CONTACTS
Leader Are we being served?
B
ack in the days when full-blown public sector markets were but a distant dream, Labour government advisers used to deliver homilies about producer ‘capture’ and consumer choice. Public services should be designed around users, not employees, they stressed – and competitive markets were the best way to ensure that. Times have moved on. Contracting and outsourcing are no longer hotly contested issues, and even politically sensitive areas like health and education have been thrown wide open to marketisation. The mantra of ‘what works’ – as against public-knows-best dogma – has now become established orthodoxy. But, as the influential Institute for Government (Opinion, pages 10–11) has highlighted, the old debates are far from settled. A rash of public sector market failures – from NHS 111 to the Ministry of Justice tagging fiasco, to repeated care home scandals – have re-raised the question: who pays the price when the market patently does not work? As Peter Wilby argues in this issue (Put to the test, pages 24–29) Michael Gove’s education revolution is transferring control of schooling from local authorities to a handful of commercial chains. The whole edifice is presided over by the secretary of state himself. A minority of pupils in Gove’s ‘little platoons’ of free schools and highperforming academies may benefit from his reforms. But the vast majority of school children face increasingly marginalised and under-funded local education services. As the IfG points out, many academy chains are further undermining parental and pupil choice by focusing on specific parts of the country: a big problem if one of them fails. Similar issues arise in the newly reformed NHS, where clinical commissioning groups are under pressure to seek competitive tenders for care services – and the acute hospital sector is keen to follow suit. However, squeezed payment-by-results tariffs, private health sector failures and a succession of care scandals (Safe in whose hands? pages 38–41) have tempered commercial appetites. All of which underscores the IfG’s advice to Whitehall to slow down the pace of marketisation, test out new delivery models more thoroughly (in particular, for ‘gaming’) and insist on full commercial transparency. Without these vital checks and balances, the only interests being served by the government’s market reforms will be those of near-monopoly private sector providers. Public service users – as ever – will be last in line.
■ Judy Hirst DEPUTY EDITOR letterstoeditor@publicfinance.co.uk
4
REDACTIVE PUBLISHING LTD 17-18 Britton Street London EC1M 5TP 020 7880 6200 www.publicfinance.co.uk Editor Mike Thatcher 020 7324 2768 mike.thatcher@publicfinance.co.uk Deputy editor Judy Hirst 020 7324 2769 judy.hirst@publicfinance.co.uk News editor Vivienne Russell 020 7324 2788 vivienne.russell@publicfinance.co.uk Reporter Richard Johnstone 020 7324 2796 richard.johnstone@publicfinance.co.uk Contributors Jane Cahane, Keith Aitken Chief subeditor Anne Lawton 020 7324 2789 anne.lawton@publicfinance.co.uk Art editor Gene Cornelius 020 7324 6227 gene.cornelius@redactive.co.uk Editorial assistant Tania Forrester 020 7324 2793 tania.forrester@publicfinance.co.uk Digital content manager Harriet Patience 020 7324 2733 harriet.patience@redactive.co.uk Sales manager Katy Eggleton 020 7324 2762 katy.eggleton@redactive.co.uk Digital sales executive Leila Serlin 020 7324 2787 leila.serlin@redactive.co.uk Recruitment sales executive Gill Rock 020 7324 6234 gill.rock@redactive.co.uk Advertising production Aysha Miah 020 7880 6241 aysha.miah@redactive.co.uk Printing Pensord, Blackwood, Gwent, Wales To subscribe to Public Finance at the annual cost of £100, call 020 8950 9117 or email publicfinance@alliance-media.co.uk. Public Finance is editorially autonomous and the opinions expressed are not those of CIPFA or of contributors’ employing organisations, unless expressly stated. Public Finance reserves the copyright in all published articles, which may not be reproduced in whole or in part without permission. Public Finance is published for CIPFA by Redactive Publishing Ltd. Public Finance 17–18 Britton Street, London EC1M 5TP Tel 020 7880 6200 Fax 020 7324 2790
Average circulation 16,597 (Jul 11–Jun 12)
Tel 020 7543 5600 Fax 020 7543 5700 Email corporate@cipfa.org Address CIPFA, 3 Robert Street London, WC2N 6RL
PublicFinance SEPTEMBER 2013 2011
PFsept13.004.indd 1
20/8/13 17:06:15