January 24, 2024 by East Bay Publishing

FREE GRAFTING DEMONSTRATION AT THE LIBRARY

CASTRO VALLEY FORUM A COMMUNITY NEWSPAPER SERVING CASTRO VALLEY SINCE 1989

WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 24, 2024

YEAR 36

MAC MEETING RECAP

INSIDE YOUR

FORUM

CV Reads 2024

Annual library program celebrates reading and community discussion

Page 2

Miley vs Esteen Candidates discuss housing, safety and services in debate

Page 3

MAC Critical of State Influence By Amy Sylvestri

CASTRO VALLEY FORUM

At its Monday night meeting, the Castro Valley Municipal Advisory Council (MAC) heard another lengthy update on the Environmental Justice Element (EJE) of the county’s General Plan. The MAC ultimately approved county staff’s work but remained skeptical about the practicality behind this state-mandated action. The EJE is part of the County’s General Plan that focuses on the “priority communities” of Ashland, Cherryland, Hayward Acres,

‘Start of Spring’

Free artists’ reception and brush painting demo this evening

Page 4

INDEX Calendar ................ 5 Classified Ads ........ 8 Crosswords ............. 9 Health & Fitness ... 12 Homes ..................... 6 Obituaries ............. 11 Opinions ............... 10 Our Town ................. 3 Sports .................. 12 Weather ................ 2 WWW.MYCVFORUM.COM

NO. 4

Crime Stats, Mobile Home Protections By Amy Sylvestri

CASTRO VALLEY FORUM

The Castro Valley Municipal Advisory Council (MAC) heard a very brief recap of 2023 crime trends and statistics from the Alameda County Sheriff’s Office at their meeting on January 16. Deputy Ruben Pola told the MAC that his department focused on being proactive and shined a light on the ACSO’s Crime Prevention Unit. “Our mission is to protect and serve, and we do that in a very advanced way here at the Alameda County Sheriff’s Office,” said Pola. “Specifically, our mission is to provide information to businesses and people. To promote a sense of community and response.” He said that the department is trying to focus on “effecting the root cause of crimes” and trying to prevent them from occurring by being out there in the community. Pola also very briefly shared 2023 crime stats during the presentation. In 2023, in Castro Valley, ACSO said there were a total of 482 reported (195 arrested) “person crimes,” including homicide, sex offenses, assaults, and property crimes. There were 1,435 “property crimes” (302 arrested) including robbery, burglary, theft, car theft, vandalism, and stolen property. see MAC on page 10

Alison Sill Embraced Her Competitive Nature By Lowell Hickey

SPECIAL TO THE FORUM

Growing up with two athletic, competitive, older brothers, Alison Sill had two choices: she could ignore sports and her brothers altogether or dig in and compete with them. For Ali (as she prefers to be called) it was an easy choice. “I looked up to my brothers,” she said. “I wanted to be just like them. I wanted to be better than them.” Using her brothers as a driving force, Sill competed in just

Hayward Area Athletic League record with 23 and is 10th in about “every sport you could in scoring in all four seasons career scoring with 49 points name.” She started playing youth soccer when she was five (2001-2004), was a three-time (13 goals, 23 assists). For her years old; she played baseball first-team All-HAAL selection outstanding soccer career, Sill has been elected to the Castro in Castro Valley Little League and two-time Most Valuable Valley Sports Hall of Fame. until she was 12; she swam for Player. the Chabot Swim Club; she Recruited by St. Mary’s, Cal As remarkable as her played softball for the Synergy Poly and Fresno State, Sill ac- individual accomplishments travel team; she even played cepted an athletic scholarship are, perhaps the most striking volleyball one year in middle at Fresno where she continued statistics about Sill’s career are school. to excel. She was second-team the won-loss records of the All-Western Athletic Conteams she played on. Castro By the time Sill reached ference her freshman season Valley High won the HAAL Castro Valley High – where (2005) and first-team All-WAC soccer championship every she lettered in soccer, swimyear she was there. “We rarely ming, and track – she realized all three years after that. A soccer was the sport that would center midfielder, Ali still holds lost,” she conceded. the Bulldogs’ career assists see SILL on page 4 take her farthest. She led the

Alison Sill

2 CASTRO VALLEY FORUM

Wednesday, January 24, 2024

Castro Valley Weather January 24 - January 28, 2024

Wednesday

AM Rain High 60° Low 51°

Thursday

Mostly Sunny High 63° Low 47°

Almanac

Saturday

Friday

Cloudy High 69° Low 53°

Mostly Cloudy High 67° Low 53°

Sunday

Partly Cloudy High 73° Low 54°

Moon Phases

Jan 24

Past Week’s Rain: 02.87 Season To Date: 11.67 Normal To Date: 00.00 Season Average: 00.00

Feb 1

Feb 8

Feb 15

Sun sets at 5:23 p.m. today, rises at 7:16 a.m. Thursday.

mycvforum.com/donate

COMMIT YOUR FAMILY TO BE FIT! Swim Lessons Available for Members Only

Annual CV Library Reading Event Kicks Off Next Month By Linda Sandsmark

CASTRO VALLEY FORUM

astro Valley Library is hosting its seventh annual “Castro Valley Reads” community event, sharing with us the novel The Cold Millions by best-selling author Jess Walter. Free copies of the book will be available to those who register for a book discussion group. “Castro Valley Reads is an opportunity to discuss thoughtful books,” says Dawn Balestreri, Manager of the Castro Valley Library. “But more than that, it is an invitation to come together as a community to grow in our understanding of important ideas and events. Nearly 1,000 community members have accepted our invitation over the past seven years. Will you join us this year?”

and sing along as local horn ensemble fun’SQ plays union songs from the 20th century. There’s no need to register for the kick-off, but please register for a discussion group before attending. Adult Services Librarian Chris Selig explains the reasons The Cold Millions was selected this year. “When we choose a book for CV Reads, we think about what’s happening in the Best-selling author world,” she says. “Last year Jess Walter we saw many people going on strike, including the Hollywood writers, United Auto Registration for the Seventh Workers, college teaching asAnnual Castro Valley Reads sistants, and Kaiser employees. is open now, and a special kick-off event takes place at the There’s a renewed interest in Library on Sunday, February unions, and this book is about 4 at 2 p.m. To register for this a time in Spokane when people event, go to aclibrary.org/cas- were struggling over the ability to even protest. We just love tro-valley-reads/ At the kickoff you can learn this book.” see LIBRARY on page 4 more about The Cold Millions

Health Officials Eying Tiered Ambulance Service Approach current relationship with Falck US expires. While many sick and A basic ambulance ride injured people need a ride to the emergency room, EMS in Alameda County costs $3,664.87, even if you are not Director Lauri McFadden says going to the emergency room, ambulances are frequently used to transport patients according to the Alameda County Health Care Services between facilities or clinics. This may also include 911 Agency (HCSA) website. Patient Navigation Services So, health officials say they like connecting with a doctor are looking at an alternative tiered-service approach to im- or physician for over-the-phone prove service in the county and triage or transporting people help residents avoid high-cost with specialized mental health crises. In some cases, she says, ambulance bills. On January 12, the Agency’s these ambulance rides are not Emergency Medical Services the best care for the patient and can be unnecessarily costly Agency (EMS) announced and ineffective. it will open its ambulance service contract to new bids “We’re doing away with this summer, with the conthe usual one-size-fits-all tract starting in 2026 when its approach, where anyone who By Michael Singer

CASTRO VALLEY FORUM

Yoga w/7 classes a week Indoors & outdoors gym W/40 classes per month of other group exercise classes

New Initiation Fee (January Only) $1500 Family now $650 Save $850 $800 Single now $450 Save $350

JANUARY FREE When you join early and pay for your 1st month dues

CHRISTMAS SPECIAL Christmas/New Year’ s Resolution Special! 2 Free Lockers 1 for each Spouse for 1 year.

FREE MONTH

w/Annual Dues, Pay for 11mo. get 12mo. FREE Offer exp 1/31/2024

Monthly Dues Monthly Dues Families = $289 Singles = $257 *Previous members of 12 months or less are not eligible for this promo. Not to be combined with any other offers.

8 NEW CHAMPIONSHIP PICKLEBALL COURTS

All Club features are included in your monthly dues. Except Babysitting, Swim lessons, Massage and Personal Training

See website “BOVSWIM.COM “ FOR ALL OUR CLASSES AND FEATURES. 1881 Astor Drive-Directions: Lake Chabot Rd. is Open. Use View Drive or Fairmont to Lake Chabot Rd. to Club @ Astor Dr. during construction.

GRAND OPENING IN MARCH 2024

Water House Coming Soon to Castro Valley March 2024

Self service water purification We specialize in Kangan, akaline and purified water Come on in, bring your own jug or purchase a new one from us! 3300 E. Castro Valley Blvd. Ste. D Castro Valley

CROSSWORD PUZZLE ANSWERS

calls 911 for health reasons is transported to an emergency room,” McFadden said. “This new approach will allow our health professionals to support each patient with the care that’s best for them, whether through the emergency room, on-site treatment, or connection to other care outside the emergency response system.” Whichever ambulance company wins the contract, EMS officials say the service must also focus on reducing known disparities in emergency care outcomes for at-risk and historically underserved populations. The new contract also requires the ambulance service to work with EMS, determine specific performance metrics, and be held accountable by the County. “Before we decided to put this contract out to bid, we consulted local EMS partners to help our residents get the timely and high-quality emergency care we all deserve,” said Colleen Chawla, director of the Alameda County Health Care Services Agency. The deadline for applications is August 15 at 2:00 p.m. Pacific. The bid number for the proposal is #HCSA-902023. Applicants are required to attend an information meeting on either February 28 or 29.

CASTRO VALLEY FORUM

Wednesday, January 24, 2024

Sheriff’s Reports COMPILED BY MICHAEL SINGER • CASTRO VALLEY FORUM

Stolen Property Assault with Deadly Weapon Thursday, January 18: at 10:16 Sunday, January 14: at 3:56 p.m., Sheriff’s deputies arrested p.m., a 35-year-old man with a 58-year-old man from Castro no permanent residence Valley on suspicion of assault was arrested on suspicion of possessing stolen property with a deadly weapon. The man was reported in an alter- and violating the terms of his cation in front of a business in parole. Deputies stopped the man for questioning outside the Castro Village Shopping a business on Redwood Road Center wielding a weapon. Deputies handcuffed the man near Jamison Way and discovand took him into custody. The ered he had stolen property in victim was treated at the scene. his backpack. The man was taken into custody. Gun and Drug Arrests PHOTO BY MIKE McGUIRE CV Senior Busted for Wednesday, January 17: at Methamphetamines Candidates for Alameda County supervisor in District 4, which includes Castro 4:00 a.m., two former convicts Sunday, January 14: at 10:00 Valley, squared off at a forum held at the First Presbyterian Church on Saturday, were arrested on illegal gun January 20. From left, incumbent supervisor Nate Miley, challenger Jennifer Es- and drug possession charges a.m., deputies arrested a teen, and moderator Michael Singer, who is also managing editor of the Forum. following a traffic stop at the 74-year-old man from Castro Boulevard and Stanton Avenue. Valley outside a home on Hobert Street near Strobridge AveDeputies stopped the vehicle for a traffic violation but found nue on suspicion of possessing the driver, a 40-year-old man, methamphetamine drugs and related drug paraphernalia. and passenger, a 37-year-old The man was in the yard when woman, with methamphetdeputies responded to a call amine drugs and marijuana support of their organizations. accomplishments in his nearly By Mike McGuire about a disturbance at the illegally packaged for sale 24 years as a member and curHe also gave examples of CASTRO VALLEY FORUM home. Deputies took the man in the vehicle. A search also rent president of the Alameda community programs he has found both suspects had illegal into custody. In the race for the Alameda County Board of Supervisors supported that will hopepossession of concealed and as well as his decade serving fully prevent crime, such as County Supervisor District 4 loaded firearms. The couple on the Oakland City Council. the REACH Ashland Youth seat, candidates Nate Miley was taken to Santa Rita Jail. and Jennifer Esteen debated Esteen focused on her public Center before several hundred people service record as a psychiatric “I really value everything Violated His Probation who braved a rainstorm to at- emergency nurse, community I’ve done for you in the past,” Monday, January 15: at 9:40 tend the event in Castro Valley activist, member of the Eden Miley said to applause. this past Saturday. Voters in Area Municipal Advisory Esteen got her own rounds a.m., deputies arrested a the district will have their say Committee (MAC) and—until of applause when she said there 37-year-old man with no perduring the California primary recently—as the vice chair of was an opportunity for a gener- manent residence on suspicion on March 5. the Alameda Health System ational change in District 4 and of violating the terms of his Long-time incumbent Miley Board. She also called attention that unchanged county policies probation and possessing to what she thinks should have have been a sore spot for some illegal drug paraphernalia. The and challenger Esteen took happened during Miley’s ten- residents such as housing and man was traveling on Castro turns addressing the crowd Valley Boulevard near San with their opening and closing ure, especially in recent years. public transportation. statements as well as their For example, Esteen said “We have a need, and it has Miguel Avenue when deputies stopped him for questioning perspectives on a range of she was running for supervisor not been met for 24 years.” and discovered his stash. Depusubjects including housing and partly due to seeming lawEsteen said. homelessness, public safety, lessness in local communities, see DEBATE on page 5 ties took the man into custody. and county services. particularly along Hegenberger Road and 98th Avenue in The event at the First Oakland. She said that while Presbyterian Church of Contact us for your the county has had a crime preHayward was sponsored by vention strategy for 20 years, it the Castro Valley and Eden Area Chamber of Commerce, has never fully invested in it. the League of Women Voters, Miley countered by touting (PER PERSON) the Smalltown Society, and his work in fighting illegal Lovewell Team the First Presbyterian Church. sideshows, which he said have (CA DRE #00689931, #01912817, #02187163) Castro Valley Forum Manalmost been eliminated in “Lovewell Team” is a dynamic, aging Editor Michael Singer the unincorporated areas. He award-winning Real Estate team moderated. said he continues to support Call 510-351-5555 or visit us at the efforts of law enforcement Miley concentrated on his www.Lovewellteam.com — A team you can love and trust — officers and has enjoyed the long service record and his

Miley, Esteen Square Off

Real Estate Needs

The Entire line of

Tom Nohr CFP®

510-888-7171

Comprehensive Financial Planning For Your Lifestyle in Retirement Since 1986 www.tomnohr.com 20632 Redwood Road Suite E, Castro Valley, CA 94546 Securities offered through Registered Representatives of Cambridge Investment Research, Inc., a broker-dealer member FINRA/SIPC. Advisory services through Cambridge Investment Research Advisors, Inc., a Registered Investment Adviser. Cambridge and Successful Financial Education Workshops are not affiliated.

Since 1969

Garden of Life Products NATURAL FOODS

San Leandro 182 Pelton Center (510) 483-3630 Castro Valley 3446 Village Dr. (510) 581-0220

Restraining Order Violation Saturday, January 13: at 12:36 a.m., a 33-year-old man with no permanent residence was arrested on suspicion of violating a court-issued restraining order and possessing illegal narcotics and related drug paraphernalia. Deputies caught up with the man outside a Castro Village Shopping Center business. The man was handcuffed and taken into custody. Stolen Vehicle Friday, January 12: at 10:29 a.m., deputies pulled over and arrested two people riding around in a stolen vehicle at the intersection of Grove Way and the Interstate 580 offramp. The driver, a 39-year-old man, was charged with driving a stolen vehicle and possession of methamphetamine, fentanyl, and related drug paraphernalia. The passenger, a 51-year-old man, was charged on suspicion of embezzlement. Deputies took the pair to Santa Rita Jail.

4 CASTRO VALLEY FORUM

Wednesday, January 24, 2024

Commit to New Year’s Resolutions

Jared Freiburg Returning to CV Arts Center February 3 to his electrifying show. It is definitely high-octane!” Spinout, a San Francisco-based 3-piece band, joins Jared to salute the big names of the ‘50s and ‘60s. They celebrate Elvis to Sinatra with a healthy serving of Jerry Lee Lewis and the Big Bopper. Jared was born and raised in Des Moines, Iowa. He began playing piano at five under the tutelage of his grandmother. While others his age were listening to pop music of the day, Jared couldn’t get enough of

the oldies. In 2015, he moved to Southern California to study Jazz Performance, but took a detour aboard the Norwegian Getaway to play the role of Jerry Lee Lewis in Million Dollar Quartet, the Tony award-winning musical. Since then, he has toured the world sharing his passion for this rollicking music. For tickets: cvartsfoundation.org or call 510-889-8961. Parking is free. The CV Center for the Arts is located at: 19501 Redwood Road.

Year. These four local artists are members of the Hayward Arts Council, as well as HayThe Hayward Arts Council ward Yueming Art Studio, and Chinese Art Association of (HAC) invites you to attend “The Start of Spring” Exhibi- San Francisco. tion artists’ reception and free On display are ink brushbrush painting demo by artist work paintings, oil, pastel, and Haijing Hu today, Wednesday, colored pencil artworks. The January 24 from 4 to 5:30pm show will be on view until at the Hayward Public Library February 19, 2024. on the second floor. The free art demo on “The Start of Spring” Wednesday, January 24 will showcases the works of Haijing be presented by Hayward artist Hu, Kenka Chu, Pan Yuchuan, Haijing Hu who has a degree and Mingming Liang and is in in Fine Arts from Guangzhou celebration of the Lunar New Academy in Canton China

and more than 20 years of art education experience. Meet and greet the artists on Wednesday, January 24 from 4 to 5:30 pm at Hayward Library Galleries, 888 C street in downtown. “The Start of Spring” Exhibition is co-sponsored by Hayward Public Library and Hayward Arts Council. Visit www. haywardartscouncil.org, call 510-538-2787 or email hac@ haywardartsconcil.org. Winda I. Shimizu is Executive Director of Hayward Arts Council.

By Terry Liebowitz

SPECIAL TO THE FORUM

There’s going to be “a whole lotta shakin’ goin’ on” at the Castro Valley Center for the Arts, Saturday, February 3, at 7:30pm as Jared Freiburg returns by popular demand. Castro Valley Arts Foundation Vice-President Mary Ann DeGrazia is excited that Jared can bring his show back to Castro Valley. “Everyone that saw him in 2022, wanted to invite their family and friends back

‘Spring’ Exhibit, Demo Today By Winda I. Shimizu

SPECIAL TO THE FORUM

How are those New Year’s resolutions going? According to the Fisher College of Business, about 49% of people have dropped their resolution by the end of January. It’s not too late to recommit to your goals with the help of classes at Castro Valley Adult & Career Education (CVACE). Stretch Your Brain. There is a ton of laughter happening in the new Improv classes at CVACE. Not only are these classes fun, but improv can improve your ability to react quickly and ignite your imagination. Spanish classes are another popular choice. Not only will your brain form CLEAN from The Black Excellence Band, new neurons but you will be performing at Cordial Cellars on Wednesday, among people who share your February 7 as part of a special Smalltown LAB. interests. Get Physical. If the cold weather is slowing you down, CVACE has classes to improve your flexibility at any fitness level such as Pilates, Power, TONIGHT! Wednesday, January 24: Creative LAB and Posture, Chair Yoga or Come join the Smalltown crew for a night of creativity. Nice and Easy Fitness. CVACE If you’re looking for a space to brainstorm, read, write, also offers a popular indoor draw, paint and would love to do it around other creatives, Pickleball class that already this is your space. The Clinic @First Pres Hayward will be has full sessions so make sure open at 7pm tonight for an open session. Look for signage to sign up now for later in at and around Trader Joe’s. 2490 Grove Way. Email: info@ Spring. Pair a fitness class with smalltownsociety.com for more details. a nutrition class all about reducing chronic inflammation. Wednesday, February 7: The LAB: featuring It’s positive peer pressure. The Black Excellence @ Cordial Cellar & Lounge Make Beautiful Music. If Join us for a special evening as we bring our LAB to you have always wanted to the public. The Lab is a monthly gathering that allows learn to play an instrument, songwriters and poets to workshop and collaborate on new your chance has arrived with and existing pieces through connection, collaboration and piano and guitar classes. If performances, in front of and among friends. Come spend you are already a musician, the evening with a special performance and then hear from consider joining the Orchestra, local artists in the community as they share their pieces. be Community Band, or Swing a part of the creative process happening in the Eden Area! Band and start performing. Doors open at 7pm. $10 suggested donation. Artists to sign Prepare for a New Career. up and share a piece, email: info@smalltownsociety.com The renowned Medical Academy at CVACE is offering classes in Medical Coding and Billing and Medical Terminology in addition to their handson medical classes. You can be Bulldogs were 5-9-4 the year working in the medical field by continued from front page before Sill arrived and 6-13 the the end of the year. At Fresno State, Sill celyear after she left. ebrated WAC titles with her Whether you want to get new computer skills, get phys- teammates in three of her four That winning spirit can be years and the one year they ical, or just learn something traced back to the front yard of missed (2006) the Bulldogs new, there is great life long her Castro Valley home where were 13-5-3. During Sill’s learning at the adult school. she played all kinds of sports career, Fresno was 47-31-8 Visit: cvadult.org or contact with her two brothers, Ryan Castro Valley Adult & Career overall and 20-4-4 in conand Trevor. ference play. By contrast, the Education at (510) 886-1000. see SILL on back page

Smalltown Events

Sill: Her Winning Spirit

Library: This Year’s CV Reads Program Will Offer Several Additional Activities continued from page 2 She adds that despite the serious topics, including free speech, there is humor in the novel and the writing is lively. There is also violence, reflecting the realities that occur when folks are caught up

in a system of inequality. The Cold Millions tells the tale of two orphaned brothers who are caught up in those turbulent times. One of the characters in the book, Elizabeth Gurley Flynn, was a real “rebel girl” living in the early 20th century.

To add depth to CV Reads this year, several additional activities are planned for readers. College history professor Jane Wolford will give a lecture about Flynn on Saturday, March 23 from 1 to 2:30 p.m. The League of Women Voters

will host a panel discussion about the First Amendment on Tuesday, March 19 from 6 to 7:30 p.m.. A lecture on income equality will be presented by Bill Sokol on Sunday, March 24 from 2 to 3:30 p.m. And on April 14 at 3 p.m.

The Cold Millions author Jess Walter will speak at Castro Valley Center for the Arts, for those participating in CV Reads. Discussion groups designed especially for those in grades 4 to 7 are also scheduled, in addition to those for

adults. Please check the Castro Valley Library website for dates and times. CV Reads is funded by Friends of the Castro Valley Library. To find out more or get involved, please see https:// www.friendsofcvlibrary.org/

CASTRO VALLEY FORUM

Wednesday, January 24, 2024

COMMUNITY CALENDAR Saturday, January 27 Gardening Series: Learning to Graft Join ForestR.org for a demonstration of grafting this Saturday, January 27, from 1 to 4pm at the Castro Valley Library. Grafting is the process of joining two plants into one. Learn of the many reasons to graft plants including the development of hardy and reliable plants, developing new varieties, and creating dwarf specimens. The demonstration will be followed with a scion exchange. Monday, January 29 Free Workshop: Castro Valley Specific Plan Castro Valley City, Inc, will sponsor a free workshop at 5:30 to 7pm, Monday, January 29, at the Castro Valley Library. The topic will be the Castro Valley Specific Plan. Comments will be forwarded to the CV MAC and County Planning Department. We hope to see you there. Tuesday, January 30 Castro Valley Rotary Hosts Aisha Knowles Alameda County Fire Public Information Officer and Office of Education Trustee (area 4), Aisha Knowles, will discuss the Russell City project with CV Rotary Club. A buffet lunch and the program take place at Redwood Canyon Golf Course (17007 Redwood Road, Castro Valley) at 12 noon 1:30pm. The cost of lunch is $20 and reservations must be made by 9pm on Sunday, January 28, by contacting Rotary at cvrotary@iCloud.com or 510-402-5123. More information is available at castrovalleyrotary.org. Saturday, February 3 Jared Freiburg Featuring Spinout There’s going to be “a whole lotta shakin’ goin’ on” at the Castro Valley Center for the Arts, Saturday, February 3, at 7:30pm as Jared Freiburg returns by popular demand. Spinout, a San Francisco-based 3-piece band, joins Jared to salute the big names of the ‘50s and ‘60s. For tickets, visit: castrovalleyartsfoundation.org or call 510-889-8961. Saturday, February 10 Hill and Valley Club Presents Bunco Madness Hill and Valley Club presents Bunco Madness at our clubhouse, 1808 B Street in Hayward. Ticket includes lunch. The event takes place on February 10, 10:30am. Please make your reservation by February 3. Door prizes and Bunco prizes will be awarded. For reservations or info, contact Pat Keathley at 510-461-1321 or pkeathley@icloud. com. Proceeds from this event support local charities. Sunday, February 11 Build Your English Conversation Skills Are you an adult English language learner who would like to build your English conversation skills? The Castro Valley Library is offering a new conversation club each month from 2 pm to 3 pm on Sunday, February 11, and Sunday, March 10. Your can improve your conversation skills by chatting with other people about everyday topics in a friendly, welcoming group. This program is for adults who are advanced beginner and intermediate English speakers. Registration is required. For more info about this and other events, visit: aclibrary.org or call 510-667-7900.

Debate: Mentality; Housing continued from page 3 “We have a need, and it has not been met for 24 years.” Esteen said. The candidates agreed that mental health was a major problem in the county. Miley said it would be his top priority if re-elected, adding that dealing with it effectively would make an impact on other issues, such as homelessness. Esteen said that much of the mental health care the county provides is at the Santa Rita Jail, where a high proportion of inmates suffer from mental health problems and where there have been a high number of inmate deaths. She called for moving much of that care from the jail to the community. “People don’t get cured in jail. They get cured in the community,” she said. Miley called for providing good mental health care in the jail. He said he didn’t want people with mental health problems in jail, but the county is required to give them mental health care if they are there. Esteen called for fighting homelessness in part by keeping people in their current homes. She called on the supervisors to pass tenant protections that were introduced when the county lifted its pandemic evictions moratorium. That effort failed due to abstentions by supervisors in February of last year. Miley said he wanted protections both for tenants and for small landlords. He said he opposed the eviction moratorium because he saw it as overly broad, not being closely linked to COVID. Miley said he supports Proposition 1 on the March ballot for homeless services and housing. He added he supports wraparound services for the homeless as well as providing them housing. Each candidate was asked what they would do about the frequent business complaint of permitting delays in the unincorporated areas for new or expanding businesses. see DEBATE on page 10

PHOTO COURTESY OF PALOMARES PRINCIPAL DR. JENNIFER TOMITA

Palomares’ Young Authors

Palomares students participated in the Bri Books National Young Authors Fair. BriBooks aims to publish one million books authored by children for children. Students used the free BriBooks writing platform and were able to write their own stories. The books were then published via Amazon, enabling family and friends to purchase copies of the published books. Students even earned some royalties. The students in the picture are holding their published books. Palomares also earned a Literary Leadership award. Six Palomares Hawks were in the top 50 National Best Selling Authors. Third grader Naya Gayrard was one of ten Jury Award winners for her book, “The Girl in the Treehouse.”

Homes

6 CASTRO VALLEY FORUM

Wednesday, January 24, 2024

REAL ESTATE GALLERY

Five Keys to Setting an Effective List Price

considerations when looking to set the correct list price: All square footage is not etting the price for the same. a home hitting the Supposing the home market is an inexact down the street with an science with any number identical square footage of factors going into the just sold – the temptation is equation. Subsequently, with to use that selling price as the current market as hot as the bar for your sale. While it is due to limited inventory, the data is important, other sellers are often tempted to factors must be included: price their home too high, Location – was it in a better potentially warding off sig- part of the neighborhood? nificant numbers of buyers. Condition – was it in better Here are five important or worse condition than By Carl Medford, CRS Special to the Forum

RECENT HOME SALES

Castro Valley —————————

18965 Patton Drive 94546: $882,000 [3 BD - 966 SF - 1948 4124 Nichandros Street 94546: $1,100,000 [5 BD - 1,878 SF - 1957 18801 Carlton Avenue 94546: $1,215,000 [3 BD - 2,236 SF - 1988 4551 Edwards Lane 94546: $1,220,000 [3 BD - 1,409 SF - 1984 19524 Barlow Court 94546: $1,225,000 [4 BD - 2,000 SF - 1960 22150 West Lyndon Loop 94552: $1,300,000 [3 BD - 2,328 SF - 2000 5110 Stone Canyon Drive 94552: $1,750,000 [3 BD - 2,334 SF - 2000 TOTAL SALES: 7 LOWEST AMOUNT: $882,000 MEDIAN AMOUNT: HIGHEST AMOUNT: $1,750,000 AVERAGE AMOUN

$1,220,000 $1,241,714

Hayward ————————-------

25512 Custom Drive 94544: $477,500 24328 Dover Lane 94541: $580,000 [2 BD - 1,208 SF - 1978 2022 Oak Creek Place 94541: $625,000 [2 BD - 1,542 SF - 1972 518 Simon Street 94541: $725,000 [2 BD - 1,013 SF - 1940 325 Lansing Way 94541: $750,000 [1,544 SF - 1900 1764 East Avenue 94541: $810,000 [3 BD - 1,570 SF - 1987 2463 Columbine Drive 94545: $872,000 [3 BD - 1,284 SF - 1974 26147 Danforth Lane 94545: $895,000 [5 BD - 1,199 SF - 1960 2643 Ocala Street 94545: $895,000 [3 BD - 1,368 SF - 1957 1277 Mcbride Lane 94544: $1,000,000 [3 BD - 1,834 SF - 1954 27141 Fielding Drive 94542: $1,010,000 [3 BD - 2,247 SF - 1986 2088 Trafalgar Avenue 94545: $1,200,000 [1,870 SF - 1960 21780 Meekland Avenue 94541: $1,200,000 [2 BD - 968 SF - 1928 27956 Edgecliff Way 94542: $1,250,000 [3 BD - 2,614 SF - 1968 22694 Valley View Drive 94541: $1,400,000 [5 BD - 2,520 SF - 1947 27991 Edgecliff Way 94542: $1,500,000 [5 BD - 2,164 SF - 1969 TOTAL SALES: 16 LOWEST AMOUNT: $477,500 HIGHEST AMOUNT: $1,500,000

MEDIAN AMOUNT: AVERAGE AMOUN

$895,000 $949,343

San Leandro ————————-------

1268 136th Avenue 94578: $400,000 [3 BD - 1,132 SF - 1949 2472 Belvedere Avenue 94577: $600,000 [2 BD - 1,108 SF - 1972 16526 Ehle Street 94578: $610,000 [2 BD - 672 SF - 1962 1699 Mono Avenue 94578: $750,000 [2 BD - 1,273 SF - 1952 15380 Laverne Drive 94579: $750,000 [3 BD - 1,347 SF - 1956 1943 Charlotte Avenue 94577: $785,000 [3 BD - 1,477 SF - 1944 15038 Wengate Street 94579: $830,000 [3 BD - 1,174 SF - 1954 14136 Santiago Road 94577: $850,000 [3 BD - 1,184 SF - 1962 1364 Linton Street 94577: $850,000 [3 BD - 1,104 SF - 1952 1657 Renaissance Lane 94578: $855,000 [4 BD - 1,708 SF - 2004 16326 Ridgehaven Drive #604 94578: $909,000 [4 BD - 1,930 SF - 2019 14297 Tiburon Road 94577: $923,000 [3 BD - 1,630 SF - 1963 1063 Victoria Avenue 94577: $1,025,000 [3 BD - 1,824 SF - 2006 2400 Prosperity Way 94578: $1,120,000 [3 BD - 2,120 SF - 1955 2351 Rocky Point Court 94579: $1,300,000 [3 BD - 2,066 SF - 1999 201 Warwick Avenue 94577: $1,650,000 [3 BD - 2,584 SF - 1946 TOTAL SALES: 16 LOWEST AMOUNT: $400,000 HIGHEST AMOUNT: $1,650,000

MEDIAN AMOUNT: AVERAGE AMOUN

$850,000 $887,937

yours? Amenities – did it have a pool? Better view? Nicer landscaping? Improvements – did it have newly remodeled bathrooms or kitchen? Flooring? 4097 Krolop Road • Castro Valley Age matters In areas where home ages An entertainer’s dream on a private street in one of CV’s most desirable areas! This completely vary, buyers tend to preredone 5 bed/3.5 bath 2,897 sqft home has it all. No expense was spared! fer newer homes over old. • Gorgeously remodeled chef’s kitchen with too many upgrades to list! While two homes may have similar square footage, room • Wide-plank hardwood flooring throughout • Formal living area plus family room count and lot size, newer ,• Dramatic, sweeping staircase homes may bring higher • Two primary suites prices. The one exception Matt Wilhite • Beautifully remodeled bathrooms to this would be historic Realtor • Detached structure in backyard, ideal for office or gym neighborhoods. DRE# 01828342 Location is critical • Side-yard access 510.329.0728 The old adage Location, • ADU potential in converted third car garage www.MattWilhite.com Location, Location is true. • Proctor Elementary School district The better the home’s situation, the higher the price, especially in areas where the © 2019 King Features Synd., Inc. view includes water or some next door is a dump, you HOROSCOPE by Salomé other attractive feature. will unfortunately seldom ARIES (March 21 to April 19): Is that Arian self-esteem in need of shoring Multiple stories detract up? Best advice: Do something that will make someone feel good about themselves. get full value for yours. No It will make you feel proud that you did it. Due to the limits of avail- one wants to live beside TAURUS (April 20 - May 20): It’s time to prove to your detractors that able land, newer homes are someone who obviously you’re way ahead of them when it comes to getting things done. So, be sure to being built closer together does not care about their avoid surprise distractions and complete that project as soon as possible. and include more stories: home or is a renter with no GEMINI (May 21 to June 20): Be careful not to waste your precious energy on frivolous matters that don’t advance your goals. Stay focused. There’ll be enough some condos, for example, incentive to maintain the time for fun and games after you reach your objective. have a garage on the first property. CANCER (June 21 - July 22): You’ve done well on your own, but now could floor with the kitchen as The best way to deterbe a good time to consider advice from confidantes, as long as you continue to let high as the third floor and mine an effective selling your own instincts be your primary guide. bedrooms one more level price is to consult with a ReLEO (July 23 - August 22): A belated New Year’s “gift” could create a problem if you feel unwilling or unable to adjust your plans and accommodate higher. Imagine hauling altor: their experience and the new development. Check out all options before deciding. groceries up three levels! As access to market data will VIRGO (August 23 - Sept. 22): There’s a possibility that you could be a result, especially for older help you dial in an effective goaded into making a statement you might regret. It’s important to stay cool no matter how heated the conversation gets. buyers, a premium is placed price. on single-level homes. Not LIBRA (Sept. 23 - October 22): A recent sad experience can become a valuable lesson. Examine it well and take what you’ve learned to help you make an only are they more conCarl Medford is a liimportant upcoming decision. venient to get around, they censed Realtor with Keller SCORPIO (October 23 - November 21): Lingering problems in a also come with larger lots, Williams Realty and a personal or professional partnership still need to be resolved so you can move on. Insist on more cooperation from everyone involved. driving the price higher. licensed general contractor. SAGITTARIUS (Nov. 22 - Dec. 21):That recent problem that made The neighborhood counts This article is sponsored by you feel emotionally trapped and physically exhausted is gone. Don’t Your home might be the Central County Marketdwell on it. Instead, make new plans and set up other goals. amazing, but if the house ing Association. CAPRICORN (Dec. 22 - Jan. 19): Your creative talents combine with a Helping you with all your REAL ESTATE needs Since 1984

Laurie Pfohl 510-851-3551

Selling & Buying

LauriePfohl@gmail.com

strong domestic aspect this week, which means you can start on those homeimprovement projects that you’ve been planning for a long time. AQUARIUS (Jan. 20 - Feb. 18): It’s a good time to anticipate an upcoming change in the near future. This could mean taking on a new career, going off to a new city or moving into a new home.

PISCES (Feb. 19 - March 20): Soon, you should be learning more about the motives of those who continue to pressure you into making a decision that you’re still unsure about. Use this information wisely.

Income Property Veterans

CRS • DRE # 00866660

Robert Jones and Associates DAVID S. WILHITE Matt Jones & Bob Jones

DRE#0137894

DRE# 00276097

Dilek Silva

DRE# 02139355

We Are Here For You

Ron Trentler

DRE# 02068317

142 JOAQUINAVE. • SAN LEANDRO • 510 -357-0120 RobertJonesandAssociates.com

PROFESSIONAL FULL SERVICE REALTOR SERVING CASTRO VALLEY AND SURROUNDING COMMUNITIES FOR OVER 40 YEARS

510-329-8984

DRE#00759835

CASTRO VALLEY FORUM

Wednesday, January 24, 2024

Redwood Christian High School Honors EJE: MAC Pointed Out 2024 Homecoming Court with Ceremony No Set Budget, Timeline

my issue is with the state, not continued from front page he Redwood Christian and parts of Castro Valley and with the local.” High School 2024 San Lorenzo. In fact, the entire MAC reHomecoming Ceremopeatedly emphasized that they In 2016, the state Senate nies were held in the Bruce D. appreciated all the work county passed a bill (SB 1000) that Johnson Gymnasium on the established environmental jus- staff did in preparing the EJE Redwood Christian Middle tice requirements for all cities but were frustrated that the School and High School camand counties in California. The state made such mandates. pus in San Lorenzo on January Alameda County Community MAC members said they 19. More than 500 students, Development Agency is in the understood that staff must parents, grandparents, staff and process of preparing the “envi- comply with SB 1000 but friends filled the gym. ronmental justice element” and questioned what kind of actual A parent or other family plans to present it for adoption policies - if any- would be put member escorted each member by the Board of Supervisors in into place and what staff and resources could be devoted to of the Court, who were introApril or May. any new initiatives. duced by Co-Masters of CereUnder SB 1000, all cities monies High School Principal and counties in California must The MAC also pointed out Justin Redemer and Assistant add an EJE to their general that no set budgets or timelines Principal Dr. Evan Barnhart, plans. were associated with the EJE. who read letters from their The EJE contains goals and MAC member Shannon Killeparents that touched everyone’s policies to reduce health risks brew also questioned how there heart, flowers for the ladies and in disadvantaged communities. could be an EJE document Homecoming Sashes for the that does not address climate The focus includes decreasmen from someone special in ing exposure to pollution and change. PHOTO COURTESY OF PALOMARES PRINCIPAL DR. JENNIFER TOMITA their lives. Principal Redeincreasing access to public And MAC member Ken mer commended the student facilities, healthy food, safe Carbone said that the docu2024 HOMECOMING COURT: Back Row (Left to Right): Senior Prince David body stating “Once again, the Barquero, Senior Prince Jacob De Castro, King Jonathan Murray, Junior Prince and sanitary homes, physical ment was toothless. students of Redwood Christian Johan Weldegabriel, Sophomore Prince Josue Putnam, Freshman Prince Jona- activity, and increasing civic “It’s not law,” said Carbone. High School have chosen an than Aguilar Front Row (Left to Right): Senior Princess Aviana Becerra, Senior engagement in public deci“It’s not a regulation- it’s an Princess Sara Collier, Queen Cristiana Ramos, Junior Princess Zanai Robinson, sion-making processes. amazing group of students expression of intent.” Sophomore Princess Isabella Arrazola, Freshman Princess Erich Geronimo. to be on our Homecoming As at previous meetings Further, the MAC called Court.” where EJE divisions took the EJE document generic and The 2024 Homecoming were joined by other HomeMateo Putnam; and Freshman place, the MAC said they De Castro; Junior Princess said it would basically fit any Queen and King, Cristiana coming Court honorees: Senior Zanai Zakiyah Robinson and Princess Erich Faith Geronimo supported the ideas presented community, not Castro Valley, Faith Ramos and Jonathan Princesses, Aviana Janell Bec- Junior Prince Johan Napolion and Freshman Prince Jonathan but were concerned that there especially. Lamon Murray, were introerra and Sara Nicole Collier; Aguilar. Weldegabriel; Sophomore were no real plans or actions “I’m getting sick and tired duced during special ceremo- Senior Princes David Esteban Princess Isabella Mia Arrazola Visit our website for more: behind the buzzwords and that of the county being run by nies held between games and Barquero and Jacob Joseph and Sophomore Prince Josue www.mycvforum.com the state was too involved in Sacramento,” said MAC chair local matters. Bill Mulgrew. “I don’t think this document really serves the “I don’t think this is really people of Alameda County.” a fair document so far,” said MAC member Chuck Moore, A full copy of the current who also lamented that it draft of the EJE is available at focused on urban areas over www.acgov/org/cda/planning/ agricultural ones. “Once again, generalplan/engagement

Last Thursday, the Castro Valley and Eden Area Chamber of Commerce held its Board of Directors installation and mixer event at the Castro Valley Moose Lodge. Members acknowledged the contribution of outgoing board member Julie Sumiki’s contribution and Alameda County District 4 Supervisor, Nate Miley, welcomed the remaining board members back. The Chamber’s executive team is comprised of Todd Anglin as 2024 Chamber Board Chairperson, Janella Anguiano as Chairperson Elect for the 2025 term, Vice Chairs Gary Howard and Lynda Foster, Treasurer Anita (Kit) Thompson, and Secretaries Jared Savas and Kristin Perrault. The Chamber also changed the title for Gary Slate to Chamber President and CEO. More information can be found at https://www.edenareachamber.com/

Roscoe is a 1 year old Pit mix. Roscoe is looking that sweet person that knows exactly how to handle a couch Hippo. Roscoe would benefit from confidence building and basic obedience. Roscoe would do best with a older kids and up. To meet Roscoe contact Hayward Animal Shelter at 510-293-7200.

Belinda is a 10 month old Shepherd mix. Belinda is compact, fun and full of energy. Belinda would love to go on hikes, runs, or any other adventure your family is game for. Belinda would do well in a home with teens and up. To meet Belinda contact Hayward Animal Shelter at 510-293-7200.

VALLEY FORUM 8 CASTRO Wednesday, January 24, 2024

Classified Advertising

ADVERTISEWITH WITH EAST EAST BAY BAY PUBLISHING PUBLISHING AND AND REACH REACH OVER OVER 65,000 60,000 ADVERTISE ANNOUNCEMENTS You can run a classified ad for a little as $35 a week. Your ad runs in both of our newspapers, the Castro Valley Forum on Wednesday and the San Leandro Times on Thursday. You can also save by placing your ad on our website at castrovalleyforum.com or sanleandrotimes.com. We’ll call you for your credit or debit card info for payment. To place an ad by phone call Patrick Vadnais at 510-614-1560, Mon-Fri 9 a.m. - 1 p.m.

CONCRETE SERVICE

S.L. CONCRETE SERVICE Driveways, Sidewalks, Stamped Concrete, Retaining Walls, Asphalt, Paving Stones. Lic.#982202. 510856-8937.

CONTRACTOR SERVICE NOTICE TO READERS

California law requires that contractors taking jobs that total $500 or more (labor or materials) be licensed by the Contractors State License Board. State Law also requires that contractors include their license number on all advertising. Advertisers appearing on this page without a license number indicate that the contractor is not licensed. You can check the status of your licensed contractor at www.cslb.ca.gov or (800) 321-2752. Unlicensed contractors taking jobs that total less than $500 must state in their advertisements that they are not licensed by the Contractors State License Board. CLASSIFIED AD DEADLINE: Monday 5:00 p.m.

FENCES/DECKS

HANDYMAN SERVICE

HELP WANTED

*SPECIALIZING IN WOOD FEN- HANDYMAN/ LANDSCAPING CES, DECKS & RETAINING SERVICE. Maintenance, Cleanups, WALLS. Replace or repair, paved Hauling, Fences, Decks/ Patios, walkways, yard cleaning, tree trim- Painting, Repairs, Tree Work, ming, topping or removal, garage Concrete. 510-712-4318. cleaning & debris removal. Insured & Handyman no job is too small. GarBonded #8189. Jerry 510-410-2427. dening, cleaning, power washing, Fence wobbly? Call Randy's Fence painting, plumbing, roofing, repairs, Reinforcement and save thousands! gutters, drain cleaning, kitchen and 510-706-6189. bath drywall, dry rot, stucco, patio, fast water heaters, Aaron 510-2097282. ARDENING

HOUSE CLEANING

REAL ESTATE AGENTS

LORENA’S HOUSE CLEANING & REGULATORY AFFAIRS SPEHANDYMAN SERVICE CIALIST: Abbott Diabetes Care, an • Also Carpet Cleaning/Installation Abbott Labs Co., located in FREE Estimates Alameda, CA seeks qualified 925-435-7748/ 510-613-5777 Regulatory Affairs Specialist. Are you interested in buying or Provide regulatory supprt for med selling a home or property? device prods, incl. regulatory subISC OR ALE missions, existing prod maint., and Would you like the help of a new prod dvlpmnt under direction Professional Agent? of Regulatory Affairs Mgr. FORD 500 like new spare tire $40 For assistance call ... Bachelor’s or foreign equiv in Bio, o.b.o., also 7-speed bicycle, alumiChem, Microbio, Pharmacology, num frame, 26” wheels, runs good Regulatory Affairs, or in a rltd sci, $50. Will text/email photos. 510-517ENTALS med or engrg fld of study w/ min 2 3351. yrs regulatory affairs exp or exp AULING ERVICE SEAL heavy duty car cover for 2005 San Leandro 62+ Community, quiet, *BEAUTY GARDEN LANDSCAPING w/in regulatd industry (med, pharToyota LE Camry. $50 firm. 415-239- private court, 2-Bdrm, 1-bath duplex. Design - Construction - Maintemaceutical, nutritional prods or 0561, Oakland. nance. Cleanups, New Lawn, Artifiother regulatd industries). Position Dishwasher, washer and dryer. NO cial Grass, Irrigation, Patios, Path- HAULING: Small and Big Jobs. requires an academ or indstrl bckpets, no smoking. $1,900+ $1,900 12 like new quilting books $50. Call ways, Brick, Stone, Concrete Fence/ Furniture, Concrete, Wood, Trash, grnd in: (i) regulatory input & proj deposit. 925-980-8943. 510-654-1951. Decks. Free Estimates! Lic.#925130. Metal, Demolition. Also house inside/ mgmt to prod life-cycle planning, outside cleanups. 510-715-1578. 510-691-8852. prod testing protocols, reprts, & LANDLORDS – Advertise your INSIGNIA 24” Color TV w/remote. www.beautygardenlandscaping.com prod apprvl regulatory stratgies; (ii) units! A vacancy day is money Used for only 1 week, with original preparng regulatory submissions, lost forever ... R. Bowman box. Like new. $50. Call Patrick 510ELP ANTED BAY AREA BLOSSOM LANDmaintainng regulatory files for prod 517-3351. SCAPING. Cleanups, Hauling, tree regstrtions, & ensurng regulatory Men’s Navy Peacoat, like new, $30. service, maintenance, new patio, complnc for med devices or pharmENTALS PACES Call 510-278-9719. deck, painting, etc. Insured. Unli- WANTED: HVAC Mechanic, expericeuticl prods; (iii) assessing regulacensed. 510-499-5453. tory implications for prod changes, enced. Clean DL. Please call: (408) You can place a FREE determining trade issues to antc605-5822 RV/ Trailer space in San Leandro JAIME’S GARDENING pate regulatory obstacls, & sup“MISC. FOR SALE” ad and Oakland& Hayward. $925/ Maintenance, Trimming, Cleanpring design review, design change for items $50 or less month. Call 510-481-9901. ups, Hauling, Sprinkler Repair/ & design transfer thru prod lifecyat: sanleandrotimes.com Timers. FREE Estimates. Insured. cle; (iv) preparing & submitting new or at: castrovalleyforum.com 510-299-9583 prod regstrtions, annual reprts, & or more info call Patrick Mon-Fri. REE ERVICE changes to existing prod post9am-1pm at 510-614-1560 (some restrictions may apply) apprvl; & (v) undrstandng, investigatng, & evaluatng emerging reguGARDENING/TREE SERVICE *A CAREFUL TREE SERVICE. lations, guidance & consensus Certified. Arborist. Lic.#694067. TrimThe City of San Leandro is now standards in order to assess reguISC ANTED ming, Removals. FREE Estimates. NAVA'S COMPLETE LANDSCAPaccepting online applications for latory implications to the business. Bonded. Call 510-581-7377. ING: Mowing, trees, cleanup, haulAn EOE. 40 Hrs/wk. $65,900We REAAALLLY $131,900 appreciate our ing, FREE estimates. 510 512-5857. HOPEWANTED YOU FIND just the HOME SERVICES GUIDE per year. Send resumes - Reel to reel music City Engineer - Readers who support our many Advertise your Home for rent in the to: Abbott Laboratories, Attn: Elvia job you areCall looking for! tapes, Patrick 510-517-3351. $14,927-$18,144/month Help for the homeowner Labor & Employment Advertisers!Salazar, Patrick V. San Leandro Times & Castro Valley Forum means business for you! Legal Asst., 233 South Wacker Dr., For more detailed information, DON’T LET ANOTHER WEEK SLIP BY! LANDLORDS - Advertise your units! Fl 25, Dept 32, Chicago, IL 60606. please visit www.sanleandro.org. To Place an Ad ... Rent it FAST with a TIMES – A vacancy day is money lost forever – Refer to ad code: Readers who ABT-0014-ES. – A vacancy day is money lost forever – EOE Thanks to our many To place an ad call 510-614-1558 WANT AD ... 614-1558 Call 614-1558

SUPPORT OUR ADVERTISERS!

/RV S

R. Bowman

To Place an Ad call 614-1558

SELL YOUR CAR OR TRUCK NOW! Advertise your vehicle for 3 weeks in the San Leandro Times and 3 weeks in the Castro Valley Forum for only…

GREAT DEAL!

10 words maximum. $1.00 for each additional word.

This offer is for private party ads only (no dealers). Items must be priced and only one item may be listed for sale. You may change the asking price at anytime (no other changes are allowed). You may cancel your ad at anytime (there are no refunds available on this $25 special). Other restrictions may apply. For more information call Patrick at 614-1558.

To Place a Garage Sale Ad 614-1558

Help for the homeowner means business for you!

To Place a Garage Sale Ad call 614-1558 IF YOUR GARAGE SALE IS RAINED OUT, WE'LL RUN YOUR AD AGAIN FOR NO EXTRA CHARGE. SLTimes

NEED

REMODELING? How about a new kitchen or bath? Check the TIMES "Classified Ads" & The TIMES "Home Service" ads for help!

San Leandro Times HOME SERVICES GUIDE Call 614-1558

Help for the homeowner means business for you!

San Leandro Times HOME SERVICES GUIDE Call 614-1558

Classified Advertising

CASTRO VALLEY FORUM Wednesday, January 24, 2024

10 CASTRO VALLEY FORUM

Wednesday, January 24, 2024

Response to ‘This Patriot Will Vote for Trump’ Letter

To Supporters of Trump: ‘Have You No Shame?’

Dear Editor, Dear Editor, I am responding to Ms. Claudia Antonucci’s January 17, 2024 In response to Claudia Antonucci’s “This Patriot Will Vote letter. for Trump”. First of all Trump’s boondoggle of a wall does not Patriotism is defined as strong love and devotion to one’s appear to be working so well, given all the immigrants coming county. Both Democrats and Republicans love their country and across the border after he left office. Second of all, So far during are patriotic. Patriots should make their voting decision based on the Biden administration America is not at war with anyone. examining issues, a candidate’s position on the issues, a candiHowever, we are trying to cope with wars in other countries. date’s character including telling the truth. The latter tells a lot I don’t believe any American president can control what goes about a candidate’s character and suitability for office. And now on in other countries. Although, I suspect Trump would have Neglect! Seventy-plus years of neglect. The Alameda County let’s examine several issues Ms. Antonucci’s raised in her letter. allowed Putin to take over Ukraine, rather than support the Public Works Agency has failed in its mission to promote a 500 miles border wall: Trump’s administration built only 52 democracy against the “genious”. America remains energy healthy and sustainable environment that supports safe and miles of new primary border wall that blocked access for people independent, and are currently producing oil more than at nany livable communities. San Lorenzo Creek, usually a tiny, quiet on foot or vehicles. The majority of miles Trump claimed were other time in our history. Gas prices have come down, and little stream, during the atmospheric river event of December for replacements of smaller and dilapidated primary and second- inflation is diminsihing under Biden’s plan. Mandatory masking 31, 2022, became a raging river, 75 yards wide and over 50 feet ary barriers that did not add to the total miles of barriers along during the pandemic actually helped reduce illness and deaths, deep in many places. This event wreaked havoc on Creekside the southern border. When you replace your backyard fence, it which were highest in states that did not require them. Finally, residents, tearing away fences and taking away precious soil, is a new fence but you haven’t added to the fencing around your there is a moral and ethical question here that MAGA people just supporting many existing homes. This event also took away yard. seem to ignore. Trump has been shown to be a sexual molester. parts of “A” Street. Rebuild military: Trump is claiming that he rebuilt the He admits to groping women, and a jury of peers has found Within months, ACPWA fixed “A” street, a central public military and quotes a figure of $2.5 billion. The source of this is him guilty of it and awarded Jean E Carrol monetary damages thoroughfare. The same isn’t true for the rest of the creek: con- not clear but is likely that total of funds earmarked for defense. for his immoral behavior. He lies about the election, as well as crete debris and dead and damaged trees remain, and the steep, This includes all funds not just new equipment. Operation and a multitude of other issues. All I can say to Trump supporters is eroded banks now threaten homes. The next major atmospheric maintenance costs make up 40% of military budgets, and mili- “Have you no shame?” river that stalls over the East Bay hills will wash away homes tary personnel makes up 23% of military budgets. Further, funds –Robert Thomas, Castro Valley and potentially threaten lives—people with families. With budgeted for new equipment will be spent over many years and climate change, this disaster is inevitable; it’s just a question of are only a fraction of military budgets. President Biden’s military when. budgets increased over Trump’s budgets. Does this mean he is After a year of many requests for help, no assistance has been more successful than Trump? provided for the homeowner affected by the looming disaster Energy independence: The US exports more oil than it uses. of losing their homes. The agency director doesn’t care and Trump had little influence on this. The trend line for the US says nothing can be done on personal property. What happens becoming a net energy exporter started under President George had moved swiftly for them. upstream affects everything downstream. There are knock-off Bush and continued under Presidents Obama, Trump and Biden. continued from page 5 Miley said that the county “It’s not inefficiency, it’s effects beyond the scope of any individual homeowner to solve. Under President Biden, US oil production rose to a new record was trying to expedite permit- favoritism —and that has no Don Castro Reservoir silted up, and no longer has any water in 2023. An article in the Washington Post on December 31, control function. Years of housing developments in the above 2023, said that under Biden, oil production in 2023 reached 13.2 ting and approvals, and that he place,” she said to applause. was pushing to make sure the In an area of common hills have added concrete to once-absorption soils, causing more million gallons per day, and this exceeded what was produced county’s “one-stop shop” for ground, both candidates agreed water to flow down all the East Bay Creeks. This is a direct under Trump. this was working properly. He to support Castro Valley as a cause for the San Lorenzo Creek to deepen and the banks to No Wars Under Trump: Factually incorrect. The War in cave in and wash away. Afghanistan was being fought during all four years of Trump’s added that in providing county full-fledged city if that’s what services generally, “It’s not a Castro Valley voters want. The Alameda County Flood Control and Water Conservation presidency and ended on August 30, 2021. Editor’s Note: Last week’s District (ACFCD) has failed for decades to help protect residents PGE bills. No question that they are too high, but Trump had sprint. It’s a marathon, and you have to keep plugging at it till preview of the candidate deand property from flooding by planning, designing, constructing, no effect of PGE bills. Prices for electricity and natural gas are you get it right.” bate misidentified two projects and maintaining flood control facilities such as natural creeks set by the California Public Utilities Commission. Electricity Esteen had a different view Supervisor Miley had helped and channels. prices increased significantly because of CA’s wildfires and of the delays. Pampas Cafe, she bring about. Miley played a Yet, ACPWA and the Alameda County Board of Supervisors PGE’s aging infrastructure. major role in getting the Lake plan to implement a new property tax for deferred projects. The Patriotism seeks what is best of our country, and this requires said, had moved into a prime Creekside residents could be their best advocates for this new leaders who do not deceive. While it is a time-honored tradition location next to Trader Joe’s— Chabot Public Market opened, but it took 18 months because rather than the Castro Valley tax. With their disdain and lack of concern, we cannot supto exaggerate your record when running for office, Trump’s of delays attributed to the coun- Marketplace. The former port this effort. Nor do we recommend voting for any current false claims exceeded normal exaggeration and are downright Alameda Board Supervisors when they come up for reelection. deceptive. Sadly, and inexorably, they are consistent with his past ty. By contrast, when she spoke Daughtrey’s Building was also to restaurant owners in the misidentified as a Doctor’s A county government that doesn’t listen to the concerns of its behavior and character and raise troubling questions about his Lake Chabot Public Market, Building. The Forum regrets citizens is inferior and inadequate! fitness for office. Patriotism demands no less. the errors. –The Creekside Residents of San Lorenzo Creek –Larry Bieber, Castro Valley though, she found that things

Creekside Residents Have Been Neglected

Debate: CV Cityhood an Area of Common Ground

Trump is the Complete Opposite of a Patriot

Trump is Dangerous

MAC: Society Crimes

Not only did Mr. Trump encourage his supporters to stop the continued from front page There were 475 reported certification of a valid vote in Congress, inciting them with lies cases of more serious “Society Long before Trump, the far right has commandeered the word about a tainted election, but he continues to mischaracterize as Crimes A” (27 arrested), which “patriot” to mean anyone who agrees with their every dotted “i” “stolen,” an election he lost by more than seven million votes. and crossed “t”. Now it means anyone who practically worships Last week Claudia Antonucci cited a number of “facts” about included drugs, animal cruelty, Donald Trump as if he was Jesus Christ. But there are some true Trump that are straight from the Trump campaign, most are un- and weapons charges. There were 215 reports (124 patriots here: *Mike Pence for fulfilling his oath of office and verifiable, like the claim of 28,000 Mexican soldiers policing the certifying the election. *Liz Cheney and Adam Kinzinger who border, but some are outright fiction. The worst of these fictions arrested) for “Society Crimes B,” including loitering, DUI, sacrificed their careers to uncover the truth. *Trump insiders was a claim that Trump paid down the national debt. Cassidy Hutchinson, Alyssa Farah-Griffin, and Sarah MatthewsWhen Trump took office, the national debt was a little under and disorderly conduct. Statistics reported within courageous young ladies who first confronted the truth within $20 trillion. At the end of four years, when he was turned out of themselves, then told the world. *Candidates Chris Christie and office by the American voters, the national debt was almost $28 Castro Valley for 2023 within Asa Hutchinson who told the truth about Jan. 6 on the campaign trillion. Under his administration the national debt increased by those categories include two trail. *And those at the DOJ and state election officials who held $7.8 trillion dollars, including about $2 trillion that resulted from homicides, 104 burglaries, 411 assaults, 318 car thefts, a goal line stand to preserve our democracy against a wannabe his tax giveaway to the wealthy. dictator and his ridiculous lie that his election was stolen. Donald I’m no big fan of Joe Biden, but Trump is dangerous, support- 404 drug violations, and 184 Trump is a traitor to our democracy for what he did on and lead- ed by white supremacists and haters of all kinds who long for a reports of vandalism. MAC members chastised ing up to January 6. He violated the sacred keystone of a democ- bygone era when the only faces you saw on TV were white, and the ACSO for not providing racy- to bow and salute the declared winner even if he disagreed the only language you heard was English. printed and more easily legible with the results. He is the complete opposite of a patriot. America is bigger than that now and we are all better for it. –Mark Perkins, Castro Valley –Rob Reynold, Castro Valley advanced statistics instead of a

small slide in the presentation. “We’d like these figures maybe a week before so we can digest them,” said MAC member Al Padro. Pola said that one major area of focus for the ACSO this year has been homelessness outreach and encampment cleanups. He said the area at the intersection of Redwood Road and Grove Way with the Trader Joe’s, El Rancho, and 7-Eleven at the intersection saw an up to 30 percent decrease in revenue due to an atmosphere rife with panhandling, open substance abuse and multiple calls for police service. Pola said the department see MAC on page 11

CASTRO VALLEY FORUM

Wednesday, January 24, 2024

MAC: Rate Hike at Park continued from previous page was able to utilize simple ideas like removing benches By Thomas Lorentzen to solve loitering issues and SPECIAL TO THE FORUM improve the area. The MAC said that law enforcement, code t has been several weeks enforcement, and other county since Sandra D. O’Condepartments would have to nor passed away. As you come together to help with know, she was the first woman homelessness issues, which ev- appointed to the U.S. Supreme eryone named one of- if not the Court (by President Reagan in largest- community concerns. 1981). Her confirmation by the Mobile Home Park Issues U.S. Senate was unanimous (there were no votes against In other MAC news, the her). council heard about an issue that is popping up all over the Those were the days my Bay Area as even the most friends. Her life and career are modest housing becomes worthy of paying homage. It increasingly unaffordable- mo- has relevance to Castro Valley. bile home tenancy. It is that 50 years ago we corresponded with each other. The Many people own mobile year was 1974. I was in graduhomes but rent the land that they are on. When ownership ate school at the University of Nevada, Reno. My major was of a park changes, rates can in Political Science. My minor go up, and realistically, most was in History. My interest in of these mobile homes aren’t these subjects was about the actually mobile in the sense they cannot be easily moved to broad flow of forces that form the composite of both fields another location. In addition to raising rates, of study. Of particular interest thoughtful and philosophical. was the relationship between Through a contact in Sacramobile home residents say some property owners intend government and the governed. mento, I was put in touch with to close parks down and devel- This curiosity led me to Sandra a State Senator in Arizona that was pursuing this subject. Her op the land for other, more lu- D. O’Connor. crative uses. County and some Because I was living in Ne- name was Sanda D. O’Connor. We exchanged views in written city councils are discussing vada at the time, it is importcorrespondence, as well as on new ordinances to protect such ant to note that there was an residents. inherent skepticism about the the phone. Despite our comsize and scope of government munications, nothing came of According to the county, (87% of the land is government our efforts. there are currently 19 mobile Later, State Senator O’Conhome parks with 550 spaces in owned). It struck me that there nor served as a Superior Court should be a debate about this the unincorporated areas. Judge and on the Arizona State on a statewide basis. Residents of the Avalon, a 49-space park in Castro Valley, I wondered if a limit could Court of Appeals. Given her told the MAC that ownership be set on the overall size of the experience, as well as a strong changed hands in November, state government. The question academic background (Stanford Law), President Reagan and they received notifications was not born with an adverof rent increases of 100% or sarial intent, but one that was appointed her to the Supreme more. Previously, a 4% cap on rent increases of the same owner was maintained. The new owner has said that the issue is complex, that there are different acclimations and rules for RVs, and that he was willing to work with residents. The matter will be before the Board of Supervisors later this month. More than 15 speakers addressed the MAC, worried that they’d be driven from their long-time homes by corporate investors. One option would be to create an overlay area for mobile parks to provide extra protecHave A tion under the law. Safe 2024! MAC member Al Padro expressed that he wanted every resident to stay in their homes and encouraged the county staff to look into the overlay option and beyond to find a resolution. He also thanked the owners for their cooperative efwww.DeerCreekCremation.com forts as discussions continued.

task. It was then that we were enabled to meet in person (see adjoining photograph). Although three decades had passed between our original communications, our memories were clear from the past. We discussed our mutual efforts, despite the lack of success in manifesting them further. Our focus, however, was fundamental to the political and legal debates of our time. As we talked, we also shared our common bond in another arena – the culture of ranching and the spirit that comes from that lifestyle. We discussed poetry, music, dance, literature, and storytelling that is born from within that domain. She, like me, had attended the Western Folklife Festival in Elko, Nevada. It was a place where people can come together to think and talk and learn in ways that are grounded in our national character. Although being on the national political stage can be exciting, it can also be enriching to be among the burros and donkeys in the Ruby Mountains in Nevada. Having that awareness made O’Connor a solid person to have served on the U.S. Supreme Court. This was also at the heart of our shared interests. She would have fit in well here in Castro Valley.

communications. I was serving Court. She on the National Board at the also had Institute of Museum & Library added qualiServices. Like O’Connor, I had fications that been nominated by a President made her an and confirmed by the U.S. interesting Senate. Although she had been choice. She scheduled to swear me in, a was practical and grounded in her views and conflict developed. As a result, another judge life experiences. This included a background in ranching. She from the Supreme Court did also valued lifelong learning, (David Souter). At a later and the value of places like swearing-in, however, O’Conmuseums and libraries as nor was able to perform the venues for that pursuit. It is through this background that Justice O’Connor and I had a chance to come together years after our original August 5, 1931 ~ January 13, 2024

Leonard Wyatt Burnand

Since 1965

Jess C. Spencer Mortuary & Crematory

21228 Redwood Rd., Castro Valley

581-9133

Offering Personalized Memorial and Cremation Services.

FD 1168 CR49

Leonard Wyatt Burnand, Jr. was born August 5, 1931 in Chicago, IL to Olive Scott and Leonard W. Burnand, Sr., the second of three children. After graduating from Maine Township High School, he entered the US Air Force. He met and married Gabrielle Leroux while stationed in France. He completed various tours in California, England, Texas, Thailand, and Germany. A veteran, he served during both the Korean and Vietnam Wars, retiring after 23 years, as a MSgt. He continued in Data Processing and Computer Operations in the banking industry until he retired from work. Church had become a large part of their lives after he married Gabrielle. You could find him involved as greeter, usher, or often in the background supporting Gaby with her many handmade banners at Faith Lutheran Church in Castro Valley, CA. Their love of the Lord was often reflected in faithful attendance of Bible studies. Once his wife died Feb. 23, 2020, just shy of their 66th anniversary, Len’s health declined. He decided to move to an assisted living facility near his daughter. Len, at 92, died at Carlton Assisted Living in Pleasant Hill, CA. He joined his Lord, his wife Gaby, his granddaughter Valerie Beth Giese, and sister Lorraine (Burnand) Lobenhofer on Saturday, January 13, 2024. He is survived by his children, Veronique and Michael Schutz, Stephanie and Brian Anderson and Pierre Burnand. He is also survived by his brother, Arthur and Pat Burnand, and many nieces and nephews. A memorial service will be held on Saturday, January 27, 2024 at 1pm. at the Episcopal Church of the Resurrection, 399 Gregory Lane, Pleasant Hill.

12 CASTRO VALLEY FORUM

Wednesday, January 24, 2024

ATHLETE OF THE WEEK

Hailey Smith

PHOTO CREDIT: ETHAN FRANKLIN

RCS Second in BACSAL

Redwood Christian Schools 5th/6th Boys Basketball team finished second in the Bay Area Christian School Athletic League 5th/6th Championship game losing 27-18 to Cornerstone Christian Academy of Antioch. To get to the Championship game, the Eagles defeated first seed Kings Valley Christian of Concord earlier in the day 32-30 in overtime! Coach Ansara Johnson stated “I am so proud of them. They played hard.” Pictured (l-r): Coach Ansara Johnson, Amaru Guanzon, Brady Strange, Luke Enos, Jonathan Catano, Jacob Bruce, Nicholas Pacheco, Leif Redemer, Michael Mujica, Steve Sobers, Ethan Azraei, Noah Choi and Dave Bravo, BACSAL League Director.

Sill: Competitive Juices Still Flowing continued from page 4 “I was their test dummy,” she chuckled. “When we were younger I was their target. I’d stand in the batter’s box when they were pitching. When they were throwing a football I’d be the target. I learned to move out of the way.” Ali, who now lives in Walnut Creek, still finds ways to keep those competitive juices flowing. She plays Sundays in a “just for fun” coed soccer league in Pleasanton and it’s a

Our Athlete of the Week is Hailey Smith. This 11th grader at Castro Valley High School plays on the Girls Varsity Soccer team and leads the league with more than 13 goals scored. Hailey is ranked in the Top 12 in North Coast Section for goals, Top 2 in NCS Division I for points scored, and Top 2 in West Alameda County - Foothill for goals, points, and assists. In its first league game of the season against Piedmont High School on January 9, Castro Valley won 3-0, with Smith scoring all three goals (a hat trick). In the second league game against Bishop O’Dowd High School on January 11, Smith had two assists and one goal in the Trojans’ win over the Dragons, 3-0.

The Matt Wilhite Team proud to Isisproud to sponsor sponsor Athlete of the Week Athlete of Smith the Week Hailey

Health & Fitness: Four Ways To Recover from Getting Sick

good bet her team wins more and running, but preparing for a triathlon would take her than it loses. She runs, snowboards, wake boards, mountain workouts to another level. By Mitch Rothbardt bikes and hasn’t ruled out “You’d have to do half-day SPECIAL TO THE FORUM competing in another Ironman workouts for nine months or event, something she did back so,” Sill said. “It’s something Getting sick is all the craze in 2013. I’ve definitely given some these days. Everyone’s getting thought to, though.” Ironman competition in on it. Friends and family consists of a 2.4-mile swim, In the meantime, Ali is com- have come down with things a 112-mile bike ride and a fortable with her current sports ranging from a bit of a cough 26.2-mile run. That’s a big activities, as well as coaching to full-on BLECCH in the last challenge even for someone as her five-year-old daughter, month, and it’s not good. It gets active as Ali Sill, who is 5-foot- Collins, who’s already playing in the way of life, and more 3 “on a good day.” She does baseball and basketball. “She’s importantly, it gets in the way work out a lot, lifting weights a great little athlete,” Ali boast- of going to the gym. I’m only ed. “Her favorite is baseball.” half-kidding about that. Here But then Collins hasn’t start- are some hints to help you get through this tough time. ed playing soccer yet. This is the seventh in a 1. Relieve your stress. This series of 16 articles profiling time of year does us all in. the 2024 inductees into the The holidays, the weather, the Castro Valley Sports Hall finances. Even a few days off of Fame. The Hall of Fame work doesn’t help. Work never ceremonies and banquet will really goes away, right? Stress be held Sunday, April 21, at compromises our immune Redwood Canyon Golf Course. system big-time, so we’ve got For tickets, go to castrovalto do things to help relieve it. leysportsfoundation.org Many studies have shown that

best way to keep yourself from exercise is a getting sick is to give your improven way to mune system the ammunition relieve stress. to fight off the molecules that It releases want to attack it. Well, consider all sorts of vegetables a Howitzer, a Stealth hormones in bomber, and the EM50 Urban our body that fight it off as well as giving us Assault Vehicle from “Stripes” a mental break from whatever’s all rolled into one for your getting us down. Even though body. you might not feel like it and 4. Watch “Stripes.” If you even though you might not be don’t know what the EM50 able to give everything you Urban Assault Vehicle is, do usually give in the gym, go yourself a favor and watch one in and do something if at all of the funniest movies ever possible and you’ll feel better made, “Stripes.” Laughter has in the long run. also been shown to help your immune system. Who doesn’t 2. Resistance train. Many studies have shown that resis- want to see Bill Murray turn tance training (pushups, sit-ups, the military upside down with hilarious consequences? step-ups) helps our immune system. (If it seems like I think “BOOM-locka-locka-lockaBOOM-locka-locka-lockathat resistance training is a kind of panacea, you’re right. I BOOM-locka-locka-lockaBOOM.” do. Because it is.) 3. Eat your vegetables. The In any case, take care of yourself and be well. By the way, if there’s anything you’d like me to write about in the future, please let me know. I always want to be sure to write Standard Synthetic Smog about things that people want Oil Change Oil Change Inspection to know. Thanks. $ 95 Mitch is the owner and head trainer at Castro Valley Fitness. He loves answering your Includes Free brake & seasonal check up fitness questions at the dog *For faster service, please call ahead for an appointment. Most cars/ light tricks. Oil change includes up to 5qts. of motor oil and new oil filter. Some vehicles require special oil and/or filter, park with Penny, Max, and Tex cost extra. Tax and disposal fee extra. Cannot combine with any other offers. Limited time only or by emailing him at: Mitch@ CastroValleyFitness.com.

plus $8.25 certificate