North American Clean Energy July/August 2022 Issue

Page 62

ENERGY STORAGE

A New Look at Performance Monitoring for Energy Storage by Stefan Greens

P

erformance monitoring for the energy storage industry has traditionally meant a hodge podge of different systems, often based on outdated technologies and interfaces, with limited or no ability to communicate with other systems. This has led to a lack of trust in what, if any, insights are provided. A new look at performance monitoring in battery-based energy storage systems (BESS) brings a holistic, cloud-based approach that incorporates data from disparate systems and workflows into a single, value-based view. Before we talk about what this looks like and what value it adds, let’s first consider what “performance” really means. In the context of a battery energy storage system, “performance” is such a multifaceted term that it requires some organizing principle for it to become useful. Different stakeholders approach performance differently, since each has different optimization targets and timescales in which to reach them. Specifically: • Operators aim to optimize direct operational metrics, such as state of health and availability. • Utilities value maintaining grid stability and reliability, via applications for frequency and voltage regulation. • Owners aim to maximize financial metrics such as ROI, remaining useful life (RUL), and NPV. • Societies and their representative governments increasingly demand renewable energy, where reducing greenhouse gas emissions is the key success metric.

Ancient Archaea. A New Energy Solution.

Electrochaea’s grid scale power-to-gas methanation process stores renewable power in synthetic methane. Co-located renewable power, biogas source and archaea enables long duration energy storage and decarbonizes the gas infrastructure. joe.feldman@electrochaea.com mark.pastore@electrochaea.com www.electrochaea.com

62

2022 JULY• AUGUST /// www.nacleanenergy.com

These success criteria are, for the most part, aligned with one another; but they also build on each other. With modern monitoring tools now able to capture, parameterize, store, and process data at scale in the cloud, a layered approach to generating successively more sophisticated and context-specific performance indicators from a foundation of directly sensed streaming data, in real time, becomes feasible. The approach, in effect, is to build a “value chain” for data. The levels of data build upon each other, like links in a chain, to provide increasingly sophisticated insights. The initial, most basic “link” in the data value chain is empirical data, captured in real time by sensors in the cells, strings, and energy blocks, and visualized directly as time series — for attributes such as voltage, current and temperature. The next link is derived metrics, directly enabled by the raw inputs. Calculating the maxima, minima, and distributions of voltages and temperatures across cells in a string or block provides a quick sense of balances (or imbalances) in the system. Various algorithmic models allow the accurate calculation of state of charge of a string as a live attribute, based on current and voltage. These outputs, when fed to a condition-action rules engine, can generate many of the alerts that an operator needs to monitor for events such as overheating, voltage imbalances, and downtime. The following link in the data value chain provides the data required for maintenance planning, where discrete data points for each charge and discharge cycle are calculated by collapsing the millions of live granular points into algorithmically derived metrics that characterize a battery’s state of health. These cyclic attributes include equivalent cycles, a measure of battery use, and indicators of battery health such as energy efficiency across a cycle and maximum capacity at top of charge, both of which degrade with aging. A number of links, or levels of data insight, exist beyond these initial three. Let’s talk about what those include. Firstly, while the data attributes we’ve already spoken about are sufficient for condition-based maintenance regimes, where individual batteries are replaced when they show sufficient performance degradation, machine-learning algorithms can go one better. By training them on the historical time series and cyclic data of individual serialized batteries, they can provide Remaining Useful Life (RUL) estimates or flag incipient anomalies, enabling predictive maintenance regimes that can dramatically cut downtime and costs. It’s always good to keep in mind that performance is, above all, a financial metric. Maximizing the ROI of a BESS means using its available cycles smartly. To accomplish this, we can link the existing value chain datasets with time series data sourced externally. For example, weather data subscriptions provide forecasts for temperature, humidity, cloud cover, and wind speed, while market data subscriptions provide dayahead energy prices. These external data sources can add an additional dimension to your dataset, driving new insights such as determining when to charge or discharge a BESS to maximize revenues for the cycle. A modern energy management system (EMS) can automate these decisions, locking in maximized cost savings.