TUESDAY May 1, 2007 FREE
Vote. Here’s where. p8
Protect your data. p26
BEFORE ... Kitchen in a breadbox. p29
WHICH do YOU PREFER? We SUPPORT Brainard, Carter, Rider, Sharp, Kirby, Griffiths, Mayo and Piebes and we tell you why. P2
>À>Ê ÀÌ Ê iÀ}iVÞÊ >Ài
WHICH WOULD YOU PREFER?
We SUPPOR T Br ainard, C ar ter, Rid er, Sharp, Kirby, Griffiths, Mayo and P iebes - and we tell you why
Tuesday, May 1, 2007
s a community newspaper, Current in Carmel is deeply invested in our city. Not only do we care about the day-to-day happenings in Carmel, but we care deeply about the quality of life that is the accumulation of our schools, our merchants, our neighborhoods and our local government. Normally, primary elections are party Brainard affairs and the media doesn't involve itself. But in Carmel, the primary election is, in fact, THE election, since the Democratic Party does not have enough adherents to mount any reasonable challenge. For that matter, neither does the Libertarian Party. So, the election on May 8 very much DOES matter. The nominee of the Republican Party essentially will be elected to office, and unless there are political upheavals of tsunaKirby mi status, we will know our leadership for the next four years one week from tonight. We believe that the best interests of Carmel citizens are served by the re-nomination of Mayor Jim Brainard and at-large Carmel City Council candidates Ron Carter and Kevin "Woody" Rider. Our decision is based on the record of the Brainard administration. Since 1995, Brainard has been driven by a commitment to keep the tax rate stable and has been able to cut taxes in 10 of the past 11 years. We were intrigued with the mayor's announcement that he would petition the state to cut the tax rate by 22 percent, a plan that has been approved by the state's Local Government Finance agency. There is no other mayor in the state who has demonstrated such an innovative knowledge of tax law or as bold an approach to cutting taxes. Too, we strongly believe Brainard deserves credit for managing the unprecedented growth in Carmel. While the city has doubled in population during the past four years, and through annexation increased its land size by 100 percent, it is encouraging that the city has been able to manage its budget with a reasonable increase. While Brainard's chief opponent, John Koven, has made the increase in budget one of his campaign issues, we believe that his protest fails the test of truth since he once chaired the Annexation Committee of the city council that increased the size of the city so dramatically. In considering this endorsement, Current in Carmel looked beyond the obvious signs of the Brainard administration, the roundabouts and the Monon Trail. Instead, we looked at the way the mayor works with the other institutions and governmental units in our community, county and state. We very much like what we see in the mayor's active participation in our public schools, his dynamic communication with
the mayor in his past term as a councilman, and he voted for a provision over Brainard's objection that ended up raising municipal property taxes in Carmel by more than 10 percent. That, coupled with votes that diminished the city's ability to communicate with citizens through its cable television channel and its Web site, lead us to conclude that Wilson represents a philosophy and time of government that long since has passed in our city. We have serious questions, if not reservations, about Wilson's vote against Clay Carter Rider Sharp Terrace while at the same time accepting a major contribution from the popular shopping center's major competitor. Carter is an outspoken and often overly candid (which we appreciate) member of our city council, who has shown his commitment to service on the Carmel Redevelopment Commission and as the guiding force behind our Farmers' Market. Carter impresses us with his conservative-but-principled approach to government. Rider, a newcomer to politics but a long-time busiGriffiths Mayo Piebes ness owner in our community, has amazed and enthused us with his commitment to youth, his drive to involve small business in community affairs, and his OPINION: OUR ENDORSEMENTS determination to see the Brainard administration's plans move forward. the school board and administrators. We've also found that he We wholeheartedly support and endorse Carter and Rider. is a strong advocate for our city in his daily negotiations and The former will continue to be and the latter will become dealings with county government and state government, where exceptional stewards of our city, your trust and your pockethe is respected for his innovation and vision. books. We believe you should add to that list city council Our office is in Arts & Design District, at the southeast corincumbents Rick Sharp, Kevin Kirby, Joe Griffiths and Brian ner of East Main Street and South Range Line Road. We've real- Mayo, because each has distinguished himself as a positive ly come to know our merchants and neighbors, and when they contributor to the city's move forward. We also believe Cherie tell us that Koven has visited their businesses and threatened Piebes will make a fine addition to council, and we urge your to stop the redevelopment of the old downtown and fire city consideration of her business, executive leadership and comhall (claims he denies), you have to wonder if his campaign is munication qualities. rational and represents progress or is simply a vendetta against While newspapers with a wider area focus likely will turn his longtime political adversary, Brainard. their attention to races such as those for the presidency and We are endorsing Carter and Kevin "Woody" Rider for difCongress, we are by, for and about Carmel. That is why we are ferent, but we believe equally significant, reasons. The negative endorsing here. That is a commitment we plan to keep in the campaign of incumbent Mark Rattermann, who is running future and a commitment we share with our readers to do our for one of the two at-large seats, seems to be entirely focused part in a community in which we all can take pride. on the city's debt; it doesn't add up when you consider the facts. Rattermann's campaign literature conveniently has left out key facts related to the payment of the debt related to the Performing Arts Center, and he ignores the administration's fiscal plan that shows debt payments without tax increases. Brian Kelly, publisher What's more, his 2003 campaign literature contained his pledge to support parks and trails, yet within one week of taking office and then consistently through his term, Rattermann voted against parks and trail projects. Wayne Wilson, the other candidate for the at-large seat, we believe, doesn't offer the level of leadership that this city needs Steve Greenberg, executive editor to move forward. Wilson decided to end regular meetings with
OUR TAKES OK, here’s the way we roll around here: No vote, no complaints. The primary election is but a week away. In effect, the course our city will take for the next four years will be decided then. Do you care? We know many of you do. Do you vote? We know many of you don’t. Look, there’s no Bush running for office, so maybe this isn’t the sexiest ballot you’ve ever seen. The blather on the nightly news has nothing to do with Koven vs. Brainard (home team always listed second). Perhaps you haven’t been reading the local paper, this one, which has profiled all the council races.
Still, there’s plenty of time to become educated AND motivated enough to get out from behind the desk or off the sofa and go vote. The state graciously gives us from 6 a.m. to 6 p.m. to exercise our right to cast a ballot. Twelve hours, people, and at most it will take one hour of your day – transportation included. A great voter turnout for any election is a wonderful statement. Carmel should lead this state in such. And if you choose to not vote, please also choose to keep quiet about what transpires beyond Inauguration Day.
Blow Your House Down It is our position that C.J.’s Law, recently signed into effect by our own governor, Mitch Daniels, is one government intrusion into our lives that we can support. In effect, House Enrolled Act 1033 requires that all mobile homes installed after June 30th of this year are required to be equipped with severe weather radios. These handy and inexpensive devices provide folks with the advanced warning required to take cover in the event of an imminent tornado. This action came on the heels of a 2005 storm system that took the lives of 25 Hoosiers. Not unlike laws on the books to require the installation and maintenance of affordable smoke detection alarms
in Indiana households, this simple measure will, doubtless, prevent the
VOTE! IT’s YOUR Right
unnecessary loss of life in the years to come. As you read this, the editors at your local newspaper encourage all of us to check the batteries and operating condition of the devices in all our homes and offices designed to protect the lives of us, our families, our coworkers, and the safety personnel who must put themselves at risk to save those not responsible enough to take steps to protect irresponsible others.
CURRENTOON by Tim Campbell Founded Oct. 24, 2006, at Carmel, IN Vol. I, No. 28 Copyright 2007. Current Publishing, LLC All Rights Reserved. 1 South Range Line Road Suite 220 Carmel, IN 46032
Sales Executive – Dennis O’Malia firstname.lastname@example.org / 370.0749 Sales Consultant – Erin Hundley email@example.com / 430.0866 Sales Consultant – Kevin Messmer firstname.lastname@example.org / 513.4359
Bookkeeper - Mary Kamerud email@example.com / 489.4444
Tuesday, May 1, 2007
Publisher – Brian Kelly firstname.lastname@example.org / 414.7879 Executive Editor – Steve Greenberg email@example.com / 847.5022 Associate Editor – Terry Anker firstname.lastname@example.org Content Editor – Jim Lindgren email@example.com Art Director – Tyler Gillaspie firstname.lastname@example.org / 472.3216 Associate Artist – Stefanie Lorenz email@example.com / 340.1836 Reporter – Gus Pearcy firstname.lastname@example.org / 403.6485
No-child plan: wrong
Tuesday, May 1, 2007
4 By Bruce Braden
In the April 17 “Our Takes”, you contend that Carmel should “expect nearly 100 per cent of its graduates to purse (pursue) an accredited four-year college degree.” I disagree. College is not for everyone. Instead, America needs more vocational education classes in high schools and more vo-tech colleges. America needs skilled and educated plumbers, electricians, carpenters, mechanics, computer programmers, etc. Look around Carmel. Look at all the construction past and present. We need people who can build enduring and efﬁcient residential and business structures. Too often, I have heard of, or read about, new homes, businesses, or other newly built structures, which have had immediate problems. The Indianapolis-Marion County Public Library comes to mind. We need service technicians in many areas. Without all these aforementioned nonacademic degree contributors to society, our so-called professionals cannot work. Professionals require structures to work in, tools to work with, and skilled people to keep them in business, whether they be medicine, law, education, politics, media, etc. No Child Left Behind is a terrible concept! It rests on the premise that all children can learn the same things at the same pace. In the age of inclusionary education, this completely ignores the special needs students and their mental, emotional, and behavioral issues that inhibit and/or slow their learning processes. But, non-inclusionary children do not learn at the same pace either. No Child Left Behind ignores the fact that many children begin kindergarten or ﬁrst grade intellectually years behind their peers because not all parents educate their children at home in reading and math fundamentals. In fact, many parents, repeating a process begun when they were preschool children, are uneducated themselves and/or unable or unwilling to teach their own children. Throw in language barriers, like those experienced at Carmel Elementary, and the prospects for failing to meet the irrational No Child goals are likely. It is irrational, then, to blame teachers and schools for failing to catch these kids up fast enough to meet test criteria. Start testing kids as early as ages 2, 3, 4, and 5. Test results will soon reveal that the learning problems of many children exist long before the schools and teachers get a chance to help. I submit that for many children, ﬁrst grade is too late to salvage them. Teachers and schools, try as they might are not to blame in these cases. I favor a complete reformation of high school core curricula and expectations. Since my own high school and college days
1964-1972, I have maintained that students should have sole choice over their own “core curriculum.” Life, even if one lives to age 70, is short. Many students of high school age have enthusiasm and aptitude for certain subjects or careers. High schools and colleges with their core curriculums seem designed to stiﬂe and eradicate enthusiasm rather than nurture it. Even if a student focused solely on history, or psychology, or mythology, or religion, or law, or medicine, said student could not learn everything about the subject in a lifetime. But, our so-called educational system imprisons talent for eight years telling students what’s best for their futures. Yes, a mind is a terrible thing to waste. But, core curriculums guarantee just that......and boredom. Sure, I have had ineffective teachers. But, at times I have been an ineffective student in classes I had no interest in, nor aptitude in. It is time that education pay more heed to the “gifts differing” of each student, rather than focusing on regimentation of robots made “ready” for four years of academic college. Bruce Braden is a Carmel resident. He holds a master’s degree in personality theory and religion.
Customers see your ads
Jill Sowder owner
Westwood Paper Co.
Thank you very, very much. I have had several customers come in and tell me they’ve seen my ads. I appreciate them telling me, and I know you do, too.”
Wanna write us a letter? You can do it a couple ways. The easiest is to e-mail it to email@example.com. The old-fashioned way is to snail mail it to Current in Carmel, 1 South Range LIKES BRAINARD’S VISION Editor: Mayor Jim Brainard is to be thanked for having the vision for Carmel and the courage to act upon that vision. We moved from a lovely home in Marion County to live in Carmel. It’s a move we have not regretted. Mayor Brainard has helped to make Carmel a most desirable place to live. We feel very fortunate to have you as our mayor. All one has to do is look around at all the improvements that have been made. I feel that is why Carmel is growing and property values have grown also.
- Peggy Owen 46032 DIGS OUR SOCCER MOM Editor: I just wanted to let you know how much I am enjoying your newspaper. I look forward to it each Tuesday, especially the articles from one of your newer contributors, Danielle Wilson. I ﬁnd her “soccer mom” humor refreshing.
Line Road, Carmel, IN 46032. Keep letters to 100 words max (we may make exceptions), and be sure to include your home zip code and a daytime number for veriﬁcation. Oddly enough, some newspapers have been hoaxed. Can you believe it? Each week, I can’t wait to see what she has been working on. It’s been great to read what most of us fellow soccer moms are thinking! In the world that we currently live in, she is a gift, being able to bring humor to an otherwise ordinary Tuesday! - Tina Uhland 46032 FUND THE PAC NOW Editor: I have read Current in Carmel since its inception. Thank you for being “local.” As I read, though, I am disappointed and frustrated at the citizens and business owners in Carmel. On Page 11 of the April 10, 2007, issue I see Mayor ( Jim) Brainard begging for money for the Performing Arts Center. C’mon people! If the mayor needed money for a soccer stadium or a football stadium, it would have been paid for by now!
- Julia Keller-Welter 46033
eshm r f e R
(BLUE RIBBON REAL ESTATE BUILDING) 641 N. Rangeline Rd. THURS. May 3 thru SAT. May 5 10:00 - 2:00
Kay’s Ladies Fashions, Art Gallery, Pfister Studio, Massage Therapist, Jewelry, Classes, Gifts, Crafts and More!
566-2905 Presented by Peg Tharp Atherton
s eFsiFrisrtst e m o m C o s s C e s n i s s BouusnitynBeu l C e n o m s r n a h o C J Wehreere Wh
$1 pri2l 2000077 JuAly
4 4 4 4 . 9 8 4 n l o l i t a a C ! m r y l o u f J n i n i g n g i n s i i t r m Co adve r o f iled mogul Automotive r poised le Howard Hub t achievement yet s for his greate
sin , Open 4 Bu le ďŹ ro P ty n u son Co E! PLUS: John ry and MOR to S s s e c c u S
blica s-Leader Pu e im /T g in h lis urrent Pub blication
ma y l t c e r i d n o i licat b u p s s nth. e o n i m s u h b c a y l e y n s a o hi ne g t h e w armel busines T d a e r e a l We to every C
eader A Times-L
u se s, it a l ca m p ie n t h os p en v n rs co to e n 7 0 0 d oc W it h th re m or e th a of ff a st ee l n d s. a m ed ic a rv e y ou r ee s to se y lo p em 0 a n d 4 ,0 0
St Fr an ci sH
os pi ta ls .o
arts fest gains $5,000 grant
Six Hamilton County nonproﬁt organizations have received grants totaling $22,347 from the Hamilton County Convention and Visitors Bureau. Carmel International Arts Festival was awarded $5,000 for advertising and promotion. Noblesville Boys & Girls Club was awarded $3,000 for design and printing of a brochure to promote rental and usage of its basketball facility. Museum of Miniature Houses was awarded $1,847 for advertising in national dollhouse and miniatures craft and collector publications as well as the Indiana State Travel Guide. Sheridan Chamber of Commerce was awarded $2,500 for Web site redesign and marketing efforts for the Sheridan Summer Concert Series. Fishers Freedom Festival was awarded $5,000 to market its annual festival and National Dog Disc Competition. Sister Cities Association of Fishers/Fishers Renaissance Faire was awarded $5,000 for advertising and promotion. Grant money is awarded to qualifying organizations twice each year through the Marketing and Promotions Grant Program. The program assists groups in developing and promoting tourism projects in Hamilton County. Award-winning projects directly impact the community by attracting visitors to the county.
“The ability to lead, including inspiring others in a shared vision.”
Through this shared vision we have also accomplished providing the best city services with a tax rate that is nearly the lowest in the state. The upcoming election is about whether Carmel continues to need and want effective leaders … those who share your vision of keeping Carmel the best place for families to grow and prosper. That is why I ask you to vote for me in this year’s Republican primary for City Council, At-Large
Paid for by the Committee to Elect Kevin “Woody” Rider
Vote for “Woody” • 18 year Carmel resident • Local Small Business Owner (Woody’s Library Restaurant in Old Town) • 9 year member of Chamber of Commerce • Member/Life Group Leader Northview Christian Life Church • Volunteer Children’s Ministry • Continue building a ﬁrst class park system, adding to our network of trails and bike lanes • To forge a stronger alliance with our local businesses and their owners • To ensure safe neighborhoods through well-trained and equipped public safety departments • To act with ﬁscal responsibility to protect our property values and keep our taxes low
The Carmel Professional Fire Fighters, Local 4444
www.CarterForCouncil.com Paid for and authorized by Carter for Council Commitee, Stephanie J. Lewis, Treasurer
Carmel FOP Lodge 185
I respectfully ask for your vote on May 8th
Tuesday, May 1, 2007
Over the past few years I believe I helped inspire you … my neighbors and friends … to share in a vision that is right for Carmel. That vision has included building the Monon Trail, establishing the Farmers Market, revitalizing Old Town Carmel, increasing our park land from forty acres to six hundred including development of the Monon Center and Central Park, and making it possible for our performing arts groups to have a home.
CARMELFEST THEME CHOSEN: “We the People” is the theme for the 19th annual Carmelfest. The 2007 Carmelfest Committee says it’s “why we celebrate the Fourth of July and America’s independence.” The festivities begin in earnest on July 3. From 4 to 10 p.m., booths with games, food, arts and crafts, and information on community organizations will ﬁll Carmel Civic Square. At 7 p.m., the Wright Brothers will take to the stage at the Gazebo. On July 4, the Mayor’s breakfast from 8-10 a.m. kicks off an event-ﬁlled day. The annual parade begins at 10:30 and the booths will be open at Civic Square from noon until 11 p.m. The Carmelfest Symphony Orchestra will begin its concert at the Gazebo at 7:45 and the Carmelfest ﬁreworks will begin at 9:45. For more information go to www.julycarmelfest.com or call 571.2464.
SHOW YOUR SUPPORT WITH A YARD SIGN CALL 847-6970
VOTING DOs AND DON’Ts The primary election is Tuesday, May 8
Polls are open 6 a.m. to 6 p.m. Voters must show a form of government-issued identification to the poll inspector or judge. Acceptable forms of identification include: Driver’s license Passport Military ID Forgetting your ID will nto prohibit you from exercising your democratic right to vote. No ID means you may vote on a provisional ballot, which will nto count until you can carry a form of ID to the Hamilton County Elections Office. Provisional ballots and the ID law were in effect last general election. Absentee ballots are due by May 7.
Tuesday, May 1, 2007
For the handicapped voter, there are voting machines that read the ballot at each polling place. By law, you must “put away” all campaign materials, because such materials are forbidden within 50 feet of the polling place. Of course, this includes buttons and pamphlets, and don’t wear the “Vote for So and So T-shirt. Source: Hamilton County Board of Elections
0201 Briar Creek - Forest Dale Elementary School, 10721 Lakeshore Drive W, gymnasium 0202 Brookshire 01- Mohawk Trails Elementary School, 4242 E 126th St., Community Room 0203 Carmel Meadows - Carmel Elementary School, 101 4th Ave. SE, Lunch Room 0204 Clay Center 1 - The Meeting House at the Village of West Clay, 2000 N New Market St. 0207 Cool Creek North - Smokey Row Road Swim & Tennis Club, 583 Ironwood Drive 0208 Daniel Warren - Carmel United Methodist Church, 621 S Range Line Rd., Front Hall 0209 Eden Brook 01 - First Baptist Church, 1010 E. 126th St., gym 0210 Greensprings - Woodbrook Elementary School, 4311 E 116th Street, gymnasium 0211 Guilford 1 - Friends Church of Carmel, 651 W Main St., Main Hall 0212 Holaday 01 - Hope CMA Church, 2500 E 98th St. Indianapolis, Fellowship Hall 0213 Hunters Trace - Manor House Carmel Care Center, 118 Medical Dr., Sterling Dining Room 0214 Keystone - Forest Dale Elementary School, 10721 Lakeshore Dr. W, gymnasium 0216 Mohawk Hills - Mohawk Hills Clubhouse, 945 Mohawk Hills Drive, Meeting Room 0217 Mt Carmel 01 - Central Christian Church, 1242 W 136th Street, Gym/Rec Room 0220 Rangeline - Carmel Clay Fire Station No. 41, 2 Carmel Civic Square, Training Room 0221 Richland - Old City Meeting Hall, 15 1st Avenue NE, Main Room 0223 White Chapel - Woodbrook Elementary School, 4311 116th Street, gymnasium 0224 Brookfield Crossing - Northview Christian Life Church, 5535 E 131st St., Main Lobby 0225 Woodland - Carmel Clay Fire Station #43, 3242 E 106th St. 0226 Cool Creek South - First Baptist Church, 1010 E 126th Street , gymnasi-
um 0227 Lakewood - Forest Dale Elementary School, 10721 Lakeshore Drive W, gymnasium 0229 Johnson Acres - Carmel High School football stadium, 136th St and Keystone Ave., stadium hospitality room 0230 Eden Brook 02 - First Baptist Church, 1010 E. 126th St., gym 0231 Guilford 2 - Friends Church of Carmel, 651 W. Main St., Main Hall 0232 Stonehedge - Carmel Assembly of God Church, 1017 West Main St., Main Sanctuary 0233 Clay Northwest - City of Carmel Street Dept., 3400 W 131st St., Westfield Break Room 0234 Brookshire North - St. Mark's United Methodist Church, 4780 E 126th St.,Room G/H 0235 Avian - Cherry Tree Elementary School, 13989 Hazel Dell Parkway. 0236 Clay Northeast - Prairie Trace Elementary, 14200 N River Rd. 0237 Arbors - Summer Trace, 12999 N Pennsylvania, Private Dining Room 0238 Blue Creek - Forest Dale Elementary School, 10721 Lakeshore Drive W, gym 0239 Brentwood - Smokey Row Road Swim & Tennis Club, 583 Ironwood Drive, Club House 0240 Holaday 02 - Hope CMA Church, 2500 E 98th St., Indianapolis, Fellowship Hall 0241 Hunters Creek - Central Christian Church, 1242 W 136th St., Fellowship Hall 0242 Kingswood 01 - Woodbrook Elementary School, 4311 E 116th St., gymnasium 0243 Lexington - Carmel Middle School, 300 S Guilford, Auditorium Lobby 0244 Mt Carmel 02 - Central Christian Church, 1242 W 136th Street, Gym/Rec Room 0246 Thistlewood - Central Christian Church, 1242 W 136th Street, Fellowship Hall 0247 Waterford - First Baptist Church, 1010 E 126th St., gym 0248 Woodfield - Carmel Clay Fire Station No. 44, 5032 E Main St., fire truck bay 0249 Woodgate - Carmel High School
football stadium, Smokey Row Road, Home Side, North End, Gate 3, Hospitality Room 0250 Brookshire 02 - Mohawk Trails Elementary School, 4242 E 126th St.,Adult Dining Room 0251 Kingswood 02 - St. Elizabeth Seton Catholic Church, 10655 Haverstick Rd., Social Hall 0252 Springmill Ponds - Carmel Clay Fire Station No. 46, 540 W 136th St., fire truck bay 0253 Copperwood - Christ Community Church, 4770 E 131st St.,Narthex 0254 Meridian - The Retreat Clubhouse, 1661 Sierra Springs Dr., Indianapolis, clubhouse 0255 Hazel Dell - Northview Christian Life Church, 5535 E 131st St., lobby 0257 Clay Center 2 - The Meeting House at the Village of West Clay, 2000 N New Market St. 0258 Bay Hill - St. Elizabeth Seton Catholic Church, 10655 Haverstick Rd., Social Hall 0259 Cherry Tree - Carmel Clay Fire Station No. 44, 5032 E Main St., fire truck bay 0260 Stonewick - St. Elizabeth Seton Catholic Church, 10655 Haverstick Rd., Social Hall 0262 Cheswick - Carmel Clay Fire Station No. 46, 540 W 136th St., fire truck bay 0263 Saddle Creek - Carmel Clay Fire Station No. 46, 540 W 136th St., fire truck bay 0264 Spring Farms - Carmel Clay Fire Station No. 46, 540 W 136th St., fire truck bay 0265 Prairie View - Northview Christian Life Church, 5535 E 131st St., Main Lobby 0266 Clay Center 3 - The Meeting House at the Village of West Clay, 2000 N Market St. 0267 Pleasant Grove 2 - Clay Township Government Center, 10701 N College Ave., Indianapolis Source: Hamilton County Board of Elections
CARMEL’S CANDIDATES FOR ELECTION (i = incumbent. D = Democrat. R = Republican.)
CARMEL CITY COURT JUDGE R - Paul Felix
CARMEL MAYOR D - Henry Winckler R - Jim Brainard (i) R - John R. Koven
CARMEL CITY COUNCIL - DISTRICT 1 D - Sarann Klain Warner R - Rick Sharp (i)
CARMEL CLERK-TREASURER R - Diana Cordray (i)
CARMEL CITY COUNCIL - DISTRICT 2 D - Julie Fernatt R - Kevin Kirby (i) R- Eric Seidensticker R - Drew Williams
CARMEL CITY COUNCIL - DISTRICT 3 D - Robyn Pauker R - John Accetturo R - Richard Leirer R - Brian D. Mayo (i) CARMEL CITY COUNCIL - DISTRICT 4 R - Thomas L. Brooks R - Joe Griffiths (i) R - Martha Roan
CARMEL CITY COUNCIL - DISTRICT 5 D - Mary Carter R - Cherie Piebes R - Lucy Snyder CITY COUNCIL - AT-LARGE - ELECT 2 D - Edward Chu D - John Sullivan R - Ron Carter (i) R - Mark Rattermann (i) R - Kevin "Woody" Rider R - Wayne Wilson
POLICE EVENT RAISES FUNDS: If you are in the mood for a ball and can’t wait for Carmelfest, be sure to check out the 2007 Policeman’s Ball. It will be from 5 to 11 p.m. this Saturday at the Oak Hill Mansion, 5801 E. 116th St.
In the fourth of a series of reports on the May 8 primary election, Current in Carmel reporter Vicki Duncan Gardner caught up with the candidates for city council seats, asking them a series of questions to give the community a sense of where they stand on various issues and topics. Her report:
THE CANDIDATES Cherie Piebes (R) District 5
Luci Snyder (R) District 5
What do you think Carmel should look like in 20 years?
What is the biggest issue facing Carmel, and what would you do about it?
Carmel will continue to be on the forefront of any city its size in the U.S. Given the well planned and proactive vision of our current city ofﬁcials, Carmel will continue to enjoy an outstanding school system, low crime rate, wonderful amenities, premier health care facilities, and a comparatively low and stable tax rate fostered by diverse economic development.
Managing Carmel’s growth. To meet the challenge of steady growth we need to carefully manage debt and spending. We should focus on our public safety system, public services and the increasing infrastructure and trafﬁc management issues needed to support this growth while maintaining our high quality of life.
In 50 years Carmel will be completely built out but because of over 80 years of progressive municipal planning and active citizens willing to work for a better community, we will have excellent schools, attractive neighborhoods, parks/ bikeways and shopping areas that have the added tax support of progressive businesses in both the Meridian Corridor and our attractive business parks. Our excellent design requirements begun in the 1970’s insured that we were a leader in attractive, progressive and livable communities.
As we move toward build-out and a slowing in the growth of assessed valuation, that means ﬂat tax revenues. We must put in place now the infrastructure for an attractive and functioning community. Efﬁcient ﬁscal planning is critical to ensure that we build what we will need and have enough revenue to pay the debt. A ﬁscal plan for capital expenditures that covers the needs of each district and insures that monetary resources can be budgeted must be put in place with input from citizens .I agree with Gov. Daniels that in order to move forward, you don’t raise taxes…you cut out wasteful spending ﬁrst.
FREEDOM BALL KICKS IT OFF: The Carmel Rotary Club will begin celebrating a few days early. On Saturday, June 30, the Rotary Club will host the annual Freedom Ball. The evening gala boasts a martini bar and wine with dinner, a silent auction with locally donated gifts worth thousands of dollars, and dance featuring the music of the Cool City Swing Band. The ball begins at 6 p.m. at the Ritz Charles, and tickets cost $75 per person or $600 for a table of eight. Be sure to get the tickets early because reservations for the black-tieoptional event are limited to the ﬁrst 400 requests. A portion of the proceeds go to local service projects sponsored by the Rotary Club. Last year the silent auction raised $16,000. For more information, go to www.julycarmelfest.com and click on “Freedom Ball.”
city council candidates weigh in
Re-Elect Joe Grifﬁths Carmel City Council District 4
and diligently for the people of the District and will continue to do so when re-elected to a second term on
Tuesday, May 1, 2007
the City Council. I your support and vote on Primary Election Day, Tuesday, May 8, 2007.
www.Joe4Carmel.org “Paid for by the Committee to Re-elect Joe Grifﬁths City Council – District 4“
115 Medical Drive
al D Medic
S. Rangeline Rd.
Car mel D r.
Mon - Fri: 10 - 6 Sat: 10 - 5
Join us May 4th, 5th & 6th for our annual grill promotion. Reps will be here grilling many of your favorite foods to sample.
All grills available in natural or LP gas
Fri & Sat: 10AM - 6PM Sunday: Noon - 5PM
We do custom built-in islands! Mention this ad and receive a FREE BBQ Tool Set & Brass Cleaning Brush with purchase of a grill.
Times running out for our Pre-Season Patio Furniture Sale. Up to 30% OFF through May 31!
Assembly, delivery & installation available: Call for info ...
Also see our outdoor/indoor water fountains, outdoor firepits, grill islands & outdoor furniture. • Woodard
• Rockwood Teak
’m thinking of the Virginia used to learn — Christ, crucifixTech murderer. ion, resurrection — real. We are each of us, It makes the inadequacy of our every human being, made secular-dominated society real. in God’s image (Genesis It’s sad to think that our 1:27). We are inherently good. individual destiny is determined We are also each of us, thanks by our capacity for evil, or that to Adam and Eve, possessed of a our striving for goodness can be heart that is “desperately wicked” defeated so easily by the evil of (Genesis 6:5, Jeremiah 17:9). We a gunman bursting into a busy are inherently evil. classroom. Modern psychology describes Current national statistics complex social and behavioral patindicate 90 percent of American Bob Walters terns, externalizing our individual teenagers are “unchurched.” That Spirituality behavior and removing blame is frightening because they are from our actions. Secular psycholmissing exposure to immensely ogy endeavors to locate blame either in the important concepts like, “do unto others as past, outside of the self, or both; the media you would have them to unto you,” “love your searches for blame where psychology leads it. neighbor” and — critically, a Bible exclusive The Bible describes good and evil in abso- — “love your enemies.” lute personal terms, locates Good in God and Mankind’s great capacity for goodness is Evil in our hearts, and makes us personally revealed when we use our freedom to seek accountable to God and to each other for our God. Our wickedness and evil is when we social and behavioral manifestations. use our freedom to define ourselves as God Pull God out of the equation and psycho(Genesis 3:5). logical description melts into a stew of nonSeek God, or Be God? Which do you think absolutes. Psychology doesn’t like the E-word. was in Seung-Hui Cho’s heart that day? Neither does the mass media. Evil is a hard word to say. It makes Satan Bob Walters (firstname.lastname@example.org), a Carmel resireal. It makes God real. It gives voice to the dent, grieves for the unspeakable loss of young truth of the Bible and the truth of our hearts. lives at Virginia Tech, and cries for their parents. It makes that church stuff nearly everyone His views do not represent this newspaper’s.
WHERE I WORSHIP (and why) Meet The Ayoubs
11 IN SPIRIT
Evil Is as Evil Does
Family Members: Labib, Ragia, Ramez, Patrick Ayoub Residence: Robinbrook Dr. Members of: St. Mary and St. Mark Coptic Orthodox Church in Carmel Why: We belong to the traditional Coptic Church which is based on the teaching of Saint Mark the apostle ,the writer of the second Gospel, who brought Christianity to Egypt and established the Church of Alexandria in about 55 AD. St. Mark structured the church worship, ordained one Bishop and seven Deacons, St. Mark established the famous school of Alexandria and was martyred by the
Romans in 68 AD. As a conservative church the Coptic Church has carefully presented the orthodox Christian Faith in its earliest and purest form handing it down from generation to generation, unaltered and true to the Apsotolic doctrine and patterns of worship. Believing in the Holy Trinity Father, Son and Holy Spirit (being one God) and believing that our Lord, God and Savior Jesus Christ , the true Son of God was incarnate ,born of the virgin Saint Mary died for us on the cross that he may grant us Salvation. Location: 800 E. 110th St. Indianapolis Phone: 848-1791
Tuesday, May 1, 2007 www.currentincarmel.com
CARMEL FIRE FIGHTERS ARE PROUD TO ANNOUNCE PRIMARY ELECTION ENDORSEMENTS Carmel Professional Fire Fighters, Local 4444 have voted to support several incumbents and new candidates in the upcoming Primary Election. All candidates were invited to participate in interviews with Local 4444. The focus of those interviews was public safety and community issues. Local 4444 had a good series of interviews, which were good opportunities to share ideas and get to know the candidates better. The results of the interviews led to the following endorsements:
For For For For For For For
Mayor: James Brainard City Council at Large: Ron Carter and Woody Rider City Council District 1: Rick Sharp City Council District 2: Kevin Kirby City Council District 3: Brian Mayo City Council District 4: Joe Griffiths City Council District 5: Cherie Piebes
Local 4444 is enthusiastic about these candidates and believes that they offer the right ideas for the future of our city and support of our firefighters and fire department. The city has made significant commitments to training and equipment that have the city fire department in the best condition it has ever been in to provide fire protection. For the very first time in the history of the city, our fire department is now fully staffed which has made a big difference in our ability to respond to the citizens of Carmel. Paid for by the Carmel Professional Fire Fighters Political Action Committee
CARMEL HIGH GRADUATES JUNE 3: Carmel High School has confirmed the schedule for graduation for the class of 2007. Ceremonies will take place June 3 at 2 p.m. at Verizon Wireless Music Center, according to Amy Skeens-Benton, one of the school’s administrative assistants. This date and time had been listed as tentative, but Verizon Wireless Music Center officials have confirmed the graduation schedule, Skeens-Benton said. As of April 10, 940 seniors are candidates for graduation.
ulie Criswell would fully completed the 2nd annual like you to take a American Cancer Society Relay For walk. A walk that Life in Carmel. will not deliver you It seems like a long time until to any particular 10 a.m. on June 9, but now is the destination but will keep you walktime to start planning and organizing in a circle. ing your team to raise enough For 24 hours, she will ask you money to conquer the dreaded and 8 to 15 of your friends to keep enemy of the body, cancer. The turning left, each team member oval encircling the football field taking turns heel-and-toeing it, at Carmel High School will be one lap at a time. Julie will make packed with your friends and famsure that you are entertained with ily walking, running, skipping, and Jeff Worrell celebrities, bands and other entermaybe even hopping if they feel so CarmelCan! tainment during each of the 1,440 inclined. The walkers are focused minutes of your circular excursion. on the goal, some are thinking And when the hands of the clock move from about loved ones, but everyone wants to beat 23 hours 59 minutes and 59 seconds to the the enemy. magic 86,400th second, you will have successThree of the more than 50 volunteers are
Jeff Worrell is a local business owner. He recognizes volunteers on “Connecting with Carmel” on Cable Channel 16. Contact him at jworrell@ advantagemedical.com.
Early auto in front of L. J. Small mercantile emporium, NE corner Range Line Rd. and Main St. Photos and information provided by the Carmel Clay Historical Society. To contact the Carmel Clay Historical Society, go to http://www.carmelclayhistory.org or call 317-846-7117. The Monon Depot Museum., at 211 First Street SW (one block south of Main Street on the Monon Trail) is open all year every Tuesday and Wednesday from 9-12, and 1-5. From March through November, it is also open every Friday, Saturday, and Sunday from 1 - 4 p.m. Open at other times by special appointments.
Mommy’s a Potty Mouth word you’re trying to avoid, and that would not be good. So what’s a frazzled mom strung-out on bad language to do? Admitting your problem is of course the first step on your road to recovery. “Hi. My name is Mommy, and I am a Potty Mouth.” Being aware of your addiction will help immensely in reducing the number of times you actually cuss. Enlist the help of family and friends and ask them to tell you when your mouth starts to go down hill. Have them suggest alternative words that are just as strong but not technically “swearing.” Crap is my all-time favorite because apart from being four-letters, it has bite, and can’t get any of my children a detention should they say it in the cafeteria. As a final resort, don’t let your children leave your side. Your sanity might suffer but your mouth will definitely stay clean. The road to good language recovery is long and hard, my fellow moms, but it is a journey we must take for the sake of our children. Just watch out for those f------ potholes; they’re a b----. Danielle Wilson is a Carmel resident and contributing columnist. You may e-mail her at danielle@ currentincarmel.com
ack before I Problem had kids, I is, once I get going, I can’t stop. never used foul Suddenly four-letter words are peplanguage. Oh pering my sentences like commas, sure, maybe and I’m putting NFL players and the occasionally s--- escaped my long-time truckers to shame. And prudish lips if I dropped a large I’m not talkin’ the mild-mannered ceramic bowl on my toes or say, I four-letter words, but the monarchy slammed a non-minivan car door of trash, Queen “C” and King “F”. on my hand, but in general, my Even my sister, who lives in L.A. and mouth was as clean as a pipe in can hold her own with the likes of the Clorox factory. So why did my Howard Stern and Eddie Murphy, words go to hell in a diaperbag as is appalled by my downward spiral Danielle soon as my children were born? into Potty-ville. Help! I’m addicted Wilson I mean, shouldn’t I be the model to swear words and I can’t stop! of G-rated speech now that all At least I’m four of my precious angels can understand not alone. I recently read a Rick Reilly article and regurgitate every single syllable escaping in Sport Illustrated about universities and colmy mouth? leges across the country trying to limit the pro But that’s just it. All day long I censor fanity used at sporting events. One professor’s myself because I am around impressionable advice is to use words that sound bad, but children. I say shoot and darn it and tartar really are meaningless. Like “sock-cucker” for sauce (a shout-out to SpongeBob) instead example. It sounds terribly offensive, but upon of using my grown-up vocab because I don’t closer inspection, it doesn’t refer to anything want my 2-year old repeating a------ at Sunday but a sock being cucked. The only problem school. By the time my husband gets home I with this technique is that if your children do can’t hold it in any longer. I must vent, and if try and mimic one of your made-up swear I really want to feel like an adult again, said word, their memory and articulation may be venting must involve juicy, colorful profanity. just immature enough to actually say the exact
Tuesday, May 1, 2007
HELP WOMEN WITH CANCER: The Indiana Women in Need Foundation Flower Sale will be held from 8 a.m. to 3 p.m. Saturday at 11592 Range Line Road in Carmel and from 10:30 a.m. to 3 p.m. at 7425 Westfield Blvd, Indianapolis. A variety of hanging baskets and potted plants will be available for $25 each. I.W.I.N. works to improve the quality of life of women with breast cancer by relieving some of the stresses and demands of everyday life.
BACK IN THE DAY ...
BUREAU NEEDS VOLUNTEERS: The Hamilton County Convention and Visitors Bureau is seeking volunteers to help it host the 2007 NCAA Division III Men’s Golf Championships May 15-18 at The Hawthorns Golf and Country Club
in Fishers and Prairie View Golf Club in Carmel. This event will feature 35 teams from across the country, in addition to five individual golfers in a 72-hole tournament format. Volunteers must be at least 18 years of age and wear the provided championship logo uniform. To become a volunteer, go to HamiltonCountyTowns.com.
Brooke Weekes, Mary Harshbarger and Annie Lukes. They help promote the event by getting people from their schools to log some laps. Last year they had 30 teams of relayers, and this year the goal jumps by 10. In her eighth season volunteering to make Relay For Life happen, Julie Criswell got started when her dad was diagnosed with prostate cancer. During the first ever Carmel event last year, it rained….and rained….and rained and yet the walkers (imitating ducks) presented the event officials with a giant sized check depicting a giant sized sum of $48,000. WOW! So join in the circle that gives life…..and relay the message to your friends.
CHAMBER SCHEDULES MAY EVENTS: The Carmel Chamber of Commerce will meet for lunch from noon to 1:30 p.m. May 9 at the new Monon Center at Central Park. Reservations are required for this event, which costs $15 for members and $20 for guests. Call 846.1049 or register online at www.carmelchamber.com.
Plan now for cancer walk
A GOLDEN MOMENT FOR LITERACY, CHS STUDENT For Current In Carmel
Melanie Heck, a 16-year-old sophomore at Carmel High School, recently received a gold medal for her focus-on-children project, “Driving Toward Literacy,” at the state Family, Career, and Community Leaders of America state conference. More than 700 FCCLA members participated at this year’s event. During the FCCLA state conference, Heck had to present her display describing the book-drive project and deliver a speech that detailed the project, the implementation and its anticipated impact. She organized a book drive through the FCCLA club at Carmel High School to benefit the library at Head Start of Hamilton County (www.hcheadstart.org). To date, the number of items collected total 1,200, but more are still coming in. As part of the effort, Melanie volunteered her time after school to work with the children at the facility and get to know them and their needs better. The library at the facility has few quality books or videos. Those that they have are older and in poor condition. Because literacy is so important in early education, Heck said she believed the project would be one that would have a positive impact on the students there.
“ It was a really great experience to organize this project and have that amount of responsibility and know we were really making a difference in our community,” said Heck, the daughter of Richard and Nancy Heck. She created flyers describing the book drive to distribute to the classes at CHS, the Carmel Clay Public Library and Carmel City Hall. Messages were created for the morning announcements at the high school and a contest was held between the student resource time classes with a pizza party going to the group collecting the most books. Melanie got the local Papa John’s to donate the pizzas. The project also was awarded a Hamilton County Youth as Resources grant for $525 late last month at the Judicial Center in Noblesville. Heck and the other students in the FCCLA club who assisted her in this project went to Noblesville to accept the grant money. YAR is an agency of the United Way. The money will be used to buy more new books, music CDs and videos for the Head Start Library. Barnes and Noble also has agreed to donate books to the effort, although it wasn’t able to specify the quantity. The FCCLA club (www.fcclainc.org) sponsor at CHS is Brooke Weeks.
Re-elect Rick Sharp
Tuesday, May 1, 2007
Carmel City Council District 1
My Continued Vision for Carmel ...
♦ Business attraction and retention ♦ Continue improving infrastructure ♦ Maintain the high quality of public safety currently delivered ♦ Increase and maintain greenspace within our community
Integrity, Experience, Commitment for Carmel
Vote May 8th
www.sharp2007.com Paid for by Friends of Rick Sharp
Paid for by Friends of Brian Mayo
MIDDLE SCHOOL PLANS 5K: Creekside Middle School will sponsor its fourth annual 5K run and walk through the Village of West Clay at 8:30 a.m. on May 19. The entry fee, which includes a Tshirt, is $15. An entire family may participate for $45. A registration form may be downloaded from www.ccs.k12.in.us/Creekside/ Main.htm by clicking on the “2007 Cat Race Brochure” link. Registrations must be received by May 11 to secure a shirt. For more information, contact Bryce Stewart at 733.6420, ext. 6021, or bstewart@ ccs.k12.in.us.
Becky Kapsalis, aka “Ask Yiayia,” is a certiﬁed parenting coach, mother, mother-in-law, grandmother, speaker and Current In Carmel columnist. She can be reached at 810.9358 or email@example.com.
n editorial in this publication two weeks ago correctly concluded that “failure is not an option” regarding the Carmel Clay Schools. I agree. The “failure” to which the editorial referenced involved Carmel Elementary School “failing” to achieve No Child Left Behind status this year. With more background and research, I am hopeful the editorial writer would have provided readers with a much different conclusion. What exactly was Carmel Elementary School’s failure? Its special education students did not score well enough on the language arts portion of the state exam, commonly referred to as ISTEP. In the other 17 categories that apply to Carmel Elementary, the school met criteria in 16. No Child Left Behind is a somewhat complicated system that requires students in sub groups (white, black, Hispanic, special education, those who quality for free lunch and textbooks, among others) to meet speciﬁc academic standards that increase in each school annually. Within a few years, all student subgroups will have to achieve at the 100 percent level for schools not to be considered NCLB failures. No educator who I know disputes these goals. Certainly, no child ever should be left behind. But to deﬁne one group of students who, with the help of their teachers and parents, worked very hard to pass ISTEP as failures is, in my opinion, inaccurate. The editorial failed to mention that all the other eligible Carmel schools met the No Child Left Behind standards for every sub group. As a matter of fact, of the 252 NCLB categories that apply to the Carmel Clay Schools, 251 were met.
• Lawn Fertilizer & Weed Control • Lawn Insect Control • Bed Mulching & Edging • Spring Clean Up
CALL ROYCE at 428-7223
GreenLawn by Design Professional Lawn & Landscape Ser vice Locally owned & operated by a 20 year Military Vet
Tony Willis is the supervisor of curriculum and communications for the Carmel Clay Schools. Contact him at firstname.lastname@example.org or at 844.9961, ext. 1093.
Show us your latest invoice and we will beat any competitor by up to 30%!
Rather than focusing on Carmel schools achieving 251 of 252 goals – a success rate of 99.6 percent – the Current in Carmel editorial emphasized the one category in which a small group of students was not yet successful. The Tony Willis dedicated, profesOn Schools sional principal, faculty and staff at Carmel Elementary deserved better. Carmel Elementary students and their parents know that their school actually far surpasses state and national academic averages. Readers who would like to know more about No Child Left Behind and how this federal legislation really affects their schools and their children might consider checking out http://www.ed.gov/parents/academic/involve/nclbguide/parentsguide.html.
Tuesday, May 1, 2007
STUDENTS CAN GET VACCINATED: Carmel High School will host a meningococcal vaccine clinic from 3 to 5 p.m. on May 15 in the high school’s community room, which is located in the commons near the South 7 entrance. Visiting Nurse Service will offer vaccines to those who have registered by May 11. Information and registration forms have been mailed home in the high school newsletter. They also are posted on the high school Web site at http://carmelhighschool.net/news/spannon/vns_ form.pdf. The cost of the vaccine is $130. For more information, contact Elaine Martin at 722.8299, ext. 120.
ouble standard! Those words have been bantered about tsince the Don Imus incident. Are we living a double standard of life with our children? Do we expect them to “do as I say, not as I do”? Do we have different sets of behavioral rules for us than for our children? I think I can truthfully say Yes to both of these scenarios. This is where being a Yiayia helps. Looking back on my childraising years, some of my double standards were: I smoked cigarettes but told Becky Kapsalis the children not to. I had Ask YiaYia wine when I was out for dinner and drove home, but told my children not to drink and drive. What disturbs me about double standards, aside from our excusing them, is that we justify them. A serious double standard exists as it pertains to prescribed drugs for our children. Take for instance Dr. David Stein’s opening remarks at a conference in San Francisco on amphetamines as it relates to ADD/ADHD (IA/HM). He states, among other things: “We’re careful about the foods we put in the bodies of our children and then we give them amphetamines (stimulants).” Dr. Stein suggests there are only “two reasons for using amphetamines in children: when well designed non-drug behavioral treatments fail, or when parents don’t want to take the time or effort to learn how to work with their child.” If you’re taking this writing to heart, my hunch is you’re not part of the latter group. Post on Fridge: One Family – One Standard For All!
A dissenting viewpoint
YES, CARA IS A WINNER: Cara Magnabosco of Carmel was awarded a $2,000 college scholarship in the Young Epidemiology Scholars (YES) Competition, one of the nation’s most prestigious and inﬂuential high school science competitions. Cara was among 60 high school students selected out of more than 700 entrants nationwide to compete in the ﬁnals held in Washington, D.C.. The YES Competition, sponsored by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation (RWJF) and administered by the College Board, is designed to spur students’ interest in the ﬁeld of public health, speciﬁcally epidemiology. Cara attends Brebeuf Jesuit Preparatory School.
2007 Mayoral Scorecard “When it comes to fiscal responsibility, Mayor Jim Brainard has delivered strong Republican leadership that is creating positive results.” Here are the facts: ;Carmel has the lowest tax rate of any city in Indiana of our size or larger and the fifth lowest tax rate of the 116 cities in our
state. ;Carmel’s mayor has consistently stated that he is committed to stable property taxes in our city and the facts are that he has consistently cut taxes in the past eleven years. This past month, he was successful in petitioning the state to allow an 18 percent tax rate reduction in our city to offset the increase in property assessments. ;Carmel has an A+ rating by nationally recognized, Standard and Poor’s independent rating agency, one of the highest rates available to a city the size of Carmel. ;Every penny of our debt is part of a fiscal plan that has been in place since 1996 and clearly shows that there will be no tax increases needed to pay the existing debt and operate the city. ;Carmel is one of only a few cities in the state that has fully funded its police and fire pension funds. ;Our water bills are about half of those of our IWC neighbors to the south. ;Our sewer bills were rolled back to 1991 levels and are lower than the day Mayor Brainard took office in spite of inflation. ;We have built a city where businesses come to create high tech, high paying jobs. This has helped establish one of the nation’s healthiest and most diverse tax bases on which to maintain low residential property tax rates. That is no accident. It is the result of sound fiscal planning and management. ;We place value in the quality of life amenities such as excellent parks, trails and our arts programs. We know and accept that these public assets are worthy of our support and nurture. We also know these investments play a vital role in attracting the corporate relocations that bring new jobs to Carmel. ;Carmel’s fiscal management is so respected that it is studied and copied by local governments throughout the state and nation.
The fiscal strength of our city has never been
more solid. I am proud of our record of financial management with consistent tax rate cuts and a plan that will pay for all the improvements that are necessary in our fast growing community without raising taxes. The discussion in this campaign regarding our city debt should focus on the fact that we have had a highly managed fiscal plan in place since 1996 that predicts our revenue and expenses. We have been very careful in keeping our debt tied to property taxes at levels that allow us to keep our tax rate under control and our taxes stable. Our debt as a percentage of assessed valuation, which is the most logical and accurate view of our debt, compares favorably to our neighboring fast-growing communities. Other arguments being made about our city debt are biased and inaccurate. It is important that the city keeps its promise to our new citizens to fix their roads and deliver city services. It is vital that we do so without creating a burden on our entire city. Our plan accomplishes that commitment and ensures a great future for Carmel.
www.brainard2007.com Paid for by the Friends of Jim Brainard Committee
VOTE MAY 8
Mayor James Brainard CARMEL, INDIANA
A per s o na l lett Carm er to el Ci t i z have e ns w expre ho ssed conc ern o ver t nega he tive a t tack my o s of ppon ent.
Dear Friends: I made a pledge to conduct a positive campaign of ideas and thoughtful discussion of Carmel’s future when I decided to run for reelection as your mayor. My opponent, in contrast, has made a number of emotional, inflammatory charges against me and my administration that have some voters questioning how they should vote. Even more troubling to me is the reality that some voters are so upset with my opponent’s attacks that they are planning to stay home on Election Day. That would be a tragic mistake in my opinion. I have decided to answer the charges made by my opponent in order to set the record straight. Here is what you should know. 1. Charges that YOU have paid for the arches in the Arts and Design District are simply not true. The arches that seem to be the focus of my opponent’s campaign are paid for by the businesses that have invested in the District and have built their shops, galleries and restaurants there. My opponent also inflated the cost by over 40% and that is hopefully just a case of not getting his facts straight. 2. You may have received a mailing that attacks the redevelopment effort in the Arts District, specifically the construction of the Lurie Art Gallery. Again, my opponent ignores the fact that the land and building are owned by a division of Stenz Construction who assumes the risk for the development. In addition, the first and second floors plus one of the condominium units have already been sold. The funds for infrastructure improvements are an investment that will actually make a profit for the city from the redevelopment of the area. This is a complicated transaction that has been thoroughly examined and approved by our legal advisors. I encourage everyone to remember the “ghost town” that was Main Street prior to redevelopment. This project is about economic redevelopment, creation of jobs, and how the city working in partnership with the private sector can improve a rundown area and create a new economic engine. 3. My opponent charges that we increased our budget by 45% and that is correct. What he doesn’t tell you is that the city increased in size by over 120% and our population has almost doubled as a result of annexation. You might think that the budget could have doubled, but it didn’t. Not only are we not raising city taxes to pay for the increased service area, but we have realized some economies of scale that are helping to keep our taxes low. Providing full city services to these new areas costs more, but we have revenue from these areas to pay for the services. Because of strong fiscal management, we have limited the growth of the budget. 4. Finally, my opponent focuses on the increase in city debt. You need to know that most of the debt tied to property taxes is used to pay for new roads and improvements in the newly annexed areas of the city. In fact, this accounts for 70 percent of the property tax linked debt which is being paid for by the increased revenue from these newly annexed areas. These funds pay for the promises that were made to the new residents of our city. These promises were made by members of the Council, including my opponent and me. It is important that these commitments be kept. For all of you who have expressed concern over the charges made by my opponent, I trust that my comments will help you understand the facts. If not, I urge you to contact me at my office at 571-2401 or through my campaign email at email@example.com. I want to help you clear up any concerns you may have or answer any questions that this campaign has created. It is a privilege and honor to serve you. I have one more thing to ask of you and that is to make sure that you cast a vote on May 8 to help us keep our city moving forward in a positive and productive direction. Very truly yours,
Mayor Jim Brainard Paid for by the Friends of Jim Brainard Committee
how to be consistent
love Roselli’s pizza. I focus on that. Commit to tell your love it so much that I kids something once, and that if eat there more than they don’t comply, you’ll invoke once a week. Why? The a consequence. Let’s them know pizza is consistently good. the program, and then go for it. No screw-ups, no unpleasant Make a consequence jar, and fill surprises. Whatever they are doing it with slips of paper that have a back there in the kitchen produces consequence written on them. a consistent pizza. (This also removes pressure from As I was munching down on you to think up consequences on the lunch buffet last week, it got the fly.) me thinking, “How can I be more • COURAGE: This isn’t easy, so consistent?” That’s what most of us be tough. If you fall short, shrug Kent Burns strive for in our lives, I think. But it off and get back on your horse. On Success it sure is hard sometimes. So, here There’s another opportunity to are some tips to help you be more be consistent coming at you right consistent. away. • COMMITMENT: If you want to be known as • CELEBRATION: When you are successful a consistent person, the first thing you must in staying true to your course, celebrate. You do is DECIDE to be consistent. As soon as you deserve it. do, you’ll be amazed at the circumstances that For most people, being referred to as “conarise to confront your decision. It’s almost like sistent” is a real compliment. Pick something the universe is saying, “Consistent? You? Yeah, important to you and be consistent to it. You’ll right.” You’ll be tested. I guarantee it. feel better. • CLARIT Y: Be very clear about what you are committing to. You’ll do nothing but Kent Burns is a Carmel resident and partner frustrate yourself (and others) if you aren’t. at MRINETWORK. He is also a professional Perhaps you want to be more consistent in speaker and author of “What’s Your Why?” His disciplining your kids. That’s a great goal, but blog is www.thewhybook.com/blogs and he can be it lacks clarity. Try selecting one element. If reached at firstname.lastname@example.org. you struggle with getting your kids to do what they are told, make that your mission and
Tuesday, May 1, 2007
DISPATCHES FINDING A FINANCIAL PLANNER YOU TRUST: Web sites, including www.fpanet.org and www.napfa.org, can help you find a financial planner in your geographic area, and you might also consider asking friends and relatives if they’ve found a planner they trust. But even if a financial professional comes highly recommended, you owe it to yourself to conduct your own due diligence to ensure that the person is a good fit for you and your goals. — morningstar.com SAVE THE EARTH WHILE DOING LAUNDRY: Whether last month’s Earth Day festivities shamed you into adopting some eco-friendly ways, or simply inspired you to step up your current environmentally conscious regimen, we recommend incorporating Charlie’s Soap into your weekly routine. The all-natural detergent is super-effective at get-
ting out everything from chocolate to pine sap, and it’s also incredibly gentle on clothes, leaving no residue or heavy perfumes. Even better, one little bag cleans 80 loads, so you can save your pennies while saving the world. Charlie’s Soap laundry powder is $12.96 and available at www. charliesoap.com. — style.com BEWARE OF BOGUS HOMEBUYERS: Be on the lookout for these scammers: The Zero-Percent Down Buyer: If your home is setting a selling-price high mark for comparable homes, a mortgage company might find it challenging to appraise your house for buyers with little or no money down. The Bully Buyer: You will be inundated with a list of things that are wrong with house — all while presenting an offer. The inspection process? It will be a nightmare. If you detect a bully, move on. The Sight-Unseen Buyer: You may get an offer from someone who has only seen photos of your house. But that can signal a trick up the sleeve. No one is going to buy a house without seeing it — this buyer just wants to tie up your house to take it off the market and make a decision later.
RICHARD Carmel City Council District 3 Richard will go to “bat” for the citizens of Carmel. Carmel Resident since 1989. Local business owner for 15 years, technology consulting. Boy Scout Leader for 7 years. ay M Carmel Rotary. TE Active member Carmel Lutheran Church. O V Ten Years US Army – two tours in Vietnam. Carmel Dads’ Club volunteer for 15 years, Board Member, Commissioner, and Coach. Ethical, hard-working and a caring neighbor.
“The only independent Republican running for the City Council” Paid for by the Committee to Elect Richard Leirer
WHATâ€™S IT WORTH? By John Pacilio, RE/MAX Ability Plus
$500K â€˘ Type: Traditional â€˘ Age: Built in 1989 â€˘ Location: Near Keystone and 136th Street (Smokey Row) â€˘ Neighborhood: Smokey Hollow â€˘ Square footage: Approximately 5000 square feet (including 1100 in the walk-out basement) â€˘ Rooms: This home offers four bedrooms including a master suite, spacious kitchen with center island and breakfast room, large den, dramatic entry, three-car garage and a ďŹ nished walk-out basement with recreation room, built in bookshelves and a wet bar. â€˘ Strengths: The mature treed lot with green-space behind, three season room, upstairs deck and lovely stone lower level patio with ďŹ re-pit create a perfect retreat for nature lovers. An amazing theater room has been added to the upstairs of the home for the avid family movie night fans. Curb appeal of this home is
outstanding in its class. The impressive structure and rich brick color accentuate the look of this home from the street. This small, one road community, ending with a cul-de-sac, provides a cozy feel. â€˘ Challenges: Tree-line behind the home is a barrier from Keystone trafďŹ c in the summer months. Fall and winter trees are bare and trafďŹ c near the intersection of Smokey Row and Keystone is visible. Luckily the Carmel band is award winning, thus, making evening practice a positive experience. John Pacilio and his team specialize in Carmel real estate with RE/MAX Ability Plus. Contact him at 216.8500 or John@JohnPacilio.com.
Got Poop? We Scoop!
vices, which include laser hair removal, sun damage repair, laser genesis and titan (skin tightening). It also offers Botox and Restylane injections. Services: Khara Spa is a full service spa, providing services such as facials, manicures, pedicures and massages. Its product line features Sonya Dakar Skin Care essentials for anti-aging, acne and maintenance.
Business: Khara Spa Owners: Dr. Dion Chavis, M.D. Location: 12730 Meeting House Road, Village of West Clay Hours: 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. Tuesday, 10 a.m. to 8 p.m. Wednesday, 9 a.m. to 8 p.m. Thursday, 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. Friday, 9 a.m. to 3 p.m. Saturday, closed Saturday and Monday Phone: 844.7706 Website: www.kharaspa.com Specialty: Dr. Chavis is certiďŹ ed in Age Management. The spa offers laser ser-
MONEY MATTERS If you won the lottery or came into a large sum of money, what would you do with it?
â€œI wouldnâ€™t really want to deal with it so Iâ€™d give it to my parents and Iâ€™d probably buy a computer because I love computers.â€? Juhyan Lee, Carmel
â€œI would pay off the house and donate some money to a church.â€?
â€œWe would move to California, buy a bunch of land and some horses. I would also donate a portion of it to help our planet.â€? Zanita Zody, Carmel
Mike Sullivan, Carmel
4IRED OF STEPPING OUT AND STEPPING IN IT 9OU DONT HAVE TO hDOOh THAT STINKY JOB ANY MORE s 0ROFESSIONAL 5NIFORMED )NSURED (ASSLE FREE
,EAVE THE DISGUSTING JOB TO US