www.windscorner.com
A Different Kind of Slow Practice Gerald Klickstein “Slow practice can establish habits that are completely unrelated to the coordination demanded for speed.” –Abby Whiteside, pianist (The Musician’s Way, p. 48) All of us acknowledge the value of slow practice: by working at deliberate tempos, we cultivate the ease that allows for speed. Why is it, then, that some rising musicians who practice slowly can’t bring their material up to tempo? Simply put, some forms of slow practice support rapid execution, and others don’t. Here are five ways to ensure that our slow practice instills the habits necessary for high-velocity performance. 1. Sense Movement Groups To execute quickly, depending on our instrument, we have to move our fingers, tongue, or other body parts in series of movements that I term ‘movement groups.’ Problem is, at slow tempos, we run the risk of feeling from note to note instead of moving in the integrated gestures required by up-tempo music. So it’s crucial that, when we work slowly and as we increase speed, we sense the same movement groups we’ll rely on at our final tempos. For instance, if a pianist practices a left-hand arpeggio using fingers 5-3-2-1, she would typically want to feel the fingers fall on the keys in a single movement sequence rather than conceiving of four unrelated finger actions. 2. Express Emotional Details Those movement groups we feel must also convey the emotional fabric of our music. Yet I’ve observed that many students will become inexpressive when they execute slowly, even though they know that emotionless practice embeds unmusical habits. Therefore, it’s vital that, during slow, deep practice, we expressively shape the passages we’re refining. If a string player zeroes in on a tricky left-hand shift, let’s say, he would be wise to adjust his metronome to a slow tempo and play with all of the dynamics, accents, articulations, and tone colors called for by the larger phrase. 3. Chunk It In tandem with feeling movement groups and expressive shapes, we also need to conceive of musical gestures as whole entities – chunks. In this way, even when we execute rapidly, our mind moves at an unhurried pace. But, again, with slow practice, we can unwittingly start thinking in bits, which won’t allow us to perform easily up to speed. Revisiting that piano example, if the left-hand fingers played continuous 16th-notes in a 4/4 measure at a brisk tempo, the pianist would usually want to perceive of the entire measure as one unit as opposed to thinking in four distinct beats.
www.windscorner.com 4. Feel Ahead With our chunks in place, to establish fluency, we must now sense upcoming chunks as we execute. Such “feeling ahead” is one of the hidden skills that expert musicians employ that commonly goes unnoticed by non-experts. In fact, I’ve found that students need frequent reminders to feel impending chunks as they play or sing; for some reason, their ‘feel ahead’ switches can be in the ‘off’ position, and they won’t notice. So let’s be vigilant during slow and fast practice that, as we mold transcendent phrases, we also direct ourselves with an inner conductor – seeing, hearing, feeling, thinking, and imagining ahead as we navigate the musical landscape. 5. Modify the Rate of Change One of the most useful techniques I know for bringing intricate material up to tempo involves slowing the rate of change instead of the tempo (see pages 62-65 of The Musician’s Way for an illustration). Take that piano example – running 16th-notes in a 4/4 measure played by the left hand – and suppose that the chords changed on every beat: • The musician could play the left hand alone near the final tempo, but repeat each chord 4 times. • When that felt easy, each chord could be repeated 2 or 3 times. • Following that, the pianist might play the first chord once and then repeat the subsequent one. • When various combinations of single and repeated chords became effortless, the pianist would play each chord once, mentally chunking the entire measure and feeling one measure ahead.