A2
OPINION
THE HOYA
friDAY, April 27, 2012
THE FINAL VERDICT
C
EDITORIALS THE LAST WORD The prevailing themes of the last eight months illustrate a year of contradictions. On the one hand, arbitration of the Campus Plan and student activism were troublingly passive. In contrast, GUSA elections and the university’s attitude toward its endowment experienced marked changes. Here now is our final word on the eventful 2011-2012 school year.
Catholic Identity Crisis The status of Georgetown’s Catholic and Jesuit identities has fueled a contentious debate throughout this year. Although extensive, these deliberations were not excessive. Rather, they are an example of exactly the kind of constant self-reflection our university needs. In February, a government professor, Patrick Deneen listed Georgetown’s transition from a liberal arts college invested in student development to a specialized, research-driven institution among his reasons for accepting a job at Notre Dame. Deneen’s comments created controversy over whether Georgetown was transitioning from a Jesuit university to a trade school. President Obama’s birth control mandate in March was also seen by some as a challenge to Georgetown’s Catholic roots, prompting further campus discussion. These conversations were valuable for Georgetown, but we believe that Georgetown’s fundamental values are not in jeopardy, as Deneen and others have suggested. Georgetown has not departed from its traditions — its Jesuit ideals are simply being adapted to the 21st century. If anything, the passage of service funding in Student Activities Fee Endowment reform, the election of Georgetown University Student Association executives who emphasized service and Catholic charity. And the strong Catholic-themed faculty response to Paul Ryan’s (R-Wis.) visit yesterday signal that Jesuit values are still a core aspect of life on campus. Georgetown’s emergence as a global research university — and ensuing debates about purpose and politics — should not be seen as a threat, but rather as an opportunity to uphold the Jesuit ideal of contemplation.
Students Sit Out Protests When Time Magazine named The Protester its 2011 Person of the Year, it almost certainly did not have Georgetown students in mind. As Occupy protests swept through college campuses across the country, the Hilltop remained noticeably tranquil. When Occupy D.C. was gaining momentum in October, many students from D.C. colleges participated. Few students, however, were from Georgetown. More recently, there has been disappointingly little activity concerning the racially infused death of Trayvon Martin last February. Although various campus groups have taken initiative on this issue, discussion should have gone beyond race-focused organizations. We are not suggesting that the Georgetown community should have taken a particular stance on these matters. We are disappointed, however, that the campus generally appears to have sat out these debates. Students have a responsibility as D.C. residents to engage with issues that concern both the nation and the international community during our four years on the Hilltop. While Georgetown remained markedly absent from local protests, students and alumni abroad have done a better job of making their voices heard amid international conflicts. In early November, Matthew VanDyke (GRD ’04) returned from Libya after spending eight turbulent months between prison and the battlefield. Later that month, Derrik Sweeney (COL ’13) was arrested after joining protesters in Cairo and emerged from the experience with remarkable resilience. We recognize VanDyke and Sweeney’s courage in involving themselves in international issues, even if their discretion can be called into question. Their activism exemplifies the conscientiousness Georgetown should show toward others, both at home and abroad.
Capital Campaign Launches “We’re very proud of the fact that we use our dollars well,” Provost James O’Donnell said last September when asked about Georgetown’s relatively small endowment. “We like to say that we punch above our weight.” The university, however, made an about-face on that position in October, launching a historic capital campaign designed to raise $1.5 billion for the school’s endowment over 10 years. Georgetown’s endowment is one of the smallest among U.S. News and World Report’s top 25 colleges. The campaign launched after Georgetown slipped one spot to 22nd in those rankings. The university correctly recognizes that contemporary universities need a healthy endowment, and the focus on “generations to come” is admirable. But some of the collection methods being used, including soliciting donations from recent alumni and the families of current students, are insensitive to both the current economic situation and the 3.5 percent tuition hike announced in February. Georgetown has already raised $840 million in this campaign, an admirable achievement. We are rooting for the university to reach its goal and thrive in the future, but we urge the school to remain sensitive in its pursuit of monetary gifts.
Paradigm Shift for GUSA This year’s GUSA campaigns may have redefined what we come to expect from our student government. The candidates in this year’s election were numerous and diverse: a record-high seven tickets, which included not only active members of GUSA, but also a variety of student leaders and a men’s varsity basketball player, all vying for the executive office. The campaigns also featured an emphasis on meticulously detailed and extensive platforms that became almost a point of parody. This came as an appreciated shift from the personality-driven campaigns of the past. What most set this year’s election apart, however, was a record-high voter turnout. While the increased number of voters was due in part to the tickets’ abilities to get their core supporters to the polls, this is not necessarily a negative. The strong turnout signifies greater student engagement, which in turn legitimizes GUSA. In all, this year demonstrated that the students of Georgetown are genuinely interested in who serves as their representatives. This, of course, places more pressure on the new executives, President Clara Gustafson (SFS ’13) and Vice President Vail KohnertYount (SFS ’13), to follow through on their campaign promises. GUSA has always wanted greater student engagement. Now it is up to them to perform.
Matthew Strauss, Campus News Editor Braden McDonald, City News Editor Evan Hollander, Sports Editor Victoria Edel, Guide Editor Danny Funt, Opinion Editor Leonel De Velez, Photography Editor Emory Wellman, Layout Editor Emily Perkins, Copy Chief Molly Mitchell, Multimedia Editor Michelle Cassidy, Blog Editor
Contributing Editors Kavya Devarakonda, Kathryn DeVincenzo, Meagan Kelly, Shakti Nochur, Eamon O’Connor, Michael Palmer, Mairead Reilly, Lauren Weber
Oct. 24
A Gray Perspective — D.C. Mayor Vincent Gray speaks out against GU’s 2010 Campus Plan at the Advisory Neighborhood Commission’s monthly meeting.
C
Bright Students Honored — A record high of 22 graduates receive the prestigious Fulbright Award for the 2011-2012 school year.
Nov. 8
Homecoming — Matthew VanDyke (GRD ’04) returns home after spending eight months in Libya, six of which were spent in a loyalist prison for fighting on the rebels’ side in the nation’s civil war.
C
Applications Skyrocket — The Office of Undergraduate Admissions announces that a record 20,050 applicants were received for the Class of 2016.
Oct. 28
C
Jan. 20
Disgruntled Deneen Departs — Professor Patrick Deneen Jan. 24 says he will resign at the end of the semester after seven years on the Hilltop for a position at the University of Notre Dame.
C
SAFE Reforms — All three proposals for the allocation of the $3.4 million Student Activities Fee Endowment are passed by a campus-wide vote.
Feb. 10
Love for Leo’s Workers — Employees of O’Donovan Hall establish a contract with Aramark that includes a $0.50 pay raise per hour and extended health benefits.
Jan 26
The Price Is Higher — Georgetown’s tuition is set to rise 3.5 percent.
Feb. 28
Rude Limbaugh — Conservative radio show host Rush Limbaugh harasses Sandra Fluke (LAW ’12) for participating in the national debate on contraceptives.
C
Making the Grade — Four of Georgetown’s professors are named among the Princeton Review’s top 300 professors.
C
Feb. 14
April 13
Technical Triumph — Georgetown’s mobile website launchApril 19 es, providing students with current news stories, GUTS bus schedules, dining hall menus and sports updates.
C
THE RAW DEAL by Anthony Mastroianni
Campus Plan Hits Stalemate Sixteen months, six zoning hearings and countless debates after the 2010 Campus Plan was first submitted, extended delays are preventing the university from moving on a path toward growth and development. While much of the plan relates to on-campus improvements, the entire process has been delayed due to neighborhood resistance. Locals insist that the university house every student on campus — a demand totally devoid of compromise — and their antagonism has led to a frustrating stalemate in the approval process. Georgetown is the District’s largest private employer, and the university’s expansion should be welcomed, not fought. Neighbors’ calls for the D.C. Zoning Commission to reject the plan have put the commission in an uncomfortable position: It must either order Georgetown to stop its growth or fly in the face of local opinion. Based on the number of times the commission’s decision has been delayed, it appears that they are content with doing neither. In the meantime, despite a series of significant compromises made by the university, Georgetown is in limbo as it waits through postponement after postponement of a final decision. Just as our 2000 Campus Plan was rejected and later appealed before passing, we’d like to see the process move forward, one way or another, rather than continue down this road of inaction.
Connor Gregoire, Editor-in-Chief Sarah Kaplan, Executive Editor Steven Piccione, Managing Editor
Sept. 23
C
Founded January 14, 1920
It’s About Time — AD Lee Reed announces plans to build a new 125,000-square-foot athletic facility.
Emma Hinchliffe Sarah Patrick Kelly Church Sam Rodman Arik Parnass Matt Carlucci Ryan Bacic Phoebe Lett Hunter Main Jamie Slater Hanaa Khadraoui Sari Frankel Zoe Bertrand Jessica Natinsky Nikita Buley Kendall Ciesemier Martin Hussey
Deputy Campus News Editor Deputy Campus News Editor Deputy City News Editor Deputy Features Editor Deputy Sports Editor Deputy Sports Editor Sports Blog Editor Deputy Copy Editor Deputy Copy Editor Deputy Copy Editor Deputy Opinion Editor Deputy Photography Editor Deputy Layout Editor Deputy Layout Editor Graphics Editor Deputy Multimedia Editor Deputy Blog Editor
Editorial Board Danny Funt, Chair Kent Carlson, Sidney Chiang, Nneka Jackson, Hanaa Khadraoui, Laura Wagner
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR “Butterfield Criticism Inappropriate” — Michael Barclay (COL ’12)
“Honor Code Gets Bad Rap” — Emily Lurie (COL ’10) Available online at thehoya.com
Jonathan Rabar, General Manager James Church, Director of Finance Erica Hanichak, Director of Marketing Michael Grasso, Director of Personnel Mary Nancy Walter, Director of Sales Michael Vu, Director of Technology Caroline Boerwinkle Catherine Hendren Martha DiSimone Kelsey Zehentbauer John Bauke Molly Lynch Holly DiClemente Michal Grabias Keeley Williams Kent Carlson Michael Lindsay-Bayley Ryan Smith
Alumni Relations Manager Special Programs Manager Accounts Manager Operations Manager Statements Manager Treasury Manager Public Relations Manager Human Resources Manager Institutional Diversity Manager Local Advertisements Manager Online Advertisements Manager Web Manager
Board of Directors
Lauren Weber, Chair Pat Curran, Connor Gregoire, Jonathan Rabar, Mairead Reilly, Sam Schneider, Amanda Wynter
Policies & Information Letter to the Editor & Viewpoint Policies The Hoya welcomes letters and viewpoints from our readers and will print as many as possible. To be eligible for publication, letters should specifically address a recent campus issue or Hoya story. Letters should not exceed 300 words. Viewpoints are always welcome from all members of the Georgetown community on any topic, but priority will be given to relevant campus issues. Viewpoint submissions should be between 600-800 words. Send all submissions to: opinion@ thehoya.com. Letters and viewpoints are due Sunday at 5 p.m. for Tuesday’s issue and Wednesday at 5 p.m. for Friday’s issue. The Hoya reserves the right to reject letters or viewpoints and edit for length, style, clarity and accuracy. The Hoya further reserves the right to write headlines and select illustrations to accompany letters and viewpoints. Corrections & Clarifications If you have a comment or question about the fairness or accuracy of a story, contact Executive Editor Sarah Kaplan at (202) 687-3415 or email executive@ thehoya.com. News Tips Campus News Editor Matthew Strauss: Call (202) 687-3415 or email campus@ thehoya.com. City News Editor Braden McDonald: Call (202) 687-3415 or email city@thehoya.com. Sports Editor Evan Hollander: Call (202) 687-3415 or email sports@thehoya.com. General Information The Hoya is published twice each week during the academic year with the excep-
tion of holiday and exam periods. Address all correspondence to: The Hoya Georgetown University Box 571065 Washington, D.C. 20057-1065 The writing, articles, pictures, layout and format are the responsibility of The Hoya and do not necessarily represent the views of the administration, faculty or students of Georgetown University. Signed columns and cartoons represent the opinions of the author(s) and do not necessarily represent the editorial position of The Hoya. Unsigned essays that appear on the left side of the editorial page are the opinion of the majority of the editorial board. Georgetown University subscribes to the principle of responsible freedom of expression for student editors. The Hoya does not discriminate on the basis of age, gender, sexual orientation, race, disability, color, national or ethnic origin. © 1920-2012. The Hoya, Georgetown University twice weekly. No part of this publication may be used without the permission of The Hoya Board of Editors. All rights reserved. The Hoya is available free of charge, one copy per reader, at distribution sites on and around the Georgetown University campus. Additional copies are $1 each. Editorial: (202) 687-3415 Advertising: (202) 687-3947 Business: (202) 687-3947 Facsimile: (202) 687-2741 Email: editor@thehoya.com Online at www.thehoya.com Circulation: 6,500.