*HVW¾R GD YLGD UHVWDQWH
M 118 119
$ DQ¼OLVH GD HVSHUDQÂD GH YLGD PHOKRUD D JHVW¾R GD PDQXWHQ¾R GH PRWRUHV H JHUDGRUHV GH $OWD 7HQV¾R
FLD 8P OHYDQWDPHQWR IHLWR SHOR ,((( UHYHOD TXH GDV IDOKDV GHWHWD GDV GXUDQWH D RSHUD¾R QRUPDO HVW¾R UHODFLR QDGDV FRP RV HQURODPHQWRV HV WDWÎULFRV HQTXDQWR RV QÕPHURV FRU UHVSRQGHQWHV SDUD DV IDOKDV GHWHWDGDV GXUDQWH D PDQXWHQ¾R RX HQVDLRV V¾R VRPHQWH GH *U¼ƬFR 2V YDORUHV FRUUHVSRQ GHQWHV SDUD FKX PDFHLUDV V¾R GH H UHVSHWLYD PHQWH 'DTXL VH FRQFOXL TXH Ä QHFHV
62
7RELDV ±VWHUKROP &DMHWDQ 7 3LQWR $%% 6 $ 7HO )D[ FRPXQLFDFDR FRUSRUDWLYD#SW DEE FRP ZZZ DEE SW
CASE STUDY
V¼ULD XPD PHOKRULD QD FDSDFLGDGH GH SUHYLV¾R GH IDOKDV GRV HQURODPHQWRV SRGHQGR R PÄWRGR /($3 GD $%% SUH HQFKHU XPD ODFXQD FUÈWLFD QR FRQMXQ WR GDV IHUUDPHQ WDV GLVSRQÈYHLV SDUD D PDQXWHQ¾R GRV PRWRUHV H JHUDGRUHV HOÄWULFRV 2 3URJUDPD GH $Q¼OLVH GD (VSHUDQÂD
FRUUHWLYD Ä H[WUHPDPHQWH PRURVD H
GH 9LGD /($3 /LIH ([SHFWDQF\ $QDO\VLV
R RSHUDGRU SRGH VRIUHU ORQJRV H RQH
2 PÄWRGR /($3 WRPD HP FRQVLGHUD
3URJUDP GD $%% XWLOL]D D SUHGL¾R GD
URVRV SHUÈRGRV GH LQGLVSRQLELOLGDGH
¾R R HQYHOKHFLPHQWR GR LVRODPHQWR
YLGD UHVWDQWH GRV HQURODPHQWRV HVWD
&RPR SRGHP WDLV SUREOHPDV VHU SUH
GR HQURODPHQWR HVWDWÎULFR GHYLGR D
WÎULFRV FRPR EDVH GH XP PÄWRGR ÈP
YLVWRV H HYLWDGRV"
IDWRUHV WÄUPLFRV HOÄWULFRV PHF½QLFRV
SDU SDUD D HODERUD¾R GH SODQRV GH PD
H DPEL HQWDLV H HODERUD XPD SUHYLV¾R
QXWHQ¾R SDUD PRWRUHV H JHUDGRUHV GH
$ PHWRGRORJLD /($3 GD $%% SDUD
GR WHPSR GH YLGD FRP XPD SUREDELOL
$OWD 7HQV¾R VXEVWLWXLQGR D XVXDO ƬORVR
PRWR UHV H JHUDGRUHV $7 SRGH FRQV
GDGH GH VHU DWLQJLGD GH 'DTXL UH
ƬD GH PDQXWHQ¾R SUHYHQWLYD RX FRUUH
WLWXLU XPD UHVSRVWD &RP EDVH QXPD
VXOWD TXH RV SODQRV GH PDQXWHQ¾R SR
WLYD SRU XPD GH PDQXWHQ¾R SUHGLWLYD
FRPELQD¾R GH GLYHUVRV WLSRV GH GD
GHP VHU RWL PL]DGRV FRP D UHDOL]D¾R
$ DERUGDJHP /($3 GD $%% SRWHQFLD D
GRV HVWH VHUYLÂR WRUQD SRVVÈYHO DQDOLVDU
GDV DÂÐHV FRUUHWLYDV QHFHVV¼ULDV GXUDQ
H[WHQV¾R GD YLGD GR PRWRU RX JHUDGRU
D FRQGL¾R H R WHPSR HVSHUDGR GH YLGD
WH SDUDJHQV SURJUDPDGDV
SDUD XP UHWRUQR PDLRU GR LQYHVWLPHQ
GH XP HQUROD PHQWR HVWDWÎULFR ¤ XP
WR IRUQHFH LQIRUPD¾R SDUD R F¼OFX
DVSHWR LPSRU WDQWH GR FRQFHLWR GR FLFOR
0DV R PÄWRGR /($3 PDLV GR TXH DSH
OR GH FXVWRV GR FLFOR GH YLGD H RIHUHFH
GH YLGD GH XP JHUDGRU RX PRWRU VH
QDV XP FRQMXQWR GH DÂÐHV GH LQV SH¾R
DLQGD XPD VÎOLGD EDVH SDUD GHFLVÐHV VR
JXQGR R TXDO RV SODQRV GH PDQXWHQ¾R
EUH PDQXWHQ¾R D FXUWR H ORQJR SUD]R
V¾R RWLPL]DGRV GH IRUPD D PD[LPL]DU R
H VREUH D RSHUD¾R RX VXEVWLWXL¾R GH
VHX YDORU SDUD R XWLOL]DGRU *U¼ƬFR
HTXLSDPHQWRV 7RGD HVWD LQIRUPD¾R WUDGX] VH QD PLQLPL]D¾R GD LQGLVSRQL
3RU RXWUDV SDODYUDV D DERUGDJHP /($3
ELOLGDGH Q¾R SODQHDGD H GR QÈYHO GH ULV
GD $%% SHUPLWH XPD PDQXWHQ¾R SUH
FR DXPHQWDQGR D SURGXWLYLGDGH H D UH
GLWLYD RWLPL]DGD GLVSRQLELOL]DQGR D
OD¾R FXVWR HƬF¼FLD
PHOKRU UHOD¾R FXVWR EHQHIÈFLR D ORQ JR SUD]R HP FRPSDUD¾R SRU H[HP
$ HVSHUDQÂD GH YLGD GRV HQURODPHQWRV
SOR FRP XPD HVWUDWÄJLD GH PDQXWHQ
HVWDWÎULFRV Ä XP IDWRU FUXFLDO QR SODQH
¾R SXUDPHQWH FRUUHWLYD
DPHQWR GD PDQXWHQ¾R GRV PRWRUHV H JHUDGRUHV GH $OWD 7HQV¾R $7 H SULQFL LQGXVWULDLV FUÈWLFDV 2V PRWRUHV H JHUD
$6 )$/+$6 '26 *5$1'(6 02725(6
GRUHV $7 V¾R WLSLFDPHQWH SURMHWDGRV H
2V JUDQGHV PRWRUHV H JHUDGRUHV FRP
)LJXUD $V IDOKDV GRV HQURODPHQWRV
IDEULFDGRV » PHGLGD Q¾R H[LVWLQGR QRU
SRWÅQFLDV QRPLQDLV GH 0: H VXSHUL
HVWDWÎULFRV HP PRWRUHV RX JHUDGRUHV $7
PDOPHQWH UHVHUYDV LPHGLDWDPHQWH GLV
RUHV WÅP XPD WD[D UHODWLYDPHQWH PDLV
SRGHP WHU LPSDFWRV PXLWR JUDYHV &RPR
SRQÈYHLV HP FDVR GH IDOKDV LQHVSHUD
HOHYDGD GH IDOKDV GRV HQURODPHQWRV
FRQVHJXH D DERUGDJHP /($3 GD $%% SUHYHU R
GDV (P FRQVHTXÅQFLD D PDQXWHQ¾R
GR TXH RV PRGHORV GH PHQRU SRWÅQ
WHPSR GH YLGD GRV HQURODPHQWRV HVWDWÎULFRV"
SDOPHQWH GRV TXH LQWHJUDP DSOLFDÂÐHV
H[SHULÅQFLD H HP F¼OFXORV TXH XWLOL]DP VRIWZDUH H DOJRULWPRV SURSULHW¼ULRV GH VHQYROYLGRV H UHƬQDGRV SHOD $%% $R ORQJR GRV DQRV D $%% FRQVWUXLX XPD EDVH GH GDGRV GH PHGLÂÐHV H DQ¼OLVHV DEUDQJHQGR PDLV GH PRWRUHV H JHUDGRUHV ORFDOL]DGRV SRU WRGR R PXQ GR D TXDO RIHUHFH XPD VÎOLGD EDVH SDUD D GHWHUPLQD¾R GD FRQGL¾R GH XP HQ URODPHQWR HVWDWÎULFR SDUD D UHDOL]D¾R *U¼ƬFR D 9DULDÂÐHV GD FRUUHQWH DR ORQJR GR WHPSR GXUDQWH HQVDLRV GH FDUJD GHVFDUJD
GH F¼OFXORV GH HVIRUÂR H SDUD D HVWLPD ¾R GD YLGD UHVWDQWH *U¼ƬFR (P FRQVHTXÅQFLD R PÄWRGR /($3 GD $%% Q¾R GHSHQGH GH UHJLVWRV GH PHGL ÂÐHV DQWLJDV UHDOL]DGDV QXP PRWRU RX JHUDGRU HOÄWULFR HVSHFÈƬFR 2V F¼OFXORV H DV DQ¼OLVHV V¾R UHDOL]D GRV SRU SHULWRV GD $%% QR VHX FHQWUR GH H[ FHOÅQFLD /($3 H Q¾R V¾R OLPLWD SHOD $%% 1R ƬQDO RV FOLHQWHV UHFHEHP
GD RFRUUÅQFLD GH GHVFDUJDV SDUFLDLV QR HQURODPHQWR
UHODWÎULRV FRPSOHWRV FRP RV UHVXOWD GRV GDV DQ¼OL VHV UHFRPHQGDÂÐHV SDUD DÂÐHV H XP F¼OFXOR GD YLGD UHVWDQWH 2V FOLHQWHV TXH QHFHVVLWHP GH DSRLR SDUD D LPSOHPHQ WD¾R GDV DÂÐHV UHFRPHQ GDGDV WÅP » VXD GLVSRVL¾R RV UHFXUVRV
CASE STUDY
GRV D PR WRUHV RX JHUDGRUHV IDEULFDGRV *U¼ƬFR E $ XP GDGR QÈYHO GH WHQV¾R HOÄWULFD D FXUYD H[LEH XP MRHOKR FRUUHVSRQGHQWH DR LQÈFLR
HVSDOKDGRV SHOR PXQGR
0$;,0,=$1'2 2 9$/25 2 SURJUDPD /($3 GD $%% IRUQHFH DRV *U¼ƬFR F $WLYLGDGH GH GHVFDUJDV SDUFLDLV FROHWDGD DR ORQJR GH Y¼ULRV FLFORV GH WHQV¾R
RSHUDGRUHV GH PRWRUHV H JHUDGRUHV
*U¼ƬFR 2 /($3 VWDQGDUG FRQWHPSOD PHGLÂÐHV HP && H HP &$
HOÄWULFRV DFHVVR D XPD IHUUDPHQWD GH PDQXWHQ¾R SUHGLWLYD GH HOHYDGD SUH
PD GH UHGX¾R JUDGXDO GH WHQV¾R QDV
$1 /,6(
FLV¾R TXH OKHV SHUPLWH D PD[LPL]D¾R
H[WUHPL GDGHV GDV UDQKXUDV (VWHV GLIH
2 SDVVR GD PHWRGRORJLD /($3 GD $%%
GR YDORU GRV VHXV DWLYRV GH PRWRUHV H
UHQWHV PÄWRGRV GH PHGL¾R DSUHVHQ
D VHJXLU » UHFROKD GRV GDGRV H GD LQIRU
JHUDGRUHV &RP R DXPHQWR GD FULWLFLGD
WDP VREUHSRVLÂÐHV PÕWXDV HP WHUPRV
PD¾R DFLPD UHIHULGD FRQVLVWH QD
GH GR WHPSR GH GLVSRQLELOLGDGH H GRV
GR TXH FRQVHJXHP UHYHODU SR GHQGR
VXD DQ¼OLVH $ SDUWLU GHVVD DQ¼OLVH SR
FXVWRV JHUDLV D VROX¾R /($3 GD $%%
DVVLP D GHWH¾R GH XP GHIHLWR D SDUWLU
GHU VH ¼ REWHU XPD LPDJHP JOREDO GR
DMXGD RV RSHUDGRUHV D DVVHJXUDUHP D
GH XP WLSR GH PHGL¾R VHU FRQ ƬUPDGD
HQURODPHQ WR HVWDWÎULFR FRP EDVH QD
REWHQ¾R GRV VHXV REMHWLYRV M
D SDUWLU GH RXWUR 2V UHVXOWDGRV SRGHP WDPEÄP VHU LQƮXHQFLDGRV SRU IDWRUHV DPELHQWDLV FRPR D WHPSHUDWXUD H D KX PLGDGH RV TXDLV GHYHP VHU WRPD GRV HP FRQVLGHUD¾R $ DQ¼OLVH 3'&$ Ä XP PÄWRGR GH &RU UHQWH &RQWÈQXD && VHQGR RV UHVWDQ WHV PÄWRGRV GH &RUUHQWH $OWHUQDGD &$ 2V HQVDLRV && WÅP XPD PDLRU VHQ VLELOLGDGH »V FRQGLÂÐHV GD VXSHUIÈFLH HQTXDQWR RV HQVDLRV &$ G¾R PDLV LQIRU PD¾R VREUH R LQWHULRU GR LVRODPHQWR
*U¼ƬFR ([WHQV¾R GD YLGD GRV PRWRUHV H JHUDGRUHV HOÄWULFRV
65
GRV PXLWRV FHQWURV GH VHUYLÂR GD $%%