Williams Lake Tribune, December 04, 2012

Page 1

Breaking news, video, photo galleries, and more always online at www.wltribune.com

TUESDAY, DECEMBER 04, 2012

Inversion causes smells

Proudly serving Williams Lake and the Cariboo-Chilcotin since 1930

VOL. 82. No. 95

$1.34 inc. HST

CHRISTMAS HOUSE A 14 YEAR TRADITION LeRae Haynes photo

Ken (left) and Julia Berry have been lighting up their home at 42 Country Club Boulevard for charity for 14 years this year. Over the years the community has donated more than $16,000 to help sick children in the community by dropping donations in the little bird house box at the front of the house. Once again this year the lights are on every day from 5 to 11 p.m. through the holiday season. Ken is pictured here in Santa’s tree house workshop. In other scenes penguins frolick on a sled run and play hockey on a rink. For more on the story turn to Page A14.

On Dec. 3 the Tribune received inquiries about the sewer smell permeating the city. The city responded that when there is a temperature inversion in the valley, unfortunately there periodically is a smell from the sewage treatment plant, and there isn’t anything that can be done.

Chiefs present Tonight at 6 p.m. Tsilhqot’in chiefs will give a presentation to Williams Lake city council on their Nation’s opposition to the “new” Prosperity Mine Proposal. Grand Chief Stewart Phillip and Chief Bob Chamberlin, along with Chief Marilyn Baptiste, will also represent the executive from the Union of BC Indian Chiefs.

Inside the Tribune NEWS A3 Chamber expresses frustration. SPORTS Stamps take division lead. COMMUNITY

Visiting students at TRU

A9 A12

Weather outlook: The outlook is for clouds and snow/rain mix.

PM 0040785583

New Prosperity proposal found deficient Monica Lamb-Yorski Tribune Staff Writer The Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency (CEAA) has told Taseko Mines there are major deficiencies in the approach the company has used to assess the cumulative environment effects of the New Prosperity Mine. In a letter addressed to Taseko, Nov. 26, panel chair Bill Ross stated: “The approach excludes a number of valued ecosystem components (VEC) and key indicators from the cumulative effects assessment. Given the importance of this deficiency, the panel is submitting this information request in advance of other information requests which will be submitted by Dec. 11, 2012.” The letter also states it is the panel’s view that this information as well as responses to forthcoming requests are required for the panel to determine if the EIS is sufficient to proceed to public hearing.

After the additional information is submitted, the panel will decide whether or not to provide a 15-day public comment period, based on the additional information provided, or to proceed to scheduling a public hearing. Responding in a letter, dated Nov. 27, John W. McManus, Taseko senior vice president of operations, expressed the company’s disappointment. “It is discouraging that the panel has used an apparent technicality to stop the timeline remaining for the panel to complete the review,” he stated. Xeni Gwetin (Nemiah Valley) Chief Marilyn Baptiste said Nov. 29 she was not surprised by the panel’s letter. “I was expecting the panel to say there are deficiencies, not just a few. What’s disheartening and disgraceful is to hear Taseko say it’s a technicality. How is it a technicality? It’s so far beyond a technicality,” Baptiste said, adding the

project should be thrown out altogether. “Why waste everybody’s time and energy with a project that’s not being taken seriously by the company that’s putting it forward? Anyone with common sense knows that a massive open pit mine surrounding a lake will not save that lake or any lake.” Tsilhqot’in National Government chair Chief Joe Alphonse echoed Baptiste, saying it was good news to hear the project’s been delayed. “It was surprising and not surprising,” Alphonse said of the letters. “Taseko feels it’s going to get the project approved through the political process and not a proper environmental one. It blows me away that they put so much resources into this and yet they are their own worst enemies when they say they don’t want any delays.” All Canadians demand a high standard and the CEAA has shown those standards are going to be up-

held, Alphonse said. Brian Battison, Taseko’s vice president of corporate and community affairs, said the panel is asking for something Taseko has already submitted. “The work they refer to was done in the first proposal and there’s no need to do additional work. It has already been determined there will be no significant environmental effects to 22 of 24 potential environmental impacts,” Battison said. Two incidents were identified by the panel where there might be significant effects have been addressed by the current EIS Battison said. A fish compensation plan in a potential 33-year mine life, addressed by the saving of Fish Lake, and effect on grizzly bears, which was not a direct result of the mine, but increased traffic that the mine might generate, he explained. See CUMULATIVE Page A3


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.