Iceman is latest gay superhero
ARTS
7
13
23
Romeo & Juliet
Divas
The
www.ebar.com
Serving the gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender communities since 1971
Vol. 45 • No. 19 • May 7-13, 2015
Changes sought for Castro plaza Rudy K. Lawidjaja
Marriage equality supporters held a rainbow flag outside the U.S. Supreme Court Tuesday, April 28 as the justices heard oral arguments in a same-sex marriage case.
Lawyers weigh in on marriage case
by Seth Hemmelgarn
analysis by Lisa Keen
Volunteer gardeners from the Deep Clean Green Team, including lead gardener Brian Gougherty, second from right, tend to the freshly planted concrete barriers in Jane Warner Plaza Sunday, May 3.
T
he U.S. Supreme Court has almost certainly made its decision about the right to marry for same-sex couples. The justices met in private conference Friday, May 1, and took a vote. They have until June 30 to issue their decision. Most legal observers who watched or listened to the oral arguments from April 28 in Obergefell v. Hodges, an appeal seeking to strike down bans on same-sex marriages in four states, predict Justice Anthony Kennedy will vote with the court’s liberal wing and find the bans unconstitutional. A few, like UC Irvine School of Law Professor Erwin Chemerinsky, believe the vote could even be 6-3, with Chief Justice John Roberts on board. Those who think Roberts could join a majority to strike down the laws were heartened by a question he posed to the attorney defending Michigan’s ban, John Bursch. “I’m not sure it’s necessary to get into sexual orientation to resolve the case,” said Roberts. “I mean, if Sue loves Joe and Tom loves Joe, Sue can marry him and Tom can’t. And the difference is based upon their different sex. Why isn’t that a straightforward question of sexual discrimination?” If the court decided state bans on same-sex marriage constitute sex discrimination, “then I can promise you that lawyers in almost any case where a law discriminates against gay people will make the argument that the law constitutes unconstitutional sex discrimination,” said Roberta Kaplan, who argued on behalf of Edith Windsor in the 2013 case that struck down a key provision of the Defense of Marriage Act. “On the other hand, there is always a bit of a disconnect with this argument, particularly when it’s clear that the law at issue was passed to treat people differently based on their sexual orientation, not their gender,” she added. See page 5 >>
S
an Francisco officials are again revamping the Castro district’s much-maligned Jane Warner Plaza, hoping that new furniture, entertainment, and other improvements will activate the parklet, making it attractive to neighborhood residents, tourists, and others.
The patch of concrete at Castro and Market streets has long been seen as a magnet for violence and harassment. Those concerns were highlighted recently after a man allegedly stabbed a woman in the plaza. The public space, which opened in 2009 See page 9 >>
Authors submit SF LGBT history document for review
Rick Gerharter
by Matthew S. Bajko
S
an Francisco planning and historic preservation officials are currently reviewing a draft version of a wide-ranging survey of the city’s LGBT past. It spans the centuries and features various groups of LGBT residents who called the city home, from Native American two-spirit tribe members and gender nonconforming Chinese immigrants to various artists and service members. Officially titled the “Citywide Historic Context Statement for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender and Queer Rick Gerharter History in San Francisco,” the Bay Area Reporter obtained A new report details the role North Beach, seen from the Coit Tower observation deck looking toward a copy of the 355-page draft Russian Hill, played in the birth of San Francisco’s LGBT community. document through a public records request. context statement is a preservation planning tool will assist with efforts to landmark, either by the Funded several years ago by a $76,000 grant that federal, state, and local governments can refer city or national programs, properties of historifrom the San Francisco Historic Preservation to when determining what places and structures cal significance to the LGBT community. Fund Committee, overseen by the Office of Eco- hold importance to telling a historical theme. See page 8 >> nomic and Workforce Development, the historic Once adopted as an official city document, it
{ FIRST OF THREE SECTIONS }
BUYERS AND SELLERS ALIKE LIKE US The City’s Best Local Ownership. Global Reach.
Noe Valley Office 415.824.1100 Marina and Pacific Heights Offices 415.921.6000 www.hill-co.com