Post-Quake Visions by YAC

YOUNG ARCHITECTS COMPETITIONS

POST-QUAKE VISIONS 24Jun’13 - 11Nov’13 Crevalcore - BO

www.youngarchitectscompetitions.com

Competition

Post Quake Visions

Dates

24/06/2013-11/11/2013

Days Jury

Partners

Bologna Alma Mater University, CNA Bologna, Crevalcore Municipality, The Plan Magazine, Riko ltd.., Wienerberger ltd.

Enrolled Teams

356

Designers

808

Countries

Australia, Austria, Azerbaijan, Belgium, Brazil, Bulgaria, Canada, Chile, China, Colombia, Croatia, Cyprus, Egypt, Ethiopia, France, Georgia, Germany, Greece, Hong Kong, Hungary, India, Indonesia, Iran, Ireland, Israel, Italy, Jamaica, Japan, Lebanon, Lithuania, Macedonia, Malaysia, Mexico, Netherlands, New Zealand, Poland, Portugal, Russia, South Korea, Spain, Switzerland, Taiwan, Turkey, Ukraine, UK, USA, Uruguay.

140

Claudio Broglia, Crevalcoreâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s Major Alessandro Boldrini, Shigeru Ban Architects Alfonso FemĂŹa, 5+1 AA Eugenia DiGirolamo, New York City Department of City Planning Matteo Agnoletto, Bologna Alma Mater University

Awarded proposals 1st Prize Team 1165 - Spadoni C. , Brunetti V.

Italy

p. 5

Italy

p. 6

Switzerland

p. 7

Team 1289 - Monaco Mazza L., Seccarello A., Reina M.

Italy

p. 8

Team 1301 - Frontalini S., Bocchini A., Comandini M., Febbretti S., Giancipoli G.

Italy

p. 8

2nd Prize Team 1444 - Nicoletto L., Paladin E., Paronuzzi M.

3rd Prize Team 1251 - Ferreira N., Lopes P.

Honorable mentions - GOLD

Team 1478 - Bruno M., Foffo M., Forlini A., Lungo A.

Italy

p. 9

Team 1254 - Ciulla C., Maiello L., Sutto N.

Italy

p. 9

Honorable mentions Team 1172 - Fu Feixiao

China

p. 11

Team 1193 - Tanzilli M., Gaetano L., Gutierrez N., Sabadella L.

Italy

p. 11

Team 1406 - Colonna P., Fiore G.

Italy

p. 12

Team 1331 - Lattanzio M.

p. 12

Team 1476 - Puissant Marine

France

p. 13

Team 1420 - Ball R.

USA

p. 13

Team 1469 - Tramoni F., Orsini A., De Rocca M., De Lipowsky J. M.

France

p. 14

Team 1408 - Donati I., Biasolo M. M., Silvestrelli S.

Italy

p. 14

Finalist proposals Team 1151 - Baillie C., Baillie M., Ward M.

p. 17

Team 1177 - Serrani A., Berti G., Milandri M.

Italy

p. 17

Team 1194 - Nesci C., Valsecchi C., Siciliano M.

Italy

p. 17

Team 1207 - Mackay T.

Australia

p. 17

Team 1218 - Cesaroni M., Ciampolini P., Daddi S.

Italy

p. 18

Team 1220 - Stoyanova I.

Bulgaria

p. 18

Team 1504 - Joseph A., Panizzo A., Paoletti E.

Italy

p. 18

Team 1243 - Becker J., Kalivoda L.

Austria

p. 19

Team 1247 - Flores C., Perez M., Zagarzazu R.

Uruguay

p. 19

Team 1250 - Aramburo H., Reyes M., Kakar O.

USA

p. 19

Team 1307 - Bellavite E., Barbaro M.

Italy

p. 19

Team 1276 - Connelly D., Aguilera J., Sanchez-Fortun J.

China

p. 20

Team 1278 - Russo C., Freddi G., Casartelli S.

Italy

p. 20

Team 1290 - Tevdorashvili E., Gotsadze G., Jvarsheishvili G., Tkemaladze R.

Georgia

p. 20

Team 1299 - Povoledo E., Liut G., Laiza T.

Italy

p. 20

Team 1310 - Traina D., Marino F., Sammarchi L., Riscino S.

Italy

p. 21

Team 1334 - Pollio A., Nika A., Pollio A., Poma I., Perri M.

Italy

p. 21

Team 1337 - Lozano E., Schwuchow U.

Mexico

p. 21

Team 1411 - Lee J., Schelew N.

USA

p. 21

Team 1417 - Fu A., Rim J.

USA

p. 22

Team 1434 - Nemethi B., Jedlicska G., Kenez G., Fialovszky T.

Hungary

p. 22

Team 1453 - Morini F., Tazioli L.

Italy

p. 22

Team 1491 - Armendariz O.

USA

p. 22

Team 1468 - Hadjisterkoti C. , Paulou C., Stavrou E., Stavrinides M., Panteli M.

Cyprus

p. 23

Team 1477 - Mintsiou A., Balampanidou E.

Cyprus

p. 23

Team 1480 - Snidero E., Ventura M.

Italy

p. 23

Team 1235 - Grazioli M., Barbu V.

Italy

p. 23

Team 1241 - Mattei A., Naglieri C.

Italy

p. 24

Team 1413 - Chiusoli A., Castellari D., Bettucchi E., Landi F., Daniele G., Naldoni L.

Italy

p. 24

Team 1483 - Orlandelli A., Natarelli D., Cassina D., Dalbon E., Bordoni F., Montalbano M., Moretti S.

Italy

p. 24

AWARDED PROPOSALS

Team 1165 - Spadoni C. , Brunetti V. EAST ENRANCE INFOPOINTS

1st Prize

SHOWROOM AND TEACHING SPACES

GENERAL PLAN 1:1000

WEST AREA INFOPOINT

AREA PROJECTIONS AND STORES

AREA PROJECTIONS

ID: 1165

2nd Prize Team 1444 - Nicoletto L., Paladin E., Paronuzzi M.

3rd Prize Team 1251 - Ferreira N., Lopes P.

! ?

3,0

In case events and exhibitions the seeds can be pulled out again, creating new spaces for outdoor activities, commercial spots and showrooms, changing completly Corso Matteotti’s space.

Once the economy of the city is brought back to a new life, the seeds could be collocated inside the new buildings, as closure of the ground floor spaces.

What if the solution to a big problem could just be a small little seed? What if the things we miss could temporary be recollocated close to where they were? This seed, icon of regrowth, could be the place where all the activities for the rebirth of the city could take place! One seed, that multiplied and assembled (thanks to its flexibility and semplicity of construction), could become the right place for everything. A class, a shop, a meeting point, a mini audtorium, etc. All sorts of micro activities that could help Crevalocore in its recovery.

RESTART

How can citizens regain their spaces, their city?

It all starts with memories and new ideas. The city hall becomes the heart of the process. Our choice is to preserve this icon, the icon of the old Crevalcore, that now becomes the starting point of this new story. A place of debate, exchange of ideas, where everyone’s inspirations could contribute to an completly new path.

1,2

TOMORROW

The seeds, founding elements of our design strategy, are highly flexible architectural devices. Their use is stricktly conected to the needs of the citizens, they can be moved, assembled and adjusted to make them suitable for any kind of activity. After the earthquake, the seeds could be assembled outdoor to replace all the functions lost due to the damages. When the construction of the new buildings is completed, the seeds will be moved inside, creating the new street side of Corso Matteotti. During the “special events” ,such as festivals or exhibitions, they can be easily moved ouside again, thanks to their modularity. The seeds measures are 1,20x3,00x3,00. Joint togheter the seeds can create a large amount of different spaces for different activities that change totally the perception of the principal street of the city.

SEED PROGRAM

TODAY

CULTURE +free time

TECHNICAL SPECIFICATIONS

+MOBILITY The seeds are designed to be easily moved by one or two people. This is what make them the perfect solution for a temporary use.

.corrugated sheet

Every seed have a weight of 80 kg maximum.

The structure consists in a square reticular grid of steel, the exterior is a corrugated sheet and the interior is made of wood.

The seeds are designed to be transported, already assembled, on normal truck. Every truck can transport 8 seeds, the total dimension of the cargo will be 2,40 m x 3,00 m x 12,00 m

.assembly

.innovation

.debate

.exposition

.convention

.business

.meeting

.work

PRODUCTIVITY

+PORTABILITY

+fun

+recreation

+shopping

+reading

+entertainment

+shows

+aggregation

.iron structure

.plywood sheathing

Every seed can be assemblated with an infinite amount of other seeds. The owner can assembly the seeds creating a large amount of different spaces with a large amount of uses.

+FLEXIBILITY

SPECIAL EVENT

NORMAL DAY

NEW PEDESTRIAN SPACE

NEW BUILDINGS

MOVING ELEMENTS

NEW BUILDING AND EXPANSIONS:

.SHOW ROOM .INFOPOINT .FAIR .SHOPS .MEDIASPACE .MICROLIBRARY .WORKSHOP SPACE .FILMFORUM .EQUIPMENT .COLLATERAL EVENTS .MARKET .TEST ROOM

MICRO ACTIVITIES:

.SHOWROOM .ATELIER .OFFICE .HOUSES

REMEMBER

MACRO ACTIVITIES:

MAIN PROJECT THEMES A depressed town center, irreparably compromised by the earthquake of 2012. Is Crevalcore only this? Crevalcore is an opportunity, a fertile land waiting for a change. A change that is not constrained by what surrounds the town but inspired by the possibilities of the world in which it’s set! Preserving the cultural business vocation of the city, we decided to create a flexible space for a spread ? laboratory in sinergy with the productive reality of the local territory, directly linked with the public space, ? ? ! the people and the city.

The choice of using light structures, is given by the great possibility to intervene on the conformation of the public space at ground level, so as to generate a continuous alternation functional, just to diversify the supply during the year.

FUNCTIONS

The public space plays a predominant role in the design choice: the ground floor of the new buildngs becomes part of the public space. Completly opened, thanks to the flexibility of the seed’s system, the ground floor of the shops, the showrooms and the laboratories is now fluidly integrated with Corso Matteotti.

PUBLIC SPACE

URBAN SEEDS Honorable mentions - GOLD

3,00 MT

corso matteotti by night

JUNE 2016

JUNE 2014 the seeds in corso matteotti

festival of history

OCTOBER 2016

corso matteotti gallery with the new building

SEPTEMBER 2015

1289

YAC

TEAM NUMBER

MODULAR TEMPORARY FLEXIBILITY ECONOMY

HISTORIC CORE STRATEGY LIVE WORK STUDY PLAY RELAX ...

Materials corrugated sheet

thermal insulation alluminium profile alluminium profile wood panel ceiling

glass perforated sheet

VIABILITY AND PRODUCTION RESOURCES

wood frame

Ferrara

wood panel wood frame thermal insulation

A22 SS12

Crevalcore

SP1

SP2 SS64 A13

corrugated sheet

Modena SP568

SS9

alluminium profile

Bologna

wood panel floor

ECONOMIC STRATEGY HUMAN RESOURCES

ACTORS INVOLVED DEVELOPMENT OF RELATIONS

PA INSTRUCTION

PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION

ASSOCIATIONS

PRIVATE COMPANIES

HISTORIC CORE

DEVELOPMENT OF PRODUCTION PROCESSES INDUSTRY LEARNING

RESEARCH

Legend

PRODUCTION

PRODUCTION OF GOODS AND SERVICES

PLACE OF CULTURE/ ADMINISTRATION

S Bologna’s Door Modena’s Door

INTRODUCTION

B M

church

The city is often a totality of relationships and tensions that develop day after day; this process leads to transformations which cause a loss of identity and recognisability of the historical fabric. Crevalcore, on the contrary, is an example of town which preserves its own structure of ancient city thanks to an economic and productive system settled beyond the old town centre. The settlement of Crevalcore, which is in the middle compared with other Emilian cities such as Modena, Bologna and Ferrara, is a further incentive to expand the synergy between the old town centre and local industries.

Town hall - new entrance

showroom

PLACE OF WORKING office / coworking

atelier

TERRITORIAL STRATEGY The study tends to the recovery of the economic, social, cultural and creative dimension of the city through a planning action starting from the launch of an external incentive. The common objective is to activate fertile relationships able to determine the development of new productive/creative processes, which can lead to a new vision of inhabiting, living and working in this place. The historical centre of Crevalcore could be the ideal landscape to host new productive additional in relation with the city itself.

shops

P PLACE OF LIVING house / apartmant

What makes Crevalcore different from other places?

PLACE OF LEISURE

EARTHQUAKE, a reflection starting from the concept of emergency, intended as lack or deprivation of one of the main qualities of the human being. The house, intended as a place hosting the different human activities: domestic, work, recreational and aggregative ones. The project starts from these premises, that is to say the reactivation of all these procedures which are replaced in the historical fabric of the ancient city; through a modular matrix, the town thus becomes a new architecture. The minimum house module becomes the cornerstone of the proposal which investigates the concept of minimum living, first as an answer to an emergency (tent, container, prefabricated building), second as a driving force for a new settlement.

cafè restaurant library garden

OTHER furniture

SOIL/GROUND PROJECT parking

In relation to the transformations of the old town centre the main axis, which is no more vehicular, is now reserved to cycles and pedestrians. Through the use of different materials and permeability, it defines a soil/ground able to recognise the limits of the new public areas, the road and the standing zone, by replacing the car parks in relation to the new configuration of the project.

project ground project green

COURTS PROJECT By observing the historical fabric of the ancient city we can recognise the presence of empty spaces (courts, open areas…) which integrate the existing buildings. The project aims to value, to requalify and to preserve these places, by imagining them as interest points/points of interest compared to the new functional plan.

TIPOLOGY A

MODULAR LIVING_1254

Honorable mentions - GOLD 11

Honorable mentions - GOLD

neighb o rho o d

Honorable mentions 13

MINERAL

SQUARE

LANDSCAPED GARDEN

FOUR LANDMARKS: E N T R A N C E S

INTERVENTION PROJECT

EXISTENT

SATELLITES: INVASIONS OF ANCIENT BUILDINGS TWO DIFFERENTS TYPES OF INSERTIONS

PAVILIONS: DIALOGUE WITH CONTEXT

DIALECTIC 3. LIONS AND

PAVISATELLITES

HISTORICAL NEUTRAL APPROACH

Pavilions are located between mineral-based and green environments. The historic arches are preserved all along the street but these are divided into two directions to bring the pedestrian inside the core of the block made up of garden space. These buildings develop a dialogue with the context around them. In opposition, satellites could be termed invasions of the ancient buildings. The rehabilitation of and extensions to existing buildings allows for a dialogue to be set up between two different programs. The project becomes the means for bringing together the analytical tools of context and programmatic diversity. The goal of these dialectics is to integrate a new architecture that is capable of blending ancient heritage with contemporary spaces and uses.

DIALECTIC 5. DIALOGUE WITH THE CONTEXT OR INVASIONS OF ANCIENT BUILDING

The abstract facades stand in bold contrast to the historical elevations. The widely recognizable Roman layout which formed the basis of this city should not engender a pastiche project but rather should lead to a different perception of the elements: building proportions, facades and the arches which shape the Crevalcore urban landscape. These elements are the foundations of future buildings. The modular grid of facades is determined by the need to provide light for the program inside. There are three kinds of grids: ‘aerated’ - which take the arches as a model for public circulation; ‘intermediate’ - for public programs; and ‘tight’ - for private programs inside the building. This system allows for adaptations for any need that arises.

DIALECTIC 4. AND ARCHITECTURAL

The different sizes and positions of the voids determine the spatial partition of the programs. The big plots are the sites of the main buildings (pavilions) while the smaller plots preserve the existing buildings, which will be rehabilitated and expanded upon by a different structure in order to form a programmatic duality (satellites). Each pavilion has an associated public space: a mineral square which extends up to the main street and a landscaped garden in the heart of the block. These five pavilions are designed to accommodate a cultural centre, a shopping center, a hotel, research facilities and an entertainment area. The satellites are annexes of these buildings designed to expand the reach of the pavilions’ programs to throughout the whole city.

FRAGMENTED AXONOMETRY: SATELLITES: CONFERENCE ROOMS (IN NEW BUILDING) AND SUITES OF HOTEL (IN ANCIENT BUILDING)

NEW BUILDING: R E C E P T I O N CONFERENCE ROOM - ANCIENT BUILDING R E C E P T I O N S U I T E S FLOOR 1

- ANCIENT BUILDING S U I T E S FLOOR 2

NEW BUILDING: CONFERENCE ROOM FLOOR 3

FRAGMENTED AXONOMETRY: PAVILION OF RESEARCH FACILITIES

R E C E P T I O N C A F E T A R I A EXPERIMENTATION HALL FLOOR 1

L ABORATORIES O F F I C E S EXPERIMENTATION HALL FLOOR 2

L ABORATORIES O F F I C E S EXPERIMENTATION HALL FLOOR 3

COMMON AREAS EXPERIMENTATION HALL FLOOR 4

The main street, the axis of the project, has to contain landmarks and city limits. Four high volumes, the same height as the church tower, form the skyline of the city and are adjacent to three squares: the entrances (city limits) and center.

DIALECTIC 2. ENTRANCES AND CENTER

The first operation of this project was identifying the dialectic between void and solid in the historic city. All along the street, the earthquake created an alternation that goes against the uniformity of ancient city. Today, the program of repairing Crevalcore must take this new landscape into consideration. Voids should be replaced by a new uniform system consisting of mixed programs.

DIALECTIC 1. VOIDS AND SOLIDS

What is the role of architecture in a world of entropy? Our built environment decays; our cultural traditions decay. In this world, architecture is neither the physical object of stone upon stone, nor the spatial voids formed by the stacking of stone upon stone; it is the armature of the in-between and the framework of a yet unanswered question of history. In this context, what position can hold up to the paradoxical relationship of old, new and the process of decay? The architectural intervention within this context inevitably must take on a light touch, respecting the projections of the historical and cultural, while actualizing the present condition. Extending from this thought, how might the architectural interventions of the urban landscape – a theater of the new – be reduced? Un Teatro del Nuovo attempts such a reduction, utilizing the simplest of architectural tools – the line – made manifest in one of the most banal architectural systems – the scaffolding. An infinite potential unfolds from its open-end application. But what form could such a system take? In this framework, the line might become an icon, a cultural archetype, an event or a platform for narrative unfolding. Could the rich history of Italy be summed up in a singular reading? Why should it be? From the line, a vast number of moments might emerge: the Cyclorama, the Shakespearean – Romeo and Juliet Tower, the Marionette, the Opera, the Cinema, the Divine Comedy, the Basilica. These archetypal projections become spatial experience. The simplicity of the line moves throughout the city, reinforcing the degradation of the existing without masking it. History is placed on display – a performance – reactivated through a re-invigoration of the layers of the urban landscape: above, within and below.

Un Teatro del Nuovo_

THE ALTERNATION BETWEEN ANCIENT CITY AND NEW SYSTEM INTRODUCED ALL ALONG THE MAIN STREET

SUPERPOSITION OF THE ANCIENT AND NEW BUILDING: PAVILIONS (LEFT) AND SATELLITES (RIGHT)

ENTRANCES - CENTER - LANDMARKS

THE NEW SKYLINE OF CREVALCORE

THE CENTER SQUARE OF CREVALCORE WITH THE ANIMATION FROM THE CULTURAL CENTER

BUILDINGS

TIMELESS URBAN DIALECTIC

Honorable mentions SHOPPING CENTER: SHOPS/ SERVICES/ RESTAURANTS

Cyclorama

HOTEL FOR TRAVELLING RESEARCHERS / MUSEUM OF EMILIAROMAGNA ENDOWMENT

RESEARCH FACILITIES: OFFICES/ EXPERIMENTATION HALL/ LABORATORIES

CONFERENCE ROOMS/ SUITES OF HOTEL

SPA / DELICATESSEN OF EMILIA-ROMAGNA SPECIALITIES

CULTURAL MULTIMEDIA EXHIBITION

DIGITAL PHOTOGRAPHY LAB / ART LIBRARY

Theatre Seating

CENTRE: LIBRARY/ CENTRE

ENTERTAINMENT AREA: SWIMMING POOL/ SPORTS ROOM/ CINEMA

Danteum

ARTIST STUDIOS / ARTIST RESIDENCY

HOTEL: BEDROOMS/ DINING ROOM/ LOUNGE

1420

Marionette

CREVALCORE’S SECTION / ELEVATION - SCALE 1.1000

CREVALCORE’S BASEMENT PLAN - SCALE 1.1000

PROGRAMMATIC AXONOMETRY: PAVILIONS AND SATELLITES

C O M M E R C I A L

R E S E A R C H

C U L T U R A L

E N T E RTA I N M E N T

S A T E L L I T E S

P A V I L I O N S

RESEARCH EXHIBITIONS / GARDEN SHOP

1476

//IL CARDO SPINA DORSALE

THE SPINE OF THE STREET GIACOMO MATTEOTTI

DIAGRAM PROCESS URBAN CONNECTION CONNECTION URBAN CONNECTION URBANURBAN CONNECTION URBAN CONNECTION

daecumanus

cardo

daecumanus

FORUM

ANTIQUE CITY ANTIQUE CITY ANTIQUE CITY ANTIQUE CITYANTIQUE +1 +1CITY +1 daecumanus

cardo

daecumanus

Honorable mentions

VIEW THROUGH THE FORUM AND THE CITY COUNCIL

daecumanus daecumanus

RESTRUCTURING OF THE CITY COUNCIL

cardo cardo cardo

daecumanus

CROSS SECTION Ech.1/500

«FORUM» GROUND FLOOR PLAN Ech.1/1 500

cardo cardo cardo

daecumanus daecumanus

HOTEL

FORUM FORUM CONNECTION FORUM FORUM FORUM TERRITORY CONNECTION TERRITORY TERRITORY CONNECTION TERRITORY CONNECTION TERRITORY CONNECTION

FORUM FORUM FORUM

AFTER SEISM AFTER SEISM AFTER SEISMAFTERAFTER SEISM SEISM

daecumanus

Crevalcore city, founded in the 13rd century, has a particular post-seismic project situation. Beyond a simple restoration, it raises the question of preservation with a special care of historic memory transmission. This project will be based on a first observation regarding the important patrimonial value of the city, arousing an approach of preservation, and thus, of support. In a second place, the project will be intensifying and will reveal the city´s configuration and layout, in the archetypal charateristics of the antique city. First of all, The project will propose a global answer by implanting a vertebral column to the Giacomo Matteotti street forming the cardo. This one is composed by an important concrete arched structure enabling the structural support of all the distorted buildings. The classical feature of the arche has been borrowed for its structural qualities of crossing of long ranges. Beyond a technical answer, it intensifies the cardo of the city creating a new wandering and a fresh eye on the city with a spaces hierarchy. The dialogue between the existing front and the project will enable to highlight and to agtgrave the current rhythm of the arches on the ground floor. Like a body living, the backbone will develop arborescences supporting the city. Moreover, the project will answer a burning question, the densification of historical centers in order to fight against the urban spreading. Indeed, the squeleton will enable to support light extensions, made in wood, put on roofs and will underline various horizontal strata of the city construction. The distorted buildings will be restored to welcome cultural equipments, media libraries and showrooms as we care about revitalizing the old center. The city hall building will be entierely rehabilitated to welcome a market place on several levels. The ground floor, open on the city, will create a continuity with the San Silvestro Church square, surrounded by mobile businesses. This central space will embody the forum of the antique city. This project is founded on a global process, adapting itself to specific situations, and may be compared with a urban sewing approach. It cannot be reduced to a formal or technical scale, it integrates the patrimonial, human, economic and poetic context in favour of the urban wandering. Plus, its evolutionary feature will allow potential densifications in the future.

+1+1+1

FORTIFICATION FORTIFICATION FORTIFICATION FORTIFICATION FORTIFICATION

HALL MARKET CITY COUNCIL

HOTEL

LONG DISTANCE LONG DISTANCE LONG DISTANCE LONG DISTANCE LONG DISTANCE

DENSIFICATION DENSIFICATION DENSIFICATION DEN

CULTURAL LABORATORIES CENTER

STREET GIACOMO MATTEOTTI

PLAN OF OPERATIONS

GLOBAL ELEVATION

WEST EAST ELEVATION

//TEAM NUMBER 1469

FINALIST PROPOSALS