Issue 1
TPJv1-11.indd 1
JULY/september 2011
8/4/11 12:03 PM
World-Class Technology. Local Commitment. Document Technologies, Inc. offers end-to-end discovery solutions including: Discovery Consulting | Data Preservation & Acquisition | ESI Processing | Hosted Data Review | Paper-based Discovery
DTI is the nation’s largest independent provider of legal support services and document outsourcing. After vigilant research and testing of the best legal technology on the market today, we incorporate our own industry-leading tools and processing techniques to assemble a package of products and services that are second-to-none. Our strength lies in the combination of this wealth of technology, our experienced team, a national footprint, and in our unique capacity to handle the largest of projects quickly and accurately.
Document technologies, inc. w w w. d t i g l o b a l . c o m
ATLANTA • BOSTON • CHARLOTTE • CHICAGO • COLUMBIA • DENVER • LOS ANGELES • NEWARK • NEW YORK • NORFOLK • ORLANDO PHILADELPHIA • PHOENIX • RALEIGH • RICHMOND • SAN DIEGO • SAN FRANCISCO • SEATTLE • TAMPA • WASHINGTON D.C. • WINSTON SALEM
TPJv1-11.indd 2
8/4/11 12:03 PM
contents
july/September 2011
Departments In Every Issue: 20
Feature Articles:
Association Profile This Paralegal Association is Setting New Standards
30
Career Path Always Moving Forward
9 Professionalism
5
Navigation Tools For Your Career
LIGHTBULB Moments 10
Regulation Update Is it Time for Regulation or Just Time to Regulate Ourselves
33
Sound Off! Survey Results Paralegals Respond to Survey on Paralegal Schools
18 Technology It’s 2011: Why Don’t Paralegal
15 Is Paralegal
Education Keeping Pace?
Schools Have E-Discovery Classes? 14
The Lighter Side Believe it or not - It’s The Law
24
View Points What Value Is There in Continuing Education?
34 35
21 Associates
vs Paralegals
Advertiser Directory Continuing Education Litigation Paralegal Boot Camp
34
Subscription Information
26 The X Factor in Indispensable
Issue 1 - 2011 • THEPARALEGALJOURNAL.COM •
3
EDITOR’S NOTE
We are excited to give you our first issue of The Paralegal Journal! Our mission is to promote the paralegal profession and to do so by inspiring career growth and reminding you that you are in a profession that you should be proud of.
Rather than just write
about what has happened in the paralegal profession this past year, we will provide tools that you can use to advance your career this year and beyond. Benjamin Franklin once said, “Without continual growth and progress, such words as improvement, achievement and success mean nothing.” The Paralegal Journal wants to be a part of that growth and progress. Sometimes that will mean publishing articles that get conversation started about topics that others consider off-limits or do not want to publish for fear of scaring away advertisers. Like a couple of the articles in this issue that question whether keeping the status quo in paralegal education is holding back the profession as a whole. Why does that matter to the paralegal who has been out of school for ten years? It matters because that newly graduated paralegal who lacks the proper training will struggle through their first, second and third paralegal jobs until they finally get the training they need or they give up on being a paralegal. All of the attorneys they have worked with along the way have formed an unfair and incorrect assessment of paralegals and that is not good for anyone. There are some “feel-good” stories out there that we will report on occasion, if it sets an example for change like the one this month in the Paralegal Association Profile section showing other associations that obstacles are only obstacles if you let them be. Sometimes obstacles are motivators for change. It has been said that your world changes when you create something and put it into the world for everyone to benefit from. That’s because what we create contains a little spark of us, a spark of who we are. At a minimum, I hope this magazine ignites a spark that you want to put out into the world, inspired by a renewed level of pride in your profession.
Many thanks and happy reading,
Ann
Ann Pearson apearson@theparalegaljournal.com
4 • THEPARALEGALJOURNAL.COM • Issue 1 - 2011
Publisher. Pearson Resource Management, LLC
Managing Editor Ann Pearson
Advertising Sales Director Tom Flynn
Graphic Design and Photography DzinDNA.com
Website iQuest Web Design
Contributing Writers This Issue Perry Binder Phillip Bradley D. Jeffrey Campbell Craig Hardesty K. Paezle Harris Terri Hendley Keisha Hudson Grace Heron-Nolan Todd Noebel Ann Pearson Gina Romaniello Erika Santiago
Contact The Paralegal Journal
Web: www.theparalegaljournal.com Email: info@theparalegaljournal.com Phone: 404-378-8370 Fax: 404-592-6109 Mail: Pearson Resource Management, LLC 1401 Peachtree Street, Suite 500 Atlanta, GA 30309 Media Kit Requests: info@theparalegaljournal.com © COPYWRIGHT 2011 by Pearson Resource Management, LLC. All rights reserved. The contents of this publication may not be reproduced without the written consent of the publisher. Articles contained in this publication may provide opinions of the authors that are not presumed to be opinions of the publisher. Any article submissions to The Paralegal Journal are submitted with consent from the author to the publisher to edit any content as deemed necessary for publication. The Paralegal Journal does not endorse or recommend any advertising materials contained herein.
Feature Article
Navigational Tools for Your Career I admit I was skeptical when I
paid for the navigational system on my car a few years ago. Not only did I resist entering my destination to get the turn-byturn directions, but I often forget to look at the map on the screen as a resource when I already knew where I was going. Fast forward to today: I regularly use the navigational system to find new places and to obtain suggested alternative routes to familiar locations.
Issue 1 - 2011 • THEPARALEGALJOURNAL.COM •
TPJv1-11.indd 5
5
8/4/11 12:04 PM
Feature Article
Does your career have a destination? Have you decided which turns to take to get there without getting lost or taking a more circuitous route than necessary? Will you use a navigational system with suggested routes or remember to look at the map?
If your goal is too vague, it will be impossible to know when it has been accomplished. Think about your general idea first, and then narrow your statement so that you have a clear objective.
For
example, a general idea is to become more proficient in technology. A specific goal is to become an advanced user of Microsoft Excel and PowerPoint.
Many large law firms require their associates to design the roadmap for their successful career, calling this map a professional development plan. They sit down with a supervisor and discuss areas of focus. Skills, client service, and leadership are just a few of
How will you know if you have met your goal? If you cannot answer
the areas that may be on the list. At regular intervals throughout the
this question, you cannot measure your progress and you are likely
year, they gauge their progress to ensure they are staying on track.
to feel frustrated. In our Excel and PowerPoint example, is there a
At the end of the year, their
certificate you can obtain to show your achievement?
accomplishments are part of the
you can reach the point where you do not need to call the help desk
Or, perhaps
evaluation and compensation
regularly for guidance.
process. While many associates aspire to be partners, the career path for a paralegal is not as well defined. It is important that you think about where you want to be in five years and use an annual professional development plan as your roadmap to success. If you want a paralegal career and not just a paralegal job, consider creating a roadmap by putting pen to paper (or laser printer
It is important to set goals that will cause you to step out of your comfort zone but are still reachable. If the goal is too extreme, you may feel defeated and throw the goal out the window entirely. If you have no experience with Excel and PowerPoint, it may be unreasonable to achieve an Advanced User status within a short period of time. Don’t set yourself up to fail.
ink to paper) and intentionally designing goals that you can achieve in a given year. Having a professional development plan says that you are serious about your career. If you wait for your employer to do things to advance your career, you will be waiting a long time. Make your own roadmap to where you want to be, take charge of getting
Don’t just randomly pick a software program to learn. Be sure that
yourself there and arriving on time.
the goal you are setting is relevant to your current position and also to your long term goals. If your word processing department always
To get you started, let’s spend time on the SMART way to set
handles spreadsheets, be sure that your time spent on Excel will move
goals.
your career forward. Is there another program that your supervising
SMART goals are specific, measurable, attainable, relevant and time-based.
attorneys want you to learn?
Without these components, the path to your defined career
We are all accustomed to working under deadlines, and goal-setting
success could take longer than necessary and be difficult to achieve.
is no different. Without a deadline, you will not be motivated. Use a specific date to reach your goal. Put the deadline on your calendar and add reminder dates to track your progress. Handle your goals like any other client deadline.
6 • THEPARALEGALJOURNAL.COM • Issue 1 - 2011 TPJv1-11.indd 6
8/4/11 12:04 PM
Feature Article Your Personal Roadmap for a OneYear Professional Development Plan The best place to start your roadmap is to look at your annual performance reviews for this past year. Break the review down into specific items you can improve upon, together with the steps you need to take to get there. For example, if you received a “good” rating rather than an “excellent” rating on the evaluation topic “understands and uses available technology in an efficient manner,” part of your professional development plan for this year may look like the chart below after you’ve defined your goal and made sure it’s a goal that is specific, measurable, attainable, relevant and timebased. General Goal
Increase technology skills in specific practice area
Specific Goal
Become an advanced user in Microsoft Excel and PowerPoint
Resources Needed
a. Time to attend monthly lunch and learns by IT dept
b. Time to find and attend free training sessions by vendors
c. Money to attend off-site webinars
d. Opportunities to put new skills to practice
Some of your yearly goals need to be steps in the direction you want to arrive in five years.
Obstacles I May Encounter
Like any other project, start with the end in mind and then break down the tasks to be accomplished to reach the goal.
a. Not enough non-billable time to focus on training without incurring overtime
b. No money in the budget
Time-frame
12 months
You should have an honest conversation with yourself about the obstacles you have identified. If there is no money in the budget,
Let’s say you are currently a litigation paralegal who wants to eventually transition to a litigation support specialist. Think about what technology you need to learn in addition to any management and leadership skills that will be required to be successful. On your professional development plan for the next twelve months, consider including some of these steps:
will you pay for the training yourself? Are you willing to spend your own time off-the-clock to learn this software? If your answer is “yes,” then keep the goal. If your answer is “no” and there is no money in your organization’s budget for outside training, then you might need a new goal. Another place to look at starting your roadmap is your resume. Update your resume to include your current employer; add any specialty classes you have recently attended and skills you have gained with your current position. Ask yourself: how does my resume look to a potential future employer? Solicit advice from a professional if possible. Finally, take a look at your goal to be sure it is SMART.
Where Do You Want to Be in Five Years? I suggest that you answer this question before you spend too much time on your one-year goals.
4 Attend litigation support training class once per year; 4 Manage large litigation cases; 4 Become active in local litigation support organization; 4 Attend free webinars on e-discovery; and 4 Attend delegation and supervision training classes. By having a professional development plan and following through on that plan, you’ve increased your skill set and advanced your career in your current position even if your destination changes along the way and you decide not to transition to that litigation
Issue 1 - 2011 • THEPARALEGALJOURNAL.COM •
TPJv1-11.indd 7
7
8/4/11 12:04 PM
support role. Accomplishing your goals may not provide you with
take a definite number of hours. The question that follows is: do
an immediate benefit with your current employer, but it will offer
you have the time to stick it out for years of night classes and long
you an increased level of confidence in knowing that your talents are
work schedules in order to achieve that goal? Only you can answer
superior enough to more easily gain future employment.
these questions if that is your goal.
Take another look at your resume. Maybe your skills are up-todate, but your length of employment at each company is too short. One of your goals on your professional development plan might be to stay with your current employer for at least another three years. Are there any resources or roadblocks that you may encounter in
Decide where you want to be in five years and start making a plan that will get you there.
reaching this goal? If your education includes an Associate Degree
Do not get lost on the way to your destination and if you do,
and a paralegal certificate, your professional development plan
use the navigational system to get you back on track. The suggested
might include taking classes towards your Bachelor’s Degree. Is
routes are only as limited as you make them. By taking control of
the goal specific? Yes, getting a college degree is a specific goal. Is
your career with a professional development roadmap and setting
the goal measurable? Yes, it is easy to measure a college degree. Is
SMART goals, your journey will be more successful and you can
the goal relevant? That depends on what the Bachelor’s Degree is
enjoy the trip along the way. h
in. While it might be helpful should you find the need to get another job, is it relevant to your current position? Only you can answer that question depending on your current position and your future desired position. Is it time-based? Yes, the goal is time-based in that it will
Did You Know?
Terri A. Hendley, RP, is a marketing and professional development consultant for busy lawyers who realize their time is better spent practicing law rather than handling the administrative tasks necessary to grow their practice. Terri’s 25 years of law firm experience in professional development and paralegal roles provides a unique understanding of the challenges lawyers face in developing and maintaining client relationships. She can be contacted by email terri@helpforbusylawyers.com.
REAL E
As of May, 2010 there were 247,940 paralegals employed in the United States. http://www.bls.gov/oes/current/oes232011.htm
TRIAD IS T FOR TIC S • Relieves Closing
• Formatio quickly a
• Provide the inves
• Web bas manage
Solutions for commercial real estate owners, developers, operators, Solutions for Exchange commercial real estate investors, REITs and 1031 Programs (TICs)owners,
• Resource for help complian
developers, operators, investors, REITs and 1031 Exchange Programs (TICs)
TRIAD specializes in corporate services and entity management for the real estate industry. Customized services for transactions in connection with purchases, acquisitions, mergers, joint ventures and financing are provided by professionals with over 45 years of experience in corporate and real estate transactions.
TRIAD specializes in corporate services and entity management for the real estate industry. services forINCLUDE: transactions in connection TRIAD’S EXPERTISE IN THE REALCustomized ESTATE INDUSTRY with purchases, acquisitions, mergers, joint ventures and financing are • LLC Formation and Qualification. provided • Registered Services. •with Lien over Searches in County, State and Federal Jurisdictions. byAgent professionals 45 years of experience in corporate and • Independent Manager appointments for special purpose entities and mezzanine loans. real estate transactions.
CASE STU
• Company Tracker to keep entities organized.
877.805.6723 8 • THEPARALEGALJOURNAL.COM • Issue 1 - 2011 TPJv1-11.indd 8
TRIAD’S EXPERTISE IN THE REAL ESTATE INDUSTRY INCLUDE: • LLC Formation and Qualification.
www.triadpros.com
• Registered Agent Services. • Lien Searches in County, State and Federal Jurisdictions. • Independent Manager appointments for special purpose entities and mezzanine loans. • Company Tracker to keep entities organized.
8/4/11
BACKGROU estate com developm constructi brokerage residentia
CHALLENG administe cost savin 12:04 PM their inves
professionalism
Instilling Professionalism & Humor in an Adversarial System © 2011 Perry Binder, Esq.
presenting “Instilling Professionalism and
Negative aspects of the legal profession
Humor in an Adversarial System” for PRM’s
Injustice, chaotic, time, rules, slow,
paralegal conference in Atlanta, Georgia.
frustrating, too serious, disparity, time
As a recovering civil litigator from a
sheets,
different decade, I am always curious about
communication, unethical. I offered sage
topics ranging from how cordial colleagues
advice on many of these issues.
Recently, I had the pleasure of
are today to whether technology makes us more efficient or more uptight. This article is an abridged version of that discussion.
2011 1986 to
Cell phone The Brick Case Management Paper Tickler System Software .pdf .tiff .jpg .doc Bates Stamp Electronic Data Boxes of docs in a Discovery Bates Motel Who has an 5 1/2 Inch floppy disk external drive? IM, Text, Tweet Get up and speak with someone After a trip down technology memory lane at the conference, I asked attendees to describe the most positive and negative aspects of the legal profession for paralegals:
Positive aspects of the legal profession Justice,
help
others,
adversarial,
lack
of
Effective communication with your attorney: I really didn’t say everything I said. – Yogi Berra
25 Years of Now v. Then BlackBerries Phone call home on weekend
difficult,
Handling ethical issues Those are my principles, and if you don’t like them…well, I have others. – Groucho Marx Dealing with mistakes So go ahead, fall down. The world looks different from the ground. – Oprah Winfrey
Perry’s L.I.G.H.T.B.U.L.B. Moments of Professionalism L. isten to your Paralegals I. nspire and challenge them with interesting work
G. ive hope to everyone in the firm H. eap compliments on Paralegals for quality work
T. each to your strengths as an attorney B. e patient with your Paralegal U. nderstand that new Paralegals lack your knowledge of the law *
L. earn from your Paralegals B. e willing to walk in your Paralegal’s shoes * I then issued a challenge to conference attendees by asking how many seasoned
Adapting to change in a professional manner
paralegals give newly minted attorneys
Change is good. You go first. – Dilbert
practicing law. The nods of agreement led
We all agreed on one thing – that paralegals today care about the quality of their work as much as paralegals did twenty five long years ago. And that is the main
a hard time for not knowing a thing about me to remember a brief period of time when paralegals were not my law heroes! But we closed on a positive note, with something I communicate in some manner to all of my students:
reason why paralegals are my law heroes.
Every one of you is special. Every one
Simply put, paralegals make litigation
of you is a productive member of society.
electronic
attorneys look so good in court, while at
discovery, equitable, resolve issues, equal,
Every one of you is what inspires me,
times do not receive the proper recognition
service, interesting, fairness, nothing is the
because every one of you has a story to tell.
or respect from supervising attorneys. For
same every day
What will your next professional adventure
this reason, I offered a serious message and
be? g
challenge to attorneys: Perry Binder, Esq. is an award-winning legal studies professor at Georgia State University and the former director of Clayton State University’s Paralegal Program (1996-2000). Perry’s training sessions for Paralegals in law firms and companies have been described as “practical, enthusiastic, and hilarious,” and are listed at http://www.PerryBinder.com .
Issue 1 - 2011 • THEPARALEGALJOURNAL.COM •
TPJv1-11.indd 9
9
8/4/11 12:04 PM
What I need
is a court reporting firm that provides timely delivery of quality court reporters and transcripts. Where can I find that?”
Relax.
Merrill’s got you covered.
Every day, Merrill Corporation, the international provider of professional deposition services, provides high-quality deposition services to clients right in your neighborhood. Working with your local, reliable Merrill office is easy and stress-free!
Is It Time For Regulation or Just Time To Regulate Ourselves?
Simply call Merrill or visit the Web for easy “one-click” scheduling: A global network of professional court reporters U.S. and international deposition locations State-of-the-art conference rooms Videoconferencing Realtime Deposition videography Streaming realtime and video A Web-based, online transcript repository That’s all it takes! Tell us what you need and we’ll take care of all the details. Call 866.351.3376 or e-mail scheduling.atlanta@merrillcorp.com to schedule your deposition today. MERRILL CORPORATION
10 • THEPARALEGALJOURNAL.COM • Issue 1 - 2011 TPJv1-11.indd 10
8/4/11 12:04 PM
regulation update They were written by the
Carolina are states that have implemented
certification (or licensure) are not new
Voluntary certification and mandatory
Florida Alliance of Paralegal Associations
voluntary certification programs through
considerations for the paralegal profession.
(FAPA) with the intent of preventing legal
their respective State Bars.
These ideas have been contemplated
secretaries and others from using the title
ohiobar.org ; http://www.floridabar.org ;
since the inception of the first professional
of paralegal and to formally define what a
http://www.tbls.org/pdf/laspln.pdf and http://
paralegal organizations.
paralegal is.
www.nccertifiedparalegal.gov respectively.
What is new
is the attention and support that these concepts are receiving today. It should not be a surprise, when you look at number of paralegals employed nationwide.
The
2010 U.S. Department of Labor estimate, even after downsizing in the last few years, indicates there are 247,900 paralegals in the United States. http://www.bls.gov/oes/ current/oes232011.htm A voluntary certification program is one a paralegal can choose to participate in to obtain a designation providing paralegal employees and employers with a benchmark to determine qualified individuals who are competent to provide legal services under the supervision of an attorney. Voluntary certification programs are offered through both NALA and NFPA, through state bar programs and through local/state paralegal associations. Mandatory certification or Licensure is a process by which an agency or branch of government grants permission to persons meeting
predetermined
committees.
Understandably the bills had supporters on both sides. Supporters believed it would help protect the integrity of the profession. Opponents worried it would give paralegals a license to work directly with clients on matters that should be handled by an attorney, putting the client at a disadvantage. May and are not being further considered.
to engage in a given occupation. It is a
As an additional blow to FAPA, the Florida
mandatory legal condition of employment
State Bar established a special committee to
generally established for the protection of
report on the Study of Mandatory Regulation
the public. This is level of regulation has
of Paralegals. After presentation of their
proposed but to date has not been approved
findings, the Florida Bar voted to endorse the
and implemented.
minority opinion of the special committee
under
consideration
by
the
Florida
Supreme court that would require the Court to develop a licensing and continuing education scheme and make it a felony for unlicensed people to identify themselves as paralegals. If passed, Florida would have been the first state requiring paralegals to
New Jersey just joined these ranks with a plan approved in October 2010.
http://
www.sjpaparalegals.org. The Empire State Alliance of Paralegal Associations, which is comprised of eight city associations, has put forth a proposal for a state wide paralegal certification proposal. The proposal created in September 2010 did not identify the organization which would administer the program. http://www.empirestateparalegals. org/position_papers
Both bills died in subcommittees in
qualifications
Recently two companion bills were
http://www.
which was not supportive of mandatory regulation.
Details of the majority and
minority reports can be found at http://www. floridabar.org The FAPA webpage suggests that they are not done pursuing mandatory regulation of the paralegal profession and are still inviting people to get involved to effectuate change. http://fapainc.org
hold a license. The bills sponsored by Sen.
While Florida is the first state to make it
Garrett Richter, R-Naples, and state Rep.
this far in the consideration of licensing, the
Richard Steinberg, D-Miami Beach, were
concept is not new or limited to the sunshine
filed March 9 and assigned to the judiciary
state.
Ohio, Florida, Texas and North
Issue 1 - 2011 • THEPARALEGALJOURNAL.COM •
TPJv1-11.indd 11
11
8/4/11 12:04 PM
regulation update Other states, such as Oklahoma, do not
expire over time. The two largest national
possibly globally, accepted definition of the
have a formal certification program but the
organizations NALA and NFPA, each have
profession and scope of work. States seem
Oklahoma State Bar has adopted “Minimum
respected certification programs that many
to be in agreement as to the education and
Qualification Standards for Legal Assistants
of the states use as a requirement to apply
work experience that qualifies someone as
and Paralegals”. Their minimum standards,
to their programs.
competent in the profession. The states also
which allow you to be employed in the
have similar takes on the amount of
capacity of a legal assistant or paralegal,
continuing education that would be
require you to have completed the CLA or
required to maintain at the front of
PACE examine or meet other school/work
the field. The difficult part will come
experience combinations. http://www.okbar.
in finding the organization that can
org/members/committees/legalasst.htm The
lead all the existing organizations
idea of having these standards is to give
to work together for the greater good
consistency to attorneys and corporations
of the profession without promoting
utilizing the services of legal assistants and
their own agenda.
paralegals, and billing clients for them.
Other states have certification programs that are not governed by their State Bar or legislature but instead have been developed, implemented and policed by state paralegal associations such as the Kentucky Paralegal Association and the Delaware Paralegal Association.
An informative resource for state by state regulation/ certification guide can be found on the NPFA website: www. paralegal.org. Click on their “Position and Issues” tab then click on “Regulation”. They have done a great job with summaries and links to each state.
With almost 250,000 paralegals nationwide, maybe paralegals who disagree with the current state of regulation and certification or who would like to keep the status quo, would be better-served to come up with their own definition, rather than having it completely in the hands of Additionally, NFPA held an entire
legislators or lawyers who have never been
http://www.kypa.org/CKP.htm and http://
conference in 2010 focusing on regulation,
paralegals? That is for you to decide. The
www.deparalegals.com/dcp-program.php
the history, the process and the future.
only way to ensure that you have a say in
With such focus on regulation at state
how we are regulated is to become active
levels and within the national professional
in your state’s paralegal associations,
organizations, it is a matter of time before
bar associations and contact your state
there is some cohesive program for the whole
representatives. a
While specific requirements to these programs can be as varied as the number of states that have them, there is some consistency.
Existing
and
proposed
programs each require applicants to meet experience criteria through a combination of national certification, school and/or work experience.
Renewal requirements are
tied to earning CLE’s within a specified time frame. Many programs have initial grandfathering clauses as well that will
profession to adhere to.
In researching
this article, I had the opportunity to read many states’ definitions of the profession. I also read through lists of criteria that qualify individuals to work in the paralegal profession. The good news is that there is a similarity in these items that would not make it hard to come to a nationally,
As Director of PRM’s Education Division, Gina Romaniello is responsible for all aspects of PRM’s paralegal educational conferences and is a contributing writer for The Paralegal Journal. Ms. Romaniello is an accomplished professional with diverse experience involving event planning and paralegal experience including compliance, franchise licensing and training. Ms. Romaniello collaborates with educators, paralegals, conference sponsors and local paralegal managers to insure PRM’s educational conferences deliver relevant and useful training that will benefit paralegals.
12 • THEPARALEGALJOURNAL.COM • Issue 1 - 2011 TPJv1-11.indd 12
8/4/11 12:04 PM
10 MINUTES OF YOUR TIME COULD SAVE YOU AND YOUR CLIENTS HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS IN REVIEW COSTS Vestigate is a hosted solution that dramatically streamlines the review process by combining the power of RenewData’s proprietary content analytics and review tool with Relativity, the market-leading review platform from kCura. Learn how organizations have radically increased reviewer accuracy – by up to 99.9% - and ensured that all relevant data has been identified. Anagram is a solution that expedites and removes the risk from the keyword selection process associated with legal or regulatory matters. Learn how to mitigate risk and improve results with a simple, transparent, explainable and more defensible method for developing keywords.
Contact RenewData to learn about two NEW, powerful solutions that drastically expedite & improve the legal review process Contact RenewData Today | www.renewdata.com | 888-811-3789 Issue 1 - 2011 • THEPARALEGALJOURNAL.COM •
TPJv1-11.indd 13
13
8/4/11 12:04 PM
The Lighter Side
Legislatures are charged with the duty
Georgia – Members of the state assembly South Carolina -
By law, if a man
of making laws that serve the interest of the
cannot be ticketed for speeding while the
promises to marry an unmarried woman, the
people. There are numerous laws that have
state assembly is in session.
marriage must take place.
yet to be made, ones that currently serve, and ones that obviously were made and
Hawaii – Not owning a boat could earn Texas - When two trains meet each other
long forgotten. Here is a list of outdated,
you a fine.
yet still existent local and state laws.
Iowa (Bettendorf ) –
Amazing, astonishing, absurd, intriguing, hilarious,
mind-boggling,
unbelievable,
implausible…..ok, you get the picture. Additional laws and their history can be found at www.dumblaws.com
Alabama –
at a railroad crossing, each shall come to a liquor stores
may not place advertisement for beer outside their store.
Illinois – It is illegal to speak English as American is the official recognized
driving while barefoot is
language.
full stop, and neither shall proceed until the other has gone; it is illegal to take more than three sips of beer at a time while standing.
Utah –
you must yield to birds while
driving on the highway.
Vermont (Barre) – All residents shall bathe on Saturday night.
against the law.
Louisiana – Having a pizza delivered to
Alaska (Fairbanks) – It is an offense
someone without their consent can bring a
Virginia – Prohibits trick-or-treating by
fine of $500.
children during Halloween.
Maine –
Washington -
to serve alcohol beverages to a moose.
Arizona – imitation
It is illegal to manufacture cocaine;
committing
a
misdemeanor while wearing a red mask is considered a felony.
Arkansas (Little Rock) – Dogs are
any portion of City Ordinance
A law to reduce crime
9 found in conflict with a local, state, or
states: “It is mandatory for a motorist with
federal government shall prevail as law if
criminal intentions to stop at the city limits
more stringent.
and telephone the chief of police as he is
Michigan – A woman’s hair is property of
entering the town.”
her husband; therefore, express permission
Wisconsin –
must be granted before going to the hair
substitute margarine for butter unless
Colorado (Boulder) – Not illegal to
salon.
expressly requested by the customer.
challenge a police officer until specifically
New York – The penalty for jumping off Wyoming – It is illegal to wear a hat that
not permitted to bark after 6 p.m.
asked to cease.
Connecticut (Southington) -
Restaurants may not
a building is death; Wearing clingy or body
obstructs the view of others in a public
hugging clothing can lead to a fine of $25.
theatre or place of amusement.
illegal to buy or possess silly string.
Pennsylvania -
Delaware (Lewes) - Getting married on
along a country road at night must stop
a dare is grounds for annulment.
every mile and send up a rocket signal,
Grace Heron Nolan is a paralegal at The Chase Law Firm in Tallahassee, Florida. Grace has worked in the legal field since 1996 in non-profit organizations, the Florida state government and private law firms. Grace received her Bachelor’s degree from Florida State University and her Associate’s degree in paralegal studies from Tallahassee Community College. Grace is a Florida Registered Paralegal (FRP), as recognized by the Florida Bar Association. She is also a member of the Paralegal Association of Florida (PAF) and the Big Bend Chapter of The Paralegal Association of Florid and currently serves as its Public Relations Chair and contributes to its monthly publication.
It is
Florida - It is against the law for to fall
Any motorist driving
wait 10 minutes for the road to be cleared of livestock, and continue; a special cleaning
asleep under a hair dryer…fines can also
ordinance bans housewives from hiding dirt
apply to the salon owner; if you want to leave
and dust under a rug in a dwelling.
your elephant tied to a meter, you must pay the same fee applicable to a car when
Rhode Island -
parked at a meter. (Orlando, Florida); It is
except ice polo and hockey, must obtain
an offense to shower naked; It is illegal to
a license to play games on Sunday; Biting
go skateboarding unless you have a license
off someone’s leg could earn you a prison
to do so.
sentence of one to twenty years.
Professional sports,
14 • THEPARALEGALJOURNAL.COM • Issue 1 - 2011 TPJv1-11.indd 14
8/4/11 12:04 PM
Feature Article
Is Paralegal Education Keeping Pace with the “New Normal”?
Issue 1 - 2011 • THEPARALEGALJOURNAL.COM •
TPJv1-11.indd 15
15
8/4/11 12:04 PM
Feature Article
By now, we have all heard and talked about the “new normal” in our industry so much that we would rather stick a pencil in our eye than hear another word about it. The reality is that our industry and our profession is -- and has been changing -- for some time. Clients are
teaching and became an administrator at the school in 2000. As a former educator, I would never argue that paralegal education is irrelevant or unnecessary; quite the contrary, I believe that paralegal education is important because solid programs provide an underlying foundation that supports critical thinking, organizational, and general communication skills, as well as legal theory and a practical application of the law. I would posit that now, more that ever, paralegal education can and should become even more relevant in preparing those poised to enter the profession.
Having said that,
now that I am a paralegal manager in a large law firm, I am finding that there are real gaps in people’s knowledge and skills that need
demanding greater efficiency; alternative
to be addressed at some educational level. I am not talking about
fee arrangements are working their way into the system slowly but surely; and
related to project management, eDiscovery, technology (more that
technology and eDiscovery are fast
In reviewing a sampling of curricula from several schools, most course descriptions have not changed a lot over the last 10 to 15 years.
growing and evolving. The recession and the “new normal” have probably accelerated these changes and served to heighten this sense of change as we adapt to newer circumstances more quickly
the need for any kind of remediation, but the knowledge and skills mere introduction), communication, and case management do not appear to be adequately incorporated into the curriculum, if at all.
than we might have otherwise done. Across the spectrum, we are having to revise our service delivery model, adapt to fee constraints, look at our processes and generally conduct much of our business more efficiently and effectively. A lot of changes have been brewing for some time, but are now simply reality. As legal professionals, we have had to look critically at our own professional development programs to ensure that we identify skills gaps that we need to address and develop. As we all embrace, or at least deal with, these changes, we cannot forget about people who are preparing to enter the profession. So, it begs the question: Is paralegal education keeping up with the changes in our industry? I earned my paralegal certificate at the National Center for Paralegal Training, an ABA-approved school in Atlanta, in 1996. Subsequently, I started
16 • THEPARALEGALJOURNAL.COM • Issue 1 - 2011 TPJv1-11.indd 16
8/4/11 12:04 PM
Feature Article Certainly, one can argue that the underpinnings of educational programs are the same: to foster critical thinking, and develop organizational and communication skills with the expectation that graduates build on their knowledge base as they progress in their careers. I get that argument, but really do not one-hundred percent buy it. There has been a shift in the profession, perhaps not to the core concepts of the foundation, but definitely to the exit competencies that are now needed which does extend to the curriculum and coursework.
A lot of programs seem to be stuck in the 80’s when it comes to technology courses still calling the class “Computers in the Law”. The majority of employers now need new-hires who are at least conversant in database structure and formation and possess the ability to construct and write
Since our needs are changing,
search terms and perform complex
we, as legal professionals and
searches.
educators, need to analyze and assess the current state
instill this knowledge on the job,
of education and decide who
one-hour seminars or, at most, day-
should provide the education
long classes do not provide enough
needed and at what level.
time to form the same foundation that can be fully built in a 30-hour
As a frequent speaker and
class.
participant at paralegal events, the first question usually asked
Additionally, some employers
of me by recent graduates and
simply do not have the available
current students is “How do
resources to provide the basic
I get my first paralegal job?”
knowledge needed by entry level
The question that really needs
paralegals.
to be asked of me and other
make you (the law firm) more likely to hire our students upon graduation.” As an employer, I obviously have a wish list that I would like candidates coming out of paralegal school to possess. Every program should require a course on eDiscovery that covers
Given the “new
normal” that is expected of law
paralegal managers and law firm administrators is “What can we teach our students that would
While employers or
external service providers can
firms, it is essential to hire a paralegal who has some level of understanding and exposure to eDiscovery, Adobe, Power Point, document databases and other legal technologies.
As legal professionals must keep abreast of trends and
the case law, the concepts, the process (as well as how to manage
changes in the industry, so, too, must educators. Moreover, we
it), what the major issues are, the prevailing solutions and best
must all remember that we are a community of practitioners each
practices. Some schools might argue that not all of their paralegal
with our own component and contribution to make. We have a duty
students plan to enter the legal industry as a litigation paralegal. To
as professionals to inform education providers of our needs and
that, they are correct. However, every person entering the industry,
requirements and our educators have a responsibility to ensure
whether they are in corporate and transactions or litigation, will be
that their programs meet the needs of the marketplace. It is the
exposed to the world of eDiscovery. Moreover, eDiscovery extends
only way to ensure that as the industry changes and the dust settles,
beyond litigation into all aspects of a business. I am not suggesting
our profession has grown with it and is poised to meet any and all
that paralegal students should be experts in eDiscovery upon
challenges that lie ahead. b
graduation; however, just like contracts, torts and real estate law, they should know the basic concepts and theory. Tangential to eDiscovery is project management. As we have most recently observed, legal project management is gaining ground and is no longer seen as a fad. While legal project management may not have reached the level of a requirement, it should be an elective course in any program. Most employers now simply expect
Craig Hardesty is the Manager of Paralegal Services for the Atlanta office of King & Spalding and is also an instructor in the Emory University Paralegal program. He has served as the Vice President of Professional Development and is the current Vice President for Outreach for the International Paralegal Management Association. Craig received his paralegal certificate from NCPT: The National Center for Paralegal Training where he subsequently taught and served as the Director of Career Services, Dean of Students, and the Executive Director. Before joining NCPT, Craig was a paralegal and the program administrator for the Georgia Law Center for the Homeless and a Policy Associate for the Georgia Center for Nonprofits. He holds a Bachelor of Arts in English from Towson State University and a Master of Public Administration from Georgia State University.
technical proficiency from paralegals.
Issue 1 - 2011 • THEPARALEGALJOURNAL.COM •
TPJv1-11.indd 17
17
8/4/11 12:04 PM
Technology
Why Don’t Paralegal Schools Have E-Discovery In Their Curriculum? Over the last ten years, the role of
corporations. I didn’t find a single paralegal
mail, e-discovery, e-filing, and so on--it is
the litigation paralegal has increasingly
program that offered a class just on project
essential that you gain the skills this text
involved
project
management. Case management seemed
seeks to impart. The 21st century is well
management whether it is for a small case
to be addressed as a component of other
under way and computer literacy is a basic
or a large e-discovery matter. I don’t think
classes but that is not project management.
competency in law offices.”
anyone would argue that today’s paralegal
As I reviewed course outlines available on
should have a strong command of available
school websites, I noticed that several of
legal technologies. Unfortunately, without
them appeared to be using the same text
on-the job training and hands-on work
book for their law office technology class. I
with these technologies, some paralegals
looked further into the text book listed and
are finding meeting this requirement quite
its author. He seems well qualified and the
a challenge as most paralegal educational
book (at over 600 pages) quite lengthy for a
programs do not include strong technology
4 – 6 week course. I found this quote from
The next step should be hiring litigation
So what can a paralegal do today to learn more about e-discovery and project management on their own time with little or no out of pocket cost?
in technology and e-discovery to teach the
litigation
technology
training as part of their coursework. I recently researched several of the popular paralegal schools looking for an e-discovery program and was disappointed in what was available (or not available). When I speak with recruiters or review job postings for litigation paralegals, technology skills, project management skills and e-discovery specific skills are generally required – not, “nice-to-haves.” So that leaves me with the question: if your paralegal school comes up short on e-discovery and litigation technology, what should you do? Paralegal schools
should
offer
an
e-discovery
curriculum but the reality is that very few do. Unfortunately, until the schools do offer it in their programs, that leaves paralegals to take on the responsibility for obtaining the education on their own. I reviewed the websites of about twenty schools and only found one who offered a class in e-discovery. All of the others offered a curriculum that met ABA standards for paralegal training but seriously fell short of teaching the technology skills required of practicing litigation paralegals in law firms or
However, the right text book is only a starting point for a school to meet competency
standards
for
discovery
technology management if the instructor has not used the tools in practice or has little background in project management. support professionals who are well-versed technology courses rather than attorneys. It
is
shortsighted
of
schools
to
continue with yester-year’s curriculum but rather they should assess what today’s practicing litigation paralegals are doing with technology to manage electronic discovery and integrate it into their existing curriculum. I agree with one of the comments my friend, Liz, made during our recent conversation: “Schools that are not offering this course of study to their students are holding them back. To develop a program that encompasses the nuances and importance of e-discovery would propel a college’s presence as a leader and pioneer
the author on Amazon discussing the book and the value of learning about technology for paralegals: “Let me state this as plainly as I can: a successful legal professional must know how to use a computer and the applications commonly used in a law office. With the advent of all things “e”--e-
18 • THEPARALEGALJOURNAL.COM • Issue 1 - 2011 TPJv1-11.indd 18
8/4/11 12:04 PM
Technology • Attending free webinars from E-DiscoveryJournal.com. When it comes to
first course in their curriculum is free. In
opportunity for paralegal schools to not offer more relevant coursework in the areas of
managing e-discovery projects, it’s almost as
technology training opportunities that are
project management and e-discovery.
important to understand what the technology
available.
in paralegal studies.” This is truly a missed
So what can a paralegal do today to learn more about e-discovery and project management on their own time with little or no out of pocket cost? There are many online and traditional classes available that are targeted to attorneys, paralegals and/or litigation support professionals. If cost is a factor because either your employer does not pay for continuing education or you are a recent graduate from a paralegal program
is capable of doing as necessarily being the button pusher running the application. The eDiscovery Journal provides access to a frequently updated software & technology matrix that matches e-discovery software to the corresponding phases of litigation and the E-Discovery Reference Model workflow. Reviewing this resource will allow you instant access to a wealth of information that goes beyond the marketing brochures.
money on, I recommend the following free
• Attend the free course available from the e-Discovery Team. This will kick
resources:
start learning about the legal aspects of
that you already spent a large amount of
• Downloading free podcasts on e-discovery from LegalTalkNetwork.com
e-discovery. Ralph Losey and his team of e-discovery experts are offering law school styled online e-discovery training and the
future issues, we will explore more free
• Read and study the Electronic Discovery Reference Model’s (EDRM. net) white paper http://www.edrm.net/ resources/edrm-white-paper-series • Set up both a Google Alert and a Google Scholar Alert for keyword: “e-discovery” (google.com). Stay current with a weekly e-mail listing the latest e-discovery blog posts, news, job listings and legal opinions. Electronic Discovery is a growing part of today’s litigation practice and schools do themselves and their students a great disservice by not offering more technology training for both tools and process (project management). If you are attending or recently completed a paralegal program that did not include e-discovery education, then take control of your career by taking advantage of the educational resources I have listed here as a start. Check out this column in our next issue as we continue to explore technology issues and provide technology tools and resources that are important to paralegals in 2011 and beyond. ERIKA SANTIAGO is an experienced litigation technology educator and consultant. Ms. Santiago was recently appointed to the position of National Director of Education and Training for ASDFED’s Chapter Support Center. She spearheads the organization’s commitment to delivering high quality educational offerings to its members and the Digital Forensics & eDiscovery communities. Previously, Erika Santiago was the National Training & Development Manager for LitWorks™ – A DTI Company where she instructed litigation support professionals on industry best practices and e-discovery project management. Erika has assisted case teams in the development of discovery management strategies and law firms and corporate legal departments with the design and implementation of their litigation support departments since 1995. Erika has delivered practical and valuable workshops to various organizations including paralegal associations, state bar associations, Legal Tech, ILTA, ASDFED, the Atlanta Association of Litigation Support Managers (she is also a past president of AALSM) and most recently, the Association of Litigation Support Professionals (ALSP). Erika@learnaboutediscovery.com
Issue 1 - 2011 • THEPARALEGALJOURNAL.COM •
TPJv1-11.indd 19
19
8/4/11 12:04 PM
Raising the Bar - paralegal Association Profile took the webcast idea and developed it into something all their own. As with most paralegal associations, the NWFPA provides at least two hours of CLE each quarter and hosts at least one day-long annual seminar per year. That’s pretty standard. What they’ve done this past year is not so standard: • NWFPA established a Livestream.com channel that allows them to webcast their monthly meetings to paralegals all along the Gulf Coast and nationwide. The members simply log onto the monthly webcast, watch online, record a confirmation code of attendance, and get the CLE credits when they report that code to the
The Paralegal Journal
Board.
NWFPA 30th Anniversary Celebration, pictured – left to right: Elizabeth Crane, Michele Mertins and Kristine Hill; Deb Johnson
result
of
this
technology we now
have members in other states.” She added,
• They also established a new membership
“Through our remote membership option, if
wanted to find a local
type for remote viewers. It is their new Remote
a paralegal qualifies as a member through
paralegal
Membership option, providing online access for
their education or work experience, they
a reduced annual membership fee of only $30
can become a remote member of NWFPA
per year. It has been very well received by new
regardless of where they live. We now have
association
that was coming up with innovative and creative
members of our association who live in other states but appreciate the benefits of a NWFPA membership and convenience of getting
ways of offering continuing education to its members.
affordable continuing education on a regular basis.” In addition to implementing these recent
We didn’t have to look far to find a paralegal
technology changes, NWFPA works closely with
association who fit the bill. The Northwest
their local bar association, the Escambia Santa
Florida
(NWFPA),
Rosa Bar Association, to present joint programs
in Pensacola, Florida, has taken strides in
and assist with marketing efforts to the bar
this area and we are hoping this profile of
association and NWFPA members. It has been
Paralegal
Association
that organization will inspire other paralegal associations to do the same. NWFPA is an affiliate association of the National Association of Legal Assistants (NALA) and has been in existence since 1981 in Pensacola, Florida. NWFPA’s membership
members and allowed NWFPA to grow their membership to paralegals who might otherwise not be members as they could not attend inperson meetings.
This includes out-of-state
members as well as Florida members.
a relationship that developed years ago and is reinforced through their members actively being involved in the bar association activities and advancing the paralegal profession in their state. This sort of working relationship with their local bar association is further highlighted
base is in excess of 130 members, but many of
• NWFPA implemented cloud storage
when you see NWFPA’s attendance list for their
those members are spread out with an hour’s
technology to save and download their
recent 30th anniversary celebration attended by
drive or more in each direction of their city.
monthly webcasts.
local judges, lawyers and NWFPA paralegals.
Long commutes make it difficult to get high
website allows NWFPA to offer their CLE
attendance at any organized event. Rather than
recordings to members who missed the
give up or settle on low attendance, NWFPA’s
monthly live webcast for a nominal fee of $10
forward-thinking leadership took steps to find
per download.
ways they could better serve their members along the gulf coast of Florida. After attending last year’s NALA convention, the NWFPA found inspiration in the Mississippi Paralegal Association’s webcast offering. The NWFPA
This cloud storage
April Williams, NWFPA’s board member
NWFPA is setting a great example on what a paralegal association can do to not only meet the continuing education needs of its members, but also to advance the paralegal profession. Join me in congratulating them on a job well
and NALA Liaison, added “these technology
done!
You can find NWFPA on LinkedIn,
solutions helped us find a way to serve the needs
Facebook and on their website at http://www.
of our paralegal members along the gulf coast
nwfpa.com. j
area of Florida, but it doesn’t stop there. As a
20 • THEPARALEGALJOURNAL.COM • Issue 1 - 2011 TPJv1-11.indd 20
8/4/11 12:04 PM
feature article By D. Jeffrey Campbell, Managing Principal, Porzio, Bromberg & Newman; Chair, American Bar Association, Standing Committee on Legal Assistants, 2002-2003.
The Shifting Balance of Profitability
Issue 1 - 2011 • THEPARALEGALJOURNAL.COM •
TPJv1-11.indd 21
21
8/4/11 12:04 PM
feature article
Associates -vsParalegals The Shifting Balance of Profitability
Anyone who questions whether it makes sense to utilize paralegals in the practice of law should think back to January and February of 2000, when most of the major law firms in the country increased associate salaries by 20 to 40 percent. You couldn’t pick up the legal press without seeing a story about skyrocketing associate salaries or the need for firms to match competitors’ salary increases in order to attract and keep good associates. Even more galling were the statements by brash young associates, circulating in cyberspace, that if they didn’t get top dollar at their current firms, they would leave. The associate pay one-upmanship of the large national and
$60,000 difference
“trickle down” effect throughout the legal marketplace. Mid-sized
associates across the range of firm sizes made more money, and law firm owners less. Yet throughout the media feeding frenzy that accompanied the associate salary wars, I didn’t see one article or hear one story about a law firm increasing paralegal salaries in order to compete for talent. In fact, paralegal compensation in most markets was virtually unaffected by the rush to pay young lawyers even higher,
Starting Associate experienced paralegal
$35,000
$70,000
salary differentials between large, mid-sized and small firms grew,
$50,000
$35,000 difference
to try to remain competitive with mid-sized ones. Although the
$90,000
positions with larger firms. Small firms in turn raised their salaries
$55,000
$40,000 difference
firms increased salaries in an attempt to maintain their competitive
$115,000
SALARIES
regional firms, which arguably could afford it, had an unfortunate
1991
1999
2001
and more insupportable, salaries. That alone should be enough to cause firms to consider paralegals as an attractive alternative to associate attorneys.
While one could certainly point to firms that have paid higher or lower salaries for starting associates or experienced paralegals, these numbers are reasonable approximations of the market over
As many law firms are now struggling through the compound
the past ten years. They demonstrate the significant increase in
effects of the economic downturn and increased associate
the gap between salaries of starting associates and experienced
compensation costs, it is an appropriate time to reflect on the
paralegals. This increase in the cost differential between associates
economic advantages of paralegal utilization. As mentioned above,
and paralegals can only be overcome by a like increase in revenue
at large law firms, paralegal compensation increases have not kept
differential, which is dependent on proportionate increases in
pace with associate compensation increases, either in absolute or
associate billing rates or average client billable hours.
percentage terms. The following chart is illustrative:
22 • THEPARALEGALJOURNAL.COM • Issue 1 - 2011 TPJv1-11.indd 22
8/4/11 12:04 PM
feature article However, the mature nature of the legal market has made it difficult
legal work will not be satisfactory and the firm will either lose clients
to increase associate billing rates significantly. And the personal and
or fail to develop new ones. However, it is very difficult to hire and
social values of many of today’s “Generation X” associates has made
retain good associates if the firm does not hold out some hope for
it equally difficult to increase the average number of client billable
partnership. Therefore, if the firm wants to have good associates
hours. Therefore, the relative probability of associates to paralegals is
it must continually increase its client base, because to have good
not as favorable today as it has been in the past.
associates is make new partners, which dictates that new work be
The cost differential in employing associates and paralegals is further illustrated by the disparity in the cost of turnover. The cost of losing and replacing a second- or third-year associate is generally estimated at approximately $200,000. The cost of losing and replacing an experienced paralegal, on the other hand, is only
found to leverage the new partners. In a mature legal market such as exists today, it is very difficult to develop an ever-increasing amount of legal work through the existing firm lawyers. Therefore, maintaining leverage and profitability solely through associates is very problematic as a long-term strategy.
roughly $100,000. Thus, although paralegal turnover is expensive
Paralegals, on the other hand, never become owners. Systemic
and should be minimized, it is only roughly half as expensive as
turnover is reduced because they do not suffer from the “up and out”
associate turnover.
syndrome. They can be trained over a relatively brief period of time
Minimizing costly turnover among firm personnel is one of the primary benefits of leveraging a law firm with paralegals. Paralegals are not subject to the same “up and out” model that governs associates.
Paralegals will never become owners of the firm.
and become reliable and steady long-term contributors to the bottom line. They never require new leverage to support themselves. They are the leverage that supports the firm.
Associate attorneys, especially the good ones, aspire and expect
In short, last year’s radical increases in associate compensation,
to become owners. Just when the firm has invested enough money
followed by this year’s economic downturn, have effectively
in associates to make them competent, efficient practicing lawyers,
highlighted the benefits of employing paralegals to provide legal
they want to share in the profits. If the firm makes them owners, it
services. Paralegal profitability, relative to that of associates, has
has lost the leverage and the investment. If the firm doesn’t make
improved over the past several years and paralegals can provide
them owners, they leave, and the firm has still lost the leverage and
stable long-term leverage in a way that associate attorneys never
the investment. This is a fundamental challenge to achieving long-
will. As employers and educators in the legal field, we ought to
term profitability through associates.
encourage the greater use of paralegals, not only for the oft-cited
A second, but related, reason that makes it difficult to achieve long-term profitability through associates is that to do so requires the firm to grow continually. If a firm wants to utilize associates, those
reasons of improved client service and reduced client costs, but also as a stabilizing factor in the economic life of the law firm. v - Reprinted from the Fall 2001 issue of the ABA SCOLA Update.
associates must be good lawyers. If they are not good lawyers, their
Issue 1 - 2011 • THEPARALEGALJOURNAL.COM •
TPJv1-11.indd 23
23
8/4/11 12:04 PM
This month’s question was posed to the legal community to get three different views on the subject:
What value do you see in paralegal continuing education?
ATTORNEY VIEWPOINT -by Phillip Bradley
Change, in the form of increasing demands and expectations, is upon the legal profession. While the focus on responding to this change has been on law schools and lawyers, forward thinking law firms will recognize that the response should also include paralegals. In October 2009, the ABA and ALI organized a summit called Equipping Our Lawyers: Law School Education, Continuing Legal Education, and Legal Practice in the 21st Century. The final recommendations of the summit included: -Develop model competencies keyed to each level of a lawyer’s professional career; -Design share transitional training programs in practice skills starting in law school and continuing through the first years of practice; and
2010 a task force to study the future of the legal profession. One of the sections of the report centered around the reality that “[l] awyers also need to rethink the model and methodology of educating and training lawyers to deliver services and serve clients in the evolving law practice environment.” The report challenges law schools to deliver skills qualified legal graduates, and the law firms to invest significantly in professional development. The concepts discussed in these reports are equally applicable to paralegals. Paralegals are a segment on the spectrum of legal services delivery providers.
Clients expect that providers for which they are paying are both skilled and competent. That is not new, but it is intensified in the new environment.
- Reform bar examinations to include phased examination, linked in part to attainment of legal skills, with some part as early as in law school.
Accordingly, law firms should have a set of core competencies for paralegals. These core competencies should be graduated from those that a paralegal must have when they begin practicing to those of an experienced and sophisticated paralegal. These core competencies will result in:
The New York State Bar, recognizing “the rapid pace of change in the legal profession, accelerated in part by the recent national economic downturn” created in
-law firms, as consumers of the products of the paralegal schools, insisting that graduates be competent in the baseline core competencies; and
-law firms developing education and training programs to advance paralegals from baseline to advanced core competencies. The reason the successful law firm will do so is its enlightened economic self interest. Clients are unwilling to pay for providers (lawyers or paralegals) lacking baseline competencies. Clients are willing to pay for providers with baseline competencies, but they are willing to pay more for providers with more sophisticated competencies. It only makes sense, then, that law firms take it upon themselves to develop their paralegals and enhance their value. Phillip A. Bradley is Senior Counsel at McKenna Long & Aldridge, where he was a partner for many years before leaving to become a client. Prior to returning to the firm, Mr. Bradley served as the Senior Vice President and General Counsel for Duane Reade, a New York based retail pharmacy chain. Previously Mr. Bradley served as General Counsel for Gentiva Health Services.
MANAGER VIEWPOINT -by Todd Noebel
Candidly, the answer to this question is probably as tricky and multi-faceted as is the issue of paralegal certification (did I hear Pandora’s Box creaking open?). In other words the value proposition is as varied as there are lawyers and law firms. For the sake of brevity we’ll put the whole
24 • THEPARALEGALJOURNAL.COM • Issue 1 - 2011 TPJv1-11.indd 24
8/4/11 12:04 PM
viewpoints certification/recertification issue to the side for now and answer the question from a more down and dirty day-to-day perspective. I happen to be a big believer in the value of continuing education for its own sake. Period. From a professional development standpoint you simply can’t afford to forego CE. You must, must hone your craft. It’s a matter of practical necessity. It is imperative that paralegals, like lawyers, keep their knowledge and subject matter expertise as contemporary and robust as possible. Of course the key is to invest in value add training, and to minimize the “just need the course for recert credit” sessions.
Think of it this way - when an attorney has a choice of which paralegal to engage on a billable matter they are most likely to go with the one who brings more tools (knowledge, skills, abilities and competencies), to bear for the client. And let’s be frank, it makes that attorney look good in the eyes of the client as well. After all, that knowledge and expertise is what clients are willing to pay for. Logic then tells us that the more knowledgeable and skilled a paralegal is, then the higher the bill rate and/or the higher the productivity and utilization will be and, ultimately, the higher the profitability. Making the time to take these classes does represent a calculated exchange. Time spent in a class, webinar, etc. is time that can’t be billed. It’s an investment in future billable work. Even more challenging and frustrating, including for me as a manager of paralegals, is the reality that when it comes time for merit raises, CE is rarely a factor given much weight in the calculations. But it does pay dividends. I go back to the reality that better educated, better trained, better skilled paralegals will get more billable work. More billable work leads, at least in our firm, to bonuses. So for me, there is high value in paralegal continuing education - both in hard and soft measures.
Todd Noebel is Manager, Human Resources at McGuireWoods LLP (with approximately 900 lawyers and 19 offices worldwide), where he has firm-wide management responsibility for the paralegal program. He is an active member of the ALA, the IPMA, and SHRM (he holds his SPHR certification). He is a published author in several professional journals and is an invited speaker at professional conferences. Todd can be reached at tnoebel@ mcguirewoods.com.
PARALEGAL VIEWPOINT -by K. Paezle Harris
As a Senior Paralegal within an inhouse legal department, I highly value and recommend continuing education among paralegals within our department. I took on the role of heading the Continuing Legal Education Program for our Legal Department in late 2009, and was tasked with seeking and providing options for relevant CLE for our attorneys and paralegals. In doing so, I attempt to provide options for our paralegals that include antitrust, litigation, electronic discovery, contracts, bankruptcy, employment issues, and intellectual property training, as those are the relevant areas for our specific paralegals. Oftentimes, I combine attorney and paralegal CLE opportunities so that paralegals can accompany their attorneys. Most importantly, I seek opportunity for CLE training within Ethics, separate and apart from the training opportunity provided
to the attorneys within our department. It is important that paralegals are aware of their ethical responsibilities; what is considered unauthorized practice of law (UPL) for themselves; as well as what behavior, by attorneys and paralegals, is considered unethical and in violation of the State Bar’s Rules of Professional Conduct. It is pertinent that paralegals have the ability to
recognize when asked to perform or witness behavior that is in direct violation of those rules. Without proper education, a paralegal could find themselves inadvertently jeopardizing their supervising attorney’s job and career, as well as their own. Over the years, I have spoken with many experienced and qualified paralegals that may have climbed the ladder of success by on-the-job training in lieu of formal education and who may feel that CLEs are not necessary for them due to this. To the contrary, I often point out that those are the very paralegals that should certainly make sure to keep up with continuing education in order to prepare them in areas that the in-house trainer(s) may have omitted or neglected.
I recommend that, no matter the education or experience level, that paralegals maintain their training within their areas of law as well as within ethics on a continuous basis. With the constant changes within technology and law, there is no way one can stay fully aware without continuing their education. Additionally, and lastly, as President of the Georgia Association of Paralegals, Inc., (GAP), and Chair on GAP’s Paralegal Standards Committee, I must recite GAP’s Position on Continuing Legal Education (“CLE”) for the Paralegal Profession which can be found at http://www.gaparalegal.org/ files/GAP_Position_Statements_2010.pdf : “GAP recommends that beginning one year after an individual has satisfied the educational standards of an entry level paralegal, he/she shall complete a minimum of 12 hours of continuing legal education (CLE) every 2 years, to include at least 1 hour of ethics.” K. Paezl_ Harris, RP, CP, is a senior paralegal at Cox Communications, Inc. in Atlanta, Georgia. Paezl_ is a Certified Mediator and Georgia Neutral who obtained her Paralegal Certificate from the University of Georgia (UGA) and her Advanced Paralegal Certificate from the University of South Carolina (USC). Locally, Paezl_ holds dual roles as GAP’s President & as GAP’s Director of Paralegal Certification and serves on the Advisory Board for Atlanta Technical College’s Paralegal Program.
Issue 1 - 2011 • THEPARALEGALJOURNAL.COM •
TPJv1-11.indd 25
25
8/4/11 12:04 PM
feature article
26 • THEPARALEGALJOURNAL.COM • Issue 1 - 2011 TPJv1-11.indd 26
8/4/11 12:04 PM
feature article
Indispensable is defined by MerriamWebster’s Dictionary as “not subject to being set aside or neglected” and
Company which makes widgets, a physical thing that their employees can see and touch, a law firm’s “widgets” is its billable efforts. As paralegals we record our time spent on substantive tasks so that law firms can bill their clients for that service and generate
“absolutely necessary.” We’ve all heard
revenue. This puts us in a position to contribute towards the firm’s
the statement that no one is indispensable.
your job security, the most effective
That particularly rings true these days. I learned that fact early in my paralegal career after leaving my first paralegal job in Florida to move to Atlanta in 1996. Lawyers and colleagues at the firm threw me a tear-jerker of a going away party. The partner I worked for even made the dessert for the party himself! Yes, that’s true, and it was almost enough to change my mind about leaving. The following year, I returned to Florida for vacation and made time to stop by the law firm to say hello to some of my former colleagues, sure that the firm was no longer in existence because like they said a year ago, “they didn’t know what they were going to do without me.” Much to my surprise, the lawyers did not have to shut down their practice after I left. In fact, they had a thriving practice and had found a great replacement for me. Imagine that!
profitability. If you want to increase way to do that is to increase the amount that you are contributing towards the law firm’s profits, which directly increases your value to your law firm. Increasing your profitability starts with your billable hours, but does not end there. Simply billing more hours for the sake of more hours will not necessarily result in higher profits. Let’s first look at a generic example of how profitability is calculated for paralegals. This is not to say that your law firm calculates it this way. This is just for illustrative purposes only and even though law firms will argue that they have a much more sophisticated way of coming up with these numbers, basic economics for profit is usually revenue less expenses equals profit. In an example for a paralegal it
in Indispensable might look something like this:
We would all like to believe that our employers simply cannot go on without us, but they do. In essence we are all somewhat dispensable to our employers. We have to be, because no employer can run a successful business in complete reliance on one particular person. I’m not here to tell you that after following my advice in this article you will be completely indispensable with 100% job security. If nothing else, the last few years have taught us that there is no such thing as 100% job security, even if you are the CEO. However, there are ways to increase your job security and increase your indispensability factor. How? Make your company more money. The focus of this article will be for paralegals working at law firms, but the principles can be applied to just about any type of organization that you work for. As a paralegal at a law firm, you work for an enterprise that exists primarily because it makes a profit. If it does not make a profit, the law firm will shut its doors just like any other business that is not making enough of a profit. The way a law firm makes that profit is through generating revenue by billing for the work that you and other professionals do for the law firm’s clients and by keeping its costs down. Unlike Acme
Issue 1 - 2011 • THEPARALEGALJOURNAL.COM •
TPJv1-11.indd 27
27
8/4/11 12:04 PM
feature article Example:
office at 5:30. Either way, that attorney is going to come to you the next time they need something done because you are available.
Revenue collected from paralegal billable time.............................. $200,000
The paralegals who left at 5:00 might have only missed out on a 30 minute project today, but over the course of the year they have
Less:
Salary, OT, Bonus..................... $ 65,000
Cost of benefits....................... $ 15,000
now considers you their “go-to” person and goes to you with her/his
Office overhead allocation.... $ 50,000
next big case or transaction.
Origination fees....................... $ 20,000
missed out on untold hours of billable time because that attorney
Be the “Yes Man” (or woman).
As a
Total Costs................................................... $150,000
paralegal manager, the single most frequent response I would get
Firm Profit.................................$ 50,000
their paralegals more was “Every time I ask her/him to do something,
from attorneys when I would ask them why they were not utilizing I get a 10-minute speech about how many other things they’ve got
Throughout my career, I have heard paralegals say they don’t have
going on and how busy they are and they’re not sure when they can
any control over the amount of work they get or whether or not a
get to my project.” Even if all of
client pays their bill. You do have
those things are true, simply saying
some control over those things.
“I’ll get it done or find someone
Here are just a few ways that
who can” will increase the amount
you have some control over the
of work you are getting. Of course
amount of work you get:
there are other follow-up things you might have to mention particular to
Be approachable.
your situation, but always start your
When someone walks in your office,
answer with “Yes.”
do you make them immediately
even a litigator, will always choose
feel welcome or are you annoyed that
they’ve
interrupted
the path of least resistance. You
you?
might be the most highly-skilled
Regardless of their position on
paralegal in the office, but if an
the food chain, you can make
attorney feels like it is a chore to
everyone who walks in your office feel welcome.
An attorney,
get you to say “yes” to a project,
In a lot of time
they will use someone else or in
management classes they teach
some cases do it themselves.
to set up your work space so that
Be a participant rather than a spectator. Participate in
you are not facing the door because that allows for interruptions. In the case of paralegals, I think it should be just the opposite. When I was
outside firm functions, attend team
a paralegal in a law firm, I can’t
lunch outings, work on pro bono
tell you the amount of times that I
cases in other departments, attend
would have a casual conversation with a lawyer standing in my door
the firm’s continuing education offerings and participate in all these
that later resulted in billable hours because the conversation led to
things rather than watching from the sidelines or reading about it
talk about a new case they had coming in the following week.
in the firm newsletter. These kinds of things build relationships
Be available.
Attorneys wait until the last minute
to get things done. We all know this. We all complain about this. That doesn’t change it or even make it acceptable, but it is reality in
with attorneys in departments you otherwise might never have made contact with.
Enjoy where you work.
I am always amazed
a law firm and no amount of complaining or resistance on our part
at the external functions I have attended and met paralegals or other
is going to change this. Be the person who is available when they
legal professionals who, upon learning that I also worked at a law
come looking for a paralegal at 5:30 to do a last minute project. It
firm, introduced themselves and the firm they worked for. Then they
might not even be a project that requires an overnighter. Maybe
proceeded to complain about firm management, the mean lawyers,
it’s a project that only takes 30 minutes; or maybe it is something
office politics and other general unhappiness with their law firm.
that is not due for a few days and you still are able to leave the
My immediate thought was “why would this person work in such a
28 • THEPARALEGALJOURNAL.COM • Issue 1 - 2011
feature article place that made them miserable,” and if they so freely complained
In this example, Paralegal A’s actual profit is less because, in
to a complete stranger about their law firm, surely people at the firm
addition to Paralegal A putting in a lot more overtime and getting a
could feel that same discontent. If you don’t like where you work,
bonus based strictly on the number of billable hours, Paralegal A’s
find somewhere that you do.
attorneys had to write off some of Paralegal A’s time as some tasks
Be the best at what you do.
Attorneys
talk to each other. Attorneys talk to each other about their cases and they talk about great (and poor) work product. If you are the best at what you do, it is only a matter of time before the other attorneys hear about it and request you on their next project. Be the paralegal who knows about the latest technology that makes the project go smoothly or saves the client money.
getting the billable work. As for the control you have over collecting more revenue, you might not have the ability to call a client and ask where their payment is (and I would strongly urge you not to unless you want to immediately reduce your job security to 0% and be escorted to the door). What you can do, and what you do have control over, is being efficient and productive with your time and drafting time entries that convey what you actually did to benefit the client – both things will make the client more willing to pay the bill and make it easier for the attorney to collect on the bill.
Revenue Collected:
$60,000
$60,000
$260,000
$ 250,000
Less: Salary, OT, Bonus
$90,000
$65,000
Cost of Benefits
$15,000
$15,000
Office Overhead
$50,000
$50,000
Orig Fees, other
$25,000
$25,000
$180,000
$155,000
Total Costs:
Potential Firm Profit:
off unproductive time, that affects a paralegal’s realization rate. The realization rate is the percentage of time billed to the percentage of time actually collected. In this chart, even though Paralegal A bills significantly more hours than Paralegal B, Paralegal A does not have that same ratio in terms of the amount collected because of a lower realization rate. This example is just to show you that more billable hours do not necessarily mean more profit for the law firm.
Those are just a few things that you have control over in terms of
Base Salary
took longer than they should have. When an attorney has to write
It’s not always about who bills more hours. Increasing your billable hours is a good start, but only if they are efficient hours. Why should all of this be important to you?
Because it
is important to your employer. Even if you do not know your productivity number, realization percentage or profitability number, someone at your law firm does and most likely they are the decision maker on raises, bonuses and job security. You might not ever know what your exact profitability number is, but you can help increase it by knowing your productivity number and working on things that you do have control over. Tracking your numbers and doing what you can to increase them can get you a few steps closer to being that indispensable paralegal. k Ann Pearson is the Owner and Founding Member of PRM, an Atlanta-based company that provides consulting and education services to law firms and legal departments, with a focus on their paralegals. PRM helps transform law firm paralegal groups into profit centers and designs customized in-house paralegal training programs for corporate legal departments and law firms, in addition to developing the Litigation Paralegal Boot Camp™ and Paralegal Resource Conferences by PRM ™. Seeing a need for a new independent legal publication geared towards today’s legal professionals, Ms. Pearson launched The Paralegal Journal in 2011. Prior to founding PRM and The Paralegal Journal, Ann was the paralegal manager for McKenna Long & Aldridge’s offices in Atlanta, San Diego and New York after many years of working as a senior paralegal at Holland & Knight LLP.
$80,000 $95,000
Issue 1 - 2011 • THEPARALEGALJOURNAL.COM •
TPJv1-11.indd 29
29
8/4/11 12:04 PM
Career Path
Times have changed. I hate to start this article by
salaries are not increasing. In addition, the
Yet, having a strong network and using it
hiring process requires a lot more effort. It
well is the best way to find a new career
is now incumbent upon a paralegal looking
opportunity. Being referred by a friend is
stating the obvious, yet it
to make a career transition to articulate
far better than blindly submitting a resume
their value and use more proactive methods
online to a general mailbox with a hundred
is unavoidable. This still
to find opportunities.
This article will
other applicants. Think of your network as
highlight 3 ways that a paralegal can take
a muscle. When it is used regularly it is
control of their job search and succeed in
strong, powerful and helps you get a lot done
is a difficult economy. We have all heard the
news
with less pain. When is ignored, it atrophies and becomes useless.
reports
Another
and unemployment
key
point
to
remember is that networking is a reciprocal process.
reports: many legal professionals
When
networking is approached from a “what can this person do for me” mindset, it will yield no
are still actively looking for jobs. These conditions
results.
Share best practices,
news of upcoming professional development events as well as other helpful information with networking
can leave even the most confident
connections,
workers and colleagues.
coThe
seeds you sow to help others will come back to you tenfold.
and experienced paralegal feeling discouraged.
Networking for a new position must
include
these days.
social
media
Everyone is using
LinkedIn, but are you actively
As a recruiter and job
using it in your job search?
search consultant, I do see
Use the following checklist to
some improvements in the legal
see if you are using LinkedIn to
employment market.
However,
the way a paralegal searches for a job has changed irrevocably.
Several years ago
it was sufficient to have the education (bachelor’s degree and/or a paralegal certificate) and several years of experience with a reputable law firm or company working in your practice area.
With
finding a new position even in a challenging
1.
economy.
“You can’t stay in your corner of the Forest waiting for others to come to you. You have to go them sometimes.” ~ Winnie the Pooh Networking – Everyone knows that
these credentials a paralegal was almost
networking is important. Nonetheless, the
guaranteed a comparable job in about 3-6
fact of the matter is very few of us do it with
months, typically even seeing an increase in
any effectiveness. Let’s face it networking
salary. Now it’s more like 9-12 months and
is time consuming and can be tedious.
its fullest potential in your job search. ~ Update your Professional Headline. This
is
what
viewers
and
potential
connections see as who you are.
This
should not be used as a job title field, such as “Owner, ABC Company.” That does not tell a potential connection who you are or what you can do for their company. ~ Upload a professional photograph. As a consultant, I will often see that
30 • THEPARALEGALJOURNAL.COM • Issue 1 - 2011 TPJv1-11.indd 30
8/4/11 12:04 PM
Career Path professionals use the same profile picture
Network, Paralegal Gateway, Legal HR
the recruiter advocate on your behalf. The
in LinkedIn as they use on their Facebook
Recruiting
National
more information a recruiter has about your
page. LinkedIn should only be a headshot
Association for Legal Professionals, Legal
career goals and experience, the better they
photo and it should not be a photo of you at
Recruiters.org, eLegal and Law Jobs to
the beach.
name a few.
&
Professional,
~ Be sure your past position descriptions
~ Participate and check group updates.
are detailed enough. These should be in
Job postings frequently appear on the discussion boards of many of the groups
3.
can find you a suitable paralegal position. “Doing the best at this moment puts you in the best place for the next moment.” ~ Oprah Winfrey Show others as well as potential
Additionally, most of
employers what you can do through your
these groups have a separate tab for “jobs”
volunteer activities. Get involved with your
to search for postings.
local paralegal association. If your local bar
mentioned above.
association has a paralegal membership, ~ Lastly, search and check for updates
join that as well.
Additionally, check
on the main Jobs tab of the LinkedIn home
for local associations that are specific to
page.
your practice area. For example, if you a
“The most effective jobseekers, ... use an average of 6.8 different employment resources when they search for jobs, combining online, networking and recruiter tools.” ~ Cynthia Morgan
litigation paralegal, you might want to join
What are some of those resources?
get to know people who can ultimately be
We’ve already covered a few of them, but
helpful in your job search, but also provides
in this new economy, it will take more
others an opportunity to get to know who you
than just in-person networking and online
are as a professional. Lastly, whatever you
networking. In addition, there are online
do, do it well and with a positive attitude.
job boards like Monster, Career Builder
Others will pick up on it and will go out of
and Law Crossing to name a few. Another
their way to assist you if they can.
2.
your local e-discovery or litigation support groups. Don’t be satisfied with just being a member; instead you should help plan activities, join committees or run for office. These activities are a great way to not only
resource is recruiters. Some law firms do paragraph form and not a bullet point list of
not post jobs, they hire recruiters to find
job duties from your written job description.
high caliber candidates for them.
If you’re not sure how to get started, look at some of your other connection’s positions for
These tips are by far not the only resources you can employ to find a satisfying and challenging position. The point is that
Recruiters are a vital piece of career
reactively applying to on-line job posts
Whether you are unemployed
in most cases will not get you the job you
looking for temporary work or unsatisfied
want. Those who look at their job search
~ Ask for recommendations from
in your current position and looking for
strategically and use multiple resources
colleagues. It is better to ask while your
your next opportunity, recruiters are great
will uncover rewarding opportunities with
employment is still fresh in their mind.
resources. Just remember that they are not
responsibilities that move their career
a commodity. Take your time to find one
forward. g
samples of what you like.
planning.
~ Don’t add any personal interests to the
who knows the market, has a successful
“interests” section of your profile. Less is
track record and most importantly, listens.
more when it comes to personal information
Also, do not have unrealistic expectations.
on your LinkedIn profile.
A recruiter cannot find a litigation paralegal
~ Join relevant groups. In addition to your local and national paralegal association groups, there are a variety of paralegal interest groups that are especially helpful if you are looking for a paralegal position, such as: Paralegal Jobs & Continuing Education, The
Paralegal
Group,
The
Paralegal
a job as a general corporate paralegal no matter how much the applicant desires to make the change in practice areas. Also be candid. Clearly state your salary expectations, why you are in the job market, why have you made your previous job moves, and anything else that will help
Keisha Hudson is the owner of KD Hudson Consulting, a job search consulting firm specializing in resume writing and outplacement services for legal professionals. Keisha is a frequent presenter on topics relating to job search strategies including resume writing, interviewing and networking. Keisha has been a featured speaker for organizations such as The Atlanta Chapter of the Association of Corporate Counsel, The Minority Corporate Counsel Association, The Gate City Bar Paralegal Section and The Georgia Association of Women Lawyers. She also taught job search strategies as an adjunct professor at Capitol University Paralegal program in Columbus, Ohio and has given presentations at John Marshall Law School and Brown Mackie College. Visit www. kdhudsonconsulting.com for additional information.
Issue 1 - 2011 • THEPARALEGALJOURNAL.COM •
TPJv1-11.indd 31
31
8/4/11 12:04 PM
When was the last lunch hour that gave you an edge over others in your field?
Lorman offers continuing education in the following areas:
They don’t come around that often. When they do, you should jump at the chance. Now you can get your paralegal continuing education from the comfort of your own office during your lunch hour. It’s so convenient.
• Government
Pearson Resource Management has partnered with Lorman Education Services to provide you with cost-effective education. Lorman has a wide variety of courses that qualify for CE.
• Purchasing
PRM is happy to pass along a 10% discount on all registrations through Lorman. Mention Discount Code i1776249 for this exclusive offer. Visit www. lorman.com/training/PearsonResource for a complete list of upcoming courses.
“Excellent information I can take back to work and apply.” – Lillana Guzman, Cardinal Coach Lines
• Human Resources • Insurance • Labor • Legal • Paralegal • Workers Compensation • Benefits Upcoming Paralegal Audio Conferences August 18 �������������Practical Implications of Metadata: To Scrub or Not to Scrub...To Mine or Not to Mine August 24 �������������Privacy Breach Litigation: Trends & The Impact of Cloud Computing and Social Media September 8 �������Ethical Considerations in Social Media September 15 ����Essential Discovery Skills for Paralegals September 22 ����Ethics for Paralegals
Visit http://www.lorman.com/training/PearsonResource for additional information or to register.
The results of our informal survey are in. We asked paralegals nationwide on Linked In groups and on our Facebook page to respond to a survey on their thoughts on paralegal schools. Here is a summary of those results.
Send out congratulations to the 3
winners of a FREE one-year subscription to The Paralegal Journal. They were announced on our Facebook page.
Did you learn enough from attending school and earning a paralegal certificate to perform all of the tasks required of you in your first paralegal position?
YES NO
43.3 % 38.3 %
OTHER 19.4%
YES 43.3%
NO 38.3% What skills could have been taught in paralegal school that would have helped prepare you better for your first paralegal position? Legal technology classes Database management
Litigation software
Trial binders
Answering discovery
Corporate maintenance
Class on medical records
Time management
How law firms operate
Trial preparation from a paralegal’s perspective
Was the paralegal school helpful in trying to find your first paralegal position after graduation?
NO Other
18.3% 50 % 31.7%
(These included responses such as: I was already employed when attending school and a decision to take other nonparalegal positions.)
Poor
Barely Acceptable
Acceptable
Pleased
Exceptional
0% 3% 20% 39% 39%
pleased 39%
acceptable 20%
exceptional 39%
barely acceptable 3%
Some of the general comments received:
More hands-on training from paralegals
YES
When asked to rate (on a scale of 1 to 5) the quality of education received from their paralegal school, the results were surprising. Despite the comments about the need for other skills to be taught and the ratings on job placement assistance and other areas, the average was a 4.2 on a scale of 1 being poor and 5 being exceptional.
No school is ever going to teach you everything you’re going to need to know walking in that front door. Period. All any school can do for any profession is hand you the tools and the base knowledge to build upon. _ Ellen Wright, Director of Operations, LaGrange Division and Paralegal, RGP Attorney Services, LLC. A lot of the skills that need to be developed cannot be learned in school. Gaining those skills takes time and cannot necessarily be taught in school. Firms are different in how they do things. Anonymous We received a very well-rounded education. _ Anonymous.
OTHER 31.7% NO 50%
YES 18.3%
I suggest that if you want to go to a Paralegal school, do your research and question the students on what kind of “hands on” training they have received. Do they know Westlaw, Lexis-Nexis or Pro-Doc? Do they know how to draft and file a simple pleading or motion? Also, sit in on a couple of the classes. The school wants your money, so there is no way they won’t let you sit in on one or two classes for free. If they won’t let you sit in on a class, find another school, fast. _ PH (Blogger from Paralegal Hell.com)
Watch our Facebook page for our next survey!
Issue 1 - 2011 • THEPARALEGALJOURNAL.COM •
TPJv1-11.indd 33
33
8/4/11 12:04 PM
What’s Next?
What’s Coming In The Next Issue? • It’s THAT time of year: Are you ready for your performance review? • Starting a Virtual Paralegal Business • How to conduct an focus group on a budget • Addressing GAPS in your resume • Marketing yourself as part of your 2012 professional to-do list • New section for in-house paralegals • Taking on new roles that will advance your career NOW • We are adding more departments and more feature articles with every issue
2011 Subscription Special:
DON’T MISS A SINGLE ISSUE! Subscribe Now at www.theparalegaljournal.com or Email: info@theparalegaljournal.com Advertiser Index
Page
$34 gets you 2 years of print AND flip book for one low price. Offer ends Oct. 1, 2011.
Visit the Advertisers on the web
Document Technologies, Inc. (DTI)........................................ 2................................ www.dtiglobal.com Lorman Education.................................................................. 8................................ www.lorman.com Merrill Corporation................................................................. 10.............................. www.merrillcorp.com Pearson Resource Management, LLC..................................... 32.............................. www.pearsonresource.com PRM Conferences................................................................... 35.............................. www.prmconferences.com Renew Data............................................................................ 13.............................. www.renewdata.com Sterling Legal Search, Inc...................................................... 19.............................. www.sterlinglegal.com Triad Professionals................................................................. 29.............................. www.triadpros.com
34 • THEPARALEGALJOURNAL.COM • Issue 1 - 2011
Issue 1 - 2011 • THEPARALEGALJOURNAL.COM •
TPJv1-11.indd 35
35
8/4/11 12:05 PM
R U O Y IS
R E T N I R P KING YOU MA
R E T T E B A ER? H S I L PUB
BUSINESS B O OST E R FREE MEMBERSHIP PROGRAM
WE MAKE PUBLISHERS BETTER
Meet our 4 industry experts that keep you on the cutting edge of publishing
Email us today for free samples and a quote at samples@shweiki.com • 512.480.0860 THE SHWEIKI
PRICE. QUALITY. SPEED.
SOCIAL MEDIA MARKETING Joe Pulizzi, Founder of Junta 42 PUBLICITY & PROMOTION Jill McGuckin, McGuckin Entertainment PR
GET-ALL-THREE GUARANTEE Learn more at shweiki.com
ONLINE STRATEGIES Ryan Dohrn, Brain Swell Media, LLC SALES TRAINING Jenaé Rubin, Sales Powerhouse
PLANT TOURS AVAILABLE!
Contact Ashley to set up your tour today • 210.804.0390
www.SHWEIKI.com