Cast of Characters Ensemble .........................................................Olivia Bayer Ensemble .................................................Rhys Boatwright Ensemble ............................................. Bailey Broxterman Ensemble; Chadwick........................ Christopher Carter Ensemble; Matthews ............................... Daniel Cooley Ensemble .................................................Marlo D’Ascenzo Ensemble ...........................................Mia Bella D’Ascenzo Ensemble ..............................................................Lily Deye Michael ............................................Anthony Frederickson Jovie ..........................................................Hannah Gregory Ensemble ...................................................... Heather Hale Ensemble .....................................................Austin Harvey Ensemble ..............................................Jackson Higgason Buddy..........................................................A. James Jones Ensemble; Shawanda ...........................Aubrey E. Jones
Ensemble; Charlie......................................... Ethan Marx Store Manager............................Deondra Kamau Means Ensemble .............................................Danielle Muething Ensemble ...............................................Janie Nalbandian Mr. Greenway ...............................................Rodney Neal Ensemble ................................................Maddi O’Connell Walter ........................................................Dain Alan Paige Ensemble ..............................................Brett Gregory Parr Deb.............................................................Joy Rolland-Oba Emily ............................................................. Deb Schubert Ensemble ............................................................Kate Stark Ensemble; Sam ..........................Robert Carlton Stimmel Ensemble ....................................................Michelle Wells Santa .......................................................... John Wenstrup Ensemble .................................................Megan Williams
Understudies: For Matthews, Chadwick, and Sam: Rhys Boatwright; for Walter and Greenway: Daniel Cooley; for Jovie: Heather Hale; for Santa: Rodney Neal; for Buddy: Robert Carlton Stimmel; for Deb and Emily: Megan Williams