Results Of Protestant’s Examination Of The Election Returns Of Sultan Kudarat, Shariff Kabunsuan

ANNEX “A” (To Protestant‟s Memorandum on the Pilot Areas) RESULTS OF PROTESTANT’S EXAMINATION OF THE ELECTION RETURNS OF SULTAN KUDARAT, SHARIFF KABUNSUAN

(1)

Exh. “500” (Precinct No. 1-A)  







(2)

ER No. 8800761; Barangay: Dalumancob; counterpart MOV is Exhibit “699” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn-out. o Entry of “3 excess ballots” is illogical since 200 ballots were allegedly found in the compartment for valid ballots and 200 voters allegedly voted.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alterations in favor of Defensor, Kiram, Oreta, Pichay, Recto and ZUBIRI, consisting of the insertion of the words “one hundred” written above the horizontal line opposite their names and the prefixing of the number “1” before their two digit entries in figures. o Pimentel‟s, Escudero‟s and Alan Cayetano‟s votes in words and figures were also tampered with and reduced. Pimentel‟s votes were reduced from 26 to 6.

TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 150, for ZUBIRI were made after his vote tallies had been closed with initials. o The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc., of the second batch. o Other candidates similarly benefited from the above fraud. o The tallies for Pimentel, Escudero, and Alan Cayetano were obviously reduced through the use of correction fluid.

SIGNATURES AND THUMB MARKS o Only 2 watchers signed and thumb marked the ER.

Exh. “501” (Precinct No. 2-A) ER No. 8800762; Barangay: Dalumangcob; counterpart MOV is Exhibit “700” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 97.98% voter turn-out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alterations in favor of Pichay, Recto and ZUBIRI, consisting of the insertion of the words “one hundred” in their total votes in words and the prefixing of the number “1” before their two digit total votes in figures.

TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 55, for ZUBIRI were made after his vote tallies had been closed with initials. o The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc., of the second batch. o Other candidates similarly benefited from the above fraud.

SIGNATURES AND THUMB MARKS o Only 2 watchers signed and thumb marked the ER.

(3)

Exh. “502” (Precinct No. 3-A) ER No. 8800763; Barangay: Dalumancob; counterpart MOV is Exhibit “701” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 99% voter turn-out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o With only 198 voters who actually voted, ZUBIRI still got a mathematically impossible 200 votes in this precinct! o Obvious superimposition of the word “two” in ZUBIRI‟s total votes in words and of the number “200” over an earlier entry in the figures column. o Pichay and Recto similarly benefited by the same type of fraud.

TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 100, for ZUBIRI were made after his vote tallies had been closed with initials.

1

o o

(4)

Tallies of different pressure are present in ZUBIRI‟s first batch of tallies, obviously made over correction fluid.

PIMENTEL and Pangilinan tallies have been erased.

Exh. “503” (Precinct No. 4-A) ER No. 8800764; Barangay: Dalumangcob; counterpart MOV is Exhibit “702” The ER for Local Positions (Councilors) has been used! Names of Senatorial Candidates are handwritten on blank spaces instead of being printed on the paper!

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o No data, since the form used is wrong.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious superimposition of the words “one hundred eighty five” in ZUBIRI‟s total votes in words and suffixing of the number “5” to “18”, making it read “185” in the figures column. o Other candidates similarly benefited by the same type of fraud.

TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 167, for ZUBIRI were made after his vote tallies had been closed with initials. o The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc., of the second batch. o Other candidates similarly benefited from the same type of fraud. o PIMENTEL tallies obviously erased. Same with Honasan.

SIGNATURES AND THUMB MARKS o Initials on tallies bear no resemblance to any BEI signature.

(5)

Exh. “504” (Precinct No. 5-A) ER No. 8800765; Barangay: Dalumangcob; counterpart MOV is Exhibit “703” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o 203 ballots found in compartment for valid ballots exceed the 200 voters who allegedly voted.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Many candidates given “zero” vote total by simply superimposing the word on the „in words” column. o Obvious superimposition of the words “one hundred forty” in ZUBIRI‟s total votes in words. The “1”, “4”, and “0” of ZUBIRI‟s votes in figures are not even aligned! This is because those numbers were simply superimposed too.

TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 100, for ZUBIRI were made after his vote tallies had been closed with initials. o The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc., of the second batch. o Pichay and Recto similarly benefited from the same type of fraud. o PIMENTEL and Alan Cayetano tallies obviously erased. Same with many other candidates.

(6)

Exh. “505” (Precinct No. 6-A) ER No. 8800766; Barangay: Dalumangcob; counterpart MOV is Exhibit “704” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Perfect 100% voter turn out. 199 out of 199. Incredible!

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious superimposition of the words “one hundred ninety nine” in ZUBIRI‟s total votes in words and of the number “199” over an earlier entry in the figures column. o Pichay similarly benefited by the same type of fraud. o Both ZUBIRI and Pichay got 100% of the votes cast (which was incidentally 100% of the total number of registered voters).

TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 173, for ZUBIRI were made after his vote tallies had been closed with initials. o The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc., of the second batch. o Pichay similarly benefited from the same type of fraud.

(7)

Exh. “506” (Precinct No. 7-A) ER No. 8800767; Barangay: Dalumangcob; counterpart MOV is Exhibit “705” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS

2

o

Incredible 95% voter turn out, allegedly 190 cast their votes out of 200 registered voters!

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious superimposition of the words “two hundred” in ZUBIRI‟s total votes in words and of the number “200” over an earlier entry in the figures column. o Recto and Singson similarly benefited by the same type of fraud. o ZUBIRI, Recto, and Singson got MORE THAN 100% of the votes cast (200 votes out of 190 votes cast!).

TALLIES o Though Recto and Singson were given 200 votes in words and figures, their tallies both total only “28”. o It is only ZUBIRI who is given additional tallies, numbering 177, after his original 23 tallies (which had been closed by initials). o The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc., of the second batch.

(8)

Exh. “507” (Precinct No. 8-A) ER No. 8800768; Barangay: Dalumangcob; counterpart MOV is Exhibit “706” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 92.96% voter turn out. o Ballots found in the compartment for valid ballots is indicated as “0”.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alterations in the total votes in words and figures of Defensor, Kiram, Oreta, and Pangilinan.

TALLIES o The additional tallies of the above mentioned candidates were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc., of the second batch.

SIGNATURES AND THUMB MARKS o Two BEI members and all the watchers did not affix their thumb marks.

(9)

Exh. “508” (Precinct No. 9-A) ER No. 8800769; Barangay: Dalumangcob; counterpart MOV is Exhibit “707” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious superimposition in the total votes in words for Recto. “Ten” became “One Hundred Ten”.

TALLIES o The additional tallies of Recto were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc., of the second batch, and were made after his entry of votes had been closed by initials.

(10)

Exh. “509” (Precinct No. 9-B) ER No. 8800770; Barangay: Dalumangcob; counterpart MOV is Exhibit “708” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 90.52% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious superimposition of the words “one hundred forty nine” in the total votes in words for ZUBIRI and of the number “149” over an earlier entry in the figures column. o Many other candidates benefited from the same type of fraud.

TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 76, for ZUBIRI were made after his vote tallies had been closed with initials. o The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc., of the second batch. o Other candidates similarly benefited from the same type of fraud. o PIMENTEL, Escudero, Alan Cayetano, and others‟ tallies were obviously reduced through erasure by correction fluid.

(11)

Exh. “510” (Precinct No. 9-C) ER No. 8800771; Barangay: Dalumangcob; counterpart MOV is Exhibit “709” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn out.

3

o

198 ballots found in the compartment for valid ballots exceeds the 195 voters who allegedly voted.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious superimposition of the number “162” over an earlier entry in the figures column of ZUBIRI. However, ZUBIRI’s total votes in words remained at “forty”. o Recto benefited from the same type of fraud.

TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 122, for ZUBIRI were made after his vote tallies had been closed with initials. o The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc., of the second batch. o Recto similarly benefited from the same type of fraud.

(12)

Exh. “511” (Precinct No. 9-D) ER No. 880078; Barangay: Dalumangcob; counterpart MOV is Exhibit “710” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious superimposition of the words “one hundred fifty four” in the total votes in words for ZUBIRI and of the number “154” in the figures column (over correction fluid). o Recto benefited from the same type of fraud.

TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 101, for ZUBIRI were made after his vote tallies had been closed with initials. o The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc., of the second batch. o Recto similarly benefited from the same type of fraud. o PIMENTEL tallies total “29” yet his total vote in words and figures is given as “eighteen”. o Tallies of Alan Cayetano were obviously reduced through erasure by correction fluid.

(13)

Exh. “512” (Precinct No. 10-A) ER No. 8800773; Barangay: Alamada; counterpart MOV is Exhibit “711” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 99.50% voter turn out. o 11 excess ballots found in the compartment for valid ballots in excess of the number of voters who voted.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Too many alterations as to make the entries almost illegible! o ZUBIRI‟s total votes in words not clearly written, reads like “one hun seventeen”, in the figures column reads like “117” or even “1117”. o PIMENTEL‟s total votes in words and in figures are crossed out.

TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 61, for ZUBIRI were made after his vote tallies had been closed with initials. o The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc., of the second batch. o ZUBIRI‟s total tallies (in two batches) number 196 but his total votes in words and figures is given as 117. o ZUBIRI‟s second batch of tallies is not closed by any initial. o The closing signature in almost all the entries is only that of the third member a certain Tarhata Saricula. o Pichay similarly benefited from the same type of fraud.

(14)

Exh. “513” (Precinct No. 11-A) ER No. 8800774; Barangay: Alamada; counterpart MOV is Exhibit “712” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious superimposition of the number “200” in ZUBIRI‟s total votes in figures over an earlier entry. o In ZUBIRI‟s total votes in words is almost illegible as only the letter “T” is superimposed on the letter “O”, making the result read like “TNEHUNDREDTWENTY”.

4

o Recto benefited from the same type of fraud.

TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 80, for ZUBIRI were made after his vote tallies had been closed with initials. o The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc., of the second batch. o Recto similarly benefited from the same type of fraud

(15)

Exh. “514” (Precinct No. 12-A) ER No. 8800775; Barangay: Alamada; counterpart MOV is Exhibit “713” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 101.50% voter turn out! (203 “out of” 200!)

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious superimposition in ZUBIRI‟s total votes in figures of numbers to make “64” read finally as “184”. o Obvious superimposition of the words “One Hundred Eighty” in ZUBIRI‟s total votes in words over correction fluid. o Oreta, Pichay, and Recto benefited from the same type of fraud.

TALLIES o Second batch of tallies, numbering 120, for ZUBIRI were obviously added. o The alignment of the additional tallies of ZUBIRI is different from the first batch of 64 tallies. o Oreta, Pichay, and Recto benefited from the same type of fraud. o All tallies were closed by only one initial which looks like that of the third member.

(16)

Exh. “515” (Precinct No. 13-A and 13-B) ER No. 8800776; Barangay: Alamada; counterpart MOV is Exhibit “714” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Too many erasures as to be almost illegible. o Incredible 96.53% voter turn out! (Allegedly 278 out of 288.)

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Too many alterations as to be almost illegible. o ZUBIRI‟s total votes in words is illegible. But there is an attempt to make it read like something with “seventy eight” at the end. o Obvious superimposition in ZUBIRI‟s total votes in figures of numbers to make read like “278” or something like that. o Other candidates benefited from the same type of fraud.

TALLIES o Second batch of tallies, numbering 220, for ZUBIRI were obviously added after his vote tallies had been closed with initials. o The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc., of the second batch. o Additional tallies, numbering 59, were also given PIMENTEL. o Additional tallies were given to many candidates.

(17)

Exh. “516” (Precinct No. 14-A) ER No. 8800777; Barangay: Banatin; counterpart MOV is Exhibit “715” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn out! o Ballots found in the compartment for valid ballots (201) exceed the number of voters who actually voted (198).

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o ZUBIRI‟s total votes in figures has been manipulated to read like “189”. o Obvious insertion of the words “one hundred” in the total votes of Pichay and Recto.

TALLIES o ZUBIRI’s tallies number only 119, yet his total votes in words and in figures is given as “189”!

SIGNATURES AND THUMB MARKS o Watchers‟ names are indicated but no signatures.

(18)

Exh. “517” (Precinct No. 15-A) ER No. 8800778; Barangay: not indicated; no counterpart MOV DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 98.99% voter turn out! (Allegedly 197 out of 199.) o Ballots found in the compartment for valid ballots (202) exceed the number of voters who actually voted (197). o Entry in Excess Ballots reads “02”, with obvious suffixing of the number “2”.

5

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Too many erasures and alterations as to make the entries illegible! o Obvious erasures in ZUBIRI‟s total votes in words and in figures, with the final entry made to read like “164”. o PIMENTEL‟s total is “two” but his tallies number “12”.

TALLIES o Second batch of tallies, numbering 38, for ZUBIRI were obviously added after his vote tallies had been closed with initials. This second batch was not closed by initials at all. o The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different size, pressure, stroke, etc., of the second batch. o ZUBIRI‟s total tallies (from the two batches) is only “163” yet his total is given as “164”. o Other candidates were also given additional tallies.

(19)

Exh. “518” (Precinct No. 16-A) ER No. 8800779; Barangay: Banatin; counterpart MOV is Exhibit “716” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 97.97% voter turn out! (Allegedly 194 out of 198.)

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious insertion of words in ZUBIRI’s total votes in words such that ZUBIRI ended up with two entries: “seventy” and “one hundred seventy”! o Obvious prefixing of the number “1” before the number “70” in ZUBIRI‟s total votes in figures. o PIMENTEL (line 28) given “zero” vote total but his tallies number 11. Alan Cayetano and Escudero also given zeros in spite of presence of tallies!

TALLIES o Second batch of tallies, numbering 100, for ZUBIRI were obviously added after his vote tallies had been closed with initials. o The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc., of the second batch. o Recto similarly benefited.

(20)

Exh. “519” (Precinct No. 17-A) ER No. 8800780; Barangay: Banatin; counterpart MOV is Exhibit “717” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn out!

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious insertion of the words “one hundred” in ZUBIRI’s total votes in words placed just above the words “eighty two”. The two entries are of different handwriting styles. o Obvious prefixing of the number “1” before the number “82” in ZUBIRI‟s total votes in figures. o Pichay and Recto benefited from same type of fraud.

TALLIES o Second batch of tallies, numbering 100, for ZUBIRI were obviously added after his vote tallies had been closed with initials. o The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc., of the second batch. o Pichay and Recto similarly benefited.

(21)

Exh. “520” (Precinct No. 17-B) ER No. 8800772; Barangay: Banatin; counterpart MOV is Exhibit “718” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 99.14% voter turn out. o “0” ballots found in the compartments for valid ballots.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS Obvious alterations to increase the votes of Recto and ZUBIRI consisting of erasures in the words and the figures.

TALLIES Additional tallies, numbering 62, for Recto were made after his vote tallies had been closed with initials.

Additional tallies, numbering 45, for ZUBIRI were made after his entry of votes.

The additional tallies were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc., of the second batch.

6

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS Signature of the BEI Chairman is different from signature in the MOV. No signature of any watcher.

(22)

Exh. “521” (Precinct No. 18-A) ER No. 8800782; Barangay: Banubo; counterpart MOV is Exhibit “719” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS Incredible 99.50% voter turn out.

The 200 ballots found inside the compartment for valid ballots is in excess of the 197 voters who allegedly actually voted. Besides, there are only 198 registered voters in the precinct.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS Obvious alterations in favor of Defensor, Kiram, Magsaysay, Montano, Oreta, Pichay, Recto, Singson, Sotto and ZUBIRI consisting of the insertion of the words “One Hundred” using a different pen, and the prefixing of the number “1” before their two digit entries in figures.

Escudero‟s votes in words and figures were also tampered with and reduced to “30”.

TALLIES Additional tallies, numbering 178, for ZUBIRI were made after his vote tallies had been closed with initials.

The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc., of the second batch.

Other candidates, particularly Recto, similarly benefited from the above fraud.

The total tallies for Escudero number 40 but was reduced to 30 in words and figures.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS BEI Chairman and Third Member‟s signatures are different from their signatures in the MOV, while Poll Clerk has no signature.

Watchers have no signatures and thumbmarks.

(23)

Exh. “522” (Precinct No. 19-A) ER No. 8800783; Barangay: Banubo; counterpart MOV is Exhibit “720” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS Incredible 99.5% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS Obvious alterations in favor of ZUBIRI consisting of the insertion of the word “one” written before the word “twenty one” in the horizontal line opposite his name and the alteration of his votes in figures to “121” .

Escudero and Alan Cayetano‟s votes in words and figures were also tampered with and reduced to “0” each.

TALLIES Additional tallies, numbering 95, for ZUBIRI were made after his vote tallies had been closed with initials.

The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc., of the second batch.

Other candidates similarly benefited from the above fraud.

The tallies for Aquino, Arroyo, Defensor, Escudero, Oreta and Trillanes were obviously reduced through the use of correction fluid.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS BEI Chairman, Third Member and Poll Clerk‟s signatures are different from their signatures in the MOV. Watchers‟ signatures in the ER are different from those in the MOV.

(24)

Exh. “523” (Precinct No. 20-A) ER No. 8800784; Barangay: Banubo; counterpart MOV is Exhibit “721” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS Incredible 100% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS Obvious alterations in favor Recto and ZUBIRI. TALLIES With tallies numbering only 40, ZUBIRI‟s total votes in words and figures is given as “195”.

With tallies numbering 66, the total votes of Escudero in words and figures is reduced to “0”!

The tallies for Alan Cayetano total 26 but his total votes in words and figures is only “15”.

The tallies for Recto are 22 but his total votes in words and figures is “192”.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS

7

BEI Chairman, Third Member and Poll Clerk‟s signatures are different from their signatures in the MOV. Watchers‟ signatures in the ER are different from those in the MOV.

(25)

Exh. “524” (Precinct No. 20-B/C)  

 



(26)

Exh. “525” (Precinct No. 21-A)   





(27)

ER No. 8800785; Barangay: Banubo; counterpart MOV is Exhibit “722” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS Incredible 90.20% voter turn out.

The 246 ballots found in the compartments for valid ballots is significantly in excess of the 221 voters who allegedly voted.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS Obvious alterations in the votes of Montano, Oreta, Pichay, Recto, Sotto and ZUBIRI to favor them.

TALLIES Additional tallies, numbering 150, for ZUBIRI were made after his vote tallies had been closed with initials.

Other candidates like Pichay and Recto similarly benefited from the above fraudulent additional tallies.

Obvious use of correction fluid to reduce the tallies of Alan Cayetano, Honasan, PIMENTEL, Trillanes and Villar.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS Signatures of the three BEI Members are different from those in the MOV. Watchers‟ signatures on the ER do not appear on the record of watchers present in the MOV. ER No. 8800786; Barangay: Bulalo; counterpart MOV is Exhibit “723”.

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS Incredible 100.1% voter turn out.

“0” ballots found in the compartments for valid ballots.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS Obvious alterations in favor of Magsaysay, Montano, Oreta, Recto and ZUBIRI, consisting of the insertion of the words “one hundred” written in the horizontal lines opposite their names and the prefixing of the number “1” before their two digit entries in the figures.

TALLIES Additional tallies, numbering 153, for ZUBIRI were made after vote tallies had been closed with initials.

Although the additional tallies of 153 for ZUBIRI make his total tallies number 184 (31 plus 153), still his total votes obtained in figures reflect “131” (with an obviously prefixed “1”) and his total votes obtained in words is simply illegible!

The additional tallies were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc., of the second batch.

Other candidates similarly benefited from the above fraud.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS Signatures of the Poll Clerk and Third Member differ from their signatures in the MOV. The BEI Chairman has no signature on the ER. Watchers‟ names are not in the record of watchers present in the MOV.

Exh. “526” (Precinct No. 22-A)  





ER No. 8800787; Barangay: Bulalo; counterpart MOV is Exhibit “724”.

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS Incredible 100% voter turn out.

The 201 ballots found in the compartment for valid ballots are 201 is in excess of the 199 voters who allegedly voted.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS Obvious alterations in favor of Recto and ZUBIRI, among others, consisting of the superimposition of the words “one hundred” written in their total votes obtained in words and the superimposition of the figures “151” and “146” respectively in the column for total votes obtained in figures.

TALLIES Additional tallies, numbering 100 each, for Recto and ZUBIRI were made after their vote tallies had been closed with initials.

The additional tallies of Recto and ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc., of the second batch.

8



(28)

Exh. “527” (Precinct No. 23-A)  







(29)

ER No. 8800788; Barangay: Bulalo; counterpart MOV is exhibit “725”.

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS Incredible 100% voter turn out.

Excess of 3 ballots found in the compartment for valid ballots is attempted to be explained by the entry “199+3 (BEI)” found in the box for the “number of voters who actually voted”.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS Obvious alterations of the votes in words and figures in favor of Magsaysay, Montano, Oreta, Recto and ZUBIRI. ZUBIRI‟s votes in figures of “195” is obviously superimposed over a earlier entry!

Osmena‟s votes in words and figures were also tampered with and reduced to “0”.

TALLIES Additional tallies, numbering 174, for ZUBIRI were made after his vote tallies had been closed with initials.

Other candidates similarly benefited from the above fraud.

The additional tallies of ZUBIRI and the others were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc., of the second batch.

Pichay has two sets of tallies, first numbering 16 and second numbering 100, yet the perpetrator of the fraud forgot to adjust his total number of votes which remained at “16”!

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS The BEI Members‟ signatures are different from those in the MOV. 2 Watchers‟ signatures in the ER were written by one person but no name is indicated.

Exh. “528” (Precinct 24-A)   





(30)

The tallies for Arroyo, Escudero, and Legarda were obviously reduced through the use of correction fluid.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS The BEIs‟ signatures are different from those in the MOV. Watchers‟ signatures in the ER are different from those in the MOV.

ER No. 8800789; Barangay: Bulalo; counterpart MOV is exhibit “726” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS Incredible 98.50% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS Obvious alterations in favor of Defensor, Magsaysay, Oreta, Pichay, Recto, Sotto and ZUBIRI, by consisting of the insertion of the words “one hundred” written in their respective horizontal lines and the prefixing of the number “1” before their two digit entries.

TALLIES Additional tallies, numbering 150, for ZUBIRI were made after his vote tallies had been closed with initials.

The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc., of the second batch. The total tallies of ZUBIRI are 188, while his total votes in words and in figures is 138.

Other candidates, like Defensor, Oreta, Pichay, Recto, Magsaysay and Sotto similarly benefited from the above fraud.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS BEI‟s signatures different from their signatures in the MOV. Watchers‟ names were written by one person and signatures appearing above said names different from the watchers‟ signatures in the MOV.

Exh. “529” (Precinct 25-A)  



ER No. 8800790; Barangay: Bulalo; counterpart MOV is exhibit “727”.

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS Incredible 97.50% voter turn out.

Entry of “202” in ballots found in the compartment for valid ballots is illogical since only 195 voters allegedly voted.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS Obvious alterations in favor of ZUBIRI, consisting of the superimposition of the words “two hundred” in his total votes in words and the number “200” in his total votes in figures.

The total votes for ZUBIRI of “200” exceeds by 5 votes the number of voters who voted!

Recto is similarly benefited.

9





(31)

Exh. “530” (Precinct. 26-A)   





(32)

ER No. 8800791; Barangay: Bulalo; counterpart MOV is exhibit “728” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS Incredible 100% voter turn out.

Entry on number of voters who actually voted is misaligned indicating an intercalation.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS Too many alterations, without initials.

Obvious insertion of the word “one” before the word “thirty” to make ZUBIRI‟s total votes in words read “one thirty” (NOT one hundred thirty).

Obvious prefixing of the number “1” before the number “30” to make ZUBIRI‟s total votes in figures read “130”.

Pichay and Recto‟s votes also fraudulently increased.

TALLIES There are three batches of tallies for ZUBIRI. Additional tallies, numbering 25 plus an additional 55 for a grand total of 80, for ZUBIRI were made after his vote tallies had been closed with initials. The additional 55 had been made after the entry of his votes had been “re-closed” (or closed for the second time)!

The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc., of the second batch. The third batch of tallies was not closed with an initial.

The total tallies of Pichay do not match with his total votes in words and in figures.

Alan Cayetano with 22 tallies was given a vote total in words and in figures of “3” only.

The tallies for Escudero, Honasan, Lacson, Legarda, Trillanes, and Villar were obviously reduced through the use of correction fluid.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS BEI‟s Third Member has no name.

Watchers‟ signatures were written by one person and the said signatures are different from those in the MOV.

Exh. “531” (Precinct No. 27-A)   



(33)

TALLIES Additional tallies, numbering 175, for ZUBIRI were made after his vote tallies had been closed with initials.

The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc., of the second batch. The second batch is aligned differently too.

Same observations for Recto.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS The Chairman and Third Member‟s signatures are different from their signatures in the MOV. Watchers‟ signatures in the ER different from those in the MOV.

ER No. 8800792; Barangay: Bulalo; counterpart MOV is exhibit “729” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS Incredible 100% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS Obvious alterations in favor of ZUBIRI by way of erasures and superimpositions of new words and figures which are almost illegible but could probably read “186”.

Pichay and Recto vote totals also altered.

TALLIES Additional tallies, numbering 180, for Zubiri were made after his vote tallies had been closed with initials.

The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc., of the second batch.

Pichay and Recto also received additional tallies.

Exh. “532” (Precinct No. 28-A)  



ER No. 8800793; Barangay: Bulalo; counterpart MOV is exhibit “730” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS Incredible 101.50% voter turn out. (202 “out of” 199!)

The entry of “203” in ballots found in the compartment for valid ballots is illogical since the number of registered voters is only 199.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS Entries are almost unreadable.

But what are clearly reflected on the copy are the superimposed words and figures!

10





(34)

Exh. “533” (Precinct 29-A)  







(35)

ZUBIRI‟s superimposed total votes in words of “one hundred ninety” and in figures of “190” are clear because these were written with heavier pen pressure. But the words were clearly superimposed over an earlier entry.

Recto similarly benefited.

TALLIES Additional tallies, numbering 140, for ZUBIRI were made after his vote tallies had been closed with initials.

The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc., of the second batch.

Other candidates, like Defensor, Recto, and Montano were also given additional tallies but Montano‟s additional tallies were not counted toward his total votes in words and in figures.

The tallies for Escudero were obviously reduced through the use of correction fluid.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS The BEI members have no names, signatures only which are different from those in the MOV. Watchers‟ have no names and the signatures appearing on the ER are different from those in the MOV. ER No. 8800794; Barangay: Bulalo; counterpart MOV is exhibit “731” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS Incredible 98.49% voter turn out.

Entries of “6” valid ballots withdrawn from the compartment for spoiled ballots allegedly for having been mistakenly placed therein and “3” excess ballots found inside the compartment for valid ballots in excess of the number of voters who voted are illogical because the number of ballots found in the compartment for valid ballots (196) is exactly equal to the alleged number of voters who actually voted (196).

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS Too many alterations, without initials.

Obvious alterations in favor of ZUBIRI. ZUBIRI‟s total votes in words read “one ninety four” with a big space, made by correction fluid, between “one” and “ninety”.

ZUBIRI‟s total votes in figures which read “194” is flushed to the left side. The big space to the right side was created by correction fluid. And the “1” is written differently from the “94”.

Pichay and Recto similarly benefited.

Obvious alterations reducing the votes of Escudero, Honasan, Magsaysay, Osmena, Pangilinan, and PIMENTEL. TALLIES The closing initial(s) in the first batch of tallies for ZUBIRI were erased with correction fluid and superimposed with additional tallies.

194 straight tallies for ZUBIRI would be against instruction number 4 indicated on the ER. Recto similarly benefited from the same type of fraud.

Pichay has 22 tallies yet vote total in words and in figures of 122.

Alan Cayetano has 24 tallies but his total votes in words and figures is “zero”.

Many candidates tallies were obviously reduced through the use of correction fluid.

PIMENTEL‟s tallies which may total 96 were erased to make them total only “9”.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS BEI Members‟ signatures are different from their signatures in the MOV. Watchers‟ signatures in the ER different from those in the MOV.

Exh. “534” (Precinct No. 30-A)  





ER No. 8800795; Barangay: Bulalo; counterpart MOV is exhibit “732” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS Incredible 100% voter turn out.

Excess of “3” ballots is illogical since the 197 ballots found in the compartment for valid ballots equal the 197 voters who allegedly voted.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS Entries are unreadable.

The only readable portion is ZUBIRI‟s total votes in words of “one hundred forty five” where the “one” has been written outside the box and the “hundred” inserted in the space above the gap between “one” and “forty five”.

The “1” in ZUBIRI‟s total votes in figures of “145” has obviously been prefixed since it is of a different stroke and slant from “45”.

TALLIES

11



(36)

Exh. “535” (Precinct No. 31-A)   





(37)

ER No. 8800796; Barangay: Bulalo; counterpart MOV is exhibit “733” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS Incredible 101.52% voter turn out. (201 “out of” 198!)

Entries of “201” in the two boxes are of different pen pressure than the other entries.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS Too many alterations.

Obvious alterations in favor of ZUBIRI consisting of the superimposition of the words “one hundred fifty three” written over correction fluid using a different pen and with different pen pressure from the other entries.

ZUBIRI‟s total votes in figures is given as “153” but the “15” and the “3” have different alignments and different pens used as well as in pen pressure.

Too many candidates benefited by the same type of fraud. Even PIMENTEL‟s votes have been altered.

TALLIES Additional tallies, numbering 138, for ZUBIRI were made after his vote tallies had been closed with initials.

The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc, of the second batch.

Too many additional tallies all over the sheet.

The tallies of Trillanes were totally erased.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Watchers‟ signatures different from those in the MOV.

Exh. “536” (Precinct No. 032-A)   





(38)

Additional tallies, numbering 100, for ZUBIRI were made after his vote tallies had been closed with initials.

The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc., of the second batch.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS Names of the BEI members are unreadable.

ER No. 8800797; Barangay: Bulalo; counterpart MOV is exhibit “734” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alterations in favor of many candidates like Recto and ZUBIRI by erasures and superimpositions of votes in words and prefixing of number “1” was added before the two-digit entries “35” of ZUBIRI. TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 100, for ZUBIRI were made after his entry of 35 votes had been closed. o The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc, of the second batch. o Other candidates, like Defensor, Oreta and Recto, similarly benefited from the above fraud. o The tallies for Aquino, Arroyo, Defensor, Escudero, Oreta and Trillanes were obviously reduced through the use of correction fluid.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Names of BEIs written by one person and their signatures are different when compared to their signatures in the MOV. o No signatures of watchers.

Exh. “537” (Precinct No. 032-B)  

 

ER No. 8800798; Barangay: Bulalo; counterpart MOV is exhibit “735” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 98.48% voter turn out. o Entry of figures 198 as the number of ballots found in the compartment for valid ballots is illogical since 195 voters allegedly voted. No record that the BEIs voted in the precinct in the MOV. DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alterations in favor of ZUBIRI by erasures and superimpositions of his votes in words and in figures.

TALLIES

12

o



(39)

Exh. “538” (Preccinct No. 32- C/D)    



(40)

ER No. 8800799; Barangay: Bulalo; counterpart MOV is exhibit “736” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alterations in favor of ZUBIRI, Sotto and Recto by erasures and superimpositions of their votes in words and figures.

TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 100, for ZUBIRI were made after his entry of 35 votes had been closed. o The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc, of the second batch of tallies. o Other candidates, like Sotto, Roco and Recto similarly benefited from the above fraud.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Names of BEIs and watchers were written by one person and signatures appearing therein differ with their signatures in the MOV.

Exh.”539” (Precinct No. 33-A)    



(41)

Additional tallies, numbering 167, for ZUBIRI were made after his entry of 25 votes had been closed. o The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc, of the second batch of tallies. o The tallies for Escudero, Honasan, Legarda and Villar were obviously reduced with the use of correction fluid.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Names of BEIs were written by one person and their signatures were different when compared to their signatures in the MOV. o Watchers‟ names and signatures have not appeared in the records of watchers in the MOV.

ER No. 8800800; Barangay: Bulibod; counterpart MOV is exhibit “737” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alterations of votes in favor of some candidates particularly ZUBIRI and Recto by erasures and superimpositions of their votes in words and figures.

TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 155, for ZUBIRI were made after his entry of zero (0) votes had been closed. o Additional tallies, numbering 194, for Recto were made after his entry of ten (10) votes had been closed. o The additional tallies of ZUBIRI and Recto were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc, of the second batch of tallies.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Names of BEIs and watchers written by one person and their signatures appearing therein differ when compared to their signatures in the MOV.

Exh. “540” (Precinct No. 034-A)    



ER No. 8800801; Barangay: Bulibod; counterpart MOV is exhibit “738” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alterations of votes in favor of ZUBIRI by erasures and superimpositions of his votes in words and figures.

TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 81, for ZUBIRI were made after his entry of ten (10) votes had been closed. o The additional tallies of ZUBIRI and Recto were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc, of the second batch.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Names of BEIs and watchers written by one person and their signatures appearing therein differ when compared to their signatures in the MOV.

13

(42)

Exh. “541” (Precinct No. 34-B)  

 



(43)

Exh. “542” (Precinct No. 35-A)     

(44)

ER No. 8800803; Barangay: Calsada; counterpart MOV is exhibit “740” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o No entry on Data of Voters and Ballots.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious reduction of the votes of Escudero.

TALLIES o Total tallies of Escudero 119, while his votes in words and figures are 22.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Names of BEIs written by one person. o No signature of Poll Clerk. o No name, signature and thumbmark of Third Member. o No names and thumbmarks of watchers.

Exh. “543” (Precinct No. 36-A)     

(45)

ER No. 8800802; Barangay: Bulibod; counterpart MOV is exhibit “739” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn out. o Entry of excess 23 ballots found inside the compartment for valid ballots in excess of number of voters who voted is illogical.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alterations of votes in favor of Pichay, Recto and ZUBIRI by increasing their votes in words and figures through erasures and superimpositions.

TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 100, for ZUBIRI were made after his entry of “25” votes had been closed. o The additional tallies of ZUBIRI and Recto were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc, of the second batch. o Other candidates, like Pichay and Recto similarly benefited from the above fraud.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Names of BEIs and watchers written by one person and their signatures appearing therein differ when compared to their signatures in MOV.

ER No. 8800804; Barangay: Calsada; counterpart MOV is exhibit “741” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Ballots found in the compartment for valid ballots are 203 or an illogical excess of 10, since 193 actually voted.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious padding of “100” votes for ZUBIRI has shown by insertion of the word “one hundred” below the horizontal line 37 and insertion of the figure “100”.

TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 100, for ZUBIRI were made below line 37 after his entry of zero (0) votes had been closed.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Names of BEIs and watchers written by one person and their signatures appearing therein differ when compared to their signatures in the MOV.

Exh. “544” (Precinct No. 37-A)    

ER No. 8800805; Barangay: Calsada; counterpart MOV is exhibit “742” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alterations of the votes of Recto and ZUBIRI by increasing it through erasures and superimpositions in words and figures.

TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 80, for ZUBIRI were made after his entry of 102 votes had been closed. His total tallies are 182, but his votes in words and figures are “192”. o The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc, of the second batch. o Recto similarly benefited from the above fraud.

14



(46)

Exh. “545” (Precinct No. 38-A)    



(47)

ER No. 8800806; Barangay: Calsada; counterpart (improvise) MOV is exhibit “743” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alterations of the votes of many candidates especially in favor of ZUBIRI by increasing his votes through erasures and superimpositions in words and figures.

TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 100, for ZUBIRI were made after his entry of 65 votes had been closed. o The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc, of the second batch. o Additional tallies, of “152” for Recto were made after his entry of 32 had been closed, which his total votes obtained in words and figures. o Other candidates like Defensor, Singson and Sotto similarly benefited from the above fraud. o The tallies for PIMENTEL were obviously reduced through the use of correction fluid.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Signatures of BEI appearing therein differ from the improvised MOV.

Exh. “546” (Precinct No. 39-A)   





(48)

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Names of BEIs written by one person and signatures appearing therein differ from the MOV. o Watchers‟ names written by one person.

ER No. 8800807; Barangay: Calsada; counterpart MOV is exhibit “744” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alterations of the votes of many candidates notably Pichay, Recto and ZUBIRI by way of suffixing the word “one” before their original votes in words and prefixing the number “1” before their two digit entries of votes. o ZUBIRI‟s original votes in words are “sixty seven”.

TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 120, for ZUBIRI were made after his entry of 67 votes had been closed. o The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc, of the second batch of tallies. o Other candidates like Pichay, Recto, Sotto and Oreta similarly benefited from the above fraud.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Names of BEIs written by one person and signatures differ from the MOV. o Watchers‟ have no names but with fictitious signatures.

Exh. “547” (Precinct No. 40-A)   



ER No. 8800808; Barangay: Calsada; counterpart MOV is exhibit “745” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alterations of the votes of many candidates notably Pichay, Recto and ZUBIRI by way of erasures and superimpositions. o As example, Recto‟s votes were increased to “195”.

TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 134, for ZUBIRI were made after his entry of 62 votes had been closed. The additional tallies and his original tallies totals 196 but his votes in words and figures still 62. o The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc, of the second batch of tallies. o Other candidates like Defensor, Pichay, Recto, Singson, Sotto and Oreta similarly benefited from the above fraud. o The tallies of Escudero, Legarda and Alan Cayetano were obviously reduced through the use of correction fluid.

15



(49)

Exh. “548” (Precinct No. 40-B)  







(50)

ER No. 8800809; Barangay: Calsada; counterpart MOV is exhibit “746” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100.5% voter turn out. o 197 voters who voted is Mathematically Impossible, since there are only 196 Registered Voters. No record in the MOV that BEI voted in the precinct.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alterations of the votes of many candidates notably Pichay, Recto and ZUBIRI by way of erasures and superimpositions. o ZUBIRI has two entries of votes in words and figures. One is written in the horizontal line opposite his name by another person. o PIMENTEL‟s votes in words and figures were erased and increased to 140.

TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 100, for ZUBIRI were made after his entry of 90 votes had been closed. o Additional tallies, numbering 154, for Recto were made after his entry of 6 votes had been closed. o The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc, of the second batch. o Other candidates like Magsaysay, Montano and Pichay similarly benefited from the above fraud. o The tallies of Escudero were obviously reduced through the use of correction fluid. o PIMENTEL‟s tallies are only 25, but his total votes words and figures are 140.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Chairman‟s signature differs with his signature in MOV and has no thumbmark.

Exh. “549” (Precinct No. 40-C)   





(51)

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Names and signatures of BEIs differ than in MOV. o Watchers‟ names and signatures are fictitious and 3 spaces are blank for names, signatures and thumbprints.

ER No. 8800810; Barangay: Calsada; counterpart MOV is exhibit “747” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 97.49% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alterations of the votes of many candidates notably Defensor, Pichay Recto and ZUBIRI by way of erasures and superimpositions. o ZUBIRI‟s and Recto‟s votes were increased to 194 each or equivalent to 100% of the voters who voted.

TALLIES o ZUBIRI‟s tallies were only 82 but his totals 194. o Recto‟s tallies were only 66 but his totals 194. o Pichay‟s tallies were only 42 but his totals 142. o Defensor‟s tallies were only 66 but his total 166. o Montano‟s tallies were only 86 but his totals 186.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Names of BEI written by one person. o Signatures of 3 watchers written by one person.

Exh. “550” (Precinct No. 40-D)  



 

ER No. 8800811; Barangay: Calsada; counterpart MOV is exhibit “748” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 101.57% voter turn out. o 129 ballots found in the compartment for valid ballots is Mathematically Impossible, since there are only 127 Registered Voters and 126 voters allegedly voted.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o The entry of votes in the columns for total votes obtained clearly appear to be written in the original as shown by the names and signatures of the last two spaces for watchers and the initials appearing after the tallies of the candidates.

TALLIES o The tallies appearing in the opposites names of the candidates seem to be different and the same as the entry of votes.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Signatures of BEIs and watchers differ than in MOV.

16

(52)

Exh. “551” (Precinct No. 41-A)   

 

(53)

Exh. “552” (Precinct No. 42-A)  

 



(54)

ER No. 8800813; Barangay: Damaniog; counterpart MOV is exhibit “750” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 101.5% voter turn out. o The 202 ballots found in the compartment for valid ballots is illogical and Mathematically impossible since, 199 voters allegedly voted.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alterations of the votes of many candidates like Magsaysay, Montano Pichay, PIMENTEL, Recto and ZUBIRI by way of erasures and superimpositions.

TALLIES o Additional tallies were made for candidates Magsaysay, Montano, Oreta, Pangilinan, Pichay, Recto, Sotto and ZUBIRI after his entry of votes had been closed. o The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc, of the second batch.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o No signature of the Poll Clerk above his/ her written name. o Only 2 watcher signed and thumbmarked the ER.

Exh. “553” (Precinct No. 43-A)  







(55)

ER No. 8800812; Barangay: Damaniog; counterpart MOV is exhibit “749” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 99.50% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alterations of the votes of many candidates notably ZUBIRI by way of erasures and superimpositions thus increasing his votes to 193 or 97.47% of those who voted.

TALLIES o Pichay‟s tallies were only 28 but his total votes in words and figures are 128. o ZUBIRI‟s tallies were 35 but his total votes in words and figures are 123.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Names and signatures of BEI differ than in MOV.

ER No. 8800814; Barangay: Damaniog; counterpart MOV is exhibit “751” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 101.5% voter turn out. o There are 198 Registered Voters in the precinct but 201 ballots found inside the compartment for valid ballots and 201 voters allegedly voted.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alterations in favor of Recto consisting of the erasures and superimpositions of the words and figures “two hundred” (200). o Obvious alterations in favor of ZUBIRI consisting of the erasures and superimpositions of the words and figures “one hundred seventy nine” (179).

TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 100, for ZUBIRI were made after his entry of votes had been closed. o The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc, of the second batch. o The tallies of Recto are only 80 but his votes in words and figures are “200”.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Only 2 watchers signed and thumbmarked the ER.

Exh. “554” (Precinct No. 43-B)  

 

ER No. 8800815; Barangay: Damaniog; counterpart MOV is exhibit “752” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 101.98% voter turn out. o 154 ballots were found in the compartment for valid ballots are illogical and Mathematically Impossible since there are only 151 Registered Voters. No Report in MOV that 3 BEI voted in the precinct.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alterations increasing ZUBIRI to 140 by way of erasures and superimpositions.

TALLIES

17

o



(56)

Exh. “555” (Precinct No. 44-A)   

 

(57)

 





ER No. 8800816; Barangay: Darapanan; counterpart MOV is exhibit “754” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alterations of the votes of ZUBIRI by way of erasures and superimpositions.

Word “one hundred” was written by another person before words “seventy seven”.

His votes in figures are readable as “1827”.

TALLIES o ZUBIRI‟s long rows of tallies, numbering 127 do not conform to the instructions where 100 ballots should be piled and read, and the sum to be recorded after the last tally.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Names of the BEI were written by one person. o No watchers names, signature and thumbmarks on the ER.

Exh. “557” (Precinct No. 45-B/C)    



(59)

ER No. 8800817; Barangay: Darapanan; counterpart MOV is exhibit “753” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o There are many erasures and double entries of total votes obtained in figures for candidates Defensor, Enciso, Escudero, Honasan, Kiram, Magsaysay, Montano, Oreta, Pichay, Recto, Singson, Sison, Sotto and Zubiri. o So many erasures in total votes obtained in WORDS are clearly seen for candidates Defensor, Enciso, Magsaysay, Montano, Oreta, Singson, Sotto and Zubiri.

TALLIES o The tallies of ZUBIRI were only 110 but his votes in words are “one hundred twenty six”.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o BEI Chairman signed above his/ her name but has no thumbmark. o Third Member has thumb marked but no signature above his/ her printed name. o No watchers signed and thumbmarked on the ER.

Exh. “556” (Precinct No. 45-A)



(58)

Additional tallies, numbering 78, for ZUBIRI were made after his entry of his 62 votes had been closed. o The additional tallies of ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc, of the second batch.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o No signatures of watchers.

ER No. 8800818; Barangay: Darapanan; counterpart MOV is exhibit “755” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alterations of the votes of many candidates like Defensor,Recto, Sotto and ZUBIRI. TALLIES o ZUBIRI‟s long rows of tallies, numbering 127 do not conform to the instructions where 100 ballots should be piled and read, and the sum to be recorded after the last tally. o Other candidates similarly benefited from the above fraud.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o No thumbmarks of the BEI. o 2 watchers signatures and thumb marks were done by the same person.

Exh. “558” (Precinct No. 46-A)    

ER No. 8800819; Barangay: Gang; counterpart MOV is exhibit “756” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alterations of the votes of many candidates like Defensor,Recto, Sotto and ZUBIRI. TALLIES

18

ZUBIRI‟s long rows of tallies, numbering 127 do not conform to the instructions where 100 ballots should be piled and read, and the sum to be recorded after the last tally. o Other candidates similarly benefited from the above fraud.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o No thumbmarks of the BEI. o 2 signatures and thumb marks of watchers on the ER were done by only one person. o



(60)

Exh. “559” (Precinct No. 47-A)   





(61)

Exh. “560” (Precinct No. 48-A)  





(62)

ER No. 8800820; Barangay: Gang; counterpart MOV is exhibit “757” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 98.50% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alterations of the votes of many candidates like Kiram, Pichay, Recto and ZUBIRI that increased their votes in words and in figures but, did not match with their votes in tallies. o Aquino‟s, Alan Cayetano, Escudero‟s in words and in figures were also tampered with and reduced.

TALLIES o The tallies for Aquino were clearly 55 but 35 tallies were only credited on his total votes obtained. o The tallies for Alan Cayetano were clearly 50 but 30 tallies were only credited on his total votes obtained. o The tallies for Escudero were clearly 100 but 60 tallies were only credited on his total votes obtained. o Candidate Pichay got 2 on his tallies but his total votes obtained are 82. o Candidate Recto got 2 on his tallies but his total votes obtained are 182. o Candidate ZUBIRI got 2 on his tallies but his total votes obtained are 190.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o 3 signatures and thumb marks of watchers on the ER were done by only one person.

ER No. 8800821; Barangay: Gang; counterpart MOV is exhibit “758” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn out.  DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Total votes in figures and words of almost all Team Unity candidates were manufactured and written by two persons TALLIES o Pimentel has taras of 30 but his total is zero (0) both in words and figures. o Zubiri taras is 60 followed by initials of BEIs. But additional 140 taras were mode after the initials o Recto initial taras is 5 duly signed but followed by 195 taras.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Poll Clerk has no thumbmark. o All 5 spaces for watchers have a name, signature, and thumbmark of only 1 person.

Exh. “561” (Precinct No. 49-A)  





ER No. 8800822; Barangay: Gang; counterpart MOV is exhibit “759” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 101% voter turn out. o There are only 197 voters who voted but 199 ballots were found in the compartment for valid ballots to make it appear that the 199 registered voters 100% voted.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alterations of votes for candidates Defensor, Kiram, Magsaysay, Montano, Oreta, Pichay, Recto, Singson,Sotto, and ZUBIRI by way of erasures and superimpositions. o Escudero‟s, Lacson‟s, Legarda‟s, Osmena‟s, PIMENTEL‟s, Roco‟s, Trillanes‟ and Villar‟s votes in words and figures were also tampered with and reduced.

TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 30, for ZUBIRI were made after his entry of votes had been closed. o The additional tallies of Zubiri were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc, of the second batch. o The tallies for Escudero, Lacson, Legarda, Osmena, PIMENTEL, Roco, Trillanes and Villar were obviously reduced through the use of correction fluid.

19



(63)

Exh. “562” (Precinct No. 50-A)    



(64)

ER No. 8800823; Barangay: Gang; counterpart MOV is exhibit “760” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alterations of votes for candidates Defensor, Magsaysay, Montano, Oreta, Pichay, Recto, Singson, Sotto, and ZUBIRI by way of erasures and superimpositions.

TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 145, for ZUBIRI were made after his entry of votes had been closed. o The additional tallies of Zubiri were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressure, stroke, etc, of the second batch. o Other candidates similarly benefited from the above fraud.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Watchers were filled-up by only one person with his/ her name written on the 4 spaces for watchers and also the thumb mark.

Exh. “563” (Precinct No. 51-A)   





(65)

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Only 2 watchers signed and thumbmarked the ER.

ER No. 8800824; Barangay: Gang; counterpart MOV is exhibit “761” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 98.99% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Written in Defensor votes in words is the word “two” with clear erasures before it and his votes in figures are readable as “2” with also a clear erasure before it. o Escudero votes in words and figures were clearly erased and written therein is “14” and “four”. o Other erasures and alteration of votes in words in figures can be clearly seen in the lines for Pichay, Recto, Singson, Sotto, Trillanes. o Clearly the votes in words and figures of Zubiri were clearly erased and superimposed with figures “194” and “one hundred ninety four”, which are written over an erased part of printed line 37.

TALLIES o His tallies has two subtotals, which are “22” followed by initials and “90” actual taras written differently. o Ten boxes of taras were clearly erased and his total as included has erasures before the figure “4”. o Tallies of Legarda, Osmeña, and Trillanes had erasures and the votes in words and figures also with erasures. o Pimentel tallies is 30 but his votes in words and figures are only “3” and three superimposed over a correction fluid. o ZUBIRI‟s votes clearly, you will see 160 taras different written and inserted by another person. o Inserted tallies can be seen in lines for Angara, Recto, Defensor, Magsaysay, Montano, Oreta, Pichay, Recto, Singson and Sotto.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Only 3 watchers signed and thumbmarked the ER.

Exh. “564” (Precinct No. 51-B)   

ER No. 8800824; Barangay: Gang; counterpart MOV is exhibit “761” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Zubiri votes in words and figures show erasures that even the printed line 37 under it was partially erased by correction fluid. His 162 votes are manufactured. o Written in Defensor votes in words is the word “two” with clear erasures before it and his votes in figures are readable as “2” with also a clear erasure before it. o Escudero votes in words and figures were clearly erased and written therein is “14” and “four”. o Other erasures and alteration of votes in words in figures can be clearly seen in the lines for Pichay, Recto, Singson, Sotto, Trillanes. o Clearly the votes in words and figures of Zubiri were clearly erased and superimposed with figures “194” and “one hundred ninety four”, which are written over an erased part of printed line 37.

20





(66)

Exh. “565” (Precinct No. 51-C)  

 o o 



(67)

ER No. 8800826; Barangay: Gang; counterpart MOV is exhibit “763” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 98.71% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS Montano‟s total votes in words and figures are 190 or 37 more than the 153 who actually voted.

Recto‟s votes in words and figures are “193” or 40 more than those who actually voted .

TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 150, for Zubiri were made after his entry of votes had been closed. o The additional tallies of Zubiri were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressures, stroke, etc, of the second batch. o Other candidates similarly benefited from the above fraud.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o The BEI Chairman has no names and signature but with thumbmark. o 3 spaces for watcher have one name, similar signature and thumbmark. The other 2 spaces have 2 different names but same style of signature. All thumbmarks in 5 boxes spaces to be the same.

Exh. “566” (Precinct No. 52-A)  







(68)

TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 106, for Zubiri were made after his entry of votes had been closed. o The additional tallies of Zubiri were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressures, stroke, etc, of the second batch. o Other candidates similarly benefited from the above fraud. o A long row of tallies of candidate Kiram were erased by correction fluid such that 100 tallies were left clearly visible. o The original 61 tallies of Recto clearly still appear in his votes in figures and words. o Villar tallies are actually 69 but his credited vote in words and figures is 1.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o The Poll Clerk has no signature. o No signature of Watchers.

ER No. 8800827; Barangay: Inawan; counterpart MOV is exhibit “764” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 99.50% voter turn out. o Entry of “4 excess ballots” is illogical since 198 ballots were allegedly found in the compartment for valid ballots and 198 voters allegedly voted.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Recto votes in words have two, entries “one hundred sixty nine” and “sixty-seven”. o Zubiri original votes in words and figures were erased by a correction fluid and changed to “189” and “one hundred eighty nine”.

TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 94, for Zubiri were made after his entry of votes had been closed. o The additional tallies of Zubiri were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressures, stroke, etc, of the second batch. o Other candidates similarly benefited from the above fraud.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Third member of the BEI has no name and signature only thumb mark. o Only 4 watchers print their names and signed but no thumbprints.

Exh “567” (Precinct No. 53-A)    

ER No. 8800828; Barangay: Inawan; counterpart MOV is exhibit “765” DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 99.50% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Erasures or Alterations of Total Votes Obtained are clearly visible for TU candidates especially Defensor, Recto and Zubiri.

TALLIES

21

o



(69)

Exh “568” (Precinct No. 54-A)    



(70)

ER No. 8800829; Barangay: Ibotigen; No counterpart MOV exhibit.

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 97.97% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alterations in favor of ZUBIRI consisting of the erasures and superimpositions of his votes.

TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 15, for Zubiri were made after his entry of votes had been closed. o The additional tallies of Zubiri were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressures, stroke, etc, of the second batch.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Only 2 watchers signed and thumbprint the ER.

Exh. “569” (Precinct No. 55-A)  





(71)

Additional tallies, numbering 125, for Zubiri were made after his entry of votes had been closed. o The additional tallies of Zubiri were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressures, stroke, etc, of the second batch. o Other candidates similarly benefited from the above fraud.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Only 3 watchers print their names and signed but no thumbprints.

ER No. 8800830; Barangay: Ibotigen; counterpart MOV is exhibit “766”.  DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 99.0% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o All TU candidates got over 100 votes, from high 191 votes or 96.46% of all who actually voted for Recto and Zubiri. The total votes obtained by all TU candidates were all fraudulent altered, manufactured and fabricated as shown by erasures in words and figures. o The total votes in words of TU candidates can clearly be seen as written by another person as shown by different handwriting style, stroke and pen used especially for Recto, Zubiri, Defensor, Kiram.

TALLIES o The actual count of tallies for Recto is only 131, but his total votes obtained is 191 padding of 60 votes. o The actual count of tallies for Zubiri is 139 but his total votes obtained is 191, a padded manufactured votes of 52.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o The names of the members of BEI and the two watchers were written by one person and the BEI signature/ initials were fictitiously done by one and same person. o 2 watchers wrote their names and thumbmarked but no signatures above their names.

Exh. “570” (Precinct No. 56-A)  







ER No. 8800831; Barangay: Ibotigen; counterpart MOV is exhibit “767”.

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100.5% voter turn out. o Entry of “3 excess ballots” is illogical since 200 ballots were allegedly found in the compartment for valid ballots and 198 voters allegedly voted.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o There are clear erasures by correction fluid in lines below the votes in figures and words of Defensor, Pangilinan, Singson, Villar and Zubiri as shown by the erasures printed horizontal lines below the votes in figures and words.

TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 50, for Zubiri were made after his entry of votes had been closed. o The additional tallies of Zubiri were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressures, stroke, etc, of the second batch.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o All BEIs did not sign the ER. o Only one space for watcher was signed and thumbmarked.

22

(72)

Exh. “571” (Precinct No. 57-A)  







(73)

Exh. “572” (Precinct No. 58-A)   





(74)

ER No. 8800832; Barangay: Ibotigen; counterpart MOV is exhibit “768”.

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn out. o Entry of “2 excess ballots” found in the compartment for valid ballots in excess of voters who actually voted is illogical.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o There are clear alterations by erasures and insertion of thw words “one hundred” above the original votes in words for candidates Defensor, Kiram, Magsaysay, Montano, Oreta, Pichay, Recto, Singson, Sotto and ZUBIRI. TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 115, for Zubiri were made after his entry of 83 votes had been closed. o The additional tallies of Zubiri were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressures, stroke, etc, of the second batch. o Other candidates like Recto and Defensor similarly benefited from the above fraud.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Watcher “Fahad Pako” has 3 names, signatures and thumbmarks in the spaces for watchers. o Watcher “Ali Ibrahim” has two names, signatures and thumbmarks in the spaces for watchers. o Names of BEIs written by the same person and signatures therein differ than in MOV.

ER No. 8800833; Barangay: Ibotigen; counterpart MOV is exhibit “769”.

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 99.49% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o The votes in figures for candidates Aquino, Bautista, Defensor, Pimentel, and Zubiri were altered. o The votes in figures for candidates Aquino, Bautista, Defensor, Pimentel, and Zubiri were altered. o In the column for words and figures, clearly 2 persons wrote some words as clearly shown in the column for Bautista and Pimentel where the word “two” was written under the word “hundred”. o In the column for Zubiri, erasures made in snowpake were done as shown by the almost total erasure of the printed figure “37”. o Further in Zubiri column for figure, the clear figure “1” between 9 and 1 with an apparent initial.

TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 8, for Zubiri were made after his entry of votes had been closed. o The additional tallies of Zubiri were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressures, stroke, etc, of the second batch.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o The thumb marks appear to have been done by one person. o Two spaces bares the name and thumb mark of “Abdilla”, 2 spaces have thumb mark but without names. o Incomplete signatures of BEIs

Exh. “573” (Precinct No. 58- B/C)    

ER No. 8800834; Barangay: Ibotigen; counterpart MOV is exhibit “770”.

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Total votes in words and figures for candidates Pichay, Recto and Zubiri bear erasures and unbelievably high.

TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 213, for Zubiri were made after his entry of zero (0) vote had been closed. o Additional tallies, numbering 220, for Recto were made after his entry of zero (0) vote had been closed. o Additional tallies, numbering 220, for Pichay were made after his entry of zero (0) vote had been closed.

23

o 

(75)

Exh. “574” (Precinct No. 59-A)   





(76)

ER No. 8800835; Barangay: Kabuntalan; counterpart MOV is exhibit “771”.

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 101.5% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alterations in favor of Defensor, Kiram, Recto, Singson and ZUBIRI by way of erasures and superimpositions. o Aquino‟s and Escuero‟s votes in words and figures were also tampered with and reduced.

TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 16, for Zubiri were made after his entry of vote had been closed. o Additional tallies, numbering 74, for Recto were made after his entry of vote had been closed. o The additional tallies of Zubiri were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressures, stroke, etc, of the second batch. o Other candidates similarly benefited from the above fraud. o Some tallies of Escudero and Kiram were erased by correction fluid SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Poll Clerk and Third Members have no thumbmarks on the ER. o No signatures of the 3 watchers only printed names and thumbmarks.

Exh. “575” (Precinct No. 60-A)   





(77)

The additional tallies of Zubiri were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressures, stroke, etc, of the second batch.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Watcher “Datumama Milog” filled-up, signed and thumbmarked on the 3 spaces for watchers. o Watcher “Faisal Mategas” signed above his printed name but no thumbmark.

ER No. 8800836; Barangay: Kabuntalan; counterpart MOV is exhibit “772”.

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o In the columns for total votes obtained in words and figures, clearly seen and readable are erasures, superimpositions and alterations of the votes of Defensor, Kiram, Pichay, Singson, Sotto and Zubiri. o In line 37for Zubiri, his votes in figures were erased in change to 171, and his votes in words show superimpositions of the words “seventy one” after the word “hundred”.

TALLIES o Additional tallies, numbering 60, for Pichay were made after his entry of vote had been closed. o Additional tallies, numbering 74, for Recto were made after his entry of vote had been closed. o The additional tallies of Pichay were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressures, stroke, etc, of the second batch.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Signature of Poll Clerk is not similar to her signature in MOV. Third Member has no signature.

Exh. “576” (Precinct No. 61-A)    



ER No. 8800837; Barangay: Kabuntalan; counterpart MOV is exhibit “773”.

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 98.9% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alterations in the votes of Recto and Zubiri by erasures and superimpositions of their votes in words and figures.

TALLIES o There are additional tallies for ZUBIRI and Recto which were obviously written by a different person other than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressures, stroke, etc, of the second batch.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o BEIs and watchers names and signatures were written by one.

24

(78)

Exh. “577” (Precinct No. 62-A)   





(79)

Exh. “578” (Precinct No. 63-A)   





(80)

ER No. 8800839; Barangay: Kakar; counterpart MOV is exhibit “775”.

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Pimentel‟s total votes in words and figures bear erasures by correction fluid and superimposed by the figure “100” and words “one hundred”. o Votes of Roco were erased by correction fluid and her total votes in words and figures were erased and superimposed to “0” and words “zero”.

TALLIES. o Additional tallies, numbering 64, for ZUBIRI were made after his entry of votes had been closed o There are additional tallies for ZUBIRI and Recto which were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressures, stroke, etc, of the second batch.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Two of the five watchers who had their thumbmarks have no signatures above their names. Three of the five watchers signed and thumb marked but their names were not written.

Exh. “579” (Precinct No. 64-A)    



(81)

ER No. 8800838; Barangay: Kakar; counterpart MOV is exhibit “774”.

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o All Team Unity candidates‟ votes in words and figures were erased and superimposed with new figures. o Zubiri‟s votes in words is altered with words “one hundred” prefixed to the word “ninety” and written above in unreadable word in line 37.

TALLIES o Vote of Lacson in taras were completely erased by correction fluid and is credited with zero votes. o Additional tallies, numbering 136, for Recto were made after his entry of votes had been closed. o Additional tallies, numbering 155, for ZUBIRI were made after his entry of votes had been closed o There are additional tallies for ZUBIRI and Recto which were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressures, stroke, etc, of the second batch. o Other candidates similarly benefited from the above fraud.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o BEIs and watchers names and signatures were written by one. o No watcher signature though all boxes with thumbmark.

ER No. 8800825;Barangay: Kakar; counterpart MOV is exhibit “776”.

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 99.50% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alterations in the votes in words and figures of many candidates, especially on ZUBIRI and Recto by erasures and superimpositions.

TALLIES. o Additional tallies, numbering 180, for ZUBIRI were made after his entry of 15 votes had been closed. o Additional tallies, numbering 169, for Recto were made after his entry of votes had been closed. o There are additional tallies for ZUBIRI and Recto which were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressures, stroke, etc, of the second batch. o Other candidates similarly benefited from the above fraud. o The tallies of Gomez, Honasan and Legarda were obviously tampered with and reduced by correction fluid.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o BEIs and watchers signatures written above their fictitious name differ than in MOV.

Exh. “580” (Precinct No. 64-B) 

ER No. 8800841;Barangay: Kakar; counterpart MOV is exhibit “777”.

25

 





(82)

Exh. “581” (Precinct No. 64-C)   





(83)

ER No. 8800840; Barangay: Kakar; counterpart MOV is exhibit “778”.

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alteration in favor of Angara, Aquino, Arroyo, Pichay, Pimentel, Recto and Zubiri consisting of the insertion of the words “one hundred” written above the horizontal line opposite their names. o Escudero‟s, Trillanes‟ and Villar‟s votes in words and figures were also tampered with and reduced.

TALLIES. o Additional tallies, numbering 120, for ZUBIRI were made after his entry of votes had been closed. o There are additional tallies for ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressures, stroke, etc, of the second batch. o Other candidates similarly benefited from the above fraud. o The tallies of Escudero, Trillanes and Villar were obviously reduced through the use of correction fluid..

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Two watchers have same signature while the other 3 have no names only signature and thumb marks. o The line for the 3 members of the BEI has no names but only signature and thumb marks.

Exh. “582” (Precinct No. 64- D/E)   





(84)

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 99.50% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alteration by erasures and superimpositions of ZUBIRI‟s votes in words and figures thus increasing his votes from zero (0) to 175. o Other candidates like Singson and Defensor similarly benefited from the above fraud.

TALLIES. o Additional tallies, numbering 175, for ZUBIRI were written below his horizontal line 37 after his vote which is zero were closed by an initial. o There are additional tallies for ZUBIRI and Recto which were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressures, stroke, etc, of the second batch. o Other candidates similarly benefited from the above fraud. o The tallies of Sotto are 26, Defensor is zero but their votes in words and figures are “60” and “26” respectively.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o The names of the BEIs were written by one person. o There are 3 watchers thumbprint without signatures.

ER No. 8800843; Barangay: Kakar; counterpart MOV is exhibit “779”.

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 92.24% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Escudero votes in words and figures are 55, but clear correction fluid can be seen, superimposed by the word “fifty”. o Obvious alterations in favor of Recto, Sotto and ZUBIRI by way of erasures and superimpositions of their votes in words and figures.

TALLIES. o ZUBIRI‟s long rows of tallies, numbering 195 do not conform to the instructions where 100 ballots should be piled and read, and the sum to be recorded after the last tally. o Other candidates similarly benefited from the above fraud.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o The BEI signatures and thumbmarks are fictitious as MOV do show records of voting and voting time and MOV not signed by BEI.

Exh “583” (Precinct No. 65-A)  

ER No. 8800844; Barangay: Kapimpilan; counterpart MOV is exhibit “780”.

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn out.

26

Entry “3 excess ballots” is illogical since 200 ballots were allegedly found in the compartment for valid ballots and 200 voters allegedly voted.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o The BEIs and watchers has no names. o Signatures of BEIs differ from their signatures in MOV. o Third Member no thumbmark. o Watchers no signatures and thumbmarks. o



(85)

Exh “584” (Precinct No. 66-A)  







(86)

Exh. “585” (Precinct No. 67- A/B)   





(87)

ER No. 8800845; Barangay: Kapimpilan; counterpart MOV is exhibit “781”.

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 99.50% voter turn out. o Entry “3 excess ballots” is illogical since 196 ballots were found inside the compartment for valid ballots and 196 voters allegedly voted.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alterations in favor of ZUBIRI consisting of the insertion of the words “one hundred” written above the horizontal line opposite his name and the prefixing of the number “1” before his two digit entries in figures.

TALLIES. o Additional tallies, numbering 100, for ZUBIRI were made after his entry of votes had been closed. o There are additional tallies for ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressures, stroke, etc, of the second batch. o Other candidates similarly benefited from the above fraud.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o This ER has no signature of any Watcher. The two unsigned names therein are not recorded in the MOV.

ER No. 8800846; Barangay: Kapimpilan; No counterpart MOV exhibit.

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alterations in favor of Defensor, Kiram, Magsaysay, Montano, Oreta, Pichay, Recto Singson, Sotto ZUBIRI consisting of the insertion of the words “one hundred” written above the horizontal line opposite his name and the prefixing of the number “1” before his two digit entries in figures. o Pimentel‟s votes in words and figures were also tampered and reduced. Pimentel‟s votes in tallies are 15 but his votes in words and figures became zero (0).

TALLIES. o Additional tallies, numbering 112, for ZUBIRI were made after his entry of votes had been closed. o There are additional tallies for ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressures, stroke, etc, of the second batch. o Other candidates similarly benefited from the above fraud.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o BEI chairman and poll clerk have no names, poll clerk has signature with no thumb mark, chairman with signature and thumb mark. o All 5 watchers have thumb marks clearly coming from one person but no names and signature.

Exh. “586” (Precinct No. 68-A)  





ER No. 8800847; Barangay: Katamlagan; counterpart MOV is exhibit “782”.

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 99.0% voter turn out. o Entry “5 excess ballots” is illogical since 202 ballots were allegedly found in the compartment for valid ballots and 197 voters allegedly voted.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Recto where his votes in words show superimposition and his votes in figures also showing superimpositions which caused it to be unreadable. o Zubiri votes in words show superimposition and his figures were also superimposed.

TALLIES. o Additional tallies, numbering 60 each, for Recto and ZUBIRI were made after their entry of votes had been closed.

27

o



(88)

Exh. “587” (Precinct No. 69-A)  







(89)

ER No. 8800849; Barangay: Katamlagan; counterpart MOV is exhibit “783”.

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 98.50% voter turn out. o Entry “2 excess ballots” is illogical since 202 ballots were allegedly found in the compartment for valid ballots and 197 voters allegedly voted.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Pimentel‟s Trillanes‟ and Legarda‟s votes in words and in figures were also tampered with and reduced by erasures through the use of the correction fluid and superimposed with words and figures five (5) for Pimentel, five (5) for Trillanes and seven (7) for Legarda. o Obvious alterations in favor of Recto by way of erasures and superimpositions of the words “eighty four” after the words “one hundred”, when his total votes in tallies are 176.

TALLIES. o Tallies for Pimentel, Legarda, and Trillanes did not match with their votes in words and figures. Tallies for Pimentel totals 15, for Legarda totals 35 and for Trillanes totals 45.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o The BEIs names written by one person. o Three spaces for watchers have same name “UDI”, and the other 2 spaces have same name “Israil”.

Exh. “588” (Precinct No. 69-B)  







(90)

There are additional tallies for ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressures, stroke, etc, of the second batch. o Other candidates similarly benefited from the above fraud.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o The members of the BEI have no names. The signature appears to be written by one person including the thumbmarks. o The signatures of the 5 watchers were clearly done by one person all the watchers have no names. The 5 thumbmarks appear to be coming from one person.

ER No. 8800848; Barangay: Katamlagan; counterpart MOV is exhibit “784”.

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 98.42% voter turn out. o Entry “3 excess ballots” is illogical since 125 ballots were allegedly found in the compartment for valid ballots and 125 voters allegedly voted.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o There are 3 corrected entries of total votes obtained both in words and figures for candidates Defensor, Recto, and Zubiri. The initial validating the correction is not found among the many initials appearing in the returns. o The total 141 votes of Zubiri both in words and figures are manufactured votes which are mathematically impossible to attain considering that 125 voters actually voted.

The excess 16 votes is concrete proof of its fabrication.

TALLIES. o Additional tallies, numbering 55, for Zubiri were made after the entry of his votes had been closed. o There are additional tallies for ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressures, stroke, etc, of the second batch. o Other candidates similarly benefited from the above fraud.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS Three (3) of the watchers with names, signatures and thumb marks have surname “Ebrahim” and their first names are “Abdudayan”, “Alan” and “Abubakar” their names are clearly written by one person.

Exh. “589” (Precinct No. 70-A)  



ER No. 8800850; Barangay: Katidtuan; counterpart MOV is exhibit “785”.

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn out. o Entry “3 excess ballots” is illogical since 198 ballots were allegedly found in the compartment for valid ballots and 201 voters allegedly voted.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alterations of many candidates especially Zubiri by way of erasures through the use of correction fluid and superimpositions of their votes in words and figures.

28

o





(91)

Exh. “590” (Precinct No. 71-A)   





(92)

ER No. 8800851; Barangay: Katidtuan; No counterpart MOV exhibit.

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 99.50% voter turn out. o 200 ballots or an excess of 4, were found in the compartment for ballots.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Obvious alterations increased their votes in favor of Pangilinan, Pichay, and Monatno by way of erasures through the use of correction fluid and superimpositions of their votes in figures.

TALLIES. o Additional tallies, numbering 169, for Zubiri were made after the entry of his votes had been closed. o There are additional tallies for ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressures, stroke, etc, of the second batch.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o BEIs names were written by one person. o No watchers signed and thumbmarked in the ER.

Exh. “591” (Precinct No. 72-A)   

 

(93)

The total 141 votes of Zubiri both in words and figures are manufactured votes which are mathematically impossible to attain considering that 125 voters actually voted.

The excess 16 votes is concrete proof of its fabrication.

TALLIES. o Additional tallies, numbering 67, for Zubiri were made after the entry of his votes had been closed. o There are additional tallies for ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressures, stroke, etc, of the second batch. o Other candidates similarly benefited from the above fraud.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o BEIs and Watchers names were written by one person.

ER No. 8800852; Barangay: Katidtuan; counterpart MOV is exhibit “786”.

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o Defensor‟s total votes in words and figures were erased by correction fluid and superimposed by figure “13” and words “thirteen”. o The votes in words of Zubiri clearly bear erasures and superimpositions in line 37 and below the line written the words “eighty eight”. His votes in figures appear to have a figure “8” suffixed after figures “18” and the suffixed eight (8) was written by another person.

TALLIES. o Zubiri‟s and Recto‟s long tallies of votes do not conform to the instructions on how to tally the votes printed and illustrated in the ER. SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o No watchers signature, though, there are two thumbmarks.

Exh. “592” (Precinct No. 73-A)   





ER No. 8800853; Barangay: Katidtuan; counterpart MOV is exhibit “787”.

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 98.99% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o This ER entries in total votes obtained, contain clear erasures and alterations of votes because of inserted additional tallies which even benefited candidate PIMENTEL who has 198 votes obtained.

TALLIES. o Additional tallies, numbering 187, for Zubiri were made after his entry of votes had been closed. o There are additional tallies for ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressures, stroke, etc, of the second batch. o Other candidates similarly benefited from the above fraud.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Names of the BEIs were written by one person.

29

o

(94)

Exh. “593” (Precinct No. 73-B)   





(95)

 





ER No. 8800855; Barangay: Katidtuan; counterpart MOV is exhibit “789”.

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o The total votes in figures of Recto and Zubiri have a clear prefixing of the figure “1” to a figure “15” for Recto and figure “12” was prefixed to figure “7” for Zubiri. o The votes in words for Recto, “one hundred” written by another person was written above the word “fifteen”. o Zubiri‟s votes in words, the words “one hundred twenty” were clearly written by another person above the word “seven” which is clearly written in different style and pen.

TALLIES. o Additional tallies, numbering 25, for Zubiri were made after his entry of votes had been closed. o Additional tallies, numbering 100, for Recto were made after his entry of votes had been closed. o There are additional tallies for ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressures, stroke, etc, of the second batch.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o No watchers signed and thumbmarked in the ER. o Names of the BEIs were written by one person.

Exh. “595” (Precinct No. 74-A)   

(97)

ER No. 8800854; Barangay: Katidtuan; counterpart MOV is exhibit “788”.

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 99.50% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o The columns for total votes obtained in words and figures are again full of erasures and alterations especially for candidates Defendor, Kiram, Montano, Pichay, Recto Sotto and Zubiri. o Defensor votes in words does not tally with the figures while the others votes in figures are hardly readable due to addition and/ or superimpositions of figures.

TALLIES. o Additional tallies, numbering 86, for Zubiri were made after his entry of votes had been closed. o There are additional tallies for ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressures, stroke, etc, of the second batch. o Other candidates similarly benefited from the above fraud.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o There are allegedly 2 watchers with thumbmarks but no signatures to their names clearly written by one person. Other spaces for 3 watchers are blank. o Names of the BEIs were written by one person.

Exh “594” (Precinct No. 73-C)



(96)

Incomplete watchers signature and thumb marks.

ER No. 8800856; Barangay: Katuli; counterpart MOV is exhibit “790”.

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 100% voter turn out.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Names of BEIs and watchers were written by one person.

Exh. “596” (Precinct No. 75-A)    

ER No. 8800857; Barangay: Katidtuan; counterpart MOV is exhibit “791”.

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Incredible 98.52% voter turn out.

DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o The votes of Honasan, Gomez, Montano, Oreta, Pimentel, Recto, Roco, Sotto, and Villar in words and figures were erased and altered to zero.

TALLIES. o Additional tallies, numbering 160, for Zubiri were made after his entry of votes had been closed.

30

o



(98)

Exh. “597” (Precinct No. 76-A)    



(99)

There are additional tallies for ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressures, stroke, etc, of the second batch. o Other candidates similarly benefited from the above fraud.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Only one watcher with no name initialed and thumbmarked this ER. o Names of the BEIs were written by one person.

ER No. 8800858; Barangay: Katidtuan; counterpart MOV is exhibit “792”.

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o No Entry on Data on the Voters and Ballots in the ER. DATA ON TOTAL VOTES OBTAINED IN FIGURES AND IN WORDS o The votes of Honasan, Gomez, Montano, Oreta, Pimentel, Recto, Roco, Sotto, and Villar in words and figures were erased and altered to zero.

TALLIES. o Additional tallies, numbering 160, for Zubiri were made after his entry of votes had been closed. o There are additional tallies for ZUBIRI were obviously written by a different person than the one who made the first batch of tallies given the different initials, size, pressures, stroke, etc, of the second batch. o Other candidates similarly benefited from the above fraud.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o Only one watcher with no name initialed and thumbmarked this ER. o Names of the BEIs were written by one person.

Exh. “598” (Precinct No. 77-A)   



ER No. 8800859; Barangay: Katuli; counterpart MOV is exhibit “793”.

DATA ON VOTERS AND BALLOTS o Unbelievably high voter turn-out of 97.97%.

TALLIES. o There are fraudulent erasures of taras by Defensor, Gomez, Osmeña, Singson, Sotto and Villar whose votes were thus reduced to “0”. o Recto‟s votes in words were erased completely and there was failure to replaced or alter. His votes in figures has clear superimpositions and readable as “128”. This is due to insertions of additional taras by another person. o Zubiri‟s total votes in words and figures altered to 192. Insertion of 154 taras by different person in different pen used.

SIGNATURES AND THUMBMARKS o There are no names of watchers.

EXHIBITS “536” up to “698” still ongoing EXHIBITS “599” up to “698” still ongoing

31