/Scroll
Vol. XC, No. 7
/DeerfieldScroll
/DeerfieldScroll
/DeerfieldScroll
/DeerfieldScroll
Deerfield Academy, Deerfield, MA
9 March 2016
WHERE WILL YOUR VOTE GO? DEERFIELD STUDENTS DEBATE PRESIDENCY Hillary Clinton
//ORLEE MARINI-RAPPOPORT I want a president who will protect my two-mom family and the rights of all LGBT people. I want a president who fights for my right and the rights of all women to make decisions about their own bodies. I want a president who believes in science and who supports the 98% of scientists who know that climate change is real and man-made and that we need to do something about it. I want a president who understands that this country was founded by immigrants and that closing the borders to one particular race or religion is hateful. I want a president who understands that there is a difference between an 18th-century definition of the “right to bear arms” and a 21st-century “right” to bear semi-automatic weapons. I want a president who will close the wage gap, so I don’t earn 79 cents to
every man’s dollar. I want a president who believes in accessible, affordable healthcare as a basic human right. And most of all, I want a president who has the experience — as Senator, First Lady, and Secretary of State — to fight for all of this and more. Hillary Clinton stands with minorities, with women, and with immigrants. She’s with us, and that’s why I’m with her.
Tia Jonsson
Bernie Sanders
Marco Rubio
John Kasich
Donald Trump
Bernie Sanders has been on the forefront of the fight for issues of social justice for his entire political career. He is vehemently opposed to the enormous influence of money in legislating and exemplifies issue-oriented politics. He has consistently fought against a criminal justice system that disproportionately affects communities of color. It is ridiculous that a black boy born today will have a one-in-four chance of being incarcerated. I support Bernie Sanders, because he is fighting for a $15 minimum wage. People who work 40 hours a week should not need food stamps to feed their families. I support Bernie Sanders, because he thinks that health care is a right for every human being. It is outrageous that 18,000 Americans die every year, because they cannot pay for the health care. While Chairman of the Veteran’s Affairs Committee, he introduced what would have been the single biggest benefits programs for veterans ever. I support Bernie Sanders, because we need a political revolution to radically change the government so that it works for everyone, especially the poor.
Marco Rubio is the best candidate for the White House in 2016. He is a young, experienced Congressman who has proven in the madness of Super-Tuesday that many Americans hold him in high regard. While Ted Cruz has large support, he is far too extreme to win a general election. Donald Trump is the Republican frontrunner, but I honestly believe that America would be better run and safer with Marco Rubio in charge. He has a clear vision for America, and is a young and appealing candidate. I believe that he is best suited to turn America in the right direction. As with every candidate, there are flaws. Bernie Sanders is a socialist, Hillary Clinton is widely viewed as untrustworthy, Cruz is too extreme, and Donald Trump excites some of his followers into a mindless, mobdriven frenzy. Rubio’s biggest drawback? From my point of view, his youth and accompanying level of experience are his only faults. However, we must remember that Rubio’s weakness does not damage his leadership potential. He is a trustworthy, thoughtful, and patriotic man who wants to put America back on track. Rubio is without a doubt the best candidate for the White House.
This election year has given us pretty much everything we expected: lots of social media attention, Republican candidates being racist, and an overall feeling of disappointment in our political system. However, despite the despair one feels while watching a Republican debate, one candidate, John Kasich, seems to have risen above the name-calling and Donald Trump pouty-face-inducing rhetoric that we see so often on Fox News. Kasich is about as moderate as a modern day Republican comes. He cut taxes by 5 billion dollars in his native state of Ohio, created 400,000 jobs, and balanced the state budget. These conservative economics appease many desires of the Republican Party as a whole: more economic growth, less government regulation, and less taxes for all. Despite this economic one-sidedness, Kasich has shown blue flashes throughout his career as Ohio governor, expanding Medicaid in his state in the summer of 2015. Kasich’s willingness to compromise is encouraging. Kasich may be slightly boring, and he is certainly not a magnet of media attention, but he is an underrated candidate that seems to have been overshadowed by the sideshow that is Trump, Cruz and the rest of the Republicans.
First, I would like to start off by saying that I am not personally fully a Trump supporter. Nevertheless, I—or rather he—can point out some reasons for why his presidency could be beneficial for the United States. In the Republican race for the nomination, Trump is by far the best candidate. He has said, “Look at the way [Cruz] dealt with the Senate, where he goes in there like a—you know, frankly like a little bit of a maniac. You’re never going to get things done that way.” In contrast he described Marco Rubio as “overly ambitious, too young” and added, “...And I have better hair than he does, right?” On the other side of the aisle, Hillary Clinton and Bernie Sanders are in a tight race for the Democratic nomination. “Unlike me,” Trump has said, “Hillary Clinton isn’t rich enough to be incorruptible.” He’s also described Bernie Sanders as “a total whack job.” There you have it—the alternatives to Donald Trump are, in his own words, maniacs and whack jobs. He is the clearest choice for president of the United States. Trump has a proven track record of financial success and is actually one of the more socially moderate Republican candidates on issues like gay marriage and abortion.
//LOGAN KNIGHT
//BALLARD BROWN
//GAVIN KENNEDY
//TEDDY DONNELLEY
#MakeAmericaGreatAgain.
DEERFIELD BEGINS TRANSGENDER DISCUSSION //SARAH JANE O’CONNOR Staff Writer Starting with the Martin Luther King Day celebration in January, DA students were asked to think about inclusion on campus. This theme was discussed in mandatory workshops on MLK Day, and further efforts have promoted inclusion across campus ever since. Kayla Corcoran, a teaching fellow, Inclusion Plan Coordinator, and Deerfield alumna, described the process by which these inclusion efforts were developed, stating that last spring, “The Board of Trustees passed a resolution to eliminate all forms of discrimination from our community.” Deerfield is creating a Strategic Plan of Inclusion On Thursday, February 25th, DA hosted an extended school meeting with the goal of furthering the inclusion of transgender people within the community. Perry Cohen ’94, a transgender Deerfield alumnus and founder of The Venture Out Project, and Meg Bolger, founder of Pride for All and co-creator of the Safe Zone Project, led the meeting. Cohen and Bolger, who also hosted a workshop on MLK Day called “Building Your Transgender Toolkit,” gave DA students and faculty guidance on how to be supportive allies of trans people through describing proper pronoun usage and answering any questions that the community had about gender, sex,
identity, and more. Cohen and Bolger also provided a basic vocabulary regarding trans issues, introducing the audience to terms such as “cisgender” and “genderqueer” to help them understand transgender identities. Before the event, Head of School Margarita Curtis sent an email to the student body, informing them that the workshop aimed to “help [the students] understand and respect differences in gender identity” and ensure “that everyone at Deerfield feels included, respected, and affirmed.” Before Cohen and Bolger began their workshop, a Deerfield faculty member came out to the school as a transgender woman. Math Teacher Alice Grimm stated her preferred name and pronouns to the audience, spurring a standing ovation. A firstyear teacher at DA, Ms. Grimm later explained her decision to come out. “I looked at the cost that being closeted was imposing on me and I considered whether I felt ready to be me in a public way.” She added, “While I am excited about the ways that Deerfield can grow, I have already cried tears of joy at the extraordinary support I have received from all parts of our community—parents, students, staff, and fellow faculty members.” As was the case with Cohen, it is very possible that some students at Deerfield may be questioning their gender identity. Ms. Grimm, after experiencing the difficulties that can come with transitioning, has important advice for any students who may be
transitioning, or who want to be supportive allies. On the issue of misgendering, which means using the wrong pronouns, when addressing an individual, Ms. Grimm stated, “Try to get the name and pronouns right. This is about affirming that someone is who they say they are. Even cis people get misgendered, calling a woman with a short haircut “sir” for example...I understand that it is often an unpleasant experience for them as well. Intentionally misgendering someone can be profoundly hurtful.” Ms. Grimm said she hopes to reassure individuals, who may be confused or anxious about their uncertainty with their identity. She encourages them to consider experimenting with which identities “fit” them the best, saying, “Trust your self-knowledge. There is no such thing as not being “trans enough” to deserve transition…Try changing how you think of yourself, how you form your appearance, maybe playing a character of a different gender. Even just reading books with a variety of authors and characters to try on different ways of thinking of yourself. I didn’t really feel settled in my identity until after I read S/He (autobiography by Minnie Bruce Pratt) and I kept saying ‘that’s so me! I feel that so hard!’” Ms. Grimm also offered herself as a resource: “I am super happy to have a conversation about gender identity with interested students.” Though many members of the community feel that Deerfield has made progress
regarding inclusion, some believe Deerfield still has a ways to go. Valentina Connell ’16, leader of Deerfield’s Gender Sexuality Alliance, said, “I think [Deerfield] still can be a stifling place for students who don’t conform to the ‘norm’ of gender and sexuality. It can be very hard to express yourself at Deerfield, since it is a school very rooted in tradition and therefore follows many heteronormative/ cisnormative conventions.” Mr. Charley Sullivan, who works in Deerfield’s Office of Inclusion and Community Life, believes that the key to preserving both DA traditions and a strong, inclusive community is to ask of traditions, “Does this nurture us as a community? Does it strengthen us and help us grow? Is it available to all? If a tradition does that, it is worthy of our heritage. If on the other hand it creates division, or excludes, if it tears down rather than build our community, we should look carefully at whether it should continue, or how it should be adjusted to be worthy of our heritage.” With the formation of the Inclusion Plan, the Deerfield community has begun to prioritize inclusion in all aspects of community life. Mr. Sullivan added, “The work of inclusion is multifaceted, complex, and involves all of us. Given our rapidly changing demographics, no one gets to stand on the sideline because they feel that this has nothing to do with them. The individual and collective work of building an inclusive community is critical and benefits us all.”