audit purposes Domain 6: Editorial independence 22. The guideline is editorially independent of the funding organization(s). 23. Conflicts of interest of the members of the guideline development group have been recorded. Domain 7: Applicability to the country healthcare system 24. There are recommendations for preventive, diagnostic, therapeutic and rehabilitative measures in different areas of care. 25. There is information as to which measures seem to be unsuitable, redundant or outdated. 26. The clinical information of the guideline is organized in such a way as to ensure that the process of clinical decision-making is systematically presented and easily understandable. 27. A strategy / concept for the easy accessibility and dissemination of the guideline is presented.
X X X X X X
GUIA : GINA 2010. EVALUADOR 2 Domain 7: Applicability to the country healthcare system 28. A concept for implementing the guideline is described.
1
2 X
29. The guideline is supplemented by a description of the methods used (guideline report). Domain 8. Methodological rigour of development when using existing guidelines 30. Systematic methods were used to search for existing guidelines. 31. The criteria for selecting guidelines as a source of evidence (so-called source guidelines) are transparently and explicitly described. 32. The quality of the source guidelines was reviewed. 33. The evidence base of the source guidelines was complemented by systematic update searches of primary evidence 34. All modifications to the recommendations of the source guidelines are clearly specified and accounted for.
3
4
X
X X X X X
Rating 1. Strongly disagree Rating 4. Strongly agree CALIFICACION GUIA
Dominio 1: Alcance y objetivos Evaluador
Item 1
Item 2
Item 3
Total
1 J
2
3
4
9
2R
3
3
4
10
Total
5
6
8
19
(Puntaje obtenido – puntaje mínimo posible)/(Puntaje máximo posible – puntaje mínimo posible) x 100