MAGAZINE CLUSTERNAUTS HAVE LANDED
Message from the (lighter side of the) moon
Learning Clusters Magazine is a recap of the conference week 12-16 October 2009.
THE TCI COMMUNITY The 350 that did it for the tribe
ALL BUSINESS REVIEWS Five top workshops revisited
The world according to Dr. Himanen
COFFEE TO GO! First look at the new TCI Cafe Madeline Smith: Learning Cluster // Patrick Dixon: Future now! // Doing things differently tomorrow // Patriciaâ€™s TOP 5
European Union European Regional Development Fund European Social Fund
12th TCI Annual Global Conference - Learning Clusters adapting to the new competitiveness scenario Jyväskylä, Finland, October 12-16 2009
ON THE COVER TCI COMMUNITY 31 Global Community at its best 42 Participants F=C3 14 The world according to Dr. Himanen ALL BUSINESS 18-23 Workhop reviews CLUSTERNAUTS HAVE LANDED 24 Message from the moon COFFEE TO GO 26 TCI cafe brought clustering challenges to the table
FEATURES 7 Editorial by Rauli Sorvari 8 Mission possible 9 Script notes 10 Personal goals 11 On my mind - Christian Ketels 12 Once you have seen the future you are
changed 15 On your tail: Clusternator Madeline Smith 15, 23, 32, 38 What I thought of today - Frank Waeltring 17 From academia to practice - Anu Tokila 21 Horror stories 29 Where do successful clusters come from? 30 Even if you have travelled far and wide 30 Off the beaten track 33 Classifieds - What are you going to do differently tomorrow? 34 General Manager’s Top 5 Moments
35 Next TCI Global Conference -
Message from H.E. Hani al Hamli
Next TCI events Just married Appointment news 37 Letters to the editor 40 Start of the journey - New TCI President 41 Anatomy of a Learning Cluster 45 Expertise from all over the world
EDITORS EDITOR-IN-CHIEF Rauli Sorvari, Regional Council of Central Finland EDITORS Anna Korpi, EduCluster Finland Katja Vuori, EduCluster Finland Mikko Markkanen, Business Arena Ltd. PHOTOS Matti Kovanen, CopperSky Ltd. Päivi Tervonen, Jyväskylä Regional Development Company, Jykes Ltd. CONTRIBUTORS Katja Vuori, EduCluster Finland Anna Korpi, EduCluster Finland Mikko Markkanen, Business Arena Ltd. Päivi Tervonen, Jyväskylä Regional Development Company, Jykes Ltd. Jutta Mattsson Anu Tokila, University of Jyväskylä Tiia Lehtinen, Business Arena Ltd. Frank Waeltring, mesopartner Toni Pienonen, University of Jyväskylä Madeline Smith, Ekos Ltd. Patricia Valnenebro, TCI Ifor Ffowcs-Williams, Cluster Navigators Ltd. Alexandra Friz, MFG BadenWûrttemberg
REGIONAL COUNCIL OF CENTRAL FINLAND
CREDITS HOSTS Executive Director Anita Mikkonen (Regional Council of Central Finland), Mayor Markku Andersson (City of Jyväskylä) CONFERENCE PROJECT TEAM Director Rauli Sorvari (ECF / Regional Council of Central Finland), Project Manager Anna Korpi (EduCluster Finland), Programme Design Mikko Markkanen (Business Arena Ltd.), Satu Heikkinen (City of Jyväskylä), TCI General Manager Patricia Valdenebro (TCI Secretariat), Leire Oiarbide (TCI Secretariat), Luis Ferreres Caro (TCI Secretariat) WEBSITE PRODUCTION AND GRAPHIC DESIGN Preoni Ltd., CEO Teemu Kettula, AD Kristian Hohkavaara, Web Developer Antti Okkonen LEARNING CLUSTERS NEWS Päivi Tervonen (Jyväskylä Regional Development Company), Jutta Mattsson, Susanna Mäkinen (Jyväskylä Regional Development Company), Tiia Lehtinen (Business Arena Ltd.), Project Manager Katja Vuori (JAMK University of Applied Sciences) PHOTOGRAPHY Matti Kovanen (Coppersky Ltd.) VIDEO PRODUCTION Neo Kekkonen, Titta Lapinkataja, Kyösti Vilkuna HUMAP TOOL - INTERACTION TOOLS AND ONLINE DIALOGUE IN MAIN CONFERENCE Humap Software Ltd., Pertti Siekkinen MODERATOR Erkki Toivanen FACILITATORS Eeva-Liisa Vihinen (Humap Ltd.), Elise Tarvainen (Regional Council of Central Finland), Vilma Väisänen (Partus Ltd.), Elina Humala (Jyväskylä Regional Development Company), Tapio Kymäläinen (DialogueLife Ltd.) PROJECT AIDE TEAM Unelmania / Team Academy, Niku Raatikainen, Noora Kärki, Jussi Tervonen, Päivi Pekkala, Minna Janhonen, Eeva Kinnunen Mervi Narinen REGISTRATION AND BOOKING SERVICE Jyväskylä Booking, Outi Kiviranta REMAINING MEMBERS OF LEARNING CLUSTERS PLANNING TEAM Elise Tarvainen (Regional Council of Central Finland), Merja LahtI (Regional Council of Central Finland), Elina Humala (Jyväskylä Regional Development Company), Taija Lappeteläinen (Jyväskylä Regional Development Company), Päivi Tervonen (Jyväskylä Regional Development Company), Aimo Pellinen (JAMK University of Applied Sciences), Pirjo Kauhanen ( Jyväskylä Educational Consortium) ACADEMIC SUMMIT SCIENTIFIC COMMITTEE rofessor Matti Koiranen (University of Jyväskylä), Project Manager Anu Tokila (University of Jyväskylä), Research Coordinator Mika Haapanen (University of Jyväskylä), Professor Hannu Tervo (University of Jyväskylä), Professor Marja-Leena Stenström (University of Jyväskylä), Leading researcher Jari Ritsilä (University of Jyväskylä) FINNISH CENTRE OF EXPERTISE PROGRAMME COOPERATION Pirjo Kutinlahti (Finnish Ministry of Employment and the Economy) CLUSTER TOURS Jukka Vilppola (Jyväskylä Educational Consortium), Markku Paananen (JAMK University of Applied Sciences), Pekka Matinaro (Jyväskylä Regional Development Company, Jykes Ltd.), Pirjo Nikku (Jyväskylä Innovation Ltd.), Ilpo Kuronen (Kuopio Innovation Ltd.), Reetta Airaksinen (Kuopio innovation Ltd.), Karen Thorburn (Hermia Ltd.), Tiia Koskinen (Hermia Ltd.), Miikka Raulo (JAMK University of Applied Sciences) TCI BOARD OF DIRECTORS Juan Manuel Esteban (Basque Government), Alberto Pezzi (Generalitat de Catalunyua), Elisabeth Waelbroeck-Rocha (BIPE), Alonso Ramos Vaca (Desarrollo Económico del Estado de Chihuahua A.C.), Arthur Bayhan (Competitiveness Support Fund), Christian Ketels (Institute of Strategy and Competitiveness, Harvard Business School), Kevin Murphy (JE Associates), Klaus Haasis (MFG Baden-Württemberg mbH), Nigel Gwynne-Evans (Economic Development & Tourism), Carlos Alvarez (Chilean Economic Development Agency), Barnabas Nawangwe (Makerere University)
Adapting to the new competitiveness scenario When starting with the production of the 12th TCI Annual Global Conference, three different themes defined its contents and the working methods. The first was the status of the world economy and the work on competitiveness development that has been based on the model by Professor Michael E. Porter. Secondly, the current question in the cluster policy debate is where are we now and how can we raise the level of clusters. The third starting point was further strengthening the global cluster and innovation expert network of TCI. Following the thinking of Professor Porter, the global and local economies are in a chaos of change. The business environment is defined by the shortage of investments, unemployment and the significant changes in the labour market. Employment and the skill needs are evolving. The demand in many sectors has collapsed, but at the same time most markets are becoming global. There is an even stronger need to build global networks. It thefore seems that all the structures in the economy are on the move all at once. The Cluster Initiative Greenbook divides different aspects of cluster initiatives into four categories: settings, objectives, process and performance. The results and discussions of the 12th TCI Annual Global Conference can be mirrored against these categories. All four are in transition and as a result, they can be defined with some new contents and weights. Moreover, the typical elements of competitiveness can be complemented with some of the concepts of learning region. These are the ability to manage change, to innovate faster and to cooperate in a more productive manner especially in the global markets. Networks emphasize the challenges of learning in communities and the ability and flexibility to change. These are some of the ideas behind the theme Learning Clusters. In the working methods of the conference we wanted to maximize the possibilities for sharing knowledge and exchange of experiences. Based on the great amount of documentation we have tried to produce some of the most interesting elements into this Learning Clusters Magazine. Unfortunately we have been able to bring forth only a fraction of all the discussions from the week. In addition to some views from Jyväskylä, the new scenario and the contents of the Learning Clusters concept will be summarised in the conclusions. We hope that this report serves as a reminder of some of the discussions and themes from the conference and will help you keep the important work going towards more successful competitiveness stories. I would like to personally extend my warmest thanks to all the participants, the speakers, the facilitators, the friends of TCI network and the members of EduCluster Finland network. All of you made the conference and the goals a reality. The work goes on – let’s keep the enriching interaction going!
Rauli Sorvari Programme Manager Rauli Sorvari has been meritorious in the long-term strategic development of education and knowledge development services within the region of Central Finland. He has been the person behind the development of a local emerging cluster, EduCluster Finland over the past years and the leader of many internationalisation processes to strengthen the global operating capacity of the region in different sectors, networks and ventures. Before his public service responsibilities, he has a long career in business and a distinguished experience from being an entrepreneur. Rauli Sorvari has also acted as the contact person of Regional Council of Central Finland in the TCI network and was the person responsible for the production of the 12th TCI Annual Global Conference.
Rauli Sorvari Regional Council of Central Finland / EduCluster Finland
12th TCI Annual Global Conference - Learning Clusters adapting to the new competence scenario
LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE 7
Mission possible When we got the call from TCI president on January 22nd 2009 and my boss Rauli Sorvari asked me whether or not I thought we could do it in about a half a year, I didn’t quite know what I was saying yes or no to. I must admit that I went back to that day more than once... Needless to say, the eight months prior to the conference were rather hectic for our core team but it all paid off in the end – thanks to all of you! The name and theme of the TCI Global Conference 2009 was defined as Learning Clusters – adapting to the new competitiveness scenario. Thinking of the current economic situation, the constant need for change and the factors that build the competitiveness of clusters, we wanted to stress learning as a key tool to face the challenges. We likewise wanted to play with the idea of clusters as networked learning organisations - learning clusters. As we went along with the programme production, we went kept with this idea of learning as one of the possible strategies to overcome challenges. The workshop themes - vision and leadership, the added value of clusters, the interaction and learning in networks, innovation processes in clusters and the aptitude to identify new business opportunities - are common for all clusters regardless of the field of activity. Similarly, you participants, the cluster and competitiveness practitioners, know best the challenges of this field, so we wanted to make the most of that vast pool of experience present in Jyväskylä 12-16 October 2009. We built the programme and the workshops in a different way than in past conferences to facilitate this joint learning process.
Str Person: Date:
ECF Anna K 11.10.2009
Background information Age 28 Height (cm) 167 Weight (kg) 62 Resting heart rate 45 Maximum heart rate 192 Body Mass Index 22,2
Measurement information Measurement length 101:35:52 Measurement time 9:36:05 - 15:11:57 Lowest heart rate 49 Highest heart rate 171 Average heart rate 85 mod maanantai Notes
Stress and Recovery Chart
Looking back, some of our ideas worked beautifully, some need more work. Therefore, the conference production has been an effective learning process for us all. We hope you got as much out of it as we did! 12:00
On behalf of the Learning Cluster Organising team,
Journal markers (No tasks given.)
Light physical activity
Other physiological states
Duration and proportion(%) of stress, recovery, physical activity and ot
Stress reactions (stress) Increase in alertness and level of activation caused by e Recovery Decrease in level of activation caused by a decrease or Physical activity Time periods with physical activity higher than 30% of V Light physical activity Time periods with physical activity lower than 30% of VO Other physiological states Physical states that are not detected as indicating phys
8 LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE
Script notes Production of the 12th TCI conference began long before there was knowledge that the global conference will be held in Jyväskylä. Production team was gathered first to make a much more local conference, but roughly at the same time and for the same target group. Before any practical issues or anything else was done, the project organisation team held three workshops together with a larger design team of different experts. The design process was based on the expertise of the members of EduCluster Finland, especially Business Arena Ltd. The main focus of these sessions was in two things, to define the goals of the week and to sketch out the working process of the conference. As setting goals it is one of the most important elements in all planning, we were thinking of what the goals of the conference are for the participant, the learner, for TCI, for the organisers and other stakeholders. The goal was ambitiously set to ‘creating the concept of a Learning Cluster’ and this was then broken into different points of view, later defining the themes of the workshops. The next step was to create the learning process. This means creating a ‘skeleton model’ of a program, a step-by-step picture about the event (see the scheme on the right). What kind of big issues need to be handled and in what order? The first half of the process was drafted to be the opening and broadening the field of vision, then the moment of total chaos. The latter parts of the process were built to close things and bring it into closure. In detail the working phases of the workshops were structured according to the Nonaka and Takeuchi SECI-model of knowledge transfer and knowledge creation: Sharing information, identifying patterns, finding new models, testing the new solutions. To enhance the experiences of different participants, we played a kind of role-play. The design team was divided into three groups and each wrote a story of why and how a certain character would come to this conference and what would he / she experience. These stories were then put together with the skeleton model and the programme outline was drafted. Many of the not-so-conventional elements of the programme came from these workshops, like the idea of the night track. These stories affected also some of the services, for example the ‘people’-section on conference website was born from them. After this, the designed learning process and the programme structure evolved some over time with more and more people getting involved into the production. But the goals and structure remained the same. 12th TCI Annual Global Conference - Learning Clusters adapting to the new competence scenario
LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE 9
PERSONAL GOALS: “If you want to make God laugh, tell him about your goals”
Tatchawan Kanitpong Graduate School of Business Administration NIDA, Thailand ”I am here because I want to learn more about clusters. We have a quite new cluster starting in Thailand, and I think we need some new tools to make it work better.”
Henna Gustafsson Jyväskylä Regional Development Company Jykes Ltd, Finland “I want to find out more information on cluster development and new trends around the world as well as networking and finding and interesting co-operation for future projects.
Kare Casals Kainuun Etu Ltd, Finland ”My goal is to find new ideas for the clusters development. This conference has confirmed some of my thoughts already.”
John Fredy Pulgarin Sierra Chamber of Commerce of Medellin for Antioquia, Colombia “I hope through knowledge transfer that takes place at the conference we can apply some learning experiences from other clusters to ours.”
Barnabas Nawanwge Makerere University, Uganda ”I have heard a lot of stories about Finland, especially success stories. I came to find out what magic does Finland and finnish people have, because they can make clusters work for the benefit of bisnes and society.” Simone Hagenauer The Business Agency of Lower Austria Ltd., Austria ”My goal is to find potential partners for future cluster co-operation, mainly in the fields of energy efficient construction & rehabilitation, plastics, food, logistics.” Nicholas Szechenyi Europa InterCluster, France “My goal is to meet cluster managers to better understand the challenges that they are facing.”
10 LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE
Peter Chisawillo Tanzania Private Sector Foundation, Tanzania “I am looking forward to learning from the experience of others on how Clusters can accelerate economic development and if they can provide resilience to economic turmoil.” Kaushik Mukherjee, Karnataka State Financial Corporation, India “I am eagerly looking forward to learning more about the mechanics of clusters, and in this salubrious Finnish autumn, hope to find an answer to the question that has been troubling me for ages: Do the members of a cluster nurture or destroy each other in the long run?”
On my mind - TCI Director Christian Ketels When TCI was launched a decade ago, clusters were still a relatively new concept for economic development professionals. At the time, one of main goals of TCI was thus to inform policy makers of the potential this approach had, to encourage more cluster efforts to be launched. Since then, the environment has dramatically changed. In Europe and many parts of North America there is hardly a region that does not have some sort of cluster effort. And the idea is catching on elsewhere, from Latin America to Asia to Africa. But support is, of course, not unilateral. And it turns out that looking at how criticism has changed over time can actually tell us quite a bit on how we can improve further improve the quality of cluster efforts. The traditional concern about cluster policies was focused on the possible distortions they might introduce. For most countries that have used cluster policy this argument has lost considerable weight in the last few years. If there were distortionary effects, they tended to be much smaller than for most other policies that would have been used instead. Cluster efforts turned out to be a way to engage in sector-specific policies in a way that was much less distortive then the traditional industrial policies. One reason is the difference in scope: while traditional policies focused on individual companies or narrow industries, cluster efforts encompass a broader set of related industries and companies. This leads to much less distortion among companies that are in narrow competition for customers or input. The other reason is the nature of the policy tools employed: cluster support tends to come in the form of subsidies for collaboration, investment, or demand, while traditional industrial support used targeted credit or temporary shelter
from competition. But while cluster efforts have been less distortive than initially feared, it remains the case that in countries with weaker institutional structures they can open a pandora’s box of intervention. In such a context, often present in emerging and developing economies, robust program structures are crucial to avoid cluster programs falling into this trap. The key concern about cluster policies now is on their actual impact. One argument focuses on the nature of cluster policy itself. Despite a number of years of experience with cluster policy, there remains a huge degree of vagueness about what it actually entails. Researchers from the new economic
The key concern about cluster policies now is on their actual impact.’
geography school have tended to see cluster policy as attempts to artificially “create agglomerations” to jump-start a process of then self-supporting cluster growth. The problem in this approach is that it is very hard for the government to determine where such jump-starting might work. And that is why most researchers are highly skeptical of such an approach. Researchers from the cluster school understand cluster policy very differently. They see it as ways to improve the competitiveness of naturally developing agglomeration by improving their internal collaboration, and by making public investments in business environment upgrading in intense dialogue with them. Agglomeration thus becomes a tool to make economic policy more effective, not an outcome that is directly targeted or created through government intervention. Seen this way, cluster policy is much less contentious, even
though differences in opinion about its potential remain. The other argument concerns the question whether cluster policy is sufficiently scalable. Looking at the experience with the impact of cluster efforts so far, most individual assessments of cluster programs come to quite positive conclusions. These efforts seem to generate beneficial results for the companies and regions involved. Much work still needs to be done on exactly tracking and quantifying the impact of cluster initiatives and programs, but that is the emerging consensus of program evaluations done so far. The problem for policy makers, however, is that success for the participants in a cluster initiative tends to be quantitatively small or even miniscule relative to the economic trajectory of a region or entire country. Can cluster policy be scaled up so that it starts having a meaningful impact at this higher level? There are a number of ideas on how to do this, but so far this remains one of the clear challenges cluster policy has to address over the coming years. It is an issue that tends to be beyond the scope of any individual cluster manager, trying to do the best possible job for his or her cluster. But for TCI as a group of practitioners it is something that we cannot ignore, if we do not want to put at risk the significant political support for cluster policies that currently exists in many countries.
Dr. Christian Ketels
is a Senior Research Fellow at the Stockholm School of Economics in Sweden and a member of the Harvard Business School faculty at Professor Michael E. Porter’s Institute for Strategy and Competitiveness.
12th TCI Annual Global Conference - Learning Clusters adapting to the new competence scenario LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE 11
IN THE ARENA
ONCE YOU HAVE SEEN THE FUTU YOU ARE CHANGED Are you out there enough?
12 LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE
IN THE ARENA
F ast U rban T ribal U niversal R adical E thical
URE, Patrick Dixon claims to linger mostly on the outer edge of the radar of future where risk and low probability rule the show. He challenged the participants to try to see the future and try to interpret the emergent signals through the six characteristics of the word future: fast, urban, tribal, universal, radical and ethic. According to him, every leader should be a futurist in their mindset and in their capacity to pick-up and react to signals. In his view, clusters can enable fast responses to the changing circumstances, but also clustering models need to deliver the results faster. There is no point in developing something for ten years and discovering that its market has vanished. It could be even worth pondering where the resources are best used, is it in R&D or the typical business and regional development or should we use the money in some other ways, better enabling the interpretation of the weak signals? Despite the work of futurists like Dixon, the dire fact is that there exist no wise men or women who can see the future from their crystal balls and tell the rest of us where to go next. So how is it possible to survive with the speed of changes? Dixon said that emotion and values are some of the key drivers now and in the future and that passion and commitment are some of the best ways to create something successful. He said that he has most commonly found the right combination of passion, motivation, radical thinking and speed in strategy in entrepreneurs, not in multinational corporations, certainly not in government.
12th TCI Annual Global Conference - Learning Clusters adapting to the new competence scenario LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE 13
IN THE ARENA
What do you say? ‘Pekka Himanen was a very refreshing speaker. Very good choice!’ ‘Maybe the content of Dixon´s presentation was a little bit too general, but very interesting anyway’ ‘Pekka Himanen speech impressed me immensely and taught me not to take anyones theory or a fact that even the whole world may believe in - for granted’
F=c3 Pekka Himanen compared Ella Fitzgerald and Count Basie’s jazz improvisation to creativity in clusters. He addressed creativity and competitiveness through the concept of enriching interaction where reciprocal appreciation, enthusiasm, a flow-like state and motivation coexist. These often self-born circumstances give rise to outstanding performances be it in jazz or in the development of information technology, highlighted by the example of Silicon Valley. Additionally Himanen wanted to draw attention to the power of creativity in overcoming challenges even when disparity in scale, the amount of resources or power structures seems overwhelming. According to him, it boils down to the clever use of resources – a circumstance not unknown to many SMEs. Success stories like Silicon Valley don’t exist everywhere, but it is possible to reach comparable effects in different scales. He saw the TCI Conference as a perfect opportunity for enriching interaction. ‘I want to highlight how unique opportunity this conference is. There are lots of people to meet from far away places. I surely hope that
14 LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE
‘Madeline Smith’s emphasis of being proactively and not reactively innovative, impressed me.’ people will stay in touch with each other after this’, said Himanen.
Where is the potential? Dan Steinbock challenged us about the same challenges of change and speed, but took the thinking most specifically to the cluster policy level. He reminded us that the recent economic recession has been created at the macro economic level but that also the micro economic level and most specifically the frameworks for developing competitiveness need to be adjusted accordingly. He raised the question that since the global economy has changed and will change significantly in the coming years that are the eyeglasses used for competitiveness development the wrong ones. The implications of change have been widely discussed but the reactions to the challenges are yet to be tuned. Steinbock challenged us to use clusters in clever ways and to look for the best possible potential, e.g. from the point of view of productivity increases instead of putting money where the money already is.
‘The key note speeches were very insightful and I came back home more challenged to ensure that the process here is better explained with the hope that it is fully embraced.’
IN THE ARENA
ON YOUR TAIL:
Clusternator Madeline Smith Madeline Smith’s keynote had the same title as the whole conference, ‘Learning Cluster’. So what do we mean by this phrase? How can clusters learn? Why should they learn? She explained why learning is so important in clusters. ‘Clusters have a great potential for learning, for making something more of the different knowledge and people in the network.’ Diverse groups learn quicker and perform better in changing circumstances and create a barrier for crisis for the companies involved in the cluster. She sees that some of the success factors include creating a so called future focus loop and especially the capacity for being proactive instead of just reacting to incoming challenges. It’s practically impossible to mould the ecosystem or the outside circumstances, but easier to try to coach the cluster and the operational culture to being more capable to face the challenges. The problem is how to create the circumstances for this kind of operational culture in clusters where different ideas, people, organizations, priorities and goals coexist. “You only need a small amount of distrust to break down the whole system”, said Madeline Smith highlighting the importance of trust in clusters and business networks.
What I thought of today Frank Waeltring, mesopartner How many real business companies involved in cluster initiatives are in this hall?, asked Patrick Dixon from Global Change Ltd. straight to the audience. “No, no, I do not mean the consultancy businesses who try to get some contracts during these days!”- “Nobody, ups! But do you not want to sell your regions to them, that they come to boost innovation in your localities? “ “When the world changes fast, keep looking further ahead” was the title of his lively, comedy and preacher style speech on the 3rd day plenum session. According to the Conference workbook Dixon is one of the leading international business consultants of multinational companies. Much more important is that he provided an insight into the business and change realities he works in. And if he talks he likes to put the finger into the wound: “The point why businesses are not here is: they just do not get your messages! Dixon is not only a good performer while running through the audience, changing slides like a maniac to reap burst of laughter form the listeners. 100s of nodding heads in the hall demonstrated that he speaks out what many others think but cannot say loudly in their daily work life. For me the main message he came up with, although not new but in a very straight way, was this one: “Businesses are the ones who are most innovative. And if we do not understand and talk to businesses, how will we understand innovation?” Clusters are not made by governments or public bodies, and we have to consider that in our daily life. What then is our role? We need to understand better the complexity of business processes and the changing environment in which businesses operate. Accordingly we ourselves have also to reflect about our promotion approaches, communication and facilitation formats with businesses.
is the Head of Innovation at Ekos Ltd where she works with innovation, cluster development and industry policy
12th TCI Annual Global Conference - Learning Clusters adapting to the new competence scenario LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE 15
First I was confused by the silent Finnsâ€Ś then I fell in love with them!
IN THE ARENA
FROM ACADEMIA TO PRACTICE Anu Tokila, University of Jyväskylä As a part of the main conference the Academic Summit concentrated crossdisciplinarily on academic aspects of learning clusters. The Summit hosted by the School of Business and Economics brought together up to 80 participants. The topics of the day dealt with learning clusters from several different aspects including their regional dimension, contribution to innovations and development of such clusters. The day was started with a keynote lecture by doctor Jukka Teräs from Scuola Superiore Sant´Anna, Pisa. With 20 years experience in the fields of high technology and regional development familiarized the audience with regional science-based clusters in non-metropolitan regions and what can we learn from them. During midday the participants had a pleasure to get acquainted with 15 interesting research cases from different countries. Audrey Leveque from Liege gave a presentation at the Innovation session about “Inter-organizational learning within innovation projects: critical stages, issues and good practices”. The project is run by a multi-
disciplinary team, who analyze the partnership collaboration in innovation projects within competitiveness clusters in the French-speaking Belgium with a focus on inter-organizational learning and project management. Leveque thanked the helpful comments she got to improve their paper. She was also happy to get comparison information and contacts to clusters in Finland and Germany. “Thanks to the Summit, I could get a lot of interviews which entered directly in the benchmarking in our research. This was really useful”, she summarized. The chair of the Summit, professor Matti Koiranen was very impressed by the variety of conference papers. “The common nominator “clustering” was present all the time, but the topics varied from A to Z. This year’s key focus “learning clusters” created several interpretations and excellent discussions”, he pointed out. The main result from his viewpoint was to see how learning clusters can enhance innovativeness and entrepreneurship at a regional level. The case studies described this kind of development very convincingly. At the end of the day, professor Charlie Karlsson from Jönköping International Business School explained how we can proceed from learning clusters to creative clusters. The problem with a pure learning cluster is that it is entirely focused on the build up of absorptive capacity and not investing in the generation of new knowledge. Karlsson emphasized that viable clusters must be able to combine the two faces of
innovation i.e. learning and knowledge generation. Overall, the busy day offered a great opportunity for networking and exchanging information and ideas. One of the participants, Laura Timonen thinks that she got a good idea of the current hot topics in the field of clusters. She has recently started her work as a project researcher at South Karelian Institute, Lappeenranta University of Technology in a project about structural change in the regional economic structures, which has a lot to do with both clusters and learning. “The Summit provided me with a wider perspective on cluster development and on structures that don’t necessarily have to be tied to specific industries or sectors, but more widely to creativity, learning and flexible competencies. I also got a good amount of references for future use and I will definitely use the conference materials in later work”, she evaluated. Despite newest research methods and exciting results, it was the people, who made it worthwhile to attend the Academic Summit. As professor Koiranen stressed in his closing speech: “Although we could have organized this summit in the internet, the virtual milieu could not have been as innovating as our face-to-face contacts are here. One of the key elements in learning is social interaction, and this Summit has been a good forum and arena for such fruitful interaction.”
12th TCI Annual Global Conference - Learning Clusters adapting to the new competence scenario LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE 17
GROUNDS FOR SUCCESS OR FAILURE Workshop 1: Vision and leadership for clusters How do you find time to do face-to-face work in large networks? How do you make sure that everybody is on the same page? How do you solve problems in networks without the traditional authority settings? How about cluster-wide development discussions?
Details Hosted by TCI Director Alberto Pezzi, facilitated by Jaana Kettunen, University of Jyväskylä Scene: There is a strong recognition of the need for new leadership as one of the key elements in creating the joint futures in clusters and business networks. Workshop 1 dealt with the primary factor determining whether clusters are effectively doing the right things towards the shared vision. Share, identify, find: The group started joint work by investigating the similarities
and differences in leadership in the presented cases. Some were more business driven, some more by government or academia. Nevertheless, the common factor was that the most important task of a network leader is to effectively support the creation of an atmosphere of open-minded and inspiring community of cooperation within the network. Challenges for a leader were found for example from breaking mental models. Conclusions: The network leader must tend to both substance and process but equally lead people. There was a discussion on the
18 LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE
characteristics of leadership in clusters overall and a point was made that the role of a cluster manager is yet a different role than network leadership as a whole. It can be questioned of whether there can even be a cluster leader or is the most effective framework shared leadership. The group identified that leadership in clusters and networks is first and foremost about leading with a vision. The group didn’t find a common recipe for successful vision building and leadership in clusters but identified several important characteristics of network leaders (see figure above). The
simple mandate to operate is not enough; true leadership is needed for creating and securing the common vision and the participants’ continuous commitment towards the shared goals. Leading in clusters and the leadership in different cluster stakeholder organisations should move in the same direction, even when crossing with the organisational boundaries and priorities.
IT’S THE MONEY, STUPID! Workshop 2: Show me the money! How to secure added value of cooperation to all stakeholders? How to bring the benefits of MNCs and their global reach to local clusters? How do you make the added value visible with demands for short term wins in long development processes?
Details Hosted by TCI Director Klaus Haasis and facilitated by Elina Humala, Jyväskylä Regional Development Company, Jykes Ltd.
Scene: The primary goal of businesses and clusters in the global world is to create added value and to increase revenue. Workshop 2 addressed no less than the raison d’être of clusters. Share, identify, find: The workshop cases highlighted that it’s all about getting to the core of value chains. As was pointed out by one of the participants: ‘Businesses and their interests need to run the show in clusters’. Nowadays these value chains typically have a global reach and the challenge for clusters is to make also the global connections work. One of the things widely discussed was bringing in the mechanism of financing into the cluster processes. Financing is a means to support growth and renewal of businesses and a membership in a
cluster should increase the possibility for private investment also for the SMEs. One of the things that was brought to the table was that fruitful initiatives do not necessarily even need public funding but are rather organic. Conclusions: In short, added value of clustering = increased sales, new products and services. The added value comes from the cluster manager setting the stage, but letting the business men do what business men do best. This is a given, but the ways of setting the stage and enabling the circumstances of growth and innovation need constant work. For example the question of financing and venture capital could be seen as a good way to ensure purely business driven development aside more regulated and rigid public funding. The key role of the
cluster manager here could be to brand and make sure that the investors see the whole cluster and value co-creation network as an appealing target for investment. However, building and implementing the strategy of the cluster can not be only the sole responsibility of the cluster manager, but all the stakeholders. As all the main speakers pointed out, the world around us is changing faster than ever. To act to the changing circumstances of competitiveness calls for strategic agility also on the cluster level from all the relevant stakeholders. It was agreed that clusters are a good means to sharing risks, costs of operation and development, investments but can also be an effective buffer for circumstances such as the current economic recession. All this requires
both the ability to keep the operational processes going and successful but also the eye on the strategy with a perceptive, agile and proactive mindset.
Jaana Kettunen and Elina Humala were both recruited two days before the conference due to some last minute cancellations. A big hug for both of you for being brave enough to take the challenge!
12th TCI Annual Global Conference - Learning Clusters adapting to the new competence scenario LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE 19
FROM ENRICHING INTERACTION TO GREAT SUCCESS
Workshop 3: Global interaction and learning in clusters Why do clusters need to learn? How to establish enriching interaction and learning in clusters?
Details Hosted by TCI Director Elisabeth Rocha and facilitated by Elise Tarvainen, Regional Council of Central Finland Scene: Effective and goaloriented learning and renewal has been identified as one of the ways to respond to the changing circumstances. Workshop 3 was reflecting on the challenge of learning in and across the local and global networks. Share, identify, find: “Why do clusters need to learn?” was one of the questions Madeline Smith raised first thing on Wednesday morning. The next questions are: “how do we learn
together and why is it so hard?”. Bringing competence development and learning into the picture of business development is not an automatic process. A case from Central Finland showcased one method of helping local businesses incorporate the development of expertise and skills as the key method in developing competitiveness. Based on the examples from the Veneto region, Alessandro Minello from Ca’ Foscari University of Venice saw developing a culture of learning cluster as a critical point in the future of clusters. In the case from Cyprus, competence development not only created the driver for new tourism entrepreneurship but also
20 LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE
formed the first steps for community empowerment. The group identified three key competences for the future: adaptability tuned to the customer needs, strategic thinking and active knowledge-oriented global approach. Lifelong learning is one the keys to establishing proactive thinking, and it needs to be given time everyday. There is food for thought in everything: every success and failure is an opportunity to build on, not just by individuals or in organizations, but also in clusters and networks. Conclusions: The workshop ended with the participants agreeing that the subject needs more work. The group agreed that one step towards cluster-wide learning process might
be a cluster development agreement. The concrete progression path and also the challenge of enhancing learning in clusters start with first creating the atmosphere of trust and open communication. The list continues with setting the goals of joint learning and development, the everyday management of learning processes and finally the ways of evaluating and measuring the impacts of learning for the competitiveness of businesses. However, even this element of cooperation comes down to the physical, concrete opportunities of interaction – the forums, the incentives, the tools – for learning from others, for sharing knowledge, for producing the fruits of enriching interaction.
WORKSHOP 2: INTERNATIONALISATION OF CLUSTERS Alexandra Friz, MFG Baden-Württemberg More than 50 international Cluster experts discussed during the World Café organised by the TCI German Contact Point the chances of cluster internationalisation. Lucia Seel, Clusterland Oberösterreich and Michael Lill, IHK Zetis, made up a list highlighting qualifications and characteristics a cluster manager should bring along in the process of cluster internationalisation. The participants defined that a cluster manager should be ambassador, integrator and strategic consultant at the same time. Alltogether, cluster internationalisation requires a charismatic leader speaking the different languages of the different stakeholders.
Pascal Lampe, NIRO, discussed with the participants whether internationalisation of clusters makes the difference and is meaningful in the current economic crisis. Cluster experts mainly agreed that cluster internationalisation is indeed meaningful. Yet, the the management staff first has to decide what they want to achieve by cluster internationalisation: the internationalisation of companies or of the cluster management itself. Christoph Beer and Nicolas Szechenyi, Inter Cluster, asked at their tables what participants expect from an international platform like TCI. Participants mainly asked for more possibilities to meet throughout the year and to have a continuing exchange of ideas, visions and working methods. It was agreed that a clear added value of TCI should consist in learning across borders and in connecting people.
HORROR STORIES Case 1. No signs of enriching interaction Once upon a time, there was a great idea upon which a group of public and private actors started to build a cluster. All the stakeholders saw great opportunities in the joint efforts and the idea was deemed highly innovative among both people outside and inside the emerging cluster. However, after one year of enthusiastic operations the momentum started to break down. Suddenly none of the key actors kept the initiative of the highest priority, the management was no longer committed to the joint actions and many of the remaining people involved lost faith and mandate to operate in the network. Looking back, the reasons behind might be seen both in the lack of short-term victories but also in the lack of longterm commitment and in the lack of honest and open cooperation. Up to now, the actors have been looking only for gains but not willing to let go of organizational boundaries, openly share information and find true, new and flexible solutions to create new business.
Case 2. Much to say about nothing A cluster group in a workshop passionately identified their forward agenda, including a division of responsibilities for immediate action that significantly broadened the cluster’s development agenda. Then at the end of the workshop the sponsoring economic development agency said to all: ‘Thanks for coming, we will now take your recommendations for action to our Board for their consideration.’ The energy of what had been a self-help cluster group immediately collapsed, the Board had little knowledge of the cluster and no passion, and nothing happened afterwards. Bureaucracy had stepped in and flattened the clustering initiative, that has now retreated back to its earlier (limited) development agenda. Ugh! Learning: A cluster’s sponsors (usually public agencies) need to be comfortable in allowing the clustering initiative to develop and manage its own agenda, and not to micromanage this.
12th TCI Annual Global Conference - Learning Clusters adapting to the new competence scenario LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE 21
ELEMENTS OF SUSTAINABLE COMPETITIVENESS
Workshop 4: Creativity and sustainable competitiveness Where is the creativity in clusters? What does it mean? What is sustainability to my me?
Hosted by TCI President Juan Manuel Esteban and facilitated by Vilma Väisänen, Partus Ltd.
Scene: As was established in many parts of the conference, competitiveness is not a stable issue and to excel and sustain competitiveness in the current circumstances calls for new means. Workshop 4 discussed different ways of building sustainable competitiveness in networks – one of the core elements of the ‘new competitiveness scenario’. Share, identify, find: The group set to ‘steal with pride’ from the experiences of others on building sustainable competitiveness through creativity and innovation. One of the solutions for this was to move from so called gravity based model to client based model in innovations. As many other discussions, also workshop 4 examined the possibility of moving from the triple helix approach to a ‘superior scale’ of creativity, entrepreneurship and ecosystem to link clusters and innovation systems better. Conclusions: There was a short but efficient examination of what are the elements of sustainable competitiveness according to the participants. The 22 LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE
statement ‘to make it you have to learn faster than your competitive environment’ is not far from the truth. It seems that some of the key factors are the ability to listen to the markets and to constantly innovate but at the same time motivate the people to change and renew their capacities, even ‘drive the change’. It could be a useful tool to clearly define the factors that are the
cornerstones of competitiveness of each cluster and more importantly define the means and elements that will be used to secure the competitiveness if one or more of the factors change. Sort of a pre-emptive strike on change.
WHATEVER WILL COME NEXT
Workshop 5: Clusters in a new world Can we build a clock rather than tell the time? Hosted by TCI Director Alonso Ramos Vaca and facilitated by EevaLiisa Vihinen, Humap Ltd. Scene: One of the most pressing themes of the conference was responding to the change and future challenges. Workshop 5 tried to bring the issue from all talk to practice in clusters.
1. Globalization 2. Economic geography 3. Climate change 4. Technology acceleration 5. Bottom of the pyramid – the rise of the emerging economies 6. Focus on the individual From these, climate change perspective emerged to have a heavy focus in the group, but in the active and energetic
Frank Waeltring, mesopartner “How to promote clusters based on more than a “snap shot insight” of business reality? Persons who want to promote innovation have to be innovative in their approaches themselves. And they have to be open to put into question their own thinking and action, ask further questions, look for new answers and new ways of doing things. And last but not least they have to be able to reflect about their own role as “change facilitators”! The 3rd day of the TCI Conference focused very much on the question of how we as practitioners learn, how we interact and with whom do we interact while working?
Share, identify, find: ‘We identified that it’s not only the economy changing, but also some other aspects’, said Alonso Ramos, the host of the workshop. The group identified six trends to meet in clusters:
What I thought of today
conversation, connections with the other five perspectives were made as well. The group agreed that all the trends present opportunities to use the markets to push for solutions, but that also the clustering models need to adapt to the changing logics. Two optional models of the new approach better tuned for the new challenges and opportunities were sketched and one of them was selected to be improved in practice. Conclusions: As highlighted by the hourglass figure above, the core question is ‘how’. Clusters are in the focal position to both absorb and interpret the looming challenges and the regulating environment as well as to gather the strengths of the players pictured at the bottom of the pyramid. The ‘how’ starts with global thinking, local action, flexibility and openness to new ideas. We remain curious to finding out what will come out of this further development of the model to help the rest of us react better to whatever will come next.
“What are our guiding mental models that drive our initiative and our work?”, asked Madeline Smith from Ekos Ltd in her great morning input. Often cluster practioners and policy advisors are very much driven by their own mindset of how the innovation system should be set up, should work and how we should intervene. “We need to change” says Smith, “challenging our cognitive barriers”. Her insights were related to her Scottish Enterprise study “Exploring cluster dynamics using the system thinking methodology” in which she empasized the need for a more reflection loop-oriented intervention approach.In this study and in her speech she emphasized an issue which can also be seen as a golden thread of comments during the workshop discussions here at the Conference: “One of the issues encountered by many public sector bodies when developing a clusters strategy is that much analysis of the industry sectors only gives a “snap shot” of how the cluster operates.” So how can we encourage learning in our cluster and in other economic initiatives that go beyond a snap shot perspective?, is a key question that has not been sufficiently tackled in this Conference. Smiths answer: “Start with pilot projects close to businesses, get different perspectives involved, work with a multidisciplinary and creative team”. And listen more to businesses, because they are the drivers of innovation!
12th TCI Annual Global Conference - Learning Clusters adapting to the new competence scenario LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE 23
MESSAGE FROM THE M
A fearless multinational group of clusternauts gathered to Jyväskylä Planetarium on Wednesday night with a mission. MISSION OBJECTIVE: To explore what’s on the cluster development
24 LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE
CLUSTERNAUTS TO GROUND CONTROL:
Reporting after achieving the target. [STOP] Small steps for clusters and clusternauts but a giant leap for competitiveness. [STOP] We, the multinational team heralded from Canada, Chile, Denmark, India, Latvia, New Zealand, Norway, Romania, and Sweden and Finland would like to thank everyone for the excellent world class work. [STOP]
t agenda 2.0. MISSION OUTCOME: Small steps for clusters - a giant leap for competitiveness In the turbulent circumstances created by the deep recession of the world economy, the clusternauts identified a need to renew the tools and methods of business and competitiveness development towards sustainable competitiveness. The goal was like a trip to the moon in the 1960s, a trip to the unknown but not out of reach. Even the basis was the same as in the 60s, the passion and the belief in knowledge and know-how, the ability to create activity towards the shared mission. The basis for this leap can be found in the top expertise of the network of cluster practitioners and scientists. Because of a determined and practice oriented science of clusters, we have been able to have and use all the relevant data for the development of clusters. In addition, the received training has given us the ability to understand the steps of development processes, to create network leadership and support innovation in clusters. The interaction between different key
stakeholders has been enriching and given birth to many new innovations. On our trip, the engine of the cluster space craft has functioned flawlessly. The technical solutions have been right and executed with quality. Both global companies and small specialized enterprises have been able to incorporate their strategies and operations enabling crossborder solutions and processes. The operations have been fit for long space travel, but bringing forth the ability for strategic re-directing, joint risk-taking and problemsolving. The cooperation has performed surprisingly well, thanks to clear roles. Intelligent evaluation has supported further efficiency in action. The decision to search the next sphere was the right one. Cluternauts extend a thank you for Ground Control for the strong support and connections. We see new joint opportunities and will develop the competence by being Future Wise. Roger.
SMALL STEPS FOR CLUSTERS 1. Know what to expect by establishing a well defined science of clusters 2. Get past the grand terms of policy in the flight manual – map out what really happens 3. Create passion to execute the joint vision even when stuck in the spaceship with no clear sight of the moon 4. Create the conditions for enriching interaction and cooperation 5. Refine the knowledge to steer the spacecraft, the clusters, redevelop the competences making sure the ship gets to where it’s going 6. Lure in the Jupiters, the multinational corporations, make them know of the special expertise available by clustering 7. Be open minded in thinking of where the next shooting star, new idea is going to come from 8. React fast to incoming threats in the radar – meteors, black holes and changing conditions
12th TCI Annual Global Conference - Learning Clusters adapting to the new competence scenario LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE 25
ir and insp ? uraging
Startersere your main enconference until now What w om the TCI Co fr insights
to allenges urse Main co you see as main ch work?
own What do in your tiveness competi
k and our wor ange in en? ed to ch and driv ne m e w de e or What do to be m in order r ou vi beha
TCI CAFÉ BROUGHT CLUSTERIN On thursday morning I arrived to the TCI Cafe in Jyväskylä. I had heard a lot about this Cafe and because of that I had plenty of time to savour the whole menu in good company. The week so far had been filled with hard work and I wanted these few hours to be the moment to put all the new pieces and ideas into place. Starters The starters were a true “tapas of insights”. There were as many answers and insights as there were new questions. Most of the issues were somehow about how should we re-think our whole approach and language when talking about competitiveness and clusters. And for most this doesn’t mean new complex models, but more down to earth or rustic style of approach. Here are some of the most common insights: - -
- - - - -
Should we see cluster development as an evolving process, from which you have to learn. Organic vs. planned growth? Or organic vs. constructed cluster! Clustering - What exactly do we mean? Is it cooperation? Is it value chain? Networking? Regional development? What about virtual development and virtual clusters? Or does it mean different things in different areas and situations? Do we need consensus on cluster definition or is it ok and richness to have different definitions? Different clusters need different tools! Clustering is a people thing, we need to go beyond models! Trust & tribes (ethics & emotion) could be the answer! This can be linked to social media and more “power to the people” style of leadership. Communications vs. static world. So far the most valuable thing has been stories from different countries. The diversity of experiences, methods and structures are amazing! But when we are talking about sharing stories, do we also accept failures? We don’t hear much of them?
Main Course The main course looked quite versatile, although few basic ingredients did dominate the plate. Many saw the building of a balanced network as a challenge. But maybe it comes down to showing benefits and motivating, especially companies and entrepreneurs. Development work in clusters is done in a long time perspective, but most businesses might evaluate their interests in a very short timeframe.
26 LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE
MID-CHECK Also, building awareness about the need to develop can be hard, because this idea should be identified by the actors themselves, not from outside. ‘We need to get to the street level, get to know the entrepreneurs and business people, is someone asking what they want? They are our customers. Common vision comes from them, we just need to keep asking and listening. HRD ROI = sharing the human capital, building competencies. Are there any good examples? Why is there no interest to this?’ - - - -
How to measure results of the cluster work in companies? Results need to be communicated in a simple and straightforward way? Long term results need patience! Multiple demands, no common goals How to make companies understand service offer?
NG CHALLENGES TO THE TABLE This can be linked to the size and shape of the cluster. A critical mass is required to have enough momentum but on the other hand, too many players might bring too many objectives. Almost everyone thought that equal involvement of academia, government and the private sector was needed. But if we start to think about the key processes inside the cluster, should there be some other “roles” too? How would you build a dream team in any other context? Would you consider different learning styles? Or roles when innovating the vision for the cluster or when putting the plans into action? There were also a lot of talk about the way different people and organisations participate, communicate and act inside the cluster. And also between clusters! What if learning is the most important process inside a cluster? If so, what are the main challenges? And what then is the main job that the cluster manager needs to do? What is cluster manager there for? Local vs. global? If the businesses are working and acting global, how can we build local clusters? On the other hand, people and enriching interaction between people is mostly a local thing, how do we balance these? Dessert Although starters and the main course had left me quite full, I still wanted to have a taste of something sweet. It has always been my favourite, and this time too it brought the whole experience into more personal level, it was about the things I will change in my own work. Here are some of the most common and most ambitious changes: - - - - - - - - - -
We need to use more learning-by-doing. Schemes to develop cooperation between enterprises and education providers. Ease up and speed up the innovation process We will create the right environment to identify the real needs, share vision. Entrepreneurial skills are the answer! Cluster managers need to think their job like entrepreneurs. Listen to the customer Challenge existing wisdom Accept diversity Do what you are good at Attract people with passion and trust!
In the end, I have to say The TCI Cafe has potential. The menu can be hard to digest, but it will leave me full of ideas for a long time. 12th TCI Annual Global Conference - Learning Clusters adapting to the new competence scenario LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE 27
Did you learn during the conference?
At learningisis like a river which Asits its best, best, learning like a river which carries youalong alongand and becomes to flow* Carries you becomes to flow* *Flow is a mental state of energized focus and full involvement
EduCluster Finland is a business and expert network made up of consultancy businesses, public education organizations and regional development agencies.
EduCluster Finland offers customer oriented learning and development services combining education and innovation expertise from diverse domains and levels of education. Services range from knowledge development and learning technology solutions to innovation and regional development tools and concepts. Our operating mode is client-based processing of development and learning where creative learning environment, top expertise and best practices coexist. Our clients are companies and public institutions.
MID-CHECK Policy Officer Nikos Pantalos, European Commission / DG Entr: A good cluster brings together different innovation actors. The actors can be small or multinational companies or universities. The public domain’s part is to create the framework for cluster development. All these components should work together. The key element for success is innovation. Because of this it´s also important not to underestimate the meaning of education. The innovativeness should be fed later on with enhancing the entrepreneurship and having a qualified staff. That should sustain the success.In the clustering initiatives it’s a mistake if the regional assets aren’t taken into account. For example it’s very hard to create an informatics cluster if there’s no ICT or biotech in the region. Policy makers should understand that good clusters are created on the base of something already existing.
SVP, Talent Management, Hilkka Alatalo-Korpi, Metso Ltd: I believe that the success of the cluster can be seen in a increase of innovation, productivity and attractiveness of the employer brand. The most important feature in a cluster is a mind set of sharing and trust - and well defined long-term goals. However I believe that in the future the innovativeness and new shares solutions will have the critical aspects. The most common mistake in clusters is done when the official structure and the plan do not follow the needs of the cluster members.
WHERE DO SUCCESSFUL CLUSTERS COME FROM? Ifor Ffowcs-Williams, Cluster Navigators Ltd: The secret of a successful clustering initiative is trust building. It also needs a broad portfolio of development initiatives underway and the cluster firmly in control of its destiny, not beholden to others. There are lot of features that need to be developed. Like trust, dialogue, openness, alignment; moving from a clutter of public agency support and clumps of firms to an integrated, innovative system.The most common mistakes in clusters are lack of agreement on the direction, paralysis by analysis and only short term funding in place to support long term development agendas. Mistakes happen also, when public sector funders base in capital cities and dictate the cluster’s agenda, and also when work load is not shared and key people are burned out.
TCI Director Elisabeth Rocha, BIPE: The secret of a successful cluster is to remain open for changes . Second important thing is good teamwork. The energy should´t be wasted in tangling with the problems inside the company or cluster. The success lies in being open to outside world and the region around the cluster. A good cluster achieves the balance of the growth. All people in the region should be benefitting from it, not just the one sector involved in the cluster. A successful cluster spreads its growth to other sectors in the region as well. It is too often forgotten, how important it is to look far ahead to the future. Many times we focus only on the present, which is a mistake. A cluster turns out bad if there is some company which is thinking only itself and doesn’t add any benefit to others. Usually that kind of company is involved only because of the public funding.
12th TCI Annual Global Conference - Learning Clusters adapting to the new competence scenario LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE 29
EVEN IF YOU HAVE TRAVELLED FAR AND WIDE Bonk Business Inc. excels in R&D. One of the older Finnish companies, now 106 years old in fact, is still one of the most innovative companies in this country. One could almost say that it is a company that has no competition, the ultimate competitive edge. As the participants of the conference were told by compressor Sven Triloqvist, Bonk Business Inc. is a multiglobal industrial conglomerate employing 13000 in 52 countries. Bonk is the world leader in pioneering Third Millennium technologies such as fully Defunctioned Machinery, Cosmic Therapy, Repacking, ADS (Advanced Disinformation Systems) and LBH (Localised Black Holes). One of the examples of Bonk R&D is the Anchovy Dynamo where now extinct Baltic anchovy swam right in the machine producing an extremely viscous lubricant. And this was only one of the many achievements almost impossible to believe.
Are you also in the business of repacking and disinformation?
OFF THE BEATEN TRACK Learning Journey into the wild No one complained about the cold weather, as 13 people attented the learning journey on Wednesday. It took the participants hiking outdoors to Hitonhauta - the devil’s grave. The journey combined storytelling and a workshop around a campfire. - Our goal was to get a new perspective on things as we thought about them in a different environment, says Tapio Kymäläinen who guided the group. According to him, the group had conversations about the themes introduced on the main conference earlier. - We talked about the accelerating speed of the world and how the pace slows down automatically in the nature. One purpose was to think alone in the silence, which turned out harder than one might think. -I told everybody to be silent and think as we walked back to the campfire. It turned out to be very challenging. According to Mr Kymäläinen the silence was achieved finally while sitting around the fire. - It created a comfortable silence. So we reached our goal.
30 LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE
Global community at its best
12th TCI Annual Global Conference - Learning Clusters adapting to the new competence scenario LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE 31
What I thought of today Frank Waeltring, mesopartner “Did we lose the market out of perspective while promoting innovation systems?” In quite not few of the presentations and inputs during the Conference there is no word mentioned about the challenges of businesses to stay or become more competitive. A lot has been said about policies and strategies on innovations, concepts, research projects and the new design of funding programmes at the EU-, national and regional levels. If we brainstorm e.g. in workshops on main criteria of sustainable competitiveness only 2 from 35 answers are related to markets. One might get the impression that we feel quite comfortable when clustering ourselves together to reflect about innovation while losing the aspect of competitiveness out of sight. This should be a provocative statement and also understood accordingly. Nonetheless, my impression is that the more we talk about radical, incremental, process, product and system innovation it seems that we lose sight of the market. Although technologypush activities are necessary in some aspects, the pull elements are nearly not mentioned anymore in this Conference. Some years ago we very much discussed the logics of regional economic development and the driving importance of demand conditions (see e.g. Porters diamond), and wanted to understand and promote the national (or global) value chain systems and its business relations between suppliers, producers, big buyers and SMEs and customers (see e.g. Porters five forces). It seems to me that while focusing on the discussion of innovation and R&D promotion, the market fell off the agenda somewhere in between the whole complexity. This is quite contrary to the findings of international studies. Let´s just mention 2 main findings from the European Commission and UNCTAD reports. The presentation of Mette Quinn (workshop 4) on creative industries and service clusters in Sweden points out that most of the innovation emerges inside businesses due to their intensive learning processes from customers as well as from creative ideas of their own employees. This is a valueable insight for the service sector of a very industrialized country. If you look at the latest UNCTAD LDC technology report you see that most of the innovation learning processes of SMEs in less developed countries also come from their customers, suppliers as well as other producers. R&D in industrialized as well as developing countries plays still a very marginal role in the promotion of innovation. Maybe there are trickle-down effects. For sure they are somewhere. Nonetheless: isn´t it time to consider these real innovation realities more intensively, approaching the analysis of innovation systems again much more from the business perspective. Michael Enright said in a workshop session: “85% of real innovations are coming from businesses and are demand-driven. 99% of the innovation promotion programmes are focusing on technology-push approaches.” This is an astonishing imbalance, is it not?
32 LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE
I will be more creative in coming up with different ways to build sustainable clusters. I will bring people together in order to have a clear picture of where we are today, what are the challenges we are facing and define a vision of where we want to be in the future.
I will improve communication to get to approach
demand driven solutions. I will look for shot-time 'lowhanging fruits' to get members involved and create a sense of belonging. My long-term goal is to be able to improve cluster competitiveness.
I will use these new ideas in the writing of the new
project plan for the cluster initiative pending for finance in 1 Jan 2010.
I will put learning into practice by integrating new
experiences and look for new solutions in the network of peope when needed.
I intend to ensure that 3 clusters are developed
(tourism, agroprocessing, horticulture) and intend to apply the Swedish model of development
I willuse the contacts I made in the conference in my future efforts and distribute my new insights at home.
I will create more awareness to the public sector
authorities and cluster leaders in Tanzania, especially on cluster management
I willtry to find a way to give up the idea that each stage in cluster development needs management skill -without getting the effect of disappointment cluster leaders that are disengaged
I will do a re-strategic planning of my company way of
developing clusters, keeping companies in the focus point and constructing a bottom up-strategy
I will rethink and consider the branding strategy of the cluster e.g. according to the branded warehouse -idea
I will lobby the public sector for more funding into the management of clustering process
I will work to establish a community of people interested in learning strategies for impact. This community will share insight through web, email, twitter etc.
As a government officer put my efforts in getting involved people in clusters and will expose the main outcomes and lessons learned about leadership
I will be creating initiatives, which will bring together the I will create more interaction btw different stakeholders triple helix players for debate on competitiveness and engage the policy makers to create frameworks for innovation in Pakistan.
I will proceed with direct actions to / with main actors of the process and by preparing an action plan for regional cluster policy.
I will make a detailed presentation to my colleagues
and send email to my chairman with recommendations for changes
I will allocate time for proactive innovative thinking in my organisation
I will try to become a better leader in my organization back home: try to become a salmon
12th TCI Annual Global Conference - Learning Clusters adapting to the new competence scenario LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE 33
TOP 5 MOMENTS THE 12TH TCI ANNUAL GLOBAL CONFERENCE
TCI General Manager Patricia Valdenebro
Meeting with friends and colleagues like every year, and checking that we keep on having the same open attitude to share and learn, and the family keeps on growing!
As Competitiveness Practitioner, some flashes of the program (although I could not make it to be present in many sessions): the open dialogue with cluster facilitators at Clusters 101, Irina, Christoph and Klaus (some clusters initiatives are in good hands), R&D at Bonk (sounds like quite familiar repacking and disinformation policies), inputs from the regional activities and working groups within TCI, plus new initiatives emerging (thanks to all the members involved, your work enriches TCI).
The warm welcome and professional work of the whole Learning Clusters organizing team, it was really easy to work with you. My special thanks to Rauli (you’d better do not answer the phone on Friday afternoons), Mikko (keep on having crazy ideas) and Anna (smooth, organized and elegant in mind and manners). We will try to keep the best of Jyväskylä for the future.
As General Manager of TCI, the meeting with the finnish Minister of Economy previous to the conference; the natural “pass the batton” between presidents, both good friends highly committed with TCI, Juanma and Alberto, and mostly the Strategic Meeting after the conference, where we could realize that a new TCI is emerging with great potential (we will work hard to make it grow).
34 LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE
I am not sure if this is a top moment, but I still remember the cold air from Jyväskylä in my face and hands when crossing the bridge to Paviljonki over the railways. And the dancing at the City Theater, thank you Markku.
13TH TCI ANNUAL GLOBAL CONFERENCE - DUBAI
Message from Secretary General Hani Al Hamli Dubai Economic Council Dear friends, Public private partnership has taken a centre stage in governments and businesses efforts worldwide to compete and prosper in today’s world. The increasing challenges and rising regional and global changes create the need for a more targeted and constantly re-adjusted approach for developing the clusters and re-positioning them to be resilient to those disruptive changes. We live in a rapidly changing world and economies around the world experience constant disruptions. We already witnessed how supply chains extend and expand and more than ever the competitors and collaborators are now often one and the same whether on national or international scene. And this is due to a paradigm shift in the competitiveness. Dubai’s economy is strongly specialized around clusters. Adopted in early 90’s the development strategies of Dubai that clearly promoted cluster development had proved to be the major precondition for Dubai’s rising position in areas such as financial, logistics, real estate and construction, tourism and others. These clusters in return increasingly grew internationally competitive and led to the rising of other clusters such as health, media and education. The Dubai Strategic Plan 2015 clearly stipulates the further development of global growth clusters in Dubai. Therefore, clusters and cluster development remain high in our agenda as they increasingly provide conditions for productivity growth, innovation, specialized labor and strong externalities. However, changes are happening and the regional specializations that are provided by clusters, built up over decades in many regions of the world, are transforming rapidly. Cluster development in Dubai, therefore, has arrived at a point where there is a need to elaborate more on the nature of collaboration between cluster stakeholders in order to make the transition of Dubai into the new stage of competitiveness – an innovation and high skilled driven economy. Early this year, the Dubai Competitiveness Council has launched the Dubai Cluster Assessment Project that came up with the first report on the Financial, Logistics, Construction/ Real Estate and Tourism clusters. Along with series a of policy recommendations on improving the business environment,
enhancing the skill base and innovation, the enhancement of linkages between the cluster stakeholders, both public and private is in the centre of our attention. We have taken the leadership in initiating the facilitation of these linkages by providing with a world class research, knowledge and expertise on these clusters as well as creating platforms for discussions and dialogue between all stakeholders. These platforms also enable us to discuss and exchange the latest trends in clusterbased policies and best-practices. These platforms are also learning cluster networks where we have prominent business and government leaders coming together to discuss and decide on what Dubai should do next in order to capitalize on its success and move into a more innovation driven, higher value added economy, to be specialized, diversified and yet unique in today’s global knowledge based economy. Our goal is not to target only selected clusters but as Professor Michael Porter says “all clusters are good”. We would like to invite all of you and your colleagues to Dubai next Fall to explore the Dubai clusters where we will also bring prominent business and government leaders to share their unique experience in developing clusters in Dubai of which some have now crossed the national boundaries. You will have the opportunity to explore the unique mechanisms and tools that Dubai constantly invents and re-invents for its successful cluster development and competitiveness. We look forward to hosting next year the TCI 13th Annual Conference in Dubai and share our experience with you on turning the global changes and challenges into national and regional opportunities. My warm regards and look forward to seeing you all in Dubai!
12th TCI Annual Global Conference - Learning Clusters adapting to the new competence scenario LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE 35
NEXT TCI EVENTS 15-17 February, Accra, Ghana: 1st TCI Regional Conference in Africa 12-13 March, New Delhi, India: 1st TCI Asia Competitiveness Forum 7-10 April, Punta Cana, Dominican Republic: 1st TCI World Conference on Tourism Clusters June, Tbc: 5CLAC -5th TCI Latin American Conference 7-11 November, Dubai, UAE: 13th TCI Annual Global Conference
JUST MARRIED - NEW TCI WORKING GROUPS TCI Gender and Economic Growth Initiative The aim of the TCI Gender and Economic Growth Initiative is to change a perceived gender/diversity/equality problem to a competitive advantage, by indentifying opportunities and collecting good practices and proven methods on gender equality as a driver for economic growth. The goal is to produce a document, which will be presented and discussed at a follow-up workshop at TCI Annual Conference 2010. Global ICT Cluster Managers Group The aim of this initiative is to create a long-term sustainable ICT Cluster Manager Community for sharing experience and generating benefits for ICT clusters and their members. In its first year, the group is already planning to organise an ICT Match-Making event at the TCI Annual Conference Dubai 2010. Cluster Finance Working Group In a global economic environment presaging tighter access to finance and more limited economic grow, cluster finance related topics are gaining relevance in cluster development. The Cluster Finance Working group ambitions to develop recommendations and to present usable solutions in the field that will be distributed through TCI and presented during TCI Annual Global Conferences. 36 LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE
APPOINTMENT NEWS New TCI President TCI Director Alberto Pezzi is the new president of the TCI network. He is also the Director of the Analysis and Foresight Unit at the Observatory of Industrial Foresight of the Department of Innovation, Universities and Enterprise of the Catalan Government. New TCI Directors Rauli Sorvari, Regional Council of Central Finland H.E. Hani Al Hamli, Dubai Competitiveness Council Dr. Amit Kapoor, Institute for Competitiveness India.
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
PIECE OF YOUR MIND What you thought of the 12th TCI Annual Global Conference Not all workshops were of the same size. Maybe there were too many? Not sure. We received many good suggestions for cases that could be presented as well as some wishes for workshop themes. As a result, we decided to split them to several workshops. We increased the amount of the workshops also to ensure the smaller group sizes to make the discussions and the atmosphere more relaxed.
The most interesting element of the conference for me was to hear from cluster “gurus” the fact that it’s all about people! I would have loved listening to Finnish business leaders’ stories; if clusters have added value to their businesses and made them more competitive. Editors: So would have we and oh boy did we try to get them! As we recognized during the week, it was a shame we didn’t have many representatives from the business world. But they are hard men and women to reach. I thought the standard of speakers was high. It is not only what they say, it is how they say it. The world cafe was a new experience for me and was excellent. I’d be interested in a summary of the points made on the tablecloths, although the reporting at the end on video was good. We hope you have the main points of the world café from our summary in this report! See page 26-27. The conference was the best so far that I have attended!
The Kalevala night would have been excellent if it had been warmer. Most of us were unable to show off our traditional costumes because we had to keep on the over coats. The evening programme was success because of you great people, you created the atmosphere! And the cold… unfortunately we weren’t powerful enough to change the weather, but we sure tried…! :) My personal self-confidence has increased, as I found that either everyone was grappling with the same issues we were, or that we were much better off in many ways.
We hope the latter group found the way of getting the information about the program anyway! I think the lounge area could have been used more and the information on the discussion topics could have been promoted more during the conference. We agree with you on this. Many were not familiar with these new elements of the conference so we should have informed more about those also on the spot. I got a lot of support on what I had learned earlier - but in a different package. Ethics, trust, passion, talented people - and of course cooperation - are those keywords I picked up. As well as the thought of competing and cooperating at the same time. This was my 12th conference, and thanks for lifting the TCI conference to a new level! Thank you! We on our turn want to challenge the hosts of Dubai to lift the next TCI conference to yet another level!
Interesting process, but I think the wrong context. TCI conferences are not about personal development, but simply to network. But I had a very good time, anyway. Thanks for your comment. We would like to see every conference as a personal/ professional learning experience, and for you networking was obviously one of the goals you set for yourself. It was hard to get an overview of the whole conference program. Too much flash animations and fancy stuff. You couldn’t print a simple overview. According to the feedback we got, many agree with you, yet there is also a group of people who enjoyed the new way of presenting the program. We think it’s just more or less a subjective matter, some like and some don’t.
12th TCI Annual Global Conference - Learning Clusters adapting to the new competence scenario LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE 37
What I thought of today Frank Waeltring, mesopartner One month after TCI: Sleepless nights and bouncing ideas! November 17, 2009 “I have to sleep over it”, is a phrase we often use after getting overwhelmened by many new impressions, thoughts, or ideas. 4 weeks after the TCI Conference I slept more than once over it and still like to remember myself back. Some of the articles reflect my impressions from the Conference. If I would have to select one final overall statement then it would be the following: “Critical success factors of a Conference with more than 350 experts on innovation are not mainly related to the topics that are selected but to the atmosphere and facilitation corridor that is provided for a fruitful and outcome oriented discussion between experienced participants!” The real new insights during conferences are less so coming out from presentations themselves but from some ideas they are able to set free within the listeners mind. The exchange on these ideas and impressions can be promoted through a professional facilitation of communication. In that way this conference was much more interactive and fruitful than earlier ones I participated in. I discovered new forms of facilitation, interaction and exchange between practitioniers. If I would have to select one of my main learnings during the conference then it would be the following:“We will have to reflect more about how we can facilitate communication and competition between business and institutional networks with the end to promote competitiveness. Cooperation in cluster promotion is just a means to this end!” The whole cluster and innovation system discussion is finally about cooperation and competition. On the one hand several TCI inputs and discussions provided interesting contributions on how to improve cooperation, how to get a deeper understanding about different mindsets, and about the importance to consider the change of mental models in our daily work. There is a need to understand better how we approach different human beings with different interests and backgrunds. What are more frutful ways to encourage a implementation-driven cooperation between businesses and relevant support institutions ?, is one of the key questions we will have to find more answers on. On the other hand a deeper understanding of how to promote implementation- and demand-driven cooperation is just beginning. Cluster and innovation promotion it is not reached only through network facilitation,
38 LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE
or only through understanding the critical human and institutional factors of cooperation. It is also about understanding and promoting competition! The promotion of clusters and innovation systems have the objective to increase the competitiveness of a certain territory. And competitiveness is very much about understanding market failures, government failures as well as network failures that hinder competitiveness. It also involves a deeper understanding of the market forces, about the demand conditions and how existing and future businesses are challenged to react on these changing market circumstances in a more effective and successful way. Actually this topic of competitiveness and its element of competition was rarely tackled during the TCI Conference. Nonetheless it is an essential one in times of globalisation. A professional management of such processes through practitioners, policy makers, consultants and businesses requires a competency in cluster facilitation that goes beyond network management but that is able to promote a reflection in businesses and support institutions of how to improve competitiveness along very concrete activities and learning loops. Not only me but many practitioners and policy makers are coming every year to the TCI Conference to learn something new. Accordingly the title in Finland was “Learning Clusters”. Maybe one of the next TCI titles could be “lessons learnt for the future”, or “demand-driven clusters and networks: success and failure criteria”, or “Cluster facilitation vs cluster management: what do we need to change?” This would then encourage a reflection about market-, government and network failures we have experienced during the last decade as well as about our own role in cluster and business promotion. It would also force us to have a deeper look again into real practical examples that are closer to business reality. I like to remember myself back to the Conference in Finland because I did meet several very motivated and committed persons with whom I would like to stay in contact. During the daily routine of our work the development of new ideas and the motvation to try things differently often gets insufficient attention. The TCI Conference is a place where this room is provided. Although I had several nights to reflect about my impressions, there are still several ideas that are bouncing around in my head. And that´s gerat! To the organizers and the TCI team: Thanks for the left bouncing ideas! It was a pleasure being there!
12th TCI Annual Global Conference - Learning Clusters adapting to the new competence scenario LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE 39
START OF THE JOURNEY
New TCI President Alberto Pezzi
It is with immense pleasure that I am addressing you in the opening section of this newsletter as the newly elected President. I accept this responsibility with deep humbleness but also with greater awareness than that of the majority of those who are reading these lines, that TCI is a great project totally built with a bottom-up approach. TCI is evidence that good ideas and knowledgeable people can jointly become a strong driver for making things happen. TCI is also in itself proof that the cluster approach works, that “coopetition” exists and works, and that there is always room for innovation and good projects even in turbulent times and a crisis scenario. Another TCI global conference has come to an end and the stimulating and innovative environment we have been exposed to over the last week in Jyväskylä is challenging us when trying to apply some of this fresh new thinking to our day-to-day jobs. This is both encouraging and frustrating, but the perseverance that will be required of us will certainly be rewarded. Certainly, the challenges that cluster practitioners, regional development policy makers and companies are facing today are extremely serious but TCI conferences always demonstrate that we are not alone, that there are always new things to be learnt, that an alternative approach is always possible and that knowledge and networking are two powerful and inexpensive tools for fostering the competitiveness of our regions. With this in mind, I therefore start a new journey as the new TCI President knowing that I will not be alone. Our clear aim is to make this organization grow as a wider network of cluster practitioners with probably the biggest repository of tacit knowledge on cluster development worldwide. How to tap and use it is our great challenge.
40 LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE
ANATOMY OF A LEARNING CLUSTER Wisdom of 350 international experts on competitiveness Settings and objective – What? The starting point of the conference was adapting to the new competitiveness scenario and the general focus has been on clusters as the drivers of economic development. One of the core issues of discussion during the week was the unpredictability of different elements of competitiveness and that one of the core issues today is the management of change in the operating environment. However, even more important than the macro level of economy and society, the focus of the conference discussions was much in the management, performance and creativity with small, practical and grassroots level activities. Things are local and global at the same time, but most problems materialize in the everyday work.
- Creativity and sustainable competitiveness: Make sure you know what your elements of sustainable competitiveness are, think which are the most critical ones and define how to secure them in times of change. - Clusters in a new world: Make sure your Anchovy Dynamo is oiled to the max to pick up new signals coming from whichever end of the hourglass.
Michael E. Porter’s renowned work analyses regional economies and the triple helix approach is mostly about the roles and cooperation schemes of innovation and competitiveness creation. How about moving even more closely looking at the process and steps of competitiveness creation itself?
In times of crisis, it is critical that the actions planned and performed are aimed at the same direction. This is an obvious challenge for policy-makers, but done correctly, different policies enable the development, growth and success of businesses. As was pointed out by many, clusters can provide a survival kit for the companies and stakeholders involved, even the signal to redirect the course and find new opportunities. Process and performance – How? We talked about creating World Class excellence in clusters and regions. But how to do it in practice, what are the processes to make this happen? These are some of the answers you gave in the conference: In general:
- Create a culture of enriching interaction – Collaboration is more a mindset than a mechanism - Find a way to involve big corporations and their global reach - Learn and innovate fast - try a lot of stuff, make mistakes, but learn from them! - Be cunning in integrating the goals of different stakeholders - Be sensitive in the strategy formation and redirection - Make sure your cluster development is a process, not a project steered by a certain funding available
In some of the key processes in clusters:
- Vision and leadership: Cluster leadership is leading with a vision, recreating the joint vision, the importance of creating trust, open culture and making sure all go towards the same direction. - Show me the money: It’s all about creating added value, reaching for both the low-hanging fruit and the moon at the same time. All stakeholders need to know their place in the value-creation schema - Global interaction and learning in clusters: Creativity rules, but ideas are nowadays less likely made by only the Einsteins in the world – teams and interaction are the key to success. Leap forward by creating learning communities.
How do you position yourself on the axes of these different processes? Are all these corners in place in your cluster? From Finland with love Madeline Smith took an example from one of the most known examples of Finnish literature, the Moomins: The Moomin stories concern several eccentric and oddly-shaped characters, they were bohemian, lived close to nature and were very tolerant towards diversity. The characters’ differences are accepted and their needs are accommodated. Like she put it, this is perhaps the culture and mindset we need to find in our networks, in our clusters, in the TCI network and in other global communities. As the holiday season is approaching and many extend wishes and gifts to each other, we wish that you keep the new ideas you got alive – don’t let the real world intervene with your good intentions.
See you in Dubai!
12th TCI Annual Global Conference - Learning Clusters adapting to the new competence scenario LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE 41
PARTICIPANTS Abreu,Maria Victoria,National Competitiveness Council,Dominican Republic Abugessaisa,Imad,Future Position X,Sweden Abulfotuh,Ms. Dalia,Egyptian National Competitiveness Council,Egypt Accaro,Louis,Tanzania Private Sector Foundaion,Tanzania, United Republic of Afrikian,Gayane,Dubai economic Council,United Arab Emirates Agostini,Julio Cezar,SEBRAE,Brazil Ahola,Pirjo,Regional Council of Central Finland,Finland Ahonen,Laura,City of Jyväskylä,Finland Ahonen,Mikko,Jyväskylä Innovation Ltd. ,Finland Ahtola-Marks,Raija-Leena,Culminatum Innovation - Living Business Cluster Programme,Finland Akhtar,Hina,JAAG BROADCASTING SYSTEMS (PVT) LTD.,Pakistan Al Aidarous,Noor,Dubai Economic Council,United Arab Emirates Al Hamli,Hani,Dubai Economic Council,United Arab Emirates Al Marri,Butti,Dubai Economic Council,United Arab Emirates Alvarez,Carlos,Chilean Economic Development Agency,Chile Andersen,Lise,University of Southern Denmark,Denmark Andersson,Ewa,Tillväxtverket,Sweden Andersson ,Markku,City of Jyväskylä,Finland Aranguren,Mari Jose,Orkestra - Basque Institute of Competitiveness,Spain Astrup Jørgensen,Christina,University of Southern Denmark,Denmark Axelsson,Helene,DalaBIT,Sweden Backman,Gunnar,OpenEye,Sweden Bashir,Amjad,Competitiveness Support Fund,Pakistan Beer,Christoph,tcbe.ch - ICT Cluster Bern, Switzerland / mundi consulting ag,Switzerland Bellika,Tor-Arne,ICT Grenland,Norway Bersier,Jacques P.,HES-SO//Fribourg - PSTFR,Switzerland Betz,Dilara,MFG Baden-Württemberg mbH,Germany Bialic-Davendra,Magdalena Lucyna,Tomas Bata University in Zlin, Faculty of Management and Economics,Czech Republic Biteniece,Zane,Investment and development agency of Latvia,Latvia Bjurulf,Staffan,Region Värmland,Sweden Blomqvist,Irina,Culminatum Innovation Oy Ltd,Finland Bode,Alexander,Darmstadt University of Technology,Germany Bonnet,Pierre,Chamber of Commerce and Industry of Lyon,France Borchardt,Andreas,Brandenburg Economic Development Board,Germany Boronenko,Vera,University of Daugavpils,Latvia Branzén,Per,The Packaging Arena,Sweden
42 LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE
Breault,Robert,Breault Research Organization,United States Brunet,Olivier,european commission,Belgium Bruskova,Pavla,Regional Development Agency,Czech Republic Burvall,Magnus,Fiber Optic Valley,Sweden Byaruhanga,Juliet,THE PRIVATE SECTOR FOUNDATION UGANDA,Uganda Campbell,Michael,South East England Development Agency (SEEDA),United Kingdom Capitine,Belarmina,CPI - Investment Promotion Centre,Mozambique Carvalho,Matheus,SEBRAE-MG,Brazil Casals,Kare,Kainuun Etu Ltd,Finland Casey,Niall,Invest Northern Ireland,United Kingdom Chisawillo,Peter,Tanzania Private Sector Foundation,Tanzania, United Republic of Darscht,Pablo,MIEM - PACPYMES,Uruguay David,Nelza,INVESTMENT PROMOTION CENTER (CPI),Mozambique Dharmaji,Ramesh,Small Industries Development Bank Of India,India Dixon ,Patrick,Global Change Ltd. ,United Kingdom Duch,Emiliano,The Cluster Competitiveness Group, SA,Spain Dugre,Vincent,Quebec transportation equipment cluster,Canada Eetgerink,Frank,Regional Development Agency East Netherlands,Netherlands Elbe,Jörgen,Univerity of Dalarna,Sweden Emmoth,Anna,Dalarna University,Sweden Engholm,Maria,,Sweden Enright,Michael,University of Hong Kong / Enright, Scott & Associates,Hong Kong Ernström,Magnus,Region Gävleborg,Sweden Espina,Javier,Goverment,Argentina Esteban,Juan Manuel,SPRI - Basque Government,Spain Fantoni,Margarida,SEBRAE-MG,Brazil Fernando,Alvarez Montalvo,Sace Desarrollos Tecnológicos, S.L.,Spain Fernvall,Lars,VINNOVA,Sweden Ferràs,Xavier,CIDEM,Spain Ferreres,Luis,TCI Network - The Competitiveness Institute,Span Ffowcs-Williams,Ifor,Cluster Navigators Limited,New Zealand Finsrud,Henrik,Work Research Institute,Norway Folladal,Per Anders,SIVA SF,Norway Freije,Inmaculada,Basque Government Department of Industry,Spain Freudenthaler,Walter,ecoplus. The Business Agency of Lower Austria Ltd.,Austria Fridman,Ragnar,Norrköping Science Park,Sweden Friz,Alexandra,MFG Baden-Württemberg mbH,Germany Furre,Harald,Oxford Research AS,Norway Gadd,Bruce,New Zealand Trade and Enterprise,Italy García Roja,Rafael,UNIVERSIDAD DE CÁDIZ,Spain
Goicolea,Juan Ignacio,Basque Government Department of Industry,Spain Granat Thorslund,Jennie,Vinnova,Sweden Graversen,Andreas Blohm,FORA,Denmark Gustafsson,Henna,Jyväskylä Regional Development Company Jykes Ltd,Finland Gwynne-Evans ,Nigel,Economic Development & Tourism ,South Africa Gyulai,Tamas,Green Technology Development Cluster,Hungary Haasis,Klaus,MFG Baden-Württemberg mbH,Germany Hagenauer,Simone,ecoplus. The Business Agency of Lower Austria Ltd.,Austria Hansen,Eric Rolf,Economic Transformations Group,United States Harju,Carita,Jyväskylä Regional Development Company,Finland Hausner,Ulrich,WTSH GmbH,Germany Heikkinen,Veli-Pekka,Jyväskylä Innovation Ltd.,Finland Heikkinen ,Satu,City of Jyväskylä,Finland Higuita Palacio,Juan Manuel,Medellin’s City Hall,Colombia Hill,Justin,department of innovation industry science research,Australia Himanen,Pekka,HIIT,Finland Hindrum,Kerstin,Swedish Marine Technology Forum,Sweden Humala,Elina,Jyväskylä Regional Development Company,Finland Huss,Catrin,Region Värmland,Sweden Hynninen,Sanna-Mari,University of Jyväskylä,Finland Härkönen,Matti,Jyväskylä Educational Consortium ,Finland Høyerby,Leif Guldborg,AluCluster,Denmark Iikkanen ,Päivi,Jyväskylä Educational Consortium ,Finland Ismalina,Poppy,Research School, SOM, University of Groningen and Fac.Econ. Business, Gadjah Mada University, Indonesia,Netherlands Jamison,Linda,Invest Northern Ireland,United Kingdom Janhonen,Minna,Unelmania / Team Academy,Finland Janiszewski,Lech,The Marshal’s Office of the Swietokrzyskie Region,Poland Jas,Mariusz,Marshal’s Office of the Lodz Region,Poland Jensen,Lars Horsholt,BrainsBusiness - ICT North Denmark,Denmark Johansson,Cecilia,VINNOVA,Sweden Johnston,Richard,Invest Northern Ireland,United Kingdom Juurinen,Anna-Liisa,Jämsek Oy - Jämsä Region Development Company,Finland Jyrki,Haataja,Kainuunmaakunta kuntayhtymä, The joint authority of Kainuu Region,Finland Jämsén,Risto,Jyväskylä Regional Development Company,Finland Jönsson-Brydsten,Monika,Region Dalarna,Sweden Kafafy,Dina,Egyptian National Competitiveness Council,Egypt
PARTICIPANTS Kanitpong,Tatchawan,Graduate School of Business Administration (NIDA),Thailand Kaperl-Sniowska,Ewa,MARSHAL`S OFFICE,Poland Kapoor,Amit,Institute for Competitiveness,India Kardemark,Gunnel,Future Position X,Sweden Karhatsu,Eija,State Provincial Office of Southern Finland,Finland Kauhanen,Pirjo,Jyväskylä Educational Consortium,Finland Kekkonen,Neo,Student,Finland Kettunen,Mikko,Kainuun Etu Oy,Finland Kettunen,Jaana,University of Jyväskylä,Finland Kiese,Matthias,University of Applied Sciences Northwestern Switzerland, School of Business,Switzerland Kinnunen,Eeva,Unelmania / Team Academy,Finland Kobro,Lars Ueland,Telemark Reaserch Institute,Norway Koiranen,Matti,University of Jyväskylä,Finland Koivumäki,Eeva-Liisa,Jyväskylä Regional Development Company Jykes Ltd.,Finland Korchagina,Nataliya,Astrakhan State University,Russian Federation Korhonen,Ismo,Jyväskylä Regional Development Company, Jykes Ltd. ,Finland Korhonen,Pirkko,City of Jyväskylä,Finland Korhonen,Hannu,Regional Council of Central Finland,Finland Korpi,Anna,EduCluster Finland,Finland Koskinen,Ari,Regional Council of Central Finland,Finland Koskinen,Tiia,Hermia,Finland Kovanen,Matti,CopperSky Ltd. ,Finland Krstanovic,Boris,The Association of Croatian ICT Clusters - cro.ict,Croatia Kumar,Dilip R.V.,SIDBI Venture Capital Limited,India Kutinlahti,Pirjo,Finnish Ministry of Employment and the Economy,Finland Kärki,Noora,Unelmania / Team Academy,Finland Lahti,Merja,Regional Council of Central Finland,Finland Laine,Hilkka,Regional Council of Central Finland,Finland Lall,Ashish,Asia Competitiveness Insitute, Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy,Singapore Lampe,Pascal,NIRO e. V.,Germany Landen,Laila,City of Jyväskylä,Finland Langkilde,Lotte,University of Southern Denmark,Denmark Lapikataja,Titta,Student,Finland Lappeteläinen ,Taija,Jyväskylä Regional Development Company,Finland Larrea,Miren,Orkestra - Basque Institute of Competitiveness,Spain Larsson,Fredrik,Future Position X,Sweden Larsson,Lars-Gunnar,VINNOVA,Sweden Latvala,Eila,JAMK University of Applied Sciences / School of Health and Social Studies,Finland
Laxell,Patrik,Synocus Oy,Finland Lehtinen,Tiia,Business Arena Ltd. ,Finland Lema,Juliana,Prime Minister’s Office,Tanzania, United Republic of Lempinen,Jyrki,Jyväskylä Educational Consortium ,Finland Leveque,Audrey,LENTIC,Belgium Lill,Michael,IHK Zetis GmbH,Germany Lind,Peter,Trekantområdet Danmark,Denmark Lindfors,Kirsi,Hermia Ltd.,Finland Lindqvist,Göran,Center for Strategy and Competitiveness, Stockholm School of Economics,Sweden Lindqvist,Maria,Tillväxtverket,Sweden Linnarsson,Kajsa,OpenGlobal Inc,United States Litzel,Nicole,IAB Institute for Employment Research,Germany Llorens-Urrutia,Juan-Luis,LKS S.Coop.,Spain Loikkanen,Teemu,Cursor Oy,Finland Lommi,Taina,State Provincial Office of Sourhern Finland,Finland Lund,Jens Erik,BSR InnoNet, Nordic Innovation Centre,Norway Lundstrom,Mikael,Compare,Sweden Ly Muñoz,Doris,Agencia Regional Desarrollo Productivo (Talca),Chile Lämsä,Tero,HUMAK University of applied sciences,Finland Majò,Anna,22@Barcelona,Spain Malin ,Aino,Jyväskylä Educational Consortium ,Finland Malmkvist,Ulrika,FindIT,Sweden Maltamo,Pekka,Jyväskylä Educational Consortium ,Finland Mark,Mccord,Deloitte Consulting LLP,Cyprus Markkanen ,Mikko,Business Arena Ltd. ,Finland Martí,Joan,ACCIÓ CIDEM|COPCA,Spain Mashiane,Tswaledi,the dti,South Africa Massari,Ilaria,Reindustria Cremona Development Agency - Catholic University of Piacenza,Italy Mathur,Ajeet Narain,Indian Institute of Management Ahmedabad,India Matinaro,Pekka,Jyväskylä Regional Development Company, Jykes Ltd. ,Finland Mattila,Sari,,India Mattsson,Jutta,Reporter,Finland Mboya,John,Prime Minister’s Office,Tanzania, United Republic of Mckeown,Bernard,Department of Enterprise, Trade & Investment,United Kingdom Meijide,Alberto,UNIVERSIDAD DE SANTIAGO DE COMPOSTELA,Spain Melle,Denis,ESC BRETAGNE BREST,France Meuronen,Teija,Lappeenranta Innovation Ltd. ,Finland Michelsen,Øyvind,Kunnskapsbyen Lillestrøm,Norway Mikkonen,Anita,Regional Council of Central Finland,Finland Minello,Alessandro,CA’ FOSCARI UNIVERSITY OF VENICE,Italy
Mitra,Sumit,University of Wollongong in Dubai,United Arab Emirates Mittal,Manoj,small industries development bank of india,India Mokadem,Fakr-Eddine,Prime Minster Office ( Dubai ),United Arab Emirates Monclus,Sonia,Barcelona Design Innovation Cluster,Spain Moreno,Jaime,National Competitiveness Council,Dominican Republic Mosai,Sello Ben,Productivitysa,South Africa Msuya,Flower,Zanzibar Seaweed Cluster Initiative,Tanzania, United Republic of Mubashir,Ellora,Institute of Rural Research and Development (IRRAD), S.M. Sehgal Foundation,India Mukherjee,Kaushik,KARNATAKA STATE FINANCIAL CORPORATION,India Musoke,Ruth Biyinzika,PRIVATE SECTOR FOUNDATION UGANDA,Uganda Mutambi,Joshua,Department of Industry and Technology,Uganda Mutka,Ulla,JAMK University of Applied Sciences,Finland Mäkeläinen,Petteri,,Finland Mäkinen,Susanna,Reporter,Finland Mänttäri,Aki,TechVilla,Finland Møller,Kim,Oxford Research A/S,Denmark Nadifi,Samy,IBI International,United States Naidoo,Vik,Deakin University and Enterprise Connect,Australia Nash,John,Iowa State University,United States Nawangwe,Barnabas,Makerere University,Uganda Niemelä,Juha S,T&E Centre for Central Finland,Finland Nikku,Pirjo,Jyväskylä Innovation Ltd. ,Finland Nikola,Eeva,Jyväskylä Educational Consortium ,Finland Nilsson,Agnetha,Region Värmland,Sweden Nissilä,Teuvo,Kainuun Etu,Finland Norrström,Lena,Triple Steelix,Sweden Norvapalo,Kare,JAMK University of Applied Sciences / School of Health and Social Studies,Finland Nyberg,Ann-Christin,Luleå University of Technology & Stockholm University,Sweden Nygård Skalman,Karin,VINNOVA,Sweden O’Connor,Fergal,University College Cork,Ireland Odhe,Janerik,Steel&Engineering,Sweden Oiarbide,Leire,TCI Network - The Competitiveness Institute,Spain Olin ,Kalevi,Regional Council of Central Finland,Finland Osterbo,Emma,NCE Raufoss /SINTEF Raufoss Manufacturing,Norway Oswald,Philipp,MFG Baden-Württemberg mbH,Germany Otala,Leenamaija,CICERO Learning,Finland Paananen,Markku,JAMK University of Applied Sciences,Finland Paatola,Matti,Jyväskylä Regional Development Company, Jykes Ltd. ,Finland Padilha,Luiz Marcelo,SEBRAE,Brazil
12th TCI Annual Global Conference - Learning Clusters adapting to the new competence scenario LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE 43
PARTICIPANTS Pajala ,Leena,Regional Council of Central Finland,Finland Pantalos,Nikos,European Commission / DG Entr,Belgium Papell,Marc,Cluster Development,Spain Partanen,Raija,Regional Council of Central Finland,Finland Patrikainen,Olli,Jyväskylä Regional Development Company, Jykes Ltd. ,Finland Pekkala,Jouni,Seinäjoki Region Business Service Center,Finland Pekkala ,Päivi,Unelmania / Team Academy,Finland Pellinen,Aimo,JAMK University of Applied Sciences,Finland Peltomaa,Jyrki,Josek Oy,Finland Perkovic,Ivan,South East England Development Agency,United Kingdom Persson,Olle,Region Gavleborg,Sweden Peräaho,Pirjo,Regional Council of Central Finland,Finland Perälä,Hannu,Jyväskylä Educational Consortium ,Finland Peterkova,Lenka,CzechInvest,Czech Republic Petershagen,Eivind,Innovation Norway,Norway Pezzi,Alberto,ACC1O-Generalitat de Catalunya,Spain Pienonen,Toni,University of Jyväskylä,Finland Pislaru,Dragos,GEA Strategy & Consulting SA,Romania Piza Cossio,Paola Andrea,Fundación Medellín Convention & Visitors Bureau,Colombia Priest,Susan,South East England Development Agency (SEEDA),United Kingdom Prochazka,Stepan,CzechInvest,Czech Republic Pudane,Evija,Investment and Development Agency of Latvia,Latvia Pulgarin Sierra,John Fredy,CHAMBER OF COMMERCE OF MEDELLIN FOR ANTIOQUIA,Colombia Päivänen ,Veli-Pekka,Regional Council of Central Finland,Finland Quinn,Mette,European Commission / DG Entr,Belgium Raatikainen,Niku ,Unelmania / Team Academy,Finland Rainio,Timo,Hermia Oy,Finland Ramis,Lluis,Cluster Development, S.L.,Spain Ramos Vaca,Alonso,Desarrollo Económico del Estado de Chihuahua A.C.,Mexico Raulo,Miikka,JAMK University of Applied Sciences,Finland Rautiainen,Nina,Central Finland Chamber of Commerce,Finland Reid,Neil,UNIVERSITY OF TOLEDO,United States Rissanen,Riitta,Savonia University of Applied Sciences,Finland Ritsilä ,Jari,University of Jyväskylä,Finland Roelofsen,Julia,InnoPraxis International Ltd.,Finland Rwakasisi,Joyce,MINISTRY OF FINANCE,Uganda
44 LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE
Rweikiza,Evans,Tanzania Private Sector Foundation,Tanzania, United Republic of Ryhänen,Frank ,Culminatum Ltd. ,Finland Sagrario,Inés,,Spain Sallinen,Aino,University of Jyväskylä,Finland Salvador Villamar,Mónica,Development Regional Agency,Chile Salvatierra,Guillermo,Provincial Agricultural Services Program,Argentina Sambua,Sosthenes,TPSF-Business Development Gateway,Tanzania, United Republic of Sanchez Adell,Raul,22@Barcelona,Spain Sandred,Jan,VINNOVA,Sweden Sandvik,Rolf André,SIVA SF,Norway Sautter,Björn,Steinbeis-EuropaZentrum,Germany Schmid,Bernhard,Vienna Business Agency / VITE,Austria Seel,Lucia,Clusterland Upper Austria,Austria Senneseth,Knut,Innovation Norway,Norway Silvennoinen ,Leena,Culminatum Ltd. ,Finland Singh,Harinder Jeet,Confederation of Indian Industry,India Singh,Indira,MNDMF - Executive Projects Office,Canada Sjögren,Dan,VINNOVA,Sweden Smith ,Madeline,Ekos Ltd. ,United Kingdom Somkuti,Mátyás,Hungarian Pole Program Office,Hungary Soo,Kuo Tong,Ministry of Trade and Industry,Singapore Sorvari,Rauli,Regional Council of Central Finland,Finland Soy,Antoni,,Spain Steinbock ,Dan,ICA,United States Stürzebecher,Daniel,MFG BadenWürttemberg mbH,Germany Subira,Antoni,IESE, University of Navarra,Spain Suslaviciute,Erna,Ministry of Economy of Lithuania,Lithuania Svensson,Klas,Tillväxtverket - Swedish Agency for Economic and Regional Growth,Sweden Svensson,Marita,Fiber Optic Valley,Sweden Svensson,Lennart,Region Skåne,Sweden Szechenyi,Nicholas,Europa InterCluster,France Sölvell,Örjan,Center for Strategy and Competitiveness,Sweden Taleb,Ms. Nehal,Egyptian National Competitiveness Council,Egypt Talmon L’Armée,Tobias,Darmstadt University of Technology,Germany Tarvainen,Elise,Regional Council of Central Finland,Finland Tarvainen,Marianna,Regional Council of Central Finland,Finland Terpager,Pouline,Nordic Council of Ministers,Denmark Tervonen,Päivi,Jyväskylä Regional Development Company,Finland Tervonen ,Jussi,Unelmania / Team Academy,Finland Teräs,Jukka,Norrum Ltd. ,Finland
Thorburn,Karen,Hermia,Finland Tidona,Christian,BioRN Cluster Management GmbH,Germany Timonen,Laura,South Karelian Institute, Lappeenranta University of Technology,Finland Toivanen ,Erkki,Journalist,United Kingdom Tokila ,Anu,University of Jyväskylä,Finland Toni,Sulameri,Hermia Oy,Finland Topdar,Asish,Small Industries Development Bank of India,India Totsis,Nikolaos,CHAMBER OF ARCADIA,Greece Tuma,Ruth,GOVERNMENT OF UGANDA,Uganda Tuominen,Rea,Jyväskylä Educational Consortium ,Finland Tyagi,Ravi,Small Industries Development Bank of India,India Urpilainen,Leo,Regional Council of Central Finland,Finland Waalen,Ragnar,SIVA sf.,Norway Waelbroeck-Rocha,Elisabeth,BIPE,France Waeltring,Frank,mesopartner,Germany Wahlgrén,Asta,JAMK University of Applied Sciences, School of Business and Services Management,Finland Valdenebro,Patricia,TCI Network - The Competitiveness Institute,Spain Walker,Richard David,Economic Development Australia,Australia Valle,Antti,Finnish Ministry of Employment and the Economy,Finland Venkata Durga Nageswara Rao,Sonti,Indian Institute of Technology (IIT) Bombay,India Wictorsson,Carola,Jyväskylä Innovation Ltd,Finland Widgren,Petri,Business Arena Ltd. ,Finland Vierne,Valentine,Brandenburg Economic Development Board,Germany Vihinen,Eeva-Liisa,Humap Ltd.,Finland Vilkkilä,Tiina,JAMK University of Applied Sciences,Finland Vilkuna,Kyösti,Student,Finland Williams,Mats,The Paper Province,Sweden Vilppola,Jukka,Jyväskylä Educational Consortium,Finland Virtanen,Esko,,Finland Wise,Emily,Research Policy Institute, Lund University and IEC,Sweden Vogelmann,Helene,VINNOVA,Sweden Volpini,Lina,SEBRAE-MG,Brazil Vos,Marita,University of Jyvaskyla,Finland Vuori ,Katja,JAMK University of Applied Sciences,Finland Vuorinen,Raimo,University of Jyväskylä,Finland Väisänen,Satu,Jyväskylä Educational Consortium ,Finland Väisänen,Vilma,Partus Ltd. ,Finland Ylimartimo,Anneli,JAMK University of Applied Sciences, School of Technology,Finland Zingmark,Anna,VINNOVA,Sweden Ziraba,Yasin Naku,Makerere University (ISCP-U),Uganda Ängsback,Åsa,Region Dalarna,Sweden
Expertise from all over the world Regional Meetings
Asia Ellora Mubashir, Consultant, Institute of Rural Research & Development: Contributions to Indian Agriculture: Case studies of Proagro and IRRAD Dilip Kumar, SIDBI Venture Capital Limited, India: Venture Funding for Innovative of Technology oriented Businesses Manoj Mittal, DGM, SIDBI: Agglomeration and deglomeration factors for cluster development – Study of select clusters Ramesh Dharma, GM, SIDBI Foundation for Risk Capital & Ravi Tyagi, DGM, SIDBI Foundation for Risk Capital: Innovation within Asian Enterprise Kaushik Mukherjee, Managing Director, Karnataka State Financial Corporation: Special Economic Zones in India Dr. Amit Kapoor, Institute for Competitiveness: Competitiveness of Cities and States in India Harinder Jeet Singh, CII, India: SME Clusters in Asia South East Asia Dr. Tatchawan Kanitpong, Assistant Professor, NIDA Business School, Thailand: The automobile cluster and its role in Thailand’s competitiveness Mr. Kuo Tung Soo, Senior Assistant Director, Economics and Strategy Division, Ministry of Trade and Industry, Singapore: Competitiveness of Singapore Dr. Ashish Lall, Associate Professor, Asia Competitiveness Institute, LKY School of Public Policy, National University of Singapore: The IT-enabled Services Cluster in the Philippines Middle East Gayane Afrikian, Director, Dubai Competitiveness Council: Clusters and Dubai’s Competitiveness Latin America Alonso Ramos Vaca: Presentation of the Latin American Cluster Network (RedLAC) Maria Victoria Abreu Malla, Technical Deputy Director - National Competitiveness Council- Dominican Republic: Tourism Clusters in the Dominican Republic: Lessons Learned Julio Agostini, Director of Operations - Sebrae-PR - Curitiba, Paraná – Brazil: Dealing with regional cluster realities in Brazil Pablo Darscht, Director of PACPYMES, Ministry of Industry, Mining and Energy, Uruguay: Fostering clusters in Uruguay: A systemic approach Doris Ly Muñoz, Innovation Officer -Maule Regional Development Agency, Chile & Marynella Salvador, Executive Director - Atacama Regional Development Agency, Chile: Contrasting clustering experiences in two regions of Chile Africa Peter Chisawillo: Update on PACF Executive Committee Activities since Cape Town Briefing on Organisation of PACF General Assembly in December 2009 Joshua Mutambi: Briefing on Institutionalisation of the Cluster Concept in Uganda Peter Chisawillo: The World Bank Competitiveness Project in Tanzania and the Cluster concept Baltic Sea Region Theme 1: Fact based innovation and cluster activities, Andreas Graversen, FORA
Theme 2: From BSR InnoNet to Programme for Innovation, Clusters and SME-Networks, Jens Erik Lund, BSR InnoNet and Helene Vogelmann, VINNOVA Theme 3: Reflections on open frameworks for innovation activities, Arne Eriksson, AEK-Consult and Henrik Hultin, synocus group
1. Vision and leadership of clusters Frank Eetgerink, Oost NV, Netherlands: Food Valley, the next step Linda Jamison, Invest NI, UK: Case Study- Leadership in the sustainable energy cluster and practical tools to support the evolution of commercial driven networks Patrik Laxell, Synocus Oy, Finland: Creative design processes in cluster settings Bjoern Sautter, Steinbeis Europa Zentrum, Germany: Strategic intercluster collaboration in the globalising knowledge economy Jan Sandred, Gunnar Backman, VINNOVA, Sweden and John Nash, Iowa State University, USA: Impact Logic Assessment – How to significantly shorten time-to-impact and create tangible change through a cluster Simone Hagenauer, ecoplus. Niederösterreichs Wirtschaftsagentur GmbH, Austria: Cluster Manager Qualification for Internationalisation of Clusters Joan Marti, ACC1Ó, Spain Kajsa Linnarsson, Open Global, USA Mikko Ahonen, Jyväskylä Innovation Ltd. , Finland 2. Show me the money! JanErik Odhe, Mikael Lundström, Mats Williams, Steel & Engineering/Compare/The Paper Province, Sweden: Business leverages by cooperation Marc Papell, Cluster Development, Spain: Spanish Software Business Mobility Cluster Harinder Jeet Singh, CII-LM Thapar Centre for competitiveness for SMEs, India: Enhancing competitiveness of SMEs - Cluster Approach Magnus Ernström, Region Gävleborg, Sweden: Implementing innovations in the public sector. Pascal Lampe, NIRO e. V, Germany: NIRO - the dynamic difference fast track for value-added to business TCI World Cluster Café: Internationalisation of Clusters and the future of Cluster networks Klaus Haasis, CEO MFG Baden-Württemberg/TCI German Contact Point Michael Lill, CEO IHK Zetis GmbH Elina Humala, Jyväskylä Regional Development Company, Jykes Ltd: How to help local actors see the global opportunities? Christoph Beer, ICT Cluster Bern, Lucia Seel, Clusterland Oberösterreich, Pascal Lampe, CEO Network Industry Ruhr East Samy Nadifi, IBI International: Quadruple Helix; Cluster Access to Finance Commentary by Antti Hautamäki, University of Jyväskylä 3. Global interaction and learning Mark T. McCord, Economic Development and Growth for Enterprises Project: Community-based tourism and cluster development: Enhancing Competitiveness through Community Empowerment Marynella Salvador, Development regional Agency: Atacama Chile, Chile and Inés Sagrario, Competitiveness Ltd., Spain: From theory to practice, AquAtacama: reinventing business. Ewa Andersson, Cecilia Johansson, VINNOVA, Sweden: Networks of clusters - a pilot case Alessandro Minello, University of Venice, Italy: Towards learning clusters? The growth and decline of clusters in Veneto region.
12th TCI Annual Global Conference - Learning Clusters adapting to the new competence scenario LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE 45
EXPERTISE Matti Härkönen, Jyväskylä Educational Consortium and Nina Rautiainen, Central Finland Chamber of Commerce: How learning becomes the leading process of new business? – Learning broker process in Central Finland. Emiliano Duch, IESE Business School, Spain: European Cluster Excellence Initiative Raimo Vuorinen, University of Jyväskylä: Added value of lifelong guidance in competence development within clusters? 4. Creativity and sustainable competitiveness Anna Majó Crespo, 22@Barcelona, Spain: Clusters development strategies in urban environments Xavier Ferràs, CIDEM, Spain: Cooperative R+D as a tool to foster emerging clusters Mette Quinn, European Commission, Belgium: Creative industries and service clusters Pirkko Korhonen, City of Jyväskylä / URBACT Programme: From Creative Clusters to the Creative Place Amit Kapoor, Institute for Competitiveness, India: Sustainability and Competitiveness Jörgen Elbe, Destination Dalarna, Sweden: Applying development models across different industries 5. Clusters in a new world Richard Walker, Economic Development Australia, Australia: Adapting to Climate Change through the development of new green industries. Risto Jämsen, Jyväskylä Regional Development Company, Jykes Ltd., Finland: Customer-oriented service model in restructuring processes Walter Freudenthaler, ecoplus - The Business agency of Lower Austria Ltd., Austria: How cluster initiatives can contribute to energy efficiency and strengthen small scaled regional economy Antoni Soy, Deputy Minister for Industry and Enterprise, Generalitat de Catalunya: New industry in Catalonia and renewal of cluster and industrial policy. 6. Knowledge non-stop Lucia Seel, Clusterland Upper Austria, Austria: Developing a new international cooperation platform for cluster organisations and their members Neil Reid, University of Toledo and the European ProClusters Association, USA: Social Network Analysis - How Can it be Used to Improve the Management of Clusters? Mari Jose Aranguren, Miren Larrea, Orkestra-Instituto Vasco de Competitividad, Spain: Evaluation to envisioning a shared future Indira Singh, Ministry of Northern Development and Mines and Forestry, Canada: Connecting Clusters: A Canada--Russia Pilot Nicole Litzel, IAB Institute for Employment Research, Germany : The Cluster-Oriented Regional Information System CORIS - adding transparency to a cluster region Julia Roelofsen, InnoPraxis International Ltd., Finland: New practical approach to using clusters for creating regional innovation system 7. Lessons from the Finnish cluster policy Introduction of the Finnish Center of Expertise Program, and its evolution as a platform for local and national cluster initiatives. Facilitated by Senior Consultant Patrik Laxell, Synocus Ltd. Ministerial Adviser Pirjo Kutinlahti, Ministry of Employment and the Economy: OSKE –program Competence Cluster presentations: Juha Miettinen, Ubiquitous Computing Competence Cluster Program, Director Mervi Pitkänen, Maritime Competence Cluster Patrik Laxell, Synocus Ltd.: Lessons learned for cluster policy making and cluster management at local and national level
46 LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE
8. A gender perspective as a mean for cluster development The Swedish Agency for Economic and Regional Growth, Ewa Andersson & Monika Jönsson-Brydsten, Innovation Norway, Eivind Petershagen, Vinnova, Jennie Granat Thorslund and Lars-Gunnar Larsson How can strategies for gender equality contribute to growth in clusters. Reflections from an action oriented gender and innovation researcher, Ann-Christin Nyberg, Luleå University of Technology Marita Svensson, Fiber Optic Valley, Emma Østerbø, NCE Raufoss Women’s forum, Kerstin Hindrum, Marine Technology Forum: Design & Product development
48 LEARNING CLUSTERS MAGAZINE
Published on Nov 2, 2009
Magazine published on the occasion of the 12th TCI Annual Global Conference "Learning Clusters adapting to the new competitiveness scenario"...