Annual Report 2021

Page 1




Dear Marble Family, What a year it has been! Amidst all the hardships we faced, Marble rose to the challenge, and for that I want to say thank you! Your support and commitment made the difference. It is hard to believe 2021 represented the second year in the pandemic. I can still remember closing the church facilities on March 13, 2020 and telling staff, “We’re closing for one week, but make sure to take enough supplies for two weeks in case it lasts that long.” I could never have imagined we would still be in the pandemic, but there are many things I could never have imagined this past year. I could never have imagined the Collegiate development project next to Marble would experience foreclosure. The vision for this project was birthed over sixteen years ago, and over those years the vision morphed and changed, but we could never have imagined it would end as it has. The news of the foreclosure has shocked, frustrated, and angered many, and I want you to know that I see this and understand the depth of what you are experiencing. As the leader of Marble, I want you to know it is my firm and sincere commitment to move us through this significant time of transition with clarity, hope and new vision for a renewed future. I have absolute confidence in God and in the Marble community to get through this together. Yes, we will experience change as a community, but I believe we can rise to this challenge together. We are fortunate Marble is on firm financial footing. At the same time, we understand there is more the congregation needs to know about Marble’s relationship with the Collegiate Churches of New York and Collegiate’s finances. We are working with Collegiate so that when the legal issues are resolved related to the foreclosure, we can provide a clear understanding of the finances around this. Last summer, we were finally able to return to in-person worship. Remarkably, our worship attendance has been strong thanks to the growth in our online viewership. Worship has been a source of connection and inspiration with all that we face. As the pandemic lessens, we hope to see you back in-person soon! We had hundreds of people joining small groups through Zoom, providing a place of community in such isolating times. We began our racial justice series, helping us all wrestle with our place and call in the quest to end racial injustice. We had twelve people commissioned as Stephen Ministers, ready to care for people who are hurting. We had over seventy people volunteering on the Care Line and as Caring Callers to ensure people have a place to turn in a time of need. These are just a few of the things highlighted in this report, and it reflects your support and commitment to rise to the challenge. May God help us continue to see what is possible in ministry in the years to come. In Christ,

Dr. Michael Bos Senior Minister



Marble Collegiate Church is a diverse, inclusive community of God’s people led by the life and teachings of Jesus Christ. We inspire everyone to become positive thinkers who make a difference in the world.


We envision a world where we all become the individuals God created us to be.

Marble Priorities

Growing Deeper

Seeking to grow in our faith in God, we commit to being a safe place to explore what it means to follow the way of Jesus who, as our source of hope, leads us to new possibilities.

Growing Relationally

Seeking to grow in our relationships with God and one another, we commit to being good neighbors in the world by seeking peace and justice for all people and cultivating a community of healing, reconciliation and transformation.

Growing in Generosity

Seeking to grow in our generosity as a grateful response to God’s blessings in our lives, we recognize everything we have belongs to God, and we commit to giving and serving as acts of worship.

Growing Young Across Generations

Seeking to grow in our capacity to be a beacon of hope and life for all people, we commit to welcoming young people and their ideas, building an inter-generational community of respect, care and belonging.


We present this 2021 Annual Report as a snapshot of a most extraordinary year. Even though we were able to come back together in person in August, and thankfully sustain in-person Worship through the Omicron surge in December, there is no question we have all been changed by this experience – as individuals and as Marble Collegiate Church. Technologies that might have been intimidating and downright scary for some of us have become crucial lifelines of connection to loved ones near and far. These same technologies enabled Marble Collegiate Church to maintain a robust ministry presence through 2021, highlighting the work of dedicated staff and volunteers who rose to a shared, unexpected challenge. In these pages are examples of our ministry through the year, the levels of engagement of our inperson and live stream congregation, 2021 financial results and the budget for fiscal year 2022. Every number is more than a number. These are real people and real dollars that came together to support the life-changing ministry of Marble Church. Each number is a testament to the power of the Marble Community. We move into 2022 with hope amidst ongoing challenges. Most importantly, we lift our grateful hearts to the God who has been with us through it all and who we know continues to guide us with an ever-present and holy hand. Soli Deo Gloria – to God be the glory.

Rev. J. Elise Brown, Ph.D. Executive Minister In his letter to the Philippians expressing his gratitude to the people of Philippi for their support, St. Paul wrote: Finally, beloved, whatever is true, whatever is honorable, whatever is just, whatever is pure, whatever is pleasing, whatever is commendable, if there is any excellence and if there is anything worthy of praise, take account of these things. (Philippians 4:8) Telling our stories is one of the strongest ways to share and express our gratitude for what God has done in our lives. Our stories provide testimony about our journeys with Christ and by so doing bring others to share in Christ’s love. Storytelling is a regular component of life at Marble. • Stories by Dr. Bos during his Sunday sermons sharing aspects of his own faith journey and of those he has pastored. • Stories in Touchpoint by Dr. Brown, other ministers and members of the Marble staff, and by congregants of how faith has guided their lives. • Testimonies by Marble members during Worship about their struggles, their journeys into faith at Marble, their gratitude for all God has provided and their commitment to giving back. • Stories shared during Prayer Circle, PrimeTime, Women’s Ministry, Small Groups, Bible Studies, and even in the “Chat Room” during Sunday Worship. This annual report is also a story, a story that with the beginning of the Covid-19 pandemic covers an unprecedented period in the life of Marble. On the one hand, this has been a time of grief, during which we have missed the human contact of worshipping, studying, and praying together. We are also working through the loss of physical spaces and managing through the significant reduction in financial support from the Collegiate Church of New York. On the other hand, this time has proved to be a testimony to the resilience of Marble Church and its members. It is a story of hope, participation, energy, and joy. It tells a story of prayer, outreach, care and support for one another. It tells a story of gratitude and giving. It tells a story of ministry, of a church providing for the spiritual needs of Christ’s community locally, nationally, and globally. I am grateful for the contributions made by each of you to the Marble story. All our stories, including this annual report, are preludes to the Marble to come. Our history is rich, our present is strong, and our future is bright. I believe that we will go “from strength to strength” (Psalm 84: 7) and “with God all things are possible” (Matthew 19:26).

Dr. G. Gregory Lozier Board Chair

Ministry by the Numbers

Marble’s Ministry



Program Participation

Social Media

Streaming Average for 2021

Average Monthly Attendance


Sunday Worship Views

Ministries / Programs include:

2,136 300

Children, Youth& Families

Chair Yoga



Small Groups

Women’s Ministry

Tuesday Bible Study

PrimeTime (55+)

Prayer Shawl Ministry

Prayer Circle

Racial Justice Series

Arts Ministry

Prayer Ministry

Afternoon Prayer

Tea Time

Gospel Choir


WeWo Views Total Countries In-Person Attendance August 8 - December 26


Marble Community Total

3,151 1,583



Adherents 6




2021 Engagement Up Over 10% Instagram






New Members


Advent & Lenten Blogs



Lent Blog: Daily Average Views

People Joined During the Pandemic May 2020 to Date



28,527 Sessions




Advent Blog: Daily Average Views


Top 5 Searched Lenten Blog on Google

Care in a Turbulent World

Once again, as we have during our long history and through so many challenging times in the world, Marble Church was blessed to be a blessing in countless ways during the turbulence of the Covid-19 pandemic. In addition to connecting with each other despite physical distance and inspiring the world through Worship and other events, we were able to expand our Ministries of Care and Education in various ways.

The Marble Care Line




1-800-531-1913 As life as we knew it changed drastically, new spiritual and emotional needs emerged in our communities. We created The Marble Care Line to help spread God’s love and hope through caring support. Trained congregants volunteer 40 hours a week to provide non-judgmental, active listening to callers Wednesdays through Sundays, 12:00-8:00pm.

The Marble Care Fund

As members of the body of Christ, we in the Marble Community have a responsibility to each other – in sickness and in health, in poverty and prosperity, in community and in isolation. During much of the pandemic we didn’t have the power of touch or face-to-face relationships to encourage each other. Yet, we did not lose the power of caring. The Marble Care Fund was established as a lifeline during this time of crisis to help Marble members who experienced direct financial impact due to Covid-19. This included loss of job, loss of income, threat of eviction and other direct impacts from the pandemic.



The Marble Call Ministry

We had a committed group of 50 volunteers who became “Caring Callers” to reach out regularly during the pandemic to those in the Marble Community who lived alone, maybe didn’t have internet and felt the most isolated. It was an important way to make sure they were doing okay and experienced an on-going connection to their church home. Our callers have reached out to nearly 200 individuals.

Call-In Worship

1-866-893-5381 For those in the Marble Community without internet access, we created a dedicated phone line that they could call on Sunday afternoons and during the following week to listen to the full Marble Worship or the sermon and scripture only.

Racial Justice Series

In May 2020, not long after video footage of George Floyd’s murder went viral, actions against racial injustice sprang up around the country. At Marble we recognized our spiritual and moral imperatives to take up the work of anti-racism from a faith perspective in meaningful ways. Throughout 2021, we recommitted ourselves to do anti-racism work and extend grace to each other as we acknowledge areas for personal growth. We established an evolving Anti-Racism Resource page on the website and continued our series of powerful conversations with dynamic guests. Hundreds of viewers have tuned in to learn and participate in topics including: Learning to Love Through Difficult Conversations, Voting Rights, and Racism and the Latinx Community. 7

Marble Outreach

Partnering with nonprofits near and far to make a life-changing difference in the lives of the most vulnerable.

Easter Offering

The congregants who worship both in person and via live stream provided monetary support through Marble’s annual Easter Offering to support the work of 53 nonprofits (43 in New York, 5 National and 5 International). The Benevolence of Marble (BOM) Committee administered the grantmaking process which raised $204,000. Grants supported needs in the areas of Education, Health (including Mental Healthcare), Hunger/Food Insecurity, Homelessness/Shelter, and Social Justice & Empowerment.

Helping to Equip New York City Children for School

Marble’s Back-to-School drive provided 480 school items for nonprofits with populations displaced by traumatic events such as domestic violence and poverty, and families impacted by mass incarceration. Marble tutors continued to provide over 30 hours of weekly tutoring online to students at PS30 in Harlem. The pandemic did not halt this mutual (for tutors and tutees) life-giving work.

Helping Others to Celebrate the Thanksgiving Holiday

Our Thanksgiving Drive helped families in need of support by providing just over 200 baskets of Thanksgiving trimmings, giving these families the opportunity to celebrate this special time of thanks with friends and family.

Spreading Joy, Love, and Light Christmas 2021

Marble congregants were full of the Christmas spirit and donated over 200 Christmas gifts to children in need at Icahn House, Osborne Association, Fresh Youth Initiatives and PS30. Joy, love, and light were expressed through these gifts.

Helping to Keep New Yorkers Warm – Winter 2021

Our congregation helped provide 248 warm weather items coats, gloves and hats for vulnerable New York children and adults at Osborne Association and Urban Pathways which provides support to homeless.

Building Friendships and Understanding Scriptural Reasoning

Once a month Marble congregants gathered with Jews and Christians online during the time of the pandemic to reflect on the sacred scriptures of Judaism, Christianity and Islam. We learned about the ways in which these scriptures are used in worship, and how individual Jews, Christians and Muslims turn to them for guidance in living a meaningful life. We also made many new friends. We are grateful for the partnership enjoyed with MuslimJewish Solidarity Committee (MJSC), Congregation Beit Simchat Torah, Central Synagogue, Muslim Community Network, the Society for the Advancement of Judaism, Muslims for Progressive Values and the Hillside Islamic Center.

Stephen Ministry

Congregants continue to provide Christ-centered care in one-on-one Stephen Ministry relationships. 12 new Stephen Ministers received 50 hours of training and were commissioned in the Fall of 2021 bringing the number of trained Stephen Ministers at Marble to just over 100. We also commissioned 2 new Stephen Leaders.


Marble Operating Results


FY 2021 Budget FY 2021 Actuals FY 2022 Budget







Income from the Marble Endowment




Collegiate Church Appropriation










Gifts from the People of Marble includes: Easter Offering: $205,429.16 (see page 8) Marble Care Fund: $10,198.00

We share our FY2021 Budget, FY2021 Actuals and FY2022 Budget for your information. We want to highlight our gratitude for the continued support Marble has received from our congregants near and far through this unprecedented time in Marble’s history. We had 978 giving households in 2021, an increase from a little over 800 in 2020. Support is coming from our ongoing, faithful congregation and from people who happen upon us online and join our livestream congregation. For every dollar of this support, we say “thank you.” These numbers reflect the new financial reality we are facing (see previous communications: September-30-Email-Update). While we do not want to minimize the significance of the financial transition we are going through, we want you to know it is our sincere commitment to move Marble toward financial sustainability. We offer this report in prayerful hope and discernment as we seek God’s guidance and strength and move forward together in 2022.

Total Recieved from 3/20-2/22: $82,107.08 Program Revenue

Total Revenue

Expenses (by department) Pastoral Care, Stewardship and Missions

(Easter Offering distribution of $205,429.16 is included)

Music and Worship




Children, Youth and Families




Adult Formation, Membership, Hospitality and Program Groups




Media and Communication (Live Streaming)




Caring for Our Staff – Finance and HR Benefits




Caring for Our Sacred Property, Facilities and Events




Capital Expenditures and Misc. Expenses Interior Renovations Project

Total Expenses Income Over Expenses

Rev. J. Elise Brown, Ph.D. Executive Minister 10










CYF Corner Highlights

In the midst of so much change and uncertainty in the world, CYF has continued to grow and thrive in new ways with God’s help. Virtual Sunday School has allowed us to provide spiritual guidance and biblical literacy to our young people. Our Youth Group continues to serve their neighbors with love by sharing their time, talent and treasure and we are proud to report that we are proud to report we have 6 youth who are preparing to make a testament of faith in Christ through our confirmation program. God has been with us through all the challenges and we’ve been able to make beauty from our ashes!

Marble Youth New Orleans Service Trip

In 2021, CYF Director Rev. Brittany Juliette Hanlin launched a campaign to send Marble Youth to New Orleans to help rebuild homes after destructive hurricanes like Katrina in 2005 and Ida in August. Their efforts raised over $25,000 and gave 15 youth the opportunity to explore their faith in the world, as they continue to discuss the effects of Climate Change on the most vulnerable communities.

Youth-led Worship and Service Project for Climate Change

In honor of Earth Day, Marble youth led our Sunday Worship that included a powerful trio of sermonettes by Amanda Crewey, Walker McSween and Ella Niewood centering around climate change and the call to action for Christians. Their service project raised $8,000 for Charity Water, working to bring clean and safe drinking water to people in developing countries, and the United Way of Houston, serving those impacted by the severe winter storm in February 2021. 11

A Ministry Snapshot Arts Ministry

In its 41st year, the Marble Arts Ministry made good use of technology to share the work of Marble artists with the masses through regular Virtual Art Exhibits at There were seasonal shows for Advent and Lent, as well as We’ve Come This Far by Faith in honor of Black History Month, Sacred Remembrance, a tribute for the 20th Anniversary of 9/11, and more. Even though they couldn’t have in-person events, they continued their traditions of the Christmas Artists’ Boutique through Facebook and Instagram, and the Summer Arts Festival featuring a week of various programs on the Marble website highlighting music from classical to jazz, dance, film/video, poetry, literature, plays and fine art including painting and photography. Painting by Leon Nicholas Kalas


GIFTS first program of 2021 featured TV and radio personality, Bevy Smith, who joined Dr. Michael Bos and Rev. Brittany Juliette Hanlin in an online conversation about overcoming obstacles and how we can live authentic lives with joy and no apologies. GIFTS collaborated with CYF on two springtime programs: a viewing and discussion via Zoom of the film Love Simon and a celebration of Pride Month in June with Bravo TV actor and LGBTQ activist Miss Lawrence, who talked about living openly and joyfully as the person God intended us to be. Throughout the year, GIFTS hosted monthly virtual Coffee Hours to connect with our community and share thoughts and experiences on surviving the pandemic. The Fellowship ended its program year with a joyous in-person brunch at a restaurant near Marble that brought a sense of hope and a light at the end of the pandemic tunnel.


PrimeTime (55+)

Our energetic, committed group continued to gather regularly on Wednesdays via video chat or phone to visit with old friends, meet new people and hear presentations on various topics. Speakers included Sister Carol Perry Zooming in from upstate, Rev. Chad Tanaka Pack from California, Marble members Dr. Jeannette Aycock and Dr. Christine Benner, and the annual tradition of variety performances by Gary Thompson and friends. As things became safer and the city re-opened, we were able to have some in-person outings including a picnic on Governors Island and the Radio City Christmas Spectacular.

Women’s Ministry

Based on their theme Together We Rise: Trust. Hope. Act., the Marble Women’s Ministry (MWM) kicked off 2021 with a virtual Winter Journaling Workshop followed by a two-day online Weekend Retreat with a combined attendance of over 150 women. The retreat We Were Made for More: TRUST More. HOPE More. ACT More. featured keynote speakers Brenda Walker, Marble Deacon and financial manager, and Rev. Susan Sparks, a trial lawyer turned preacher, comedian, and author. MWM collaborated with the Arts Ministry to co-sponsor an interview of Broadway veteran Brenda Braxton and later hosted a virtual Movie Night to view the film Minari. Other highlights included daily Lenten and Advent blogs written by MWM members, virtual Coffee Hours and a Bird Watching Tour, and the first in-person event in over 16 months: a Nature Walk in Central Park. The year ended with a poignant Hallowtide Service of Remembrance and a celebratory Christmas Party. 13

Notable Mentions The Boiler Room Today

Thanks to the dedicated work of John McHugh, our Property Manager, and a host of architects and construction personnel, after eight years of our church boiler being housed on 29th Street, it now lives in its own Boiler Room on our church property. We cannot overstate how excited we are about this. Now we are working to clean up our corner of 29th Street, getting some needed help for our trees and sidewalk and beginning to work on a permanent ADA ramp that will enable people to easily get into the church building through the 29th Street entrance.

Resuming In-Person Worship

After nearly a year and a half of being virtual only, Marble was thrilled to open its doors for Worship once again in August 2021. As the pandemic continues to improve, we are overjoyed to see new and familiar faces return to our beautiful Sanctuary.

FORUM 2021: Sacred Food ~ Blessed Earth

On September 9, 2021, Marble partnered with the Temple of Understanding for our second global forum on the climate. In connection with the UN Food Summit, 2021’s forum was on Sacred Food – Blessed Earth. The health of all living things is connected to how we source our food, and together we explored the connection between food and the climate crises, and ways we can positively address this.


Current Marble Staff and Board Ministers Dr. Michael Bos

Nick Giardina

Fred Meads

Rev. J. Elise Brown, Ph.D.

Clay Hale

Zoila Perez

Senior Minister

Executive Minister

Rev. Brittany Juliette Hanlin Associate Minister

Media Production Specialist Development, Database, and Receivable Specialist

Brian Hampton

Director of Children’s & Youth Choirs Receptionist

Don Piper

Program Coordinator

Administrative Assistant for CYF Ministry

Yvon Plaisimond

Joshua Hansen

Laura Ramirez

Rick Harper

Tanya Rivera

Daphne Kim

Desmond Roberts

Director of Membership & Connecting

Greg Lum

Mario Sprouse

Staff Virgilio Belen

Beatriz Marin

Gary Thompson

Accounts Payable / Payroll Accountant

Wedding Coordinator

John McHugh

Mike Thurlow

Baleta M. McKenzie

Judy Tulin

Rev. Susanah Wade Associate Minister

Program Leaders Kenneth V. Dake Director of Music

Christina Morano Keiser

Director of Media & Communication

Kim Sebastian-Ryan


Daniel Finegold

Part-time Production Assistant

Karla Fritsch

Publications Manager

Luis Furniel Maintenance


Events & Space Usage Manager Director of Human Resources Art Director

Property Manager Director of PrimeTime & Small Group Ministries

Rev. Rashad McPherson

Associate in Ministry and Music


Receptionist & HR Assistant Part-time Receptionist Part-time Receptionist Arts Coordinator

Executive Assistant Coordinator of Pastoral Care

Siobhan Tull

Program Leader for Online Community

Jerry Williams Maintenance

Board of Elders & Deacons Gregory Lozier Elder & Chair

Marcelle Doll

Elder & Vice Chair

Barbara Sagan

Deacon & Treasurer

Sandra Diaz

Elder & Secretary

Eileen O’Connell

Elder & Church Master

Trenesa Danuser Elder

Theodore Gregory

Renier van Aswegen

John Hupalo

Brenda W. Walker

Tim Lee

John E. Rorer, II

Matthew Morse

Greg Walker

Sheila Moses

Clair Zak


Deacon Deacon Deacon Elder

Deacon Deacon

Elder Emeritus Elder Emeritus Elder Emerita

Tomasita L. Sherer Deacon


Dr. Michael Bos, Senior Minister 1 West 29th Street / New York, New York 10001 / 212 686 2770