Full download Management accounting change approaches and perspectives 1st edition alawattage pdf do

Page 1


download ebook at ebookgate.com

ManagementAccountingChangeApproachesand Perspectives1stEditionAlawattage

https://ebookgate.com/product/managementaccounting-change-approaches-and-perspectives-1stedition-alawattage/

Download more ebook from https://ebookgate.com

More products digital (pdf, epub, mobi) instant download maybe you interests ...

Advances in Management Accounting Volume 11 Advances in Management Accounting 1st Edition John Y. Lee

https://ebookgate.com/product/advances-in-management-accountingvolume-11-advances-in-management-accounting-1st-edition-john-ylee/ Construction Accounting Financial Management 2nd Edition Steven Peterson

https://ebookgate.com/product/construction-accounting-financialmanagement-2nd-edition-steven-peterson/

https://ebookgate.com/product/change-management-masterclass-astep-by-step-guide-to-successful-change-management-1st-editionmike-green/

https://ebookgate.com/product/protection-security-and-safeguardspractical-approaches-and-perspectives-2nd-ed-edition-june/

Handbook

of Management Accounting Research 1st Edition

Christopher S. Chapman

https://ebookgate.com/product/handbook-of-management-accountingresearch-1st-edition-christopher-s-chapman/

Change Management Revised Edition Revised Edition

Management Extra Elearn

https://ebookgate.com/product/change-management-revised-editionrevised-edition-management-extra-elearn/

Management Accounting for Decision Makers 5th Edition

Peter Atrill

https://ebookgate.com/product/management-accounting-for-decisionmakers-5th-edition-peter-atrill/

Management Accounting for Decision Makers 6th Edition

Peter Atrill

https://ebookgate.com/product/management-accounting-for-decisionmakers-6th-edition-peter-atrill/

Hospitality management accounting 8th ed Edition Martin G. Jagels

https://ebookgate.com/product/hospitality-managementaccounting-8th-ed-edition-martin-g-jagels/

Management Accounting Change

Management Accounting Change: Approaches and perspectives, an important new management accounting text, bridges the gap between technical, managerial and theoretical perspectives in management accounting. The book discusses technical developments in management accounting from conventional cost accounting to contemporary strategic management accounting and beyond. Part I shows how conventional cost accounting techniques and management control models evolved in line with the development of mass production and bureaucracy. Part II discusses how recent developments such as customer and strategic orientations in business, flexible manufacturing, postbureaucracy, network and virtual organizational technologies implicate in management accounting. The book also provides a number of alternative theories through which the transition of management accounting from mechanistic to post-mechanistic approaches can be explained. Parts III and IV elaborate rational theories and interpretive/critical theories, respectively.

This exciting text meets a desperate need for an advanced management accounting textbook that incorporates theory with practice that is accessible and engaging for all those studying in this challenging area.

Danture Wickramasinghe (B.Sc., M.Com, M.Sc., Ph.D.) obtained his Ph.D. from the University of Manchester where he also teaches management accounting and control. He has taught management accounting in a number of universities over 20 years and has been published in Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal, Critical Perspectives on Accounting, Financial Management (UK), Advances in Public Interest Accounting and the Journal of Accounting and Organizational Change

Chandana Alawattage (B.Sc., MBA, Ph.D.) obtained his Ph.D. from Keele University and teaches management accounting at the University of Aberdeen Business School. He has taught management accounting and related subjects in various other universities over 10 years and has been published in Critical Perspectives on Accounting, Journal of Accounting and Organizational Change and a number of conference proceedings in critical accounting.

Management Accounting Change

Approaches and perspectives

Danture Wickramasinghe and Chandana Alawattage

First published 2007 by Routledge

2 Park Square, Milton Park, Abingdon, Oxon OX14 4RN

Simultaneously published in the USA and Canada by Routledge

270 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10016

Routledge is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group, an informa business © 2007 Danture Wickramasinghe and Chandana Alawattage

Typeset in Perpetua by Keystroke, 28 High Street, Tettenhall, Wolverhampton

Printed and bound in Great Britain by The Cromwell Press, Trowbridge, Wiltshire

All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reprinted or reproduced or utilized in any form or by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publishers.

British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data

A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library

Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data Wickramasinghe, Danture.

Management accounting change : approaches and perspectives / Danture Wickramasinghe and Chandana Alawattage. p. cm.

Includes bibliographical references and index.

1. Managerial accounting. I. Alawattage, Chandana. II. Title.

HF5657.4.W522 2007

658.15′11—dc22

2006039487

ISBN10: 0–415–39331–0 (hbk)

ISBN10: 0–415–39332–9 (pbk)

ISBN13: 978–0–415–39331–7 (hbk)

ISBN13: 978–0–415–39332–4 (pbk)

To our families

List of illustrations

Preface

Acknowledgements

1Learning management accounting change 1

A starting point: the relevance lost1

Setting the scene 2

What is management accounting? 4

Why ‘change’?10

What has changed in management accounting? 11

MACh as a movement from one approach to another12

Perspectives on MACh15

Have you understood the chapter? 22

Beyond the chapter22

Further reading 23

2Towards mass production and bureaucracy

A starting point: the challenge of a potter 27

Setting the scene 27

A brief note on method of historical dialectics30

Marxist understanding of production 32

Pre-modern modes of production 32

Characteristics of craft production34

Crisis of craft production37

Transformation to mass production38

Alternative theoretical explanations for emergence of cost accounting47

Have you understood the chapter?50

Beyond the chapter 50

Further reading50

3Towards product costing 51

A starting point: costing for economic depression 51

Setting the scene51

What is costing?53

Historical developments in costing56

Categories of cost and their meanings60

Cost categorization practices64

Calculative practices of product costing66

Contributions to mechanistic approach78

Have you understood the chapter?79

Beyond the chapter80

Further reading80

4Towards profit planning through budgeting 81

A starting point: corporate budgeting is a joke! 81

Setting the scene 81

Origin of budgeting and standard costing 84

Link between standard costing and budgeting91

Profit planning through budgets: procedures and calculations95

Budgetary configuration of mechanistic organizations113

Different approaches to budgeting118

Have you understood the chapter? 121

Beyond the chapter 121

Further reading 122

5Towards management control through budgeting 123

A starting point: management control in a students’ surgery 123

Setting the scene 124

On the notion of control 125

Management control 126

What do we do with these frameworks? 132

Budgetary control: techniques and procedures 133

Standard costing – analysis of variances140

Sales variances152

Legitimated budgets in the mechanistic form156

Have you understood the chapter?157

Beyond the chapter 158

Further reading 158

6Towards economic models of decision-making 159

A starting point: economic men in an economic world 159

Setting the scene 159

Neoclassical economic model of the firm and management accounting 164

Profit maximization in the long run: economics of capital budgeting 190

Economic modelling of the firm200

The other perspective: accounting as the meta-theory of economics?203

Have you understood the chapter?203

Beyond the chapter204

Further reading204

Part IIPost-mechanistic approaches to management accounting205

7Towards customer orientation and flexible manufacturing 207

A starting point: encountering Japanese 207

Setting the scene 207

Post-mechanistic change – understanding the complexity and totality210

Changing context: from local to global213

Changing organizational intents: from financial to strategic216

From mass to flexible manufacturing 218

Summing up: post-mechanistic organizations and management accounting232

Have you understood the chapter? 236

Beyond the chapter 236

Further reading237

8 Towards strategic management accounting 238

A starting point: accounting’s challenge in the new world 238

Setting the scene 239

What is SMA? 242

Directions in SMA250

Accounting for corporate strategy250

Business-level strategies: accounting for competitive market positioning261

Performance measurement systems: from conventional to strategic 266

The BSC as an integrative/strategic PMS 271

Critical views of the BSC274

Have you understood the chapter?279

Beyond the chapter280

Further reading 280

9Towards cost management 281

A starting point: the cost of cost cutting 281

Setting the scene 282

Cost management revisited 285

ABC as a powerful programme of cost management288

Deficiencies and misconceptions of traditional costing 290

What is ABC? 292

Activity-based management 305

ABC implementation: researchers’ views308

Summing up: alignment with the post-mechanistic form313

Have you understood the chapter?315

Beyond the chapter315

Further reading315

10Towards new management control and governance in new organizations

A starting point: governing by relations 316

Setting the scene 316

A typology of organizational transformation319

Management control and governance under bureaucracy320

Crisis in the bureaucratic form of management control and governance324

Changes in intra-organizational control and governance332

Changes in inter-organizational control and governance337

Summing up344

Have you understood the chapter?344

Beyond the chapter 345

Further reading345

A starting point: market versus hierarchy 349

Setting the scene 350

The agency problem 354

Theory of principal and agent356

Transaction cost economics 365

TCE and management accounting research373

Have you understood the chapter?379

Beyond the chapter379

Further reading380

12Towards contingency theory of management accounting

A starting point: generalized contingencies 381

Setting the scene 382

Contingency theory as a perspective 384

Contingency theory: classical studies in organization theory 385

In management accounting: modelling and reviewing of contingencies390

A small flood of accounting research394

Is contingency theory a panacea for accounting research?398

Contingency theory revisited402

Summing up406

Have you understood the chapter?406

Beyond the chapter 407

Further reading407

x

Part

IVInterpretive and critical perspectives on management accounting change

13Towards interpretations, institutions and networks in management accounting411

A starting point: a beginning of the end 411

Setting the scene 411

Functionalism: meaning and problems414

Interpretive sociology420

Concerning a gap: old institutionalism427

New institutionalism432

Actor–network theory435

Summing up: how do we understand the change? 438

Have you understood the chapter?440

Beyond the chapter440

Further reading440

14Towards political economy of MACh 442

A starting point: politics of struggles 442

Setting the scene 442

What is critical? 445

Marxist and neo-Marxist perspectives on management accounting 449

Control, resistance and consent: neo-Marxist extensions of labour process and control 460

Gramscian theory of hegemony468

Have you understood the chapter? 474

Beyond the chapter474

Further reading 474

15Beyond political economy of MACh 475

A starting point: the critical divide 475

Setting the scene 475

A critique of the critical 478

What is postmodernism/post-structuralism? 480

The Foucauldian way: emphasizing the disciplinary 483

The Habermasian way: understanding and changing accounting systems 491

Summing up500

Have you understood the chapter?500

Beyond the chapter501

Further reading501

Illustrations

FIGURES

1.1MACh from mechanistic to post-mechanistic approaches

4.3Link

5.1 Organizational control process and budgeting

5.2Summary of variances: how profit variance is explained

6.1 Firm in perfectly competitive market ‘takes’ market

6.2

6.3Neoclassical economic model of a firm’s

6.4

6.5Fixed

6.6 Modelling

6.7 Illustrative Case Example 6.1: C–V–P analysis – graphical representation

6.8

6.9

6.10

7.1Hierarchy

8.1Three-way strategic extension of management accounting

8.2SMA as accounting for strategic

8.3Sony Corporation as a portfolio of SBUs

8.4BCG

8.5General

8.6 Overview of Porter’s framework

8.7 Competitive structure – five forces model

8.8Porter’s

8.9PMS and organizational control systems

8.10The BSC’s critical strategic dimensions and measurement

9.1The ABC cost allocation model

9.2Link between ABC and market value

9.3Transformation from the mechanistic to the post-mechanistic

10.1Forms of organizations and arenas of management control

11.1Principal’s payoff curve

11.2Agent’s indifference curve

11.3Optimum employment contract with information symmetry

11.4Information symmetry and asymmetry – differences in agent’s utility and principal’s payoff

12.1Contingency theory perspective on management accounting

framework for AIS design

14.1 Defining characteristics of critical perspectives

in mode of production

14.3Intellectual leadership in its structural context

TABLES

3.1Technical and social views compared

3.2Example of product costing: ABB Motors model

3.3Example of product costing: Denver Sala AB model

4.1Evolution of notion of standards with incentive payment schemes

5.1 Terminology of price and quantity variances

6.1Net present value calculation

7.1 Post-bureaucratic characteristics of organizations

7.2From mechanistic to post-mechanistic

8.1Conventional versus strategic management accounting

8.2 Directions of/approaches to SMA

8.3Corporate reasons for being ‘not for profit’ – some examples

8.4 Strategic labelling and prescriptions in BCG growth share matrix

8.5Generic strategies of market positioning

8.6 Conventional PMS – critical indicators at organization level

8.7Comparison between conventional PMS and BSC

9.1 Cost accounting and cost management compared

9.2Activities in a business enterprise

9.3Mainstream ABC academic studies: issues in implementation

10.1Post-bureaucracy: implications for management control and governance

11.1Implications of bounded rationality and opportunism

11.2How governance structures differ

12.1Structures in two forms of organizations

12.2Accounting studies on contingency theory

14.1Subject, modes of struggles and modes of objectification

BOXES

1.1Views

6.3Differences in revenue concepts between perfectly and non-perfectly

6.4Constant and diminishing returns to variable factor

6.5Derivation of cost curves from production curves

8.1BSC design and implementation – Kaplan and Norton’s

10.1Governing

EXHIBITS

3.1Calculation

9.1

9.2Reclassification

CASE EXTRACTS

4.1Process

4.4Annual sales budget for year ending 31 December 200X

4.5 Monthly sales budget for year ending 31 December 200X

4.6Annual

4.7Material

4.8

4.9

4.11Variable

4.12Fixed

5.1Calculation

5.2Performance

5.3Direct

5.4Direct

5.5Direct

5.6Direct

5.7Summary

5.8Calculation

5.9

5.10Calculation

5.12

Preface

Welcome to the changing world of management accounting! In this book, we will take you through this world of management accounting and show you how this particular discipline originated and has changed. We will meet key author ities in the discipline to inquire into why and how this change has occurred. At some points, we will have a break to think about the fascination as well as the complexity of this c hange. At other points, we will debate whether we have to accept different perspectives on management accounting change. Let us start the journey at the beginning.

THE BEGINNING

The idea of writing this book was generated, thanks to a ‘free’ telephone package, during hour-long intellectual discussions. One day, we were talking about the selection of journal articles for teaching advanced management accounting to third-year undergraduates. We focused on the fact that students at this level often struggle to understand and contextualize these ‘hard-going’ articles. Our conclusion was that there is no bridge between these academic articles and technical textbooks Even though a lot of excitement occurs in this academic world, nothing is effectively conveyed to these undergraduates. The ‘remedial measure’ which emerged from our discussion was to write this book! But the genesis of this idea goes far back to our own undergraduate learning. In those good old days, we thought management accounting was merelya tec hnical subject. The ability to deal with more ‘complex’ calculative problems would constitute the supremacy of knowledge After decades of research and teaching, we have now realized that management accounting knowledge lies in a wider spectrum. It lies not only in techniques but also in the changing context in which such techniques evolve; not only in the implementation of techniques, but also in the effects of such implementation; not only in one-sided but also in multiple aspects. A boost came from this realization to write a book on management accounting embracing such a wider spectrum. This is it. It is about the change in management accounting from a mechanistic to a postmechanistic approach. This is also about multiple perspectives on this change.

The rationale

Change is a per vasive reality. Everything changes everywhere. Management gurus talk about c hange. There has been a flood of management fads such as ‘change management’, ‘managing change’, ‘incremental change’ and ‘radical change’. Simultaneously, best practices for change are xvii

now emerging. Attempts have been made for popularizing management strategies, such as ‘continuous improvement’, ‘learning organization’, ‘TQM’ and ‘business process re-engineering’. Change has come to be the religion in the field of management. Everybody admires change. Management accounting is not an exception. Since the 1980s the status quo of both theory and practice of management accounting has been questioned. Change has come to the top of management accounting’s agenda. It has become one of the most popular topics among hundreds of Ph.D. students around the world. Some explore how management accounting changed in the last century. Others look into how it is changing now. Some attempt to discern whether there is a real change beyond discourse and slogan. Others try to see whether it changes incrementally or radically. Some question whether change is possible in the first place. Others question whether change is even necessary. Some attempt to explore the issue of resistance to all this change.

Unfor tunately, the change agenda has been compartmentalized within academia. Even though ‘new’ techniques are being poured into technical texts, an understanding of change has been far from the territory of undergraduate education. Is this fair to undergraduates and M.Sc./MBA students? Would it be a good idea to add a text covering the change agenda? If so, how could we explain change? How could we produce a complete text? We found answers to these questions through our telephone conversations. The undergraduates and M.Sc./MBA students must embrace the change agenda if they want to know about both the theory and practice of management accounting. As long as there is no suc ha text, the compilation of a complete text on management accounting is the demand of the day. As long as we are experiencing a rapid change that we have never seen before, it is an immediate necessity. Management accounting change is a response to the external pressures as well as internal transformations. That said, it is due to the interaction between technological/environmental changes and changing management/organizational ideologies. Such changes are fundamentally linked to the nature of economy and society. Once, economy and society were based on craft production. Later, following the industrial revolution, this transformed into mass production within a mechanistic and monopolistic environment. This context gave rise to product costing methods, the ancestor of management accounting The approac h to this accounting came into congruence with mechanization and monopolization: the ‘mechanistic approach’ to management accounting. Now, following the IT revolution in the factory, customer orientation in the market and globalization of the world, ‘good old’ management accounting has become subject to serious attacks from both academics and practitioners. People are now busy discovering a postmechanistic approach to management accounting to be implemented in new factories within a new market and a newworld. A number of new management accounting techniques as well as practices have now emerged.

How do we explain the change? Obviously, there is no definitive answer. The answers depend upon our perspective. Different perspectives produce different views of change. We therefore present all possible perspectives, allowing the reader to choose one or several. You may recognize different perspectives, argue for and against them, and be interested in adopting one or some. It is up to you. We do not believe that there is any absolute truth in the field of management accounting. All we can do is engage in speculation and inter pretation. Moreover, we can explain what we see through some frameworks which we think suitable. Our aim is not to provide definitive answers to the issues of management accounting change. Rather, we want to raise issues for thought, discussion and reflection. Perspectives which we unfold in the second half of this book will provide an alter native framework for this intellectual exercise. These perspectives range from fashionable economic ideas to critical political debates, from economic theories to political thoughts, and from well-established models to emerging theorizations.

xviii

STRUCTURE AND CONTENT

This book contains fifteen chapters. In Chapter 1, we introduce a framework of views, approaches and perspectives. The rest of the book is divided into four parts. In the first two parts, we concentrate on technical development in management accounting from mechanistic to post-mechanistic approaches.

On mechanistic approaches, Part I discusses the emergence of management accounting in relation to:

 mass production and bureaucracy (Chapter 2)

 product costing (Chapter 3)

 profit planning through budgeting (Chapter 4)

 management control through budgeting (Chapter 5)

 economic models of decision-making (Chapter 6)

On post-mechanistic approaches, Part II covers recent modifications and innovations in management accounting concerning:

 customer orientation and flexible manufacturing (Chapter 7)

 strategic management accounting (Chapter 8)

 cost management (Chapter 9)

 new organizations and management control (Chapter 10)

Par ts III and IV introduce per spectives – the rational, the interpretive and the critical. Within the rational perspective, two chapters introduce:

 neoclassical economic theories of MACh (Chapter 11)

 contingency theory of MACh (Chapter 12)

The inter pretive and critical per spectives are unfolded in three chapters that address:

 interpretations, institutions and networks in MACh (Chapter 13)

 political economy of MACh (Chapter 14)

 beyond political economy of MACh (Chapter 15)

GUIDE

This book has been written for advanced students in management accounting. By ‘advanced students’ we mean those taking third- or fourth-year management accounting courses at underg raduate level, and those on M.Sc. and MBA programmes. Perhaps the last two parts will be more useful for these students in choosing an appropriate theoretical framework for data analysis.

This book can be read in a tailored manner. If you want to know about management accounting history, you may concentrate on Part I, with a general understanding of Parts II, III and IV. If you want to know about how management accounting change occurs, you may concentrate on both Parts I and II, with an overview of Parts III and IV. If you want to advance your understanding of why management accounting emerged in a particular manner, then you may concentrate on

Parts I, III and IV, with an understanding of Part II. If you need to know about the whole gamut of management accounting change, then you should give all parts your careful and questioning attention. In addition, this book can be used as a reference guide, when academic needs arise, and we have made every attempt to include the most up-to-date references and resources.

However you use this book, it is important to test your understanding. For this, we have included two types of chapter-end questions. First, under ‘Have you understood the chapter?’, there are questions to test your understanding as well as memory. Second, under ‘Beyond the chapter’, there are open-ended critical questions that will broaden your understanding beyond the mere content of the chapter. When you deal with these questions, you may consult additional resources listed at the end of each chapter in the ‘Further reading’ sections. If you intend to probe into ‘unseen issues and perspectives’, these additional resources will be more helpful.

We hope you enjoy reading this book, and that it will provoke divergent thoughts, theoretical debates and multiple reflections.

KEY TO BOXES

Lear ning objectives: Presented at the star t of eac hc hapter, these boxes carry the highlights of core coverage in terms of learning objectives/outcomes you should achieve/acquire after studying each chapter.

Key terms: Presented between necessary paragraphs throughout the text, these boxes entail relevant definitions of key concepts, techniques and methods covered in respective sections of each chapter.

Point in focus: Inser ted in respective sub-sections throughout the text, these boxes summarise the main point being discussed, which will be a useful guide for revising each chapter.

Acknowledgements

This book is a product of the help and blessings of a number of people. From the inception, Professor Trevor Hopper at the University of Manchester encouraged us by providing stimulating comments and guidance. His specific comments on the shape of a book of this natureresulted in meaningful changes and modifications. Equally, Professor Robert Scapens at Manchester was instr umental in providing further encouragement. In particular, one of us had the opportunity to share a final-year course on advanced management accounting with Professor Scapens from which this book began and developed. The students at Manchester who took this course provided formal and ad hoc comments collectively and individually on most of the early versions of the chapters. We were glad to see that the students were excited to know that there is some knowledge of accounting behind number s whic h they had inadvertently ignored.

We wish to acknowledge the professional and friendly support given by Jaqueline Curthoys, Francesca Heslop and Emma Joyes atRoutledge and their understanding of the pains of putting this book together.While producing it, we received much encouragement and support from the staff in the production department at Routledge. Above all, Emma made all this possible.

We would like to thank the following publishers whose materials have been included in the text: ASQ, Cornell University, USA; Blackwell Publishers Ltd., UK; Elsevier Ltd., UK; Harvard Business School Publishing, USA; Oxford University Press, UK; Palgrave Macmillan Ltd., UK; Sage Publications, UK; Simon & Schuster Inc., USA; Thompson Publishing Services, UK; and Univer sity of Alabama Press, USA.

Every effort has been made to contact copyright holders for their permission to reprint selections of this book. The publisher swould be grateful to hear from any copyright holder who is not here acknowledged and will undertake to rectify any errors or omissions in future editions of this book.

Over the past twenty years or so, we have discussed much of the material contained in this book with undergraduate students from a technical perspective. During the past fifteen years or so, we have discussed the same material with postgraduate and MBA students from a managerial perspective, believing that management accounting textbook materials are universal solutions for organizational problems. It was our studies at Manchester (with Professor Trevor Hopper) and at Keele (with Professor Peter Armstrong and Dr Darren McCabe) that began to provide us with a set of critical perspectives from which those technical and managerial prescriptions of management accounting could be seen differently.We wish to acknowledge those students with whom we enjoyed the ‘wonderful world of management accounting’, and Trevor, Peter and Darren for their

critical insights which led us to question the state of that world of management accounting. This book is a product of this long journey.

We are so grateful to Sanjeevanie Cooray, a PhD student at the University of Manchester, and Tharusha Goonaratne, a lecturer at the University of Colombo, for their comments and corrections on technical aspects of the entire book. Mr John Kitching read the whole manuscript in draft and took great care in making comments on the expression and presentation. We benefited greatly from his comments for changes and recommendations. Manoj, Kasun and Shamanie Wickramasinghe provided immense help in ‘correcting’ early drafts and giving all secretarial support.

Our families lived with this book for several years. We are grateful for their forbearance and encouragements during this time which was far too long for all of us. Our wives, Lalanie and Shamanie should have the credit for providing the stimulating academic and social environment in whic h the book materialized. It was delightful to have our children Imesha and Sajan Alawattage and Kasun and Manoj Wickramasinghe ‘disturb’ the daily writing process.

Chapter 1 Learning management accounting change

A STARTING POINT: THE RELEVANCE LOST

Wr iting in the 1980s, Johnson and Kaplan (1987: xi–xii) argued for a ‘r elevance lost’ in management accounting. By this, what they had in mind was the issue of inappropriateness of current management accounting whic h offered, they believe, little capacity for providing useful and timely information for better decisions and control in the areas of product costing and managerial performance. Moreover, they pointed to the contemporary environment of rapid technological c hange, vigorous global and domestic competition, and enormously expanding informationprocessing capabilities. Conventional management accounting which developed from a stable and monopolistic environment had been ‘subservient to financial reporting’ rather than facilitating internal processes for better management of resources.

Johnson and Kaplan contended that the period between 1825 and 1925 represented the heyday of management accounting, during which cost management practices were well developed. However, after 1925, virtually nothing was developed, yet the same practices were used by firms even in the 1980s. If management accounting systems in organizations were to respond to environmental changes and to be shaped into meaningful managerial devices, then there was a simple question as to how the century-old knowledge of management accounting could be suitable for the contemporaryworld of management. To put it another way,as Johnson and Kaplan illustrated from the case of General Motors, the inadequacy of current systems arose from a lag in replacing prewar cost accounting systems, designed for financial reporting and tax purposes, with modern information and accounting systems.

The Japanese counterparts of General Motors, Johnson and Kaplan pointed out, were using different methods and techniques detached from external financial reporting and were becoming more competitive in the global market. Emerging management ‘philosophies’ suc h as total quality management (TQM) and continuous improvement have come to be parts of management accounting systems which provide both financial and non-financial information. Management accountants in suc h contexts have become business analysts and internal consultants rather than a type of suppor t staff providing auxiliary ser vices to line managers. In Japan, practices of management accounting systems in different organizations vary, depending upon the nature of market they cater to, rather than relying on a set of prescriptions developed outside the organization.

SETTING THE SCENE

What you have seen above is a non-changing nature of management accounting in a changing environment. It summarizes why management accounting has not been responding to this change. In response to this, several new techniques of management accounting have been developed in the last two decades. In this book, we categorize these techniques under three major titles: cost management, strategic management and management accounting in new organizations. This development is now commonly known as management accounting change (hereafter MACh). To learn about MACh, some would tend to concentrate only on these new developments. Does this make sense of MACh? Were there any early changes in management accounting at all? What is management accounting in the first place? How do we learn about MACh in a sensible manner? Is there only one way of learning about change? These questions have motivated us to write this chapter. Let us first talk about your previous management accounting courses.

MACh can be reflected in recent developments in three major areas: cost management, strategic management and management accounting in new organizations.

Basic questions which motivated us:

 Does this make sense of MACh?

 Were there any early changes in management accounting at all?

 What is management accounting in the first place?

 How do we learn about MACh in a sensible manner?

 Is there only one way of learning about change?

The introductory management accounting cour ses thatyou have taken emphasized the technical aspects of management accounting They introduced you to various management accounting techniques. They also guided you to rehearse and practise those techniques through examples and chapter-end exercises. Moreover, from advanced management accounting texts, you learned about new developments in those techniques. Thereby, you may believe that MACh means those additions to the existing stock of techniques. Further, you might tend to think that these techniques emerge on their own. This is partly correct, in that changes in management accounting are reflected in the emergence of new techniques. However, you inadvertently neglect external factors which underlie such developments. To capture the total picture of change, we believe, one should understand not only those technical developments but also their underlying socio-economic factors. One of the main themes around which this book is organized is that technical developments in management accounting take place in correspondence with evolutions in socio-economic systems as a whole. That said, management accounting evolves to serve certain managerial rationales in evolving socioeconomic systems.

The purpose of this chapter is to provide a framework which aligns technical developments in management accounting with the major phases in the evolution of socio-economic systems.

To begin with, we will first define management accounting in terms of three different views: technical–managerial, pragmatic–interpretive and critical–socio-economic. These views tell us that the definitions of management accounting can be an interpretive and ideological project rather than an ultimate conclusion of a ‘science of management accounting’. This will also point to an interesting comparison between the three views which blur the widespread conception that management accounting belongs to a single world view dominated by a global project of professionalization.

 To define management accounting in terms of three views: technical–managerial, pragmatic–interpretive and critical–socio-economic

 To compare and contrast the three views which may blur the conception that management accounting belongs to one single world view

The second set of learning objectives has been specified for the examination of the notion of MACh. After raising the issue of understanding this term, a section will define MACh as a movement from mechanistic to post-mechanistic forms of management accounting. In this, references will be given to respective chapters to specify the working definitions of the terms ‘mechanistic’ and ‘post-mechanistic’.

 To examine the phenomenon of MACh

 To view MACh as a movement from mechanistic to post-mechanistic forms

The last section of the chapter will define the notion of perspectives, the second theme of the book. Two perspectives will be teased out: rational–economic and critical–social. As will be shown, the per spectives provide not only a meaning system for understanding MACh, but also a guide for evaluating alternative research paradigms which have been debated in management accounting research.

 To define the notion of perspectives by dividing them into rational–economic and critical–social

 To highlight the academic significance of understanding alternative perspectives on MACh

WHAT IS MANAGEMENT ACCOUNTING?

This question has been repeatedly asked by almost all management accounting texts. They rely largely on some popular definitions developed by accounting professional bodies. Accordingly, the commonly held view is that management accounting is a unitary and universal practice, independent of the time and space in which it operates. For this, management accounting has a specific set of functions based on perfectly defined techniques which have been developed from both theory and practice. It is hoped that wherever and whenever these techniques are used, the same outcomes are expected, and their fullest original forms are adopted. While this view has to be respected, we can move beyond this point, to study the subject broadly and realistically.

The commonly held view is that management accounting is a unitary and universal practice, but we move beyond this point, to study the subject broadly and realistically.

Instead of providing a firm definition of what management accounting is, it might be better to look at different world views of the subject. In some sense,we can consider three different views of management accounting, and sets of its functions. The first set is related to the technical–managerial view, which is widely held by practising management accountants and most textbook writers. The second set is related to the pragmatic–interpretive view, which is promoted by a group of accounting researchers who attempt to understand management accounting practice. The third set is related to a critical–socio-economic view, which offers critical evaluations of the functioning of management accounting within its broader socio-economic context. A brief account of those views is presented below.

There can be three world views of management accounting:

 technical–managerial view

 pragmatic–interpretive view

 critical–socio-economic view

Technical–managerial view

According to the technical–managerial view, management accounting is:

1.A set of calculative practices. In support of decision-making and control, management accountants use various techniques, such as product costing, budgeting, variance analysis, cost–volume–profit analysis, investment appraisal and so on. All these calculative practices are collectively known as management accounting.

2. A manager ial function or a sub-system of the overall organizational information system. In an organization, there are certain managerial functions, such as production, marketing, HRM,

R&D, etc. Management accounting, which is often under the purview of finance, is such a managerial function. The role of that management accounting function is to support decisionmaking and control by providing financial and non-financial information.

According to the technical–managerial view, management accounting constitutes a set of calculative practices and a managerial function or a sub-system of the overall organizational information system.

To maintain management accounting as a set of calculative practices and a distinct managerial function within organizations, the necessary infrastructure is provided by professional bodies and academia. They develop, disseminate and diffuse management accounting knowledge and techniques, and they train and qualify necessary personnel to practise management accounting. Box 1.1 shows two definitions of management accounting from two professional bodies.

BOX 1.1VIEWS OF PRACTITIONERS

American Accounting Association, 1958

The application of appropriate concepts and techniques in processing the historical and projected economic data of an entity to assist management in establishing plans for reasonable economic objectives and in the making of rational decisions with a view toward achieving these objectives.

Chartered Institute of Management Accountants (UK), 2000

Management accounting is an integral part of management. It requires the identification, generation, presentation, interpretation and use of information relevant to:

 formulating business strategy;

 planning and controlling activities;

 decision-making;

 efficient resource usage;

 performance improvement and value enhancement.

The technical–managerial view represents the conventional wisdom of management accounting whic h is presented in most textbooks. Students using these textbooks reproduce the underlying tec hniques in the for m of calculative and prescr iptive answers to their exam questions. Graduates and professionals, those who have passed these exams, reproduce the management accounting techniques as part of management accounting practices within organizations. Consultants who

believe that these techniques provide solutions to managerial problems reproduce those techniques as applicable models. In this way, the conventional wisdom of management accounting is sustained generation after generation, with some modifications and changes offered by textbooks, universities, professionals and consultants. Being a powerful organizational practice, this conventional view has now succeeded in influencing the daily programmes of organizational and individual lives: we cannot find any organization which avoids the use of accounting information for a variety of purposes. Chapters 3, 4, 5 and 6 introduce this sustained wisdom of the subject matter of management accounting.

The technical–managerial view represents the conventional wisdom of management accounting, with some modifications and changes offered by textbooks, universities, professionals and consultants. This has now become a powerful organizational practice.

Pragmatic–interpretive view

The pragmatic–interpretive view is concerned with management accounting practice. By ‘practice’, we mean the ways in which it is applied and the organizational consequences of such applications. These concerns are usually raised by researchers rather than practitioners. However, as research efforts in this regard are fragmented, it is difficult to synthesize these concerns into a single phrase. Some researchers – for example, Robert Kaplan and his followers – provide descriptive accounts of practices, identify prevailing problems and formulate solutions. Other researchers – for example, Birkett and Poullaos (2001) – study practices, identify changing features and define the subject in more pragmatic terms. Some interpretive researchers – for example, Rober t Scapens – studythe practice more closely and explain the same theoretically.Abr ief sketch of the contributions of Kaplan, Birkett and Poullaos and Scapens is presented below.

Some researchers provide descriptive accounts of practices, identify prevailing problems and formulate solutions. Others study practices, identify changing features and define the subject in more pragmatic terms. A third group study the practice more closely and explain it theoretically.

According to Johnson and Kaplan (see p. 1 above), management accounting is a corporate information system that is subservient to external financial reporting rather than providing useful and timely information for product costing and managerial performance. Thus, it is important, as implied by Johnson and Kaplan, to develop more appropriate management accounting systems for better decision-making and management control. Following this recognition of ‘irrelevance’, Harvard Business School academics led by Robert Kaplan developed/introduced more ‘relevant’ management accounting techniques suc h as the balanced scorecard (BSC) and activity-based costing (ABC). The former argued for a connection of management accounting with strategy and the role of non-financial performance. The latter introduced an alternative cost allocation method

along with a methodology for ‘activity-based management’. Chapters 8 and 9 will explore these two developments and their managerial consequences. The chapters highlight that, despite these consequences, the ‘new’ techniques tend to be popular and influential.

To Johnson and Kaplan, today’s management accounting is irrelevant to today’s environment. The balanced scorecard (BSC) and activity-based costing (ABC) have been introduced as more ‘relevant’ techniques. Chapters 8 and 9 will explore these developments.

According to Birkett and Poullaos (2001), the current state of management accounting is an outcome of a historical evolution from the 1950s. In that decade, the emphasis was on the term ‘management accounting’ in which costing and budgeting techniques became the central subject matter. (This existed even earlier as separated organizational practice.) From the mid-1960s, management accounting was a support or staff role which concentrated on planning and control, while early budgeting and costing became organizational routines. From the mid-1980s, it was about ‘resource management’, which invaded the ‘provinces’ of others, such as waste management, continuous improvement and business process re-engineering (BPR). From the 1990s, the ‘resource management’ perspective on management accounting became more focused on risk management and value creation. Consequently, Birkett defines management accounting in more pragmatic terms:

Management accounting is part of the management process which is focused on organizational resource use. Thus, it refers to managerial processes and technologies that are focused on adding values to organisations by attaining the effective use of resources, in dynamic and competitive context.

(IMPAS1, section 28, cited in Baxter and Chua, 2006)

To Birkett and Poullaos, management accounting is an outcome of a historical evolution: in the 1950s it was conventional ‘management accounting’; from the mid-1960s, it was a support or staff role; from the mid-1980s, it was about ‘resource management’; from the 1990s, the ‘resource management’ perspective became more focused on risk management and value creation.

Moreover, Birkett (as a single author) articulated that management accounting practice is a product of four inter related factors: social institutions (e.g., professions and the state), organizational context, technologies and research contributions. By configuring these factors, Birkett believed, the ‘resource-based perspective’ on management accounting can be furthered by establishing cer tain organizational practices, such as ‘direction setting’, ‘structuring’, ‘commitment’, ‘change’ and ‘control’. Management accounting (that is, accountants) is a facilitator in mater ializing these practices. Birkett also highlighted the fact that, as a distinct professional practice, management accounting is under ‘threat’, as its current trend is to invade ‘other provinces’ of organizational

Another random document with no related content on Scribd:

Myogalepyrenaïca, II 304.

Myxineglutinosa, 309.

M y x i n o ï d e n , 316.

N.

N a b e r , Prof. S. A., over het vaderland der Ariërs, 413.

N a c h t z w a l u w , Zuid-Amerikaansche, stemorgaan van een , II 95.

N a c h t z w a l u w e n , zie Caprimulgidae.

N a d a i l l a c , Markies de, over den voorhistorischen mensch in Amerika, 409.

N a g e l s , der apen, 291.

N a h s u a , II 348.

N a m u , II 348.

N a p e l s , verhouding der seksen bij wettige en onwettige geboorten te — , 505.

N a t t e r e r , over den scherpen reuk der wilden, 102.

N a t u u r l i j k e t e e l t k e u s , II 396.

N a u l e t t e , grot van la — , 47; onderkaak van la — , 47.

N e a n d e r d a l , mensch van het , 420.

N e a n d e r d a l s c h e d e l , 45, 388; vorm van den , 46; inhoud van den , 107.

Nectarinidae, II 95.

N e d e r d u i t s c h e r s , 382.

N e d e r l a n d , verhouding der mannelijke en vrouwelijke geboorten in , 504; jaarlijksche toeneming der [517]Joden in , 502; verhouding der seksen in — , 505;

volkstellingen in , 505; verhouding der seksen in verschillende levenstijdperken in , 507.

N e d e r l a n d e r s , 382; volgens Haeckel nauwer verwant met de Angelsaksen dan met de Hoogduitschers, 383.

N e d e r l a n d s c h e bewoners der Kaapkolonie, naam door de — aan Pneumora gegeven, 574.

N e g e r s , 381; schedelinhoud der 107; haar der , 387; afbeelding van op Egyptische monumenten, 372; wijken niet terug voor de blanken, 387; witte — , II 147; afstamming der , II 346.

N e g e r r a s , 379, 380.

N e g r o ï d e schedels, in Europa gevonden, 388.

N e m e r t i n e n , de naaste verwanten van den stamvorm der gewervelde dieren, 300.

N e o l i t h i s c h e periode, 44.

N e o l i t h i s c h tijdvak, 429.

Nervus trigeminus, 43. Nesodon, 296.

N e s t b o u w , II 173; van Grallina australis, II 173; van den Baltimorevogel, II 174; gewijzigde — van Ploceus en musschen, 151.

N e s t e n , van visschen in Suriname, II 35.

N e s t h a n g e r s , zie Icteridae.

N e t v l e u g e l i g e n , geluiden der — , 570.

N e t v l i e s , gele vlek op het der apen, 41.

N e u f v i l l e , Dr. de, over de sterfteverhouding der Joden en Christenen te Frankfort, 502.

N e u g e b a u e r , over overtallige zogklieren en tepels, 104.

N e u s a p e n , 320.

N e u s b l o e d i n g e n , maandelijks periodiek terugkeerende , 40.

N e u s g a t e n der apen, 291.

N e u s h o o r n met beenig neusschot, lijken van den — gevonden, 110.

N e u s h o o r n s , 290.

N e u s h o r e n v o g e l s , zie Bucerotidae.

N e u s s c h o t , der apen, 291.

N i e b e l u n g e n l i e d , over den Wisent en den Urus, 256.

N i e r e n , afmetingen der — , 384.

N i e u w - C a l e d o n i ë r s , tandstelsel der — , 109.

N i e u w - G u i n e a , steenen werktuigen uit — , 262.

N i e u w - H o l l a n d e r s , 318, 320, 411; voeten der , 41; gemiddelde schedelinhoud van de , 108; familietaal bij de , 175; tandstelsel der , 109; familietrek tusschen de Afrikaansche negers en de — , 387; — wijken terug voor de blanken, 387; uitsterven der , 388.

N i e u w - M a l t h u s i a n i s m e , II 396.

N i e u w - Z e e l a n d , steenen werktuigen op gevonden, 266.

N o e m H o t e p , muurschildering in het graf van , 371.

N o n v i l l e , de hoeveelheid maïs in vier dorpen der Seneca’s verbrand, 261.

N o o r d - B r a b a n t , overmaat der mannelijke geboorten in , 508; getalsverhouding der seksen in , 506; der mannelijke en vrouwelijke geboorten in — , 598; getalsverhouding der levend en levenloos aangegevenen in — , 508; der wettig en onwettig geboren jongens en meisjes in , 509.

N o o r d - H o l l a n d , overmaat der mannelijke geboorten in , 508; getalsverhouding der seksen in , 506; der mannelijke en vrouwelijke geboorten in , 508; getalsverhouding der levend en levenloos aangegevenen in , 508; der wettig en onwettig geboren jongens en meisjes in , 509.

N o o r d l a n d , II 348.

N o o r d p o o l s t r e k e n , vroeger grootendeels land en het oorspronkelijk vaderland van den mensch, 417.

N o o r w e g e n , verhouding der geboorten in — , 504. [518]

N o r f o l k , de gemengde bevolking van het eiland — , 377.

N u b i ë r , afgebeeld op een Egyptisch monument, 372.

N u b i ë r s , 379, 381; wijken niet terug voor de blanken, 387.

N u b i s c h e r a s , 379, 380.

Nymphae der Hottentotsche vrouwen, 377.

O.

Oblata melanura, 310.

O c e a n i s c h e eilanden, waardoor zij zich kenmerken, 42.

Odontornithes, 297.

O e r a m n i o t e n , 317, 319.

Oecodoma cephalotes, 289.

O e r d a r m d i e r e n , 315, 319.

O e r d i e r e n , 319.

O e r - G e r m a n e n , 382.

O e r m e n s c h e n , 318, 381.

O e r - r i n g w o r m e n , 300.

O e r -T h r a c i ë r s , 382.

O e r v i s s c h e n , 317, 319.

O l i f a n t a c h t i g e D i e r e n , 290; — op de ruïnen van Palenqué afgebeeld, 262; beenderen van — in de sables de l’Orléanais, 295.

O l i f a n t e n , witte — , II 147.

O m b e r v i s s c h e n , II 35.

Ondatra, zie Fiber zibethicus.

O n d e r k a a k , van la Naulette, 44, 47; van Arcy, 47; van Moulin Quignon, 36; menschelijke uit het Schipkahol, 48.

O n d e r r i j k e n en klassen, 528.

O n d e r w i j s , verplicht en kosteloos een krachtig palliatief tot leniging der sociale ellende, 396.

O n t b o e z e m i n g e n , 156.

O n t w i k k e l i n g , stilstand in de — , 38; bewijs voor de trapsgewijze — van sommige dieren, 151; stilstand in de en misvormingen die daarvan het gevolg zijn, 38; van het individu een verkorte herhaling van die der soort, bewezen door de Amphibieën, II 223.

O n t w i k k e l i n g s p h a s e n van den menschelijken typus, 293.

O n v o l l e d i g o n t w i k k e l d e d e e l e n , 33.

O o g e n , correlatie tusschen de kleur der en die van huid en haar, 38.

O o g l i d , derde , 43.

O o r s p r o n k e l i j k e menschen, 381.

O o s t e n r i j k , verhouding der seksen bij wettige en onwettige geboorten in , 505; verhouding der geboorten in — , 504.

O o s t e r l i n g e n , 379.

O o s t - P r u i s e n , verhouding der seksen bij wettige en onwettige geboorten in , 505.

O p e r c u l u m , beteekenis van het woord , 303.

O p e i s c h e r , de en zijn rol bij de bruiloft in Drenthe, II 376.

Ophidium barbatum, 310.

O r a n g - O e t a n , 318, 320; afbeelding der hersenen van den door Schroeder van der Kolk en Vrolik, 39; waarnemingen van A. R. Wallace omtrent een jongen , 40; hersenen van den en van den mensch, 293; woonplaats van den — , 41, 294; gemiddelde schedelinhoud van den — , 108.

Oreotragus saltatrix, 259.

O r g a n e n , rudimentaire — , 33; van Rosenmüller, 34; homotype , 33.

O r g a n i s c h e lichamen door synthese gevormd, 314.

Ornithorhynchus, 290; spoor van , II 258.

Orthragoriscus, II 35.

Orycteropus capensis, II 259.

Oryxgazella, II 259.

Oscines, II 95.

O s - k i k v o r s c h , II 36.

Osphronemus olfax, II 34.

O s t i a k e n , 376.

O t a h e i t e r s en Engelschen, de bevolking van het eiland Pitcairn bestaat uit bastaarden tusschen , 377.

Otis, 501.

Otolithus regalis, II 35.

O u d e B r i t t e n , 382.

O u d h e i d van het menschelijk geslacht, 295.

O u d h e i d van den mensch, praehistorische — bewezen, 401.

O u d - P r u i s e n , 382. [519]

O u d - S a k s e n , 382.

O u i s t i t i ’ s en Rolapen, hoofd der — en van den mensch, 293.

O v e r b e v o l k i n g bij de bijen, 215.

O v e r g a n g s z i n t u i g e n , 35.

O v e r t a l l i g e t e p e l s , 38; in de okselholte, de lies en den rug, 38.

O v e r t a l l i g e v i n g e r s e n t o o n e n , 38.

O v e r t a l l i g e z o g k l i e r e n , 104.

O v e r z i c h t , Systematisch der twaalf menschensoorten, 380.

O v e r i j s e l , overmaat der mannelijke geboorten in , 508; getalsverhouding der seksen in , 506;

der mannelijke en vrouwelijke geboorten in , 508; der levend en levenloos aangegevenen in , 506; der wettig en onwettig geboren jongens en meisjes in , 509.

O w e n , Prof. R., over de verdeeling der zoogdieren, 290; over de hersenen van den mensch en de apen, 39.

Oxystomus, 528.

P.

P a a r d e n , merkwaardige trekken uit het leven van — , 150.

Pachydermata, II 304.

Pacochoerus aethiopicus, II 259.

P a e d o g e n e s i s , 312.

Pagellus erythrinus, 300; mormyrus, 310.

P a i n t e l , over het geweten bij wilden, 260.

P a l a e o l i t h i s c h e tijdvak, 319; oudste volksverhuizingen in het , 400; periode, 44.

Palaeotheria, 290.

P a l e n q u é , ruïnen van , 262.

P a n g e n e n , 314.

P a n s f l u i t , 229.

P a n t e r , zwarte — , II 147.

P a p e , over het bewaren der Cicaden in Spanje, 571.

P a p e g a a i die de taal van een uitgestorven Indianenstam sprak, 227.

P a p e g a a i e n , II 174; hun geestvermogens, II 152 v.v.

P a p e i t i , scherpe reukzin van een bewoner van , 102.

Papilio Machaon, venkelgeur van , 609.

P a p o e a r a s , 379, 380.

P a p o e a ’s, 318, 381; inhoud van den schedel der , 107; haar der — , 370; grenslijn tusschen — en Maleiers, 375; uitsterven der , 387; familietrek tusschen de en de Hottentotten, 387; wijken terug voor de blanken, 387; metopisme bij de , 109; familietaal bij de , 175.

Paradisiadae, II 95.

P a r a d i j s v o g e l s , zie Paradisiadae.

P a r a h y b a , tunnel onder de — door mieren gegraven.

P a r a l l e l c i r k e l s , verhuizing in de richting der — niet de oorspronkelijke, 409.

P a r a s i t i s m e , 298.

Pardalotus, II 174.

Paridae, II 95, 174.

P a r k e n , omheind, opdat de wilde runderen er zouden kunnen blijven voortleven, 258.

P a r k e r , over het dooden van bastaarden in Australië, 377.

P a r i j s , verhouding der seksen bij wettige en onwettige geboorten te , 505.

P a r i j s c h e kerkhoven en schedels, 108.

P a r i j z e n a a r s , uit armengraven, gemiddelde schedelinhoud der , 107; uit de 12de eeuw, gemiddelde schedelinhoud der , 107; uit eigen graven der 19de eeuw, gemiddelde schedelinhoud der , 107; uit de 19de eeuw, gemiddelde schedelinhoud der , 107.

P a s g e b o r e n e n , hersengewicht van , 156.

P a s t e u r , zijn proeven over generatio spontanea, 314.

Pediculati, II 35.

P e l a g i s c h e Fauna der Glasdieren, 528. [520]

P é l i s s o n , over den smaak eener spin voor muziek, 529.

Percidae, 310.

P e r e z , J., over geluiden van insekten, 570.

P é r i g o r d , oude grotbewoners van , 44.

P e r i o d e , palaeolithische , 44; neolithische — , 44.

P e r i o d e n , geologische — van de organische geschiedenis der aarde, 319.

Perissodactyla, 290.

P e r m i s c h e periode, 319.

Peronaeus longus, 44.

P e r u a n e n , gemiddelde schedelinhoud der oude — , 407; landbouw der tijdens de ontdekking van Amerika, 261.

P e s c h e l , over de verscheidenheid van talen in Amerika, 175.

Petromyzontes, 349.

P e u l , 379.

P e u l v r u c h t e n , familie der , 218.

P f e i f f e r , Mevr., over den scherpen reuk der wilden, 102.

P f i t s n e r , W., over den kleinen teen bij den mensch, 34.

Phaëton, II 224.

Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.