Collin powel in the Vietnam war

Page 1

The War Photography of Philip Jones Griffiths

YESTERDAY

Beatles’ last concert, San Francisco, 1966

Colin Powell

AUGUST 2016

HistoryNet.com

Do You Suffer From: · Heel Pain · Joint Pain · Back or Knee Pain · Neuropathy · Plantar Fasciitis · Arthritis

· Diabetes · Obesity · Achilles Tendinitis · Bunions · Hammertoe · Heel Spurs

G-DEFY

EXTORA II

(QMR\ WKH EHQH¿ WV RI H[HUFLVH ZLWKRXW KDUPIXO LPSDFW RQ \RXU MRLQWV Boost energy Combat health issues Increase mobility Relieve pain Extora I

Absorbs Harmful Impact

Returns Energy

Men Sizes 7.5-15 - White TB9006MWS - Black TB9006MBL

AVAILABLE

Women Sizes 5-11 - White TB9006FWS - Black TB9006FBL

Extora II

W

hether it’s health-related or caused by an injury, discomfort can occur in anyone at any age— and there’s no excuse to exercise less. In fact, being active with discomfort is the most natural way to keep your joints moving smoothly. Experience a better life with Gravity Defyer footwear—ease your discomfort and rediscover movement! The moment you put on a pair of Gravity Defyer shoes, you’ll get Á DVKEDFNV RI WKH GD\V ZKHUH nothing could stop you.

Each Gravity Defyer shoe is exclusively designed with patented VersoShock® Technology, a system of springs that simultaneously work together to absorb harmful shock and return energy throughout the body. Get rid of that “I-can’t-doanything-anymore” attitude and let Gravity Defyer give you the relief you need while boosting \RXU HQGXUDQFH DQG FRQÀ GHQFH Transform your life right now and invest in a pair of Gravity Defyer shoes today!

Men Sizes 7.5-15 - Black TB9007MBL - White TB9007MWS Women Sizes 5-11 - Black TB9007FBL - White TB9007FWS

119 95

$149.95 $

OFF $3000Your Order

Free Exchanges Easy Returns

Promo Code: MS9HHA5

Call 1(800) 429-0039

GravityDefyer.com/MS9HHA5

Don’t Forget

Gravity Defyer Corp. 10643 Glenoaks Blvd. Pacoima, CA 91331

to check out our other products to relieve discomfort:

Men’s Dress

Women’s Sandals

G-Comfort Insoles

VersoShock® U.S Patent #US8,555,526 B2. This product has not been evaluated by the FDA. Not intended to treat, cure or prevent any disease. Shoes must be returned within 30 days in like-new condition for full refund or exchange. Credit card authorization required. See website for complete details.

Advertisement

Analog and digital display Stop watch function Built-in alarm LCD complications Electro-luminescence backlight

Suggested Retail $395…

NOW, on you wrist for $29 95r For a limited Time Only

Amazing New Hybrid Runs Without Gas The new face of time? Stauer’s Compendium Hybrid fuses form and functionality for UNDER $30! Read on...

I

nnovation is the path to the future. Stauer takes that seriously. That’s why we developed the Compendium Hybrid, a stunningly-designed hybrid chronograph with over one dozen analog and digital functions that is more versatile than any watch that we have ever engineered.

New technology usually starts out at astronomical prices and then comes down years later. We skipped that step to allow everyone the chance to experience this watch’s brilliant fusion of technology and style. We originally priced the Stauer Compendium Hybrid at $395 based on the market for advanced sports watches... but then stopped ourselves. Since this is no ordinary economy, we decided to offer the Compendium Hybrid at 92% off. That means this new technological marvel can be yours for only $2995! Welcome a new Digital Revolution. With the release of the dynamic new Compendium, those boxy, plastic wrist calculators of the past have been replaced by this luxurious LCD chronograph that is sophisticated enough for a formal evening out, but rugged and tough

enough to feel at home in a cockpit, camping expedition or covert mission. The watch’s extraordinary dial seamlessly blends an analog watch face with a stylish digital display. Three super-bright luminous hands keep time along the inner dial, while a trio of circular LCD windows track the hour, minutes and seconds. An eye-catching digital semi-circle animates in time with the second hand and shows the day of the week. The watch also features a rotating bezel, stopwatch and alarm The Compendium: The functions and green spectacular face of the electro-luminescence latest watch technology. backlight. The Compendium Hybrid secures with a rugged stainless steel band and is water-resistant to 3 ATMs. Guaranteed to change the way you look at time. At Stauer, we believe that when faced with an uphill economy, innovation and better value will always provide a much-needed boost. Stauer is so confident of their latest hybrid timepiece

Smart Luxuries—Surprising Prices

that we offer a money-back-guarantee. If for any reason you aren’t fully impressed by the performance and innovation of the Stauer Compendium Hybrid for $2995, simply return the watch within 30 days for a full refund of the purchase price. The unique design of the Compendium greatly limits our production, so don’t hesitate to order! Remember: progress and innovation wait for no one! WATCH SPECS: - Three LCD windows show hour, minute and second - Stop watch function - Fits 6 3/4"–8 3/4" wrist - 2 year warranty on movement

Offer Limited to First 2500 Respondents

92% OFF

Stauer Compendium Hybrid Watch—

Now $29 95

+S&P

Save over $365

Other discounts and coupons do not apply to this exclusive offer.

Call now to take advantage of this limited offer.

1-800-333-2045 Promotional Code VHW712-06 Please mention this code when you call.

Stauer

14101 Southcross Drive W.,

® Dept. VHW712-06

Burnsville, Minnesota 55337

www.stauer.com

August 2016

On the Cover:

Colin Powell looks up K\YPUN H [PJRLY [HWL WHYHKL PU 5L^ @VYR [V JLSLIYH[L ]PJ[VY` PU [OL .\SM >HY 7/6;6! (5+9,> /63)9662, .,;;@ 04(.,:" 05:,;! 05;,9-6;6 (3(4@ :;6*2 7/6;6

22

COLIN POWELL’S VIETNAM

On the rise Major Colin Powell, Z[HɈ VɉJLY MVY operations in the (TLYPJHS +P]PZPVU takes a break V\[ZPKL OPZ I\URLY H[ *O\ 3HP PU

2

VIETNAM

COURTESY COLIN L. POWELL

;OL MVYTLY PUMHU[Y` VɉJLY PU Vietnam talks about the war’s PUÅ\LUJL VU OPZ KLJPZPVUZ HZ 1VPU[ *OPLMZ JOHPYTHU HUK ZLJYL[HY` VM Z[H[L

6 8 14 16 18

Feedback Today In the News Homefront July-August 1966 Then & Now Arsenal The First Stealth Aircraft

21 Editor’s Notebook 58 Media Digest 64 Rewind Actor Jon Provost

36

THE FIRST BATTLE OF KHE SANH

In April 1967, Marines in western Quang Tri province moved to sweep NVA from bunkers in Hills 861 and 881. By Arnold Blumberg

28 SKY WARS

How Hanoi forced U.S. airwar leaders to improve battle space management, aircraft paint schemes and precision weapons. By Carl O. Schuster

50

THEY CAME, AND DIED, TO KEEP THE PAST UPON ITS THRONE

44

STARK IMAGES OF MEN AT WAR 7OPSPW 1VULZ .YPɉ[OZ» photographs show the universal struggles of people everywhere.

A seasoned war JVYYLZWVUKLU[ YLÅLJ[Z on his time in Vietnam, before, during and after the fall of Saigon. By H.D.S. Greenway

JOIN THE DISCUSSION AT VIETNAM MAG.COM

MICHAEL A. REINSTEIN CHAIRMAN & PUBLISHER DAVID STEINHAFEL ASSOCIATE PUBLISHER

AUGUST 2016 VOL. 29, NO. 2

CHUCK SPRINGSTON EDITOR DEBRA NEWBOLD MANAGING EDITOR JERRY MORELOCK SENIOR EDITOR SARAH RICHARDSON SENIOR EDITOR ELIZABETH HOWARD COPY EDITOR JON GUTTMAN RESEARCH DIRECTOR DAVID T. ZABECKI EDITOR EMERITUS HARRY SUMMERS JR. FOUNDING EDITOR STEPHEN KAMIFUJI CREATIVE DIRECTOR BRIAN WALKER GROUP ART DIRECTOR PAUL FISHER ART DIRECTOR LORI FLEMMING PHOTO EDITOR ADVISORY BOARD ROBERT H. LARSON, JAMES R. RECKNER, CARL O. SCHUSTER, EARL H. TILFORD JR., SPENCER C. TUCKER, ERIK VILLARD, JAMES H. WILLBANKS CORPORATE ROB WILKINS Director of Partnership Marketing MICHAEL ZATULOV Finance DIGITAL JOSH SCIORTINO Associate Editor

The siege of the U.S. Marine base at Khe Sanh in 1968, one of the most prominent battles of the war, was preceded by the Khe Sanh hill fights of 1967, which are recalled in this issue. To learn more about both battles, visit HistoryNet.com and search “Khe Sanh.” <PZW]OP ÅZ[\PIVL IKKW]V\[ IVL stunning photos, our website puts aW] QV \PM ÅMTL _Q\P \PM \ZWWX[ _PW fought in one of America’s most controversial wars. Let’s connect Vietnam magazine Go digital Vietnam magazine is available through iTunes or at Zinio.com 4

VIETNAM

ADVERTISING COURTNEY FORTUNE Advertising Services cfortune@historynet.com TERRY JENKINS Regional Sales Manager tjenkins@historynet.com RICK GOWER Regional Sales Manager rick@rickgower.com RICHARD VINCENT Regional Sales Manager rvincent@historynet.com JOSH SCIORTINO Web Sales jsciortino@historynet.com DIRECT RESPONSE ADVERTISING RUSSELL JOHNS ASSOCIATES 800-649-9800 VIET@russelljohns.com SUBSCRIPTION INFORMATION 800-435-0715 or SHOP.HISTORYNET.com. Yearly subscriptions in U.S.: $39.95. List Rental Inquiries: Belkys Reyes, Lake Group Media, Inc. 914-925-2406; belkys.reyes@lakegroupmedia.com Vietnam (ISSN 1046-2902) is published bimonthly by HistoryNet, LLC. 1600 Tysons Blvd., Suite 1140, Tysons, VA 22102-4883; 703-771-9400 Periodical postage paid at Leesburg, VA, and additional mailing offices. Postmaster, send address changes to Vietnam, P.O. Box 422224, Palm Coast, FL 32142-2224 Canada Publications Mail Agreement No. 41342519 Canadian GST No. 821371408RT0001 © 2016 HistoryNet, LLC The contents of this magazine may not be reproduced in whole or in part without the written consent of HistoryNet LLC. PROUDLY MADE IN THE USA

GETTY IMAGES/BETTMANN

THE BATTLES OF KHE SANH

Advertisement

Urgent: Special Summer Driving Notice

To some, sunglasses are a fashion accessory…

But When Driving, These Sunglasses May Save Your Life!

Studies by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) show that most (74%) of the crashes occurred on clear, sunny days

Drivers’ Alert: Driving can expose you to more dangerous glare than any sunny day at the beach can… do you know how to protect yourself?

T

he sun rises and sets at peak travel periods, during the early morning and afternoon rush hours and many drivers find themselves temporarily blinded while driving directly into the glare of the sun. Deadly accidents are regularly caused by such blinding glare with danger arising from reflected light off another vehicle, the pavement, or even from waxed and oily windshields that can make matters worse. Early morning dew can exacerbate this situation. Yet, motorists struggle on despite being blinded by the sun’s glare that can cause countless accidents every year. Not all sunglasses are created equal. Protecting your eyes is serious business. With all the fancy fashion frames out there it can be easy to overlook what really matters––the lenses. So we did our research and looked to the very best in optic innovation and technology. Sometimes it does take a rocket scientist. A NASA rocket scientist. Some ordinary sunglasses can obscure your vision by exposing your eyes to harmful UV rays, blue light, and reflective glare. They can also darken useful vision-enhancing light. But now, independent research conducted by scientists from NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory has brought forth ground-breaking technology to help protect human eyesight from the harmful effects of solar radiation

Eagle Eyes® Lens

simulation

Slip on a pair of Eagle Eyes® and everything instantly appears more vivid and sharp. You’ll immediately notice that your eyes are more comfortable and relaxed and you’ll feel no need to squint. The scientifically designed sunglasses are not just fashion accessories—they are necessary to protect your eyes from those harmful rays produced by the sun during peak driving times.

light. This superior lens technology was first discovered when NASA scientists looked to nature for a means to superior eye protection— specifically, by studying the eyes of eagles, known for their extreme visual acuity. This discovery resulted in what is now known as Eagle Eyes®. The Only Sunglass Technology Certified by the Space Foundation for UV and Blue­Light Eye Protection. Eagle Eyes® features the most advanced eye protection technology ever created. The TriLenium® Lens Technology offers triple-filter polarization to block 99.9% UVA and UVB— plus the added benefit of blue-light eye protection. Eagle Eyes® is the only optic technology that has earned official recognition from the Space Certification Program for this remarkable technology. Now, that’s proven science-based protection. The finest optics: And buy one, get one FREE! Eagle Eyes® has the highest customer satisfaction of any item in our 20 year history. We are so excited for you to try the Eagle Eyes® breakthrough technology that we will give you a second pair of Eagle Eyes® Navigator™ Sunglasses FREE––a $99 value! That’s two pairs to protect your eyes with the best technology available for less than the price of one pair of traditional sunglasses. You get a pair of Navigators with stainless steel black frames and the other with stainless steel gold, plus one hard zipper case and one micro-fiber drawstring cleaning pouch are included. Keep one pair in your pocket and one in your car. Your satisfaction is 100% guaranteed. If you are not astounded with the Eagle Eyes® technology, enjoying clearer, sharper and more glare-free vision, simply return one pair within 60 days for a full refund of the purchase price. The other pair is yours to keep. No one else has such confidence in their optic technology.Don’t leave your eyes in the hands of fashion designers, entrust them to the best scientific minds on earth. Wear your Eagle Eyes® Navigators

Navigator™ Black Stainless Steel Sunglasses

Receive the Navigator™ Gold Sunglasses (a $99 value) FREE! just for trying the Navigator™ Black

Navigator™ Gold Stainless Steel Sunglasses

Certified EAGLE EYES® was developed from original NASA Optic technology and was recently inducted into the Space Foundation Technology Hall of Fame.

Fit­ons available for $39+S&H Black or Tortoise­Shell design

with absolute confidence, knowing your eyes are protected with technology that was born in space for the human race. Eagle Eyes® Navigator™ Sunglasses $99† Offer Code Price $49 + S&P Save $50

PLUS receive the Navigator™ Gold absolutely FREE!—2 pairs for the price of one!

1­800­333­2045 Your Insider Offer Code: EEN421­03 You must use this insider offer code to get our special price.

Stauer

® 14101 Southcross Drive W., Dept. EEN421­03 Burnsville, Minnesota 55337

www.stauer.com Rating of A+

† Special price only for customers using the offer code versus the price on Stauer.com without your offer code.

Smart Luxuries—Surprising Prices ™

A Door Gunner’s Close Call Your “Flying Banana” article (April 2016) refers to the mission of the 81st Transportation Company, out of Tuy Hoa, on Dec. 22, 1962. I was the door gunner on the aircraft that was shot down. The bullet came right by my head and lodged in the hoist control panel. One of our forward transmission oil lines took a direct hit. Since the pilots _MZM JMQVO LZMVKPML _Q\P PW\ \ZIV[UQ[[QWV Æ]QL IVL _M PIL TW[\ transmission oil pressure, they decided to make an emergency landing. Our wingman landed beside us and we all clambered aboard. Later that day, after the [South Vietnamese army] had secured the area, we went back out and repaired the aircraft so we could get it back to Pleiku. Enclosed is a photo of me and the oil line. Al Doucette Stockton, Calif.

Location, Location, Location I read with great interest Chuck Springston’s Editor’s Notebook, “The Core Question and the Search for an Answer” (June 2016). As a young Marine with India Company, 3rd Battalion, 4th Marines, who walked almost the entire 50-mile length of the DMZ [separating North and South Vietnam] during 1967-68, the search for an answer is easier: Look at the Korean War. In Korea, the DMZ was 160 miles long, and because Korea is a peninsula it reached from sea to sea, so U.N. troops were eventually able to hold it. In Vietnam, had Laos instead been a “Southeast Asian Sea,” the 50-mile DMZ could have been sealed, preventing any invasion from North Vietnam. And we 6

VIETNAM

would still have a presence there, just as the 2nd Infantry Division stands guard in Korea. It was all about the geography. James Cool Tucker, Ga.

Remembering the Kids I enjoyed your issue with the GIs and the Vietnamese kids (photo feature, April 2016). I served with the 1st Cavalry Division, Wild Card Company, 2nd Battalion, 12th Cavalry Regiment, between Tay Ninh and Loc Ninh 1968-69, near Landing Zone Grant and LZ Buttons. Every so often we would go through small villages, and the kids would always be looking for a handout. I’d see these two little girls together [in photo above],

probably sisters. Every time I look at this picture, I wonder if they survived the war. Kenny Cellilo Florida Keys

If Goldwater Had Won I read “Nightmare Up North,” by Paul Novak (February 2016), the B-52 navigator who participated in Linebacker II in December 1972. Apparently he is a contemXWZIZa WN UQVM 1 ÆM_ \PM .̆ Phantom in 1968 and 1970, while stationed at Cam Ranh Bay. In 1964 I voted for Barry Goldwater. Had he been elected, I believe an operation similar to Linebacker II would have occurred as early as 1965. If that had happened, the Vietnam War would have ended more like the Korean War did. David Herbert Billings, Mont. Corrections: Because of a typographical error, the 33rd H-21 company was UQ[QLMV\QÅML QV ¹<PM .TaQVO *IVIVIº (April 2016). In “Monsters of Metal” (April 2016), the names Carl Fleischmann and Karl Fontenot were spelled incorrectly. Because of an inaccurate posting to a chat group of Vietnam War journalists, “The Terrorist Attack That Shook the World” (June 2016) mistakenly stated that journalist Marvin Wolf was at the My Canh restaurant when it was bombed on June 25, 1965.

Send letters and email: Vietnam Editor 1600 Tysons Blvd., Suite 1140 Tysons, VA 22102-4833; or Vietnam@historynet.com

A

B LL Bu ig -NE tt ge W on r s

s o N act r nt Co

“My friends all hate their cell phones… I love mine!” FR EE Car Charg er Here’s why.

Say good-bye to everything you hate about cell phones. Say hello to the ALL-NEW Jitterbug Flip. “Cell phones have gotten so small, I can barely dial mine.” Not the new Jitterbug® Flip. It features a larger keypad for easier dialing. It even has a larger display so you can actually see it. “I had to get my son to program it.” Your Jitterbug Flip set-up process is simple. We’ll even program it with your favorite numbers. “I tried my sister’s cell phone… I couldn’t hear it.” The Jitterbug Flip is designed with a powerful speaker and is hearing aid compatible. Plus, there’s an adjustable volume control. “I don’t need stock quotes, Internet sites or games on my phone. I just want to talk with my family and friends.” Life is complicated enough… The Jitterbug Flip is simple. “What if I don’t remember a number?” Friendly, helpful Operators are available 24 hours a day and will even greet you by name when you call.

Monthly Plan

$14.99/mo

$19.99/mo

Monthly Minutes

200

600

Operator Assistance

24/7

24/7

Long Distance Calls

No add’l charge

No add’l charge

Voice Dial

FREE

FREE

Nationwide Coverage

YES

YES

30 days

30 days

Friendly Return Policy

1

More minute plans available. Ask your Jitterbug expert for details.

“I’d like a cell phone to use in an emergency, but I don’t want a high monthly bill.” The Jitterbug Flip has a plan to fit your needs… and your budget. “Many phones have features that are rarely needed and hard to use!” The Jitterbug Flip contains easy-to-use features that are meaningful to you. A newly designed built-in camera makes it easy and fun for you to capture and share your favorite memories. And a new flashlight with a built-in magnifier helps you see in dimly lit areas, the Jitterbug Flip has all the features you need. Enough talk. Isn’t it time you found out more about the cell phone that’s changing all the rules? Call now, Jitterbug product experts are standing by.

“My cell phone company wants to lock me in a two-year contract!” Not with the Jitterbug Flip. There are no contracts to sign and no penalty if you discontinue your service. Available in Red and Graphite.

Order now and receive a FREE Car Charger for your Jitterbug Flip – a $25 value. Call now!

NEW Jitterbug Flip Cell Phone Call toll-free to get your Jitterbug Flip. Please mention promotional code 103511.

1-888-763-5161

www.jitterbugdirect.com 47665

We proudly accept the following credit cards:

IMPORTANT CONSUMER INFORMATION: Jitterbug is owned by GreatCall, Inc. Your invoices will come from GreatCall. Plans and Services require purchase of a Jitterbug phone and a one-time setup fee of $35. Monthly fees do not include government taxes or assessment surcharges and are subject to change. Coverage is not available everywhere. 5Star or 9-1-1 calls can only be made when cellular service is available. 1We will refund the full price of the Jitterbug phone and the activation fee (or setup fee) if it is returned within 30 days of purchase in like-new condition. We will also refund your first monthly service charge if you have less than 30 minutes of usage. If you have more than 30 minutes of usage, a per minute charge of 35 cents will be deducted from your refund for each minute over 30 minutes. You will be charged a $10 restocking fee. The shipping charges are not refundable. There are no additional fees to call GreatCall’s U.S.-based customer service. However, for calls to a GreatCall Operator in which a service is completed, you will be charged 99 cents per call, and minutes will be deducted from your monthly rate plan balance equal to the length of the call and any call connected by the Operator. Jitterbug and GreatCall are registered trademarks of GreatCall, Inc. ©2016 GreatCall, Inc. ©2016 firstSTREET for Boomers and Beyond, Inc.

New mission OV-10 Bronco observation and attack planes, which ÄYZ[ ZH^ HJ[PVU PU Vietnam, occupy a “middle ground” between drones and HK]HUJLK ÄNO[LY QL[Z

A pair of Vietnam-era OV-10 Broncos, which performed reconnaissance and attack functions in the war, ZMKMV\Ta [XMV\ \PZMM UWV\P[ JMQVO \M[\ML NWZ ÆaQVO UQ[sions in the Middle East. The U.S. Central Command, responsible for the military’s operations in the Middle East and Afghanistan, would not say exactly where the OV-10s were based or where they attacked but did specify that the planes, with their distinctive twin tail booms, ÆM_ QV []XXWZ\ WN 7XMZI\QWV 1VPMZMV\ :M[WT^M \PM = ; ̆ TML QV\MZVI\QWVIT KIUXIQOV IOIQV[\ \PM 1[TIUQK ;\I\M QV 1ZIY IVL ;aZQI KWUUWVTa KITTML 1;1; The Broncos are part of an experiment to see if “light turboXZWX IQZKZIN\ IZM UWZM MЄMK\Q^M in conducting counterinsurgency operations,” a U.S. military representative told CNN. During their deployment, the planes completed 134 sorties, including 120 combat missions, over a span of 82 days beginning in May 2015 or shortly thereafter. Originally the Pentagon proposed to spend $20 million on the OV-10s in 2012, but Sen. John McCain, chairman of the Senate Armed Services Committee, objected. “There is no urgent operational reY]QZMUMV\ NWZ \PQ[ \aXM WN IQZKZIN\ º \PM NWZUMZ >QM\VIU prisoner of war said in a statement. Lawmakers subseY]MV\Ta KIVKMTML UW[\ WN \PM *ZWVKW N]VLQVO J]\ \PM military eventually succeeded in paying for a trial for two planes by diverting money from other programs. The idea for deploying the Broncos is that these older 8

VIETNAM

KW]V\MZQV[]ZOMVKa IQZKZIN\ KIV UWZM KW[\̆MЄMK\Q^MTa Æa KTW[M̆IQZ []XXWZ\ UQ[[QWV[ \W PMTX = ; OZW]VL \ZWWX[ and pilots better see and attack low-tech insurgents. The turbo-prop planes were the perfect middle ground between drones and more technologically advanced RM\[ IKKWZLQVO \W 8I]T ;KPIZZM I NWZUMZ )ZUa :IVOMZ _PW [MZ^ML QV 1ZIY IVL )NOPIVQ[\IV IVL Q[ VW_ I [MVQWZ fellow at the Center for a New American Security, Y]W\ML Ja +66 The military also wanted to know if Broncos or similar XTIVM[ KW]TL \ISM W^MZ NWZ RM\ ÅOP\MZ[ such as F-15 Eagles and F/A-18 Hornets, which conduct most U.S. airstrikes in the Middle East but are much more expensive to buy and operate than a propeller-driven plane like the OV-10, said Central Command spokesman Bryant Davis. North American Aviation, now part of Boeing Co., developed the Bronco in the 1960s to provide the Pentagon with a small, cheap attack XTIVM \PI\ KW]TL \ISM WЄ NZWU ZW]OP IQZ[\ZQX[ KTW[M \W \PM ÅOP\QVO <PM )QZ .WZKM 6I^a IVL 5IZQVM +WZX[ LMXTWaML hundreds of OV-10s in Vietnam. The military will be reviewing the results of the Broncos’ trial deployment. The assessment will “determine if \PQ[ Q[ I ^ITQL KWVKMX\ \PI\ _W]TL JM MЄMK\Q^M QV \PM K]Zrent battle space,” Davis said. Lt. Gen. Bradley Heithold, head of Air Force Special Operations Command, has already hinted, however, that the military will stick with Q\[ K]ZZMV\ RM\ ÅOP\MZ[ NWZ I\\IKS UQ[[QWV[

PHOTOS: USAF

VIETNAM WAR PLANES TESTED ON ISIS

Back Comfortable cotton blend in black with soft eece lining

Contrasting grey thermal lining in hood

Striking design features proud patriotic and veteran memorial art

Front

Wear a Bold, Patriotic Design Our “Veterans Pride and Brotherhood” Men’s Hoodie honors those brave individuals who have courageously served, and forged a bond with their brothers in arms. Crafted in a black cotton-blend knit, our hoodie features classic zip-front styling. The front of the hoodie showcases an embroidered American flag patch and the words Pride and Brotherhood. Showcased on the back is a dramatic patch designed to include a detail of the Vietnam War Memorial against an American flag framed by the wings of a bald eagle along with the words Proud Veteran. The hoodie has two front pockets, rib knit cuffs and hem, and a soft fleece lining. The hood features contrasting gray thermal lining and metal toggles on the cords. Imported. RESERVATION APPLICATION

Exceptional value; satisfaction guaranteed This jacket is a superb value at $89.95*, payable in four convenient installments of $22.49 each and backed by our 30-day guarantee. Send no money now; just return the Reservation Application. You won’t find this exclusive design in stores. So don’t miss out—order yours today!

A Custom-Crafted Exclusive From The Bradford Exchange www.bradfordexchange.com/vethoodie ©1984. VVMF and F.E. Hart. All Rights Reserved. Used with permission. ©2016 BGE 01-20213-001-BIB

SEND NO MONEY NOW Mrs. Mr. Ms. Name (Please Print Clearly)

Address

9345 Milwaukee Avenue · Niles, IL 60714-1393

YES. Please reserve the “Veterans Pride and Brotherhood” Men’s Hoodie for me in the size indicated below.

❑ M (38-40) 01-20213-011

❑ XL (46-48) 01-20213-013

❑ L (42-44) 01-20213-012

❑ XXL (50-52) 01-20213-014

City State

Zip

E39572 *Plus $11.99 shipping and service. Please allow 2-4 weeks after initial payment for shipment. All sales are subject to product availability and order acceptance.

KERRY AND KISSINGER SPEAK AT VIETNAM WAR SUMMIT

3PUNLYPUN LɈLJ[Z * 7YV]PKLY WSHULZ ZWYH` (NLU[ 6YHUNL ZV\[OLHZ[ VM :HPNVU

Fifty years later 1VOU 2LYY` YLÃ…LJ[Z VU [OL =PL[UHT >HY K\YPUN H KPZJ\ZZPVU H[ [OL 3)1 SPIYHY` VU (WYPS

2][\ _MMS[ JMNWZM 8ZM[QLMV\ *IZIKS 7JIUI¼[ [KPML]TML Ã…Z[\ ^Q[Q\ to Vietnam in May, Secretary of State John Kerry attended a Vietnam War summit at the presidential library for Lyndon B. Johnson QV )][\QV <M`I[ 3MZZa LMTQ^MZML \PM SMaVW\M ILLZM[[ WV )XZQT focusing on the changes in Vietnam and its relationship with the United States. <PM =VQ^MZ[Q\a WN <M`I[ IVL \PM 2WPV[WV TQJZIZa KW̆PW[\ML \PM []UUQ\ _PW[M WÐ…KQIT[ [IQL \PM M^MV\ _I[ PMTL \W WЄMZ IV PWVM[\ appraisal of the war and Johnson’s role in the failure. “When the 4*2 8ZM[QLMV\QIT 4QJZIZa _I[ Ã…Z[\ LMLQKI\ML 8ZM[QLMV\ 2WPV[WV XZWKTIQUML »1\¼[ ITT PMZM \PM [\WZa WN W]Z \QUM¸_Q\P \PM JIZS WЄ ¼º [IQL 5IZS 3 =XLMOZW^M TQJZIZa LQZMK\WZ ¹1V SMMXQVO _Q\P 8ZM[QLMV\ 2WPV[WV¼[ ^Q[QWV NWZ PQ[ TQJZIZa _M _QTT \ISM IV ]V^IZVQ[PML TWWS I\ \PM UW[\ KWV\ZW^MZ[QIT NIKM\ WN PQ[ XZM[QLMVKa º 0MVZa 3Q[[QVOMZ [MKZM\IZa WN [\I\M NZWU ! \W ! IVL 8PIU Quang Vinh, Vietnam’s current ambassador to the United States, [PIZML \PMQZ XMZ[XMK\Q^M[ WV \PM _IZ I[ LQL Ã…TUUISMZ 3MV *]ZV[ _PW[M ̆XIZ\ LWK]UMV\IZa WV \PM _IZ Q[ M`XMK\ML \W IQZ QV Panel participants included Bob Kerrey, a Medal of Honor recipient and former U.S. senator; Charles Robb, Johnson’s son in law, a Marine in Vietnam and former U.S. senator; Jan Scruggs, founder and president emeritus of the Vietnam Veterans Memorial Fund; Tom Hayden, one of the antiwar leaders of the 1960s and later a +ITQNWZVQI TMOQ[TI\WZ# )TM`IVLMZ *]\\MZÃ…MTL I NWZUMZ :QKPIZL 6Q`WV aide who disclosed the White House taping system; and journalists 8M\MZ )ZVM\\ ,IV :I\PMZ ,I^QL 5IZIVQ[[ IVL 2WM 3TMQV 10

>1-<6)5

) ZMXWZ\ WV \PM PMIT\P MЄMK\[ WN )OMV\ Orange, released in March by the Institute of Medicine, recommends that the ,MXIZ\UMV\ WN >M\MZIV[ )NNIQZ[ OQ^M [MZ^QKM̆ZMTI\ML LQ[IJQTQ\a LM[QOVI\QWV \W ^M\MZIV[ _PW PI^M JTILLMZ KIVKMZ IVL hypothyroidism and exhibit “Parkinson’sTQSM [aUX\WU[º J]\ LW VW\ PI^M 8IZSQVson’s disease. “There is no rational basis for exclu[QWV WN QVLQ^QL]IT[ _Q\P 8IZSQV[WV¼[̆TQSM [aUX\WU[ NZWU \PM [MZ^QKM̆ZMTI\ML KI\MOWZa LMVW\ML I[ 8IZSQV[WV¼[ LQ[MI[M º the report stated. 1V ! >M\MZIV[ )ЄIQZ[ ILLML 8IZkinson’s to its list of diseases possibly associated with exposure to the chemical defoliant. VA officials said a working group will study the report and prepare a response to department Secretary Robert McDonald on whether Parkinson’s-like diseases should be added to the 15 disMI[M[ \PI\ ITZMILa Y]ITQNa >QM\VIU ^M\MZIV[ NWZ LQ[IJQTQ\a JMVMÃ…\[ IVL PMIT\P care. The process could take up to two aMIZ[ IKKWZLQVO \W >) WÐ…KQIT[ The Institute of Medicine report, in another finding, determined that scientific research does not support a XZM^QW][Ta PMTL JMTQMN \PI\ [XQVI JQÃ…LI WKK]Z[ I\ PQOPMZ ZI\M[ QV \PM WЄ[XZQVO WN M`XW[ML ^M\MZIV[

TOP LEFT: LBJ LIBRARY, PHOTO BY DAVID HUME KENNERLY; TOP RIGHT: PHOTO BY DICK SWANSON/THE LIFE IMAGES COLLECTION/GETTY IMAGES

Report Links Agent Orange to Bladder Cancer, Hypothyroidism

REFUGEE’S BOOK WINS PULITZER FOR FICTION

The Sympathizer, the best-selling debut novel by Vietnamese refugee and University of Southern California professor Viet Thanh Nguyen, was awarded the 2016 Pulitzer Prize for Fiction. The Sympathizer is a tale of a Communist Party spy who escapes Vietnam in 1975 and goes to the United States, where he lives a double existence—as a resident and an informer. Nguyen, who escaped Vietnam in 1975 when he was 4 and grew up in California’s Bay Area, has always been fond of spy novels, he said in an interview with The Guardian. The life of the spy in his novel, who makes his way by duality and subterfuge, resonated with someone who grew up as an immigrant in America, he said. “There’s that experience of feeling between two worlds, seeing things from two sides, being the lone minority in an environment.” 6O]aMV ZMKMV\Ta X]JTQ[PML I VWVÅK\QWV JWWS Nothing Ever Dies, which examines the way memory of the Vietnam War—and war in general—is made, curated and abused by those in power.

CLOCKWISE FROM TOP RIGHT: VIETNGUYEN.INFO, PHOTO BY ANNA MIN; PHOTOS BY JENNIFER E. BERRY; TWITTER/@PLANTU; WENN US/ALAMY STOCK PHOTO

Vietnam Dove Artist Draws Brussels Solidarity Cartoon

Plantu, a French political cartoonist whose Brussels tribute went viral on social media after the March 22 attacks in Belgium, made his debut during the VietVIU ?IZ 0Q[ ÅZ[\ X]JTQ[PML LZI_QVO I dove holding a question mark in its beak, appeared in 1972 in the French newspaper Le Monde, shortly after Plantu, the pen name of Jean Plantureux, had started working there. The peace dove, a commentary on hopes for a resolution of Vietnam War, ZMÆMK\[ WVM WN 8TIV\]¼[ UIRWZ \PMUM[" international violence and corruption, according to France’s English-language newspaper The Connexion. He also does humorous takes on French politics. Plantu’s Brussels cartoon illustrates the solidarity between Belgium and France in the wake of the closely spaced terrorist I\\IKS[ QV JW\P KW]V\ZQM[ 1\ [PW_[ \_W ÅO]ZM[ MUJZIKQVO WVM _MIZQVO .ZIVKM¼[ ÆIO \PM W\PMZ _MIZQVO *MTOQ]U¼[ ) PMIZ\ Q[ above their heads and the dates of the recent terrorist attacks in 8IZQ[ IVL *Z][[MT[ IZM [KZQX\ML ]VLMZVMI\P \PM ÅO]ZM[ Plantu co-founded the association Dessins pour La Paix (Cartooning for Peace) in 2006 and is its president.

Lapel Pin for Veterans A specially designed Vietnam War lapel pin is available to all living veterans who served on active duty in the U.S. armed forces at any time from Nov. 1, 1955, to May 15, 1975, regardless of location. The pins are engraved with an American bald eagle, a blue circle, a laurel wreath and six stars representing the six nations that fought as allies in Vietnam. Embossed on the back of the pin is “A Grateful Nation Thanks and Honors You.” The pins are part of the Defense Department’s 50th anniversary commemoration of the war. They generally are presented at public events held by organizations that have chosen to become commemorative partners in the program. >QM\VIU ^M\MZIV[ KIV ÅVL KWUUMUWZItive events in their communities by visiting www.vietnamwar50th.com/events. New events are frequently added to the TQ[\ >M\MZIV[ KIV IT[W ÅVL I KWUUMUWZItive event by using an email link available at www.vietnamwar50th.com/lapelpins. AUGUST 2016

11

ARCHAEOLOGISTS EXAMINE MYSTERIOUS PLAIN OF JARS

The Rev. Daniel Berrigan, 94, a Jesuit priest who led protests against the Vietnam War, died on April 30, in New York. Berrigan and eight others, including his younger brother and fellow priest, Philip Berrigan, stole draft records from ;MTMK\Q^M ;MZ^QKM WЅKM[ QV +I\WV[ville, Maryland, on May 17, 1968, IVL [M\ ÅZM \W \PMU ][QVO PWUMUILM napalm. They were arrested, and the Å^M̆LIa \ZQIT ZM[]T\ML QV I \PZMM̆aMIZ prison sentence for Daniel, which he evaded for several months by going underground. He served about two years. Berrigan wrote a play about the event, The Trial of the Catonsville Nine , which also became a movie. Philip died in 2002. 12

VIETNAM

put in ceramic vessels; others were buried in a pit covered with limestone blocks. In the third type of burial, the body was placed in a grave. -^MV _Q\P \PM VM_ Ă…VLQVO[ \PM N]VK\QWV WN \PM [\WVM RIZ[ ZMUIQV[ I Ua[\MZa <PM PMI^QM[\ Q[ KIZ^ML NZWU one single piece of sandstone that is estimated to weigh about 32 tons and dates to a period between 600 BC and AD 500, according to Australian Geographic. š7VM \PMWZa Q[ \PI\ C\PM RIZ[E _MZM ][ML \W LMKWUXW[M the bodies,â€? said Dougald O’Reilly, who spearheaded the ZM[MIZKP š4I\MZ IN\MZ \PM ÆM[P _I[ ZMUW^ML \PM ZMUIQV[ UIa PI^M JMMV J]ZQML IZW]VL \PM RIZ[ Âş

Santiago Erevia, 70, a Vietnam War veteran and retired mail carrier who had been denied the nation’s highest military honor for 45 years because he was Hispanic, died on March 22 in San Antonio. In 2014, following a 12-year Pentagon investigation, President Barack Obama awarded the Medal of Honor to Erevia and 23 other Army veterans, most of them Hispanic, who fought in World War II, Korea and Vietnam. Erevia, who served in the 101st Airborne Division, singlehandedly wiped out four enemy bunkers while his comrades lay wounded near Tam Ky City on May 21, 1969.

Country music legend Merle Haggard,79, died on his birthday, April 6, at his home in Palo Cedro, California. The Country Music Hall of Famer wrote and recorded for more than 40 years, releasing dozens of albums and No. 1 hits. He was perhaps best known for “Okie From Muskogee,â€? a patriotic anthem released in 1969 at the height of the Vietnam War. The song reached No. 1 in the Billboard country singles charts and quickly became noteworthy for its anti-hippie lyrics proclaiming, “We don’t burn our draft cards down on Main Street; we like living right and being free.â€? Haggard changed his tune in 2005, writing “America First,â€? an anti– Iraq War song that included the lyrics, “Let the rest of the world help us for a change, and let’s rebuild )UMZQKI Ă…Z[\ Âş

CLOCKWISE FROM TOP RIGHT: IMAGEBROKER/ALAMY STOCK PHOTO; KRISTOFFER TRIPPLAAR/ ALAMY STOCK PHOTO; DOD PHOTO/ALAMY STOCK PHOTO; AP PHOTO

The Plain of Jars, an area encompassing 85 ancient sites in Laos, is being explored once again by archaeWTWOQ[\[ \PIVS[ \W MĐ„WZ\[ W^MZ \PM TI[\ LMKILM \W KTMIZ unexploded bombs and mines left from the Vietnam War. Scientists can now excavate those sites, many in remote areas, BBC News explained. The excavation is part of a VM_ Ă…^M̆aMIZ XZWRMK\ JM\_MMV \PM OW^MZVUMV\ WN 4IW[ IVL )][\ZITQIV ZM[MIZKPMZ[ QV\MV\ WV Ă…VLQVO KT]M[ \W \PM origin and purpose of the giant urns, which range from 3 to 9 feet tall and 2 to 6½ feet in diameter. )ZKPIMWTWOQ[\[ [XMV\ Ă…^M _MMS[ \PQ[ aMIZ M`KI^I\ing a site where they found 384 of the pots and human remains estimated to be 2,500 years old, according to Smithsonian magazine. :M[MIZKPMZ[ QV \PM ! [ \PMWZQbML \PI\ \PM RIZ[ _MZM a type of crematory, and archeologists this year found three burial types at the Plain of Jars. Some bones were

A Tribute to Those Who Served

A bold statement in solid sterling silver, gold and black onyx

Honor with pride the brotherhood of courage that answered their country’s call to action over the years with the Veteran’s Pride and Brotherhood Ring—a fine jewelry exclusive honoring those who served and forged a bond that remains to this day.

A Moving Achievement in Craftsmanship and Design Crafted of solid sterling silver and plated in 24K-gold, the Veteran’s Pride and Brotherhood Ring features a stirring bas relief portrait of three vets plated in 24K gold against a genuine black onyx center stone. The protective wings of a proud American eagle, also plated in 24K gold, embraces this tribute. A dramatic motif of stars and stripes flanks each side of the band, and engraved inside are the poignant words, “Pride and Brotherhood.” Exceptional Value ... Immeasurable Significance The perfect way to show your remembrance, or a great gift for the veteran in your life, this magnificent ring can be yours for just $199*, payable in 5 convenient installments of $39.80 To reserve a ring in your name, backed by our unconditional 120-day guarantee, send no money now. Just fill out and send in the coupon today. But hurry—this is a limited time offer!

Expertly crafted in solid sterling silver and plated in 24K gold Genuine black onyx center inlay featuring a dramatically detailed veterans sculpture www.bradfordexchange.com/7794 A FINE JEWELRY EXCLUSIVE RESERVATION APPLICATION LIMITED TIME OFFER Reservations will be accepted on a first-come, first-served basis. Please respond as soon as possible.

the

BRADFORD E XC HANGE j e w e l ry

9345 Milwaukee Avenue · Niles, IL 60714-1393

YES. Please reserve the Veteran’s Pride and Brotherhood Ring for me as described in this announcement.

Arrives in a custom presentation case with Certificate of Authenticity

Send no money now! Mrs. Mr. Ms. Name (Please Print Clearly)

Shown actual size.

Your Complete Satisfaction Guaranteed To assure a proper fit, a ring sizer will be sent to you after your reservation has been accepted. ©1984. VVMF and F.E. Hart. ©2016 The Bradford Exchange 01-07794-001-BIR

*Plus $9.98 shipping and service per item. Please allow 4-6 weeks after initial payment for shipment. Sales subject to product availability and order acceptance.

Address City State

Zip

Email (optional)

01-07794-001-E39574

July 13 Richard Speck, right, breaks into a Chicago townhouse where student nurses are staying and strangles or stabs to death eight women, one of whom is raped. He was arrested July 17 and spent the rest of his life in prison.

JULY-AUGUST

1966

July 2 Tennis star Billie Jean King wins the ÅZ[\ WN PMZ six Wimbledon singles championships, putting her on the path to 12 career singles titles in the four major tennis tournaments. July 11 The Newlywed Game, hosted by Bob Eubanks, premieres on ABC. It was a ratings hit with its risqué chatter about “making whoopee.”

14

VIETNAM

Aug. 1 Former Marine sniper Charles Whitman, perched atop a 28-story tower at the University of Texas in Austin, begins a shooting spree that kills or wounds more than 40 people. About 90 minutes later, he _I[ [PW\ LMIL Ja \_W XWTQKM WЅKMZ[

Aug. 10 NASA launches its Lunar Orbiter I to photograph lunar surfaces that could help determine future landing sites. On Aug. 23, the spacecraft transmitted \PM ÅZ[\ XPW\W WN -IZ\P I[ seen from the moon.

Aug. 24 Michael Caine and Shelley Winters star in )TÅM, a comedy-drama about a selfabsorbed womanizer who must face the consequences of his actions. Caine was nominated for a best actor Academy Award.

July 6 Fifty-two American prisoners of war are forced to march 2 miles through the streets of Hanoi past thousands of civilian spectators, some of whom physically attack the POWs. The brutal spectacle shocked the American public and drew widespread condemnation.

Aug. 15 <PM ÅZ[\ best-seller in what M^WT^M[ QV\W I VM_ genre, Kennedy assassination conspiracy books, appears when Mark Lane’s Rush to Judgment is published.

Aug. 29 At Candlestick Park in San Francisco, the Beatles perform \PMQZ ÅVIT TQ^M concert, afterward playing primarily in recording studios. The concert ended an 18-day, 14-city North American tour.

July 7 Task Force Delta of the Marine 3rd Division begins Operation Hastings just south of the Demilitarized Zone to block North Vietnamese Army troops moving into Quang Tri province. South Vietnamese soldiers were also involved in the operation, which ended successfully on Aug. 3. The death toll was 126 Marines, 21 South Vietnamese and more than 800 North Vietnamese. July 20 Navy pilot Lt. j.g. Dieter ,MVOTMZ JMKWUM[ \PM ÅZ[\ )UMZQKIV QV the war to successfully escape a POW camp. After sneaking out of a Laos prison, Dengler walked south for 23 days and was spotted near the DMZ by Air Force reconnaissance pilot Lt. Col. Eugene Deatrick, who called in a rescue helicopter that picked up Dengler. Aug. 11 1V I ¹NZQMVLTa ÅZMº QVKQLMV\ )QZ .WZKM *̆ JWUJMZ[ IVL .̆ ÅOP\ers mistakenly attack Coast Guard cutter Point Welcome, patrolling about a mile south of the DMZ. The attack killed cutter commander Lt. j.g. David *ZW[\ZWU \PM ÅZ[\ +WI[\ /]IZL[UIV killed in Vietnam, and Engineman 2nd Class Jerry Phillips. Nine other crewmen and two passengers were wounded. Aug. 18 Delta Company, 6th Battal-

ion, Royal Australian Regiment, wins the Battle of Long Tan, on a rubber plantation 42 miles southeast of Saigon, when 124 Aussies defeat a 1,500man force of the North Vietnamese Army and Viet Cong. Killed were 18 Delta soldiers and 245 enemy troops. CLOCKWISE FROM OPPOSITE TOP LEFT: ALLSPORT UK/ALLSPORT; AP PHOTO/CHARLES HARRITY; NASA; PICTORIAL PRESS LTD/ALAMY STOCK PHOTO; BETTMANN/CORBIS; HERITAGE AUCTIONS, DALLAS (2); ABC PHOTO ARCHIVES/ABC VIA GETTY IMAGES

AUGUST 2016

15

NOTRE DAME CATHEDRAL HO CHI MINH CITY

AGE FOTOSTOCK/ALAMY STOCK PHOTO; INSET: AP PHOTO

Bell towers of the Saigon Notre Dame Cathedral frame a Marine helicopter on April 29, 1975, as evacuation of the city begins ahead of approaching Communist forces. The cathedral, today surrounded by the growth of modern Ho Chi Minh City, was built during French colonial rule. Construction began in 1877, and the cathedral was dedicated in 1880. V

16

VIETNAM

24-ounce fine porcelain food-safe stein is fullysculpted according to time-honored tradition

Shown much smaller than actual size of appr. 9¾ inches tall

® Officially Licensed Product of the United States Marine Corps Proud Supporter of the Marine Corps Recruit Depot Museum Historical Society

Thumb rest features the Eagle, Globe and Anchor symbol

TOAST the Devil Dogs! Few mascots deserve a toast hoisted in their honor as much as the Devil Dog of the United States Marine Corps! Now the all-new USMC Devil Dog Collector’s Stein celebrates the Corps’ rough and ready symbol in historic tradition as a fully-sculpted porcelain stein. Of cially licensed by the U.S. Marine Corps and available exclusively from The Bradford Exchange, this tough dog comes attired as a drill sargeant with spit and polish showing in the golden detailing on his hat and on the handle and body of the stein. With a tattoo on his arm and the Latin words of loyalty on the base, this Devil Dog is a perfectly fun way to show off your Marine Corps pride. Act now to get yours in four installments of only $24.99 each, for a total of $99.95*. Edition limited to just 95 ring days and porcelain requires intensive hand-crafting. Our 365-Day Guarantee assures your complete satisfaction. To order, send no money now. Just complete and mail the Reservation Application to reserve your USMC Devil Dog Collector’s Stein today! ©2015 BGE 01-21931-001-BIU

www.bradfordexchange.com/corps

9345 Milwaukee Avenue · Niles, IL 60714-1393

YES. Please reserve the USMC Devil Dog Collector’s Stein for me as described in this announcement. Limit: One per order.

Please Respond Promptly

Mrs. Mr. Ms. Name (Please Print Clearly)

Address City State

Zip

01-21931-001-E39571 *Plus $14.99 shipping and service. Limited-edition presentation restricted to 95 firing days. Please allow 4-8 weeks after initial payment for shipment. Sales subject to product availability and order acceptance.

Revolutionary “turboramjetâ€?: The turbojet 1 \ZLK H ZPUNSL ZWVVS MVY [HRLVŃœ HUK JSPTIPUN employing a unique fuel bleed from compressor [V HM[LYI\YULY [V HJOPL]L Z\WLYZVUPJ Ă…PNO[

Long range at high speed: The aircraft was equipped for aerial refueling en route to the target and home base.

He’s got the pilot’s back: ( YLJVUUHPZZHUJL Z`Z[LTZ VŃ?JLY VWLYH[LK electronic warfare and sensor systems, which improved survivability, signals and optical intelligence collection.

Going dark: The airframe’s shape reduced its radar signature as well as drag. Dark, absorptive WHPU[ THKL [OL WSHUL KPŃ?J\S[ [V spot in the stratosphere.

THE FIRST STEALTH AIRCRAFT *a +IZT 7 ;KP][\MZ

18

VIETNAM

LOCKHEED SR-71 BLACKBIRD Crew: 2 Engines: 2 Pratt & Whitney J58 turbojets at 34,000 lbs. of thrust Wingspan: 55 ft. 7 in. Length: 107 ft. 5 in. 4H_ [HRLVŃœ ^LPNO[! 172,000 lbs. Max. speed: Mach 3.4 Cruising speed: Mach 3.2 Max. range (unrefueled): 2,900 miles Max. altitude (service ceiling): 85,000 ft. Operating altitude: 82,000-84,000 ft. Sensor suite: Sidelooking airborne radar; Fairchild high-resolution tracking cameras (one HRB Singer camera infrared), electronic intelligence, electronic countermeasures GREGORY PROCH

7V 2]Ta ! \PM 6WZ\P >QM\VIUM[M Ă…ZML \_W ;)̆ []ZNIKM̆\W̆IQZ UQ[[QTM[ I\ ;:̆ ) 6W ! 6MQ\PMZ KZM_UIV [I_ \PM ;)5[ LM\WVI\M IJW]\ UQTM[ JMPQVL \PM []XMZ[WVQK š*TIKS̆ JQZL Âş _PW[M KZM_[ KITTML Q\ š0IJ] Âş IN\MZ \PM LMILTa XQ\ ^QXMZ QV 7SQVI_I 2IXIV 6W UQ[[QTM QV \PM _WZTL KIUM I[ KTW[M I[ \PM 6WZ\P >QM\VIUM[M ;)5 LQL \W KI\KPQVO I *TIKSJQZL <PM 4WKSPMML ;:̆ IVL Q\[ )̆ XZMLMKM[[WZ LMZQ^ML NZWU \PM +1)Âź[ ! :IQVJW_ ;\]La QVQ\QI\ML QV ZMKWOVQ\QWV WN \PM 4WKSPMML =̆ [Xa XTIVMÂź[ ^]TVMZIJQTQ\a \W ;W^QM\ ;)5[ <PM [\]La [\I\ML \PI\ I XTIVM KIXIJTM WN []Z^Q^QVO ;)5 [a[\MU[ U][\ PI^M I [UITT ZILIZ KZW[[̆[MK\QWV ][M ZILIZ̆IJ[WZX\Q^M UI\MZQIT[ WXMZI\M IJW^M NMM\ IVL Æa I\ []XMZ[WVQK [XMML[ <PW[M ZMY]QZMUMV\[ NIZ M`KMMLML \PM I^QI\QWV IVL MVOQVM \MKPVWTWOa WN \PM \QUM 7V )]O ! ! \PM +1) [MTMK\ML I 4WKSPMML LM[QOV KWVKMQ^ML Ja \PM KWUXIVaÂź[ )L^IVKML ,M^MTWXUMV\ ,MXIZ\UMV\ ISI \PM ;S]VS ?WZS[ PMILML Ja MVOQVMMZ 3MTTa 2WPV[WV >QZ\]ITTa M^MZa I[XMK\ WN \PM IQZKZIN\ PIL \W JM LM^MTWXML NZWU [KZI\KP 8ZWJTMU[ _Q\P \PM 8ZI\\ IVL ?PQ\VMa 2̆ MVOQVM[ LMTIaML \PM QVQ\QIT )̆ ÆQOP\ ]V\QT 2IV ! <PM )QZ .WZKMÂź[ \_W̆[MI\ ^MZ[QWV \PM ;:̆ Ă…Z[\ ÆM_ WV ,MK ! 1\ QVKT]LML I JIKS[MI\ ZMKWVVIQ[[IVKM [a[\MU[ WĐ…KMZ \W WXMZI\M Q\[ MTMK\ZWVQK []Z^MQTTIVKM [a[\MU[ MTMK\ZWVQK KW]V\MZUMI[]ZM[ MY]QXUMV\ JM\\MZ KIUMZI[ IVL OZW]VL̆UIXXQVO ZILIZ <PM ;:̆ JMOIV \W ZMXTIKM \PM +1)Âź[ )̆ [ I\ 3ILMVI )QZ .WZKM *I[M WV 7SQVI_I QV 5IZKP ! IVL ÆM_ Q\[ Ă…Z[\ UQ[[QWV W^MZ 6WZ\P >QM\VIU WV 5IZKP ,]ZQVO \PM VM`\ [M^MV aMIZ[ 3ILMVĬJI[ML ;:̆ [ ÆM_ UWZM \PIV UQ[[QWV[ W^MZ 6WZ\P >QM\VIU +IŬ JWLQI IVL 4IW[ 7VTa \_W _MZM TW[\ IVL \PI\ _I[ JMKI][M WN UMKPIVQKIT NIQT]ZM <PM *TIKS̆ JQZL[ XZW^QLML \PM JM[\ QUIOMZa WN \PM ;WV <Ia XZQ[WVMZ WN _IZ KIUX []XXWZ\ML *̆ ZIQL[ Ja RIUUQVO MVMUa ZILIZ IVL KWVL]K\ML [WVQK JWWU[ W^MZ \PM š0IVWQ 0QT\WVÂş 87? KIUX \W JWT[\MZ UWZITM IVL NIKQTQ\I\M \PM XZQ[WVMZ[Âź QV\MTTQOMVKM IK\Q^Q\QM[ <PM ;:̆ _Q\P ]XOZILM[ [MZ^ML \PM )QZ .WZKM NZWU ! \W !! IVL _I[ Q\[ WVTa _IZ̆ XTIVM VM^MZ \W []Đ„MZ I KWUJI\ TW[[ >QZ\]ITTa M^MZa\PQVO IJW]\ Q\ _I[ I Ă…Z[\" \PM [\MIT\P NMI\]ZM[ KWUX]\MZ̆I[[Q[\ML I^QWVQK[ QVMZ\QIT VI^QOI\QWV [a[\MU IVL MVOQVM[ <PM *TIKS̆ JQZLÂź[ TWVOM^Q\a IVL ]VMY]ITML KWUJI\ ZMKWZL UIZS[ Q\ I[ \PM \P KMV\]ZaÂź[ UW[\ IL^IVKML PQOP̆XMZNWZUIVKM IQZKZIN\ V

Videos For Vietnam Veterans SCENES FROM IN-COUNTRY BASES: Dong Ha Base & $LU¿HOG 1966-68, 50 min. Assault on Long Binh Tet 1969, 60 min. Takhli AB 1964-1970, 110 min. Bien Hoa AB 1964-69, 80 min. Some DVDs are narrat Tuy Hoa AB 1966-1968, 75 min. Phan Rang AB 1965-70, 60 min. ed, some are not. Cu Chi 1967-70, 50 min. Most are in color, some Phu Bai 1968-71, 60 min. AB 1965-1968, 60 min. are in black and white. Tan Son Nhut An Khe, 1965-67, 75 min. Long Binh 1967-72, 60 min. Each one is different! Chu Lai AB 1965-68, 75 min. Call or visit the Camp Eagle 1971, 35 min. Phu Cat AB 1966-68, 70 min. website for details. Cam Ranh Bay AB 1966-68, 70 min. Dong Tam Base 1967-1969, 45 min. Nakhon Phanom AB 1966-70, 60 min. NSA Da Nang, Camp Tien Sha 1966-71, 60 min.

Hard To Find Video Titles!

Marine Tankers In Vietnam, 60 min. Road Warriors: Truckers Vietnam, 60 min. American POWs in Vietnam, 60 min. USMC Camp Reasoner, Hill 510, 3rd MAF, 45 min. Da Nang Outer Limits: Dog Patch, Danang 500, 60 min. 1st Air Cav. Div. Battle For Ia Drang Valley, 70 min. 25th Inf. Div. Search & Destroy Missions, 45 min. 4th Infantry Division Search & Destroy Missions, 45 min. 11th Armored Cavalry, Black Horse Regiment, 80 min. Army Engineers In Vietnam, 110 min. Operation Pegasus: Khe Sanh Rescue 1968, 45 min. Andersen AFB, Guam 1965-75, 70 min. 9th Inf. Division Search & Destroy Missions, 50 min. 11th Light Infantry Brigade Vietnam, 60 min. Combat Trackers & Their Dogs 45 min. Combat Inf. Soldier: Life In Field, 60 min. Dogs of the Vietnam War: Scout, Sentry, Patrol, 100 min. 23rd Infantry Div. “Americal” In Vietnam, 80 min. NVA Easter Offensive Of 1972, 60 min. Special Forces With Montagnard Training, 100 min. Special Forces in Vietnam: Early Years, 60 min.

Navy In Vietnam Small Boat Warfare, 90 minutes USS Oriskany Fire Off Vietnam 1966, 60 min. USS Oriskany Off Coast of Vietnam, 40 min. USS Forrestal 1967 Fire Off Vietnam, 70 min. USS Forrestal (CV-59) 1950s-60s, 90 min. USS Enterprise Fire Off Hawaii, 1969, 45 min. USS Enterprise (CVAN-65) 1960-70, 90 min. USS America (CVA-66) 1965-68, 60 min. USS Midway (CVA-41) 1945-70, 60 min. USS Kitty Hawk (CV-63) 1961-79, 75 min. USS Constellation (CVA-64) 1964-70, 45 min. USS Independence (CVA-62) 1960s, 90 min. USS Princeton (CV-37) 1950s-60s, 80 min. USS Shangri-La (CV-38) 1944-1968, 45 min. USS Coral Sea (CVA-43) 1965-70, 50 min. USS Intrepid (CV-11) Off Vietnam, 60 min. USS Yorktown (CV-10) Vietnam, 45 min. USS Bon Homme Richard 1950s-60s, 45 min. USS Franklin D. Roosevelt 1960s, 85 min. USS Repose & Corpsmen, 60 min. USS Ticonderoga, 60 min. Coast Guard in Vietnam, 60 min. LST Operations in Vietnam, 40 min.

Newer Releases 101st Airborne Div: Search/Destroy Missions, 50 min. 173rd Airborne Div: Search/Destroy Missions, 55 min. Bangkok, Thailand R&R In The 1960s, 50 min. National Route 9, A Journey along Route 9 near the DMZ., 60 min. “Rocket City”: Attacks On Da Nang AB, 70 min. 1st Aviation Brigade In Vietnam, 60 min. Op. Pershing, 1st Air Cav., May 1967, 60 min. Destroyers In The Vietnam War, 65 min. 3rd Brigade 82nd Airborne In Vietnam, 60 min. 5th Special Forces Group Vietnam, 55 min. African Americans In Vietnam, 60 min. Op. MacArthur, 4th Inf. Div. in the Battle Of Dak To 1967, 60 min. 1st Air Cavalry, 1965-1967, 60 min. Southern Man: The Road To Vietnam Training at Forts Jackson, Campbell, & Gordon in the 1960s, 70 min.

Marines In Vietnam Marines 1965/ Ops Starlite/Harvest Moon, 90 min. Marines 1966, Ops Macon/Hastings/Prairie, 70 min. Marines 1967 with Op Independence, 90 min. Marines 1968, Op. Baxter Gardens, 80 min. San Diego Boot Camp ‘69 & 73, 45 min. Parris Island Boot Camp 1960s, 45 min. Marine Staging Battalion, Camp Pendleton, 30 min. Khe Sanh Base with 1st Marines, 45 min. Con Thien & Op. Buffalo, 60 min. Battle for Hue City, 45 min. Marine Aviation: 1st MAW, 90 min. Siege Khe Sanh & USAF, 45 min.

Sammy Davis Jr. Tour of Vietnam

Were you at Long Binh, Can Tho, FS Base or 101st Airborne A Shau Valley 1969-71, 60 min. Aboard USS Hancock 101st Airborne Div. In Vietnam, 90 min. A r m y 5th Infantry Div. Vietnam 1968-70, 45 min. when he toured in 1972? 1st Inf. Div: Vietnam & Germany, 102 min. In See it all again in the 196th Light Infantry Brigade, 52 min. Vietnam 198th Light Infantry Brigade, 60 min. original documentary plus 173rd Airborne Battle for Dak To, 50 min. outtakes and photos! Military Police (MPs) Vietnam, 70 min. 9th Infantry Division In Vietnam, 60 min. 7KLV '9' EULQJV EDFN WKH ÀOP Huey UH-1: Training to Vietnam, 115 min. that never saw wide release Army Helicopter Units Vietnam, 90 min. and faded into obscurity 1st Div. Search/Destroy Missions, 60 min. 173rd Airborne Brigade in Vietnam, 60 min. plus you’ll experience Army Artillerymen in Vietnam: Fire a behind-the-scenes Support & Fire Support Bases, 80 min. Army Basic at Fort Ord & Advanced perspective from a combat Training 1960s, 90 minutes cameraman who accompanied 199th Light Inf. Bde 1967-70, 60 min. Sammy from Los Angeles to Questions? Call Us Because All Sales Are Final Vietnam to Hawaii. First DVD 29.95 60 Min. Color.

$

Air Force In Vietnam

F-4 Phantom In Combat, 60 min. B-57 Canberra at Phan Rang, Bien Hoa, Danang, 60 min. C-130 Operations In Vietnam, 81 min. C-7 Caribou In Vietnam, 70 min. Jolly & Super Jolly Green Giants, 85 min. Tactical Air Recon With RF-4, RF-101, 90 min.

Camp Evans & Op. Delaware 1968, 60 min. Nha Trang/Camp McDermott 1965-69, 60 min. U-Tapao, Thailand 1967-72, 60 min. Korat AB, Thailand 1965-1970, 70 min. Camp Carroll & Rock Pile 1967-1970, 30 min. Binh Thuy Naval Base 1968-69, 50 min. Lai Khe, Di An & Phu Loi 1966-1970, 80 min. Da Nang AB/USMC 1965-1970, 100 min. Camp Enari (Dragon Mtn) 1968-1969, 30 min. Ubon & Udorn, Thailand 1966-69, 60 min. Dau Tieng Base & $LU¿HOG 1965-70, 45 min.

Tet: Attack on Tan Son Nhut AB, 60 min. C-47, EC-47 & AC-47 Vietnam, 80 min. Close Air Support & Forward Air Controllers, 100 min. F-105 Wild Weasel at Korat AB 1966, 20 min. F-105 Thunderchief In Combat, 75 min. AC-119 Gunships, 100 min.

Additional DVDs In The Same Order Are $19.95 FREE SHIPPING USA $15 International Call

ea.

1-760-765-1283 With Credit Card Send Check/MO To:

Traditions Military Videos Dept V PO Box 656 Julian CA 92036

Perfect Choice HD™ is simple to use, hard to see and easy to afford…

Invention of the Year PERSONAL SOUND AMPLIFICATION PRODUCTS (PSAPs)

THEY’RE NOT HEARING AIDS

NEW Now with more power and clarity!

Now you see it... Now you don’t

Perfect Choice HD is NOT a hearing aid. It is a Personal Sound Amplification Product (PSAP). Hearing aids can only be sold by an audiologist or a licensed hearing instrument specialist following hearing tests and fitting appointments. Once the audiologist had you tested and fitted, you would have to pay as much as $5000 for the product. Personal Sound Amplification Products use advanced digital processing to amplify the frequencies of human speech. Thanks to the efforts of a doctor who leads a renowned hearing institute, this product is manufactured in an efficient production process that enables us to make it available at an affordable price.

only you’ll know you have it on. It’s comfortable and won’t make you feel like you have something stuck in your ear. It provides high quality audio so soft sounds and distant conversations will be easier to understand. Try it for yourself with our exclusive home trial. Some people need hearing aids but many just want the extra boost in volume that a PSAP gives them. We want you to be happy with Perfect Choice HD, so we are offering to let you try it for yourself. Call now, and you’ll find out why so many satisfied seniors are now enjoying their Perfect Choice HD, hearing their grandchildren and what the world has to say. Call today!

The unit is small and lightweight enough to hide behind your ear...

SOUND QUALITY

Less than 1 ounce Excellent: Optimized for speech

FITTING REQUIRED?

No

ONE-ON-ONE SETUP

Free

RETURN POLICY COLOR

Full refund of product purchase price within 60 days Beige, Brown or Silver

Please mention promotional code

103512.

1-877-726-7525 1998 Ruffin Mill Road, Colonial Heights, VA 23834 Perfect Choice HD is not a hearing aid. If you believe you need a hearing aid, please consult a physician.

81078

WEIGHT

Call now toll free for our lowest price.

A bad war for presidents Antiwar protesters rally outside the White House on May 9, 1970, during Richard Nixon’s presidency.

DAVID FENTON/GETTY IMAGES

A War That Didn’t Produce a President

The United States will shortly be electing a new president. No one knows for certain who that will be, but we can be fairly sure— from the list of top contenders—that the winner won’t be a Vietnam veteran. At least one combat veteran from almost every other major war in American history ended up in the White House. What’s more, most U.S. wars also propelled a top general \W \PM VI\QWV¼[ PQOPM[\ WЅKM The Revolutionary War: As we all know, it made General George Washington famous IVL PMTXML PQU JMKWUM \PM ÅZ[\ XZM[QLMV\ +WV\QVMV\IT )ZUa WЅKMZ 2IUM[ 5WVZWM JMKIUM \PM ÅN\P XZM[QLMV\ <PWUI[ 2MЄMZ[WV IVL 2IUM[ 5ILQ[WV [MZ^ML QV \PM >QZOQVQI militia, where they performed administra\Q^M L]\QM[ IVL _MZMV¼\ QV \PM ÅOP\QVO War of 1812: Generals William Henry HarZQ[WV IVL )VLZM_ 2IKS[WV )T[W BIKPIZa <IaTWZ 2WPV <aTMZ IVL 2IUM[ *]KPIVIV 5M`QKIV ?IZ" /MVMZIT[ BIKPIZa <IaTWZ and Franklin Pierce. Also Ulysses S. Grant. Civil War: General Grant, of course, but IT[W /MVMZIT[ :]\PMZNWZL * 0IaM[ 2IUM[ /IZÅMTL IVL *MVRIUQV 0IZZQ[WV /MVMZIT Chester A. Arthur had administrative du\QM[ WЄ \PM JI\\TMÅMTL IVL /MVMZIT )VLZM_ 2WPV[WV _I[ UQTQ\IZa OW^MZVWZ WN <MVVM[[MM ?QTTQIU 5K3QVTMa IT[W _I[ QV \PQ[ _IZ Spanish-American War: Rough Rider Theodore Roosevelt.

World War I: Harry S. Truman and Dwight , -Q[MVPW_MZ _PW [MZ^ML [\I\M[QLM IOIQV[\ PQ[ _Q[PM[ ?WZTL ?IZ 11" /MVMZIT -Q[MVPW_MZ 2WPV . 3MVVMLa 4aVLWV * 2WPV[WV :QKPIZL 6Q`WV IVL /MWZOM 0 ? *][P :WVITL :MIOIV [MZ^ML [\I\M[QLM JMKI][M WN XWWZ MaM[QOP\ 6W XZM[QLMV\[ _MZM 3WZMIV ?IZ ^M\MZIV[ J]\ NIZ NM_MZ \ZWWX[ XW\MV\QIT XZM[QLMV\[ [MZ^ML QV \PI\ KWVÆQK\ \PIV NW]OP\ QV ;W]\Peast Asia during the Vietnam War, about 1.8 million compared with almost 3.4 million. Among Vietnam combat veterans, DemWKZI\ 2WPV 3MZZa QV IVL :MX]JTQKIV 2WPV 5K+IQV QV MIKP VIJJML PQ[ party’s nomination but lost in the general MTMK\QWV 8ZM[QLMV\ /MWZOM ? *][P [MZ^ML [\I\M[QLM QV \PM <M`I[ )QZ 6I\QWVIT /]IZL General Colin Powell, who fought in VietVIU I[ I aW]VO WЅKMZ PI[ WN\MV JMMV UMVtioned as someone who might have run and won. In an interview with Vietnam, Powell M`XTIQV[ _Pa PM PI[ KWV[Q[\MV\Ta ZMN][ML those entreaties. And he gave his thoughts on why no other Vietnam combat veteran has been elected president. We also asked: Could the United States have won the war? Could South Vietnam’s forces have succeeded after the American withdrawal if U.S. funds had not been cut off? What are the lessons of the war? Powell’s answers to these and many more questions begin on pg. 22. —Chuck Springston AUGUST 2016

21

Colin Powell’s Vietnam And the Making of an American Statesman

The young captain Colin Powell leans against his hooch in the A Shau Valley in 1963 wearing his ¸ZOV^VɈ¹ \UPMVYT 6U WH[YVS [OL UHTL tag and silver bars were gone, and the grenade was carried TVYL JHYLM\SS`

22

VIETNAM

UNLESS OTHERWISE NOTED, ALL IMAGES COURTESY COLIN L. POWELL

M

any Vietnam veterans had their lives and careers shaped by military, political and diplomatic actions during the war, but Colin Powell is the only one who helped shape military, political and diplomatic actions at the highest levels after the war. 0M [MZ^ML QV \PM WЅKM WN ,MNMV[M ;MKZM\IZa 0IZWTL Brown during Jimmy Carter’s administration and in \PM WЅKM WN :WVITL :MIOIVŸ[ LMNMV[M [MKZM\IZa +I[XIZ ?MQVJMZOMZ :MIOIV UILM 8W_MTT PQ[ VI\QWVIT [MK]rity adviser in 1987. Two years later George H.W. Bush IXXWQV\ML PQU KPIQZUIV WN \PM 2WQV\ +PQMN[ WN ;\IЄ I position he continued to hold in Bill Clinton’s presidency until October 1993. He culminated his government career as George W. Bush’s secretary of state from January 2001 to January 2005. 8W_MTT I +Q\a +WTTMOM WN 6M_ AWZS :7<+ OZIL]I\M KWUmissioned a second lieutenant in June 1958, served in >QM\VIU I[ I KIX\IQV IL^Q[QVO ;W]\P >QM\VIUM[M ]VQ\[ NZWU ,MKMUJMZ ! \PZW]OP 6W^MUJMZ ! IVL I[ I UIRWZ QV \PM ZL 1VNIV\Za ,Q^Q[QWV )UMZQKIT NZWU 2]VM ! \PZW]OP 2]Ta ! ! )N\MZ ZM\]ZVQVO \W \PM =VQ\ML ;\I\M[ PM MIZVML IV 5*) NZWU /MWZOM ?I[PQVO\WV =VQ^MZ[Q\a QV ! IVL was selected for the White House Fellows program, which enabled him to spend a year working in PresiLMV\ :QKPIZL 6Q`WVŸ[ 7ЅKM WN 5IVIOMUMV\ IVL *]LOM\ His rise up the ranks included positions as a battalion commander in Korea, a brigade commander in the 101st )QZJWZVM ,Q^Q[QWV IVL KWUUIVLQVO OMVMZIT WN > +WZX[ QV /MZUIVa 1V )XZQT ! ! 8W_MTT _I[ XZWUW\ML \W four-star general and that October became Joint Chiefs KPIQZUIV VW\ WVTa \PM ÅZ[\ )NZQKIV̆)UMZQKIV QV \PI\ XW[Q\QWV J]\ IT[W \PM aW]VOM[\ WЅKMZ IOM IVL ÅZ[\ :7<+ OZIL]I\M 0M W^MZ[I_ \PM ,MKMUJMZ ! ! QV\MZ^MV\QWV QV 8IVama to oust dictator Manuel Noriega, who refused to relinquish power after democratic elections and had been KPIZOML _Q\P LZ]O \ZIЅKSQVO *]\ 8W_MTTŸ[ ZMIT ZQ[M \W fame occurred during the 1991 Gulf War’s Operation ,M[MZ\ ;\WZU TI]VKPML IN\MZ ;ILLIU 0][[MQVŸ[ 1ZIYQ forces invaded neighboring Kuwait. Powell’s tenure as secretary of state was marked by [WUM WN \PM UW[\ \]U]T\]W][ M^MV\[ QV ZMKMV\ )UMZQKIV PQ[\WZa" \PM ;MX\ \MZZWZQ[\ I\\IKS[ \PM QV^I[QWV WN )NOPIVQ[\IV QV 7K\WJMZ IVL \PM QV^I[QWV WN Iraq in March 2003. 8W_MTT \ITSML IJW]\ PQ[ M`XMZQMVKM[ QV >QM\VIU TQVgering controversies of the war, the lessons he drew from it and why he never ran for president in an interview with Vietnam -LQ\WZ +P]KS ;XZQVO[\WV

In your memoir, My American Journey, you recall a conversation with South Vietnamese Captain Vo Cong Hieu at a base in the A Shau Valley during your ďŹ rst assignment in the ďŹ eld. He said something that would come to sum up the war in your mind. I got out of the helicopter, looked around and saw that the base was against the side of a mountain, and the other side of the mountain was Laos. There we were, in a huge tripleKIVWXa NWZM[\ )VL TWOQK [Ia[ ?Pa Q[ \PQ[ JI[M PMZM' ?PI\ [\ZI\MOQK X]ZXW[M Q[ Q\ [MZ^QVO' <PI\ [\ZI\MOQK X]ZXW[M I[ M`XTIQVML \W UM Ja +IX\IQV 0QM] _I[ š1\Âź[ PMZM \W XZW\MK\ \PM IQZĂ…MTL Âş ?MTT _PI\Âź[ \PM IQZĂ…MTL PMZM NWZ' š<W ZM[]XXTa \PM JI[M Âş 1\ [\Z]KS UM I ̆aMIZ̆WTL QVNIV\Za KIX\IQV I[ š?MÂźZM PMZM JMKI][M _MÂźZM PMZM Âş 6W_ \PI\ _I[ I JQ\ ]VNIQZ <PM IQZĂ…MTL ITTW_ML aW] \W PI^M W\PMZ WXMZI\QWV[ OWQVO WV and it established a presence in the valley. Even so, “We’re here because we’re hereâ€? was a metaphor for the war? We kept adding troops, we kept addQVO JWUJMZ[ _M SMX\ ILLQVO Ă…OP\MZ XTIVM[ <PMZM _MZM 3,000 advisers when I got there, and my contingent brought it up to well over 11,000. But it wasn’t enough. We kept adding, adding, adding, and we deceived ourselves into thinking we were making more progress than we actually were. 1\ Ă…VITTa KIUM \W I PIT\ _PMV /MVMZIT C?QTTQIUE ?M[\moreland asked for yet another large tranche of soldiers, IVL 4aVLWV 2WPV[WV [IQL š<PI\Âź[ Q\ 6W UWZM Âş ?M PIL \PMZM \PMV C ! E It had become a much broader war, not just sandalclad Viet Cong guys running around. The North VietVIUM[M )ZUa PIL KWUM QV 6W UI\\MZ _PI\ _M LQL _M could not stop them from coming down the Ho Chi Minh Trail. We could not stop them from re-equipping or resupplying their forces. ?M SMX\ PWXQVO _M KW]TL LZI_ \PMU W]\ QV\W Ă…`ML JI\tle, where they could be defeated. But they had a better strategy than we did. They picked their place and time. <PMa KIUM W]\ L]ZQVO \PM <M\ 7Đ„MV[Q^M CI\ \PM MVL WN 2IV]IZa ! E IVL KI][ML I TW\ WN LIUIOM <PMa TW[\ huge numbers, but they understood it wasn’t a military operation. It was a political operation. They were not IQUQVO \W SQTT )UMZQKIV[ <PMa _MZM IQUQVO \W SQTT \PM )UMZQKIV [XQZQ\ )VL \PMa []KKMMLML You and the other advisers in the early years were sent to Vietnam by Presidents Dwight Eisenhower and John Kennedy. Did Eisenhower and Kennedy make a mistake in starting the movement of U.S. troops to Vietnam? 6W 1\ [\IZ\ML W]\ I[ I ZMÆMK\QWV WN \PM +WTL ?IZ _Q\P \PM ;W^QM\ =VQWV IVL +PQVI IVL W]Z LM[QZM \W help this small country defend itself against insurgency IVL I NWZMQOV QV^I[QWV CNZWU 6WZ\P >QM\VIUE ?PMV 1 AUGUST 2016

23

went over there in 1962, I felt I was doing something []ЄMZQVO NZWU \PM 6>) IVL \PM >+ And what would we have done? Occupy the whole noble, and that’s what President Kennedy thought when country with a million American soldiers and keep them he was sending us over. The original mission was to advise the South Viet- there? Remember, we were not invading Vietnam. We namese on how to defend themselves. Time passes, and _MZM ÅOP\QVO I >QM\VIUM[M _IZ QV ;W]\P >QM\VIU <PMZM you have the Gulf of Tonkin incident [in August 1964, was a border, the 17th parallel. So they [the North Vietwhen North Vietnamese torpedo boats attacked a U.S. VIUM[M )ZUa IVL >QM\ +WVOE PIL I [IVK\]IZa <PMa destroyer]. Lyndon Johnson is the one who made the kept pouring in support, pouring in troops, taking masfateful decision to add more. Then you have the Marines sive casualties, but kept coming. And we were not seriand the Army starting to come in 1965. But I can’t put ously bombing them in a way that hurts. 1 TW^M IQZ XW_MZ 1 ][ML IQZ XW_MZ QV M^MZa KWVÆQK\ 1 that onto Eisenhower or Kennedy. Eisenhower wouldn’t help the French [who controlled have been seriously involved in. But I’m also an infanVietnam in the 1950s and wanted the U.S. military to \Za WЅKMZ 1N aW] KIV¼\ PWTL IVL KWV\ZWT \PM OZW]VL aW] RWQV I ÅOP\ IOIQV[\ >QM\VIUM[M [MMSQVO QVLMXMVLMVKME PI^MV¼\ _WV 8TIVM[ Æa JIKS \W \PMQZ JI[M[ ;PQX[ IZM I\ when he was asked. He was very careful about getting sea. If you want to really win a war, you’ve got to have into foreign entanglements. There has been speculation I O]a _Q\P I ZQÆM In World War II we bombed Germany into total destructhat if Kennedy had lived, he would not have continued. tion, but it wasn’t until the Russian army entered Berlin I don’t know what he would have done. As I ended my year as an adviser in ’63, I realized and we met the Russians at the Elbe that the war was brought to a conclusion. In Japan, we sent an we had been stomping around in the forest army to take control after the destruction of and chasing people who were not catchable. I love air power. Hiroshima and Nagasaki. We were starting to do things we thought I used air would help us, such as destroying crops. We After we left in 1973, could the South were walking through planted areas with power in every Vietnamese have prevailed against the chemical sprayers, spraying manioc plants KWVÆQK\ 1 PI^M North’s invasion if the United States had and rice plants. Then we started burning been seriously continued to fund them? That’s the view hooches. I thought, the hooches can be reinvolved in. of a lot of Vietnam veterans—that it was built in a day, and this will be replanted. So \PM +WVOZM[[ _PW TW[\ \PQ[ _IZ 1 KIV¼\ J]a where is this all going? But I’m also an By the time I left in 1969, after my second QVNIV\Za WЅKMZ into that. By that point, it didn’t make any LQЄMZMVKM _PM\PMZ _M KW]TL PI^M C_WVE JMtour, it was clear that we had gotten into a If you can’t hold cause the American people had made a deciwar we didn’t fully understand. It was not a and control the sion. We are a people’s army. And the losses war of communism vs. capitalism or totalwere hundreds a week. I do not think that itarianism vs. democracy. It was a war of ground, you \PM )UMZQKIV XMWXTM PIL \PM _QTT \W ÅOP\ nationalism. The North Vietnamese were haven’t won. the kind of war that the North Vietnamese determined to reunite Vietnam into one 8TIVM[ Æa JIKS _MZM OWQVO \W ÅOP\ country. You have to remember what was going on to their bases. Do you think we could have beat the Ships are at sea. in the country at the time. I arrived home CNZWU \PM ÅZ[\ \W]ZE \PM LIa 3MVVMLa _I[ North Vietnamese and won the war? They If you want to SQTTML IVL \PMV Å^M aMIZ[ TI\MZ PQ[ JZW\PMZ were prepared to put every life at risk. They really win a war, was killed. Martin Luther King was killed were truly willing to lose whatever it took April 4, 1968. The country was really comto win. I remember seeing a statistic that you’ve got to ing apart. We had racial problems. The vice said their birth rate is higher than any kill have a guy with president resigned in disgrace and then the rate we can impose upon them. This will go I ZQÆM president got caught in Watergate and he on forever. And they were going to be susresigned in disgrace. There was still a Sotained by outside powers. ^QM\ =VQWV <PMZM _I[ [\QTT I 8MWXTM¼[ :MX]JTQK WN +PQVI¸ During World War II, the objective was to take ter- UIaJM 6Q`WV PIL JMMV \PMZM J]\ Q\ _I[V¼\ aM\ \PM +PQVI rain and hold it until the enemy surrendered. In Viet- it is today. We had a recession. The counterculture was nam, it was search and destroy, kill large numbers of sweeping across the country. We had to do something. the enemy in an area, then pull back. Could U.S. forces And one of the things we had to do was get out of the war. have applied the take-and-hold approach to get a clear So what do we as a country say to the families of victory? My own view was—notwithstanding what many of my fellow veterans have said—that we could not have those who died there? What did they die for? Did they done that. We were never prepared to put in what would die in vain? They served their country. And when the have been required. We also were supporting a regime country called on them, or conscripted them, they didn’t that had lost some of its legitimacy. We had coup after shrink from it. You should be proud of the fact that your coup. It wasn’t a government that had the support of the loved one answered the call. We regret all of the losses, all of the 58,000. I lost XMWXTM IVa TWVOMZ 8MWXTM _MZM []ЄMZQVO MKWVWUQKITTa 24

VIETNAM

Helo down Major Powell looks at circling helicopters after the November 1968 crash landing of a copter that carried him, Maj. Gen. Charles Gettys, commander of the Americal Division, and others. Powell pulled a barely conscious Gettys from the wreckage. All of the men survived. Bottom, Powell receives the Soldier’s Medal for heroism from Gettys.

Little troopers Powell and South Vietnamese Captain Vo Cong Hieu visit children from a Montagnard tribe at an A Shau Valley base in 1963.

three of my CCNY classmates, including one of my dearest friends, Tony Mavroudis. But \PI\¼[ _IZ 1\ _I[ \PM ÅZ[\ WVM we ever lost like that. It was a biggie. But we came out of it. America is a country of enormous resilience. What are the lessons of the Vietnam War? The major lesson I used as chairman, national security adviser and secretary of state was to advise leaders: Make sure you ]VLMZ[\IVL _PI\ aW]¼ZM OM\\QVO QV\W ,WV¼\ ÅOP\ I _IZ with somebody who has a greater investment in it and a greater cause than ours. That’s manifested itself in other things I have said over the years, such as “You break it, you own it.” The second lesson is once you decide something is worth it and you’re prepared to invest military force, QV ILLQ\QWV \W XWTQ\QKIT IVL LQXTWUI\QK MЄWZ\[ UISM []ZM you don’t just send a few advisers and think that will work. This has become known as the Powell Doctrine, but it really is classical military doctrine. If you look at the basic principles of war, the two captured in my thinking are objectives and mass. First, what is the objective? What are we trying to do? Have we analyzed the enemy, the terrain, the weather and all the other aspects of the situation? An objective should have a political basis to it. Why are we doing this politically? Not just can we do it militarily. And once you’ve got the objective, the other part is mass. What I call decisive force. People are forever calling it Powell’s “overwhelming” force doctrine. I used that word once, and I realized it was a bad word. Never

used it again. “Decisive” means make sure you put enough in so that you will prevail, will have a decisive outcome. Desert Storm is a perfect example. Panama is an even better example. When Manuel Noriega killed one of our people [a Marine stationed in Panama] and assaulted some others, we had a plan ready. We’ve got 13,000 stationed there already, and let’s send another 13,000 in. We have a [Panamanian] president in waiting, hiding under a bed. He’s been elected, so once we take the country over, we’ve got a guy to swear in that same day. We got rid of the Panamanian army, but we brought it right back, reconstituted it, which is what we did not do in Iraq many years later, to my distress. We didn’t take charge of Iraq. We disbanded the army, which was a huge strategic error, compared to what we did in Panama, where we rebuilt it as fast as we took it apart, which was what we were supposed to do in Iraq. But that was not the decision made in the Pentagon. We did not secure the country. And it goes south for four years until President Bush orders a surge, but the surge should have come at the beginning, not in the end. And [W _M¼ZM [\QTT QV \PQ[ KWVÆQK\ 1ZIY¼[ VW\ aM\ I []KKM[[ QV my judgment. Should a corrupt dictatorial leadership, like South Vietnam’s, deter us from joining forces with a country even though we have a common enemy? It should deter us, but deter doesn’t mean stop. It means there is a yellow blinking light, and we ought to be very, very careAUGUST 2016

25

On patrol Powell poses in the A Shau Valley, where he was an adviser to a South Vietnamese battalion.

At the White House Powell meets Richard Nixon in the fall of 1972 after being selected as a White House Fellow.

In charge As chairman of the Joint *OPLMZ VM :[HɈ Powell oversaw Operation Desert Storm in 1991.

After the Vietnam War, how did you and the other young career officers size up the condition of the U.S. Army and determine any changes that needed to be made? The advisers who went in were very professional. The Army and Marine Corps troops that started deploying in ’65 were very professional. They had good leadership. But over the next several years, we started to lose a lot of people and were rotating a lot of people with one-year tours and six-month command tours. The quality of the force deteriorated. We started to have drug problems. There were some fragging problems, not as many as people suggested, but I used to be careful in my own hooch, move my bed around because there was the potential to be fragged by your own troops. The young soldiers coming in ref lected the society they were coming from. Support for the war was dropping. Racial tension was rising. Conscription was seen as a problem. When I was in Korea as a battalion commander, we were at the beginning of the all-volunteer force. It hadn’t been funded adequately, so the youngsters we were getting tended to be not high school graduates. Judges had said to some: Go to the Army or go to jail. A high percentage did not speak English. The challenge was immense, but it was the most rewarding year I’ve ever had—getting these kids in shape. I told them,“If you do drugs, I’m going to throw you out.” Every morning I got up with them, and we ran 4 miles and got them tired. And we kept them tired all day long, so when night fell they were too tired to get into too much trouble. We constantly had competitions. Best clerk, best mess hall, best anything, to make sure that every youngster who had never been successful in high school

had a chance to win. Some of my WЅKMZ[ PIL _Q^M[ _PW KIUM QV \W teach these kids, get them GEDs, send them home better than we got them. A couple of years later I was a brigade commander in the 101st, in ’76 to ’77. By then you could see the quality improve because we were taking 95-98 percent high school graduates. The real end to this period and the beginning of a new era was Ronald Reagan. He and my boss, Cap Weinberger, put tons of money into the military and restored pride. And from then on it’s been a fabulous force. What was your favorite music from the 1960s and ’70s? In the ’60s I was pretty much in the forest, but Marty Robbins’ “El Paso” was one of my favorites. I knew Elvis Presley. I liked his music. I really remember the songs of the early ’70s because I was in Korea NZMMbQVO Ua J]\\ WЄ QV \PQ[ UM\IT hut that I lived in. AFN [American Forces Network] would come on in the morning and play “Rock the boat, don’t rock the boat baby,” by the Hues Corporation. Also Fifth Dimension songs, and there was “Hotel California” [by the Eagles]. That era was noted for some unusual clothing styles. What did you wear when you were off duty? I could not keep up with the troops. They were wearing bell-bottoms. And the black troops had some sharp clothes that you wouldn’t believe. Go look at some of those old Super Fly movies, and you’ll see what they wore. There’s a picture of me shaking hands with President Nixon, and you’ll see my hair is a lot longer. I had something of a fro, but not a full fro, and I was wearing a hideous double-knit suit. Which political or military leaders do you admire most? Lincoln was a remarkable political and military leader. And Washington, who lost over and over but learned as he lost and became a brilliant strategist. Eisenhower

MIDDLE: PHOTO BY OLLIE ATKINS/WHITE HOUSE/THE LIFE PICTURE COLLECTION/GETTY IMAGES; BOTTOM: AP PHOTO

ful about getting deeply involved in these places. But sometimes the politics and the strategic situation require you to do so.

was not noted as a great tactician in his MIZTa aMIZ[ J]\ PM _I[ I OZMI\ [\IЄ WЅKMZ and a great strategist. He went from colonel to four stars in three years and got command of Europe. One person I should mention is George Marshall. Roosevelt had to decide who was going to go to Europe to lead the invasion. Marshall badly wanted it, and Roosevelt gave it to Eisenhower, who had been a juVQWZ WЅKMZ ]VLMZ 5IZ[PITT :WW[M^MT\ [IQL “George, I could not sleep well at night if you were not here.” And Marshall said, “Yes, sir.” And that was the end of it. “Yes, [QZ º 0M _I[ \PI\ SQVL WN [MTÆM[[ TMILMZ \PI\ I have always admired. In almost every major war in American history, someone who served in it became president. How come one of the longest wars, Vietnam, never produced a president? We didn’t win. None of the generals emerged from Vietnam with political reputations. Do you ever regret not having run for president? No. I found other ways to serve our nation and my fellow citizens. V

Colin Powell Born: April 5, 1937, New York City Residence: McLean, Va. Education: City College of New York, bachelor’s degree in geology; U.S. Army Command and :[HɈ *VSSLNL -VY[ 3LH]enworth, Kan.; MBA, George Washington <UP]LYZP[`" 5H[PVUHS >HY *VSSLNL -VY[ 4J5HPY Washington, D.C. Military service: June 1958-September 1993, assignments included: ࠮ 7SH[VVU SLHKLY *VTpany B, 2nd Armored 9PÅL )H[[HSPVU [O Infantry Regiment, Germany ࠮ ,_LJ\[P]L VɉJLY HUK commander, Company + UK (YTVYLK 9PÅL )H[[HSPVU [O 0UMHU[Y` Regiment, Germany ࠮ *VTTHUKLY *VT pany A, 1st Battle .YV\W [O 0UMHU[Y`

Regiment, 2nd Infantry Brigade, 5th Infantry +P]PZPVU 4LJOHUPaLK -VY[ +L]LUZ 4HZZ ࠮ (K]PZLY Z[ (9=5 (YT` VM [OL 9LW\ISPJ VM =PL[UHT 0UMHU[Y` +P]Psion, Military Assistance (K]PZVY` .YV\W =PL[UHT ࠮ 0UZ[Y\J[VY < : (YT` 0UMHU[Y` :JOVVS -VY[ Benning, Ga. ࠮ ,_LJ\[P]L VɉJLY YK Battalion, 1st Infantry Regiment, 11th Infantry Brigade, 23rd Infantry +P]PZPVU (TLYPJHS Vietnam ࠮ +P]PZPVU . VWLYH[PVUZ Z[HɈ VɉJLY YK 0UMHU[Y` +P]PZPVU (TLYPJHS =PL[UHT ࠮ 6WLYH[PVUZ YLZLHYJO HUHS`Z[ 6ɉJL VM [OL Assistant Vice Chief of :[HɈ >HZOPUN[VU ࠮ *VTTHUKLY Z[ Battalion, 32nd Infantry Regiment, 2nd Infantry

+P]PZPVU ,PNO[O < : Army, Korea ࠮ 6WLYH[PVUZ YLZLHYJO systems analyst, 6ɉJL VM [OL (ZZPZ[HU[ Secretary of Defense 4HUWV^LY HUK 9LZLY]L (ɈHPYZ >HZOPUN[VU B.LYHSK -VYK WYLZPKLU[" James Schlesinger, defense secretary] ࠮ *VTTHUKLY UK Brigade, 101st Airborne +P]PZPVU (PY (ZZH\S[ -VY[ Campbell, Ky. ࠮ :LUPVY TPSP[HY` HZZPZ[HU[ to the deputy secretary of defense, Washington [Jimmy Carter, president; Harold Brown, defense secretary] ࠮ (ZZPZ[HU[ KP]PZPVU JVTTHUKLY [O 0UMHU[Y` +P]PZPVU 4LJOHUPaLK -VY[ *HYZVU *VSV ࠮ +LW\[` JVTTHUKPUN general, U.S. Army Combined Arms Combat +L]LSVWTLU[ (J[P]P[`

-VY[ 3LH]LU^VY[O ࠮ 4PSP[HY` HZZPZ[HU[ [V [OL secretary of defense, Washington, [Ronald Reagan, president; Caspar Weinberger, defense secretary] ࠮ *VTTHUKPUN NLULYHS V Corps, Germany ࠮ (ZZPZ[HU[ [V [OL WYLZPdent for national security HɈHPYZ UH[PVUHS ZLJ\YP[` HK]PZLY B9LHNHUD ࠮ *VTTHUKLY PU JOPLM -VYJLZ *VTTHUK -VY[ 4J7OLYZVU .H ࠮ *OHPYTHU 1VPU[ *OPLMZ VM :[HɈ >HZOPUN[VU [George H.W. Bush, Bill Clinton, presidents] Civilian government service: secretary of state, January 2001January 2005 [George W. Bush, president] Today: *\YYLU[ HJ[P]P[PLZ include: ࠮ *OHPY IVHYK VM ]PZP[VYZ *VSPU 7V^LSS :JOVVS MVY

*P]PJ HUK .SVIHS Leadership, City College of New York ࠮ -V\UKLY HUK JOHPYTHU emeritus, America’s 7YVTPZL (SSPHUJL H NYV\W VM VYNHUPaH[PVUZ with programs to help youths graduate from high school and succeed in life ࠮ )VHYK VM KPYLJ[VYZ *V\UJPS VU -VYLPNU Relations ࠮ )VHYK TLTILY Smithsonian Institution’s African American Museum of History and Culture ࠮ *OHPYTHU ,PZLUOV^LY -LSSV^ZOPWZ HU international program for emerging leaders in ]HYPV\Z ÄLSKZ ࠮ (K]PZVY` HUK IVHYK WVZP[PVUZ ^P[O ]LU[\YL JHWP[HS ÄYT 2SLPULY 7LYRPUZ *H\ÄLSK )`LYZ HUK )SVVT ,ULYN`

AUGUST 2016

27

Bombs away Air Force F-105D ;O\UKLYJOPLMZ Ã…`PUN ^P[O H ) +LZ[YV`LY center, drop their loads VU 5VY[O =PL[UHT K\YPUN a raid on June 14,1966. Inset: Thunderchiefs strike North Vietnamese [HYNL[Z PU -LIY\HY`

28

VIETNAM

SKY WARS Starting from scratch, North Vietnam created the world’s strongest air defense system, forcing U.S. air power to rise to the challenge

USAF PHOTO; INSET: AP PHOTO/DOD

By Carl O. Schuster

AUGUST 2016

29

O

n March 2, 1965, 250 U.S. and South Vietnamese aircraft struck two enemy targets near the town of Dong Hoi, just north of the Demilitarized Zone. Operation Rolling Thunder had begun. The U.S. Air Force attacked one of the targets, Xom Bang Ammunition Depot, with 160 aircraft. Five were shot down; four others were damaged. The South Vietnamese air force planes struck the more lightly defended Quang Khe Naval Base with 90 planes. Two were damaged. President Lyndon B. Johnson had ordered the U.S. military on Feb. 24, 1965, to launch the attacks even though assessments by the CIA, Defense Intelligence Agency and State Department’s Intelligence Bureau indicated that bombing alone would not break Hanoi’s will. Unfortunately for Johnson and his advisers, the intelligence analysis turned out to be correct. North Vietnamese Communist Party leader Le Duan, who consolidated his hold on power in December 1963 by pushing aside Ho Chi Minh and other party officials, was committed to unifying Vietnam rapidly. He placed the military on a wartime footing in July 1964 and sought Chinese and Soviet military assistance. Le Duan received virtually everything he requested. Some IQL PIL ITZMILa IZZQ^ML QV MIZTa ! )UMZQKIŸ[ ÅZ[\ airstrikes took place on Aug. 5, 1964, as the Johnson

30

VIETNAM

administration retaliated for an August 2 torpedo boat attack on a U.S. destroyer in the Gulf of Tonkin. Within days, North Vietnam’s allies began sending advisers, \MKPVQKQIV[ IVL UQTQ\IZa MY]QXUMV\ \W ÅTT 0IVWQŸ[ IQZ defense requirement. The Soviet Union and China had previously established training programs for Vietnamese pilots. The initial group of pilots went to the Soviet Union for instruction in 1956, the year the North Vietnamese air force was founded. Moscow’s advanced jet aircraft trainQVO XZWOZIU OZIL]I\ML Q\[ ÅZ[\ >QM\VIUM[M XQTW\[ QV ,Mcember 1963. Two months earlier Hanoi had combined the North Vietnamese Air Force and the Air Defense Force under one command that oversaw ground-based anti-aircraft systems. The Soviet Union delivered 36 MiG-17s in February 1964, and that month North Vietnam formed its first ÅOP\MZ ]VQ\ \PM ! [\ ;IW ,IW :ML ;\IZ .QOP\MZ :MOQUMV\ +PQVI XZW^QLML NW]Z ;PMVaIVO .̆ [ I ^MZ[QWV WN \PM ;W^QM\ 5Q/̆ IVL .̆ [ 5Q/̆ [ QV TI\M )]O][\ )QZÅMTL[ KIXIJTM WN PIVLTQVO RM\[ QVKZMI[ML NZWU \_W QV 1958 to 33 by December 1964 and to 44 by June 1965. In September 1964 North Vietnam and China set up a joint air warning system that enabled Hanoi to track air \ZIЅK W^MZ \PM /]TN WN <WVSQV IVL 4IW[ *a ,MKMUJMZ the North had more than doubled its anti-aircraft bat-

BETTMANN/CORBIS

SAM site A North Vietnamese unit just outside Hanoi mans an SA-2 surface-to-air missile in October 1967.

Deadly blast A SAM’s warhead is detonated as it nears an F-105D and throws fragments that strike the plane (trailing smoke). The pilot was killed.

Unmatched in the sky No SAM ever came within 2 miles of damaging an SR-71 Blackbird, a supersonic “stealth” spy plane.

TOP: USAF PHOTO; INSET: LOCKHEED

teries and radars. Hanoi brought its air defense systems together in an integrated network in January 1965 and [M\ ]X \PM WXMZI\QWV¼[ PMILY]IZ\MZ[ I\ *IK 5IQ )QZÅMTL _PMZM \PM IQZ NWZKM IT[W PIL Q\[ PMILY]IZ\MZ[ 7VM [MK\QWV I\ \PM IQZ LMNMV[M PMILY]IZ\MZ[ \PM )QZ ;Q\]I\QWV +MV\MZ XZWKM[[ML IQZ LMNMV[M LI\I )VW\PMZ [MK\QWV \PM ?MIXWV[ +WV\ZWT ;\IЄ KWWZLQVI\ML \PM ZM[XWV[M \W IXproaching enemy aircraft and decided which air defense KMV\MZ _W]TL \ISM WV \PM I\\IKSMZ[ ;WUM ;W^QM\ IQZ LMNMV[M XMZ[WVVMT JW\P KQ^QTQIV IVL UQTQ\IZa PIL IZZQ^ML ]VLM\MK\ML Ja UQL̆.MJZ]IZa ! 5W[KW_ LMTQ^MZML ZILIZ̆O]QLML ;)̆ []ZNIKM̆\W̆IQZ UQ[[QTM[ \W 6WZ\P >QM\VIU QV 5IZKP []ZXZQ[QVO )UMZQKIV UQTQ\IZa TMILMZ[ QVKT]LQVO :WTTQVO <P]VLMZ KWUUIVLMZ[ \PM )QZ .WZKM¼[ VL )QZ ,Q^Q[QWV IVL \PM 6I^a¼[ IQZKZIN\ KIZZQMZ <I[S .WZKM <MV ;)5 \ZIQVQVO KMV\MZ[ PIL JMMV KWUXTM\ML Ja \PM MVL WN 5IZKP WZ MIZTa )XZQT )T[W QV MIZTa )XZQT = ; UQTQ\IZa WЅKQIT[ JMOIV UISQVO NWZUIT ZMY]M[\[ \W [\ZQSM \PM ;)5 TWKI\QWV[ J]\ ,MNMV[M ;MKZM\IZa :WJMZ\ 5K6IUIZI ZMRMK\ML \PW[M ZMY]M[\[ 0M LQL VW\ JMTQM^M \PM 6WZ\P >QM\VIUM[M PIL \PM M`XMZ\Q[M \W ][M \PM ;)5[ IVL ÅO]ZML ;W^QM\ \MKPVQKQIV[ QV >QM\VIU _W]TL VW\ ZQ[S [\IZ\QVO I _IZ _Q\P \PM =VQ\ML ;\I\M[ Ja I\\IKSQVO )UMZQKIV IQZKZIN\ ;)5 [Q\M[ _Q\P UQ[[QTM[ QV XTIKM JMKIUM N]TTa WXMZI\QWVIT QV 2]Ta The first SAM strike KIUM WV 2]Ta ! _PMV IV ;)̆ LW_VML IV )QZ .WZKM .̆ + 8PIV\WU 11 7VM KZM_UIV _I[ SQTTML IVL \PM W\PMZ _I[ KIX\]ZML 5K6IUIZI \PMV LMXTWaML IQZKZIN\ MY]QXXML _Q\P ZILIZ̆RIUUQVO MY]QXUMV\ \W 1VLWKPQVI IVL IOZMML \W KWV[QLMZ ZM\ITQI\WZa [\ZQSM[ WV I KI[M̆JăKI[M JI[Q[ IOIQV[\ \PM [XMKQÅK ;)5 [Q\M[ \PI\ I\\IKSML = ; NWZKM[ 0IVWQ NWZM_IZVML WN \PM ÅZ[\ IXXZW^ML = ; KW]V\MZ[\ZQSM[ \PZW]OP Q\[ QV\MTTQOMVKM WXMZI\QWV[ LMXTWaML IV\Q̆IQZKZIN\ O]V[ IZW]VL MIKP \IZOM\ML [Q\M IVL UW^ML \PM ;)5 JI\\MZQM[ \W VM_ TWKI\QWV[ <PM O]V[ LW_VML [Q` )UMZQKIV IQZKZIN\ IVL [M^MZMTa LIUIOML VMIZTa I LWbMV UWZM <PZMM 6WZ\P >QM\VIUM[M ;)5 ZMOQUMV\[ _MZM IK\Q^M Ja )]O][\ ! J]\ ;W^QM\ LWUQVI\QWV WN \PM ;)5 KWUUIVL̆IVL̆KWV\ZWT [a[\MU[ KZMI\ML XW\MV\QIT KWWZLQVI\QWV XZWJTMU[ JMKI][M TIVO]IOM LQЄMZMVKM[ KW]TL \ZQOOMZ TI]VKPM[ IOIQV[\ NZQMVLTa IQZKZIN\ 0IVWQ¼[ IQZ

defense headquarters reduced that risk by adding a third [MK\QWV I JQTQVO]IT OZW]X \PI\ \ZIV[TI\ML IQZ []Z^MQTTIVKM [a[\MU ZMXWZ\[ IVL ^MZQÅML \PM ;)5[¼ \IZOM\ QLMV\Q\QM[ <PM KWWZLQVI\QWV XZWJTMU[ OZIL]ITTa LMKZMI[ML I[ ;W^QM\̆ \ZIQVML >QM\VIUM[M XMZ[WVVMT \WWS W^MZ \PM KZQ\QKIT WXMZI\QWVIT XW[Q\QWV[ QV \PM ;)5 ]VQ\[ *a ;MX\MUJMZ ! )UMZQKIV I^QI\WZ[ NIKML I KWV[\IV\Ta QUXZW^QVO 6WZ\P >QM\VIUM[M IQZ LMNMV[M [a[\MU *MKI][M UW[\ )UMZQKIV XTIVM[ TIKSML ZILIZ _IZVQVO LM^QKM[ IVL MTMK\ZWVQK KW]V\MZUMI[]ZM[ []KP I[ ZILIZ̆ RIUUQVO MY]QXUMV\ \PM XQTW\[ PIL \W ZMTa WV ^Q[]ITTa [QOP\QVO UQ[[QTM TI]VKPM[ QV \QUM NWZ I ¹;)5̆JZMISº UIVM]^MZ¸I \QOP\ \]ZV IVL LQ^M¸\W M^ILM \PM UQ[[QTM *]\ that meant ditching their bombs and descending into antiIQZKZIN\ O]VVMZa ZIVOM <PMZM \PMa NIKML QVKZMI[QVOTa QV\MV[M ÅZM [\IZ\QVO _Q\P PMI^a O]V[ PIZI[[QVO \PM QVKWUQVO ÆQOP\[ I[ \PMa XI[[ML NWTTW_ML Ja UMLQ]U IVL TQOP\ _MIXWV[ KWVKMV\ZI\QVO WV \PM TMIL IQZKZIN\ I[ \PM ÆQOP\ OW\ KTW[MZ \W \PM \IZOM\ ;UITT̆KITQJMZ O]V[ MVOIOML \PM XTIVM[ I[ \PMa ZMIKPML \PMQZ JWUJ̆ZMTMI[M XWQV\ )UMZQKI¼[ ÆaMZ[ IT[W PIL \W KWV\MVL _Q\P 6WZ\P >QM\VIU¼[ ÅOP\MZ XQTW\[ _PW¸IT\PW]OP W]\V]UJMZML IVL \MKPVWTWOQKITTa PIVLQKIXXML¸\ZQML \W QV\MZKMX\ Q[WTI\ML = ; IQZKZIN\ TMI^QVO \PM \IZOM\ IZMI WZ IUJ][P QVJW]VL XTIVM[ MVK]UJMZML _Q\P JWUJ[ 7\PMZ 6WZ\P >QM\VIUese aircraft protected the interceptors from American ÅOP\MZ M[KWZ\[ )[ _Q\P ;)5 MVOIOMUMV\[ \PM I\\IKSML QVJW]VL = ; IQZKZIN\ LQ\KPML \PMQZ JWUJ[ \W []Z^Q^M 1N MZZIV\ JWUJ[ PQ\ KQ^QTQIV[ \PM \ZIOMLa JMKIUM OZQ[\ NWZ 0IVWQ¼[ XZWXIOIVLI UQTT AUGUST 2016

31

Leading the way Air Force Colonel Robin Olds gets ready for another mission in his F-4C Phantom. He was credited with four MiG kills over North Vietnam.

32

VIETNAM

HANOI’S AIR DEFENSES 120 100 80 60 The enemy Major Tran Hanh, a regimental commander in North Vietnam’s air force, is in a MiG-21 PFM.

McNamara’s emphasis on maximizing sorties and bomb tonnage aided Hanoi’s air defense. To achieve UWZM [WZ\QM[ XMZ LIa XQTW\[ PIL \W Æa LQZMK\ ZW]\M[ \W \PMQZ \IZOM\[ ZML]KQVO \PM LQ[\IVKM IVL NTQOP\ \QUM <PMa IT[W VMMLML \W Æa WV Å`ML [KPML]TM[ _Q\P [\IVLIZLQbML JWUJ IVL N]MT TWIL[ \W KZMI\M IV I[[MUJTăTQVM MЅKQMVKa \PI\ OMVMZI\ML UWZM \ISMWЄ[ NZWU IQZÅMTL[ IVL TI]VKPM[ NZWU KIZZQMZ LMKS[ *]\ \PW[M ZMY]QZMUMV\[ IT[W XZMKT]LML \PM ][M WN LMKMX\Q^M \MKPVQY]M[ []KP I[ IMZQIT NMQV\[ [QVKM \PM[M QVKZMI[ML ÆQOP\ \QUM IVL N]MT KWV[]UX\QWV ZML]KQVO \PM XW[[QJTM V]UJMZ WN [WZ\QM[ IVL JWUJQVO[ <PM ZQOQL predictable sortie rates and bomb tonnage, I XI\\MZV NWZ UW[\ WN ! ̆ _MZM I OQN\ \W Hanoi’s air defenders. 6WZ\P >QM\VIUŸ[ SVW_TMLOM WN = ; IQZ WXMZI\QWV[ _MV\ NIZ JMaWVL \PM XZMLQK\IJQTQ\a WN \PM [WZ\QM [KPML]TM[ .ZWU ! \W ! 0IVWQ KWV[Q[\MV\Ta IKY]QZML \W PW]Z[Ÿ VW\QKM WN \PM LIQTa \IZOM\ TQ[\ IVL [\ZQSM \QUM[ MVIJTQVO Q\[ NWZKM[ \W XW[Q\QWV IQZ LMNMV[M[ IZW]VL \PM UW[\ KZQ\QKIT \IZOM\[ IVL \ZIV[Q\ ZW]\M[ ;XMK]TI\QWV IJW]\ \PM [W]ZKM WN \PI\ QV[QLM QVNWZUI\QWV KWV\QV]M[ \W \PQ[ LIa J]\ = ; KWUUIVLMZ[ QV ;W]\PMI[\ )[QI \WWS IOOZM[[Q^M [\MX[ \W [P]\ WЄ [MK]ZQ\a TMIS[ 0IVWQ IT[W OW\ _IZVQVO[ NZWU ;W^QM\ [PQX[ UWVQ\WZQVO = ; KIZZQMZ[ QV \PM ;W]\P +PQVI ;MI 7\PMZ ITMZ\[ KIUM NZWU WXMZI\Q^M[ IVL TQ[\MVQVO XW[\[ QV 4IW[ IVL VMIZ = ; JI[M[ QV <PIQTIVL IVL ;W]\P >QM\VIU <PW[M _IZVQVO[ WN\MV LQLVŸ\ ZMIKP IQZ LMNMV[M [\I\QWV[ ]V\QT UQV]\M[ JMNWZM \PM XTIVM[ IXXMIZML WV \PMQZ ZILIZ[KWXM[ J]\ KWUJQVML _Q\P \PM QV\MTTQOMVKM NZWU W\PMZ [W]ZKM[ \PMa PMTXML \PM 6WZ\P >QM\VIUM[M QLMV\QNa \ZIKS IVL KW]V\MZ \PM IQZ[\ZQSM[ /ZW]VL̆KWV\ZWT QV\MZKMX\ WXMZI\WZ[ WN\MV SVM_ \PM )UMZQKIV[Ÿ _MIXWV[ IVL N]MT [\I\][ IVL [PIZML \PI\ QVNWZUI\QWV _Q\P \PMQZ XQTW\[ <PI\ IL^IV\IOM _I[ XIZ\QK]TIZTa \MTTQVO NZWU ! \W UQL̆ ! _PMV )UMZQKIV IQZKZIN\ _MZM ÆaQVO QV\W 6WZ\P >QM\VIUM[M IQZ [XIKM _Q\PW]\ []ЅKQMV\ IMZQIT

40 20 0 1963 1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969 1970 1972 Does not include the 5,000+ small 7.62mm-14.5mm weapons Anti-aircraft artillery x 100 SAM batteries MiG ďŹ ghter planes Trained ďŹ ghter pilots

[]Z^MQTTIVKM WZ ILMY]I\M [QOVIT[ QV\MTTQOMVKM []XXWZ\ = ; NWZKM[ QV \PM :WTTQVO <P]VLMZ KIUXIQOV PIL WVTa limited radar coverage of North Vietnam’s air space for U]KP WN \PM WXMZI\QWVÂź[ Ă…Z[\ aMIZ <PMa ZMTQML XZQUIZQTa WV I ZILIZ NIKQTQ\a I\WX 5WVSMa 5W]V\IQV VMIZ ,I 6IVO ZILIZ WV 6I^a [PQX[ IVL šIQZJWZVM MIZTa _IZVQVOÂş ZILIZ on E-1 Tracer planes based on aircraft carriers. Hanoi’s advantages played a critical role in the early IQZ̆\W̆IQZ MVOIOMUMV\[ 7V )XZQT ! I ÆQOP\ WN NW]Z 5Q/̆ [ NZWU \PM ! [\ .QOP\MZ :MOQUMV\ []ZXZQ[ML 6I^a .̆ +Z][ILMZ[ I\\IKSQVO \PM <IW *ZQLOM IVL [M^MZMTa LIUIOML WVM Ă…OP\MZ <PM VM`\ LIa \PM 6WZ\P >QM\VIUM[M [PW\ LW_V \_W WN NW]Z .̆ <P]VLMZKPQMN[ J]\ TW[\ WVM WN \PMQZ W_V \W \PM .̆ ;]XMZ ;IJZM Ă…OP\MZ M[KWZ\[ -+̆ IQZKZIN\ _Q\P MIZTa _IZVQVO ZILIZ _MZM deployed to Indochina one month later. 0IVWQ TMIZVML \PI\ \PM = ; UQTQ\IZa PIL divided North Vietnam into six geographic \IZOM\ bWVM[ KITTML šZW]\M XIKSIOM[ Âş _Q\PQV _MMS[ WN \PM XTIVÂź[ QUXTMUMV\I\QWV WV 6W^ ! <PI\ [IUM UWV\P \PM ;W^QM\ =VQWV LMTQ^MZML 5Q/̆ [ OQ^QVO \PM 6WZ\P >QM\VIUM[M )QZ .WZKM Q\[ Ă…Z[\ \Z]Ta UWLMZV Ă…OP\MZ̆QV\MZKMX\WZ *]\ Ja \PM \QUM \PM XQTW\[ _MZM N]TTa Y]ITQĂ…ML WV \PM ;W^QM\ RM\[ 0IVWQ PIL JMO]V \W TW[M Q\[ QV\MTTQOMVKM IL^IV\IOM <PM = ; )QZ .WZKM QVQ\QI\ML I LZWVM ZMKWVVIQ[[IVKM XZWOZIU QV .MJZ]IZa ! IVL \PM LZWVM[ ]VKW^MZML \PM ;)5 WXMZI\QVO XIZIUM\MZ[ IVL \IK\QK[ 7\PMZ QUXZW^MUMV\[ in information collection came from covert radar and TQ[\MVQVO [\I\QWV[ QV 4IW[ ITWVO _Q\P VM_ ZILIZ[ IVL [QOVIT[̆QV\MTTQOMVKM MY]QXUMV\ WV )UMZQKIÂź[ IQZJWZVM MIZTa _IZVQVO XTIVM[ American aviators also began to employ deception \MKPVQY]M[ IN\MZ )QZ .WZKM +WTWVMT :WJQV 7TL[Âź 7XMZI\QWV *WTW LW_VML Ă…^M 5Q/̆ [ WV 2IV ! 0Q[ []KKM[[ QV[XQZML KWUUIVLMZ[ \W KPIVOM ÆQOP\ ZW]\M[ IVL NWZUI\QWV[ \W PQLM \PM V]UJMZ IVL \aXM[ WN IQZKZIN\ IVL KI][M

OPPOSITE AND ABOVE: USAF PHOTO

NORTH VIETNAMESE SUCCESSES SPURRED THE UNITED STATES TO ESTABLISH FIGHTER SCHOOLS SUCH AS THE NAVY’S “TOP GUN�

AUGUST 2016

33

KWVN][QWV IJW]\ XW\MV\QIT \IZOM\[ ;WUM\QUM[ ร OP\MZ[ IZUML NWZ IQZฬ \Wฬ IQZ KWUJI\ ร M_ ITWVO ZW]\M[ \ZILQ\QWVITTa ][ML Ja JWUJMZ[ )TT WN \PW[M KPIVOM[ KWUJQVML _Q\P W\PMZ VM_ UMI[]ZM[ IVL MY]QXUMV\ XIQL Wะ QV \PM []UUMZ WN ! _PMV = ; ร OP\MZ[ LW_VML XMZKMV\ WN 6WZ\P >QM\VIUยผ[ ร OP\MZ[ UW[\Ta 5Q/ฬ [ <PM 6WZ\P >QM\VIUM[M Y]QKSTa KPIVOML \PMQZ \IK\QK[ and became adept at close-in combat maneuveringโ [WUM\PQVO \PM = ; PIL LZWXXML NZWU UW[\ WN Q\[ XQTW\ \ZIQVQVO XZWOZIU[ QV \PM MIZTa ยผ [ *M\_MMV 7K\WJMZ ! IVL 5Ia ! 6WZ\P >QM\VIUM[M 5Q/ฬ [ LW_VML = ; IQZKZIN\ IVL TW[\ WVTa WVM 5Q/ฬ [ QVร QK\ML XMZKMV\ WN ITT = ; IQZKZIN\ TW[[M[ QV ! <PW[M 6WZ\P >QM\VIUM[M []KKM[[M[ [X]ZZML \PM =VQ\ML ;\I\M[ \W ZMฬ QV[\Q\]\M IQZ KWUJI\ \ZIQVQVO IVL M[\IJTQ[P ร OP\MZ [KPWWT[ []KP I[ \PM 6I^aยผ[ ยน<WX /]V ยบ \W MV[]ZM VW WXXWVMV\ _W]TL MVRWa IV IL^IV\IOM QV IMZQIT KWUJI\ ?PMV \PM =VQ\ML ;\I\M[ JZW]OP\ QV VM_ \MKPVWTWOa 6WZ\P >QM\VIU WN\MV QLMV\Qร ML KW]V\MZUMI[]ZM[ IVL \IK\QK[ _Q\PQV LIa[ WN \PM )UMZQKIV[ยผ ยนร Z[\ ][M ยบ .WZ M`IUXTM ;)5 ]VQ\[ NWQTML )UMZQKIV RIUUQVO MY]QXUMV\ IVL VM_ = ; IV\Qฬ ZILQI\QWV UQ[[QTM[ยธ_PQKP TWKSML WV \W \PM ZILQI\QWV MUQ\\ML Ja ZILIZ[ I\ ;)ฬ [Q\M[ยธ Ja X]\\QVO \PM ;)5 O]QLIVKM ZILIZ[ QV [\IVLJa UWLM ]V\QT \PM ร VIT XPI[M[ WN IV MVOIOMUMV\ )[ \PM )UMZQKIV[ LM^MTWXML [a[\MU[ \W LM\MK\ \PM ZILIZ[ WV [\IVLJa 0IVWQ ZMKMQ^ML UWLQร KI\QWV[ NZWU 5W[KW_ \PI\ MVIJTML ;)5 ]VQ\[ \W O]QLM \PM UQ[[QTM[ ^Q[]ITTa \W \PM \IZOM\ <PM ;)5 [Q\M[ IT[W QV[\Q\]\ML ยนUI[[ UQ[[QTM TI]VKPM[ยบ \W W^MZ_PMTU RIUUQVO Mะ WZ\[ IVL MUXTWaML ยนZILIZ [PQN\QVOยบ \IK\QK[ยธKWVVMK\QVO U]T\QXTM ZILIZ[ \W I KWV\ZWT ]VQ\ IVL ^IZaQVO \PM ones used during an engagement. *]\ \PM 6WZ\P >QM\VIUM[M VM^MZ LM^MTWXML []KKM[[N]T \IK\QK[ \W KW]V\MZ \PM )QZ .WZKMยผ[ ;:ฬ *TIKSJQZL I []XMZ[WVQK [Xa XTIVM _Q\P ZILIZฬ IJ[WZX\Q^M XIQV\ \PI\ OI^M Q\ ยน[\MIT\Pยบ KPIZIK\MZQ[\QK[ ;MM )Z[MVIT XO 6W 6WZ\P >QM\VIUM[M ร OP\MZ[ KW]TL ZMIKP Q\[ ฬ NWW\ WXMZI\QWVIT IT\Q\]LM IVL VW ;)5 M^MZ KIUM _Q\PQV UQTM[ WN LIUIOQVO WVM .ZWU Q\[ ร Z[\ ร QOP\ W^MZ 6WZ\P >QM\VIU WV 5IZKP ! \W Q\[ TI[\ QV ! \PM ;:ฬ ยผ[ KIXIJQTQ\QM[ IVL _MTTฬ XTIVVML UQ[[QWV[ MVIJTML Q\ \W WXMZI\M W^MZ 6WZ\P >QM\VIU _Q\P ^QZ\]IT QUX]VQ\a

IVL MVTIZOM \PM KW]V\Zaยผ[ LIUIOML QVNZI[\Z]K\]ZM M`XIVL \PM IQZ NWZKM IVL ZMQVNWZKM \PM IZUa XIZ\QK]TIZTa \PM \ZWWX[ OWQVO \W \PM ;W]\P 0IVWQยผ[ IQZ LMNMV[M KWUUIVLMZ[ IT[W ZMWZOIVQbML <PMa ZML]KML \PM V]UJMZ WN LMXTWaML ZILIZ[ Ja I \PQZL \W J]QTL I ZM[MZ^M WN N]VK\QWVQVO MY]QXUMV\ \PI\ KW]TL JMKWUM QUUMLQI\M ZMXTIKMUMV\[ NWZ TW[[M[ <PMa IT[W LMKWUUQ[[QWVML ITT \PM PMI^a IV\Qฬ IQZKZIN\ _MIXWV[ _PQKP PIL XZW^ML QVMะ MK\Q^M IOIQV[\ PQOPฬ XMZNWZUIVKM IQZKZIN\ ;WUM _MV\ \W KWI[\IT LMNMV[M ]VQ\[ J]\ UW[\ _MZM X]\ QV [\WZIOM IVL \PMQZ XMZ[WVVMT \ZIV[NMZZML \W \PM OZW]VL NWZKM[ 7^MZ I \PQZL WN \PM TQOP\ IVL [UITTฬ KITQJMZ IV\Qฬ IQZKZIN\ O]V[ _MV\ [W]\P \W XZW\MK\ OZW]VL ]VQ\[ IOIQV[\ IQZ IVL PMTQKWX\MZ [\ZQSM[ <PM[M UW^M[ ZML]KML 0IVWQยผ[ PWUM IV\Qฬ IQZKZIN\ IZ\QTTMZa NWZKM NZWU I[ UIVa I[ _MIXWV[ WN ITT [QbM[ QV ! \W ฬ UU _MIXWV[ Ja ! 0W_M^MZ \PM 6WZ\P >QM\VIUM[M MUXTWaML LMKMX\QWV ]VQ\[ \W UISM Q\ IXXMIZ \PI\ \PZMM \QUM[ \PI\ V]UJMZ ZMUIQVML QV XTIa 5WZM \PIV [UITTฬ KITQJMZ _MIXWV[ UIVa WXMZI\ML Ja _WUMV IVL [\]LMV\[ _MZM KWVKMV\ZI\ML IZW]VL \PM UW[\ KZQ\QKIT \IZOM\[ =XWV \ISQVO Wะ KM QV 2IV]IZa ! ! 8ZM[QLMV\ :QKPIZL 6Q`WV TQUQ\ML IQZ WXMZI\QWV[ W^MZ \PM 6WZ\P \W IMZQIT ZMKWVVIQ[[IVKM J]\ PM I]\PWZQbML KW]V\MZ[\ZQSM[ IOIQV[\ 6WZ\P >QM\VIUM[M NWZKM[ \PI\ ร ZML WV \PM ZMKWVVIQ[[IVKM IQZKZIN\ LMTMOI\QVO ZMOQWVIT KWUUIVLMZ[ LQ[KZM\QWVIZa I]\PWZQ\a \W [\ZQSM 6WZ\P >QM\VIUยผ[ IQZ JI[M[ <PI\ NWZKML 0IVWQ \W UW^M ร OP\MZ[ \W W\PMZ IQZร MTL[ IN\MZ TIVLQVO IVL ZMXTIKM \PMU _Q\P L]UUa IQZKZIN\ WZ XTIVM[ \PI\ _MZM ]V[IT^IOMIJTM +Q^QTQIV ^WT]V\MMZ[ IVL _WZS KZM_[ QVKT]LQVO +PQVM[M UQTQ\IZa MVOQVMMZ[ Y]QKSTa X]\ \PM JWUJML IQZNQMTL[ JIKS QV ][M J]\ IQZKZIN\ UIQV\MVIVKM IVL WXMZI\QWVIT ZMILQVM[[ []ะ MZML 6Q`WV TI]VKPML 7XMZI\QWV 4QVMJIKSMZ WV 5Ia ! ! QV ZM\ITQI\QWV NWZ 0IVWQยผ[ -I[\MZ 7ะ MV[Q^M \PI\ JMOIV WV 5IZKP 4QVMJIKSMZ MUXTWaML *ฬ ;\ZI\WNWZ\ZM[[ JWUJMZ[ _Q\P XW_MZN]T []XXWZ\ \PI\ QVKT]LML VM_ \IK\QK[ MTMK\ZWVQK _IZNIZM [a[\MU[ IVL XZMKQ[QWVฬ O]QLML JWUJ[ I[ _MTT I[ ZMITฬ time intelligence and surveillance. After some initial []KKM[[M[ IOIQV[\ \PM 4QVMJIKSMZ [\ZQSM[ 6WZ\P >QM\VIUยผ[ IQZ LMNMV[M NWZ\]VM[ ZIXQLTa LMKTQVML 0WXQVO \W OM\ IVW\PMZ JWUJQVO PIT\ 0IVWQ QV^Q\ML ยนXIKQร [\[ยบ IVL [aUXI\PQbMZ[ NZWU IZW]VL \PM _WZTL \W _Q\VM[[ \PM )UMZQKIV JWUJMZ[ยผ ยนKZQUQVIT LM[\Z]K\QWV ยบ 8ZWOZM[[ I\ \PM 8IZQ[ XMIKM \ITS[ QV 7K\WJMZ ! TML 6Q`WV \W MVL 4QVMJIKSMZ 1 WV 7K\WJMZ *]\ \PM 6WZ\P >QM\VIUM[M TMN\ \PM VMOW\QI\QVO \IJTM _PMV \ITS[ JZWSM LW_V QV ,MKMUJMZ IVL 6Q`WV WZLMZML 7XMZI\QWV 4QVMJIKSMZ 11 _PQKP JMOIV WV ,MK ! 4QVMJIKSMZ 11 )UMZQKIยผ[ TIZOM[\ JWUJQVO KIUXIQOV JM\_MMV ?WZTL ?IZ 11 IVL 7XMZI\QWV ,M[MZ\ ;\WZU QV !! QVKT]LML UI[[Q^M *ฬ [\ZQSM[ WV KZQ\QKIT \IZOM\[ QV IVL IZW]VL 0IVWQ IVL 0IQXPWVO 0IZJWZ 0IVWQ IOIQV QV^Q\ML ยนXIKQร [\[ยบ \W _Q\VM[[ )UMZQKIยผ[ QVP]UIVM JWUJ-

HOPING TO GET ANOTHER BOMBING HALT, HANOI INVITED โ PACIFISTSโ TO WITNESS AMERICAN BOMBERSโ โ CRIMINALโ ACTS

Despite the Air Defense .WZKMยผ[ XMZKMQ^ML []KKM[[ 4M ,]IV NIKML XWTQ\QKIT XZWJTMU[ QV ! 0IVWQยผ[ IZKPQ^M[ QVLQKI\M \PI\ PM NIKML ITUW[\ WXMV ZMJMTTQWV QV \PM XIZ\a ZIVS[ IN\MZ \PI\ aMIZยผ[ PWZZMVLW][ TW[[M[ L]ZQVO \PM +WUU]VQ[\[ยผ <M\ 7ะ MV[Q^M _PQKP JMOIV 2IV]IZa IVL KWV\QV]ML QV\W 5IZKP <W OIQV \QUM \W ZMI[[MZ\ PQ[ XW_MZ IVL ZMJ]QTL PQ[ NWZKM[ 4M ,]IV IOZMML \W MV\MZ XMIKM \ITS[ QN \PM =VQ\ML ;\I\M[ MVLML \PM :WTTQVO <P]VLMZ JWUJQVO[ _PQKP 2WPV[WV LQL WV 6W^ ! 4M ,]IV PW_M^MZ WZLMZML PQ[ VMOW\QI\WZ[ \W [QOV VW\PQVO R][\ SMMX \PM \ITS[ OWQVO 0M ][ML \PM ฬ UWV\P PQI\][ QV = ; IQZ[\ZQSM[ \W X]ZOM \PM XIZ\aยผ[ ยนLQ[[QLMV\[ ยบ ZMXIQZ 34

VIETNAM

U.S. AIRCRAFT COMBAT LOSSES 400 300 200 100 Target hit The U.S. Air Force bombs the Phuc @LU HPYÄLSK UVY[O of Hanoi in 1967.

NATIONAL MUSEUM OF THE US AIR FORCE

ing, but Nixon didn’t relent until Hanoi returned to the Paris peace talks and accepted his terms. The Paris Peace Accords were signed on Jan. 27, 1973. But Le Duan had no intention of honoring the agreement, which removed the bulk of U.S. troops from South Vietnam and enabled him to reconstitute his devastated NWZKM[ QV \PM ;W]\P QV XZMXIZI\QWV NWZ \PM ÅVIT WЄMV[Q^M that captured Saigon on April 30, 1975. By war’s end North Vietnam had built the world’s densest integrated air defense system, and the American response can still be seen in integrated air campaign procedures, comprehensive battle space management XZWKML]ZM[ XZMKQ[QWV̆\IZOM\ML _MIXWV[ ÅZML NZWU W]\side the range of anti-aircraft artillery, paint schemes \PI\ UISM = ; XTIVM[ UWZM LQЅK]T\ \W [XW\ \IK\QK[ \W suppress air defenses and intense air-combat training. Hanoi’s air defenders gained their greatest successes largely because of shortcomings in American planning, policies and operations early in the war. Despite the UMVIKM WN ;)5[ IVL 6WZ\P >QM\VIUM[M ÅOP\MZ IKM[ anti-aircraft guns remained the primary threat to American planes during Rolling Thunder. The later introduction of precision bombing all but eliminated that threat during the Linebacker operations. The North Vietnamese air defenses’ real success was political, not military. Although the air defense network never threatened American air superiority, it prevented American air power from forcing Hanoi to abandon its plans for conquering South Vietnam. It also weakened America’s political will by reducing the bombing KIUXIQOV¼[ IKK]ZIKa IVL MЄMK\Q^MVM[[ _PQTM QVÆQK\QVO heavier losses than Americans expected. North Vietnam’s Air Defense Force was but one component of a comprehensive war strategy directed at a single objective—unifying Vietnam under Hanoi’s rule. As long as Le Duan enjoyed Chinese and Soviet support, only invasion, his army’s total destruction or his ZMUW^IT NZWU XW_MZ _W]TL NWZKM PQU \W IJIVLWV ]VQÅKI\QWV 0IVWQ UWLQÅML UQTQ\IZa IVL LQXTWUI\QK \IK\QK[ in response to American actions and technology, but the strategic objective remained unchanged. Negotiations

0

1964

1965

1966

1967

1968

Anti-aircraft artillery/small arms MiG fighter planes

1971

1972

SAMs Total

_MZM WЄMZML WVTa \W OIQV \QUM \W XZMXIZM NWZ \PM VM`\ step toward conquering South Vietnam. If Johnson had ramped up his Rolling Thunder operation before or during the 1968 Tet Offensive and bombed North Vietnam with the force of Linebacker II, \PM KWUJQVI\QWV WN IV MЄMK\Q^M JWUJQVO KIUXIQOV IVL devastating troop losses might have forced Le Duan to sign a peace agreement earlier. Le Duan likely would have ignored that agreement too; however, it seems unlikely that the Johnson administration and Saigon regime would have completed the economic and political reforms needed to withstand a Communist assault. Thus, the ultimate outcome of the war would probably have been the same as it was in 1975. But America’s large-scale involvement would have ended much sooner, saving thousands of lives and billions of dollars. Historians may debate whether the United States should have resumed the bombing or continued supporting Saigon when North Vietnam breached the 1973 peace agreement, but renewed bombing was unlikely because America had lost its will to continue the war. South Vietnam’s political shortcomings and its long, almost indefensible border also would have complicated any attempts at a sustained defense. What’s more, another U.S. intervention risked a negative reaction in the international community and a response from China and Russia that could have harmed diplomatic initiatives to improve relations with those countries. North Vietnam’s leaders entered the war with a strategy, a thorough knowledge of their opponent, a complete understanding of the resources required to achieve their objective and a willingness to do whatever it took to win. America’s most senior leaders understood neither their enemy nor the impact of their operational restrictions on U.S. forces. V

Carl O. Schuster is a retired Navy captain with aMIZ[ WN [MZ^QKM 0M ÅVQ[PML PQ[ KIZMMZ I[ IV QV\MTTQOMVKM WЅKMZ ;KP][\MZ _PW TQ^M[ QV 0WVWT]T] Q[ I \MIKPMZ QV 0I_IQQ 8IKQÅK =VQ^MZ[Q\a¼[ ,QXTWUIKa and Military Science program. He wrote “The Rise of North Vietnam’s Air Defenses” in the June 2016 issue. AUGUST 2016

35

The First Battle of Khe Sanh 36

VIETNAM

A year before the famous 1968 siege of the remote American outpost, Marines fought a brutal struggle to seize its surrounding hills

AP PHOTO

A

By Arnold Blumberg

s Sergeant Donald E. Harper Jr. led his squad up a small rise during a routine patrol just west of the airstrip that served the Marine base camp at Khe Sanh, 50 North Vietnamese Army regulars hit \PM ]VQ\ _Q\P [UITT̆IZU[ Ã…ZM SQTTQVO WVM )UMZQKIV IVL _W]VLQVO IVW\PMZ 0IZXMZ X]TTML JIKS IVL ZMY]M[\ML artillery support. After several artillery barrages and \_W OZW]VL I[[I]T\[ \PM 5IZQVM[ Ã…VITTa \WWS \PM PMQOP\ _Q\P PMI^a KTW[M̆QV Ã…OP\QVO <PM 5IZQVM[ _PW[M \W\IT losses for the day were one dead and 11 wounded, found nine enemy bodies, an 82mm mortar, mortar ammuni\QWV IVL ZIVOM̆ÅVLQVO MY]QXUMV\ TQ\\MZQVO \PM UW]VL <PI\ JI\\TM NW]OP\ WV .MJ ! Ja 0IZXMZ¼[ squad—from 2nd Platoon, Bravo Company, 1st Battalion, !\P 5IZQVM :MOQUMV\ ZL 5IZQVM ,Q^Q[QWV¸XZW^ML \W be a harbinger of even deadlier battles. <PM ^QTTIOM WN 3PM ;IVP QV _M[\MZV 9]IVO <ZQ XZW^ince, was about 15 miles below the Demilitarized Zone separating North and South Vietnam. A Marine combat base about 1 mile north of the village sat astride 0QOP_Ia ! IV MI[\̆_M[\ ZWIL TMILQVO QV\W 4IW[ <PM NVA were active in the region, which provided valuable ZW]\M[ \W QVÃ…T\ZI\M ;W]\P >QM\VIU <ZIQT[ KZW[[QVO \PM hills and low mountains were covered by jungle canopy ]X \W NMM\ \ITT _PQTM TW_MZ XI\P[ _MZM PQLLMV Ja LMV[M MTMXPIV\ OZI[[ IVL JIUJWW \PQKSM\[ <PM \PZMM UIQV ZW]\M[ \W 3PM ;IVP _MZM LWUQVI\ML Ja \PM ̆NWW\ ,WVO <ZQ 5W]V\IQV \PM PQOPM[\ \MZZIQV QV \PM IZMI IVL 0QTT[ 6WZ\P IVL ;W]\P <PI\ IZMI VWZ\Pwest of the Marine base, was sown with well-hidden J]VSMZ[ IVL L]ŎQV Ã…OP\QVO XW[Q\QWV[ \PM 6>) ][ML \W protect troop-staging areas and secure supply caches.

)N\MZ \PM TI\M .MJZ]IZa Ã…OP\QVO \PM ZL 5IZQVM ,Q^Q[QWV JWT[\MZML ]VQ\[ QV \PM 3PM ;IVP IZMI 7V 5IZKP the division reinforced Bravo Company, led by Captain Michael W. Sayers, with troops from Echo Company, 2nd *I\\ITQWV !\P 5IZQVM[ KWUUIVLML Ja +IX\IQV ?QTTQIU * <MZZQTT <PM 5IZQVM[ QVKZMI[ML \PMQZ XI\ZWT[ _Q\P XIZ\QK]TIZ MUXPI[Q[ WV \PM IVL PQTT[ I[ \PMa \ZQML to prevent the NVA from positioning artillery and mortars close enough to the Khe Sanh base to threaten it. 7V 5IZKP [\ 8TI\WWV QV <MZZQTT¼[ KWUXIVa _I[ ZM\]ZVQVO NZWU I VQOP\ UQ[[QWV WV 0QTT IN\MZ TWWSQVO unsuccessfully for opportunities to ambush the NVA IVL _I[ Q\[MTN IUJ][PML I\ I U <PM XTI\WWV TML Ja ;MZOMIV\ ,WVITL 4WZL _I[ PQ\ Ja QV\MV[M KZW[[Ã…ZM WV I JIUJWW̆JWZLMZML \ZIQT )N\MZ I ̆UQV]\M Ã…ZMÃ…OP\ \PM XTI\WWV¼[ \PZMM [Y]IL[ LZW^M \PM MVMUa I_Ia IVL \PMV ZM\]ZVML \W M^IK]I\M WVM LMIL IVL Ã…^M _W]VLML 5IZQVM[ <PMa IOIQV KIUM ]VLMZ PMI^a Ã…ZM <PQ[ \QUM \PM KI[]IT\a KW]V\ _I[ [Q` SQTTML NW]Z _W]VLML IVL one missing. ,]ZQVO \PM Ã…ZMÃ…OP\ 4WZL PIL KITTML QV IZ\QTTMZa Ã…ZM but the NVA still refused to withdraw. Help came to the beleaguered unit from two squads of the 2nd Platoon in ;IaMZ[¼ *ZI^W +WUXIVa ]VLMZ VL 4\ /I\TQV 2 0W_MTT _PW PIL JMMV WXMZI\QVO IJW]\ I PITN̆UQTM MI[\ WN 0QTT ¹?M _MZM Ã…VQ[PQVO ]X I VQVM̆LIa LIa [_MMX WN \PM IZMI _PMV _M PMIZL I Ã…ZMÃ…OP\ JZMIS W]\ I\WX 0QTT IVL _M _MZM WZLMZML \W ZMQVNWZKM \PM XTI\WWV QV \PM Ã…OP\ º remembered Kenneth Price, a medic in the 2nd Platoon. )QZ[\ZQSM[ LZW^M \PM 6>) NZWU \PM KZM[\ WN \PM PQTT IVL JW\P )UMZQKIV ]VQ\[ WKK]XQML \PM []UUQ\ <PMa NW]VL MVMUa LMIL NZWU \PM O]V JI\\TM[ IVL IQZ[\ZQSM[

Taking a stand U.S. Marines are positioned on Hill 881 North near Khe Sanh in early May 1967.

)=/=;<

The combat losses in February and March 1967 were a prelude to the “First Battle of Khe Sanh,” one of the Vietnam War’s hardest-fought battles, which began on April 24. That morning 2nd Lt. Thomas G. King’s 2nd Platoon in Sayers’ company moved to Hill 700, a little south of Hill 861, and positioned mortars to provide ar38

VIETNAM

tillery support for a sweep that 1st and 3rd platoons were conducting north of Hill 861 to see if enemy troops were in nearby caves that 1st Platoon had found the day before. Five men from the 2nd Platoon mortar team went to Hill 861 to set up an observation point at the top, where they could direct the artillery ÅZML NZWU 0QTT ,]ZQVO \PM climb they were ambushed, and four were killed. T h e g u n f i r e o n H i l l 8 61 prompted King to send a squad to make contact with the mortar observation team. They too came under savage small-arms fire and returned to Hill 700, where King’s mortars, along with artillery at Khe Sanh base, shelled the NVA on Hill 861. The Marines then went back and recovered two of the bodies. The other two couldn’t be found. Captain Sayers, who had left the Khe Sanh base, accompanied by a security platoon, joined King on Hill 700 and ordered the 1st and 3rd platoons to move southeast across Hill 861 and hit the NVA from the rear. The two platoons started forward, but were soon struck by five 82mm mortar rounds and heavy fire on their right, forcing them to pull back. The 1st and 3rd platoons dug in for the night at the base of Hill 861. Sayers, his security platoon and 2nd Platoon returned to the base camp. The Battle of Khe Sanh’s initial action cost the Marines 12 killed, 17 wounded and two missing. Five NVA were known dead. The Marines surmised from the April 24 engagements that the enemy was positioning itself in the hills to prepare for an allout attack on the Khe Sanh base. To counter the expected NVA assault, the III Marine Amphibious Force headquarters at Da Nang sent elements of 3rd Marine Regiment, 3rd Marine Division, to Khe Sanh on April 25. Regimental commander Colonel John P. Lanigan ordered Lt. Col. Gary Wilder, chief of the regiment’s

THE MARINES PLASTERED THE HILLS WITH 325 TONS OF BOMBS AND ARTILLERY SHELLS

AP PHOTO; OPPOSITE TOP RIGHT: AP PHOTO/JOE HOLLOWAY, JR; BOTTOM RIGHT: AP PHOTO

The Marines cleared a landing zone on 861’s summit for a helicopter evacuation of their casualties, but enemy harassment continued for the next several hours. “After arriving at the top of Hill 861 we came under heavy enemy mortar attack,” Price said. One of the attacks killed Sergeant Harper, whose squad PIL JMMV \PM ÅZ[\ \W MVOIOM \PM NVA just a few weeks earlier, the former medic said in a posting on the Vietnam Veterans Memorial’s Web page for Harper. Terrill and Echo’s 2nd Platoon were transported to the landing zone by helicopter and spent the next two days in a fruitless sweep of the area north and west of the hill. The NVA had slipped away. The March 16 action cost the Americans 20 killed and 59 wounded, almost all from Terrill’s company. The last of the American casualties _MZM ÅVITTa TQN\ML WЄ 0QTT WV March 17. In the following weeks, the Khe Sanh base, with Sayers in charge, received welcome reinforcements in the form of a tank section, some Ontos armored fighting vehicles—each mounting six 106mm recoilless rifles—and a few armored trucks carrying 40mm cannons or .50-caliber machine guns. Artillery support was provided by Battery F, 2nd Battalion, 12th Marine Regiment, 3rd Marine Division, sporting a mix of 155mm howitzers and 4.2-inch UWZ\IZ[ 7Є[M\\QVO \PM[M OIQV[ was the departure of Terrill’s company on March 27. By early April, Sayers’ command totaled less than 1,000 men.

What’s the exit? Highway 9, jokingly labeled an interstate, takes Marines to Khe Sanh.

Rising casualties A Marine cares for a wounded comrade on Hill 881 North in May 1967 after a North Vietnamese attack.

Marking the spot Marines lay down smoke to guide airstrikes near Khe Sanh in February 1967 and then scurry for cover.

AUGUST 2016

39

3rd Battalion, to take his unit to Hill 861. Wilder’s lead unit, Kilo Company under Captain Bayliss L. Spivey Jr., moved two platoons up the hill. The [\ 8TI\WWV _I[ JI\\MZML _Q\P Ã…ZM NZWU IV 6>) KWUXIVa XZW\MK\ML Ja J]VSMZ[ IVL []XXWZ\ML Ja UWZ\IZ[ <PQKS ^MOM\I\QWV UILM Q\ PIZL NWZ \PM 5IZQVM[ \W [XW\ IVL KW]V\MZ MVMUa Ã…ZM KWUQVO NZWU \PM M`XMZ\Ta PQLLMV NWZ\QÃ…ML XW[Q\QWV[ )[ LIZSVM[[ IXXZWIKPML [\ 8TI\WWV PIL IL^IVKML WVTa IJW]\ aIZL[ _PQTM VL 8TI\WWV IT[W UM\ Ã…MZKM ZM[Q[\IVKM IVL UILM TQ\\TM PMIL_Ia ;XQ^Ma¼[ MV\QZM KWUUIVL L]O QV NWZ \PM VQOP\ -IZTQMZ QV \PM LIa ;IaMZ[ IVL PQ[ KWUXIVa¼[ VL 8TI\WWV PIL TMN\ 3PM ;IVP Ja PMTQKWX\MZ ZMRWQVML \PM UMV I\ \PM JI[M WN 0QTT IVL \ZQML \W M^IK]I\M \PM _W]VLML *]\ LMV[M NWO IVL QVKWUQVO UWZ\IZ ZW]VL[ PIUXMZML PMTQKWX\MZ TIVLQVO[ IVL MNNWZ\[ \W KIZZa [WUM WN \PM _W]VLML IVL LMIL W]\ WV NWW\ *ZI^W +WUXIVa UILM TQ\\TM XZWOZM[[ IVL \PM \PZMM XTI\WWV[ [XMV\ IVW\PMZ VQOP\ QV \PM Ã…MTL 7V )XZQT \PM 6>) X]UUMTML ?QTLMZ¼[ JI\\ITQWV KWUUIVL XW[\ JMTW_ 0QTT _Q\P UWZM \PIV UU UWZ\IZ ZW]VL[ Ã…ZML NZWU 0QTT ;W]\P¼[ MI[\MZV [TWXM <PM MVMUa IT[W Ã…ZML UWZ\IZ IVL ZMKWQTTM[[ ZQÆM [PMTT[ I\ \PM 3PM ;IVP JI[M IT\PW]OP UW[\ PQ\ W]\[QLM \PM KWUXW]VL ,]ZQVO \PM UWZVQVO +IX\IQV ;XQ^Ma¼[ 3QTW +WUXIVa WN \PM ZL 5IZQVM[ NIQTML QV I [MKWVL I\\MUX\ \W [KITM 0QTT IVL _MZM XQVVML LW_V R][\ JMTW_ \PM PQTT Wilder sent newly arrived Captain Jerrald E. Giles and PQ[ 3QTW +WUXIVa WN \PM !\P 5IZQVM[ \W I[[Q[\ ;XQ^Ma 40

VIETNAM

BRIAN WALKER

;OL OPSS ÄNO[Z VM An ambush on Hill 861 that killed all but one member of a Marine team from the Khe :HUO JVTIH[ IHZL ZWHYRLK H ÄYLZ[VYT VM YPÅL HY[PSSLY` HUK N\UZOPW YV\UKZ [OH[ ZWYLHK to Hill 881 North and Hill 881 South between (WYPS HUK 4H` ILMVYL IH[[HSPVUZ MYVT the 3rd Marine Division forced the North =PL[UHTLZL (YT` [V YL[YLH[

/QTM[ PMTXML XZW^QLM KW^MZQVO Ã…ZM \PI\ MVIJTML Spivey to withdraw. 1V \PM UMIV\QUM ;IaMZ[¼ KWUXIVa I\\MUX\QVO \W TQVS _Q\P ?QTLMZ I\ \PM JI\\ITQWV KWUUIVL XW[\ _I[ IUJ][PML IVL []NNMZML [W UIVa KI[]IT\QM[ \PI\ Q\ KW]TL VW\ UW^M NWZ_IZL WZ JIKS_IZL ;IaMZ[ _I[ IUWVO \PM _W]VLML <PI\ VQOP\ PQ[ ]VQ\ _I[ QV LIVOMZ WN JMQVO W^MZZ]V IVL []Z^Q^ML WVTa JMKI][M *I\\MZa . I\ 3PM ;IVP X]\ ¹I ZQVO WN [\MMTº¸I[ ;IaMZ[ LM[KZQJML Q\¸IZW]VL \PM KWUXIVa¼[ XW[Q\QWV IVL the enemy dared not attempt to penetrate it. /QTM[¼ UMV _MZM IOIQV [MV\ \W \PM IQL WN \PMQZ NMTTW_ 5IZQVM[ IVL PMTXML ;IaMZ[ OM\ _PI\ _I[ TMN\ WN PQ[ JI\\MZML KWUXIVa \W ?QTLMZ¼[ XW[\ \PM UWZVQVO WN )XZQT <W XZW^QLM UWZM UMV NWZ \PM LMNMV[M WN 3PM ;IVP JI[M 4\ +WT -IZT : ,MTWVO¼[ VL *I\\ITQWV ZL 5IZQVM[ _I[ IQZTQN\ML NZWU IV IZMI VWZ\P WN 0]M +Q\a \W 3PM ;IVP _PMZM Q\ _MV\ QV\W KIUX MI[\ WN ?QTLMZ¼[ JI\\ITQWV \PM VQOP\ WN )XZQT )LLQ\QWVITTa *I\\MZa * [\ *I\\ITQWV \P 5IZQVM[ IZZQ^ML I\ 3PM ;IVP WV \PM \P .WZ \PM JM\\MZ XIZ\ WN \PI\ LIa IVL \PM VM`\ 5IZQVM IVL )ZUa IZ\QTTMZa XW]ZML IZ\QTTMZa [PMTT[ WV\W 0QTT _PQTM IQZ I\\IKS[ LZWXXML \WV[ WN WZLVIVKM \W [WN\MV ]X \PM MVMUa WV \PM PMQOP\ Ja WJTQ\MZI\QVO PQ[ [WTQLTa J]QT\ IVL KWVKMITML J]VSMZ[ 4I\M QV \PM IN\MZVWWV WN )XZQT \PM 5IZQVM[ XZMXIZML NWZ I \_W̆JI\\ITQWV I[[I]T\ WV 0QTT 0QTT ;W]\P IVL 0QTT 6WZ\P QV \PI\ WZLMZ ,MTWVO¼[ JI\\ITQWV KPIZOML 0QTT _Q\P \_W KWUXIVQM[ IJZMI[\ J]\ \PM 5IZQVM[ NIKML VW WXXW[Q\QWV I[ \PMa OIQVML \PM KZM[\ <PM IQZ IVL IZ\QTTMZa JWUJIZLUMV\ PIL NWZKML \PM 6>) \W IJIVLWV \PM XW[Q\QWV IVL \PM J]VSMZ[ IVL NW`PWTM[ LMNMVLQVO Q\ 7VKM 0QTT _I[ [MK]ZML 5QSM +WUXIVa WN ?QTLMZ¼[ JI\\ITQWV UW^ML ]X WV ,MTWVO¼[ _M[\MZV ÆIVS NZWU 3PM ;IVP <PM VM`\ LIa ?QTLMZ¼[ UMV KIX\]ZML I [UITT PQTT IJW]\ I PITN̆UQTM VWZ\PMI[\ WN 0QTT ;W]\P )V 6>) VQOP\ I\\IKS _I[ JZWSMV ]X Ja IZ\QTTMZa Ã…ZM )\ LI_V WV )XZQT ?QTLMZ XZMXIZML \W I\\IKS 0QTT ;W]\P _PQTM ,MTWVO UW^ML \W_IZL 0QTT 6WZ\P \W [MK]ZM ?QTLMZ¼[ ZQOP\ ÆIVS IVL Ã…VL I [Q\M \W I[[I]T\ \PM PQTT ) Ã…MZKM Ã…ZMÃ…OP\ JZWSM W]\ JM\_MMV 0W\MT +WUXIVa WN ,MTWVO¼[ JI\\ITQWV IVL \_W 6>) XTI\WWV[ PWTML ]X QV I J]VSMZ KWUXTM` VMIZ \PM []UUQ\ 6QVM 5IZQVM[ LQML IVL _MZM _W]VLML L]ZQVO \PM KTW[M̆QV Ã…OP\QVO 4I\MZ \PI\ IN\MZVWWV IN\MZ I PMI^a = ; IZ\QTTMZa JWUJIZLUMV\ NWTTW_ML Ja \PM XZWTWVOML KWUJI\ WN I OZW]VL I[[I]T\ \PM 5IZQVM[ Ã…VITTa LQ[TWLOML \PM 6>) [WTLQMZ[ NZWU \PMQZ J]VSMZ[ ¹<PMZM _I[ VW _Ia WN OM\\QVO \PMU W]\ CWN \PM J]VSMZ[E°]VTM[[ aW] LZIOOML \PMU W]\ IN\MZ \PMa _MZM LMIL º ;\INN ;O\ :]JMV ;IV\W[ WN /WTN +WUXIVa QV ,MTWVO¼[ JI\\ITQWV \WTL I ZMXWZ\MZ IN\MZ \PM JI\\TM ?QTLMZ¼[ JI\\ITQWV IT[W ZIV QV\W IV MV\ZMVKPML MVMUa QV \PMQZ I\\IKS \PM [IUM LIa WV 0QTT ;W]\P 5K,WVVMTT .̆ 8PIV\WU 11[ LZWXXML \WV[ WN JWUJ[ WV \PM PQTT

before the Marines began their climb. The NVA hit them _Q\P I]\WUI\QK _MIXWV[ Ã…ZM NZWU KWVKMITML J]VSMZ[ IVL [VQXMZ[ QV \ZMM[ =VIJTM \W OW NWZ_IZL WZ \W ZM\ZMI\¸ JMKI][M WN 6>) XW[Q\QWV[ JaXI[[ML WV \PM _Ia ]X¸\PM 5IZQVM[ \ZILML O]VÃ…ZM _Q\P \PM MVMUa NWZ [M^MZIT PW]Z[ JMNWZM \PMa KW]TL UW^M JIKS LW_V \PM UW]V\IQV _Q\P \PM PMTX WN I 0]Ma PMTQKWX\MZ¼[ O]V[ <PMa TW[\ SQTTML IVL ! _W]VLML <PM MVMUa []ЄMZML SQTTML

AP PHOTO

In the early TQOP\ WN 5Ia \PM 5IZQVM[ XTI[\MZML 0QTT[ 6WZ\P IVL ;W]\P _Q\P \WV[ WN JWUJ[ IVL IZ\QTTMZa [PMTT[ <PM JIZZIOM[ IVL IQZ[\ZQSM[ KI][ML WVM 6>) XTI\WWV \W JWT\ NZWU Q\[ J]VSMZ[ WVTa \W JM UW_ML LW_V QV \PM WXMV Ja )UMZQKIV IQZKZIN\ )JW]\ MVMUa [WTLQMZ[ _MZM SQTTML \PI\ _Ia <PM VM`\ LIa ?QTLMZ¼[ JI\\ITQWV MI[QTa \WWS KWV\ZWT WN 0QTT ;W]\P IN\MZ \PM 6>) _Q\PLZM_ NZWU \PM [Q\M _PMZM Q\ PIL J]QT\ TWŎIVL̆LQZ\̆KW^MZML J]VSMZ[ 5MIV_PQTM ,MTWVO¼[ UMV IL^IVKML ]X 0QTT 6WZ\P _Q\P /WTN +WUXIVa I\\IKSQVO NZWU \PM MI[\ IVL -KPW +WUXIVa NZWU \PM [W]\P 0MTL QV ZM[MZ^M _I[ 0W\MT +WUXIVa )N\MZ \_W I\\IKS[ []XXWZ\ML Ja IZ\QTTMZa /WTN VMIZML \PM []UUQ\ ]VLMZ PMI^a UWZ\IZ Ã…ZM -KPW _I[ Ã…OP\QVO Q\[ _Ia \W \PM \WX ]V\QT I [Y]ITT _Q\P PMI^a ZIQV[ IVL UXP _QVL[ NWZKML ,MTWVO \W [][XMVL \PM I[[I]T\ IVL X]TT JIKS NWZ \PM VQOP\ <_W 6>) KWUXIVQM[ KW]V\MZI\\IKSML ]VLMZ KW^MZ WN LIZSVM[[ \PM UWZVQVO WN 5Ia [\ZQSQVO I\ \PM VWZ\P̆ MI[\ [QLM WN ,MTWVO¼[ ÆIVS WV 0QTT 6WZ\P 1V PIVL̆ \W̆PIVL NQOP\QVO \PM MVMUa \ZWWX[ XMVM\ZI\ML -KPW +WUXIVa¼[ TQVM[ IVL ZMWKK]XQML [WUM J]VSMZ[ QV \PM UQLLTM WN \PM 5IZQVM XW[Q\QWV <PM )UMZQKIV[ KWJJTQVO \WOM\PMZ LM\IKPUMV\[ WN MVOQ̆ VMMZ[ IVL ZQÆMUMV [\ITTML \PM I\\IKS _Q\P \PM I[[Q[\IVKM WN O]V[PQX[ IZ\QTTMZa IVL RM\ Ã…OP\MZ[ J]\ KW]TL VW\ X][P \PM QV\Z]LMZ[ W]\ WN \PMQZ XW[Q\QWV ) [MKWVL _I^M WN 6WZ\P >QM\VIUM[M IXXMIZML \W JM UW^QVO \W_IZL -KPW NZWU \PM _M[\ J]\ _MZM [\WXXML Ja UU ZMKWQTTM[[ ZQÆM Ã…ZM NZWU ?QTLMZ¼[ UMV XMZKPML WV 0QTT ;W]\P ,]ZQVO \PM UWZVQVO WN 5Ia ,MTWVO¼[ UMV KIX\]ZML 6>)̆WKK]XQML J]VSMZ[ IN\MZ [I^IOM KTW[M̆QV Ã…OP\QVO \PI\ ZM[]T\ML QV \PM LMI\P[ WN 5IZQVM[ IVL \PM _W]VLQVO WN UWZM 6>) [WTLQMZ[ NW]OP\ \W VMIZTa \PM TI[\ UIV _Q\P SQTTML IVL \PZMM \ISMV XZQ[WVMZ 7V 5Ia ,MTWVO¼[ UMV _MZM ZMILa \W \ISM \PM []UUQ\ of Hill 881 North. After blasting the hill with artillery Ã…ZM -KPW IVL .W`\ZW\ KWUXIVQM[ [\IZ\ML W]\ I\ IJW]\ ! I U -VMUa ZM[Q[\IVKM NWZKML \PW[M ]VQ\[ \W JIKS WЄ J]\ NZQMVLTa IQZKZIN\ IVL IZ\QTTMZa _WZSML \PM PQTT W^MZ _Q\P UI[[Q^M KWVKMV\ZI\QWV[ WN JWUJ[ IVL [PMTT[ .W`̆ \ZW\ IVL /WTN KWUXIVQM[ I\\IKSML WVKM UWZM IVL MV̆ KW]V\MZQVO WVTa [VQXMZ Ã…ZM \WWS \PM []UUQ\ R][\ JMNWZM X U ?Q\P \PI\ []KKM[[ \PM 5IZQVM[ KWUUIVLML \PM PQOP OZW]VL []ZZW]VLQVO 3PM ;IVP For the next \PZMM LIa[ \PM 5IZQVM[ PIL TQ\\TM KWV\IK\ _Q\P \PM 6>) IVL \PMV [XW\\ML \PM + ,Q^Q[QWV _Q\P̆ LZI_QVO \W_IZL 6WZ\P >QM\VIU IVL 4IW[ <_W XTI\WWV[ NZWU .W`\ZW\ +WUXIVa QV ,MTWVO¼[ JI\\ITQWV \IVOTML _Q\P ZMIZO]IZL W]\Ã…\[ WN \PM +WUU]VQ[\ LQ^Q[QWV WV 5Ia !

Fire away An M60 machine gun on Hill 881 5VY[O PZ ÄYLK at the enemy in May 1967.

_PQTM [KW]\QVO 0QTT I NM_ UQTM[ VWZ\P_M[\ WN 0QTT 6WZ\P -KPW +WUXIVa RWQVML \PM Ã…OP\ IVL Ã…VITTa IN\MZ I ̆UQV]\M L]MT \PM 6>) [\IZ\ML \W ZM\ZMI\ 5IZQVM IQZ XW_MZ IVL IZ\QTTMZa \MIZQVO QV\W \PM MVMUa¼[ ZIVS[ \]ZVML IV WZLMZTa _Q\PLZI_IT QV\W I ZW]\ ?PMV \PM Ã…OP\ MVLML 5IZQVM[ _MZM LMIL IVL ! _W]VLML <PQZ\ăWVM 6>) [WTLQMZ[ TW[\ \PMQZ TQ^M[ <PM IK\QWV WN 5Ia ! _I[ \PM TI[\ TIZOM MVKW]V\MZ WN \PM ̆LIa NQZ[\ JI\\TM WN 3PM ;IVP )T\PW]OP IŎ OZM[[Q^M OZW]VL I[[I]T\[ PIL \ISMV \PM PQTT[ QV I KWV^MV\QWVIT JI\\TM \PI\ XQ\\ML \PM 5IZQVM[ IOIQV[\ I _MTT̆MV\ZMVKPML MVMUa U]KP KZMLQ\ IT[W _MV\ \W \PM IZ\QTTMZa IVL IQZ̆[]XXWZ\ IZU[ NWZ W^MZ_PMTUQVO \PM enemy resistance. <PM PQTT JI\\TM[ IZW]VL 3PM ;IVP KW[\ \PM 5IZQVM[ SQTTML _Q\P _W]VLML KWUXIZML _Q\P IV 6>) TW[[ WN ! LMIL UW[\Ta NZWU + ,Q^Q[QWV¼[ \P :MOQUMV\ )N\MZ \PM JI\\TM 5IZQVM[ JI[ML I\ 3PM ;IVP XI\ZWTTML \PM PQTT[ J]\ LQL VW\ UIQV\IQV I N]TT̆\QUM XZM[̆ ence there. *a \PM MVL WN ! \PM 6>) WVKM IOIQV JMOIV J]QTLQVO ]X Q\[ NWZKM[ QV \PM 3PM ;IVP PQTT[ IVL JMOIV I [QMOM WN \PM 5IZQVM JI[M WV 2IV ! <PM JI[M ZMUIQVML ]VLMZ [QMOM ]V\QT )XZQT _PMV ZMQVNWZKMUMV\ Ã…VITTa NWZKML \PM 6WZ\P >QM\VIUM[M \W _Q\PLZI_ V

)ZVWTL *T]UJMZO IV I\\WZVMa QV *IT\QUWZM [MZ^ML QV \PM )ZUa :M[MZ^M ! ̆ MVLQVO PQ[ \MZU I[ I [\IЄ [MZOMIV\ QV I UIQV\MVIVKM KWUXIVa 0M _ZQ\M[ on military topics for history publications. AUGUST 2016

41

Solemn moment Bodies from the hill ÄNO[Z HYL WYLWHYLK MVY [YHUZWVY[ VU 4H`

42

VIETNAM

PHOTOS: AP PHOTO

Why Khe Sanh? )UMZQKIV \ZWWX[ Ã…Z[\ IZZQ^ML in the Khe Sanh area in August 1962, when an Army Special .WZKM[ LM\IKPUMV\ M[\IJTQ[PML a camp at the tiny airstrip just VWZ\PMI[\ WN \PM ^QTTIOM WN 3PM ;IVP <PM[M [WTLQMZ[ MVOIOML QV JWZLMZ WJ[MZ^I\QWV IVL KTIVLM[\QVM IK\Q^Q\QM[ \W XZM^MV\ \PM UW^MUMV\ WN MVMUa \ZWWX[ IVL weapons into South Vietnam from neighJWZQVO 4IW[ IVL 6WZ\P Vietnam. As the war PMI\ML ]X /MVMZIT William WestmoreTIVL KWUUIVLMZ WN = ; KWUJI\ NWZKM[ QV >QM\VIU KWV[QLMZML 3PM ;IVP I OWWL TWKI\QWV¸LM[XQ\M Q\[ Q[Wlation from other U.S. opera\QWV[¸NWZ OI\PMZQVO QV\MTTQOMVKM ITWVO \PM 6WZ\P >QM\VIU·;W]\P >QM\VIU·4IW[ JWZLMZ IVL K]\ting off the Ho Chi Minh Trail as a Communist supply route. During the fall of 1966, intelTQOMVKM ZMXWZ\[ VW\ML QVKZMI[ML UW^MUMV\ Ja \PM 6WZ\P >QM\namese Army on an east-west trail that ran into the region NZWU 4IW[ <PM [\ *I\\ITQWV ZL 5IZQVM :MOQUMV\ ZL 5IZQVM ,Q^Q[QWV []XXWZ\ML Ja I JI\\MZa NZWU \PM [\ *I\\ITQWV \P Marine Artillery Regiment, was LMXTWaML \W 3PM ;IVP WV ;MX\ ! ! \W [M\ ]X I KWUJI\ JI[M 1V \PM NWTTW_QVO UWV\P[ \PM JI\\ITQWV LQL VW\ M`XMZQMVKM IVa [QOVQÃ…KIV\ MVKW]V\MZ[ _Q\P \PM MVMUa IVL QV .MJZ]IZa ! Q\ _I[ ZMXTIKML Ja I [QVOTM KWUXIVa *ZI^W +WUXIVa [\ *I\\ITQWV !\P 5IZQVM :MOQUMV\ ZL 5IZQVM ,Q^Q[QWV I]OUMV\ML Ja I ̆UIV [MK]ZQ\a XTI\WWV IVL []XXWZ\ML Ja I ZMQVNWZKML IZ\QTTMZa JI\\MZa ? P Q T M * Z I ^ W + W U X I V a O]IZLML \PM 5IZQVM JI[M IVL IQZNQMTL I TWKIT UQTQ\QI NWZKM \PM +Q^QTQIV 1Z ZMO]TIZ ,MNMV[M /ZW]X UIVVML I ;XM-

KQIT .WZKM[ KIUX I\ 4IVO >MQ IJW]\ UQTM[ [W]\P_M[\ WN \PM KWUJI\ JI[M *M[QLM[ JMQVO ]VLMZUIVVML IJW]\ \ZWWX[ \PM [UITT ] V Q \ [ L M NM V L Q V O \ P M J I [ M _W]TL PI^M \ZW]JTM OM\\QVO ZMQVNWZKMUMV\[ IVL []XXTQM[ Ja ZWIL JMKI][M 0QOP_Ia ! the main east-west thoroughNIZM QV \PM IZMI PIL JMMV K]\ WNN IJW]\ 18 miles east of Khe ;IVP Ja \PM 6>) [QVKM )]O][\ ! TMI^QVO air transport the only means of relief. All through 1966 IVL MIZTa ! \PM 111 5IZQVM )UXPQJQW][ .WZKM¸ZM[XWV[QJTM NWZ LMNMVLQVO \PM 3PM ;IVP IZMI¸_IV\ML \W IJIVLWV \PM JI[M JMKI][M WN Q\[ ZMUW\MVM[[ ]VNI^WZIJTM _MI\PMZ KWVLQ\QWV[ XZW`QUQ\a \W 6>) []XXTa TQVM[ IVL \PM QUUMV[M TWOQ[\QKIT MNNWZ\ VMMLML \W [][\IQV Q\ L]ZQVO I [QMOM *M[QLM[ KWVL]K\QVO I [\I\QK LMNMV[M I\ 3PM ;IVP _I[ ZMX]OVIV\ \W \PM 4MI\PMZVMKS[ _PW[M KWUJI\ LWK\ZQVM KITTML NWZ UWJQTM WЄMV[Q^M IK\QWV *]\ ?M[\UWZMTIVL IVL WÐ…KQIT[ QV ?I[PQVO\WV _IV\ML \PM 5IZQVM[ \W PWTL \PM JI[M JMKI][M \PMa [I_ Q\ I[ I _Ia \W LZI_ I TIZOM 6>) NWZKM QV\W JI\\TM IVL LM[\ZWa Q\ _Q\P []XMZQWZ Ã…ZMXW_MZ IVL I KW]V\MZ\PZ][\ QV\W 4IW[ <PM LM\MZUQVI\QWV \W PWTL 3PM ;IVP _PQKP _I[ JM[QMOML NWZ LIa[ JMOQVVQVO 2IV ! LQ^MZ\ML )UMZQKIV I\\MV\QWV IVL ZM[W]ZKM[ NZWU W\PMZ IZMI[ WN ;W]\P >QM\VIU L]ZQVO \PM ! +WUU]VQ[\ <M\ 7ЄMV[Q^M )VL \PMZM _I[ VW KW]V\MZ\PZ][\ QV\W 4IW[ 3PM ;IVP _I[ XMZUIVMV\Ta IJIVLWVML Ja = ; NWZKM[ QV MIZTa 2]Ta IVL WKK]XQML Ja \PM 6>) ¸)ZVWTL *T]UJMZO AUGUST 2016

43

STARK IMAGES OF MEN AT WAR 8PQTQX 2WVM[ /ZQЅ\P[ \ZI^MTML \PM OTWJM \ISQVO XQK\]ZM[ IVL PQ[ XPW\W[ ZMÆMK\ \PM ]VQ^MZ[IT [\Z]OOTM[ IVL MUW\QWV[ WN XMWXTM M^MZa_PMZM <PMa ZM[WVI\M _Q\P KWVÆQK\ UWZITQ\a [\ZQNM IVL ITQMVI\QWV 1V \PM ! [ /ZQЅ\P[ \]ZVML PQ[ I\\MV\QWV \W >QM\VIU ¹AW] LQLV¼\ PI^M \W JM I OMVQ][ QV ¼ \W _WZS W]\ \PI\ \PMZM _I[ [WUM\PQVO ^MZa QUXWZ\IV\ PIXXMVQVO QV >QM\VIU º /ZQЅ\P[ [IQL QV IV QV\MZ^QM_ QV \_W aMIZ[ JMNWZM PQ[ LMI\P ?WZSQVO NWZ \PM 5IOV]U XPW\W IOMVKa PM [PW_ML \PM PIZ[P ZMITQ\QM[ WN _IZ QV XPW\WOZIXP[ \PI\ _MZM WN\MV \WW KWV\ZW^MZ[QIT NWZ 5IOV]U \W [MTT 5W[\ _MZM VW\ [MMV ]V\QT X]JTQ[PML QV PQ[ JWWS >QM\VIU 1VK QV ! 1V .MJZ]IZa /ZQЅ\P[¼ LI]OP\MZ 3I\PMZQVM 0WTLMV IVVW]VKML \PI\ I NW]VLI\QWV [M\ ]X Ja /ZQЅ\P[ _W]TL M[\IJTQ[P IV I_IZL \W MVKW]ZIOM QVLMXMVLMV\ XPW\WOZIXPMZ[ _WZSQVO QV QV\MZVI\QWVIT KWVÆQK\ bWVM[ \W KWV\QV]M PQ[ TMOIKa WN KW^MZQVO [\WZQM[ W\PMZ_Q[M QOVWZML V *MPQVL /ZQЅ\P[ Q[ PQ[ XPW\W WN I _WUIV \IOOML _Q\P \PM LM[QOVI\QWV >6+ NWZ ¹>QM\VIUM[M KQ^QTQIV º

INTENSITY )QZKZM_[ WV I KIZZQMZ QV \PM ;W]\P +PQVI ;MI ZM[XWVL \W I ZMY]M[\ NWZ JWUJ [\ZQSM[ !

44

VIETNAM

TOP LEFT: JEFF MORGAN 04/ALAMY STOCK PHOTO; ALL OTHER PHOTOS: PHILIP JONES GRIFFITHS/MAGNUM PHOTOS

PHILIP JONES GRIFFITHS

BRAVERY This 10-year-old South Vietnamese soldier was referred to as a “little tiger,” 1968. AUGUST 2016

45

PHOTO CREDIT

COMPASSION American GIs show concern for a wounded >QM\ +WVO ÅOP\MZ _PQKP /ZQЅ\P[ [IQL sprang from a soldierly admiration for their enemy’s dedication IVL JZI^MZa !

46

VIETNAM

AUGUST 2016

47

CAMARADERIE ¹5MV SVM_ \W ÅTT ]X _Q\P \PM VI\]ZIT ^IZQM\aº WN _I\MZ /ZQЅ\P[ [IQL !

SORROW A refugee from U.S. bombing ÆMM[ _PI\ PIL JMMV I ¹[PW_KI[Mº LQ[\ZQK\ WN ;IQOWV !

48

VIETNAM

REGRET <PM WЅKMZ¼[ \ZIV[UQ[[QWV[ \W PIT\ \PM KTW[M IZ\QTTMZa []XXWZ\ KW]TL VW\ XMVM\ZI\M \PM UM\IT P]TT WN \PM ^MPQKTM _PMZM PM PIL \ISMV ZMN]OM 1968.

DARING ) [WTLQMZ NZWU \PM !\P 1VNIV\Za ,Q^Q[QWV ÅZM[ JIKS I\ \PM >QM\ +WVO L]ZQVO ÅOP\QVO QV \PM []J]ZJ[ WN ;IQOWV ;MKWVL[ TI\MZ \PM J]QTLQVO _I[ LMUWTQ[PML Ja I ZWKSM\ ! AUGUST 2016

49

They Came, and Died, to Keep the Past Upon Its Throne A war correspondent, on the front lines for five decades, tells why he doesn’t buy the argument that Saigon fell because the United States took away its logistic and air support By H.D.S. Greenway

The Americans Depart Upon joining the Washington Post in the summer of ! 1 UW^ML Ua NIUQTa \W ?I[PQVO\WV 7VM WN Ua ÅZ[\ assignments was to cover a press conference that Secretary of State Henry Kissinger had called in October of 1972 in which he stunned the world with the words “peace is at hand.” At long last the North Vietnamese, after torturous negotiations in Paris, had agreed to a KMI[M̆ÅZM WV W]Z \MZU[ PM [IQL .WZ \PW[M WN ][ QV \PM audience who had reported from Vietnam, it was an electrifying moment. We didn’t learn until later that Kissinger had trouble explaining the terms of his peace treaty to South Vietnam’s president, Nguyen Van Thieu. When he did so, Kissinger cabled President Richard Nixon from Saigon to say: “We face the paradoxical situation that the North, _PQKP PI[ MЄMK\Q^MTa TW[\ Q[ IK\QVO I[ QN Q\ _WV# _PQTM \PM ;W]\P _PQKP PI[ MЄMK\Q^MTa _WV Q[ IK\QVO I[ QN Q\ has lost. One of the major tasks now is to restore realities and get the psychological upper hand.” Kissinger 50

VIETNAM

thought that Thieu did not understand the scope of Hanoi’s concessions. But Thieu understood the situation better than Kissinger. “The issue is the life and death of South Vietnam and its 17 million people,” Thieu told the American ambassador, Ellsworth Bunker. “Our position is very unfortunate. We have been very faithful to the Americans, and now _M NMMT I[ QN _M IZM JMQVO [IKZQÅKML° 1N _M IKKMX\ \PM LWK]UMV\ I[ Q\ VW_ [\IVL[ _M _QTT KWUUQ\ []QKQLM°IVL I will be committing suicide.” <PQM] _I[ ZQOP\ <PM NI\IT ÆI_ QV 3Q[[QVOMZ¼[ XMIKM LMIT was that it allowed the North Vietnamese to maintain \PMQZ NWZKM[ LMMX QV[QLM ;W]\P >QM\VIU MЄMK\Q^MTa W]\ÆIVSQVO \PM ;W]\P IVL X]\\QVO \PM +MV\ZIT 0QOPTIVL[ QV peril should the North Vietnamese decide to attack again QV LMÅIVKM WN \PM \ZMI\a _PQKP Q[ M`IK\Ta _PI\ \PMa LQL .ZWU \PM JWWS .WZMQOV +WZZM[XWVLMV\ Ja 0 , ; /ZMMV_Ia +WXaZQOP\ Ja 0 , ; /ZMMV_Ia :MXZQV\ML Ja XMZUQ[[QWV of Simon & Schuster Inc.

OPPOSITE: COURTESY WILLIAM TUOHY

) 6I^IT :M[MZ^M WЅKMZ ,I^QL /ZMMV_Ia [\IZ\ML PQ[ KIZMMZ I[ I Time magazine war correspondent in Indochina QV [XZQVO ! ¹1\ _I[ >QM\VIU \PI\ WJ[M[[ML UM \PMV º /ZMMV_Ia [IQL IVL PM IKY]QZML I ZMX]\I\QWV NWZ JMQVO T]KSa 0Q[ T]KS ZIV W]\ QV 0]M L]ZQVO \PM <M\ ÅOP\QVO QV .MJZ]IZa ! _PMV PM _I[ PQ\ QV \PM TMO _PQTM PMTXQVO to carry a wounded Marine. 1V [XZQVO ! /ZMMV_Ia NW]VL PQU[MTN JIKS QV 0]M L]ZQVO \PM -I[\MZ 7ЄMV[Q^M ¹)UMZQKIV KWUJI\ \ZWWX[ were mostly gone, and it was going to be South Vietnam’s big test to see whether they could hold their own with American air and logistic support,” he said. The North Vietnamese Army launched one of its attacks along the My +PIVP :Q^MZ IN\MZ \PM NITT WN 9]IVO <ZQ +Q\a /ZMMV_Ia _ZW\M ¹?W]TL \PM ;W]\P >QM\VIUM[M ÆMM I[ \PMa PIL LWVM I\ 9]IVO <ZQ'º <PM ;W]\P >QM\VIUM[M UIZQVM[ IZUML _Q\P VM_ _QZM̆O]QLML IV\Q\IVS UQ[[QTM[ ÅZML IOIQV IVL IOIQV ¹1\ _I[ Y]Q\M I VQOP\ J]\ \PM 5a +PIVP TQVM PMTL º /ZMMV_Ia ZMXWZ\ML <_W UWV\P[ TI\MZ PM _I[ WЄMZML I RWJ _Q\P \PM Washington Post. In an excerpt from his recently published UMUWQZ /ZMMV_Ia TWWS[ JIKS WV _PI\ PM [I_ I[ \PM _IZ _I[ _QVLQVO LW_V.

PHOTO CREDIT

Bloodied in battle A wounded H.D.S. Greenway rests after being hit at Hue during the Communists’ February 1968 Tet 6ɈLUZP]L

AUGUST 2016

51

To be fair to Kissinger, he thought that if the North Vietnamese cheated on the peace agreement, the entire might of the United States could come down hard on the cheaters. But even as Kissinger was negotiating in Paris, the political will to continue the war was crumbling in the United States. American troops were leaving, and ConOZM[[ MЄMK\Q^MTa MVLML )UMZQKI¼[ ZM\ITQI\WZa KIXIJQTQ\QM[ Ja JIVVQVO IVa N]Z\PMZ IQZ[\ZQSM[ \PM NWTTW_QVO []UUMZ After some months, the Post named me as its bureau KPQMN QV 0WVO 3WVO _PMZM Ua NIUQTa [M\\TML J]\ Q\ _I[ to Saigon that the Post [MV\ UM MIZTa QV ! 1 [WWV LQ[KW^MZML 3Q[[QVOMZ¼[ KMI[M̆ÅZM _I[ QV VIUM WVTa >QM\VIUM[M WV JW\P [QLM[ _MZM [\QTT LaQVO JMKI][M MIKP [QLM _I[ \ZaQVO \W KWV[WTQLI\M Q\[ XW[Q\QWV IVL M`XIVL Q\[ \MZZQ\WZa <PM IOZMMUMV\ ITTW_ML NWZKM[ \W [\Ia QV XTIKM [W JW\P [QLM[ ZIQ[ML \PMQZ ÆIO[ W^MZ \PM \MZZQ\WZa \PMa KWV\ZWTTML <ZI^MTQVO IZW]VL \PM KW]V\Za[QLM 1 _I[ QV\MZM[\ML \W [MM PW_ UIVa LQ[\ZQK\[ _MZM ÆaQVO >QM\ +WVO ÆIO[ 5IVa WN \PM IZMI[ \PI\ \PM )UMZQKIV[ PIL \PW]OP\ XIKQÃ…ML IVL [WTQLTa ]VLMZ OW^MZVUMV\ KWV\ZWT _MZM VW\ 1V IKKWZLIVKM _Q\P \PM \ZMI\a )UMZQKIV \ZWWX[ _MZM \W TMI^M >QM\VIU NWZ\P_Q\P 7V 5IZKP ! \PM TI[\ KWV\QVOMV\ LMXIZ\ML NZWU ;IQOWV¼[ <IV ;WV 6P]\ )QZXWZ\ IJWIZL I [QT^MZ +̆ )QZ .WZKM RM\ [PWZ\Ta IN\MZ X U 1\ _I[ I LIa WN KMZMUWVQM[ IVL [XMMKPUISQVO =XWV KTW[QVO LW_V 5QTQ\IZa )[[Q[\IVKM +WUUIVL >QM\VIU /MVMZIT .ZMLMZQKS ?MaIVL [\WWL I\ I\\MV\QWV QV I []V52

VIETNAM

JISML XIZSQVO TW\ _PQTM I ZMKWZLQVO WN ¹<PM ;\IZ̆;XIVOTML *IVVMZº _I[ XTIaML W^MZ I TW]L[XMISMZ <PM OMVMZIT [IQL that the United States had accomplished its mission to ¹XZM^MV\ IV ITT̆W]\ I\\MUX\ Ja IV IOOZM[[WZ \W QUXW[M Q\[ _QTT \PZW]OP ZI_ UQTQ\IZa NWZKM º 0M [IQL \PI\ \PM ¹ZQOP\[ of the people of the Republic of Vietnam to shape their W_V LM[\QVa IVL \W XZW^QLM NWZ \PMQZ [MTN̆LM\MZUQVI\QWV PI[ JMMV ]XPMTL º <PQM] \PIVSML \PM )UMZQKIV[ NWZ ITT \PMa PIL LWVM QV ¹\PQ[ PQ[\WZQK [\Z]OOTM º )V ]OTa [KMVM XMZPIX[ UWZM ZQKP QV [aUJWTQ[U \PIV \PM WÐ…KQIT [XMMKPM[ \WWS XTIKM _PMV I KW]XTM WN P]VLZML >QM\VIUM[M KQ^QTQIV[ JZWSM \PZW]OP \PM _QZM M^MV JMNWZM \PM TI[\ )UMZQKIV PIL LMXIZ\ML <PMa TWW\ML \PM KWUUQ[[IZa IVL QV UQV]\M[ \PMa PIL LZIOOML W]\ \IJTM[ KPIQZ[ NIV[ KIVVML OWWL[¸M^MZa\PQVO \PI\ _I[V¼\ JWT\ML \W \PM ÆWWZ IVL [WUM \PQVO[ \PI\ _MZM ;W]\P >QM\VIUM[M UQTQ\IZa XWTQKM PMTXML \PMU UW^M \PM [\WTMV goods through the wire. *MKI][M \PM >QM\ +WVO _MZM IV`QW][ \W TMOQ\QUQbM \PMQZ IZMI[ WN KWV\ZWT QV \PI\ [XZQVO WN ! \PMZM _I[ IV WXXWZ\]VQ\a \W QV\MZ^QM_ \PMU \PI\ PILV¼\ JMMV XW[[QJTM JMNWZM .ZIVKM[ .Q\b/MZITL I RW]ZVITQ[\ WV I[[QOVUMV\ for the 6M_ AWZSMZ IVL 1 PI\KPML ]X I [KPMUM \W ^Q[Q\ the Viet Cong in their forest lair in the contested provQVKM WN +P]WVO <PQMV LMMX QV \PM 5MSWVO :Q^MZ LMT\I ?M LZW^M \PM ?I[PQVO\WV 8W[\¼[ KIZ LMMX QV\W \PM LMT\I IVL W]\[QLM I [UITT ^QTTIOM KITTML 4WVO 5a <PQ[

CLOCKWISE FROM TOP: AP PHOTO; AP PHOTO/FRANCES STERNER; AP PHOTO/NEAL ULEVICH

At the table Delegates from the United States, South Vietnam, the Viet Cong and North Vietnam sign the Paris Peace Accords, Jan. 27, 1973.

Ticket out A Catholic priest in Saigon watches a helicopter on the U.S. Embassy roof during an evacuation on April 29,1975.

Climbing to safety South Vietnamese attempting to escape a Communist takeover try to scale a 14-foot wall at the U.S. Embassy on April 29, 1975.

was a sort of no-man’s-land between government-controlled areas and the territory of the Provisional Revolutionary Government, as the Viet Cong called themselves. We had sent a small boy into the forest to make contact for us, taking a message saying we were American journalists who would like to tell their story to the world. After a wait that seemed hours long, armed men began to emerge from the tall grass at the forest’s edge. I was very nervous. They were surprisingly young. Only a few carried AK-47s, the standard Soviet assault rifle. Most were armed with captured American M16 rifles and grenade launchers. They carried American field radios too, and most wore dressy Seiko watches with expansion wristbands such as could be bought in the better shops in Saigon. There seemed to be some question of whether we were prisoners or guests, but eventually we were brought to a jungle camp, where a handsome man, obviously in authority, said: “We welcome you, and it does not matter if you are journalists or CIA because we have won the war.” Just before midnight we _MZM \WTL \PI\ I [MVQWZ WЅKQIT would receive us now. He was clearly an educated man. His conversation ran from battle to Vietnamese poetry. His drift was the absolute conviction that they had won the war. The importance of the Paris agreements was that the Americans had admitted their defeat. I contrast this certainty on the part of the Viet Cong with what the Americans were saying at the time. General Creighton Abrams thought Hanoi was agreeing to peace “because they [have] lost and they [know] it.” But the men of the forest thought otherwise. The Paris accords were just another milestone in the long history of Vietnamese fighting foreigners, said our host. The Americans were sim-

ply going the way of the “Mongols, the Chinese, the Japanese, the French.” These Provisional RevolutionIZa /W^MZVUMV\ WЅKQIT[ UILM VW MЄWZ\ \W PQLM \PM NIK\ \PI\ \PM North Vietnamese Army was also in the region. The Northerners had come to help their brothers in the South, they said, because there was only one Vietnam. We were given some food, and the talk went on and on into the small hours of the morning. When we started to nod, we were told that it wasn’t every day we got to talk to a high official and that we should stay awake. But it did begin to feel like Scheherazade working on her 900th tale. For Kissinger and Nixon, the peace accords had awarded them peace with honor, or so they thought. But, as I wrote for the Washington Post at the time: “To the PRG of Long My it seemed that peace with honor meant nothing less than the completion of the Vietnamese revolution started so long ago by Ho Chi Minh, and that the American withdrawal and the ceaseÅZM IOZMMUMV\ _MZM [QOVQÅKIV\ victories, but by no means the last step along that road.” That TI[\ [\MX _I[ VW\ NIZ WЄ The Fall of Saigon In the spring of 1975, on orders from the Washington Post, I went back to Saigon from Phnom Penh, where I had been for many weeks, just before that city fell to the implacable Khmer Rouge. South Vietnam appeared to be collapsing, and that was a bigger story in the eyes of the Post. The entire American enterprise in Indochina was falling apart with a speed no one had anticipated. Thieu, without telling his American allies, had decided on a military evacuation of the Central Highlands to consolidate his forces. The evacuation was illplanned and ended in panic and rout. Hue, Da Nang, Nha Trang AUGUST 2016

53

On the scene Laotian tribesmen supported by the United States are being evacuated in spring 1970 ahead of a North Vietnamese advance. Greenway is at the top left, reporting for Life magazine.

Trying to get out A South Vietnamese family crouched outside the U.S. Embassy in Saigon goes over evacuation plans on April 24, 1975.

54

VIETNAM

9PÅL H[ [OL YLHK` A Viet Cong soldier with an AK-47 participates in a militia exercise in the Mekong Delta in spring 1973. Greenway was in the delta interviewing =PL[ *VUN VɉJPHSZ during that period.

OPPOSITE, CLOCKWISE FROM TOP: COURTESY ARNOLD VON BOHLER; AP PHOTO; AP PHOTO/FRANJOLA

and all the coastal cities were falling as South Vietnam’s JMTW_ I[ _MTT I[ ÆW\QTTI[ WN PWXMTM[[Ta W^MZÅTTML JWI\[ XIKSML _Q\P >QM\VIUM[M TQSM ÆW\[IU IVL RM\[IU TMN\ WV once-proud army simply disintegrated. I quoted President Gerald Ford as having recently said the surface after a gigantic ship has gone down. I jotted in my notebook a quote from a James Russell \PI\ ¹\PM _QTT WN \PM ;W]\P >QM\VIUM[M XMWXTM \W ÅOP\ NWZ their freedom is best evidenced by the fact that they are Lowell poem that is inscribed near the graves of British redcoats who fell at Concord bridge back in MassachuÆMMQVO \PM 6WZ\P >QM\VIUM[M º ¹<PM WXXW[Q\M IXXMIZ[ \W JM \Z]M º 1 _ZW\M ¹)TT W^MZ [M\\[ QV \PI\ [IUM UWV\P aMIZ[ XZM^QW][Ta ¹<PMa \PM VWZ\PMZV XIZ\ WN \PM KW]V\Za \PM _QTT \W ÅOP\ ^IV- came three thousand miles, and died, to keep the past ished when the panic struck, and some of the South Viet- ]XWV \PM \PZWVM º ?M PIL KWUM UQTM[ \W >QM\VIU VIUM[M IZUa¼[ JM[\ ]VQ\[ LQ[[WT^ML _Q\PW]\ ÅZQVO I [PW\ to do the same thing. The evacuation went on through the night, the last When discipline was gone some of the soldiers vented their rage and frustration by looting and killing peo- JMQVO \ISMV WЄ \PM ZWWN MIZTa QV \PM UWZVQVO \PM VM`\ LIa _PMV 6WZ\P >QM\VIUM[M \IVS[ J]Z[\ ple, and many of the refugees speak with through the gates of Saigon’s presidential contempt and hatred about the venality 1V ! \PM palace. and corruption of the Saigon government. Russians were Many central Vietnamese hate the Saigon everywhere, Returning to Saigon OW^MZVUMV\ º Seven years later I returned to Saigon, <PQM] _I[ ÅVITTa XMZ[]ILML \W [\MX LW_V and despite all VW_ WЅKQITTa 0W +PQ 5QVP +Q\a IT\PW]OP IVL ÆM_ I_Ia QV\W M`QTM I[ \PM )UMZQKIV[ they had done everyone still called it Saigon. I checked in \ZQML \W ÅVL I ÅO]ZM UWZM IKKMX\IJTM \W \PM to help Hanoi to the Hotel Majestic, down by the waterCommunists. But the Communists were havfront. The last time I had seen it, there was during the war, ing none of it. a big hole in the facade where a rocket had )[ 6WZ\P >QM\VIUM[M NWZKM[ LZM_ KTW[MZ they were not hit during the ancient régime’s last days. strangers would clutch at foreigners in the popular. When 6W_ W]\[QLM \PM NZWV\ LWWZ \PM IJIVLWVML streets of Saigon begging to be rescued. Vietwalking through TMOIKa WN )UMZQKI¼[ TW[\ _IZ \PM UQ`ML̆ namese friends I had known for years would race children left behind, begged for coins. come with drawn faces to plead for help. It the streets, Upstairs, when the door to my room closed was hard to look into their eyes and not see children would behind me and the bellboy departed, to my an accusation of betrayal. shout “Russian, surprise I found myself in tears. )[ LIaTQOP\ JZWSM WV )XZQT ! ! [M^:][[QIV º 7VM )[ 1 UILM Ua ZW]VL[ QV\MZ^QM_QVO ;IQeral of us went across the street and up to gon’s new masters, it became clear that the roof of the Caravelle Hotel. With sinkkid threw a bag Southerners in what had been the Viet Cong ing stomachs we watched the lazy arc of WN M`KZMUMV\ PIL JMMV [PW^ML I[QLM Ja \PM 6WZ\PMZVMZ[ I PMI\̆[MMSQVO UQ[[QTM ZQ[M ]X IVL ÅVL Q\[ at me. and that everything was going to be done way to an airplane, which immediately Hanoi’s way. disintegrated. We knew that very few of Wrongheaded agricultural practices, abandoned in ][ _W]TL TMI^M \PM KQ\a ITQ^M QN \PM 6WZ\P >QM\VIUM[M LMKQLML \W WXXW[M \PM )UMZQKIV IQZ M^IK]I\QWV \PI\ _I[ later years, were being imposed on Southern farmers. 7VM IT[W [I_ [QOV[ \PI\ 6WZ\PMZVMZ[ _MZM \ISQVO TIZOM about to begin. AMIZ[ TI\MZ \PM 6WZ\P >QM\VIUM[M KWUUIVLMZ /MV- Y]IV\Q\QM[ WN T]`]Za OWWL[ NIV[ IQZ KWVLQ\QWVMZ[ M^MV eral Van Tien Dung, wrote that he had received instruc- refrigerators, away from Saigon to use in Hanoi and tions from Hanoi to press on with the attack on Saigon W\PMZ 6WZ\PMZV \W_V[ 1 [XMV\ -I[\MZ WN ! QV 0IVWQ \PM ÅZ[\ \QUM 1 PIL J]\ VW\ \W QV\MZNMZM _Q\P IV )UMZQKIV M^IK]I\QWV¸IV JMMV QV \PM 6WZ\P <PM KQ\a _I[ Z]V̆LW_V _Q\P VW\PQVO order that he protested but obeyed. )\ \PM MUJI[[a Q\[MTN _M NW]VL 5IZQVM O]IZL[ N]ZQ- for sale in the shops and depressed-looking people. But ously chopping down a tree in the courtyard behind the the old French colonial architecture was a delight. The chancery in order to make room for a helicopter landing Vietnamese today are tearing it down to make room for IZMI )UJI[[ILWZ /ZIPIU 5IZ\QV PIL ZMN][ML \W TM\ PQ[ the new, but I would still rate Hanoi as the most charm[\IЄ K]\ Q\ LW_V JMNWZM \PQ[ UWUMV\ JMKI][M PM \PW]OP\ QVO KQ\a QV ;W]\PMI[\ )[QI Easter Sunday dawned to a steady drizzle, but the IVa [QOV \PI\ )UMZQKIV[ UQOP\ JM IJIVLWVQVO ;IQOWV +I\PWTQK KI\PMLZIT _I[ N]TT \W W^MZNTW_QVO 1 PIL M`would sow panic among the Vietnamese. )[ UWZVQVO \]ZVML \W IN\MZVWWV \PM XIVQK \PI\ 5IZ- pected religion to be suppressed, but clearly the Comtin had feared came down upon us like a squall line. munist regime had decided not to be too strict in their Hundreds of Vietnamese headed for the embassy, all WЅKQIT I\PMQ[U The Russians were everywhere, and despite all they beseeching to be let in. When the helicopters arrived from the South China Sea, the wash from their rotors had done to help Hanoi during the war, they were not tore open the plastic bags awaiting burning, and thou- popular. When walking through the streets, children [IVL[ WN XIXMZ[ ÆM_ QV\W \PM IQZ QV I KWVNM\\Q WN [MKZM\[ _W]TL [PW]\ ¹:][[QIV :][[QIV º 7VM SQL \PZM_ I JIO WN I got aboard a helicopter just as it was getting dark. M`KZMUMV\ I\ UM 5a TI[\ \ZQX \W >QM\VIU QV ZM^MITML I KW]V\Za 1V \PM ;W]\P +PQVI ;MI IV )UMZQKIV ÆMM\ TIa _IQ\QVO AUGUST 2016

55

South Vietnam falls ;OL Ă„YZ[ *VTT\UPZ[ ; [HUR [V LU[LY [OL 7YLZPKLU[PHS 7HSHJL NYV\UKZ (WYPS

trying on the garments of capitalism while still keeping political control, much as China had done. Saigon was on its way to becoming a miniature Hong Kong with buildings sprouting and growing ever higher. Like all American visitors, I was surprised by the lack of bitterness. I got a good explanation of that when I met with Vietnamese WĐ…KQIT[ _PW _MZM Y]QKS \W [Ia \PI\ Q\ _I[ QUportant for Vietnam to have normal relations with the world’s leading power, especially with a growling China next door. “And it helps to have won,â€? said a veteran of that long war.

The Revisionists In the years since the fall of Saigon, revisionist theories have sprung up like weeds. It was said that we had actually won the war by 1972, that the South Vietnamese could have held on after our troops had left if only Congress had not closed down the war and refused to allow the United States to retaliate when the North Vietnamese broke everything agreed upon in Paris. But the South Vietnamese leader[PQX _I[ VM^MZ IJTM \W QV[\QTT I [MV[M WN LMLQKI\QWV IVL [IKZQÅKM NWZ their cause. The Communists represented nationalism, while the South always appeared to be the puppet of foreigners, and steeped in corruption at that. I had seen the South Vietnamese hold the My Chanh line against +WUU]VQ[\ I\\IKS QV \PM -I[\MZ 7ЄMV[Q^M WN ! _Q\P \PM PMTX WN )UMZQKIV ÅZMXW_MZ J]\ VW\ )UMZQKIV OZW]VL \ZWWX[ :M^Q[QWVQ[\[ have used this battle to say that if only we had supported the South in 1975, Saigon wouldn’t have lost the war. I do not buy that argument. Once the Paris Peace Accords allowed the North Vietnamese to ZMUIQV QV \PM +MV\ZIT 0QOPTIVL[ W]\ÆIVSQVO \PM ;W]\P >QM\VIUM[M the country’s fate was sealed. Besides, no matter how many times the North Vietnamese were halted, they always had the option to OW PWUM TQKS \PMQZ _W]VL[ IVL XZMXIZM NWZ aM\ IVW\PMZ WЄMV[Q^M 5IVa aMIZ[ IN\MZ \PM _IZ 1 UM\ NWZUMZ ,MNMV[M ;MKZM\IZa :WJMZ\ McNamara, who had just written a book admitting that he and the Kennedy and Johnson administrations had been all wrong about the war. He said he had never understood that the war was more about Vietnamese nationalism than it was about communism. He and a team of Americans journeyed to Hanoi to talk to Vietnamese about how it had all seemed from their point of view. The AmeriKIV[ PIL JMTQM^ML \PI\ QN \PMa QVÆQK\ML MVW]OP XIQV WV \PM >QM\VIUese—bombed them and killed them in great numbers—there would come a time when they would throw in the towel. When McNamara brought this up with his Vietnamese interlocutors, they told him, to the contrary, the bombing had actually increased morale. No strategy or tactic short of genocide, McNamara concluded, would have won the war for us. In Vietnam it was the other side who, in President John F. Kennedy’s words, were willing to pay any price, bear any burden, in defense of what they considered most QUXWZ\IV\" \PM ZM]VQÅKI\QWV WN \PMQZ KW]V\Za IVL \PM M`X]T[QWV WN foreign armies. V 56

VIETNAM

AP PHOTO/YVES BILLY

Americans believed if \PMa QVÆQK\ML enough pain on the Vietnamese— bombed them and killed them in great numbers— there would come a time when they would throw in the towel. The bombing had actually improved morale.

Advertisement

VETERANS DISCOVERING AFFORDABLE SOLAR GENERATOR – PRODUCES 1500 WATTS OF AC POWER FOR FREE! Breakthrough new device provides power during outages or when you’re on the go. NASHVILLE, TN – Frank Bates was living in a small northeast town when his electricity went out for the fourth time that winter. The result of a powerful nor’easter that knocked down trees and power lines, the blackout lasted for nine bonechilling days. In the middle of a vicious winter, his family had to endure life with no refrigeration for perishables, no electric stove for cooking, no televisions, no cellular telephones, no computers – and with no power for the pump, no water for drinking, washing or flushing. But the absolute worst of it was they had no heat. “That did it for me,” said Bates, “We were totally dependent on a giant utility company. And too often their power went out, even in nice weather. But they still had the gall to constantly demand rate increases. Their bills were killing us and their service plain stank. “Depending on that company for uninterrupted power was a fool’s game. Of course, the entire electrical system all across the country is so decrepit that I guess we should be happy it doesn’t go down more often than it does. Anyway, I decided I had to find a way to reduce my complete dependence on greedy utility companies.” Bates’s first step was to move to a warmer state where his energy needs would be reduced. Then, he set out on a mission to learn everything he could about the alternatives available to frustrated consumers who want to slash their ties with the mega-utilities. “First off, I knew I needed my own generator. But it had to be something I could easily move and take with me if we had to leave home quickly. But all the so-called portable generators on the market weighed a lot more than I can lift. Plus, many used something like 15 gallons of gas each day just to keep running. And that’s assuming gas will be available, and it may not be. What’s more, those things are all incredibly noisy, they smell awful, and their exhaust can literally kill you.” Bates quickly realized that a gas generator was not the answer he was looking for. Instead, he concluded the time had come for a lightweight portable generator that was not only powerful, but also 100% fueled by the sun. He had uncovered research that showed the technology for such a generator already existed. It had been proven again and again. However, it also showed he would have to get it designed and built from scratch. By a stroke of luck, a friend introduced Bates to a rogue engineering genius in Utah. “Just like me, he was sick of being held hostage by the electric company,” Bates explained. “And for over 20 years, he’d been working to perfect the use of solar energy around the world. He jumped at the opportunity to join forces with me to do something that hadn’t been done before. It was really very exciting. After all, we would be designing a completely new generator.” Bates specified that it had to be very affordable and it had to be portable. Also, he wanted it to operate as quietly as possible. And most importantly, it could not use even a single

PATRIOT POWER GENERATOR 1500 drop of gasoline. It took many months before the design of this breakthrough generator was complete. And months more before full production could begin. Bates says it was worth the wait. Thrilled with the performance of his new solar-powered generator, he named it the Patriot Power Generator 1500. Bates had accomplished everything he’d set out to do. “Finally,” he said with a grin, “I was able to thumb my nose at the massive utilities that were just about bleeding me dry. I immediately started saving real money. And, for the first time ever, I was confident that my family would have reliable electric power whenever they needed it.” This remarkable generator is actually able to operate safely and near-silently indoors to produce 1500 watts of continuous AC power – up to 3,000 watts peak. That’s enough to power a freezer to ensure a long-lasting supply of safe-to-eat food. Or to use a slow cooker, a toaster oven, even a coffee maker. With a Patriot Power Generator 1500, you could have enough lights for safety and comfort. You’d be able to charge your cell phones, laptops and tablets. Power an electric blanket so you can stay warm at night. Even keep certain essential medical devices operating. And much more. The heart of the Patriot Power Generator 1500 is a safe, stateof-the-art lithium-ion polymer (LiPo) battery that charges fully in 3.5 hours or less, using the included advanced-design folding solar panel. Surprisingly, the unit weighs just 38 pounds. It fits neatly into almost any cargo space, and is great to bring along if you go camping. It can be recharged up to 2,000 times, and holds a full charge for 6 months, so it’s instantly ready for use when you need it.

Interested parties can learn more about the Patriot Power Generator 1500, by logging onto BLACKOUT26.COM or by calling a special toll-free number 1-800-392-0306. Agents are standing by to take orders. Get started on the road to energy independence.

CALL 1-800-392-0306 OR GO TO BLACKOUT26.COM

Blood on His Hands: JFK’S Costly Blunders The Lost Mandate of Heaven: The American Betrayal of Ngo Dinh Diem, President of Vietnam Ja /MWЄZMa , < ;PI_ 1OVI\Q][ 8ZM[[

58

VIETNAM

Being re-evaluated President John F. Kennedy talks with Averell Harriman, assistant secretary of state for the Far East, on July 18,1963.

IT[W XWQV\ML \W PQ[ PMI^ăPIVLML Z]TM _PQKP ITQMVI\ML ;W]\P >QM\VIU¼[ XWX]TI\QWV IVL QVKZMI[ML \PM ZQ[S \PI\ \PM _IZ _W]TL JM TW[\ \W 6WZ\P >QM\VIUM[M·[XWV[WZML +WUU]VQ[\ O]MZZQTTI[ )KKWZLQVO \W \PQ[ KWV^MV\QWVIT ^QM_¸VW\IJTa I[ ;PI_ [PW_[ ZMTMV\TM[[Ta XZWUW\ML I\ \PM \QUM Ja ;IQOWV¼[ )UMZQKIV XZM[[ KWZX[ _PQKP LM[XQ[ML ,QMU¸ \PM ;W]\P >QM\VIUM[M XZM[QLMV\ PIL \W OW IVL \PMZMNWZM \PM 3MVVMLa ILUQVQ[\ZI\QWV R][\QÃ…IJTa KWTT]LML QV PQ[ ZMUW^IT ;PI_ XZM[MV\[ ,QMU I[ I LMLQKI\ML TMILMZ WN QV\MOZQ\a I XWX]TIZ >QM\VIUM[M VI\QWVITQ[\ LMMXTa KWU-

UQ\\ML \W PQ[ +I\PWTQK NIQ\P¼[ \MVM\[ Ã…ZUTa ZM[WT^ML VW\ WVTa \W XZW\MK\ PQ[ KW]V\Za IOIQV[\ 6WZ\P >QM\VIUM[M IOOZM[[QWV J]\ IT[W \W ZM[Q[\ JMKWUQVO UMZMTa I Ã…O]ZMPMIL IVL XI_V WN \PM )UMZQKIV[ +ITTQVO ,QMU¼[ U]ZLMZ ¹I UQ[\ISM WN ]VXIZITTMTML XZWXWZ\QWV º ;PI_ I[[MZ\[ \PI\ Q\ ZWJJML ;W]\P >QM\VIU WN \PM WVTa TMILMZ _PW[M NIUM [\I\]ZM IVL VI\QWVITQ[\ KZMLMV\QIT[ ZQ^ITML \PW[M WN \PM 6WZ\P¼[ 0W +PQ 5QVP 6W []J[MY]MV\ ;W]\P >QM\VIUM[M TMILMZ XZW^ML KIXIJTM WN QV[XQZQVO \PM KW]V\Za¼[ XWX]TI\QWV _Q\P \PM NMZ^WZ VMKM[[IZa \W []KKM[[N]TTa ZM[Q[\ 6WZ\P >QM\VIU

EVERETT COLLECTION HISTORICAL/ALAMY STOCK PHOTO

)T\PW]OP >QM\VIU ?IZ PQ[\WZQIV[ PI^M JMMV Y]QKS \W KZQ\QKQbM 8ZM[QLMV\[ ,_QOP\ , -Q[MVPW_MZ 4aVLWV * 2WPV[WV IVL :QKPIZL 5 6Q`WV NWZ \PMQZ MZZWZ[ QV [\ZI\MOa XWTQKa IVL R]LOUMV\ ZMOIZLQVO )UMZQKI¼[ QV^WT^MUMV\ QV \PM _IZ 2WPV . 3MVVMLa WN\MV OM\[ I ¹XI[[º¸PQ[ VIUM [MTLWU IXXMIZ[ WV \PM ¹[PWZ\ TQ[\º WN XZM[QLMV\[ _PW ¹TW[\º >QM\VIU /MWЄZMa ;PI_¼[ <PM 4W[\ 5IVLI\M WN 0MI^MV PW_M^MZ UISM[ I [WTQL KI[M \PI\ 3MVVMLa IVL PQ[ \WX IL^Q[MZ[¸XIZ\QK]TIZTa ? )^MZMTT 0IZZQUIV¼[ QVÆ]MV\QIT ;\I\M ,MXIZ\UMV\ KTQY]M¸WZKPM[\ZI\ML ¹I XWTQ\QKIT LQ[I[\MZ \PI\ TML )UMZQKI QV\W I XZW\ZIK\ML IVL KW[\Ta _IZ º ;PI_¼[ JWWS ZM^MIT[ 3MVVMLa¼[ LQ[I[\ZW][ JT]VLMZ[ \PI\ UIa PI^M TW[\ \PM >QM\VIU ?IZ JMNWZM \PM =VQ\ML ;\I\M[ JMOIV Ã…OP\QVO Q\ QV MIZVM[\ )[ Q\[ []J\Q\TM XZWUQ[M[ ;PI_¼[ JWWS XZQVKQXITTa NWK][M[ WV \PM 3MVVMLa ILUQVQ[\ZI\QWV¼[ ¹JM\ZIaITº IVL KWTT][QWV¸I\ \PM ^MZa TMI[\ Q\[ IKY]QM[KMVKM¸QV \PM 6W^ ̆ ! UQTQ\IZa KW]X \PI\ ZM[]T\ML QV \PM I[[I[[QVI\QWV WN ;W]\P >QM\VIUM[M 8ZM[QLMV\ 6OW ,QVP ,QMU ;PI_¼[ QUIOM WN ,QMU JI[ML WV M`\MV[Q^M ZM[MIZKP WZQOQVIT [W]ZKM[ IVL LMKTI[[QÃ…ML LWK]UMV\[ [PIZXTa KWV\ZI[\[ _Q\P \PM _QLMTa IKKMX\ML ^QM_ WN ;W]\P >QM\VIU¼[ Ã…Z[\ XZM[QLMV\ ,QMU PI[ \aXQKITTa JMMV XWZ\ZIaML I[ I KWZZ]X\ LM[XW\ _PW [\]JJWZVTa QOVWZQVO )UMZQKIV IL^QKM UMZKQTM[[Ta XMZ[MK]\ML \PM KW]V\Za¼[ *]LLPQ[\ UIRWZQ\a QV NI^WZ WN PQ[ NMTTW_ +I\PWTQK[ +ZQ\QK[

Even if you are unswayed by Shaw’s revisionist presentation of Diem’s character and leadership, you have to question the Orwellian logic of the Kennedy administration’s support for his removal: Led by the Harriman faction, Kennedy’s top advisers concluded that Diem was not “democratic enough” to suit them, so they colluded in a bloody coup d’état that murdered Diem and replaced his elected government with a military dictatorship! The Kennedy administration’s complicity in the military cabal’s coup was hardly a shining example of democracy in action. Even North Vietnam’s leadership was astonished that the United States had conspired to eliminate the South Vietnamese leader the Communists most feared.

Shaw also recounts another inexcusable Kennedy blunder that arguably was his administration’s worst mistake LQZMK\Ta QVÆ]MVKQVO \PM war: the egregiously inept decision binding the United States by interna\QWVIT \ZMI\a \W WЅKQITTa honor the “neutrality” of Laos. Signed in Geneva on July 23, 1962, by the United States and 14 other nations—notably North Vietnam and its principal Communist supporters, China and the Soviet Union, who enthusiastically approved it—the one-sided treaty, based on “unenforceable neutrality,” was a farce from inception. Hanoi immediately violated the agreement, sending thousands of North Vietnamese Army troops (joining Laotian Communist allies, the Pathet Lao) to occupy Laos’ entire eastern half and construct the extensive logistical network,

known as the Ho Chi Minh Trail, which was vital for North Vietnam’s prosecution of the war. North Vietnam had maintained logistical routes and bases in Laos since at least 1958 to supply Viet Cong guerrillas in South Vietnam. It is hardly an exaggeration to state that every American killed in ground combat in South Vietnam during the war died from a bullet, rocket-propelled grenade, mortar round, artillery shell or hand grenade brought south via the Ho Chi Minh Trail. There was no other practical means for Hanoi to get the instruments of death south other than through “neutral” Laos. Thanks to Kennedy’s unconscionably foolish Laos treaty—“forged by Harriman,” Shaw points out— North Vietnam had free rein to exploit this monumental advantage. Although the United States bombed the Laotian trails, the massive MЄWZ\ _I[ LQ[IXXWQV\QVOTa QVMЄMKtual. And the ill-fated 1971 Laos

incursion by U.S.-supported South Vietnamese ground troops proved far too little and much too late. Shaw’s insightful book shows that Vietnam War historians must stop giving Kennedy a pass. Clearly, Kennedy has blood on his hands— Diem’s and that of an untold number of American GIs. —Jerry D. Morelock

A Noble Cause: American *I\\TMĂ…MTL >QK\WZQM[ QV >QM\VIU by Douglas Niles, Berkley Caliber, 2015 Those who enjoy reading accounts of American ground combat actions in the Vietnam War will undoubtedly like this book on battles fought and won by the Army and

MEET ME IN VIETNAM JOHN BLACK

Thirty great, original gut-wrenching songs written and sung from the heart. FEATURING

Go to YouTube for latest John Black Music Videos: Dear Dad, and I’m Just Hangin’ On

Visit John Black’s website at www.meetmeinvietnam.net Two-CD set available at www.cdbaby.com and Apple iTunes at Meet Me In Vietnam, John Black

Order directly from John Black at 206-353-0979

White Water Red Hot Lead A nonfiction story about Swift Boat duty Vietnam 1967 and 1968

Author Dan Daly was the officer in charge of PCF 76. It begins in Coronado and brings you on board their patrols out of Da Nang, Chu Lai and Cua Viet. Operating with other crews, the stories cover blistering firefights, brutal weather and comradeship of Swift Boat duty. Tempered by humor and a touch of romance.

“Did our job well and proud of our service� Buy your summer reading today!

whitewaterredhotlead.com

the Marine Corps between 1965 and 1972. It covers the engagements you would expect to be included—Operation Starlight (1965), Ia Drang (1965), Operation Attleboro (1966), Iron Triangle (1967), Operation Junction City (1967), Siege of Khe Sanh (1968), Tet Offensive (1968) and Hamburger Hill (1969)—but also discusses some that are less well known, such as 5IZQVM IK\QWV[ I\ \PM ÅZ[\ JI\\TM WN 3PM ;IVP ! IVL \PM ÅOP\ \W secure Dong Ha (1968). The book features 14 battles, and \PM ÅVIT IK\QWV )V 4WK ! Q[ I departure from the others, which were waged by U.S. Army and Marine ground forces. The Battle WN )V 4WK WVM WN \PM SMa ^QK\Wries during the North Vietnamese -I[\MZ 7ЄMV[Q^M _I[ NW]OP\ IVL won by the Army of the Republic of Vietnam, accompanied by U.S. advisers and decisively supported by American air power. The battle is a welcome addition, showcasing the often-overlooked but vital role XTIaML Ja )UMZQKIV WЅKMZ[ IVL VWVKWUUQ[[QWVML WЅKMZ[ NZWU ITT the services who trained, guided IVL _PMV VMKM[[IZa I[ I\ )V 4WK fought alongside their South Vietnamese counterparts. After a brief introduction, chapters on each of the 14 combat actions are presented in chronological order. These are all solid accounts, which is to be expected, since it seems from the short bibliography that the author has based them XZQUIZQTa WV WЅKQIT PQ[\WZQM[ X]Jlished by the U.S. Army Center of Military History and the U.S. Marine Corps History and Museums Division. All 16 maps are reproduced from the ones created for \PW[M WЅKQIT PQ[\WZQM[ 5IVa WN \PM Army and Marine Corps histories, however, can be read in full online— readers seeking new information and fresh insight on these battles _WVŸ\ ÅVL \PMU QV A Noble Cause. A further criticism is that the JWWS MVL[ IJZ]X\Ta _Q\P )V 4WK 1\

9LHW 1DP 5HPHPEHUHG 1Kӟ 9LӋW 1DP ȼɨɫɩɨɦɢɧɚɧɢɹ ȼɶɟɬɧɚɦɫɤɢɟ

$Q DOEXP RI 6QDSVKRWV IURP D 6ROGLHU 9,(7 1$0 5(0(0%(5(' LV D SKRWRJUDSKLF PHPRLU RI 9LHWQDP LQ WKH PLG V E\ $UP\ 6WDII 6HUJHDQW -RKQ +XGDQLVK ZKR VSRNH 9LHWQDPHVH DQG WRRN WKH SKRWRV LQFOXGHG LQ WKLV ERRN

66* +XGDQLVK SKRWRV FDSWXUH VFHQHV RI HYHU\GD\ OLIH LQ 6DLJRQ &DQ 7KR 1KD 7UDQJ .RQWXP DQG 3OHLNX +H ZURWH KLV PHPRLU LQ WKUHH ODQJXDJHV (QJOLVK 9LHWQDPHVH DQG 5XVVLDQ IRU D ZLGHU DXGLHQFH

$YDLODEOH LQ VRIW FRYHU IURP

ZZZ YLHWQDPUHPHPEHUHG XV

-RKQ +XGDQLVK ɂɜɚɧ ɏɭɞɚɧɢɱ

Derl Horn shares an

/HW EH \RXU 9LHWQDP &RPEDW 7RXU JXLGH JHW \RX EDFN LQ FRXQWU\ -RLQ WKLV \HDU DV ZH FRQWLQXH WKH &RPPHPRUDWLRQV DV FRPEDW XQLWV EHJDQ 6HDUFK 'HVWUR\ 2SV LQ HDUQHVW

9LHWQDP 9HWHUDQ 2ZQHG 2SHUDWHG VLQFH

"

" % " #! " % # " % # ! $

&DOO WROO IUHH 6HH XV DW HPDLO

of his memories of being drafted into the Marine Corps during the height of the Vietnam War. From the moment the drill instructor slammed the bus door shut at the San Diego airport as a recruit to fighting on the war torn battlefields of Vietnam, he shares his struggles, the horrors of war, the support of family and friends, and the stabilizing power of his faith in God.

www.bloodsweatandhonor.ga and Available on Amazon

“To you, it’s the perfect lift chair. To me, it’s the best sleep chair I’ve ever had.� — J. Fitzgerald, VA It’s a “Sleep Chair�– for a comfortable and relaxing night’s sleep

It’s a “Lift Chairâ€?– that puts your feet safely on the oor – you’re ready to go! ÂŽ

It’s a “Chair�– for crafting, eating, visiting with friends and family

The Perfect Sleep Chair

It’s a “Sit Back Chair�– for reading, watching TV and resting

1-888-639-6890

Call now toll free for our lowest price. Please mention code 103513.

2500+ Military Designs Army, Navy, Air Force, Marines

Call now! Toll-free! 1-888-223-1159

• Custom pins & patches available. Dealer inquiries welcome.

HONORS by Hoover’s Mfg., Co. Dave@hmchonors.com www.hmchonors.com P.O. Box 547VN, Peru, IL 61354 Fax: 1-815-223-1499

C A P S

BUCKLES • PAT C H E S

FREE COLOR CATALOG

B A L L

• • • •

UR Y! YO A K D O TO BO UR TO

• HAT PINS • MEDALS •

46402

´7KH ERWWRP OLQH LV WKH ZDU LV RYHU ,W UHDOO\ ZDVQ¡W RYHU WLOO , ZHQW EDFN ´ *HQ 1RUPDQ 6FKZDU]NRSI LQ

EXCITING, POWERFUL AND TRUE STORY

TOGETHER THEN. TOGETHER AGAIN.

For information on placing a Direct Response or Marketplace ad in Print and Online contact us today: Vietnam 800.649.9800 / Fax: 800.649.6712 / viet@russelljohns.com / www.russelljohns.com

Golden 50th Anniversary Tours It has been over 50 years since the 173rd Airborne and the US Marines began combat operations in Vietnam. Return with us to historic battlefields, villages and famous cities where you spent part of your youth. Bring your family, your friends and buddies. Consider a reunion in Vietnam! We have a variety of tour programs to suit your interests. Check them out on our website today!

Vietnam History and Culture Tours III Corps and Central Highlands April 2016 - accepting reservations I Corps: Khe Sanh to Quy Nhon IV Corps: The Mekong Delta Panorama of Vietnam: The Best All-Country Tour

Your places & your dates for individuals, families, buddies or groups Our second decade of exceptional tours! Vietnam Veteran Owned and Operated

PO Box 340 • Flourtown PA 19031 Ph. 215-248-2572 • Email: MilSpectours@aol.com

Webpage • www.gomilspec.com

CLASSIFIEDS ANTIQUES/COLLECTIBLES COLLECTOR BUYS Vietnam War letters, documents, photographs, buttons, posters, pamphlets, artifacts, etc. No weapons. Contact Stuart: StuartKL@aol.com or (877) 428-9362.

BOOKS/PUBLICATIONS TITLE: “BLUE WATER RED BLOOD”, AUTHOR: JED MAITLAND-CARTER. Description: Duty, Honor, Courage. Available on Amazon. 99 cent download.

SPECIAL EVENTS 7/13TH ARTILLERY (VIETNAM) REUNION ALL RED DRAGON BATTERIES. Louisville, KY, Embassy Suites. September 28th - October 2nd. Call Robert Adams: (859) 806-5199 or Jon Taylor: (603) 677-6570.

_W]TL PI^M JMVMÅ\\ML NZWU I ÅVIT KPIX\MZ QV _PQKP \PM I]\PWZ UQOP\ PI^M [PIZML PQ[ \PW]OP\[ IVITa[M[ IVL KWVKT][QWV[ JMaWVL \PW[M JZQMÆa \W]KPML ]XWV QV \PM QV\ZWL]K\QWV IVL QV PQ[ KTW[QVO [MV\MVKM[ QV MIKP WN \PM JI\\TM KPIX\MZ[ .WZ M`IUXTM _PI\ KWUUWV \PZMIL[¸TMILMZ[PQX \IK\QKIT [SQTT ÅZMXW_MZ IVL UWJQTQ\a \PM KW]ZIOM IVL [IKZQÅKM WN [WTLQMZ[ IVL 5IZQVM[¸_MZM \PM SMa[ \W \PM[M JI\\TMÅMTL ^QK\WZQM[ [XIVVQVO [M^MV aMIZ[' 6WZ LW _M TMIZV PW_ \PM I]\PWZ KPW[M \PM \Q\TM# XZM[]UIJTa Q\¼[ NZWU :WVITL :MIOIV¼[ )]O][\ ! XZM[QLMV\QIT VWUQVI\QWV IKKMX\IVKM [XMMKP" ¹1\¼[ \QUM _M ZMKWOVQbM \PI\ W]Z[ _I[ QV \Z]\P I VWJTM KI][M º <PMZM Q[ ^MZa TQ\\TM LQ[K][[QWV WN ¹\PM KI][M º 6M^MZ\PMTM[[ \PM JWWS XZW^QLM[ I PIVLa KWTTMK\QWV WN KWVKQ[M [\IVLIZL JI\\TM PQ[\WZQM[ QV I [QVOTM [W]ZKM ¸2MZZa , 5WZMTWKS <PM 5 *I\\TM :QÆM Ja 4MZWa <PWUX[WV 7[XZMa 8]JTQ[PQVO 7`NWZL -VOTIVL )\ \PM JMOQVVQVO WN \PM >QM\VIU ?IZ \PM UIQV[\Ia )UMZQKIV TWVO IZU _I[ \PM /IZIVL 5 [MUQI]\WUI\QK ZQÆM WN ?WZTL ?IZ 11 NIUM# I\ Q\[ KWVKT][QWV Q\ _I[ \PM 5 *]\ NWZ \PM LMKILM WZ [W QV JM\_MMV = ; NWZKM[ ZMTQML XZQUIZQTa WV \PM 5 <PM XZWL]K\ WN I XZW\ZIK\ML LM^MTWXUMV\ M`IKMZJI\ML Ja [Y]IJJTM[ _Q\PQV 6)<7 \PM 5 ][ML \PM [IUM UU J]TTM\ QV I UŬTWVO KI[M ]T\QUI\MTa ILWX\ML Ja 6)<7 IVL ][ML QV \PM *MTOQIV̆UILM .6 .)4 ZQÆM <PM TI\\MZ JMKIUM 6)<7¼[ XZQVKQXIT _MIXWV J]\ \PM =VQ\ML ;\I\M[ KPW[M \PM 5 IVL ÅZ[\ ÅZML Q\ QV IVOMZ QV >QM\VIU <PM _MIXWV¼[ PMN\QMZ [QbM IVL _MQOP\ KIUM ]VLMZ KWV[\IV\ KWUXIZQ[WV _Q\P \PW[M WN Q\[ QV\MVLML []KKM[[WZ \PM 5 <PM 5 PW_M^MZ WЄMZML OZMI\MZ ZMTQIJQTQ\a IVL TWVŎZIVOM [\WXXQVO XW_MZ IVL [WUM ZMOIZLML Q\ I[ \PM JM[\ ZQÆM \W [MM )UMZQKIV [MZ^QKM *]\ W\PMZ[ KWV[QLMZML Q\ I NIQT]ZM JMKI][M WN Q\[ [PWZ\ [MZ^QKM TQNM JMNWZM I[[I]T\ ZQÆM[ TQSM \PM 5 IVL )3̆ MKTQX[ML Q\ 1V <PM 5 *I\\TM :QÆM 4MZWa <PWUX[WV _PW ][ML \PM 5 QV KWUJI\ OQ^M[ I LM\IQTML \ZMI\UMV\ WN Q\[ LM^MTWXUMV\ Q\[ UIVa ^IZQIV\[ Q\[ [MZ^QKM ][M IVL Q\[ XMZNWZUIVKM )T\PW]OP \PM = ; )ZUa IVL 5IZQVM[ ][ML \PM 5 UIQVTa QV >QM\VIU Q\ _I[ VM^MZ KWUXTM\MTa IJIVLWVML ) [MZQM[ WN 5 [ [XMKQITTa UILM NWZ IKK]ZIKa QV UIZS[UIV[PQX KWUXM\Q\QWV[ M^WT^ML QV\W \PM @5 IVL 5 [VQXMZ ZQÆM[ \PI\ ITWVO _Q\P \PM 5 [I_ M`\MV[Q^M ][M QV KWVÆQK\[ NZWU >QM\VIU \W )NOPIVQ[\IV >IZQIV\[ WN \PM 5 IZM [\QTT ][ML Ja UIVa IZUQM[ IVL Q\[ XWX]TIZQ\a PI[ SMX\ \PM ZQÆM QV KQ^QTQIV ][M ) OWWL UIVa WN \PW[M 5 [ IZM TQKMV[M̆XZWL]KML Ja QZWVQKITTa \_W J][QVM[[M[ QV \PM 8MWXTM¼[ :MX]JTQK WN +PQVI I []XXWZ\MZ WN \PM MVMUa \PI\ )UMZQKIV[ _MZM \ZaQVO \W SQTT _Q\P \PM ZQÆM QV >QM\VIU )]\PWZ <PWUX[WV UIVIOML \W []UUIZQbM \PM 5 ¼[ M^WT]\QWV NZWU KWVKMX\QWV \W WJRMK\ WN [MV\QUMV\ QV I [IOI aM\ \W MVL¸IVL \W XIZIXPZI[M \PM /ZI\MN]T ,MIL _PI\ I TWVO [\ZIVOM \ZQX Q\¼[ JMMV ¸2WV /]\\UIV AUGUST 2016

63

A dog’s best friend Jon Provost made his mark on American popular culture at the tender age of 7, when he played Timmy 5IZ\QV QV \PM KTI[[QK <> [PW_ Lassie. Provost, who had

started acting as a toddler in 1953, played Timmy for seven years ! ̆ [\IZZQVO _Q\P 2]VM 4WKSPIZ\ IVL 0]OP :MQTTa I[ PQ[ adoptive parents. Provost left showbiz at 18 and moved to Northern California. In 2008 he wrote his autobiography, Timmy’s in the Well. Today Provost still does some acting and is an active supporter of IVQUIT ZQOP\[ 0M PI[ [MZ^ML WV \PM JWIZL WN +IVQVM +WUXIVQWV[ for Independence for more than two decades. The red-checkered sports shirt and blue jeans Timmy wore are in the Smithsonian 1V[\Q\]\QWV¼[ 6I\QWVIT 5][M]U WN )UMZQKIV 0Q[\WZa 8ZW^W[\¼[ website is www.jonprovost.com.

On Lassie’s continuing popularity: We did over 250 PITN̆PW]Z MXQ[WLM[ 5WZM \PIV aMIZ[ TI\MZ \PM [PW_ is still on in over 50 countries. I get fan mail from all over the world. I’ll be walking down the street or in a supermarket, and somebody will come up to me and say, “Excuse me. You look like that boy who was on Lassie.” It’s good because nobody ever came up and said they hated Lassie. What the show meant to the troops in Vietnam: I got a letter from a veteran who said that while he was in the hospital they ran some Lassie episodes on TV and he was able to escape mentally, if only for half an hour, and NWZOM\ PQ[ W_V XIQV IVL MVRWa \PM [PW_ 0M [IQL ¹AW] OW\ quite a few of us through some hard times.” 64

VIETNAM

Growing out of the part: I had a seven-year contract. The studio wanted to extend it for three more years, but I was 14. I was tired of being Timmy. I was going through puberty. I was looking at girls, and they were looking at me like I was that little boy. I wanted out. Supporting the troops: After Lassie, I did a lot of USO shows in the States. Lassie and I would do a little show on the stage. And I’d talk to the guys. On June Lockhart: June Lockhart is doing great; just turned 90 and is still working. For years we’ve talked about doing a remake of Lassie, where I have moved to the big city and have a family and want to get back to my roots, back to the farm. But producers would rather do Naked and Afraid or something. Supporting war dogs: When we left Vietnam, we left \PM LWO[ 1\ _I[ PWZZQJTM 6W_ \PIVS /WL CUQTQ\IZaE dogs are adopted by their handlers when they return. The United States War Dogs Association sends care packages all over the world—mainly Afghanistan, to \PM O]a[ NWZ \PMQZ LWO[¸_Q\P \ZMI\[ IVL \Wa[ IVL [\]Є They asked if I would get a photograph of me and Lassie to include in this package. I’m signing 4,000 photos, and I hope it brings a smile to their faces. ¸1V\MZ^QM_ Ja 5IZK 4MMX[WV

LEFT: PHOTO BY CBS PHOTO ARCHIVE/GETTY IMAGES; RIGHT: COURTESY JON PROVOST

How he got the role in Lassie: I had already been in more than 10 movies and some early live television. In 1956 the producers of Lassie were looking for a young boy to replace Tommy :M\\QO _PW XTIaML 2MЄ C5QTTMZ QV \PM ÅZ[\ \PZMM [MI[WV[E 0M had outgrown the part. I met with the proL]KMZ[ <PMa _IV\ML UM \W JM <QUUa CQV I ZM^IUXML [PW_E J]\ I[SML QN 1 OW\ ITWVO _Q\P JQO LWO[ 1 PIL IT_Ia[ been raised around animals so that wasn’t a problem. But they couldn’t fake the bond between Lassie and the JWa [W 1 _MV\ \W [\Ia _Q\P 4I[[QM I\ CIVQUIT \ZIQVMZE Rudd Weatherwax’s ranch outside LA for a weekend, and Lassie and I got along. I always like to say I got two paws up from Lassie, and that got me the job.

0W_ \PQVO[ _MZM LQЄMZMV\ \PMV" I would get hundreds of pieces of fan mail, and my mother would answer all of them. She would put our return address on the envelope and even our telephone number. People would show up to our house unexpectedly, but they _W]TLV¼\ JM Z]LM 5WU _W]TL MVL up bringing some of these kids to \PM [\]LQW 1\ _I[ I LQЄMZMV\ \QUM

LIBRARY OF CONGRESS

...like Winston Churchill, Rosa Parks or Jesse James Search PERSONALITIES at HistoryNet.com More than 5,000 articles available online HistoryNet.com

TO RECOGNIZE VIETNAM VETERANS & HONOR RECIPIENTS

★★

Featuring the Vietnam Medal & Ribbon, the Vietnam Memorial Wall, Gleaming Black Onyx Capstone -PLUS 10 Brilliant Personal Birthstones

o Mark the 50th Anniversary of The Vietnam War we present our unique commemorative ring to honor your Service to Country.

T

• The entire ring is crafted of pure Sterling Silver, heavily plated in 24 Karat Gold, antiqued and polished by hand. The inner band is smooth and solid for comfort fit. OUR RINGS ARE NEVER HOLLOWED OUT!

• Your ring will be CUSTOM MADE TO ORDER IN AMERICA, by one of the oldest and finest makers of Commemorative Military Jewelry.

• As a permanent mark of exclusivity, your ring will be engraved on the inner band with your initials, Service Branch and the year dates of your service.

• The unique ring top features powerful hand-chiseled lettering of the word VIETNAM set across a gleaming black onyx Capstone, then framed by ten of your personal birthstones.

INTEREST-FREE PAYMENT PLAN “Thank you� priced at a remarkably low $199*, an affordable payment plan is also available. See order form for details. Your 100% satisfaction is guaranteed or you may return your ring within 30 days for replacement or refund – no questions asked. So, order yours today!

• Your Vietnam Medal & Ribbon, hand-enameled in its Official Colors are richly displayed on one shank. • The opposite shank is a bold sculpture of an emotional Veteran visiting the Vietnam Memorial Wall and the words "YOU ARE NOT FORGOTTEN.� • Honor recipients may choose to have their Purple Heart, Silver Star or Bronze Star Medal & Ribbon in place of the Memorial Wall shank.

SHOWN WITH WHITE ZIRCON BIRTHSTONES

HONOR RECIPIENTS May choose to have their Medal/Ribbon in place of the “Memorial Wall� shank.

Purple Heart

FREE FLAG PIN WITH ORDER

Silver Star

Bronze Star

YOUR CHOICE OF BIRTHSTONE: JANUARY

FEBRUARY

MARCH

APRIL

MAY

JUNE

GARNET

AMETHYST

AQUAMARINE

WHITE ZIRCON

EMERALD

ALEXANDRITE

JULY

AUGUST

SEPTEMBER

OCTOBER

NOVEMBER

DECEMBER

RUBY

PERIDOT

SAPPHIRE

ROSE ZIRCON

GOLDEN SAPPHIRE

BLUE ZIRCON

BIRTHSTONES ARE SIMULATED FOR SIZE & CLARITY. NAMES REFER TO COLORS, WHICH MAY VARY SOMEWHAT.

FOR FASTEST SERVICE CALL TOLL FREE TO ORDER: Monday - Friday from 9am - 5pm EST. Have Credit card and ring size ready when ordering.

Or, Mail to: Veterans Commemoratives™ 50th Anniversary Vietnam Rings • Two Radnor Corporate Center, Suite 120, Radnor, PA 19087-4599

â?‘ YES. I wish to order my Vietnam Veteran Ring, personalized with my birthstones & engraved with my initials, Service Branch and the years I served. INITIALS DESIRED (3): ________

________

________

BRANCH: â?‘Army â?‘Navy â?‘Air Force â?‘Marine Corps â?‘Coast Guard SERVICE YRS: ______ to ______ RING SIZE: _____ Use sizer below or consult jeweler.

� I am a Honor Medal Recipient - Put my Medal/Ribbon in place of the “Wall.� � Purple Heart � Silver Star � Bronze Star NOTE: A copy of your DD214 or other authorizing document must be sent with your order. Thank you.

3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14

I NEED SEND NO MONEY NOW. Bill me in four monthly installments of $ 49.75* each, with the first payment due prior to shipment. SHIPPING ADDRESS (We CANNOT ship to P.O. Boxes) Allow 6-8 weeks for delivery. Name ______________________________________________________ Address______________________________________________________ City_________________________________ State____ Zip ____________ Signature ____________________________________________________ Phone # ______________________ Email__________________________ *Plus $19.95 for engraving, shipping & handling. PA residents add 6% sales tax. ($13.14)

BARRINBRS-VTN-0816

Š ICM 2016

FOR OTHER FINE MILITARY VETERAN WAR RINGS, WATCHES AND COMMEMORATIVES VISIT US ONLINE AT WWW.VETCOM.COM

Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.