E8 by Maria Ramirez

‘Picasso Black and White’ at the Guggenheim Museum - NYTimes.com

HOME PAGE

TODAY'S PAPER

VIDEO

MOST POPULAR

12/11/12 10:36 PM

Subscribe: Digital / Home Delivery

U.S. Edition

Search All NYTimes.com

Art & Design WORLD

U.S.

N.Y. / REGION

BUSINESS

TECHNOLOGY

ART & DESIGN

BOOKS

SCIENCE DANCE

HEALTH

MOVIES

MUSIC

SPORTS

OPINION

TELEVISION

ARTS

THEATER

ART REVIEW

STYLE

VIDEO GAMES

‘Picasso Black and White’ at the Guggenheim Museum

The God Glut

You might expect “Picasso Black and White,” at the Guggenheim, to feel like a glamorous gimmick — the museum-blockbuster version of Truman Capote’s Black and White Ball.

The first of Picasso’s variations on “Las Meninas,” inspired by Velázquez, is on loan from the Museu Picasso Barcelona.

Connect With Us on Twitter Follow @nytimesarts for arts and entertainment news.

Arts Twitter List: Critics, Reporters and Editors

A sortable calendar of noteworthy cultural events in the New York region, selected by Times critics. Go to Event Listings » Enlarge This Image

2012 Estate of Pablo Picasso/Artists Rights Society (ARS), New York, David Heald, via Koons Collection

"The Kiss," a Picasso work from 1969.

JOBS

REAL ESTATE

AUTOS

EVENTS

What’s Popular Now

By KAREN ROSENBERG Published: October 4, 2012

2012 Estate of Pablo Picasso/Artists Rights Society (ARS), New York, Gassull Fotografia, via Museu Picasso, Barcelona

TRAVEL

Colorless Panorama Widens Vistas of Picasso

Enlarge This Image

FACEBOOK TWITTER

Childhood Obesity Drops in New York and Philadelphia

GOOGLE+

E-MAIL Happily the exhibition, billed as the first monochromatic look at Picasso’s SHARE whole career, is much more than a PRINT clever conceit. It’s as eye-opening as it REPRINTS is elegant, especially among the later works on the upper ramps, which push well past the obligatory NeoClassicism and Analytic Cubism into bracingly sensual explorations of the figure, strident political cries de coeur à la Guernica, and winking homages to Delacroix and Velázquez.

“Picasso Black and White” is, furthermore, a refreshing change from the parade of shows about Picasso’s relationships with women (as in Gagosian’s recent series of exhibitions) or with other artists (“Matisse/Picasso,” “Picasso and American Art,” “Picasso and the Avant-Garde in Paris”). Here there is just Picasso, stripped down and essentialized, his classical lines and radical sense of painting as sculpture both heightened by the restricted palette. And in places that palette is more liberating than limiting. As Gertrude Stein put it, “There is infinite variety of gray in these pictures, and by the vitality of painting the grays really become color.” She was talking about Picasso’s early gray still lifes, but her words could easily describe later works like “Marie-Thérèse, Face and Profile” (1931), a portrait of the young and pliant muse we know from boldhued paintings like “Le Rêve.” Also extraordinary: the vast majority of the show’s works are private loans, about half of them secured from the Picasso family in what is certainly a remarkable feat by the show’s curator, Carmen Giménez. (Ms. Giménez, the museum’s curator of 20th-century art and a former director of the Museu Picasso Malaga, organized the show with help

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/10/05/arts/design/picasso-black-and-white-at-the-guggenheim-museum.html?_r=0

Page 1 of 4

‘Picasso Black and White’ at the Guggenheim Museum - NYTimes.com

Enlarge This Image

Museo Nacional Centro de Arte Reina Sofía, Madrid, Bequest of the artist, 2012 Estate of Pablo Picasso/Artists Rights Society (ARS), New York

Picasso's “Head of a Horse, Sketch for Guernica," at the Guggenheim Museum.

12/11/12 10:36 PM

from the associate curator Karole Vail.) Thirty-eight of the show’s 118 works have never been exhibited in this country, and 5, among them the sharply angular “Bust of a Woman With a Hat” (1939) have never been seen anywhere in public. The implication is that we are seeing a more personal side of Picasso in his black-and-white paintings, most of which, Ms. Giménez suggests in the catalog, have wound up in the hands of the family and the Musée National Picasso in Paris because the artist was unwilling to part with them.

The few loans from other museums do not disappoint. They include “The Milliner’s Workshop” from the Pompidou in Paris; the first of Picasso’s variations on “Las Meninas,” from the Museu Picasso Barcelona; and three studies for “Guernica” from Reina Sofía in Madrid. Together these works support a theory, voiced by the critic David Sylvester, that Picasso often turned to black and white in his busier, more ambitious paintings. It was his elegant solution to crowded compositions, “just as the reduction of color to grisaille in Analytic Cubism resulted from the pressure of its intricate problems of form.” “Picasso Black and White” puts forth other ideas about his reasons for paring down his palette, as he did on and off over his career. He had Blue and Rose periods but nothing resembling a “black-and-white period,” as Ms. Giménez reminds us. Or, as the photographer Brassai observed, he had several black-and-white periods: “A period of painting on a flat surface with a bright and varied palette was regularly followed by a sculptural period with little color.” One possible motivation for these colorless phases concerns the centuries-old tradition of grisaille, a form of gray or brown tonal painting. Often it was meant to create the illusion of sculpture, as works like Picasso’s “Bust of a Woman, Arms Raised” (1922) seem to do. (A valuable lesson of this show is that Picasso’s interest in fusing painting and sculpture did not begin and end with Cubism.) The black-and-white paintings may also owe something to ancient history, namely the Paleolithic cave paintings that Picasso is known to have visited and admired. The figures in “The Lovers” (1923), for instance, are thickly outlined on a brushy gray ground that could pass for limestone. You might also see, in parts of the show, a less classic and more contemporary Picasso — an artist who used a black-and-white palette because he saw it everywhere, in newsreels and newspapers and images in art books. Looking at “The Milliner’s Workshop” (1926), with its interlocked biomorphic forms in many shades of gray, you have the uncanny sense that you are looking at a black-and-white reproduction of a colorful abstract painting. The obvious explanation, however, is the show’s most haunting one: that Picasso used black and white to reconnect to his Spanish heritage. This is clear from the Guernica studies and the Velázquez-inspired “Meninas,” of course, but also from the series of seated women that he painted in Nazi-occupied Paris in the 1940s. They may have teeth on the sides of their heads and eyes that stare in different directions, but they are, unmistakably, heiresses to Goya’s gray ladies.

The Collection E-Mail Sign up for the latest in all things fashion from acclaimed critics and reporters of The Times delivered weekly. Privacy Policy

MOST E-MAILED

The experience of “Guernica” seems to have intensified Picasso’s black-and-white painting. His large narrative works, like the “Rape of the Sabines” (1962), reveal an expanded tonal range, with high contrast reserved for areas of particular urgency. And in http://www.nytimes.com/2012/10/05/arts/design/picasso-black-and-white-at-the-guggenheim-museum.html?_r=0

RECOMMENDED FOR YOU

1. Events in Westchester 2. Russia: Prosecutors Investigate After Exhibition Draws Complaints Page 2 of 4

‘Picasso Black and White’ at the Guggenheim Museum - NYTimes.com

12/11/12 10:36 PM

smaller paintings like the vanitas-themed “Skulls,” the grays thicken to thundercloud density.

ARTS | WESTCHESTER

In This Show, the Abstract Is Here and Now

Inevitably “Picasso Black and White” is also a judgment on Picasso the colorist, repackaging a long-held criticism — that he was indifferent to or indiscriminate with color — as a virtue. “The fact that in one of my paintings there is a certain spot of red isn’t the essential part of the painting,” Picasso himself once said to Françoise Gilot. “You could take the red away, and there would always be the painting.”

4. Events in New Jersey 5. Breathing Life, and Art, Into a Downtrodden Neighborhood 6.

The Guggenheim has put Picasso’s words to the test, filtering color out of the picture entirely. And, just as he promised, the painting is still there.

SCENE CITY

Parties Precede and Proceed 7. Events on Long Island

“Picasso Black and White” continues through Jan. 23 at the Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum, 1071 Fifth Avenue, (212) 423-3500, guggenheim.org.

ARTS | LONG ISLAND

Subverting the Standard Survey A version of this review appeared in print on October 5, 2012, on page C32 of the New York edition with the headline: Colorless Panorama Widens Vistas of Picasso. FACEBOOK

TWITTER

GOOGLE+

E-MAIL

9. A King of Art With the Midas Touch

Try unlimited access to NYTimes.com for just 99¢. SEE OPTIONS »

10.

ARTS | CONNECTICUT

Small-Scale Works That Surprise at Every Turn PRESENTED BY

Get Free E-mail Alerts on These Topics Art

Picasso, Pablo What’s This? | Don’t Show

Guggenheim, Solomon R, Museum Ads by Google

what's this?

Are You Writing a Book? Get a free guide to professional editing & publishing options.

www.iUniverse.com

House hunting in ... Mexico ALSO IN REAL ESTATE »

See images of San Miguel de Allende, a hillside home built by artisans Tapping Into the potential of stylish living in Peru

Ads by Google

what's this?

Picasso Paintings Huge selection of Picasso Paintings items.

Yahoo.com

INSIDE NYTIMES.COM

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/10/05/arts/design/picasso-black-and-white-at-the-guggenheim-museum.html?_r=0

Page 3 of 4

‘Picasso Black and White’ at the Guggenheim Museum - NYTimes.com

WORLD »

OPINION »

12/11/12 10:36 PM

N.Y. / REGION »

SCIENCE »

OPINION »

Op-Ed: Marriage Equality

More state legislative wins and continuous energy in public opinion are vital as the Supreme Court considers sameGateway Recreation Area sex marriage.

Book Details American Minutiae for Russians Home

World

Faces Long Recovery

U.S.

N.Y. / Region

Business

Privacy

Technology

Your Ad Choices

Science

Health

MUSIC »

Op-Ed: The Farm Bill and Birds

How to Control an Army of Zombies Sports

Opinion

Terms of Sale

Arts

Corrections

Loss of conservation requirements could lead to the destruction of breeding grounds for game birds and Big Boi’s Swagger With a Bit waterfowl. of Angst

Style

Travel RSS

Help

Jobs

Real Estate

Autos

Work With Us

Site Map Advertise