Architectural Ethnography: Case Study House W
Institut für Stadt- und Regionalplanung ABRIDGED HOUSE
LOCATION
INTRO
CHRONOLOGIES
“Architectural Ethnography, in reconnecting pieces of today‘s disconnected society, and critiquing from viewpoints both inside and outside of architecture, allows us to learn many things from the drawings of our time” - Momoyo Kaijima 2018
Through our research the intertwining chronologies of different actors and networks who influenced the house or were influenced by it were created. The chronologies of its primary three loci, of Egon Wrobel - its current and longest resident, of the cemetery which as an extension of Berlin’s imprints of the house, and of the ABRIDGED HOUSE house itself.
For her “Experiments” with Architectural Etnography Kaijima proposes varying modes of viewing - drawing of architecture, drawing for architecture, drawing among architecture and drawing around architecture. Through our distinctive perspectives each of us have attempted exactly this. Our theoretical understanding of the topic was informed through the readings of Tim Ingold, Bernard Rudofsky, Bruno Latour and Albena Yaneva - yet we carry out the study only in its original mode- “as an experiment”
Berlin
+
Haus W ABRIDGED HOUSE ABRIDGED HOUSE
Page 1
HAUS -W Wrobel’s house is located in the far suburban, just outside the official boundary of Berlin. Built in 1945 by Carl Metzner from the ruins of Berlin, it tells a fascinating tale of time, space and context and most importantly of its residents.
Drawing something in all its details means seeing it another time for the first time. The process of drawing is intertwined with the process of understanding what we see.
The process to getting out of the comfort zone and towards new experiences, drawing as a reproduction of our mind.
Page 1
Like a trace of perceptions that are formed in our subconscious and are expressed through drawing.
Page 2 Page 2
Adding/leaving stuff out on purpose, different to a photograph which shows how something REALLY is.
5
0 1
2
6
4
Investigating a place unknown to me using drawing as the core method – also the uncertainty of where this investigation might lead
0 1937 - Karl Metzner - a Berlin stone mason sculptor starts his office and workshop right next to the railway station of the newly planned central cemetery of Berlin- in preparation for the grand capital of the world Germania. 1 1945 - At the end of the WWII the Metzners decide to leave Berlin city which had suffered huge damages in the bombing. They decide to build a house in Stahnsdorf in the outskirts of Berlin where Karl Metzner formerly had his
3
Drawing is a different way of thinking. Reproducing what is perceived through drawing, captures something more.
2 The raw material from the house comes from the rubble of the Berlin bombing, among which are some parts of museums and famous structures. Metzner given his vocation as a stone mason/sculptor skilfully integrates this into his house. 3 Another source of material is from the old cemetries of Schöneberg, Berlin. from which 15,000 graves were moved to the Stahndorf cemetry. The surplus gravestones surved as a resourceful alternative to building materials in post war Prepared by : Anto Gloren | Instructor: Oxana Gourinovitch | Chair : Prof. Stephanie Herol
Autoethnographic imprints are strongly produced in our drawings. Drawing enrich our understanding of the built environment and its cultural significance.
4 1973 - After the death of her husband Johanne Metzner sells her house to Wilfred Zander - a professional film stuntman. In the stories related in popular account and printed in newspapers - Zander is believed to have kept his pet tiger in the back yard. Our Interview with Zander though revelaed this was only a legend, there were infact two donkeys that have mutated to a tiger in the 5 1975 - Within three years Zander’s application to migrate to West Germany was accepted. He sold the house to Egon Wrobel - an artist and sculptor. Egon has changed the house through his art exhibits and extensions and has been home to him since then. 6 Egon’s and Haus W are coherently connected inseparable entities. As Wrobel also works in his workshop that he built at Haus W, his work additively transforms the house progressively.
th
or
ead d ir the ves.” r ono msel h not ty the o ldt d ni e f o e g wh o di Ihl f e n a s ) l o e s O “Th n hav Nazi gere e oft ut th Mana o y (ab eter m Ce
N
rea a ing cred a lo s un d wa the e rat ease st of a p e ec a A s the d he e t for to d ate nhof. h Ba
of e K of Ro irc h da fam ma ho y o nti f w it u ci a bo s sm s as arc p te hi an lan d te d ne of ct al d m s on o an an g n y d wi the ce sc th le ul th co br pt e nc ity or w ep bu s o or t ria f ks ls the .(1 )
it ith a w is t n a or h r ce ld e ea in me a ten of m clud tery nd th l 206 on e s a um d i in ec rge hec o en n th Ge nd st i tar t p e rm l n es ro Br an ar the te an y. ge ct d I st io en t n b is lis ur t. g
d
W
s wa ” s res orf to p x . w Eahnsd 1913 o d Wi o St y) in e h “T rlin t eter e lin Be (cem n h ee f -Ba ans rchho S ial m W stki c e e p ro A s ned f Südw ope e the v ser ) (11 hn Sta R orf
Th
g e B
evn ra f hn art o a S-Bront p n the e , th the f ted i n o i at at in nspor c i f i s ctr itors re tra e l E is e 929 .(3) V fins w 1 the nutes e cof r e Aft 20 mi nd th (5) s a ery train, agon w the ched a att
no e c gr t o em on ievi nly ete du es ng fre ry ca e bur and qu Bah th nce to ied re ent nh t e l e o ea of he bu ati d f w se t c t a ves by a of he utu lso o th s th ce ra v f t e e m l is he S- e si to Ba ter gn rs hn y ifian d
f
Th
h
or d s n
et ith p ca erie lan 33 me s o s f o to ,00 th f Sc r r se bea 0 de e p hön elo c ha lve r th cea lan eb ati e o s Th d t . T e c se of rg n o d pa e r heir hos ost (5) reb Ber f s i e to rts bu gr e w of t . Th uri lin x c e pl the and rial ave ho he r e fa al in 1 man w s w s la e m of 9 . a uf or fo cke bu ili u 38 r fe k rc d ria es pt In th re w ib t l h o t at d as ly he th ad bo he u qu se ca cle m em sl r fir ic ve rr ar ea o s kl ra ie ed ns th wl sho t y y l h d .( e y rt ea fo a ou 5 re an ag r llo lt t ) o b d e A ft u w s d in a r ia y the he ed u be tota ls ea w l e th e st r wo ar m n of e op la rk d ce any tran 15, t p u e ed r ca e m gr s 00 et a fer 0 co the rri to l v c e Th m w ed ary es red of f . t pl o o e i o to p to ns et rk n n es S a be la el o t n n y( f ar ah d st ne 1) e nd ur op d . ol o n pe pl d s r er f.H h d. an tin th en ad an c g w th e or e k al so ha d
h
ta S e
W
s
ab etzn tio ly l er’ n oc s an at of d ed fice th in e t an ce hi d m s w et loc or er i k y. of sh th op e w S- a Ba s hn sui st ta-
.
ry o t as
M
e fB
t , n rli
AL
TH
e ß a str
S , 1 1
CA N
8 g n i 3 n n i 9
tah r o d ns
LT OW
ll e t f,
TE
pl et ed
rld o w o e f s h o t h e re. n ea n r h m a a o c he aso B he e t b d m 0 n e o W i t t a s 09. in loc tone d 10 us e l a c r e re d s y an ial la 19 fH B p o or were base ter spec s al ed in i f s r s e r n es lin eme he bu pen d a l f d p teri Ber e c to t o so a d e e an me r a te th ext ag f wa Th r t r g s n ce tzne osi ht n ’ ho hho r s e rli Me opp rig c a e r p i e rl S th stk p and B i t o l a r W we h a e K lb ever nts orks nhof d A ü S to ia, s eve d w ah e du an ese e an ry B sed. 8 93 Germ of th Offic mete cea 1 In tal ext his Ce e de t i e h cap e conlished m th ing t h ab fro ing t n L I est ay br NA r A w d WC ha res a ted fo O T L t ea TE e R E m y cr OV E e IDG R all EB
an e c d on th st e ru lin c e tio w n en of t i th nt e o ra op il er wa at y io lin n e in w 19 as 13 c . om
1The
Th
L A R U T : W C Y E E H T I S P H U A C O R R H G A NO DY H U T T E ES S A C ony m e cer tation g nin hof s from e p d o al Frie l train nhof. i c i off dorf ecia nbah ons e i s h , t tahn by sp r Fer stat 3 1 o S d e 9 , 1 the avele dam he tw 2 s t une ce in sts tr n Pot and J On pla gue erli oute .(11) B r c k d too invite then y the traffi a the t was ing d ublic p a wh followed to n Thee ope r we
hn
ei ba chs
Sta hn
m eS op ant tat en ti ion ed ll t w in he as 19 lin d 48 es or . r e-
Th
hn
ba chs
h
n-
te , Tö
zle z u p e aw ther s jig le re he rubb at we t me the s th f Mu a c be with terie ble o e l e b g ubb Alon cem he ru r rlin use. ebergrom t e B ho n f the his Schö facts ries. rombuild f the arte centu f ted d to ss o r and not c e e l f e col start l proc re-wa des i s e a iec tzner buria the p y dec p ble h Me he re from es b a u val whic rom t ones at tim e Th ugh rial f bst use m o o thr mate m -To the h i s wa d by h edate r usems, p seu
ei
fR dor
su e r an me ebu vi d in d in ria s gr ito se 19 l a es rs cu 50 nd si to rit . B p ve t y, u l ly he m t t an dw so ea he tin in ut nt dif g dl hw th fic pr ed e a u oc . st t th lty es ch e of s ur nu ar re ch m ri ya be va rd r l pr of o-
to ue s d 53 onth 9 ro 1 p 19, nty ming of sly y u r o e n a ni mi anuce. Tw begin o J on pla the nly o e n e i l took e. At n i l e l h rai d t ever servic e e s n th clo ork into 1]. of n e ag bah uch w back ne [1 p s p h ic r, s ent us o sto e y R e weve line w revio ar r h o c o p s mp eut rk. H 4, the o the e t D s o t Thi e. rlin on w 1, 195 ded e d B ti 1 s mi East truc ber was a s m The k con epte hicle e S c tra r, on her v t e lat 5, ano 195
or t
dge
ri yb a ailw r(7). r The he wa . d t e nu ys of i t on a isc inal d d s f wa the t r g spo durin n a l tr acht a c ll lo ehrm A . ) f(7 the W r o y nsd up b h a St lowh d e ch as b a e y r l (6) w m r a d A Can e R he etlow t , T l 22 the i r Ap ver On ke o c brü si phe
se
s d it
Th
Th
r a eW
Un po til he int Au St re sou gus ah th th t ns e d o 19 do ec f C 46 rf. ea ha , se rlo a d tte co w n rp Th er bu s e rg e e in R ta s c ke ta ol bu Sta ed n tio lec ha ilt hn Ar by n ti s tr , fro on Ce d u in 1 do my uc m r be me nre 935 f, w mo k to ne rie ter str . S hi ved c i s y i th ws of , cte nc h t in t e ch at m pap th her d a th he to t c e vi urc an ers ce e ces e R We he si h y r m w s u hr b co to ya v ep e er t ss m ar o r (1 nne s d rd isito ort ter e s th ian ach rac 1) c ro ou r e y o e s t ks tio p t s d vis m S o h n pe of avo so ito eti ou ldi ad al d r fea id me rs me thw ers so ap r ed i . s e n T fa idly and th cid he rob st ci . t e e d lit Th he so nt ai at e n u s, ly ed la u th s m w o th ck be es is of r t de a r of cl ail in e.
1
Th cl e B e w ar erl a i ru r B lar ner na bbl erl ge Trü nt e in am m s so by o m of m h un e fa et an ts rfr m im d o au ou e (c f e s s on ru nbu ha t bb R ild s rov le ub in va er th ble gs lu si ro w . ab all ug om le y)( h e s 10 p n an ). os d Th t re is m -
s u o h n o e c . h g. t d n o t oin a rlin n i r g a f Be ad on e w v e so em o yet h t m s t ing ton r a s e o p uild a s tzn rlin w n e i M Be rl ed b n as . e u B roy tio ra le in s m t oca F a o s t t r w e f d ’s v y R ha bat r y t e e a r w the w of th zne et GD o a h m s ile e the erve ble Met ive. c s o f h d r of t B r ), w m rub arl nat o o c d o y es ue t e d C ter s e 5(8 r r n o d t e ah erri 52, W es. D r de m th s an le al t i Th il 194 S c t 19 ss rde e fro rce iab e d r e h T th ay d pa bo s s use ou a v ’ . Ap r d t n n M ali e ho res le a e n o n d e z e I n hus th t v am um et eir k of rubb u o M t 28 hou ec oc f e e d th lac the d r h n e - a the wit on b vel d T cte ar e w R ry rom DR tati tra u st w ad r D t G rito . F e G n s he s po lf m e e e th ter erlin g th Bah nd t d Th hims an urg st B terin n S- es a G n so FR denb n We en inde pass ). e th ran ee i from reil the . (7 , 9 B ns ed e D of top 4 9 n In 1 ted o -Wan bann s, th lidity eck s h n e a a loc Berli been stanc the v ute c d um re, min d a n h a rs irc He ltic e . lin ese ation a mu n th t to rol s ked i t ec n o c e ch r we n o e the
N
Fr St om br ahn No th idg sdo vem e e rf b tr ne w e ac x a r On k t to s 19 of t Af h th clo 45, t e t h N er 27 e e b sed the ot th t ce lo t pl o is h m w o fir ac nl t In et n- tr st e e y s M er up af re ag wa t w ay y T fic co ai s as 19 ra o , n n p s 4 ilw ten ex st a on s u 8, ay br cep ruc th sen cce a l to üc t f tio e g ss oa ra er fu d St ke. or n il. t l, te ah T n m (7 ra th st ns hu ew ea ) ffi e w do s, ly su c fir as rf. it w es res on s c t t ar as tab of th ra r e in ied po lis th ce w o ss he e m en ut ib d br et t .1 le bu id er ba 2 to s ge l y ck oc w lin be ra t o al es g ilw o S m k . an ay ta otiv fr Th , h om e S re ns es i su d in th Re nce o c m rf lu e ic t ed fr d Dr hs he , b om ing ei ba S lin h ü ut D a de n s dw c r al e o n et es so ili al S- u tn t th de en Ba p Ki e n de hn a m rch tr S- r an B on st ak hof sp ah t at e i io sh n or n s he n if t o ta re ov t s t f t io to er he n re a de t 1 d b ce 2.4 rid as 3 ge ed p.m . to . ok
5 4 9 f
1 o h t 8
e-
f ld ina
1
ll a eW
Th
na e f (1 ) fl lora 2, ou ( 13 r al ) ish so ed p in oss th ibl e yt m he ea f nw au hi le
Th
r fte a s eek ) w ew e.(11 f t firs Straß e h r in t haue d are arsc e p W p isa ation d , rts hn st o p a sup S-B e g th n the n i ud sed o l c f, in e reu o o r ly r e we f r e utt . Thes b The built s wa
ll Wa e th
rau F g ilin ger in a an t a ti m fro g kep lity e a s n e i u r ho f hav e s in h y o t e d ght egen onk u d o l two n b rban a e r tm u we y tun h the e s h at t nal roug h o i t d ess us th f ale 6) o e o r v e a p e fam e r ver. (1 r h e d = and s ma ugh atsoe Z o i h d t h fre He 5). im w Wil zner. rd(1 ith h tiger + t kya w w no e M bac vie nd a r the n inte yard k In a is bac in h
Fi th nal l pe e W y Z Eg rio est and on d h wa er W e li s a ’s p ro ve p e be d pr rm l t in ove it o th d to w e f in e ho o 1 m m rm 97 m he er 5, ig so ap for rate ld art a t th m bri o e en ef ho t us of e.
Th Za e w th nde all is r w pe , th as rio e clo At t d, res se to he w id ly th e an e g n e d te nt ua w o In d of rd es f t to th ed m hi t v he m e o e s ia 1 “b .”( a ov ho n t 9 t 6 h 1 u e u he c 0 e s w t 7) co to se E as th Z u se , h th d as a n e w ov n nd te ur t. ag e tr er t e w in i e h e r cr e w es g d s “ ow y a B ys to t. te e de rel s in ut m sc d. ea ja th : ap ”( se il e e 17 d fo y ) m rh g e al rab be f a be ca ye d us ar e , it
Th
ca e h to red ous M the fo e w so etzn he r, as de ld er, alt ow unh Th r.(1 it to wh of ing of e r 6) H en Fr. r. sh de na eco Za e nt tu lo n(1 re ni s 2, 13 is ati ) e on vi -
f go n i d loa emol n u d the also rud r h g fowas t wit n i uild sed vacanod b a The dece was peri a d the d an h for t e ish grow l era
in nd o a and ove t b s hu to m se to r he d u o of eede er ho uld g y wa ner n ld h o wo hofa g z o n sin Met he s ce wh Bah ails a R e p , Fraume. S ntain alled the h t c f o er ge ho ua ll Aft old a care- an aq t, sti rance e her nior rough s stre appea e i a S der th on th he dis t Zan alks pite w s for ße de n. o a str Stati y wa
n tio p e rec GDR e th to a new , 1 96 nted rs, a m, 1 er as re yea tsda til b o cemion w r two r P - un e s D Stat e ove erkeh 1964 g fab a s n tl v e y arl of th a lit kraft pring uildi g wa e As ding After üter om s the b uildin f the o G r l , . b bui pany EB ses f that the nnel t was t tu r V i com nt, prem . Afte o tha rian le tha t s a 3 ten d the 197 pair, pedes rubb r e e use embe o disr . The ith th 6 t c De ell in n 197 led w i f il ric n up as f w w blo form (11) . t pla uced d pro
uri b for ance n pe port use o l stil us im beca chs wa revio lace l cat n. y r te t its p rial p igina Berli e em t los l bu ts or est nder c he es, i entra om i to W ed u nes t ughR tim an, c off fr nged plac bsto cal o h t Alt in GD opoli ly cut belo was y tomistori r w rd n als met plete h no chya 2, ma art-hy. r 8 a m ic l n as as co , wh e chu in 19 m a tural a ro a it w t are gh th ction ble f cay n n u te a e me n tho t pro valu t to d f n Eve ume them re le f e n mo me o e – w o iv – s pect s per
or th
3 7 9
N
e h t of n y e itte n r ou e wr disj in . Th he a r h t burg top t t r ou den m. s f e an a. h t er in Br 1.00 t f . A rted from .m sta d “ a 23 se” t rea ) : 1 a , Ro por (11 1 e 6 ” n m 9 tio ans lin a 1 c , r a be 13 per of Tr t Be f t r s “O er s o nt, u e d g , s t W u day nis to n nme ner A h , a i t iro etz ay mer R M ains S d l n al env au M w Su sum e GD hn tr n sed , Fr i h a l t w r a e nclo ner ne r of ll S-B e B r z , a e e he he his e Met c t n ord h of a f t l t e o f r r o n c g a e in ce. I of C der. rf east l pat e a t in the se spa way Zan n e a d d a th m rom 13). u ti h necte sing ilfre h s f 2, W on as o W w o rest s.(1 l t p c f s e o fo ard di r the ous e d e tw a h e eH c t T f e er. wes a th d a ov ng d l n o a g chi s h n t i k re s ta croa o n m t th star en e i W re se u wly t a n slo are
reo f the and n s. O tion E e of e e tr na nc nd esig orta a es al d imp h s bu g sign rmer h t i n fo n w wro the w gro th the us of r e i t ov al (w ind i e lb ign rem a , ) s ere ain bahn h t till orm mdhofs s s f m i nd a Frie r o e f lat tele a m th .(11) p s Thert, a s al fro ilway n cou a sig for ra not place s thi
2 2 0
l e b ro n W i n n o r g bo g E . g as bur n i ild dy” w ster the u b tu In ost a n f s i o er n . P and t n e und etow 944 ker w m sh use hom in 1 ami t no i l ab “ho his tion cer it. I bel t s e the ed ecu s a ith ro e th t of ly fl ers th, a d w ch W h t i en mi e p mi nite mu w 8 sid is fa cap lds s u as 3 9 1 t re h, h o es a go wa is n i u s W t d s h e n s i s ) a ong ew sia n a an au y s g b e j e H l s o b nd ing Ru ati us m. ) d orie e y t r o 0 i c n st to nt a . Be e of edu he h of h .(2 e s u e 9 W v is e req of th f Th curr 193 ncla d his ght t part aus s ils g d E te bou ble f H a e r w a h e r ,t erb lan ple lly era nt o t e ic s e i t n t s m n p a o cre e g s t Ins an I he co d fin inse impr a n h co an ntin w e n n , w b o a h a t a r t d os (n i er tor be rs u hu ies e r s i a o m u for er z ulp s t be n o a e o l t th N sc em lf d ed s qu o n c a e n hi a e l bu e r g p n as ost se hims i l o 4. T w a d o l n l i n d e 201 w e e s s e alm robe b r as 13ha era e W s h t a h , 20 s s ) e a as n 4 e are 009 rn na h d(1 e e w d t he rd 2 il fau ure e w b d , 3) T eco e The en s h e T s. as u t.(2 on r s h n n a s, e e r t ma land w re me o n s r e to al ti a thi w fus ver w e t re r se nd. n t a tha dee ic sta u B ies nd tr it s, a cen l i b oar po o r b h f o ant our
2
s s ne
r e ild
ad s ha
W
g ikin h lar u p po .(21) a ow rness n 000 , s 6 e i ne h wild nd i l u o y t r i a w , a s ailw lete r e at er , rep m i m t r es (22) fo W22 e l S a h i a. T effic e are t o u ro to in th g n di s live r o Acc boar d wil
vea the peng n alo n stu voke d te ow e lan ve gr they p k re a we ing h d ran t tha build e an s l e tre ation in fi e l litt he st nding e Th of t l sta l e nu s. Sti doupast. the
is h c i wh gues e i her ) intr s ing road d l i bu tation e h eilt e (s c f the dorf s o ftraß e m s o fro tahns the es hnh r g d ad d Ba han the S and me e s . e s o e Th call osity ctit me in cave at h 11 i l the a l r l i , 2 , t o u a s o s ’s c air wns “St at h ombs re als irds, ly a p e e n g t b o in are the es a of t on 5) y r nd fa rns n m l s x a s m en a ir ho n he ecie t to nd fo ecie is no ts”, ( d w r n a p p y n a , rick the gree ve at s etre er a 53 s eter pla e o c e s r i r b ls r, d rs, em and an sively arpen cked d n u r c a e a e a t h s ya fo m o ls p e ain d ma lso s rans rch tal of e ani ild b shop s. Th nima m u Ch A to , th rs, w gras sect ed a ng tiplie ats a r also i t k s r e r sta mul he go boa we ner. inte adg s of ing in nge t n i u pa also ts, t Wild So a cor in w m. B pecie well enda e e t n e i h d d f t g in y an or th 16 s od- re or sp r had g pla age. o e o a D f g n o ts“ e dee werin le dam din leepi he da ially e als of w any r l n i e rew t is s ing t espec re ar ecies or m try. am nd th nd flo parab l e o r e a Th A ba Du ung The 0 sp pe f em als ain, res a e irre . 1 t o . C h y t y 3 g d in eter xes eter and bio f the fel in ag ructu caus e l a o o m h b m I get e st hus r ce den e ce rflies also ger e to av t a t o h e nag ged m gr s and wo in t butt le, bu Man a e f e e mmana m fro lant ) h t her cies o peop ldt th ut oar osso and p ” (23 r efe e o B f p l s eat Ih ld bery bl rees ards. i f r a t w re s Ol ev ant t avey t a e t e ragr d gr no f n on ces a spa
ve 198 er ry 9 W w stw suc ro b h Be o h hile ess el pl rlin ad “T full had ay . h rü y a ed It elp m de n in is a ed me sig exh th lso c rfr ne ib e a lea au d itio or m r e j n ig e th n” ew fo in m e - e r s or r R lle w of y ub u r h th of bl bb y f ich e th e le or h ho e of w t e us rol po om he e. e st en it w pl a ay r ed
l-
ha s, c
ge
the
n cha
le
p peo
y e rat db t e s wlu ts. form l e i i v n s to ts onme tran tric r the p n e o s m r tte envi ace i n. ropoc tive f a ext rban w sp n tur anth arra t n n i o u o r s c unds on h ans ft ou our t i f m i n in ll o surro ectio n hu to sh nds a o andy that trosp nd n need n frie e Weaut r’s in ple a we uma s u Ho day b eade f peo here non h f o ry very the r ives o es, w our o t s d e ke e l tim of e h T es an invo es th rate sion Prepared by: Anto Gloren e lu g g to len pes chan desp e inc Instructor: Dr. Oxana Gourinovitch o it r h Chair: Prof. Stephanie Herold It h how in ou for t Institut für Stadt - und Regionalplanung s d r an eove peal ”. p y r Mo t it a he cit n t poi ht to “rig
th
or
e h T
d n E
N
tin s i ind ndly e r a e fo ho e H w ous her. hico irit h he toget og C e sp t h and und ving d d in t l o n obe bly b his lo ork a r W ha rs tw s r gui embe the a rem on in se. s u live e ho h of t
In
Th
va e r nc ew ed ild be ing au o tif f t ul he ly. c on te xt
of H
au
s
sed a e dec have d e es sorm” sit hou e f e ty an h f th“emp burb at “ t o h site any rge su ign t g rin nd m er la rue s u o hb ea a e cutt ). A t dorf. g i ne g ar ooki . (14 hns e h T adin by c cated n Sta i i d lo un n fille repl rived re r beehat a has a t es tern” s we
H e th ad an rou ds d gh “I de (2 n er 2)” 20 “f or s . 09 sa r on In , ry ea si Ju twe .” so te ly lv H ns M .( 2 e e 23 01 a co of th ayb ). 3, nim nc pi e e e a a liv th lu ty pe ls es is de a rm w i s. nd of s w it ere liv a to w s in y t pr as ho g oo e se be m is t a su n rv in u e gs ch ed d t h fo to til 20 e rp a l M ga pe re sk ac ar ngs se n e ch w of rv ow 20 er in , th g bu 14 e e th td to cou ea e m de a d” hu nte ad yb (2 nt d 2) . eo w pa th ild ss ur e fu bo ing ki tu lli ar re ng s w is ill ne qu ce es stio n ta ki ng
till s t i of ouls s e s rac s of ugh t l ica e live ) Tho s y 0 h h e p ft in t ent.(2 m , so it le evid e n go trace more g n lo lible t, is w o de in i n n i s i d all t the sone too. W u ri The ain, b imp y in it t e rem wer beau o s wh e wa r the
-
W e Th