Monday, October 4, 2010

Daily Herald the Brown

vol. cxlv, no. 83 | Monday, October 4, 2010 | Serving the community daily since 1891

315 Thayer renovations to grow campus housing Corp. accepts

By Brigitta Greene Metro Editor

Renovations to the University-owned apartment building at 315 Thayer St. will result in 66 more on-campus beds by 2012, said Margaret Klawunn, vice president for campus life and student services.

The renovations represent the largest expansion of the residence hall system since the opening of Vartan Gregorian Quad in 1991.

Though located on the northern end of the Pembroke campus — a predominantly freshman residential community — the new residence hall will likely house sophomores and juniors. Single and double bedrooms will be “clustered” along a central hallway, with a shared lounge and study space on each floor, Klawunn said.

The four-stor y brick building is currently part of Brown’s auxiliary housing system. Its 32 student residents live in two- and three- bed-

The ArabIsraeli conflict on campuses

By Sarah Forman Staff Writer

Of the hundreds of passions and interests pursued on campus, none manages to simultaneously unite and drive apart the community as much as the conflict in Israel and Palestine.

higher ed

gift to fund humanities

room apartments, paying about $750 in monthly rent, Richard Bova, senior associate dean of residential and dining ser vices, wrote in an e-mail to The Herald. It is not now considered part of the on-campus residence hall system.

Preliminary plans for the new residence hall include the relocation of central stairways, opening greater flow across all four floors and allowing adequate egress for safety. As it stands, the stairways block access across floors, creating a tower-like feel, Klawunn said. The University does not rent rooms on the fourth floor due to a lack of exits.

Despite its current flaws, “the building has good bones,”she said.

Construction is expected to begin this summer, President Ruth Simmons wrote in her Oct. 2 e-mail to the University community. Funding for the renovations was approved by the Corporation’s Budget and continued on page 9

Capital projects top weekend’s meeting

By Alex Bell Senior Staff Writer

inside

www.browndailyherald.com

continued on page 5

Simmons to work on U.S.-Muslim relations

By Kristina Fazzalaro Senior Staff Writer

President Ruth Simmons was nominated on Sept. 22 to the steering committee of Partners for a New Beginning, a non-partisan, nonprofit organization dedicated to improving relations between the United States and Muslim countries. A Brown program, Heritage as Bridge, will be Simmons’ first initiative as a member.

Partners was founded jointly between the Department of State and the Aspen Institute, a non-

profit organization dedicated to pursuing common ground and deeper understanding on critical issues, according to the organization’s website.

The steering committee is responsible for “operationalizing” this partnership, according to Toni Verstandig P’12, executive director of Middle East Programs at the Aspen Institute and secretariat of Partners.

“Partners for a New Beginning is the follow-up to President Obama’s Cairo Speech,” Verstandig said. In June 2009, Obama dis-

URI tackles GLBT rights

BY Abby Kerson Contributing Writer

Students at the University of Rhode Island staged a sit-in protest on behalf of the school’s Gay Lesbian Bisexual Transgender Center. The protest began Sept. 23 and came to an end eight days later on Oct. 1 when the university’s administration agreed to meet the students’ seven demands.

Big voices on campus “It’s an extremely hot button issue on campus,” said Liz Jackson ’01, a law student at the University of California, Berkeley and a member of Berkeley Students for Justice in Palestine. “It’s extremely polarized.”

Last year, the Associated Students of the University of California — Berkeley’s student senate — passed a measure urging divestment from two American companies that supply war

News.......1–6 Arts..........7 Sports.....8–9 Editorial....10 Opinion.....11 Today........12

continued on page 6

Stephanie London / Herald

Interior renovations to auxiliary housing at 315 Thayer St. will double its bed count and bring it into the on-campus housing pool by 2012.

The discourse on College Hill can be polarized — even with two groups specifically designed to reinforce the middle ground — in a manner that just doesn’t happen with other forms of student activism. But even if table slips and guest speakers leave some students feeling torn between just a few sharply different perspectives, the contention and rancor at some other campuses leaves Brown looking positively harmonious.

continued on page 6

cussed his aspirations in Egypt to renew engagements with Muslim countries. The Cairo Speech “lays out four pillars in which that engagement can be advanced — economic opportunity, science and technology, education and exchange,” Verstandig said.

Partners is first reaching out to five target areas: Egypt, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, Indonesia, Pakistan and Turkey, she added.

One of the best features of the

During this weekend’s meeting, members of Brown’s highest governing body reviewed year-end budget results, accepted gifts, approved plans to expand housing and dedicated buildings.

The University formally accepted a $3 million gift to fund a new humanities initiative, which will serve as a “stimulus for innovation” in humanities and aid the University in its goal of attracting senior-level humanities faculty, said Dean of the Faculty Rajiv Vohra P’07.

Vohra said that in the past seven years, 60 percent of faculty hires have been assistant professors, while only 25 percent have been full professors. Vohra said the need for senior faculty hiring is “most acute” in the humanities due in part to resignations and retirements. In the next three years, he said he hopes to hire six new “pre-eminent humanists.”

Vohra said the gift will not be used for hiring faculty directly, but will most likely be used for programmatic purposes such as developing new curricula, running seminars and conferences and supporting research projects.

“When you’re trying to recruit a lot of senior faculty at the same time,

METRO

Courtesy of Brian Stack

URI’s GLBT center arranged a protest calling for the university to meet student demands.

The issues were brought to the forefront in mid-August when a group of students were harassed by a group of males who screamed “faggot” from their car and sped off, according to Brian Stack, a student

volunteer for the GLBT Center and the leader of the sit-in.

Stack and other GLBT students met with David Dooley, president of the university, at his house in late August, along with other members of the administration, to discuss their concerns.

“The students were very effective, very articulate in presenting their demands,” said URI Vice President for Student Affairs Tom Dougan, who was also present at the meeting. The students gave the administration a written list of demands after that meeting, he said.

Despite the meeting and a Sept.

7 blog post written by the president addressing recent harassment continued on page 6

ABWxD

Bruno vs. URI

Social network

Student conference discusses ways to better the world

Brown football loses for the first time this season

William Tomasko ‘13 supports Facebook use – to an extent

ARTS, 5

SPORTS, 7

Opinions, 11

195 Angell Street, Providence, Rhode Island

herald@browndailyherald.com

Page 2

THE BROWN DAILY HERALD

C ampus N EWS

Monday, October 4, 2010

“There’s never a dull moment.”

— Cheryl Manni, owner of LaSalle Bakery

Innovative local bakery supplies Blue Room with popular treats

By Ashley Aydin Senior Staff Writer

LaSalle Bakery sits on the corner of River and Admiral Streets in the Elmhurst neighborhood of Providence.

Its orange walls match the Halloween decorations of spiders, ghosts and pumpkins hanging from its ceiling.

Upon entering the bakery, customers are drawn to the boards that read “European Croissants, Breakfast Sandwiches, Cakes for all Occasions, Fresh All Natural Dog Bones” in white chalk along the walls. The smell of freshly baked bread wafts from the shelves right next to the cheese pizza behind the counter.

As on any other day at the bakery, the tables are occupied by groups of all ages: the young, the old and everyone in between, enjoying rich pastries and one another’s company.

This is not LaSalle’s only location.

The bakery also has a store on Smith Street in Providence.

Cheryl Manni and her husband Michael run the bakery together.

A Blue Room favorite The bakery provides the breakfast pastries that are available in the Blue Room every day, with a selection of croissants, scones, fruit tarts and muffins of all different flavors.

“I usually order muffins. My favorite is pistachio, although other people find it strange,” Jorge Tamames ’14 said.

Brown discovered LaSalle “through word of mouth,” Manni said. “I think there was someone working at Brown who came here.

He might’ve just mentioned he loves coming here.”

But this bakery wasn’t the only one competing for top billing at the

Ashley Aydin / Herald

LaSalle Bakery, which supplies the Blue Room with sweets, has a wide variety of pastries, sandwiches, pizza, and more.

Blue Room.

“The Blue Room menu development team, which was led by Dining Services’ Executive Chef and included students, evaluated the offerings of several area bakeries,” Jacques Larue, director of retail dining, wrote in an e-mail to The Herald.

“We brought in a bunch of breakfast goods,” Manni said.

From Manni’s samples, Brown picked the ones they wanted to serve at the Blue Room.

“LaSalle was the hands-down favorite and determined to have a superior product line on the basis of product quality, presentation and taste. Being local and meeting the guidelines of the Real Food initiative were also among the key selection criteria,” Larue wrote.

Carrying the name This November will mark the

sudoku

35th anniversar y of the Mannis’ purchase of LaSalle.

“My husband worked here as a pan boy on Smith Street,” Manni said. “He lived right behind the bakery. He washed pans with his hands.

That’s how they used to do it in the old days. That’s how he started, when he was 15 years old.”

FEATURE The Mannis ultimately purchased the business in 1975, when Cheryl was 24 and Michael was 25.

“When the owner got sick, he asked Michael to buy it. My husband used his creativity in the bakery. In the bakery you’re always staying on top of things. There’s never a dull moment,” Manni said.

The name LaSalle was inspired by the bakery’s surroundings.

“On Smith Street, there was a La-

Innovation meets tradition Under the Mannis’ direction, the bakery’s offerings have expanded over the years.

“We kind of advanced into a little more of a cafe to keep up with the times. You have to be something for everybody,” she said.

LaSalle makes sandwiches, pizza, muffins, croissants, tiramisu, paninis, cupcakes, cakes, fruit tarts, salads and soups-to-go, as well as many other goods daily. “We have people trained that make them fresh everyday,” Manni said.

The bakery also offers various kinds of coffee flavors such as ti-

continued on page 5

Faunce changes shuffle student groups

By Caroline Hughes Contributing Writer

Daily Herald the Brown

Editorial Phone: 401.351.3372 | Business Phone: 401.351.3260 George Miller, President Claire Kiely, Vice President

Salle pharmacy, LaSalle tailors and a bunch of other stores with LaSalle in their names. That’s why the bakery’s called LaSalle. We’re also across the street from La Salle Academy. We just carried the name,” Manni said.

ramisu, banana hazelnut, snicker doodle and pumpkin spice, among others.

“The only things we don’t sell are doughnuts,” Manni said.

Innovation is one of the owners’ top priorities at LaSalle. New items are regularly introduced to customers, and the bakery has a committee specifically focused on developing new baking ideas.

“Usually the bakers have meetings along with my husband, Michael. They’ll think of something new. They brainstorm together. They read a lot of bakery magazines. They also go to a lot of conventions,” she said. “We’re always trying to keep creative to keep people interested.”

The bakery also has a five-member committee devoted to decorating its baked goods.

“We basically do birthday cakes and standard types of cakes. On weekends, we do wedding cakes and something that requires more work,” Manni said.

There are two really busy times of the year for LaSalle: Christmas and St. Joseph’s Day. Manni said the bakery is also busy on holidays such as Easter and Thanksgiving.

But the bakery is booming with business ever yday and working hours are extensive.

“Smith Street starts at 3 a.m. This store starts at 1 a.m. … because we do the breads here. We close at 7 p.m. here and at 8 p.m. at the Smith Street store. So we’re basically almost open most of the day,” Manni said.

The bakery’s early hours explain the warmth of the pastries first thing in the morning at the Blue Room.

Katie Koh, Treasurer Chaz Kelsh, Secretary

The Brown Daily Herald (USPS 067.740) is an independent newspaper serving the Brown University community daily since 1891. It is published Monday through Friday during the academic year, excluding vacations, once during Commencement, once during Orientation and once in July by The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. Single copy free for each member of the community.

POSTMASTER please send corrections to P.O. Box 2538, Providence, RI 02906. Periodicals postage paid at Providence, R.I. Offices are located at 195 Angell St., Providence, R.I. E-mail herald@browndailyherald.com.

World Wide Web: http://www.browndailyherald.com.

Subscription prices: $319 one year daily, $139 one semester daily.

Copyright 2010 by The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. All rights reserved.

Even Ricky Gresh, senior director for student engagement and chair of the Stephen Robert ’62 Campus Center planning committee, doesn’t know why the Leung Gallery is so quiet.

It was supposed to be a social space, he said.

One of the goals of the renovations of Faunce House, Gresh said, was to increase the square footage of shared meeting spaces such as the Leung Gallery, in addition to accommodating student clubs.

The campus center has permanent spaces assigned to Brown Student Agencies, the Student Activities Office, the Undergraduate Council of Students, the LGBTQ Resource Center, Brown Student Radio and other groups. A computer lab on the third floor contains computers for use by student publications and a room for painting and projects.

Creating open spaces for socializing, studying and meeting meant decreasing the rooms allocated to specific student groups, Gresh said.

Many clubs that had individual offices in Faunce before the renovation now use storage lockers and multi-use meeting rooms throughout

the building. A room dedicated to service, political and social justice organizations houses many groups that previously had their own spaces on campus.

Gresh said he held meetings with student leaders to discuss the renovations, and because he was working so closely with student groups, he didn’t feel there was any unwillingness from student groups who were losing their offices.

Before the renovation, “some groups didn’t even know they had space — some groups really used the space minimally,” he said.

Student groups and organizations previously in Faunce were moved to T.F. Green Hall or J. Walter Wilson.

Sam Eilertsen ’12, executive producer of BTV, said his group was unhappy when they found out in the spring that they could not return to their studio in Faunce after the renovations. Instead, the group was transplanted to T.F. Green.

During the renovation phase, BTV was transitioning away from cable broadcasting and to Internetbased programs. Eilertsen said the administration didn’t think BTV needed the Faunce space anymore due to the changing format of the station. Their studio in Faunce was

given to BSR. “I thought that they did have a reasonable explanation for why they weren’t giving us that particular space back,” said Eilersten. He said that administrators did work with BTV to find the most suitable permanent space on campus for the group. He said his one complaint about the new location is the difficulty of transporting heavy equipment from T.F. Green to shooting locations around campus.

Gresh said several groups had individual needs that he took into account during the relocation process. For example, Project Health needed more space than what it was given after the renovations and was moved into Hillel.

The BSR studio, production space and office were specifically remodeled to suit a radio station.

BSR Station Manager Fiona Condon ’12 worked closely with the project manager to create a space uniquely suited to the organization’s needs.

The renovations added special phone and data lines, as well as rows of shelves for the station’s extensive CD collection.

Andrew Migneault ’11, president continued on page 4

Monday, October 4, 2010

THE BROWN DAILY HERALD

C ampus N EWS

Page 3

“Everyone should care about the future of China.”

— Xu Wenli, leader of China’s democratic party

Chinese democracy: Prof. called on by White House Xu Wenli speaks out

By Jesse Morgan Contributing Writer

By Ben Kutner Contributing Writer

When Xu Wenli spoke in his office, he used his hands like a true orator.

On his wall, he displays a red poster with the words “Free Xu Wenli” over a photo of his face.

Xu, a leader of China’s democratic party and a senior fellow at the Watson Institute for International Studies, conducted a European tour across 14 nations this summer.

“My mission in Europe was to carry out diplomatic activities, academic exchanges, make friends and rekindle the flame of desire for a republic in China,” Xu wrote in an e-mail about his trip. His trip was on behalf of both the China Democracy Party and the Watson Institute, he said.

Xu was not always interested in Chinese politics, he said through a translator. His interest began on April 5, 1976, when he witnessed the communist police forces brutally crush a mourning ceremony for the death of Zhou Enlai, the first premier of the People’s Republic of China, he said.

He was compelled to take action and published an anti-communist magazine called the April Fifth Forum, earning him the nickname “China’s Godfather of Dissent.”

In 1998, Xu’s efforts in helping to found the China Democracy Party were successful, and he remains one of the party’s leaders. “The only way to go against a party that commits many wrongdoings is to create a party,” he said.

“Thus, the mission of the Democratic Party of China, which I passionately lead, is to attempt, for the third time, to establish a republican political system in China and ending the

current Chinese Communist Party’s one-party dictatorship,” Xu wrote.

Since 1982, Xu has served a total of 16 years in Chinese prisons. “In reaction to his declining condition, international human rights groups, the US ambassador to China and Western officials called for his release,” according to the biography on the Watson Institute website.

He was exiled to the U.S. on Dec. 24, 2002, and by Jan. 1, 2003, President Ruth Simmons had offered him a spot on the Brown faculty, Xu said.

“Maybe within five years, there will be major progress with the democratic movement,” Xu said about China’s future. “There will be multiple parties, not restricted only to communism.”

He explained that communism originally took a firm stance at a time when China had no economic growth, but now that more money is in the hands of civilians, government control is becoming weaker. “There are multiple money holders that will cause disruptions within the system,” he said.

Xu’s trip to Europe was a warmup for the events he’ll do in the future, he said. He plans on taking five or six more trips across the world to promote and raise awareness for the Chinese democratic movement. “Everyone should care about the future of China,” Xu said. He warned that the world should “pay more attention.”

“The educated are aware of what’s wrong with this country. This awareness is huge progress,” Xu said.

“It’s like a bucket of water being held up from the Revolution (of 1911). Like 100 years of water added to that bucket, the weight will break soon,” he said. “I hope so.”

Christopher Koller may be an assistant professor of community health while on campus, but when he canceled class Sept. 22, he had a good reason: The White House had called.

Koller serves full-time as Rhode Island’s health insurance commissioner and went to Washington to attend a meeting with President Barack Obama.

Koller was among about 35 insurance regulators who gathered in the Old Executive Office Building for a private meeting with the president and about 20 members of his senior staff, according to Koller. Students had the day off from Koller’s graduate-level PHP 2400: “The U.S. Health Care System: Case Studies in Financing, Delivery, Regulation and Public Health.”

To mark the six-month anniversary of the passage of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, Obama held counsel with the people on whom he relies to execute health care reform: state insurance officials. Secretary of Health and Human Services Kathleen Sebelius and Secretary of Labor Hilda Solis headed the first 30 minutes of the one-hour meeting, while Obama joined the discussion for the sec-

ond half.

According to Koller, Obama presented the group of insurance regulators with three guiding points. First, the chief goal of reform is to make health care better for patients. Second, the states, not the federal government, are responsible for enforcing the reforms. Third, slow is all right if it helps programs work — taking the time to enact effective strategies is time well spent.

Obama then encouraged regulators to lead with courage, Koller said. Obama’s message, Koller paraphrased, was: “Hold insurers accountable and don’t make compromises for compromise’s sake.

Don’t shrink from what you have to do.”

Both Obama and his staff are fully aware of the key role states play in effecting health care reform, Koller said.

Rhode Island has already taken a step in this direction that other states have not. In 2004, Gov. Donald Carcieri ’65 announced the creation of the Office of the Health Insurance Commissioner and put Koller in charge. This unburdened the Department of Business Regulation, which handled all insurance issues until that time, and set up an office to deal specifically with health insurance policy and delivery. Rhode Island remains the only

state with a separate office dealing in health insurance regulation.

Koller summarized the mission of his office with a comparative point.

“If you can’t afford auto insurance, you take a bus. But if you can’t afford health insurance, we force your providers to care for you,” he said.

This year has presented Koller and students in PHP 2400 with a unique opportunity not just to talk about the structure and performance of the U.S. health care system, but also ato see how the new reforms play out.

As a teacher, one of Koller’s primary goals is to make sure his students are exposed to a balance of professional and academic material, he said. Koller’s course gives students an exclusive look at the health care system — its financial machinery, the range in quality of care and the various players involved — from an insider’s perspective. Koller said he also benefits from teaching because it allows him to take a step back from his government work.

But just as Koller holds insurance companies accountable in Rhode Island, his students don’t get free passes either — after he returned from his White House trip, students were required to attend a makeup lecture.

Page 4

THE BROWN DAILY HERALD

C ampus N EWS

Monday, October 4, 2010

“It’s just a thing that we love the most.”

— Sudarshan Sriraman ’11 on cricket

Changed rooms for student groups Cricket on the rise in

popularity at Brown

continued from page 2 of the Computer Network Management Group, helped create the computer lab in the new campus center specifically for student publications. Before the renovation, the group had computers in the 14th floor of the SciLi and in a lounge in Pembroke.

The computer lab in Faunce houses five computers, a large conference table and a separate storage room. Migneault says the biggest user of the computers is the College Hill Independent, which publishes weekly, but he estimated that ten annual or semestral publications will use the space this year.

In addition to meeting rooms and open lounges, the LGBTQ Resource Center has a lounge within their three-room complex. Preference is given to LGBTQ-affiliated groups, such as the Queer Alliance, but Kelly Garrett, coordinator of the center, says any student group is welcome to ask her about using it.

New, brightly colored signs in the hallways of the campus center direct visitors to the organizations and spaces in the building. Because the mezzanine above the Leung Gallery connects both sides of the floor, visitors can traverse the entire level easily.

By Ju Myoung Kim Contributing Writer

Katie Green / Herald

The welcome desk serves as an entry and information point in the new Campus Center.

Garrett and Condon think these changes have made their locations more accessible to the public. The LGBTQ Resource Center was moved to the third floor of Hillel during the renovations, and BSR spent the year in T.F. Green. The temporary locations were difficult to find, Garrett and Condon said.

Condon added that the noise of practicing musicians interfered with the radio station’s broadcasts.

“I feel like we’re a little more visible than we were before,” said Garrett. She said there have been more visitors this year than last year.

Despite the centralized location and large meeting spaces of

the campus center, Condon said student groups aren’t utilizing the meeting rooms as often as they could.

“The rooms I see allotted to specific groups have relatively low traffic,” she said. Garrett and Migneault also mentioned they would like to see more usage out of their spaces.

Gresh said he is pleased with the renovations, but willing to make changes if student groups have problems with the new setup. He said he is discussing the option of card swipe access for members into organizations’ rooms, as opposed to a key box, allowing for better security and easy access.

Despite a lack of proper facilities and equipment, a group of students is attempting to revive the Brown cricket club, making do with tennis balls and, as its field of play, the Main Green.

“It’s just a thing that we love the most,” said Sudarshan Sriraman ’11, a member of the club.

In past years, cricket’s presence at Brown has been informal, but this year’s group is working hard to make the sport a regular feature.

“It has definitely been at a much lower key for the last few years,” Sriraman said, “but since last year, we have been working on getting a lot of people.”

According to Sriraman, this semester, the club has 15 regular members, and a few more joining in for practices. Usually 20 to 25 people play in a practice.

“This year, we have a good solid group now meeting regularly,” he said. “Basically, people who really love the sport joined and tried to revive it.”

One of the club’s goals this year is simply to play regularly and “get a lot of people watching us,” Sriraman said. He himself first got involved last semester when he saw students and their cricket equipment on the green.

Rahul Srivathsa ’14, a new member, agreed. “It’s an open club. Anyone can join,” he said.

According to Sriraman, six new members joined the club this year.

“It’s exciting to see kids trying out for the first time and showing how much potential they have,” he

said. He added that having no experience is not a problem for playing cricket, because “it’s something that you can pick up really quickly.”

Despite the progress this semester, however, the club is still struggling with logistical hurdles. “It’s still in its beginning stage,” Srivathsa said.

According to Sriraman, the “key limitation” is the lack of proper facilities and equipment. Right now, “the primary focus is getting the facilities,” he said.

The club needs a wide and open field, with the appropriate bats, nets and balls. This year, the club usually plays on the Main Green or Pembroke Field, but Sriraman said they need “a place proper for playing cricket without smacking anyone’s window.”

The club is “in the process of looking at what the options are,” Sriraman said. “As soon as we find appropriate facilities, we plan to have a formal team, hopefully by spring,” he added, saying they would like to be ready to join other Ivy League teams in various tournaments.

Sriraman said it is “really down to the individuals how much they can achieve in a particular year.” He said his goal this year is to “set up a robust structure” for upcoming years.

Srivathsa said he is “definitely continuing,” adding that he believes the group has potential to grow.

Sriraman called cricket “a sport with the richest tradition in the world.”

“The fundamental thing about cricket is that there are so many ways in which you can participate in the games,” he said. “It’s just an incredibly enjoyable game.”

Page 5

THE BROWN DAILY HERALD

C ampus N EWS

Monday, October 4, 2010

“I still have a chance of getting into heaven.”

— Stephen Robert ’62 P’92, who offered to give anonymously

Corporation reviews year-end finances continued from page 1

Alex Bell / Herald

The audience gave Chancellor Emeritus Stephen Robert ’62 P’91 a standing ovation for his speech.

Robert ’62 ‘deeply touched’ at dedication

By Alex Bell Senior Staff Writer

Against a rainy backdrop, members of the Corporation, administrators and students crowded into a tent on the Main Green on Friday to formally dedicate the $20 million Stephen Robert ’62 Campus Center.

The ceremony was part of this weekend’s meeting of the Corporation, the University’s highest governing body.

“Starting with freshman orientation in 1958, this building has been a very, very big part of my life,” Chancellor Emeritus Stephen Robert ’62 P’91 told the audience. In his remarks, Robert recalled some of his fondest memories at Brown centered around the building and his old morning routine of picking up his mail in the old Faunce mailroom.

He recalled one particularly vivid memory of getting a “Dear John,” or breakup letter, from his girlfriend one morning.

“My fraternity, which thankfully is no longer on campus, had an award every year for the member of the fraternity that got the best quote-unquote ‘Dear John’ letter, and I really won the prize,” Robert reminisced.

He refrained from expounding more on that memory — his wife was in the audience.

Robert fell out of touch with the building until he became a trustee of

the University in 1984, when he rediscovered it as a favorite meeting location for old friends and colleagues.

When he became chancellor in 1998, he was given an office on Benevolent Street.

“It was so boring and dull, I immediately stopped having meetings there and went back to the Blue Room,” Robert said.

He praised the new Blue Room as having “the best food and aesthetics of any place on campus,” noting the difficulty he encountered in finding a seat for lunch that day as a testament to its popularity.

He said the campus center is open all night most of the week, which has unexpected benefits.

“You may think that that has no purpose, but you’re wrong,” he explained to the audience taking shelter from the rain in the tent. “It turns out that on some very hot nights in the fall, at like four or five in the morning, the guards discovered many Brown students sleeping in the building because it’s air conditioned. So there’s a use of this new building that we never even imagined.”

Robert said he is awed by the building’s centrality, importance and “in all modesty, having my name on it.”

“Although I realized that God evidently rewards those who give anonymously, (President) Ruth (Simmons) wrote me a letter after I of-

fered to give it anonymously saying she refused, so I still have a chance of getting into heaven,” Robert joked.

Taking a more serious tone, Robert explained the meaning of the newly renovated building for him.

“The thing that is so fulfilling to me is to see how it’s being used, and that to me is worth more than all the pictures, all the design work,” Robert said. “Just to walk in and see the students and others in the Brown community using and enjoying it for the purposes for which we constructed it makes my heart swell.”

The dedication ceremony included a performance by student group leaders exemplifying uses of the campus center to various student groups, a video presentation featuring administrators’ reactions to the building, remarks by Simmons and a formal acceptance of the building by current Chancellor Thomas Tisch ’76 along with presidents of the Undergraduate Council of Students, Graduate Council of Students and Medical Student Senate. The ceremony was followed by a cocktail reception on the second floor of the campus center.

“I’m deeply touched that this building — often considered the center of Brown — is home to the Robert Campus Center,” Robert concluded.

“My hope is that many generations find warmth and friendship within its walls.”

Family bakery makes a name with locals continued from page 2 “The bakers come into work at three in the morning to start baking everything. They have to come in early in order to get it out early for Brown,” she said.

The bakery provides pastries for other businesses, but wholesale is not a big part of what the business does, Manni said.

“We’re really particular. We make sure it goes to good people. We do a lot of sampling,” she said.

All in the family LaSalle Bakery is a favorite to many locals. Even the Democratic candidate for mayor, Angel Taveras, has a favorite: LaSalle’s chocolate pudding cake, said Manni.

“Our croissants are very popular.

We sell a lot of ham and cheese and spinach and feta croissants –– sandwiches, too,” she said.

The local favorite is the Italian ham sandwich, which includes roasted peppers and fresh mozzarella, Manni said.

She added that the bakery also sells many calzones and muffins.

“Every day is different … you can come in here at 10 a.m. and not find any muffins, and on another day you can come in and everyone wants calzones,” she said.

As for her own favorite, Manni said she likes “anything chocolate.”

Manni said she considers LaSalle a neighborhood bakery, one that has customers with familiar faces.

“Over the years, I’ve seen people grow up and bring their children in,” she said.

Manni said the family atmosphere continues to inspire the bakery, because it is a family-run business — the Mannis’ sons work there.

With the success of the bakery’s two locations, the Mannis are currently in the process of looking to open a third store.

“It’s locations, locations, locations. This summer we checked a few places,” she said. “In the future, there may be one or two more openings.”

But Manni said that there are still a lot of things to think about before the opening of the third store.

“Whatever we’re doing, we’re doing it right,” Manni said. “Because our customers keep coming in, we’re making them happy. As long as they’re happy, we’re successful.”

it helps to be able to show we’ve thought about the humanities,” Vohra said. “This says to them there’s a lot of other support that will come with these positions.”

Chairs of humanities departments will meet this week to decide what to do with the gift, Vohra said.

Michael Steinberg, director of the Cogut Center for the Humanities, praised the notion of attracting more senior faculty in the humanities. He said he hopes the humanities initiative can be used to draw scholars from around the world and help make more interdisciplinary bridges at Brown among not only the traditional humanities, but also the sciences.

“There really aren’t clear borders to the humanities,” Steinberg said. “This, for me, is really Brown at its best.”

Corporation members — who meet in October, February and May to make key strategic decisions such as approving the University’s budget — also heard about the state of the University’s endowment, which ended fiscal year 2010 at $2.180 billion, up from $2.038 billion at the end of the previous year. After a 10.2 percent appreciation in the endowment’s funds, a draw of $134 million used to cover operational expenses and $55 million in gifts to the endowment, the endowment showed a 6.9 percent gain for the year, according to Executive Vice President for Finance and Administration Beppie Huidekoper.

The current five-year and 10year returns were 4.6 percent and 6.2 percent, respectively, she said.

Huidekoper said the University aims to reduce its draw from the endowment for operational expenses from last year’s 6.5 percent to about 5 percent.

If and when the endowment might return to its peak of $2.8 billion is still unknown, she said.

“Nobody is terribly optimistic about having big high returns in the market,” Huidekoper said.

“Our investments are slightly more conservative now than in the past.”

The Corporation also heard a report about the Campaign for Academic Enrichment. The fundraising drive, which is set to end Dec. 31, has raised $1.542 billion toward its increased goal of $1.6 billion by the end of fiscal year 2010, according to an Oct. 2 campus-wide e-mail from President Ruth Simmons. The Brown Annual Fund — composed primarily of donations by alums and parents — reached $36 million, with 31,342 individual donors, Simmons wrote.

The Corporation formally accepted $36 million in gifts.

A $15 million gift from anonymous donors composed nearly half of the gifts accepted. Of the gift, $3.5 million will be used for brain science, $3 million for the new Humanities Initiative, $2.5 million for arts initiatives, $1 million for the Marine Biological Laboratory collaborative research initiatives and $5 million pending donor designation in support of the Plan for Academic Enrichment, according to the e-mail.

The Corporation also approved funding for renovations beginning next summer to 315 Thayer St., which is currently used for auxiliary housing. Living units in Brown’s auxiliary housing system are usually rented out to graduate students and upperclassmen with off-campus permission, but have also been used recently to house younger students as a result of a shortage of on-campus housing.

The Corporation gathered in a tent on a rainy Friday evening along with administrators and students to dedicate the $20 million Stephen Robert ’62 Campus Center.

Chancellor Thomas Tisch ’76 P’07 and Simmons also led the Corporation on a door-opening visit to the newly renovated $42 million Metcalf Laboratories on Saturday. The building is slated to be the new home of the Department of Cognitive, Linguistic and Psychological Sciences.

Page 6

THE BROWN DAILY HERALD

C ampus N EWS

Monday, October 4, 2010

“I think they find her wise.”

— Joukowsky Director Susan Alcock, on Pres. Ruth Simmons’ appeal

Groups look for common ground in Israel-Palestine conflict continued from page 1 materials to Israel, but the student president later vetoed the proposition, and his veto was upheld.

“The student body overwhelmingly supports divestment,” Jackson said. But student dissent and demonstration have occasionally turned violent in California, she explained, with “some really intense” physical interactions erupting between members of pro-Israel groups and students encouraging divestment.

At Columbia, though, students are “predominantly pro-Israel,” said Michael Shapiro, president of Columbia’s Israel-supporting group LionPac. In contrast, the most vocal faculty at Columbia opposes Israel’s policies, he said.

“The faculty get pretty involved, especially on the anti-Israel side,” he said, referencing vocal pro-Palestinian professors like Rashid Khalidi and Joseph Massad. “It is concerning to us.”

Jackson said that the faculty at Berkeley tends to also support divestment and SJP’s other initiatives, but “the administration is hostile to SJP and any criticism of Israel.”

At Brown, the conversation is much less influenced by faculty voices.

“The faculty really want to leave this debate in the hands of the students,” said Laura Fried ’12, president of Brown Students for Israel. “They’re very reluctant to be explicit about their personal views.”

David Jacobson, director of the

program in Judaic studies, said there are no professors currently in the Middle East Studies department who are strongly associated with one side in the conflict between Israel and Palestine.

“It’s very good that MES is not poisoned by some of the politics,” he said. “There has been a problem in academia of professors teaching in what I would consider to be a biased way.”

When Brown Students for Justice in Palestine has approached faculty for help and advice, they tend to find support, said Alysha Aziz ’12, a Brown SJP member. This year, the group plans to start reaching out to the administration as well. The group works to encourage University Hall to divest from companies that profit from Israel’s occupation of the Palestinian territories.

The action-oriented group is not directly tied to Berkeley’s SJP or any other of the dozens of university groups sharing the same name, though they participate in regional networks. No national structure unites all of the SJP groups calling for various forms of divestment, but many participate in the international Israeli Apartheid Week that likens Israeli occupation of the Palestinian territories to racial segregation in 20th-century South Africa, Aziz said.

More similar than they appear Jacobson said much of the polarization at Brown “is out of ignorance.

A lot of people involved don’t know a lot.”

Two years ago, Jenna Zeigen ’12 and Sophia Manuel ’11 helped create Puzzle Peace — originally under a different name — in order to “promote dialogue and to say that this isn’t a one-sided discussion,” said Zeigen, the group’s current president.

“The loud screaming voices that you hear are often Israel or Palestine,” she explained. “But when you got down to it, most people are less divided.”

Manuel added that the individuals involved in the four groups dedicated to the discussion — Puzzle Peace, BSI, Brown SJP and Common Ground — are “much more nuanced” than they might appear.

“Most of the leaders of these groups are actually friends with each other,” she said.

Fried, the president of BSI, said she worries that “a lot of people think they need to associate with one camp” and choose to only support Palestine’s national aspirations or Israeli security concerns.

“They don’t have to choose a side, and they shouldn’t be choosing sides,” she said. “The needs and interests of both peoples are intrinsically linked.”

Even though BSI’s mission statement is directly tied to supporting Israel, she said its leaders staunchly support both groups. Fried said that the group does not want to convince students to only support Israel, but that it instead exists to make sure that students hear more than one perspective.

“Unfortunately, there is quite a

bit of uniformity in higher education when it comes to the Arab-Israeli conflict. The overriding narrative is one that views the Palestinians as blameless — and ignores internecine struggles — while uniformly condemning Israel, often to the point of delegitimizing the country’s existence,” wrote Cinnamon Stillwell in an e-mail to The Herald. Stillwell is the West Coast representative for Campus Watch, a group dedicated to promoting objective scholarship in Middle East Studies academia.

Religious connections Because Israel is a Jewish state with sites holy to Judaism, Islam and Christianity, religious dimensions often color the political debate on college campuses, even at Brown.

Both BSI and Puzzle Peace operate out of Brown/RISD Hillel and use Hillel funds.

“We see ourselves as a political group,” Fried said, explaining that her group is not religious even though it gets support from Jewish organizations.

She said BSI has started to rethink its Hillel connection, especially since it was placed next to religious groups at the September Activities Fair instead of with other political groups.

Francesca Contreras ’11, another Brown SJP member, said that religion is not a part of criticism of Israel. Brown SJP includes Jews and Muslims, and half the group has no identity ties to the issue, she said.

When Berkeley students were de-

bating the original motion to encourage divestment of university funds from companies supplying Israeli war materials, Jackson — who went on a Taglit Birthright trip to Israel through the Brown/RISD Hillel while she was an undergraduate student — said that many students spoke out to say, “I support divestment because I’m Jewish.”

Moving forward As peace talks stall and conflict continues in Israel and Palestine, the conversation on college campuses is still going strong.

“I think there’s hope for a common ground,” Fried said, especially if groups start to work for “more evenkeeled” programming.

This spring, Jacobson, the Judaic studies professor, will begin a new course on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict that will look at how different groups remember and describe the narrative. The course was originally planned as an Undergraduate Teaching and Research Award involving two students, Sami Jarbawi ’12 — a Palestinian student who grew up in the West Bank — and Avi Schaeffer ’13 — a former Israeli soldier who died in a car accident last February.

“I’m really hoping to have an impact on the campus as a whole,” Jacobson said of his goals for the course and the programming that will accompany it.

“Let’s put aside the rhetoric,” he said. “Let’s see if we can just understand what these stories are about.”

‘Heritage as Bridge’ plans scholar exchange with Turkey continued from page 1 organization is its desire to work with the countries, not to dictate what needs to be done, Verstandig said.

“The steering committee and chairs feel strongly that the partnerships will advance Muslim communities,” Verstandig said. “We’re not going to countries and saying this is what works best. … We’re asking them what’s important to them and what their priorities are.”

Simmons, currently the only academic on the steering committee, was chosen because of her ability

to translate ideas into reality, Verstandig said.

“I think they find her wise,” said Susan Alcock, director of the Joukowsky Institute for Archaeology and the Ancient World. “She can talk to a range of constituents — she’s a very cohesive person,” she added.

The first step Brown is taking to contribute is its participation in the Heritage as Bridge project, which is being led by Alcock.

The Heritage as Bridge project hopes to draw on both the economic and educational benefits that heritage sites, such as archaeological sites, parks and their museums,

offer host countries and tourists, according to Alcock.

Alcock said the program will first work with Turkey. It will eventually feature an exchange of scholars between individuals at Brown and those in Ephesus and other cities in Turkey.

There will be an emphasis on encouraging young people to get involved, especially women, Alcock said. The archaeology field largely comprises women, due in part to the feminization of the humanities, Alcock added. This will contribute to the “quest for female voices in the Muslim world,” she said.

Incorporating what Heritage as Bridge is doing into classes at Brown is another goal, Alcock said.

The program aims to get students thinking about what it is like to work in the Middle East and what heritage sites mean.

Alcock said she also hopes to hold a workshop soon to discuss the project among academics, government officials, members of the private sector and entrepreneurs.

The mixing of private and public groups by Partners for a New Beginning is another of its great features, Alcock said: “It’s an amazing group of people.”

Both Alcock and Vice President for International Affairs Matthew Gutmann said they are excited to hear back from students.

“This is a long-term commitment of Brown,” Gutmann said. “Involvement of Brown students is a priority.”

The University’s involvement represents the “importance of academics” in helping solve conflicts, Gutmann said.

“Brown students, scholars and professors can tackle global problems,” Verstandig said, citing past programs in assisting Haiti and Pakistan.

After sit-in, URI to provide more support for GLBT center continued from page 1 against the GLBT community, the students still felt their requests were not being met, according to Stack.

He added that the post seemed to make promises without following through on them. Stack also said the students wanted to be involved in the meetings the administration was holding to address the issues.

The students’ list of demands included a larger space to accommodate the GLBT Center, a full-time paid employee to address the needs of GLBT students, compensation for student staff members and sensi-

tivity training for faculty, staff and resident advisers.

The protesting students met with several members of the administration on Sept. 30, and the administration agreed to meet the students’ demands. The university is committed to getting the center a new home, and proposed a plan to renovate an existing building, an $800,000 undertaking, according to Dougan. As of Oct. 1, the students had yet to accept the proposal, he said.

The university agreed to hire a new full-time staff member when the new center is completed, gen-

erating funds to pay the employee from new student housing that will also be created by the planned renovation.

Prior to the sit-in, the GLBT Center held brief sensitivity training for resident advisors, where “no one paid attention and some people walked away thinking ‘that’s so gay’ is freedom of speech and they don’t have to do anything about it,” Stack said. There will be more educational and sensitivity training for faculty, students and staff as a result of the sit-in.

URI is also going to create an advisory committee to address the

issues of the GLBT community that will include students, according to an Oct. 1 press release from URI. The URI community’s reaction to the protest was mixed. Both Dougan and Stack agreed that the community was largely supportive, but Stack said that after the protest began, a note was placed under a GLBT Center staff member’s door saying “shut up faggots we know where you live.” He added that someone called him a “faggot” while walking to class during the protest.

The university has arrested one student for GLBT harassment related to the protest but “the difficulty is

that, as frequently as they occur, it is very infrequent that we can identify the perpetrator,” Dougan said. “We want to make this a welcoming and safe campus for everyone,” he said.

The changes won’t happen immediately, Dougan said. He added that he is going to ensure “students are in meetings with officials to monitor the process and hold the university responsible.”

“It looks like this time they are actually committed to solving these things, but only time will tell,” Stack said. “It looks like we are going to get ever ything we need for our safety,” he added.

Arts & Culture The Brown Daily Herald

Monday, October 4, 2010 | Page 7

RISD and Brown go global for ‘A Better World by Design’

By Anita Badejo Staff Writer

“We have a problem,” Ed Mazria, founder and executive director of Architecture 2030, told a nearly-full Salomon 101 during the keynote panel for the “A Better World by Design” conference Saturday. Luckily, he was speaking to exactly those who want to fix it.

The three-day conference, organized and run completely by Brown and Rhode Island School of Design students, took place on College Hill last weekend.

Known as “ABWxD” for short, the event has been held on the Brown and RISD campuses during the first weekend of October annually since 2008. According to its website, the conference “connects students, professionals, and individuals from a variety of disciplines in order to build a global community of socially conscious and passionate innovators.”

Sharon Langevin ’09 GS created the conference during her junior year with Steve Daniels ’10 and two RISD students, she told The Herald.

As members of Engineers Without Borders, she and Daniels had heard much talk of plans for similar events that never came to fruition. When the two joined the group’s executive board during their junior years, they finally decided to host a lecture series, she said. What they ended up creating

was far more: a multi-day event that featured numerous speakers, panelists, workshops, tours and exhibitions.

This year’s ABWxD brought 13 speakers, 12 panels, eight workshops and a whole host of other activities to College Hill to promote innovative and sustainable design, technology and business practices and improve the world.

The conference was organized by a general committee of 12 Brown and RISD students selected last fall, who oversaw everything from accounting for the $75,000 cost to finding speakers and panelists, Langevin said. In addition, an advisory committee of students who had been involved with ABWxD before, including Langevin and Daniels, provided support to general committee members.

“My main goal is really to inspire students to take action,” Langevin said. “I think there are a lot of students who have thought a lot about what they want to do to make a difference in the world, but don’t really know how to go about it.”

Conference organizers attempted to inspire as many individuals as possible by having a wide and diverse range of fields represented, including architecture, engineering, urban planning, art, design and environmental studies.

“There’s really something for just about everyone,” said Matt Severson ’11, an advisory committee member.

“Pretty much every word out of each speaker’s mouth is inspiring or educational in some way.”

Members of a keynote panel that took place on Saturday exemplified the diversity of areas discussed in the conference. The panel was moderated by Saul Kaplan, the founder and “Chief Catalyst” of Business Innovation Factory, a Providence nonprofit concerned with system-level solutions to various social issues.

The panelists spoke of their own work in addressing what Kaplan posed as the ultimate dilemma of addressing global issues today: “It’s not about having good ideas. … It’s about, how do we bring these ideas to scale?”

Entrepreneur and environmentalist Lisa Gansky, who recently published a new book titled “The Mesh,” discussed the growing importance of sharing resources and items to battle problems with the environment and sustainability.

Bloom Energy Product Manager Peter Light ’01 expressed concern over the inefficiency of energy production, particularly the numerous processes of transformation and transportation that current forms of energy undergo before finally being used.

Bloom Energy designs technology for converting chemical energy directly into electricity to maximize utility and efficiency and address the growing demand for energy in the world today.

Vice President of Operations for

Stephanie London / Herald

Students and panelists come together to inspire “a global community of socially conscious and passionate innovators.”

Better Place Aliza Peg spoke of her company’s attempts to further the “electrification” of the automobile industry and accelerate the transition from gas- to electricity-powered vehicles.

Global climate change, current U.S. unemployment and real estate crises were Mazria’s main concerns.

His company is attempting to address these problems with proposals to boost the U.S. building sector through tax deductions for energy-saving construction, he told the crowd.

Jeremy Jacob ’12, who went to a lecture by Mazria, said he offered some “interesting solutions” to sys-

tem-wide change, taking into account concrete government implementations.

Graciela Kincaid ’12, who took 15 pages of notes during the various lectures and panels, said she especially enjoyed Saturday’s panel on ethics and design. The conference broadened her notion of design to include a wide variety of approaches to world problems, she added.

“It’s really encouraging to go to a conference like this where everyone is so passionate and so energetic and so excited. It renews whatever enthusiasm you have for global issues and solving problems,” Kincaid said.

‘Hope’ for Pakistan: student groups fundraise in Salomon

By Natalie Villacorta Contributing Writer

The Pakistani Student Association brought “Asha” — which means “hope” — to Salomon 101 Friday night with a benefit show for Pakistan flood relief.

The association hosted the event to raise awareness about August’s floods, which have been severely underpublicized, according to Fatimah Asghar ’11, the show’s organizer.

“Asha” featured student performances by Brown’s spoken word group Word!, the Higher Keys, New Works African Dance Troupe and Badmaash Dance Company.

In the lobby, the student association sold Pakistani crafts to raise additional funds before and after the show. All proceeds went to relief effort organizations screened by Brown students. As students filtered into the auditorium, photographs of the flood’s devastation scrolled on the screen: whole landscapes of muddy water, destroyed roads and bridges and thousands of black tents for the displaced.

The emcees, Osman Chaudhry ’11 and Malcolm Shanks ’11, described the extent of the damage: 21 million people have been affected by the floods and 8 million have been displaced. Over $3 billion worth of crops and 4,000 kilometers of road have been destroyed. Water-borne diseases such as dysentery are rampant.

Asghar began the show with a spoken word piece about the after-

math of Hurricane Katrina in New Orleans, accompanied by Franny Choi ’11 and Jamila Woods ’11. As they softly sang the phrase “muddy water,” Asghar transformed into a hopeless New Orleans mother who had the “back water blues in her bones.” The floods had stolen her son from her, warped her legs and made familiar faces bloated and unrecognizable.

Asghar did not write the poem for this event, but at least four other poets who performed responded specifically to the floods in Pakistan.

One such poet was Laura BrownLavoie ’10.5, whose poem, “Counter Insurgent,” played with the different meanings and variations of the word “surge”: water surging, urgent aid and counterinsurgencies.

Audience response to the spoken word was supportive. Students snapped their fingers to express agreement with particularly poignant observations. Providence local Chris Johnson elicited this response when he suggested that “this generation’s obsession with aliens, vampires and zombies is a metaphor for how strange we feel in our bodies.”

Ramsey Jeremie ’12 and Choi, other audience favorites, shared their passion about the subjects they were addressing — reality and the lives of army wives, respectively — sincerely and contagiously.

The spoken word was performed in groups of three and four between musical and dance performances that lightened the mood. The Higher Keys’ charming renditions of “Fly Me

to the Moon” and “Stay With You” provided some romantic relief. New Works got the audience clapping and tapping their feet to the tribal beats of African drums. The audience’s eyes were glued to the bare feet that kicked and stomped, the arms that flailed in synchrony and the torsos that shimmied in all directions.

Asian fusion dance company Badmaash spiced it up with a mash up of M.I.A., Flo Rida and Bollywood music. The dancers entertained the audience by combining some serious gangster attitude with traditional Bhangra and other dance styles.

The energy in the room was infectious.

Throughout the performance, Chaudhry called the audience’s attention to the dire need for clean water, food, shelter and basic medical treatment.

The United Nations has called the floods the worst natural disaster in the organization’s history. The number of people who have lost their homes or have been injured is greater than the combined total of individuals affected by the 2005 South Asian tsunami and the Haiti and Kashmir earthquakes. But the United States government has only provided $70 million in aid, Chaudhry mentioned. He reminded the audience that “this is not sup-

posed to be a disaster Olympics,” but the response to the floods has been inadequate.

The turnout for the show was impressive despite Friday’s rainy weather, and Asghar said she was pleased with the way the show came together. Most students who attended were previously aware of Pakistan’s situation, but were moved by the artistic depiction of the damage.

“It is very exciting the way art can bring people together around an issue,” said Jesse McGleughlin ’14. “Something that art can do that statistics cannot is strike an emotional cord that can push people into action.”

SportsMonday The Brown Daily Herald

SCOREBOARD

Monday, October 4, 2010 | Page 8

M. WATER POLO

M. WATER POLO

VOLLEYBALL

FIELD HOCKEY

CROSS COUNTRY

Brown 5 MIT 4

Brown 16 Fordham 8

Yale 3 Brown 0

Harvard 2 Brown 3 (2OT)

Paul Short Invite

Brown 11 Iona 6

Brown 2 Yale 3

Men’s team - 23rd Women’s team - 12th

FOOTBALL

Passing not enough for Bruno, as URI wins Governor’s Cup

BY ETHAN MCCOY Sports Staff Writer

The football team lost for the first time this season, falling to the University of Rhode Island, 27-24, in over time. Quar terback Kyle Newhall‑Caballero ’11 threw for 325 yards and three touchdowns in his first start of the season, but it was not enough to stop URI from taking home the Governor’s Cup in front of a sellout crowd in Kingston, R.I. On the first possession of overtime, Brown (2-1, 1-0 Ivy League) failed to put the ball in the end zone and was forced to settle for a 34-yard field goal by kicker Alex Norocea ’14. Newhall-Caballero was hit hard on Brown’s last play in the fourth quarter and was replaced by Joe Springer ’11 for the overtime drive. The three-point lead gained by Br uno did not stand for long. On the Rams’ first play of their overtime possession, quarterback Steve Probst took the ball on a quarterback keeper 25 yards for the winning touchdown.

Probst did most of his damage on the ground, rushing for 84 yards and three touchdowns.

Things got off to a rocky start for the Bears. With 9:24 remaining in the first quarter, after a Brown three-and-out on the team’s first possession, URI blocked the Brown

Jesse Morgan / Herald file photo

Quarterback Kyle Newhall-Caballero ‘11 had a strong performance in the Bears’ loss Saturday afternoon, completing 25 passes for 325 yards.

punt and recovered the ball in the end zone to go up 7-0.

Bruno answered three plays later. Newhall-Caballero hit wide receiver Alex Tounkara ’11 on a slant route over the middle.

Tounkara then shed a tackle and outran the URI defense 61 yards for the touchdown, evening the score up at 7-7. A Probst rushing touchdown on URI’s next drive gave the Rams a 14-7 lead that held going

into halftime.

In the third quarter, the Bears again tied the game on another Newhall-Caballero touchdown pass, this time on a 21-yard connection to tight end Alex Prestley ’11, capping off a 69-yard drive.

The teams exchanged scores in the fourth quarter. After the Prestley touchdown, URI took advantage of good field position and moved the ball efficiently before Probst grabbed his second touchdown of the game, this one coming on a rush up the middle from the oneyard line.

The Bears struck back on the ensuing possession. Starting at its own 26-yard line, Brown wasted no time in tying up the game. The Bears moved the ball through the air to the URI 19-yard line before Newhall-Caballero hit wide receiver Jimmy Saros ’12 for the touchdown to cap a seven-play, 74-yard drive.

Both teams had field goal chances late in the fourth quarter, but neither unit could convert to give its side the lead. Norocea pulled a 44-yard attempt left with 3:28 remaining in the game. Louis Feinstein missed a 42-yarder for URI as time expired, sending the game into over time, where the Rams would triumph.

Bruno was unable to establish a consistent running attack,

but a strong passing game with Newhall‑Caballero at the helm paced the of fense. The receiving corps saw strong games from Tounkara (seven receptions, 119 yards, one TD), Saros (six receptions, 61 yards, one TD) and wide receiver Tellef Lundevall ’13 (eight receptions, 60 yards), but the efforts were not enough to get the win.

The defense that shut down Harvard was unable to recreate last week’s performance. The Bruno “D” forced no turnovers and surrendered a whopping 230 yards on the ground to a strong and balanced Ram rushing attack, led by running back Ayo Isijola’s 97 yards.

After digging itself an 0-2 hole to start the year, URI has rejuvenated its season. With Saturday’s win and a victory over New Hampshire — No. 8 in the Football Championship Subdivision ­— last week, the Rams are back to .500 and riding high.

Brown must regroup and prepare itself for next week’s game.

Bruno will hit the road again to Worcester, Mass., to take on the Crusaders of Holy Cross (2-3), who are coming off a win over Fordham. The game will be the final non-conference matchup for the Bears before the squad faces six more Ivy League foes in their hunt for the league title.

W. SOCCER

Team kicks its way to two home draws

BY MADELEINE WENSTRUP Contributing Writer

Though it did not win, the women’s soccer team remains unbeaten on its home field. The Bears took both of their opponents, the University of New Hampshire (45-3) and Columbia (6-2-2, 1-0-1 Ivy League), into double overtime this week, with both games ending in draws.

New Hampshire 2, Brown 2 Brown fought UNH for 110 minutes on Wednesday afternoon, ending in a 2-2 tie. Each team dominated a half — Bruno controlling the first half with a 12-4 shot advantage and the Wildcats taking the second 45 minutes with 11 shots to the Bears’ four.

Midfielder Mika Siegelman ’14 kicked things off for the Bears with a goal nine minutes into the half.

The goal was set up by midfielder Gina Walker ’11, who drew the defense away with a shot from the left corner that was blocked by UNH

goalkeeper Erica Correa. Siegelman, following the play into the box, was there to tap in the deflected ball.

Siegelman was modest about her role.

“It was pretty much all Gina,” she said. “I was just there.”

The Bears continued to keep the game in their favor and walked away from the first half with a 1-0 lead.

Then it was the Wildcats’ turn.

After taking two shots on goal in the first eight minutes, UNH connected on its third attempt. Goalkeeper MC Barrett ’14 jumped for the save, but the ball was out of reach and UNH tied the score, 1-1.

Still filled with the momentum of the first half, forward Eliza Marshall ’13 took things into her own hands.

She trapped the ball and scored on a high kick from 25 yards away only a minute after the Wildcats had evened the score.

But the Bears could not hold off their opponents and the Wildcats battled to even the game once again.

UNH fired off three shots after Mar-

shall’s goal before finally making it in on a one-on-one play between Barrett and UNH’s Chelsea Kuss.

After two overtime periods, the game remained at 2-2. The Wildcats had a slight shot advantage during the overtimes, 4-3, but a cross by forward Marybeth Lesbirel ’12 that led to a missed shot by forwardmidfielder Louisa Pitney ’14 was the closest that either team came to scoring during the extra time.

Barrett said it was a tough result, especially considering Brown’s firsthalf advantage.

“We definitely thought that we outplayed them at times,” she said.

Columbia 0, Brown 0 The Bears came into their second Ivy League game against Columbia with ferocity. In an aggressive first half of play, Bruno held a slight shot advantage, 9-8, and increased its chances in the second half, taking 12 shots to Columbia’s five. continued on page 9

Emily Gilbert / Herald

Goalkeeper MC Barrett ’14 allowed two goals against the University of New Hampshire, but she shut out Columbia.

Page 9

THE BROWN DAILY HERALD

S ports M onday

Monday, October 4, 2010

“Ivy League games are going to be tough.”

— Pat Laughlin, head coach for men’s soccer

M. Soccer

Squad tops Columbia in first Ivy clash

BY ZACK BAHR Sports Editor

October has brought many things to Providence — like chilly evenings, rainy days and an Ivy League win for the men’s soccer team. The No. 17 Bears (6-0-2, 1-00 Ivy League) snapped Columbia’s three-game winning streak (4-5-1, 0-1-0) with a decisive 3-0 victory.

“Ivy League games are going to be tough,” said Head Coach Pat Laughlin. “I felt we played with good energy and created some excellent scoring chances.”

A wet field made for an exciting game. Players from both teams had problems staying up when chang-

ing direction. Forward Jon Okafor ’11 found the net just 15 minutes into the fast-paced game. This is the quickest Brown has scored all season.

“The wet field made the game quicker and forced the players to be ver y clean with their touch,” Laughlin said.

Goalkeeper Paul Grandstrand ’11 kept a perfect record on the game with three saves. Bruno is currently third in the nation in shutout percentage with only Indiana getting the ball past Grandstrand and a smothering defense.

Impressive footwork played a role in the other two Brown goals.

Forward Austin Mandel ’12 moved

down the field and maneuvered around defenders to set up forward T.J. Popolizio ’12 at 39:30. Mandel then found the goal himself with a hard, 10-yard strike in the 79th minute.

In total, Bruno took 19 shots on goal to the Lion’s eight.

Twenty-one out of the 26 players on Brown’s roster saw playing time during the game, with the final two goals coming from non-starters.

The Bears will be back on their home pitch this Tuesday for a game against No. 18 St. John’s University.

The Red Storm are coming off an overtime loss to No. 5 Louisville.

Last year, Brown battled St. John’s to a 1-1 tie in Queens, N.Y.

Jonathan Bateman / Herald

After scoring a goal, forward Austin Mandel ’12 celebrated with teammate Evan Coleman ’12 in Saturday’s victory over Columbia.

Aux. housing to join on-campus pool Match ends in tie despite continued from page 1 Finance Committee at this weekend’s meeting.

The project is just “the first to emerge” in a sequence of residence hall improvements the University will make as part of efforts to increase on-campus housing capacity and “desirable living spaces,” Klawunn said.

On-campus housing is currently over capacity, with 75 undergraduates living in temporary housing, Bova wrote. Some current residents of 315 Thayer St. are undergraduates who moved from temporary on-campus arrangements.

The University will look to a combination of renovation and new construction not only to provide for the current demand, but also to increase capacity over the long term.

Administrators are considering limiting off-campus student life, recognizing the need for greater suite- and apartment-style living.

“We are certainly … wondering whether it wouldn’t be desirable to have more juniors living on campus,” Klawunn said.

Housing improvements will focus on increased common lounge and study space, encouraging a community dynamic. Design priorities have changed over time,

www.browndailyherald.com

she said. When the majority of campus dorms were built, “people lived and studied differently. You would be more inclined to go to the library or to be using other spaces,” Klawunn said, adding that students now prefer to study inside their dorms.

Klawunn pointed to dormitories such as the Graduate Center that she said would benefit from renovation. Grad Center could be reconfigured to allow for more natural light and common space.

Planners and administrators are considering similar renovations to current dorms, but no finalized plans have been announced.

aggressive plays, overtime continued from page 8 For ward-midfielder Kiersten Berg ’14 had the audience on its feet when she made a dangerous attempt in the 66th minute of play. A tumble landed Berg on the ground and took Lions goalkeeper Lillian Klein from her position in the box. Looking to take advantage, Berg struggled to take a shot from a sitting position, but a Lions defender cleared it just in time.

The teams took three shots apiece in the overtime periods, but the score remained locked at 0-0.

Goalkeeper Amber Bledsoe ’14 had four saves and Barrett blocked three, keeping the Lions off the board.

The teams combined for 24 fouls and two yellow cards. For the Bears, an aggressive game was no surprise.

“We were expecting a tough battle,” Siegelman said. “It was pretty physical right off the bat.”

The Bears continue on their home-field streak this Tuesday when they face Holy Cross at 5 p.m.

“Its nice to go out to Stevenson (Field),” Barrett said. “We have our fans, we get in our own routines, we like playing at home.”

Editorial & Letters The Brown Daily Herald

Page 10 | Monday, October 4, 2010

l e t t e r to t h e e d i to r

Pass the DREAM Act now To the Editors: I applaud the brave undocumented students who told their stories, and Alexandra Ulmer’s ’11 thoughtful treatment of the topic (“Undocumented Students Protest Status,” Oct. 1).

The DREAM Act would create a path to citizenship for students who graduate from high school in the United States and complete two years of college or military service.

Students like Christian, Steve and Alejo demonstrate why the DREAM Act must pass now — it is wasteful and un-American to relegate these hardworking and ambitious young

people to permanent second-class status. This should be a no-brainer; unfortunately, the DREAM Act failed as an attachment to the recent Defense Reauthorization.

I encourage anyone who was moved by the story to contact Sen. Harry Reid, D-Nev., and demand that the DREAM Act be given a standalone vote immediately. Undocumented students have waited too long for justice, and our country needs their talent and drive.

Lily Axelrod ’09 North Miss. Organizer, Mississippi Immigrants Rights Alliance

J ulia S treuli

Something to say?

Become a Herald columnist. opinions@browndailyherald.com

t h e b r o w n d a i ly h e r a l d Editor-in-Chief

Managing Editor

Deputy Managing Editors

Senior Editors

George Miller

Chaz Kelsh

Emmy Liss Joanna Wohlmuth

Ben Hyman Seth Motel

editorial Arts & Culture Editor Anne Speyer Arts & Culture Editor Suzannah Weiss Features Editor Sara Luxenberg Features Editor Brian Mastroianni Metro Editor Brigitta Greene Metro Editor Ben Schreckinger News Editor Sydney Ember Sports Editor Zack Bahr Sports Editor Tony Bakshi Asst. Sports Editor Ashley McDonnell Graphics & Photos Graphics Editor Stephen Lichenstein Graphics Editor Alex Yuly Photo Editor Stephanie London Photo Editor Max Monn Photo Editor Hilary Rosenthal Jonathan Bateman Sports Photo Editor Jesse Morgan Asst. Sports Photo Editor Production Copy Desk Chief Kelly Mallahan Asst. Copy Desk Chief Joe Milner Asst. Copy Desk Chief Dan Towne Design Editor Julien Ouellet Asst. Design Editor Gili Kliger Asst. Design Editor Leor Shtull-Leber Asst. Design Editor Katie Wilson Web Editor Neal Poole Post- magazine Editor-in-Chief Sam Carter Editor-in-Chief Kate Doyle Editor-in-Chief Marshall Katheder

Business General Managers Claire Kiely Katie Koh

Office Manager Shawn Reilly

Directors Sales Kelly Wess Finance Matthew Burrows Client Relations Margaret Watson Christiana Stephenson Alumni Relations Managers Local Sales Isha Gulati Local Sales Arjun Vaidya National Sales Rajiv Iyengar University Sales Aditi Bhatia University Sales Jared Davis Recruiter Sales Trenten Nelson-Rivers Maximilian Barrows Business Operations Business Analytics Jilyn Chao Danielle Marshak Credit and Collections Special Projects Alexander Carrere Staff Kathy Bui Opinions Opinions Editor Michael Fitzpatrick Opinions Editor Alyssa Ratledge Editorial Page Editor Matt Aks BLOG DAILY HERALD Managing Editor Matt Klimerman Managing Editor Anne Simons Managing Editor David Winer

e d i to r i a l

Dream on We were extremely disappointed to read last month that the U.S. Senate failed to pass the National Defense Authorization Act because only 57 of its 100 members supported the bill on a party-line vote. We miss the days when the defeat of a bill authorizing military operations at the hands of arcane procedural shenanigans was major news. Sadly, such shenanigans have become par for the course in the Senate.

This vote was particularly unfortunate because of an important piece of legislation that was expected to be attached to the defense bill. The Development, Relief, and Education for Alien Minors (DREAM) Act would grant legal residence to undocumented immigrants who came to the United States as children and attend college or join the military.

Polls indicate that about two-thirds of Americans support the act, and it has in the past enjoyed overwhelming bipartisan support in Congress. Seven years ago, the DREAM Act was sponsored by two Republican senators and passed the Judiciary Committee in a Republican-controlled Senate by a 16-3 vote. For now, however, partisan bickering has killed the bill.

The Herald reported last week on the heartwrenching predicament faced by undocumented students. Many of these students have been in the country since they were quite young and did not consciously choose to violate immigration law. Some of them even expressed frustration at their parents for putting them in a situation where they must constantly worry about being found out and punished.

The DREAM Act would remove the terrifying spectre of deportation and ensure these students won’t be sent away to what is to them essentially a

foreign country. Moreover, by encouraging college attendance and providing a path to legality, the act can give new opportunities to would-be innovators and entrepreneurs who will contribute to the American economy. According to the Herald article, some students are uncertain of how their status might impact college admissions and have been advised by their high school counselors not to apply to college or to go to a community college instead.

We commend the University for trying to ease the burden on undocumented students. By treating them as international students, Brown avoids the problems associated with their lack of Social Security numbers and other difficulties imposed by immigration laws.

It is still lamentable that national politicians are using these students and future ones like them as pawns in a political game.

Fortunately, there is still hope. The Senate will come back into session after the midterm elections but before the newly elected senators are sworn in.

The defense bill, which includes military pay raises, is usually considered must-pass. If there is enough support, the DREAM legislation might come up then.

Rhode Island’s delegation in the Senate supported the DREAM Act the first time around, and we hope they continue to fight for its passage. The idea that senators might put aside counterproductive partisanship and pass an important bill seems a little farfetched these days. But at least we can dream.

Editorials are written by The Herald’s editorial page board.

Send comments to editorials@browndailyherald.com.

Julien Ouellet, Leor Shtull-Leber, Designers Carrie Craven, Kelly Mallahan, Katrina Phillips, Dan Towne, Emma Wohl, Copy Editors

Alex Bell, Fei Cai, Lindor Qunaj, Suzannah Weiss, Night Editors Senior Staff Writers Ana Alvarez, Ashley Aydin, Rebecca Ballhaus, Alexander Bell, Nicole Boucher, Fei Cai, Kristina Fazzalaro, Sarah Mancone, Claire Peracchio, Lindor Qunaj, Mark Raymond, Luisa Robledo, Caitlin Trujillo, Alexandra Ulmer Staff Writers Anna Andreeva, Anne Artley, Anita Badejo, Casey Bleho, Amy Chen, Alicia Dang, Sarah Forman, Miriam Furst, Max Godnick, Thomas Jarus, Julia Kim, Kristina Klara, Leonardo Moauro, Emily Rosen, Bradley Silverman, Anne Simons, Qian Yin Senior Sales Executives Katie Galvin, Liana Nisimova, Isha Gulati, Samantha Wong Sales Associates Roshni Assomull, Brady Caspar, Anna Cook, Siena deLisser, Begum Ersan, Tommy Fink, Ryan Fleming, Evan Gill, Debbie Lai, Jason Lee, Katie Lynch, Sean Maroongroge, Zahra Merchant, Edjola Ruci, Webber Xu Senior Finance Associates Jason Beckman, Lauren Bosso, Mae Cadao, Margot Grinberg, Adam Fern Finance Associates Lisa Berlin, Mahima Chawla, Mark Hu, Jason Lee, Nicholas Robbins, Daniel Slutsky, Emily Zheng Design Staff Rebecca Ballhaus, Caleigh Forbes, Kyle McNamara Web Staff Warren Jin, Claire Kwong, Adam Zethraeus Photo Staff Qidong Chen, Janine Cheng, Alex DePaoli, Frederic Lu, Quinn Savit Copy Editors Nicole Boucher, Zoe Chaves, Greg Conyers, Claire Gianotti, Aida Haile-Mariam, Victoria Hartman, Tiffany Hsu, Christine Joyce, Mrinal Kapoor, Abby Kerson, Juhee Kwon, Matthew Lim, Alexandra McFarlane, Joe Milner, Rajan Mittal, Lindor Qunaj, Kate-Lyn Scott, Carmen Shulman, Rebecca Specking, Dan Towne, Carolina Veltri Editorial Page Board Members Anita Mathews, Tyler Rosenbaum, Melissa Shube, Gaurie Tilak

C O R R E C T I O N S P olicy The Brown Daily Herald is committed to providing the Brown University community with the most accurate information possible. Corrections may be submitted up to seven calendar days after publication.

C ommentary P O L I C Y The editorial is the majority opinion of the editorial page board of The Brown Daily Herald. The editorial viewpoint does not necessarily reflect the views of The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. Columns, letters and comics reflect the opinions of their authors only.

L etters to the E ditor P olicy Send letters to letters@browndailyherald.com. Include a telephone number with all letters. The Herald reserves the right to edit all letters for length and clarity and cannot assure the publication of any letter. Please limit letters to 250 words. Under special circumstances writers may request anonymity, but no letter will be printed if the author’s identity is unknown to the editors. Announcements of events will not be printed. advertising P olicy The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. reserves the right to accept or decline any advertisement at its discretion.

Opinions The Brown Daily Herald

Monday, October 4, 2010 | Page 11

Farewell to the Tea Party

BY MICHELLE UHRICK Opinions Columnist Many of my friends would like to consider themselves good-natured socialist-populists.

Aside from the fact that they won’t be running for office anytime in the near future, this means that they consider themselves to be open-minded yet distinctly anti-establishment political thinkers. And like many on the far left, I think that they have a disguised but distinct sense of relief now that the Tea Party has imploded into a right-wing values-fest (in the media, at least).

The existence of a third party — ­ an antiestablishment, for-the-people third party — stirred up some strange feelings for a left feeling betrayed by Obama’s centrism. After all, the Tea Partiers embodied a kind of grassroots outrage, an indignation on behalf of the people, that the left had practically patented. Broad political stereotypes paint liberals as anti-conformists and conservatives as status quo up-holders, not the other way around. The cause bringing people into the streets and encouraging social deviance is supposed to be world peace, not fiscal responsibility. In the public imagination, it’s the hippies that hold protests for ridiculously unattainable ideals and found third parties with no hope of winning. The Tea Partiers burn with an anti-establishment fervor of which most liberals did not think the right was capable.

Although I doubt many would admit it today, when the Tea Partiers first emerged, there seemed to be some respect from

across the aisle for their refusal to endorse either party and attempt to forge their own middle path to their goals. To make matters even more confusing, the Tea Party was ostensibly founded on libertarian grounds — in other words, the right of the people to do as they please without government interference. Libertarianism not only has admirers among the left, but is essentially the default perspective for the mainstream left when it comes to social issues.

has morphed into the least libertarian viewpoint of all. The new and unpredictable has become the old and familiar and seems likely to fracture the Republican base right as Democratic faith was beginning to falter.

And somehow, despite my non-Tea Partyish, slightly bigger-government leanings, it all seems a shame. There seems to have been a point, that point when the left did not know how to react to it, when the Tea Party was saying something. Something like “All

What at first appeared to be a new, libertarian, third-party movement has morphed into the least libertarian viewpoint of all.

Any of that respect has since vanished.

With Christine O’Donnell’s primary win in Delaware and the ensuing leakage of videos of her speaking out against everything from masturbation to evolution, the worst fears of the left seem to have been confirmed: The Tea Party is little more than a front for the same-old right-wing Christian kookiness.

Since O’Donnell’s underdog campaign beat out her Republican opponent, talk about the Tea Party’s signature small government issues has been completely replaced by talk about what appear to be its new social issues.

Somehow, on the liberal side, there seems to be a sigh of relief. What at first appeared to be a new, libertarian, third-party movement

we ask for is the freedom to succeed and the freedom to fail” in response to the government bailouts — a quote, it turns out, originally taken from Terry Pratchett, who is by all accounts a liberal novelist. Something like “America is living beyond her means and lacks fiscal responsibility,” which was a rallying cry for many on the left during the Bush years. Their focus on the country that will be left to future generations, rather than the country as it exists today, can be traced to the arguments that environmentalists have made for years, replacing concern for natural resources with concern for fiscal resources and future tax burden. Many Tea Party groups seem to have co-opted the

“Dissent is the highest form of patriotism” slogan that became so contentious during the Bush years.

I am cherry-picking, of course, skimming over aspects of Tea Party ideology that would anger most Brunonians, such as the use of the word “socialist” in a negative light.

Yet at a time when so many Americans are angry over so many different things, and so little is being done, it seems worthwhile to highlight the commonalities and origins of the many different movements of American politics.

The Tea Party, like most movements fuelled by grassroots-populist anger, was probably never destined for the big stage, and perhaps it’s for the best. The line between social and fiscal issues, which Tea Party leaders fought so hard to draw, was bound to fracture as soon as they had an actual candidate.

Unless O’Donnell can rescue her image and turn the conversation back from social to financial issues, this is likely the end for the Tea Party’s chances at becoming more than a branch of far-right conservatism. However, at a time when the only thing that the parties in power seem capable of agreeing on is that certain issues are intractable, from the war in Iraq to the hand-off to big business, it is nice to have a reminder of the power of thirdparty fury, no matter how misdirected it may appear to have become.

Michelle Uhrick ’11 is an international relations and economics concentrator from Connecticut. She can be reached at michelle_uhrick@brown.edu.

Dealing with the Facebook

BY WILLIAM TOMASKO Opinions Columnist Last Friday, “The Social Network” swooped into movie theaters across the country, earning sky-high reviews and a “98 percent fresh” rating from RottenTomatoes.com.

The movie describes how Facebook was founded, offering a creation myth for the addictive, ubiquitous website.

Aaron Sorkin, who wrote the screenplay, apparently began the project already biased against Internet communication. In one script he wrote for “The West Wing” back in 2002, online commentators are derided as muumuu-wearing chain-smokers.

Last week, he told New York Magazine, “It only takes five (online comments) before you find somebody with a severe mental disorder.”

He also does not think too highly of social networking sites like Facebook. In a recent interview with the Daily Beast, he dismissed the basis for those sites, saying, “I don’t call (using them) socializing. I call it acting and performing. I feel that socializing on the Internet is to socializing what reality TV is to reality.” Largely because of this dim view, he doesn’t use Facebook.

I want to disagree with him about this.

After all, ever since starting my Facebook account almost five years ago, I’ve devoted plenty of time to maintaining my profile, sharing wall posts with friends and somewhat shamelessly stalking acquaintances. If

I agree with him, it seems that I’d have to declare that substantial amount of time wasted on unproductive interaction.

Still, his argument is persuasive. It’s much easier to control how I’ll be perceived through my Facebook profile than through live contact. On Facebook, I can create my own appearance with my profile picture and decide exactly what I want others to know about me. In person, however, I can’t filter what others will perceive.

sages posted on Twitter as a future resource for historians, one problem considered was “selection bias.” Since “Tweets are designed for public consumption,” one professor told Slate at the time, “if you’re looking at what someone ate for breakfast, you’re also looking at what someone wants everyone to think (he or she) ate for breakfast.”

Still, the tinted version of reality that we create through social networking doesn’t have to be a problem, as long as it can be

The tinted version of reality that we create through social networking doesn’t have to be a problem, as long as it can be viewed through the proper perspective.

Sorkin is right that Facebook isn’t a reliable tool with which to judge the people we know. To some degree, people will always reinvent themselves as they decide how to portray their online personalities as flatteringly as possible. Our wall posts, status updates and photo albums are directed at a wide audience, and are meant to tell the story about our lives that we want to tell, whether or not that story is accurate.

When the Library of Congress announced in April that it would begin archiving all mes-

viewed through the proper perspective. The benefits of Facebook, including it being an efficient way of staying in touch with friends and managing networks of acquaintances, can outweigh the downside of its limited truth-sharing. This works as long as Facebook isn’t the last word on what we know about each other.

Over the summer, I came across a blog post warning that Facebook was imitating TV as a new source of unhappiness: “It cannot be psychologically healthy to com-

pare yourself” to TV characters, the author writes, because those characters are disproportionately beautiful, interesting and witty.

In addition, “social networks have inadvertently created the same effect, but using an even more powerful source. Instead of actors in Hollywood, the characters are people that you know to be real and have actually met. The editing is done not by film school graduates, but by the people themselves.”

We know the less-than-rosy details in our own lives and in the lives of the people we’re close to; we don’t learn about these details from stalking acquaintances on Facebook, and therefore it can be easy to think those people are dealing with their school, work and social lives better than we are.

If I were to rely exclusively on wall posts and news feed updates to understand how those around me are feeling, and if all Facebook users did the same, then I’d agree with Sorkin that the site excessively distorts reality.

However, that exclusivity isn’t how people actually use Facebook. It doesn’t replace human interaction; it complements those connections. And as long as we continue enjoying non-digital communication — and maybe spend less time looking at what people we barely know have decided to put online — we can continue enjoying Facebook for what it’s good at doing.

William Tomasko ’13 is from Washington, D.C. He can be reached at william_tomasko@brown.edu.

Today The Brown Daily Herald

5

New campus center formally dedicated

7

5

c a l e n da r October 4

5 P.M.

ToMORROW

comics October 5

11 A.M. LGBTQ Vigil, Faunce House

Bat & Gaz | Sofia Ortiz

“Pictures from the Hay: Celebrating the John Hay at 100,” List Center

7:30 P.M.

8 P.M.

“Rebuilding Haiti” by Dr. Paul

“A Tale of Two Sisters” Film

Farmer, Salomon 101

Screening, Smith-Buonanno 106

menu SHARPE REFECTORY

VERNEy-WOOLLEY DINING HALL LUNCH

Beef Tacos, Mexican Infused Rice, Vegan Chinese Stir Fry, Vegetable Egg Rolls

Beef or Vegetarian Tacos, Mexican Corn, Peanut Butter & Jelly Bar

Cabernet Voltaire | Abe Pressman

DINNER Beef Pot Pie, Baked Potatoes, Peas with Pearl Onions, Lo Mein Noodles

60 / 55

63 / 56

Monday, October 4, 2010

9

Today

to m o r r o w

Learning how to improve the world

t h e n e w s i n i m ag e s

3

to day

Chicken Pot Pie, Vegan Ratatouille, Arabian Spinach, Mashed Butternut Squash

crossword

Dot Comic | Eshan Mitra and Brendan Hainline

Fruitopia | Andy Kim

The Adventures of Team Vag | Wendy Kwartin

Page 12