Annie Gould Gallery
Now what? Judge is ready to rule in Charlottesville zoning case, but opens door to more evidence
By Sean Tubbs
One month after City Council approved a new zoning code that allows more residential density across Charlottesville, a group of property owners filed a lawsuit arguing they would be harmed by the changes.
Last week, Charlottesville Circuit Judge Claude Worrell dismissed two of the four counts in White v. Charlottesville but left room for further hearings on the other two.
“Plaintiffs have provided a sufficient question of fact for the Court to hear evidence regarding the promulgation of the new zoning ordinance,” Worrell wrote in a three-page ruling dated November 12.
One of the open questions under Virginia law is whether the new development code was “drawn and applied with reasonable consideration for the existing use and character of property,” including a review of transportation requirements and other public services.
So far, all of the legal proceedings have dealt with a motion from the city that states the plaintiffs have no merit and no standing to sue. Each owns a lot that now allows six or eight units rather than the one per mitted under the old zoning.
Worrell concluded the plaintiffs have the right to bring the case, and his invitation for evidence relates to the question of whether Charlottesville followed state regulations.
In his ruling, Worrell also said if both parties are prepared to proceed without submitting new evidence, he would be ready to “rule as to the sufficiency of the suit as a matter of fact and law.”
The property owners want their day in court.
“The plaintiffs expect to present evidence regarding the promulgation of the new zoning ordinance at a trial on this matter,” said Mike Derdeyn, the plaintiffs’ attorney.
gagement, said the city does not comment on pending litigation.
In late September, Fairfax Circuit Court Judge David Schell ruled against a provision added to Arlington County’s land use regulations that had the same intent as Charlottesville’s development code—to increase the number of places people can live. Schell, a retired judge, was assigned to the case after Arlington judges recused themselves because they are homeowners. Worrell, a property owner in Charlottesville, did not recuse himself.
When asked if it would submit anything new, Afton Schneider, Charlottesville’s director of communications and public en-
Part of Schell’s ruling against Arlington’s Expanded Housing Option program hinges on the same section of state code that has kept the Charlottesville case alive. Arlington County has indicated it will appeal the ruling.
According to the website ARLNow.com, Schell’s ruling will permit several dozen units being built under the EHO program to proceed, but he warned they may one day need to be torn down depending on how the appeals process works out.
A handful of “major development plans” have been filed with the City of Charlottesville, including the conversion of 303 Alderman Rd. from a single-family house to six townhomes and a by-right request to
“Plaintiffs have provided a sufficient question of fact for the Court to hear evidence regarding the promulgation of the new zoning ordinance.”
JUDGE CLAUDE WORRELL
Judge Worrell, who has been on the bench since July 2013, issued the three-page ruling nearly five months after hearing arguments in the case.
BENTIVAR MANOR
Exquisite brick home on 88 private acres less than 5 miles from town. Excellent quality throughout, spacious, over 11,00 sf. Beautiful views, tranquil setting, trails, long frontage on the Rivanna River. MLS#652353 $4,875,000 Jim Faulconer, 434.981.0076 and Will Faulconer, 434.987.9455
NEWLISTING
CEDAR RIDGE
A rare 80-acre estate nestled in the foothills of the Blue Ridge Mountains. The immaculate turnkey custom cedar home, located at the property’s highest point, boasts stunning panoramic mountain views and an array of captivating water features. MLS# 658780 Court Nexsen, 646.660.0700 and Katherine Leddington, 646.593.0333
HIGH FIELDS
Scenic 42-acre farm just 10 miles from Charlottesville. Features pastures, woodlands, serene creek, antique farmhouse, updated kitchen, 4-bedrooms and 3-baths. Panoramic Blue Ridge Mountain vistas, and substantial barn. MLS#651245 $1,565,000 Jim Faulconer, 434.981.0076 or Will Faulconer, 434.987.9455
THE HOLSINGER
Exceptional 2-bedroom, 2.5-bath condo, located just steps from the historic Downtown Mall. Luxurious living spaces, spacious floor plan, fully loaded kitchen, hardwood floors, a private balcony, and secure parking. Enjoy vibrant downtown living! MLS#656160 $1,178,000 Jim Faulconer, 434.981.0076 or Will Faulconer, 434.987.9455
FIELDS OF BOAZ
A country French estate on 24 acres 6 miles from the University of Virginia. Timeless charm and modern luxury with soaring ceilings, spacious primary suite, home office, wine cellar, guest quarters, and private pond. MLS#652608 $3,995,000 Court Nexsen, 646.660.0700
GRASSMERE
Spectacular contemporary home privately situated atop nearly 17 serene park-like acres in the highly desirable Ivy area with Blue Ridge Mountain views! Truly a special & unique offering with a wealth of opportunities to enjoy! This 4-5 BR home with spacious rooms is an entertainer’s dream! $2,235,000 MLS#657960 Will Faulconer, 434.987.9455
CHEVAL NOIR
Exceptional small horse farm on 15 acres in Albemarle. 4-bedroom, 3.5-bath, bonus room, a stunning light-filled great room with storybook views, and first-floor primary suite. Farm: 3-stall barn, paddocks, run-in, trails and pasture. MLS#657379 $1,274,000 Bridget Archer, 434.981.4149 or Pam Dent, 434.960.0161
ENDWYKE
This stunning 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath replica of an 1800s Federal-style home in Appomattox captures the elegance and timeless design of early American architecture while offering the conveniences of modern construction. $1,150,000 MLS#658395 Bridget Archer 434.981.4149 or Pam Dent 434.960.0161
GONE AWAY FARM
barn, & fenced garden. MLS#658352 $3,450,000 Jim Faulconer, 434.981.0076/Will Faulconer 434.987.9455
WESTERN ALBEMARLE
Newly renovated 5,700 sq. ft. brick home on 5 acres between Charlottesville and Ivy in Western Albemarle. With 4 bedrooms, 4.5 baths, and garage apartment, this home offers elegance and comfort. Enjoy 10 ft ceilings, three fireplaces, and a gourmet kitchen with dual appliances. MLS#657678 $1,950,000 Jennifer Von Reuter, 202.957.3465
HISTORIC STAUNTON Meticulously renovated National Historic Register home, blending modern amenities with remarkable charm. 5-bedrooms with hardwood floors, stained glass windows, and trim. Quartz kitchen, magnificent primary suite, terrace apartment. MLS#653080 $1,195,000 Court Nexsen, 646.660.0700
KESWICK ESTATE
Nestled near Keswick Hall lies Keswick Estate, a gated community offering a 2.10± acre building site blending country life with resort living in Virginia’s Blue Ridge Mountains. Build your dream home minutes from amenities like golf, dining, tennis, and more. MLS#650785 $470,000 Court Nexsen at 646.660.0700
E HIGH STREET
Charming Boutique Building in coveted downtown location. Unique, light-filled condo located just one block off Court Square. Opportunity to have an office and/or residence in this immaculate property. Bright, large rooms with a tremendous amount of flexibility of how to use the space. Front and rear entrances with cute deck in the back. $615,000
LOCUST AVENUE
Charming 1929, classic brick home located in north downtown. Tastefully renovated and updated without losing the original character. 9’ ceilings, built-in bookcases, beautiful woodwork, trim and crown Professionally landscaped yard with mature plantings offers room for relaxation, play, and entertaining. Private, off-street parking. Walkable community with wide streets and sidewalks. Quick access to major roadways, UVa and Downtown. Recent upgrades include: new roof 2022, replacement windows, renovated bathrooms, exterior painted 2022, and new Plantation shutters $899,900
STONEY CREEK DRIVE
Fabulous home in Mill Creek South. Set on an elevated lot with fenced backyard and a side deck that overlooks the woods. Unique floor plan includes a first floor primary suite with a walk-in closet; a half bath and a full laundry room. The living room features a masonry gas fireplace. The bright kitchen opens to both the living room and dining room. 3 nice sized bedrooms on the second floor and another full bath. Property includes a large storage shed and a semi-circle driveway. $519,900
