Port Phillip Heritage Review, Version 14, 2009
151
Prepared for the City of Port Phillip by Andrew Ward, Architectural Historian
6.11
Carlisle Street (east) - HO 316
Existing Designations: Heritage Council Register: National Estate Register: National Trust Register:
nil nil nil
Description: This Area is situated at the east end of Carlise Street at Hotham Street and encompasses Hawsleigh Avenue. Whilst there is representation from the nineteenth century and Post Federation periods, the Area is dominated by Inter-War structures, most notably the St. Colman’s Catholic Church complex and the walk-up apartments of Carlisle Street and Hawsleigh Avenue. Both the church and church hall are dominant Italian Romanesque Revival structures in red brick and unpainted cement highly representative of the church’s best work of the day. Their gable roofed facades are balanced by pavilions intended to support towers, only one of which has been built, its distinguishing cupola being a local landmark. Both buildings are connected by a high brick wall of the Inter-War period that conceals more recent buildings behind. There are several dominant two storeyed Inter War apartment developments formed around courtyards. They have low front fences and spacious garden settings. “Hawsleigh Court” is in the Mediterranean Style with Tuscan columns to two storeyed loggias facing Hawsleigh Avenue. They are located at the end of wings enclosing a central courtyard. Comparable developments include “Triona Court”, “Hillsden Court” and “Merri Court” whilst others of the period that contribute to its importance are “Waikato” and “Charters Towers”. “Astolat” is a remarkable English Cottage style Inter War apartment complex prominently situated at the Hawsleigh Avenue corner. Its picturesque gabled roofs, tall chimney stacks, half timbering , shingles, porches and ironmongery represent best practice of their time, the extensive use of rustic clinker bricks establishing links with other contemporary buildings, including “Charters Towers” and the Kollel Beth Hatalmud Yehuda Fishman Institute opposite as well as a number of other buildings further afield. There is stylistic diversity here, Georgian fanlights, lancet archways, drip moulds, cast cement lamp posts, Tuscan columns, picturesque roof lines and the heavy handed Romanesque forms of the Catholic Church being typical of elements imparting aesthetic value. The buildings of earlier periods have a subordinate but nevertheless important role. The presence of large nineteenth century villa residences is demonstrated by “Oakview”, recently named presumably after the large oak tree in the expansive front garden, and the “Meryula Guesthouse, defaced at the time of its conversion into a guesthouse but being readily recognizable as a substantial modified Victorian villa. The east side of Hawsleigh Avenue is dominated by Post Federation duplex dwellings with characteristic highly decorated gable ends, fretted verandah ornamentation, casement windows with lead lit upper lights and red brick walls with rough cast banding. Whilst the Inter-War period buildings have survived with a remarkable degree of completeness, changes to the Post Federation period houses include overpainting, the removal of front fences and the replacement of some verandah posts. There are also instances where the formerly pretty cottage front gardens have been paved to accommodate off street parking and one example of a carport built in the diminutive frontage setback.