Metrics That Matter

A Marketing Data Strategy Q&A with GAVIN

A nationally ranked brand strategy firm, GAVIN™ started its agency story in York, PA, and has grown to serve clients coast-to-coast with multiple offices and teammates across the country. The team has been recognized by dozens of top business and marketing industry media for their growth, team culture, and comprehensive marketing and communications services, delivering high-performance outcomes for their clients.

Q: What metrics and data should businesses be tracking?

Every business should begin with a solid foundation of performance metrics spanning visibility and conversion channels. Key metrics might include monthly or quarterly website traffic sources, lead form conversions, media coverage volume, and engagement across owned social platforms. For those with the resources to dive deeper, many other metrics and tools are available to measure the success of digital marketing efforts. A few examples include:

• Keywords: Gauge the effectiveness of your SEO strategy.

• Email Open and Click-Through Rates: Insights into messaging performance based on monitoring.

• Conversion Rate Optimization (CRO): Testing website elements (design, user experience) to boost conversion rates.

• Customer Lifetime Value (CLV): Average revenue per customer, guiding acquisition and retention.

• Return on Investment (ROI): Measures investment profitability; tracks effective revenue-driving channels.

• Social Media Engagement: Analyzes likes, comments, and shares to understand audience connection with your brand.

These metrics help paint a fuller picture of performance. Digital marketing isn’t just about driving clicks; it’s about how your audience discovers, trusts, and engages with your brand.

Q: Are there common metrics that businesses often overlook, or mistakes they make?

Absolutely. Branded keyword growth is often overlooked, yet it’s a powerful indicator of brand awareness driven by PR efforts and digital content. Another common mistake is failing to track post-click behavior—focusing solely on traffic metrics without analyzing what users do next or how to guide them toward conversion.

Marketing teams and leadership frequently prioritize topline numbers without questioning whether those metrics translate into meaningful business outcomes or contribute to the organization’s long-term growth and relevance.

Q: What information should businesses focus on most?

Focus on KPIs (key performance indictors) that align with short- and long-term business goals. For sales growth, track qualified leads and ROAS (return on assets). For visibility, monitor share of voice, sentiment, and engagement across channels.

The goal is to measure momentum—are people finding you, staying, and talking about you? Are they engaging to build a relationship or seeing value in your content that drives retention or spending?

Q: Once businesses have data, what should they do next?

Data should be at the core of your strategy, guiding optimizations and bringing you closer to your sales goals. For instance, if a press mention generates more organic traffic than your ad spend, it’s a clear sign to invest more in PR. If users bounce from your landing pages, it’s time to revisit the messaging or improve the user experience.

Changes don’t need to happen every month—adjustments take time to deliver results. However, regular evaluation is essential. Marketing is not a “set it and forget it” process. We recommend establishing consistent review cycles with your team or agency to uncover insights, refine strategies, and plan your next steps to drive meaningful results.

Q: What strategies help prioritize and focus on the most important metrics for a business's goals?

Align every metric with a clear business objective— whether it's building brand awareness, generating leads, or securing media coverage. Create a structured hierarchy: primary KPIs, supporting metrics, and diagnostic indicators. Let your data do more than just report numbers; use it to tell a compelling story.

What value did that new event bring to the organization? How did a fresh piece of content or a prominent feature in a key publication enhance your campaign's impact? Can these efforts continue to deliver results with further investment? Let strategy define what truly matters, rather than letting metrics drive the narrative.

Q: What are the most critical metrics in a business's first year vs. during its growth phase?

During a business's first year, the most critical metrics are typically focused on acquisition and customer retention. These would include metrics such as website traffic, lead generation, conversion rates, and customer lifetime value.

During the growth phase, a business typically prioritizes expanding its reach, boosting brand awareness, and optimizing for greater efficiency. Considering customer acquisition cost (CAC), return on ad spend (ROAS), and how brand equity (earned media and share of voice) supports retention and word-of-mouth referrals for further expansion. It’s easy to become fixated on trying to do everything, but you need to build from a core set of data points and phase in metrics as you evolve and better understand where your customers, recruits, or partners are coming from.

It is important to note that every business is unique and may have different KPIs depending on its industry, target audience, and goals. It's essential to regularly review and adjust these metrics based on the current stage of the business and its objectives.

Q: How do you recommend businesses balance quantitative metrics with qualitative customer feedback?

Numbers tell you what’s happening, but stories explain why. We encourage clients to pair analytics with tools like Net Promoter Score (NPS), review sentiment, and social listening insights if they can. PR analysis—especially tone, reach, and type of publication—adds qualitative depth to performance, but it also takes time to establish some patterns. Together, they can help guide new content and outreach plans to your current and future customers.

Q: What tools or software would you recommend for small businesses to track and analyze performance?

For most small businesses, these tools form a strong tech stack:

• Google Analytics 4 (site behavior and attribution)

• Google Search Console (SEO health)

• Semrush (keyword tracking and competitor insights)

• Media Monitoring tools like, Meltwater or Cision, depending on your budget.

• NinjaCat (cross-platform reporting)

• Tools like HubSpot or Sprout Social can add more functionality to your content scheduling and data reporting processes as your needs grow. Many of these tools can work together, or custom reporting solutions can be built.

Q: Any notes on things like social stats, impressions, pixels, SEO, and Google Business Profiles?

Install Meta and LinkedIn pixels early for retargeting. Track impressions, engagement, and CTRs on social, but always connect them to conversions or referral volume. Keep your Google Business Profile updated—it’s key for local SEO. Invest in ongoing SEO content, even with quarterly updates.

When analyzing LinkedIn, track engagement, follower demographics, and industry benchmarks. Tools like Sprout Social offer a full view of performance across platforms. Check impression-to-engagement ratios to ensure visibility drives action.

Q: What’s your advice for businesses to stay “ahead of the curve”?

Establish proactive visibility by staying engaged in the media, creating impactful thought leadership content like blogs, white papers, and op-eds, and optimizing search engines and reputation management.

Keep a close eye on trends—we recommend tools like Semrush for tracking keyword performance and Meltwater for media analysis—and be prepared to adapt your campaigns to shifts in audience behavior or media landscapes. Partnering with a reputable marketing agency can help businesses stay current on industry trends and implement effective strategies aligning with their goals and target audience.

Networking with other professionals in your industry can provide valuable insights and connections to stay informed about the latest developments and best practices. Attend conferences, join online communities or associations, and actively engage with peers to foster new ideas and collaborations.

Don’t hesitate to experiment with new channels or messaging strategies; you’ll quickly identify what resonates. Explore niche social platforms, specialized media outlets, and multimedia opportunities to connect with specific audiences through paid promotions or earned media efforts.

50 East 4th Avenue, York

evolving-influence.com | 717.848.8155