BACHELOR OF SCIENCE (HONOURS) IN ARCHITECTURE THEORIES OF ARCHITECTURE AND URBANISM (ARC61303) SYNOPSIS: REACTION PAPER (AUGUST 2018)
Name: Tan Chin Werng
ID No.: 0324408
Lecturer: Mr. Prince Favis Isip
Tutorial Time: 10-12pm
Reader/Text Title:
Synopsis No: 1A
A Global Sense of Place
Author: Doreen Massey
Regarding the viewpoint of ‘place’, some scholars tend to against the closure and openness of the place. Highlighting the closeness of the place, emphasizing that the place has become a victim of the world, claiming to "defend the place" and resist globalization.(pp.1) But for Massey, the biggest problem with these views is that they define a boundary around the place, distinguish between insiders and outsiders, and construct conflicts between “us” and “them”. (pp.1) A place is constructed by a rich process of social interaction which is a process of constant dynamic change.(pp.7) As instance, 8 years ago, protesters gathered in Guangzhou to protect Cantonese language due to the increasing in the amount of television broadcast in Mandarin.➀ That’s fine in defending their dialect’s uniqueness; but advocating cultural heritage and opposing local and external language are two distinct issues. It is completely immersed in a narrow cultural imagination, and even neglects that Guangzhou’s locality itself is built on the continuous social and cultural connection with the outside world which its dialect is by no means “pure”. As Massey mentioned, the connection and interaction between the local and the external world does not represent the demise of locality. She illustrated this concept with Kilburun.(pp.5-6) People from all over the world come here with their own different cultures, habits and memories. At the same time, they change their place in their own way. The sense of place formed here is no longer a simple sense of community, no obvious exclusivity. Kilburn has gradually formed a new sense of local identity with the inclusive of various cultures; and the cultural elements contained contribute to global culture which has gathered and formed a new one. The place has created both open and closed global sense of place that intertwined. As an end note, author completely abandoned the position of opposing the global and the place, but linked the two in a theoretical framework: a transnational social relation in a communication loop with many other places. Only an improving sense of local can truly promote the integration of society and ultimately promote the advancement and development of society. ➀ Ramzy.A (2010). Protesters Stand Firm on Cantonese Rights. Time. Retrieved at 22 October 2018 from http://content.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,2008060,00.html
Word Count: 353
Mark
Grade
Assessed by:
Date
Page No.