Ashwin 4, 1421 Zilqad 23, 1435 Regd No DA 6238 Vol 2, No 168
FRIDAY, SEPTEMBER 19, 2014 | www.dhakatribune.com | SECOND EDITION
WEEKEND
7 | LONG FORM RMG INDUSTRY OF BANGLADESH: PAST, PRESENT AND FUTURE
ONE FOR SORROW, TWO FOR JOY
20 pages plus 24-page weekend supplement | Price: Tk12
11 | OP-ED
B1 | BUSINESS
FACING IT TOGETHER
TAX FAIR DRAWS HUGE CROWD IGNORING STRIKE
Blame game after Sayedee verdict Now all top state officials admit flaws in appointing prosecutors, investigators
PM: Verdict spoils Sayedee’s face
kar Ali Manik n Julfi with Udisa Islam
Reza Chowdhury and n Kamran Emran Hossain Shaikh
As justice seekers in every corner of the society are now blaming the prosecution and the probe agency for their incompetency in dealing with the historic cases at the war crimes tribunal, none of the designated high officials of the government are ready to shoulder the responsibility. Those conducting the cases in the two tribunals were supposed to be praised by people for dealing with the historic war crimes cases. But many of them came under spotlight negatively for their incompetency and suspicious role. Against these criticisms, the attorney general, the former law minster and the former junior law minister, while defending themselves, are now blaming each other for recruiting incompetent people and lack of supervision. Frustration and grievances mounted among people in the last 48 hours after senior Jamaat-e-Islami leader Delawar Hossain Sayedee’s death penalty was commuted to imprisonment until death at the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court on Wednesday. They are raising questions on the poor performance of investigators and prosecutors, incompetency, commitment to get appointment for the jobs and the appointment process. There is also apprehension of money making through secret deals with the defence side. Open criticisms surfaced occasionally in the last four years over the performance of some prosecutors and grouping among them.
Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina yesterday told parliament that Jamaat-e-Islami leader Delawar Hossain Sayedee’s reputation as an Islamic preacher would exist no more following the Supreme Court’s final verdict. Speaking at the end of the third session, the Leader of the House said Sayedee’s capital punishment, instead of imprisonment until death, would have made people happier. She also said the constitution amendment act would protect the judiciary more, trashing the allegations that the government had made the judiciary accountable to the legislature for political reasons. In her around 45-minute speech, the premier for the first time blamed the main opposition Jatiya Party. Opposition Leader Rawshan Ershad had to endure some criticisms made against her husband, JaPa chief HM Ershad’s rule. “Yesterday [Wednesday], a judgement was pronounced. What happened was not desirable to anyone. People would have been happy if [the Appellate Division] upheld the death sentence [of Sayedee],” Hasina said, mentioning that a free and independent judiciary, not her government, had given the verdict. “We have nothing to say,” she said. “Sayedee was known as a religious preacher. But this verdict will portray him as a violator of women, a killer, a looter and a war criminal.” People now know what a “heinous”
Mahbubey Alam
Shafique Ahmed
Qamrul Islam
If you knew what sort of prosecutors were appointed it would give you the creeps
You better ask Qamrul. He brought most of the prosecutors. He looked into the political interest
None of the prosecutors was appointed without his [Shafique] recommendations
But after Wednesday’s verdict, criticisms, questions and suspicions about the role of prosecutors and investigators have been discussed widely. Not only the justice seekers, the attorney general – country’s top law officer, and the law minister are also talking openly to the mass media over these issues. After the verdict, Attorney General Mahbubey Alam at a talk show with a private television channel said: “If you come to know what type of people
have been appointed as prosecutors it will give you the creeps.” He said a lawyer who did not have any experience in dealing criminal cases was also appointed as prosecutor. Mahbubey also cited an example by strongly criticising performance of the investigators. When asked how such unqualified and incompetent people were appointed and who were responsible for recruiting them, he denied his responsibility saying that he was not involved
with the recruitment process. He, however, gave a hint that former law minster Barrister Shafique Ahmed had been behind the controversial appointments. Recently, the Appellate Division bench dealing with the war crimes appeal cases blasted the attorney general for not having a helping hand from the tribunal during a hearing. A judge commented: “There is no court in Bangladesh where so much money is spent. Why then is your
Muhith: Political hiring in govt bank boards backfired n Asif Showkat Kallol Finance Minister AMA Muhith yesterday admitted that political appointments in the boards was one of the reasons behind the poor performance of the state-owned banks. Emerging from meetings of the cabinet committees on economic affairs and public purchase, he told reporters: “When we came to power last time [in 2009], we made some political appointments in the state-owned
Investigators have found that the directors of Sonali Bank were largely responsible for Hall-Mark loan scam banks. We thought they would consider the banks as their own institutions. But that decision has backfired.” He also said: “We have already appointed experienced banking professionals in the boards of the state-owned banks instead of appointing people on political considerations.”
On Wednesday, the government appointed former Krishi Bank chairman Sirajuddin Ahmed Chowdhury as the chairman of state-owned Janata Bank. There is an allegation that when he was the CEO of state-owned Sonali Bank, Sirajuddin went to visit a Sonali Bank-financed project by the entrepreneur’s helicopter. Yesterday, when a reporter reminded the finance minister of that, he said he knew about the matter and it was a “misconduct.” Muhith’s remark comes on the back of a heated exchange of words between him and Professor Abul Barkat, the immediate past chairman of Janata Bank. The standoff was ignited after the government had suspended the bank’s CSR activities, saying some of its funds were in question. Barkat, who was at the helm of the bank for two consecutive terms, alleged that Muhith had sought money from the bank’s CSR fund for a boat race in his home constituency. As his demand was not entertained, he stopped the bank’s CSR activities, Barkat alleged. But Muhith said the funds should be put into “better” use and Barkat could not stay the bank’s chairman forever. PAGE 2 COLUMN 1
INSIDE
8 | World
Egypt has moved to close down one of the last bastions of Muslim Brotherhood dissent with sweeping new rules to curtail violent protest at Al Azhar University, among the world’s most venerable centres of Islamic learning.
3 | News
The International Crimes Tribunal 1 has kept another case, six cases in the last six months, awaiting for verdict after hearing arguments in the war crimes case against Jamaat-e-Islami leader ATM Azharul Islam.
4 | News
The passage of the 16th constitutional amendment bill was briefly thrown into confusion when parliament chamber’s sound system noisily malfunctioned, apparently embarrassing the speaker and Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina.
15 | Sport
China’s two-time Grand Slam-winner Li Na is poised to retire, state media reported Thursday, in a move which would bring down the curtains on Asia’s most successful tennis career.
5 | News
The Social Welfare Ministry is seeking permission from the prime minister’s office to use mobile courts against beggars in nine selected areas of the capital frequented by foreigners.
6 | Nation
Even after 15 years, Khulna Textile Palli project continues to struggle against legal cases filed against it. Consequently, a project that could have ensured jobs for 28,000 people has fallen under great uncertainty as a direct result of these unresolved cases.
PAGE 2 COLUMN 1
person Sayedee was during the war, she said. The Awami League chief also slammed Jamaat for calling a shutdown to protest the verdict. “Is Jamaat unhappy? Possibly they would be happy if the capital punishment order was upheld. What is the justification of calling hartals? Why will people support a hartal if it is called in favour of a war criminal?” The premier said it was a hartal against the judgement of the judiciary. “The judiciary will look into it.” Hasina thanked JaPa for its support in passing the constitution amendment bill. She said the previous three-member Supreme Judicial Council headed by the chief justice could not protect the judiciary. “The fate of the judges lay on three persons. But now, it has to be made with a two-thirds majority in legislature,” she said adding that the amendment would “protect the sanctity and dignity” of the judges and the judiciary. Before her speech, the opposition raised widespread food adulteration, water logging in Dhaka, bad roads across the country, poor conditions in jails and other public interest issues. “You have to address the use of chemicals and formalin in food at any cost. This problem cannot be stopped overnight. It has been on for three decades,” said Rawshan in her closing speech. The opposition leader said Dhaka gets waterlogged during the monsoon and the problem must be solved. The frequent power outages in posh PAGE 2 COLUMN 4