Issuu

Tuesday, October 28, 2025

youarecurrent.com

Clay Middle School sub claims CCS fired her for public criticism

Bur Oak Bridge officially opens

Carmel City Council approves 2026 budget

Irsay’s Carmel property sold to several buyers

Ben & Jerry’s to open shop in Carmel

PRIVATE EVENTS

From holiday events to business dinners, we set the stage for extraordinary private events.

Choose Your Space: Glass Chimney Room – Up to 30 guests oard Room – Up to 16 guests

Let us make your event effortless and unforgettable. Call Sonya at 463.269.5157 to book.

THE WARMTH OF THE SEASON, SERVED TO

HOLIDAY GIFT CARDS

Stop by Anthony's Chophouse to grab our exclusive gift card promo: Buy a $100 gift card and get a BONUS $20 gift card.

Perfect for holiday gifting or treating yourself to an unforgettable dining experience.

About us

Founded October 24, 2006, at Carmel, IN Vol. XX, No. 1

525 North End Dr. Ste. 175 Carmel, IN 46032 317.489.4444

Contact the editor

Have a news tip, calendar item or photo to share?

Contact Managing Editor Todd Golden at todd@ youarecurrent.com or call 317.489.4444. You also may submit information at currentincarmel. com. Our print deadline is eight days prior to publication. Submissions for online accepted daily.

Share your thoughts

Letters to the editor may be sent for consideration to letters@youarecurrent. com. Letters have a maximum word count of 300 words. Please include your city of residence and a contact phone number for verification. Current Publishing may refuse letters.

Advertise your business

If you’re interested in reaching the Carmel market (35,089 households), you may obtain more information by emailing ads@youarecurrent.com (subject: Carmel advertising) or by calling 317.847.5022.

Legal advertising legals@youarecurrent.com Obituaries obits@youarecurrent.com

Delivery questions

circulation@youarecurrent.com

Join our community facebook.com/youarecurrent x.com/youarecurrent instagram.com/youarecurrent

Opinions

The views of the columnists in Current in Carmel are their own and do not necessarily reflect the positions of this newspaper.

Happy Halloween

To all your little ghosts & goblins!

Ex-CCS sub claims letter led to retaliation

By Ann Marie Shambaugh AnnMarie@youarecurrent.com

A former Clay Middle School employee is alleging Carmel Clay Schools fired her for publicly sharing some of her concerns about the district. CCS claims she resigned.

Beth Straw, who worked as a permanent substitute teacher at Clay from 2017 until Aug. 1, said she knew she would likely face consequences after Current in Carmel published her letter to the editor in October 2024, but she didn’t initially expect to lose her job.

“I honestly didn’t think they would fire me, because they are so desperate for subs,” Straw said.

The Carmel resident said she submitted the letter on behalf of dozens of teachers who signed off on it but were afraid to publicly identify themselves, for fear of retribution. Current does not run unnamed letters to the editor, but Straw said she felt so strongly that the public needed to know about the teachers’ concerns that she felt it was worth the risk signing her name to it.

“I’m 76 (years old). If I get fired, it’s not going to kill me. I’ll still eat,” Straw said. “But (the other teachers) knew if they put (their names) on it, there would be retribution. Probably not being fired, but they could be really tormented in class and moved around to different schools.”

A few days after the letter was published, Clay Middle School Principal Todd Crosby and Assistant Principal Catherine Gahl summoned Straw for a meeting. Straw said they asked why she had written the letter rather than bringing her concerns to them, and she told them she and other teachers had done so multiple times.

Several weeks went by, and Straw thought the matter was behind her. But in mid-December 2024, then-CCS

Superintendent Michael Beresford sent her an email instructing her to meet with him in his office the following day.

“You are not in trouble, I just want to fully understand the context of the topics you covered in the (letter to the editor),” Beresford stated in the email.

Straw replied to ask if she could bring someone with her, and Beresford stated that she should attend alone.

When Straw arrived, she said Beresford was joined by CCS School Board President Kristin Kouka and attorney Andrew McNeill.

“(Beresford) spent probably 15 to 20 minutes grilling me on how many teachers were involved in this,” Straw said. “He really was wanting names. I told him, ‘My husband doesn’t even know. I’d go to my grave with those names.’”

Straw left the meeting flustered, but as time went on and she neared the end of the second semester of the school year without hearing anything else, she assumed she was in the clear.

That changed when she realized her annual evaluation hadn’t occurred during the spring and later discovered it had been scheduled for 3 p.m. May 22, the last day of school.

During the brief meeting, Crosby and Gahl discussed her performance evaluation for the year, which had dropped in nearly every category since her last review.

In the Professionalism/Confidentiality/Service Focused category, Straw’s performance was “unacceptable.” A note below stated the importance of communicating concerns directly with school leadership.

“Publicly expressing criticisms in a manner that may reflect negatively on the school does not align with our shared commitment to fostering a positive and supportive culture within Carmel Clay Schools,” the note stated.

Straw, who was already planning to switch to a part-time role the following school year but hadn’t yet told school administrators, told Crosby and Gahl at the meeting that she intended to resign

from her position. However, she still planned to return part-time.

But on Aug. 1, Straw received an email from Kelli Hackett, an administrative assistant in the district’s HR department, alerting her that based on concerns noted in her evaluation, she would no longer be assigned as a substitute at Clay. She would, however, “remain eligible and welcome to substitute” at other CCS schools.

The following week, when Straw attempted to log in to a CCS software program to prepare for the new school year, she discovered she had been locked out.

“That’s how I found out I was done,” Straw said.

Current requested an interview with every CCS employee mentioned in this story and in response received a statement from Supt. Tom Oestreich, who replaced the retiring Beresford in July.

“The former staff person in question was offered the opportunity to continue serving as a substitute in 14 of our 15 schools but declined the parameters set and chose to resign,” Oestreich stated. “Carmel Clay Schools has nothing further to add at this time, as this is an ongoing legal matter.”

Straw told Current she didn’t resign and isn’t aware of what parameters Oestreich referred to in his statement.

Beresford declined to comment on specific personnel issues.

“Anytime concerns about the district were raised, we investigate to see if there is validity to those concerns,” Beresford said. “We do so respectfully and professionally at all times.”

Attorneys representing Straw sent CCS a letter this month seeking her reinstatement as an unrestricted substitute teacher at Clay and back pay for the time she has missed.

Straw is represented by Liberty Counsel, a nonprofit Christian advocacy organization that focuses on First Amendment and religious freedom issues.

For the full version of this story, youarecurrent.com/?p=263610.

136th & Meridian or 131st & Towne Rd

Straw

Bur Oak Bridge officially open for pedestrians

By Todd Golden todd@youarecurrent.com

The Bur Oak Bridge, which connects Carmel to Fishers, was open for pedestrians after an Oct. 20 ribbon-cutting ceremony featuring officials from communities on both sides of the White River.

The 500-foot span links Carmel’s Hazel Landing Park and Fishers’ Heritage Park. The bridge provides pedestrians access to three major rail trails in suburban north Indianapolis. They are Zionsville’s Big Four Rail Trail, Carmel’s Monon Greenway and Fishers’ Nickel Plate Trail.

Carmel Clay Parks & Recreation Director Michael Kltizing, Clay Township Trustee Paul Hensel, Hamilton County Commissioner Christine Altman, Delaware Township Trustee Debbie Driskell, Fishers Mayor Scott Fadness and Carmel Clay Parks & Recreation Board President Judy Hagan all spoke during the dedication.

The organizations they represented all played roles in the construction of the $11 million bridge via funding and

other means. Officials lauded the communication and coordination necessary to get the bridge built.

“To me, the bridge doesn’t just represent safe passage. It doesn’t just represent the beauty of the surroundings or the history and the value that White River brings to our community, but more importantly, this represents cooperation,” Altman said.

Fadness joked about other “possibili-

ties” the bridge might provide.

“As I was standing there, I had this image in my head of the next time Fishers and Carmel get into an argument, we’ll meet right here in the middle.

(Carmel Mayor) Sue (Finkam) and I will come to terms right here,” said Fadness, who also joked that there was not a roundabout in the bridge.

Klitzing said the bridge was named following input from Native American

tribes.

“The tribes next asked for a listing of native plants and trees that you might find along the river in this location that might have been witnessed by visitors to the site over the generations,” Klitzing said. “Given the prominence of several bur oak trees nearby, they chose this for the bridge’s name.”

Once the ribbon was cut, cyclists and walkers immediately began using the bridge.

The new Bur Oak Bridge spans the White River and links Carmel’s Hazel Landing Park and Fishers’ Heritage Park. (Photos by Kelly Sullivan)

Clay Township Trustee Paul Hensel, right, and Hamilton County Commissioner Christine Altman cut the ribbon to officially open the Bur Oak Bridge Oct. 20.

Carmel City Council approves amended 2026 budget

By Ann Marie Shambaugh AnnMarie@youarecurrent.com

The Carmel City Council unanimously approved the 2026 budget during a lengthy meeting Oct. 20 after making several amendments.

The $144 million general fund budget is generally flat compared to 2025, as Senate Enrolled Act 1 led to the city expecting to receive approximately $10 million less in property tax revenue next year than originally projected.

Carmel Mayor Sue Finkam called the version of the budget presented at the meeting a “compromise proposal” that included several adjustments in response to feedback from city councilors.

“Our efforts to maintain the strong fiscal health of Carmel will continue in earnest,” she stated in an Oct. 21 press release. “I look forward to keeping Carmel safe, maintaining a pro-growth economy and remaining a welcoming community for all.”

Approved amendments include:

• Reducing the Carmel Fire Department full-time regular pay line item by $300,000 in response to the city hiring two fewer lateral recruits than previously projected

• Increasing funding for arts grants by $110,000 to equal 2025 spending

• Adding $50,000 to the Carmel Police Department budget for after-hours security at City Hall

The City Council approved some amendments of its own, including:

• Removing $10,000 in travel expenses

• Adding $15,000 to the Marketing and Communications Department budget to boost support for city commissions and committees

• Reducing the amount of funds appropriated for outside legal fees from $475,000 to $350,000

Councilor Matt Snyder described the passage of the budget as an “incredible feat” accomplished after weeks of discussion, scrutiny and collaboration.

“If this is a good budget, everybody up here and the mayor should feel disappointed, because I believe that is the sign of success. It’s a sign of cooperation,” he said. “That’s the sign of a good negotiation.”

The council also approved a measure at the meeting capping the city’s property tax rate for 2026 at 77.83 cents per $100 of assessed value, its current rate.

In addition, the meeting included approval of 2026 salary levels for city employees and elected officials. The council amended the ordinance to remove the positions of chief infrastructure officer and economic development director, two vacant positions that the city does not plan to fill in 2026.

The council also amended an ordinance setting salaries for elected officials to maximum amounts that would include a 3 percent cost of living adjustment

CARMEL HIGH SCHOOL

Open House Open House

SUNDAY, NOVEMBER 2 11 AM - 1 PM

If you haven’t visited CHS recently, you’ll be amazed by what’s new! Discover our brand-new Polytechnic wing featuring state-of-the-art facilities for culinary, construction, media, and automotive courses. See the impressive new natatorium, meet our dedicated staff, and experience programs in action in our art studios, performing arts wing, and innovative STEM spaces.

“If this is a good budget, everybody up here and the mayor should feel disappointed, because I believe that is the sign of success. It’s a sign of cooperation. That’s the sign of a good negotiation.”

– MATT SNYDER

to match the amount received by city employees. Initially, the mayor, city court judge, city clerk and some appointed members of the city’s leadership team were not set to receive a COLA, while the city council did expect to receive one.

The council approved an ordinance last year aligning elected officials’ COLA with the amount received by city employees in an effort to depoliticize a vote to increase its own pay. With the amended ordinance, all elected officials are eligible for the COLA but are not required to take it.

The 2026 budget does not include funding for PrimeLife Enrichment, a Carmel nonprofit that serves senior citizens. Finkam said she has had discussions with another organization that may be able to provide the funds, but if that doesn’t work out the city plans to appropriate $50,000 in grant funds to PrimeLife in 2026, the same amount donated this year.

Alumni, neighbors, and memberscommunity are invited to tour Carmel High School and experience the opportunities that inspire success.

Finkam

COMMUNITY

Historic districts approved, City Hall ordinance introduced

By Ann Marie Shambaugh AnnMarie@youarecurrent.com

In addition to approving the 2026 budget, the Carmel City Council discussed several other matters Oct. 20. Topics included the creation of two historic districts, updates to the residential rental registration ordinance and Carmel City Hall accessibility.

 WHAT HAPPENED: The council approved the creation of two historic districts.

 WHAT IT MEANS: The new districts encompass the Wilkinson-Hull house on East Smoky Row Road and the Klingensmith-Pettiner Farmstead on Cherry Tree Road. The designation is to protect historic buildings in the city.

 WHAT’S NEXT: Properties within a historic district must receive approval from the Carmel Historic Preservation Commission for exterior changes, relocation or demolition.

 WHAT HAPPENED: The council approved several amendments to the residential rental registration and permit program.

 WHAT IT MEANS: In June, the council approved an ordinance capping residential rentals at 10 percent of dwellings in each neighborhood and requiring property owners to register rental homes. Amendments include requiring homeowner’s associations to acknowledge that a rental property owner is in good standing and bumping the fine for failing to

register to $2,500, plus $1,000 per subsequent day. City attorney Benjamin Legge said the previous penalty was likely not significant enough to deter some property owners from renting homes without registering them.

 WHAT HAPPENED: The council sent an ordinance establishing public areas of Carmel City Hall to its land use committee for further discussion.

 WHAT IT MEANS: Councilor Matt Snyder drafted the ordinance after learning Mayor Sue Finkam was considering moving some public meetings from evenings to earlier in the day. The earlier meetings are anticipated to save the city $173,000 annually in overtime and other costs. The ordinance aims to ensure City Hall is open any time a city board or commission would like to schedule a meeting. Finkam said she does not oppose the ordinance.

 WHAT’S NEXT: The committee’s next meeting is set for 5:30 p.m. Nov. 5. A meeting location had not been announced as of press time.

 WHAT HAPPENED: The council approved an ordinance setting maximum 2025 salaries for city employees.

 WHAT IT MEANS: The ordinance retroactively adjusts salaries for eight positions identified during a salary study as being miscategorized. Broader efforts to adjust citywide salary ranges were previously rejected by the council.

DISPATCHES

 City Of Carmel announces Trick-ortreat hours — Trick-or-treating in Carmel will take place from 5 to 8 p.m. Oct. 31. Homes welcoming trick-or-treaters should turn on their porch lights. Those who do not wish to participate, or run out of treats, should turn off their porch lights.

 Halloween trash pickup — Carmel Utilities announced that Republic Services will begin trash and recycling collection one hour earlier Oct. 31. Republic

will begin collection at 6 a.m. and conclude at 5 p.m. This change will help ensure trucks are out of the neighborhood, helping to create a safer environment for trick-or-treaters that evening.

 St. Christopher’s Pumpkin Sale — The St. Christopher’s Pumpkin Sale runs through Oct. 31 at St. Christopher’s Episcopal Church at 1402 W. Main St. in Carmel. Proceeds benefit Hamilton County Harvest Food Bank.

Nonprofit Strong Towns opens Carmel chapter

By Todd Golden todd@youarecurrent.com

Strong Towns, a national nonprofit that advocates for reimaging American cities, recently established a chapter in Carmel.

According to its website, Strong Towns Carmel’s mission is to provide legal housing choice; provide safe and productive streets; and reduce parking mandates, such as parking minimums for certain buildings. It advocates by communicating with local officials and by trying to be an active voice in local government.

Affordable housing falls under Strong Towns’ definition of “legal housing choice.” According to its website, Strong Towns Carmel advocates for zoning changes “to allow missing middle housing without destroying existing neighborhood character.”

Carmel resident Jordan Kohl is the conversation leader for Strong Towns Carmel. The organization calls its chapters “local conversations.” Kohl said Carmel’s group has 20 members so far.

“We’re in a kind of a housing crisis, right? Because housing has become so unaffordable for people to be able to live in downtown Carmel, near all of that walkable vibrancy, and so we want to help advocate for more affordable housing,” Kohl said.

Kohl said Carmel’s zoning is mostly for single-family housing or apartments, which makes options such as townhouses, duplexes and other forms of potentially affordable housing difficult to build in the city.

Scott Lowe is a Carmel resident and

member of Strong Towns Carmel.

“You don’t have entry-level housing (in Carmel), basically,” he said. “Somebody just out of school or a retiring person, you know that that price point doesn’t exist in Carmel.”

Kohl said zoning changes have been successful in other Strong Towns communities where Strong Towns is active. He said part of Strong Towns’ mission is to work with city officials to educate them on housing options.

“For example, legalize ADUs (accessory dwelling units) so that you can build a small house in your backyard using space that’s otherwise empty,” he said. “You can build a 600-square-foot unit that someone could afford to buy or rent and be able to create new housing without destroying the character of the neighborhood,” Kohl said.

Carmel City Councilor Shannon Minnaar has met with Strong Towns members. Minnaar said Carmel has put into action what Strong Towns believes in as far as having a walkable, accessible city.

“The advocates for Strong Towns raise valid questions about long-term financial sustainability and community inclusivity. I think that’s great,” Minnaar said. “Ultimately, the challenge is for Carmel to evolve thoughtfully, preserving the quality of life that makes it desirable while making it resilient and an accessible community for generations to come. I think we all agree on that.”

Strong Towns Carmel has monthly meetings. The next is Nov. 22. For more, visit strongtownscarmel. org.

DISPATCHES

 Menards food drive — Throughout the month of October, Menards home improvement stores are serving as a drop site for a local food pantry. Menards offers nonperishable food items that can be donated to the food pantries, from boxes of cereal to cans of soup that can be found in our grocery department for immediate donation. There is a large collection box near the exit doors to place donations. The Carmel location at 2150 E. Greyhound Pass will donate to Open Doors Westfield.

 Section of Monon Greenway closed — Carmel Parks & Recreation has closed a section of the Monon Greenway that crosses under City Center Drive for construction. It closed Oct. 6 and the detour is expected to last to Oct. 31, weather permitting. The recommended detour is to go to 3rd Avenue south of Carter Green, go through the roundabout at City Center Drive, and return to the Monon Greenway north of City Center Drive.

Irsay’s Carmel land sold to several buyers

By Todd Golden todd@youarecurrent.com

Property in Carmel formerly owned by the late Indianapolis Colts owner Jim Irsay has been gradually sold since August.

A trust controlled by Irsay’s daughters, who share ownership of the Colts, have sold the land to several buyers according to publicly available Hamilton County property records. Indianapolis Colts CEO Carlie Irsay-Gordon, Executive Vice President Casey Foyt and Chief Brand Officer Kalen Jackson formed the trust.

The latest sale involved 96.2 acres of land at the northwest corner of West 116th Street and Clay Center Road. The property includes an approximately 11,000-square-foot residence. The sale was finalized Oct. 13.

The property was bought by Zionsville-based Wade Haven Holdings LLC, a limited liability company created Sept. 8 by AES Restaurant Group founder John Wade. AES Restaurants owns 230 Arby’s restaurants in 17 states, including 27 Arby’s in Indiana. Wade declined to comment on the purchase when reached by Current. Four additional holding companies have bought land once owned by Irsay, who died May 21, in an area bounded by West 116th Street, Clay Center Road and

Hoover Road.

A total of 17.5 undeveloped acres on Hoover Road were purchased Aug. 25 by Whats Rookin LLC. Hamilton County property records indicate that Whats Rookin is associated with Indianapolis Colts guard Quenton Nelson and wife Farrah Housefield.

A total of 14.2 acres at 1430 W. 116th St. were purchased Aug. 28 by FDE Holdings LLC, Inc., controlled by Indianapolis-based Taft Service Solutions Corp.

A single 10.25-acre parcel at 1616 W. 116th St. was purchased Aug. 22 by Schoolhouse Six LLC. The company was created Aug. 4 and controlled by Indianapolis attorney Valerie Kucic.

A total of 7.65 acres were purchased Sept. 23 by 1721 W. 116th LLC. There is no record of the LLC filed with the Indiana Secretary of State’s office and no additional information listed on Hamilton County property records.

Purchase prices for the Carmel Irsay’s properties in Carmel were not available. Besides the Carmel properties, two Irsay-owned estates in northern Indiana are also for sale or are in the process of being sold. A 6-acre estate on Lake Maxinkuckee near Culver is listed for $19.9 million. Another former Irsay-owned estate in Culver listed for $6.9 million has a contract for sale pending, according to the website Realtor Andrea Kelly.

CORRECTION — Renee Butts is the Public Education Officer for Carmel Police Department. She was mis-identified in the Oct. 21 edition of Current in Carmel.

GIS Screenshot of parcel sold to Wade Haven Holdings LLC.

Vanquish Shower Mold!

Ambaty closes in on quest

Mohan Ambaty raced a half-marathon in Chile

By Todd Golden todd@youarecurrent.com

Joining the “seven continents club” is a goal for runners to complete a half marathon or marathon on all seven continents.

Carmel resident Mohan Ambaty, 56, has been on the quest since 2019 and is closing in on completing his goal. He checked South America — his sixth continent — off his list when he competed in the 21K race at the Patagonian International Marathon at Torres del Paine National Park near Puerto Natales, Chile, Sept. 6. Ambaty has completed marathons or half marathons in North America (2018), Asia (2019), Antarctica (2022), Australia (2023) and Africa (2024).

ment of the race itself. He had to overcome a knee injury.

As he trained for the half marathon in late June, Ambaty suffered pain in his left knee. Doctors found no structural damage but diagnosed the problem as inflammation from overuse. He said he ran almost 300 miles in June alone in preparation for the half-marathon.

Ambaty

This time, however, Ambaty –– who is the chief information officer at the Indiana Department of Health –– faced a different challenge apart from the toll of the travel and the physical punish-

Although initially advised by doctors not to run in the half-marathon. Ambaty found an alternate recovery regimen that allowed him to train.

“The last choice given was to see a physiotherapist just three weeks before my race,” Ambaty said. “He did some magic.”

Ambaty was able to jog at a pace that allowed him to finish the half-marathon within the six-hour limit.

Because of the punishing nature of the Patagonian course, a physician’s certification was required for Ambaty to compete. He finished with a time of 2 hours, 25.06 minutes; was 15th in his 50-59 age group; 143rd among men’s competitors; and was 230th overall.

Co. confronts e-bike usage

By Jessica Todd jessica@youarecurrent.com

Hamilton County municipalities are eyeing regulations to address the speed and safety of e-bikes on roadways and trails.

An e-bike, or electric bike, is a bicycle with a battery-powered electric motor that assists the rider with pedaling.

Several Hamilton County cities are taking steps to regulate e-bike usage.

The Fishers Police Department announced Oct. 6 that patrols on and around trails will increase in response to reports of juveniles blocking and riding in traffic.

Indiana State Rep. Alaina Shonkwiler (R-Noblesville) said e-bikes are a safety concern.

“(Residents) I have spoken with are concerned for the safety of other pedestrians, children and cyclists on trails when an e-bike passes (on a trail) at a higher rate of speed,” Shonkwiler said. “Depending on the classification of the e-bike, they are restricted on where they can be ridden — roads versus mul-

tiuse pathways and trails.”

According to REI Co-op, a U.S.-based outdoor gear and apparel retailer, e-bikes are categorized into three classes:

• Class 1: Pedal-assist only, stopping at 20 mph.

• Class 2: Has a throttle-powered mode and offers pedal assist up to 20 mph.

• Class 3: Pedal-assist only, but the assistance continues up to 28 mph.

City officials in Carmel reviewed the issue in June after receiving several complaints from constituents about speeding along the Monon Greenway. An ordinance establishing regulations for the use of micromobility devices within the City of Carmel had its first reading Oct. 20. It was sent to the Land Use and Special Studies Committee.

“These new electric dirt bikes are not legal, but there are more and more of them flying around Carmel,” Carmel City Council Member Matt Snyder said in June. “It’s young children (riding them), and to me the safety of these children has become an impetus to make something happen much faster.”

VFW Post 10003 Military Ball

Donna

CEF unveils new logo

news@currentincarmel.com

The Carmel Education Foundation unveiled a new logo Oct. 15.

According to a press release, the logo focuses on raising community awareness, enhancing donor engagement and clearly communicating CEF’s mission and impact.

The new primary logo is a “C” stylized as a mosaic made of geometric shapes. The outer circle is designed in the colors of all 15 Carmel Clay Schools, as it references CEF’s representation of every school across the district.

ing of its integral role in the Carmel community.”

The brand development project started in January and was approved by the CEF Board in April.

The interior circle components represent the city of Carmel (blue), education (yellow) and the foundation (green) to symbolize unity between all three entities.

CEF stated in a press release that it will be “focused on formalizing its messaging to ensure clear and consistent communication of its mission, values and unique value propositions to strengthen the public’s understand

The rebranding project was led by Carmel-based Pence Media Group, which donated in-kind services to the project as a CEF Community Partner.

“For nearly 60 years, our foundation has invested in generations of students and educators,” stated Jennifer Penix, Carmel Education Foundation CEO. “This new look and voice honors our history while positioning us for the future. It communicates not only who we are, but the incredible impact we continue to make for every student in Carmel Clay Schools.”

CEF was founded in 1966 and has awarded more than $2.5 million in scholarships and has given nearly $2 million in grants to support Carmel Clay Schools students.

For more, visit ccs.k12.in.us/

Bonterra aquires firm

By Todd Golden todd@youarecurrent.com

OneCause, a Carmel-based fundraising technology firm, has been acquired by Texas-based software company Bonterra. The acquisition was jointly announced by both companies Oct. 15.

The cost of the acquisition has not been disclosed.

OneCause, at 11711 N. Meridian St., Suite 310, has 205 employees, including 119 in Indiana. Most employees in the Carmel headquarters work remotely.

Founded in 2008, OneCause creates digital-based fundraising software and fundraising options for clients. According to OneCause, it has helped over 14,000 nonprofits raise $8 billion for their charitable causes.

OneCause CEO Steve Johns said the acquisition is “a validation of everything we’ve built” and a validation of the Indianapolis-based tech scene generally.

“We grew here, we created significant economic impact here in the state, and then we became nationally known and recognized for the leadership position

that we carved out for ourselves and the leadership position that we took In supporting event-based fundraising for nonprofits,” Johns said.

Johns said the acquisition came about because of interest from Bonterra and the “trusted brand” that Johns said OneCause has become. OneCause will still operate under its own name, but with “a Bonterra company” added to the business title.

“After 15 years of growing the business, we felt it was the right time to join forces with a partner,” Johns said. “The nonprofit organizations that we serve and the causes that they champion are so pervasive that we really needed to have broader reach, depth and scale. Becoming part of the Bonterra network really gets us there.”

As for OneCause employees are concerned, Johns said there will be no changes for now.

“It is business as usual. (OneCause will) continue to serve the needs of our customers and continue to operate out of the headquarters in Carmel,” Johns said.

For more, visit bonterratech.com

Quality women’s clothing, jewelry and gifts.

30 N Rangeline Rd. | Carmel, IN 46032 | 317- 993-3011 Monday - Saturday 10 a.m. - 5:30 p.m.

884 Logan St. | Noblesville, IN 46060 | 317-674-8573 Monday - Saturday 10 a.m. - 5:30 p.m.

BASHBOUTIQUE.NET

20% OFF*

One Item Store Wide

*Excludes Ambre and Brighton Products. One discount per purchase. Cannot be combined with any other offer or promotion. Valid through November 8, 2025 featuring

No Gimmicks, Just Growth

LN receiver attracting major college attention

By Mark Ambrogi mark@youarecurrent.com

There are good reasons why Lawrence North High School junior wide receiver

Monshun Sales is a consensus five-star college football recruit.

Sales was second in the 200 meters in 21.56 seconds at the IHSAA boys state track and field finals in June and was on the winning 400 relay team. He had set a state record of 21.09 in the 200 prelims.

“When you add in his big 6-foot-5 frame, he’s not only fast, he’s tall and he becomes hard to bring down once he gets going,” Wildcats coach Patrick Mallory said.

Sales has 35 receptions for 782 yards this season heading into the Oct. 31 Class 6A sectional game against Lawrence Central. He had 34 catches for 568 yards last season.

“I feel like I most improved in my catching and getting open,” Sales said. “Track helps me get more explosive.

ATHLETE OF THE WEEK

MONSHUN SALES

Favorite athlete: Jeremiah Smith

Favorite musician: NBA YoungBoy

Favorite subject: History

Favorite movie: “Friday”

Favorite vacation spot: Miami

It really teaches me how to run and stride.”

He has seen his yards per-catch average rise from 16.7 yards to 22.3.

“He’s bigger, faster and stronger,” Mallory said.

Besides physical qualities, Mallory said Sales keeps maturing.

“We get them as young kids and some might not even be teenagers yet,” Mallory said. “Once they get into a system

and they see what the system can do for them, it really helps that process of thinking and what they can probably do.”

Sales is optimistic about the team’s chances in the postseason.

“We are more motivated than ever,”

he said. “We have something to prove to everyone doubting us. We don’t care about that. We want to prove to ourselves that we are who we say we are.”

Sales has a slew of scholarship offers, including from the University of Alabama, Ohio State University, Indiana University, University of Oklahoma, University of Michigan, University of Notre Dame and Purdue University

“Everybody is going to be drawn to what they can see — the tangibles versus the intangibles,” Mallory said. “They see the big body that can move and then you see him catch the ball. If you can take the top off the defense here, you are probably going to be able to do it at each level as you keep moving up.”

Sales began playing football when he was 5.

“What makes me passionate about the sport is it makes me want to play harder seeing my mom happy watching me play,” he said.

To nominate a high school student for Athlete of the Week, contact mark@ youarecurrent.com.

•

• No referral necessary, unless

Lawrence North’s junior wide receiver is a five-star recruit. (Photo courtesy of Lawrence North athletics)

CHS boys tennis team completes unbeaten season

By Mark Ambrogi mark@youarecurrent.com

The Carmel High School boys tennis team was ready for the pressure moments.

The No. 1 Greyhounds completed a 25-0 season Oct. 18 in winning the IHSAA state championship at North Central High School. They edged No. 2 Homestead 3-2 in the title match.

“I think the key to an undefeated season for us was that we were a very deep team with a lot of experience. Our three singles players were all seniors who had all played varsity throughout high school,” said senior Andrew Kim, who played No. 2 singles. “Our No. 1 singles (West Worobel) and one of our No. 1 doubles players (David Liu) were also on the team that won state two years ago, so we were prepared for big moments and big matches.”

Carmel coach Dan Brunette’s fifth state championship as a coach, two with the Greyhounds and three with North Central.

Shankar finished with a 24-1 record. In addition to No. 3 singles, the Greyhounds also earned victories at No. 1 and 2 doubles in straight set in the final. Junior David Liu and sophomore Jade Sangar finished with a 19-3 mark at No. 1 while junior Rajeev Singh and sophomore Andrew Hall had a 14-0 record.

Senior Wes Worobel (25-1) suffered his first loss of the season at No. 1 singles. Kim finished with a 20-6 record.

“It was weird Wes lost that last match because he had beaten that kid twice,” Brunette said. “Our No. 1 doubles team lost the first round to Zionsville and Wes lost the last round possible. We lost in 2023 the same way.”

Kim was awarded the Mental Attitude Award

With the score tied at 2-2, senior Vishal Shankar edged Eric Ji 6-4, 6-4 at No. 3 singles to give Greyhounds the winning point in the state championship match, which was played in the morning Oct. 18 because of the weather forecast. On Oct. 17, the Greyhounds topped No. 15 Avon 4-1 in the quarterfinals and No. 9 Hamilton Southeastern 5-0 in the semifinals.

CHS has won 16 boys state tennis titles, second to North Central’s 21. It was

“The Mental Attitude Award was a huge honor to receive and made that day so much more special for me because it was an unexpected surprise at the same time that I was celebrating the state title together with my team,” Kim said. “It was very encouraging to be recognized for my character and academics in addition to my athletic endeavors.”

Kim, who doesn’t plan to play in college, played No. 3 singles last year.

The Carmel High School’s boys tennis team celebrates its IHSAA state championship. (Photo courtesy of CHS athletics)

Kim

‘WORTH THE WAIT’

Carmel officials explain yearslong delay in debut of Japanese Garden expansion

By Ann Marie Shambaugh AnnMarie@youarecurrent.com

When the City of Carmel demolished four buildings in 2021 to make room for the expansion of the Japanese garden behind City Hall, officials said they expected the project to be substantially complete by the end of that year.

Nearly four years later, gates surround much of the site to keep people out of the construction area. As the first phase nears completion, it’s not clear when the full project will be done.

Several factors have contributed to the delay, including pushback on the initial proposal, the addition of a hands-on garden designer with limited availability, and mounting financial uncertainties.

Carmel Mayor Sue Finkam, who was a member of the Carmel City Council when the project began, is eager to see the final result.

“I’ll admit, I share the community’s impatience that it’s taken longer than we hoped, and the cost overruns are coming at a terrible time,” Finkam said. “I’m deeply grateful to everyone who has worked so diligently to bring this vision to life.”

The project is a collaboration between the city, which funded the purchase and demolition of buildings to expand the pond; Clay Township, which is funding garden design and construction at the north end of the site; and Carmel Clay Parks & Recreation, which will maintain the area and may chip in funds to help complete the first phase.

Clay Township Trustee Paul Hensel, who served on the township board from 2019-2022, said a series of setbacks and unforeseen circumstances, such as the COVID-19 pandemic, have contributed to the delay.

“It’s just the nature of everything that’s had to happen, all the moving parts to get it all to work,” he said.

SLOWING DOWN

The Japanese garden opened in 2009 as Carmel celebrated 15 years of friendship with its Sister City in Japan, Kawachinagano. It includes a sukiya gate assembled by craftsmen who traveled from Japan to install it, as well as a path, sculptures and benches.

A decade later, Clay Township announced it would include improvements to the garden in its Impact Program, a $60 million initiative that provided upgrades to several parks and supported other projects in the city.

Initially, the south end of the garden expansion was set to incorporate elements of Chinese culture as a nod to Carmel’s Sister City relationship with Xiangyang, which became official in 2012. (Carmel ended the partnership in 2024 in response to a new state law.)

However, officials received pushback on the idea, which had grown to incorporate all of Carmel’s Sister Cities, according to Carmel City Councilor Matt Sny-

der, who served on the Clay Township Board in 2019.

“We started down that path with a design and then learned that while Carmel has made great efforts to strengthen relationships with all of these foreign entities, many of them still don’t play well together,” Snyder said. “In an effort to keep the harmony and not create further conflict, (we decided) to go back to just the Japanese garden.”

Clay Township scrapped the original design plans, which Snyder described as “Americanized,” and pivoted to a new plan. The township hired world-renowned designer Hoichi Kurisu, who previously served as landscape director for the Oregon-based Japanese Garden Society, to redesign the garden.

But that meant the project timeline would significantly extend.

“One of the factors that makes (Kurisu’s) gardens so spectacular is that he not only does the design work, but he also personally field directs the placement of every plant, stone and major landscape feature within the garden,” CCPR Director Michael Klitzing said. “Since he designs and constructs gardens worldwide, the construction of the garden has had to work around his availability. While this has prolonged the construction timeline, the end results will be well worth the wait.”

Kurisu did not respond to a request for comment.

Klitzing said Phase 1 of the project, which primarily includes Kurisu’s improvements at the north end of the site, should be complete by the end of the year.

The timeline for the rest of the project, however, remains unknown, as funding to complete it seems to have become unclear.

FUNDING QUESTIONS REMAIN

In 2021, Carmel officials said they expected the expansion project to cost $17 million, with Clay Town-

ship covering approximately $3 million of the cost. The city spent $10.8 million to purchase the now-demolished buildings to make way for the larger pond, which added water retention capacity near a developing area, and contributed funds to expand it.

Funding for what has become Phase 1 fell below the total cost, so Klitzing said CCPR will likely contribute $50,000, which will allow the park to open to the public. The parks board and city council are expected to vote in November on reallocating dollars within CCPR’s general fund to cover the cost.

Beyond that, approximately $150,000 is still needed to complete Phase 1 with enhanced landscaping, Klitzing said.

Previously, the Carmel Redevelopment Commission had considered using funds from impact fees collected for every new dwelling unit constructed in the city to help cover project costs, but that appears to no longer be on the table. In an emailed response to a question from Current about the funds, City of Carmel spokesperson Kate Lustig confirmed CRC funds are not allocated for the garden expansion.

Funding for future phases of the garden has been complicated by Senate Enrolled Act 1, a new state law that reduces property taxes for homeowners while decreasing property tax revenues for local governments.

Klitzing said he expects impact fees generated by continued growth in the city’s core will help fund future phases of the expansion, but he believes city and township dollars “will also likely be needed.” He welcomes other partners interested in helping to fund the project to reach out to CCPR for more information.

ON THE COVER: A pedestrian bridge is among features included in a redesign of the Japanese Garden. Bridge railings must be installed before the garden can reopen.

(Photo by Ann Marie Shambaugh)

The Japanese Garden expansion south of Carmel City Hall includes increasing the size of the pond, a refresh of the northern area by renowned designer Hoichi Kurisu and increased stormwater capacity. (Rendering courtesy of Paul Hensel)

Commentary by Larry Greene

This Windemere home in Carmel underwent a remarkable transformation featuring a sunroom addition, new deck and sunken porch designed for year-round outdoor living.

THE BLUEPRINT

• Replaced the dated deck and concrete patio with a multilevel outdoor retreat that flows seamlessly from the home.

• Added a bright and airy three-seasons room with panoramic windows for natural light and weather-protected comfort.

• Built a spacious new deck ideal for dining, grilling and entertaining.

• Created a cozy sunken porch with integrated seating for relaxing around the fire.

• Unified the design with cohesive finishes and architectural detailing that complement the home’s exterior.

Greene is the owner of Worthington Design & Remodeling (formerly Case). You

You’re Invited

Thursday,

Join us for a night of celebrating the year’s most remarkable stories of rescue and redemption. You’ll enjoy a plated dinner, a silent auction featuring exclusive items and experiences, and so much more!

A Ben & Jerry’s for Carmel

By Sara Palmer news@youarecurrent.com

Carmel is about to get sweeter in December when Ben & Jerry’s opens a Scoop Shop at 1685 E. 116th St. In the spirit of Ben & Jerry’s mission to link business with community good, franchisee Erron Clayton plans to localize that purpose here at home.

“Our local community is what keeps us thriving,” Clayton said. “So, that’s where we’re going to focus our efforts.”

A Lawrence North High School graduate and longtime entrepreneur, Clayton said a business journal article about Ben & Jerry’s stuck with her. When she noticed Indiana didn’t have a Scoop Shop, and given her ties to the area, she decided to launch one in Carmel.

Ben & Jerry’s has a long history of social awareness and community engagement, and Clayton said the Carmel shop will keep that momentum going by supporting local schools, celebrating readers with free cone rewards and pitching in on community-level efforts.

Visitors can expect the full Ben & Jerry’s experience.

“We will be a full Scoop Shop,” Clayton said. “We will have everything that is available to our consumers.”

That includes grocery-store favorites and rotating, shop-only flavors.

“There are tons more flavors that aren’t even sold in the grocery stores. You’re able to enjoy those new flavors that you would never get a chance to because we’ve never had a Scoop Shop here,” she said.

She added that the menu includes ice cream cakes, brownies, cookies and freshmade waffle cones, and doggie treats.

Clayton also highlighted quality and dietary range. Ben & Jerry’s, she said,

brings “super-premium” ice cream and offers kosher-certified flavors. For guests with dietary needs, the shop will post QR codes linking to nutrition and allergen details, with a printed binder available on request.

“We want information to be readily available so that you can make the best choice for your health,” she said.

Options will include dairy-free, sorbet and vegan selections.

Grand-opening festivities are slated for December. Once the ribbon is cut, the shop will be open seven days a week with hours that flex by season. Clayton said the shop will feature neon lighting, including neon clouds and a roughly 6½-foot ice-cream cone, plus a mural in classic Ben & Jerry’s style that nods to the Indiana Pacers, Indianapolis Colts, Indiana Fever, Monument Circle and a possible Indianapolis skyline.

Clayton said she plans additional locations in Westfield, Fishers and Noblesville, with an eye on nearby Zionsville-Boone County and, in time, Marion County.

“My main focus is serving great ice cream, providing a great atmosphere for people to come and enjoy,” Clayton said.

DISPATCHES

 Pence Media Group adds three members – Carmel-based Pence Media Group has added three new professionals to its consultancy business. Samantha Gray joins as a digital marketing professional, bringing over a decade of experience in paid and organic channels. Kelly Asiala is an award-winning public relations specialist focusing on media relations and influencer campaigns. Kassie Green is a content strategist specializing in social media strategy and execution.

 South College hires director for new program – South College Indianapolis hired Dr. Shannon Layton as the director for its new Physician Assistant Studies degree program. Located in Carmel, the program is a 27-month curriculum designed to prepare graduates for physician assistant practice. Layton previously served as a faculty member at South College Nashville. The program aims to address a regional need for advanced healthcare practitioners. For more, visit south.edu/indianapolis.

The storefront at 1685 E. 116th St. where the Carmel Ben & Jerry’s location will open in December. (Photo by Todd Golden)

The Chris Center rebrands to Kindling Minds

news@currentnoblesville.com

The Chris Center, a nonprofit that works to strengthen youth mental wellness in Hamilton County and Marion County schools, announced that it has rebranded to Kindling Minds.

Kindling Minds was created in 2021 as The Chris Center by Nancy Elbert. It was named after Elbert’s brother, Chris Elbert.

“We knew we needed a name that more accurately reflects our mission, work and future, and we also wanted a name that stays true to Chris Elbert’s memory and legacy of compassion, community and empathy,” Kindling Minds Executive Director Sandra Moreira stated.

Moreira said that although the organization rebranded, it has the same mission to help teens and pre-teens in central Indiana build resilience and improve mental wellness through research-informed programs rooted in connection with animals, nature and art.

“We have a new name, but we have the same staff, board and volunteers who truly spark connection and ignite hope,” Moreira stated.

Kindling Minds has three programs in Marion and Hamilton county schools, including Noblesville, Westfield, Fishers and Carmel and served nearly 700 teens and preteens in 2024.

The organization’s PAWS Wellness Support Program teaches and models skills for stress-reduction, joy and social connection through registered dog/ handler teams and encourages students to use the power of the human-animal connection in their own lives.

Its Mindful Arts Program builds mindfulness, connection, self-expression and self-regulation through creative artmaking.

Through a partnership with Stone Farm, Kindling Minds’ Alpaca-Assisted Wellness programming teaches about mindfulness, stress-reduction, empathy and social connection.

For more, visit kindlingminds.org.

Tenor gets rare villain role in Indy Opera

By Mark Ambrogi mark@youarecurrent.com

This will be a rare experience for Ganson Salmon.

“For once in my life as a tenor, I get to play the bad guy,” Salmon said. “Most of the time I’m singing the lover role.”

Salmon plays the Duke of Mantua in Indianapolis Opera’s production of “Rigoletto” Nov. 14-16 at The Tarkington at Allied Solutions Center for the Performing Arts in Carmel. “Rigoletto” features the music of composer Giuseppe Verdi.

“The Duke is a lecherous manipulator and powerful and a cruel guy,” Salmon said. “He uses his power and charm to get what he wants. It’s an interesting character study to step into because it’s much different than just singing sweet love duets. There’s a lot of layers. It’s something that I’m so excited to do.”

The Whitestown resident said it’s a stimulating exercise to play the villain.

“You have to be willing to be disliked by the audience,” he said. “I had the experience in the past when I sang in ‘Madame Butterfly’ and they disliked the naval officer Pinkerton, who leaves the Japanese wife with the child in Japan and marries an American woman. The audience learns to hate Pinkerton so much that they will boo Pinkerton at the end. Though they may not realize, they are booing the nice and kind-hearted opera singer that played this role. From that experience, it helped me learn something from the role of the Duke, that you have to be willing to be disliked.”

Salmon said he loves the music from “Rigoletto”

“Not just the songs that I get to sing but the great duets and arias sung by Rigoletto and his daughter Gilda,” he said.

Mark Rucker plays Rigoletto Nov. 14 and 16. Jose Luis Maldonado plays the role Nov. 15. Brandie Inez Sutton portrays Gilda.

Salmon, an Indianapolis native who

graduated from Heritage Christian School in 2011, began his career as a resident artist with Indianapolis Opera in 2016. The Ball State University graduate, who earned a master’s degree at Mannes School of Music in New York City, had a small supporting role in the Indy Opera production of “Mansfield Park.”

Since then, Salmon said he has been part of numerous Indy Opera concerts, Opera in the Park twice and was in the COVID-19 livestream production of “Madame Butterfly” in November 2020.

“That was with a small orchestra and in front of a very small studio audience in 2021,” Salmon said. “This actually will be my main stage leading role debut with Indianapolis Opera. It’s extraordinarily meaningful to be here at home in Indianapolis with my family and friends and to be singing with this wonderful opera company that I’ve had a fruitful relationship with over the years. It’s time to take stock on how far I’ve come personally and to put on a great show for everybody.”

Salmon said he is thankful his

97-year-old grandmother, Sarah Jane Gradison, will attend “Rigoletto.”

“She supported Indianapolis Opera on its board long before I knew what opera was,” Salmon said. “She still loves hearing about my career and follows it very closely, so I’m so excited to sing in front of her.”

Since moving back to the Indianapolis area during the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020, Salmon can travel to perform in a variety of locations.

“It’s a nice balance, less cost of living and I get to be around my family rather than be in New York City or somewhere else,” said Salmon, who grew up in the Lawrence area.

For more, visit indyopera.org.

IF YOU GO

What: Indianapolis Opera’s production of “Rigoletto”

When: November 14–16

Where: The Tarkington at Allied Solutions Center for the Performing Arts in Carmel Tickets: indyopera.org

‘TOOTSIE’

“Tootsie” runs through Nov. 23 at Beef & Boards Dinner Theatre in Indianapolis. For more, visit beefandboards.com.

‘SPOOKY NIGHT OF COMEDY’

Dave Dugan and Steve Iott will perform “A Spooky Night of Comedy” at 7:30 p.m. Oct. 30 at The Cat, 254 Veterans Way, Carmel. For more, visit thecat.biz.

‘FOUR SEASONS’

The Indianapolis Symphony Orchestra will present Vivaldi’s “Four Seasons” at 7:30 p.m. Oct. 30 at the Payne & Mencias Palladium at Allied Solutions Center for the Performing Arts in Carmel. For more, visit thecenterpresents.org.

FEINSTEIN’S CABARET

Don Farrell will host “Monster Mash: A Night to Dismember!” Oct. 29, followed by “The Magic of David Ranalli” Oct. 30, “Murder Mystery Night” Oct. 31 and “Celebrating Celine” with Jenene Caramielo Nov. 1-2 at Feinstein’s cabaret at Hotel Carmichael in Carmel. For more, visit feinsteinshc.com.

‘YOUNG FRANKENSTEIN’

Actors Theatre of Indiana presents “Young Frankenstein” runs through Nov. 9 at the Studio Theater at Allied Solutions Center for the Performing Arts in Carmel. For more, visit thecenterpresents.org.

‘BUGS BUNNY’

“Bugs Bunny at the Symphony” is set for 8 p.m. Nov. 1 and 2 p.m. Nov. 2 at the Payne & Mencias Palladium at Allied Solutions Center for the Performing Arts in Carmel. For more, visit thecenterpresents.org.

RUMOURS ATL: A FLEETWOOD MAC TRIBUTE

Rumours ATL: A Fleetwood Mac Tribute will perform at 8 p.m. Nov. 14 at Hendricks Live, 200 W. Main St, Plainfield. For more, visit hendrickslive.org.

Ganson Salmon plays the role of the Duke of Mantua in Indianapolis Opera’s production of “Rigoletto.” (Photo courtesy of Ganson Salmon)

Pub features weekly Irish music sessions

By Mark Ambrogi mark@youarecurrent.com

Madeleine Luther was looking for a musical outlet.

The 2013 Carmel High School graduate grew up playing the violin in school orchestras.

The Noblesville resident plays fiddle in the Indianapolis Ceili Band. When she can, she performs with other musicians in a traditional Irish session every Tuesday night at the Brockway Pub in Carmel. The tradition started in 2009.

“I grew up watching Riverdance, which was really popular when I was a kid,” Luther said. “As I was getting older and didn’t want to continue playing classical, I found a fiddle teacher in Carmel, Emily Thompson, and started playing with her. From there, I got into the sessions and Indianapolis Ceili Band. I have two young boys, so I used to come a lot more, but now I come when we’re all able. It’s kind of my escape. I’m a mom and a preschool teacher. This is my hobby that I do for fun.”

shanties and folk tunes.

Noblesville resident Ed Delaney has been a member of the Indianapolis Ceili Band since it started several years. He plays the accordion and concertina, which is a small accordion.

The Ceili Band plays a variety of Irish festivals throughout central Indiana, along with St. Patrick’s Day celebrations, weddings and other shows.

“There are two other sessions in the Indianapolis area that Ceili Band members go to, depending which is closer to their home,” Delaney said. “I’ve played this music since I was a teenager. I play old-time American music and play banjo on the side. But Irish music has always been my thing. The thing that sets the Brockway apart for us is that it’s been a stable home for music for years now. We’ve had lots of people like Jim (Fallis) that showed up and wanted to learn an instrument and how to play with others.”

JOSEPH ROBINETTE

Indianapolis resident Jim Fallis said anyone that has an instrument can play in the session.

“We come and play for the joy of playing,” he said. “I’ve been here nights when we have 35 people come in. We usually have seven to 14. We have several people that do vocals.”

Fallis said the sessions are where he learned to play.

Many of the people who join in the sessions are with the Indianapolis Ceili Band, which Fallis joined a year ago. He plays the mandolin and the tenor banjo. He previously played in a band called Rusty Musket, which performed sea

Alberta Lathan, a north Indianapolis resident, has been with the Ceili Band since the beginning. The rehearsals are held at her house. The Ceili Band traveled to Ireland in August. She also frequently attends the Brockway sessions.

Lathan said it is special “to have a business willing to make space for traditional Irish music at a consistent time, sometimes when they might be very busy. It’s wonderful for people just beginning to play Irish music and they can come and listen.”

Lathan, who plays the flute, has won awards in Irish regional competition for her vocals.

For more, visit Indianapolis Ceili Band on Facebook.

Madeleine Luther plays the fiddle at the Irish session at Brockway Pub in Carmel. (Photo by Mark Ambrogi)

ENTERTAINMENT

‘Happy Birthday’ wins Heartland Film’s top prize

By Mark Ambrogi mark@youarecurrent.com

Heartland International Film Festival showcased more than 100 films, including 19 world/U.S. premieres, 27 regional premieres and seven Special Presentations from major distributors during its Oct. 9-19 run in Indianapolis.

As is often the case, Heartland Film Artistic Director Greg Sorvig said he expects many will draw Academy Award attention.

“Top contenders from our festival include Audience Award winners ‘Nuremberg’ and ‘Rental Family,’” Sorvig said. “Both are starting to make some awards’ season noise. Other major contenders featured at the festival were ‘Blue Moon,’ ‘Sentimental Value,’ ‘The Tale of Silyan” and ‘The Secret Agent,’ and others. ‘Happy Birthday,’ our $20,000 Grand Prize for Best Narrative Feature Award winner, is also the Egyptian entry for this season’s Academy Awards.”

Sorvig said it was a happy surprise that Sarah Goher’s “Happy Birthday” won the Grand Prize.

“She and her husband, Mohamed Diab (“Cairo 678,” 2012), are the first couple to have won the same major top honor with films they separately directed,” Sorvig said. “We are proud of our international slate of winners in this year’s festival.”

The Opening Night film, “Rental Family,” directed by HIKARI from Searchlight Pictures, won the Narrative Special Presentation Audience Choice Award. The Closing Night film, “Nuremberg,” directed by James Vanderbilt from Sony Pictures Classics, received the Overall Narrative Audience Choice Award. The festival presented more than $60,000 in cash prizes to recipients.

The Hoodox Indiana Spotlight Award goes to a film that highlights stories from the Hoosier state or created by filmmakers in Indiana. Director Andie

Redwine accepted the $2,000 Hoodox Indiana Spotlight Award for the world premiere documentary, “The Tenderness Tour.” The film also won the Indiana Spotlight Audience Choice Award. Since 1989, Indianapolis native Richard D. Propes has traveled more than 5,000 miles by wheelchair, raising hundreds of thousands of dollars for charities worldwide in his nationally recognized effort known as the Tenderness Tour. A paraplegic/double amputee with spina bifida, Propes completed the 35th year of the acclaimed event last year. He is the founder and publisher of TheIndependentCritic.com and a member of the Indiana Film Journalists Association.

Propes also is the namesake of two Heartland International Film Festival’s social impact awards. “Comparsa,” directed by Vickie Curtis and Doug Anderson, received the $2,000 Richard D. Propes Documentary Social Impact Award. “Shakti,” directed by Nani Sahra Walker, received the $2,000 Richard D. Propes Narrative Social Impact Award, as well as the $2,500 Best Narrative Premiere Award.

“Jimmy & The Demons,” directed by Cindy Meehl, won the $20,000 Documentary Feature Grand Prize. The documentary followed 79-year-old artist Jimmy Grashow as he poured four years into his magnum opus. He died in September.

DISPATCH

 Etheridge to return to Palladium — Singer-songwriter Melissa Etheridge will have a new album to support when she returns May 3, 2026, to the Allied Solutions Center for the Performing Arts in Carmel. The 7:30 p.m. performance will be Etheridge’s fourth at the Payne & Mencias Palladium and her first since 2018. Tickets start at $55 and can be purchased online at thecenterpresents.org, by phone at 317-8433800, or in person at the Payne & Mencias Palladium’s box office.

OCT. 24 - NOV. 9

Indianapolis resident Richard D. Propes was the subject of the world premiere documentary “The Tenderness Tour.” (Photo courtesy of Heartland Film)

Brian Frost and Julianne Deely-Frost R

CHS presents ‘Dracula’

By Mark Ambrogi mark@youarecurrent.com

Maisan Hasan is used to playing comedic roles, but there is not much funny about the Prince of Darkness.

The Carmel High School sophomore plays the title character in the school’s production of “Dracula” Oct. 30 to Nov. 1 at the school’s Studio Theatre. The shows are at 7 p.m. Oct. 30-31 and 2 and 7 p.m. Nov. 1.

“It’s fun to play like the horror villain,” Hasan said. “It’s fun to play a serious role because I’ve been doing comedy, comedy, comedy forever. I finally got a chance to show my serious acting. I love this adaptation. I think the writing is amazing.”

Senior Aurora Mras plays Lucy.

“I love playing a victim that gets taken over at the end,” Mras said. “It’s fun to play two different sides of a role. I also get to kill Dracula at the end, so the comeback is her being possessed and then killing him in the end. I love the character arc.”

“I’m so excited to put all the costumes and the props together,” she said.

Senior Lainey Weishaar and Camil McGhee are the assistant directors.

“I’m used to being on stage, but being backstage kind of gives me a new perspective and deepened my love for theater,” McGhee said.

Senior Nolan Zircher plays Norbert Briggs, who helps at the insane asylum,

“He gets to display all kinds of emotions on stage. He’s also kind of the comedic relief. He’s got a lot of tragic moments,” Zircher said.

For tickets, visit carmeldrama.org,

Carmel High School cast and production members of “Dracula.” Front, from left are Lainey Weishaar, Camil McGhee, Aurora Mras. Back, from left, Javier Valdiosera, Nolan Zircher, Joaquin Valdiosera and Maisan Hasan. (Photo by Mark Ambrogi)

Editor,

COMMUNITY VOICES

Give kids on e-bikes a break

Give the kids a break. The ones riding e-bikes down the trail, the ones fishing in the neighborhood ponds, the ones out exploring. Give the kids a break. They could be sitting inside glued to screens, lost in games, or doing who knows what online. Instead, they’re outside. They’re learning new things, talking with friends, finding independence, and maybe even discovering what makes them come alive.

Give the kids a break. When you see them flying past on an e-bike, don’t scowl. Wave. Say, “What a great day to be outside.” When you see them casting a line in your pond, don’t shout. Walk over. Ask, “Hey, did you pick up your fishing line?” or “Catch anything good today?” Interact with them. Encourage them. Remember what it felt like to be young and curious.

Give the kids a break. They might not always know where the property lines are, but they know they’d rather be outside than in a basement playing another shoot ’em up game. Isn’t that worth something?

Give the kids a break. Let’s not follow e-bikers home or turn a teachable moment into a confrontation. Let’s remember these are our neighbors’ children. Kids raised by good families who care, kids who want to explore, test limits, and find their way.

Give the kids a break. Talk to them, guide them, appreciate that they’re out in the world instead of hiding from it. Let’s choose patience over anger, kindness over judgment. Because someday, when they’re the ones raising kids here, they’ll remember who gave them a break.

Spotlight on Art helps kids

Editor,

Some work never makes headlines. It shows up quietly — day after day — in gyms, therapy rooms, and court hallways, binding communities together.

Spotlight on Art Benefitting Children — a charitable event that will take place from 5 to 8 p.m. Nov. 6 at Ritz Charles in Carmel — was born to honor that unseen work. Spotlight on Art has raised more than $150,000 for three local organizations: Boys & Girls Club of Noblesville, Prevail Inc., and The Children’s TherAplay Foundation. They are neighbors who walk with our children through their hardest moments.

At the Boys & Girls Club of Noblesville, children are known by name, offered meals and mentored by people

Brandon Wenger, Carmel who believe in them.

Prevail’s work is quieter. They sit with survivors of abuse and help children speak the unspeakable. Through community support they provide care, free of charge — lifelines built on trust and courage.

At Children’s TherAplay, therapy looks like joy. A child on horseback finds balance, strength, and confidence — hope in motion.

People often ask why we do Spotlight on Art. Because art changes things. It opens hearts, bridges beauty and justice, creativity and compassion. When you purchase a painting, you fill more than a wall — you fill a need.

Esther Lakes, Carmel, founder of Spotlight on Art Benefiting Children

Too little or too much?

Commentary by Terry Anker

Walking into his home, one could immediately tell that he was a collector. The walls were lined with shelves and those were lined with beer cans, thousands of them. There were ones from foreign lands. There were ones to commemorate this or that. There were ones no longer manufactured. And there were ones that showed the progressive logo and can design from the early days to the present. Really, there were a lot of beer cans. The collector was delighted to share tales of his decades-long work to assemble the group. For some, he traveled many miles to attend gatherings of the like-minded. There are lectures, meetups and beer celebrity sightings. While many of us wouldn’t fully understand or embrace the project, others loved it just as much as our intrepid collector did.

While lines that distinguish the ethos of collectors from those of the simple accumulators are not abundantly bright, we still seem ready to call out a hoarder for their transgres-

sions and assume ourselves not to be. Minimalist or maximalist, we find the level to which we fill our lives. For many, fewer is better. For others, having one of each example is barely enough. What is it that makes the need so strong?

In his own autobiographical documentary, an heir to a multibillion-dollar fortune complained to his similarly situated father of the boredom that accompanies an inherited life of leisure. Dad admonished the youngster to take up collecting as he’d done, perhaps maps, in the expectation that after a life’s work, he could gift the group to a museum. Wasn’t it his duty? The assembly of objects has long been the purview of the aristocratic class. But is it our desire to be like them or something more shared and deeply human that urges the habit?

Current Publishing will consider verifiable letters of up to 300 words sent in a Microsoft Word document or in the body of an email. Letters may not be of a campaigning or advertising nature. Letters should be exclusive to Current Publishing. Unsigned letters and letters deemed to be of a libelous nature will not be published. Letter writers will be given once-monthly consideration for publication of submissions. Current Publishing reserves the right to end published audience debate on any topic. Current Publishing reserves the right to edit and shorten for space, grammar, style and spelling, and Current may refuse letters. Send submissions to letters@youarecurrent.com; letters sent to any other email address will not be reviewed. Letters must include the writer’s full name, hometown and daytime telephone number for verification purposes only.

Terry Anker is an associate editor of Current Publishing, LLC. You may email him at terry@youarecurrent.com.

0.19 acres at 31 1st Ave NW, Carmel, IN 46032

Parcel # 16-09-25-12-02-027.000

0.20 acres at 0 1st Ave NW, Carmel, IN 46032

Parcel # 16-09-25-12-02-028.000, as further described:

Lots numbered 3 and 10 in Simeon Hawkins Addition to Bethlehem (now Carmel), an addition in Hamilton County, Indiana, as per plat thereof, recorded in Deed Record 30, Page 441 in the Office of the Recorder of Hamilton County, Indiana excepting therefrom the following described property which was conveyed to the City of Carmel Redevelopment Commission by Quitclaim Deed recorded on March 2, 2007 as Instrument No. 2007012511 in the Office of the Recorder of Hamilton County Indiana:

A portion of the property of the Carmel Civic Square Building Corporation

A part of Instrument Number 9006320

May 28, 2006

A part of the Northeast Quarter of Section 25, Township 18 North, Range 3 East of the Second Principal Meridian, Clay Township, Hamilton County, Indiana and also being a port of Lots Numbered Three (3) and Ten (10) in Simeon Hawkins Addition to Bethlehem (now the City of Carmel) recorded in Deed Book 30, page 441 in the Office of the Recorder of Hamilton County, Indiana, more particularly described as follows:

Commencing at the southeastern corner of Lot Numbered Three (3) in said Simeon Hawkins Addition; thence North 00 degrees 01 minutes 47 seconds West (Basis of Bearings assuming the East Line of the Northeast Quarter of said Section 25, Township 18 North. Range 3 East to be North 00 degrees 00 minutes 00 seconds East) 10.00 feet along the eastern line of said Lot 3 to the POINT OF BEGINNING of this description (all of the courses contained within this description are parallel with or perpendicular to said eastern line); thence South 89 degrees 58 minutes 13 seconds West 52.00 feet; thence North 00 degrees 01 minutes 47 seconds West 19.00 feet; thence North 89 degrees 58 minutes 13 seconds East 17.00 feet; thence North 00 degrees 01 minutes 47 seconds West 90.00 feet; thence North 89 degrees 58 minutes 13 seconds East 35.00 feet to the eastern line of said Lot 10; thence South 00 degrees 01 minutes 47 seconds East 109.00 feet along the eastern lines of said Lots 10 and 3 to the POINT OF BEGINNING, containing 0.095 acres (4,138 square feet), more or less.

AND

0.09 acres at 0 1st Ave NW, Carmel, IN 46032 16-09-25-12-02-028.001, as further described:

AND

0.03 acres at 0 Main St, Carmel, IN 46032 16-09-25-12-00-001.000, as further described:

NOTICE OF SALE OF REAL ESTATE

PART OF THE NORTHEAST QUARTER OF SECTION 25, TOWNSHIP 18 NORTH, RANGE 3 EAST, CLAY TOWNSHIP, HAMILTON COUNTY, INDIANA, DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS:

Beginning at the northeast corner of Lot 10 in Simeon Hawkin’s Addition, the plat of which is recorded in Deed Book 30, Page 441, in the Office of the Recorder of said Hamilton County; thence north 89 degrees 15 minutes 24 seconds east a distance of 10.00 feet to the northwest corner of Lot 14 in the original plat of the Town of Bethlehem, the plat of which is recorded in Deed Book “E”, Page 512 in said Recorder’s Office; thence south 00 degrees 01 minute 47 seconds east, along the west line of lots 14 and 13 in said original plat of the Town of Bethlehem, a distance of 131.11 feet to the southwest corner of said lot 13; thence south 89 degrees 12 minutes 04 seconds west a distance of 10.00 feet to the southwest corner of lot 3 in said Simeon Hawkin’s addition; thence north 00 degrees 01 minute 47 seconds west, along the east line of said lots 3 and 10 in said Simeon Hawkin’s addition, a distance of 131.12 feet to the point of beginning.

AND

0.15 acres at 40 W Main St, Carmel, IN 46032 16-09-25-12-02-026.000, as further described:

Part of lot 2 in Simeon Hawkin’s Addition to Bethlehem, now Carmel, described as follows: Begin 25 ½ feet west of the southeast corner of said lot and run west 48 feet; north 132 feet; east 48 feet, south to beginning point, in Hamilton County, Indiana.

Section 25, Township 18, Range 3, Simeon Hawkins lot Pt 2

Subject to easements and restrictions of record.

Notice is given hereby that The City of Carmel Redevelopment Commission (“CRC”) will open and consider written offers of purchase (the “Proposals”) of the parcels of real estate that are depicted as Parcel # 16-09-25-12-02-027.000, Parcel # 16-09-25-12-02-028.000, Parcel # 16-09-25-12-02-028.001, Parcel # 16-09-25-12-00-001.000 (partial), and Parcel # 16-09-25-12-02-026.000 (collectively hereinafter referred to as the “Parcels”). The Parcels are approximately 0.19, 0.20, 0.09, 0.03, and 0.15 acre in size.

CRC will open the Proposals at 6:30 p.m. local time on November 19th, 2025, as part of a Meeting called by the CRC to be held at the Carmel City Hall, One Civic Square, Carmel, Indiana 46032 (the “Public Opening”), unless a Special Meeting is called at a date differing with proper public notice. The Proposals shall be submitted to CRC at One Civic Square, Carmel, Indiana 46032 (“City Hall”). The deadline for submission of Proposals is 5:00 p.m. local time on November 19th, 2025, (the “Receipt Deadline”). At least five days before the Public Opening, interested parties will be able to obtain from the CRC Offices information concerning the room in which the Public Opening will occur.

The offer by CRC of the Parcels for sale is made on the conditions set forth below (the “Conditions for Acquisition”).

Permitted Use: Shall be any mixed-use development with preference given to for-sale condominiums. The project shall (a) have architectural and design characteristics commensurate with the design of other redevelopment projects on Main Street; (b) provide adequate on-site parking for new uses; and (c) provide Storm Water Management for Parcels and coordinate stormwater management system to include surrounding areas and existing City infrastructure coming from properties to the north, west, east and south.

CRC Contribution: CRC is not committing to make any contribution to, or investment in, the Parcels.

Minimum Offering

Price: $2,450,000,, which is the average of two appraisals.

Earnest Money: A non-refundable deposit of $5,000.00 (all of which shall be applicable against the purchase price for the Parcels).

Parcel Condition: The Parcels are being offered on an “as-is” basis.

Current Conditions: The Parcels currently serve as parking lots, vacant office, and parking garages.

Due Diligence: The successful bidder shall be responsible for all costs of due diligence with respect to the Parcels, including, without limitation, costs to: (a) obtain title insurance, a survey, and new or updated environmental reports; and (b) perform tests and inspections.

Acquisition Date: The sale and purchase of the Parcels shall occur

on or before December 17, 2025 (the “Closing Date”), at which time, the successful bidder shall: (a) pay to CRC the purchase price; and (b) acquire fee simple title to the Parcels.

Additional

Requirements: The successful bidder must satisfy the following requirements:

(a) the purchase price shall be paid on the Closing Date; (b) all Proposals shall include proof of available funds; and (c) commit to using the Parcels for the Permitted Use.

Preferential Features: The CRC will give preference to a plan that incorporates surrounding parcels, includes condominiums developed as flats, and includes complementary architecture.

Proposal Requirements: Each Proposal must comply with the requirements of this Notice.

CRC has caused to be prepared the exhibits listed below (the “Exhibits”), and CRC will make all of the Exhibits available at the CRC Offices for examination and use by all interested persons. This Notice, together with the Exhibits, constitutes the “Bid Package”.

Exhibit A Instructions to Bidders

Exhibit B Form Proposal

Exhibit C Outline of Project Agreement

Requests for information concerning the Bid Package or requests for access to inspect the Parcels should be directed to: Henry Mestetsky, Executive Director, Carmel Redevelopment Commission, 580 Veterans Way, Carmel, Indiana 46032; telephone: (317) 819-7207; e-mail hmestetsky@carmel.in.gov. RFP Materials and Exhibits referenced will be made available at this office prior to bids due.

CRC reserves the right to: (a) consider or reject without consideration any Proposals that do not satisfy the Proposal Requirements; (b) reject any or all Proposals; and (c) make an award to the highest and best bidder, as described more particularly in the Bid Package, even if the Proposal submitted by the highest and best bidder does not satisfy all of the Conditions for Acquisition. In determining the highest and best bidder, CRC shall take into consideration the following:

(a) The purchase price for the Parcels, as proposed in each Proposal.

(b) The general business reputation of the bidder.

(c) The experience of the bidder with respect to the operation of projects similar to the bidder’s proposed Permitted Use of the Parcels (the “Similar Projects”).

(d) The proposed pro forma, site plan and abuilding massing.

(e) The record of the bidder with respect to the operation of Similar Projects in compliance with plans, permits, and laws.

(f) The current ability of the bidder to operate the Parcels in compliance with plans, permits, and laws.

(g) The financial resources of the bidder and its principals.

(h) The financial resources of the bidder’s equity investors.

(i) The extent to which the Proposal incorporates the Preferential Features.

Satisfaction by the bidder of the Proposal Requirements, compliance of the bidder with the Conditions for Acquisition, and satisfaction by the bidder of any additional requirements of the Bid Package.

(j) Any other factors that CRC determines to be important in carrying out and serving: (i) the Conditions for Acquisition; (ii) the legal purposes of CRC; and (iii) the interests of The City of Carmel, Indiana, and its residents, from the standpoint of both human and economic welfare.

A successful bidder will be required to execute a binding Project Agreement with CRC that is acceptable to CRC and that commits the bidder to: (a) satisfy the Conditions for Acquisition; and (b) fulfill the commitments made by the bidder in its Proposal. The Project Agreement shall include the terms and conditions outlined on Exhibit C to the Bid Package.

A bid submitted by a trust (as defined in IC 30-4-1-1(a)) must identify each:

Beneficiary of the trust; and

Settlor empowered to revoke or modify the trust.

Dated: 10/28/25 and 11/04/25 The City of Carmel Redevelopment Commission

PUZZLES

1. Group of Girl Scouts

6. Duke Energy electrical unit

9. Part of a barn

13. A2Z Cafe seating option

14. Life story, briefly

15. Mayberry boy

16. It began as Standard Oil of Indiana, then merged with BP in 1998

17. Breakfast drinks, initially

18. Drool catchers

19. ___ Speedwagon

20. Laundry room supply

23. White River angler’s aid

24. Napleton car

25. Parents of Gen-Xers

27. Body part between elbow and wrist

31. It ended 11/11/1918

32. “Terrible” czar

33. Monon Community Center place to play hoops

35. Grayish brown

39. Lower limb

40. Halloween blunder 42. “Ready, ___, go!”

43. Curacao neighbor

45. Scrooge’s cry

46. Author/filmmaker

Vladic

47. Apt. units

49. Quantity held in a large bag

51. Imaginary source of fear

55. Artist Lichtenstein

56. Clean air org.

57. “You got that right!”

59. Navigation letters

62. Exited

64. Poetic tribute

65. Bazbeaux Pizza topping

67. Facts, briefly

68. Zilch

69. No-no

70. Steinbeck novel: “East of ___”

71. Blown Away hair product

72. “Your Movie Sucks” writer DOWN

1. Building beam

2. City on the Tiber

3. Colts shutout, on a scoreboard

4. Non-Rx

5. Fear

6. ISO instrument

7. Muslim veil

8. City on the Moskva

9. Tennis shot

10. Express one’s view

11. Dietary need

12. Fishers HS exams

21. Key ___, Fla. 22. Half Price Books section

24. Barbie’s beau

26. “Mamma ___!”

27. Nike rival

28. Finished

29. Prego alternative

30. “Butt out!,” briefly 34. Butler’s Lacy School advanced degs.

36. B-52 org.

37. Miami County town about 50 miles north of Westfield

38. List-ending abbr.

40. Disney deer

41. Scarlett of Tara

44. Bikini top

46. Fever foe

48. “See ya!”

50. Wolf’s kin

51. Contradict

52. Topple

53. Social faux pas

54. WJJK classic hit

58. Peddle

59. Tease

60. Destitute

61. Bratty kid

63. Freight weight

66. Capture Answers on Page 27

574-398-2135 shidelerjay@gmail.com www.jayspersonalservices.com

Join our exciting and supportive team serving older adults in a non-franchise, local fitness facility. We are looking for an experienced, part-time trainer with the possibility of moving to full-time. Clients are provided, so there is NO SELLING. BA/BS 4-year or greater degree in exercise related field required. If you have a passion for changing the lives of older adults, you will want to be part of our welcoming environment. Send resume and cover letter to info@motion4lifefitness.com

FLAVORS OF FALL

WITH CHEF KARL BENKO

"The inspiration behind Anthony’s Chophouse’s new fall menu was born from collaboration. “It’s truly a team process here,” says Chef Karl Benko. “We have four incredible chefs on-site and everyone brings something unique to the table.”

Together, the culinary team embraces the spirit of the season with heartier fare and bolder flavors - dishes rooted in comfort and depth."

“We try to work seasonality in where it makes sense and not force it,” he says.

“Think of everything that would go into the root cellar of a French home 200 years ago —parsnips, garlic, sweet potatoes, kale, pickled items. Those are the ingredients that inspire us.”

The result is a menu that honors the integrity of the season, blending rustic inspiration with refined technique for an experience that feels both nostalgic and new.

Book your table

anthonyschophouse.com

3uprooftop.com

PRIVATE DINNERS ROOFTOP PARTIES

Holiday events are better at 3UP. Reserve your date now!

Book your private holiday party & secure your preferred date.