Water Dog Lake Park and Open Space by ShaunWagner

WATERDOG LAKE PARK & OPEN SPACE 2021 Park Entrance Re-design Proposal submitted to the City of Belmont at the invitation of CityWrights Collaborative

Shaun Wagner Senior Design Project DES-505 Spring 2021

Table of Contents Chapter 1: Introducing the Project 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 8. 10. 12. 13. 16. 18.

Abstract Introduction Problem Statement Purpose Statement City Of Belmont Vision Statement Significance Assumptions Project Scope / Parameters Preliminary Research Project Timeline Definitions of Terms Three Possible Hypotheses

Chapter 3: Procedural Methodologies 36. 37. 40. 41. 43. 45. 47. 49. 51. 53. 55. 57. 59. 61. 63. 65. 67.

Chapter 2: Research Methodologies 20. 21. 23. 25. 27. 30. 31.

Introduction Project Partners Panel of Experts Personas: Beneficiaries and Stakeholders Park User Story Board Scenarios Early Survey / Data Conclusions Final Hypothesis / Proposed Solution

Introduction Problem Statement / Purpose Statement Project Goals Comparative Analysis: Information + Signage Matrix Mapping: Information + Signage Comparative Analysis: Waste Management + Water Feature Comparative Analysis: Visual Appearance + Materials Matrix Mapping: Visual Appearance + Materials Proposed Solutions: Before Map Proposed Solutions: After Map Design Inspiration: Structure + Aesthetics Concept Ideation + Development Material Selection + Visual Appearance Proposed Solutions: Park Entrance Station Proposed Solutions: Mini-Mural Park Entrance Gate Proposed Solutions: Park Entrance Portal Alternate Solutions: Toilet Screening Chapter 4: Procedural Methodologies

71. 73. 75. 77. 79. 81. 83.

Branding Solution Solution Matrix / Beneficiaries User Experience Comparative Analysis Proof of Concept Next Steps Conclusion

Appendix Bibliography Dimensions Survey Questions User Data

Table of Contents Chapter 1: Introducing the Project 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 8. 10. 12. 13. 16. 18.

Chapter 3: Procedural Methodologies 36. 37. 40. 41. 43. 45. 47. 49. 51. 53. 55. 57. 59. 61. 63. 65. 67.

Chapter 2: Research Methodologies 20. 21. 23. 25. 27. 30. 31.

Introduction Project Partners Panel of Experts Personas: Beneficiaries and Stakeholders Park User Story Board Scenarios Early Survey / Data Conclusions Final Hypothesis / Proposed Solution

71. 73. 75. 77. 79. 81. 83.

Branding Solution Solution Matrix / Beneficiaries User Experience Comparative Analysis Proof of Concept Next Steps Conclusion

Appendix Bibliography Dimensions Survey Questions User Data

Chapter One Abstract This study utilizes a research and design process to analyze the current problems and find solutions at the location of Water Dog Lake Park and Open Space in Belmont, CA. Parks are an important part of a city’s image and personality and represent the shared vision and values of its residents. Through the research it is hypothesized that a new park entrance / gateway / portal will serve as a welcoming park attribute, and will emphasize the city’s intended brand identity.

Water Dog Lake Park and Open Space is a valuable community resource in Belmont. Many user groups enjoy the park such as mountain bikers and dog walkers. The park features a small lake which is a storm overflow runoff for the area. There are two gated entrances to the park, the main entrance being on the East side of Hallmark Road.

Problem Statement

Purpose Statement

Water Dog Lake Park & Open Space, a community shared nature area and valuable city resource, doesn’t currently meet the brand / image the city of Belmont wants to portray, as indicated in the city’s stated values. It is also an opportunity location to implement the City Arts Master Plan.

Create a park vision which will positively enhance the city’s brand as a desirable place to live, increasing property value and the attractiveness of the city for high quality development. The solution should recognize the value of art as a reflection of community values while promoting inclusiveness through community engagement.

Problem Statement

Purpose Statement

Significance This proposal aims to use Water Dog Park as a representation of the City of Belmont’s Values, as laid out by the city’s vision statement. These values are an outline of how the city’s residents view themselves, and how they want to be perceived. The city itself is a product that needs cohesive branding and accurate representation The park is a part of this overall vision, and should feel like a welcoming representation.

Assumptions Parks are essentially a reflection of a city’s values and are interpreted as such. Park users and city officials agree that the entrance station is unappealing and would benefit from a complete re-design. Users of the park would appreciate new park signage and wayfinding materials Varying user groups deserve equal use of park trails and resources

Project Scope / Parameters This proposal will be limited in scope to the park entrance area on Hallmark Road. - Permanent port-a-potty - Trail map kiosk - Dog / bike wash station

Preliminary Research My initial trip to the park provided me with the following observations about the park / park entrance: - Cluttered look is confusing - Trail map is weathered / unreadable - Rules don’t make sense (dogs on leash only?) - Wayfinding signs are confusing - Bike Wash and water are on opposite sides - Port-a-potty is unsightly - Certain unsettling atmospheric attributes - Very nice trails and lake - Very “neighborhoody” feel

Project Timeline • Researching and reviewing past projects • Overview of class • Introduction to creative research

• Problem/Purpose Statements • 6 major sub-problems • 3 most challenging sub-problems

• 3 possible projects • Community Partners • Problem/Purpose/Research for all

Week 2

Week 3

Week 4

• Propose solutions / objectives • Final Hypothesis • Final Problem / Solution Statement

• Comparative Analysis • Mapping Matrix • Survey Questions

• Refine Hypothesis from 3 • Narrow down problem statement • 3 most challenging sub-problems

• Stakeholders / Beneficiaries • Challenges / Schedule for users • Storyboard problems

• Choose one project • Library research tools • start researching chosen project

Week 1

• 10 parts research project • Assumptions / Scope • Terms / Definitions

Week 5

Week 6

Week 7

• Mid-Term Report • Research / Data Analysis • Finalize research methods • Finalize bibliography / report

Week 8

Week 9

Week 10

Project Timeline • Researching and reviewing past projects • Overview of class • Introduction to creative research

• Problem/Purpose Statements • 6 major sub-problems • 3 most challenging sub-problems

• 3 possible projects • Community Partners • Problem/Purpose/Research for all

Week 2

Week 3

Week 4

• Propose solutions / objectives • Final Hypothesis • Final Problem / Solution Statement

• Comparative Analysis • Mapping Matrix • Survey Questions

• Refine Hypothesis from 3 • Narrow down problem statement • 3 most challenging sub-problems

• Stakeholders / Beneficiaries • Challenges / Schedule for users • Storyboard problems

• Choose one project • Library research tools • start researching chosen project

Week 1

• 10 parts research project • Assumptions / Scope • Terms / Definitions

Week 5

Week 6

Week 7

• Mid-Term Report • Research / Data Analysis • Finalize research methods • Finalize bibliography / report

Week 8

Week 9

Week 10

Definitions of Common Terms

Wayfinding – User experience designed to guide people through a physical environment and enhance their understanding of the space. In this instance: the park map, trail signage, and road signage Port-a-Potty – Permanent toilets installed at park entrance Screen – Wall(s) installed to hide the toilets Park Entrance – The east side of Hallmark Road entrance

Definitions of Common Terms

3 Possible Hypotheses 1.

A re-design of the entrance to the park would allow a more cohesive branding with the city of Belmont City Arts Program’s vision.

2. The user experience of the park should be re-designed with Universal Design principles and equal stakeholder use considered. 3. A co-operative effort with City Wrights Collaborative will be an effective way to work with city government, City Arts Program, and current built environment to create an effective park design strategy.

3 Possible Hypotheses 1.

A re-design of the entrance to the park would allow a more cohesive branding with the city of Belmont City Arts Program’s vision.

Chapter Two Several research methodologies were used in this report to determine the best possible design solution. User personas, survey data, in-person and online research, and a panel of experts were consulted to author a concise problem statement and creative design solution.

City of Belmont Public Art Master Plan Belmont is embarking on a significant initiative to restore the city’s historical engagement with the arts, by actively incorporating art into our civic spaces.

CityWrights Collaborative Partnership In partnership with CityWrights Collaborative, we will create a vision document for park development that articulates a broad and compelling vision of how the park could be transformed, to serve in branding the City as a desirable place to live.

Panel of Experts

Phil Evans CityWrights Collaborative

Phil Evans is an advisor, mentor, and collaborator on this project. He lives in Belmont and founded CityWrights Collective, which does work transforming public spaces

Nicholas Haig-Airick

Nina Roberts

Freelance Mountain Bike Lifestyle Blogger

Faculty Director of Community Engaged Scholarship & Learning, Institute for Civic and Community Engagement

Panel of Experts

Phil Evans CityWrights Collaborative

Phil Evans is an advisor, mentor, and collaborator on this project. He lives in Belmont and founded CityWrights Collective, which does work transforming public spaces

Nicholas Haig-Airick

Nina Roberts

Freelance Mountain Bike Lifestyle Blogger

Faculty Director of Community Engaged Scholarship & Learning, Institute for Civic and Community Engagement

Stakeholder / Beneficiary Personas Juan – Juan is an employee of the city of Belmont and works in the Public Art Program. He is passionate about city planning and revamping Belmont.

Marian – Marian is a Dogwalker who comes to the park twice a day with a group of 3 dogs. They enjoy letting their dogs play in the park and lake area .

Janice – Janice is a 68-year-old woman who enjoys coming to the park to feed the ducks. She gets annoyed when people don’t pick up their dog poop, or when mountain bikers ride by too fast.

Phillis – Phillis is a working mother who commutes to SF for work on weekdays. She has 3 children who attend school next to the park, and she wants them to be safe making their way home alone after school.

Bill – Bill is a Vietnam Veteran who lives in a tent on the outskirts of the park. He tries to stay out of people’s way but has nowhere to go.

Joey - Joey is an avid mountain biker and lifestyle blogger who comes on weekends to go on trail rides in the park. He uses the trails and the wash station.

Stakeholder / Beneficiary Personas Juan – Juan is an employee of the city of Belmont and works in the Public Art Program. He is passionate about city planning and revamping Belmont.

Marian – Marian is a Dogwalker who comes to the park twice a day with a group of 3 dogs. They enjoy letting their dogs play in the park and lake area .

Janice – Janice is a 68-year-old woman who enjoys coming to the park to feed the ducks. She gets annoyed when people don’t pick up their dog poop, or when mountain bikers ride by too fast.

Bill – Bill is a Vietnam Veteran who lives in a tent on the outskirts of the park. He tries to stay out of people’s way but has nowhere to go.

Joey - Joey is an avid mountain biker and lifestyle blogger who comes on weekends to go on trail rides in the park. He uses the trails and the wash station.

Possible Park User Scenarios 1. Mountain bikers, hikers, and families walking all share the trails which are rather narrow 2. Competition occurs for park amenities 3. Port-a-Potty is necessary but unsightly 4. Park signage is small and confusing 5. Storm drain area looks like the movie “IT”

Early Survey Data Conclusion Users of the park overall enjoy the park and like the different aspects available. People think the entrance on Hallmark road could be more welcoming and less cluttered. People like having the port-a-potty. Most people would like to have a more visually appealing entrance station. Some people don’t care about the look of the entrance, but those people are not opposed to changing it.

Final Hypothesis A re-design of the Hallmark Road entrance to the park would create a more welcoming atmosphere and more accurately represent the City of Belmont’s values.

Proposed Solution The various scattered elements can be combined into a park entrance station, which will consist of a semi-permanent structure on a cement pad. The structure will be visually appealing and serve all existing functions in one package.

Final Hypothesis A re-design of the Hallmark Road entrance to the park would create a more welcoming atmosphere and more accurately represent the City of Belmont’s values.

PERT Chart

Midterm Research In-person visit to park Survey park users Beneficiaries Building codes City Art Plan Comparative Analysis Inspiration Boards

Problem / Purpose Final Hypothesis Propose Solution Project Scope Project Goals Define Deliverables

Prototype Accurate measurements of park entrance area CAD model and blueprints for entrance station design Variable placement / material options Desired manufacturing / building process

Finalize Finalize prototype with accurate measurements, materials, overhead map Final rendered images of entrance station in context Detailed renders of all aspects of station with call-outs User storyboard / show station in use Narrative / storytelling Final Report

PERT Chart

Midterm Research In-person visit to park Survey park users Beneficiaries Building codes City Art Plan Comparative Analysis Inspiration Boards

Problem / Purpose Final Hypothesis Propose Solution Project Scope Project Goals Define Deliverables

Prototype Accurate measurements of park entrance area CAD model and blueprints for entrance station design Variable placement / material options Desired manufacturing / building process

Chapter Three “Our wooded residential areas are diverse, peaceful, and well maintained. Our actions today preserve and enhance Belmont’s beauty to make it even lovelier for future generations.“ - City of Belmont Vision Statement

Introduction

Comparative analysis was conducted at several San Francisco area parks, which informed the final plan for a proposed solution. The physical manifestation of this project will be a park entrance station with a rugged look that welcomes people into the park and defines the portal / gateway.

Introduction

Problem Statement

Purpose Statement

The entrance to Water Dog Lake Park & Open Space, a community shared nature area and valuable city resource, doesn’t currently provide a welcoming atmosphere in line with the image Belmont describes in its vision statement.

A new park entrance station will provide a first impression, welcoming visitors and offering amenities. This will define the area as the main entrance to the park, in addition to organizing the cluttered appearance of the area.

Problem Statement

Purpose Statement

Project Goals Create park entrance “Station” combining various features of trail map, bike / dog wash, bulletin board etc. Consolidate assortment of single signs into one area in a cohesive manor Build a screen to hide the port-a-potty Identify areas that could hold mounted City Arts related material (mural, mosaic, etc) Surprisingly, only 50% of people surveyed considered Hallmark Road as the main entrance to the park. A large part of the re-branding of the park is creating a portal that is a visual point of interest, as well as a clear indicator to visitors that they are indeed inside Water Dog Lake Park and Open Space in Belmont, CA. When someone googles the park, they should be guided to this place and immediately recognize it as the park entrance.

Comparative Analysis

Information & Signage

Wayfinding Materials from Area Parks

Water Dog Lake Park and Open Space Current On-Trail Signage / Trail Markers

Coastal Trail and Area Information

“Philosopher’s Way” trail signage

Comparative Analysis

Information & Signage

Wayfinding Materials from Area Parks

Water Dog Lake Park and Open Space Current On-Trail Signage / Trail Markers

Coastal Trail and Area Information

“Philosopher’s Way” trail signage

Matrix Mapping

Information & Signage

More Information

Natural Look Blending In

Manufactured Look Clear and Visible

Less Information

Matrix Mapping

Information & Signage

More Information

Natural Look Blending In

Manufactured Look Clear and Visible

Less Information

Comparative Analysis

Waste Management & Water Feature

Current Design: Trash Can on Cement Pier This is the current trash can at the entrance of the park next to the port-a-potty. The mounting has shifted, and the can is now crooked. There is no available recycling. Debris gets caught in the mesh and the top needs to be secured with a wire.

Improved Design: Trash + Recycle Cabinet This is a combined trash and recycling system in a single unit. It is visually more attractive, will not shift, and provides the added benefit of allowing users to recycle.

Current Design: Wood Post Fountain The current solution is a wooden post which is now crooked and rotting. The additional spigot is approximately one foot high.

Improved Design: Drinking Fountain with Water Bottle Filler This design is convenient for drinking as well as filling water bottles. Dog Bowl can also be filled from above.

Comparative Analysis

Waste Management & Water Feature

Current Design: Wood Post Fountain The current solution is a wooden post which is now crooked and rotting. The additional spigot is approximately one foot high.

Improved Design: Drinking Fountain with Water Bottle Filler This design is convenient for drinking as well as filling water bottles. Dog Bowl can also be filled from above.

Comparative Analysis

Visual Appearance & Materials

Changeable Graphic Panel

Wooden Fencing

Composite Material Weathered Look

Stainless Steel Panel Walls

Metal Grate

Comparative Analysis

Visual Appearance & Materials

Changeable Graphic Panel

Wooden Fencing

Composite Material Weathered Look

Stainless Steel Panel Walls

Metal Grate

Matrix Mapping

Visual Appearance & Materials

More “City Arts” Related Content

Rugged Look Blending In

Manufactured Look Clean and Modern

Less “City Arts” Related Content

Matrix Mapping

Visual Appearance & Materials

More “City Arts” Related Content

Rugged Look Blending In

Manufactured Look Clean and Modern

Less “City Arts” Related Content

John S. Brooks Memorial Sign

Proposed Solutions ”Before” Entrance Layout This is a bird’s eye view of the park entrance gate at Hallmark Road. On the right there is a permanent “port-a-potty”, large signs and a trash can on cement piers, a park bench and trail entrance. On the left there is a water source with drinking fountain and knee-high spigot, and a bike /shoe scrubber.

Sign: Mountain Lions

Wood Bench

Park Rules Sign

Park Map / Podium

Bike / Shoe Scrubber

Bulletin Board / Pamphlets Rock Trash Can / Mount

Drinking Fountain / Water Spigot

Dog Waste Bag Dispenser

Metal Pole / Chain Wheelchair Accessible Portable Toilet

Water Service Access

Entrance Gate Chain Link Fence

To Hallmark Road

Water Dog Lake Park Sign

Sign: Sign: Mudslide Covid Sign: Sign: Sign: Dog Rules Belmont Watch Waste

Signs: Valuables in Car Open / Closed Chain Link Fence

John S. Brooks Memorial Sign

Sign: Mountain Lions

Wood Bench

Park Rules Sign

Park Map / Podium

Bike / Shoe Scrubber

Bulletin Board / Pamphlets Rock Trash Can / Mount

Drinking Fountain / Water Spigot

Dog Waste Bag Dispenser

Metal Pole / Chain Wheelchair Accessible Portable Toilet

Water Service Access

Entrance Gate Chain Link Fence

To Hallmark Road

Water Dog Lake Park Sign

Sign: Sign: Mudslide Covid Sign: Sign: Sign: Dog Rules Belmont Watch Waste

Signs: Valuables in Car Open / Closed Chain Link Fence

John S. Brooks Memorial Sign

Proposed Solutions ”After” Entrance Layout This is the same view with the proposed solutions implemented. The built structure (option #3), entrance gate and water feature area create a portal to welcome the user into the park. Signs are consolidated to the structure and Belmont Public Art Program materials are displayed on the entrance gate.

Sign: Mountain Lions

Wood Bench

Cement Pad

Bulletin Board / Pamphlets & Park Map Podium

Chain Link Fence Bike / Shoe Scrubber Rock Dog Waste Bag Dispenser

Drinking Fountain / Water with Hose and Sprayer

Signs Behind Trash Bins

Gravel / Drainage with Wood Border

Trash / Recycling In Wooden Bins

Wheelchair Accessible Portable Toilet

Entrance Gate

Water Service Access

To Hallmark Road

Wood Structure / Walls + Slanted Roof

Water Dog Lake Park Sign

Sign: Park Rules and Hours Mountable Display for Rotating Belmont Arts Content

Chain Link Fence

John S. Brooks Memorial Sign

Sign: Mountain Lions

Wood Bench

Cement Pad

Bulletin Board / Pamphlets & Park Map Podium

Chain Link Fence Bike / Shoe Scrubber Rock Dog Waste Bag Dispenser

Drinking Fountain / Water with Hose and Sprayer

Signs Behind Trash Bins

Gravel / Drainage with Wood Border

Trash / Recycling In Wooden Bins

Wheelchair Accessible Portable Toilet

Entrance Gate

Water Service Access

To Hallmark Road

Wood Structure / Walls + Slanted Roof

Water Dog Lake Park Sign

Sign: Park Rules and Hours Mountable Display for Rotating Belmont Arts Content

Chain Link Fence

Design Inspiration

Structure & Aesthetic Study

Design Inspiration

Structure & Aesthetic Study

Concept Ideation and Development

New Park Entrance Station

Concept Progression & Iterative Process Developing a very basic shape study helped to identify what components would be necessary in the new design, and how existing park signage would be incorporated. This is the rudimentary shape of the port-a-potty enclosure and map display signage. The structure contains a cement pad, wooden posts, and brick / wooden walls to blend in with the rugged, natural look of the park.

Concept Ideation and Development

New Park Entrance Station

Concept Ideation and Development

Material Selection / Color / Visual Appearance

Materials Rustic Wood

Color Palette Black

Finished Wood

Brown

Brushed Steel

Grey

Corrugated Tin Sheet

Silver

Visual Language Straight Lines and Geometric Shapes juxtapose with Natural and Rustic Finishes to create a modern look that also fits in to the Natural Surroundings. When comparing existing structures, there was a necessary balance between looking too manufactured and looking too rugged and/or run down.

Concept Ideation and Development

Material Selection / Color / Visual Appearance

Materials Rustic Wood

Color Palette Black

Finished Wood

Brown

Brushed Steel

Grey

Corrugated Tin Sheet

Silver

Proposed Solutions

New Park Entrance Station Concept

Park Entrance Station The plan for the park entrance consists of a new entrance “station”, a semipermanent structure that hides the port-a-potty. Trail map will be mounted on the wall of the station, under the awning which protects it from weather. Bike / Dog Wash and Water feature will be moved to opposite side of trail with its own area.

Proposed Solutions

New Park Entrance Station Concept

Proposed Solutions

New Park Entrance Station Concept

How it Works The back of the structure has doors that open allowing the toilet to be moved in and out and accessed for pumping. The toilet at the entrance is considered permanent, however it must be pumped/ serviced every two weeks and also needs to be movable.

Proposed Solutions

New Park Entrance Station Concept

Proposed Solutions

Mini-Mural Park Entrance Gate

Belmont Art Mural Gate The entrance gate will be transformed into a display mount which will feature rotating art displayed in conjunction with the Belmont Public Art Master Plan. Relocating the current assortment of informational signs will allow space to showcase local artists while giving park visitors a warm and fun welcome.

Proposed Solutions

Mini-Mural Park Entrance Gate

Proposed Solutions

Entrance Portal

Park Entrance Portal The new structure will consolidate the toilet, trash can, map and sign display under a covered area on a cement pad. All information & amenities are in one place. The structure and gate mural create a clear entrance portal and eliminate the confusion of extraneous elements. New visitors will feel welcome, and the local community will appreciate the updated look and features.

Proposed Solutions

Entrance Portal

Alternate Solutions

Port-A-Potty Screening Options

Option #1 – Vinyl Wrap

Option #2 – Folding Wall

Vinyl applied with a digital printed image, as seen on some vehicles. The image can be a texture such as wood or trees that blends into the surroundings or could be used to display Belmont Public Art content.

A three-panel freestanding wall on all sides of the toilet except the door. Attached with bolts or secured to the ground with cement piers. The wall that faces the path will display various signs.

Alternate Solutions

Port-A-Potty Screening Options

Option #1 – Vinyl Wrap

Option #2 – Folding Wall

A three-panel freestanding wall on all sides of the toilet except the door. Attached with bolts or secured to the ground with cement piers. The wall that faces the path will display various signs.

Chapter 4 The Final Chapter will focus on user feedback, benefits to stakeholders, and future possibilities in terms of expansion. Further analysis of solutions and current comparative park design in San Francisco will inform the final design.

Branding Solution The re-design of the park entrance successfully represents Belmont’s brand, which is clearly defined in their vision statement. Connecting with nature, support of the arts, and actively making improvements for the future are some of the principles displayed.

Solution Matrix

Entrance Structure

Public Art

Water Feature

Beneficiaries Park Users

Local Community

City of Belmont

The solution with the maximum benefit was the public art display, followed by the entrance station. The water feature should be re-designed in the future, but in the big picture it offers the least benefit.

Solution Matrix

Entrance Structure

Public Art

Water Feature

Beneficiaries Park Users

Local Community

City of Belmont

User Experience What is the optimal experience of a visitor at the park entrance?

2 1. Looks up places to hike with dog online, Google Maps leads them to the Hallmark Road entrance. 2. Arrives at park entrance portal “This must be the place.”

3. Walks up to entrance structure, looks at the park map and available information, grabs a dog waste bag and hits the trail. 4. Finishes up hike, throws away dog waste bag, uses the toilet, and takes a park brochure.

User Experience What is the optimal experience of a visitor at the park entrance?

2 1. Looks up places to hike with dog online, Google Maps leads them to the Hallmark Road entrance. 2. Arrives at park entrance portal “This must be the place.”

Comparative Analysis Park Entrance / Portal

Photo

Golden Gate Park is an example of a clear park entrance portal / gateway which welcomes visitors to the park and lets you know exactly where you are. A similar idea is communicated here at Water Dog Lake.

Comparative Analysis Park Entrance / Portal

Photo

Proof of Concept

Main Park Entrance Portal

Before The first thing that greets visitors as they step through the gate is a toilet, and the second thing is a trash can. The map is much too small for some people to read and is badly weather damaged. The park rules sign is large, imposing and feels out of place next to the tiny map.

Proof of Concept

Main Park Entrance Portal

Proof of Concept

Main Park Entrance Portal

After The new structure serves as a clear focal point. The large map is the first information they encounter. The small signs have been moved to the wall facing the entrance, allowing the gate to be used for the mural. The park rules sign, moved next to the structure, will no longer dominate the area.

Proof of Concept

Main Park Entrance Portal

Proof of Concept

Main Park Entrance Portal

Proof of Concept

Main Park Entrance Portal

Proof of Concept

Main Park Entrance Portal

Proof of Concept

Main Park Entrance Portal

Next Steps Possibilities for further development

Update Trail Signage

New Park Map

Water Fountain and Bike Ramp

The on-trail wayfinding materials need to have a cohesive system that is easy to understand. Update look to match the entrance.

A new park trail map designed to be easy to see and understand for all types of people and abilities.

Update the water fountain area and add a hose + sprayer. Add a ramp to the bike wash.

Next Steps Possibilities for further development

Update Trail Signage

New Park Map

Water Fountain and Bike Ramp

The on-trail wayfinding materials need to have a cohesive system that is easy to understand. Update look to match the entrance.

A new park trail map designed to be easy to see and understand for all types of people and abilities.

Update the water fountain area and add a hose + sprayer. Add a ramp to the bike wash.

“We choose to make our home among these beautiful hills, trees, parks, views and open spaces” City of Belmont Vision Statement

Conclusion The true appeal of the park is the beauty and connection with nature that residents of Belmont and Park visitors alike enjoy. The park entrance makes a first impression to people visiting Belmont, lets them know the city has to offer, what they value, and makes them feel welcome.

“We choose to make our home among these beautiful hills, trees, parks, views and open spaces” City of Belmont Vision Statement

Appendix This section contains raw data including bibliography, survey questions, and raw data from park user / beneficiaries. This information was extremely valuable in forming a solution that enhanced all users’ enjoyment of the park.

Bibliography City of Belmont Public Art Master Plan 2020 https://www.belmont.gov/departments/parks-and-recreation/parks-rec-projects/pubic-art-master-plan-2 CityWrights Collaborative Official Website www.citywrights.net County of San Mateo Building Code, Ordinance 4822, Board of Supervisors of the county of San Mateo. https://planning.smcgov.org/sites/planning.smcgov.org/files/12072019_Building%20Code%20Ordinance% 202019_1_0.pdf Tang, Bo-sin; Wong, Kwan To. “Threshold effects of incremental redevelopment of an industrial property on a residential neighborhood.” Landscape & Urban Planning, Apr 2021, Vol. 208 Wu, Chunliang; Kim, Inhi; Chung, Hyungchul. “The effects of built environment spatial variation on bikesharing usage” Cities, Mar 2021, Vol. 110 Mäntymaa, Erkki; Jokinen, Mikko; Juutinen, Artti; Lankia, Tuija; Louhi, Pauliina. “Providing ecological, cultural and commercial services in an urban park” Landscape & Urban Planning. May 2020, Vol. 110 Rutledge, Albert J. A Visual Approach to Pak Design. Garland Series 1981 Williams, Christopher. Origins of Form. Taylor Trade Publishing UK 1981 Molnar, Donald J. Anatomy of a Park – Essentials of Recreation Area Planning & Design. Waveland Press 1986

Structure Dimensions

Main Park Entrance Portal

Structure Dimensions

Main Park Entrance Portal

Mural Mount Dimensions

Park Entrance Gate

Mural Mount Dimensions

Park Entrance Gate

Survey Questions 1. How would you rate the park experience overall? 2. What do you consider to be the main park entrance? 3. How do you feel about the port-a-potties at the trailhead? 4. How do you feel about the bike / dog wash station? 5. Do you think dogs should be allowed off leash anywhere? 6. Do you think mountain bikers should be allowed on all trails? 7. What do you think of the Trail Map Kiosk? 8. What do you think of the bulletin board display? 9. How easy or difficult is it to know where you are on the trails with the current trail markers?

Most Difficult

Common Difficult Activities for Park Stakeholders

Juan

Janice

Average Difficulty

Least Difficult

Balancing the needs of a variety of city residents with limited resources.

Fighting Government Bureaucracy in order to get legislation passed

Scheduling conflicts

Facing oncoming mobility issues due to age

Need for Social interaction

Budgeting

Homeless lifestyle is hard on aging body and mind

Alcoholism and nutrition

Applying for government assistance

Stigma against trans people

Physical hard work of dog walking

Balancing work / life schedule

Raising children to be responsible citizens

Balancing work / life

Finding time for personal friendships and relationships

Making sure freelance career stays on track

Focusing on safety and avoiding injury

Answering emails, being reliable

Bill

Marian

Phillis

Joey

Most Difficult

Common Difficult Activities for Park Stakeholders

Juan

Janice

Average Difficulty

Least Difficult

Balancing the needs of a variety of city residents with limited resources.

Fighting Government Bureaucracy in order to get legislation passed

Scheduling conflicts

Facing oncoming mobility issues due to age

Need for Social interaction

Budgeting

Homeless lifestyle is hard on aging body and mind

Alcoholism and nutrition

Applying for government assistance

Stigma against trans people

Physical hard work of dog walking

Balancing work / life schedule

Raising children to be responsible citizens

Balancing work / life

Finding time for personal friendships and relationships

Making sure freelance career stays on track

Focusing on safety and avoiding injury

Answering emails, being reliable

Bill

Marian

Phillis

Joey

Daily Activity Schedule 8:00 am

9:00 am

10:00 am

11:00 am

Quick coffee and bagel before work

First meeting of the day, usually in-person but now on zoom

Discusses ideas for Public art in Belmont with colleagues

Fundraiser idea meeting for city of Belmont

Wakes up and starts getting out of bed

Watches Fox news and eats oatmeal and Metamucil

Drives to Water Dog Park to feed the ducks

Parks at the trail head and walks to the water, rests at benches along the way

Walks to the porta-potty, woke up much earlier

Eats a can of beans with tortillas

Drinks several beers and reads a book of poems

Takes a nap in the sun in the park

Wakes up and goes over today’s dog walk schedule

Eats breakfast and feeds their own personal dogs.

Picks up first round of dogs and takes them to Water Dog Lake Park

Arrives, parks at trailhead, and walks first group of dogs in the off-leash area

Has been up since 6 getting her kids ready for school

Drops off youngest child at school, (pre-covid)

Drives to SF for work, is an essential worker

Settled in at work, completing daily tasks

Heads out to meet friends for coffee

Meets friends in SF downtown, they plan to ride the trails at Water Dog

Loads up mountain bikes and drives to Belmont

Parks at upper open space entrance, unloads bikes and hits the trail

Juan

Janice

Bill

Marian

12:00 pm

1:00 pm

Lunch Break

Office / Paperwork

Sits at the lake and enjoys the quiet, feeds some ducks

Yells at someone for not picking up their dog poop

Rides bike to 7-11

Uses portapotty

2:00 pm

3:00 pm

Meeting with local artists / workshop

Wrapping up work day

Heads home from office

Volunteers at local women's shelter

Waters garden at home, has some tea

Goes to Social security office to fill out paperwork

Uses internet outside of Starbucks

Returns to WDOS

Finishes up second dog walk

Uses the portapotty, gets back in car to return home

Cleans up camp spot

4:00 pm

Packs up dogs and leaves park

Lunch Break

Work, kids at school

Picks up youngest from school, heads home

Mountain Biking

Mountain biking, filming for video blog

Packs up and goes with friends to have some beers at the brewery

Slamming some more brewdogs and watching the days gnarly MTB footage

Picks up second round of dogs

Phillis

Joey

5:00pm Gets ready for dinner with family

Eats supper and talks to daughter on the phone

Returns to the area outside of the park, where he has his tent set up Drops off dogs and heads home for the day

Orders delivery for dinner, older kids walked home from school earlier Returns home and posts online about the Water Dog Lake Park

Daily Activity Schedule 8:00 am

9:00 am

10:00 am

11:00 am

Quick coffee and bagel before work

First meeting of the day, usually in-person but now on zoom

Discusses ideas for Public art in Belmont with colleagues

Fundraiser idea meeting for city of Belmont

Wakes up and starts getting out of bed

Watches Fox news and eats oatmeal and Metamucil

Drives to Water Dog Park to feed the ducks

Parks at the trail head and walks to the water, rests at benches along the way

Walks to the porta-potty, woke up much earlier

Eats a can of beans with tortillas

Drinks several beers and reads a book of poems

Takes a nap in the sun in the park

Wakes up and goes over today’s dog walk schedule

Eats breakfast and feeds their own personal dogs.

Picks up first round of dogs and takes them to Water Dog Lake Park

Arrives, parks at trailhead, and walks first group of dogs in the off-leash area

Has been up since 6 getting her kids ready for school

Drops off youngest child at school, (pre-covid)

Drives to SF for work, is an essential worker

Settled in at work, completing daily tasks

Heads out to meet friends for coffee

Meets friends in SF downtown, they plan to ride the trails at Water Dog

Loads up mountain bikes and drives to Belmont

Parks at upper open space entrance, unloads bikes and hits the trail

Juan

Janice

Bill

Marian

12:00 pm

1:00 pm

Lunch Break

Office / Paperwork

Sits at the lake and enjoys the quiet, feeds some ducks

Yells at someone for not picking up their dog poop

Rides bike to 7-11

Uses portapotty

2:00 pm

3:00 pm

Meeting with local artists / workshop

Wrapping up work day

Heads home from office

Volunteers at local women's shelter

Waters garden at home, has some tea

Goes to Social security office to fill out paperwork

Uses internet outside of Starbucks

Returns to WDOS

Finishes up second dog walk

Uses the portapotty, gets back in car to return home

Cleans up camp spot

4:00 pm

Packs up dogs and leaves park

Lunch Break

Work, kids at school

Picks up youngest from school, heads home

Mountain Biking

Mountain biking, filming for video blog

Packs up and goes with friends to have some beers at the brewery

Slamming some more brewdogs and watching the days gnarly MTB footage

Picks up second round of dogs

Phillis

Joey

5:00pm Gets ready for dinner with family

Eats supper and talks to daughter on the phone

Returns to the area outside of the park, where he has his tent set up Drops off dogs and heads home for the day

Orders delivery for dinner, older kids walked home from school earlier Returns home and posts online about the Water Dog Lake Park