THE RAUDABAUGH REPORT NLRB MEMBER DECISION PARTICIPATION
(Fiscal Year 2017 to date: October 1, 2016 – June 14, 2017)
Total NLRB Published Decisions (Binding Precedent)…..........126* (100.0%) Full NLRB Published Decisions (all Members participating)........0 (0.0%) Default/Summary Judgment Decisions.……………………………......29 (23.0%) *Includes 103 (81.7%) “C” (complaint) cases; 19 (15.1 %) “R” (representation) cases; 4 (3.2%) “C&R” cases. NLRB Member NLRB Member Decisions/ Total Reported NLRB Decisions
NLRB Published Decisions CY 2017….. 87 FY 2017……126 CY 2016…..269 FY 2016…...298 CY 2015…..287 FY 2015……319 CY 2014…..285 FY 2014……197 NLRB Member Dissenting Opinions/ Total NLRB Dissenting Opinions
126/126 (100%) 126/126 (100%) 126/126 (100%)
Miscimarra (M) Pearce (P) McFerran (Mc)
31/36 4/36 1/36
(86.1%) (11.1%) ( 2.8%)
NLRB PANEL/MEMBER ANALYSIS
M,P,Mc
126/126
(100.0%)
36/126 (28.6%)
Total Dissenting Opinions by Panel Member M (31), P (4), Mc (1)
Totals
126/126
(100.0%)
36/126 (28.6%)
M (31), P (4), Mc (1)
NLRB Panel/Full Board
Total NLRB Panel Decisions/ Total Published Decisions
Total Panel Decisions with Dissenting Opinion/Total Panel Decisions
PUBLISHED DECISIONS BY NLRB REGION/SUBREGION INTAKE FY 2016 NLRB Published Decisions 6 ( 4.8%) 7 ( 5.6%)
15 - (and former 26) - New Orleans 16 - Fort Worth
FY 2016 NLRB Published Decisions 5 ( 4.0%) 2 ( 1.6%)
3 - Buffalo
4 ( 3.2%)
18 - (and former 30) - Minneapolis
3 ( 2.4%)
4 - Philadelphia
5 ( 4.0%)
19 - (and former 36) - Seattle
3 ( 2.4%)
5 - Baltimore
2 ( 1.6%)
20 - (and former 37) - San Francisco
6 ( 4.8%)
6 - Pittsburgh
0 ( 0.0%) 12 ( 9.5%)
21 - Los Angeles
4 ( 3.2%)
22 - Newark
3 ( 2.4%) 4 ( 3.2%)
NLRB Region 1 - (and former 34) - Boston 2 - New York
7 - Detroit
NLRB Region
8 - Cleveland
3 ( 2.4%)
25 - (and former 33) - Indianapolis
9 - Cincinnati 10 - (and former 11) - Atlanta
3 ( 2.4%) 4 ( 3.2%) 7 ( 5.6%)
27 - Denver 28 - Phoenix
3 ( 2.4%) 10 ( 7.9%)
29 - Brooklyn
5 ( 4.0%)
31 - Los Angeles
4 ( 3.2%)
12 - (and former 24) - Tampa 13 - Chicago 14- (and former 17) - St. Louis
11 ( 8.7%) 7 ( 5.6%)
32 - Oakland Total FY 2017 NLRB Published Decisions 163 (100.0%)
©John N. Raudabaugh
3 ( 2.4%) 126 (100.0%)
National Labor Relations Board – Published Decisions – Fiscal Year Fiscal Year 2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 2000 1999 1998 1997 1996 1995 1994 1993 1992 1991 1990 1989 1988 1987 1986 1985 1984 1983 1982 1981 1980
Oct.
Nov.
Dec.
Jan.
Feb
Mar.
Apr.
May
June
12 13 30 4 4 6 30 12 10 4 11 5 24 20 25 41 43 14 31 51 13 49 31 28 40 23 37 47 33 12 15 37 39 24 47 15 19 49
17 19 28 2 10 20 30 11 12 12 12 12 24 28 37 25 29 51 29 53 35 32 30 102 49 47 27 23 47 48 36 68 70 18 37 42 45 58
10 36 42 6 21 60 26 9 17 36 15 27 45 25 1 67 28 19 17 9 30 79 60 0 81 52 60 16 35 97 30 64 143 28 130 47 66 72
11 15 12 19 11 10 18 15 12 7 64 15 6 25 9 0 39 27 30 6 18 14 64 0 45 70 80 29 51 18 40 77 51 34 22 57 134 100
17 36 14 24 13 13 13 7 16 28 27 11 25 21 9 2 27 30 36 1 44 29 52 75 38 61 79 22 55 28 73 51 106 114 45 79 27 106
12 20 38 9 18 10 26 8 25 12 44 20 26 32 22 9 30 45 64 4 27 46 67 20 79 97 61 42 54 38 49 63 108 146 50 134 120 114
16 19 25 29 24 14 22 6 15 13 45 29 16 38 46 7 56 35 48 37 44 40 74 30 49 72 63 27 42 42 47 84 58 128 17 89 98 94
21 36 17 28 16 10 17 10 14 25 55 34 21 31 35 24 52 41 41 22 44 36 64 43 116 59 78 40 79 47 47 75 37 66 37 97 65 113
10 19 38 11 19 28 20 10 11 19 27 19 39 44 43 24 34 40 40 37 41 26 43 46 24 42 52 46 125 87 77 92 41 75 12 83 113 99
©John N. Raudabaugh
July 21 12 15 21 19 24 11 23 18 24 24 22 37 46 40 49 32 31 36 30 39 54 67 33 90 46 42 40 146 71 31 45 123 17 119 105 104
Aug. 57 47 27 0 25 56 119 11 24 37 48 61 24 49 32 116 80 25 75 35 63 86 57 48 76 81 41 55 36 48 41 43 83 190 104 78 244
Sep.
Total
7 16 23 5 56 14 55 18 36 61 53 40 78 93 44 76 67 70 80 17 39 58 84 142 112 63 97 66 65 120 115 135 108 37 239 227 190
126 298 319 197 162 271 296 273 184 234 422 297 349 403 415 315 579 481 462 411 378 492 683 552 744 801 727 472 682 664 653 798 847 947 641 1,105 1,097 1,343
National Labor Relations Board – Published Decisions – Calendar Year Calendar Year 2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 2000 1999 1998 1997 1996 1995 1994 1993 1992 1991 1990 1989 1988 1987 1986 1985 1984 1983 1982 1981 1980
Jan.
Feb
Mar.
Apr.
May
June
11 15 12 19 11 10 18 15 12 7 64 15 6 25 9 0 39 27 30 6 18 14 64 0 45 70 80 29 51 18 40 77 51 34 22 57 134 100
17 36 14 24 13 13 13 7 16 28 27 11 25 21 9 2 27 30 36 1 44 29 52 75 38 61 79 22 55 28 73 51 106 114 45 79 27 106
12 20 38 9 18 10 26 8 25 12 44 20 26 32 22 9 30 45 64 4 27 46 67 20 79 97 61 42 54 38 49 63 108 146 50 134 120 114
16 19 25 1 29 24 14 22 6 15 13 45 29 16 38 46 7 56 35 48 37 44 40 74 30 49 72 63 27 42 42 47 84 58 128 17 89 98 94
21 36 17 28 16 10 17 10 14 25 55 34 21 31 35 24 52 41 41 22 44 36 64 43 116 59 78 40 79 47 47 75 37 66 37 97 65 113
10 19 38 11 19 28 20 10 11 19 27 19 39 44 43 24 34 40 40 37 41 26 43 46 24 42 52 46 125 87 77 92 41 75 12 83 113 99
July 21 12 15 21 19 24 11 23 18 24 24 22 37 46 40 49 32 31 36 30 39 54 67 33 90 46 42 40 146 71 31 45 123 17 119 105 104
Aug. 57 47 27 0 25 56 119 11 24 37 48 61 24 49 32 116 80 25 75 35 63 86 57 48 76 81 41 55 36 48 41 43 83 190 104 78 244
©John N. Raudabaugh
Sep. 7 16 23 5 56 14 55 18 36 61 53 40 78 93 44 76 67 70 80 17 39 58 84 142 112 63 97 66 65 120 115 135 108 37 239 227 190
Oct. 12 13
30 4 4 6 30 12 10 4 11 5 24 20 25 41 43 14 31 51 13 49 31 28 40 23 37 47 33 12 15 37 39 24 47 15 19
Nov. 17 19 28 2 10 20 30 11 12 12 12 12 24 28 37 25 29 51 29 53 35 32 30 102 49 47 27 23 47 48 36 68 70 18 37 42 45
Dec.
Total
10 36 42 6 21 60 26 9 17 36 15 27 45 25 1 67 28 19 17 9 30 79 60 0 81 52 60 16 35 97 30 64 143 28 130 47 66
87 269 287 285 139 220 296 327 177 221 436 291 300 423 425 245 612 497 469 375 413 410 722 543 704 849 725 510 653 622 729 710 793 1,129 497 1,215 1,071 1,294
THE RAUDABAUGH REPORT NLRB MEMBER DECISION PARTICIPATION
(Fiscal Year 2016 to date: October 1, 2015 – September 30, 2016)
Total NLRB Published Decisions (Binding Precedent)…...............298* (100.0%) Full NLRB Published Decisions (all Members participating).......11 ( 3.7%) Default/Summary Judgment Decisions…………………………………...….55 ( 18.5%) *Includes 268 (89.9%) “C” (complaint) cases; 28 (9.4%) “R” (representation) cases; 2 (0.7%) “C&R” cases. NLRB Member Pearce (P) Miscimarra (M) McFerran (Mc) *[Hirozawa (H)] *Hirozawa’s term ended August 27, 2016
NLRB Member Decisions/ Total Reported NLRB Decisions 262/298 (87.9%) 207/298 (69.5%) 193/298 (64.8%) [243/290 (83.8%)]
NLRB Published Decisions CY 2016…..230 FY 2016…..298 CY 2015…..287 FY 2015…..319 CY 2014…..285 FY 2014…..197 CY 2013…..139 FY 2013…..210 CY 2012…..220 FY 2012…..271 NLRB Member Dissenting Opinions/ Total NLRB Dissenting Opinions 0/0 ( 0.0%) 134/138 (97.1%) 3/138 ( 2.2%) [1/138 ( 0.7%)]
NLRB PANEL/MEMBER ANALYSIS NLRB Panel/Full Board
P,M,Mc *P,M,H *[P,H,Mc] *[M,H,Mc] *[P,M,H,Mc] Totals
Total NLRB Panel Decisions/ Total Published Decisions
Total Panel Decisions with Dissenting Opinion/Total Panel Decisions
55/298 (18.5%) [105/290 (36.2%)] [ 91/290 (31.4%)] [ 36/290 (12.4%)] [ 11/290 ( 3.8%)] 293/293 (100.0%)
30/55 (54.5%) [72/105 (68.6%)] [ 2/91 ( 2.2%)] [20/36 (55.6%)] [11/11 (100.0%)]
Total Dissenting Opinions by Panel Member M (30) [M (72)] [Mc (2)] [M (18) H(1) Mc(1)] [M (11)]
PUBLISHED DECISIONS BY NLRB REGION/SUBREGION INTAKE FY 2016 NLRB Published Decisions 4 ( 1.3%) 14 ( 4.7%)
15 - (and former 26) - New Orleans 16 - Fort Worth
FY 2016 NLRB Published Decisions 7 ( 2.3%) 8 ( 2.7%)
3 - Buffalo
9 ( 3.0%)
18 - (and former 30) - Minneapolis
5 ( 1.7%)
4 - Philadelphia
9 ( 3.0%)
19 - (and former 36) - Seattle
20 ( 6.7%)
NLRB Region 1 - (and former 34) - Boston 2 - New York
NLRB Region
5 - Baltimore
15 ( 5.0%)
20 - (and former 37) - San Francisco
12 ( 4.0%)
6 - Pittsburgh
21 - Los Angeles
14 ( 4.7%)
7 - Detroit
5 ( 1.7%) 13 ( 4.4%)
22 - Newark
9 ( 3.0%)
8 - Cleveland
13 ( 4.4%)
25 - (and former 33) - Indianapolis
3 ( 1.0%)
6 ( 2.0%) 10 ( 3.4 %) 7 ( 2.3%)
27 - Denver 28 - Phoenix
6 ( 2.0%) 27 ( 9.1%)
29 - Brooklyn
17 ( 5.7%)
13 ( 4.4%) 13 ( 4.4%)
31 - Los Angeles
23 ( 7.7%)
9 - Cincinnati 10 - (and former 11) - Atlanta 12 - (and former 24) - Tampa 13 - Chicago 14- (and former 17) - St. Louis
32 - Oakland Total FY 2016 NLRB Published Decisions 163 (100.0%)
©John N. Raudabaugh
16 ( 5.4%) 298 (100.0%)
THE RAUDABAUGH REPORT NLRB MEMBER DECISION PARTICIPATION (Fiscal Year 2015 to date: October 1, 2014 – September 30, 2015) Total NLRB Published Decisions (Binding Precedent)…...........….319* (100.0%) NLRB Published Decisions Full NLRB Published Decisions (all Members participating)………..14 ( 4.4%) CY 2015…..219 FY 2015…..319 Default/Summary Judgment Decisions………………………….…………..69 ( 21.6%) CY 2014…..284 FY 2014…..197 *Includes 269 (84.3%) “C” (complaint) cases; 24 (7.5%) “R” (representation) CY 2013…..139 FY 2013…..210 cases; CY 2012…..220 FY 2012…..271 26 (8.2%) “C&R” cases. NLRB Member NLRB Member Decisions/ NLRB Member Dissenting Opinions/ Total Reported NLRB Decisions Total NLRB Dissenting Opinions 235/319 (73.7%) 0/0 ( 0.0%) Pearce (P) Miscimarra (M) 136/319 (42.6%) 37/72 (51.4%) 228/319 (71.5%) 2/72 ( 2.8%) Hirozawa (H) McFerran (Mc)* 133/319 (41.7%) 1/72 ( 1.4%) Schiffer (S) * [79]/[99] [79.8%] 0/0 ( 0.0%) Johnson (J)+ {173}/{301} {57.5%} {32/69} {46.4%} *McFerran’s term effective December 17, 2014; Schiffer’s term ended December 16, 2014; Schiffer decisions [ ] +Johnson’s term ended August 27, 2014; Johnson decisions { } NLRB PANEL/MEMBER ANALYSIS NLRB Panel/Full Board Total NLRB Panel Decisions/ Total Published Decisions
Total Panel Decisions with Dissenting Opinion/Total Panel Decisions
P,M,H 49/319 (15.0%) 14/49 (28.6%) {4}/319 ( 1.3%) 0/4 ( 0.0%) P,M {J} P,M,Mc [S] 16+[11]/319 ( 7.6%) 4/27 (14.8%) P,H {J} {43}/319 (13.7%) 14/43 (27.5%) P,H,Mc [S] 23+[25]/319 (15.3%) 0/48 ( 0.0%) P,Mc [S]{J} {38+[11]}/319 (15.6%) 6/49 (12.2%) M,H{J} {11}/319 ( 3.5%) 2/11 (18.2%) 12+[9]/319 ( 6.7%) 5/21 (23.8%) M,H,Mc [S] M,Mc [S]{J} {5+[7]}/319 ( 3.8%) 4/12 (33.3%) {31+[10]}/319 (13.1%) 2/41 ( 4.9%) H,Mc [S]{J} {8+[6]}/319 ( 4.5%) 10/14 (71.4%) P,M,H,Mc [S]{J} Totals 18+{222+[79]}/319 (100.0%) PUBLISHED DECISIONS BY NLRB REGION/SUBREGION INTAKE FY 2015 NLRB NLRB Region NLRB Region Published Decisions 1 - (and former 34) - Boston 15 - (and former 26) - New Orleans 20 ( 6.3%) 2 - New York 13 ( 4.1%) 16 - Fort Worth
Total Dissenting Opinions by Panel Member M(14) M(4) {J(14)} {J(6)} M(1) H(1) M(5) H(1) M(3) Mc(1) {J(2)} M(10), {J(10)}
FY 2015 NLRB Published Decisions 18 ( 5.6%) 5 ( 1.6%)
3 - Buffalo
10 ( 3.1%)
18 - (and former 30) - Minneapolis
4 - Philadelphia
15 ( 4.7%)
19 – (and former 36) - Seattle
21 ( 6.6%)
5 - Baltimore
18 ( 5.6%)
20 - (and former 37) - San Francisco
10 ( 3.1%)
6 - Pittsburgh
5 ( 1.6%)
21 - Los Angeles
13 ( 4.1%)
22 - Newark
15 ( 4.7%)
7 - Detroit
14 ( 4.4%)
8 - Cleveland
8 ( 2.5%)
9 - Cincinnati
10 ( 3.1%)
27 - Denver
16 ( 5.0%)
28 - Phoenix
10 - (and former 11) - Atlanta
25 - (and former 33) - Indianapolis
©John N. Raudabaugh
9 ( 2.8%)
5 ( 1.6%) ( 0.0%) 24 ( 7.5%)
THE RAUDABAUGH REPORT NLRB MEMBER DECISION PARTICIPATION (Fiscal Year 2014 to date: October 1, 2013 – September 30, 2014) Reported Decisions……………………………………………………………….1971 (100.0%) Reported Decisions Full Board Decisions………………………………………………………………….8 ( 4.1%) CY2 2013…..139 FY3 2014.....197 Default/Summary Judgment Decisions……………………………………34 ( 17.3%) CY 2012…..220 FY 2013…..210 CY 2011…..296 FY 2012…..271 Member Member Decisions/ Member Dissenting Opinions/ Total Reported Decisions Total Dissenting Opinions 144/197 (73.0%) 1/36 ( 2.9%) Pearce (P) Miscimarra (M) 99/197 (50.5%) 18/36 (57.1%) 132/197 (66.8%) 2/36 ( 2.9%) Hirozawa (H) Johnson (J) 119/197 (60.2%) 14/36 (37.1%) 114/197 (58.2%) 1/36 ( 2.9%) Schiffer (S) PANEL/MEMBER ANALYSIS Panel/Full Board Total Panel Decisions/ Total Panel Decisions with Total Dissenting Total Reported Dissenting Opinion/ Opinions Decisions Total Panel Decisions by Panel Member P,M,H 29/197 (14.8%) 6/29 (20.7%) M(5) H(1) P,M,J 6/197 ( 3.1%) 10/197 ( 5.1%) 2/10 (20.0%) M(2) P,M,S P,H,J 38/197 (18.9%) 7/38 (18.4%) P(1) H(1) J(6) P,H,S 10/197 ( 5.1%) P,J,S 36/197 (18.4%) 3/36 ( 8.3%) J(3) M,H,J 7/197 ( 3.6%) 1/7 (14.3%) M(1) 26/197 (13.3%) 5/26 (19.2%) M(5) M,H,S M,J,S 14/197 ( 7.1%) 2/14 (14.3%) M(1) S(1) 10/197 ( 5.1%) H,J,S 8/197 ( 4.1%) 6/8 (75.0%) M(4) J(5) P,M,H,J,S Totals 197/197 (100.0%) REPORTED DECISIONS BY REGION/SUBREGION Region Reported Region Reported Decisions Decisions 1 - (and former 34) - Boston 15 - (and former 26) - New Orleans 13 ( 6.6%) 5 ( 2.5%) 2 - New York 5 ( 2.5%) 16 - Fort Worth 3 ( 1.5%) 3 - Buffalo
2 ( 1.0%)
18 - (and former 30) - Minneapolis
7 ( 3.6%)
4 - Philadelphia
10 ( 5.1%)
19 - Seattle
5 ( 2.5%)
5 - Baltimore
11 ( 5.6%)
20 - San Francisco
5 ( 2.5%)
21 - Los Angeles
7 ( 3.6%)
6 - Pittsburgh 7 - Detroit 8 - Cleveland 9 - Cincinnati
4 ( 2.0%) 12 ( 6.1%)
22 - Newark
12 ( 6.1%)
8 ( 4.1%)
25 - (and former 33) - Indianapolis
4 ( 2.0%)
7 ( 3.6%)
27 - Denver
1 ( 0.3%)
10 - (and former 11) - Atlanta
6 ( 3.0%)
28 - Phoenix
17 ( 8.6%)
12 - (and former 24) - Tampa
6 ( 3.0%)
29 - Brooklyn
9 ( 4.6%) 7 ( 3.6%)
13 - Chicago
13 ( 6.6%)
31 - Los Angeles
14- (and former 17) - St. Louis
11 ( 5.6%)
32 - Oakland Total
1
Includes 174 (88.3%) “C” (complaint) cases; 16 (8.1%) “R” (representation) cases; 7 (3.6%) “C&R” cases. CY (Calendar Year to Date; January 1 – December 31) 3 FY (Fiscal Year to Date; October 1 – September 30) 2
©John N. Raudabaugh
7 ( 3.6%) 197 (100%)