TECHNICAL UNIVERSITY OF DENMARK
42090 - HOLISTIC DESIGN OF ENGINEERING SYSTEMS
Design project focused on increasing marine biodiversity, through the utilisation of wind turbines, thereby contributing to the mitigation of their impact on marine life and strengthening the ecosystem.
Developed by Group 6
Under the guidance of Josef Oehmen
In collaboration with Spring
DTU Aqua National Institute Of Aquatic Resources
INTRODUCTION
Climate change is a significant global problem that requires immediate attention. To combat this issue, there has been a push towards renewable energy sources, such as wind, solar, and hydroelectric power.
Offshore wind turbines have become essential in reducing greenhouse gas emissions. However, they can have unintended consequences on marine ecosystems, that may undermine their significant contribution to the promotion of clean energy and the fight against climate change.
Sea Forward aims to develop a sustainable product that benefits marine life around offshore wind turbines, ensuring minimal impact on marine ecosystems while contributing to clean energy production and business development.
While turbines represent a major advance in the fight against climate change, the negative effects they have on marine life prevent their contribution from being fully appreciated and exploited. A new challenge is therefore emerging towards the mitigation of these impacts and probably the pursuit of multidisciplinary solutions with a broader focus on the integration of different disciplines.
For wind energy companies, this booklet introduces Sea Forward's proposal to address the following problems identified in the ocean around offshore wind turbines:
EXISTING SOLUTIONS
Reefs / Artificial Reefs / Ship wrecks
Advantages
- Ecological disruption because of plastics, petroleum and other harmful materials.
- May attract illegal fishing.
- Could destroy existing habitat if is not placed well.
Disadvantages
- Helps to enhance biodiversity. - Can be build in many different forms and materials.
- Creates new habitats for different species.
- It could help to brake energy waves.
Cages
Advantages
- Helps to enhance biodiversity.
- Can be build in many different forms and materials.
- Creates new habitats for different species.
- Creates a safe place for different species to survive.
Disadvantages
- Ecological disruption because of plastics, petroleum and other harmful materials.
- May attract illegal fishing.
- Could destroy existing habitat if is not placed well.-
Wind turbines / Offshore Wind Parks
Advantages
- Generates clean energy.
- Sustainable solution.
- Their location and functionality brings safety to species could habitat on its surroundings.
Disadvantages
- They are sometimes dangerous for some birds and ships.
- Can generate noise pollution.
- Maintenance and transportation are a huge problem.
WHAT IF ?
Reefs
Ship wrecks
Artificial Reefs
Fish Kindergarden Cages
Offshore Wind Farms FoundationCONSIDERATIONS
Oxygen levels
Temperature
Level 1: 5 - 10(m)
Level 2: 10 - 15(m)
Level 3: 15(m) - below
Waves
30 Meters of sunlight
BIODIVERSITY ENHACEMENT SYSTEM
DETAILS
Top Level
Cage size: 50x50x150cm
Mesh size: 5x5cm
Medium Level
Cage size: 50x50x150cm
Mesh size: 10x10cm
Bottom Level
Reefs 50x50x50cm
POTENTIAL BENEFITS
Integrating two of the existing solutions, cages and artificial reefs, is based on the main advantage of reducing costs compared to the construction of new structures. And in turn, on the promotion of a collaborative economy, where people work together and contribute to a common benefit. By using existing products, it will help to save money on materials, construction and logistical planning. This can help make the overall system more economically viable, which is especially important in today's search for and implementation of efficient and sustainable solutions.
While the main objective of the system is to increase biodiversity, the overall idea opens the door to the integration of two key industries for humanity at this time. Wind Energy and Aquaculture, so the system aims to be a sustainable and integrated system that seeks to make the most of ocean resources. On a complex system level, the benefits would be reflected in:
- Integration and empowerment of the two industries
- Sustainable use of marine resources and space
- New economic opportunities
- Overall cost reduction
The proposed system is closely aligned with the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). It actively contributes to the achievement of five different SDGs, directly and indirectly three of them specifically related to the Biosphere level. By focusing on the bottom of the pyramid, the system is able to directly address key issues such as: Life Below Water and Climate Action, which are vital for the success of the following levels. Furthermore, the impact of the system goes beyond these immediate concerns, as it helps to create a positive and reactive chain that also contributes to the fulfilment of other SDGs like: Industry, Innovation and Infrastructure, Affordable and Clean Energy and Life on Land. Ultimately, the system is a fundamental tool in the quest for a more sustainable and equitable future for all.
Sea Forward system presents a holistic approach in terms of promoting viable and sustainable solutions in the fight against climate change. It focuses primarily on increasing biodiversity around offshore wind turbines in order to mitigate the negative effects of this industry on marine life, it is considered to be a part of an engineering system with a very important social scope as well.
For Sea Forward system, the attraction and conservation of two species are crucial to the fulfilment of its objectives.
COD FISH
Cod fish brings great benefits on a biodiversity, food chain and economic level.
- It supports a variety of marine life, such as eelgrass in Danish waters, which in turn is an important aquatic plant serving as a touchstone for many different species, including miso-species, which live in symbiosis with it.
- As a large predator, cod fish would eat the miso-predators playing a key role in maintaining a balanced food chain.
- Cod is a commercially valuable fish species and can therefore provide a sustainable source of seafood and a new market opportunity as well.
Having more lobsters in Danish waters represents both life cycle and economic benefits.
- Lobsters are a cold-water species and particularly vulnerable to the effects of climate change, such as warming and acidification of the oceans. Maintaining a healthy population would help in measuring the impact of the system in relation to mitigating negative effects on the water.
- From a market point of view, generating a sustainable production of lobsters would represent a large income, as they are sought after by trade.
LOBSTERTESTING
This phase will consist on create a similar environment for different fish to evaluate how they manage with their new environment and if they use the system as it was intended. This phases will last a couple of months to be able to have proof of concept and evaluate possible changes.
The next two phases will be tested at the same time ,if possible to be able to determine how fast the system is working and what can we do to get ready when is possible to have the ideal conditions for fish to grow, this phases will last some months to be able to have results.
This last phases will be done depending on how willing the stakeholder to try the system as the solution can be implemented in any of the three. To study how the different species will interact with the new source of protection, home and environment, is necessary to wait more than a year, also to have proof of the results the testing needs to be accompanied with cameras to take weekly/monthly pictures of the improvements.
Phase 1: Fish tank Phase 2-3: Small rivers / lakes - Harbor Phase 4-5-6: Old wind turbines / Working Wind Turbine / New locations.FURTHER DESIGN
Cage design approach
Round version Views
Modular
Di erent shapes
Stackable
Reef design approach
THE TEAM
The working team consists of seven Design and Innovation Master students, with different backgrounds, passionate about sustainability and innovation. By using a multidisciplinary approach combining design, engineering and marine biology, the team pursues creative solutions that promote marine biodiversity and contribute to a more sustainable future.
FILIP
Furbo Enevoldsen
S195765
Product Developer
Denmark
FELIPE
Chacón
S223298
Creative Director
Colombia
CAROLINA
Valderrama
S222643
Project Manager
Colombia
YASAMAN
Chalabi Hajkarim
S222507
System Analyst
Iran
TARA
Skov Rudkjøbing
S165144
Journalist
Denmark
HENDRIK
Stegers
S230258
Creative Director
Germany
HANNA
Juul-Andersen
S193993
Project Coordinator
Denmark