Daily
the Brown
vol. cxlvi, no. 18
Herald
Friday, February 18, 2011
Panelists debate gay marriage
Since 1891
Asst. soccer coach goes missing
R i t e s o f Pa s s ag e
By Tony Bakshi Sports Editor
By Katherine Sola Senior Staff Writer
inside
continued on page 3
news...................2-3 Arts.........................5 editorial..............6 Opinion.................7 SPORTS...................8
Hilary Rosenthal / Herald
Professor of Comparative Literature Arnold Weinstein read from his new book, “Morning, Noon and Night” at the Brown Bookstore yesterday afternoon.
Weinstein reflects on growth and discovery By Emma Wohl Senior Staff Writer
Professor of Comparative Literature Arnold Weinstein read an excerpt from his new book “Morning, Noon, and Night” and discussed its creation in front of a small crowd of community members and students in the Brown Bookstore Thursday afternoon. The book of literary analysis touches on the same subjects of confusion, isolation and discovery experienced in adolescence that Weinstein teaches in the first-year seminar COLT 0610D: “Rites of Passage.”
But “Morning, Noon, and Night” goes beyond the scope of the class, looking not just at the process of growing up but at growing old as well. Weinstein began with a defense of literature as a subject worthy of study, emphasizing that it is “not informational, but experiential.” He compared literature to the practice of trying on clothes in a store. It allows readers to “try on” an experience, he said. But literature is also a voyage, he added, one that is cheaper and more comfortable than today’s air travel.
Magic class melds philosophy, science By Anne simons Staff Writer
Your room is in complete disarray — clothes everywhere, books and notebooks scattered across your bed, old take-out containers littering the floor. You absolutely hate cleaning, but it has to be done — can magic help?
FEature This was the hypothetical problem recently posed to members of a student group studying magic. You could clean your room and then practice a form of selfhypnotism to make your brain forget the unpleasant memories, the group proposed. As far as your
Weinstein also discussed the themes in his book. Growing up and adolescence are areas fitting for the college classroom because students are in a sort of limbo, he said. But he said it is more difficult to bring attention to the subject of old age and aging. “I have the wisdom to know that if I taught a class about growing old, I would have an attendance of zero,” Weinstein said. The chapter he chose to read analyzes “a book that nobody’s ever continued on page 2
brain is concerned, your room was dirty one moment and clean the next. This may be possible through the practice of modern magic — a blend of magic, philosophy and cognitive science. Evan Stites-Clayton ’11, who turned heads last semester with his Group Independent Study Project on lucid dreaming, is casting his spell on broader themes of magic in a course this semester called “Modern Magic and Mysticism.” The class is not recognized by the University for credit and is instead what Stites-Clayton termed a “group unofficial student project,” or “GUSP.” It is sponsored by Global Extensions, a support
Hilary Rosenthal / Herald
continued on page 3
Students attended the annual Liquid Nitrogen Ice Cream Event hosted by the Brown chemical engineering group yesterday in Barus and Holley.
Rip some rope
Rewind
Bears set sights on Ivy, national titles
Uhrick ’11 looks back on her education
Sports, 4
Denis Chartier, an assistant coach of the women’s soccer team, has been missing since Feb. 6, according to Marisa Quinn, vice president for public affairs and University relations. Chartier’s family members have filed a missing persons report with the Burrillville Police, Quinn wrote in an e-mail to The Herald. The team held a candlelight vigil for Chartier Tuesday at 11 p.m. on the Meister-Kavan Field behind the Olney-Margolies Athletic Center. Pincince and several members of the team spoke at the event. Pincince, who was a captain with Chartier on the men’s soccer team at Woonsocket High School, said he last spoke to Chartier Feb. 5. “All our thoughts and prayers are with Coach Denis,” Pincince said. “We’re just focusing on finding him.” Chartier concluded his 16th year as a coach on the Bears’ staff at the end of the 2010 season. He coached the team for 13 years from 1989-2001 and returned to the program in 2008, according to the athletics department. The University “has made support services available to members of the community affected by the news,” Quinn wrote.
I scream for ice cream
opinions, 7
weather
“Separate is not equal.” At the end of the Janus Forum’s panel on gay marriage last night, Jesse McGleughlin ’14 — the daughter of two lesbian mothers — stood up to argue for the right of gay couples to marry, brandishing the familiar phrase to the applause of the audience in MacMillan 117. The panel featured both proponents and opponents of gay marriage, but McGleughlin was responding to an argument from Douglas Allen, professor of economics at Simon Fraser University, who said gay couples should be granted a marriage institution separate from that of heterosexual couples. In his presentation, Allen explored the costs and benefits of opening the institution of marriage to include gay couples. He said gay, lesbian and heterosexual couples are “much different” from each other, and traditional marriage should not include gay couples.The laws governing heterosexual marriage would have to adapt to accommodate the small number of gay couples, he argued, with negative effects on heterosexual couples, including a higher divorce rate. He described civil unions as a parallel institution to marriage for gay couples, and suggested the possibility of creating one type of union for lesbians and another for gays. On the other side of the debate, M.V. Lee Badgett, professor of economics at the University of Massachusetts at Amherst, said there was virtually no difference between heterosexual and gay couples and that gay marriage poses “no harm to the institution of marriage.” She highlighted similar divisions of labor and income disparity in gay and heterosexual households. Both gay and heterosexual couples want to marry for reasons of “love, commitment and mutual support,” Badgett said. Andrew Koppelman, professor of law at Northwestern University, described two different models of marriage. The older, more traditional model sees couples getting married soon after they mature sexually for the purpose of procreation. He then described a newer model, in which couples
t o d ay
tomorrow
52 / 32
36 / 17