The Freeman's Journal 01-03-19

CAPTIVATED by

CAMERAS •F

IA E WIL

L

COOPERSTOWN AND AROUND

www.

DG

Volume 211, No. 01

1808 BY

VISIT THE EXPANDING

OUNDED

JU

R

IN

Otsego County’s Newspaper

O M C O PE

CAMERA BUFF COLLECTED ‘THOUSANDS’ OVER THE YEARS/B1

For 210 Years

AllOTSEGO.com

Cooperstown, New York, Thursday, January 3, 2019

Newsstand Price $1

The Fenimore ROCKS! Museum’s Biggest Show To Feature Photos Of Madonna, Cher, All Of Rock’s Greatest

“There are more than 100 pieces to this collection,” said curator Chris COOPERSTOWN Rossi. “It’s the largest show we’ve ever put on.” adonna is Ritts’ “Rock Portraits” coming to debuted at the Rock & Cooperstown.

Roll Hall of Fame in So is David Bowie.

Cleveland, Ohio, in 2015.

Bob Dylan, Bruce “There’s a whole difSpringsteen and Tina ferent element to his rock Ritts took iconic Turner will be here too, portraiture. It’s not just the photos of Cher – and part of “Herb Ritts: The many other rock stars. visual connection, there’s Rock Portraits,” due to a sonic connection as open April 2 at The Fenimore Art Muwell,” said Greg Harris, Rock & seum.

Please See PHOTOS, B5

Rock and Roll Hall of Fame President Greg Harris, right, visited The Fenimore’s Clark Gallery over the weekend to see where Ritts’ photos will land. With him is Todd Kenyon, Fenimore director of marketing.

By LIBBY CUDMORE

Ian Austin/The Freeman’s Journal

Christian Shaefer of Richfield Springs, who mounted a surprise write-in campaign to win a county coroner post in the Nov. 6 election, takes the oath of office Tuesday, Jan 1, at Foothills in Oneonta/

M

MORE PHOTOS, A3

Both Mayors, Seward Weigh State Of State ONEONTA

John Heller, Oneonta • 1980-2018

FIREMAN DIES A HERO

S

tate Sen. Jim Seward, R-Milford, and two mayors, Cooperstown’s Ellen Tillapaugh Kuch and Oneonta’s Gary Herzig, were due to address the Otsego Chamber’s annual State of the State Breakfast at 8:30 a.m. Wednesday, Jan. 2, at SUNY Oneonta’s Morris Conference Center. For details, check

COOPERSTOWN

T

AllOTSEGO.com

AllOTSEGO.com

►THE OTSEGO LAND TRUST announced the donation of a conservation easement on 133 acres of forests, hills, farmland and wetlands in the Town of Oneonta on Friday, Dec. 28.. ►A FIRE DESTROYED the Fred A. Roos Jr. house at 264 Geywits Road, Town of Springfield on Friday, Dec. 28, according to Assistant Chief Dale Schulz of the Springfield Center Fire Department. No injuries were reported, but the fire remains under investigation. ►OUTGOING CONGRESSMAN John Faso wouldn’t rule out running for Congress again in 2020 – but wouldn’t rule it in either, he told WAMC President Alan Chartock. ►310 AIRBNB HOSTS in Otsego County each earned about $5,900 in supplementary income in 2018, the company announced at year’s end.

Convenient Care Opens At Bassett’s Mother Ship

By PATRICK WAGER

www.

ON

Ian Austin/The Freeman’s Journal

John Heller, engaged to marry next Oct. 12, helped his fiancee, Amber Roe, and his four nephews to safety before being trapped inside 5 Walling Ave., Oneonta, last Saturday evening, Dec. 19

By LIBBY CUDMORE

here’s been one in Herkimer for 18 years and in Oneonta for 10.

And Thursday, Jan. 3, Bassett Hospital will open an “after-hours” Convenient Care Center at the main hospital here.

Dr. Winther The new unit will have seven patient-care rooms and will be staffed at first with “an advanced practice clinician” – a physician’s assistant or nurse practitioner – one registered nurse, one medical office assistant and one registration staff.

Over time it is expected that the unit Please See BASSETT, B4

Local Women Plan Bus To D.C. March

By LIBBY CUDMORE

ONEONTA

J

ohn Heller died a hero.

The former Oneonta firefighter made sure his four nephews, Donovan, 9, Maddox, 7, Macall, 5 and Rawley, 2, as well as his fiancée, Amber Roe, were safe when an early-morning fire broke out in his 5 Walling Ave. home on Saturday, Dec. 29.

“He and Amber are my heroes,” his sister-inlaw, Erika Heller, wrote in an emotional FaceIan Austin/The Freeman’s Journal Heller was trapped in the top floor of 5 book tribute. “They saved my babies and he Walling Ave., where he may have tried to made the ultimate sacrifice for our family.”

Please See FATAL FIRE, B5 escape through the broken window.

ONEONTA

T

his year, Butternuts Valley Indivisible won’t just be marching in the third annual Women’s March for Women Jan. 19 in Washington, D.C. They’ll be marching for everyone, said Amy Pondolfino, who is organizing the local contingent.

Please See MARCH, B4

THE FREEMAN’S JOURNAL & HOMETOWN ONEONTA, OTSEGO COUNTY’S LARGEST PRINT CIRCULATION 2010 WINNERS OF The Otsego County Chamber/KEY BANK SMALL BUSINESS AWARD

THURSDAY, january 3, 2019

A-2 THE FREEMAN’S JOURNAL

LOCALS Richfield’s ‘Gentle Giants’ All-American Clydesdales RICHFIELD SPRINGS

W

CCS Dominates Cobleskill, Unatego in Dick White TournEY

COOPERSTOWN

which collectively, brought in $20,000 to help realize a Dream for a much deserved Cancer patient. Captain Max took 5th in Halter class & Patrick took 9th, as well as two other team wins which included Royal Rex.

ith over 700 Clydesdales competing to be the best of the best at the 2018 World Clydesdale Show, Captain Max, Royal Rex and Patrick, of Rolling Meadows Clydesdales in Richfield Springs placed in all classes, culminating in nominations for the All-American Clydesdale Awards, their Wilson hugs her 2,000-pound owner, Donna babies, champions Captain Max, Wilson, reported. right, and Royal Rex. Shown in the same arena as The famous They had a full summer Budweiser Clydesdales, of shows, with wins at the Wilson’s Clydesdales Midwest Regionals at the brought home a total of Wisconsin State Fair, Boone six ribbons from the World County Fair and the NationShow, including 1st & 4th als at the Iowa State Fair. place single cart in the Make-A-Wish category,

the snow is here!

we have a huge selection of saws , trimmers & snow throwers

Centers Cooperstown Hosts Gingerbread House Competition

C

enters Cooperstown hosted their annual gingerbread house competition, where residents competed by unit to create the best gingerbread house.

• 1st Place, the Memory Care Unit • 2nd Place, a tie between Rehab and Mountain Ridge Unit • 3rd Place, tie between Country Meadows and the Rolling Hills Units.

Cheryl Clough/The Freeman’s Journal

Cooperstown’s John Kennedy battles Cobleskill-Richmondville’s Pat Nichols for a rebound in the Hawkeyes 52-44 win over the Bulldogs last evening. Cooperstown won in the opener of the annual Dick White Christmas Tournament on Saturday, Dec. 27. Later that day, the Hawkeyes beat Unatego 77-33.

All

HANEY ON LIST: Carson Haney, Hartwick, has been named to the dean’s list at Nazareth College for the Fall 2018 semester.

OTSEGO.home-improvement Become a Reinhardt Home Heating Customer

Sharon SpringS garage 6799 Route 23, Oneonta · 607-432-8411 1375 US 20, Sharon Springs · 518-284-2346 www.sharonspringsgarage.com Mon - Fri: 7:30 am to 5 pm · Sat: 7:30 am to Noon

Serving the Central New York counties of Otsego, Delaware, Chenango and Schoharie

For the past 80 years we have sought to bring smart energy products to our residential and commercial customers.

We deliver expertise with every gallon of fuel, 24/7, 365 days a year.

Our goal is for you to experience true home comfort.

Join us!

We Make Warm Friends! www.ReinhardtHomeHeating.com · 607-432-6633 3919 State Highway 23, West Oneonta

THURSDAY-FRIDAY, january 3-4, 2019

THE FREEMAN’S JOURNAL & HOMETOWN ONEONTA A-3

Cheering OUT & Swearing IN!

The state senator’s wife, Cindy, holds the Bible for the 17th time as James L. Seward, R-Milford, surrounded by his family, took the oath of office from County Judge Brian Burns, right, Tuesday, Jan. 1, in the Foothills Atrium. Others from left, are son Ryan and his wife, Kelly Ann; daughter Lauren, and granddaughters Vivian and Nora.

At Oneonta’s First Night, Greg Lee and other members of his Cosmic Karma Fire troupe, top, spin flames for onlookers outside Foothills’ Atrium.

At right, the Elite Dance Company’s Dejalei Champen and Emily Kane hoist Lillian Stalter up in the air.

With his namesake father by his side, county Sheriff Richard J. Devlin Jr. takes the oath from county Judge John Lambert, who was alspo swron in for a second 10-year term.

County Coroner David Delker, the Edmeston funeral director, kisses wife Karen after being sworn in for the first time.

Assemblyman Chris Tague, who represents the county’s four easternmost towns, acknowledges applause.

Otsego county’s new assemblyman, John Salka, RBrookfield, recites the pledge.

Rod Roberts, above, swings Cuca, his wife of 36 years, around the dance floor to “What a Wonderful World.” At right, tiger-faced Leah Puylara and Owen Meade, and his Aunt Lisa Foster, all from Milford, pause for a souvenir photo.

IAN AUSTIN Photos for HOMETOWN ONEONTA & The Freeman’s Journal

New Year’s celebration saLe! Now Through JaNuarY 14!

We give special thanks to the business & residential people in our region for making us the best flooring store in the area!

Check out our awesome selection of customized blinds and so much more!

remNaNT bLowouT! seLecT IN-sTocK remNaNTs For 17 types of in-stock select and better hardwoods seLecT IN-sTocK TILe includes Free in-stock grout with every order!

99 $ sq ft 4 $ .79 and up $

Family Owned and Operated

61 South Main Street, Oneonta 607-353-7433

Perspectives

THURSDAY, january 3, 2019

A-4 THE FREEMAN’S JOURNAL EDITORIAL

Upstate Looms Small On Governor’s Agenda G ‘L aining control of the state Senate, Governor Cuomo’s party can do anything it wants to – anything it can agree on, that is – in Albany.

So why wouldn’t our energetic chief executive have issued a plan for the first 100 days, which he did in the 20-point “Justice Agenda” he unveiled in an address to VIPs at Albany’s Rockefeller Institute Dec. 17?

It contains many worthy points, many of them over-

et this agenda be New York’s Declaration of Independence. We declare independence from this federal government’s policies. We disconnect from the nationalism, and the racism, and the chaos, and the xenophobia, and the misogyny, and the discrimination, and the dissembling of this Washington administration. We proclaim our Federal Government’s policy not only regressive, not only repugnant to New York values, we declare it un-American.

Let us pass this ambitious progressive agenda as New York’s restoration of true democracy, restoring fairness, progress and pride.”

GOV. ANDREW CUOMO • Unveiling His ‘Justice Agenda’ Dec. 17 at The Roosevelt Institute, Albany

due, and the governor – if he is indeed planning a run for president in 2020 – on each point draws a stark

contrast between his administration on the Hudson and the Trump Administration on the Potomac.

One noteworthy lapse, however, is the lack of any specific mention of or strategy for Upstate, which

increasingly seems under duress and headed for more of the same in 2019. Happy New Year!

• In years past, Governor Cuomo was bullish on Upstate, although corruption allegations and, now, convictions have dimmed the promising Buffalo Billion and the nanotech expansion up the Mohawk Valley.

Still, Cuomo’s 10 economic development councils – Otsego County is included in the Mohawk Valley’s – were an early innovation, having 10 districts compete Please See EDITORIAL, A5

GOVERNOR’S 20-POINT ‘JUSTICE AGENDA’

On Spending, Pot, LGBTQ Rights, Cuomo Charts Path Editor’s Note: With Democrats taking control of the state Senate Jan. 1, 2019, Governor Cuomo’s party now controls the state Legislature and his office for the first time in years, prompting him not to wait of the traditional State of the State message, but to issue a first-100-days “Justice Agenda,” a call to action for the state’s Democrats. Here are the 20 points: ►Ensure a Progressive Tax System, maintaining millionaire’s tax, permanently capping property-tax increases at 2 percent. ►Cut Middle-Class Taxes while Fighting to repeal SALT, the federal limits on state and local deductions. ►Protect Quality, Affordable Health Care by ensuring the health exchange and coverage of pre-existing conditions will be protected at state level. ►Codify Reproductive Rights by passing the Reproductive Health Act and the Comprehensive Contraceptive Coverage Act within 30 days to protect Roe v. Wade protections.

From the Governor’s Office

Governor Cuomo outlines the 20 points in his “Justice Agenda” for the first 100 days of Democratic control Dec. 17 at the Roosevelt Institute in Albany.

►Enshrine Gender Equality into Law, by passing Equal Rights Amendment to add sex as a protected class. ►Combat Gun Violence, by passing bump-stock ban, extending waiting period to buy a gun from three to 10 days.

►Expand $150 Billion Infrastructure Plan, adding $50 billion for new airports, bridges, train stations across state. ►Ease Traffic in NYC Business District by overhauling Mass Transit Authority. ►Ensure Education Equity by

LETTERS

OUNDED 1808 BY

O M C O PE

•F

IA

R

IN

DG

E WIL

Otsego County’s Newspaper

own generous raise in a halfmillion-dollar management salary reset. Some downplay the financial impact, but the county board raise alone will cost taxpayers about $84,000 per two-year term.

Some representatives expressed reservations but, in the end, it was nearly unanimous. The salary package originated in the Administration Committee where

JU

To the Editor: Have you ever decided your own salary for the coming year? If so, did you opt to use another person’s money to give yourself a nearly 30-percent raise?

Unlikely. Many of us would consider that unethical and shocking.

The Otsego County Board of Representatives recently did just that, including their

For 210 Years

L

James C. Kevlin Editor & Publisher

the legislator raises were initially included with those of the department heads.

After lengthy discussion, we decoupled them, creating two separate resolutions.

The department head raises were voted out of committee unanimously, but the county board raises were approved along party lines, with Republicans voting for their own raises and Democrats dissenting.

For unknown reasons, these were repackaged into one resolution for the county board meeting where I moved to amend the resolution to remove the raises Please See STAMMEL, B6

A New Year’s Poem

By DOREY MUNCH, Oneonta

T

he closing of the old year, The dawning of the new Have brought me to my cupboard Armed with firm resolve To rummage through the shelves within And root out those inhabitants Destined for the garbage bin.

What a sorry lot it is It pains me to disclose, For in enumerating, My faults I must expose.

Here’s leftover grievances All dried up in the box, There’s a little bottled rage Fizzled flat with age.

And over here, what’s this I see Moldering in the corner?

A heap of judgments made in haste

Tara Barnwell

That time has swiftly laid to waste.

And here, up front, in easy reach For self-commiserating: Old hurts, indignities and slights – Spices that have lost their bite.

Next, what’s this my hand has touched, Secreted on highest shelf?

A treasured grudge tucked away, Keeping for another day.

Away with all that is here stored, Unholy accumulation!

How good, how cleansing for the soul To have these sins retired.

But not so fast – let’s not be rash, For who would be offended Or think me less than thrifty if I put back on the shelf a few Whose dates have not expired?

Advertising Director & General Manager

From The Heart Of Ohio

Libby Cudmore

Not So Wild In The Heart

Managing Editor

Amanda E. Willsey Business Manager

Thom Rhodes Advertising Consultant

Larissa Ryan Office Manager/Circulation Ian Austin Photographer

Kathleen Peters • Graphics & Production

►Protect Public Sector Unions, by expanding protections for public sector labor unions at the local level, and to ensure workers have labor rights in the gig economy. ►Keep Housing Affordable, by reforming rent regulations, including ending vacancy decontrol, repealing preferential rent and limiting capital improvement charges to protect affordable housing and respect tenants’ rights. ►Pass the Child Victims Act, to ensure those who abuse our children are accountable criminally and civilly. ►Protect LGBTQ Rights, by codify the Gender Expression Non-Discrimination Act into state law and end conversion therapy. ►Legalize Adult Use of Recreational Marijuana, ending the disproportionate criminalization of one race over another by regulating, legalizing and taxing adult use of recreational marijuana. ►Ensure Fairness in the Criminal Justice System, by ending cash bail and enacting speedy trial and discovery reforms.

POEM TO EDITOR

What About Health, Retirement Benefits?

increasing funding for poor schools.

(A coalition of public educations is seeking a $2 billion increase) ►Pass a Dream Act, to ensure a higher education system that opens the door of opportunity to everyone. ►Launch the Green New Deal, to make New York’s electricity 100-percent carbon-neutral by 2040 and put state on path to eliminating carbon footprint. ►Ensure Clean, Safe Drinking Water for All, by investing in our water infrastructure and clean our water for our children and our children’s children. ►Improve Our Democracy, by enabling voting by mail, early voting, same-day and automatic voter registration, synchronizing federal and state elections, and make ►Election Day a state holiday to ensure as much participation as possible. ►Increase Trust in the Democratic System, by closing the LLC loophole, banning corporate campaign contributions, overhaul our campaign finance system and ending outside income for lawmakers.

Judith Bartow Billing

Tom Heitz Consultant

IN MEMORIAM: Mary Joan Kevlin, Co-Publisher, 2006-17 OFFICIAL NEWSPAPER FOR Otsego County • Village of Milford • Town of Middlefield Cooperstown Central School District Subscriptions Rates: Otsego County, $48 a year. All other areas, $65 a year.

First Class Subscription, $130 a year.

Published Thursdays by Iron String Press, Inc. 21 Railroad Ave., Cooperstown NY 13326 Telephone: (607) 547-6103. Fax: (607) 547-6080.

E-mail: info@allotsego.com • www.allotsego.com Contents © Iron String Press, Inc.

A

lthough we do not normally make any New Year resolutions, we must admit that we did this year, as there are times in life when we tend not to make the best choices, leaving us needing to make some changes.

And such seems to be the case when we chose the name “From the Wilds of Ohio” for our current writings. Since doing so, we have discovered there is actually a place in Cumberland, Ohio, which is called “The Wilds.”

From their website we learned that “The Wilds is a private, non-profit conservation center located on nearly 10,000 acres of reclaimed mine land in rural southeastern Ohio. It was cre-

ated as the conservation center of the future by a group of civic leaders, political leaders and zoo professionals who believed that a serious scientific approach CATHERINE was required to LAKE find solutions to ELLSWORTH environmental concerns.”

We understand, from those who have visited The Wilds, that it is well worth the trip.

•

As a result of what we have learned, we decided, for our New Year resolution, we should choose a different name under which to write. And we thought perhaps “From the Heart of Ohio” might work.

Unfortunately, that moniker is claimed by Centerburg, a village of 1,773 people located in Knox County, Ohio. It must be noted that Centerburg is the geographical center of Ohio and thus its claim to the heart of the state is most appropriate.

However, given Centerburg’s proximity to Mount Vernon, which is about 20 miles northeast of Centerburg and in the same county, we thought we Please See COLUMN, A5

AllOTSEGO.com

E-MAIL LETTERS TO EDITOR TO info@

THURSDAY, january 3, 2019

THE FREEMAN’S JOURNAL A-5

BOUND VOLUMES Compiled by Tom Heitz and SHARON STUART, with resources courtesy of The Fenimore Art Museum Research Library

200 YEARS AGO

Lost at the last annual cattle show and fair at Cooperstown, a Pocket Book, containing eight dollars in bills; one note of hand against Sylvanus Campbell for eight dollars and fifty cents, dated about two years ago; three notes against E. Cumpston, at Schoharie, of different dates; and two receipts against William Scott, of Oxford. Whoever will return said Pocket Book and the contents, shall be handsomely rewarded by the subscriber. Judah Waters, Jun. Turnpike in Otsego – An application will be made to the Legislature at the next Session for a law authorizing the building of a Turnpike Road from the second great western Turnpike in the Town of Edmeston at or near Martin Lee’s dwelling house in the county of Otsego, through Burlington, Exeter, Plainfield, and Richfield, in the most proper place to intersect the Hamilton and Skeneateles turnpike at or near Jeremiah Meacham’s in Richfield.

January 4, 1819

125 YEARS AGO

150 YEARS AGO

The Indians – A distinguished Army officer who has become acquainted by actual service with the character, temper and necessities of the Indian tribes, says in a private letter: “The military do not want charge of the Indians, but it is a necessity that they should have it if the Indians are to be saved from extermination. The settlers will attend to that in time if matters rest where they are. The Indians must be protected from the white man and the whites must also be protected from the Indian. Only troops can perform such service, and to do it well they must not be embarrassed or controlled by a Bureau under a different head, whose ideas work through entirely different channels from those of the military.” These are very sensible views, but they are not likely to find favor with the Agents, Superintendents and other appointees of the Indian Bureau – nor with certain Senators in Congress said to be in league with these fellows.

January 1, 1869

Otsego Lake went into the deep-freeze Christmas night, and by Thursday morning its surface was completely covered with ice. December 26 is the earliest closing date for the lake in 13 years. The wind died down late Christmas afternoon and during the night the temperature plunged to a frigid 25 below zero in Springfield at the northern end of the lake and to 14 below at the weather station in Cooperstown. The lake was ice-bound for 94 days a year ago. It opened on April 5.

January 1, 1969

25 YEARS AGO

In action at Bursey Gymnasium on December 28 and 29, the CCS Redskins won the Booster Club Boys’ Basketball Tourney for the fifth time in twelve years with a hard January 4, 1894 fought 58-51 win over the Yellowjackets of Oneonta. It was junior Justin Smith’s defensive block of a Quame Patterson shot that turned back a spirited Oneonta rally in the closing seconds of the fourth quarter. As Patterson penetrated the Before the war and up until the word was passed along Redskins’ zone and went up for a 15-foot jumper that would that Uncle Sam had selected him to chase the Kaiser, Tim have knotted the score at 53-all with less than a minute O’Connor was a printer in the Office of The Freeman’s remaining, the 6’2” Smith rose to the occasion and stuffed Journal, where his honesty of purpose, coupled with a rare the 5’ 11” guard’s shot cleanly. quality of keen Irish wit endeared him to his fellow workJanuary 4, 1994 ers. He changed the printer’s apron for the khaki last spring and in due time went across. He went “over the top” four times without a scratch. He did, however, gain twenty pounds in weight and a lot of experience. He writes: “Dear Look at the folio line at the top of this page: Volume Mother, Now, it is all over, there will be no more ‘over the 200, No. 1. With this edition, The Freeman’s Journal top’ and ‘at them boys,’ no more shells or machine gun marks the beginning of its 200th year as chronicler of bullets to duck – and to think I came through it all without a Cooperstown in the making. Very few newspapers in the scratch – but I had a lot of narrow escapes. But a miss is as U.S. have made it so far. For two centuries, this newspaper good as a mile. I have been ‘over the top’ four times in all has been Cooperstown’s companion, creating a record of and I also took part in that last big famous American push, our common life, some of it statistical – births, deaths, the just before the Germans gave up.” annual date of Otsego Lake’s freezing – some of it high January 1, 1919 drama, much of it of high literary merit.

January 4, 2008

100 YEARS AGO

10 YEARS AGO

Still 29 – And Still Wild?

just how we might stop such COLUMN/From A4 unwanted mailings. We were might be able to make the not particularly successful claim that we are writing if in New York, and we rather not exactly from the “Heart doubt we will be any more of Ohio,” at least from very successful in Ohio. nearby the “Heart of Ohio.”

• So, until someone comWe have also plains, we think discovered, we shall plan to much to our continue to do so. horror, that it is We also hasten not possible to to note that we avoid birthdays have, at a very in Ohio any early date, sucmore than it cessfully fulfilled was possible to our resolution for do so in New the year.

York. Our natal And while we day seemed to think it is safe to arrive out here say that we have Open the card: without any escaped to what It reads, “You’re welcome.” trouble at all. seems to be a And while somewhat better climate, we have discovered we did grudgingly mange to celebrate our birthday, that moving does not eliminate several things which we we were most delighted that the Ohio Ellsworths were had hoped to avoid in Ohio. able to find at the Kenyon • College Bookstore, which is The first is the onslaught of catalogs and solicitations. famous for its selection of greeting cards, one that we In fact, we honestly think they have gotten worse. We thought really said it all. On have received catalogs from the front it read “Happy 29th Again,” while inside it said companies from which we “You’re Welcome.” have never heard before.

For many years now, we And they all seem inclined to inform us that if we don’t have turned 29 again. And so we were most pleased that order sometime from them, in Ohio we received a card we will not be receiving another such catalog. How- which is in keeping with our thinking. And we hasten to ever, we suspect we shall point out that the card will not be that fortunate. work for years to come.

As for the solicitations, We must say, as 2018 we find them somewhat eashas drawn to a close, we ier to ignore for the simple are somewhat stunned to fact that they are easier to realize that we have been recycle. However, that was in Ohio for four months. It not true when the Winter 2018 edition of Giving Mat- seems like we have just left Cooperstown most recently. ters, the Spectrum Health But that is not the case. So, Foundation and Helen as the time flies by, we find DeVos Children’s Hospital Foundation Magazine, found ourselves in Ohio sending best wishes to all for a its way into our mailbox. happy, and healthy, 2019.

And while we readily admit we did make a donaPLEASE NOTE: Mail tion to this organization in comments to 125 Colonial memory of a cousin, we Woods Drive, Mt. Vernon, certainly did not expect to OH 43050, call receive such a weighty tome 740-993-0603 or e-mail in return. However, we are cellsworth47@icloud.com. completely clueless as to

The casual peace-time connotation of the phrase “Happy New Year,” is entirely out of focus at the beginning of the year 1944 with the armies of the United States and her Allies arrayed on or behind the lines of a dozen fighting fronts about the world. To the whole world the phrase, above everything else, means the coming of the end of the war in Europe at least in the next twelve months. Think of the thousands of our own sons, brothers, husbands, daughters and sisters, now serving in Italy, North Africa and England, and also in the Pacific, and what it will mean to them when they know that Hitler has been defeated and that that phase of the war is ended. The year has opened with assurances from many high quarters that just that will take place in 1944. Who has the heart to let them down? May it be a Happy New Year!

January 5, 1944

50 YEARS AGO

175 YEARS AGO

“Time and Tide wait for no man” – Another year has made us all older, if not better, than we were. And, in entering upon a new one, it is fitting that gratitude should fill our hearts for comforts enjoyed and blessings received. With such a feeling, and without ill will toward any of the human family, we tender to our readers the compliments of the season, wishing them collectively and individually prosperity and happiness.

James L. Edson of Milford, is requested to call at this office and take away some Theatre bills he caused to be printed about three months since, or something may be said and done about the transaction, not much to his credit.

The robber of the trunk from Pomeroy & Co. has not yet been discovered. But it is stated that there is some clue which will lead to a discovery.

January 1, 1844

75 YEARS AGO

B

‘Populism’ Isn’t A Dirty Word, It’s As American As Apple Pie

ack in 2008, at the time of the Populists object to the status quo, financial crisis, I published a to being ruled by elites, to what they book about the history of popu- see as a rogue establishment, whether lism called “Fixing the System: A His- left-leaning or right-leaning, that’s tory of Populism, Ancient & Modern.” no longer accountable to the general It didn’t make me famous, but it did public. aim to understand the rising political American populism has a rich if phenomenon of populism – something often forgotten history. Nineteenthwhich since has morphed into a global century American populists were not tidal wave. socialists, but small-scale Since 2016, we’ve had an capitalists. They were farmexplosion of political upheavers, artisans, and professionals around the world – all als. Private enterprise was widely described as populist: central to their values. The the Brexit vote in Britain, ideal was to own your own Trump’s election, and the business, not to work for a rise of separatist and nationcorporation. alist parties in Europe and Populists fought to keep beyond. We can also include private enterprise widely disthe “yellow vests” in France tributed among many small, ADRIAN and movements in places like KUZMINSKI independent producers, and Brazil, Venezuela, Mexico, to resist the emergence of and the Philippines. dominating monopolies.

Populism is easily misunderstood. It In mainstream American media can be found on both the left and right today, however, “populism” is mostly a of the political spectrum. It’s not about dirty word. The media paints a pichow liberal or conservative you are. ture of populists as angry malcontents It’s about the failure of the system to responding to their problems out of provide economic and social security emotion rather than reason. for a large part of the population.

They are said to be easily seduced

The Freeman’s Journal

Our columnist was prescient: Adrian Kuzminski’s 2008 study of populism, “Fixing the System,” foreshadowed Bernie Sanders’ and Donald Trump’s populism by eight years.

by demagogues, like Trump, who play on their fears rather than their hopes, Please See KUZMINSKI, B6

EDITORIAL: After ‘Justice Agenda,’ ‘Progress Agenda’ EDITORIAL/From A4 against each other for economic-development funding – may be the best ideas win!

And that continues to pay dividends.

Just the other day the CFA round (for Comprehensive Funding Application grants) that rejected a gas decompression station at Pony Farm also approved $950,000 for Andela Glass to build a commerce park in Richfield Springs and $437,000 for the Red Shed Brewery, across Route 33 from Ommegang.

The Fenimore Art Museum, among other things, got $135,000 to host a Rock and Roll Hall of Fame photo exhibit this summer, and the Hall of Fame got $300,000 for the “Nine Top Artifacts of Your Favorite Team” promotion. This, of course, helps tourism, an anchor for everything else in Otsego County.

•

So we’re by no means ignored.

Still, it’s been much explored – in Time magazine, the New York Times and, this past weekend, The Wall Street Journal – that Upstate New York is flat or declining, (although it shouldn’t be.)

Governor Cuomo “blamed cold weather for the state’s population exodus, but last year frigid New Hampshire with no income tax attracted 3,900 newcomers,” the Journal opined. Federal limits on property-tax deductions may drive affluent people elsewhere, it added. “Immigration flows into New York City mask the economic debacle” – economic debacle, wow – “of Upstate.”

The Times’ “The Hard Truths of Trying to ‘Save’ the Rural Economy,” published Dec. 14, has been much tut-tutted about around here, but it lumped Upstate with Nebraska – two different animals.

The reality is Upstate may be flagging, but, with Cooperstown as

a magnet and Oneonta on the make, Otsego County doesn’t have to.

A legislator in Pennsylvania’s Anthracite Region – now, that has challenges – used to often say, “We didn’t get into this mess overnight, and we aren’t going to get out of it overnight.”

That’s certainly true here, too.

Still, Governor Cuomo needs a 20point agenda for the second 100 days.

Once the party faithful’s hot buttons are pushed via the “Justice Agenda,” we need a “Prosperity Agenda.”

Happily, underneath a patina of ideology, Cuomo is a results guy. With Amazon and Google planning transformative projects in New York City, it’s time for the governor to brush off the dust on his Upstate initiatives.

There’s much aspiration here. But we’re a far way from yesteryear’s Empire State. This governor can continue getting us back on the right track, if he chooses to.

THURSDAY-Friday, january 3-4, 2019

A-6 THE FREEMAN’S JOURNAL & HOMETOWN ONEONTA

4914 State Hwy 28 Cooperstown 607-547-5933 221 Main Street, Andes 845-676-3600

MLS#117678 $289,000 Spectacular Country Offering 55 surveyed acres w/2,700 sq ft, built in 2003. 1-floor living, insulated finished walk-out basement. Landscaped grounds.

Call Kathy Fistrowicz @ 607-267-2683 (cell)

MLS#117521 $78,000 Charming 3-BR, 1½-bath home on a dead-end street. Close to local shopping, school and I-88.

Call Nicole Posey @ 518-598-7919

MLS#119204 $79,500 3-Unit Apt Building in Great Location Between Oneonta/Cooperstown. 1 large 4-BR apt downstairs, 2 upstairs 1-BR apts. Includes shop, barn, parking.

Call Melissa Klein @ 518-705-9849 (cell)

MLS#118020 $239,000 Ranch home w/custom kitchen, private setting. 2+ acres, close to Oneonta, Sidney.

Call Carol Olsen @ 607-434-7436 (cell)

MLS#118491 $269,900 Lakefront “Bree ze Clift” Well kept year-round cottage, 62' Canadarago lake frontage, 2-car garage, central air, 2 BRs, 1 bath, walk-up attic, second bath.

Call George (ROD) Sluyter @ 315-520-6512 (cell)

lis NE tiN W g!

www.howardhanna.com

MLS#115766 $185,000 Sun Shelter Technology Private driveway on 65 acres in Delhi. 4-BR, 2-bath, 1,900 sq ft home w/front and rear 4decks. wait !is close to I-88. Large Spacious BR, 2 Don’t bath house Call Ron Guichard @ 845-676-3600 (cell)Make your backyard, workshop/garage, small shed. appointment today. Priced to go this week!

Virtual Tour: www.RealEstateShows.com/708598

MLS#118563 $339,000 Catskilll Mountain Paradise! Selling for less than 80% of building costs! 3 hours from GWB. 32 acres, 2+ miles of trails w/spectacular mountaintop view!

Call or text Erin Moussa @ 607-435-1285 (cell)

lis NE tiN W g!

PR NE iC W E!

75 Market Street Oneonta 607-433-1020

MLS#114624 $59,900 MLS#113323 $279,000 1982 double-wide w/3 BRs, 2 baths and 1½ story, 2-car Beautiful Country 4½-bath home garage. New heatingHome system,6-BR, updated electrical, new w/in-law walls andapartment ceiling in 1 on BR.12.5 Newacres. ceiling2inoutbuildings master bath. and Potential income.

Callamazing Sharon P.valley Teatorviews. @ 607-267-2681 (cell) Call Rodney Campbell @ 315-868-0148 (Cell)

MLS#118958 $59,900 A Silver Lining Opportunity awaits the motivated investor.

2,500 sq ft, village conveniences, water and sewer, zoned commercial or residential.

Delhi location.

Call Ron Guichard @ 845-0676-3600 (office)

MLS#116301 $465,000 Prime Commercial Location! 3 Properties Bundled! Gifford’s Sporting Goods Store (and 3-4 BRs over the store) and 2 multi-family houses. All zoned mixed use. Highly traveled intersection.

Call/text Erin Moussa 607-435-1285 (cell)

PR NE iC W E!

MLS#116949 $159,500 Lovely country ranch home w/large 3-season porch and 2-car garage. Well maintained house sits on 3 manicured acres, plus 2-acre building lot.

Call Stephen Colwell @ 607-435-6542 (cell)

MLS#119170 $164,900 Beautiful Cape Cod Home Built in 2003 on almost 3 acres w/3 BRs, 1 bath, stunning kitchen w/granite counters, hickory cabinets, hardwood floors.

Call Carol Olsen @ 607-434-7436 (cell)

lis NE tiN W g!

PR NE iC W E!

PR NE iC W E!

MLS#118994 $425,000 Magnificent Log Home on 90 Acres ! 4 BRs, 2 full baths, 2 kitchens, large pond, indoor pool! Great hunting and hiking! Prime location near Cooperstown and Oneonta.

Call David K. Mattice @ 607-434-1647 (cell)

lis NE tiN W g!

AllOTSEGO.homes

MLS#115617 $138,000 Prime Location 4-BR, 1½-bath Oneonta home w/many upgrades including roof in 2010. Borders Wilber Park’s upper level.

Call David K. Mattice @ 607-434-1647 (cell)

MLS#117614 $349,000 Fabulous 3-story Colonial 3,884 sq ft on 6+ acres.

3 FPs in paneled cherry library, formal LR, master suite,1st-floor laundry, 2-car attached garage.

Call Katherine Fistrowicz @ 607-267-2683 (cell)

MLS#119271 $59,900 Beautiful Setting Nestled in the Catskills hamlet of Bloomville. Views of valley and river below. 3-BR, 2-bath home at an affordable price.

Call Adam Karns @ 607-244-9633 (cell)

Locally owned and operated Single and multi-family homes Commercial property and land

99 Main Street, Oneonta office 607.441.7312 fax 607.432.7580

Motivated Seller! Versatile property on 1½ acres. 104' x 44' Morton building w/electric, overhead doors, plus historic 4-story antique barn which has been refurbished and in excellent condition w/updated electric, insulated and heated office and workroom, oil furnace, wall-mounted propane heating unit. Lots of options for this great property on State Hwy w/easy access to I-88. Currently a profitable antique store (inventory could be included).

MLS#118212 $99,900

www.oneontarealty.com Lizabeth Rose, Broker/Owner

Beautiful Home in the Heart of Oneonta! Large 3-car garage w/storage loft, flat backyard, beautiful enclosed front porch. Inside on the first floor: kitchen w/newer appliances opens into large formal DR, office w/built-ins, full bath, den, and, to top it off, large LR w/fireplace, hardwood floors! Upstairs features include 4 BRs, large updated full bath, large laundry room w/sink, storage. Prime location, hardwood floors throughout and amazing layout!

MLS#118297 $139,900

Cricket Keto, Licensed Assoc. Broker Peter D. Clark, Consultant

HUBBELL’S REAL ESTATE 607-547-5740•607-547-6000 (fax) 157 Main Street Cooperstown, NY 13326

ASHLEY

E-Mail: info@hubbellsrealestate.com Web Site: www.hubbellsrealestate.com

29 Pioneer Street, Cooperstown · 607-547-4045 Patricia Bensen-Ashley – Licensed Real Estate Broker/Owner

Generous-sized Home

Fully Remodeled

(8541) Welcoming 3-BR, 2-bath home has rolling hills vista on 2.24 acres. Fresh interior paint, bay window, open design, open staircase, spacious LR, master bath, new eat-in kitchen, formal DR. Newer roof, 2 porches, newer windows. CV-S Schools.

Hubbell’s Exclusive—$165,000

Hidden Paradise

(8388) This delightful Cooperstown Village residence offers eat-in kitchen, hardwood flooring, back porch, 4 BRs, 1½ baths. Spaciously yours for a very comfortable lifestyle.

LR, parlor, home office, mud room, original natural woodwork. Hot water heat. Cooperstown Schools.

Hubbell’s Exclusive—$275,000

John Mitchell Real Estate

216 Main Street, Cooperstown • 607-547-8551 • 607-547-1029 (fax) www.johnmitchellrealestate.com • info@johnmitchellrealestate.com

Let Us Take You Home Dave LaDuke, Broker 607-435-2405

Laura Coleman 607-437-4881

Mike Winslow, Broker 607-435-0183

Madeline K. Woerner Jane McCoy 607-434-3697 607-232-3442

Kristen Bellois 607-282-2251

REALTY

CONNOR

Debbie Watkins-Parker 914-489-3523

Every week someone decides to sell a house.

Every week someone decides to buy a house.

BE THERE WHEN THEY MAKE THE DECISION!

(8519) Remodeled 3-BR, 2-bath Colonial on 11.98 acres includes formal DR, master BR w/beamed cathedral ceiling, 3-car garage, den, newer windows, oak flooring, tile baths, newer eat-in kitchen w/quartz counters, large barn. CV-S Schools.

Hubbell’s Exclusive—$275,000

BUY • SELL • RENT Also specializing in Property Management

Rob Lee Licensed Real Estate Salesperson 607-434-5177 roblee1943@gmail.com

New Country Listing—On quiet country road, sitting on ±17 acres, this 3-BR, 2-bath home is easy maintenance w/steel roof and siding. Perfect second or year-round home w/±1,200 sq ft, pine walls, tile floors, lots of closets. Kitchen off great room, systems room/laundry. Electric heat or woodstove. Lots of light, custom iron grates over windows and doors. 3-bay garage has high ceiling, electric door openers. Light woods, views across the valley. Land slightly slopes southeast, perfect for hops or hemp. Open field and woods at boundaries. Cooperstown School District. Just outside Middlefield Center. Easy drive to Cooperstown or Route 20.

Offered Exclusively by Ashley-Connor Realty $225,000 Visit us on the Web at www.ashleyconnorrealty.com Contact us at info@ashleyconnorrealty.com

For Appointment: Patricia Bensen-Ashley, Broker/Owner, 607-437-1149 Jack Foster, Sales Agent, 607-547-5304 • Donna Skinner, Associate Broker, 607-287-4113 Chris Patterson, Associate Broker, 518-774-8175

Real estate agents in the know advertise in THE REgION’S lARgEST NEWSpApER REAl ESTATE SECTION. Call 607-547-6103 NOW!

AllOTSEGO.homes

All

OTSEGO.life

Dine

Sushi in · Take out · O Regul ar Rolrder Online l 50% off PAGE B-1

THURSDAY-FRIDAY, JANUARY 3-4, 2019

CAPTIVATED by

211 M

CAMERAS

ain Str eet · tokyooOneonta · 60 7neonta .com 431-9999 Fri-Sat: Mon-Thu: 11 11 am

Paulette Cotter pauses among hundreds of cameras in her Town of Milford home, part of her late husband’s collection. She estimates Alan, who collected and traded toys, cavern memorabilia and other antiques, bought and sold “thousands” of cameras over 45 years. Above is a stereopticon slide of the young couple.

am to 1 1

to pm · Su 10 pm n: Noo n

to 9 pm

HAPPENIN’ OTSEGO

THINGS TO DO Oneonta Octane’s Lloyd Johnson, dribbles past Binghamton Bulldog’s David Haye.

The Octane will play at SUNY on Sunday.

Basketball, Play, Movie, Or Burn Christmas Tree

R

Collector Lives On In Collection, Remains Of ‘Thousands’ Of Items

By JIM KEVLIN MILFORD CENTER

W

Japane se Cuis ine

hen the newlyweds arrived in Santa Barbara, Calif., in 1968 – he had enrolled in the Brooks Institute of Photography – there, in a window of a Main Street bank, was a “huge display” of multiple antique cameras.

Arriving on the West Coast in 1969, Alan bought a small camera like this one, then bought one camera a day for the next two years.

Alan Cotter sought out the collector – all these years later, wife Paulette remembers him only as “Kent” – and bought a miniature camera. For the next two years, “we collected a camera a day,” she said.

When he graduated from Brooks in 1969, “it was ridiculous, economy-wise. Grads were pumping gas; he didn’t want to do that,” said the wife.

Thus began a life of buying and Please See COTTER, B3

AllOTSEGO.life

Jim Kevlin/

ISD’S ROXANA HULBURT STEPS UP

No, they’re not a rock band, but board President Roxana Hurlburt and Director Bill Youngs are the new duo that will be leading Foothills Performing Arts Center into the new year.

With Foothills Fortunes Rising, New President At Board’s Helm

By JIM KEVLIN ONEONTA

I AllOTSEGO.life

Jim Kevlin/

n 2017, Foothills Performing Arts Center hosted 271 events. In the year just ended, that rose to 321, an 18 percent increase.

In 2017, 18,983 fans walked through Foothills’ doors. In 2018, that rose to 28,128, just shy of a 50-percent increase.

“There’s something for everyone,” Roxana Hurlburt explains cheerfully.

The vice president of ISD, the tech consulting firm, Hurlburt became

‘T

here’s something for everyone.”

ROXANA HURLBURT Foothills’ new president

president of the Foothills board Jan. 1, succeeding Johna Peachin, who is stepping back to board treasurer.

On the one hand, there are Metropolitan Opera simulcasts; (Bizet’s “Carmen” is coming up Feb. 2.)

On the other hand, Roxana reported, there’s Thompson Square, the husPlease See FOOTHILLS, B3

THE FREEMAN’S JOURNAL • HOMETOWN ONEONTA

ing in the New Year in a high-octane way as Oneonta’s own professional basketball team, the Oneonta Octane, takes on the Syracuse Nationals in their first home game of the year. 6 p.m. Sunday, Jan. 6, Chase Gym, SUNY Oneonta. Info, LIBBY (607) 432-0001.

CUDMORE • Say goodbye to that old Christmas tree and enjoy a delicious drink with Brewery Ommegang’s Snap Crackle Hop! Throw your tree on the pyre, then enjoy a beer or some hot chocolate around the crackling fire. Noon – 3 p.m. Saturday, Jan. 5, Brewery Ommegang, 656 Co. Hwy. 33, Cooperstown. (607) 544-1800.

• Here’s your chance to take the stage as Orpheus Theatre holds an open casting call for all roles in the classic musical “Damn Yankees.” Wear comfortable clothing, be prepared to dance/sing/read. 7 p.m. Friday, Jan. 4, 2 p.m. Saturday, Jan. 5, Foothills Performing Arts Center, Oneonta.

(607) 432-1800.

• Discrimination Matters film series presents “Loving,” about the story of Richard and Mildred Loving, who challenged and won the Supreme Court case against interracial marriage. Open discussion to follow. Free, open to public. Light snacks available, or bring your own. 7 p.m. Friday, Jan. 4, Waterfront Room, Hunt College Union, SUNY Oneonta.

• Cooperstown Concert series features Caitlin Canty performing folk, blues, country music. 7:30 p.m. Saturday, Jan. 5, The Otesaga, Cooperstown. (607) 547-1812 • COMING UP: The Cabin Fever Film Series kicks off next weekend with “Phantom Thread”6:30 p.m.

Friday, Jan. 11, The Fenimore Art Museum, Cooperstown. (607) 547-1400.

AllOTSEGO.com, WHERE OTSEGO COUNTY GOES FOR BREAKING NEWS

VISIT www.

Like a good Neighbor, StAte FArM iS there. ® with…

Melissa Manikas, Agent Cooperstown, NY 13326 607-547-2886

B-2

AllOTSEGO.life Friday, January 4

FILM SERIES – 7 p.m. Discrimination Matters presents “Loving,” the story of Richard & Mildred Loving. Discussion follows. Free, open to public.

Snacks available, or bring your own. Waterfront Room, Hunt College Union, SUNY Oneonta.

AUDITIONS – 7 p.m. Open call for all roles in musical “Damn Yankees” presented

by Orpheus Theater. Wear comfortable clothing, be prepared to dance/sing/read.

Foothills Performing Arts Center, Oneonta. 607-432-1800.

FILM SCREENING – 7 p.m. Fun family outing to see “Wreck It Ralph 2.” Cost, $5/adult. Children under 17 enter free. Wieting Theater, 168 Main St., Worcester.

CONTRADANCE – 7:30 p.m. Dance featuring music

by Eleemosynary, Casey

THURSDAY-Friday, JANUARY 3-4, 2019 Mullaney calling. Arrive at 7:15 for introduction to steps.

Admission, $8/adult. First Presbyterian Church, 25 Church St., Cooperstown.

607-547-8164.

Saturday, January 5

SNAP CRACKLE HOP – Noon - 3 p.m. Bring tree for traditional Christmas Tree pyre, enjoy beers, hot cocoa, more. Brewery Ommegang, 656 Co. Hwy. 33, Cooperstown. 607-544-1800.

AUDITIONS – 2 p.m. Open call for all roles in musical “Damn Yankees.” See Friday Listing.

FILM SCREENING – 7 p.m. Fun family outing to see “Wreck It Ralph 2.” See Friday Listing.

CONCERT SERIES – 7:30 p.m. Cooperstown Concert series features Caitlin Canty performing folk, blues, country music. The Otesaga,

Cooperstown. 607-547-1812.

Sunday, January 6

FILM SCREENING – 2 p.m.

Fun family outing this holiday season to see “Wreck It Ralph 2.” See Friday Listing.

BASKETBALL – 6 p.m.

Cheer on Oneonta Octane basketball team at first home game of 2019. SUNY Oneonta. 607-432-0001.

Monday, January 7

STITCHERS GROUP – 1 - 2 p.m. Bring knit, crochet, other stitching project to work in company of knowledgeable peers. Harris Memorial Library, 334 Main St., Otego.

607-988-6661.

Wednesday, January 9

DEADLINE – Last day to register for Webinar “Manage Risk in Your Agritourism Business!” 5 sessions

All OTSEGO. dining & entertainment

OTSEGO COUNTY

A COMPLETE GUIDE TO WHAT’S FUN AROUND HERE send calendar items to info@allotsego

.com

covering legal marketing, human resource, financial, weather/production. Free, materials, snacks, beverages provided. Cornell Cooperative Extension, 123 Lake St., Cooperstown. 518-234-4303 ext. 111.

BUSINESS SEMINAR – 8 - 10 a.m. NYS Mandated Anti-Harassment Policies and Sexual Harassment Training with County Chamber member Maria N. Smirensky. This training is for Owners/Managers to learn best practices for your individual company.

Open to public. Otsego County Chamber, 5th floor, 189 Main St., Oneonta. 607-267-4010.

BAKE SALE – 3 - 4 p.m.

Support class of 2020. PAC Milford Central School, 42 W. Main St., Milford. 607-2867721.

WRITING CLUB – 4:15 p.m.

Join local writers to improve your craft, share ideas/progress in supportive environment. All ages/abilities welcome. Harris Memorial Library, 334 Main St., Otego.

607-988-6661.

CHESS MEETING – 6 - 11 p.m. Weekly meeting welcomes players of all levels. No fees. Cafeteria, College Union, SUNY Oneonta. Call Dom at 607-484-7240.

CLUB MEETING – 7 p.m.

Sportsmans club meets to discuss business, upcoming events. Open to public.

Oneonta Sportsmans Club, 251 Rod & Gun Club Rd., Oneonta. 607-433-0515.

Thursday, January 10

PUBLIC SPEAKING – 6:15 p.m. Practice your public speaking with the Toastmasters. The Green Earth, 4 Market St., Oneonta. Visit oneonta.toastmastersclubs. org GAME NIGHT – 6:30 - 10 p.m. Play ongoing fantasy game Dungeons & Dragons.

Newcomers welcome. Free, Roxbury Arts Center, 5025 Vega Mountain Road, Roxbury. 607-326-7908.

Friday, January 11

SCRAPBOOKING – 9 a.m.

- 5 p.m. Souperbowl/Resolutions event. Get organized, start new year off right! Elm Park Methodist Church, 401 Chestnut St., Oneonta. 607432-6552.

FUNDRAISER – 6 p.m.

Enjoy Cat Yoga with Lisa Brown and Susquehanna SPCA. All proceeds to Susquehanna SPCA. Suggested donation, $10. Bring your own mat. First Baptist Church, 21 Elm St., Cooperstown.

607-547-9371.

MOVIE NIGHT – 6 - 8 p.m.

Enjoy family movie night featuring “Ice Age.” Popcorn & drinks provided. Admission, $2. Harris Memorial Library, 334 Main St., Otego. 607988-6661.

FILM SCREENING – 6:30 p.m. Beat Cabin Fever with “Phantom Thread” (2017) about the love life of dressmaker Reynolds Woodcock.

Free with donation. The Fenimore Art Museum, Cooperstown. 607-547-1400.

CONTRADANCE – 7:30 -

• Bocca osteria • happy hour

Half Price Pizzas and BOGO On all hOuse drinks*

www.boccaosteria.com · 607-282-4031 5438 State Hwy 28 · Cooperstown, NY 13326

Every Friday 5 pm to 8 pm *Bar service only

new york pizzeria 2 large plain pizzas $25* Tax included! Toppings extra

75 Chestnut Street, Cooperstown · 607-547-2930 126 Main Street/ Rt 20, Richfield Springs · 315-858-0405 Not valid w/other offers • 1 coupon per person

10 p.m. Square Dance with Doubleday Dancers Western Square Dance Club of Cooperstown at Winter Dance. Caller, Ray Taylor. Cue, Elma Taylor. Admission, $5/ person. Cooperstown Elementary School. 607-547-8665.

Saturday, January 12

OPERA – 12:55 p.m. Live streaming “Adriana Lecouvreur” by Cilea. Foothills Performing Arts Center, Oneonta.

607-431-2080.

Sunday, January 13

WEDDING EXPO – Noon - 3 p.m. Find areas best DJs, bakers, caterers, health & fitness experts, venues, MORE. Find experts to make your special day perfect. Foothills Performing Arts Center, Oneonta.

607-431-2080.

SELF DEFENSE – 5 p.m.

Defense course for anyone looking to broaden handgun knowledge, be physically/ mentally prepared to defend themselves with it. Cost, $50/person. Oneonta Sportsman’s Club, 251 Rod & Gun Club Road, Oneonta.

607-433-0515.

BASKETBALL – 6 p.m.

Cheer on Oneonta Octane basketball team at home game. SUNY Oneonta. 607432-0001.

Monday, January 14

STITCHERS GROUP – 1 - 2 p.m. Bring knit, crochet, other stitching project to work in company of knowledgeable peers. Harris Memorial Library, 334 Main St., Otego.

607-988-6661.

PUBLIC SPEAKING – 5:30 p.m. Practice public speaking with the toastmasters. All welcome. The White House Building, The Fenimore Art Museum, Cooperstown. Call 607-547-1466 or e-mail b.fischer@fenimoreart.org.

Tuesday, January 15

KIDS MORNING MOVIE – 9:30 - 11:30 a.m. Bring the kids for fun morning movie “Nemo.” Harris Memorial Library, 334 Main St., Otego.

607-988-6661.

COMMUNITY PROGRAM – 2 p.m. The Gathering Place presents Selinda Brandon, wildlife biologist, presenting on the Eastern Coyote.

Refreshments to follow.

Woodside Hall, 1 Main St., Cooperstown. 607-547-0600 ext. 101.

Do what you Do and let our readers know about it!

Bands. ConCerts. arts. theatre.

Food. entertainment. Comedy. Films. musiC. Fashion. Fairs. Festivals. Plays. museums. exhiBits. danCe. sPorts.

Whatever!

Tell our readers what you’re up to!

Reach the most newspaper readers in Otsego County.

Call 607-547-6103 noW!

AllOTSEGO.

dining&entertainment

AllOTSEGO.life

THURSDAY-FRIDAY, JANUARY 3-4, 2019

B-3

Cotters Traded ‘Thousands’ Of Cameras, In 47 Years Together COTTER/From B1 selling cameras, Daguerreotype images, Stereopticon slides – you name it – even “magic lanterns,” like the Zoetrope, a pre-film animation device that provided exotic scenes and sights the general public wouldn’t have seen otherwise.

Based in Santa Barbara until 1984, when the couple moved to Morris, Alan would travel to collectors’ conferences on the East Coast, picking up choice examples en route and back.

During the 1970s, the couple produced three national camera-collector directories that sold for $8 apiece. “There were no computers, it was all by hand on a typewriter,” said Paulette, who was a teacher by day and typist by night.

She also produced “Reflecting On Photography, 1839-1902, The Cotter Collection,” with a Daguerreotype of Alan on the cover.

The photographer died young, having inhaled too many mercury fumes, the same thing that killed Louis Daguerre, the French inventor of the process, Paulette said.

Over a lifetime, the Cotters – Alan passed away in 2015 – bought and sold “thousands” of cameras and related items, said the wife.

When Wayne Wright, retired NYSHA library director, was putting together “Oneonta Photographers, 1850-1930” last summer for the Greater Oneonta Historical Society, he learned of Paulette’s collection.

On stopping by, “I was amazed,” he said.

He ended up borrowing a rare two-lens Stereopticon camera, the type used by Oneonta photographer William Meremess in the 1870s, to round out the exhibit. (Wright is installing three panels in the City Hall lobby this week.)

The Cotters both grew up on

that I dawned on him who I was.”

When she graduated two years ahead of him, they married.

After another year at Wheaton, they headed out to Brooks, and the collecting began. For two years in the late 1970s, Alan also curated the college’s photography museum.

“He was interested, he got me interested,” said Paulette. “He was the collector, but he always ran it past me.

It was something we did together.”

In the 1980s, with their two sons growing – Brady Cotter, now OHS track coach and Earth Science teacher, and Ben Cotter, the Southside chiropractor – the couple moved back east so the boys would know their grandparents and This is one of Paulette extended family. They bought a Cotter’s favorite photos house, sight unseen, in Morris. with her husband Alan.

There, they opened an antique store, but it was a block off the Long Island, 25 miles from each main road. So in the 1990s, they other – he in Babylon, she in Merbought an old Federal-style farmrick. But they met at a Baptist house right on Route 28 at Milford summer camp in Freehold when she Center, renovated it and built a shop was 14, he was 12. “We used to out front, increasing usable space play ping-pong together,” she said. from 2,200 to 3,700 square feet.

After high school, she headed off Today, photo equipment domito Wheaton College in Illinois. Two nates, but not exclusively, as Alan years later, who showed up but Alan. would swap cameras for other The two sang in the college choir tointriguing gether, but objects, “he didn’t including recognize a stuffed me. We lion from a all hung Boston muaround seum and together a stuffed after choir alligator to eat toprone atop a gether and cabinet. play pingHe also pong,” she dabbled rememin perhaps bered. “It 20 other wasn’t This miniature camera in the Cotters’ types of until collection includes instructions in collectibles, November Russian. KGB, maybe? from board

AllOTSEGO.life

Jim Kevlin/

In conducting the Cotters’ antique camera business, husband Alan wasn’t opposed to a swap. This one brought a lion, stuffed for a Boston museum at the turn of the 20th century, to a place amid the photographic equipment.

games, to toys, to souvenir plates of tourist-destination caverns like Howe’s in Schoharie County.

But cameras do abound, and much of the variety, Paulette attests, were developed for private detectives – and even spies. One camera was designed to attach to the photographer’s chest, with the lens fitting through a button hole, and activated by a switch in the photographer’s pants pocket.

Another camera looks like a tool box, with the lens camouflaged on its front face. “They were designed to look like other things,” Paulette said. Another hand-sized camera bears Russian markings; KGB standard-issue, perhaps?

Other cameras are on pivots, allowing a panoramic shot of, for instance, high school classes.

Sometimes you see the class wag twice – he ducked behind his class-

mates and appears on the right and left of the lineup.

Another pivot allows a 360-degree image.

And there are related items, such as a photographer’s brocade couch, where all sides fold down to allow variety in poses.

For his 30 years in Otsego County, Alan was also choir director at Oneonta’s Main Street Baptist Church. The son of a pastor, “he loved the Lord,” he wife explained.

Diagnosed with cancer in 2011 and given nine months to live, he battled the disease with homeopathic methods, surviving until March 29, 2015. Still, he certainly lives on amid his collection.

“He never found an end to collecting,” said Paulette, “because he always found something new – something he had never seen before.”

New Foothills President Brings Can-Do Attitude From Business Experience FOOTHILLS/From B1 band and wife combination that performed their country playlist to a full house this past Veterans Day. With George Wells, Townsquare Media’s former local GM, as president of Orpheus Theatre’s board, Oneonta’s cornerstone community theater troupe and Foothills have reconciled after a years-ago rift of long-forgotten origin.

Orpheus’ Starstruck Players will perform “Law & Order: Fairy Tale Unit,” Jan. 11, 12 and 13 in the upstairs theater, and recently designated Foothills home to its children’stheater arm.

Highlights of this past year

··

included the Power of Dance, based in New Jersey, organizing a contest for dancers from Oneonta’s local troupes.

Most of its events are in larger cities, from Albany to Cleveland and Columbus, Ohio.

And, of course, Amy Schumer, visiting Delaware County relatives, turned up one day and offered to test material from her summertime national tour at a Foothills benefit in May. The show sold out in a few hours, and raised $11,000, allowing Foothills to make a sizeable donation to Opportunities for Otsego’s women’s shelter.

Perennial events are going

FLOOR STORE

new under them!

GOT COLD FEET??? carpetPut some As low as

strong, too, said Hurlburt, pointing to the Shamrock Swing in March, where boys and their moms spending an evening dancing and eating pizza, the masculine counterpart to the Family Y’s annual Daddy-Daughter Dance at SUNY’s Hunt Union the month before.

The annual Taste of Foothills, where local restaurants highlight their specialties, followed by a comedy act, filled the 600-seat Bettiol Theatre for a performance for nationally hailed mentalist Craig Karges in October.

“It’s all positive down there,” said Hurlburt the other day in a double interview at ISD headquarters that included Bill Youngs, the Foothills director who has guided the day-to-day progress over the past three years.

Except for a stint in Troy,

where she and her husband, Jim, “childhood sweethearts,” lived while newlyweds, Roxana has lived most of her life in Otego. However, she took advantage of her time in the Capitol District to attended Hudson Valley Community College.

Returning to Greater Oneonta, she was assistant to Frank Isbell, then Fox Hospital president, before joining ISD 30 years ago and building the business with company president Ron Ranc.

Over the years, as sons Jim Jr. and Jesse were growing up – the Hurlburts also have two grandchildren, Cooper, 5, and Gunner, 8 – she was active in community groups such as the Cub and Boy scouts, Little League, and the Otego Volunteer Fire Department Ladies’ Auxiliary, as well as the Otsego Chamber and

Kim’s

1sq. ft.

$

Kut & Style NeWNEW LoCatioN, YOU...

NewNEW You,STYLE! New Style

Hundreds of styles to choose from, large selection of Wool, Sisal & Nylon. Patterned, braided and much more! Installation + padding as low as $2.11/sq ft.

Come on by & give us a try!

4316 County Hwy 11 Cooperstown 607-547-6038 krazytoms.com sales@krazytoms.com SinCe 1962

Open weekdays: 9 am to 5:30 pm Thursday: 9 am to 7 pm Saturday: 9 am to 4 pm Closed Sunday

Catskill Hospice boards.

She “grew up with” the Bettiol family, and entrepreneur Gene Bettiol, Southside Oneonta’s developer, encourage her to join the Foothills board a few years ago. (Bettiol had adopted the performing arts center after the death of his son, Gene Jr., one of the originators of the Foothills idea, along with promoter Peter Macris and others.)

While Gene Sr. passed away in December 2017, his wife Betty has continued to support the undertaking, most recently providing tables, chairs and linens for the Atrium, where weddings, dinners and social events are hosted.

The benefactor also provided chairs for the “black box” production room and the upstairs theater, which

Kevin Kurkowski

607-432-2022

22-26 Watkins Avenue, Oneonta Monday through Friday 8 am - 4:30 pm

Perms Wash, Cut & Style

6208 State Highway 28 • 547-7126 (On the Corner in Fly Creek)

…It’s comIng…

thrills Bill Youngs – previously, his staff of three, led by veteran Geoff Doyle, now office manager, had to ferry furniture around the sizeable complex as events required.

Hurlburt sees Foothills taking advantage of opportunities that will surface through the City of Oneonta’s DRI (the Downtown Revitalization Initiative), noting a recent $15,000 grant was used to hire Paperkite, the Cooperstown consultant, to develop a marketing strategy.

The city’s theater consultant, Webb Associates, envisions Foothills as eventually managing the historic Oneonta Theater, although what happens there remains to be determined.

Roxana emphasized Foothills plans to be as prudent with public money as it is with its own. City Hall had provided $20,000 to repaint the 10-year-old main building, but it was discovered that the current tannish color was mixed in with the cement in the original construction.

If the building were to be painted, it would only peel, requiring another $20,000 paint job in eight years.

Roxanna Hurlburt, then chairing Foothills’ facilities committee, gave City Hall its money back.

B-4 THE FREEMAN’S JOURNAL & HOMETOWN ONEONTA

Convenient Care Unit Opens

BASSETT/From A1 will be staffed by a combination of new and current staff shifting over to the department.

The unit will be open evenings and weekend, according to Karen Huxtable-Hooker, Public & Media Relations director. (The Oneonta and Herkimer units are open 8 a.m-7 p.m. weekdays and 9 a.m.-4 p.m. weekends.)

Dr. Mark Winther, Emergency & Trauma Services chief, said the unit will treat “urgent, non-life-threatening medical issues.”

“The way healthcare is evolving nationally has made the common practice of utilizing primary care and/or the emergency department for this inefficient and costly,” he said. “We hope Cooperstown Convenient Care will provide for this growing need.”

He expects the patients to come to the center with “sore throats, coughs, earaches, fevers, colds and flu, sprains and strains, vomiting, diarrhea, minor burns or rash.”

The new department will provide such services as

THURSDAY-FRIDAY, JANUARY 3-4, 2019

“X-rays, limited lab testing and minor procedures, such as stitches and acute wound care,” he said.

Huxtable said this new service has been under consideration for a few years while demand for the service was explored and space identified.

Echoing Winther, she said this service will provide nonemergency care for people who don’t have a primarycare doctor, or can’t get in right away to see the doctor.

It’s expected most insurances will cover the services, although she encouraged patients to make sure.

Local Women To March In D.C.

MARCH/From A1 “We’ve got children in America who spent Christmas in cages and abusive camps along our border,” said Pondolfino. “We have the March For Our Lives and #MeToo. “The Women’s March is one of many, but it encompasses a lot of issues, and they all intersect.”

This will be the local group’s second trip to D.C. for the march, starting with the inaugural march in 2016.

In 2018, Indivisible joined the march in New York City.

“We heard some great

speakers in New York City,” she said. “Someone spoke on disability, another spoke on #MeToo, and there was a wonderful Jewish woman who spoke. It was a good cross-section. The challenge is that so many issues are important.”

Speakers for the 2019 Women’s March have not yet been announced.

This year, the bus will board at 11 p.m. Friday, Jan. 18 and make stops in Sidney and Binghamton before driving overnight to D.C. Tickets are $80, and reservations are

being taken at BVIndivisible@gmail.com or (607) 267-0493 “We found a Waffle House two blocks from the National Mall that takes reservations!” said Pondolfino. “Or if you don’t want breakfast, you can go watch the sun rise over the monuments.”

The speakers will begin at 10 a.m., with the march itself beginning at 11 a.m. There will be activities throughout the afternoon. Or, Pondolfino said, participants are welcome to visit museums, which are free, before meeting at the bus at 6 p.m. to travel home.

LEGALS Legal

Legal nOtice

Notice of Formation of KOMEEKHA COTTAGE LLC. Arts. of Org. filed with Secy. of State of NY (SSNY) on 12/19/18.

Office location: Otsego County.

SSNY designated as agent of LLC upon whom process against it may be served. SSNY shall mail process to: The LLC, 9 Westridge Road, Cooperstown, NY 13326.

Purpose: any lawful activity.

6LegalFeb.7 Legal nOtice

Notice of Formation of WESTRIDGE COTTAGE LLC. Arts. of Org. filed with Secy. of State of NY (SSNY) on 12/19/18.

Office location: Otsego County.

SSNY designated as agent of LLC upon whom process against it may be served. SSNY shall mail process to: The LLC, 9 Westridge Road, Cooperstown, NY 13326.

Purpose: any lawful activity.

6LegalFeb.7 Legal nOtice

Notice of formation of ONEONTA AIRPORT PROPERTIES, LLC. Articles of Organization were filed with the NY Secretary of State on December 11, 2018.

The office of the LLC is to be located in Otsego County.

The Secretary of State has been designated as agent of the LLC upon whom process against it may be served. The Secretary of State shall mail a copy of any process against the LLC served upon it to: The LLC. 602 Bullville Road, Montgomery, NY 12549.

The purpose of the LLC is to engage in any lawful act.

6LegalFeb.7 Legal nOtice

Notice of Formation of Melody Village Investors LLC, Art. of Org. filed

Legal

with Sec’y of State (SSNY) on 11/26/18.

Office location: Otsego County.

SSNY designated as agent of LLC upon whom process against it may be served. SSNY shall mail copy of process to Reg. Agents, 90 State St., Ste. 700, #40, Albany, NY 12207.

Purpose: any lawful activities.

6LegalJan.31 Legal nOtice

Notice of Formation of Melody Village Manager LLC, Art. of Org. filed with Sec’y of State (SSNY) on 11/26/18.

Office location: Otsego County.

SSNY designated as agent of LLC upon whom process against it may be served. SSNY shall mail copy of process to Reg. Agents, 90 State St., Ste. 700, #40, Albany, NY 12207.

Purpose: any lawful activities.

6LegalJan.31 Legal nOtice

Notice of Formation of Melody Village Owner LLC, Art. of Org. filed with Sec’y of State (SSNY) on 11/26/18.

Office location: Otsego County.

SSNY designated as agent of LLC upon whom process against it may be served. SSNY shall mail copy of process to Reg. Agents, 90 State St., Ste. 700, #40, Albany, NY 12207.

Purpose: any lawful activities.

6LegalJan.31 Legal nOtice

Notice of formation of MDFARMEQ, LLC. Arts. of Org. filed with the SSNY on 12/12/18.

Office: Otsego County.

SSNY designated as agent of the LLC upon whom process against it may be served.

SSNY shall mail copy of process to the LLC, 807 County Highway 35, P.O. Box 155, Maryland, NY 12116.

Purpose: Any lawful purpose.

6LegalJan.24 Legal nOtice

Legal

Notice of Formation of a NY Limited Liability Company Name: OSTERHOUDT MECHANICAL LLC. Articles of Organization filing date with Secretary of State (SSNY) was 12 December 2018.

Office location: Otsego County.

SSNY has been designated as agent of LLC upon whom process against it may be served and SSNY shall mail copy of process to 5940 St Hwy 7, Oneonta, NY 13820.

Purpose is to engage in any and all business activities permitted under NYS laws.

6LegalJan.24 Legal nOtice

Notice of formation of Friends of the Trans Adirondack Route, LLC. Article of Organization filed with the Secretary of State of NY (SSNY) 5/21/13.

SSNY has been designated as agent upon whom process against it may be served.

Purpose of LLC: to engage in any lawful act or activity.

Street address of Principal Business location is 246 Southside Drive, Oneonta, NY 13820.

County of Principle Business is Otsego.

6LegalJan.24 Legal nOtice

Notice of formation of Sugarhouse Farms Limited Liability Company in Otsego County.

Articles of Org. filed with NY Secretary of State (NS) on December 4, 2018, NS is designated as agent upon whom process may be served, NS shall mail service of process (SOP) to 3 Michael Drive, Schenectady, NY 12303.

The purpose of Sugarhouse Farms LLC is to operate as a corporation legally and lawfully in the State of New York.

6LegalJan.24 Legal nOtice

Notice of formation of

Legal

B.C.E. HOME SERVICES, LLC Articles of Org. filed NY Sec. of State (SSNY) 12/12/2018.

Office in Otsego Co. SSNY desig. agent of LLC whom process may be served. SSNY shall mail process to 304 Main St., Schoharie, NY 12157, which is also the principal business location.

Purpose: Any lawful purpose.

6LegalJan.24 Legal nOtice

Notice of formation of

Legal

The Secretary of State has been designated as agent of the LLC upon whom process against it may be served. The Secretary of State shall mail a copy of any process against the LLC served upon it to: The LLC, 45-75 159th St., Flushing, NY, 11358.

The purpose of the LLC is to engage in any lawful act.

6LegalJan.10 Legal nOtice

Notice of Formation of a NY Limited Liability Company Name:

The Parish Paper, LLC.

SUMMIT GROVE BUILDERS LLC.

Filed with SSNY on 12/1/2018.

Office Otsego County.

SSNY designated as agent for process and shall mail to: 41 Ford Ave., Oneonta, NY 13820.

Purpose: Any lawful purpose.

6LegalJan.24

Articles of Organization filing date with Secretary of State (SSNY) was 13 November 2018.

Office location: Otsego County.

SSNY has been designated as agent of LLC upon whom process against it may be served and SSNY shall mail copy of process to 8211 St Hwy 80, Springfield Center, NY 13468.

Purpose is to engage in any and all business activities permitted under NYS laws.

6LegalJan.10

Legal nOtice

NOTICE OF FORMATION OF A DOMESTIC LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY (LLC) HUNT’S REAL ESTATE PROPERTIES LLC The Articles of Organization were filed with the New York State Secretary of State on October 29, 2018.

OFFICE LOCATION: Otsego County.

The Secretary of state is designated as Agent upon whom process against the LLC may be served. The Secretary of State shall mail a copy of any process against the LLC to 297 Shaw Brook rd, South New Berlin, NY 13843.

PURPOSE: To engage in any lawful act or activity.

6LegalJan.10 Legal nOtice Notice of formation of 61 CHURCH STREET, LLC. Articles of Organization were filed with the NY Secretary of state on November 2, 2018.

The office of the LLC is to be located in Otsego County.

Legal

Name: ANTHONY WAHL REAL ESTATE LLC. Articles of Organization filing date with Secretary of State (SSNY) was 27 November 2018.

Office location: Otsego County.

SSNY has been designated as agent of LLC upon whom process against it may be served and SSNY shall mail copy of process to 568 St Hwy 166, Cooperstown, NY 13326.

Purpose is to engage in any and all business activities permitted under NYS laws.

6LegalJan.10 Legal nOtice

Notice of Formation of Craft 174 LLC, Art. of Org. filed with SSNY on 9/20/18.

Off. loc.: Otsego Co. SSNY designated as agent upon whom process may be served & shall mail proc.: 174 Underwood Dr., Otego, NY 13825.

Purp.: any lawful purp.

6LegalJan.10 Legal nOtice

Legal nOtice

Notice of formation of

Notice of Formation of a NY Limited Liability Company

31 Pioneer Street, LLC

Name: ANTHONY WAHL PROPERTY LLC. Articles of Organization filing date with Secretary of State (SSNY) was 1 November 2018.

Office location: Otsego County.

SSNY has been designated as agent of LLC upon whom process against it may be served and SSNY shall mail copy of process to 568 St Hwy 166, Cooperstown, NY 13326.

Purpose is to engage in any and all business activities permitted under NYS laws.

6LegalJan.10 Legal nOtice

Notice of Formation of a NY Limited Liability Company

Filed 11/20/18 Office: Otsego Co. SSNY designated as agent for process & shall mail to: 31 Pioneer Street Suite 3, Cooperstown, NY 13326 Purpose: all lawful 6LegalJan.17 Legal nOtice

SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF OTSEGO INDEX NO. 1023/2014 REVERSE MORTGAGE SOLUTIONS, INC

Plaintiff, Plaintiff designates OTSEGO as the place of trial situs of the real property vs.

DANIEL CROWELL, OTSEGO COUNTY TREASURER, AS ADMINISTRATOR FOR THE ESTATE OF ROSEMARIE CHESLA; RONALD CHESLA,

Legal

AS HEIR TO THE ESTATE OF ROSEMARIE CHESLA; CHRISTOPHER CHESLA, AS HEIR TO THE ESTATE OF ROSEMARIE CHESLA; PAMELA CHESLA, AS HEIR AND DISTRIBUTEE TO THE ESTATE OF ROSEMARIE CHESLA; CRYSTAL (SURNAME UNKNOWN), AS HEIR AND DISTRIBUTEE TO THE ESTATE OF ROSEMARIE CHESLA; UNKNOWN HEIRS OF THE ESTATE OF ROSEMARIE CHESLA; any and all persons unknown to plaintiff, claiming, or who may claim to have an interest in, or general or specific lien upon the real property described in this action; such unknown persons being herein generally described and intended to be included in the following designation, namely: the wife, widow, husband, widower, heirs at law, next of kin, descendants, executors, administrators, devisees, legatees, creditors, trustees, committees, lienors, and assignees of such deceased, any and all persons deriving interest in or lien upon, or title to said real property by, through or under them, or either of them, and their respective wives, widows, husbands, widowers, heirs at law, next of kin, descendants, executors, administrators, devisees, legatees, creditors, trustees, committees, lienors and assigns, all of whom and whose names, except as stated, are unknown to plaintiff; SECRETARY OF HOUSING AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT; NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF TAXATION AND FINANCE; UNITED STATES OF AMERICA; THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK; Defendants.

SECOND SUPPLEMENTAL SUMMONS Mortgaged Premises: 79 SOLAR BLUFF WORCESTER, NY 12197

To the above named Defendants YOU ARE HEREBY SUMMONED to answer the complaint in this action and to serve a copy

Legal

Legal

of your answer, or, if the complaint is not served with this summons, to serve a notice of appearance on the Plaintiff’s Attorney within 20 days after the service of this summons, exclusive of the day of service (or within 30 days after the service is complete if this summons is not personally delivered to you within the State of New York) in the event the United States of America is made a party defendant, the time to answer for the said United States of America shall not expire until (60) days after service of the Summons; and in case of your failure to appear or answer, judgment will be taken against you by default for the relief demanded in the complaint.

pending for further information on how to answer the summons and protect your property.

Sending a payment to the mortgage company will not stop the foreclosure action.

YOU MUST RESPOND BY SERVING A COPY OF THE ANSWER ON THE ATTORNEY FOR THE PLAINTIFF (MORTGAGE COMPANY) AND FILING THE ANSWER WITH THE COURT. RAS BORISKIN, LLC Attorney for Plaintiff

NOTICE OF NATURE OF ACTION AND RELIEF SOUGHT

Legal nOtice

THE OBJECT of the above caption action is to foreclose a Mortgage to secure the sum of $165,000.00 and interest, recorded on June 11, 2007, at Liber 1524 Page 661, of the Public Records of OTSEGO County, New York, covering premises known as 79 SOLAR BLUFF WORCESTER, NY 12197.

The relief sought in the within action is a final judgment directing the sale of the premises described above to satisfy the debt secured by the Mortgage described above.

OTSEGO County is designated as the place of trial because the real property affected by this action is located in said county.

NOTICE YOU ARE IN DANGER OF LOSING YOUR HOME If you do not respond to this summons and complaint by serving a copy of the answer on the attorney for the mortgage company who filed this foreclosure proceeding against you and filing the answer with the court, a default judgment may be entered and you can lose your home. Speak to an attorney or go to the court where your case is

BY: Matthew Ingber, Esq. 900 Merchants Concourse, Suite 310 Westbury, NY 11590 516-280-7675 4LegalJan.3

Notice of Formation of Professional Service Limited Liability Company (PLLC) Name: Leatherstocking Certified Registered Nurse Anesthetist and NP in Acute Care Services PLLC; d/b/a: Leatherstocking Anesthesia and Acute Care. Articles of Organization were filed with the Secretary of State of New York (SSNY) on September 21, 2018.

Office location: Otsego County.

The SSNY has been designated as the agent of the PLLC upon whom processes against the PLLC may be served. The SSNY shall mail a copy of the process to the PLLC, 225 Bristol Road Hartwick, NY 13348. Purpose: For any lawful purpose.

6LegalJan.17 Legal nOtice

Notice of Formation of David Benjamin LLC Arts of Org. filed with New York Secy of State (SSNY) on 11/8/18. Office location: Otsego County. SSNY is designated as agent of LLC upon whom process against it may be served. SSNY shall mail process to: 165 W. End Ave, Apt 17D, NY, NY 10023. Purpose: any lawful activity.

6LegalJan17

AllOTSEGO.life

THURSDAY-Friday, JANUARY 3-4, 2019

B-5

Fenimore Breaks New Ground With Rock, Roll Photography PHOTOS/From A1 Roll Hall of Fame president (and a CGP graduate.)

A famed photographer of celebrities in the 1980s‘90s, Ritts was known for his black-and-white portraiture, much of it shot in the style of classical Greek sculpture. He died of pneumonia at the age of 50 in 2002.

“He created icons,” said Harris. “So much of what we think of when we think of these artists is because of him.”

Following a successful run at the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame, the exhibit toured at other art museums, where a

friend of Rossi’s saw it and reported back to her.

“When we realized we had a connection to the Rock Herb Ritts & Roll Hall dies in 2002. of Fame through Greg, we knew we had to bring it to the Fenimore,” said Rossi.

Fenimore Director of Marketing Todd Kenyon said he believes the exhibit will “resonate with the baseball crowd,” too.

“At the core of it, to have it at this great art museum that celebrates folk and American art, these images are a perfect fit,” said Harris.

The exhibit features some APARTMENT FOR RENT of Ritts’ iconic images of David Bowie, Michael Jackson, FOR RENT Village of Bob Dylan, Bruce SpringCooperstown 2/2 home steen, Tina Turner, Dizzy next to NBT on Pioneer and Gillespie and others, as well Church. Den, library, small as music videos, interviews, kitchen, close to Bassett, contact sheets and Ritts’ own Main St., the gym, etc. Quiet camera.

“There’s a mini-gallery of complex. $1800/mo plus utilities and heat. Text 6 pm8 pm 607-437-6853

AllOTSEGO. classifieds

Whitehill Cottage Fully furnished 2 bedroom upstairs apartment. Livingroom, stocked kitchen, bathroom. 5 miles from Cooperstown. Plus Garage. $800/month+utilities. Single person preferred. Yearround rental. Contact Rob Lee 607-434-5177 TFN

Madonna,” said Harris. “He photographed her more than 30 times.”

Visitors will even have a chance to snap a Rittsinspired selfie at a photo booth made up to look like Madonna’s iconic “Cherish” music video shoot, and music by the artists will be playing throughout the gallery.

“We’ve had exhibits where there are websites, but this really brings it to a multi-sensory level,” said Rossi.

But more than just the Ritts photographs, Rossi is working with Rock & Roll Hall of Fame curators to bring additional items from their collection to the Fenimore as part of the exhibit. “We’re getting Rod Stewart’s brown tiger-print jumpsuit, Sting’s bass and one of Slash’s guitars,” said Rossi.

“These are not just items these artists touched,” said Harris. “All of the items have connection to making that music. It adds a contextual element to the exhibit.”

To accommodate the exhibit, the entirety of the Clark Gallery, some of which is

ists. The lineup has not been announced yet, and, according to Kenyon, the committee will meet to plan a schedule later in the month.

The exhibit runs through Sept. 2 and is part of what Rossi called “a summer of music.”

Starting May 25, the Fenimore will host “Perfect Harmony: The Musical Art & Life of William Sidney Mount,” a collection of 25 oil paintings, pencil drawings, musical instruments, and related objects on loan from the Long Island Museum.

The exhibit will also feature music by Mount playing throughout.

For the opera fans, the Fenimore will display two dresses worn by opera singer Beverly Sills in the 1975-1976 production of “La Traviata,” as well as the exhibit “Floating Palaces of the Hudson” and will include images of the old paddle wheelers in conjunction with the Glimmerglass Festival’s production of “Showboat.”

“The whole thing is going to be a lot of fun,” said Rossi.

“It’s like being in a candy

Madonna, by famed rock photographer Herb Ritts, will be making an appearance at The Fenimore next summer.

used for storage, will have to be opened up. “We’re going to use the Community Gallery as well, and might even move the entrance of the exhibit into the Great Hall,”

she said.

The Fenimore received $135,0225 in a CFA funding to promote the exhibit, including live concerts, film screenings and talks from art-

Fireman Saved Her, 4 Boys, Then Died, Sister-In-Law Says

FATAL FIRE/From A1 According to Heller, the boys were spending the night at the home when the fire broke out just after 4 a.m.

“What began as a fun sleepover with their uncle John and soon-to-be aunt Amber turned into a nightmare,” wrote Heller.

According to Fire Chief Center City Oneonta! RePatrick Pidgeon, the call modeled one bedroom, 2nd came in from the County 911 center at 4:23 a.m. The first floor apartment. $725 per crew, with the engine and the month, includes heat and ladder truck, arrived on the hot water. NO Pets! Referscene at 4:29 a.m. ences and current credit “They could see the fire check required. Contact from Main Street,” said Betsy or Becky at Benson Pidgeon. “They called in Agency Real Estate, 607everyone.”

432-4391.

In all, 18 Oneonta fireTFN fighters came with an ambulance, a command vehicle

All

OTSEGO.

opportunities

Join Our Team of Dedicated and Caring Professionals Residential Associates (FT & Substitutes – FT: M-F, 2nd shift & M-R, 3rd shift; Subs: all shifts)

Center Associate Assistant Teacher Classroom Teacher Building Healthy Families Support Specialist

Maddox suffered burns in the fire, but, according to his mother, is expected to make a full recovery.

Inside the residence, an adult male, whom Mayor Gary Herzig later identified as Heller, was located and transported to Fox Hospital, where he was pronounced dead.

An Oneonta native, Heller graduated OHS in 2000. In November 2002, he joined the Oneonta Fire Department as an on-call firefighter, and in 2003, moved to part-time.

He served in this capacity until August 2009.

According to Roe’s Facebook page, the two got engaged in July and had a wedding planned for Oct. 12, 2019.

“He was a good guy,” said Police Chief Doug Brenner.

“I think that’s obvious.”

Andrew Turner, president of the Oneonta Professional Firefighters, issued a state-

ment mourning Heller’s passing Monday, Dec. 31. “It is with sadness and deep loss that the Oneonta Professional Firefighters learned of the tragic passing of John Heller, a former part-time member of the Oneonta Fire Department,” he wrote. “We extend our deepest sympathies to the Heller family.”

He continued, “During his years as a member of the Department, John’s actions made a difference in the lives of our residents – and his actions on Saturday were central to saving the lives of those closest to him. We pray for peace to John, and all who he touched and loved.”

The cause and location of the fire is still under investigation by the state office of Fire and Control Division of the state Department of Homeland Security, which was on the scene with an investigative team and a K9 unit at 8 a.m. Saturday morning.

Two Go Fund Me Campaigns are in the works; the first, “Support For Amber” aims to help Roe rebuild after losing everything in the

EOE

Calling hours for Heller will be held 5-8 p.m. Thursday, Jan. 3 at the Bookhout Funeral Home in Oneonta.

The funeral will be held 1 p.m. Friday, Jan. 4.

“They are both our heroes,” said Heller. “They both did what they needed to save our boys.”

AllOTSEGO. homes

Thinking of Remodeling?

Think of Refinancing!

LGROUP@STNY.RR.COM www.leatherstockingmortgage.com 607-547-5007 (Office) 800-547-7948 (Toll Free)

New Purchases and refinances • Debt Consolidation Free Pre-Qualification • Fast Approvals • Low Rates Registered Mortgage Broker Matt Schuermann NYS Banking Dept.

Loans arranged by a 3rd party lender.

31 Pioneer Street, Cooperstown (directly next door to Stagecoach Coffee) INterIor Features —2 BRs; 2 full baths —Completely gutted and renovated in 2016 —Open kitchen w/granite counter, SS appliances —Entry foyer —Den/office —First-floor master suite —Second BR on second floor —2 en suite baths —Propane fireplace

Lovely Cooperstown Village home, completely renovated in 2016.

Master suite w/whirlpool tub, separate shower, walk-in closet.

Kitchen w/mahogany counter, granite island, pantry. LR w/brick gas fireplace and white brick chimney, pine ceiling. 3-season sun room.

Large upstairs BR w/private bath. Patio w/access to Maple Street.

Convenient village location.

Co-exclusively offered at the new price $249,000

REALTY, INC

OFO is a family-oriented organization offering competetive wages, excellent benefits & opportunities for professional growth. For an application, submission instructions, benefit package summary & descriptions of all employment openings, visit

fire, and the second, to raise money to give the four boys a one-year membership to Noah’s World, as well as to replace the winter weather gear lost in the fire. “We thought the best gift for these boys would be the gift of play,” wrote organizer Meg Lynne (search “Noah’s World Year Pass For Heller Boys” at GoFundMe.com).

Welcome the New Year in Your New Home!

Don Olin

Building Healthy Families Resource Specialist WIC Nutritionist www.ofoinc.org

and a brush truck to fight the fire. Mutual aid came from West Oneonta and Otego, with Laurens covering the station and the Fast Teams from Worcester and Franklin, as well as two ambulances from Cooperstown Medical Transport.

Trapped inside, Heller and Roe hurried to get the boys to safety. “They were completely trapped on the top floor of the building,” she wrote.

“Once he had them all out on the fire escape, he was unable to get out. He died because he did everything he could to make sure that his fiancée and my sons were out of the home safely.”

Amber and the boys were transported by ambulance to Fox Hospital, where they were treated and released.

exterIor Features —Built 1920 —Raised ranch —Full foundation —Frame construction —Wood siding, metal roof —Patio

37 Chestnut street · Cooperstown · 607-547-5622 · 607-547-5653 (fax) parking is never a problem!

For Appointment Only Call: M. Margaret Savoie, Real Estate Broker/Owner – 547-5334 Marion King, Real Estate Associate Broker – 547-5332 Eric Hill, Real Estate Associate Broker – 547-5557 Donald DuBois, Real Estate Associate Broker – 547-5105

Timothy Donahue, Real Estate Associate Broker – 293-8874 Madeline Sansevere, Real Estate Salesperson – 435-4311 Catherine Raddatz, Real Estate Salesperson – 547-8958 Michael Welch, Real Estate Salesperson – 547-8502

For reliable, honest answers to any of your real estate questions, call 607.547.5622 or visit our website www.donolinrealty.com

Home of the Week Whitehill Cottage — This 1,878 sq ft farmhouse sits on 2+ acres just 5.6 miles from Cooperstown, surrounded by beautifully done perennial gardens, sweeping lawn, Red Creek in the back. This well done 2-family cottage-style home has upstairs w/2 BRs, LR, full bath and eat-in kitchen currently rented by the week in summer.

Main floor has enclosed porch, LR, den w/vaulted ceiling, formal DR, BR, ½ bath, full bath/laundry. Pretty wood floors, lots of charm.

Well appointed kitchen. Front and side porch, large back screened porch. Lots of storage. Great rental opportunity or easy conversion back to a 1-family home. Barn w/2-car garage, work area. Replacement windows, newer roof, move-in ready. Cooperstown Schools.

Offered Exclusively by Ashley-Connor Realty $275,000

ASHLEY

REALTY

CONNOR

29 Pioneer Street, Cooperstown 607-547-4045 www.ashleyconnorrealty.com info@ashleyconnorrealty.com Patricia Bensen-Ashley Licensed Real Estate Broker/Owner For Appointment: Patricia Bensen-Ashley, Broker/Owner, 607-437-1149 Jack Foster, Sales Agent, 607-547-5304 Donna Skinner, Associate Broker, 607-287-4113 Chris Patterson, Associate Broker, 518-774-8175

B-6 THE FREEMAN’S JOURNAL

THURSDAY, JANUARY 3, 2019

OBITUARIES

Rodman D. Carter, M.D., 90; Longtime Bassett Hospital Urologist COOPERSTOWN – Rodman Dana Carter, M.D., a long-time surgeon at Mary Imogene Bassett Hospital whose career in urology spanned over 40 years, passed away following a valiant battle with cancer Friday afternoon, Dec. 28, 2018, at his home in Cooperstown with his family by his side.

He was 90.

Born April 6, 1928, in Ashtabula, Ohio, he was a son of the Rev. Edwin R. Carter, a

minister in the Congregational Church and the United Church of Christ, and Lillian Herter Carter. After graduating from high school he served his country in the Navy.

A graduate of Harvard University, Class of 1949, he received urological and surgical training at Columbia University College of Physicians & Surgeons.

At one time he worked with Dr. Virginia Apgar, the creator of the Apgar Scale for

warehouse clearance* *on all in-stock monuments

Complete On-premise Custom Carving and Lettering Facility 11 Genesee Street, Cherry Valley•607-264-8201 www.cvmemorials.com

grading babies’ health at birth.

In 1953, Dr. Carter arrived at Bassett Hospital, where he enjoyed a long career. Board certified in general surgery and urology, he became a member of the senior staff in 1962, and until 1993 he continued teaching the house staff the art and science of surgery as the hospital grew and expanded.

After he retired from Bassett and began spending

winters in Palm Coast, Fla., he continued to offer his services in that area until he completely retired in 1997.

He was a member of American Legion in Florida, and was an ardent supporter of the Friends of Bassett.

Dr. Carter is survived by his wife of 60 years, Mary Imogene Newell Carter, a native of Cooperstown. They were married April 18, 1958, in a ceremony in Cromwell, Conn., with Dr. Carter’s

father officiating.

Dr. Carter is further survived by one daughter, Michelle “Micki” Weir of Granville; two granddaughters, Dana Temp of Esperance and Shawna Tierney of Bristol, Maine; four great-grandchildren, Olivia Temp, and Finnegan, Liam and Angus Tierney; one sister, Caroline Wall; two sisters-in-law, Noreen Newell of Cooperstown, and Marion “Billie” Williams of

Portland, Oregon; and many nieces and nephews.

A private gathering will be held later this spring.

Memorial donations may be made to Friends of Bassett, 1 Atwell Road, Cooperstown, NY 13326 or Catskill Area Hospice and Palliative Care, 297 River Street Service Road, Oneonta, NY 13820.

Arrangements are entrusted to the Connell, Dow & Deysenroth Funeral Home.

Bonnie Canning Hofmann, 64; Brookwood School Pioneer COOPERSTOWN – Bonnie Canning Hofmann, 64, formerly of Cooperstown, a Brookwood School founding board member, passed away on Dec. 25, 2018, at her home in Hawaii after a long illness.

Bonnie was born on July 19, 1954, in Brooklyn, where she grew up. She attended the University of Stony Brook and SUNY Plattsburgh, where she received her nursing degree.

She loved her community and dedicated much of her

time to the preservation of Cooperstown; Bonnie was well known for her influence in the conservation of Otsego Lake and surrounding areas.

Bonnie was a tenacious founding board member and benefactor to The Brookwood School. She was a core contributor to the vision that helped ensure the success of the school in the community.

She had a gift for seeing and validating everyone’s point of view. She is treasured

by those who worked alongside her – selfless, energetic, passionate and full of good humor.

She later moved to New Bonnie York City with Canning her family and Hofmann continued her involvement with her community. She was a giving person and was known by all for her kindness

and generosity.

Bonnie always kept her roots in Cooperstown and would return to her home during the summers.

Bonnie is survived by her husband, Bruno; children, Erin Canning, Oliver Hofmann, Tatjana Hofmann and Ina Hofmann; her grandson, Joel.

There will be a celebration of her life in the early part of the summer of 2019, at the lake in Cooperstown, her favorite place.

KUZMINSKI: Demagogues, Don’t Underestimate Populists Grandma loved her farm, her family, and playing her old guitar.

Lester R. Grummons Funeral Home will take the time to find out what made your loved one special.

Whether it’s finding just the right flowers, or finding a musician to play her favorite tunes on her old guitar, we’ll do what’s necessary to make her service as unique as she was.

Lester R. Grummons Funeral Home 14 Grand Street, Oneonta • 607-432-6821 www.grummonsfuneralhome.com

KUZMINSKI/From A5 on their economic and social insecurities, and who find scapegoats for them to blame.

There’s a lot of truth in this. Trump has indeed whipped up a frenzy, particularly among white, working men, richer as well as poorer – his so-called “core” supporters. He’s fed their resentments and fears by telling them that immigrants are taking away their jobs, gender advocates are taking away their masculinity, politicians are taking away their freedoms, and secularists are taking away their religious values.

Real populism, however, isn’t so easily fooled by demagogues.

In the heyday of American populism – in the 19th century – a series of movements led by farmers, artisans, and other small business people recognized that growing corporate power, particularly among railroads and banks, was destroying the free enterprise system of small, independent producers.

They organized democratically, founded political parties, drafted platforms, and demanded accountability from their representatives.

These old-time American populists

were battling the powerful trusts, or monopolies, that came to dominate the economy after the Civil War. In key infrastructure areas like transportation and energy, the monopolies were able to set exorbitant rates for services and products, including access to resources and credit. Small businesses were hamstrung and ultimately marginalized in favor of large enterprises which were able to make the rules for economic success.

To remedy this, the populists demanded the conversion of key infrastructural sectors into public utilities repurposed to facilitate rather than exploit small producers. Railroads, they argued, should be run on a regulated, non-profit basis to ensure low-cost access to markets by their customers. Similarly, banks should be run on a non-profit basis as to ensure low-cost credit to borrowers.

Their idea was to turn enterprises with too much monopoly power into accountable public utilities, but otherwise to allow the free market to run its course. If many independent producers have to use the same infrastructure (like railroads or the Internet), or rely on a common provider of essential products or services (like energy companies or

banks), those ought to be transformed into public utilities.

Populist demands for public control of monopolies were thwarted by the robber barons of the day, who made sure that lucrative monopolistic choke-points of the economy in transportation and finance and beyond remained in private hands.

Progressives and New Dealers for a time limited corporate power, but didn’t go as far as the populists thought necessary.

So it’s no surprise that monopoly power is back, along with the economic and social disparities it exacerbates.

Populism is back too. The original populist agenda of public control of monopolies combined with widespread capitalist enterprise may yet turn out to the best way to provide economic security, opportunity, and responsibility for the greatest number.

And to the extent it fosters economic independence, it would also preserve liberty, or political independence – for there can be no political independence without economic independence.

Adrian Kuzminski, retired Hartwick College philosophy professor and Sustainable Otsego moderator, lives in Fly Creek.

STAMMEL: It’s Not County Rep Salaries, It’s Whole Package

versar y Our 130th anni

Tillapaugh Funeral Service Our historic Family Room

Our Chapel comfortably seats over 200.

George M. Tillapaugh (1888-1913) · Revo and Anna Tillapaugh (1913-1958) George G. and Marjorie Tillapaugh (1935-1988) · Martin H. Tillapaugh (1988-Present)

dignity · tradition · continuity 28 Pioneer Street, cooPerStown • 607-547-2571 Proudly serving area families since 1888

STAMMEL/From A4 for representatives and the chair.

While my motion was seconded for discussion, no one joined me in voting to remove or reject the legislator raises.

The timing is especially concerning. Instead of approving a raise for an incoming class of new representatives, we are mid-term and approving raises for ourselves. It’s also done at a time when the IGA committee is looking

at new county management plans, which may reduce the role of county representatives.

Finally, economic storm clouds may be gathering. The county is disproportionately reliant on bed and sales taxes, which track volatile consumer spending. It appears the stock market is set for its worst year since 2008 and economists predict a recession within two years. These raises are essentially locked into future budgets. When the economy falters, the board will need to raise taxes or cut services.

During the holiday season when we should consider less fortunate neighbors, there is a distinct “Let them eat cake” vibe coming from the county board. Another representative claimed that because the raise was already included in the budget, no further debate was necessary. This belies the fact that items may be budgeted and then not spent, returning monies to the fund balance or transferring to any number of other line items.

How politicians choose to spend your money reflects values decisions. Every dollar

a legislator spends on him or herself is a dollar that won’t fill the pothole outside your house, or enhance school security, or support the animal shelter, or fight the opiate crisis, or encourage economic development, or just provide tax relief.

The salaries are just the tip of the iceberg attached to absurd and often hidden perks.

County representatives are part-time and short-term elected officials but are entitled to health insurance benefits for themselves and family, even into retirement. My understanding is a politician can win election three times and then be voted out of office after six years of service and suddenly be considered “retired,” with all the benefits that go along with that.

The representatives recently made a show of doubling the amount they contribute to their own health insurance.

This means taxpayers are now responsible for 90 percent of the cost as opposed to the former 95 percent. Our full-time rank and file union employees pay significantly more for insurance and had to fight for

2 percent salary raises.

County officials should not follow the lead of politicians in Washington and Albany, who have lost the trust of the people. At the local level, we need citizen legislators who bring diverse perspectives, work together for a few years, then pass the baton to the next civic-minded person.

During my time with the County I have pledged not to accept any of the health insurance, retirement benefits, or travel reimbursement, as I believe these are incompatible with part-time public service.

Until these benefits are reformed, a representative may accept them and each of us makes our own decision on what’s right for us.

If we believe the benefits are ethical, transparency should not be a problem. It is my hope that county representatives will reflect over the holiday about who we are elected to serve and that we will return in January with the spirit of real reform.

ANDREW STAMMEL County Representative Town of Oneonta