Skip to main content

Pembroke College Gazette 2021

Page 87

Pembroke College cambridge society

annual gazette issue 95 w september 2021

Pembroke College, Cambridge cb2 1rf Telephone (01223) 338100 Fax (01223) 338163 www.pem.cam.ac.uk © The Master & Fellows of Pembroke College, Cambridge Printed using vegetable based inks on paper from certified sustainably managed forests. 100% recyclable.


Painting of Malcolm Lyons by Louise Riley-Smith


annual gazette | 3

CONTENTS Editor’s Note From the Master A. WRITINGS AND TALKS A Tribute to David Buckingham – Ken Siddle Malcolm Lyons Remembered – Ian Pattinson ‘This Was My Life’: A Conversation With Nick Firman – Loraine Gelsthorpe and Nick McBride ‘A Small College Man’: George Gabriel Stokes and Pembroke College, Cambridge – Jayne Ringrose Art Gifts to the Pembroke Shahnameh Centre – Firuza Abdullaeva-Melville The Cartoonist and the Demon-King: How the Shahnameh Became Wartime Propaganda – Archie Williams Commemoration of Benefactors (1): Laurence Booth – Lizzy Ennion-Smith Dame Ivy Compton Burnett Prize for Creative Writing B. COLLEGE NEWS Reappointment of the Master New Fellows Fellows’ News Gifts to the College The Dean’s Report Development Office Report The Valence Mary (1997) Endowment Fund College Clubs and Societies C. THE COLLEGE RECORD The Master and Fellows 2020–2021 College Officers 2021–2022 Matriculation 2020–2021 Annual Examinations, First Class Results 2021 College Awards Graduate Scholarships and Awards Higher Degrees Conferred D. THE PEMBROKE COLLEGE CAMBRIDGE SOCIETY Members’ News Annual General Meetings of the Society Local Contacts Rules of the Society Presidents of the Society E. DEATHS AND OBITUARIES List of Deaths Obituaries F. MEMBERS’ CORNER Dhòmnaill Choir – Rory MacLeod

4 6 11 14 17 23 35 45 54 58 65 65 71 74 76 79 85 86 107 113 115 117 120 127 128 133 135 139 141 143 147 149 187


4 | pembroke college

EDITOR’S NOTE This year’s Gazette looks back on another very difficult year in the history of Pembroke College, and I hope reflects how well Pembroke has risen to the challenge of looking after its students – and how well the students have risen to the challenge of helping each other – against a background of limits on face-toface interactions, weekly tests for Covid-19, and many of Pembroke’s facilities being closed down for a large part of the year. We can only hope that next year will see a return to normal; but whatever next year holds, we will be going into it without some very significant figures who have been lost to Pembroke not – fortunately – because of Covid-19, but through retirement. The Master has noted in his contribution to this Gazette that our beloved Senior Tutor, Dan Tucker, will be stepping down from that role in October after five years of superlative service to the College. His assistant, Sally Clowes, will be retiring at the same time. Speaking personally, it has been an absolute privilege to know Sal in her time here. She has always been a rock of decency, humanity, patience, and good cheer. She is one of the best persons I have ever known and will be hugely missed. Also missed will be our former Head Gardener, Nick Firman, who retired in January 2021 after an incredible 55 years working for the College, 48 of them as Head Gardener. This Gazette includes an interview with Nick, looking back on his time at Pembroke. The dividers in this Gazette are made up of some snapshots of just a few of the glories of Pembroke’s gardens that Nick is responsible for, and that will be his enduring legacy to the College. The final retirement that I would like to acknowledge in this note is the one that hits hardest and closest to home. My assistant, Frances Kentish, will be retiring in December 2021, and as a result this Gazette will be the last produced with her help. In total, she has worked on seven Gazettes under the editorship of John Dougherty, eleven with me, and one with Chris Young (when I was on leave in 2015–16). 20% of all the Gazette’s ever produced have therefore come under Frances’ watchful eye. It is a remarkable record. Only a Shakespeare would be able to find words adequate to express the debt that I owe Frances, not just in helping me produce the Gazette, but also in our even longer-standing respective roles where I serve as Tutor for Graduate Admissions and she as Graduate Admissions Secretary. The job of Graduate Admissions Secretary is an incredibly difficult one: a fact that is not as widely appreciated as it ought to be because Frances makes it look so easy. It involves reading a huge number of files, turning them over to either me or Tim Weil (in charge of admissions decisions on the sciences side) for decision (while letting us know whether any aspects of those files warrants particular attention – in particular, whether the file belongs to a student who was accepted for a graduate place at Pembroke last year but failed to get enough funding to take up their place and is trying again this year), communicating our decisions to the University, keeping an eye on how many offers have been made across the range of different categories of postgraduate student that we accept at Pembroke and whether we are keeping a proper balance in terms of the offers we are making both between and within those different categories, while at the same time communicating with the graduate students we


annual gazette | 5 make offers to (and chasing up those who have not let the College know whether they will be able to take up the places they have been offered at Pembroke) and performing a huge number of functions relating to the graduate population at Pembroke in co-ordination with Loraine Gelsthorpe, the Tutor for Graduate Affairs. That Frances was able to keep so many of these plates spinning for so long, while also helping with the production of the Gazette, and also helping the Dean with Chapel matters, and also taking charge of the arrangements for students’ graduating (as well as the traditional and yearly MA dinner) – and do all of these things perfectly – makes her one of the most remarkable people I know, and also makes her retirement richly well-deserved. Pembroke was incredibly lucky to have Frances working for it for as long as it did, and we can only hope that fortune will smile on us again when it comes to the almost impossible job of finding a replacement for her. And on a personal level, I will miss terribly her kindness, calmness, common sense, and loyalty. Frances obviously occupies the place of honour when it comes to thanking those who have helped with the production of this year’s Gazette. I would also like to thank for their contributions to this year’s Gazette: Becky Coombs (the third and last remaining member of the remarkable team that Becky, Sal and Frances formed on LL staircase for so many years, to Pembroke’s huge benefit) and Sally Clowes; Genny Grim and Lizzy Ennion-Smith; Sally March, David Franks, Martine Goncalves and Julia Champion in the Development Office; Anna Lapwood and Andrew Morris; Firuza Melville and Jayne Ringrose; all the students who both submitted reports on this year’s activities among Pembroke’s various clubs and societies and who performed heroics in keeping those activities going under almost impossible circumstances; all those who contributed obituaries for the Deaths and Obituaries section of the Gazette; and the Fellows of Pembroke College for their various contributions to this Gazette.

N.J.M.


6 | pembroke college

FROM THE MASTER Last summer we were all keenly looking forward to a better 2021. We had just gone through an Easter Term with all teaching being done online, with most students back at home and studying and doing their exams from there, with an almost deserted College, and with none of the glorious celebration that normally comes with June in Cambridge. Surely 2021 couldn’t be as bad as this? Well, we’ve tried very hard to make it better; but it’s been a struggle. It was especially a struggle in Lent Term, when once again a national lockdown meant that most students had to study and work from home, and even for those who were still in Cambridge there was no music or sport or socialising at all. But Easter Term this year was far better, even though we still had to ask everyone to wear masks in indoor communal spaces, and to observe social distancing, and to collect food in boxes from the Servery. Just seeing our students back in College was a delight, and the place was buzzing with life and activity again, and on the sunny days of early June everyone was sitting out on the Bowling Green Lawn reading or revising or chatting. As we came towards the end of term we brought Formal Hall back for six nights over the final three weeks: everyone had to sit in groups of six, with space between each group, including of course the Fellows on High Table. We put the six Formal Halls up online for students to book their places; and within ten minutes every single place had been booked. It was a very good indication of how sorely missed many of the community aspects of College life have been, through these pandemic times. And then at the end of term we erected a huge marquee and were able to put on a Matriculation Dinner for our first-year students (who had never been able to matriculate properly at the start of the year); we did a barbeque for our second-year students; we gave a Barham Dinner to celebrate graduation for our third-year students; we did a lunch and graduation ceremony for the graduands; and we put on a combined Matriculation and Graduation Dinner for our postgraduates. None of these, sadly, were in Hall; they were all in the marquee with tables of six clearly separated; but it felt really special, particularly after the fifteen months we had all been living through. I’m firmly hoping that by the time we get to Michaelmas virtually all of our students will have been doubly vaccinated and we’ll be able to provide much more of a sense of life lived as a College community. Through all of these difficult months we have been guided and led by our Senior Tutor, Dan Tucker. Dan has handled everything with astonishing patience and humanity. Whether it’s carrying out complex risk assessments for meeting rooms or events; or trying to understand the often contradictory advice and guidance from the Department for Education; or coordinating plans with the University or the City Council or Public Health England; or working with the Junior Parlour and Graduate Parlour, whose contributions to College life through the whole period have been terrific; or setting out a weekly letter to all students explaining what is happening and why; or dealing with a host of individual enquiries and special circumstances: Dan has remained calm and unflustered throughout. And he has struck exactly the right balance between keeping


annual gazette | 7 everyone safe whilst ensuring that they can have some joy too. Dan is also of course a distinguished veterinary academic, a global expert on pigs, and is in high demand around the world for his knowledge and advice. He does now want to focus much more on his research and his international advisory work, and will step down as Senior Tutor when his initial five years come to an end in September. He will be much missed. We are of course delighted that he will remain a Fellow of the College. One of the most important of all tasks for a Master is to lead the process of choosing a new Senior Tutor. We advertised, and received some very strong applications, and in late February I chaired an interview panel of Fellows to try and find the best new Senior Tutor possible. I’m very happy to say that we did in fact find a particularly outstanding candidate, whom we’ve appointed, and who joins us from 1st September. He is Robert Mayhew, Professor of Historical Geography at Bristol University, who has a formidable academic record, but now wants to focus his energies on student support and College life. For nine years he was a resident Warden at Bristol, with responsibility for the pastoral, disciplinary, social and sporting life of the undergraduates, and leading a team of Tutors. In his application he talked about ‘the centrality of personal engagement to building a successful academic environment’. For me, this precisely describes the ethos of Pembroke. Our academic success comes because of the warmth and friendliness and mutually supportive nature of our College community. Crucial to that warmth and friendliness, of course, are the interdisciplinary engagement – and cohesiveness – of our Fellowship. Elsewhere in the Gazette you will be able to read the remarkable list of achievements, awards and publications that have been secured by our Fellows during the past year. It’s an outstanding list, and alongside it runs a commitment to the College, to our students, and to the process of education and research that forms our fundamental purpose. We did, sadly, lose one of our most distinguished Emeritus Fellows back in February. Professor David Buckingham joined Pembroke as a Fellow in 1970, after his appointment as the first holder of the Professorship of Theoretical Chemistry at Cambridge. His work studying the optical, electric and magnetic properties of molecules and intermolecular forces shed light on the fundamental physical properties of matter. His work was acknowledged and recognised across the world. To this day, quadrupole moments of molecules are measured in buckinghams. He also found time to be a talented cricketer, serving as President of CUCC for some twenty years. Above all, David was one of the nicest, gentlest, most engaging colleagues you could possibly want to have. When we celebrated his ninetieth birthday in Parlour, his beaming smile lit up the room, and lit up our hearts. That, too, is what Pembroke life is all about.

C.R.S.


A. WRITINGS AND TALKS


annual gazette | 11

A Tribute to David Buckingham Ken Siddle The following tribute to David Buckingham was delivered by Ken Siddle, the Senior Treasurer of the Cambridge University Cricket Club and a Fellow of Churchill College (as Professor (Emeritus) of Molecular Endocrinology), at David’s funeral on 1 March 2021.

I want to talk about David’s passion for the game of cricket, a passion that runs as a continuous thread throughout his life, and to which I owe almost 40 years of precious friendship with the loveliest man you could wish to know. He was born in Pymble, a suburb of Sydney, and like all good Australians was introduced to cricket at an early age. His skills were soon recognised and he played for his prep school and then Barker College for whom he took a hat-trick in a senior game against Waverley College in 1947 (he proudly retained the match ball with its commemorative engraved plaque). His cricket skills were further honed alongside those in chemistry at the University of Sydney, where he won what he always liked to refer to as ‘my Blue’. When he came to Cambridge to study for a PhD he played in a couple of trial games during his first summer but did not represent the University in matches of any consequence that year. I don’t know whether it was pressure of work or competition for places that kept him out of the first XI. In any event, he made his first-class debut for Cambridge the following season, 1955, playing four matches against the might of Surrey, Yorkshire, Essex and Middlesex. At the end of that summer, having completed his PhD in express time, he swapped light Blue for dark and took up a research fellowship at ‘the other place’. As far as I can see he did not actually play for Oxford University – he was after all no longer a student – but he certainly engaged with OUCC and soon became its Treasurer. For several years he turned out for the Free Foresters, an itinerant club made up largely of former Oxbridge players, whose annual matches against the ancient Universities were at that time accorded ‘first class’ status. With the Foresters he played several times in The Parks as well as returning to Fenner’s. David was primarily an opening batsman and (by this time) only an occasional off-break bowler – in his last first-class game in 1960 he opened the batting with Henry Blofeld, a name that will be known to some ‘dear old things’ from his colourful cricket commentaries of later years. His first-class record of 349 runs in 10 matches (with highest scores of 52 not out for Cambridge University and 61 for Free Foresters) may appear modest, but he played in a golden age of University cricket, with and against at least eight past and future England captains (Norman Yardley, George Mann, Peter May, Ted Dexter, Tony Lewis, Ray Illingworth, Brian Close and MJK Smith), one captain of Australia (Ian Craig) and many other great England test players (including Fred Trueman, Willie Watson, Bob Appleyard, Jim Laker, Tony Lock, Trevor Bailey, Doug Insole, Bill Edrich, Freddie Brown, Alan Smith and Bob Barber). He was never one to brag about his playing days, but could sometimes be persuaded to reminisce about facing Fred Trueman in his pomp, and would be quick to remind his listeners, with a characteristic twinkle in his eye, that Fred did not get him out!


12 | pembroke college When David returned to Cambridge in 1969 as Professor of Chemistry, his name soon appeared again in CUCC papers. The Treasurer at that time, Jack Davies (himself a legend of University cricket, who at Fenner’s in 1934 had bowled the immortal Donald Bradman for a duck), recorded in the minutes of the 1974 AGM that ‘he was hoping to hand over to a successor during this tour of duty and an approach was being made to Professor Buckingham, formerly a treasurer of OUCC but now resident in Cambridge.’ And so in 1977 David succeeded Jack as Senior Treasurer of CUCC, becoming the only person to hold that office in both Oxford and Cambridge. We should note that the Senior Treasurer is the Officer responsible to the University for the overall conduct of the Club and not just its finances. David served with two Club Presidents, Sir Derek Bowett (President of Queens’) and Sir John (later Lord) Butterfield (Master of Downing). And then when John Butterfield stood down in 1990, David was himself elected President of CUCC – a singular honour that undoubtedly meant a great deal to him (and I succeeded him as Senior Treasurer). David served as President for an unprecedented 19 years, guiding Cambridge cricket with enormous enthusiasm and calm authority, and earning the respect and affection of players and University colleagues alike. He was a most courteous and gracious host on formal occasions, often in Pembroke College, and an assured and eloquent figurehead when representing the Club at Lord’s. He cared passionately about Cambridge cricket and its traditions while recognising the challenges faced by the Club if it was to retain first-class status, and the need to move with the times. He oversaw many changes, not least our transition to one of six national university centres of excellence, alongside the sale of a piece of Fenner’s ground to fund the building of an indoor cricket school, a sensitive project that he guided with great tact. As he approached 80 (albeit a very young 80!) David expressed a desire to step down as President and in 2009 he handed over to Roger Knight (an Old Blue and former Chief Executive of MCC). He retained a keen interest in the Club however, and we continued to see him at Fenner’s every summer – somehow the route from Lensfield Road to Pembroke College unerringly took him that way – and he seldom missed the Varsity Match at Lord’s. It goes without saying that his wisdom, enthusiasm and friendship will be greatly missed but we intend that he will be commemorated at Fenner’s in due course. I shall always picture him greeting me with his broad smile and that twinkle in his eye.


annual gazette | 13

In the Long Room at Lord’s

Receiving a presentation in 2009 at Fenner’s from Ted Dexter, to mark David Buckingham’s retirement as President of the Cambridge University Cricket Club


14 | pembroke college

Malcolm Lyons Remembered Ian Pattinson (1970) Ian Pattinson studied Law at Pembroke from 1970–1973. He is currently Chairman of the R&A Board and Chairman of the Royal & Ancient Golf Club of St Andrews. He has worked as the Rules of Golf Advisor at the Open Championship for both the BBC (from 2004–2015) and Sky TV (from 2016–2018). Here he shares his memories of Malcolm Lyons.

I first met Malcolm in his rooms in College over 50 years ago, not many yards from the chapel where we were due to gather last year in his memory and to celebrate all that he had achieved. It is no exaggeration to say that this was an encounter that would set the course of my life. With a father who was at Pembroke in the ’30s and a brother in the ’60s, my destiny was (in theory) prescribed, but attaining this holy grail proved much more problematical. In those times, the strict entry procedure was to sit A-levels first and follow these, a few months later, with an entrance exam. For the lucky (or was it the questionable) candidates, an interview with both tutors for admissions might then follow. My academic record, while not a disaster, was far from outstanding – even so, it was not the start I expected when my first interviewer inauspiciously opened with the simply shocking question: “Pattinson – what went wrong with your A-levels?” But later, I carefully edged around vast, untidy piles of books to enter the room of (the then) Dr Lyons to the greeting: “Come on in, Ian; it’s good to see you – I hear your golf handicap is now 2.” Having eventually been admitted to read law, I was not exposed to Malcolm’s prodigious scholarship or intellect, which was fortunate for me, as he was probably a genius and I was possibly a dunderhead. But whenever I saw him in College, I was warmly and reassuringly greeted as though I was part of the community of Pembroke, which was all I needed to know. Malcolm later introduced me to Ursula, who was both charming and elegant and an exceptional academic in her own right, as well as a gracious and welcoming hostess at Bottle Hall and later – after I had left Pembroke – at Walnut Tree Cottage. Within the prolific range of her own talents was the ability to make a simply consummate cassata, which remains unforgettable to this day. But I digress. Sir Roger Tomkys (in issue 94 of the Gazette) has recounted the circumstances of the Lyons’ family move to St Andrews, the Home of Golf, during Malcolm’s early life. There he taught himself to play golf; of that I am convinced. No-one who saw Malcolm play in later years could possibly believe that he had ever received a lesson in his life. A classical, balanced golf swing is a thing of beauty. By contrast, Malcolm’s own technique was simultaneously both fascinating and mildly excruciating to watch. His action was eccentric and unorthodox. He eschewed conventional – ie spiked – golf footwear and wore instead, stout walking shoes with sensible rubber soles. When first we played, his antique golf bag contained an unmatched set of clubs from another era. Malcolm was not, in truth, athletic and he assumed an ungainly and awkwardly narrow stance prior to making a golf stroke. A look of extreme concentration would totally absorb his


annual gazette | 15 features, as he drew the club back slowly, almost in the style of a fly fisherman about to cast his line, before launching his club at the ball with all the ferocity of a caveman killing his lunch. It was a wonder he ever hit the golf ball at all; but he did so very successfully, propelling it a significant distance and he played unbelievably well. I really do not know how he did this, but he became an accomplished golfer, achieving a low single figure handicap. Malcolm was unfailingly modest and self-effacing and had absolutely no ego, but he certainly had a secret weapon. His unassuming, genial personality masked the key to his success – it belied a discreet competitive spirit. With his impish sense of humour, he liked nothing better than first to deceive a youthful golfer into thinking that his bizarre method meant he must be incompetent and then watch as the match developed and a different reality dawned on his hapless opponent. This resulted in the defeat of many a frustrated golfer. Malcolm’s invariable reaction to this was to smile innocently and very quietly utter his unique laugh – “tee hee!” In 1962, Malcolm had become a member of the Royal and Ancient Golf Club of St Andrews, the most significant Golf Club in the world. He loved to play the Old Course and would stay with his sister, who lived in the town. What a coincidence that he was required to visit St Andrews University so regularly to examine its PhD students… Latterly, although he could not visit the Royal and Ancient, he was awarded a locker in the ‘Big Room’, a hallowed area of the clubhouse – an accolade reserved for the Club’s most senior members. Malcolm’s awkward co-ordination and possibly his eyesight prevented him from driving a car, but he prevailed upon the saintly Ursula to deliver him to golf and afterwards collect him, whether from Gog Magog, Royal Worlington, or even the links of St Andrews. He greatly enjoyed his membership of the Royal and Ancient and his deceptively good play there carried him to his greatest golfing successes, with victories in two major Club competitions – the Calcutta Cup, in a foursomes partnership with his friend Michael Scott, and the John Ellis Knowles Trophy, which he won on his own account. Malcolm’s time as Tutor for Admissions (Arts) in the College corresponded with an unprecedented run of success for Cambridge in the annual Varsity golf match. A Pembroke golfer invariably featured in the team and indeed, during Malcolm’s reign, Pembroke produced more golf blues than any other Cambridge college apart from Trinity. As has been stated by Roger, the loss of Ursula was a monumental blow for Malcolm and the last years of his life were challenging. Although I knew that his health was not robust, the news of his death on the evening of 18 December 2019 nevertheless came as a shock to me. For earlier, that very afternoon, after quite a gap since my previous visit and armed with a bottle of the Royal and Ancient’s no 2 whisky, which I knew he would enjoy, I chanced to call on him, thank heavens. He was, of course, physically diminished but he was working when I arrived and his spirit certainly shone brightly. As I had found before, the range of Malcolm’s conversation, especially when lubricated by a dram or two, was wide ranging. With some


16 | pembroke college prompting, many topics of interest were discussed – his upbringing; golf (naturally); his brief attachment to MI6; Pembroke; Ursula and how his faith had sustained him after her death; university sport and its relationship to academic success (which he correctly maintained are more often linked than not); the Royal Family (of which he was supportive); Scottish rugby (which he said made him too nervous to watch); and the recent General Election. Neither did he forget to mention his gratitude to his terrific carer, Stella. By chance, I reminded Malcolm of our very first meeting all those years ago and how lucky I felt to have been admitted to Pembroke. “You deserved your place” is all he said about that, for which I will always be grateful. In the academic world he inhabited, Malcolm was of course formidably distinguished but he was kind and anything but a formidable man. He had an acute memory, was genuinely interested in others, especially the young and he was surprisingly well informed about a great variety of topics too numerous to mention here. As will many whose lives he touched, I feel very fortunate to have met him. He was a man for all seasons.


annual gazette | 17 ‘This Was My Life’: A Conversation With Nick Firman

Loraine Gelsthorpe and Nick McBride Nick Firman retired as Head Gardener of Pembroke College in January 2021, after nearly 56 years of service to the College, having joined the College as an apprentice gardener in April 1965 at the age of 16. On a somewhat overcast day at the end of July, we met with Nick in the grounds of Pembroke College and sat down in the Fellows’ Garden to talk about his life at Pembroke. We began by asking him how he became interested in gardening in the first place. ‘I was always interested in gardening at home. My parents actually bought me a small greenhouse when I was 14 or 15 and I used to grow tomatoes and things like that in it. I asked them to get it for me. Then at school we had a period in an afternoon when we could do a subject like woodwork or pottery, and the school had just bought a new greenhouse so obviously I headed straight for that. It had a little plot of ground outside which we could cultivate and grow things on as well.’ Neither of Nick’s parents were particularly interested in gardening – ‘Dad used to do the garden, but he wasn’t keen, I think’ – and he attributes his interest to the fact that he ‘was never a great academic and gardening seemed like a nice job, out in the air and fairly relaxed.’ Nick’s exploration of gardening at school was interrupted by his getting the job as apprentice gardener on £5 a week at Pembroke College. Gordon Miller was the Head Gardener at Pembroke, having taken over from Bob Eley. Gordon’s son attended the same school as Nick. ‘Gordon’s son got to hear that I was looking for a job, and he must have told his father, and his father came down to my house to have a chat with me. He invited me back to the college to have a look round. When I went to the college, there was a chap near the rockery who looked like he was a gardener – so I asked him where the gardens department was. It turned out he was Meredith Dewey – he was always being mistaken for one of the gardeners.’ Nick was taken on, and brought under Gordon Miller’s wing. ‘Gordon taught me probably everything I know about gardening. He used to take me round different colleges and on other trips. There used to be something called the Walkerian Society at the Botanic Gardens, and we used to go there for lectures and talks on a Monday evening – though I don’t think that exists anymore. The College also sent me to Milton Farm School [now the College of West Anglia] where I earned certificates in horticulture.’ Interaction with the Fellowship was limited at that time. Fellows might bring their plants to the College greenhouse to be looked after, but otherwise their main contact was with Meredith Dewey, as the Garden Steward. ‘He was a lovely chap – very helpful and nice. He would come down and have a cup of tea and ask if we would do various jobs around the college and on his rockery. We did have to take the chance when he went on holiday to tidy up any gardening work that he had done himself – he was never


18 | pembroke college that tidy with his work. But he never said anything when he came back from holiday and saw what we had done. We would also find these lumps of coal in the rockery below one of his College set windows – he would throw them at the birds that were pecking at the plants he was growing there. He was a character. I think when he died, he left each of the staff a small amount of money in his will. He was a very nice person and when he retired he moved to Millington Road and had a nice garden there.’ Nick with Meredith Dewey Nick looked back fondly on those early days working in Pembroke: ‘They were good days. There was no electricity in the potting shed, but a much larger greenhouse than now. No computers, no emails. One Garden Steward, which made it easier to make decisions.’ Gordon Miller ‘never used to stop long in any job. He would always be moving on. He used to stop about five years and then move on and take on another garden.’ When Gordon Miller left Pembroke, two other Head Gardeners were appointed in quick succession, and Nick started to look for opportunities elsewhere. Gordon Miller told Pembroke it should try to keep Nick on, and so when the position of Head Gardener fell vacant again, the College was only too happy to accede to Nick’s suggestion that it should take a chance on him and give him the job. So in 1972 Nick got his chance to move up to become Head Gardener, becoming one of the youngest Head Gardeners in Cambridge at the age of only 23. Nick wasn’t at all intimidated at the thought of becoming Head Gardener at such an early age: ‘When I started, the job wasn’t as complicated as it is nowadays. It was just about gardening, both in the College and around the hostels, where I think we did an excellent job. My plan was just to carry on with what Gordon had been doing in terms of introducing new plants and flowers into the garden. It wasn’t like I was a new guy, intending to do things dramatically differently from how they had been done before.’ He did take advantage of regular meetings of all the Head Gardeners to exchange ideas, and trips to other colleges and the Botanic gardens bore fruit in the form of cuttings, ‘but nowadays there doesn’t seem to be the time to do that kind of thing. Everyone is rushing around doing things, so the Head Gardener meetings just died out.’ A photo from around 1976 shows Nick with his team. Nick is in the centre, at the back, with George Jackson on the left and Alfie Hutter on the right. Tom


annual gazette | 19 Middleton (the brother of a former College butler) is at the bottom left, and the young man in green dungarees is Guy Fuller – at the time an apprentice gardener at Pembroke, and now Head Gardener at Robinson College. 1976 was also the year of the great drought, and Pembroke ended up in a bit of trouble when the local newspaper noted just how lush and green the lawn in First Court was looking. The Bursar ordered Nick and his team to stop watering the lawn immediately! The team that Nick had assembled around him was reduced when Bill Grimstone took over as Garden Steward. ‘He had very Victorian principles: two can run the gardens, he would say.’ This put a lot of pressure on Nick, which was eased somewhat once Brian Watchorn, Loraine Gelsthorpe and Geoffrey Edwards were appointed to the Gardens Committee; the size of Nick’s team gradually got back to a more manageable four.

The old greenhouse and Master’s Lodge (both demolished when Foundress Court was built)

The old herbaceous border around the Fellows’ Garden


20 | pembroke college Nick obviously witnessed, and had to cope with, many changes in his time as Head Gardener. ‘The biggest change was the construction of Foundress Court and the New Master’s Lodge. That resulted in our losing a spectacular herbaceous border that was on the site of what become Foundress Court. We also lost the greenhouse and potting shed that we occupied – that was located on the left as you walked through the back gates of the College. To replace that, the current greenhouse was constructed – but it isn’t that practical: it’s too tall to heat very easily. It’s an architect’s dream – I think it was modelled on the plane trees in the avenue – rather than a gardener’s dream. It seems like every time we have moved, our premises have got smaller. So two years after we had got settled in our new quarters, the extension to the Library took away a lot of the new space that had been created for the gardeners. Maybe the development of the Mill Lane site will create a bit more room for storage.’ The expansion of the Pembroke May Balls over time also created complications for the gardeners. What used to involve just one marquee on one lawn now sprawls over multiple lawns. One May Ball which resulted in a lorry getting stuck in the Foundress Court lawn also sticks in Nick’s mind: ‘At least we got a new lawn out of it, I suppose.’ Reflecting on mistakes that had been made in his time at Pembroke, Nick’s thoughts immediately went to the walnut tree in First Court that students and Fellows of a certain vintage will still remember. Having a tree in First Court had always been a dream of Meredith Dewey’s, Nick recalls, but Meredith Dewey had wanted a eucalyptus tree planted there. Instead, the idea of a walnut tree was taken up. Getting the walnut tree established proved difficult: ‘It was planted, pulled up, disappeared, planted, pulled up, disappeared – we even had to go to one of the hostels to collect it, because the students had pulled it up as a joke. In the end the original tree disappeared altogether, so a bigger specimen was planted that would be much harder for the students to pull up.’ And there was no end of difficulties once the tree was established: ‘The trouble was whenever you watered First Court, you would also be feeding the tree, so there were problems with the tree undergoing tremendous growth so that it had to be cut back a great deal. The leaves killed the grass underneath, and you also had problems with the students climbing the tree, and branches falling off. In the end, it was proposed that we should just remove it, and we convinced the council to allow us to do that with the aid of an old photo with showed what First Court looked like before the tree was installed.’ Nick also wonders whether the installation of box hedging around the Bowling Green was a mistake. It was intended to discourage students from running across the Bowling Green, but in practice might have the effect of encouraging students to jump over it or into the hedging. But any mistakes are more than counter-balanced by the achievements that Nick is most proud of. ‘I am proud of the First Court at this time of year, when you have the geraniums and fuchsias blooming, and also the plumbago – which many people say you have to grow in a greenhouse. It really gives me a buzz when people say “It looks lovely”. The fuchsias are flowers that we have grown ourselves – they aren’t brought in, like they were when Gordon was Head Gardener – and it’s a lot of work. I also like the shrubs and pomegranates and campsis along the Hitcham Building in Ivy Court. The campsis has been there


annual gazette | 21 longer than me.’ Another achievement also represents what Nick thinks will be the biggest challenge for his successor as Head Gardener: ‘Getting everyone working as a team.’ Asked how he achieved this, Nick said, ‘You have to work with people’s different personalities, and guide people, give them challenges and things to do.’ Looking after the new Mill Lane site would also be a substantial challenge, in Summer bedding border in Ivy Court, consisting in Silver Cineraria, particular finding enough Busy Lizzies, and Castor Oil plant water to sustain the flowers, plants and trees that will be a feature of the new site. The roar of a nearby lawnmower just starting up interrupted our conversation, and prompted a question about the increasing mechanisation of gardening, and how it is paid for. ‘When Gordon started, we only had one mower which would be used for the whole College – by the time it was all done, it was time to start all over again. And we only had a push lawnsweeper, which you would push along to sweep the leaves up. So everything was done by hand. We didn’t have budgets in those days – if I wanted to buy a new machine, I had to go and see the Bursar, Colin Gilbraith, and ask for the money. Now we have budgets, and if there is anything we needed, I could ask for some additional money on the budget to cover that. But no one ever refused us what we needed – we always got what we wanted. We do get complaints about the noise created by things like the leaf blowers, but they do make everything a lot easier than they used to be.’ Nick had opened our conversation by acknowledging that ‘There comes a time when you’ve got to retire. You can’t be going on forever’. By way of finishing our conversation we turned to the question of why he had decided to retire when he did. The decision was triggered by Covid-19. For 35 years, Nick and his wife Julie had been living in, and looking after, one of the student hostels owned by Pembroke on Barton Road. ‘We had to go past students every day to get to our living accommodation and because of my age we were worried about my catching Covid, so we thought it was probably a good time to leave the hostel and retire as Head Gardener.’ Nick and Julie were very sad to leave the hostel and Pembroke after 91 years of service between them: they enjoyed living in the hostel and looking after it. ‘Originally, it was a way of making ends meet. The opportunity of being a hostelkeeper at Barton Road came up, and I had a word with Mr Gilbraith and he gave us the key.’ He reminisced that it used to be the case – in the days before international programmes and large numbers of graduate students studying at Cambridge that resulted in student hostels being used round the year – that


22 | pembroke college hostel keepers were permitted to let out vacant student rooms during the Long Vacation, so long as they gave the College some of the rent earned by doing so. ‘You had people from other countries staying in the hostel, and you could talk to them and have a chat.’ Nick also enjoyed interacting with the students in the hostels, though he feels older generations of students were more friendly than newer generations have tended to be. Tom Kirkwood stuck in his mind as someone he remembered fondly: he would sometimes play football in the garden with Nick and Julie’s children, who grew up in the hostel alongside the students The hostel at 26 Barton Road living there. The home Nick now shares with Julie has ‘a small garden at the back, paved, with things in pots that need to be watered. It keeps me occupied. I have a big lawn at the front, which a lot of people comment on as looking really nice.’ He misses being involved with looking after the gardens at Pembroke: ‘This was my life. I would be at Barton Road and I would often pop in, even on a Sunday morning. But I would never put in for overtime: it was partly my hobby and partly my job. So to be cut off from that is difficult.’ Our conversation finished, we got up and walked across to the Orchard to take the photograph of Nick that begins this piece, with Nick standing yards away from Meredith Dewey’s rockery, where he asked 56 years ago for directions to the garden department. We hope there will be many more opportunities to reminisce with Nick over such a remarkable period of service to the College – as he said when asked whether there was anything more that he might share with the readers of the Gazette that we had not covered: ‘There is probably still a lot more that hasn’t been discussed.’ With huge thanks to Nick and his remarkable service to the College and its gardens!

The garden at 26 Barton Road


annual gazette | 23

A ‘Small-College Man’: George Gabriel Stokes and Pembroke College, Cambridge Jayne Ringrose This paper was originally delivered at the Stokes 200 Conference at Pembroke College on 17 September 2019. I should like to thank the organizers of the conference, Professor Silvana Cardoso and Professor Julyan Cartwright, and especially Dr Christopher Ness, Fellow of Pembroke College, for help with preparing the original presentation. Mr Matthew Mellor, Fellows’ Steward at the College kindly gave permission for me to quote from the Parlour wine books. I am grateful to the Master and Fellows of Pembroke College Cambridge for permission to cite and quote from the College Archives, and to my successor as College Archivist, Mrs Elizabeth Ennion-Smith and to the College Librarian, Ms Genny Grim for facilitating this and for much other help. I am likewise grateful to the Syndics of Cambridge University Library and to the Superintendent of the Manuscripts Reading Room, Mr Frank Bowles and his staff for much assistance. Finally I owe a debt of gratitude to Dr Mark McCartney, Dr Elisabeth Leedham-Green, Professor David B. Wilson and Mrs Julia Wilson, and the Reverend Margaret Widdess.

Introduction According to the Cambridge University Calendar (1837, 193–197), when George Gabriel Stokes first came up to Pembroke College, there were 40 undergraduates, plus two sizars,1 in addition to the Master, Gilbert Ainslie, and 12 Fellows (there were two vacancies and two Bye-fellows),2 while according to the University Calendar of 1902–03 (708–720), there were 13 foundation fellowships but over 240 undergraduates. Stokes became a member of Pembroke on 7 July 1837, when his name appears in the admissions book (in Latin) as follows:3 Stokes, George Gabriel, fourth son of the Reverend Gabriel Stokes, Rector of Skreen in county Sligo in Ireland, born there, and having reached his nineteenth year [i.e. aged eighteen], was admitted to the second [undergraduate] table under the Tutor, Mr Arlett, 7 July 1837


24 | pembroke college His contemporary John Power, reforming and modernising Master from 1870–80, had been admitted less than a month earlier. There were eighteen entrants in all that year. This article traces Stokes’s occasionally chequered connection with Pembroke College from his Admission to his death in the Mastership in 1903. What did Stokes see at Pembroke when he got off the coach which had brought him from Birmingham en route from Bristol?4 Not what the modern fresher sees today. The fourteenth-century gateway opened into a tiny enclosed medieval court, one of the smallest in the University, the site formed of the two original strips of land given by the Foundress to her College in the fourteenth century.5 On the right, the south side, was a medieval range which included the old Master’s Lodge, its eighteenth century extensions stretching beyond the present range towards the Chapel. Straight ahead was the College Hall, smaller than the one we know today, and again dating back to the fourteenth century. Both Hall and south range were to disappear during Stokes’s time at Pembroke. Of the Old Court, only the north range, with the College Library, (now the Old Library) some sets of rooms and the buttery were to remain. The second court, approached through the screens between the Hall and the kitchen, was originally known as New Court, now Ivy Court. Beyond it lay the Orchard, with Ridley’s Walk, traditionally associated with the Protestant Martyr and Master Nicholas Ridley and leading to an historic tennis court, to the bowling green, and, to the north east of New Court, the Sphere. This was a planetarium built by the Master Roger Long (held office 1733–70), famed for his eccentricities such as the water velocipede upon which he rode round the pond in his garden. The stars were represented by holes in the metal of the Sphere, which was turned by a handle, originally operated by his servant Richard Dunthorne, and the interior seated thirty spectators. Stokes the undergraduate Stokes’s Tutor was Henry Arlett, who in 1837 was combining the Office of Tutor with that of Treasurer and President (that is, Vice-Master). He was to influence Stokes’s life and career almost up to his death in 1869. Stokes quickly established himself academically. The College held an internal examination every summer. As is well known, Stokes was beaten in his first year by John Sykes, a future Fellow and civil servant who obtained 325 marks in classics (well below Stokes’s 377) but 524 in maths while Stokes only managed 481. Stokes soon recovered however, and in his third year in 1840, obtained 1,421 marks in Mathematics and the Greek Testament. Sykes got 986 and Power 715. Meanwhile, he was mopping up scholarships, which could be held at Pembroke in plurality. Stokes held a foundation scholarship from 1838 to the end of his third year. He also collected for example in his third year a Senior Greek scholarship (Power only got a junior Greek) and an Ipswich Scholarship.6 Like other students, Stokes dined daily in Hall, the scholars sitting at the same table as the rest of the students. Chapel was compulsory twice on Sundays at 9.30 am and 6.00 pm;7 it was compulsory once on other days at 7 am or 6.00 pm. Gilbert


annual gazette | 25 Ainslie, Master 1828–70 was Vice Chancellor in 1836–37 and laid the foundation stone of the Fitzwilliam Museum in 1837. Stokes would have seen the building going up in his undergraduate years and later. Stokes passed the previous examination (in his day a compulsory examination for all students on one of the gospels in Greek, a Greek and a Latin classical text and Paley’s Evidences of Christianity). This was held in the fifth term with the chance of a re-take the following October; it was geared mainly to pass men, that is, those aiming no higher than ordinary degrees. The final major hurdle was the Tripos or Senate House examination, taken in January, often in freezing conditions. The American Charles Astor Bristed, who came up to Trinity in 1840, could not bring himself to notice the Senior Wrangler of 1841 as anything other than a ‘Small-College man’, though he conceded that such a triumph was an unusual occurrence, and remarked that the mathematical examination that year was very difficult and played havoc with candidates’ expectations. First election to a Fellowship Stokes was immediately elected to his Fellowship on 23 January, and was admitted to this in the Chapel. He dined for the last time at the second table on the fifth week of the Lent Quarter 1841, and for the first time at the Fellows’ table, on the sixth week of the Lent Quarter. But where exactly was Stokes’s room? By the time intelligible records of rooms begin in 1870, Stokes had long moved out of College into Lensfield Cottage backing on to the site of the modern Scott Polar Research Institute in Lensfield Road. College tradition asserts that as a young don he occupied the high gabled room with gothic windows, which now overlooks Trumpington Street on the outside and, it was said, fitted it up as a physics laboratory. This room is medieval in origin and may be the ‘magna camera’ or ‘big chamber’ which is mentioned in the earliest College property records.8 Until the late nineteenth century it formed the extreme end of the subsequently demolished south range, and it is just possible that other rooms were associated with it. For Stokes, these were the years of the entries in the parlour wine books which record bottles of wine presented in settlement of bets, or as forfeits for misdemeanours. Unlike the case with modern wine books, the nature of the misdemeanour is described but there is no account of exactly who was there. Thus, on 30 October 1847, Mr Stokes bets Mr Power that Pratt of Caius was second Wrangler. (John Henry Pratt afterwards Archdeacon of Calcutta and a physicist, was third Wrangler in 1833.) On 2 November, Mr Stokes paid a bottle on being appointed moderator (Senior examiner). On 14 May 1848, Mr Stokes is fined a bottle of wine for spilling Mr Sykes’s claret. On 13 June 1848, Mr Stokes broke a wine glass; on 7 November 1848, Mr Stokes is fined a bottle of wine for tearing The Times. Meanwhile, Stokes served as Praelector in 1845, presenting students for degrees in the Senate House, and was Bursar (assistant Treasurer) in 1846 and 1847. This would suggest involvement with the celebrations for the five hundredth anniversary of the founding of the College in 1847. In 1849 he of


26 | pembroke college course became Lucasian Professor of Mathematics. And yet the College, described by one former undergraduate as a ‘Caravansera of idlesse’9 seemed to be declining, especially in numbers, reaching its nadir (during Stokes’s absence from the Fellowship) when Edward London Pincott came on 18 October 1858, only to leave the College and go to Caius after keeping five days of residence, the only entrant of his year. Marriage and the University Commission of 1850 As is well known, Stokes forfeited his Fellowship upon his marriage. As various dates have been given for this, it should be noted that the marriage took place on 4 July 1857. The Master Gilbert Ainslie, preoccupied with the University of Cambridge Act of 1856 wrote from Hall Garth in Lancashire: on 6 October 1856: ‘My dear Stokes, Altho’ I cannot say that I am sorry that you should have determined to lead a married rather than a single life, I am truly sorry to think that you will have ceased to be a Fellow of my College’. He went on: ‘I think you happy in escaping some of the changes which the new Act will bring upon us’.10 Henry Arlett, Stokes’s former Tutor wrote on 18 November: ‘We hope you have chosen the better part and will be as happy as you deserve to be but the Old House can ill afford to lose you and there is a general wish that it were possible to keep you one of us still. At present I am sorry to say no progress has been made towards a Statute to enable a married Professor to retain his Fellowship and if it ever pass it will be in the teeth of considerable opposition only by a compulsory enactment of the Commissioners’.11 Why, therefore, given Stokes’s evident popularity with the Fellows of Pembroke did it happen that, after the College received new statutes in 1861 allowing married Professors to retain their Fellowships in certain circumstances, was it a further full six years before Stokes was re-elected to his Fellowship on 22 May 1867? It is not possible to say for certain, but there may be a clue in Stokes’s involvement with University Reform. Right up until the middle of the nineteenth century, the University of Cambridge had still been running largely on the Elizabethan statutes of 1570. Privileges were entrenched and there was little possibility of change to meet modern requirements, most notably the growth of the under-endowed University as distinct from the wealthy Colleges. A Royal Commission (‘the Graham Commission’; see note 7 above) was appointed in 1850 to inquire into the two ancient universities. The Commission’s report resulted in the Cambridge University Act of 1856. For the purposes of this article, the main thing is that the Act set up Statutory Commissioners, to oversee the revision of the statutes of the University and Colleges. The Act permitted the Colleges to reform their own statutes. For the most part, they did not do so, and the Commissioners accordingly exercised their power to frame statutes for the Colleges. This, it may be imagined caused enormous disagreement and rancour amongst the Colleges (and indeed the University reformers). Stokes, needing to supplement his meagre income from the Lucasian Professorship, became an assistant secretary to the Commissioners in 1859, and found himself facing the


annual gazette | 27 opposition of the Fellows of his own College. The last straw was the proposal that the College should contribute a part of its revenue to the funding of the University. In their reply to the Commissioners of 14 December 1859 addressed to ‘G. G. Stokes Esq’ by name, as Secretary to the Cambridge University Commissioners, and indeed signed by Henry Arlett, now the President (Ainslie the Master having withdrawn altogether), the Fellows made it clear that they could hardly be expected to consent to this innovatory proposal, which they regarded, like the Commission itself, with deep suspicion.12 Re-election to a Fellowship The statutes which the College eventually received in 1861 dipped a toe, so to speak, in the waters of a married Fellowship. Henceforth up to two married Fellows could be elected, either Professors in the University on an income of less than £80 a year, or else men distinguished in learning or science. Thus John Couch Adams was able to marry in 1863 and retain his Fellowship. The College records are silent as to why Stokes was not re-elected to his Fellowship at the first opportunity, The actual date of his re-election was 22 May 1867. This date should be noted carefully. So many sources, including Stokes’s Times obituary and his entry in the Encyclopaedia Britannica say that it happened in 1869.13 Stokes was elected together with Mr Lambert (third wrangler the same year)14 and they were forthwith admitted in the Chapel. The ten Fellows who signed the register included men like John Power and Charles Searle who were to change the face of the College. Stokes, who attended College meetings assiduously, was to give them quiet support. It looks like a pivotal moment. Stokes may have felt this himself: we find him giving a bottle in Parlour on 23 March 1868, in honour of the birth of a daughter,15 exactly ten months after his re-election, which he learned in response to subsequent enquiry was as a man distinguished in science rather than as an under-remunerated Professor. Ainslie died in 1870. His successor as Master – and Stokes’s friend and contemporary – John Power was a man with a plan. He and Searle set to work rapidly to revive the College, at the same time appointing Stokes as President (the equivalent of Vice-Master) in 1874. The College is transformed The remainder of the century saw a total transformation of Pembroke in terms of buildings and numbers. For what follows, I summarize from the excellent account by Pembroke’s architectural historian, the late Peter Meadows.16 Alfred Waterhouse was appointed as architect, and planned the entire rebuilding of the College. The red buildings on Trumpington Street were the first to go up in 1871–72, providing three staircases of accommodation. Then, significantly for further developments, a new Master’s Lodge was built for Power in 1873. A new Lodge meant freedom to demolish the old Lodge, a predominantly 18th century building connected with the medieval south range, which was removed too, leaving the vista which we now see from within the College Gate across to the Chapel. This left the old Hall with its two stories above,


28 | pembroke college standing rather forlorn, and Waterhouse was eager to pull it down. This the Fellows consented to in 1875, provoking a storm of controversy in the Press and by letter, in which Stokes’s friend, Edmund Venables, now Precentor of Lincoln Cathedral took a leading part albeit unsuccessfully. Waterhouse’s Hall, the one which eventually provided a backdrop for Stokes’ Jubilee celebrations, was a single story building, with a rather gaunt interior. Beyond it was the Combination Room, which was to be opened out in the next century as the present High Table area with its (currently) three long tables. Meanwhile Waterhouse swept on, designing a new Library in 1877–1878. The destruction of the Old Library, which the Fellows voted to approve in 1878 was prevented only by the Fellows’ replacing Waterhouse with George Gilbert Scott, Jr to re-consider the Trumpington Street frontage (now more or less what we see today), the Old Library (which he preserved as a matter of conscience) and the Chapel which he extended very sympathetically to take the increased numbers of undergraduates. Pembroke also owes New Court (1881) to him. These buildings are the best evidence we have of the College’s expansion as numbers of undergraduates increased, mostly from the public schools and many of them pass-men taking ordinary degrees. Elder statesman in College and University The expansion of Pembroke coincided with the second Royal Commission on the Universities set up in 1872. The resulting Universities of Oxford and Cambridge Act of 1877, like the earlier one, created Statutory Commissioners to make statutes for the University and Colleges. This time, Stokes, once a lowly assistant secretary to the earlier Commissioners, was one of the seven Statutory Commissioners named in the Act, alongside others among the Great and the Good, such as the Lord Chief Justice, also Professor J. B. Lightfoot, soon to be the toweringly great Bishop of Durham and Lord Rayleigh. In their work, the origins of the twentieth century University can be perceived. At the same time, Stokes was playing his part as a Fellow of Pembroke, taking part in the meetings which led to the drawing up of the new College statutes granted in 1881. Sadly he was not elected Master in 1880, to Lord Kelvin’s17 regret. He remained President, deputising for Searle, the Master as required. Stokes himself was a trustee of the College Mission and was involved in the appointment of Charles Freer Andrews (better known afterwards as a friend and colleague of Gandhi) as missioner in Walworth.18 Again, we find him at a College meeting on Saturday 19 October 1897 joining with other Fellows in attempting to persuade the Master Dr Searle, already seriously depressed, not to resign over the playing of Sunday Golf at the North Surrey Golf Club on a College Estate at Norbury.19 As late as a College meeting on 10 October 1900 Stokes, with others, was asked to consider and report on ‘the introduction of the electric light’ in the Chapel and in the Hall. They were still discussing it in July 1902.20 In January 1894 the Dean, James Bethune-Baker wrote enclosing the Chapel card, and adding ‘I should be so glad if you could possibly give us three or four short addresses next term on some of the subjects in which you can speak as no


annual gazette | 29 one else can; for example a few points of the relationship between Christianity and Physical Science’.21 Stokes was already known to some of the undergraduates as ‘The angel Gabriel’ as with majestic countenance he read the lesson in chapel on Sunday evenings.22 The letter sent by the Fellows to the sculptor Hamo Thorneycroft on 6 February 1897 asking him if he would undertake a bust of Stokes referred to the latter’s ‘finely chiselled features’.23


30 | pembroke college

Jubilee as Lucasian Professor The bust and its copy were presented to Pembroke College and to the University at the reception held in the Fitzwilliam Museum on the evening of the first day of Stokes’s Golden Jubilee as Lucasian Professor, on Thursday 1 June 1899, attended by a thousand people at which Lord Kelvin spoke.24 On the following day came the morning congregation at the Senate House, with the presentation of the addresses. Stokes together with The Vice-Chancellor, The Master of Downing, sat side by side on the dais. The Registrary read out the names of the Universities and other bodies, and of their representatives. These handed their addresses to the Vice-Chancellor who handed them to Stokes. Lord Lister, the President of the Royal Society lost his glasses, and according to the Cambridge Review ‘The floor of the Senate House was bright with coloured gowns


annual gazette | 31 and uniforms and the whole scene was dignified, impressive and worthy of the occasion’. There was scarcely time for the luncheon for 400 at Downing. The second session in the Senate House during the afternoon saw the presentation of the gold medal of the University of Cambridge and the conferment of honorary degrees. Later on there was a garden party at Pembroke, where the band was good and the ices superb, and the Medals and addresses were displayed in the Hall. The final dinner that evening in the Hall of Trinity began very late. In one of the speeches, the Master of Trinity, Henry Montagu Butler revealed that the reason that Stokes was never at Trinity was that he had been refused admission by the then Master, the formidable Dr Wordsworth, the brother of the poet, who was accordingly described as ‘A man of a thousand virtues and one crime, in spite of which he strangely died in his bed’. Mastership and death Dr Searle, the Master, who had been in an invalid chair throughout the Jubilee proceedings, died in July 1902. On the day of the funeral, 1 August, the Fellows drafted a letter inviting Stokes to be ‘a Candidate for the Mastership’. They wrote: ‘We desire that the College should have the distinction of having your name as Master associated with it and we feel that it is in the best interests of the College that you should undertake the duties of the Office’.25 They offered to grant exemption from residence in the Lodge and even hinted at a future building scheme which might include a new Master’s Lodge. So on 12 August 1902 Stokes became Master for the last six months of his life, during which time he was in increasingly poor health. He lived with his daughter Isabella and her husband Dr Laurence Humphry in their house ‘Lensfield’, roughly on the site of the steps of the present chemistry laboratories. There he was to die on 1 February 1903. The coffin rested in the College Chapel of Pembroke on the night before the funeral. On the following day, Thursday 5 February, it was carried round three sides of the court, as is customary for a Master, accompanied by the hymns ‘On the resurrection morning’ and ‘O God our help in ages past’, to the College gate, whence it was taken up to Great St Mary’s Church. Various University and other


32 | pembroke college dignitaries had assembled in the Senate House to join the procession. The Dean of Pembroke, Bethune-Baker, officiated according to the Book of Common Prayer, together with Stokes’s Vicar from St Paul’s, the Revd H P Stokes. The Bishop of Exeter, Dr H E Ryle, soon to be translated to the See of Winchester, also took part. At the end, to the singing of Bishop Walsham How’s great hymn “For all the Saints” a procession formed up with carriages and followers on foot to go from Great St Mary’s to the Parish burial Ground of St Paul’s Church in the Mill Road cemetery.26 Let it never be said that the College has no monument to him. The central light of the East window of the Chapel depicting the Crucifixion flanked by the Foundress, Marie de St Pol Countess of Pembroke, and Bishop Matthew Wren, donor of the Chapel. was given in his memory by his daughter Isabella, in 1906. It was designed by her brother-in-law, G W Humphry. The College also added the two lights, one on either side, depicting Pembroke benefactors. There is an inscription below and to the left of the Foundress largely hidden by the pediment above the altarpiece: ‘In piam memoriam Georgii Gabriel Stokes posuit filia’ (His daughter placed this in pious memory of George Gabriel Stokes).27 1

A sizar was originally a poor student who performed menial services in the College, such as waiting at table, in return for reduced fees. There was no stigma attached to this. By Stokes’s day this had become a kind of minor scholarship or exhibition. 2 A Bye-Fellowship was a kind of Minor Fellowship, with a fixed salary, not on the Foundation. Such might be compared with senior research studentships today; residence was not required. 3 Pembroke College Archives College MS E beta Page 104 ‘Stokes, Georgii Gabriel filius natu quartus Reverendi viri Gabriel Stokes de Skreen in comitatu de Sligo in Hibernia Rectoris ibidem natus atque annum agens undevicesimum admissus est ad mensam secundam sub tutore Magistri Arlett Julii 7 1837’. Marginal annotations record his graduation as BA and Senior Wrangler and election to a foundation Fellowship in January 1841 and to the Mastership in 1902. 4 The information about Stokes’s journey to Cambridge and many other details comes from the unpublished biographical Memoir of George Gabriel Stokes by Henry Paine Stokes (no relation), Vicar of Stokes’s Parish Church, St Paul’s Church Cambridge, Cambridge University Library MS Add 8699. 5/1. 5 Marie de St Pol, Countess of Pembroke. The original foundation Charter is dated Christmas Eve 1347. 6 Scholarships, like examination results, were recorded in the examination book, and also in the College register, under the respective years. By this period, the historic names of the scholarships were not held to be of great significance. The College Register, Pembroke College Archives, College Manuscript B Beta 7–9 records in the second part (Beta 8) on p 156 the election on Tuesday 13 June 1838 of Stokes to a foundation scholarship at the end of his first year, which he retained for the rest of his undergraduate career; p 169 records his election on 29 May 1839 to a Parkin and Bowes scholarship in his second year; College MS B epsilon 1 (College Register vol 10), records on p 12 Stokes’s election to a Watts senior Scholarship for Greek and an Ipswich Scholarship on 9 June 1840. Stokes’s Greek was exemplary, but he would not have fulfilled the schooling qualifications for the Parkin and Bowes or the Ipswich scholarships had they been required. 7 This information comes from the account of the College supplied to the Graham Commissioners by the Master, Gilbert Ainslie in Report of the Commissioners appointed to


annual gazette | 33 enquire into the State, Discipline, Studies, and Revenues of the University and Colleges of Cambridge; together with the Evidence…, (Parliamentary papers, 1852–53) HC xliv [1559]: evidence, separately paginated from the Report, 319, 323; it was known as the Graham Commission after its Chairman, John Graham, Bishop of Chester. 8 The room with its pointed gable appears in the centre of the Trumpington Street street frontage in every illustration of the exterior of the College. The suggestion that the room was the magna camera was made by Sir Ellis Minns, President of the College (and archivist) in an article ‘The yearly rose’, Pembroke College Cambridge Annual Gazette 26 (1952),13–15. 9 See Thompson, Wayside Thoughts, Being a Series of Desultory Essays on Education (1868), 94–99: ‘I still had the mathematical lecture-room to fall back on. I had but to strike the rock in faith and streams of science would well out. I went to a garret in the further quadrangle, The ceiling sloped very uncomfortably down to the ground, some panes in the window were broken and a dismal fire gave out a little smoky warmth … After lectures we would breakfast; some few of us would do an hour or two’s reading. At noon there would be a meeting for luncheon, and we would enjoy a tankard of good ale and a few comfortable pipes; we would then take a long constitutional or play at cricket or row upon the narrow winding river; we would dine at four; retire to a singular mélange of pipes, fruit and premature port wine, the chapel bell would summon us at six; after chapel we would retire to billiards and return to a pleasant whist party at ten, where sandwiches and illimitable stores of ale and pipes would keep us in good humour until very early hours’. 10 Gilbert Ainslie to Stokes, 6 October 1856 (Cambridge University Library MS Add 7656, A 242). 11 Henry Arlett to Stokes 18 November ?1867 (Cambridge University Library MS Add 7656, A 803). 12 Pembroke College Archives, papers relating to statutes and the Royal Commission, Reply of the Fellows of Pembroke College Cambridge to the remarks of the Commissioners, page 3: under Chapter 4 of the proposed new statutes ‘Payment for University purposes’ they wrote ‘The statute proposed by the Commissioners under this head is one of such great importance that the Fellows respectfully submit that they can hardly be expected to consent to its enactment till its intention and probable effect are better understood’. This was surely putting it mildly. 13 The Times 2 February 1903 p 7; Encyclopaedia Britannica 11th ed (New York 1910–11) Vol 25 p 951 Stokes, Sir George Gabriel, describes it as twelve years after his marriage of 1857. 14 Carlton John Lambert, third Wrangler 1867, afterwards Professor of Mathematics at the Royal Naval College Greenwich. 15 This was Dora Susanna, who sadly died in infancy. 16 See Grimstone, Pembroke College Cambridge: A Celebration (Cambridge: Pembroke College, 1997), ch 6. 17 ‘I am very sorry you are not Master of Pembroke. … I felt sure that you would be elected and hoped much that you would consent to accept the office’. Kelvin to Stokes, 28 November 1880 in David B. Wilson, The Correspondence between Sir George Gabriel Stokes and Sir William Thomson, Baron Kelvin of Largs vol. 2 1870–1901 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1990, 514). Searle succeeded Power as Master, and accordingly continued the College’s policy of expansion in numbers. 18 Searle to Stokes, 6 March (probably) 1896 Cambridge University Library MS Add 7656, S 323. The year is not given but Andrews arrived in Walworth in April 1896. 19 Pembroke College Archives, Notes relating to College meetings, 1896–1904 (unpaginated). 20 ibid.


34 | pembroke college 21 Bethune-Baker to Stokes, 18 January 1894; Cambridge University Library MS Add 7656, B 345. 22 Stokes was ‘a man whose personal faith so shone forth that the undergraduates called him, and not in mockery “the Angel Gabriel”’: Benarsidas Chaturvedi and Marjorie Sykes, Charles Freer Andrews: A Narrative (London: George Allen and Unwin, 1949, 15). 23 The correspondence with Thorneycroft is preserved in the College Archives with other material relating to works of art in College. 24 For what follows see the unsigned account “News of the week and notes” Cambridge Review 20, 7 June 1899, 382–383; also Cambridge University Reporter 29 no 40 (1898–99), 6 June 1899, 1016–22. College Treasury accounts record that the total cost to the College of the proceedings came to £206 15s 6d; the cost of hiring the Band of the Royal Artillery came to £28 15s 0d, tents, etc. from Messrs Eaden Lilley came to £12 19s 0d and a mysterious £3 was spent on police.(Pembroke College Archives, College MS M alpha 11 Treasury Accounts vol 11, 1889–1910, unpaginated). 25 The letter with related material is preserved in Pembroke College Archives, Notes relating to College meetings, 1896–1904 (unpaginated). 26 The Order of service is preserved in the papers of H P Stokes, Vicar of St Paul’s Church Cambridge University Library MS Add 8699. 4/1/1. These papers as a whole, which I have consulted extensively, include a detailed memoir of Stokes, his scientific achievements, and his religious and ethical views. The funeral was also reported in detail on the Cambridge Daily News 6 February 1903. This is reproduced on the website of the Cambridge Mill Road Cemetery (http://millroadcemetery.org.uk/mrc2015/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/Stokesfuneral_report.pdf and http://millroadcemetery.org.uk/stokes-george-gabriel/). The correct date of the burial is 5 February. The hymn ‘For All the Saints’, not mentioned in the Daily News report, would most likely have been sung to the tune ‘Sarum’ by Sir Joseph Barnby. Vaughan Williams’s better known ‘Sine Nomine’, written for the English Hymnal was not published until 1906. 27 A fitting inscription: Isabella contributed a memoir of her father to the first volume of J. Larmor (ed) Memoir and Scientific Correspondence of George Gabriel Stokes, 2 volumes (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1907).


annual gazette | 35

Art Gifts to the Pembroke Shahnameh Centre Firuza Abdullaeva-Melville This is a sequel to the essay in the 2020 Gazette on the millennium of the death of Abu’lQasim Ferdowsi, author of the legendary Shahnameh.

I would like to acknowledge our special gratitude for the very generous gifts, on top of the initial foundation endowment received from Ms Bita Daryabari, which the Pembroke Shahnameh Centre has already received during its relatively short life. These presents which we started to acquire from the very first day of our existence prove that the activities we offer, the vision we have and the direction we are moving towards are in great demand and appreciated by those who care about Persian culture in the West, and especially in the UK. The nature of the gifts shows that it is recognised in the outside world as the Centre where art and culture is valued and promoted at a particularly high level, successfully standing in line with more established Cambridge art institutions in Cambridge. On the occasion of its first jubilee the Pembroke Centre accepted with much gratitude several generous gifts, which were added to its collection of important Persian artefacts, established on the day of its inauguration on 24 May 2014. From Ali Javad The Shahriah Shanameh The Shahriar Shahnameh was offered by Ali Akbar Javad, whose friendship was established in 2014 at Harvard. Ali Javad, a private collector, businessman and screenwriter who migrated to the USA in 1975, resides in Washington D.C. He donated his unique manuscript, which he suggested to the Centre be named the ‘Shahriar Shahnama’ in memory of his late brother Dr Shahriar Javad, who had passed away less than two months earlier. The manuscript is interesting due to both its artistic characteristics and provenance, which shows that it found its way to America most likely after it was sold at Quaritch in London in 1901. According to the ex librises on its flyleaves, the book was in the possession of several American owners, including Lowell M. Palmer Weicker Sr. (1903–1978), governor of Connecticut and Mrs Elizabeth RobertsonMiller-Weicker-Fondaras, wealthy heiress and famous socialite of New York and Paris (1916–2012), who established academic scholarships in honour of her three husbands. Elizabeth spent quite a long time in France

Fig.1 King Kay Kavus ascending the sky on his flying machine with four eagles used as engine. He is shooting an arrow which is returned to him by angel who covers the arrow with the blood of fish. Shahriar Shahnameh, Iran, early 17th century


36 | pembroke college with her second husband and became a serious propagandist of French culture in the USA, especially thanks to her most generous annual Bastille Balls that she organised in New York. She was awarded the Legion d’Honneur for her services to France. This manuscript, lacking its colophon, can nevertheless be dated to the first half of the 17th century, for the characteristic features of its illustrations and calligraphy, which both seem to have been produced at the same time. It contains 32 miniature paintings, generally in reasonable condition, though often quite abraded and revealing some later retouching. The paintings regularly break out of the text and picture frame, and employ a variety of different stepped formats. The illustration programme of the manuscript has quite a regular list of episodes, frequently illustrated in other copies of the Shahnameh. There is even a painting depicting the introduction scene – Ferdowsi presenting his poem to Sultan Mahmud in the garden of his palace in Ghazna. However, Rostam’s seventh and most important labour, when he kills the White Demon, is missing. Perhaps it disappeared before or during the time when the manuscript was rebound; the order of its folia was seriously disturbed and the pages were trimmed to fit the new lacquer binding produced in typical Qajar fashion. Both the outside and Fig. 2 Ex libris of Lowell M. Palmer Weicker Sr. inside covers of the papier maché (1903–1978), governor of Connecticut who was one binding are decorated with floral of the owners of the manuscript designs and two important scenes from the Shahnama: Rostam kills Sohrab and Rostam kills Isfandiyar. Similarly, the Qajar binding decorated with the battle scenes depicting Rostam killing Isfandiyar and Rostam killing Ashkabus replaced the original one of the manuscripts produced in 1651 for Shah ‘Abbas II (Dorn 333), now in the National Library of Russia, St Petersburg. There is, however, another mystery: in the Quaritch sale catalogue of 1901 in the entry dedicated to this manuscript it is mentioned that it had 30 miniature paintings. The copy in its current state has 32 pictures and some of them are either missing or misplaced: a few pages bear the traces of pigments from the paintings that were on the opposite pages, which are not there anymore. A more precise conclusion will be made when a more thorough study of the text of the whole manuscript is completed.


annual gazette | 37 Siyavush carpet For the fifth anniversary of the existence of the centre, Ali Javad presented to the Pembroke Centre a figurative Shahnameh carpet and a portrait of Abbas Mirza. The carpet (136 ¥ 208 cm in size) of Mohtasham-style from Kashan depicts a story from the Shahnameh. It is made of wool and cotton with silk trimming. The carpet was produced at the end of the 19th – beginning of the 20th century. A similar piece was auctioned at the Christie’s sale on 26 April 2018 in London. The scene describes the Iranian Prince Siyavush playing polo at the court of his Turanian host King Afrasiyab, seated with his jealous Fig 3 Iranian Prince Siyavush playing polo at the brother Garsivaz at the top of the court of Turanian King Afrasiyab, Muhtashamstyle scene. The text in the surrounding carpet, wool and silk, 136 x 208 cm, Kashan, frame runs clockwise in three bands late 19th early 20th century working outwards from the centre and contains many interesting variations on the standard version of the epic. Portrait of Abbas Mirza Abbas Mirza (1789–1833) was the favourite son of Fath Ali Shah (1772–1834), Crown Prince of Qajar dynasty and the Head of the Shah’s Foreign Office. He never became the Shah as he died a year before his father. However, his personal influence on the policy of Persia during one of the most troublesome periods of its history, the so-called Great Game is impossible to overestimate. The first peak of the Great Game period, also called the Tournament of Shadows, fell at the beginning of the 19th century, when after the defeat of Napoleon the world was left only with two superpowers, Great Britain and Russia. Their rivalry was seen most of all in the Middle East, especially Persia, which was considered to be a buffer zone between the growing Russian Empire with the Crimea, the Caucasus and parts of Central Asia, and the British territories in India. The rivalry did not have the features of open military conflict between the two empires but the competition penetrated all spheres of interaction at political, diplomatic, and economic levels. The portrait is on one hand quite traditional in early Qajar art, when Persian painters started to actively use the techniques of European visual art, namely oil on canvas. The features of the Prince at his early age are rather generic and standard, however, the background and the horizontal layout is quite unusual:


38 | pembroke college the head and shoulder portrait is put in the middle of the ‘carpet’ ornament surrounding Abbas Mirza dressed in full gear in his princely crown and bejewelled jacket. It seems that a whole series of such portraits was produced: several others were sold recently at a London auction.

Fig. 4 Portrait of Abbas Mirza in his early age, Iran, late 19th century

Fig. 5 Ali Javad presents to Firuza Melville the portrait of Abbas Mirza for the Shahnameh Centre during his visit to Pembroke in September 2019


annual gazette | 39 From the Gharavi family The Simurgh Shahnameh The Pembroke Centre accepted another copy of the Shahnameh on loan from Ameneh, Reza and Sara Gharavi of Toronto and Tehran. The manuscript was called the Simurgh Shahnameh by their late father in whose memory they dedicated their offer. It is originally an early-mid 15th-century manuscript, containing 489 folios and approximately 54,000 verses. The manuscript includes 50 pages of ornamentation and 27 narrative illustrations. The copy is nor signed nor dated but remains a handsome volume, despite the rather heavy overpainting, evidently done in India.

Fig. 6 Princess Rudaba meets knight Zal during the a duck shoot. Simurgh Shahnameh, Iran, early mid 15th century

Cama Shahnameh On the kind offer of the same Gharavi family the Centre keeps on loan four folia from the exceptionally precious 14th-century Shahnameh copy, which is known as the Cama manuscript due to its original location in the K.R. Cama Institute in Mumbai. Ameneh Gharavi brought this manuscript from Toronto in memory of her father Dr Mehdi Gharavi, who served as cultural attache in India. In very poor condition, these pages are the only ones whose whereabouts and existence are currently known. The manuscript is undated but certainly a very early copy of the text and one of a small group of manuscripts almost certainly illustrated in the first decades of the 14th century, probably in Shiraz.

Fig. 7 Execution of knight Faramarz, son of Rostam by Prince Bahman, son of Isfandiyar who was killed by Rostam. Shahnameh by Ferdowsi, Iran, 14th century


40 | pembroke college From Alexander Ross A pair of exceptional Khatamkari armchairs are a part of the Centre’s collection, on loan from Alexander Ross in memory of his late mother, Dr Pourandokht Pirayesh, author of the bilingual Perso-German book of translations of the 12thcentury Persian Classics Rose and Nightingale, introduced by Abdul Hussein Zarrinkoub. Alexander was educated in film and business at the universities of Heidelberg, Cambridge, Paris, London and UEA. The chairs were commissioned by Alexander Ross’s grandfather Hassan Pirayesh from the same artisan who had made a similar set for Fig. 8 Khātamkari armchair, Iran, Reza Shah in around 1938. He believes that the late 1930s other set remains in the Niavaran Palace. As part of the set there was a desk with the signature of the maker; however, it was sold at auction several years ago. Khātamkari (or khatambandi) is a traditional Persian technique of inlaying. It is a version of marquetry where artefacts are made by decorating the surface of wooden objects with delicate pieces of wood, bone and gilt metal fragments precisely-cut intricate geometric patterns. Designing of inlaid articles is tremendously laborious process. Sometimes to produce a square inch of such ornament a master should produce more than 400 tiny pieces to be put together as an intricate mosaic. The popularity of this technique reached its peak during the Safavid period. From Ali Sarikhani The Centre’s collection includes Qur’anic verse in polychrome tile (kashikari) technique donated by Ali Sarikhani. The large panel of tiles comprising the second part of the verse No 256 from the Second Su-rah Al-Baqara (The Cow): ‘Let there be no compulsion in religion: Truth stands out clear from Error: whoever rejects evil and believes in Allah hath grasped the most trustworthy hand-hold, that never breaks. And Allah heareth and knoweth all things’. The panel was commissioned from master craftsmen from Isfahan as part of the set of tiles to decorate the entrance of the Sarikhani Museum of Persian and Islamic art.

Fig. 9 Kashikari (mosaic) panel with a Qur’anic verse, Isfahan Henley, 2010


annual gazette | 41 From Veronica Shimanovskaya The Pembroke Shahnameh Centre possesses several art works by Veronica Shimanovskaya, curator of most of the Centre’s exhibitions. She is a St Petersburg born international artist, and independent curator, educated at Harvard and University of East London (PhD), currently based in San Francisco Bay Area, where she is a founder and a CEO of Ephemereye, a digital platform that supports video art and artists. Painting of Princess Manizheh Shimanovskaya in her monumental painting offers her interpretation of the story of the Turanian Princess Manizheh who fell in love with the Iranian knight Bizhan and sacrificed everything for the sake of her love. Her version deeply contrasts with the traditional depiction of one of the crucial episodes of the Persian Romeo and Juliet story: when Bizhan was exposed in Manizheh’s chambers and was incarcerated in a pit. In many cases he is the only one who is depicted as suffering from separation from his beloved and sitting in inhuman conditions. In Shimanovskya’s rather feminist painting it is the reverse: we can see Fig. 10 Princess Manizheh by Veronica only Manizheh, who came to visit her Shimanovskaya, oil on canvas, London, 2014 beloved Bizhan. In fact the spectator is presented as Bizhan, sitting in the pit, punished and suffering but invisible. Bringing Manizheh into spotlight and hiding Bizhan, Shimanovskaya restores the justice of the real protagonist of the ancient story. For centuries her role of a Princess who was capable of sacrificing comfort and wealth for her love was completely ignored. The main focus was always on Bizhan and sometimes his rescuer, Rostam, who were recognised as the main heroes of the story. Sculpture of King Zahhak Shimanovskaya’s interpretation of Zahhak shifts the attention of the narrative from human empathy — of which king Zahhak was incapable after Ahriman implicated him in his scheme of self indulgence, avarice, and gluttony — to the concept of love, of which Zahhak became

Fig 11 King Zahhak tormented by his snakes by Veronica Shimanovskaya, bronze, London, 2015.


42 | pembroke college incapable and unable to give to his wives when two serpents sprung up from his shoulders. Veronica’s sense of irony guided her decision to turn the serpents into Zahhak’s arms and rendered him unable to hug anyone or even comfort himself, as he had nothing with which to do so but two vicious snakes. From Sergey Feofanov Sergey Feofanov (b. 1950), a renowned painter, ceramist, animator and theatre and stage designer, Member of the Russian Fine Arts Academy and the National Artists Society, has been invited to design performances in various theatres in Russia, Germany, Georgia, Japan and India. Feofanov has donated to the Centre two ceramic versions of his Simurghs, a mythical bird that is the eternal patron of the main legendary Iranian hero Rostam. Feofanov presented one for the inauguration of the Centre and the second for its third anniversary. Both chamottes were a part of his Simurgh series, which were presented at his blockbuster personal exhibition in the Russian Fine Arts Academy in Moscow. His large in size ‘Ferdowsi flying on the Simurgh’ has much in common with the monument to the poet produced by Abo’l-Hasan Seddighi and Hasan-Ali Vaziri in 1933. The sculpture was lost; however, Feofanov miraculously managed to recreate the original idea, having never seen SeddighiVaziri’s Ferdowsi riding the Simurgh. What is even more notable is that Feofanov’s source of inspiration was mainly the 14th-century star-shaped tiles excavated in the historical site of the Tahkt-e Sulayman in northern Iran, which has been perceived as the melting pot of various cultural and artistic traditions which were represented in the archaeological complex dating from the preIslamic past until the Mongol invasion.

Figs. 12 and 13 ‘Ferdowsi flying on the Simurgh’ by Sergey Feofanov, chamotte and gold, Moscow, 2014


annual gazette | 43 From Vyacheslav Zabelin (VIK) Three graphic art works have been given to our Centre in the memory of Vyacheslav Zabelin (29 October 1953 – 16 February 2016) (‘VIK’) by his widow Olga Zabelina . VIK was a non-conformist artist and poet. He was born in Mongolia and educated in Leningrad in Serov Art College. For many years he was working as a conservator in the Peterhoff Museum, and stage designer in the Alexander Theatre and the Demeni Puppet Theatre. From the early 1970s he became an active member of the Leningrad group of non-conformist artists. All three pieces of his Shahnameh series has a strong Petersburg flavour. He illustrated three episodes: ‘Rostam and Tahmina’, ‘Zal and Rudaba’ and ‘Zal in the Simurgh’s nest’. All of them combine the traditional iconography of medieval manuscript illustration of these famous episodes with Petersburg’s specific architectural features, like the Neva embankment, or St Isaac’s Cathedral – all depicted in his strikingly recognisable manner. Worthy of special note is his interpretation of the visit of the Turanian Princess Tahmineh to the Iranian knight Rostam in his bedchamber during the night, offering herself to become the mother of his child during his stay in her castle. In so far as VIK read the episode in Russian translation from Tajik, his interpretation of the ancient story was influenced by his perception of the Tajik labour migrants in St Petersburg who are involved mainly in the market trade. Thus his Rostam and Tahmineh are not medieval Persian aristocrats but local grocers in a big European city.

Fig. 14 Zal in the Simurgh’s nest by Vyacheslav Zabelin, pencil, and watercolour on paper, St Petersburg, 2015

Fig. 15 Rostam and Tahmineh by Vyacheslav Zabelin, pencil and watercolour on paper, St Petersburg, 2015


44 | pembroke college From Irina Volkodaeva Professor Irina Volkodaeva is the Head of Department of Design of Urban environment at the University of Design in Moscow. She presented this Manizheh porcelain doll to the Centre after the exhibition of her series of historical reconstructions of various epochs and nations. When Volkodaeva decided to create her version of Manizheh, she chose to present a young lady in the costume of the early Qajar period with which she became familiar through the masterpieces of Qajar art, especially portraits of harem ladies in the collections of the Oriental Museum in Moscow and the Hermitage Museum in St Petersburg. From Hamid-Reza Ghelichkhani

Fig. 16 Manizheh by Irina Volkodaeva, porcelain, fabric, turquoise beads, Moscow, 2016

Dr Hamid-Reza Ghelichkhani is a one of the most prominent Iranian calligraphers of our times who is not only a practitioner but also a well-known specialist in Persian and Perso-Indian literature and calligraphy. Dr Ghelichkhani produced his calligraphic pieces when he was staying at Cambridge as a visiting scholar during Michaelmas 2013 being attached to the Faculty of Asian and Middle Eastern Studies, where he was also conducting Persian calligraphy workshops. His calligraphies presented to our Centre contain excerpts from the Shahnameh. One of them reproduces a double verse (bayt) from the finale of the poem, which many contemporary Iranians perceive as the motto of its author and the essence of his whole magnum opus: I have constructed a palace out of my verse That will never be destroyed by the wind or rain I shall not die – these seeds I’ve sown will save [My name and reputation from the grave] (dedicated to Dr Firuza Melville)

Fig. 17 Calligraphy with the final verses from the Shahnameh by Ferdowsi (ca. 970– ca. 1020) by Hamid Reza Ghelichkhani


annual gazette | 45

The Cartoonist and the Demon-King: How the Shahnameh became Wartime Propaganda Archie Williams With thanks to Dr Firuza Melville for her insights, translations and edits throughout the composition of this piece.

Having worked closely with Dr Firuza Melville on my undergraduate History dissertation about the 1648 Windsor Shahnameh, I was excited to have the opportunity to return to the Centre having now completed my degree and begun my MPhil in Islamic Art and Architecture at Wolfson College, Oxford. I was able to complete my internship remotely in January under Dr Melville’s supervision. As an undergraduate I spent time researching American and Soviet wartime films, and so a recently-acquired set of propaganda posters produced by the British government in 1942 for distribution in Iran jumped out at me. As can be imagined, opportunities to combine an interest in Second World War propaganda with one in Islamic art do not come along very often, so I was eager not to miss this one. The posters depict scenes from the Zahhak cycle of the Shahnameh, with the faces of wartime world leaders added to make a political point in the hope of enlisting Iranian support for the allied war effort. Thanks to the kind donation of John Drake, whose late father Sir Eric Drake collected the posters, the Centre now has almost all (five of six) of the series. Sir Eric spent over fifteen years working in the Anglo-Iranian oil company at their refinery at Abadan, starting as an accountant in 1935 and becoming the general manager in Iran in 1950. He then played a prominent role in negotiations with the British cabinet following Mohammed Mossadeq’s oil nationalisation of 1951, the events of which he and his wife Margaret discuss in Episode 5 of the 1985 documentary End of Empire. It was while he was a young man in Abadan that he came upon these posters, and carefully transported them out of Iran during that uncertain period. After leaving Iran, Sir Eric took up positions in Australia and North America. Returning to the UK, he eventually became chairman of BP, a post which he held from 1969 to 1975. In his retirement, Drake devoted himself to heritage preservation as a Trustee of the Westminster Abbey Trust and chairman of the Mary Rose Trust. It is therefore appropriate that these posters should have now found their way into an academic institute, especially one affiliated with his alma mater, Pembroke College. We are grateful for this generous donation, which makes these unusual documents available to students and academics working across the university, as well as the wider public. www The pictures were drawn by the Egyptian-born cartoonist Kimon Evan Marengo, known professionally as ‘Kem’, while working for the Political Warfare Executive’s (PWE) French and North Africa section. He produced the cartoons in late 1942, and they were distributed originally as posters but then reissued as postcards in November 1943 on the eve of the Tehran Conference.


46 | pembroke college The original idea for propaganda based on the most well-known stories of the Shahnameh had been mooted in private correspondence between Dr Arthur Arberry, later the Sir Thomas Adams Professor of Arabic at Pembroke College, and the Persian intellectual Mojtaba Minovi, then working for the BBC Persian Service and teaching the language at Oxford. In these letters, Minovi had suggested that the demon-king Zahhak might be depicted ‘like Hitler with Musso[lini] and Tojo [...] as the two snakes growing from his shoulders’, and indicated verses which might be used (Homan, 2002). This idea was passed onto Kem who set to work making this idea a reality between March and October 1942. The surprising collaboration between an Iranian intellectual, a Cambridge orientalist, the Foreign Office, and an Egyptian cartoonist thus produced the unique set of images which caught Sir Eric’s eye in wartime Abadan. The images themselves follow the story of the demon-king Zahhak, one of the Shahnameh’s most well-known cycles. It appears in the early ‘mythical’ section of the poem, and features one of Ferdowsi’s classic confrontations between good and evil, a story with a moral simplicity which the later text rarely returns to. In the original, the ambitious prince Zahhak is persuaded by Ahriman (Satan) to kill his father, and take over his kingdom. Now a king, Zahhak is once again visited by Ahriman, this time in disguise as a cook, who serves him a sumptuous dinner of meat: a luxury which humanity had never before tasted.

Fig. 1. Zahhak/Hitler enthroned before Ahriman/Goebbels. The caption reads: ‘Two snakes grew out of the shoulders of Zahhak the wizard and destruction was rained down on the people.’ (This and subsequent translations thanks to Dr Melville)

Fig. 2. Zahhak/Hitler receives his tribute of Iranian youth, with Ahriman/Goebbels beside him The caption reads: ‘The laws of the wise became hidden and the desires of madmen became widespread; the hand of the madmen grew long for the evil; goodness was only heard of in secret.’


annual gazette | 47 In gratitude, Zahhak grants Ahriman’s wish to kiss his shoulders, and when he does so snakes sprang from them and could only be satisfied if fed a human brain every day. This is the subject of the first of Kem’s posters (Fig. 1), which depicts Goebbels as Ahriman serving Zahhak/Hitler a cup of coffee while Nazi officers, clad in both turbans and swastika armbands, stand around. Just as Minovi had recommended, the snakes on his shoulders bear the faces of Mussolini and Tojo. Though Zahhak is an Arab king, the growing arrogance of Shah Jamshid – the rightful ruler of Persia – leads his people to invite Zahhak to take over the country and rule in his stead. Only too glad to oblige, Zahhak takes over Iran, has Jamshid sawn in two, marries his two daughters, and begins a reign of terror. A parallel was doubtless intended with those under Reza Shah who believed that courting an alliance with Germany might offer a solution to the country’s ills. Kem’s second poster (Fig. 2) attempts to depict where such an alliance might lead, with Zahhak/Hitler brandishing a sword and a whip over his unfortunate victims. In light of Camran Michael Amin’s discussion of the growing use of sexual and violent imagery in the Iranian Press of the 1940s, this grotesque image would have been well-suited to the sensationalist tastes of Iranian consumers (Amin, 2001). But this was also coupled with reference to one of the most graphic scenes of the Shahnameh, the story of the execution of the Zoroastrian Prophet Mazdak, who is executed along with his followers who are buried alive with their feet in the air as a grisly reflection of the Prophet’s utopian idea of a ‘human garden’. This scene, though incorrect for the Zahhak cycle, shows how closely Kem engaged with the Shahnameh tradition in producing this work. The third poster sees the beginning of Zahhak/Hitler’s downfall (Fig. 3). In the poem, one night Zahhak is in bed with Arnavaz (one of the daughters of Jamshid). He has a nightmare in which he is set upon by three noble warriors, the youngest of whom proceeds to skin him and use that flayed skin to bind his hands and take him to Mount Damavand. Troubled, Zahhak consults his astrologers who predict his doom at the hands of a man named Faridun, who has yet to be born. Following a familiar literary trope of a man resisting fate, Zahhak sends men to find the boy and chase him into the mountains in a vain attempt to cheat death. Minovi intended to Fig. 3. Zahhak/Hitler has a nightmare about use this scene to further build a political the coming of three warriors, here Churchill, narrative: he suggested that Churchill Stalin, and Roosevelt. The caption reads: could take on the guise of Faridun, and ‘Then he saw three warriors of the royal appear accompanied by ‘his older and household suddenly appear’ greater Brothers, Roosevelt and Stalin’


48 | pembroke college (Holman 2002). In this poster, Zahhak/Hitler’s attendants guide the viewer through the scene with their gazes, with one directing the viewer towards the dream-bubble, the others towards the restless dreamer. This mimicked the inner workings of the medieval miniatures which inspired Kem. The next poster (Fig. 4) repeats the scenery of the first, another technique not unfamiliar in older Persian manuscripts. This has the effect of heightening the contrast in this scene when, instead of receiving tribute from Ahriman/Goebbels, Zahhak/Hitler faces an angry subject. In the poem, Kaveh the blacksmith comes to beg for the life of his last surviving son, after his last seventeen had been fed to Zahhak’s snakes. Zahhak agrees to show mercy if Kaveh will sign a document attesting to his clemency. But Kaveh refuses, and defiantly raising his leather apron as a flag of rebellion (Derafsh-e Kaviani) he assembles a crowd to find Faridun and bring an end to Zahhak’s reign. Fig. 4. Kaveh raises his leather apron in protest to Zahhak/Hitler’s tyranny. The caption reads: ‘He cried and struck his head before the Shah, ‘O Shah, I am Kaveh in demand of justice. There must be a limit to oppression, oppression must always have a just cause’

Fig. 5. Kaveh leads a triumphant procession, with Zahhak/Hitler bound and the allies following behind. The caption reads: ‘Strongly he tied his two hands and waist, so that his fetters could not be broken even by a raging elephant’

The fifth poster sees the culmination of the efforts of Kaveh and the warriors (Fig. 5). In Ferdowsi’s original, the crowd finds Faridun hiding from Zahhak’s men in the Alborz Mountains. With their support he storms the palace, and eventually succeeds in capturing Zahhak and becoming the new ruler of Iran. In Kem’s poster, once again it is three warriors who answer Kaveh’s call for justice rather than just the one. The allies follow on horseback behind the blacksmith and the defeated king, whose crown has fallen to the floor – a common symbol of disgrace in Persian art.


annual gazette | 49 The final poster of the series – the only one to elude Sir Eric’s collection – brings the story to a close (Fig. 6). Rather than kill him, Faridun is told by the angel Sorush to nail Zahhak to Mount Damavand and leave him there for eternity. In this image, the three warriors watch as the nails are driven into Zahhak/Hitler’s limbs. At the top right, three soldiers look on and hold their swords – their resolute stance contrasting with the German stormtroopers who had looked furtively around in the first poster. In the bottom left hand corner, onlookers hold the flags of Britain, America, the Soviet Union and – barely discernible at the edge of the frame – Iran. www Fig. 6. The victorious allies have Kaveh nailed to As a student of Islamic Art, I was struck by Mount Damavand, to stay there for eternity. The Kem’s sensitive use of the source material caption reads: ‘Swiftly as a post messenger he to construct these posters. The settings, brought Zahhak away and bound him to Mount perspective, and content of the image all Damavand and, when the name of Zahhak combine to create an effective pastiche of became as dust, the world was cleansed of his evil’ the miniatures which adorn many Shahnameh manuscripts. One wonders whether Dr Arberry provided Kem with access to Persian manuscripts, in original or reproduction, to which he could refer. In these settings, the presence of Nazi symbolism has a particularly unsettling effect on the viewer. The decision to depict the attendant figures common in paintings of this style with jackboots, pistols, and swastika armbands makes a statement about the violation of Persia’s historic culture by German influence. Minovi knew that in order to mobilise the sentiments of the Iranian population most effectively, British propagandists would do well to make use of one of Ferdowsi’s most popular stories. In his correspondence with Dr Arberry, he assured him that ‘my people are accustomed to putting new interpretation to old and familiar quotations’ (Holman, 2002). The unmistakable image of a rampaging monarch with snakes on both his shoulders would have been immediately recognised both by educated elites, familiar with the manuscripts, and to the rest of the population familiar with the scenes from the walls of zurkhaneh (traditional sports clubs or gymnasia) and coffee-houses, which had been popular in Persia since the sixteenth century. With Iran’s oil reserves and its strategic position – giving a potential route into the Soviet Union for American lend-lease war materiel – Kem’s task of winning over Iran’s population was high on the British government’s list of priorities. Yet this would also be an extremely difficult task, even for a veteran cartoonist like


50 | pembroke college Kem. For all the political controversy and ferment of the Reza Shah’s Iran, one thing which could unite much of the population was a deep fear of British and Russian power and sympathy towards the rising new Germany, whose ideology incorporated the ancient Iranian paradigm of an ideal human emulating Zoroastrian beliefs distantly and fragmentarily reflected in Nietzsche’s Also sprach Zarathustra. Reza Shah established rather a close relationship with Hitler mainly because of his personal sentiments: having risen from the lowest rank of the Russian Cossack brigade to become War Minister and eventually crown himself Shah of Iran, establishing the last Persian dynasty in December 1925, he knew too well about the military, political and economic activities of both Russia and Britain, while Germany was never a part of the game at that level. These sentiments had its roots in the ‘Great Game’ of the nineteenth century, and only grew more pronounced with the Anglo-Russian occupation of much of Iran in World War I. Indeed, only a year prior to the printing of these posters, British and Soviet forces had once again – without a formal declaration of war and after the Iranian government had agreed to meet their ultimatum – invaded the country, bombed its major cities into submission, and forced the Shah’s abdication. By 1942, all of Iran’s major roads and railways had been requisitioned for allied trucks heading into the USSR, the famous ‘Persian Corridor’. To those who saw these cartoons, it might have seemed ironic that it was the Allies rather than the Axis powers who had occupied Iran and were now ‘feeding’, if not on the brains of its youth, then at least on its resources and infrastructure. Turning to Kem’s fifth poster, depicting the trussed Zahhak/Hitler being bundled off to Mount Damavand (Fig. 5), one can detect the ways in which Kem tried to make his propaganda message more palatable. In the original story, though three warriors come to Zahhak in his dream, it is only Faridun who answers Kaveh’s call. In these posters, however, Kem depicts three warriors – Churchill, Stalin, and Roosevelt – coming to depose Zahhak/Hitler. This went some way to diluting the poster’s Anglophile stance. The appearance of Stalin – complete with a hammer and sickle on his turban – might have engaged the many Iranians whose sympathies lay with the left-wing Tudeh party, closely aligned as it was with Moscow. Some might also have viewed Roosevelt’s inclusion positively, at a time when America retained some of that Wilsonian promise as a potential check on British ambitions. But for many, the appearance of Winston Churchill – the man who, before becoming Prime Minister, had in 1909 persuaded the Admiralty to take out a commanding share in the Anglo-Persian Oil Company – would have been total anathema. With its positive depiction of the allied leaders, it is not hard to see why these posters were reissued on the eve of the Tehran Conference to prepare the ground for the leaders’ arrival in the city to discuss their war aims. Yet it is also possible to imagine that this poster could have backfired among Iranian nationalists who might have seen the trio not as heroic warriors, but unwelcome invaders. Indeed, it is possible that for some Iranians the repurposing of their national epic by a foreign power might have produced reactions of indignation, or even outrage. The Zahhak cycle is such a favourite in part because of the character of Kaveh. The only charismatic commoner in the Shahnameh, the blacksmith-


annual gazette | 51 turned-revolutionary held unique appeal to the masses and served as an archetype for generations of Iranian rebels. This poster was neither the first nor the last time that Kaveh would be evoked in response to political events. Between 1916 and 1922, for example, constitutional activist turned Shahnameh scholar Hasan Taqizadeh edited a magazine entitled Kaveh, featuring nationalist articles which reflected on the Anglo-Russian occupation during the First World War. In Kem’s posters, Kaveh is evoked in a completely different way: rather than resisting foreign invaders, here he appears leading them into his country. Perhaps this is in line with Ferdowsi’s story, recognising – as did Kaveh – that his motley band of followers could not topple Zahhak alone. Yet Kem was playing a dangerous game by recasting a symbol of Iranian independence as a harbinger of foreign domination. Looking at the fifth poster, a hierarchy is created as Kaveh walks barefoot before the mounted allies. It is also telling that, while other characters were changed into recognisable political personalities, Kaveh is portrayed as a generic Iranian man. Though Kem likely feared to single out a single politician in the unstable political climate of wartime Iran, when anyone he chose might fall from favour before his poster even hit the press, this also visually marginalises the only figure in these cartoons who represents Iran. In using such evocative source material, Kem had a powerful means of connecting with ordinary Iranians. Yet this also carried the risk that, by taking liberties with the source material, his reinterpretation of the beloved story might come across as arrogant or inappropriate. Taken in this light, these posters could be seen as a striking example of the nexus between Orientalist scholarship and colonial power. The specialist knowledge of Dr Arberry, a scholar in the pay of the British Government, was used here to produce propaganda to justify the extension of colonial power (albeit informal) to an occupied people. Yet the complex process of cross-cultural interaction which gave rise to these posters defies such easy categorisation. Their inception involved the agency of Mojtaba Minovi, an Iranian intellectual often critical of Western orientalists, and the artistic skill of a colonial subject, the Egyptian-born Kem. If these posters reveal anything, it is the mechanics of the process whereby the British Government worked out how to craft their wartime propaganda to unfamiliar cultures. This process prioritised not only the learning of British academics but also with the input of ‘representatives’ of the culture in question, a mantle which Minovi took on enthusiastically. It is fascinating to read the exchange between Arberry and Minovi and consider how their knowledge and ideas passed from academic correspondence into officially-produced propaganda. Similar posters and processes doubtless exist for countries across the world, produced by similarly personal and haphazard methods: one may think, for example, of how Japanese propaganda paid close attention to the specific discontents of interwar India, and consider how similar conversations with Indian nationalists played a part in shaping them. For me, these posters offer lessons to Shahnameh scholars. In the foregoing discussion, we have seen how different actors – from exiled intellectuals to British intelligence – turned to the Shahnameh to communicate an agenda. This was possible thanks both to the openness of the text, allowing it to be used to


52 | pembroke college justify a wide range of messages, and its popularity, making it a powerful tool in the hands of propagandists. Yet it is this same openness which makes any one interpretation insufficient. Referring to the original poem, the nuance of Ferdowsi’s text – especially the unexpected complexity of Zahhak’s character – makes Kem’s retelling of the story seem oversimplified, his political metaphor seem crude. Though the Shahnameh has been used and abused for a thousand years, it resists control. Often used to justify absolutist visions of monarchy, Ferdowsi’s kings repeatedly bring ruin to Iran through their flaws. A rallying cry for nationalists, the poem is packed with reflections on the tragedy of war and inevitability of death. Through such paradoxes, the Shahnameh will always exceed the meanings imposed upon it. www A note from Firuza Melville The posters are a brilliant result of collaboration of three specialists in their fields: art, Persian studies and propaganda, in which all three showed a good level of professionalism. However, to be able to appeal to the local population in Iran using the visual paradigm of the Shahnameh it was Arthur Arberry of Pembroke College, Cambridge with the help of Mojtaba Minovi, BBC analyst and presenter in those days, later a prominent scholar of classical Persian literature and professor of Tehran University, who were responsible for choosing the set of the most popular episodes from the Zahhak story and their visual representations in medieval manuscripts. Each of Kem’s posters has a particular well-established iconography of illustrating the original stories. To prove this I shall bring the prototype of only one, which is missing in Drake’s collection, where even the use of the text block is masterfully imitated. The poster depicts Hitler bound on the rock with two snakes hanging off his shoulders – Mussolini and Tojo. Three great warriors are riding by: Churchill, Stalin and Roosevelt, while in the bottom left the flags of their nations are waved at by their supporters. There is a hint of a fourth flag – of the host country (Iran) – but it is not prominent. To enhance the role of the leader of the glorious procession Churchill is dressed up in the tiger-skin mantle, which is a traditional costume of the main hero of the Iranian national epic – Rostam who by this time had not been born. One of the prototypes of this poster is now a part of the Shahnameh copy kept in the Bodleian Library (Ouseley Add. 176, f. 30 recto). The manuscript was commissioned by Ibrahim Sultan, governor of Shiraz and the grandson of Timur (Tamerlan), around 1425. It depicts the legitimate Iranian King Faridun, riding the Cow Barmaya and watching the evil Arab King Zahhak being taken out of the palace and bound on the volcanic Mount Demavand which is now outside Tehran. Zahhak spent his last thousand years devouring, by means of his monstrous snakes, the youth of Iran. Barmaya, according to Ferdowsi’s narrative, should already have been killed


annual gazette | 53 by Zahhak as she was the one who, in the absence of his murdered parents, was looking after the baby – like the she-wolf after Romulus and Remus. Nevertheless, Faridun, sitting on his foster-mother cow, is witnessing the expulsion of the foreign tyrant as the ruler of his country – being crucified inside the crater of the volcano where Zahhak will be tortured by the fire as in hell. He will be kept there until the end of the world as a living example of universal evil brought to a deserved punishment. His groans are the explanation of the rumblings of the sleeping volcano which are still to be heard.


54 | pembroke college

Commemoration of Benefactors (1): Laurence Booth Lizzy Ennion-Smith In the first of what is hoped to be an occasional series in the Pembroke Gazette focussing on College benefactors, the College Archivist Lizzy Ennion-Smith discusses the impact of Laurence Booth on the College.

The College has been fortunate to have a great many benefactors over its centuries of existence. From small gifts to large gifts, each benefactor has contributed to the development of the College into what it is today. As part of the Commemoration of Benefactors Service, I looked at one of our benefactors in more detail: Laurence Booth. Not to be confused with Sir Philip Booth, a 16th century benefactor who gave the College property in London. Laurence appears on the third page of one of our earliest surviving books of benefactors. This particular volume dates from around 1730, based on the date of the last entry in the volume.

Why choose Laurence? He was certainly an interesting character, rising and falling with the fortunes of his patrons, he cemented the College’s links with the North; but he was also named by Bishop Andrewes as the College’s ‘third founder’ so I wanted to find out more. Booth was born around 1420, the illegitimate son of John Booth of Barton in Eccles, Lancashire. He likely came up to Pembroke in the late 1430s or early 1440s, and took degrees in both civil and canon law by 1448. But prior to this he had received papal dispensation as a son of unmarried parents for promotion to holy orders, and had been duly ordained priest in 1446. The Pembroke Fellowship clearly saw something in him, electing him Master of Pembroke in 1450. A position he held till his death. He was the first Master who was not a Fellow and his election followed a petition from the Fellowship to the Pope for dispensation from the Statute compelling them to elect a Master from the Fellowship. This desire for a Master not from the Fellowship came from a


annual gazette | 55 wish for the College to have a wider influence, especially at Court. In anticipation of the success of the petition, Laurence had already been elected to succeed Hugh Damlet who had resigned in April 1450. The papal bull for the dispensation is dated November of that year. This document was conserved in 2020 and a close up of the seal, made of lead, shows the papal seal of Pope Nicholas V. The heads of the Apostles Saint Peter and Saint Paul can just about be seen.

Initially a mainly absent Master, firstly as chancellor and keeper of the privy seal for Queen Margaret, better known as Margaret of Anjou, wife of Henry VI, then as Dean of St Paul’s, and from 1457 as Bishop of Durham. But with his fortunes tied to the Lancastrian cause, the Yorkist victory in 1461 at Towton meant a return to College. Matthew Wren found evidence in the College records of commons that in the 1460s Laurence was in residence at the College for long periods. He returned to favour with the Court by 1473 when he was made Lord Chancellor and in 1476 he became Archbishop of York – that year the College gates were painted – possibly in honour of so great an event. Laurence died at Southwell in May 1480, perhaps after a long illness, for he drew up his will on 28th September 1479. He was buried alongside his brother in the chantry chapel dedicated to St John the Baptist which he had founded there, and which his executors were to complete. Alas we cannot see his tomb today as it appears it was destroyed by a falling wall in 1847. So a brief summary of his career has been given, but for members of Pembroke, we are particularly interested in his impact upon the College. As I have said, he was elected Master in 1450 and immediately began to work on behalf of the College. Just a year after his election he obtained for the College the perpetual lease of St Thomas’s Hostel from St John’s Hospital for a yearly rent of six


56 | pembroke college shillings and eightpence! The length of this plot ran from what is now Trumpington Street to approximately the main entrance to the current library and the width from about halfway through the chapel to the end of the Red Buildings. The Hostel brought more students to the College with 34 noted as in residence by 1457, each paying eightpence a term to the College. A lucrative source of income and influence! The library over the Hall was also completed during Booth’s Mastership and it may in fact have been Booth who paid for it or obtained donations to pay for it. His donations also enhanced the then Chapel, adding stained glass, and giving stalls, a rood-screen, loft and figures of Saints. It is also said he had saffron planted in the gardens. When a new plaster ceiling was added to the Hall in 1926, Laurence’s arms were incorporated into the design, along with those of other significant benefactors: the Foundress, Henry VI, Archbishop Grindal, Bishop Andrewes, Sir Robert Hitcham, Sergeant William Moses, and Sara Lonsdale. Have a look next time you are in Hall and see if you can spot Laurence’s arms – they feature a bishop’s mitre above the shield. The shield itself is described in heraldic terms as Argent, three boar’s heads erased sable erect, i.e. white with 3 black boars heads. He would also go on to secure property lying between the College and St Botolph’s which gave the College access to a bakery and brewery. This is now the triangle of land between Pembroke Street and Botolph Lane. Add to this his work to secure earlier gifts from Henry VI of the rectory and advowson of Soham, Linton Priory and a cell at Isleham which could have been lost to the College upon the accession of Edward IV, and Laurence was indeed a significant benefactor. And a benefactor not just to the College. He held the position of Chancellor of the University for 2 years from 1456 and saw to it that work started on the building of new schools for the public acts and lectures. Laurence’s gifts to the College were not all so concrete, under him the fame of the College grew and it began to nurture great men: Thomas Langton for example, a Fellow in 1461 went on to be bishop of successively, St David’s, Salisbury and Winchester and became Provost of Queen’s College, Oxford. Richard Stubbs, Fellow from around 1467 became Master of Clare Hall and William Chubbes, Fellow from 1466, became the first Master of Jesus to give just 3 examples. Laurence’s final act for the College was to bequeath the manor and advowson, or the right to appoint the vicar, of Orton Waterville or Cherry Orton in Huntingdonshire, now a suburb of Peterborough. It was named after the Waterville family who settled there after the Norman Conquest. Much of the land at Orton Waterville was sold off in the 1950s when managing agricultural property became expensive. But the College retains many documents relating to Orton Waterville, including a licence of mortmain for the original transfer of the manor to the College in February 1480. The document includes the seal of Edward IV.


annual gazette | 57

Each of our benefactors have their own stories and I hope I will be able to share some more of these with you in the future.


58 | pembroke college

The Dame Ivy Compton Burnett Prize for Creative Writing 2021 Lizzy Ennion-Smith This year the prize was judged by the distinguished writer, Holly Corfield-Carr, a poet and Research Fellow in English at Murray Edwards College, Cambridge. She said this about the winning entry: ‘This sequence of five poems is so finely balanced, slowly tilting around the “calculated pivot” of the central poem “North Pole” as disappearance turns to return, mountain to marsh, death to life. From the bright flipper bones of a leatherback turtle on the windowsill of “Bone House” to the ash of a forest fire in the final poem “Noonmark Mountain”, these poems glow and grow with each other.’ The author of this year’s winning entry (as in 2018) is Katherine Robinson, who is doing a PhD in English on ‘Reanimated mythic traditions: Celtic influences on Ted Hughes’ mythopoesis and confessional poetry’.

BONE HOUSE When I duck into the shed to find a rake, the wings of a Siberian swan splay above me. White down loosens from brittle skin and catches in my hair as I pull the door closed. It died, caught in a telephone wire, last winter, and you saved the wings and strung them above empty flowerpots and old gardening gloves. Its dry muscles keep Russian summers and arctic winds hanging in our shed. You gather bones and boil them clean. Flipper bones of a leatherback turtle cross on the windowsill. Thousands of miles of sea calcified in those bones. Shapes animals held a long time stay: vertebrae stud the bookshelf, jawbones rattle in the dresser drawer, teeth stubble the soil of your houseplants. When we draw the curtains or reach for books, We are reaching through absence. MALLORY ON EVEREST The climber sees a dull whiteness that doesn’t gleam like snow. A hobnail boot half-emerges from the scree, and an ankle extends bare and brittle. Yellowed shrapnel of bone jags out of torn trousers: an ugly fracture.


annual gazette | 59 His tattered shirt flaps across a wind-polished back, bleached and hardened by sun and the mountain’s dry freeze, scapulas still articulate. Wind sweeps a body clean seventy years here. Nothing hides. He lies face down, thinning hair tousled and frozen. Half-bare arms reach up to grasp the slope. Kneeling beside the body, the climber takes off his gloves, eases the man’s collar back, his hands already so numb the sweater’s frayed yarn feels large and vague in his fingers. Cold hair pricks his knuckles as he finds a hand-lettered label stitched to the wool: G. Mallory. He’s followed this man so long in his mind that now he’s caught up to him, Mallory seems so nearly alive he wants to set the broken bone and help him down to the tents. He fumbles with the frozen jacket– snow goggles stuffed in a pocket: it was dusk when he fell, the glare fading off the ice as he pushed back to camp. He covers Mallory’s bare arms with the unravelling sweater his wife knitted back in Surrey. He can still feel the strength of the dead man’s triceps. When he finds the altimeter, frozen in a trouser pocket, it’s cracked. He can’t retrieve any record of how high Mallory climbed. If he holds it any longer, his fingers will freeze to the steel.


60 | pembroke college He seals it in a Ziploc bag and puts his gloves back on. The rest of his team arrives and they cover Mallory, as gently as they can, with scree so souvenir hunters won’t find him. NORTH POLE I. The cold’s less piercing than he’d expected. No wind, a quiet so thick he feels almost protected. Banks of blown snow unreel as far as he can see: nothing unearthly, no strange blue light calcified to stillness, no spectral ice arches. The snow is rough and bare as pastures. II. At home, skunk cabbage fluted by the rusted water pump. He’d lie in bed too long, watch dry grass stubble old snow and think of climbing: roping himself to the cusped tip of the Matterhorn, leaning back into air. Summits. Places he’d almost tricked death, then come back. III. He walks a wide circle, stepping back from now to last night as time zones splay beneath him: a calculated pivot could keep him forever in a dazed pause, tracking a single hour through longitudes gathered like strings of a marionette.


annual gazette | 61 When the plane roars south, he watches latitudes flash neon in the cockpit. There’s nowhere to go except south from here, and the plane is speeding. Blurred snow becomes hypnotic as blue, corrugated lines of sea ice trawl beneath them. PERSEPHONE RETURNING When thrushes call along the thawing marsh I look for you. Sometimes I’ve almost seen that place where you wait and slipped my fumbling hands between its doors that open, close, a sound I hear in sleep, in water, in trees. Everything stirs with rumours of you until the sound is your breath. I bring you the ruddy fringe of maple flowers, downy fronds of fiddlehead ferns uncurling by vernal pools, a soft, sundered rabbit’s tail I found in the marsh grass. NOONMARK MOUNTAIN After the forest fire had stripped the mountain shoulder bare, birches were the first trees to come back. They greened the burned patch, shading it pale and soft against dark, orderly pines. When I climbed the mountain, birches branched around me, speckled as eggs, white bark beginning to spread up thin, new trunks that, in winter, would bend hunched with snow, too pliant to rise again, even when the thaw came, out of the low bow ice had forced. The next year, canopies of leaves ramified along the ground and greened, still bound to roots that broke bare ash and turned cinder into earth.


B. COLLEGE NEWS


annual gazette | 67 towns and cities, so long as they had any sort of training hospital to boast: Scunthorpe, Falkirk, Swinton, St Helen’s and, sometimes, too, London, Manchester, Birmingham, Glasgow. I’m told that my first sentences were uttered in a thick Glaswegian accent (I still wish this had stuck). Arabic would come later. As it turns out, my mother was in Newcastle on a ‘locum’, a ‘weekender’, and I wasn’t technically due for another couple months. So, when she, on shift, felt it was time to eject the alien in her body, she was hurried over to St Mary’s, which in November 1993 was already half-demolished, whence she promptly demanded: ‘a hot bath in one of those legged tubs’. She demanded codeine too, lots of it, bless her, so I was born premature and blue. My point is, because we moved around a lot, I don’t really have any ‘growing up I loved my history teacher’ narrative to furnish the Gazette’s readers with. In fact, we often missed school in these moves (then sat special entrance exams to make up for lost years). And, relatedly, after my mum had had a postcolonial moment and upped and moved us to Cairo, I, in turn, promptly took a flight to Liverpool, got a job (I was 14) and dropped out of school. The following year, I took self-taught A-levels, having paid to sit them at a random London sixth form and soon was well on my way to becoming a development economist at Sussex. This was in 2010, when I was still subscribed to the Economist and thought Paul Krugman was god’s gift (I’ve managed to forgive myself since and atonement comes in the form of a small fortune in subs to the London Review of Books). I think I became disillusioned with the subject by about the fourth lecture of term. The end of term, meanwhile, brought the Tunisian Uprising, with the Egyptian Uprising hot on its heels: purpose, promise and euphoria. Off I went. I had a bit of an uphill battle with the department, partly because I was perennially absent away revolutionising, but also because I wanted to write my dissertation in the IR/History departments. In the end, I managed it and graduated with a thesis entitled: ‘Universities of Finance: An Economic Sociology of Privatisation in UK Higher Education’. I’m still proud of that work: it foreshadowed all the difficulties menacing the HE sector and its beleaguered workers today. Sussex had also planted in me (and anyone who would listen to the old Marxist dons) an abiding interest in the ‘origins of capitalism’. So, in 2013, I went to study Economic and Social History at Oxford (St Antony’s) with the intent of tracing Egyptian-Italian entanglements in the global Transition to Capitalism and with some very big bones in the agrarian (pastoral?) ‘Brenner Debate’ to pick. By this point, a military dictatorship in Egypt had crushed the revolution’s dreams and broken my heart, and I had started to work closely with Jane Humphries on working-class autobiography in England, but also Iraq and Egypt. So I graduated with distinction with a thesis that looked at women activists and prisoners in Egypt’s sixties instead. Theory, which historians don’t always like, also became important to me around then. I’d had a few PhD options and, in the end, had fancied Italy might be nice for a change, so I went to the European University Institute. Florence was great, but in the end, didn’t quite agree with me and I took an MA instead. In 2015, I went back to Oxford (Merton), on an ESRC studentship and a T. E.


annual gazette | 69 permanent position in the Cambridge Zoology Department. I had also been to Australia and the US to work in the field there, focusing on bird species where extended families raise young together and on species that are routinely exploited by brood parasites like cuckoos or cowbirds. With my research team, I discovered that adults cooperate to provision offspring yet are vulnerable to manipulation by a lazy partner; that siblings are rivals for resources yet can cooperate to obtain more food from their parents; and that offspring reliably signal how hungry they to provisioning parents yet can also demand food than is optimal for parents to supply. We also discovered that these different forms of evolutionary conflict and cooperation within the family are usually hidden from plain view. Sometimes they are concealed by layers of adaptation and counter-adaptation that result from interactions between the social partners (parent and offspring, brother and sister, male and female, and so on). For example, it turns out that a young bird is constrained in its ability to demand too much food because parent birds carefully regulate their sensitivity to their brood’s begging displays, and limit the food that they supply in response. Nestlings then restrain their demands to avoid wasting energy on unrewarded begging. They are forewarned of their parent’s likely generosity through chemical signals in the egg, and adjust their demands accordingly. Parents that will supply lots of food dose their eggs with more androgens and their brood has a correspondingly demanding begging display. Different families thus have different rules of social engagement. Some have noisy chicks with parents highly attuned to their needs and whereas others have more subdued offspring and relatively insensitive parents. It’s only by transplanting nestlings to different nests, and exposing them to the different provisioning rules that exist within their foster family, that these layers of adaptation and counteradaptation can be broken up experimentally and the underlying evolutionary conflict between parents and offspring then fully revealed. More generally, these observations show how animals impose selection upon each other when they interact socially. The demands of the offspring impose selection on parents to fine-tune their response – so they can avoid being manipulated; the responsiveness of parents imposes selection on offspring to attend to chemical signals in the egg – to prevent wasteful begging. This means that behaviour is not only the product of evolution, but is itself an agent of selection and so can influence the course of subsequent evolutionary change. Determining exactly how behaviour influences evolution is now the main topic of research in my lab, and has been ever since I was promoted to Professor in 2013. For this work, I switched to studying burying beetles, a common insect in our woodlands. They too have interesting social lives, centred around the corpse of a small mammal or bird. The parents shave off the fur or feathers, roll the flesh into a ball, cover it in antimicrobial fluids, and bury it below ground where it becomes an edible nest for their larvae. Parents guard their larvae and feed them, like chicks in a nest, until the larvae have entirely consumed the dead body at which point the larvae crawl off into the soil to pupate. All of this action takes place within days, with each generation lasting about 6 weeks, and it can be brought into the lab. What is more, larvae can survive with


70 | pembroke college no parental care – at least in lab conditions. This means we can subject beetles to experimental evolution by manipulating the supply of parental care for generation after generation, and in different ways for different populations. We can then watch how evolution unfolds in each experimental population. We are using this approach to determine general ways in which behaviour might change the course of evolution: by providing a channel for non-genetic inheritance (including epigenetic inheritance); by changing the response to selection; by favouring particular forms of genetic architecture; and by influencing the extent of genetic variation. In 2019, I was appointed Director of the University’s Museum of Zoology and this has opened up new research possibilities. From the start of the next academic year, I will co-lead a new Strategic Research Initiative across the University (called Collections – Connections – Communities), to facilitate research projects that use the University’s collections in novel ways. One major strand of this work will involve testing the suggestion that visiting museums and galleries has a positive impact on health and wellbeing, with clear societal benefits to be gained if it turns out that this is indeed the case.


annual gazette | 71

FELLOWS’ NEWS Arthur Asseraf was awarded the British Kuwait Friendship Society Book Prize for his book Electric News in Colonial Algeria. He was also awarded the Pro Futura Scientia Fellowship by the Swedish Riksbanken for three years. Rosalind Polly Blakesley was appointed a Fellow of the Society of Antiquaries, and a Trustee of the Samuel Courtauld Trust. Hugo Bronstein was appointed Reader in the Department of Chemistry and Physics. Nick Burton was made an Assistant Professor at the Van Andel Institute in Michigan. Sanne Cottaar was awarded the 2021 Harold Jeffreys Lectureship by the Royal Astronomical Society. Hannah Elsisi’s dissertation was awarded the Malcolm H. Kerr Dissertation Award in the Humanities by the Middle Eastern Studies Association, and the Leigh Douglas Memorial Award for best dissertation on Middle East Studies by the British Society for Middle East Studies. She has also been awarded a one-year Research Fellowship at the Crown Center for Middle Eastern Studies in Boston. Andrea Ferrari was elected Fellow of the European Academy of Sciences, the Academia Europaea, and the Royal Society of Chemistry. He was also awarded the Blaise Pascal Medal in Materials Science from the European Academy of Science. Robin Franklin was awarded the 2021 King Faisal Prize in Medicine for his work on the topic of regenerative medicine in neurological conditions. Allegra Fryxell obtained a postdoctoral research position in the Chair for Science Studies at ETH Zürich, and was also awarded a Branco Weiss Fellowship that will support her in her researches. Renaud Gagné’s book Cosmography and the Idea of Hyperborea in Ancient Greece: A Philology of Worlds was published by Cambridge University Press. Loraine Gelsthorpe was awarded the 2021 European Society of Criminology Lifetime Award for her distinguished contribution to European criminology. Clare Grey was awarded the 2021 Körber European Science Prize, which is worth € 1 million. Alex Houen has published a chapbook of poetry entitled Malapartings (Equipage, 2021) that engages with poems by the Italian writer Curzio Malaparte. Mike Hulme has been awarded the 2021 Eduard Brückner Prize by the German Meteorological Society for outstanding interdisciplinary achievements in climate research. His latest book – Climate Change – has just been published by Routledge in their Key Ideas in Geography series.


72 | pembroke college Nicholas Jones was appointed Reader in the Department of Materials Science and Metallurgy. Lauren Kassell was appointed to the Chair in the History of Science at the European University Institute in Florence. Rebecca Kilner was elected a Fellow of the Royal Society. Wanne Kromdijk was awarded a UK Research and Innovation Future Leaders Fellowship. Rebecca Lämmle was appointed Senior University Lecturer in the Department of Classics. She also produced (with Richard Hunter) an edited edition of Euripides’ Cyclops, that was published by Cambridge University Press. Luca Magri was made a Reader in Data-Driven Fluid Mechanics by Imperial College London. Jessica Maratsos was awarded the Samuel H Kress grant from the Renaissance Society of America for her book, Pontormo and the Art of Devotion in Renaissance Italy, which will be published in September by the Cambridge University Press. Robert Mayhew, who becomes Senior Tutor of the College in September, was made a Fellow of the British Academy. Nick McBride co-authored the Independent Review of Administrative Law that was presented to the UK government in March 2021. Torsten Meißner was highly commended in the Cambridge University Student Union student-led teaching awards for his lecturing in Classics. Gos Micklem was appointed Professor in the Department of Genetics. Anna Maria Pappa has obtained an appointment in the Faculty of Chemical Engineering at Khalifa University, in Abu Dhabi. Mark Purcell was made a University Proctor. Chris Smith, the Master, was appointed to the Board of the English National Opera. Stephanie Smith was given a student-led teaching award by the Cambridge University Student Union for her small group teaching in science and technology. Max Sternberg has been appointed as Honourable Secretary of the Society of Architectural Historians of Great Britain. His co-edited volume Modern Architecture and the Sacred was published by Bloomsbury. Ashok Venkitaraman was made Director of the Cancer Science Institute of Singapore, as well as Distinguished Professor in the Department of Medicine at the National University of Singapore Yong Loo Lin School of Medine. Colin Wilcockson was presented with a handsomely bound and printed volume of his writings called A Miscellany of Prose and Poetry.


annual gazette | 73 Chris Young was awarded the North American Society for Sport History’s 2021 Anthology Prize for his The Whole World Was Watching: Sport in the Cold War (edited with Robert Edelman).


74 | pembroke college

GIFTS TO THE COLLEGE From – Kevin van Anglen, a donation of money to the Library for the purchase of books/other library materials in the fields of Anglophone American, Canadian and West Indian Commonwealth literature Anonymous, a copy of his book Paradise Postponed (Pebury Publications, 1994) Elizabeth Bedwell, five chemistry primers Marcus Buckingham, three works on management Clare College, a copy of For Her Good Estate by Frances A. Underhill (Moonwort Press, 2020) Tony Coates, a copy of Down Your Street: Cambridge Past and Present by Sara Payne (The Pevensey Press, 1983) John Drake, five of the six posters that depict scenes from the Zahhak cycle of the Shahnameh (see article on p 45) John Durrell, two copies of Hammer’s Guide to German Grammar and Usage by M. Durrell (Routledge, 2017) Henry Edmundson, a copy of his book Tales from the Himalaya (Vajra Books, 2019) Anthony Fitzsimmons, a copy of his co-authored book Rethinking Reputational Risk (Kogan Page, 2017) Loraine Gelsthorpe, a copy of her co-edited book Spaces of Care (Hart, 2020) Colin Gilbraith, a copy of Openings to the infinite ocean by Tom Shakespeare (Quaker Books, 2020) Stephen Halliday, five works on history Rosemary Hoppitt, a copy of her book Deer Parks of Suffolk 1086–1602 (The Suffolk Institute of Archaeology & History, 2020) Harry Howard, the sculpture Crown of Thorns by Austin Mitchell The estate of Malcolm Lyons, personal papers and several hundred early printed books Guy Marriott, a copy of Holmes and Watson: A Miscellany by S. C. Roberts (British Library, 2018) Jonathan Marten, a copy of Systems Biology by Edda Klipp et al. (Wiley, 2010) Samantha Matthews, a copy of her book Album Verses and Romantic Literary Culture (OUP, 2020)


annual gazette | 75 Christopher Maycock, a copy of his edited book Selected Poems of Susanna Blamire (Bookcase, 2008) Elaine Moohan, a copy of her co-edited book The Complete Works of Robert Johnson (The Musica Scotica Trust, 2019) Stella Panayotova, a copy of her edited book The Art and Science of Illuminated Manuscripts: A Handbook (Harvey Miller Publishers, 2020) Daniel Rosenthal, exhibition materials from the collection of Tom Rosenthal Richard Skinner, 11 volumes of his poetry and prose David Stocker, a collection of 20 first edition Alfred Wainwright guides and sketchbooks Tony Verity, four classical works translated by him Philip Xiu, 35 medical textbooks Publications mentioned in the Fellows’ News section of the Gazette were donated by: Michael Wilcockson Publications mentioned in the Members’ News section of the Gazette were donated by: Bernard Adams (1958), John Nicholas (1961), Anthony Campbell (1964), Cliff Webb (1967), Robbie Low (1970), Martin Rowson (1978), Robert Porter (1984)


76 | pembroke college

THE DEAN’S REPORT Pembroke Chapel Anxiety, improvisation and risk management are not qualities that one associates with the rather stable patterns of worship in Pembroke College Chapel. Covid-19 has this year posed its particular challenges to the chapel, and I think we are emerging strengthened in a number of ways. Walking round the Chapel with the Director of Music before the beginning of Michaelmas term, trying to work out what 2 metre spacing actually meant was a sobering experience. We could fit a choir, or a congregation, but not both. We were very fortunate that work on Emmanuel URC, now purchased by Pembroke College, did not commence in Michaelmas Term. This gave us a far larger building, originally designed to hold 700 people, and safe under Covid regulations for a choir and 30 members of the congregation. So Services commenced at the beginning of Michaelmas with the Girls choir singing on Wednesday and the Chapel Choir singing on Sunday. We scanned the regulations, marked a place for every seat, kept the windows and doors open whatever the weather, wiped and sanitised seats, and wore masks when we were not actually speaking or singing. A number of positive things emerged from this time. Because we could not invite preachers in person, and because a proportion of the congregation joined online, I asked a number of distinguished artists and art historians to record talks about their work, with presentations which worked as well online as they did live. The resulting meditations were diverse, vivid and remarkable – you can get a flavour of them at: https://sms.cam.ac.uk/collection/3593266 Emmanuel URC was the church of P T Forsyth, the Scottish theologian and preacher about whom I wrote my PhD. There was a particular pleasure to officiating twice a week from his pulpit. It was quite demanding to be setting up and taking down a sound system for each service, connecting up the data projector, trying to ensure that the projection screen was straight, turning recordings and pictures into videos, streaming, uploading and downloading. However, the final result was a set of recorded services which reached far more people than we have ever done in person. Pastoral and tutorial discussions were often undertaken on Zoom, but where ever possible we met outside. The Chapel Cloister became, for days at a time, my key place of work – huddled in a clerical cloak. From there I could see the life of the college flowing past. As the lockdown tightened, we had to do more with less – simple evening meditations, with recorded music. One or two singers, often from the same household, providing music for the Sunday morning Communion. Compline with a half choir, sometimes all upper voices and sometimes all lower. Meanwhile we instituted a ‘Welfare Goody Box’. Each day I, or the College Counsellor, or the Director of Music, or the College Nurse put out a ‘Thought for the Day’ via Facebook and email. Each day we put out a small diversion for


annual gazette | 77 students in College Lockdown. Packs of cards or packets of seeds. Marbles and walking maps of Cambridge. Origami paper and Pembroke tattoos. We received very positive feedback. Clearly this was primarily a gesture, but in difficult times it can be good to know that people have thought about you. Towards the end of the year things became a little more normal. Work began on the URC so we went back to Chapel. A permanent streaming system was installed, so we were no longer leaping around with cables and tripods at the beginning of each service. We were able to do a lovely Havdallah ceremony in the Fellows’ Garden, guided by a Jewish student who wanted us to share the joyfulness of the end of Sabbath. The Leavers’ Evensong went ahead, albeit with the Choir in the Nave and the Congregation in the Cloister, and I and the Readers addressing both from the antechapel. Over the summer we have a number of weddings, some of which are carried over from last year. There is the possibility of a short choir tour/retreat, and the challenge of integrating further into our worship the challenges of Climate Justice and Migrant Justice, the opportunities of increasing diversity, and need to make music and worship part of our outreach, both as a Chapel and as a College.

Pembroke House Normally the Pembroke House report is an opportunity for me to write about the connections between Pembroke College and Pembroke House and all that we have done over the course of the year to strengthen and celebrate them. This year these connections have been virtual, to a large extent. The most significant initiative to strengthen links has been Project PEM. This is organised by a Pembroke undergraduate, with support from Pembroke Admissions, and is creating a link between selected Pembroke students, as College Buddies for some young people in Walworth as they head towards university choices, and the UCAS application system. Pembroke College is also providing some money for the administrative costs of the scheme. The purpose is to enable the Walworth students to make the very best applications they can to a range of universities and courses, and to enable the Pembroke students to learn mentoring skills and to begin to be involved with Walworth. I was pleased to be able to take a service at St Christopher’s just after Easter, and the Trustees have continued in active support of the Pembroke House Staff and projects, but face to face visits have not been possible this year. However there has been an enormous amount of activity at Pembroke House itself, and I think this is best captured in the foreword to the papers for the AGM. If you are a Pembroke Subscriber you will receive these independently. Please accept my apologies for the duplication. If you are not a Pembroke Subscriber and would like to be, please be in touch at jtdg2@cam.ac.uk.


78 | pembroke college Foreword At the start of this year, on 1 April 2020, we’d just been plunged into lockdown by the coronavirus pandemic: the greatest crisis that most of us can remember. Over the next 12 months – faced by the most challenging of circumstances – our community showed incredible strength, resilience, solidarity, and love. At the outset of the crisis, like so many other places across the country, we saw a huge groundswell of community spirit and mutual aid, with hundreds of local people stepping forward to help their neighbours in whatever way they could. Even more remarkably, through all the ups and downs of the crisis, that community spirit here in Walworth has shown no sign of flagging. Pembroke House jumped into action as soon as lockdown hit. At the start of April, we’d already set up an emergency Food Hub, kick-started a programme of virtual activities, and begun working with partners to inspire a coordinated local response to Covid-19. Over the past year, this work has gone from strength to strength. Thanks to the skill, dedication and hard work of an incredible team of volunteers and staff we’re now in a position to look beyond the immediate, emergency response, to the part we can play in Walworth’s long-term recovery from the crisis. But this year has also been a wake-up call. The pandemic has exposed and exacerbated the struggles that many local families face – but it didn’t cause them. Despite the growth in our activity over the past ten years – and indeed despite all our work over the past 135 years – Walworth remains an area of vast and growing inequality. Just as our founders did, we need to be clear-sighted – not just celebrating what works, but confronting what doesn’t. The past year has only reinforced something we’ve known for a while: that we won’t solve deep-rooted challenges through traditional charity work alone. We need to forge a new approach – adapting our settlement values to the challenges of today. And while Pembroke House doesn’t have all the answers – no single organisation or approach does – we do believe we have a role to play in bringing people together to find new solutions. With hundreds of residents coming together with the local authority, civil society and the private sector to support their neighbours through the Covid crisis, the foundations for this new collaboration have been strengthened this year. As we emerge from the crisis, we are determined to build on what we’ve achieved and learned together this year, redoubling our efforts to build a stronger and more equal Walworth.

J.T.D.G.


annual gazette | 79

DEVELOPMENT OFFICE REPORT From the Development Director I am rarely at a loss for words when it comes to writing my little piece for the Gazette. This time, however, I reflected on how hard it would be to sum up what has been an extraordinary year not just for Pembroke – its students, staff and Fellows – but you too. I sincerely hope that you and your friends and family have managed as well as possible over the course of this pandemic. I normally spend a little time opining before getting on to the business of telling you about how Pembroke’s fundraising and other development activities have done but this time I shall start at the numbers. Last year, you contributed a staggering £14.7 million to the College. The wonderful matching contributions from the Dolby family helped to achieve this number, but since their support is released on the basis of what you contribute to the marvellous Mill Lane project and Ray and Dagmar Dolby Court, I would like to say a huge thank you to all of you for your extraordinary contributions. We now stand at £64.5 million raised towards the £75 million needed for the Mill Lane redevelopment and a staggering £20 million more has been contributed towards bursaries, academic support and the general student experience. Again, thank you. While the extraordinary physical expansion of Pembroke remains an overriding strategic and fundraising priority, it is worth repeating that its purpose will be to enable the College and its people to do what they already do well in even better and more conducive circumstances. I am not merely talking about the academic, intellectual or research progress of our students and Fellows, but also the personal development of young minds by creating super social spaces to meet, try new things and continue to make a positive impact while they are here and when they leave. The Mill Lane development will be a wonderful thing to have, and enjoy, but it brings with it great responsibility. Even as I thank you, donors to the College, for your generosity, and volunteers for such generosity of time and spirit in support of so many activities, I contemplate a question that I want us all to ask ourselves as we seek to complete the funding of Mill Lane and build a refounded future for Pembroke. Whether we are resident members or returning ones, we are absorbed in the place and the spirit of the College even if it means different things to different people. Whatever it does mean, it is the product of centuries of benefaction and of nurturing care and we thank our predecessors for it. The question (and our theme now) is, “What will our successors thank us for?” in the years, decades and centuries to come? In the immediate term, I trust it will be for the creation, with little or no outstanding debt, of an impactful physical stamp on Pembroke and Cambridge more widely, but what of the longer term? It is worth noting that, at the time of writing major donations have been agreed and/or already received from Michael Milstein (2009) and his family, Roger Ferguson (1973), and Sam Blyth (1972). Their support will leave a permanent and positive mark, as will the wonderful class of 1984 with the Café that will bear their year’s name.


80 | pembroke college I must also thank Bill (1965) and Weslie Janeway for their inspiring gift to support Pembroke music with a truly extraordinary endowment. The exciting transformation of the Emmanuel United Reformed Church into an emblematic teaching and music venue for all Cambridge, together with the immense platform of this endowment, should give Anna Lapwood and her successors supreme confidence in the College’s musical presence for time immemorial. Among other thanks and tributes, I should also pay one to Peter Jackson (1995) who has been a sterling and energetic chairman of the Campaign Board; he was instrumental in the successful launch and initial thrust of The Time and the Place Campaign. He has now handed the reins to Marcus Bökkerink (1983) as Chair and Jo Prior (1984) as Vice-Chair to take us not only through to the successful conclusion of this Campaign but also to see us into the next phase of Pembroke’s advance. In my capacity as Honorary Secretary of the PCCS, I should also like to tell you that the Committee, which ran a broader ‘election’ exercise than in previous years thanks to seeking self-nominations, has extended its remit to include not just three representatives from each decade from the 1960s to the 2010s, but also regional ones. Details can be found in the relevant section of this Gazette. One notable event this year is the 25th anniversary of our Corporate Partnership Programme. The programme exists to provide a home for our corporate partners in the College whilst assisting them with navigating the opportunities in Cambridge. It was the brainchild of my predecessor, Howard Raingold, as a way for corporate donors to have a more meaningful connection to the College. Over time the programme has evolved and we currently have 11 partners, all of whom enjoy bespoke and mutually beneficial partnerships. The move to digital engagement over the past year has provided challenges, but also opportunities. We hosted the 2020 William Pitt Seminar, BT Lecture and the 2021 Parmee Prize online and were thus able to open these to a larger, and worldwide, audience. In addition to the College supporting our partners with their challenges by connecting them and wiring them into the brains of Cambridge, the College and its people also benefit from the exposure to real world challenges, as well as placements and other opportunities for our students. And finally, a note closer to home. The Development team said a warm goodbye and thanks to a number of colleagues in the past twelve months. Both Tracy Price and Sylvia Davidson, assiduous and meticulous monitors of your generosity, have now left for what we trust will be more relaxed lives, while Julia Champion, likewise known to so many of you, has now retired after five thoroughly enjoyable years (at least for us!). Thank you to all of them, and thank you too to Janette Skinner and Mariola Thorpe who have stepped efficiently and energetically into the shoes of Tracy and Sylvia; I am on the search for a replacement for Julia and hope sincerely that by the time you are reading this, I have found one! It has been lovely to have Edward Button back to assist our efforts while his performing work as one of the King’s Singers went into something of an abeyance during the worst of the pandemic so far; and to have enlisted the excellent services of Katy Bennett (2017) to encourage the Reunion Years ending


annual gazette | 81 in -0 and -1 to support much-needed bursaries that will bear their years’ imprints. During the course of the next academic year, we are looking forward to refamiliarising ourselves with Hannah Wilson, our Senior Development Officer, as she returns from maternity leave. Organising an office can be difficult even in good times and while I have been so lucky over the years to have worked with really brilliant colleagues, I must pay a personal, heartfelt and grateful tribute to the ones who have endured the most recent sixteen or so months. It has been a privilege to work with them all, even though some I have barely seen or been in the same room with in all that time. I am so grateful to them for battling through the various challenges of enforced home-schooling, illness, isolation, restriction, technology and everything else to have created as good a year on so many fronts as we could possibly have hoped for. So thank you. thank you. thank you to David Franks, Martine Goncalves, Jamila Khalil, Sally March, Clelia McElroy, Nami Morris, Kate Parsley and Sarah Richey. Thanks to their energy, patience and effort, the connection with Pembroke Members seems even to have improved on some fronts even as we have missed you all at parties, lectures and dinners and the like. If we can do this in a year like 2021, what can we all achieve beyond it?

M.R.M.

The Matthew Wren Society The prevailing Covid-19 pandemic meant that the 24th meeting of the Society was held online on Saturday 17 October 2020. 87 members of the Society logged in to hear words of welcome and an update from the Master, as well talks by Mark Wormald, the archivist Lizzy Ennion-Smith, and the Director of Music, Anna Lapwood. Membership of the Society is open to anyone who has notified the College of an intention to benefit the College by a bequest. Matthew Wren (1585–1667), undergraduate, Fellow and President of the College (1616–24), and Bishop of Ely (1638–67), had been a notable benefactor (his body is interred in the crypt of the Chapel, which he had built as a gift to the College, in 1665). The Society has a membership of 499. The names of those who have consented to be identified – together with a number of recent bequests received – are listed below. To all, the College is extremely grateful. 1944 Mr C A Price FRICS 1945 Mr P B Mackenzie Ross 1946 Professor K N Palmer 1949 Mr H J L Fitch Mr R H King Mr R L Stewart

1950 Mr M J C Annand Mr P C Flory 1951 Mr J J M Barron Dr A B Carles OBE MBS Mr J L Dixon Mr G B Smethurst

1952 Mr J J Fenwick CBE DL Mr R N Field Dr G R Hext Mr T J Milling Mr M J Munz-Jones Mr P J Pugh


82 | pembroke college 1953 Mr H G Branchdale Mr R B Carter Mr I D McPhail Mr N A Robeson Mr R M Watson Mr J M Whitehead 1954 Mr N I Cameron Mr M J Flux Dr G F Fooks Mr A H Isaacs MBE Mr I Meshoulam Mr R J M Thompson 1955 Mr R L Allison RD Sir Michael Bett CBE Mr J E Bowen FRCS Eng Mr G J Curtis Mr D W Eddison Mr J D Hind Mr T R Hopgood Mr N La Mar Dr H J F McLean CBE Mr G S Pink Mr N M Pullan Mr J M P Soper Mr J S Tucker Mr R J Warburton 1956 Mr P W Boorman FRSA Professor B M Fagan Mr K E Piper Mr M A Roberts 1957 Mr M A A Garrett MBE FCII Dr C B Hall Mr T R Harman Mr T J Harrold Professor J M H Hunter Mr J B Macdonald Mr J W S Macdonald Mr D W H McCowen Mr R B Wall Mr P J Yorke 1958 Mr R A C Berkeley OBE Mr O C Brun Mr R J M Gardner

1959

1960

1961

1962

1963

Mr J D Harling Mr J Lawrence Mr J G G Moss Professor G Parry FSA The Rt Hon Sir Konrad Schiemann PC Mr J SutherlandSmith Mr A H Wakeford Mr W R Williams JP Dr J N Woulds JP DL Mr A R Bridgman Mr S H Duro ARCM FRCO Mr P N Jarvis Mr M G Kuczynski Mr J A McMyn FCA Mr D P Robinson Professor Y A Wilks The Hon Justice Ian Binnie CC QC Mr R J Gladman Mr R E Palmer Dr J P Warren Mr J B Wilkin Mr P G Bird Mr J A H Chadwick Mr N C GroseHodge OBE Dr S Halliday Professor H R Kirby Dr R S MauriceWilliams FRCP FRCS Mr J C Robinson Mr M C Stallard FRCS Mr R M Wingfield Mr B A Howseman Sir Richard Jewson KCVO Dr M J LlewellynSmith AM KStJ Mr R C Sommers Professor J C R Turner MA PhD ScD Dr R N Cuff

1964

1965

1966

1967

1968

Mr A W Gunther Mr I G A Hunter QC Mr R J Kellaway Mr P D Skinner CBE Mr J A Stott Mr E R Tibbs Dr W C Airey Dr J C D Hickson Mr S F Kelham Mr D J Shaw Mr H J Shields Mr E M F Temple Mr P Bann Mr N I C Brocklehurst Mr R P Edwards Mr M L Greenwood Mr C R M Kemball MBE Mr S R Lawrence Mr H M Skipp Mr J J Turner Dr J G Vulliamy Mr C J B White Dr J G Williams Dr R G H Bethel Mr J V P Drury Mr B R Goodfellow Dr E M Himsworth Mr A D Jackson Mr R I Jamieson Mr D A Salter Mr R C Wilson Dr D J Atherton Mr J A Cooper Mr C R B Goldson OBE Mr M Goodwin Mr C R Webb Mr I C Brownlie Mr I P Collins Mr G N Horlick Mr P d’A KeithRoach Mr D E Love Mr P D Milroy Mr A J Murdoch Mr T J H Townshend Mr J P Wilson MA F Coll P


annual gazette | 83 1969 Mr R Braund Mr P G Cleary Mr N I Garnett Mr B C Heald Dr C J D Maile Mr I C Melia Mr M G Pillar Mr W R Siberry QC Professor J R Wiesenfeld Mr N S Wild 1970 Dr J R Deane Dr W S Gould Mr A J C Graham Mr N A MacKinnon Mr A McDonald Dr H J Perkins Mr I R Purser Mr D A Walter 1971 Mr P Bowman Mr W C M Dastur Mr R H Johnson Dr R Kinns Mr M H Thomas 1972 Mr S C Lord Mr C D Newell Mr A G Singleton 1973 The Rt Hon Sir Patrick Elias Dr P R D H Greenhouse FRCOG Mr K J Russell Mr S J N Shepherd 1974 Mr M T Adger Mr A L C Byatt Dr K A Foster FRSB The Rt Hon Sir Charles HaddonCave PC Mr A S Ivison Dr A J Makai Dr C V Nowikow JP Mr S G Trembath 1975 Mr P W Blackmore Mr S E de Somogyi Dr R A Hood QVRM TD DL Sir Richard Jacobs Mr A J V McCallum

1976

1977

1978

1979

1980

1981

1982

1983

1984

Mr D A Rew QVRM TD Mr P R Sanford Mr R B Sloan Dr K P Van Anglen Mr M N Armstrong Mr M C Bullock Dr M J Burrows Mr N P McNelly Mr P C Nicholls Mr C P Robb Mr N J Brooks Mr J E SymesThompson FRICS Major General S M Andrews CBE C Eng FIET Revd Father J C Finnemore Mr M K Jackson Mr M Russell-Jones Mr C D C Savage Mr D S Walden Mr P S J Derham OBE Dr L J Reeve FRHistS Brigadier W J F Kingdon Mr J P Snoad Mr M E Bartlett Dr I M McClure Mr S D Morgan Mr A Rahman Mr I C Carter FRSA Mr J S Davison Mr D J Hitchcock OBE Mr C S Teng Mr D M Benton Mr D N Pether Mr M J Pollitt Dr S J Rosenberg Mr L R Somerville Dr P Wilson Mr J R Baker Ms V J Bowman Mrs C F Holmes Mr A D Marcus Ms J M L Prior

1985 1986

1987 1988

1989 1990 1991

1992

1994

1995 1997

1998 2000 2001 2003

Dr D S Richardson MA FRCP Mr J M Furniss Mr C M F Viner Mr J P Johnstone Mr R D R Stark Mr J M Wolfson Miss C M Thomé Mr A E K Vanderlip Mr N K C Chan Dr B J J Dent FRGS Mr D L Gilinsky Ms N J McCabe Mr A T McIntyre Mr A R Read Mr B J L Wilkinson Mr R W Bayly Miss L Rice Dr C L Hansen Dr L J Walker Ms D Batstone Mr B J S Bell Dr S A Heise Dr G P Shields Professor J P Parry Dr V A Pugsley Mrs C E Stanwell Professor A M R Taylor Sir Roger Tomkys KCMG DL Mr M A BagnallOakeley Dr A Guha Mr H P Raingold Ms H E M Walton Mr J P Jackson Mr A R Danson Mr A R B A Mydellton Mr G F Watts Ms J A Davies Mr H R Perren Mr A W Morris ARAM Miss V A Skinner Mr G R I LlewellynSmith Mrs H J Williamson Dr M G Williamson


84 | pembroke college 2004 Mrs J A GoreRandall Mr J Mayne 2006 Mr M R Mellor 2009 Mr G O Ulmann

2011 Miss C L Sutherell Mrs A Beckley Mr W F Charnley

Miss C A Hammersley Mrs M Quinn Mr M A Quinn Dr A Strazzera

The College apologises for any inadvertent omissions, and invites members willing to see their names listed in future to write accordingly to Janette Skinner or Mariola Thorpe at the College. Bequests The College acknowledges with gratitude the following bequests which were received between 1 July 2020 and 30 June 2021: 1946 Professor M C Lyons £202,997 1947 Mr P R Langham MC & Mrs M E Langham £1,000,000 1949 Mr E D Peacock £7,500 Mr J R Beckley £4,000 1951 Mr A M Hall-Smith £1,000

1954 1956 1962 1963

The Rt Revd H F de Waal £1,000 Professor D H Mellor £5,000 Mr M R Riley £7,500 Dr G B Houston a further £752 Mr S C Palmer £2,500 1976 Mr N G Walker £10,000

A Gift to Pembroke in Perpetuity, helpful information on making a legacy, can be obtained by telephoning Janette Skinner or Mariola Thorpe on (01223) 339079, writing to the Development Office, or emailing do3@pem.cam.ac.uk. J.C.D.H.

Master’s Society The 19th meeting of the Master’s Society was held over Zoom on Saturday 13 March 2021. The Master talked with three junior members about their experiences of learning at Pembroke over lockdown and there was a presentation of the Mill Lane Development by Beatie Blakemore of Haworth Tompkins. Professor Rebecca Kilner, Professor of Evolutionary Biology, closed proceedings with a talk on the Museum of Zoology, where she is the Director. Between the talks two recordings of Frank Huo (2017), current junior member, performing Fauré’s Barcarolle in G Flat, Op. 42 and Chopin’s Barcarolle in F Sharp, Op. 60 were played. The Master thanked all members of the Society for their generous support. Membership of the Society is open to anyone who has made gifts totalling £2,000 or more to the College in the financial year prior to the event; invitations are also sent to donors for the two years following a gift of £5,000 or more, and for five years following a gift of £10,000 or more. Donors of £50,000 or more will be granted indefinite membership of the Society. To all, the College is very grateful. The date of the next Master’s Society Lunch, the twentieth, is Saturday 20 March 2022.


annual gazette | 85

THE VALENCE MARY (1997) ENDOWMENT FUND The value of the Valence Mary (1997) Endowment Fund stood at £3,568,396 on 31 March 2021, compared with £3,080,820 a year earlier. It is largely invested in equities. The time weighted return in the period was +19.3%. A copy of the accounts is available from Matthew Mellor (Development Director and Steward of the College). The Trust thanks David Miller (1977) for his continued good advice with regard to the Trust’s investments.


86 | pembroke college

COLLEGE CLUBS AND SOCIETIES BOAT CLUB 2020–2021 Captain of Boats:Tom Sharp Women’s Captain: Abby Robinson Men’s Captain: Toby Chesser

2021–2022 Captain of Boats: István Bence Kovács Women’s Captain: Molly Foxwell Men’s Captain: Hamish Elder

Throughout this bizarre year, PCBC has remained a vibrant community with great successes on and off the water. Easter term saw ten full Pembroke crews training, racing, and having fun in the sun on the river but it was no smooth ride to get there! I had never seen PCBC train as much over the summer vacation as we did last summer – Toby and Abby’s ‘Panvalencian Games’ gave rowers and coxes a chance to get fit and have fun while competing in teams for points. This got all our members ready and keenly anticipating a return to rowing in Michaelmas. We were proud to be the first college boat club to get eights back on the Cam after summer when we started our pre-season training in September. It quickly became clear that we would have plenty of strength and depth to the crews on both sides this year and soon we were planning to enter six senior eights into Fairbairn’s. New arrivals with previous rowing experience at their schools, previous clubs and even GB junior programmes joined our PCBC returners to produce some truly rapid senior crews for so early in the year. It was a real shame not to be able to race in the Fairbairn’s Cup but nonetheless it was a real joy simply to be back on the Cam and going fast. PCBC’s head coach, Seb Matthews, has probably been up and down the towpath more than anyone else in Cambridge this year. Seb’s friendly and relaxed coaching style pairs well with a determination to see rowers of all levels in the club dig deep to find every last bit of speed they can muster. A quick, dynamic catch and a smaller tap-down to have blades closer to the water on the recovery are now distinctive hallmarks of the Pembroke rowing stroke that Seb has introduced to the club. Seb’s coaching is well supplemented by the return of PCBC alumni to coach crews throughout the year which not only makes our crews faster but really maintains the sense of community and longevity in the club that we all love so much. Without swaps this year, members found new and safe ways to have fun together. Our new social secretary, Ben, did an awesome job of arranging activities in whatever formats were possible at any given time. In addition, group cycle rides brought members of different crews together and were made all the snazzier by PCBC’s brand new cycling kit. Once Fairbairn’s had officially been cancelled and the boathouse closed for lockdown, focus naturally turned towards Lent term and so our senior rowers started making good use of the outdoor ergs in the gazebo (fondly known as the Gazergbo) on the Red Buildings’ lawn. Slowly but surely, it became clear that no rowing would be possible in Lent term. PCBC members kept busy with the Panvalencian Games II, Bewl Bridge Virtual Erg Regatta and, of course, the Pembroke Regatta which was held as a virtual running competition this year. It was especially good fun to have a good number of PCBC


annual gazette | 87 alumni teams competing in the virtual regatta and we very much hope to welcome as many alumni crews as possible in Cambridge for next year’s regatta. Through the long weeks of lockdowns, Pembroke Circuits Society (CircSoc) played a crucial role in the weekly training of many rowers with PCBC’s own Toby, Rob, Charles and Ben running weekly circuits sessions over Zoom. It now has members from various college boat clubs and even the Master joined for a session. CircSoc sports kit can often be seen on the river as a reminder of the unexpected and welcome phenomenon that CircSoc has become in Cambridge’s college rowing community. April came, lockdowns eased, and the boat club roared back into action. Novice rowers and coxes finally got enough water time to get into ‘swing’ of rowing and the senior crews started training hard for a term of racing. Covid safety measures saw our members training a little differently and with more of an emphasis on water training. This certainly kept PCBC’s coxes busy and coxing captain Amy did an excellent job of helping the club’s many new coxes find their feet. Kevin, who had put in the long hours over successive lockdowns getting everything ship-shape at the boathouse, was pleased to see students back and we tried our best to not give him too much repair work to do over the term. It has been another stunning year for Cambridge in the boat races, with Pembroke rowers Laura Stewart and Rob Harris contributing to their crews’ respective wins against Oxford at Ely in the women’s lightweight crew and Goldie crew. PCBC members and alumni were cheering the light blue crews on from their homes while following the races with PCBC’s boat race watching party at which we were treated to boat race insights from PCBC alumnae Cath Bishop (1989) and Georgina Charlesworth (1988). With May Bumps cancelled for safety concerns, PCBC’s top crews instead focused on head races and regattas and picked up some great results. W1 were consistently one of the fastest women’s crews on the Cam, taking first place in the IV in Spring Head-to-Head and another first place in the Radegund Mile in the VIII. W1 were struck by Covid isolations for the June Eights Regatta but still managed solid wins over the Pembroke Regatta course against LMBC and Queens’. M1 took second place at Head of the Cam and second again at 99’s Regatta where they beat Christ’s and Downing before losing in the final to a rapid Magdalene M1. M1 could not quite replicate these results in the June Eights Regatta but M2 put in a fantastic performance in the regatta to win the second division. For more race results, news and updates, please do have a look at our social media pages and newly refurbished website and never hesitate to get in touch, either by email or on the website. This year, PCBC is delighted to announce the launch of the PCBC alumni boat club for alumni and friends of the club to help those (like myself!) who wish to keep in contact and stay involved in PCBC long after their time at Pembroke. We look forward to seeing students and alumni alike involved in all things PCBC next year, from Pembroke Regatta to May Bumps and plenty more besides, and we look forward to another fantastic year at the boathouse. Row on PCBC! Tom Sharp


88 | pembroke college CRICKET Without students in Cambridge during last year’s Easter Term, the Pembroke Cricket team entered the summer with a squad composed primarily of players with no college cricketing experience. We started the season with our first Cuppers match away against Girton College; batting first under some cloudless skies that would prove to be rare throughout the season, our team which included 9 debutants took the match to a last over finish, but unfortunately it did not end in our favour. We then moved towards our first home fixture against 2019 Cuppers victors Fitzwilliam College. Despite our groundsman Trev’s tremendous efforts, the match was called off and we would have to wait to make our home appearance against Caius. Our match against Caius was scheduled for the end of a rain-filled week, and fortunately we managed to play a full-length match. Despite a strong bowling performance, we fell well short with the bat and would have to continue to wait for our first win of the season. In what would prove to be our final Cuppers match of the season, we played Corpus Christi College on a hot Thursday afternoon. Coming into the match 2 players short, we batted first and posted what seemed a low total of 75-All Out. Some impressive, consistent bowling and an excellent fielding performance made up for our reduced numbers and kept Corpus under control, bringing us into the last over with Corpus on 68–9. The third ball of the over struck the stumps and announced our first and only victory of the short season. During this truncated season we had a very strong core of first year players, and we can look forward to a stronger Cuppers run next year with this year’s experiences aiding us. Sam Beer (Captain 2020–21, and 2021–22)

FOOTBALL (MEN’S) 2020–2021 1st XI Captain: Rob Wong Vice-Captain: Will Holmes Secretary: Tele Agusto 2nd XI Captain: Fred Holker 3rd XI Captain: Josh Cudby

2021–2022 1st XI Captain: Tele Agusto Vice-Captain: Ollie Reed Secretary: Matt Hawthorn 2nd XI Captain: Joe Steane 3rd XI Captain: David Moleski

Fresh off a successful title winning season in division 2 and an uncharacteristically early exit in Cuppers the previous year, the club had lofty expectations to meet in division 1 this season. With several strong players having left during the summer, this was no easy task and this year’s large fresher intake definitely came at the right moment. Pre-season saw an outstanding 6–2 win against Robinson, most notably a memorable performance from fresher Jack Seery who, in his first game for the


annual gazette | 89 club, arrived midway through the second half and scored a quickfire hat trick before subbing himself off. Unfortunately, our first two official fixtures were less successful – playing against two of the strongest teams in Cambridge in Caius and Fitz gave us little to no time to properly adapt to division 1. Our first league game at Caius ended in an undeserved 4–0 defeat, with our team creating good chances but unable to convert, hitting the woodwork on several occasions. This was followed immediately by a rollercoaster of a game against Fitz – a game in which we found ourselves 4–3 up with just five minutes to go, but ultimately ended up losing 4–5. Despite coming away with no points to begin the season, the raw talent in our team was clear to see and we all knew how good a team we had this year. Rather predictably, Covid-19 threw the season into disarray and on the eve of our first Cuppers fixture, lockdown was announced. A temporary pause to the season snowballed into the entire league season being voided, leaving Cuppers as the year’s only competition. This suited us perfectly, given it is seemingly PCAFC tradition to show up for Cuppers games only, and our final game before lockdown showed exactly this. Going back to Caius for a rematch, a gritty performance saw some beautiful attacking football, exquisite defensive clearances, and phenomenal saves by Cam Keith with the score 3–3 after extra time, which meant the dreaded penalties were upon us. Cool and calm heads prevailed for the first two, but they managed to save our third, leaving us behind. A solid save by Cam brought us level, before their final penalty hit the bar. This meant that our next penalty was a chance to win the game – unfortunately, it was captain Rob Wong’s turn to take and he’s had an impressive run of penalty misses over the past years. Luckily, this time was different and he found the back of the net, providing all of us with a great high before going into lockdown We started off Easter Term with the hunger of a team that had gone half a year without a match, beating Emma comprehensively 6–0 in the last 16 of cuppers. Haydn Francis and Rob Perry delivered particularly decisive performances with a hat-trick and two goals from centre back respectively. This set up an away fixture against John’s in the quarter finals. Despite a difficult first 15 minutes, we were able to dig deep and frustrate the opposition before clinical finishing in the second half gave a 2–0 win much to the dismay of the home crowd. The semifinal fixture against Fitzwilliam just four days later was a frustrating one. An early Fitz goal was quickly cancelled out by Gareth Morgan who continued his fantastic cuppers scoring streak. Despite stoic defending and some fantastic saves from Cam Keith we conceded twice more once in unlucky circumstances. But ultimately, although we were unable to reach the final, we once again proved to be one of the finest college teams at Cambridge. Much like Italy at the Euros so far, our Easter term run was made possible by having fantastic players in every position and working together as a team, such that we didn’t rely too heavily on any one player. Cuppers provided a very welcome distraction this term – the return of football showed us how much we love this game and there’s no better place to play it in Cambridge than at PCAFC. Rob Wong and Tele Agusto


90 | pembroke college RUGBY Captains: Max Murphy (Pembroke) and Tom Allen (Girton) This is the second year that Pembroke and Girton have come together to create the best combined college rugby team in Cambridge: Pirton. Naturally, the pandemic made it a difficult season for us – especially given that rugby involves a lot of close contact. Nevertheless, we still managed to have a brilliant year. During the summer, in light of the Black Lives Matter protests that were happening around the world, we decided to run 400 miles to raise money for Show Racism the Red Card – an anti-racism charity that focusses on getting rid of racism from sport. We ended up raising over £2000. Ensuring that we are an inclusive rugby team is something that we have continued to emphasise throughout the year. By the time we arrived back in Cambridge, lots of new freshers from both Pembroke and Girton had joined the team. Because of Covid-19, the games throughout this term were non-contact – but to be honest when we saw the size of some of the players from other colleges, we weren’t really complaining. Our first tournament was at Girton. Having progressed all the way from Division 4 at the start of last season to Division 1 by the end of it, the pressure was on for us to show what Pirton were about. Despite not having trained together at all, we went on to win most of our games. Unfortunately, as Michaelmas went on, more and more of us ended up having to self-isolate which meant that we never really got the chance to play as a full team – but we did have a tournament towards the end of term (where we won all but one of our games). In Lent Term we weren’t able to play any rugby – but come Easter term we were all ready and excited to go again. We started by playing a tournament where we beat both Emma and Fitz, proving ourselves as worthy Division 1 members. One of the highlights of the season, which took place a few weeks later, was the social touch tournament. We entered it with our first ever mixed men’s and women’s Pirton team. Thanks to the women from Pembroke and Girton – who knew the best strategies for non-contact rugby – we won several games. To mark the end of the season, we entered the first contact tournament of the year. None of us had played contact for over a year. Our first match was against John’s. It turns out playing this college is much more difficult when tackling is required – the size difference between us and them made it look more like a Year 7 vs Year 11 school football game than a college rugby match. Five of us ended up in Addenbrooke’s – ranging from a split-open lip to a broken finger. Nonetheless, those of the team who survived the initial battering did very well to only narrowly lose to Caius and Robinson. With some training at the start of next season, we’ll be ready to go back to contact rugby which is what we all enjoy the most. Overall, despite the circumstances, we had a great season – and we are very excited for new members to join Pirton next year. We’re very grateful to Trevor Munns, the groundsman, for keeping the playing fields in perfect condition


92 | pembroke college With Covid restrictions over-shadowing all College events, the afternoon quickly became much more complicated than anticipated. But with the solid planning of two engineers and with the good luck of some gorgeous weather, many came to play and enjoy strawberries and cream in bubbles of six throughout the afternoon. PCTC had been re-born. That afternoon had produced three men’s teams, a women’s team and a growing list of avid social tennis players. James and I had also surreptitiously been on the scout for what later became ‘PCTC Heroes 2020/21’: more Captains. It was decided that James would Captain the men’s teams, Hermione Wright would Captain the women’s team and I would arrange a new PCTC initiative – social tennis. The world subsequently gave us three weeks before another Covid lockdown arrived. These weeks were some of the busiest for PCTC this year. They saw the strengthening of our women’s and men’s first teams with regular outdoor (astroturf ) and indoor (Hills Road) tennis sessions, put into practice during matches against other colleges in the Michaelmas League. Social tennis grew rapidly with a regular Sunday slot where 20–30 Pembroke students of all years met and knocked about. We also had a week-long tournament ‘swap’ against Gonville & Caius College, which culminated in an evening of Covid-safe socializing across Cambridge. The November lockdown sadly resulted in us no longer being able to organize tennis. Nevertheless, we were fortunate enough to be able to continue to play singles tennis on one of the courts as a form of daily exercise. To facilitate this, we set up a platform that enabled both our social tennis and team players to join a tennis ladder on an app, allowing them to challenge other players to a singles hit and us to safely provide some much-needed social interaction during this difficult period. The new, tougher lockdown in the new year was another blow to the club’s ambitions. We were unable to play at all throughout Lent term. Good news came soon, however. Tennis was back on for the Easter term. As students came back to Cambridge for exam term, our Cuppers run began and social tennis started up again. It was great to see tennis finally being played on the grass courts. For the weeks before the exam period, it really felt like life had returned to PCTC. Despite a short hiatus as Cambridge suddenly went quiet and exam papers were written, our men’s first team continued to show their strength against other colleges in Cuppers, reaching the final! Our women’s and lower men’s teams also put in a valiant effort in their respective cuppers draws. Further, preparations were underway for a summer tournament in what would have otherwise been May Week. PCTC came together on Sunday 20th June 2021 for a big summer tournament across our nine courts. It was a wonderful opportunity for our women’s teams, men’s teams and social tennis players to finally meet over our shared passion. A week later, the men’s first team played Churchill College in the Cuppers final. We put in a very strong performance, but this was unfortunately not quite


annual gazette | 93 enough to beat the even stronger team they put forward. I am sure the team would join me in saying what a delight and honour it was to play these matches on the beautiful grass courts under the sun, making memories that will last a lifetime. Overall it has been an extraordinary year for PCTC. Despite the odds, we were able to build a thriving community of tennis players from all across Pembroke. It was a pleasure to see freshers meeting PhD students, completely unaware they were talking with someone many years older than themselves. My thanks goes to everyone that has made this possible, to name but a few: Hermione, James, Jovan and David for their work on the committee; Tibo and Jay for their continued advice as previous Captains; Trevor for his amazing work on the grounds; Lily for her belief in the club in the GAC allocation; and all our members who brought life and soul to PCTC 2020/21. Igor Sterner

CIRCUITS SOCIETY Pembroke College Circuits Society (CircSoc) came into existence in the closing weeks of Easter term 2019, but came into its own under the unprecedented circumstances of lockdown. In happier times CircSoc met weekly across from the college boat house to exercise together in wind, rain or shine. Burpees in the mud are not an attractive proposition at the best of times, so the societies’ committee were surprised when, during a global pandemic, the club took on more participants than ever before, from Pembroke and beyond. The society began amongst a group of friends, gathered in the New Common Room for a leaving party. This small group dared to ask the biggest of questions: What if a well-worn collection of bodyweight exercises could be something more? What if instead of just spending time together, this group of friends could do exactly what they had been doing for months, but also be a ‘committee’ of a ‘society’? What if, and, if so, how much would stash cost? From such noble beginnings, a committee of Charles Dudley, Rob Perry, Ben Hatton, Toby Chesser and Dan Shailer began holding circuits in much the same way they had done in the past, but now (crucially) under the auspices of CircSoc. In the early days of the society, few chose to turn up – to the extent that often the very same committee members who initiated the society forgot to set alarms or found themselves (by tragic but immovable coincidence) otherwise engaged. All of this would change in March 2020, when students were asked not to return to Pembroke for Easter Term. Without lectures to sleep through and academic work to procrastinate, the committee found themselves in dire need of structure to give lockdown meaning and began to attempt ‘virtual’ circuits. At first, only a handful of dedicated circuiteers clocked onto Zoom every Friday afternoon, but soon a second weekly session was introduced for those locking down in different time zones. Before long students of other colleges began to join and – even after an unexpected second lockdown – the CircSoc community grew. This culminated in the one year anniversary of virtual CircSoc: a celebration of Zooming through circuits, introduced by the Master, Lord Chris Smith.


94 | pembroke college Over two years have passed since its inception and Pembroke College Circuits’ Society’s membership now stands at over a hundred students and academics from eight different colleges. It has a logo (a martlet so keen for circuits it grew limbs), a motto and, all importantly, stash to put them on. In all that time has CircSoc lost its roots? If its roots are doing circuits, probably not. It is fair to say that after a bumper year, Easter Term ended with a whimper: over half of the committee self-isolating and no May Week Circuits (a tradition of CircSoc held the morning immediately following the Pembroke May Ball). Three of the committee have also now graduated from Pembroke, but we are hopeful that the legacy of CircSoc – virtually and in person – will live on in the burpees, sit-ups and spotty dogs of future circuiteers. Dan Shailer

MUSIC SOCIETY PCMS President: Sam Barrett PCMS Senior Treasurer: Andrew Morris PCMS Secretary: Joe Beadle The Pembroke College Music Society (PCMS) has taken on new life this year, steered with enthusiasm by Mr Andrew Morris and a committee comprised of Joseph Beadle, Owen Saldanha, Sam Weinstein, Lily Young, Lucy Holland, Anfu Wang, and Frank Huo. Committed to providing a supportive platform for musicians of all abilities to showcase their talents, PCMS revived its free, biweekly concert series at 2pm on Saturdays in term-time, at first held in the United Reformed Church (URC) on Trumpington Street. Michaelmas Term began in style with a concert by the Freshers. Tom Myles performed a clarinet sonata by Saint-Saëns; Annie Brown a flute sonata by C.P.E. Bach; Fraser Gaffney a clarinet bagatelle by Finzi; Tom de Csilléry a movement from Ysaÿe’s Sonata No. 2 for violin; Joseph Steane and Joel Penrose a Viotti cello duet; and Jonathan Bingham, Cameron Scott, Tamir Smith and Noam SolomonsWise joined forces as a jazz quartet. It was the promise of an exciting year to come for PCMS. For the second Michaelmas concert, we were most fortunate to hear current PhD student at Pembroke, Laurence Cochrane, together with fellow Cambridge PhD students Peter Asimov and June Park, perform Dvořák’s Piano Trio No. 4 in E minor, op. 90 (“Dumky”) and Mendelssohn’s Piano Trio No. 2 in C minor, op. 66. The audience greeted their interpretations with rapturous applause. A sure highlight of Michaelmas term was the Kenderdine Concert. Kenderdine Concerts are given by guest artists to commemorate the commitment to College music of the late Dr Sidney Kenderdine, past President of PCMS. This year’s Kenderdine Concert was an organ recital in the Chapel by Pembroke’s own Director of Music, Anna Lapwood, ahead of her live recording on BBC Radio 3. Anna offered a thrilling programme of works by Patrick Gowers, Owain Park, Maurice Ravel, Philip Moore, and Kerensa Briggs. It truly was most fitting that


annual gazette | 95 Anna performed on the organ that Sidney Kenderdine was so instrumental in creating and on which he often played, and we remain grateful for her support of PCMS over the course of this challenging year. PCMS was determined not to let the lockdown of November 2020 inhibit its renewed momentum, adapting swiftly to virtual concerts, whereby performers recorded their pieces individually and sent them to be compiled into YouTube playlists later circulated to the wider College community. The first of these Fraser Gaffney’s one man clarinet trio featured Keyi Yu’s performance of traditional Chinese songs on her guzheng (古箏 a Chinese plucked zither); Fraser Gaffney’s technical feat of a one-man performance of Mozart’s Divertimento III for three clarinets; Jonathan Bingham and Hamish Elder’s flute and guitar duet of the traditional tune ‘Marcin’s Mazurka’; Owen Saldanha’s performance of a dazzling piano etude by Kapustin; and Joseph Beadle’s performance of Frederick Stocken’s mysterious and turbulent ‘Archangels’ triptych for organ. PCMS’ final concert of Michaelmas Term, again broadcast online, was a delightful rendering of Mozart’s Clarinet Quintet in A Major, K.581, given by clarinetist Tom Myles, first violinist Elizabeth Webb, second violinist Emma Paterson, violist Julius Kiln, and cellist Seth Collin. Countless College members, students and Fellows alike, voiced their gratitude to the society for continuing to provide a transient escape from the otherwise troubling times, and for fostering a sense of ‘unity in isolation’ in the College community. Two more virtual concerts displayed PCMS’ characteristic perseverance and ingenuity in Lent Term, which the majority of students underwent virtually from home. The first, recorded in Hefei, China, was Frank Huo’s inventive piano recital of the music of Chopin and Fauré. Frank presented Frank Huo performing Chopin and Fauré three pairs of impromptus, nocturnes and barcarolles in the same key by each composer. The creative artistry and technical brilliance of Frank’s playing were unforgettable. The second was a variety concert that featured Anfu Wang’s piano performance of ‘Colourful Clouds Chasing the Moon’ (彩雲追月) by Wang Jianzhong 王建中; Sam Weinstein’s interpretation of the first movement from Debussy’s Cello Sonata; Tom de Csilléry’s dramatic presentation of Ysaÿe’s ‘Ballade’ from Sonata No.3 for violin; Joseph Beadle’s jazz piano rendition of Hiromi’s ‘The Tom and Jerry Show’; and Owen Saldanha’s piano performance of Debussy’s ‘La Cathédrale Engloutie’ and Rachmaninoff ’s Prelude in G Major.


96 | pembroke college Following the return of most students for Easter Term, PCMS ushered in the joyful return of in-person music-making with four more concerts. The first was another variety concert held in the URC. Keyi Yu returned to perform and inform the audience about her guzheng; Frank Huo delivered an elegant reprise of two barcarolles by Fauré and Chopin; and Joel Keyi Yu’s guzheng Penrose captured the emotional intensity of the first movement from Debussy’s Cello Sonata in D Minor, L.135, and Bloch’s ‘Prayer’ from ‘Jewish Life,’ B.54, accompanied by Owen Saldanha. The second concert was headlined by the JTN Trio, starring Pembroke’s very own first-year musician Noam Solomons-Wise on drum kit, Queens’ College musician Tamir Smith on double bass, and prospective applicant Jay Carlin on piano and vocals. The jazz trio welcomed guest soloist and first-year music student at Pembroke, Jonathan Bingham on saxophone. Their exhilarating programme delighted a foot-tapping audience that filled the URC to maximum capacity (according to social distancing measures). The third concert of Easter Term was a virtuosic solo piano recital by Pembroke’s outgoing Senior Organ Scholar and fourth-year engineering student Owen Saldanha, performed in the Master’s Lodge on a sunny May afternoon to a limited audience. Owen divided his programme into three parts: jazz/classical fusion, which featured works by Kapustin and Gershwin; French Impressionism, which presented pieces by Debussy, Ravel and Morel; and Romanticism, which showcased a Rachmaninoff prelude and a Chopin ballade. A choir of chirping birds in the trees outside made for an unexpected, tranquil accompaniment to Owen’s exquisite playing. The society remains most grateful to the Master for hosting Owen’s recital. PCMS’ 2020–21 concert series came to a truly beautiful end with a performance of Brahms’ Clarinet Quintet in B minor, op. 115 in the Chapel, delivered skillfully by clarinetist Tom Myles, first violinist Tom de Csilléry, second violinist Emma Paterson, violist Julius Kiln, and cellist Seth Collins. The committee and Director of Music, Anna Lapwood enjoyed a splendid barbecue to celebrate the conclusion of this busy and fruitful year for PCMS. In a year in which cancellations have been many and disappointments inevitable, PCMS’ endeavour to let the music play on has been relished by its performers and audience members alike. For this, I end with sincere thanks to the committee for their dedication in overcoming the countless challenges of the Covid-era, all this year’s performers for their eagerness, and the audiences, both physical and virtual, that have supported them. Whether enjoyed in-person or virtually, this year’s dynamic concert series has provided solace and pleasure as we look back, and has promised variety and excitement as we look forward to those of years to come. Joe Beadle


annual gazette | 97 THE COLLEGE CHOIRS The past 12 months have, in many ways, been incredibly challenging. Trying to maintain the musical life and identity of the College through constantly changing guidance was no mean feat! It has, however, provide us with constant opportunities to innovate, rebuild, and reflect on what it is that is important to us. We began Michaelmas term with the excitement of releasing our first choral album All Things are Quite Silent, recorded the previous year. The album, made possible thanks to a generous donation from Christine Hansen, brought together the chapel choir and girls’ choir to sing some of their favourite repertoire. The recording itself was one of the highlights of the previous year, but we were all excited and nervous to see how it was received! We were thrilled to receive some really positive reviews in Gramophone, BBC Music Magazine, Classics Today and MusicWeb International with a five star review in Choir & Organ. The CD has now passed over two million streams online – copies can still be purchased online or from the Porters’ Lodge if you haven’t had a chance to listen yet! Following the excitement of our album launch, we jumped straight into a busy Michaelmas Term. The newly-acquired United Reformed Church enabled both choirs to continue to meet and sing together in full, with a socially-distanced congregation. Over the past couple of years, the social impact of choral singing has become increasingly obvious and relevant. As such, we decided that chapel choir Evensongs would be followed by socially distanced pizza and the occasional Disney sing-a-long: really important moments for the students to momentarily leave all thoughts of the Pandemic to one side and have a vaguely normal student experience. As national and local cases increased we gradually pared back our forces, first moving to streamed, congregation-less services (sans pizza), then reducing the choir, and eventually stopping altogether. We have been very lucky not to have any outbreaks of Covid-19 in either of our choirs – it’s reassuring to know that all the measures put in place seem to work! Having had to stop all singing by the end of Michaelmas term we had one particularly moving moment just before all the singers went home: there were some fireworks to mark the end of the term in a positive way, and bring the college community together on the bowling green. Just as the fireworks finished, the choir stepped onto the lawn holding candles and sang Silent Night, the whole college watching on in total silence. We didn’t realise at the time that this would be the last in-person singing we would do in several months! Our Lent Term was almost entirely virtual, mostly revolving around weekly zoom rehearsals. As a Director of Music, my challenge became trying to find ways to help the choirs retain a sense of identity and purpose – I was becoming increasingly aware that all their learning was taking place on zoom, so choir rehearsals had to offer something different. The girls’ choir had a visiting speaker come to answer questions at the end of every rehearsal, with guests including Jess Gillam, Georgia Mann, Katie Derham and Errollyn Wallen. In addition to their weekly rehearsals, the chapel choir had a weekly masterclass or talk on a whole range of topics from sightreading and tuning through to Renaissance polyphony with Peter Phillips and a more general Q&A with Roderick Williams.


98 | pembroke college In-person singing didn’t stop altogether, though! We were very lucky that two of our sopranos, Hannah & Zoe, had stayed in College and were in a household with Coco, chapel clerk. We worked with the Dean to make sure that there were at least two sung services coming out of the college chapel every week – a simple service of Compline by candlelight, and Sunday Eucharist. I’m extremely grateful to Hannah, Zoe, Coco and James for entering into these services with such positivity, and I think we all found them to be a bit of a lifeline throughout the Lent term. The streaming of the services was made possible by another very generous donation from Bobby King which facilitated the purchase of livestreaming equipment. We realised relatively early on that we were likely to have to fuse online and in-person music-making for the foreseeable future, and sure enough the livestreaming equipment has proven essential to the continuation of our activities this year. Being forced online offered numerous other opportunities for innovation. Both choirs have been exploring composition over the past year or so, with the composer Ola Gjeilo doing a Q&A with the chapel choir about writing for choral ensembles. Several members of the chapel choir have now furnished us with new pieces which we were able to sing when we were finally back in the same room again. The girls’ choir, meanwhile, have been building on their collaborative composition project started last academic year, and were thrilled to hear the BBC Singers give the premiere of ‘The Pembroke Carol’ live on BBC Radio 3. The chapel choir have also been working alongside me and one of our sopranos, Ellie, in running the NHS Chorus-19, a virtual choir made up of over 1,000 NHS staff from across the UK. Our Pembroke choristers have helped support the choir in recording for various projects and events over the course of the year, including singing the National Anthem for the Caraboa Cup Final at Wembley Stadium. Singing at Pembroke is certainly varied…! One positive of not being able to meet in person during Lent term was that when we finally were all allowed to sing together at the start of Easter term we appreciated it so much more. We took a cautious approach throughout the term, starting off with small groups of singers in rotas, and not permitting a congregation other than those people involved in the service itself. The small group singing was a valuable chance to rebuild the sound of the chapel choir step by step after such a long break, but I have to say it was a wonderful moment when, halfway through the term, we were allowed to bring the whole choir back together again. With stringent measures in place (including 2m distancing, masks, and the singers all taking a lateral flow test before every rehearsal), we were able to have the full choir singing together for the last few weeks of term. At the same time, we were allowed to bring the Girls’ Choir back into the college chapel having kept them separate in the URC for the rest of the year. The easing of restrictions was also marked by a very special concert in the URC, given by our College-musician Joseph Middleton alongside mezzo-soprano Sarah Connolly. The recital sold out within an hour of tickets going on sale – the appetite for live music-making has certainly not gone away – and it was a really extraordinary occasion. Whilst we still couldn’t have a congregation in the chapel, we found ways to bring the college community together for the traditional end of term events. The


annual gazette | 99 final Compline of term took place outside in the chapel cloister with a congregation standing around the court, accompanied by an incredible sunset and the sound of a blackbird singing along. A team of choristers then worked hard to decorate the cloister for our May Week Evensong, covering all the pillars with flowers. The congregation sat outside and the choir sang half of the service in the chapel and the rest of it outside. By the end of the service, a small crowd of students and staff had gathered to hear the final piece of music which proved to be an emotional way to end the year. The service was followed by a choir dinner in the Dean’s garden: an opportunity to say goodbye to our outgoing choir members and our senior organ scholar, Owen Saldanha. The end of term was also marked by Pembroke College Bach-a-thon, now in its fifth year. This year we had 92 organists from all across the world performing the complete organ works of Bach in 24 hours, all raising money to support our musical colleagues in Zambia through the work of the Butterfly Tree and the Muze Trust. People in college often joke that once something has happened three times in a row it may as well have been written into the college statutes – I have a feeling the Bach-a-thon will be an institution for many years to come! Before winding up for the year, we managed to fit in one last hurrah: a new CD recording with the girls’ choir. The recording took place in the chapel and was a wonderful chance for the choristers to work with each other intensively over the course of several days. The sessions were long, with 7 hours of recording on the final day. I think it says it all, though, that when we finished that final session early, the girls asked if they could sing through as many settings of the Magnificat as they could remember. As we look to the future, I hope for the sake of the students that choir might start to look slightly more normal. I think we’re all excited for the day when we can finally stand shoulder to shoulder, take a collective breath, and blast out a hymn in a completely full chapel. Anna Lapwood

JUNIOR PARLOUR President: Lily Young Vice-President: Elise Goddard Treasurer: Aakash Gupta Welfare Officer: Lily Olliver Women’s and Non-Binary Welfare Officer: Izzy Greig Men’s and Non-Binary Welfare Officer: Joseph Edwards BME Officer: Tami Olorunfemi Disabled Students Officer: Alex Parnham-Cope

Women’s and Non-Binary Welfare Officer: Safa Al-Azami Ents Officers: Lucy Giarnese and Georgie Warner Food Officer: Matthew Perry Publicity Officer: Pippa Meek Access Officers: Rosie Bridgwater and James Brownsey Charities Officer: Joel Penrose Green Officer: Grace Blackshaw Accommodation Officer: Lucy Hyde


100 | pembroke college International Students Officer: Muhammad Syed LGBT+ Officer: Callum McKenzie-Finnigan

JP and Bar Officer: James Roy Sports Officer: Anna Gardner

It is fair to say that this year has been like no other for the Junior Parlour Committee. Michaelmas brought its challenges in the forms of planning a socially-distant Freshers Week, navigating a second national lockdown and supporting a rising number of students in self-isolation. Around half the undergraduate population did not return to Cambridge for Lent term, so once again our business was conducted online. This provided an excellent opportunity to hone in on our college committee work. Much work was done behind the scenes during what turned out to be a very busy term for us, and a conscious effort was made to work more closely with the Graduate Parlour Committee. In the Easter term we enjoyed hosting in-person events once more, taking advantage of the easing restrictions and pleasant weather. Without having ever experienced Cambridge in ‘normal’ times, the 2020 matriculation year group has dominated the JPC in numbers and led the way in supporting students and enacting long term change. It is impossible to list all the work done by each officer, but I hope to mention a few highlights. A wide range of events have been put on to foster the lively community at Pembroke. We’ve hosted a bottomless brunch at Revs, a Halloween treasure hunt, a charity quiz which raised £367 for Doctors Without Borders, a virtual halfway hall and a variety of online competitions. I am sure the Ents, Food, JP & Bar and Charities Officers are looking forward to holding more in-person events soon. Look out for JP & Bar Officer James Roy’s college cocktail competition over the summer! Our Welfare Team, elected this Lent term, have done a great job in providing a wide range of activities and support. With tea breaks by the orchard on Friday afternoons in exam term, care packages for female and non-binary students, the provision of sexual health supplies, a menstrual cup scheme, a gender expression fund, an emergency contraception fund, Pride gift sets in June, daily Zoom study sessions in Lent (‘Lockdown Library’), online Zumba sessions and the creation of a collaborative Pembroke Spotify playlist, there has been no shortage of welfare initiatives! Welfare officers also serve a representational role. Actions include working with the GPC to ensure Pembroke signed up to AccessAble (an auditing scheme to enhance the provision of accessibility information), revising the Student Misconduct Procedure to provide greater transparency and support for the students concerned, and conducting a diversity and inclusivity survey to inform discussions next year. Celebrating Black contributions and legacies, then-BME Officer Maya McFarlane’s programme of events for Black History Month was a highlight of Michaelmas term and Women’s and Non-Binary Officer Safa AlAzami followed this superbly with International Women’s Week in Lent. Led by Green Officer Grace Blackshaw, Pembroke Orchard Green Society has had a very successful year. Meeting with senior members of college staff,


annual gazette | 101 lobbying fellows and collecting signatures from students and alumni they successfully campaigned for the College to commit to full divestment from fossil fuels by the end of 2023. Green Week too was a success; challenges and activities involved sustainable cooking, thrifted clothing, room heating, nature photography and composting food waste. The Access Team has also been incredibly busy, running a shadowing scheme and meeting prospective students, producing a variety of video content for the Pembroke YouTube channel (including accommodation tours for both prospective and current students) and organising a student-led focus group with PhD candidate Melissa McCreery. With the first cohort of Foundation Year students arriving in October 2022, we will be watching the scheme closely to see how Pembroke could be involved. Looking ahead to next term, we are very excited for Freshers’ Week to welcome our new students. We look forward to planning a fuller-scale event, but anticipate that some restrictions may still be in place and Covid-related anxieties will not have disappeared. Recognising the growing importance of providing training, this year the Equality and Diversity and Consent Workshops will be outsourced to a professional provider. Though the JPC will remain involved in shaping the content of these workshops, paid professionals will offer their expertise and relieve the JPC and other student volunteers from the task of delivery. To welcome our new students we will also see the return of the Freshers Squash, tours of Cambridge, mingle-sessions, Feminist Society and Green Society events, college family night, drinking and non-drinking events and more. Provided it is safe to do so, we look forward to holding the first Pembroke BOP since January 2020! I would like to thank all the Pembroke staff who have worked side by side with us during this exceptional time; those in the Tutorial Office, in the Porters’ Lodge, in Catering, in Finance, in Maintenance, in Housekeeping, in the Library, the College Nurses, the Tutors, the Fellows who sit on many committees and the Master. Working cooperatively has never been more important and I believe the Pembroke community has come out stronger as a result. Finally I wish to thank each and every JPC member for their resilience and dedication. This year has been challenging to say the least, but they have risen to the occasion and I am very proud to lead them. With strong foundations I look forward to another productive year of representation, collaboration and community-building. Lily Young

GRADUATE PARLOUR President: Eoin Elliott/ Coco Huggins Vice-President: Panos Doudesis Secretary: Bella Boyles Treasurer: Vasileios Frantzis Welfare Officer: Iona Cuthbertson Events Officer A: Ira Shokar

Graduate Parlour Steward: James Cunnison International Officer: Gillian Samios Women’s Officer: Natalie Wallis LGBTQ+ Officer: vacant BAME Officer: Ghaneassha Nadarajan


102 | pembroke college Events Officer B: Savannah Robisch-Chandler External Events Officer: Lori Kregar External Representation Officer: Cristina Santos

Charity Officer: Molly Rowlands Housing Officer: Sarah Gonzalez Environmental Officer: Kate Brockie IT Officer: Jan Blumenkamp 4th Year Representative: Tek Chung

Despite the Covid-19 pandemic blighting the social and academic landscape this year, Pembroke’s Graduate Parlour has continued to evolve and thrive under the everchanging conditions. The academic year saw rapidly shifting tiered restrictions, two national lockdowns and several waves and variants of the coronavirus, but also some great cooperative efforts and achievements in the most difficult of circumstances. Full of hope and anticipation after a summer of easing restrictions and low case numbers, the committee went all out with a very successful ‘blended’ Freshers’ Week 2020, consisting of mixture of in-person and virtual events. The usual subject suppers were replaced by an admittedly far less fancy series of zoom sessions, but the staple Pem favourite of tea and cake was retained, alongside some socially-distanced drinks receptions in the recently acquired United Reform Church (URC) building on Trumpington Street. In-person BAME and LGBTQ+ meet and greets were also able to continue, as well as a College Family night and tours of the college. Michaelmas Term saw the advent of ‘The Household Night’ as a new phenomenon, with themed events packages being sent out to graduates to use with their housemates, sometimes with an added online element. This proved to be a real hit and continued throughout the year. Green hats, shamrocks, gold coins and Guinness in a box accompanied an online playlist of Irish songs for St Patrick’s Day, alongside a take-away cheese and wine tasting bag and an adornment of European regalia for the Eurovision song contest. As well as Household Nights, the GPC instigated virtual Harry Potter movie nights in Lent term, where GP members could join a virtual call and chat whilst watching the films with some popcorn! In Michaelmas, the committee were also able to host socially distanced film screenings at Halloween and Christmas time, which were a great opportunity to meet new and old friends over some classic movies and drinks. As well as Household Nights and (virtual) movie nights, Covid saw the evolution of the regular tea and cake sessions into a Support Group which was able to continue throughout the various lockdowns, providing an invaluable place for grads struggling with isolation, perhaps living alone, to come and meet others outside in Ivy Court. The ‘Welfare Walks’ scheme, started by Events Officer and incoming GP President Ira Shokar, also proved to be hugely popular; graduates could sign up every week to be paired with someone at random from the GP to go for a socially-distanced walk, giving them a valuable opportunity to meet others in the community. This project soon extended to other colleges, including Queens and Jesus, allowing for some welcome inter-collegiate interaction during lockdowns when the only legally-sanctioned form of extrahousehold social-contact was socially-distanced exercise duos… International


annual gazette | 103 Officer, Gillian Samios, also began a language exchange scheme with a similar format, allowing native speakers and/or language learners to be paired up with someone else to practise on walks. This had significant uptake, including a few more challenging requests like Welsh and Hebrew! Weekly virtual yoga classes were also offered to all GP members, as well as a bi-weekly Tuesday zoom quiz in Lent term and an Among Us games night on Wednesdays. The well-loved Pembroke Papers continued with a temporary zoom format as indeed, did all committee meetings. The usual Burns’ Night bonanza was replaced by a Black Watch bagpiper processing around the college grounds, which was a real excitement in the depths of January lockdown. Green Week and International Women’s Week, organised by Kate Brockie and Natalie Wallis in collaboration with the Junior Parlour, were incredible feats of Covid-compromise and included a host of speaker events, initiatives and activities, from new composting bins to Upcycling sessions. Easter welcomed the gradual easing of restrictions and my appearance as the Pembroke Easter bunny, hiding copious amounts of chocolate eggs across the Pembroke College gardens and grounds, accompanied by a set of 12 clues which, if solved, revealed the eggs’ locations. The first team to solve all the clues also received a rather larger chocolate egg as a prize delivered to them, enabling those staying away from Pembroke during the pandemic to also participate and be in with a chance of glory! Easter term also saw the proposed introduction of two new committee positions, Access Officer and Disabilities Officer, designed to boost inclusivity and diversify representation. Joint lobbying by the JPC and GPC also saw Pembroke commit to the Access Able scheme and the infamous KFC (Kitchen Fixed Charge) being reformed to a new Student Facilities scheme. As restrictions have eased, the GPC have successfully hosted an LBGTQ+ garden party and a Prosecco afternoon tea on the college lawns. Grads have also enjoyed a series of formals and BA dinners this summer, thanks to the tireless efforts of the Catering Team. The committee continue to work with the college to make the graduate community a safe and happy place, despite the myriad of issues which continue to befall us in Covid times. I am confident that incoming President Ira Shokar and the rest of the new team will make a success of the next academic year, however difficult the road ahead. Coco Huggins


C. THE COLLEGE RECORD


annual gazette | 107

THE MASTER AND FELLOWS 2020–2021 THE MASTER The Rt Hon Christopher Robert Smith, Baron Smith of Finsbury, PC, MA (1977), PhD (1979)

FELLOWS 1964

James Christopher Durham Hickson, MA (1964), PhD (1966), Life Fellow

1982

Norman Andrew Fleck, MA (1983), PhD (1984), FREng, FRS, Professor of the Mechanics of Materials, Director of the Cambridge Centre for Micromechanics

1984

Michael Christopher Payne, MA (1985), PhD (1985), FRS, Professor of Computational Physics

1985

Trevor Robert Seaward Allan, BCL Oxon, MA (1983), LLD, FBA, Professor of Jurisprudence and Public Law

1992

Jonathan Philip Parry, MA (1982), PhD (1985), Professor of Modern British History, President Mark Roderick Wormald, MA, DPhil Oxon, College Lecturer in English

1993

Donald Robertson, MA (1987), MSc, PhD LSE, University Senior Lecturer in Economics

1994

Loraine Ruth Renate Gelsthorpe, BA Sussex, MPhil (1979), PhD (1985), Professor of Criminology and Criminal Justice Torsten Meißner, MA Bonn, DPhil Oxon, University Senior Lecturer in Classics

1995

Robin James Milroy Franklin, PhD (1992), Professor of Stem Cell Medicine Christopher John Young, MA (1994), PhD (1995), Professor of Modern and Medieval German Studies Silvana Silva Santos Cardoso, BA, MEng Porto, PhD (1994), Professor of Fluid Mechanics and the Environment

1997

Nicholas John McBride, BA, BCL Oxon, College Lecturer and James Campbell Fellow in Law (2000) Nigel Robert Cooper, MA (1995), DPhil Oxon, Professor of Theoretical Physics

1998

Kenneth George Campbell Smith, MA (2000), PhD Melbourne, Professor of Medicine and Head of Department of Medicine, Honorary Consultant Physician, Addenbrooke’s Hospital Lauren Tamar Kassell, BA Haverford, MSc, DPhil Oxon, Professor of History of Science and Medicine

1999

Vikram Sudhir Deshpande, BTech Bombay, MPhil (1996), PhD (1998), Professor of Materials Engineering


108 | pembroke college 2001

Demosthenes Nicholas Tambakis, MA (1993), PhD Princeton, College Lecturer and Pyewacket Fellow in Economics Nilanjana Datta, MA (2008), BSc, MSc Jadavpur, PhD ETH Zurich, Reader in Quantum Information Theory Andrea Carlo Ferrari, Laurea, Politecnico di Milano, PhD (2001), ScD (2013) Professor of Nanotechnology

2002

Rosalind Polly Blakesley, MA (1996), DPhil Oxon, Professor of Russian and European Art

2003

Alexander William Tucker, MA (1989), VetMB (1992), PhD (1997), Reader in Veterinary Public Health

2005

Simon Learmount, MA University of East Anglia, MBA (1996), PhD (2000), University Lecturer in Corporate Governance Samuel James Barrett, BA Oxon, MPhil (1996), PhD (2000), Reader in Early Medieval Music

2006

Alexei Shadrin, MSc, PhD Moscow, Reader in Approximation Theory James Theodore Douglas Gardom, MA Oxon, PhD King’s College London, Dean and Chaplain Katrin Christina Ettenhuber, MA, MPhil (2001), PhD (2005), College Lecturer in English

2007

Matthew Robert Mellor, BA Oxon, MA (2010), Development Director Sir Stephen Patrick O’Rahilly, MD, FRS, Professor of Clinical Biochemistry and Medicine Gábor Csányi, MA (1994), PhD MIT, Professor of Molecular Modelling Menna Ruth Clatworthy, BSc, MBBCh Wales, PhD (2006), Reader in Immunity and Inflammation

2009

Colin Martyn Lizieri, BA Oxon, PhD LSE, Grosvenor Professor of Real Estate Finance Alexander Houen, BA, MPhil Sydney, PhD (1999), University Senior Lecturer in Modern Literature Renaud Gagné, MA Montreal, PhD Harvard, Reader in Ancient Greek Literature and Religion Mina Gorji, BA (1996), MPhil, DPhil Oxon, University Senior Lecturer in English Caroline Burt, MA (1999), MPhil (2000), PhD (2004), College Lecturer in History, Admissions Tutor

2011

Randall Scott Johnson, BA/BS Washington, PhD Harvard, Professor of Molecular Physiology and Pathology Christoph Hubert Loch, Dipl-Wirtsch-Ing Darmstadt, MBA Tennessee, PhD Stanford, Director and Professor of Management Studies at the Cambridge Judge Business School


annual gazette | 109 Clare Philomena Grey, MA, DPhil Oxon, FRS, Geoffrey Moorhouse Gibson Professor of Chemistry Maria Abreu, BSc LSE, MPhil Tinbergen, PhD Amsterdam, University Lecturer in Land Economy 2012

Stephen David John, BA (2000), MPhil (2002), PhD (2007), University Senior Lecturer in Philosophy of Public Health

2013

Andrew Thomas Cates, MA (1991) PhD (1989), Treasurer and Bursar Paul Ross Cavill, MA, MSt, DPhil Oxon, University Lecturer in Early Modern British History John Hay Durrell, MSci (Imperial) PhD (2001), Reader in Superconductor Engineering Maximilian Jan Sternberg, BA (King’s College London), MPhil (2002), PhD (2007) University Senior Lecturer in Department of Architecture Hildegard Gemma Maria Diemberger, PhD (Vienna), College Lecturer in Human, Social and Political Sciences Sanne Cottaar, BSc, MSc (Utrecht), PhD (California), University Lecturer in Seismology Timothy Thomas Weil, BSc (St Louis), PhD (Princeton), University Senior Lecturer in Zoology

2014

Thomas Gospatric Micklem, BSc (Imperial), PhD (1989), Director of the Cambridge Computational Biology Institute, Professor of Computational and Molecular Biology Iza Riana Binte Mohamed Hussin, AB/AM (Harvard), PhD (Washington), University Senior Lecturer in Department of Politics and International Studies

2015

Paul Simon Warde, BA (1995), PhD (2000), Reader in Environmental History Mark Charles Wyatt, MSc (Queen Mary) PhD (Florida), Professor at the Institute of Astronomy Anil Venkata Sesha Madhavapeddy, BEng (Imperial), PhD (2007), University Lecturer in Computer Science Guillaume Jean Emmanuel Hennequin, BSc (SUPELEC) MSc (Edinburgh), PhD (EPFL, Lausanne), University Lecturer in Computational Neuroscience

2016

Daniela Passolt, MA (Hamburg) MSc (SOAS), PhD (LSE), Director of International Programmes Rebecca Verena Lämmle, MA, PhD (Basel), University Senior Lecturer in Classics

2017

Nicholas Oscar Burton, BS (Wisconsin), PhD (MIT), University Fellow at the Centre for Trophoblast Research Geoffrey Francis Hayward, MA, DPhil (Oxon), Professor of Education Nicholas Gwilym Jones, MEng, PhD (Imperial), University Reader in the Department of Materials Science and Metallurgy


110 | pembroke college Johannes Karl Richard Bausch, MASt, PhD (2017), Drapers’ Company Research Fellow Allegra Rachel Pennant Fryxell, MPhil, PhD (2016), Trebilcock-Newton Trust Research Fellow 2018

Moreed Ahmad Richard Arbabzadah, MA, MPhil, PhD (2012), College Praelector Michael Hulme, BSc, PhD (University of Wales, Swansea), Professor of Human Geography Johannes Kromdijk, MSc, PhD (2010), University Lecturer in the Department of Plant Sciences Assef Ashraf, MA, MPhil, PhD (Yale), University Lecturer in the Faculty of Asian and Middle Eastern Studies Amanda Prorok, MSc, PhD (EPFL, Switzerland), University Lecturer in the Department of Computer Science and Technology Jessica Anne Maratsos, MPhil, PhD (Columbia), Keith Sykes Research Fellow Mark Halliday, PhD (Leicester), Ron Thomson Research Fellow Chika Tonooka, MA (Tokyo), Mark Kaplanoff Research Fellow

2019

Luca Magri, MSc (Padua) PhD, University Lecturer in the Department of Engineering Albert Cardona, BA, PhD (Barcelona), Reader in the Department of Physiology, Development and Neuroscience Hugo Andres Bronstein, MChem (Oxon), MSc (KCL) PhD (Imperial), University Reader in the Department of Chemistry and Physics Anna-Maria Pappa, MSc (Thessaloniki), PhD (Ecole des Mines de SaintEtienne), Maudslay-Butler Research Fellow

2020

Arthur Asseraf, MA (Columbia), MSc (LSE), DPhil (Oxon), University Lecturer in the History of France and the Francophone World Rebecca Kilner, BA (Oxon), PhD, Professor of Evolutionary Biology Hannah Elsisi Ashmawi, BSc (Sussex), MSc (Oxon), MA (European University Institute Florence), Abdullah Mubarak Al-Sabah Research Fellow

EMERITUS FELLOWS Anthony William Nutbourne, MA (1954) Richard Hawley Grey Parry, PhD, ScD (1983) Colin Gilbraith, MA (1975), MVO Colin George Wilcockson, MA (1958) Antony Gerald Hopkins, PhD, FBA Ian Fleming, ScD (1982), FRS John Ryder Waldram, MA (1963), PhD (1964) Sir Roger Tomkys, MA (1973), KCMG Robert Joseph Mears


annual gazette | 111 William Bernard Raymond Lickorish, ScD (1991) Leo Broof Jeffcott, MA (1994) PhD Sathiamalar Thirunavukkarasu, MA (1971) Nicholas Stanislaus Baskey, MA (1998) Brian Watchorn, MA (1965) Howard Peter Raingold, MA (1982) Michael David Reeve, MA (1966), FBA Michael George Kuczynski, MA (1972) Susan Helen Stobbs, MA (1970) Rex Edward Britter, MA (1979) Geoffrey Richard Edwards, MA (2008) Barbara Ann Bodenhorn, MPhil (1979), PhD (1990) Christopher John Blencowe, MA (2006) Alan Michael Dawson,MA (1978), PhD (1994) Alan Garth Tunnacliffe, MA (1994), PhD London Sir Richard Billing Dearlove, MA (2003), KCMG, OBE Charles Peter Melville, MA (1976), PhD (1978) Jan Marian Maciejowski, MA (1976), PhD (1978) Nicholas Barry Davies, MA (1977, FRS John Stephen Bell, MA (1978), FBA Ashok Ramakrishnan Venkitaraman, MA (1993), PhD London, MB, BS Vellore, India, The Ursula Zoellner Professor of Cancer Research, Director of the Medical Research Council Cancer Unit, University of Cambridge Sylvia Huot, MA (2004), BA California, PhD Princeton, FBA, Professor of Medieval French Literature

HONORARY FELLOWS 1988 1992 1998

1999 2002 2004

2006

2007 2008 2010

Sir John Frank Charles Kingman, ScD (1969), FSA, FRS Sir Simon Kirwan Donaldson, MA (1979), DPhil (Oxon), FRS The Rt Hon. Sir John Anthony Chilcot, GCB, PC, MA (1973) The Rt Hon. Sir Konrad Hermann Theodor Schiemann, PC, MA (1965) The Rt Hon. Sir Alan Hylton Ward, PC, MA (1968) Emma Louise Johnson, MA (1992), MBE William Hall Janeway,CBE, PhD (1971) Sir Michael Bett, CBE, MA (1977) Roger Walton Ferguson Jr, MA (1976), PhD Harvard Sir Christopher Owen Hum, MA (1971), KCMG Sir Marcus Henry (Mark) Richmond, PhD, ScD (1971), FRS The Rt Hon Christopher Robert Smith, Baron Smith of Finsbury, PC, MA (1977), PhD (1979) Sir Stephen John Nickell, CBE, BA (1965), FBA Martin Biddle, CBE, MA (1965), FBA, FSA Peter Stuart Ringrose, MA (1971), PhD (1971) Paul Anthony Elliott Bew, Baron Bew of Donegore, MA (1971), PhD (1974) Stephen Jay Greenblatt, MA (1968) David Anthony Brading, MA (1960), PhD (UCL), LittD (1991), FBA Jeremy Bloxham, BA (1982), PhD (1986), FRS The Rt Hon. Sir Patrick Elias, PC, MA, PhD (1974)


112 | pembroke college 2014 2015 2016 2018 2019

William Frank Vinen, MA (1952), PhD (1956), FRS Victoria Jane Bowman, BA (1987), MA Sir Simon Gerard McDonald, MA, KCMG, KCVO Eric Idle, BA (1962) Catherine Bishop, MA (Wales), PhD (Reading) Gerald O’Collins, AC The Rt Hon Lord Justice Sir Charles Haddon Cave Dame Henrietta Louise Moore, DBE, FBA

WILLIAM PITT FELLOWS 1996 1997 2009 2013 2018 2019

2020

Sir Mark Henry Richmond, ScD (1971), FRS Richard Chiu, BA (1971) Peter Stuart Ringrose, PhD (1971) Richard John Parmee, BA (1973) Kai Dai, MD, BSc (China Medical University, Shenyang), EMBA (2012) Timothy John Whitley, BSc (Kent), PhD (Essex) Reza Khorshidi, MSc (Amirkabir, Tehran), DPhil (Oxon) Rajendra Seeruthun, BSc (UCL), MBBS (Imperial), MBA Barry John Varcoe, BA (South Bank), PhD (Glasgow Caledonian) Shi Wang, BA (Lanzhou) Robert Davis, BA MBA (LBS)

BYE-FELLOWS 2009 2012 2017 2018

2019 2020

Rebecca Lucy Coombs, BA (Bristol), PhD (Paris) Andrew Enticknap, MBA (UEA) Richard Ned Lebow, MA (Yale), PhD (New York), FBA Nami Morris, BA (SOAS) Mary Céline Newbould, MA, MPhil, PhD Anthony Louis Odgers, MA, MBA (1994) Mark Edward Purcell, MA (Oxon), MA (UCL) Stephanie Georgina Smith, MA, MSci, PhD (2011) Géraldine Dufour, BA (Université Paris XII), BA (Nottingham Trent University), MA (Birmingham University), MA (London), MA Robert Anthony Griggs Anna Ruth Ella Lapwood, BA (Oxon)

FELLOW-COMMONERS 2004 2005

2006 2007 2009

George Simon Cecil Gibson John Andrew Hulme Chadwick, MA (1968) Keith Gordon Sykes, MA (1973) Randall Wayne Dillard, LLM (1983) Norman McLeod Bachop, MA (1968) Anthony Harwick Wilkinson Christopher Bertlin Turner Adams, MA (1957)


annual gazette | 113

2013

2015 2016 2018 2020

John Charles Grayson Stancliffe, MA (1952) John Kevin Overstall, MA (1962) Paul David Skinner, BA (1963) Bita Daryabari, BSc (California State), MSc (Golden Gate University) Graham David Blyth, BA (1972) Mubarak Abdullah Al Sabah, BA (Buckingham), MPhil (2000) Datin Paduka Faridah Abdullah, BA (Adelaide), PhD (King’s College, London) Peter Lawson-Johnston Robert King (1949) Fadi Boustany, MBA (1994) James Patrick McCaughan

FOUNDRESS FELLOW 2016

Dagmar Dolby, BA (Heidelberg)

Master: Lord Chris Smith

COLLEGE OFFICERS 2021–2022 President: M C Payne Senior Tutor: R Mayhew Dean and Chaplain: J Gardom Treasurer and Bursar: A Cates Praelector: M Arbabzadah College Proctor: P Cavill Steward: M Mellor College Curator: S Learmount Tutor for Graduate Affairs: L Gelsthorpe Director of Undergraduate Admissions: C Burt Directors of Graduate Admissions: N McBride, T Weil Fellow Librarian: P Cavill Long Vacation Tutor: L Gelsthorpe Development Director: M Mellor Fellow for Freedom of Information: N McBride Data Protection Lead: J Durrell Financial Secretary: M Abreu Undergraduate Tutors: A Ashraf, A Cates, H Diemberger, J Gardom, S John, N Jones, N McBride, T Meißner, M Mellor, D Passolt, M Sternberg, T Weil Graduate Tutors: C Burt, J Durrell, J Gardom, R Lämmle College Lecturers: C Burt (History), N Cristafi (Modern and Medieval Languages), N Datta (Mathematics), H Diemberger (Human, Social and Political Sciences, K Ettenhuber (English), N McBride (Law), D Tambakis (Economics), M Wormald (English) Directors of Studies: Anglo-Saxon, Norse and Celtic: E Ashman Rowe Architecture: M Sternberg Asian and Middle Eastern Studies: A Ashraf Chemical Engineering: S Cardoso


114 | pembroke college Classics: T Meißner, M Arbabzadah Computer Science: A Prorok Economics: D Robertson, D Tambakis Education: G Hayward Engineering: G Csanyi, J Durrell, A Ferrari, G Hennequin English: K Ettenhuber, M Wormald Geography: M Hulme History: C Burt, P Cavill History and Modern Languages: C Burt, P Cavill, N Cristafi History and Politics: P Cavill History of Art: R P Blakesley, J Maratsos Human, Social and Political Sciences: H Diemberger Land Economy: M Abreu Law: N McBride Linguistics: M Deuchar Management Studies: S Learmount Mathematics: N Datta Medicine: M Clatworthy, M Hill, A W Tucker Modern Languages: N Cristafi, S Huot, A Schneider, C Young Music: S Barrett Natural Sciences: A Buskell, N Cooper, S Cottaar, S John, N Jones, R Kilner, G Micklem, M Payne, S Smith, T Weil, M Wyatt Philosophy: A Buskell, S John Psychological and Behavioural Sciences: A Greve Theology: J Gardom Veterinary Medicine: M Hill, A W Tucker Director for International Programmes: D Passolt Lectrice in French: M-L Rebora Academic Associates: Anatomy: A May Biochemistry: E Andrews Chemical Engineering: G Moghaddam Computer Science: S Jaffer Economics: S Lu English: C Charteris German: M Kant History: I Chambers History of Art: K Ilko International Programmes: J Dougal, K Zeynep Linguistics: R Sileo Mathematics: M Castle Modern and Medieval Languages: G Boitani Music: K Ashton Natural Sciences: C Buckley Neuroscience: K Scott Physics: F Lee Psychology and Behavioural Sciences: A Segonds-Pinchon Writing Skills: R Berengarten, M Rice Zoology: J Gerlach


annual gazette | 115

MATRICULATION 2020–2021 MICHAELMAS TERM 2020


116 | pembroke college


annual gazette | 117

LENT TERM 2021

EASTER TERM 2021

ANNUAL EXAMINATIONS, FIRST CLASS RESULTS 2021


118 | pembroke college


annual gazette | 119


120 | pembroke college

COLLEGE AWARDS 2020–2021


annual gazette | 121


122 | pembroke college

Foundress Prizes


annual gazette | 123

College Prizes


124 | pembroke college

Foundation Award


annual gazette | 125 Foundation Awards Continuing

Foundation Scholarships


annual gazette | 127

GRADUATE SCHOLARSHIPS AND AWARDS 2020–2021


128 | pembroke college

HIGHER DEGREES CONFERRED


annual gazette | 129

M


D. THE PEMBROKE COLLEGE CAMBRIDGE SOCIETY


annual gazette | 133

MEMBERS’ NEWS 1939 Eric Goldrein celebrated his 100th birthday on 29 May 2021; his birthday party was attended by the Pipes and Drums of the 103rd Regiment of the Royal Artillery (in which Eric served during World War II) playing him ‘Happy Birthday’ and Sir Brian Leveson PC gave the speech in his honour. 1957 Nicholas Flemming’s book Apollonia on my Mind: The Memoir of a Paraplegic Ocean Scientist was published by Sidestone Press. 1958 Bernard Adams’s translation of Architecture in Hungary was published by Corvina. 1961 John Nicholas’s book (co-authored with George Reeve) Main Line to the South – Part One: The Southern Railway Route Between Basingstoke and Southampton was published by Irwell Press. 1963 Malcolm Haslett’s The Mountain on the Other Side of Light trilogy (comprising A Cry for Help (2018), The Search for the Opening (2019), and Fles (2020)) was published by Austin Macauley Publishers. 1964 Anthony Campbell was awarded a CBE in the 2021 New Year’s Honours list for his services to biochemistry. His book Mirror Image: What Darwin Missed was published by Welston Press. 1967 Cliff Webb’s three volume work Haberdasher’s Company Membership Records 1500–1800 was published by the British Record Society. 1970 Melvyn Jones’s book That Contentious Spirituality was published by Shield Books. Robbie Low’s children’s book Mama Mia and the Pizza Pie Party (with artwork by Jan Burrell) was published by Lostwithiel Letters, with all proceeds going to charities working with disadvantaged children. 1972 Sam Blyth was made an Advisory Board Member of the Smithsonian National Museum of Natural History. 1973 Roger Ferguson became a board member of Cambridge in America. 1977 Neil Cadwallader was appointed a Specialist Civil Circuit Judge. 1978 Martin Rowson’s lockdown diary in verse, Plague Songs, was published by Smokestack Books. He also illustrated Luke Wright’s poetry collection The Ballad Seller (Nasty Little Press) and published eight specially commissioned drawings from the latter years of Laurence Sterne’s life under the titled Yorick’s Progress (Shandy Hall Press). 1979 Simon McDonald became a life peer, becoming Baron McDonald of Salford. He was also awarded a GMCG for services to British foreign policy in the 2021 Queen’s Birthday Honours list. 1983 John Sharpley was awarded a CBE for his work as Surgeon Captain in the Royal Navy. 1984 Gail Davey was awarded an OBE in the 2020 Queen’s Birthday Honours list for services to tackling neglected tropical diseases. Robert Porter’s book For the Love of Fish: An Aquarist’s Journey was published by Ichtheon.


134 | pembroke college

1985 1987 1990

1991

1995 1996 1997 1999

2007 2014 2015 2016

2017

2019

Tom Shakespeare was awarded a CBE for services to disability research in the 2021 Queen’s Birthday Honours list. Marcus Nodder’s book I Am: The Answers to Life’s Biggest Questions was published by Inter-Varsity Press. Ian Maclean was awarded an MBE in the 2020 Queen’s Birthday Honours list for services to the UK textile industry and the Covid-19 response. Val Gibson was awarded an OBE in the 2020 Queen’s Birthday Honours list for services to science, women in science, and public engagement. Julian Norton’s book A Yorkshire Vet: The Next Chapter was published by Coronet. Adrian Brettle’s book Colossal Ambitions: Confederate Planning for a Post-Civil War World was published by the University of Virginia Press. He also curated the American Civil War Museum’s Southern Ambitions exhibit. Caroline Mackenzie (née Dargies)’s book A Latin Lexicon: An Illustrated Compendium of Latin Words and English Derivatives was published by Archaeopress. John Aston was knighted in the 2021 Queen’s Birthday Honours list for his services to statistics and public policymaking. John Palfrey’s book (co-authored with Urs Gasser) The Connected Parent: An Expert Guide to Parenting in a Digital World was published by Basic Books. Andy Mydellton’s book Victorian Tottenham Hotspur was published by TSL Publications. John Bew led the UK government’s integrated review Global Britain in a Competitive Age, which was published in March 2021. Ed Yong – who works as a staff writer specialising in science at The Atlantic – was awarded the 2021 Pulitzer Prize for explanatory reporting. Greg Buchanan’s novel Sixteen Horses was published by Mantle. Alexander Waghorn was made a Fellow in Law at Selwyn College, Cambridge. Myfanwy Hill was made Loke Fellow in Medical Sciences at King’s College, Cambridge. Livia Russell was the joint winner of the 2020 Society of Italian Studies Undergraduate Prize for her dissertation on ‘Contact and intimacy: Mario Giacomelli’s photo-poetic encounters’. Stephanie Smith’s debut novel What’s Left of Me is Yours was published by Orion. It was subsequently longlisted for the 2021 CWA John Creasey (New Blood) Dagger and the 2021 Jhalak Prize Book of the Year by a Writer of Colour. Gabriel Jamie was awarded a Leverhulme Early Career Fellowship.


annual gazette | 135

ANNUAL GENERAL MEETINGS OF THE SOCIETY AGENDA FOR THE 2021 AGM Thursday 18 November; The Drapers’ Hall, drinks at 7.00 pm, dinner at 7.30 pm Nominations for 2021–2022 President: TBC Vice-Presidents: Sir Roger Tomkys, H P Raingold Honorary Vice-President: Mrs C F Holmes Chairman of Committee: Dr J E Morley Secretary: M R Mellor Treasurer: Dr A T Cates Editor of Gazette: N J McBride Secretary of London Dinner: A S Ivison Secretary of Scottish Dinner: R M B Brown Secretary of South Western Dinner: A B Elgood 1950s representative: G J Curtis Committee to 2022: N E Orosz*, Dr C J Bishop*, Dr S E Deacon*, G H C Smith* Committee to 2023: A R K Watkinson*, Revd J C Finnemore*, S J Hilton*, Dr J E Neffendorf*, R M Sanders* Committee to 2024: S G Sperryn, D Brigen, R W Bayly, C G Beal, T H Ellerton, J E Spencer Overseas Representatives: T P Itoh, Dr C L Hansen, Dr A Guha, Ms D S Q G-S Wambold, Ms L Parodi-Huml *due to last year’s hiatus on recruiting to the Committee it was agreed at the AGM to extend the term of serving members by twelve months to cover the current pandemic. AGENDA FOR THE 2020 AGM Thursday 19 November; held over Zoom, at 6.00 pm Nominations for 2020–2021 President: Ms E L Johnson Vice-Presidents: Sir Roger Tomkys, H P Raingold Honorary Vice-President: Mrs C F Holmes Chairman of Committee: Dr J E Morley Secretary: M R Mellor Treasurer: Dr A T Cates Editor of Gazette: N J McBride Secretary of London Dinner: A S Ivison Secretary of Scottish Dinner: R M B Brown Secretary of South Western Dinner: A B Elgood In the light of the Covid-19 pandemic, the Committee should remain constituted as it is until the end of the academic year 2020–21. Namely: 1950s representative: G J Curtis Committee to 2021: A B Roberts*, D L Taylor*, Dr M D Castle*, J I Hirschowitz*, G Ulmann*, Dr D J Atherton, N E Orosz, Dr C J Bishop, Dr S E Deacon, G H C Smith


136 | pembroke college Committee to 2022: A R K Watkinson, Revd J C Finnemore, S J Hilton, Dr J E Neffendorf, R M Sanders Committee to 2023: Self -nominations will be sought again and considered alongside those already received at the Easter meeting.


annual gazette | 137

DINNERS AND RECEPTIONS Pembroke College Cambridge Society London Dinner Due to the Covid-19 pandemic, there wasn’t a PCCS London Dinner in 2020. It is hoped the 94th dinner of the Society will be held at the Drapers’ Hall on Thursday 18 November later this year. The Secretary of PCCS would welcome suggestions from members of guest speakers for future London dinners whom they can help contact.

Scottish Dinner The 70th Annual Dinner in Scotland will be held at the New Club on Friday 12 November 2021. Further details will be circulated to members in due course.

South Western Dinner A date has been secured at the Clifton Club for the 20th Annual South-Western Dinner on the evening of Friday 12 November 2021. Details will be circulated to members over the summer.

Trans-Tasman Online Event On Thursday 15 October 2020 Pembroke held an online event for Members living in Australia and New Zealand. The event began with a warm welcome from the Master, who then invited Peter Moore (1978) and Rebecca Caroe (1984) to give a quick ‘View from…’ Australia and New Zealand respectively. Lord Smith brought alumni up to date with what had been happening in College during the first six months of the pandemic, the steps taken to enable the majority of students to return to Pembroke for Michaelmas Term 2020 and progress made on the Mill Lane project. He also thanked Andrew Shelton (1976) and Peter Moore for all the help they have given in support of the Davis McCaughey Scholarship Fund. Three of the College’s Australian students then said a few words. Niki Sivakumaran (2020, LLM) spoke about her experiences of studying at Cambridge during the pandemic. Stephanie Forrest (2018) talked about the benefits and challenges of trying to write up her History PhD and play a full life in the postgraduate community while having to remain in Melbourne. Finally, Deborah White (2020), the current Davis McCaughey Scholar, thanked Members for supporting the fund, which enabled her to come to Cambridge to read for an MPhil on Criminological Research.


138 | pembroke college At the end of the event, the Master led a toast to the College and its Members – albeit a non-alcoholic one for those joining from the UK at 8 am! The College would like to thank Peter Moore for his assistance in organising this event. ATTENDED

1947 1955 1957 1960 1962 1967

1969

1970 1971

The Master 1972 Mr S B Myer AC LLD Dr J M Henderson 1974 Mr J C Key Dr R A M Wilson 1976 Dr M J Llewellyn1977 Smith AM KStJ 1978 Dr I M Ling 1980 Mr P M McLennan 1983 Mr P G Powell Davies Dr P F Crapper 1984 Mr R S A Lubett 1987 Mr P J Tooth 1989 The Hon A D Erskine Mr W S Etheridge 1994 Dr I E Topliss 1996

Mr D M H Townshend Mr R J Lamb Dr S D West Mr A G Shelton Mr D J Asteraki Mr P J Moore Mr R H Myer AO Mr R I J McIndoe Mr C F Thomson Miss R E Caroe Dr A M Ryan Mr R S Doyle Dr I E Hopley Dr A T J Domanti Professor P M W Gill

1997 2004 2006 2013

2014 2018 2020 `

Miss K A O’Shea Mr T S Richardson Mr M R Mellor Mr S Cousins Dr C A Landers Miss L Mishal Mr D K R Kinsey Miss S J Bakker Ms S J Forrest Ms N Sivakumaran Ms D M White Miss S A March Dr A Strazzera

Pembroke Victoria Society Dinner On Friday 21 May 2021 the Pembroke Victoria Society met for a dinner at the Australian Club in Melbourne, hosted by Michael Bartlett (1981). Organiser Peter Moore (1978) described it as a ‘wonderful evening of camaraderie and storytelling, with many sharing their College experiences’, adding that ‘Victoria went into a snap lockdown the following week so we got the dinner in just in time!’ ATTENDED 1963 1971 1976 1978

Mr A W Gunther Dr I E Topliss Mr A G Shelton Mr P J Moore & Mrs K Moore

1981 1983 1994

Mr M E Bartlett 1995 Mr R I J McIndoe Mr A J R Barker Dr A T J Domanti & Mr W Daniels

Dr J A Forrest & Mrs C Forrest Dr A Strazzera

Also present were Mr C Briggs and Ms V Greenwood from Cambridge Australia Scholarships.


annual gazette | 139

LOCAL CONTACTS Australia Adelaide Dr M J Llewellyn-Smith AM KStJ (1962) 27 Kate Court Adelaide SA 5000 Australia Email: michael.llewellyn.smith.1962@ pem.cam.ac.uk

Melbourne Mr P J Moore (1978) Email: peter.moore.1978@pem.cam.ac.uk

Mr A G Shelton (1976) Andrew Shelton & Co Level 2 88 Collins Street Sydney Melbourne VIC 3000 Miss L J Sproston (1994) Australia Email: Email: lorna.sproston.1994@pem.cam.ac.uk andrew.shelton.1976@pem.cam.ac.uk Mr T D Beresford (1994) Email: tim.beresford.1994@pem.cam.ac.uk Canada Dr A Guha (1994) Phase 5 Research 99 Spadina Avenue Suite 400 Toronto ON M5V 3P8 Canada Email: arnie.guha.1994@pem.cam.ac.uk China

Hong Kong

Mr T D P Kirkwood (1987) Kirkwood & Sons LLC 3610 Capital Mansion No 6 Xin Yuan Road South Chaoyang District Beijing 100004 China Email: tom.kirkwood.1987@pem.cam.ac.uk Mob: +86 1380 1358 781 China office: +86 10 8486 8099 US office: +1 570 506 9850

Mr Paul Tao (1985) Email: ptao@nh-holdings.com Ms Bianca Law (1996) Email: biancalaw@gmail.com Dr Terence Kwan (2012) Email: ttlkwan@gmail.com


140 | pembroke college Japan

Singapore

Mr T P Itoh (1966) LOGOS Capital Partners Inc 4-4-12-4-1 Takanawa Minato-ku Tokyo 108-0074 Japan Email: peter.itoh.1966@pem.cam.ac.uk Tel: +81 3 3445 5890

Mr B D Clarke (1981) Raffles City, PO Box 1456 Singapore 911749 Republic of Singapore Email: barry.clarke.1981@pem.cam.ac.uk Tel: +65 6775 0542 Mob: +65 9277 0028

USA New York Mr C P Robb (1976) 161 East 79th Street Apt 12B New York, NY 10021-0433 USA

San Francisco Mr P G Cleary (1969) 531 Diamond Street San Francisco CA 94114 USA Email: peter.cleary.1969@cam.ac.uk

UK London Mr A S Ivison (1974) CMS Cameron McKenna Mitre House 160 Aldersgate Street London EC1A 4DD Bristol Mr A B Elgood (1972) Upper Hounsley Farm Hounsley Batch Winford Bristol Somerset BS40 8BS Email: tony.elgood.1972@pem.cam.ac.uk

Leeds Mr D R Sneath TD DL (1966) 7 Kirkby Road Ravenshead Nottingham NG15 9HD Email: david.sneath.1966@pem.cam.ac.uk Scotland Mr R M B Brown (1989) 79 Hamilton Place Aberdeen AB15 5BU


annual gazette | 141

RULES OF THE SOCIETY 1.

The Society shall be composed of past and present Members of Pembroke College, Cambridge, and shall be called the ‘PEMBROKE COLLEGE CAMBRIDGE SOCIETY’.

2.

The objects of the Society shall be: (a) To promote closer relationships among Pembroke Members, and between them and the College. (b) To publish an Annual Gazette, and to issue it free to all Members of the Society.

3.

The subscription for Life Membership of the Society shall be decided from time to time by the Committee.*

4.

The Officers of the Society shall be a President, one or more VicePresidents, a Chair of Committee, a Treasurer, an Honorary Secretary (who shall be a Fellow of the College), the Dinner Secretaries, an Editor of the Gazette, and such local Secretaries as may be desirable. The Officers shall be elected at the Annual General Meeting and shall hold office for one year. Nominations, with the names of the Proposer and Seconder, shall be sent to the Secretary six weeks before the Annual General Meeting. The retiring President shall not be eligible for re-election for a period of three years after his or her retirement. The office of President is held annually and alternately by a Fellow and by a non-resident Member of the College. He or she is normally expected to give the address at the London dinner, proposing the toast to the College (if a non-resident Member) or responding (if a Fellow).

5.

The Management of the Society shall be entrusted to a Committee consisting of the following Officers, namely the Chair of Committee, the Treasurer, the Honorary Secretary, the Dinner Secretaries, the Editor of the Gazette, a current Fellow (who has not been a Junior Member of the College), and not fewer than twelve other Members of the Society to be elected annually. Nominations for the Committee shall be sought in advance of and later recommended by the spring meeting of the Committee, to be ratified at the Annual General Meeting. Of the elected members of the Committee, six shall retire annually by rotation according to priority of election, and their places shall be filled at the Annual General Meeting; a retiring member shall be eligible for reelection after a period of one year from his or her retirement. The Committee shall have power to co-opt additional members for a period of one year.


142 | pembroke college 6.

Members of the Committee shall have, as their primary considerations: (a) The relationship between the College and its non-resident Members. (b) The assistance they can give to the College in encouraging attendance at events and participation in other College activities. (c) Evaluation of ways of improving the connection between the College and non-resident Members. (d) The quality of the events that are organised under the aegis of the Society.

7.

The Committee shall meet at least twice in every year, a week after the end of the Lent (spring) and Michaelmas (winter) Terms respectively. At all meetings of the Committee seven shall form a quorum. The spring meeting shall review nominations for committee membership and the annual accounts of the Society.

8.

The Committee shall arrange an Annual Dinner or other Social Meetings of the Society in London and elsewhere.

9.

The Annual General Meeting of the Society shall be held on the day fixed for the London Dinner. The Secretary shall send out notices of the Meeting at least one month before it takes place.

10.

The Committee in their discretion may, and upon a written request signed by twenty-four Members of the Society shall, call a Special General Meeting. Fourteen days’ notice of such a Meeting shall be given and the object for which it is called stated in the notice.

11.

No alteration shall be made in the Rules of the Society except at a General Meeting and by a majority of two-thirds of those present and voting, and any proposed alteration shall be stated on the notice calling the Meeting.

*The Committee decided (10 December 1982) that, for the time being, the Life Membership subscription shall be nil. This decision was made possible by an offer from the College of an annual subvention from the Bethune-Baker Fund which, it was hoped, would provide a sufficient supplement to the Society’s income to enable expenses to be met, particularly the expenses of printing and postage of the Annual Gazette.


annual gazette | 143

PRESIDENTS OF THE SOCIETY 1924 1925 1926 1927 1928 1929 1930 1931 1932 1933 1934 1935 1936 1937 1938 1939 1946 1947 1948 1949 1950 1951 1952 1953 1954 1955 1956 1957 1958 1959 1960 1961 1962 1963 1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969 1970 1971 1972 1973 1974 1975

J F P Rawlinson E G Browne G R Eden L Whibley F Shewell Cooper A Hutchinson F S Preston E H Minns J B Atkins H G Comber E H Pooley J C Lawson J E Singleton J K Mozley M S D Butler J C C Davidson S C Roberts R A Butler M S D Butler J W F Beaumont J T Spittle P J Dixon H E Wynn Sir Wavell Wakefield V C Pennell E H Pooley B E King H Grose-Hodge S C Roberts H F Guggenheim Sir William Hodge The Rt Hon Lord Salmon A J Arberry A G Grantham B Willey G W Pickering M B Dewey J M Key W A Camps D G A Lowe W S Hutton R G Edwardes Jones T G S Combe H F G Jones G C Smith Sir Eric Drake

1976 1977 1978 1979 1980 1981 1982 1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021

J Campbell J G Ward D R Denman W L Gorell Barnes M C Lyons D A S Cairns M V Posner Sir Patrick Browne Lord Adrian J G P Crowden L P Johnson The Rt Hon Lord Prior J Baddiley T J Brooke-Taylor J C D Hickson P J D Langrishe J R Waldram G D S MacLellan S Kenderdine Sir Peter Scott A V Grimstone The Rt Hon Lord Taylor Sir Roger Tomkys Sir John Chilcot C Gilbraith J K Shepherd B Watchorn R H Malthouse M G Kuczynski Sir Patrick Elias Sir John Kingman Ms V J Bowman M G Kuczynski R H King J S Bell R G Macfarlane M R Wormald N G H Manns Sir Richard Dearlove Mrs C F Holmes S A Learmount A S Ivison J Gardom J A Wilson T Weil Mrs E L Johnson


E. DEATHS AND OBITUARIES


annual gazette | 147

LIST OF DEATHS The College notes with regret the deaths of the following members: 1940 1942 1944 1945 1946 1948

1949 1950

1951

1952

1953 1955

1956

1957

1958

1959

1960

Leslie Lynn Marr (1 May 2021; see obituary p 177) Neville Clive Goldrein (2 April 2020; see obituary p 161) Alastair Kydd Hanton (26 May 2021; see obituary p 163) Derek Randall Smith (1 February 2021; BA Mechanical Sciences) Brian Gerald Saunders (26 February 2020; BA Mathematics) Rex Hereward Hack (26 October 2020; BA Economics/Law) Robin Miles Lloyd Humphreys (19 July 2019; BA Classics) John Martyn Drysdale Knight (11 May 2021; BA Geography/History) Ralph Nicholas Quartano (1 January 2021; see obituary p 178) Robert James Seaton (17 October 2019; BA Mathematics) Ralph Bonnett (26 January 2020; BA Law/Mathematics) Humphrey Robert Harlow (21 February 2020; BA Natural Sciences) Reginald Patrick Morton (12 September 2020; BA Economics/Mathematics) Thomas Orrok Mackay Simpson (25 September 2020; BA Economics/English) Robert James Yates (12 April 2021; BA Natural Sciences) Roger Martin Button (14 June 2020; BA Architecture) Roger Varian Clifford (1 August 2020; BA Geography/Modern & Medieval Languages) David John Crowe (23 August 2019; see obituary p 157) Alexander Michael Hall-Smith (31 May 2020; BA Natural Sciences/Medicine) Robin Miles Garnett (16 December 2020; BA Geography) Thomas Geoffrey Goodwin (7 July 2021; BA History) John Kerry Hoskin (26 October 2020; BA Modern & Medieval Languages) John Edward Louis Lebus (22 January 2021; BA Economics) Richard Dennis Clift (10 November 2020; BA History; CMG) Thomas William Miller-Jones (19 February 2021) John Hayman Dempster (4 April 2021; BA Natural Sciences) William Paterson Ormerod (31 July 2020; BA Natural Sciences/Medicine; BChir) Michael Anthony Worsfold (December 2020; BA Natural Sciences) Peter George Cobb (6 September 2020; BA Law/Music) Victor Sadler (1 January 2021; BA Modern & Medieval Languages/Natural Sciences/Psychology) John Brian Butcher (14 September 2020; BA Natural Sciences/Engineering) Thomas Evans (2 October 2020; BA Mathematics) Paul Francis Anthony Sharpling (18 July 2020; BA Modern & Medieval Languages) Michael Anthony Campbell Winterton (14 June 2021; BA Economics/Law) Arthur Philip Cracknell (21 April 2021; see obituary p 154) Donald Alexander MacLeod (27 September 2020; see obituary p 176) Humphrey Vincent Taylor (19 February 2021; see obituary p 182) Peter Lendon Bell (19 May 2021; BA Mechanical Sciences) Richard James Jackson (21 September 2020; see obituary p 171) Brian Rebbeck (20 June 2020; BA Mechanical Sciences) Crispin John Stephen Moncrieff Simpson (January 2021; member of Pembroke 1959; Fellow of Wadham College, Oxford) Roger Edward Brookin (1 January 2020; BA Classics/Oriental Studies)


148 | pembroke college

1961 1962 1963

1964

1966 1967 1970 1972 1974 1977 1979 1981 1984 2005

Michael Anthony Hogben (26 July 2020; BA Mathematics) Martin Robert Lloyd (10 January 2021; BA Natural Sciences/Theology) Anthony Simon Vanpraagh Steele (1 May 2020; BA Mathematics) Malcolm Corrie (30 August 2020; Cert Ed) Stuart Joseph Woolf (1 May 2021; see obituary p 183) David Somerville Cook (19 September 2020; see obituary p 151) Michael John Hare (31 October 2020; see obituary p 165) Seamus Francis Deane (16 May 2021; see obituary p 158) Andrew Dickson Hartley (3 September 2020; see obituary p 166) Michael McBean Page (25 February 2021; BA Economics) Stephen Conrad Palmer (30 October 2020; BA Economics) Seth Andrew Schaffer (2 March 2021; see obituary p 181) Nicholas John Denham Church (1 December 2020; BA History) Roger Harold Heape (4 May 2021; BA Geography) Peter David Ogden (3 November 2020; BA Mathematics) John Graham Russell (24 April 2021; BA Geography) David Galbraith Ainslie (29 August 2020; BA History/Law) Peter Morgan Rawcliffe (14 December 2020; see obituary p 180) Amyand David Buckingham (4 February 2021; see obituary p 149) Robert Andrew ‘Bill’ Budd (19 October 2020; BA Natural Sciences) Hugh Thomas Michael McMurray (7 November 2020; BA Law) Kevin Jackson (10 May 2021; see obituary p 169) Mark Richard Ayliffe (31 August 2020; BA Engineering) Miles Adrian Piers Ashworth (13 September 2020; BA Computer Sciences/Natural Sciences) Andrew Christopher Jackson (October 2017; BA Law) Katrin Dominique MacLean (1 April 2021; see obituary p 174) Ian Mason (26 April 2021; PhD Organic Chemistry; CEO Domestic & General) Francis Christopher Buchan Bland (28 January 2017; BT William Pitt Fellow)

This Gazette also carries an obituary for Kenneth William Huddart (at p 167), whose death was announced in the 2019 Gazette, and for Michael Acworth Lomax (at p 173), whose death was announced in the 2020 Gazette.


150 | pembroke college David completed his PhD at Corpus Christi in just two years, and he moved to Oxford in 1955, having been appointed as a Lecturer and Tutor at Christ Church. In 1958, David became a University Lecturer but remained at Christ Church. It was a fascinating time in the Common Room, with its being frequented by Robert Blake, Hugh Trevor-Roper, Roy Harrod, Lord Cherwell, George Pickering, the Dean Cuthbert Simpson, and WH Auden. One evening, Auden asked David what he was reading, and David told him about the Ukrainian physicist George Gamow’s book Mr Tompkins in Wonderland (1940), which explained how the universe would be affected by changes in the fundamental constants of nature. Auden was fascinated and asked if he could borrow the book. Nine months later, after an enquiry from David as to how he was getting on with the book, Auden put a poem in David’s pigeon-hole entitled ‘After Reading a Child’s Guide to Modern Physics’. The poem can readily be found on the Internet, or in collections of Auden’s poetry. David’s researches on intermolecular forces continued and in 1963 he made an most important breakthrough working with Dr RL Disch of Harvard University on equipment at the National Physical Laboratory in Teddington: together they measured the electric quadrupole moment of carbon dioxide molecules. The following year, David met his future wife Jill Bowles, a physiotherapist. For several years, David had been going to the National Research Council in Ottawa for a six week spell each summer. In 1964, he decided to make the trip to Canada on the Cunard Liner ‘Franconia’. It was on board the Franconia that he met Jill, who was going to work on Vancouver Island. They were married in Oxford in 1965, just before David was due to leave Christ Church to take up his appointment as Professor of Theoretical Chemistry at the University of Bristol. David’s distinction was such that after only four years in a vibrant department at Bristol, he was soon snapped up by Cambridge for its own chair in Theoretical Chemistry. This is what brought David to Pembroke College, becoming a Fellow in 1970. While at Cambridge, David’s work on the optical, electric and magnetic properties of molecules continued. David and Laurence Barron, who studied as a post-doctoral student with David from 1969 to 1975, did some exciting work on the Raman scattering of circularly polarised light, which led to the development of a whole new field of study, on vibrational optical activity. The practical applications of David’s research were manifold, and continue to be relevant to this day: advanced medical imaging techniques build on David’s work on nuclear magnetic resonance, while his work on nonlinear optical phenomena lies at the heart of modern-day fibreoptical telecommunications and laser technology. David also did a huge amount of work supporting the work of colleagues in the Chemistry Department (including by supervising undergraduates, exceptionally for a University Professor), led hugely impressive research teams, and lectured the main quantum mechanics course at Cambridge for more than 25 years. This support was continued worldwide through David’s editorship of the scientific journal Molecular Physics from 1968–72, and in particular Chemical Physics Letters from 1978–99, with David sending hand-written letters to authors and paying meticulous attention to the detail of their articles. David’s editorship of the latter journal was very time-consuming as the journal was published weekly. As many as


152 | pembroke college member of the Alliance Party and its Treasurer while in his 20s. He fought five successful public elections – three in succession to Belfast City Council, one to the Assembly in 1982 and most memorably his election as Lord Mayor of Belfast in 1978. He was the first non-Unionist to hold that office since the Liberal Viscount Pirrie in 1898. To achieve this end David assembled a remarkable coalition ranging from Unionists to Republicans and including the redoubtable Gerry Fitt. It must be remembered that no local politician exercised power in Northern Ireland between 1974 and 1999 and so the city council was, for much of David’s time in politics, the major centre for political debate in the absence of a Stormont parliament. David and his wife Fionnuala (née Deeny) brought to the Lord Mayoralty inclusiveness, tolerance, generosity and style. The contrast was all the greater as the Troubles were still at their height. David was a beacon of liberalism in the darkest of times. David’s courage deserves recognition. This is firstly in the physical sense, for the Alliance party headquarters was bombed and its leader had a police bodyguard. David was runner-up in a Westminster by-election in 1982 in South Belfast; it was held because the previous MP was murdered by the IRA. When the British and Irish governments entered into the Anglo Irish Agreement in 1985 some councils including Belfast refused to strike a rate or discharge their statutory duties in protest. This process would have led to considerable hardship for ordinary people. David believed that these strikes should be challenged in the courts. His moral courage is manifest, because he brought the proceedings personally and would have had to pay the council’s legal costs if he had lost. Nor can his proceedings have been popular with all of his professional clients, given the milieu from which he came. In the event he won in the High Court before Brian Hutton, later Lord Hutton, who has himself passed away this summer. That decision was upheld in our Court of Appeal – vindicating David’s initial opinion – and we got our costs! When politics ended for David with the proroguing of the Assembly in 1986, it seemed, to me at least, that he returned to practising law with pleasure. He was highly regarded professionally, particularly in the fields of probate and conveyancing. He could not resist in 1994 accepting the offer of the chairmanship of the Police Authority although it was regarded by many as a poisoned chalice. So it proved to be in that his reasoned calls for reform to make the Royal Ulster Constabulary, as it then was, more acceptable to the community as a whole did not win favour with a majority of his colleagues and lead to a split on the Authority and his own departure from that office. David’s judgment was vindicated by the reforms implemented under Lord Patten only a few years later as a key part of the Good Friday Agreement. David’s work spread over so many valuable and learned bodies that it is impossible to address them all but it is right to single out the Northern Ireland Voluntary Trust of which he was chairman for some 25 years. As Paul Sweeney says David’s appointment as the first Chairman was inspired. He raised millions


annual gazette | 153 of pounds by his passionate advocacy and tireless efforts, millions which were then spent constructively and wisely in the support of the voluntary and community sector in this part of the world. David is survived by Fionnuala, their daughter Barbary, and their four sons, Johnny, Patrick, Julius and Dominic. Hugh Burkitt (1963) writes: David didn’t just have gravitas. He had gravity. His reassuring solidity, his wonderfully deep resonant voice, his calm way of talking and his willingness to listen made him attractive. His physical presence drew people towards him. When I met David at Cambridge 57 years ago he was playing the role of Falstaff . He was witty himself, but happy also to be the source of wit in others. Just like Falstaff he drank copious amounts of sherry and generously dispensed even larger quantities of it from his room on the ground floor at 5 Pembroke Street to anyone on their way into Hall. I was particularly drawn to David because he wasn’t taking life too seriously. He was already a sophisticated member of the second year when I arrived as a freshman and I was easily led astray when he encouraged me to smoke and drink and chat rather than get down to my studies. Fortunately, the Boat Club had its own rather quaint set of training rules which kept me from complete moral collapse. For two weeks before a race we were ordered not to smoke and drink, to go to bed by 10.30pm and to get up for an early morning walk before breakfast in Hall. Fortunately the reward for this early rising strongly appealed to David and he led me on the path of righteousness – towards the special Boat Club Breakfast of double eggs and bacon. I was delighted that Johnny’s appreciation of David’s life included among David’s serious political and charitable achievements, his proud boast of having won his Pembroke oar by achieving four bumps ‘All before Grassy’. This triumph was in fact a foretaste of David’s ability to apply his formidable leadership skills to knotty problems in politics. David had worked out that in his last year he was not going to be selected for the College first eight, but what he could do would be to row himself in a brilliant second crew. The plan was that it would make a triumphant four bumps while the Pembroke first eight was going Head of the River for the first time in over thirty years. At that time the Boat Club ‘Heavies’ – our collective name for the leaders of the club – had little interest in the second eight because of their obsession with making the first boat go fast enough to go Head of the River. So David developed a year-long strategy. The first requirement was to recruit a whole new set of freshmen and persuade them to take up rowing. Then he had to teach them how to race in an eight and then he had to teach them how to make a bump. At each stage the normally laid-back David applied prodigious quantities of energy and discipline to his task. He charmed eight innocent novices into coming down to the river; then for their first term he barked alternate encouragement and abuse at them from the bank; then he jumped into the boat with them in the second term; and finally in the May Bumping Races he wound them up to attack the enemy crew ahead of them on the river so fast and furiously that the poor chumps didn’t know what had hit them – until their crestfallen cox was raising


annual gazette | 155 in 1964. Arthur began his career as a Lecturer in the Physics Department of the University of Singapore (now the National University of Singapore) and the University of Essex, moving to the University of Dundee as a senior lecturer in 1970. He was promoted to Reader in 1974, to Professor of Theoretical Physics in 1978 and was subsequently appointed to the Carnegie Chair of Physics in the Department of Applied Physics and Electronic & Mechanical Engineering. Arthur’s early research was concerned with the determination of band structures and Fermi surfaces of metals, exploiting group theory to maximise the accuracy of calculations within the constraints of the computing facilities of the day. His interest in band structure led to the study of several other grouptheoretical problems in solid-state physics, with results published in about 80 papers between 1965–1980. Of particular note is that his 1972 book with Dr C. J. Bradley The Mathematical Theory of Symmetry in Solids: Representation Theory for Point Groups and Space Groups was reprinted in 2010 as part of the Oxford Classic Texts in the Physical Sciences. The relevance of this theory is that symmetry has consequences for a variety of physical processes in, and properties of, crystalline materials. Subsequently, he was involved in extending the theory to cover magnetically-ordered solids. This led to the publication, with Dr B. L. Davies, of an extensive set of computergenerated tables of co-representations of magnetic (Shubnikov) space groups. This is now also a classic work in the field. Arthur wrote several books during this period, including textbooks and substantial monographs on Fermi surfaces and symmetry in magnetic materials. Several of these books have since been translated into other languages, including Russian, Japanese, Polish, Spanish and Chinese. He also served for several years on the International Committee for the series of International Colloquia on Group Theoretical Methods in Physics. Having established an international reputation in one field, Arthur’s personal challenge was to establish a reputation in another. In the mid-1970s his interests changed from the quantum mechanics of solids to the study of environmental issues and climate change using remote sensing, a field then in its infancy. This switch was prompted by the existence, on the one hand, of the satellite data receiving station that had been constructed in the former Department of Electrical Engineering & Electronics at Dundee University and, on the other hand, groups of academics across the university who were involved in environmental research and consultancy. In making this change his aim was to provide a link between the generators of satellite sensor data and the environmental scientists and engineers who were interested in their use. In addition to the development and operation of the satellite data receiving station, Arthur sought to use remotely sensed data to obtain information about natural and anthropogenic environments which either could not be obtained by conventional in-situ methods or could be obtained more cost-effectively. His group was concerned with a broad range of quantitative remote sensing topics, including: • modelling Earth-surface conditions and atmospheric transmission properties,


156 | pembroke college • developing sophisticated software to facilitate the automatic and operational processing of remotely sensed data for the estimation of geophysical variables in near-real time, • calibrating space-borne instruments post-launch, and • developing airborne imaging spectrometers. Arthur initiated and implemented a very extensive programme of summer schools between 1980–99, for which Dundee became famous throughout Europe and beyond. It is credited with advancing the use of remote sensing within the teaching and research of many academic, governmental and commercial organisations. Arthur was particularly proud of his contributions to the study of imagery from the Advanced Very-High-Resolution Radiometer (AVHRR), a remote sensing instrument on the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) series of satellites. His 1997 book on AVHRR sensors and their associated data remains the definitive work on this topic. Arthur was appointed Editor-in-Chief of the International Journal of Remote Sensing in 1983, just three years after its founding. In 2008, he stepped down as Editor-in-Chief, but continued to support the journal as Co-Editor-in-Chief, until the end of 2020. During his 37 years of working for the journal, it grew from a quarterly publication with an annual page budget of 500 pages, to a bi-monthly publication with an annual page budget of 10,000 pages. He personally contributed a significant body of research to the journal, including 130 research papers, reviews, and editorials. He was instrumental in the 2010 launch of a sister journal, Remote Sensing Letters, and also served on that journal as Associate Editor until 2021. Arthur retired from Dundee University in September 2002. As Professor Emeritus, he authored, co-authored, or edited eight additional books and many special issues of the International Journal of Remote Sensing. With his egalitarian principles, Arthur was a truly international scientist, believing firmly in a global scientific community that worked together for the common good. In his retirement, he continued to contribute actively to teaching and research, collaborating with institutes in China, Malaysia and Europe to promote science and scientists and to help give a voice to those who sometimes find it difficult to be heard in a western-dominated world. In China, Arthur helped hundreds of graduate students and young scientists in remote sensing at Nanjing University, Tsinghua University and the State Key Laboratory of Remote Sensing Science, by advising them on their research and guiding them in publishing their works. The National and Kapodistrian University of Athens conferred an honorary doctorate on Arthur in June 2011. He was also awarded the Remote Sensing Society Medal in 1989; the Schwidefsky Medal of the German Photogrammetric Society/ISPRS in 1996; the Remote Sensing Society President’s Award in 1996. He was twice awarded the Medal of the Remote Sensing and Photogrammetry Society, the second time in 2017. He was a valued member of several national and international societies, committees, and working groups.


annual gazette | 159 distinguish themselves worldwide as poets, academics and statesmen. Deane attended Queen’s University Belfast (1957–61) and Pembroke College Cambridge (1963–1968) and held visiting fellowships at Berkeley before returning to a lectureship at University College Dublin where he would become Professor of Modern English and American Literature and, subsequently, appointed Professor of English and Donald and Marilyn Keough Professor of Irish Studies at the University of Notre Dame, Indiana in 1993. He was also a leading figure in Irish literary and cultural life for many years, as one of the important influences behind The Crane Bag journal (1977–85) and of Field Day Theatre and publishing company responsible for what many consider to be a revival of Irish theatre and intellectual life particularly in the 1980s and 1990s when the country was experiencing some of the most damaging and tragic events of what became the ‘Troubles’. Deane’s doctoral thesis at Pembroke College on ‘The Reception and Reputation of some thinkers of the French Enlightenment in England between 1789 and 1824’ was a crucial defining subject for his intellectual and political development. He saw Irish literature in the wider frames of European writing and was an early exponent of post-colonial theories which would find expression in the three volumes of the original Field Day Anthology of Irish Writing (covering 550 AD – 1988) of which he was general editor (a further two volumes devoted to women writing was published in 2002), and in the significant series of Clarendon Oxford Lectures he gave in 1995, subsequently published as Strange Country: Modernity and Nationhood in Irish Writing Since 1790. His novel-memoir Reading in the Dark (1996) would reach a new and popular audience: it was short-listed for the Booker Prize and winner of several prestigious awards including The Guardian Prize and the Irish Times International Fiction Prize. A volume of collected essays Small World: Ireland 1798–2018 was published by Cambridge University Press shortly after his death. I asked two of Ireland’s creative writers, one from the north, one from the south, to offer their thoughts on Seamus Deane and what he meant to them. Firstly, the novelist Eoin McNamee, director of Trinity Oscar Wilde Centre (TCD): ‘You felt that Seamus Deane had your back. That there was a steadying hand. I’m not much given to reading critical writing about the North and haven’t found much in what I have read but Deane knew when the intellect should defer to the art, and that if there was a risk to be taken you would be given a fair hearing when fair hearings were in short supply.’

And Thomas Kilroy, playwright and novelist, a long-standing friend of Deane’s from their time in University College Dublin (UCD) in the 1960s as he relates in this short eulogy written especially for the Gazette: ‘My relationship with Seamus was part friendship, part a passion for the use of language. The two became entwined. It began in the nineteen sixties when we were both trying to make academic careers in University College Dublin under the sharp eye of Denis Donoghue. I was six years older than Seamus but he was the teacher and I was the student. One of the revelations that he brought to me was the connection between the Irish literary experience and Europe.


160 | pembroke college ‘We made several trips to Derry and he drove with me to my own home-place in Callan. For the first time I became aware of the reality of the border. We had at least one chilling road-block, at night, on the streets of Derry. We were exchanging our different experiences of Irishness. We were seeking out one another’s parents. When I met his father I was putting body on most of the Deane stories. I think he wanted to meet my father and mother because he knew that they were both active in the War of Independence, he, a commandant in the IRA and she, in Cumann na mBan, a stickwielding rustler of cattle from the estates of the East Galway landlords. ‘I was also a friend of some of those in the Field Day Company, with Deane, Brian Friel, Stephen Rea and Seamus Heaney before I joined them on the board with David Hammond and Tom Paulin. We were in and out of one another’s houses, talking excitedly about the great plans of Field Day. I know that Friel and Rea were anxious to bolster up the theatre weight on the board with another playwright, even one from the South, I think they were also conscious of the great engine of Deane steaming down the tracks beside them. Friendship was needed to hold it all together, with its rock solid base, its foundation of a shared understanding.’

One of Deane’s most sharply focussed and expressed views comes to mind: ‘[I]t is difficult to enter into the wider world without denying the inner world. It is not just an escape from nationality, of the British or the Irish variety; it is an escape into the belief that one is ‘free’, that one is the maker of the world he sings. I think this is a glamorous and vacuous notion’. But the last word should go to Geraldine Meaney, fellow-academic, scholar and editor and a younger colleague for many years during Seamus Deane’s tenure at UCD: ‘It has been apparent since Seamus Deane’s death how much his teaching, thinking, and writing is part of the cultural and intellectual life of twenty first century Ireland. A great moderniser of literary criticism and the university teaching of English in Ireland, it seems as if every writer and half the journalists in the country attended at least one of his mesmerising lectures. Somewhere between a dramatic monologue and intellectual immersion therapy, whole new vistas on literature, philosophy and history could open out from a handful of well-chosen sentences. ‘The powerful opening lines of his 1972 poem ‘Derry’ have become iconic of the place, the Troubles, and Seamus Deane’s relation to both. Much of his later questing, questioning critical career is hinted at in the less familiar lines when ‘the mind’s eye/Perceives the ghost/of the hand’s try’ to summon a different future beyond the confines of a history of dispossession and violence. Reading in the Dark was a poet’s novel, as AS Byatt shrewdly commented, lyrical, poised, but also haunted, an eloquent examination of powerful silences. The quest to re-imagine the relationship between past and future was at the heart of the monumental Field Day Anthology of Irish Writing. It was typical of his intellectual integrity that when three volumes and 4,000 pages failed to adequately include women’s writing and traditions, he commissioned two more volumes and 3,250 more pages that brought nation and gender into dialogue. His critical legacy is an insight into the dynamic relationship of cultural production and national identities that has implications far beyond the ‘strange country’ which remained home on so many levels, despite his move to Notre Dame University in the 1990s.


162 | pembroke college During the Second World War his school was evacuated to Pocklington, about 20 miles away, and he never forgot seeing his home town on fire during the blitz. He took his higher school certificate – the A-level equivalent – at 16, gaining a rare distinction. In 1942 he read law at Pembroke College Cambridge, achieving a 2.1 Honours degree at the age of 18, the youngest in his year. He was the college secretary of the debating society, a member of the Cambridge University band society – jazz was the current craze – and he played the saxophone. Commissioned into the East Yorkshire Regiment, he was posted to East Africa in early 1945, and learned Swahili during the convoy journey out to Burma. He was sent to Italian Somaliland to serve in the Somalia gendarmerie, where his Swahili was vital. As he had Italian warrant officers he also taught himself Italian. He prosecuted for a time in the criminal court in Mogadishu, run by the British military administration, and then went to Villagio, a small Somali village, to command a company of Somali troops. When his father died in 1946, he returned to the UK on a compassionate posting, serving the remainder of his time based in Liverpool, where the family now lived, as the adjutant at a transit camp. A mistaken phone call led to his coincidental meeting with a young doctor, Sonia Sumner, whom he subsequently married. Demobbed in 1947 he took articles of clerkship and passed his solicitors’ finals after 18 months instead of the usual two years. He opened his own practice which grew into one of the largest firms in Liverpool with a staff of some 200. He was appointed a deputy circuit judge in the crown and county courts. Sonia, meanwhile, built up her own medical practice. After retirement he attended lectures at the Liverpool University law faculty, purely for interest. His wife was busy with freelance journalism and doing locums for other doctors. He chaired various committees within the Liverpool chamber of commerce and also the Liverpool Royal Court Theatre, which was transformed from a derelict unheated barn to its original beauty, when first built in 1937. He made video documentaries of the various holidays he and Sonia had taken. As Sonia already spoke fluent Hebrew, he decided to learn it as a language and not just as a means of prayer, and pursued its study with serious vigour. He was a very committed Jew. As mayor of Crosby he insisted that all the banquets were kosher, and that his chaplain, Rabbi Stanley Wolfe, should make Hamotzi in Hebrew before formal dinners, which the mainly non-Jewish visitors clearly appreciated. He also held a special ceremonial service for aldermen and councillors at Princes Road Synagogue. He became warden and subsequently senior warden at Princes Road Synagogue, where he introduced the Sephardi pronunciation into the service – and continued to serve until 2011. He was a member of various committees, including Shaare Zedek and The Technion, and the Liverpool Old Hebrew Congregation sub-committee and select committee. He continued to hold senior positions at Princes Road and also the Southport Hebrew Congregation and was for some years a member of the Merseyside Jewish Representative Council. In 2004 he and his wife made aliyah, dividing their time between Liverpool and Jerusalem, where they bought a flat.


164 | pembroke college revenue from a given asset over time, and helped to make discounted cash flow techniques a fundamental tool for evaluating investment opportunities. In 1968, Alastair sought and secured the position that would take him to retirement in 1986 – he was put in charge of the National Girobank: a national bank that the then Labour government set up through the UK’s network of 22,000 post offices, in order to provide a way of accessing banking services for even the most isolated communities. The National Girobank had an initially shaky start, making losses in its early years – and there was some suggestion that the new Heath government would shut it down. However, Alastair managed to turn things around and the National Girobank started turning a small profit. Alastair used his position at the National Girobank to transform the banking sector: where the National Girobank went, other banks were soon forced to follow. He not only introduced the concept of free banking but also the idea of interest-bearing current accounts. The National Girobank was the first to experiment with telephone banking, and its Link network of cash point machines allowed customers at other banks to withdraw money from Link machines. Even before retirement, Alastair had started branching out into pursuing other causes. From the 1970s onwards, he became an assiduous road safety campaigner, targeting tax breaks for company cars (that were eliminated in 1992), bull bars on the front of cars, and lorries that were prone to knock pedestrians and cyclists over when reversing or turning left. He helped set up the Ethical Investment Research and Information Services (Eiris) which provided pension schemes and investment managers with information about how ethical the companies they were invested in were, and in particular on their degree of involvement with apartheid South Africa. Alastair joined the board of Eiris on his retirement from the National Girobank and continued to be involved in Eiris well into his 90s. The same year, Alastair also became vice-chair of Christian Aid. He used his connection with Christian Aid to combine forces with Oxfam and Cafod to set up the Fair Trade Foundation in 1992, which allowed supermarkets to label food and supplies as ‘fair trade’ so long as they guaranteed the producers of those products a good price for their products and a royalty on their sales. Alastair was involved as trustee or chair in dozens of charities concerned with road safety and environmentally-friendly transport: the London Amenity & Transport Association, Living Streets, the London Cycling Campaign, Airport Watch, Campaign for Better Transport, the Foundation for Integrated Transport, the Environmental Transport Association. He campaigned to spread 20mph zones in residential areas, to memorialise road deaths so as to help planners identify and tackle particularly dangerous areas of road, and to install traffic calming and car-free areas in Southwark, where he lived. Alastair was such a familiar figure riding his bike around Southwark that Southwark Council used him as their ‘poster boy’ for their 2016 #cyclehappy campaign. The same year, Alastair was given a Lifetime Achievement Award at the Cycle Planning Awards. Alastair is survived by his wife Margaret, their daughter Fiona, and their two sons, Angus and Bruce.


168 | pembroke college Ken was born in India and went to school there and at Harrow. He spent two years commissioned in the Royal Signals before going up to Pembroke College on a scholarship to read Natural Sciences (Physics) from 1954 to1957, graduating with First Class honours. As an undergraduate, Ken occupied a set next to the then Dean, Rev Meredith Dewey. He was Student Secretary for the Pembroke Walworth Mission and also stayed there for a few months when he moved jobs to London after graduating. He continued to take a very keen interest in College, including attending an event at the Pembroke Mission not long before he died. While at Cambridge, he met his wife, Audrey Newboult (Homerton 1954–57). He was thrilled that his son David Huddart (1977) followed him to Pembroke. By a wonderful coincidence his granddaughter Anna Lapwood, as current Director of Music at Pembroke College, is now the third generation of the family to be closely associated with the College. Ken was moved when we gave him one of the Pembroke ‘memorial crosses’ shortly before he died. After graduating, Ken worked at Reyrolle, Hebburn, leading nuclear and switchgear research, and then at Central Electricity Generating Board as system designer of the 500MW High Voltage Direct Current link from Kingsnorth to London. With the establishment of the Greater London Council in 1965, it became clear that engineering skills were needed in the emerging fields of traffic engineering, transport management and road safety. Ken rose to the challenge, and was appointed head of traffic signals research. Ken rose to be Chief Traffic Engineer for London before the abolition of the GLC in 1986, and also acted as Greater London Officer for Road Safety. He contributed to systems improving traffic efficiency and safety across the world, including the introduction of urban traffic control, bus lanes and mini roundabouts in London and elsewhere in the UK. At the GLC he also launched an annual road safety campaign. One campaign ‘Isn’t your life worth a light?’ promoted the idea that all motorcyclists should ride with their headlights on at all times, which is now part of standard motorcycle design. While at the GLC he welcomed professionals from around the world, and undertook traffic consultancy with the World Bank in Singapore, Madras, Manila, Calcutta, Mombasa and Baghdad. He taught traffic modelling in Northern Ireland, Israel, Zagreb and Australia. After the abolition of the GLC he worked as a traffic engineering consultant, initially for The MVA Consultancy, including a new tram system in Hong Kong, where he was proud to have cured traffic queues at the Lion Rock Tunnel. He also introduced speed cameras in Lothian, a road safety audit in Israel and toll plazas in Poland, amongst many other projects. He was passionate about evidence-based road safety, for example playing a lead in the campaign to mandate the wearing of seatbelts, contributing to a major reduction in deaths and serious injuries. As Peter Guest, who worked with Ken both at the GLC and with The MVA Consultancy, observed: ‘Ken was not without a sense of humour, but humour with an edge. Back in the 1970s I was attending a PTRC event where Ken was


170 | pembroke college On graduating with a First in English in 1977, academia and the media briefly vied for Kevin’s talents. Kevin embarked on a PhD that went nowhere and in 1980 he took up a teaching position at Vanderbilt University in Tennessee. However, academia was too narrow for someone of Kevin’s vast array of talents and interests, and in 1984 he moved to London, working for the BBC on Radio 4’s arts programme Kaleidoscope and BBC2’s Saturday Review. The launch of the Independent in 1986 saw Kevin become the Independent’s arts editor – where he distinguished himself as being able at very short notice to supply high quality copy to fill gaps created by others who had failed to come through with pieces that they had been commissioned to write – and the Independent of Sunday’s film critic. Kevin continued to work for the BBC, directing in 1987 a documentary on Anthony Burgess – whose writings for the Observer Kevin had grown up on – called Burgess at Seventy that Burgess fans consider one of the best documentaries made about Burgess. In the 1990s, Kevin made the leap to becoming a full-time freelance journalist. In his 2002 book London Orbital about travelling around London on the M25, the novelist Iain Sinclair described Kevin as the ‘freelance’s freelance’, burning up the hours on ‘essays in New York, reviews in London, radio, TV, presentation, production, small press squib, large press remainder’ and so busy that he had to compose a piece while going for a hike with Sinclair through the Surrey countryside. Kevin’s decision to go freelance resulted in an amazing stream of publications, including at least 30 books. There were books on cinema – Schrader on Schrader (1990), The Language of Cinema (1998), BFI monographs on Nosferatu (2013), Lawrence of Arabia (2007), and Withnail and I (2004) (a film very close to Kevin’s heart). There were acclaimed studies of Humphrey Jennings (2004), modernism’s annus mirabilis Constellation of Genius – 1922: Modernism and All That Jazz (2013) (a book described by Will Self as ‘that most counterintuitive of things, an insanely readable book about modernism’) and The Worlds of John Ruskin (2018). There were comic books (illustrated by Hunt Emerson): How to be Rich (2005), Dante’s Inferno (2012), How To See (2013), Bloke’s Progress: An Introduction to the World of John Ruskin (2018), and Lives of the Great Occultists (2020). There was a book for children in rhyming couplets: Greta and the Labrador (2019). There was poetry: an English translation of the Polish poet Adam Mickiewicz’s Crimean Sonnets (2015) and an edited collection of Anthony Burgess’ poetry, Revolutionary Sonnets (2002). There were books that reflected Kevin’s quirky, exuberant genius: Invisible Forms: A Guide to Literary Curiosities (2000), Letters of Introduction (2004) (A–Z treatments of ten writers and two themes), A Ruskin Alphabet (2004) (the same A–Z treatment, but just for John Ruskin), Moose (2008) (a study of the animal that Kevin was nicknamed after, with his home in Linton, Cambridgeshire, being named ‘Moosebank’), and Bite: A Vampire Handbook (2010). The last resulted in Kevin getting into film production: he commandeered the publicity budget allocated for the book by its publisher and used the money to produce, with the musician Colin Minchin, a short film called Bite: Pavane for a Vampire Queen. The film was credited to Alces Productions (‘alces’ is the genus of mammals covering the moose and the elk) and further short films would be produced by Alces.


172 | pembroke college Bournemouth, who gave him the details of her younger sister so he could contact her when he returned to Cambridge. When back at University, he wooed Wiltrud, the younger sister, with invitations to student parties, and feasts of Fitzbillies coffee and walnut cake. Having graduated in 1962, Richard then undertook a PhD under the supervision of Asher Korner. The focus of Richard’s PhD was measuring the number of transfer ribonucleic acids (tRNAs) per active ribosomes in a cell. In the course of doing so, Richard also discovered a particular type of ribosomal RNA molecule, known as 5S RNA. Richard obtained his PhD in 1966. Never one to do things by halves, Richard’s thesis was no different: it consisted of a two volume work that led to a university edict that in future PhDs in the sciences should not exceed 50,000 words. Having obtained the PhD, Richard took up a position as Resident Fellow in the Department of Molecular Biology at the University of Geneva, working with Alfred Tissières. He also married Wiltrud in October 1967. After a year, Richard returned to Cambridge, taking up a Research Fellowship at Pembroke. In 1970, Richard made a major breakthrough with Tony Hunter (whom he had met while working on his PhD), publishing a joint paper in Nature that established that that in eukaryote cells the initiation of protein synthesis is primed by a methionine amino acid supplied by a specialized tRNA. As a result, he was made a University Demonstrator (a Junior Lecturer) in the University of Cambridge, becoming a full Lecturer three years later in 1973. 1970 also saw Richard begin a 15 year long collaboration with Tim Hunt – again, someone he had first met while working on his PhD – on the regulatory steps governing protein synthesis. After Tim Hunt left Cambridge, Richard’s research began to focus on ‘internal ribosome entry segments’ (IRESs) that enable ribosomes directly to initiate translation of cellular and viral mRNA into protein products. But Richard and Tim Hunt would collaborate one more time at the start of the 1990s on developing a coupled transcription-translation system using T7 RNA polymerase. Richard loved designing a clever experiment and working out its implications, so it is not surprising that one of his most significant contributions was technical in nature. In 1976, Richard and his PhD student Hugh Pelham developed the widely used reticulocyte lysate system which enabled in vitro investigations of the mechanisms of translation. In those more innocent days, Richard did not consider patenting the system. The assay became an invaluable tool for investigators seeking to link genes to their protein products and remains a standard toolkit in many molecular biology labs. As a Director of Studies at Pembroke, Richard was a particularly astute and valued interviewer. He believed in fairness, equality and merit, and would spend a long time preparing for interviewing, pouring over each candidate’s background and comparing average school results to find those candidates who had achieved over the odds. His brilliant statistical analysis of the large and varied candidates that the College attracted was much missed by his colleagues when he retired. Aside from the stress of battling the Cambridge traffic to get in on time for 9am lectures, Richard greatly enjoyed his work. He particularly enjoyed


annual gazette | 175 travelled from Berlin to Moscow, making the journey that would become my first book, Stalin’s Nose. In 1989 Eastern Europe was in a state of euphoria and we met people who opened their hearts and told us their stories, drawn out in part by Katrin’s light touch, engagement and positivity (as well as fluent German and French). In the course of researching further books, we rode shotgun with an armed Burmese hill tribe warlord, met Aung San Suu Kyi in Yangon, canoed across parts of Canada and hand-build a feather-light flying machine that would lift me into the blue Cretan sky. After our wedding, attended by bridesmaids Joanna Prior and Christine Gettins (1984), Katrin wrote thank-you letters aboard a container ship in the mid-Atlantic. We lived on Mull, in the Cairngorms, London, Tuscany and Berlin before finally settling in rural Dorset. Our home gave us a door that we could close behind us, and we did time and time again, even after the birth of our son. We three hot-air ballooned over the Nile, slept in a mud hut in Sri Lanka, hummingbird-watched in Texas, ate horse tenderloin with Arctic thyme glaze in Iceland, and every summer on West Country walks collected wild elderflower for her to make her divine cordial. My solo travels came to be squeezed in between family milestones. After surviving a nerve-wracking road trip across Afghanistan, I rang home to announce that I was still alive. ‘And Finn can walk!’ Katrin called down the line. For 32 years we were all but inseparable, and not only because Katrin edited my every book with astute insight. Together we wrote Gift of Time about the striving for una bella morte – a good death – after my mother’s battle with cancer. And alongside shared adventures, she explored her individual gifts: becoming an innovative basket maker years before the craft was recognised as an art, reinventing herself as an Alexander Technique teacher, embracing photography as a late passion, capturing patterns, symmetries and colours of the natural (and in Berlin unnatural) world. Then at the age of 55, within two years of her parents’ deaths, cancer came out of nowhere. Its diagnosis may have been delayed by the restrictions of the first pandemic lockdown but the shocking speed of its growth wouldn’t have changed the outcome. Katrin stood up to it, declaring out loud that she didn’t invite it into her body, emboldened by the Māori affirmation kia kaha, meaning stay strong. Yet after a false dawn of successful treatment, she passed away at home in her sleep, peacefully, with me holding her hand and telling her that she is so loved. To some of us, 32 years may seem like a long time, but it isn’t and wasn’t. Katrin was taken much too soon, cruelly soon – yet for more than 32 years she lived with a gentle firm intensity, not wanting to waste a minute, as if indeed she too sensed that there truly was ‘so little time’. She embodied so many glorious qualities: her calm and measured voice, full of warmth and empathy, that could suddenly bubble into ribald laughter; her genuine smile, clean soul, clear heart and sparkling eyes, always looking, really looking, noticing, remembering, asking, caring; the joy and incredibly brightness she brought into a room; her immeasurable love for Finn; her untiring focus on what was beautiful, on possibilities. Every suppertime over our years together she lit candles, taking it all in, making the meal a special ritual, finding a home in us. ‘Life is not measured


178 | pembroke college But the initial result of the collapse of the Borough Group and his marriage was that Leslie took a step back from painting and turned to a new pursuit: car racing. He eventually became good enough in the sport that he competed in two Formula One grand prix races in 1954 and 1955, coming 13th in the first and being forced to drop out of the second because of damage to his car. A photographer captured Leslie’s car leading Stirling Moss’s and Juan Manguel Fangio’s Mercedes cars into a bend, though Leslie would readily and ruefully admit that he wasn’t on the same lap as they were. 1954 also saw Leslie make his movie debut alongside Stirling Moss in the racing movie Mask of Dust. By 1956, Leslie realised that despite some successes in car racing – first place in the 1955 Cornwall MRC Formula One Race, and fourth in the 1956 New Zealand Grand Prix – he was pushing his luck by continuing to race, and a crash at Invercargill in New Zealand led to his retirement as a racing driver, much to the relief of his mother who would stay in bed when he was racing and wait for his call to confirm he had not been killed. After a detour into film-making – producing a documentary about detergents for Unilever in 1956 that won best documentary at a Belgrade film festival (Leslie presumed his must have been the only entry) and a documentary filmed in Lapland in 1957 about reindeer migration in temperatures of about -40°C – Leslie returned to his first love: art. In 1961, he moved to New Zealand, living alone in a small fisherman’s hut by Lake McKerrow, living on trout that he would catch from the lake, and developing his talent as a painter. In 1962, Leslie married Lynn Moynihan, with whom he would have two daughters, Joanne and Rebecca. They initially lived in Devon, where Leslie would paint while also teaching in Barnstaple. In 1969, they moved to Norfolk, which inspired Leslie to produce paintings of the local churches and flowers. However, he would also travel with Lynn around Britain, the Mediterranean and New Zealand, and they spent six years on the Isle of Arran. After 36 years together, Leslie and Lynn’s marriage was dissolved in 1998 and the following year, Leslie met Maureen Dormer, a former actress who would become Leslie’s third wife in 2002. Leslie and Maureen settled in Gillingham, Norfolk but continued to make expeditions to far-flung places for Leslie to paint. In 2012, Leslie’s work was celebrated with an retrospective exhibition at the Piano Nobile gallery in London, under the title Leslie Marr at 90. He continued painting until the last year of his life. Leslie is survived by Maureen, his daughter Joanne (Rebecca died in 2016 from breast cancer), and three grandchildren. Ralph Nicholas Quartano 3 August 1927 – 1 January 2021 Obituary by Kate Quartano Brown Ralph Nicholas Quartano was born in 1927, the only child of a Greek civil engineer from Corfu and an Australian-Scots champion golfer. At prep school during the war he cleaned rifles and made Molotov cocktails for the Home Guard.


184 | pembroke college where he retained his Professorship. Stuart and Anna settled in the village of Settignano, just northeast of Florence. From there, Stuart not only worked at the EUI, but also took up a teaching position at Ca’ Foscari, the University of Venice, observing that he was ‘living every Englishman’s dream’ by being able to work in both Florence and Venice. Stuart’s historical research interests continued to spread further and further outwards, and started to turn towards France, with a co-authored work on State and Statistics in France 1789–1815 coming out in 1984, an edited collection on Domestic Strategies: Work and Family in France and Italy in 1991, and a major work on Napoleon’s Integration of Europe the same year. Stuart also produced a similarly comprehensive book on The Poor in Western Europe in the Eighteenth and Nineteenth Centuries in 1986. After leaving the EUI in 1993, Stuart finished his career holding the dual position of Research Professor at the University of Essex, and Professor of Contemporary History at Ca’ Foscari, where he created the European Doctorate in the Social History of Europe and the Mediterranean. He rounded off his publication career with a history of the Aosta Valley (1995), and – perhaps anticipating the turn European politics was about to take – a reader on Nationalism in Europe (1996). Stuart is survived by his wife Anna and their daughter Deborah, and a generation of European historians who were either taught and supervised by Stuart, or helped and advised by him.


F. MEMBERS’ CORNER


annual gazette | 187

A Dhòmnaill Choir Rory MacLeod (1984) Rory MacLeod composed the following poem (‘Dear Donald’ in English) in honour of his father Donald MacLeod (1957) on Donald’s passing in September 2020 (see obituary p 176). (The photograph on the right shows Donald and Rory on the day when they both collected their MAs from the University of Cambridge in July 2015.) A Dhòmhnaill ‘ic Chailein ‘ic Dhòmhnaill ‘ic Dhòmhnaill ‘ic Chailein mac an t-Seanaileir ri linn Iain a’ Chùil Bhàin, deicheamh ceann-cinnidh Chloinn ‘icLeòid, tha sinn uile gad ionndrainn!

Donald son of Colin son of Donald son of Donald son of Colin, son of the General, of the line of fair-haired John, tenth chief of Clan MacLeod, we all miss you!

Ged a bha thu beag nad àirde agus màlda nad mhiannan, sheas thu gu h-àrd nar spèis a’ cur mar fhiachaibh oirnn ar meas.

Though you were small of stature and modest in your appetites, you stood tall in our estimation commanding our respect.

Nad òige, bu tu am fiadh: clis, sgiobalta, uasal. Srùth do thiodhlacan gu nàdarra, torrach mar a’ chraobh ubhal.

In youth, you were a deer: nimble, quick, noble. Your gifts flowed naturally, fruitful like the apple-tree

Cho maireannach ’s a bha e luath, bha d’ shuirghe le Ròs-Màiri seunta, a’ tionndadh paidhreadh a thàinig o nèamh gu dachaigh thalmhaidh làn gaoil.

As enduring as it was fleeting, your courting with Rosemary was enchanted turning a match that was made in heaven into an earthly home full of love.

Ged a fhritheil sibh banrigh is dùthaich, còmhla agus air feadh an t-saoghail, b’ e an rud bu mhotha a choilean sibh ath-stèidheachadh ar teaghlach san Eilean.

Though you served queen and country, together and around the world, your greatest achievement was re-establishing our family on the Island.

Sruth fìon aosta na h-aoigheachd bhon taigh aig Ceann Loch Follairt, ’s gun a bhith a’ dìochuimhneachadh roinnean fialaidh aran na fàilte.

The fine wine of hospitality flowed from the house at Kinlochfollart, and not to be forgotten were the generous helpings of the bread of hospitality.

Thèid an reis air adhart, tha an fhuil fhathast làidir, agus tha thu nad òige a-rithist mar a chunnaic mi lem shùilean fhìn…

The race continues, the blood is still strong, and you are young again as I have seen with my own eyes…

… agus bha thu a’ coimhead eireachdail!

… and you looked magnificent!


188 | pembroke college

MA Degree The following information concerning the MA degree may be useful to members of the Society: Standing: a Bachelor of Arts may be admitted Master of Arts six* calendar years after the end of his or her first term of residence, provided that (which is usually the case) at least two years have elapsed since taking the B.A. degree. Fees: a fee of £5 is payable by those who took their BA degree in 1962 or earlier. Please give at least four weeks’ notice before the Congregation at which you wish to take your degree. Correspondence should be addressed to the Praelector. * For affiliated students, five years.

Dining Rights and Guest Rooms Dining rights Members who hold an MA or other Master’s degree or a higher degree from the University, or are qualified for an MA, are welcome to dine in College during Full Term or the period of residence in the Long Vacation. For the academic year 2021–2022, ‘Full Term’ means 5 October –3 December, 18 January to 18 March, and 26 April to 17 June; residence in the Long Vacation runs for five weeks from early July. • There will be no High Table dining until the start of Michaelmas Term 2021; kindly see notices in due course via email or the College’s website (www.pem.cam.ac.uk) for further information as the situation develops over the course of the Academic Year. • Dining for Members is available on Fridays and Sundays during term or Long Vacation Residence except on occasions when large College events take place. • A Member may dine as a guest of the College at High Table up to four times each academic year (once a term and once in the Long Vacation Residence), provided a Fellow or other authorised person is present to preside. On one of those occasions, overnight accommodation is free of charge for the Member if it is available. It is regrettably not normally possible for spouses/partners to dine at the High Table. However, for the academic year 2021–2022, the College is intending to hold four ‘Members’ Evenings’, when up to ten Members and their guests (twenty people in all) may dine at the College’s expense. It is recommended that large parties of Members, or Members and their spouses/partners, should seek to use these evenings as particularly good opportunities to dine in the College. Pending confirmation of the reopening of the High Table, the dates of these occasions in 2022 will be: Monday 24 January, Sunday 20 February, Wednesday 4 May, and Sunday 5 June. Attendance by a Member and their spouse at such Evenings is now restricted to one per annum for this particular academic year, so as to allow as many Pembroke Members as possible to avail themselves of this opportunity. On the evening that you have booked in to dine, we would be grateful if you could arrive at the Senior Parlour no later than 7.15 pm for drinks before dinner. The dress code is smart but it is not obligatory to wear a gown.


annual gazette | 189 Guest rooms • Overnight accommodation may also be available in College, at a reasonable charge (one person £61, two people £90 per night). • Accommodation is available for a maximum of two consecutive nights. • Guest rooms may only be booked by Fellows or Pembroke Members. If a Pembroke Member books the room, he or she should be the one, or one of the people, to stay in it. It is not normally possible to reserve rooms for nonPembroke members. • If available, overnight accommodation is free of charge for the Member, once a year, when a Member dines as a guest of the College at High Table. • The College regrets that children under the age of fourteen are unable to stay overnight at Pembroke. The College has three en-suite guest rooms (one twin-bedded room in H staircase and two double-bedded rooms in G, H and K staircases). Given these limited facilities, early notice is strongly advised when making inquiries. The College would be grateful to be informed at the earliest opportunity if a Member’s plans to visit have to be amended. Pembroke regrets that it will be necessary to charge a Member for the full cost of the room in the event that that Member should cancel his or her visit without giving at least 24 hours’ notice. College accommodation is usually available from 2.00 pm on the day of arrival; kindly observe any protocol which the porters may ask of you. Guests are asked to check out and remove their luggage before 9.30 am on the day of departure (but the Porters’ Lodge can store luggage until later in the day if necessary). Breakfast is not included in the charge but Members are welcome to have breakfast in the Buttery (usually open Monday to Friday in term time between 8 am and 10 am and for brunch at the weekend between 10 am and 1.15 pm, 11.00 am – 1.15 pm out of term). Payments are accepted by card only. How to book Arrangements for dining or for staying in a guest room should be made by completing and submitting the Accommodation and Dining Online Booking Form (https://www.pem. cam.ac.uk/alumni-development/connecting-pembroke/dining-rights-and-guest-rooms/ accommodation-and-dining-online). Bookings can be made between 8.00 am and 4.00 pm, although urgent enquiries will be dealt with outside those hours. If you experience any difficulties using the online form, please phone the Development Office on 01223 339079 or email dev@pem.cam.ac.uk. A provisional guest room booking will be made on receipt of the enquiry. We ask that payment be made within one working day to confirm the booking by telephoning 01223 339079 with your payment details. A full refund can be provided if the booking is cancelled with at least 24 hours’ notice.


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Pembroke College Gazette 2021 by Pembroke College Cambridge - Issuu