OPINION
Hamza Nizam Kazi
TikTok is a data collection service pretending to be a social network
brim with vulgar content and there is no way to stop it. It is viewed directly or indirectly by millions of users either intentionally or unintentionally. However, banning these social media apps on the basis of such content without blocking the material on it creates a mockery of the notices and tweets that are published by regulators. If one video/post is not posted/published on one online platform the same is posted on the other platform that is available and gets the same likes and followings thus creating a Streisand effect. So if you ban TikTok, someone can simply use a VPN to post something there and then another person with a VPN can find it on TikTok and post it to twitter or facebook. At the end of the day, the content is still out there, and because of the ban it might actually foster more interest. And at the end of the day, it makes the regulator look silly because it becomes apparent that the people that are supposed to be regulating social media do not understand it at all. Regulators in different countries and especially here in Pakistan need to realize that these social media apps developed in nother day, another ban. The PTA banned TikTok China have different laws and regulations under which they are again on July 21st, 2021 on the basis that there is the developed. There are strict government rules and regulations inside continuous presence of inappropriate content on the China where there is censorship for users over its platforms to online platform and its failure to take such content comply with local laws and regulations. Speaking of which, when down. This step has been taken under the Prevention these apps are internationally marketed and move beyond China of Electronic Crimes Act 2016. It is a step that has been the playing field becomes vast and the censorship medium is kind taken so many times now it is exhausting. of disabled. Consequently, people have vastly different experiences The question that arises is that whilst the same content is when using these apps and posting content online. available on different platforms, TikTok seems to be an easy target to Here, the Pakistan Telecommunication Authority being the suspend and ban. Is this decision taken in haste? Or are the millions of regulator, needs to step up and have a censorship framework and people on this platform denied access because they are not considered policy which needs to be either highlighted to these companies or particularly important? implemented through local operators. Imposing a ban citing vulgar If one considers carefully, in fact, there is no need to even considcontent on the platform and removing millions of videos may not be er it carefully. Just the slightest attention, the most sparing of thoughts, a long-term viable option and may not hold for long. Despite being a bare glance will tell you that all social media apps are filled to the an Islamic republic and constitution highlights that way of life shall be following the fundamentals of Islam the overall censorship should be across the board on all social media apps having such vulgar content. On the other hand, citing “national security concerns” in respect of such a Hamza Nizam Kazi ban may have a different viewpoint altogether. These social media apps, particularly Tikis a corporate and technology Tok’s parent company ByteDance, are headquartered in Beijing and with strict government lawyer having experience controls over companies the Chinese government could compel them to share personal data of foreign nationals/ users. This area could possibly be a scenario for the local regulators and in the telecom industry and economic and political decision-makers to ponder over. advising digital startups. Furthermore, considering the geopolitics of the region and the growing influence of He can be reached on China in Pakistan, does Pakistan really want to get in this 5th generation warfare by banning social media apps on the basis of security concerns is the question for the higher-ups. With hamza.n.kazi@gmail.com the Pegasus scandal round the corner and cybersecurity concerns at their peak, this can open for advice on legal and a plethora of questions on the cybersecurity of Pakistan. regulatory issues pertaining Pakistan having the best tech minds needs to up its antics with a comprehensive cybersecurity policy and need to have the various applications scrutinized before allowing them to the telecom sector and since banning and suspension of one app over and over again is a temporary solution and not electronic media. a permanent one.
Instead of banning it every few months, the PTA needs to come up with a proper censorship framework
A
COMMENT
17
