Volume XXXVI No. 12 • 16 June, 2016
www.ourvalleyvoice.com
Jury Finds Tulare County Victorious in Animal Control Lawsuit
Julia Jimenez, her mother, and Paul Grenseman in front of the Tulare County Courthouse.
After a grueling three-week trial, it only took 45 minutes for a jury to come to a verdict on a suit against Tulare County, Paula Mendoza and Yessica Ozuna, both employees of Tulare County Animal Control. Paul Grenseman and Julia Jimenez filed suit in Tulare County Superior Court, against the County of Tulare, in November of 2014. The suit against the county was for discrimination, racial/ethnic and sexual harassment, failure to prevent discrimination and failure to prevent harassment as well
Catherine Doe as retaliation. The jury of 12 unanimously found in favor of the county on all counts. The Honorable Judge Bret Hillman said that three-week trials were rare, only happening once or twice a year. Concerning the verdict, he said that he has seen juries take five minutes, some weeks, or end in a mistrial--which happens when a jury cannot come to a decision.
LAWSUIT continued on 16 »
Visalia City Council Votes 3-2 on New Sign Ordinance Catherine Doe After 38 years Visalia has new a new sign ordinance. At the June 6 city council meeting, the vote was three to two in favor, with council members Amy Shuklian and Greg Collins voting no. While Shuklian and Collins voted no they were mostly satisfied with new sign ordinance. Updating Visalia’s sign ordinance has been a topic of discussion at retreats and city council meetings since before 2011. The purpose of the ordinance is to regulate the size, number and placement of signs. The ordinance regulates all signs, whether they may be for businesses, garage sales, new subdivisions, or mobile or temporary signs such as those used during elections or special events. Since a 2015 Supreme Court ruling, a sign cannot be prohibited based on its content. Mayor Steve Nelson was very happy with the final product but said it comes
down to enforcement. Tracy Robertshaw, Neighborhood Preservation Manager, told the city council that the new sign ordinance was in fact enforceable. For years, many complaints were left unresolved because parts of the old ordinance were not enforceable, such as temporary banners. “The previous ordinance was too ambiguous, making enforcement difficult. The new ordinance is very clear about how banners are to be used,” said Robertshaw. “Our office will first work on educating the community and business owners about the new sign ordinance. We will then be sending courtesy notices to those that are still out of compliance.” Robertshaw added that most people comply with the courtesy notice but she anticipates a few people receiving fines. The last time the sign ordinance was updated was in 1978. A draft ordinance was completed
SIGNS continued on 11 »
Kings County Incumbents Win, Measure K Loses in Primary Catherine Doe Measure K, the proposed public safety tax, suffered a tough loss during the June 7 primary while both incumbents retained their Kings County Supervisor seats. Measure K needed two-thirds of the vote to pass but just missed the mark by receiving 66.35%. The measure came within 40 or 50 votes of its goal. A few provisional and mail-in ballots remain to be counted before the election is certified, but Kings County registrar of voters does not expect it to catch up. Called the public safety tax, all county law enforcement, council members, and supervisors rallied behind Measure K. Kings County Sheriff Dave Robinson said that there was no organized opposition to the measure. Measure K would have preserved the quarter cent sales tax imposed by a statewide tax initiative Proposition 30 passed in 2012. When Proposition 30 expires in 2017, King’s County sales tax
will now go down from 7.5% to 7.25%. Had Measure K passed it was estimated to bring in $4 million annually. The revenues generated would have been allotted to public safety agencies in the county and then proportionately according to the population to the four cities. The original sample ballot mailed out to voters mistakenly left out a pro-Measure K argument signed off on by Hanford Police Chief Parker Sever, Kings County Sheriff Dave Robinson, Kings County Fire Chief Bill Lynch, Lemoore Fire Chief John Gibson and Kings County Supervisor Doug Verboon. It is speculated that may have made a difference in the outcome. The company that printed the sample ballots made an error and pro-Measure K argument was mailed out separately to all voters. Even with the community support, tax hikes are historically very difficult to pass in Kings County.
KINGS continued on 10 »
Amy Shuklian and her campaign manager Karen Tellalian. Joseph Oldenbourg/Valley Voice
Tulare County Voters Elect New Blood to Board of Supervisors Tensions were high as all of the local candidates waited patiently for the primary election returns on June 7. The first of several reports came out at 8:15pm, with the absentee vote, and those results remained consistent throughout the night. Visalia City Council woman Amy Shuklian won over Tulare County Supervisor Phil Cox by ten points and was the winner of the race for Tulare County Supervisor seat for District 3. She celebrated her victory with family and friends at the Vintage Press. When asked about her ten point lead soon after the first summary report was revealed–the mail-in ballots–Shuklian said, “It feels good. I’m not calling it yet, now the precincts will come in, but it’s important to get that early lead.” When it was over, Shuklian said, “From day one, from when I first announced in July, I knew it was going to be a tough race.” Shuklian said that her campaign raised money from 250 donors giving anything from five dollars to thousands. “I out-campaigned him,” she said. “I kept it clean, stuck to the issues, and let people know why I was the better candidate.” Shuklian’s campaign included identifying high-propensity voters and started with walking the districts. High-propensity voters are those who have voted in the last four of five elections. Out of the 13,800 likely voters, her campaign crew knocked on 8,008 doors and spoke with 4,712 residents face to face. Of those residents, 51% said they were voting for her.
Catherine Doe She was grateful for the victory but it was not unexpected.“We walked, walked more and walked some more,” said Shuklian. Her staff started walking precincts in the rain in January and ended in the 108 degree heat during the weekend before the primary. “I campaigned until 8pm tonight,” she said on the night of the election. Because there were only two candidates, there will be no runoff in November. Shuklian will be taking office in January of 2017. Shuklian’s victory leaves an empty seat on the Visalia City Council, made even more interesting with the newly adopted district elections. The Visalia City Council adopted the district map in May of last year. Districts 1--Shuklian’s--and 2, councilmember Bob Link, will be up for election in November. District 1 is right in the middle of Visalia and extends north. District 2 is southwest Visalia. The filing period to run for either of these districts starts now.
Smith and Crocker Come Out On Top in District One Supervisor Race
In Tulare County Supervisor District 1, Dennis Smith found himself the winner with 21.7% of the vote. Kyler Crocker finished second, with 19.4%. The top two go on to the November general election.
SUPERVISORS continued on 11 »