FWS Proposes New Rule for Take Permits Under the Endangered Species Act Conservationists claim the new rule combines policies in a way that fails to require permanent conservation measures and allows participants to back out of the agreement at any point. by Alanna Madden, Courthouse News
T
he U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service (FWS) proposed a new rule in early February to revise regulations regarding survival and incidental take permits under the Endangered Species Act. The announcement received mixed reactions by midafternoon, with the Interior Department stating the rule strengthened voluntary conservation opportunities, while conservationists claimed it streamlined the process for companies to harm vulnerable species. According to FWS’s proposed enhancement of survival and incidental take permits,
the overall purpose of its revisions are intended to reduce costs and time associated with negotiating and developing applications for take permits — where “take” is broadly defined as “to harass, harm, pursue, hunt, shoot, wound, kill, trap, capture, collect or to attempt to engage in any such conduct,” according to NOAA Fisheries. However, the revisions themselves include clarifying the appropriate use of permits and the agency’s authority to issue permits for non-listed species without including listed species. The revisions also include simplifying requirements for permits by combining safe harbor agreements and candidate conservation agreements with assurances — or voluntary landowner agreements — into one agreement type. “The purpose of the proposed regulatory revisions is to improve the implementation of the conservation programs under ESA section 10(a) and to increase voluntary participation,” wrote Christine Schuldheisz, public affairs specialist for FWS, in an email with CNS. Schuldheisz further explained that the agency plans to achieve this goal by simplifying processes and concepts that are often the sources of confusion and delay. “The proposed rule would not signifi-
Cattlemens Livestock Regular Sales
Auction Co., Inc.
CATTLE Every Friday at 9 a.m.
BelenLivestockAuction.com
ALL BREEDS BULL SALE Monday March 27, 2023 1:00 p.m.
For more information or to consign cattle, please give us a call or drop by. We guarantee our same high quality service as in the past.
P.O. Box 608 • Belen, NM OFFICE: 505-864-7451 • FAX: 505-864-7073 BRANDON MAJOR — 505-270-4873 • ELIJAH PADILLA — 505-573-0546 BUCKY RUSSELL — 505-410-3216 • CHARLIE MYERS — 505-269-9075
30 MARCH 2023
cantly change the way we currently implement the section 10 program or expand the reach of species protections,” Schuldheisz added. “To the extent the revisions relate to the documents required to support a permit application, they clarify the requirements for those documents but do not impose additional requirements that would result in significantly increased costs to small entities.” When asked how the proposed rule change would benefit threatened or endangered species, Schuldheisz gave reference to the Interior’s press release earlier Wednesday, which stated: “ESA section 10 permits have long been used to encourage candidate conservation agreements with assurances and safe harbor agreements, which are voluntary landowner agreements designed to benefit candidates or listed species, respectively. “They have also been used to permit the take of listed species incidental to private development activities. ESA Section 10 permits allow for a variety of activities, some of which can benefit endangered species through innovation.” But contrary to the Interior’s point, the
35 Minutes 4 Servings 8 Ingredients
Pepper Beef Steaks with ChileCilantro Butter
Ingredients: 4 3/4 inch thick Sirloin Tip Center Steaks 1/3 cup country Dijon-style mustard 2 tablespoons peppercorns 2 teaspoons ground cumin 1/4 cup butter 1 tablespoon fresh cilantro 1 teaspoon garlic 2 anaheim peppers Preparation:
Step 1 Combine mustard, peppercorns and cumin in small bowl. Remove and reserve 1/2 for brushing. Spread remaining mustard mixture on both sides of beef Sirloin Tip Center Steaks. Cover and marinate in refrigerator 1 hour.