Legal Defence of Defendants in the Criminal Process and Its Effect

Page 1

Legal Defence of Defendants in the Criminal Process and Its Effect January 1998

Legal Defence of Defendants in the Criminal Process and Its Effect

    

Basic legal framework Goals, methods and limitations of the study Results Summary Appendix 1: Questionnaire

In 1998 the Bulgarian Helsinki Committee launched a project for drafting a mechanism for setting up a Legal Aid Commission, which included a study of the current state of legal assistance and its effect on criminal process in the Republic of Bulgaria. Funds for accomplishing the project were kindly provided by the Open Society Fund in Sofia. The study is the first stage of a large-scale project for establishing a system of legal aid for indigent defendants. Basic legal framework Article 30, para. 4 of the Bulgarian Constitution gives everyone the right to legal counsel "from the moment of detention or from the moment of being charged". However, although the Constitution guarantees the right to participation of a defense counsel in the criminal proceedings, it does not guarantee the positive obligation of the state to provide a lawyer to certain categories of people. Since September 1992 the Republic of Bulgaria has been a party to the European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, whose Article 6, para. 3 (c) gives everyone charged with a criminal offence the right "to defend himself in person or through legal assistance of his own choosing or, if he has not sufficient means to pay for legal assistance, to be given it free when the interests of justice so require". Thereby the European Convention goes further than the Constitution by obliging the state to provide legal defense for indigent defendants "when the interests of justice so require". This obligation of the Bulgarian state is presumed to be met by two acts of internal law which contain provisions, stipulating that legal assistance be provided to certain categories of people. These are the Code of Criminal Procedure (CCP) and the Attorney Act (AA). Article 70 of the CCP provides for mandatory participation of a defense counsel or defender in all stages of the criminal proceedings in cases where the accused is a minor; the accused suffers from physical or mental disabilities which impede him to conduct his own defense; when the case refers to a crime for which the punishment provided is the death penalty, life imprisonment or deprivation of liberty for not less than ten years; when the accused does not speak Bulgarian; when the interests of the accused persons are contradictory and one of them has a defense counsel, and when the case is tried in absentia. For these categories of defendants the respective authority shall be obliged to appoint as defense counsel a person practicing the legal profession. In these cases lawyer's fees are paid by the state and, more specifically, by the budgets of the respective institutions. In addition to the CCP, Article 35, para. 1 of the Attorney Act obliges lawyers to provide free legal assistance to poor persons and to persons on alimony. However, no organizational infrastructure has been created at the bar associations for the enforcement of this provision, the state has not provided means for guaranteeing its application, and the widespread conviction among practicing lawyers is that this is a defunct law.


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.
Legal Defence of Defendants in the Criminal Process and Its Effect by BG Helsinki - Issuu