the mother died. “I tried to transfer — but no university I applied to, either public or private, would take N.Y.U.’s credits,” she said. This was because the department she is in at N.Y.U. is a unique, liberal, creative one, a friend later explained. Most of the other young women she

worked with in the dungeon or tantric massage place were, like her, college students. “Some were Sarah Lawrence girls, some were from CUNY — but the vast majority were from N.Y.U.,” she said. “Masseuse, stripper, escort, prostitute — it is an epidemic. We come to the universities to better our lives. No girl should have to sell herself for a better life.” Right now, she has enough cash to last the next three months. “I am lucky. I’m out,” she said. “But I’m afraid if things don’t work out, I might have to go back.” Finishing her wrenching story, she turned and walked off the stage to sustained applause. “That took a lot of guts — even with a mask on,” Miller said. A recent article in the Atlantic reported that N.Y.U. is the first university to “cross the 1,000 sugar babies” threshold” on SeekingArrangement, a site that connects young women with wealthy “sugar daddies.” Among those at the rally were three women representing three generations of a family from 505 LaGuardia Place, which is located on one of the superblocks where N.Y.U. would build. Sarah Soffer, who grew up in the building with former Councilmember Alan Gerson and attended Stuyvesant High School with him, said she only wished Gerson had been re-elected to a third term, feeling he would have fought the university’s project forcefully, unlike Margaret Chin. “I feel that Chin has a large district with a varied constituency and didn’t realize the damage this would do to N.Y.U. continued on p. 9

Cude: Town and gown are united against this N.Y.U. continued from p. 8


the community,” she said of N.Y.U. 2031. “I went to all the hearings, and I never heard anyone who wasn’t either in construction or from N.Y.U. speak up for the plan.” Other councilmembers automatically deferred to Chin, since the project is in her district, she said, whereas if Gerson had been fighting it, it wouldn’t have sailed through. Meanwhile, Community Board 1, in Lower Manhattan, actually was begging N.Y.U. to build down there instead, she recalled. Her daughter, Eve Liberman, 14, sat next to actor Matthew Broderick in the City Council three years ago when they both took turns testifying against the project. Asked if her thoughts about the N.Y.U. plan have changed since then, she said no. “No, it hasn’t,” she said. “Back then I was in sixth grade, I was 11. I was traveling out of the neighborhood by subway to school. And if I was doing that, why couldn’t the N.Y.U. students? I’m traveling even farther now to get to school,” she said. In that vein, her mom added that cramming all of the students into a campus “core” in the Village doesn’t serve them well, either. “The nature of coming to New York City as a student is to embody the city at large,” she said. “This is New York — either it’s for you or it isn’t. I think many students see N.Y.U. as a place to explore New York.” Asked for her view, grandma Shirley Soffer — an original tenants of 505 LaGuardia — said, “I don’t agree with the destruction of the community. We need to have the open space.”

Do they have to “throw shade”? Three generations of a Village family all say no to the N.Y.U. plan, from left, Shirley and Sarah Soffer and Eve Liberman.

District leader candidate Terri Cude summed it all up succinctly: “Flowers not towers; parks not perks.” “Everyone talks about town-gown conflict,” she said. “We are town and gown together against a real estate developer that shares its name with a university.” Although none of the opponents’ celebrity supporters were on hand, they did help the cause digitally. Padma Lakshmi, Susan Sarandon, Mark Ruffalo and John Leguizamo all tweeted about the rally, while Matthew Modine — whose number of followers is blowing up with the success of his new series, “Proof” — did a retweet about it. John Beckman, the T:8.75” university’s spokesperson,

countered the charges made at the rally with some statistics. He said N.Y.U. has increased its financial aid budget by 185 percent since 2002 and provides nearly $270 million annually in scholarships. Since 2010, he said, N.Y.U. has reduced the average debt upon graduation by more than $13,000 — with the average debt for an N.Y.U. graduate below the national average. Also, he noted, N.Y.U. for the past 10 years has continued to be ranked in the top five of the Princeton Review’s “dream schools.” Financially, the university’s endowment has tripled since 2002, and both S&P and Moody’s have rated N.Y.U.’s bonds in the AA range, he noted. Plus, 20 percent of incoming freshmen, he pointed out, are the first in their family ever to attend college. N.Y.U. is planning to keep Coles gym, on Mercer St., open through at least Nov. 15. The university plans to start the N.Y.U. 2031 project there, by tearing down Coles and replacing it with a far-larger building, currently known only as the “Zipper Building,” which would have a new gym in its basement level. The current gym serves 3,000 people daily during the school year. N.Y.U. says it will meet the needs of its student athletes and swimmers at its Palladium building on E. 14th St. and “through other arrangements at nearby external venues.” N.Y.U. is also readying a new fitness facility at 404 Lafayette St. that will contain cardio training and recreation classes. Miller protested, “Is there another major university without a proper gym for its entire community? Considering how much it costs to go to N.Y.U., there is no good reason to deprive our students of that indispensable resource.”


Everyone depends on electricity. So if you ever need to report a loss of power, now you can text OUT to OUTAGE (688243) and follow the prompts. Also, check our outage map to get estimated restoration times at

September 3, 2015


Essex Market open, but needs marketing: Vendors BY YANNIC RACK



September 3, 2015


trolling through the Essex Street Market, casual visitors will be mostly oblivious to the troubles its historic halls have seen over the last few years. On closer inspection, they might notice the few shuttered stalls whose spaces have sat empty for almost a year. And sometimes, the corridors displaying fresh produce and exotic fare can feel deserted even without comparing them to bustling days gone by. The market, which celebrated its 75th anniversary this year, has had to cope with a sharp drop in business ever since the Essex Crossing redevelopment was formally announced in 2012. As part of the $1 billion project, which began construction across the street last month, nine blocks in the area will be transformed from what are now mostly parking lots to apartment buildings and a range of shops and cultural spaces. Also part of the plan is a new and larger home for the market, which will be located just across Delancey St. Many local residents and visitors wrongly believe that the market has closed its doors until the new space opens in three years, much to the dismay of the old-time grocers, as well as newer artisanal bakers and the like, that still serve the surrounding Lower East Side community. “I think that there was a dramatic drop after the project was announced for a lot of vendors, because there was a lot of public uncertainty about the future of the market — if we’re closed now, if we’re closing later,” said Anne Saxelby, who opened her own market stall, Saxelby Cheesemongers, nine years ago. Saxelby said her shop lost about a third of its customers within one year after the plans were made public. She did note that some of the older vendors, who have been there for decades and rely heavily on the area’s public-housing population, were not hit quite as hard. Nonetheless, the crunch was felt by all the merchants, and as a result three stalls, including one butcher run by Saxelby’s husband, closed down earlier this year. But now there are some efforts underway that have market vendors at least hoping for a return to business as usual. Saxelby heads the Essex Street Market Vendors Association. The group was created in 2012 to advocate for vendors’ rights during the Essex Crossing project and works with the Lower East Side Business Improvement District and the city’s Economic Development Corporation, which oversees and rents out spaces at the market. The vendors have long criticized E.D.C. for neglecting the market and failing to counter the impression that it is closed until its relocation. But now their tone has changed, albeit only slightly, in the face of new programs that are supposed to reverse the current trend. The market will open for extended hours from Sept. 11 through December, which E.D.C. says will be complemented by “programming” to help drive foot traffic — things like market tours and screenings as part of the LES Film Festival. It is also providing the business improvement district with $10,000 for advertising in the coming year, part of an agreement that will see the organization take over some other marketing responsibilities, as well. “We have been working closely with the vendors association on a variety of marketing and programming initiatives,” Tim Laughlin, the

Though the market needs to draw more people in, new exterior banners to flag the attention of passersby were only added this spring.

BID’s executive director, said, adding that he couldn’t disclose any details just yet. The BID had also planned to install Street Seats directly outside on Essex St. this summer, to increase awareness of the market and encourage customers and passersby alike to linger. But last week Laughlin said that the program, which is organized in coordination with the city’s Department of Transportation, will be delayed until next April. The initiative had been pushed back repeatedly and eventually became too expensive, since the seats are only seasonal and have to be removed by October. At this point, Laughlin said, the time window had become too small. “In concert with the Street Seats, we’ll be requesting a variety of improvements to parking regulations that both support customers and vendors on that block,” he said. Saxelby said that while they were disappointed to have to wait another seven months, the vendors agreed that it made more sense to delay the program so that it can run for the whole season. What could signal a change at the market much sooner, however, is a new management structure: Around three weeks ago, the vendors association was formally incorporated as a nonprofit, something that had been in the works for some time. “We’re incorporated as a merchants association now, so we’re a 501c6 nonprofit, which is a slightly more limited form than a 501c3,” Saxelby said. “It’s basically to do marketing, promotion and advocacy for a group of small merchants. Our goal wasn’t self-management by the vendors association but alternative management with a new nonprofit structure,” she said, adding that this model has proved itself at other public markets around the country, including Pike Place Market in Seattle and Reading Terminal Market in Philadelphia. With the incorporation process complete, E.D.C. is now providing funding to hire a part-time vendor services coordinator, who will support the vendors by liaising with community organizations and city agencies, and take over many of the tasks and coordination that are required on a daily basis. “We hope to hire that person in September and have them help us strengthen all those relationships and make the market ever more visible in

the public eye,” Saxelby said. That would also benefit the new tenants that are moving in soon. E.D.C. told The Villager this week that it is finalizing agreements with four vendors who will once again fill the market to full capacity. An agency spokesperson said that one of the new stalls will be occupied by Puebla Mexican Food, the restaurant that this spring had to close its doors after 25 years on First Ave. between E. Second and E. Third Sts., due to a rent hike. Other vendors could potentially include a craft beer shop and a Japanese food vendor, according to a source at the market. Saxelby said she hopes the mix will also include a butcher. Filling the empty spaces might, at the very least, boost morale among the other vendors, if Saxelby’s reaction is an indicator. “I feel like a full market is a vibrant market,” she said. “It’s like the broken windows theory — if there’s a couple of things going wrong, then it makes it look like there is more going wrong. The market is still a vibrant place, so filling it up to capacity is absolutely the way to go.” In general, though, she is still careful not to heap too much praise onto E.D.C. “E.D.C. has managed the market but I wouldn’t say we’ve worked together,” she remarked. “We’ve really had more of a collaboration with the BID in terms of making change.” She specifically mentioned E.D.C.’s long approval processes for simple things like putting up signs outside or allowing a TV crew to come in and film a segment, which would attract press coverage and visitors. “I feel like there’ve been steps made to sort of turn things around, but we’re just starting to see the first bits of real action and commitment to change,” Saxelby said. The vendors still have three years left in their historic building, which dates from the administration of Mayor Fiorello La Guardia, when it was built to house pushcart vendors, who were clogging up the streets. But the low-slung structure itself can sometimes seem like part of the problem. The market’s 15,000 square feet are hidden behind a drab and uninviting facade; the banners out front advertising the market were only installed this spring. “The building that we’re currently in is kind of like a shed, people don’t know what’s going on inside,” Saxelby said, adding that all of the vendors were looking forward to the move across the street to the bigger location. “It’s going to be a lot more visible from the street, it will be all glass, which is great.” The vendors at the old market will get first dibs on the new spaces and moving expenses will be covered by the developers. So far business at the current location hasn’t rebounded, at least not at Saxelby Cheesemongers, though it hasn’t dropped off any further, either. Whether the upcoming marketing initiatives will pay off, along with previous ones — like the market’s 75th anniversary celebrations earlier this year — remains to be seen. Since the summer months are generally tough on retailers in the city, Saxelby thinks it could all finally pan out this fall. “We’re just hopeful that these new agreements that are being put in place now will pave the way for a more effective, collaborative relationship moving forward,” she said. “But they are still untested.”



t Course



ing Courses: Jacket e


Name 4C 6 x 5.69

YourFuture Future Starts NOW! Your Starts NOW! Every course you need to be certified is offered daily.

Su Futuro Empieza Ahora!

Home Health Aide (Day and Evening Courses) Experienced Instructors Job Assistance Provided



estar certificado se ofrece diario.


HOME HEALTH AIDE TRAINING New to our Jamaica Campus Home Health Aide Training

a division of

Day and Evening Courses• Experienced Instructors 54-06 Myrtle Avenue, 2nd Fl. 168-25 Jamaica Avenue JOB Assistance Provided • Se Habla Espanol

Jamaica, NY 11432 Ridgewood, NY 11385 168-25 Jamaica Ave., 54-06 Myrtle Ave., 2nd Fl.718-609-1674 718-307-7141 Jamaica, NY 11432 Ridgewood, NY 11385 718-609-1674 718-307-7141 EXCLUSIVE! Accessible by Accessible by FJE M andBECOME Q58, Q55, B52,A TRAINLTO B26, B54

and Q24, Q56

SECURITY GUARD INSTRUCTOR 40 Hour Instructor Development Course

SECURITY GUARD TRAINING Instructors: Tom Flynn & Bob Loveridge

We have NYS DCJS mandated Security Guard Training Courses: • 8 Hour Pre-Assignment Training Course Become a NY State Certifi ed Job Security Guard Today! • 16 Hour On the Training Course • 8 Hour Annual In-Service

8 Specialty HR. Pre-assignment Courses: • Fire Guard Prep Class OSHA 10 Job • OSHA 30 •CPR / AED 16 HR. •on the Training Fireguard Prep CARE TRAINING CENTER IDC - (InstructorEFFICIENT Development Course)

Su Futuro Empieza AHORA! Jamaica Ave., paraestar certificado se ofrece diario. 54-06 Myrtle Ave., 2nd Fl.Cada168-25 curso tiene que necesitas Jamaica, NY 11432 Ridgewood, NY 11385 Asistente de salud domiciliaria a division of 718-609-1674 718-307-7141 (Cursos de Dia y de Noche) Accessible by L M and Q58, Q55, B52, B26, B54

Accessible Instructores con by experiencia J Ebuscar trabajo Assistimos Fen and Q24, Q56 September 3, 2015


God’s Love We Deliver is back and cooking BY LINCOLN ANDERSON



September 3, 2015


od’s Love We Deliver recently took The Villager on a tour of its new building at Sixth Ave. and Spring St., offering a look not only at the place’s interior, but also at the nonprofit’s high-volume, health-conscious cooking operation that sustains thousands of seriously ill people each week. The $28 million project — done in a year and a half — has transformed G.L.W.D.’s former headquarters, a squat, two-story, 60-year-old building, into a new five-story facility, more than doubling the space to 48,000 square feet. In addition to its boosted height, the new building’s shiny aluminum cladding certainly makes it hard to miss. Originally a library for the blind, the former building was nondescript, and, when viewed from the outside, gave little sense of what went on inside. The new headquarters boasts large windows that both let in light and let people see what’s going on inside. “In our redesign, we wanted to let people from the outside know who we are,” said Karen Pearl, the organization’s president and C.E.O. “Before, with our little brick building, you couldn’t see what we were doing.” Similarly, increasing the sense of openness, the new entryway sports a staircase on the corner offering access from both Sixth Ave. and Spring St. Not far from the front doors, in an area with slightly chilled air, volunteers were doing “meal packaging and kitting,” as Pearl explained. Each bag contained either regular food, modified food or individually prepared food, per each client’s needs. For example, some meals are pureed for people who can’t chew. Adjacent to this area is the vehicle bay on Spring St., which is now enclosed, where the G.L.W.D. vans pick up the food for delivery. It’s hoped that the building will achieve a LEED Silver energy-efficient designation. In that vein, Pearl pointed out numerous bike racks lining the bay’s walls. For the benefit of volunteers and employees who bike, there are showers in the basement to wash off the sweat. On the second floor is the hub and heart of G.L.W.D. — its new 10,000-square-foot kitchen. In spots along the walls are memorial and honor tiles that once adorned the former kitchen. Those with red hearts honor individuals who have passed on. Running things in the Joan Rivers Bakery is Chuck Piekarski, a G.L.W.D. employee. It was clear-

With its new, bigger building, God’s Love — which sports its own signature flag on the rooftop — hopes to achieve new heights.

Chuck Piekarski runs the Joan Rivers Bakery.

Volunteers putting scoops of cranberry scone dough in individual tins.

ly meant to be, as he noted, since in Polish, his last name actually means, “son of a baker.” The late comic Rivers was a longtime God’s Love supporter. “The nice thing is Joan knew she was going to be honored with the bakery before she passed away,” noted David Ludwigson, the chief development officer. In a light-filled corner of the bakery, a group of regular volunteers — they have all volunteered there for about five years, two to three times a week — were scooping dollops of low-sugar / low-fat cranberry scone dough into individual tin containers. Three hundred of these were then loaded onto trays, which were then put onto a tall cart, which was then wheeled into a high-tech, man-size oven to cook, after which they would be flash-frozen. “It’s so much safer for the food,” Pearl noted of the freezing method, which God’s Love has used exclusively since 2013. “Everything that leaves here is frozen or chilled. Clients like the chilled-food model — they can eat what and when they want.” It’s all a streamlined operation. Sometime ago, for example, Piekarski realized that cracking hundreds of eggs each day was too time consuming. So he now uses liquid egg yolks instead that he buys by the quart. “When you cook 5,000 meals a day, you learn about efficiency,” Pearl explained. Nearby, another employee was mixing soup in big 60-gallon vats — vegetable bean or beef minestrone. Eighty-five staff and 8,000 volunteers keep G.L.W.D. running. All of the meals are provided to the clients for free. God’s Love started in 1985 as the AIDS crisis was gripping New York, advocating the concept of “food as medicine.” Fifteen years ago, the organization shifted its mission, and now provides meals to seriously ill people with any of 200 different diagnoses, including H.I.V./AIDS, cancer, heart disease and renal failure, plus Alzheimer’s, Parkinson’s and multiple sclerosis. Children of sick individuals also get free meals, since people who can’t cook for themselves can’t do it for their kids. Half of the clients get frozen meals delivered twice a week — with each delivery covering the meals for half the week — while the other half opt for all the meals to be delivered on one day each week. G.L.W.D. doesn’t fry food, and no preservatives, additives, artificial GOD’S LOVE continued on p.13

again in its gleaming new Spring St. building GOD’S LOVE continued from p. 12


flavors or colors are used. “We have to be extra-careful with food because our clients’ immune systems are compromised,” she noted. The kitchen gets cleaned three times a day, and everyone around the food has to wear a hair net or hat. They soon hope to add a digester, which will break down any leftover food by using enzymes, after which the waste can then be poured right into the sewer. The third and fourth floors include office space for G.L.W.D. staff and areas for volunteers to gather. The fifth floor features a large communal education space with a demonstration kitchen, which will be used for teaching and donor events. Setbacks at the fifth-floor level have been used for terraces, with outdoor seating for volunteers and others to relax before or after their shifts. Finally, on the rooftop is a sweet-smelling, thriving garden featuring basil, mint, rosemary, bronze fennel, lemongrass, thyme, sorrel, dill and more — all potential ingredients for the food. Recently, the mint had been included in iced tea and the basil in a marinara sauce. “The lemongrass was used to make a great lemongrass broth,” noted Emmett Findley, God’s Love’s manager of communications. In a unique arrangement, the meals provider’s building’s rooftop is technically accessible to the future residents of the new luxury residential high-rise being built just to the north. “There actually aren’t that many apartments in there, so we don’t think a lot will come up here,” Pearl predicted. Allowing the open-space access to the rooftop let the developers extend their building farther toward G.L.W.D. than the zoning normally would have allowed, she said. Helping finance its own project — but raising neighbors’ ire — G.L.W.D. sold $6 million worth of air rights to that adjacent development. Neighbors who opposed both projects protested that because the deed restriction on the God’s Love property mandates community use, the development rights could not be transferred for a private, market-rate use. However, Pearl said, “There’s actually not anything that was not done 100 percent according to building code. A lot of nonprofits are selling air rights. We could have built apartments on top but we didn’t.”

The exterior of the new God’s Love building features distinctive-looking aluminum panels. The developers of the neighboring building to the left bought $6 million worth of development rights from the meals provider.

Making soup in 60-gallon vats.

The G.L.W.D. rooftop has a garden to provide fresh ingredients — and also to provide hypothetical open-space access for future high-end residential neighbors to the north.

Putting trays of the scones on a large rolling cart that will then be wheeled into a high-tech oven and baked at 400 degrees.

Plus, she added, “The air rights were not addressed in the deed.” More to the point, she said, the air rights sale allowed God’s Love to build its great new building. During the construction, G.L.W.D. moved its operations to South Williamsburg and paid rent, which added to the project’s overall cost. Some Soho residents no doubt would have preferred that the organization simply relocate there, rather than build a new H.Q. whose design and materials, they charge, are not contextual with the surrounding area. But Soho is where God’s Love owned its property, and Soho is where it will now continue operating in its new state-of-the-art building, which will allow it to better fulfill its mission of helping the severely ill through healthy food. September 3, 2015


Vote for change; Vote Cude-Gault on Sept. 10 EDITORIAL


ost New Yorkers are focusing on enjoying what’s left of the summer right now. But there is a primary election coming up, on Thurs., Sept. 10. Locally, the contest for Democratic district leader in the 66th Assembly District, Part B, is the big race. The district, which stretches from the Washington Square area down to Battery Park City, is currently represented by John Scott and Jean Grillo, who are being challenged by Terri Cude and Dennis Gault. Simply put, this race is a case of one good pair of candidates facing off against another. Scott and Grillo, who both live in Tribeca, have done a capable job. Scott has been active on school issues and Grillo is a leader on the Battery Park City Community Emergency Response Team, or CERT, formed after the 9/11 World Trade Center terrorist attack. Cude is an up-and-coming activist who has carved out a spot for herself on Community Board 2 and is co-chairperson of the Community Action Alliance on N.Y.U. 2031 — a coalition of neighborhood and preservation

groups who have been battling the university’s South Village mega-development plan. A Bleecker St. resident, she is the only one of the four candidates to live in the district’s northern part. Gault, who resides in Battery Park City, is a public school teacher in the East Village and his school’s union representative. In all honesty, this race was fueled by a political club war. Scott and Grillo split off a few years ago from Downtown Independent Democrats and formed a new club, Downtown Progressive Democrats. Why? Though neither D.I.D. or D.P.D. will say so in as many words, it was really because D.I.D. supported Jenifer Rajkumar in her race against incumbent City Councilmember Margaret Chin. So then, returning to the district leader candidates, what is the difference between the two slates? In part, the difference is Chin. Scott and Grillo are allied with her; Cude and Gault are willing to stand up to Chin, and to any other politician, developer or university (often the latter two are one and the same, aren’t they?) that threatens the quality of life and historic fabric of the Village and all of Part B. Also, Cude has made the fact that she lives in the district’s northern end a campaign plank, and we agree with her — it is important to have a politi-

cal presence in this neck of the woods. Perhaps having a strong and passionate voice like Cude’s as district leader could have helped rein in the massive, overreaching N.Y.U. plan. We sorely need that kind of vibrant advocacy. And, sadly, Chin is still showing she’s tone deaf to the upper part of her district, as she continues to try to push through an affordable housing project on the Elizabeth St. Garden when an even better site exists at Clarkson and Hudson Sts. We don’t need to enable anymore misguided plans right now — what we need is someone who has the community’s back. That Cude has risen to the position of first vice chairperson at C.B. 2 shows that she is both politically astute and that her peers respect her leadership abilities. And her boundless energy is more than evident in the community events she has led, from teaching kids how to bike at Mercer Playground, to free document shredding. On Thanksgiving, you’ll find her at Le Souk serving free turkey dinners to those who have no family to celebrate with for the holiday. The Cude-Gault team, in short, will bring new energy to this political office, which is, admittedly, unpaid and the entry-level party position, but which, historically, has played an oversize role in Village politics and activism. Cude

and Gault are fighters, and would fit right in with that fighting tradition. It’s time for a change. It’s time to speak truth to power. It’s time to stand up for our community and to protect our open spaces from wrongheaded development. Cude and Gault understand that, and they’re willing to go to the mat for this community. Scott and Grillo can continue with their good activism in their community — but it’s time for new leadership at district leader. As for the judicial delegates on the ballot in Part A (the Village), Scott and Grillo say they actually didn’t mean to have an election, and this confusion admittedly seems to be part of the feud between D.I.D. and D.P.D. Again, they are all good candidates, but if D.P.D. says they didn’t mean to run a slate, then let’s take them at their word, and elect the opposing slate. This SNAFU, unfortunately, also means there will be an election in Part A, which will cost taxpayers more than $100,000, according to Part A District Leader Keen Berger, who tried her best to persuade the Board of Elections to call off the election and save the money. (Yeah, good luck with that!) Anyway, whereas the judicial delegates race is arcane, the district leader race is critical for this community’s future. Vote Cude-Gault on Thurs., Sept. 10!

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR The Manitoba says: Tina rocks! To The Editor: Re “A punk rocker ponders his bar’s future” (news article, Aug. 27): At first I didn’t know who this woman writer was. After 40 years of giving interviews and occasionally being the interviewer, I am hesitant to do interviews more times than not. I feel that the people did not properly represent

me in the past, and were very poor at doing interviews. I looked into Tina Benitez-Eves’s background a little and made the decision to be interviewed. I think Tina did a fantastic job. I feel very accurately represented. I feel my own personal voice was heard the way I’d like it to be heard, and I have no complaints. Tina is a professional and very talented. Handsome Dick Manitoba


Manitoba’s was made for me To The Editor: Re “A punk rocker ponders his bar’s future” (news article, Aug. 27): I’m saddened by this. But I do understand, in this world of greed and rising rents, the difficulties of keeping an interesting piece of history like this open. For me, Manitoba’s was my home and still is — even though I’m a little far away from it right this minute. Richard and Zoe gave me a home, and my obvious love for punk, rock ’n’ roll and being a musician of this genre naturally drew me there. They encouraged my wild persona as a bartender, welcomed me and made Manitoba’s a huge part of my life. See you in 2016. Don’t you dare close without me! Labretta Suede

Some ideas for new park To The Editor: Re “Hospital triangle goes ‘back to the land’ as new park opens; AIDS memorial is coming next”

A natural spot for Biden to put out ‘feelers’ for a run? 14

September 3, 2015

LETTERS continued on p. 16

Jeans to Jordans: Fashion-forward...or backward? RHYMES WITH CRAZY BY LENORE SKENAZY


ou get up in the morning and walk out the door clad in history. Every item you’re wearing owes a debt to the genius of yesteryear, just as surely as Elvis owes a debt to Muddy Waters, and vegans owe a debt to vegetarians. The problem is, it’s hard to see how the flappers of the 1920s influenced the hippies of the ’60s, or who bequeathed us the skinny jeans of today, until you take a look at the sweep of fashion history. That’s exactly what Daniel James Cole and Nancy Deihl do in their new book, “The History of Modern Fashion.” “Fashion always interlocks with culture,” says Deihl, director of the master’s program in costume studies at New York University. For instance, adds Cole, who also teaches fashion history at both the university and the Fashion Institute of Technology, just look at the jeans you’re probably wearing right now. (I am!) Denim is a uniform for many of us today, but most likely it was first used in Europe as a boat covering, says Cole. The word “denim” comes from “de Nimes” — French for “from the town of Nimes.”

It was those classy Italians in Genoa who turned the boat cloth into pants. The word “jeans” sounds like “Genes,” the French word for Genoa. While Levi Strauss is often given credit for inventing the iconic pants — which it seems, he didn’t — “He was still a genius,” says Cole. That’s because Strauss realized jeans were the perfect thing to make and market in 1849 San Francisco, epicenter of the gold rush. The miners there spent a lot of their time knee-deep in the river, panning for gold nuggets. The woolen pants they were wearing rotted when wet. Denim, a strong cotton weave, did not. It could handle mud, water, and a lot of wear. And it still can. That’s one of the reasons jeans are still around. “You can buy Levis today that are essentially the same design as the 1850s,” says Cole.

You can also buy jeans that are very different. For their book, six years in the making, Cole and Deihl pored over images from every era. In a 1920s magazine they found an ad for denim gardening overalls in pastel colors for women. Bingo! That’s when denim leapt the gender barrier. By the 1950s, movies starring brooding young men showed those men brooding in blue jeans. Marlon Brando in “A Streetcar Named Desire” and James Dean in “Rebel Without a Cause” wore jeans tighter than you’d want to wear if, say, you were panning for gold. But they were perfect for making audiences swoon. Pretty soon if you wanted to look young and sexy, you were wearing jeans, rebelling against the establishment by refusing to wear neatly pressed pants or dresses. The first Gap store opened in 1969, its name a salute to the chasm between the generations. Jeans were the Gap’s specialty. By the disco era, the designer world caught on and gave us jeans by Calvin Klein, Gloria Vanderbilt and Yves Saint Laurent. Now jeans could be fancy.  Those who think deeper about fashion than the rest of us have realized clothes provide three things: utility, status and seduction. Jeans do all three. No wonder they’re still so popular. But of course, they’re not the only fashion item out there. The book takes readers on a beautifully documented romp from the 1850s through today, with stops at every decade, from the

Gibson Girl to Kim Kardashian. Each era introduced some new idea of beauty. In the early 1900s, says Deihl, the perfect figure was the hourglass, with a bust and butt almost cartoonishly pillowy. Garments were lined with padding and ruffles to make slim figures look full. As for legs, who cared? No one saw them.   Screeech! By the 1920s, the female ideal was the exact opposite — flat flappers were dancing in knee-baring skirts. “Suddenly your legs were on display,” says Deihl. “That was kind of traumatic for people.” Maybe not for the guys, but gals had to figure out how to display a body part they’d never bothered with before. And it hasn’t gotten any easier. The ’30s demanded curves again, and World War II gave us broad-shouldered broads as they took on the jobs the menfolk left behind. The ’50s saw a lot of matchy-matchy perfection. And then came the ’60s as almost an echo of the ’20s — another rebellion against the old guard, complete with even shorter skirts (and more leg for ladies to worry about presenting). The hip-hop revolution of the ’80s gave us tracksuits as fashion, major jewelry for men, and our current obsession with sneakers.  Today, says Deihl, fashion is busy mining the past for the next big thing.  Seems like it always has.  Skenazy is a keynote speaker and founder of the book and blog “Free-Range Kids”

Born and bred: The Beastie Boys rocked my world BY ELANA RABINOWITZ


he first rap album ever to hit number one was birthed in Brooklyn. From three Jewish guys — how was that possible? I grew up in the Flatbush section of Brooklyn, way before any hipsters burrowed there. The gritty outer borough, where my suburban Jewish camp friends didn’t want to visit, was where my liberal therapist parents bought a 14-room Victorian home for under $40,000 due to white flight. The only thing I enjoyed more than listening in on my mother’s sessions in our living room, was listening to the infectious music of the Beastie Boys. I was a junior in high school when I first heard their music in the back seat of a tan Oldsmobile. I went with a group of seniors to the Kingsway Movie Theater in Gravesend to see “Top Gun,” when my friend put his white cassette inside the car radio. “Brass Monkey, that funky Monkey... .”

From the first riff, I was drawn in. Within minutes everyone in the car was singing and bopping their heads fiercely to the beat. “Got a castle in Brooklyn, that’s where I dwell. ...” I liked it. I felt a little funky. At 16, I was just becoming me. This group hit the world a few times over, but for us natives their beats resonated differently. Something about their mere existence, their baseball caps and boyish good looks, gave us street cred. Suddenly, our borough was not a mob spoof or big hair, it was three bright boyz from the county of Kings, and I began to feel like a queen, just due to my zip code. We grew up in a different era, where you could go around the corner and get a Jamaican beef patty, then stop at a bodega to buy something to wash it down. No ID, we could still get a 40 or a Bartles & James wine cooler and sip it in a brown paper bag on a stoop in Park Slope with friends, chain smoking

Newports. Getting whiffs of music pouring out of boom boxes passing by, smirking when a Beastie Boys song was playing. I spent endless nights on the D train, going to see my older brother’s band in the city, forcing me to grow up sooner than I should have. My brother was the same age as MCA; both musicians, they hit the Downtown scene when CBGB was synonymous with the LES. They were white. They were Jewish. They were from Brooklyn and cool. Maybe I was. There were a group of us who didn’t quite fit the mold of how the media portrayed young Brooklynites to be. We wore black, but not in a goth way, and though we were white, we had a little color. We were bridge-and-tunnel before there were million-dollar lofts, but we were aight. Like most teenagers of the time, I memorized every lyric to every song the Beastie Boys ever sang. As I got older and their music meant more, I felt like I was growing up along with

them. Adam Yauch redefined himself, and like any good Jewish boy, became a Buddhist. I left New York, first for college, and then to travel the world. Yet, when “No Sleep Till Brooklyn,” came on, no matter where I was, no matter who I was with, I danced and sang like I was home, clenching my fists and raising them high in the air. When I heard that Yauch died, I felt a hole shoot through my body, so deeply that I thought I might not mend. I put on my black hoodie sweatshirt and danced my ass off, like I was 16 again. I danced for the memory of a man I barely knew, for a time that had slipped away all too quickly. Today I conjure up these memories when my confidence wanes. I listen to the Beasties’ songs on my iPod and I am at peace. When I visited the trendy Smorgasbord in Downtown Brooklyn, I found myself at Adam Yauch Park and I smiled. September 3, 2015


LETTERS TO THE EDITOR LETTERS continued from p. 14

(news article, Aug. 27): So, that’s it? Rudin development produces a vest-pocket, tax-deductible-in-perpetuity parklet, and The Villager rolls over and says, “You tore down the only hospital from Hell’s Kitchen to Battery Park and replaced it with a doc-in-the-box, and a gated community for the super-rich, but you gave us a water feature and a couple of verses from Whitman, so that’s O.K.”?  It seems all that’s missing is a flowery inscription: “In honor of those whose lack of political integrity, failure of community planning, mismanagement, and greed made this something-like-apark possible.” Or perhaps tasteful floral plantings spelling out, “Shame!” Paul Scoles

Political profile par excellence To The Editor: Re “A socialist presidential candidate — no, not that one — looks back” (news article, Aug. 27): An excellent, well-written profile of McReynolds: both his career as well as his legacy. In fact, I think I met him in 1984 when he ran for U.S. Senate in New York versus Chuck Schumer. You can almost feel McReynolds’s fierceness and dedication. But Joseph Mulkerin does a great job of bringing out his humanity and caring as well. Jeff Jacobs

Thoughts on Theater Trump To The Editor: Trump, so far, triumphs. I do not believe he will be the Republican candidate. But, his popularity is most curious and interesting. The surge of support is indicative of the souring of the American people’s mind regarding the American candidates. Clinton is hated. Bush is part of a dynasty. Who cares about each of these people? At the recent Republican debate, only Trump said what he thought. There was no self-censorship, despite the absence of concrete solutions offered. I speak with so many of the lower classes who make up our country’s population. The press and its fellow travelers, along with the celebrities, the politicians — or so they think — are members of the ostensible elite. They are a small elite, with attendant fame. Trump is one of the elite, the moneyed elite. Trump’s money gives him membership, since there is no real class system here in the U.S. of A., as there remains in Europe. The elite feel superior to the rest of us, and so hate the traitor Trump, since such betrayal shakes the established order of the permanent government in place. How, they ask, can this man — one of us, rich as us — try to run as a common man? Will the Trump method of thinking infect the other candidates and allow them to break the carapace that hides them, so that they cannot say


September 3, 2015

what is being thought by the unwashed? The left and the right are one and the same, the same rotten bunch, as they delude the unwashed. About time, isn’t it? So, it is not so much about Theater Trump, but us, the audience who applaud him for his courage. Perhaps we shall find the authentic candidate — if not Trump, or it might be Trump.   Bert Zackim

She’s crazy for Skenazy To The Editor: Re “How town, smellin’ in the city; A lovin’ noseful” (Rhymes With Crazy, by Lenore Skenazy): I just started reading the East Villager, given to me by a friend two issues ago. (How the hell did I miss it? I’ve been down here for years.) I’ve been living in New York City from 16 to 62 years old. (How the hell did that happen? I’ll tell you how: When you gotta escape from Ohio, you really gotta go!) As a social worker who has been doing contracting work for the family courts of New York City (a nightmare, I assure you, even when it’s rewarding), I take my damn laughs wherever I can get them, and I find Lenore Skenazy’s columns delightful. I was thinking fondly of my late, sainted older brother — who I lost in May of last year — who left the city. But while you can take the boy out of New York, you could never take New York out of the boy. One of the things he always wanted to know on a regular basis in the summertime was, “So, what’s l’air du temps this week?” And he wanted details! Thank you for the laughs, really. And I only wish I could send your articles to my brother. He needed his laughs too, may he rest in peace. Lia Brigante

Cheered and educated me To The Editor: Re “New York’s nightclub queen was as big as Texas” (Rhymes With Crazy, by Lenore Skenazy): It’s Thursday morning and I’ve just read this wonderful column. Some people are born with a talent for living large and joyously; but if you’re not inhabiting the same years, you never get to share the excitement and the fun. Thanks, Ms. Skenazy, for cheering up a difficult morning and giving me a new association to enjoy each time I pass the Jefferson Market Library. I mentioned Thursday because, if I had known in time for LindaAnn Loschiavo’s presentation, I certainly would have been there — though I probably would have been part of the crowd extending out the door.  Jeannie Segall

Time to snip those pits To The Editor: Re: “Crusty pit bull victims hurt and howling

mad” (news article, Aug. 20): Roberta Bayley, whose dog died after allegedly being attacked by a pit bull, suggests that it may take a pit bull eating a celebrity baby for the city to do something to prevent more attacks by unrestrained dogs. But pit bulls and other dogs have attacked and killed babies — and each one was a celebrity to his or her family. The city is being pressured to increase “save rates” at its animal shelters at any cost, making it much more likely that aggressive and dangerous dogs will remain on the streets and even be released into the community. This pressure also results in animals being handed over to anyone who will take them, including people who are unable to properly care for them. Many shelters are concentrating solely on statistics and throwing out vital safeguards in attempts to avoid euthanasia. Irresponsible “life at any cost” policies are a formula for more suffering, not saving lives. The humane way to reduce the need for euthanasia, as well as the incidence of dog bites in the city, is to focus on spaying and neutering — which prevents more animals from being born only to end up homeless, and can reduce dogs’ aggression, making them less likely to attack. We must work together to push for mandatory spay/neuter laws, lobby to outlaw pet shops and puppy mills, and make sure that every animal in the community is sterilized and being humanely cared for. Visit to learn more.    Teresa Chagrin Chagrin is an animal care and control specialist, People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA)

Walk on the wild side To The Editor: It is Friday, 8:23 p.m, and I just got off the bus at Astor Place. I try to use the sidewalk on the west side of Cooper Square, when construction is not blocking my crossing to E. Fifth St. It is the only decent sidewalk to get me to my senior housing and being a senior, alas, I walk less securely than I used to. Today, I’m walking there when a noiseless electrical Vespa-style scooter zips past me at full speed. Outside the deli on E. Fourth St. and Second Ave. I’ve counted a dozen or more of them. They need no registration, no permit of any kind, and can freely ride on the sidewalks, and I feel very menaced by them. Add them to the wild bicyclists, roller skaters, skateboards that also now come motorized, the gizmos people stand up on — and last but not least, motorized wheelchairs that go faster and faster — never mind the speeding cars and cars ignoring poorly placed traffic lights — I now say a prayer every time I leave the house. Marianne Landre Goldscheider E-mail letters, not longer than 250 words in length, to or fax to 212-229-2790 or mail to The Villager, Letters to the Editor, 1 Metrotech North, 10th floor, Brooklyn, NY, NY 11201. Please include phone number for confirmation purposes. The Villager reserves the right to edit letters for space, grammar, clarity and libel. Anonymous letters will not be published.

Fall Back: Annual Autumn Festivals


Somewhere that’s green: Communal Spaces sets its short play fest in Manhattan and Brooklyn community gardens.



ike fall, that fleeting sweet spot between summer ’s messy swelter and winter ’s bone-chilling cold, we’re keeping this introduction brief — all the better to get right down to the business of presenting our totally subjective picks from the robust harvest of fall festivals in and around Manhattan. It begins!


Green gathering places are an integral part of the show (and sometimes get cast as central

acters), when Communal Spaces presents short plays in Manhattan and Brooklyn community gardens. The Alphabet City venue gets title billing, in Sarah Bernstein’s “Catfight at the Oasis,” which has long-suffering but dedicated garden administer Joanne tasked with brokering peace between the pro-cat lobby and bird fanciers who want to ban feline strays from Green Oasis Community Garden. Angela Santillo makes her fifth consecutive contribution to Communal Spaces with “Welcome to The Fall,” in which a contemporary tour guide experiences fallout from a smokejumper ’s 1973 crash landing on property occupied by a meteor strike survivor. The plays run at 2:30 & 3:30 p.m., respectively, in Green Oasis


Limited stage space serves as inspiration for DANCE NOW artists.

Garden (E. Eighth St. btw. Aves. C & D). Charly Evon Simpson’s “An Apple Today” finds two sisters meeting at Warren St. Marks Garden (619 Warren St. in Park Slope, Brooklyn) to speak in confidence. When they encounter a former classmate, memories of playground romances and acts of emotional agression come flooding back. You’re already there for the 5 p.m. “Apple,” so it’s job accomplished when Dominic Finocchiaro’s “enter a garden” beings at 6. “Leaves turn from green to red to brown and fall to the ground. Life happens.” That’s all the playwright is divulging about the plot. Free. All plays run Sept. 12–27, Sat. & Sun. For more info, as well as a description of what’s on the boards

(or brick pathways) in Bed-Stuy’s Classon Ful-Gate Community Garden and La Perla Garden (76 105th St. in Manhattan), visit


From its first year in 1995, those who’ve created content for DANCE NOW have been both constrained and inspired by the festival’s unconventional venues — which included swimming pools, firehouses, and galleries — until landing on its feet for good at Joe’s Pub, where the “less is more” mantra came with a mandate for FESTIVALS, continued on p.18 September 3, 2015


No drama involved in this guide to FESTIVALS, continued from p. 17


Feast on a Mediterranean diet of theater and dance, Sept. 8-13 at Between the Seas. Pictured: “Per…Inciso” grooves to Italian pop songs.

“brevity, clarity and effect.” The 2015 edition will feature contributions from 50 New York-based choreographers who’ve presented over the past 20 years. Some, such as David Parker and Jeffrey Kazin will revive works (“Old Fashion Wedding,” a duet from 2009), while others will reimagine them (Heidi Latsky and Lawrence Goldhuber ’s “Head Duet”). Established artists like Aszure Barton, Doug Elkins, and Ellis Wood (once up-and-comers) will be joined by emerging choreographers including Jordan Isadore, Cori Marquis, and Donnell Oakley. At 7 p.m. Wed. Sept. 9–Sat. Sept. 12 at Joe’s Pub (425 Lafayette St. btw. E. Fourth St. & Astor Place). Tickets: $20 in advance, $25 at the door. Encore Performance of 12 “producer’s picks” Thurs. Sept 24. ($25 advance, $30 at the door). To order: 212-967-7555 or Also visit


Veterans of the 1960s Greenwich Village scene share the bill with young groups from today’s New York City, at folk promoter Eli Smith’s fifth annual forward-looking throwback to the time when “the likes of Woody Guthrie and Pete Seeger came together on Sunday afternoons to play music and socialize in the park.” From a stage in the southeast portion of the park, by the Garibaldi statue, the legendary John Cohen (of the New Lost City Ramblers) will appear with old time string band The Down Hill Strugglers. Also booked for the afternoon: Balkan and gospel-influenced singer and songwriter Feral Foster; country blues guitar and fiddle duo Hoodoo Honey Drippers; Jalopy Theatre house jug band The Whisky Spitters; and square dance caller Alex Cramer, who’ll guide you in matters of partner-spinning and do-si-doing. Free. Sun. Sept. 13, 1–5 p.m. in Washington Square Park. Visit


The third annual Chelsea Film Festival, Oct. 15-18, focuses on women in film and media.


September 3, 2015

Day in and day out, they say a balanced Mediterranean diet is the best thing for you — but there’s

nothing wrong with binging once a year, at least when it comes to that region’s culture. The fifth annual Between the Seas festival returns to The Wild Project with six days and nights of theater, dance, and performance art. From Catalonia, “Dreams of the Mediterranean” is an atmospheric storytelling performance in which illustrator Borja González speed paints, with sand, on a light table. Ephemeral images are projected on a giant screen, as large-scale puppets and the live music of pianist Roc Sala swirl around him. In the New York premiere of “A Palo Seco,” the contemplative words and fiery movement of Rebeca Tomas express her inner dialogue about motherhood and the Spanish art of flamenco. Lebanese playwright Issam Mahfouz’s “The Dictator” gets a new English translation and minimalist staging. The 1969 absurdist exploration of tyranny (eerily applicable to our 2016 presidential race) concerns a “mentally disturbed individual under the illusion that he is humanity’s long-awaited savior.” A creative team from France and Catalonia has built “Hearts Beating Like Drums” around the stories of women impacted by living through war. A series of low- or no-cost discussions and performances on the first day address the experiences of Mediterranean refugees and migrants. Sept. 8–13 at The Wild Project (195 E. Third St. btw. Aves. A & B). For tickets (most shows $20, $15 with student/senior ID), call 212352-3101 or Full schedule at


This edition of CMA’s Cultural Festival series puts the spotlight on Nigeria, with events throughout the museum — including performances from Brooklyn Music School’s World Percussion Department, the chance to design and animate your own Ibibo Puppet in the Media Lab, and workshops teaching techniques to make Yoruba masks, Adire cloth fabric designs and a traditional Nigerian FESTIVALS, continued on p.19

fall comedy, dance, theater & more FESTIVALS, continued from p. 18

board game. Other fall Cultural Festivals are Caribbean (Oct. 25), Mexican (Day of the Dead theme, Nov. 1), Indigenous People (Nov. 15) and Native American (Nov. 22). Sun., Sept. 20. All Cultural Festivals take place 10 a.m.–5 p.m. at the Children’s Museum of the Arts (103 Charlton St. btw. Hudson & Greenwich Sts.). Free, with general admission (infants free, $12 for ages 1–65, senior admission is pay-asyou-wish). Call 212-274-0986 or visit


It was named for the place where every screening happens, and where its founders live — but the shorts, documentaries and features chosen for the Chelsea Film Festival have always had an international flavor. This year ’s edition, the third, retains that programming penchant while dedicating itself to the theme of women in film and media. A day of panel discussions (Oct. 17, 10:30 a.m.–5:30 p.m.) will focus on emerging international markets, On Demand distribution, and the value of financing films made by women. Before the festival, free panels (topics to be announced) take place at the W. 14th St. Apple Store on Sept. 30, Oct. 7 and Oct. 14. Establishing a presence far past its four days in October, CFF will be launching a new monthly series at Bow Tie Cinemas Chelsea (23rd St. & Eighth Ave.) — to debut on Nov. 9 with a 7 p.m. screening of the 2015 Grand Prix Winner. Future installments will present an indie feature that has appeared in the festival’s programming, followed by cast/filmmaker Q&A and a networking reception. Oct. 15–18 at the SVA Theatre (333 W. 23rd St. btw. Eighth & Ninth Aves.) and other Chelsea locations. Visit, where the roster of films will be announced in midSept.


Some people never go below 14th St., while others refuse to


An immigrant family relocates to California, in the musical memoir “Escaping Queens” (part of Theater for the New City’s Dream Up Festival).

venture above it. For the first time in its six-year history, Theater for the New City’s Dream Up Festival ministers to both stubborn groups, while encouraging them to broaden their horizons. Although most of the action is staged in TNC’s sprawling East Village home, some of it takes place at a Hell’s Kitchen venue equally adept at multitasking (the Producers’ Club Theaters and Bar). So there’s no excuse not to catch one of Dream Up’s 27 musical, drama, improv, dance or aerial performances (they’ve also got a “Scratch Night” series of works in development). Comedy is not pretty, Steve Martin told us with his 1979 album title, hinting at the ugly reality that life as a stand-up comic is largely about treading water once you leave that little island with the mic, the laughs, and the applause. “The Boom” takes place in a shabby condo owned by the management of Pittsburgh’s Steel City Funny Factory. Three comics on the bill are thrown together: a past-his-prime veteran, his second banana pal, and a new guy whose viral video appeal both eludes and confuses the old guard. This dynamic of foxhole friendship and cutthroat competitiveness is something the cast and creators of “Boom” know intimately (though they’ve learned to laugh about it). Club circuit comic, TV pundit and ghostwriter Vinnie Nardiell makes his debut as a playwright, FESTIVALS, continued on p.20


You’re about to get lucky. Style, seduction and skin are on display at the New York Burlesque Festival.


Des Bishop’s “Made in China” charts his quest to learn the language for a Chinese stand-up audience. Part of the 1st Irish Theatre Festival. September 3, 2015


Fall festivals you won’t want to leaf leave seem also figure into Hassem Khemiri’s immigrant and tolerance-themed “Invasion!,” which has its ensemble of four playing multiple characters. Teenagers Yousef and Arvind are the main focus, as they navigate New York’s hip-hop culture while challenging stereotypes. An Italian/Puerto Rican immigrant family discovers you can’t go home again, after “Escaping Queens” and settling in California. The musical memoir of Joe Ortiz — a melting pot of Latin beats, Sicilian ballads, bluesy riffs, jazz and 1950s radio hits — makes its New York debut after a well-received run at Cabrillo Stage in Aptos, California. The Dream Up festival plays through Sept. 20 (but not every show runs until then). Mon-Fri, 6:30 & 9:30 p.m. and Sat./Sun. at 2, 5, & 8 p.m. At Theater for the New City (155 First Ave. btw. 9th & 10th Sts.) and the Producers’ Club (358 W. 44th St. btw. 8th & 9th Aves.). For tickets ($12, $15, $18, $20), visit or call 212-686-4444.


The Black Rock Coalition celebrates its 30th year, with daily events in September.

FESTIVALS, continued from p. 19

with Amoralists Theater Co. member Mark Riccadonna directing for the first time. Working comics Dan Stern, DJ Hazard and Richie Byrne play the quick-thinking, hair-trigger trio. Dream Up mines matters of home, family, assimilation and reinvention in a multitude of productions, including Rachel Graf Evans’ drama “Inch by Inch,”

which gives Bridget a house and a garden — and the chance to dig up old questions about identity — when her mother ’s death requires a hasty return to her old childhood home. Andrea Fulton’s “Roof-Top Joy” is a musical comedy/drama concerning two new tenants of an upscale Brooklyn high-rise who discover what’s below the thin veneer of wealth and power that lurks behind every door. People who aren’t what they

You may have the right to go topless in Times Square, but there’s a good chance those painted ladies would land in the hoosegow if their bare-breasted busking was accompanied by the sort of bumping, grinding, twirling tassels and unabashed sexuality on display at the New York Burlesque Festival. Those who like their skin with a side of seduction are set to get lucky, when the fest’s 13th edition celebrates “glitter and glamour in Gotham with over 100 performers from around the Globe!” Brooklyn is the location for a teaser and premiere party on Thurs./Fri., with a “Saturday Spectacular” at B.B. King Blues

Club (W. 42nd St.), a free Sun. 2–7 p.m. showcase/bazaar at The Tippler (in Chelsea Market), and The Golden Pastie Awards at The Highline Ballroom (W. 16th St.). Some featured talent you’ll be able to finally put a face (or other body parts) to the name: Bunny Buxom & Schaffer the Darklord, Sizzle Dizzle, Dr. Lucky, Francine “The Lucid Dream,” Tigger, Julie Atlas Muz, Dirty Martini, Matt Knife, Scotty the Blue Bunny, Gal Friday, Kitten LaRue, and Cherie Nut. Sept. 24–27. Tickets are sold through each venue, with a four-day VIP pass ($125.19) available at


Forget everything you know about entertainment that flows from the Irish people’s supposed penchant for pain and suffering, high drama, and excessive drink. A river of tears most certainly runs through Origin Theatre Company’s 1st Irish, but the salty stream is from excessive laughter — because comedy is the theme for this eighth edition of the city’s only theater festival dedicated to Irish playwrights. Dublin’s New Play Company returns for the fourth time, with Donald O’Kelly’s “Fishamble,” a comedic road trip-cumdark thriller that finds an ex-con and a nun being chased across Ireland, as they search for a roll of film. Comedian Des Bishop, who’s made a name (and a niche) for himself by creating solo performances based on his immersive cultural experiences, brings “Made in China” to 1st Irish, after its March 2015 limited run at The FESTIVALS, continued on p.21


Katz Moving has a stellar reputation for excellence in the moving industry.

Check out our 5 Star

Customer Reviews

Jewelry, Watches, & Tchotchkes REPAIR

Please mention “Community Media” when placing your move. Katz Moving will donate 5% of your move to The Ali Forney Center


47-47 Austell Pl., Long Island City, NY 11101 • NYSDOT #T-38598 • USDOT #2280679 Terms and conditions apply, can't be applied with any other offer, offer expires on 3/31/2015. Must mention "community media" when calling.


September 3, 2015

43 Aveneue A New York, NY 10009

Mention this ad & Recieve

20% Off 212.505.9400

Spring forward to fall festivals FESTIVALS, continued from p. 20

Barrow Street Theatre. The solo show recalls his travels to China on a quest to learn Mandarin, in order to perform stand-up for Chinese audiences. The lessons must have stuck: Bishop has relocated to his native Flushing, in order to launch a Chinese-centric comedy club called “The Humor Section,” at Huang Cheng Gen Tea House (135-14 Northern Blvd.). Opening weekend is Sept. 26 & 27. See for more info. Limerick’s Bottom Dog Theatre brings “Language UnBecoming a Lady” to Chelsea’s the cell (a frequent presenter of Irish subject matter). The “Lady” is Liam O’Brien, who plays an aging drag queen hunkered down in her dressing room, recalling pivotal moments of her life. Equal parts tart and sweet, Eugene Pack’s “Celebrity Autobiography” series at The Triad (which features celebrities reading passages from often howlingly bad celeb-written bios) goes all-Irish for one night only. The precise tome is under wraps — but announced readers include Michael Urie (“Buyer and Cellar”) and Tate Donovan (“24”) Ensconced at Union Square’s DR2 while his W. 22nd St. Irish Repertory Theatre undergoes a game-changing renovation, director Ciaran O’Reilly will premiere a 1st Irish entry just two weeks after the having helmed IRT’s long run (closing Sept. 5) of “The Weir,” a bone-chilling collection of one-upmanship ghost stories told by a country pub crowd. “The Quare Land” is a comedy by John McManus, about a prickly Irish farmer who — while taking his first bath in four years — is interrupted by a golf course developer intent on getting a contract signed. The 1st Irish Theatre Festival runs through Oct. 4. For tickets and schedule, visit


To celebrate its 30th year, the volunteer-powered Black Rock Coalition is presenting 30 concerts during the 30 days of September, in recognition of how “Black musicians have a central, vital role to play in shaping edgy, righteous, driving rock.” Festival co-founder and guitarist Vernon Reid (of Living Colour), Tamar-kali and Pillow Theory are among the artists


Iranian artist Ali Moini makes tension tangible, in his Crossing the Line Festival performance.

on the roster, along with listening sessions, retrospectives, showcases and a BAMCafé (Sept. 18–19) concert from the BRC Orchestra, playing the Jimi Hendrix “Band of Gypsys” album. See for more info. The New York Comedy Festival (Nov. 10–15) schedule includes Billy Crystal conversing with David Steinberg, and new “Daily Show” host Trevor Noah (both at Town Hall). In a festival replete with marquee names (Bill Maher, Margaret Cho, John Leguizamo), the must-see is Kathy Griffin, in a Nov. 12 Carnegie Hall gig that will hopefully have her conducting an acerbic postmortem on her time in the main “Fashion Police” chair. Purchase tickets and access the full schedule at nycomedyfestival. com. The 10 shows presented by The New York Gypsy Festival (Sept. 18–Oct. 4) include Georgian folk ensemble Zedashe, NYC’s Underground Horns and Slavic Soul Party, and the NYC debut of French/ North African brass orchestra Fanfarai. Ticket prices and venues vary. Visit Thespis, a competition-structured festival that brings new work to the stage, takes place through Sept. at Hudson Guild Theater (411 W. 26th St.). Playing Sept. 14, 16 and 19, “Brush Strokes” is a musical that finds aging art lovers Virginia and Eric drawn together, but wary of their controversial pasts. See for tickets and the full schedule of shows. In collaboration with found-

er/curator Peter Michael Marino (whose “Late With Lance” just played the Edinburgh Festival Fringe), The Peoples Improv Theater brings back their loopy and eccentric (often to the point of insane) SOLOCOM Festival of one-person storytelling, music, stand-up, improv and cabaret performances — Nov. 20–22 at their E. 24th St. home base, and the newly-opened PIT Loft on W. 29th St. The shows (dozens of them) range from 15 to 60 minutes. Get info at solocom. The NYC nonprofit service and advocacy organization Community Access holds its 11th Annual Mental Health Film Festival at Village East Cinema (Second Ave. & 12th St.) on Sept. 26. The features and shorts, all addressing life with mental illness, include the US premiere of “No Letting Go,” about a family whose middle child is diagnosed as bipolar.

Filmmakers and cast members for the features will be in attendance for an audience Q&A. Visit for the full schedule, and communityaccess. org for info on the event sponsor. The French Institute Alliance Française cultural and language center ’s Crossing the Line Festival showcases the work of interdisciplinary artists from around the world, in a variety of premiere venues and public spaces. Iranian artist Ali Moini’s “Lives” (Sept. 29 & 30 at NY Live Arts on W. 19 St.) is a dance of tension between his fictional, political, mythical and real selves — while NY-based Elana Langer ’s “WhatILiveBy” is a free, interactive happening that will pop up at festival events and kiosks throughout the city, all in the service of launching her fantastic new “product-less” brand. Visit for the full schedule of performances (Sept. 10–Oct. 4) and venues.

September 3, 2015


To Advertise Call: 646-452-2490 Deadline – 12 noon Wednesday


September 3, 2015

To Advertise Call: 646-452-2490 Deadline – 12 noon Wednesday

September 3, 2015


To Advertise Call: 646-452-2490 Deadline – 12 noon Wednesday

Staying in the loop has never been easier! CALL 646-452-2475 TO SUBSCRIBE


September 3, 2015

September 3, 2015


‘The world’s greatest outdoor art show’ is still doing great FLASHBACK BY YANNIC RACK


his Labor Day weekend, the Washington Square Outdoor Art Exhibit will once again take over the sidewalks around University Place, from E. 13th St. south to W. Third St. Now in its 85th year, the twice-yearly street fair has been around slightly longer than this newspaper. It was originally put on two years before The Villager published its first edition in 1933. The exhibition got its start when Jackson Pollock, in desperate need of funds to pay the rent on his Greenwich Village studio, where he lived and worked, propped up some of his paintings on a sidewalk near Washington Square Park. According to the exhibition’s Web site, fellow Village artist Willem de Kooning, in similar financial straits, soon joined him. A few decades later the show was well established, and in the fall of 1960 it featured on the front page of The Villager for attracting a record number of artists scheduled to show off their fine art, photography, sculptures and other crafts. “The 58th Washington Square Outdoor Art Exhibit will get underway tomorrow afternoon with a record number of artists displaying an unquestionably record number of oils and watercolors,” the Sept. 1, 1960, article read. “More than 750 artists have registered their work, surpassing the nearly 750 who entered the world’s greatest outdoor art show for its spring session this year.” The show ran for three weeks and was expected to draw upward of 150,000 visitors from the metro area, “plus many nearby and far-away states.” This summer, the exhibition will be on two successive weekends. But the number of artists has dropped significantly compared to half a century ago. Over Labor Day weekend, around 110 exhibitors are scheduled to show their art, while 85 will fill the sidewalks on Sept. 12 and 13, according to John DiBiase, a longtime exhibitor and the fair’s new executive director. “There’ll probably be a few more,” he told The Villager this Monday, adding they were still processing some applications. Back in 1960, another week had to be added onto

The Villager’s front-page illustration from Sept. 8, 1960, showing a scene from the Washington Square Outdoor Art Exhibit.

the schedule. The reason was not the high demand, however. Although the Washington Square area was choked by a throng of visitors on its opening weekend, the edge of Hurricane Donna soon brought a steady stream of rain to the city. “It is doubtful that this world-renowned art show has ever had such horrible weather, seven days of rain, during its illustrious history,” The Villager reported on Sept. 22, 1960. This weekend’s forecast is for sunny skies and temperatures just below 90 degrees, so nothing should get in the way of a successful exhibition, albeit on a smaller scale than in times gone by. “If the weather is good,” DiBiase said,” there are thousands of people that come by in the three days.”




September 3, 2015

Wonton rent hike, taxes force out Charlie Mom CHARLIE continued from p. 1

1982. Its odd “L”-shaped configuration pleasantly muffled the avenue’s traffic hum and also distanced its customers from its own fast-paced reception desk, where efficient Chinese women patiently answered phones, packed take-out orders and dispatched bike messengers. A sharp right turn into Charlie Mom’s sunny brick-walled enclosure facing W. 11th St. led patrons to an old-school dining experience that’s become a rarity: no music, no eye-popping monitors, no rushing. Whether it was a cast party for 20, a jolly family celebration or a private tête-à-tête, waiters served with great dispatch and neither the kitchen nor the restroom was an embarrassment. So why did they close? Was it the competition across the street, from newly opened Shu Han Ju, at 465 Sixth Ave. “No, Shu serves spicy Szechuan-style, oily food, very different from our chef,” explained David, a former manager. In a hushed tone, he added, “Rent going too, too high!” But Conrad Bradford, an associate

Charlie Mom, at Sixth Ave. and W. 11th St., closed last Wednesday after 33 years at the location.

broker at Miron Properties, who has leased commercial space in the Village and Midtown to many restaurateurs, had the advantage of an insid-

Punk with bad pit is dead NATAS continued from p. 6

fogy, but that’s how I feel.” As for Trachtenberg, in addition to feeling furious about what happened to Bayley’s dog, he said he’s tired of the crusties hunkering down in front of their building, which they like to do since it’s right next to a 2 Bros. $1 pizzeria. “This is a super-sad ending to a super-sad story, but it is an ending,” he said. “There are no winners here or really anything to learn from this jackass’s death. Maybe there’s some closure here, but I’m not even sure about that.” There are three types of crusties, in his experience: locals, travelers and ones who just come in from Jersey or the suburbs for the summer and wind up spiraling down while “living in the dirt.” “These kids don’t take care of themselves and really don’t have the ability to take care of a dog,” he said. “They s--- and piss on our building’s front door. They are very agro ‘spanging’ for cash. They are loud and don’t care who they disturb. Trust me, all of this will come out when a crusty kid’s dog attacks a child. It’s just a matter of time. I’ve seen many close calls.” In related news, concerns are growing about a homeless encampment

around P.S. 63 and McKinley Playground, on E. Third St. between First Ave. and Avenue A. Garrett Rosso, the manager of the Tompkins Square Park dog run, said “a whole mélange of homeless kids” are camping out there, as well as a family that sleeps on a mattress, plus travelers during the summer. “Debris and human excrement surround the park’s vegetation at McKinley Playground and line the steps of P.S. 63 elementary school,” he said. “Meanwhile, three off-leash pit bulls rummage around the playground while their owners sleep in the park. It was so bad last year that the school had to cancel fire drills because of the number of campers and debris outside the school. Now the campers have moved into the park playground. “The school’s playground is jointly operated with the Parks Department,” Rosso noted. “Who is empowered to clean this park, as well as the two elongated sidewalk bridges in front and behind the school? The sidewalk bridges for school construction have been filled with campers, off-leash dogs and debris for the past year, which is hazardous to pedestrians and students.” The school grounds and park need to be cleaned, not periodically, but every single day, he stressed.

er’s view. Three years ago, when he showed Han a vented space in the East Village that was available at a below-market rate, Bradford learned that Charlie Mom’s current lease obligated the owner to pay 65 percent of the real estate tax increase. In a 12-month period, that tax had jumped from $80,000 a year to $110,000. “It’s a combination of factors here,” observed Bradford. “Mr. Han is now 87 years old; he has a staff of 23, many of whom wish to retire; real estate taxes went sky-high; and whenever a lease ends, many merchants will find the new rent increases insupportable. “What’s crushing entrepreneurs and small businesses in Manhattan,” he added, “is the burden of a serious rent, along with the double whammy of high, unpredictable taxes. The only safe harbor is to buy a building or settle into a commercial condo.” Interior decorator Martin Hutner, who moved to Greenwich Village in 1969 and recalls partying with Marlon Brando at Trude Heller’s famed club, at Sixth Ave. and Ninth St., agrees. His suppertime standby, Gene’s Restaurant, at 73 W. 11th St., is next door to Charlie Mom and has been serving “Continental Cuisine of Distinction since 1919” — thanks to a long-ago purchase of their premises. Marilyn Dorato, the former Greenwich Village Block Associations president — whose in-laws enjoyed running the classic West Village hangout Fedora’s for several decades, and who also owned their stately townhouse at 239 W. Fourth St. — was shocked to hear about Charlie Mom’s demise. “I’m so sad,” she said. “We ordered from there several times a month and I am going to miss their Peking duck.” Leslie and David Burgin, members

of the W. Ninth St. Block Association, who moved to the Village in 1967 and were die-hard Charlie Mom fans, also registered their dismay. “For me, they were an institution,” Leslie said. “The staff treated everyone well, the tables were nicely spaced, and it wasn’t so dim that older people cannot read the menu. We patronize many neighborhood places to enable them to stay in business. Then they vanish anyway. What can we do?” Longtime Village resident and activist Gloria Gilbert, noting that one of Charlie Mom’s pluses was that they never nuked the vegetables, emphasized that the Village is losing the affordable, ethnically diverse eateries that used to be a big attraction. “If only we could do something to stop one more bank, nail salon or CVS from eating up this neighborhood,” she lamented. Ironically, lower Sixth Ave. was once darkened by an elevated railway that significantly reduced real estate values — even long after it was demolished, leaving many three-story 19th-century houses intact, including the Charlie Mom’s address. In 1892, two disgruntled landlords fought back. Maria and Henry Hoops had improved a Sixth Ave. property near St. Joseph’s Church, only to see their investment decline in value, thanks to the steam, smoke, cinders and vibrations from the overhead trains. So they sued the Metropolitan Elevated Railway Company, charging it for lost real estate income, as well as the loss of the peaceful enjoyment of their multistory dwelling, hidden beneath the sunless tracks and unrentable at prime market rates. Now if only we could get that dirty old El back. September 3, 2015




QUALITY HEALTH INSURANCE THE HIGHEST-RATED Qualified Health Plans and Medicaid plan in NYC and LI** *

New Yorkers know quality. That’s why more than one million New Yorkers choose Healthfirst for top-rated health plans in NYC and Long Island. Our plans offer the coverage and benefits you deserve, whatever your age or income. Let us help you find a plan that’s right for you.


THE TOP-RATED Medicare Advantage † HMO Plan in NYC

Call 1-844-HF-FOR-NY

Plans are offered by affiliates of Healthfirst, Inc. *2015 Quality Rating by NY State of Health, the official health plan marketplace. **Based on indicators chosen by the New York State Department of Health and published in its 2014 publication A Consumer’s Guide to Medicaid Managed Care in NYC and on Long Island. † 4-star rating is for the 2015 plan year that runs from 1/1/15 through 12/31/15. Medicare evaluates plans based on a 5-star rating system. Star Ratings are calculated each year and may change from one year to the next. ©2015 HF Management Services, LLC. NYCOR001782 H3359_MKT15_111 Accepted 07222015 INA15_77(a)


September 3, 2015

Profile for Schneps Media