Strategic buyer's guide: Evaluating your VMS for workforce intelligence
Introduction
From system of record to strategic platform
Assessing VMS technology in today's era of work
Red flags hiding in plain sight
Strategic questions to ask providers
Decision matrix: Making the right VMS choice
Making your decision
The future of work
About Beeline
Organizations with a vendor management system (VMS) have realized, to varying degrees, the same baseline benefits – better visibility, cost savings, streamlined processes, improved compliance.
That said, not all VMS technology, services, and support are created equal. This guide provides clarity and confidence for organizations re-evaluating the VMS market, helping you identify the capabilities and partnership qualities that will support your program through this next era of work.
By Staffing Industry Analysts' latest account, 83% of large organizations have implemented a VMS. This technology was originally conceived as a system of record supporting contingent workers sourced through staffing agencies (vendors). It was a straightforward solution for a straightforward problem: track your vendors and manage your temp workers.
The benefits of a VMS – visibility, efficiency, cost savings, compliance, and higher worker quality – have largely remained the same. However, what it takes to achieve these today has changed dramatically.
Think about visibility. Ten years ago, having a dashboard that showed you how many external workers you had and what you were spending was groundbreaking. Today, real visibility means having market intelligence that shows you if you're paying competitive rates, predictive analytics that surface risks before they become problems, and sophisticated, role-based reporting tools that simplify program management.
While early VMSs were essentially procurement systems adapted for staffing, forward-looking platforms have evolved significantly since those days. Now, they've become strategic systems that adapt to the changing dynamics and best practices of modern workforce management.
Skilled talent demand
With specialized skills in high demand, companies need to move quickly and intelligently to find the right resources.
AI
Advanced AI brings with it new challenges around ethics, compliance, and the responsible use of emerging intelligence.
Compliance complexity
Keeping up with worker classification laws and data privacy regulations is a constant challenge, especially for global companies.
Optimization pressures
Processes are breaking under the weight of global expansion, complex workforce ecosystems, and innovation pressure.
To keep pace with today's demands, companies need to evolve how they evaluate VMS solutions. What worked five years ago— comparing feature lists and checking boxes on RFPs—no longer delivers the insight or outcomes you need.
Use these five pillars to build a smarter, more strategic framework for VMS evaluation.
Why it matters: External workforce management is complex, nuanced, and constantly evolving, requiring a provider whose sole focus is getting it right. VMS platforms bolted onto broader HCM or procurement systems often treat contingent workforce as an afterthought, with limited R&D investment and generalist teams making critical decisions.
Why it matters: Your business runs on a unique combination of systems, partners, and workflows. A modern VMS must complement that ecosystem, connecting across HCM, ERP, and procurement tools without dictating how you work. An open integration framework ensures freedom, flexibility, and scalability as your workforce strategy and tech stack evolves.
Why it matters: A VMS might claim to support 100+ countries, but "support" can mean anything from just allowing you to list workers in that country to having full invoicing capabilities and local compliance automation. If your company's five-year plan includes geographic expansion, understanding the depth of localization between VMS providers is critical.
Why it matters: When things go wrong (and eventually, something will), you need a VMS partner who's invested in your success, not a vendor who points you to a ticket queue. Must-haves here are dedicated client resources who know the technology and have a deep understanding of your program.
Why it matters: Real trust isn’t built on promises; it’s earned through transparency. Choosing a VMS is a high-stakes decision, and you need confidence that your provider will deliver reliably, protect your data, and support you through complex workforce challenges, including ethical innovation, while staying invested in your success for years to come.
Keep an eye out for fundamental philosophical differences that indicate a VMS provider is prioritizing their own interests over yours.
Pure-play VMS vs. bolt-on module: Are decisions driven by people 100% focused on the contingent workforce or juggling multiple HR and Procurement technology priorities?
ERP-dependent ecosystems vs. open integrations: Can you use best-in-class tools from any vendor or are you limited to what's in their ecosystem?
Rigid regional frameworks vs. global scalability: Can you truly operate globally with local flexibility or are you constrained by one-size-fits-all approaches?
Ticket-based support vs. human-centered engagement: When you need help, do you talk to someone who knows your program or submit a ticket and wait?
AI with vs. without human oversight: Is AI used to augment human decisions with accountability or are you in the dark about how conclusions were reached?
When it's time to choose your next VMS, don't take promises at face value. Ask the questions that expose what's real and what's just talk.
1. What percentage of your parent company's R&D budget is dedicated specifically to external workforce management vs. other product areas?
2. How many subject matter experts on your team have deep backgrounds in contingent workforce management, MSP operations, or staffing industry expertise?
3. Who will be our primary contacts post-implementation, and what is their background in external workforce management? reached?
1. What's your largest client deployment (worker volume and geographic spread)?
2. How do you handle localization beyond just language translation?
3. Can you share examples of how customers have adapted their programs using your VMS?
1. Who will be our main points of contact, and what does access to them look like?
2. How do you charge for your services, and what drives cost increases over time?
3. Can you share customer references who were in a similar situation to ours?
4. What's your innovation roadmap, and how do customer needs influence it?
1. What principles guide your AI development?
2. How does the system explain its recommendations or decisions to users?
3. What safeguards do you have in place to prevent bias in AI-driven decisions?
1. How does your platform integrate with tools outside your vendor ecosystem?
2. How do you handle integrations with systems you don't have pre-built connectors for?
3. What talent types does your platform support beyond traditional contingent workers?
It's important to understand these five pillars in the context of your own program. Create a score framework where each pillar is weighted according to your specific needs. This will ensure a strategic VMS fit. Here are some examples to help you think about it.
Fortune 50 firm with complex compliance needs
Build a scoring matrix. Use objective criteria. But also pay attention to the intangibles:
1. Which provider seems to understand your business and your challenges?
2. Asked the best questions during the evaluation?
3. Was most transparent about their limitations?
4. Provided evidence of real innovation versus feature parity?
The right VMS isn't just the one that checks every box—it's the one that proves to be the right partner for your journey.
The workforce landscape will continue to evolve. Regulations will change. Technology will advance. New talent models will emerge. The best VMS for this business environment is the one built on principles of openness, intelligence, and true partnership—demonstrating alignment with your goals and delivering long-term value.
The future of work is here, and it's more complex, more dynamic, and more opportunity-rich than ever before. Make sure your VMS is a competitive advantage in navigating it.
A thoughtful assessment today ensures your VMS propels your workforce strategy—rather than holding it back.
For over 25 years, Beeline has empowered businesses worldwide to achieve competitive advantages with their extended workforce. Beeline Extended Workforce Platform gives companies the visibility needed to mitigate risk, achieve cost savings, and meet dynamic business needs. With tailored solutions that solely focus on the complexities of the extended workforce, clients leverage Beeline products that fit their unique requirements. Through thousands of integrations, clients can connect their extended workforce data from all technology stacks, including major procurement and HR systems. Join the list of renowned brands benefiting from Beeline’s deeply seasoned experts, collaborative innovation, and industry-leading partner network.
Explore more at beeline.com