LED professional Review (LpR) – May/June 2024 – LpR#103

Page 1

NavigatingtheFutureof LightingwithScienceand Innovation

Inthiseditionofourmagazine,wedelveintoarangeofcompellingtopics withinthelightingindustry,emphasizingtechnologicalinnovation,health impacts,andenvironmentalsustainability.Theissuefeaturesan explorationofadvancedmicro-opticstechnologiesthatenhancethe precisionandefficiencyoflightingsystems,crucialforapplicationsin mobilityandconsumerelectronics.Thetransformativepotentialof Scan-to-BIMtechnology,facilitatedbysmartphonesequippedwithLiDAR sensors,ishighlightedforitsroleinrevolutionizingarchitecturaland lightingdesignthroughefficient3Ddataacquisitionandmodelcreation. AninterviewwithDr.JenniferVeitch,PresidentoftheCIE,provides insightsintohercareerandthestrategicdirectionoftheorganization, emphasizingtheintegrationofscientificresearchwithglobalsustainability goals.ProfessorDr.ManuelSpitschandiscussesthesignificant non-visualeffectsoflightonhumanhealth,advocatingforadvancements instandardizedlightexposuremeasurements.Additionally,ananalysisby Dr.SebastianKnocheandDipl.-Ing.MarinaProskeaddressesthe environmentalimpactsofLEDluminaires,focusingonsustainableproduct designandimprovedrecyclingprocesses.Thevibrantlightingmarketin Asiaisexaminedforitsgrowthandinnovation,reflectingtheregion’s uniquechallenges.Lastly,AdamLilienfromULSolutionsdiscussesthe developmentofcircadiantoolsthatenhancethecircadianperformanceof lightingproducts,aimingtodesignhealthierindoorenvironments.Each articlecontributesuniqueperspectivesonthecurrenttrendsandfuture directionsinlighting,highlightingtheindustry’scommitmenttoenhancing bothhumanwell-beingandenvironmentalstewardship.

Enjoyyourread!

YoursSincerely,

EDITORIAL 4 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design Issue103/May-June/2024
LEDprofessional,TrendsinLighting,LpSDigital&GlobalLightingDirectory InternationalSolid-StateLightingAlliance(ISA),MemberoftheBoardofAdvisors MemberoftheGoodLightGroupandtheEuropeanPhotonicsIndustryConsortium
LugerResearche.U.,Founder&CEO

8 ARoadmapforLightandHealth

byProf.Dr.ManuelSPITSCHAN,Professorfor ChronobiologyandHealthattheTechnical UniversityofMunichandMaxPlanckResearch GroupLeaderattheMaxPlanckInstitutefor

20 Dr.JenniferVEITCH,PresidentofCIE compiledbyEditors,LEDprofessional

ULINTERVIEW

26 AdamLILIEN,GlobalBusiness DevelopmentManagerofLightingatUL Solutions compiledbyEditors,LEDprofessional

ECO-DESIGN

30 EnvironmentalImpactsofLED Luminaires,RecyclingPractices,and RecommendationsforaMore SustainableLightingIndustry byDr.SebastianKNOCHE,TRILUX;Dipl.-Ing. MarinaPROSKE,FraunhoferIZM

CONTENT OVERVIEW 6 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design Issue103/May-June/2024 4 EDITORIAL COMMENTARY
NEWS 10 InternationalLightingNews CIEINTERVIEW
BiologicalCybernetics

MICRO-OPTICS

40 ThePromisingFutureofFree-form Micro-OpticsinMobilityInteriors byChristianFORSTNER,HeadofSalesat Seisenbacher

LIGHTINGDESIGN

42 TheFutureofScan-to-BIMin LightingDesign byMartinHUBER,Co-Founder&CEOof MetaroombyAmrax

MARKETREPORT

50 Solid-StateLightingMarketReport:ASIA byDr.J.NormanBARDSELY,ChiefAnalystat InternationalSolid-StateLightingAlliance

56 ExpertTalksonLight–TimeMatters,ShiningLightonMetabolic Health

CONTENT OVERVIEW 7 Issue103/May-June/2024 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design
LPSDIGITALTALKS
58 ABOUT|IMPRINT ADVERTISINGINDEX 2 Würth 3 CreeLED 5 Röhm 9 LightingEurope 11 EUCHIPS 13 EdisonOpto 15 CreeLED 17 InstrumentSystems 19 DALIAlliance 25 Yujileds 47 LightingRecipeStudio 48 TrendsinLighting 49 GoodLightGroup 55 LEDprofessionalReview 59 GlobalLightingDirectory 60 LEDprofessionalReview

Prof.Dr.Manuel SPITSCHAN

Prof.Dr.ManuelSpitschanisthe RudolfMössbauerAssistant ProfessorforChronobiologyand HealthattheTechnicalUniversity ofMunichandaMaxPlanck ResearchGroupLeaderatthe MaxPlanckInstituteforBiological Cybernetics.Afterstudiesin psychologyattheUniversityofSt Andrews,Prof.Spitschanreceived hisPhDonmelanopsinsensitivity inthehumanbrainfromthe UniversityofPennsylvania.He completedpost-doctoraltraining atStanfordUniversity,the UniversityofOxfordandthe UniversityofBasel.Heiscurrently theSpeakeroftheDaylight AcademySteeringCommittee, andChairoftheCIEJoint TechnicalCommittee20.

www.tscnlab.org

ARoadmapforLightandHealth

In1980,AlLewyandhisteam discoveredthatlightexposureatnight suppressestheproductionofthe endogenoushormonemelatonin.About 20yearslater,twoteamsatThomas JeffersonUniversity,ledbyGeorge “Bud”Brainard,andattheUniversityof Surrey,ledbyDebraSkene, characterizedthewavelength dependenceofmelatoninsuppression bylight,identifyingasignaturefora non-rod,non-conephotoreceptor underlyingmelatoninsuppression. Almostatthesametime,the photopigmentmelanopsinandits expressioninasubsetofnervecellsin theretinawasdiscovered.Another20 yearslater,ateamaroundAndrew PhillipsandSeanCaincharacterized significantindividualdifferencesin melatoninsuppressioninpeople.

Thesefundamentaldiscoveriesin neurosciencehaverevolutionizedhow lightisused,conceptualized,and measuredinthebuiltenvironment. Inadditiontotheassessmentoflight exposureintermsofphotometry, α-opic radiometry(standardizedbytheCIEin theInternationalStandardCIES 026/E:2018)allowsustoestimatejust howthephotoreceptorsintheretinaare affectedbyenvironmentallight.These standardized“physiologicallyrelevant” quantities,particularlythemelanopic equivalentdaylightilluminance (melanopicEDI)areessentialforany lightingengineeringanddesign approachesputtinghumanresponsesat thecentre.

Whatshouldthefollowingyearsof researchonthenon-visualeffectsof lightlooklike?Thereareseveralkey emergingapproachesandtechnologies thatwillmovetheneedleinmakingthe sciencecountinthe“realworld”.

Thefirstoneconcernstheuseof wearablelightloggersthatallowfor measuringlightexposureinthefield.

ahttps://melidos.eu/

bhttps://tscnlab.org/podcast

chttps://doi.org/10.17605/osf.io/rxa35

IntheEURAMET-fundedMeLiDos projecta,anovelframeworkfor characterizationandcalibrationofthese lightloggersisdeveloped,andfeeds intoacurrentlyactiveCIEcommittee (CIEJTC20).Inadditiontothetechnical aspectsofthiswork,moredatasets measuringlightexposureindiverse populationsacrosstheglobewillneed tobecharacterizedtoderivebaseline measurementsoflightexposure.Sucha globalmeasurementcampaign necessarilyneedssomeharmonization ofapproaches,butonlythrough’big data’willthefieldbeabletounderstand justhowmuchlightpeoplereceive–andwhatopportunitiesforimproving theirlightexposureforoptimizinghealth outcomes.

Aseconddirectionconcernsthe appreciationofindividualdifferencesin thenon-visualeffectsoflight,and further,understandingwhichbiological, geneticandbehavioralmechanisms drivethesedifferences.Similarly, large-scalecoordinatedeffortsare neededtocreateanevidencebasethat reflectsthosewhocanbenefitfrom optimallightexposure–andthatisallofus.

Athirdareaofworkthatisofhigh priorityisthedevelopmentofeffective communicationsstrategiesforvarious stakeholders–thegeneralpublic,and alsoprofessionalgroupsthatcanuse knowledgeofthenon-visualeffectsof light.Myteamhasrecentlystartedthe podcastLightO’Clockb,andinarecent meetingIchairedinLadenburg,agroup ofinternationalexpertsagreedon developingeffectivecommunications strategiesandwroteaWhitePaperc aboutit,whichwillseeimplementation overthenextyear.

Thefollowing20yearsofresearchon theinfluenceoflightonhealthwillallow ustomovetheneedle–andmakethe neurosciencecount. ■

COMMENTARY PROFESSORDR.MANUELSPITSCHAN 8 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design Issue103/May-June/2024

NewManagingDirectorat InstrumentSystems

https://www.instrumentsystems.com

On2April2024thepositionoftheManaging DirectorpassedfromYasumasaKuboyamato Dr.YutaYamanoi,whotogetherwithCEODr. MarkusEhbrechtformthenewInstrument Systemsmanagementteam.

Dr.YutaYamanoihasdistinguishedhimself throughmorethantwodecadesof professionalexperienceinthefieldofcolor andlightmeasurementtechnology.Aftereight yearsinthedevelopmentdepartmentat KonicaMinoltaSensinginJapan,in2016he transferredtoKonicaMinoltaSensing AmericasInc.asBusinessDevelopment Manager.Inthiscapacityhealsotookover thesupportofkeyaccountcustomersinthe ITsegment.Mostrecently,hewasSenior ManagerforStrategicPlanninginLight& DisplayandColor&Appearancedivisionof KonicaMinoltaSensingBusinessUnitin Japan.AsascientistwithaPhDin“Earthand SpaceSciences”hethusdisposesof extensiveandhighlyrelevantknow-howinthe businessareaofthewholly-ownedKonica MinoltasubsidiaryInstrumentSystems.

Inhisnewrole,overthenextfewyearshewill continuetopromotethecooperationbetween theKonicaMinoltasubsidiariesoftheSensing BusinessUnitwiththeirLight&Displayand Color&Appearancedivision,whichalso includesInstrumentSystems.Dr.Markus EhbrechtwelcomesDr.YutaYamanoitohis newposition.Inthecourseoftheregular changeinthedoubleleadershipheislooking forwardtostrengtheningthecompany togetherwithDr.YutaYamanoiforthevolatile marketsituation,creatingnewaddedvaluefor thecustomers.

ThedepartingYasumasaKuboyamahasbeen ManagingDirectorofInstrumentSystemsin GermanysinceApril2023andisnowtaking overanewdepartmentinKonicaMinolta SensingbusinessunitinJapan.

InstrumentSystemsGmbH InstrumentSystemsGmbH,foundedin Munichin1986,developsandproduces high-endlightmeasurementtechnologythatis indispensableforthemanufacturersof consumerelectronics,(AR/VR)displays, mLEDwafers,VCSEL/lasersystems, automotivelightingandLED/SSLmodules.All

solutionsbenefitfromourCASseriesof high-precisionspectroradiometersthatare recognizedandinuseallovertheworld.In combinationwith2Dimagingcolorimeters, integratingspheresandgoniometersystems, theyenablehigh-precisionandaccurate measurementsintheentirerangefromUVto IR,traceabletoPTBorNIST.Today, InstrumentSystemsisoneoftheworld’s leadingmanufacturersoflightmeasurement technology.AtitsBerlinfacility,the“Optronik Line”ofproductsisdevelopedandmarketed fortheautomotiveindustryandtraffic technology.OursubsidiaryinKorea supplementstheproductportfoliowiththe “KimsoptecLine”fortheKoreanlight& displaymarket.InstrumentSystemshasbeen awholly-ownedsubsidiaryoftheKonica MinoItaGroupsince2012. ■

ThorstenCramernewCEOof

AnsorgGmbH–Shapingthe FutureDirection

https://ansorg.com

AnsorgGmbHannouncedthatThorsten Cramerhasbeenleadingthecompanyasthe newCEOsinceMarch1,2024.With extensiveleadershipexperienceinthelighting industryatinternationalcompanies,Mr. Cramerbringscomprehensiveexpertisetothe management.

Asakeycornerstoneofitslong-termstrategy, AnsorgGmbHaimstoestablisha future-orientedmanagementstructure.This includesgraduallytransferringresponsibilityto anewleadershipteamcomposedof experiencedprofessionalsinsales,finance, andoperations.Thefirstphaseofthisnew managementstructurewassuccessfully initiatedin2022,appointingkeypositionsin operationsandfinancewithexperienced executives.ThorstenCramer’sappointment asCEOmarksanotherstepinthis development.Thismeasurestrengthensthe leadershipstructureofAnsorgGmbHand supportsthetargetedfurtherdevelopmentof corporatemanagement.

AnsorgGmbHwillcontinuetofocuson providinginnovativeandoutstandinglighting solutionsfortheretailindustry.“Ilookforward tocontinuingAnsorg’ssuccessstory,”said ThorstenCramer.Thecurrentmanaging directors,RudolfPützandManfredMeier,will

continuetoactivelysupportthetransitionand remainwiththecompanyasshareholdersin advisoryroles. ■

DOEReleasesFirstEver FederalBlueprintto DecarbonizeAmerica’s BuildingsSector

www.energy.gov/eere/buildings/buildingtechnologies-office

FirstComprehensiveFederalStrategyOutlines PathwaystoReduceEmissions90%in BuildingsSectorby2050,Reinforcing PresidentBiden’sInvestinginAmericaAgenda toLowerEnergyCosts,ImproveResilience, andTackletheClimateCrisis.

TheBiden-HarrisAdministrationreleased DecarbonizingtheU.S.Economyby2050:A NationalBlueprintfortheBuildingsSector,a comprehensiveplantoreduce greenhouse-gas(GHG)emissionsfrom buildingsby65%by2035and90%by2050. TheU.S.DepartmentofEnergy(DOE)ledthe Blueprint’sdevelopmentincollaborationwith theDepartmentofHousingandUrban Development(HUD),theEnvironmental ProtectionAgency(EPA),andotherfederal agencies.TheBlueprintisthefirstsector-wide strategyforbuildingdecarbonization developedbythefederalgovernment, underscoringPresidentBiden’s whole-of-governmentapproachtocutting harmfulcarbonemissionsandachievingthe nation’sambitiouscleanenergyandclimate goals.

“America’sbuildingsectoraccountsformore thanathirdoftheharmfulemissions jeopardizingourairandhealth,butthe Biden-HarrisAdministrationhasdevelopeda forward-lookingstrategytoslashthese pollutantsfrombuildingsacrossthenation,” saidU.S.SecretaryofEnergyJenniferM. Granholm.“Aspartofawhole-of-government approach,DOEisoutliningforthefirsttime everacomprehensivefederalplantoreduce energyinourhomes,schools,and workplaces—loweringutilitybillsandcreating healthiercommunitieswhilecombatingthe climatecrisis.”

Buildingsaccountformorethanonethirdof domesticclimatepollutionand$370billionin

NEWS INTERNATIONALLIGHTING 10 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design Issue103/May-June/2024

annualenergycosts.ReducingGHG emissionsfrombuildingsisessentialto reachingtheBiden-HarrisAdministration’s goalofachievingnet-zeroemissionsby 2050.TheBlueprintprojectsreductionsof 90%oftotalGHGemissionsfromthe buildingssector,whichwillsaveconsumers morethan$100billioninannualenergycosts andavoid$17billioninannualhealthcosts.

OneinfiveAmericanslivesinahouseholdthat isatleastonemonthbehindonitsenergy bills,accordingtotheU.S.CensusBureau HouseholdPulseSurvey.Economically disadvantagedcommunitiesaremorelikelyto faceenergyinsecurityduetohighenergy costs.Theyarealsomorelikelytosufferfrom theeffectsofsubstandardbuildingconditions andhealth-harmingpollution.Toaddress theseinequities,theBlueprintemphasizes affordabilitythroughreducedenergyand technologycosts,aswellasmeasuresthat wouldhelpmakecommunitiesmoreresilient topoweroutagesandclimatechange-fueled extremeweatherevents.

Fourstrategicobjectives:

• Increasingbuildingenergyefficiency

• Acceleratingonsiteemissionsreductions

• Transformingtheinteractionsbetween buildingsandtheelectricitygrid

• Minimizingtheemissionsfromproducing, transporting,installing,anddisposingof buildingmaterials

Eachobjectivehasspecificperformance targetsandmarket,policy,andtechnology milestonestoreachby2035and2050. Meetingthesetargetswillrequireaccelerated deploymentofawiderangeof decarbonizationandenergyefficiency technologies.TheBlueprintoutlines coordinatedfederalactionsthatcanincrease thespeedandscalewithwhichthese solutionsaredeployed.Thoseactionsinclude fundingresearchanddevelopmenttodevelop lower-costtechnologies,expandingmarkets forlow-carbontechnologies,providingdirect fundingandfinancing,andsupportingthe developmentandimplementationof emissions-reducingbuildingcodesand appliancestandards.Inlinewiththe Biden-HarrisAdministration’seffortstohelp ensurethebenefitsofthecleanenergy transitionflowdirectlytoimpacted communities,theBlueprintalsooutlinesways thatfederalagenciescansupportstate,local, andTribaldecarbonizationobjectives.

Toachievethesegoals,DOEisfocusedon buildinginnovationsinthreepivotalareas: buildingupgrades,efficientelectrification,and smartcontrols.DOE’sapproachstrivesto advancescalabletechnologiesandinstallation solutionsforaffordable-housingresidents whileexpandingworkforcecapabilitiesatthe stateandlocallevels.

DOE’sAffordableHomeEnergyShot™,which aimstoreducetheupfrontcostofupgrading

ahomebyatleast50%andreduceenergy billsby20%withinadecade,willaccelerate progresstowardtheemissions-reduction targetsestablishedintheBlueprint.Tolearn moreaboutDOE’seffortstoimprovethe efficiencyandaffordabilityofAmerica’s buildingstock,visittheBuildingTechnologies Officehomepage. ■

DOELaunchesFinalPhaseof ItsL-PrizeLighting Competitionon

Manufacturing&Installation

https://americanmadechallenges.org/challenges/lprize

TheU.S.DepartmentofEnergy(DOE) launchedthethirdandfinalphaseofits LightingPrize(L-Prize®)competition,aDOE American-MadeChallengedesignedtospur groundbreakinginnovation,local manufacturing,andthebenefitsofan inclusive,clean-energyeconomyfor next-generationlightingincommercial buildings.Phase3,calledManufacturing& Installation(M&I),willunfoldover16months andrewardproductionandinstallationof productsthatmeetL-Prizetechnical requirementsinreal-worldbuildings.Upto fourcompetitorsearningthemostpoints basedontechnicalanddesigninnovation,

11 Issue103/May-June/2024 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design

U.S.content,production,andinstallationwill shareanawardof$10million.

“ThisfinalphaseoftheL-Prizeisprimedto showcasenext-generationlightingsolutions thatcombinehighefficacywithexceptional lightingquality,data-drivencontrol,and sustainabledesignandconstructioninreal buildings,”saidMandyMahoney,DOE BuildingTechnologiesOfficedirector.“What makesthisprizedifferentfrommanyothersis thatitwillshowcaseboththeproducts’ innovativefeatures,andalsotheirpotentialto scale.Anditrewardscompetitorsforthinking creativelyabouthowtomakethemin America.”

TheL-Prizeadvancesthestate-of-the-artin LEDlighting,encouraginginnovatorsto developadvancedluminairesandlighting systemsthatleadtotransformativedesigns, products,andimpacts.Inadditiontoits technicalinnovationgoals,theL-Prize prioritizesequity,affordability,and resilience-relatedinnovationsthatwillsupport thebroaddeploymentofwinningsolutionsto allcommunities,particularlythosewithlimited resources.

“I’mexcitedabouttheapproachtoequityin thisphaseoftheL-Prize.Itmeetsthe commitmentDOEhasmadetotheJustice40 Initiative,sothat40percentoftheoverall benefitsofcertainfederalclimate,clean energy,affordableandsustainablehousing, andotherinvestmentsflowtodisadvantaged communitieswherethey’reneededmost,” addedMahoney.

TheM&IPhasewillrecognizeteamsthatare abletotranslateinnovationsinspiredbythe L-Prizetomarketavailabilityandinstallation. TheM&IPhasehastwoseparatetracks:the LuminaireTrackandtheConnectedSystems Track.Competitorsmaysubmittothe LuminaireTrack,theConnectedSystems Track,orseparatelytobothtracks.DOEwill evaluateeachtrack’ssubmissions independently.Allentriesmustmeetthe minimumtechnicalrequirementsandbefully commerciallyavailableandphysicallyinstalled inreal-worldapplications.Entriesmust demonstratebenefitsrangingfromenergy efficiencyandlightingqualitytoconnectivity andsustainability.TheM&IPhasealso includesevaluationcriteriauniquetothis phase,includingU.S.manufacturingcontent, installation,anddeploymentstrategy.

HowtoParticipateintheL-Prize’sM&IPhase: VisittheL-Prizewebsitetoviewthecomplete competitionrequirementsandtimeline.Forms toexpressinterestinthecompetitionaredue October1,2024. ■

NewWorkingGroupto CollaborateandAdviseon HorticulturalLightingControls

https://www.designlights.org/ourwork/horticultural-lighting/technicalrequirements/hort-v3-0/

Lightingandcontrolsmanufacturers, engineeringanddesignconsultants, non-profits,researchers,andindoor cultivatorsareamongstakeholdersrecently appointedhelptheDLCacceleratethe horticulturallightingindustry’sadoptionof networkedlightingsolutionsthatadvance bothcropproductionandenergyefficiency.

“Thecontrolledenvironmentagriculture industryhasgrownsteadilysincetheDLC createditsfirsthorticulturallightingtechnical requirementsandQualifiedProductsListin 2018,”DLCExecutiveDirectorandCEOTina Halfpennysaid.“Welookforwardto collaboratingwiththeseindustryexpertsas wetaketheDLC’shorticulturalprogramtothe nextstep,expandingtheroleofconnected andintegratedlightingsolutionsthatwill enhancebothenergyuseandcrop production.”

Representingtheinterestsoftheirrespective industriesratherthanindividualcompanies andorganizations,membersofthe HorticulturalLightingControlsTechnical WorkingGroupinclude:

• MikhailSagal,TSRgrow

• ErikRunkle,MichiganStateUniversity–CollegeofAgriculture&NaturalResources

• GretchenSchimelpfenig;Greenhouse Lighting&SystemsEngineering(GLASE) Consortium

• EricEisele,GrowFlux

• MarkBlonquist,ApogeeInstruments

• CristinDziekonski,Fluence

• IhorLys,Agnetix

• FrancoisR.-Moisan,SollumTechnologies

• EmmanuelWJLOomen,Hawthorne GardeningCompany

Thenine-memberpanelwillprovideinputon DLChorticulturallightingprogramupdates, creationofresources,andrelatedactivities. Moreover,astheDLCcontinuestoimprove theefficacyandqualityofhorticulturallighting eligibleforutilityincentivesandrebates,the workinggroupwillprovidetechnicaland strategicfeedbackandinputonactivitiessuch as:

• Mappingopportunitiesforhorticultural lightingcontrolsandintegratedcontrols solutionsthatsaveenergyand/oroptimize cropproduction;

• Addressingchallengesandriskstothe advancementofenergy-savingand/or production-improvingconnectedsolutions; and

• Reviewinganddevelopingresourcesthat supporttheDLC’smission,DLCefficiency programmemberobjectives,andgrower needs,includingcasestudies,grower educationandguidance,andprogram implementation.

TheHorticulturalLightingControlsTechnical WorkingGroupisexpectedtomeetquarterly. ExploretheDLCwebsiteformoreinformation abouthorticulturallightingandthe HorticulturalLightingTechnicalRequirements, andtosearchforandviewhundredsof productsontheHortQPL. ■

amsOSRAMSellsPassive OpticalComponentsAssetsto FocuslightTechnologies

www.focuslight.com/

amsOSRAM(SIX:AMS)sellsrelevantPassive OpticalComponentsassetstoFocuslight TechnologiesInc.forEUR45millionincash.

“Withourstrategicefficiencyprogram ‘Re-establishtheBase’,wehavepromisedas onekeyelementtoexitthenon-coreportfolio inoursemiconductorbusiness.Nowwe deliveranotherimportantstepandannounce thesaleofrelevantPassiveOptical ComponentsassetstoFocuslight TechnologiesInc.,whoisanexcellenthome forthem.amsOSRAMcontinuesexecuting its‘Re-establishtheBase’programaccording toplan,”saidAldoKamper,CEOofams OSRAM.

NEWS INTERNATIONALLIGHTING 12 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design Issue103/May-June/2024

Executingthe‘Re-establish-the-Base’ Program

OnJuly27th,2023,thecompanyannounced its‘Re-establishtheBase’program,focusing onitsprofitablecoreasanewbasefor sustainable,profitablegrowth.

Intermsofportfoliomeasuresaimedatexiting certainnon-corebusinessesinthe semiconductorportfolio,thecompanyhad prioritizedthecarve-outofthePassiveOptical Componentsbusiness.

amsOSRAMsignedanagreementwith FocuslightTechnologiesInc.(Focuslight–NeverStopExploring),afast-growing companyinopticaltechnologies, headquarteredinXi’an(China)andlistedon thestockexchangeinShanghai(China),for thesaleofrelevantassetsofitsPassive OpticalComponentsbusiness.Focuslight TechnologiesInc.agreedtoacquirethose assetsforEUR45millionincash.The transactionissubjecttoclosingconditions whichincludeapprovalsbytheshareholders ofFocuslightTechnologiesInc.andChinese regulatoryauthorities.Itisexpectedtoclose inthethirdquarter2024.

Theexistingbusinessinopticalcomponents forConsumerapplications,generatingaround EUR50millionofrevenuesin2023and phasingoutin2024,isnotpartofthe transaction. ■

LumiledstoSellitsLamps andAccessoriesBusinessto FirstBrandsGroup

https://lumileds.com

Lumileds,LLC,oneoftheworld’sleadingLED manufacturersandsolutionprovidersforthe globalautomotive,illumination,display,and flashmarketsandFirstBrandsGroup,LLC (“FirstBrands”),aglobalautomotiveparts

manufacturerthatservestheworldwide automotiveaftermarket,haveenteredintoan agreementforFirstBrandstoacquirethe LampsandAccessoriesbusinessofLumileds for$238M.UnderFirstBrands,theLamps andAccessoriesbusinesswillcontinueto expanditsglobalofferingsandpositionits productsandleadingbrandsinthe automotiveaccessoriessector.

“TheautomotiveOEMlightinggo-to-market synergiesandconditionsthatmadetheunion ofLumiledsandPhilipsautomotivelighting businesssocompellingnearlyadecadeago havechangedastransportation manufacturershaveadoptedLEDsastheir standardlightsourceandtraditional automotivelightsourceshavetransitionedto primarilyanautomotiveaftermarketbusiness,” saidSteveBarlow,LumiledsCEO.“Our LampsandAccessoriesandourLED businessesareindustryleadersintheir respectivemarketsandwillbefreetofocuson theongoinggrowthoftheiruniquebrands, channels,andcustomers.”

Thesaleisexpectedtocloseinthe2nd calendarquarterof2024.

Aspartoftheacquisition,Lumileds automotivelampsfactoriesinChina, Germany,andPolandwilltransferwiththe LampsandAccessoriesbusiness.Lumileds willretainitsfactoriesandsitesinThe Netherlands,UnitedStates,Malaysia, Singapore,GermanyandJiaxingChina.

CitiactedasfinancialadvisorandDLAPiper actedaslegaladvisortoLumileds.

AboutLumileds:Lumiledsisagloballeaderin OEMandaftermarketautomotivelightingand accessories,cameraflashformobiledevices, MicroLED,andlightsourcesforgeneral illumination,horticulture,andhuman-centric lighting.Ourapproximately5,500employees operateinover30countriesandpartnerwith ourcustomerstodeliverneverbeforepossible solutionsforlighting,safety,andwell-being. Learnmoreathttps://lumileds.com.

AboutFirstBrands:FirstBrands™isaglobal automotivepartscompanythatdevelops, marketsandsellspremiumproductsthrough aportfolioofmarket-leadingbrandsthatoffer best-in-classtechnology,industry-leading engineeringandmanufacturingcapabilities, andsuperiorcustomerservice. ■

SignifyIntroducesAmbitious NetZeroEmissionsReduction Targets,ValidatedbySBTi www.signify.com/global/sustainability/ourprogram

Signifyannouncedthatitisexpandingits climateactionwithambitiousnewNetZero emissionsreductiontargets.Thecompany hasintroduceda2040net-zerotargetanda commitmenttoreduceabsolutescope1,2 and3greenhousegas(GHG)emissionsby 90%withouttheuseofcarboncredits.These targetshavebeenreviewedandvalidatedby theScienceBasedTargetsinitiative(SBTi).

“Absoluteemissionsreductionhasalways beenthebackboneofourclimateaction.We havereducedmorethan75%ofour operationalcarbonfootprintsince2010. Throughthecombinationofradical improvementsintheefficiencyofourproducts andhundredsofinitiativesimplementedin factories,offices,andacrossouroperations, wehavereducedourfullscopegreenhouse gasemissionsbyhalfsince2019.”

13 Issue103/May-June/2024 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design

“Webelievewehaveanimportantroletoplay inthetransformationtowardalow-carbon economy.Ourdedicationtosustainable innovationhasenabledustocontinuously breakthroughenergyefficiencytechnology barrierswithourLEDproductsandconnected systems.”

–MauriceLoosschilder,GlobalHeadof SustainabilityatSignify

In2019,Signifybecameoneofthefirst30 companiesworldwidetohaveitscarbon emissionsreductiontargetsvalidatedbythe SBTitobealignedwiththe1.5°Cpathway. Havingsurpassedits2025targets,Signifyhas setfurthernear-andlong-termreduction targetsandwillbeintroducingadetailed ClimateTransitionPlanin2024.Thefollowing climategoalshavebeenreviewedand validatedasscience-basednet-zerotargets:

• OverallNet-ZeroTarget:Signifycommitsto reachnet-zerogreenhousegasemissions acrossthevaluechainby2040.Near-Term Targets:Signifycommitstoreduce absolutescope1and2GHGemissions 50%by2030froma2019baseyear.

• Signifyalsocommitstoreduceabsolute scope3GHGemissions50%withinthe sametimeframe.

• Long-TermTargets:Signifycommitsto reduceabsolutescope1and2GHG emissions90%by2040froma2019base year.Signifyalsocommitstoreduce absolutescope3GHGemissions90% withinthesametimeframe.

Signifyhashalveditsgreenhousegas emissionssince2019,withacumulative reductionof334milliontonsCO2einexcess oftherequirementsoftheParisagreement’s 1.5-degreepathway.

Signify’ssustainabilityprogramBrighterLives, BetterWorld2025setouttodoublethepace ofdecarbonizationrequiredbytheParis Agreement’s1.5°Cscenariobytheendof 2025.Thecompanyisproactiveinreducing emissionsacrossitssupplychain, participatingintheCDPSupplyChain programandencouragingsupplierstocommit toscience-basedtargets.

“Weareproudtobepartoftheglobal movementforambitiouscorporate decarbonization.Thisvalidationofourtargets setsanexampleourpeersandthebroader industrymustfollowasweredoubleour effortstoreduceemissionsacrossthevalue

chaininlinewiththeParisagreement’s 1.5-degreepathway,”saidLoosschilder.

AbouttheScienceBasedTargetinitiative TheScienceBasedTargetsinitiative(SBTi)isa collaborationbetweentheCarbonDisclosure Project(CDP),theUnitedNationsGlobal Compact,WorldResourcesInstitute(WRI) andtheWorldWideFundforNature(WWF). Launchedin2015,SBTidefinesand promotesbestpracticeinscience-based targetsettingandindependentlyassesses companies’targets. ■

SignifyIntroducesNew

UltraEfficientand3DPrinted Innovations,Supportingthe TransitiontoEnergy-efficient, SustainableWorkspaces

www.signify.com/global/innovation/3d-printing

Signifyhasintroducedcutting-edgesolutions thateffectivelyilluminateworkspaces,support productivityandacceleratethetransitionto energy-efficient,sustainablebuildings.

UltraEfficientluminairesdriveenergy efficiency

SignifycontinuestoexpanditsUltraEfficient (UE)range,withnewpanels,recessed luminaires,anddownlightsthathelp businesseslowertheircarbonemissions, whiledeliveringsubstantialcostsavingsover time:

PhilipsUltraEfficientTrueBlendisarecessed fitting,suitableforawidevarietyofceiling typesthatcansimplifytheprocessof switchingtoLEDs.Itsmodulardesignmakes itpossibletofitTrueBlendluminairesinthe samecutoutasexistingfittings,deliveringtime andcostsavingsforthecustomer.

PhilipsPowerBalanceUErecessedluminaires andPhilipsLuxSpaceUEdownlightscome withanultra-highefficacy(upto 174 lm/W and 160 lm/Wresp.),tunablewhiteoption, andalifetimeof50,000hrsatL90.Withthese UltraEfficientluminaires,userscanyield energysavingsofupto21.7%comparedto othercomparableLEDluminaires.Witha similarlook,feelandlightdistribution,they allowforaneasyreplacementofcurrent luminaires.TheyalsomeetSignify’sstrict LightingforCircularitycriteria,withpartsthat areserviceable,reusable,refurbishableand recyclable.

TheUltraEfficientrangewillbefurther extendedwiththePhilipsUltraEfficient CoreLinepanelinMay2024.

“Signifyissettingthestandardforoffice

lighting,investinginunderstandingand anticipatingourcustomers’needs,and developingproductthatfit.Withbuildings responsiblefor40%ofenergyconsumption and36%ofgreenhousegasemissionsinthe EU,thereisanurgentneedforbusinessesto transitiontoenergyefficientsustainable workspaces.Wearedrivingdownenergyuse withourUltraEfficientrange,savinginstallation timeandcostforourcustomers,while minimizingtheuseofmaterialswithour 3D-printedEssentialsandGrandrange,and reducingtheamountofplasticsinourtrade packagingby70%.”

–SophieBreton,ProfessionalBusinessLeader forEuropeatSignify

Remarkable,customizableand sustainablyprintedconnectedlighting fromPhilipsMyCreation

Developedtotransformofficesintoinspiring placestowork,thePhilipsMyCreationrange is3D-printedusingbio-circularmaterials, offeringunparalleledfunctionalityand customization,withawiderangeofcolor, texture,anddesignstochoosefrom.All MyCreationproductsareprinted-to-order, reducingwasteasnoexcessproductsare produced.

TheMyCreationEssentialdownlighterismade fromatleast55%bio-circularplastics. Integratedemergencylightingisavailablenow, withwall-mountedlightingcominginMay.The MyCreationGrandPendant,alsomadewith 55%bio-circularprintedparts,offersstylish, andfunctionallightingdesign,withtheability toconnecttodifferentlightingsystems.

TheGreenSpacePerfectFitisavailablein manysizestofitanyspaceintheceiling.With housingsandtrimsmadewithatleast65% post-industrialrecycledpolycarbonate,itis 3D-printedtoorder,makingitanidealsolution forrenovationprojects. ■

ZumtobelIntroducesthe EXTONAExplosion-proof Luminaire

www.zumtobel.com

Zumtobel’snewmoisture-proofluminaire EXTONAisidealforuseinhazardousareas andharshindustrialconditions.Certifiedfor

NEWS INTERNATIONALLIGHTING 14 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design Issue103/May-June/2024

useinATEX2/22zones,thisexplosion-proof luminaireisparticularlyresilientthankstoits robustdesignandisalsoprotectedagainst themostchallengingconditions,suchas significantdustformationorpowerfuljetsof water.Italsofeaturesimpact-resistant housingandanemergencylightfunction.

Harshenvironmentalconditions,forexample inindustrialspacesandhalls,demandalot fromthetechnicalequipmentinthem–the lightinginparticular.That’swhyZumtobelis launchinganewlightingsolutionthatmeetsall therequirementsofchallengingenvironments: thenewEXTONAmoisture-proofluminaire, whichoffersreliablelightoutputtocertified standardseveninthemostdifficultconditions. Thisincludeseffectiveprotectionagainst explosionsinaccordancewiththeATEX guidelines(ATmosphèresEXplosives),which relatetoenvironmentsthatcouldhavean explosiveatmosphereonanongoingor short-termbasis.Apotentialsourceof ignition,suchasaluminaire,couldtriggera detonationinthistypeofenvironment,but thatisnotthecasewithEXTONA:asan ATEX-certifiedmoisture-proofluminairewitha maximumsurfacetemperatureof80°C, EXTONAispermittedforusein2/22zones. What’smore,vapors,gasesanddustsinthe atmospherewon’taffecttheluminaire’slight quality:withareductioninluminousfluxof L85after100,000hoursofuse,EXTONAis demonstrablydurableandrobust,helpingto saveoncosts.

Thankstoitsreliableexplosionprotection, EXTONAisasafelightingsolutionthatis suitableforallindustrialapplicationsand sectorswiththesetypesofpotentialhazards. Thisincludesareasintheautomotiveindustry wherepetrolisstoredorwherescrapmetalis pressed,wherebodyworkispaintedorwhere lithiumbatteriesaremanufactured.EXTONA alsoplaystoitsstrengthsinpowerstations–forexampleinengineroomsandbiogas plants,petrolandpelletstores,orwoodchip productionplants.Themetalworkingindustry

isanothersectorwherethisluminaireisa perfectmatch–inanyareaswherewelding, soldering,blasting,sandingorpaintingtake place.Thewoodworkingindustrycanalso benefitfromitshighdegreeofexplosion protection,forexampleinareasaroundsaw mills,chippersorpaintshops.Lastbutnot least,EXTONAisidealforthetextileand paperprocessingindustries,offeringample explosion-prooflightoutputfortherecycling, grindingandshreddingoffabricandpaper,for example.

Maximumprotectionagainstimpacts, dustandwater

Aswellasitshighlevelofexplosionprotection, theluminairealsooffersoutstanding resilience.EXTONAcanwithstandevenheavy impactsandsignificantmechanicalforces, andanIK10ratingmeansithasthehighest possiblelevelofimpactresistance.Thanksto itsIP66protectionclass,thismoisture-proof luminaireisalsoreliablyprotectedagainst challengingenvironmentalconditionssuchas penetratingdustorpowerfuljetsofwater.In addition,thehousingismadefromdurable polycarbonatewithUVstabilizationtoprevent discoloration.EXTONAcancopewithawide rangeoftemperaturesandworksaswellin coldconditionsofupto-20°Casitdoesin extremeheatofupto60°C.

Asanotherbenefit,theluminaireofferscleverly designedsafetyfeaturesforemergenciesand isfittedwithanemergencylightfunctionas standard,withasingle-batterypowersupply thatprovidesforanoperatingtimeofthree hours.Thismeansthatareliablelightsource isguaranteed,evenwhentheunexpected happens,sothatenoughtimeandlightare availabletoevacuateahazardousareainan emergency.ThankstotheDALIprotocol,the emergencylightingsupplycanbeseamlessly connectedtobuildingmanagementsoftware andcanberegularlyreadout,testedand monitored.TheDALIintegrationenablesthe luminairetobecontrolledindividuallyandin responsetocurrentneedswithinadynamic digitallightingmanagementsystem.

Maximumefficiencypairedwithoptimal luminousefficacy

EXTONAcombinesATEX-certifiedlighting withoptimalluminousefficacy:the moisture-proofluminaireisavailablewithsix differentluminousfluxvaluesfrom 1,200 lmto

11,000 lmasstandard,butcanalsobe upgradedtoaversionwithupto 16,500 lmon customerrequest–withanefficiencyofupto 166 lm/W.Thisreducespowerconsumption, lowersoperatingcostsandminimizesCO2 emissions,optimizingtheenvironmental footprintofindustrialplants.Theluminaireis suppliedwithaneutralwhitelightcolorat 4,000 Kasstandardandoffersimpressive colorrenderingofCR180,whilethe medium-beamlightdistributionprovides optimalilluminanceforindustrialapplications. EXTONAcanalsobeinstalledinavarietyof ways:whetherit’smountedontheceiling,a wallorapoleorsuspendedwithacable suspensioncordorachain,theluminairecan beoptimallyadaptedforanycontextand space.

“WithEXTONA,we’vecreatedalighting solutionthatuniquelycombinesbrilliantlight quality,highstandardsofexplosionprotection, maximumdurabilityandexcellentenergy efficiency.Thismeansthateveninchallenging industrialenvironmentswecanachieve human-centeredlightthatprovidesthe highestdegreeofsafetyandusabilityaswell ascreatingapleasantatmospheretoworkin. Mythanksgototheprojectteam,whohave carriedoutreallyexcellentwork”,saysFelix Breuss,ProductManagerforProtected LuminairesatZumtobelLighting. ■

LUXEONHL4XforHigh OutputApplications& ImprovedEfficiency

https://lumileds.com

Lumiledsannouncedthereleaseofits LUXEONHL4XpowerLEDthatdeliversthe lightingindustry’shighestoutputandefficacy; itfurtherstheabilityforlightingmanufacturers tostandardizetheirdesignsarounda commonfootprintandprovesthatmeaningful LEDefficacygainsarestillpossible.

LUXEONHL4Xisdesignedspecificallyfor outdoorandindustrialapplicationssuchas stadiumlights,streetlights,andhighbay luminaires,aswellastorchesandrugged portabledeviceswherethehighlumen density,efficacy,robustness,andqualityof lightarecritical.Thehigh-powerdomed packagedeliversveryhighoutput,excellent

NEWS INTERNATIONALLIGHTING 15 Issue103/May-June/2024 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design

efficacy,colorstability,andlongevity regardlessoftheapplicationorenvironment.

Withtypicaloutputof 680 lmat 700 mAand typicalefficacyexceeding 168 lm/W, LUXEONHL4Xoffersmanufacturersasimple, seamlessupgradeforvirtuallyanyexisting applicationusingasimilar3535package. Engineersmanagedtheopticaldesignsothat existingopticsforsolutionswith 2 mm2 work withthenewLED.

LUXEONHL4XataGlance

• Industrystandard3535packagewitha 3-stripefootprint

• CCToptionsof3000K,4000K,5000K, 5700K,and6500K

• CRIoptionsof70,80,and90

• 4Amaximumdrivecurrent

• Optimizedintensitydistributionforhigher systemopticalefficiency(nolossoflight outputbelowthehorizon)

• Uniquedomedesignisoptimizedto maximizelightoutputwithin±130°

• Largethermalpadallowshighdrive currentsandclose-packedLEDs

“ThefeaturesofLUXEONHL4Xmakeitideal forhigh-lumenapplicationssuchasindustrial andstadiumlighting,”saidNomanRangwala, HeadofProductMarketingandManagement (L1)atLumileds,“However,theoptical compatibilitywithmanyexisting3535optics makesitpossibletoreplacelower-performing LEDsdirectlyandimprovesystemefficiency by 10 lm/Wormore.Thiswillbeagame changer.” ■

ToyodaGoseiDevelopsUV-C

internationallyinApril2024,topromotetheir widerusefordisinfectingwater,airand surface.

Comparedwithmercurylamps,UV-CLEDs areenvironmentally-friendlyasitis mercury-free,morecompact,andhavea longerlife.Theseadvantagespromotedtheir wideuseindevicesfordisinfectingairand surfacesduringtheCovid-19pandemic. SincetheydifferfromlightingLEDsin composition,however,lightoutputhasbeen stilllimited.Forwaterpurificationplantsand othersituationswherehighdisinfection performanceisneeded,mercurylampsare stillused.

ToyodaGoseihasleverageditsexpertisein crystallizationanddesignofblueLEDsfor lighting,andsuccessfullydevelopedUV-C LEDsthatachievelightoutputatthelevelof 200milliwattswithasinglechipwhendriven byacurrentof350milliamperes. ImprovementoftheLEDstructureand compositionquadrupledtheamountoflight thatcanbeextracted.EnhancedLED performanceincludingdisinfectingcapability ofaboutthreetimeshigherwillexpandtheir applicableareasincludingafuturealternative tomercurylamps,contributingtomore hygienicandsaferliving. ■

DALIAllianceLaunchTest

andCertification

SpecificationsforDALI+

www.dali-alliance.org

www.toyoda-gosei.com

ToyodaGoseiCo.,Ltd.hasdevelopeddeep ultraviolet(UV-C)LEDswithlightoutputthatis amongthehighestintheworld.UV-Cisused indisinfectionasitdestroysviralandbacterial DNAstructuresandinhibitstheirreplication. Asanalternativelightsourceformercury lampsusedfordisinfection,improved performanceofUV-CLEDshasbeen expected.SamplesalesofToyodaGosei’s highperformanceLEDswillstarted

TheDALIAlliance,recognizedasthe internationalauthorityinlightingtechnology standardization,hasunveiled much-anticipatedcertificationdetailsforits wirelessspecification:DALI+overThread.

Aslightingspecificationsincreasinglyseek smarter,sustainable,andinteroperable solutions,DALI+emergesasacrucialenabler ofstandardizedwirelessorIP-basedlighting systems.Thealliance’scollaborationwith partnerssuchasThreadGrouphasresultedin theintegrationofenhancedsecurityand encryptionsolutions,ensuringtheintegrity andconfidentialityofdatatransmissionwithin DALI+networks.

KeyfeaturesofDALI+withThreadinclude:

• WirelessMeshNetwork:Threadcreatesan InternetProtocolversion6(IPv6)based wirelessmeshnetwork.Off-the-shelf Threadborderrouterscanalsobeusedto connectmultipleThreadnetworksthrough IPtechnologies,suchasEthernetorWi-Fi, allowingahighlyscalablelightingcontrol system.

• ExtendedAddressing:Inadditiontothe standard64controlgearand64control deviceaddresses,DALI+withThreadIPv6 routingallowsalmostunlimitedaddressing capability.TheusualDALIbroadcast,group andshort-addressingmethodsareincluded togetherwithIPunicastandmulticast capability.

• Interoperability:DALI+certificationincludes allthebenefitsoftheexistingDALI-2and D4icertificationprogramswithextensive testing,independentverification,andlisting ofeverycertifiedproductinapublicly searchableproductdatabasetoensurea highlevelofproductinteroperability. Furthermore,DALI+bridgedeviceswill allowDALI-2wireddevicesorsystemsto connectwithandoperatewiththeproducts inaDALI+wirelesssystem.

• DeviceSupport:DALI+supportsawide arrayofcontroldevices,including occupancysensors,lightsensors, switches,sliders,rotaries,and pushbuttons.Controlgearsupport currentlyincludesLEDdriverswiththethree optionaldataparts:luminairedata,power andenergy,anddiagnosticsdata.

PaulDrosihn,GeneralManageroftheDALI Alliance,expressedenthusiasmaboutthe launch,stating,“Thisrepresentsasignificant advancementinDALI-enabledtechnology. Ourmembersanduserswillexperiencethe benefitsofenhancedwirelessinteroperability andstrengthenedsustainabilitycredentials.” Drosihncontinues,“Moreover,thismilestone underscoresoursteadfastcommitmentto drivinginnovationandnurturing eco-conscioussolutionswithintheindustry. ByleveragingthepotentialofDALItechnology, wearenotonlyrevolutionizinglightingcontrols butalsolayingthegroundworkforamore sustainablefutureforgenerationstocome.”

Commentingonthecollaboration,Klaus Waechter,VPCommercialBuildingsat Thread,said,“Weareproudtocollaborate withtheDALIAllianceinutilizingThread technologyintheDALI+specification.This

NEWS INTERNATIONALLIGHTING 16 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design Issue103/May-June/2024
LEDwithWorld-ClassLight Output

partnershipunderscoresourcommitmentto advancingwirelessconnectivityand interoperabilityforcommercialgrademarkets andthelightingindustryingeneral.” ■

NordicPowerConverters LaunchesTwoVersatile ProductsforLEDLighting

www.npc.lighting

NordicPowerConvertersisthrilledto announcetwosignificantadditionstoour productportfolio:theInviTrackCasambi GatewayandtheInviTrackLEDDriverwith ManualDimming.Recentlyshowcasedat Light+Building2024inFrankfurt,these productsunderscoreourcommitmentto providingsmart,efficientlightingsolutionsthat catertobothadvancedwirelesscontrol systemsanddesiresforsimplisticyet high-qualitymanuallightingcontrol.

InviTrackCasambiGateway:Advanced WirelessLightingControl: TheInviTrackCasambiGatewaysetsanew standardinlightingcontroltechnology, facilitatingseamlessintegrationwithCasambi wirelesssystems.Thispowerfulgatewaycan manageupto64DALIdevicesinupto8 groups,offeringhighflexibilityandcontrol. Moreover,thegatewaysimplifiestheDALI addressingprocess,makingiteasierthanever toconfigureandcustomizelightingsettingsto suitanyenvironment.Beingpartofthe InviTrackfamily,theInviTrackCasambi gatewayisfullyintegratedinto3-phasetrack systemsfromGlobal,Stucchi,Eutrac,and PowerGear.

KeyFeatures:

• IntegratessmoothlywithCasambiwireless systems,offeringexpansivecontrolover lightingsettings.

• Controlsupto64DALIdevicesinupto8 groups,enablingcomprehensive managementofdiverselighting environments.

• SimplifiestheDALIaddressingprocess, allowingforeasycustomizationand configurationthroughthegatewayitself.

• FitsallmajorEuropean3-phasetrack systems

InviTrackLEDDriverwithManualDimming: WhereSimplicityMeetsExcellence Showcasingourdedicationtointuitivelighting solutions,theInviTrackLEDDriverwith ManualDimmingdeliversuncomplicatedand directmanualcontrol.Thisdriversimplifiesthe processofachievingtheideallighting ambiance,enablingadjustmentsthatareboth immediateandprecisewithoutrelyingon digitalcontrollers.Itsstraightforward operationmakesitanexcellentchoicefor settingswheresimplicityandtactile responsivenessareparamount.

Itisanidealchoiceforenvironmentslike museumsandgallerieswherelighting precisioniscrucial,butmayalsofindusesin residentialorotherapplicationswheresimple andstraightforwardlightingcontrolisdesired. Finally,theInviTrackLEDDriverwithManual Dimmingboaststhehigh-qualityperformance featuresoftheInviTrackLEDdriverfamily, suchasaverywideoutputwindow,low inrushcurrent,flicker-freelight,andsmooth dimmingcapabilitiesdownto0.1%.

KeyFeatures:

• Manualdimmingfunctionalityforeasy, intuitivecontroloverlightinglevels.

• Idealforsettingsrequiringpreciselighting adjustments,enhancingvisualexperiences withouttheneedfordigitaldevices.

• Delivershighperformancewithawide outputwindow,lowinrushcurrent, flicker-freeoperation,andsmoothdimming downto0.1%.

Withtheselatestproductlaunches,Nordic PowerConverterscontinuestoleadinthe developmentofinnovativelightingsolutions thatmeetandexceedtheexpectationsofour customers.Whetherforspecialized applicationsorbroaderlightingprojects,the InviTrackCasambiGatewayandInviTrackLED DriverwithManualDimmingaredesignedto transformthewaylightingiscontrolledand experienced. ■

OpticalComponentswitha LowerCarbonFootprint

www.plexiglas-polymers.com

BWFProfilesusesPLEXIGLAS®proTerraM5 containingrecycledmaterialforhigh-quality opticalcomponentsinluminaires.

Sustainableluminairedesignisamultifaceted standardwhichcanbebrokendowntothe manufacturingprocessofeverysingle

luminaire.Althoughtheuseofrecycled materialisaresource-efficientoption,it reachesitslimitsforlensesandlightcoversas theserequirerecycledmaterialswithflawless opticalproperties.Onesuchmaterialis PLEXIGLAS®proTerraM5,amolding compoundfromRöhmcontainingrecycled polymethylmethacrylate(PMMA).

Bymakinganopticalcomponentforthe lightingmanufacturerRIDIusingthismaterial, BWFProfiles,aleadingmanufacturerof high-qualityplasticprofilesforthelighting industry,hasproventhatitispracticalfor partssuchasthis.BWFProfilesuses PLEXIGLAS®proTerraM5toproducea continuous-rowlightingsystemforaconcept studyontheRIDILINIAEVOsystem,which waspresentedattheleadingtradefairLight+ Building2024asanexampleofsustainability.

Sustainablemoldingcompoundwith recycledmaterial

“OurPLEXIGLAS®proTerraM5molding compoundcontainsupto30percent mechanicallyrecycledPMMAfrom post-industrialsources,whichismixedwith newPLEXIGLAS®inacontrolledmanner. Thisreducesthematerial’scarbonfootprintby 30percentcomparedtonewmaterial,” explainedChristianBitsch,SeniorMarket TechConsultingManagerintheMolding CompoundsbusinessunitatRöhmGmbH.

NEWS INTERNATIONALLIGHTING 17 Issue103/May-June/2024 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design

Decisioninfavorofthecirculareconomy Lightingmanufacturersandtheirsuppliers strivetoproduceinanenvironmentallyand climate-friendlymanner,assustainabilityhas becomeanestablishedmarketdemand.“At BWFProfiles,theprocessedmaterialsalone accountfornearly80percentofthe company’scarbonfootprint,”saysNico Sonntag,MaterialsDevelopmentEngineerat BWFProfiles.That’swhythecompanyplaces suchalotofvalueonusingresource-efficient materialsandhandlingthemsparingly–for example,bywastingaslittlematerialas possiblewhenstartingtheextruderandby returningproductionwastedirectlytothe internalrecyclingprocess.

FlorianBisle,DirectorInnovation& DevelopmentatBWFProfiles,added:“We haddiscussedpossibleapproachesforthe sustainableproductionoflightcovers.We rejectedtheoptionofprocuring mass-balancedmaterial,andinstead,devised asolutionbasedonadirectcirculareconomy, whichmeantthatwehadtotestvarious recompoundedmaterials.”Inthiscase,this referstoreprocessedmaterialscontaining post-industrialrecycledmaterial.

“PLEXIGLAS®proTerraM5impressedus withitsopticalpurity”

“Theprerequisitewasthatweobtained recycledmaterialswithoutanyinclusionsor unwantedblackspecks.PLEXIGLAS® proTerraM5convinceduswithitshighpurity,” saidBisle.Thehigh-qualityPMMAplastic providesidealconditionsforthecircular economybecauseitcanbecompletely recycledtimeandagainwhilemaintaining virtuallyidenticalmaterialproperties.Its exceptionalopticalpropertiesarealso retained.

“Weneedareliablepartnerthatcan guaranteeconsistentlyhighquality.Inthis respect,weareingoodhandswithRöhm,” Bisleemphasized.“Weshareapartnership thatgoesbackmanyyears.Manydecades ago,BWFProfileswasthefirstcompanythat processedPLEXIGLAS®moldingcompounds initsextrusionbusiness.Andeventodaywe relishbeingapioneerfornewprojectswiththe newandsustainablePLEXIGLAS®proTerra.”

Coextrudedprofilewithtailored properties

Theopticalcomponentsfortheconceptstudy ontheRIDILINIAEVOcontinuous-rowlighting systemcontainaround78percent PLEXIGLAS®proTerraM5.Inorderto achievethelightandproduction-related propertiesthatRIDIwaslookingfor,BWF Profilescoextrudedthe60-millimeter-wide profilewithtwoPMMAproductsfromRöhm: ThecentrallypositionedTIRlensconsists entirelyofPLEXIGLAS®proTerraM5.Aswith othercrystal-clearPLEXIGLAS®molding compounds,itpossessesexceptionallyhigh lighttransmissionwithvirtuallynoabsorption ofvisiblelightinthematerial.Theprofilebase,

thecrosspiecesthatholdthecircuitboardin placeandthelateralsnap-inhooksmust withstandhighmechanicalstresses. Therefore,PLEXIGLAS®Resistwithahigher impactresistanceisaddedtothe PLEXIGLAS®proTerraM5usedinthis segment.

Strongpartnershipforinnovative, sustainablelightingtechnology

TheopticalqualityalsoimpressedtheCEOof RIDILeuchtenGmbH,ManfredDiez,and ProductManagerEdwinBaran:“Theoptical componentswithrecycledmaterialmeetour stringentqualitydemandsforasustainable lightingsolution.IncollaborationwithBWF Profiles,ouraimisalwaystoproduceas sustainablyaspossiblewiththehighest degreeofenergyefficiency.Startingfromthe veryfirstdiscussions,wefocusondesigning productsthatmeetthedemandsofthe circulareconomy.” ■

BrightView’sNewDisplayFilm

BoostsBrightnessupto30%

www.brightviewtechnologies.com

BrightViewTechnologies,aleadingglobal supplierofVisualIntelligence™solutions,has announcedthelaunchofitsnew PolycarbonateBrightnessEnhancingFilms (BEFs),engineeredtoincreasebrightnessup to30%forhigh-performancedisplaydesigns. Anidealsolutionfordesktopmonitors, laptops,tabletsandothercustomdisplays, theuniquefilmstackhelpsengineeringteams achieveadvancedopticswhileensuring efficiency.

“InnovationinAIchipsandothertechnologies areleadingtoexcitingbreakthroughsacross manyapplications,butdesignengineersmust balancetheseadvancementswithobjectives foropticsandpowermanagement,”said JenniferAspell,CEOofBrightView. “BrightView’snewBEFsextendourfull portfolioofdisplayfilmsolutionsdesignedto supportinnovatorsattheforefrontof cutting-edgetechnologydevelopment, empoweringthemtotakeadvantageofthe latestsolutionswithanadvanced,efficient displayfilmforoptimizedvisualintelligence.”

BrightView’sBEFsleverageahigh-quality polycarbonatesubstrate,combinedwith premiereedge-litandmini-LEDmicrolens array(MLA)stacks,tomaximizebrightness

andefficiency.Thetwo-filmsolutionhelps increaseoutputfromthebacklightand minimizepowerconsumptionofthedisplay–makingitavaluableresourceforoptical deploymentacrossemergingautomotive, augmentedreality,virtualrealityand aerospaceapplications,amongothers. ■

NichiaAutomotiveInnovation CenterinGermany

www.nichia.co.jp/en/

Inasignificantmovetospearheadthefuture ofautomotivelightingdesignandfunctions, theworld’sleadingLEDmanufacturerNichia announcedthelaunchoftheNichia AutomotiveInnovationCenterlocatedin Aachen,Germany.Thenewlyinaugurated facilitymarksapivotalstepinthecompany’s ongoingcommitmenttoinnovateanddeliver enhancedsupporttocustomersthathave rapidlyevolvingrequirements.

NichiaAutomotiveInnovationCenter’smission istodevelopadvancedandsustainable lightingsolutionssuchasimprovementof roadsafety,visualcomfortandenergy efficiency,aswellasenhancingtheaesthetic appealandfunctionalityofvehiclesbyutilizing andcombiningNichia’slatesttechnologies.In closepartnershipwithindustryleaders, togetherwiththeR&DteamatNichia’s headquartersinJapan,theCenterwill acceleratethedevelopmentoftechnology breakthroughsandachievequickermarket entry,whileconsistentlyprioritizingadvances inthequalityoflight.Tosupportthenext generationofautomotivelightingsolutions, NichiaAutomotiveInnovationCentercontains awidearrayoflaboratorytoolsfortesting, modeling,monitoring,analysis,andrapid prototyping,amongothers.

Dr.UlfMeiners,ManagingDirector,Nichia AutomotiveInnovationCenter,explains:“The keytounlockingthefullpotentialof automotivelightingliesincollaboration.By workingcloselywithbusinesspartnersand academia,wewillbringgroundbreaking solutionstothemarketfasterandmore efficientlythaneverbefore.Asaresult,the Centercanrapidlyacceleratethepaceof innovation.Industryleadersthatarereadyto redefineautomotivelightingstandardsneedto connectwithuswithgreaturgencytotruly shapethefuture.” ■

NEWS INTERNATIONALLIGHTING 18 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design Issue103/May-June/2024

Dr.JenniferVEITCH

“Lightandlightingresearchcan contributeto12oftheUN SustainableDevelopmentGoals. Fewsubjectareascanclaimsucha broadreach.”

PhotoCredits:©NationalResearch CouncilofCanada2019.

CIEINTERVIEW DR.JENNIFERVEITCH
LightingtheWayForward–AComprehensiveLookattheCIE’s StrategicVisionfortheFutureof Lighting,

Inthisenlighteninginterview,JenniferVEITCH,presidentoftheCIE, sharesinsightsintoherextensivecareerinthelightingindustry,beginning fromheracademicpursuitsinenvironmentalpsychologytohersignificant contributionsattheNationalResearchCouncilofCanada.She discussesherdeep-rootedconnectiontolighting,fueledbybothfamilial influencesandherearlyprofessionalengagements.Throughoutthe interview,sheoffersanin-depthexplorationoftheCIE’sorganizational structure,itspivotalroleinadvancinglightingscienceandstandards,and thestrategicobjectivesoutlinedintherecentlypublishedCIEResearch Strategy.Thisdocumentaimstoenhancetheintegrationoflighting researchwithglobalsustainabilitygoals,demonstratingthecritical impactoflightingonbothhumanhealthandenvironmentalwell-being.

https://cie.co.at

LEDprofessional: Couldyouplease shareyourprofessionaljourneywith us?Howdidyouentertheworldof lighting,andultimatelybecomethe PresidentoftheCIE?

Dr.JenniferVEITCH: EarlyinmyuniversityyearsIencounteredenvironmental psychology,whichseekstounderstand howourphysicalsurroundingsaffectus and,inturn,howweaffectourphysicalworld.AtthatsametimeIworkedin thelabofapsychologyprofessorwho hadaninterestinlighting,andIbecame involvedinhisresearch.Myfatherwas anindirectinfluence–hewasaprofessorofinteriordesign,andtaughtlighting tohisstudents.I’msurethatfromhimI learned,atanearlyage,howimportant lightingistothespatialexperience.

Likemanypeople,onceIwas“bitten bythelightingbug”Istayedpassionate aboutit.IwasfortunatetofindaprofessionalhomeattheNationalResearch CouncilofCanadarightoutofmydoctoralstudies(attheUniversityofVictoria inBritishColumbia,Canada),andhave workedthereasaresearchereversince. ThefirstCIESessionafterIjoinedthe NRCwas1995inNewDelhi,whereIgot toknowmanypeoplewhohavesince becomefriendsandcolleagues–andI waspersuadedtojoinmyfirstTechnicalCommittee,TC6-11.WhenitsChair hadtostepdownafewyearslater,I tookonthatroleandledthefinalwork onwhatbecamethefirstconsensus publicationconcerningtheeffectsoflight onhealth(CIE158:2009),originallypublishedin2004.

Thesedays,manyorganizationslookto demonstratetherelevanceoftheirresearchbylookingtohaveittakenupby others,andIquicklycametoseethe CIEasanimportantbodyfortranslatingmyresearchintolightingguidance andrecommendations–andequally, asthesourceofdiscussionsandideas fornewresearch.Ialsofoundthatby takingonincreasingresponsibilitiesasa leaderintheCIE,Ilearnednewskillsthat transferredbacktomydailywork.I’ve servedasaTCmember,TCChair,DivisionMember(forCanada),DivisionSecretary,DivisionDirector,Vice-President Technical,andnowCIEPresident.Everystephastaughtmecommunication andmanagementskills–andalways, broughtmeintocontactwithinteresting, lovelypeoplewhohavebecomegood friends.

LEDprofessional: Naturally,many peoplerecognizethenameCIE,but it’slikelynoteveryoneisawareof whattheCIEdoesforthefieldof lightingandhowtheCIEisorganized. Wouldyougiveusacloserlookatthe CIEasanorganization?

Dr.JenniferVEITCH: Everyonewhois deeplyinvolvedinlightingknowsthatit’s acomplextopic.Notsurprisingly,the CIEisacomplexorganization.Broadly speakingwehavetwoaspects:oneas acollegialorganizationthatpromotes knowledgeexchangeaboutthescience (andtoalesserextent,theart)oflight andlighting,andoneasaninternational standards-developingorganization.We structureourworkintosixDivisions,

eachwithresponsibilityfordevelopinga workprograminitsscope:Visionand Color;PhysicalMeasurementofLight andRadiation;InteriorEnvironmentand LightingDesign;TransportationandExteriorApplications;Photobiologyand Photochemistry;ImageTechnology.Divisionsmanagethescientificworkflowand proposeTechnicalCommitteesthatwill developapublication,usuallyatechnical reportoraninternationalstandard,that representsaninternationalconsensuson thattopic.Followingarigorousreview andapprovalprocess,whichinvolves CIENationalCommitteesspreadoversix continents,thesedocumentsarepublishedbytheCIE.CIEevents,ranging fromscientificconferences(heldevery twoyears)toexpertsymposia,workshops,andtutorialssupportthetechnicalworkbybringingpeopletogetherto presentandtodiscusstheirresearch.

LEDprofessional: Inthisinterview,we wouldliketodelveintotherecently publishedCIEResearchStrategy andshedmorelightonthisimportant document.WhatinspiredyoutocontributetotheCIEResearchStrategy, andhowdoesyourpersonalbackgroundorinterestinlightinginfluence yourwork?

Dr.JenniferVEITCH: Ithinkit’sfairto saythatlightandlightinggetstakenfor grantedamongpeoplewhohaven’tyet foundthelightingcommunity(bywhich Imeaneveryonewithaprofessionalinterestinlightandlighting).Thinkofhow youexplainwhatyoudotoaneighbor fromanotherindustry–I’llbettheyex-

CIEINTERVIEW DR.JENNIFERVEITCH 21 Issue103/May-June/2024 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design

presssurpriseaboutourfield’stechnical complexity!Thisleadsmanyresearch fundersnottoprioritizelightingtopics.Likeallresearchers,I’vefacedthis problemandcanseehowifonlyour workwerebetterappreciated,andbetter funded,wecouldaccomplishsomuch moretoimprovethelitenvironment,improvehumanandecologicalhealthand well-being,andreduceresourceuse.

Aboutadecadeago,theCIEleadership recognizedthatwecouldhelptheresearchcommunitybydevelopingatool tohelpthemtoarticulatetheimportance oftheirresearchtopics,andthatinthe processwecouldnudgeresearchersto focusontopicsthatourexpertsjudged willsupportthenextgenerationsoflightingguidanceandstandards.Thefirst CIEResearchStrategywaspublishedin 2015,andourprogramofprovidingResearchSupportletterslaunchednotlong after.

ThelatestrevisionoftheResearchStrategy,releasedin2023,representsamajorreorganizationofthedocument,with itsmostoutstandingfeaturebeingto connecttheresearchthemeswiththe waysinwhichtheresultscansupport theachievementoftheUNSustainable DevelopmentGoals(SDGs).Thereare 17SDGs,andlightandlightingresearch cancontributeto12ofthem!Fewsubjectareascanclaimsuchabroadreach, andIfindthatveryexciting.It’sshapinghowIthinkaboutmyownfutureresearchandIhopeitwilldosoforothers.

Thereare17UNSustainableDevelopmentGoals (SDGs),andlightandlightingresearchcancontributeto12ofthem.

LEDprofessional: Whataretheprimarygoalsyouaimtoachievewith theCIEResearchStrategy,andhow doyouenvisiontheseobjectivesadvancingthefieldsoflightandlighting overthenextdecade?

Dr.JenniferVEITCH: Wehopetoinspireresearcherswhosesubjectmatter fallsintoourthemes,sothattheywilldevelopresearchproposalsthataddress thosethemes.Withoutreiteratingthe wholedocumenthere(it’savailablehere:

https://cie.co.at/research-strategy),we wanttheresearchcommunitytotakeon projectsthataddressthetopicsoutlined sothatwecangetonwithnewandupdatedguidance.Then,wewantresearch funders–bywhichImeannationalfundingagencies,charitablefoundations,and industry–tosupporttheseprojectsso thattheyhavetheresourcestoprovide ustheknowledgeweneed.Furthermore,webelievethatwiththisadded supportwillcomeagreaterappreciation oftheimportanceoflighttolife,sothat overtime,theapplicationofthisresearch willresultinbetterlightingforall.

LEDprofessional: Inwhatwaysdo youforeseedigitalizationtransformingmetrologyscienceandthelighting industry,andwhatarethepotential challengesandopportunitiesassociatedwiththistransformation?

Dr.JenniferVEITCH: Atthemostbasic level,makingdataFAIR(Findable,Accessible,Interoperable,andReusable) canimproveourabilitytomakeuseof thetremendousvolumeofdatawecan generate,especiallyascomplexcomputationsarethebasisofdecision-making. Forlighting,havingcleardata-sharing protocolsandstandardizedmetadata andfileformatsforthenextgenerations ofsimulationsoftwarecansupportlightingdesignandimprovethefinaloutcomes.Thisisespeciallyimportantfor physiologicalexperimentswithpeople, whichareextremelycomplexandexpensive.Itisthereforeimportantthatthese experimentsareverywelldocumented, withverydetailedmetadata,inorderto guaranteescientificreproducibilityand reusability.

Machine-readablestandardscouldenablefasterandmoreaccuratedeterminationsthatproposeddesignscomply withtherelevantdocuments,possibly basedontheoutputofthosemoreaccuratesimulations.Weareintheearly daysofunderstandingallthesteps neededtoimplementthatvision.

Therearelotsofchallengesto‘digitalization’initsmanyforms,buttheoneIsee mostclearlyisintheneedforconsensus.Interoperabilityrequiresagreement amongparties,andIhaveyettoseea machinethatcanquicklybringeveryonetothesameconclusion,especially iftheremightbeacommercialinterest involved.

LEDprofessional: Couldyouelaborateontheimportanceofinclusiveandequitablelightingintoday’s globalcontext?HowdoestheCIE plantoaddressdiversity,equity, andinclusioninlightingresearchand standards?

Dr.JenniferVEITCH: Mostofthefundamentalresearchonwhichpresent-day lightingisbasedwasconductedusing whatpsychologistscallWEIRDsamples: “White,Educated,Industrialized,Rich, andDemocratic”.Thislimitsthegeneralizabilityoftheresults,becausewelack informationaboutmostofthepopulation.Furthermore,mostresearchersfilter outtheextremescores(outliers)and focusontheaverage.Aswestarttoexploremorediversesampleswelearn,for example,thatthereareinter-individual differencesinthespectralsensitivityof theconephotoreceptorsthatourcurrent modelsdonottakeintoaccount,and thesemeanthatdeterminationsofcolor appearanceandphotometricquantities basedonasinglestandardobserver don’taccountwellfortheexperiences ofmanypeople.Whenwelackgood information,wecan’tdevelopguidance thatwillimprovethequalityofthelitenvironmentforthepeoplewhoareleft out.Thatiswhywehavecalledinthe ResearchStrategyfordiversityandinclusiontobeaddressedasanoverarching themeinallprojects.Thisextendstothe compositionofresearchteams,whereverpossible,becausetheevidenceis clearthatmorediverseteamsperform better.

LEDprofessional: HowdoestheCIE ResearchStrategyalignwithenvironmentalsustainabilitygoals,particularlyinreducingcarbonemissions andminimizinglightpollution?

Dr.JenniferVEITCH: Eachthemeinthe ResearchStrategyisalignedwiththeUN SDGs,soIinviteyourreaderstoseethe documentforallthedetails.Ouraimis toenablebetteruseoflightandlighting insupportoftheSDGs,andthatmeans beingabletodelivertherightlightinthe rightplaceandintherightamountatthe righttimetomeettheuserneedsforthat applicationwithoutenergywastageand whilerespectinglocalecologicalconditions.Obtrusivelight,astheCIEcalls it,iswastedenergyaswellascausing harmtofloraandfaunaandourappreciationofthenightsky.

CIEINTERVIEW DR.JENNIFERVEITCH 22 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design Issue103/May-June/2024

Carbonemissions,ofcourse,dependin largepartontheenergymixinagiven placeandtime,andthisisoutsidethe CIE’sscope.Whatwecandoistoprovideguidancethatreduceslightingenergyuse,withreducedcarbonemissions followingfromthat.

LEDprofessional: Withthedecline intheuseofincandescentsources andtheriseofLEDtechnology,what newchallengesariseinthecalibration ofphotometersandspectrometers, andhowistheCIEaddressingthese challenges?

Dr.JenniferVEITCH: TheCIEhaspublishedanewreferencespectrumforLED photometry,withtheintentthatLED sourcesshouldbedevelopedtorealize it.TheseLEDsourceswouldthenreplacetheoldincandescentsourcesfor calibrationofphotometers.Giventhat measurementerrorishigherwhenthere isaspectralmismatchbetweenthe calibrationsourceandthetestsource, theshifttotheLEDreferencespectrum shouldincreasemeasurementquality whenthetestsourceisanLED(asisincreasinglythecasetoday).

Therestillremainstheproblem,however,thatLEDscan’tpresentlyreplace incandescentsourcesforcalibrationof spectroradiometers,particularlyoutside thevisiblerange(i.e.intotheultraviolet andinfrared).Hereitisimportantthat therelevantresearchisdrivenforward, andIampleasedtosaythattheCIEresearchstrategyhashelpedtoinitiatea majorinternationalresearchproject(see https://www.ptb.de/epm2022/new stand/home).Sadly,however,withthe technologicalshifttowardsLEDs,the know-howtomanufacturemetrological incandescentreferencelightsourcesis alsodeclining.

LEDprofessional: Whatarethemost significantrecentdiscoveriesabout theimpactoflightingonhumanhealth andwell-being,andhowmightthese findingsinfluencefuturelightingdesignandstandards?

Dr.JenniferVEITCH: Thereareseveral interestingdevelopments,althoughitwill beawhilebeforetheyarefirmlyenough establishedtomeritinclusioninguidance documentsorstandards.Iamintrigued bytheevidencethatdaytimebrightlight exposurecaninfluencethequalityof sleeponthenightfollowing.Froma

buildingscienceperspectivethemountingevidencethatwebenefitfrombright dayspointsincreasinglytotheneedfor moreandbetterdaylightinginbuildings. Iamintriguedbyevidencesuggesting thatalthoughthenear-infraredregionof thespectrumisnotalargecontributor tobrightnessperception,itmighthave otherinfluencesonphysiologyandbehaviour.Iftheseearlyresultsholdupto closerscrutinyandreplication,itcould haveaprofoundeffectonlightsources andonthequantitiesweusetodescribe theirefficacy.

Practicalexamplesoftworoomsthatcombine daylightandelectriclight.PhotoCredit:©NationalResearchCouncilofCanada2019.

LEDprofessional: Howdoyousee theroleoflightingevolvingwithinthe frameworkofsmartcities?Whatare thekeyconsiderationsforintegrating lightingsystemswithotherurbanservices?

Dr.JenniferVEITCH: Smartcitiesgive thepotentialtounderstandhowplaces areused,asopposedtohowtheywere plannedtobeused.Thisallowsdesignersandplannerstobetteraddressthe realneedsofurbandwellers.Itgivesan understandingofthe“life”ofthecity, howspacescomealiveandgotosleep, andhowtheychangethroughoutthe day.

Adaptivespacescansenseoccupancy anddensityofoccupancy,adjustingto theneedsofthepeopleinthespace whileminimizingenergyusageandreducingecologicalimpacts.Itdoes, however,comewithsomerisks.For example,asmartlightingsystemmight followpeopleastheymovethroughthe

streets,toreduceenergyuseandenvironmentalconsequences.Someindividualsmightperceivethisasspotlighting, andcouldfeelunsafethinkingthatthe governmentiscontrollingtheirconditionsanddrawingunwantedattention tothem.Othersmightappreciatethis becauseitdrawsattentiontointruders orbadactors.Smartlightingneedsto beimplementedsensitivelyandwithan understandingofhowpeoplefeelwithin spaces,howtheyuseandmovewithin spaces,notjusthowtheysee,andnot onlytoenergyconsiderations.

Thenumberandlocationofstreetlightingcolumnsalsorequirescarefulattentionforsmartcitylightinginstallations.Thepolestodayarespacedand arrangedtomeetthelightingrequirements,andsmartnessisanadd-on.If theybecomesmartaccesspointsthat arespacedandarrangedtomeettherequirementsforthesmartcity,andstreet lightingbecomesanadd-on,lightingdesignandthequalityofourlitspaceswill suffer.

LEDprofessional: Thestrategyemphasizestheimportanceofcollaborationacrossvariousfields.Couldyou provideexamplesofinterdisciplinary researcheffortsorpartnershipsthat arecrucialforadvancingtheCIE’s strategicobjectives?

Dr.JenniferVEITCH: Totakeoneexample,it’sbecomingclearerthatour exteriorlightinghasunintendedeffects onotherspeciesandlightexposurein thebiologicalnightisn’tallthatgoodfor humans,either.However,inurbanareas peoplerelyonexteriorlightingtotravel safelyonroadsandtofeelsecureintheir neighborhoods.Weneedtofindthebalancebetweentheseconsiderations,but todothisweneedabetterunderstandingfromecologists,photobiologists, visionscientists,psychologists,illuminatingengineerssothatlightsources, lightingsystems,controls,andthedesignguidancetousethemwiselycanall cometogetherharmoniously.

LEDprofessional: Whatarethemain challengesyoufaceinconducting researchanddevelopingstandards intherapidlyevolvingfieldoflighting technology?

Dr.JenniferVEITCH: Touseanage-old expression:“Themorethingschange, themorethingsstaythesame”.Asal-

CIEINTERVIEW DR.JENNIFERVEITCH 23 Issue103/May-June/2024 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design

ways,researchersstruggletofundtheir research.Industrymaybedoinglotsof in-houseresearch,butfromtheperspectiveofanon-industryresearcheritcan beachallengetoobtainthenecessary fundingforresearchandtosupportthe time(andtravel)toparticipateinstandardsdevelopment.Researchalsotakes time,andIknowthattherehasalways beenadisconnectbetweenthespeed ofresearchandthedesireforspeedy standardsdevelopment.Thisproblem hasbecomeevenmoreofachallenge giventherapiddevelopmentoflighting technologies.Bothofthosethingsbeing said,thechanginglandscapeoflighting togetherwiththeadvancesinunderstandingtheeffectsoflightonpeople andbiologicalsystemsmakesthisavery excitingtime,whichmakestheeffortsto overcomethesechallengesworthwhile.

LEDprofessional: Whatadvicewould youoffertoyoungresearchersand professionalsenteringthefieldof lightingresearch?HowcantheycontributetothegoalsoutlinedintheCIE ResearchStrategy?

Dr.JenniferVEITCH: First,readtheResearchStrategyandbeamazedandexcitedatthebreadthanddepthofatopic manytakeforgranted.Then,choose researchtopicsthatderivefromtheResearchStrategy!Theseareareasthat thecollectivehivemindoftheCIEDivisionshaveidentifiedasfruitfulareas. Asyourworkevolves,takeadvantage oftheCIEmechanismstodevelopyour ideasandobtainfeedback.Presentat CIEevents,joinaCIEResearchForum (forthosetopicsthathaveone),andtake partindiscussionsofyourtopic.Publish yourworkinjournalswherewecanfind it.Astheknowledgeofyourtopicbuilds, lookforCIEtechnicalcommitteeswhere youcancontributeyourunderstanding toconsensusreports,guidelinesand standards.Finally,helpustomakeallof thisworkavailabletotheworld,sothat lightandlightingmaketheirduecontributionstotheachievementoftheUN SDGs.

LEDprofessional: Beyondthetechnicalandscientificaspects,howdoyou hopetheCIEResearchStrategywill influencethebroadersocietalunderstandingorappreciationoflightand lighting?

Dr.JenniferVEITCH: Anyonereading thisisontheinsideofthelightingcom-

munity,butthereisworktobedoneto increasepublicawarenessofhowlight andlightingcontributetoalllifeonearth. DevelopingtheResearchStrategy2023 revealedtoushowstronglyconnected ourworkistotheUNSDGs,whichare themselvesadistillationofsocietal,even planetary,goals.Wecanusethistostart theconversationwitheveryonefrom researchfunderstoregulators,other standardsdevelopers,buildingandinfrastructureprofessionals,publichealth agencies,andthepublicatlarge.As researchfindingscomein,wecanuse theframeworkoftheResearchStrategy themestodeliverupdatedmessages aboutprogress.Inturn,it’smyhopethat wewillreceivefeedbackfromallofthese engagedgroupstoinformthenexteditionoftheResearchStrategy,whichwe wouldexpecttobein2027.

LEDprofessional: Artificialintelligencenowpermeatesmanyareas oflife.HowwillAIinfluencethelightingsector,andistheCIEalreadyaddressingthistopic?

Dr.JenniferVEITCH: TheCIEisnot yetaddressingtheuseofAIinlighting. Thisisnotinmypersonalareaofexpertise,butIwouldthinkthatthereisgood potentialforusingmachinelearningapproachestooptimizeenergyuseand lightingsystemoperation.Iamaware thatthereareindividualresearchersor systemdevelopersengagedinexploringthispossibility,andIhavebeentold thattherearealgorithmsthatcanbe usedtochoosebetweenluminaires, forexampletooptimizemultipledesign parameters.Asweaddparametersto ourrecommendations,suchtoolscould helpdesignerstomanagetheincreasingcomplexityofthetask.Thatsaid, careandsensitivitytouserneedswill remainparamount.Justaswehave learnedthatAItrainingmodelsforfacial recognitionhaveinbredbiases,itislikely

thatwithoutcarefulattentionAI-based toolsforlightingdesignwillnotfulfilthe promiseofdeliveringbetterlightingdesigns.

Wealsoknowthattherearemeasurementdeviceswhichuseformsofartificial intelligencesuchasmachinelearning, look-updatabases,andreconstruction techniquestoproduceasynthesized measurementresult.Thishasimplicationsintermsofmeasurementuncertaintyevaluationandmeasurement traceability,butalsofortheusers:How dotheyknowifsuchadeviceismeasuringsomething“new”andeffectively guessingtheresult?Blindtrustinan AImodelthathasnotearneditwillnot serveuswell.

LEDprofessional: Fromapersonal perspective,whatisyourvisionfor thefutureoflighting?

Dr.JenniferVEITCH: Myvisionisfor moreaccessiblehigh-qualitylightingfor all.Theexpertgroupoflightingdesignerscandogreatwork,butmanyplaces donotbenefitfromtheirexpertise,and almostnoonehasaccesstothisexpertiseforlightingintheirhomes.Weneed tomakeiteasierforeveryonetoexperiencehighqualitylighting,bywhichI meanlightingthatmeetstheirneedsas userswhilerespectingthearchitectural, environmental,andeconomicconsiderationsofthecontext.TheCIEcan’t removeallofthebarriers,butwecan convenetheexpertstodevelopguidanceandwecancommunicatewith ourcollectivevoicesabouthowtoapply it. ■

Foradditionalinformation,pleasevisit https://cie.co.at

CIEINTERVIEW DR.JENNIFERVEITCH 24 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design Issue103/May-June/2024

AdamLILIEN:

“Forlightingmanufacturersconsidering marketingtheirproductsascircadianlighting solutions,I’dstronglysuggesthavingUL Solutionstestoneoftheirluminairessothatthey becomefamiliarwiththeservice.”

ULINTERVIEW ADAMLILIEN
CircadianToolsAdvancetheHealth andLightingMarket–AdamLILIEN,GlobalBusiness DevelopmentManagerofLightingat ULSolutions

Supportinghealthforbuildingoccupantsthroughindoorlightinghas beenonthehorizonforyears.In2015,industryexpertstoldusthatthe circadianlightingmarketwouldbeamulti-billion-dollarbusinessby2022. Still,thereneedtobemoreprojects,giventheupsideofdeliveringbetter sleeptothepeoplewholiveandworkinbuildings90%oftheirlives.In thisarticle,we’lllookatwhatsciencesays,what’srequiredtoimprove ourhealth,andwhattoolshavebeenmissing.Forthispurpose,we interviewedAdamLilien,globalbusinessdevelopmentmanagerof LightingatULSolutions,whohasbeenworkingtoresolvetheseissues.

LEDprofessional: We’veseen“healthy lighting”asagoalforyears,butit doesn’tseemtobeamovementyet. Whynot?

AdamLILIEN: Changetakestime.We aremovingrelativelyquicklyinthelightingindustry,especiallyintoday’sdiscussion.Thechallengeisthatwearenot movingasquicklyaspossible,negatively impactingpeople’shealth.

LEDprofessional: HowhasULSolutionsapproachedtheissueofacceleratingtheimpactoflightonhealth?

AdamLILIEN: Inlate2019,wepublishedtheULDesignGuideline24480for PromotingCircadianEntrainmentwith LightforDay-ActivePeople.Thatguidelinegavelightingdesignersthe“howto” fordeliveringhealthyspaces.Thedocumenttellsthelightingdesignerwhat tolookforinaluminaire.Forexample, lookingatthehorizontalandverticaldistributionsisessential,asisthespectral powerdistribution(SPD).Thedocument alsoexplainsthesciencebehindthese minimalrequirementssothatthelighting designerbecomesawareofthelaboratoryandfieldstudiesbehindthedocument.Myparticipationindeveloping thedocumentwastopulloutandcodify thesixstepsalightingdesignerneedsto followtoachievethedesigngoals.We calledthisthe“QuickGuide.”Thedocumenthelpededucateandanswerallthe lightingdesigncommunity’squestions.

Wealsospokeatconferences,provided webinars,publishedonsocialmedia,

andprovideddetailsonourwebsite. Thenitwastheindustry’sjobtomake thechange.However,wekepthearing thesamethings:“Makethiseasysowe canuseit.”That’swhenwestartedto askourselves,“What’sneededtomake designinghealthyspaceseasier?”

Ittooksometime,butintheend,we cameupwithseveraltoolsthatwe’ve launchedtoacceleratetheadoptionof healthyspacesinbuildings.

LEDprofessional: Youmentionedthe toolsthatyou’velaunched.Couldyou describethemandaddresswhothey aredesignedtohelp?

AdamLILIEN: WhatULSolutionsdevelopedisaserviceforlightingmanufacturerstoletthelightingdesignersknow thecircadianperformanceoftheirluminaires.Wereportthecircadianscore basedonthreepublishedcalculation methods:

• TheWELLBuildingStandard,based onequivalentmelanopiclux(EML)

• ULDesignGuideline24480,basedon circadianstimulus(CS)

• DIN/TechSpec(TS)67600,basedon melanopicequivalentdaylightilluminance(m-EDI)

Asthisscoremeasuresthe“non-visual” performanceoflighthittingthevertical planeoftheeye,itwastotallydifferent fromanythingthatexisted.Withthis score,thelightingdesignersstarttheir designprocessknowingtheyhaveselectedtherightproducts.Wecallthe

laboratoryresultsthecircadianluminaire score.

Thesecondisaservicethatinformsthe buildingownerofthecurrentscoreof circadianlightingintheirbuilding.Thisis aservicewhereULSolutionscomesto yourfacility,collectsdata,andproduces afloorplanthattellsthelightingdesigner andspaceplannerwherelightis“deliveringthedesireddesigngoal”andwhere thespaceis“belowgoal.”

Withthistool,informationisavailable tounderstandthespaceandresolve theissuesthatarenotvisible.Wecall thistheCircadianFieldMeasurement Service.

LEDprofessional: Canyousharehow thecalculationsaremadeforthecircadianmodels?

AdamLILIEN: Hereisthemostcomplicatedcalculation:theCScalculationthat ispartofULDG24480andisfoundon page46ofthedocument.Thefollowing equationdefinesCS:

CS =0 7 ∗ (1 1 1+( CLA 355 7 )1 1026 )

Perhapsit’sclearwhythelightingdesignersaskedustomakethis“simple.”

LEDprofessional: Howdotheseserviceswork?Aretheyavailablenow?

AdamLILIEN: Yes.Infact,bothofthese serviceslaunched,andweareproviding testresultsforlightingmanufacturers, lightingdesigners,propertyowners,and audienceswedidnotinitiallyexpect.

ULINTERVIEW ADAMLILIEN 27 Issue103/May-June/2024 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design

LEDprofessional: Let’sdiscussthe firstservice.HowdoestheCircadian LuminaireScorework?

AdamLILIEN: Forlightingmanufacturers,ourcircadianluminairelaboratory inAllentown,Pennsylvania(USA),measuresasingleluminaire,capturingthe photonsenteringtheeyeatthevertical plane.Tomakethedatauseful,wemeasureeachluminairetypesimilarly.For example,eachrecessedceilingtroffer isplacedinthesamespotintheceiling; eachwallsconceisinthesamelocation; andeachdesklampismeasured.Over nineluminairetypesaretested;wedefinemorewitheveryrequest.Wethen usethecalculationmethodspublished bythethreeworkingcommittees:

• WELLBuildingStandardV2,basedon EML

• ULDesignGuideline24480,basedon CS

• EuropeanDIN/TechSpec67600, basedonm-EDI

ThisgeneratestheCSoftheluminaire. Wealsocapturedthewattagedrawthe luminairewasusing.TheluminairemanufacturerreceivestheirdatainaULSolutionsletterreport.Afterdeliveringthe letterreports,thelightingmanufacturersrequestedthatwedevelopaway topromotetheirproductstothelightingdesignercommunity.Theyfeltan independentthirdpartywasbetterpositionedtobethetrustedmessenger.

Fortunately,wehavetheanswerand aredevelopingacustomizedsearch templatewithinULProductiQ®.This onlinedatabasecurrentlyservesasthe pointofreferenceformillionsofusers whoneedULCertificationinformation (see Figure 1).

WiththenewCircadiansearchtemplate withinProductiQ,whichwedeveloped inresponsetothemanufacturer’srequestandisnowlaunched,alighting designerwillcometothesiteanduse ourpowerfulparametricsearchtoolsto discoverwhichproductissuitablefor theirupcomingproject.Forexample, first,theyselectthecategoryofluminaire theyarelookingfor,suchasatroffer, pendant,wallsconce,floorlamp,desk lamp,orevenachandelier.Then,they sorttheproductswiththehighscore atthetopbasedontheparametersof theirdesigngoal;forexample,EMLif theyaredesigningforWELLBuilding

Standardpoints,m-EDIiftheirprojectrequirestheEuropeanlightinggoal,orCS ifthedesignrequirementsareseeking thosegoals.AccesstoviewProductiQ requirestheone-timesetupofacomplimentaryaccount,withoptionalpaidfeaturesavailable.Oncetheaccountisset up,customerscangodirectlytothecircadianfeaturesat UL.com/CircadianiQ.

LEDprofessional: YousaidtheCircadianLuminaireScoreservicehas launched.Whatareyoulearning?

AdamLILIEN: We’vedeliveredcircadian scoresfornumerousluminaires,and manufacturerscannowstartusingthe circadiansearchfunctiononProductiQ. See Figure 1.Wewerealsosurprised, asoneofthefirstcustomerswasnota luminairemanufacturerbutamanufacturerofareflectivesurfaceinabuilding. Theirproductshavedifferentreflective scores,andtheywantedtoverifythat thebrightersurfaceincreasedthecircadianscoreofthespace.Wearealso discussingexpandingtheservicetoincludeotherreflectivesurfacessuchas paints,flooring,ceilings,andfurniture.

LEDprofessional: Movingtothesecondservice:HowdoestheCircadian FieldMeasurementServicework?

AdamLILIEN: Wecometoyourfacility anywhereintheworld,collectthedata anddeliverafloorplanindicatingthe circadianscoresforeachspace.

Thereasonwecreatedthisserviceis thatweheardthat,forlargerspaces, theworkneededtobesimplified.Let megiveyouanexample.IfI’malighting designeraskedtomeasurethecurrent circadianscoreofaspaceforacustomer—eitherbecauseofaretrofitand we’rekeepingthelighting,ortheproject hasjustfinished,andwewanttoknow ifweachievedthecorrectlightinglevels —Icanpulloutmyluxmeterandtake afewdozenreadings.That’sgoodfor smallerspacessuchasasmallofficeor aconferenceroom,butwhataboutan ampleofficespace,aschool,orevena hospitalcomplex?

Duetothecomplexityandthepotentialexpense,ULSolutionsdevelopeda datacollectionmethodwherewecan capturethousandsofreadingsinone ortwohours.Weprovidethecustomer withadetailedfloorplan,asillustrated

in Figure 2,indicatingtheCSofeach space,where:

• GREEN=abovegoal

• YELLOW=slightlybelowgoal

• RED=significantlybelowgoal

Figure2: CircadianFieldMeasurement.AfterUL Solutionscollectsthedataatthesite,thelightingdesignercanselectthedesiredcalculation method:EML(WELLBuildingStandard),m-EDI (DIN/TS67600),orCS(ULDG24480).

Alightingdesignerandspaceplanner willnowknowwhattheywanttoalterif anything.WealsodevelopedtheMarketingClaimVerificationaboutVerified SpaceforPromotingCircadianEntrainmentwithLightsothattheproperty ownerorthebusinessoccupyingthe spacecancommunicatetheresultsthey achievedtothepublic.AfterULSolutionsprovidestheCircadianFieldMeasurementService,theULMarkreports theaveragespacescore,whetherit’sa conferenceroom,afloororabuilding (seebelow).

LEDprofessional: Howisthemarket response?Whatareyouseeing?

AdamLILIEN: We’vedeliveredthisservicetooneofthelargestrealestate ownersintheworldandtoamid-sized architectinOhiowithglobalcustomers. Inbothcases,thecustomershavetold usthatthissolvesaproblemtheydid notrealizetheyhad.Althoughtheyare leadersindeliveringhigh-qualitylighting forvisualacuityandcomfortatenergyconsciouslevels,theydidnotanticipate beingabletorateanamplespaceforits circadianhealthscore.Realestateownerswanttooffercircadianlightingtoget

ULINTERVIEW ADAMLILIEN 28 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design Issue103/May-June/2024

Figure1: CircadianProductiQ®,ULSolutions’onlinesearchdirectoryforproducts,includingluminairestestedbyULSolutionsfortheircircadianscore.

businessestosignamulti-yearlease. Byofferingthissolutionasatenantimprovement,theydon’tevenpayforthe service,asthelightingandcontrolsinnovationisappliedtothetenantimprovementbudget.Theprospectivetenant wantsthecircadianlightingimprovement sothattheycantelltheiremployeesthat theyworkforacompanythatisattentivetooccupants’health.Theyalsouse healthimprovementstorecruittop-tier employees.

Architecturefirmswanttooffertheircustomersscience-baseddesignthatimprovesthehealthofthebuildingoccupants.Whilethebuildingretrofitthey designedmayhavedeliveredexcellentresults,wehavediscoveredthat workersinthespacecouldundothedesign.Asintheexamplefromarecent customer,someoftheofficesinRED scoredsignificantlybelowthedesign goalofCS ≥ 0.3,eventhoughtheywere adjacenttoGREENofficesthatscored abovethegoal.Furtheranalysisrevealed thatthelowerscorewasduetotheoccupantdimmingthelights,alteringthe sensitivityoftheoccupancysensor,and closingthewindowblinds.Asaresult, theyareconsideringULSolutionstodelivereducationtotheofficeworkersso thattheybetterunderstandhowtheofficewasdesignedtodeliverthe“bright day”signalthatisnecessarytoentrain (synchronize)the24.2-hourhumancircadianrhythmtothenaturalcycleofa day(24.0hours).Inessence,theyare modifyingtheircircadianlightingdesign.

LEDprofessional: Whatwouldyoudo nextifyouwerethelightingmanufacturer?

AdamLILIEN: Foralightingmanufacturerconsideringmarketingtheirproductsasacircadianlightingsolution,I’d stronglysuggesthavingULSolutions testoneoftheirluminairessothatthey becomefamiliarwiththeservice.Once tested,lightingdesignerscanfindthe manufacturer’sproductwiththescore andconsiderspecifyingtheproducton theirnextproject.

LEDprofessional: Isthereanyadditionalbenefitforamanufacturerwith acircadianlightingsolution?

AdamLILIEN: Imagineamanufacturergettingspecifiedinaproject.That projectmaybe6monthsout,12months out,oreven18monthsout.Whileall projectshaveariskofthecontractor “valueengineering”theproductatthe lastmoment,whentheprojectresults aredesignedforahealthyoutcome, valueengineeringwon’tbeanoption. Lightingmanufacturerscallthisa“spec lock;”theirproductwillbelockedinto thefinalsolution.

LEDprofessional: HowdidULSolutionsgetstartedonthisadventure?

AdamLILIEN: ULSolutions’involvementstartedbackin2018whenMark ReaoftheLightingResearchCenterat RensselaerPolytechnicInstitute(New

York,USA)cametous.Hehadtheidea toexploreamuch-neededcircadian approachconsideringadifferentsetof parametersthantheothermethods.

WithULStandards&Engagementmanagingtheprocess,theIndustryTask Groupworkedfor18monthstodefine thegoal,discussthescience,andwrite apaper.

Theindustryhadalottosay.ULStandards&Engagementpublishedtheproposedpapertwiceforpubliccomment, andweevenreachedouttoothercountriestocollectotherscientificresponses forconsideration.Onlyafterall350responseswereaddresseddidULStandards&Engagementconsiderpublishingthepaper.InNovemberof2019,the ULDG24480paperwaspublished.

LEDprofessional: WhyULSolutions?

AdamLILIEN: Withourdeepexpertise incircadian-effectivelighting,itmakes sensethatwecontinueonourmission topromotesafer,moresecureandsustainablelivingandworkingenvironments forpeoplethroughtheapplicationofscience. ■

Foradditionalinformation,pleasevisit UL.com/circadian

ULINTERVIEW ADAMLILIEN 29 Issue103/May-June/2024 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design

SustainableLightingIndustry

RESEARCHPROJECTSUMATRA

Dr.SebastianKNOCHE1,ResearcheratTRILUXand Dipl.-Ing.MarinaPROSKE2,ResearcheratFraunhoferIZM

Wearesurroundedbyluminairesand artificiallightalmosteverywhere.The costsarecorrespondinglyhigh:13% oftheGermanelectricityconsumption isusedforlighting.Thisisassociated withhighgreenhousegasemissions. Andourlifecycleassessmentsshow thattheresourceconsumptionforluminairesisofsimilarrelevanceasthe greenhousegasemissions. LifecycleassessmentswereconductedforaselectionofLEDluminaires.Theresultsshowthepotential formakinglightingquantitativelymore sustainable.Ifthedevelopmentofan LEDluminaireisguidedbylifecycle assessments,thispotentialcanbeexploitedinthebestpossibleway. Wealsoinvestigatedstate-of-the-art recyclingprocessesandassessedthe realisticrecyclabilityofluminaires. Here,too,wefoundpotentialforimprovement.Thesecannotbeexploited throughimprovedproductdesign alone,butrequireacoordinatedapproachbetweenmanufacturersandrecyclersforthesimultaneousimprovementofproductdesignandrecycling processes.

Introduction

“Sustainabledevelopmentisdevelopment thatmeetstheneedsofthepresentwithoutcompromisingtheabilityoffuturegenerationstomeettheirownneeds.”This definitionofsustainabilitybytheUnitedNationsdatesbackto1987 [1].Inessence, thismeanstoactinawaythatwecan continuedoing,basically,forever.

BackgroundonLifeCycle Assessments

ThefollowingenvironmentalimpactcategoriesareconsideredinourLCAs:

• ADPelements (Abioticdepletionpotentialoftheelements):Utilizationof resources(minerals,metalores)thatare limitedonearth.

1 TRILUXGmbH&Co.KG,Heidestraße4, 59759Arnsberg,Germany sebastian.knoche@trilux.com

2 FraunhoferInstituteforReliabilityand MicrointegrationIZM,Gustav-Meyer-Allee 25,13355Berlin,Germany marina.proske@izm.fraunhofer.de

IntheresearchprojectSUMATRA (Sustainable MaterialsinFutureLuminaireDesigns–from Recyclingbackto Application),theaimistodothingsquantitatively,andnotjusthaveaqualitative discussion.Tothisend,weuseenvironmentalLifeCycleAssessments(LCAs). Inalifecycleassessment,theenvironmentalimpactsthatariseovertheentire lifecycleofaluminairearemeasuredin variousenvironmentalimpactcategories. Thisenablesquantitativecomparisonsto bemadebetweendifferentproductdesigns,sothatitcanbepreciselystated whethervariantAorvariantBcausesthe lowerenvironmentalimpactforproviding thesamebenefit.However,itisnotpossibletomakeastatementontheabsolute achievementofsustainability,asthiswould requireacomparisonofthedetermined environmentalimpactsofaluminairewith amaximumlevelthatisconsideredacceptable.Thismaximumlevel,called“Safe OperatingSpace”inthescientificliterature ofPlanetaryBoundaries [2,3,4],isdifficult todetermineforasingleluminaire.

• ADPfossil (Abioticdepletionpotential ofthefossils):Consumptionoffossilraw materials(oil,coal,gas),whicharefinite onearth.

• GWP (GlobalWarmingPotential):Emissionofgreenhousegases,measuredin kgCO2 equivalent.

• Toxicities (FreshWater/Marine/Terrestrial/Human):Releaseoftoxicsubstances.

• AP (Acidificationpotential):Emissionof substancessuchassulfurdioxide,which causeacidrain,forexample.

• EP (EutrophicationPotential):Water bodiesbeingenrichedwithnutrients (e.g.phosphates);whichhasadverseeffectssuchasalgalblooms,forexample.

• ODP (OzoneDepletionPotential):Depletionoftheozonelayerinthestratosphere(whichisournaturalUV-Cblocker onearth).

• POCP (PhotochemicalOzoneCreation): Creationofozoneneartheground, whichishighlyreactiveandhasadverse healtheffectswheninhaled.

EnvironmentalImpactsofLED
Luminaires,RecyclingPractices, andRecommendationsforaMore
ECO-DESIGN ENVIRONMENTALIMPACTSOFLEDLUMINAIRES 30 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design Issue103/May-June/2024

TheSUMATRAConsortium

TheSUMATRAresearchconsortium consistedof:

• TRILUXGmbH&Co.KG: Dr.SebastianKnoche,HorstRudolph, SonjaBeckmann,GregorGroteSchulte,FelixBruchhage,Katrin Discher,TorbenTillmann

• InventronicsGmbH: JürgenSchwarz,MarkusZiegler,Peter Kulf,BernhardOrben,MarkusHeckmann,ReinhardLecheler

• InterzeroCircularSolutionsGermany GmbH: CarlaKrätz,TorbenKabbe

• Fraunhofer-InstitutfürZuverlässigkeit undMikrointegration(IZM): MarinaProske,JanaRückschloss, OtmarDeubzer

• AssociatedpartnerKardorffIngenieure LichtplanungGmbH: GabrielevonKardorff

Theresearchprojectwasconducted fromJune2021toSeptember2023 andreceivedfundingfromtheGerman FederalMinistryforEconomicAffairsand ClimateAction.Theresponsibilityforthe contentofthispublicationlieswiththe authors.

However,inthefirstindicativelifecycle assessments,wefoundthatmostimpact categoriesareverysimilarlydistributed andabout95%ofthemoriginatefromthe electricityconsumptionintheusephase. Itisthereforesufficienttoselectonerepresentativefortheseimpactcategories.Our choiceistofocusonthe GlobalWarmingPotential(GWP).TheGWPcanbe reduceddirectlybyincreasingenergyefficiency.

Asecondmetricthatisinthefocusofour considerationsisthe AbioticDepletion Potentialoftheelements(ADPe).In contrasttotheGWP,largecontributions occurintheproductionphaseoftheluminaireduetothematerialsused.TheADP isthereforerelatedto materialefficiency Thiscomplementstheaspectmentioned first,(GWP/energyefficiency)inameaningfulway.

ClimateChange

Thereisabroadconsensusamongscientiststhatclimatechangeisextremely importantforourlifeonearth,asthere-

PartoftheSumatrateam:KlausRöwekamp,TorbenKabbe,MarinaProske,PeterKulf,SonjaBeckmann, SebastianKnoche,CarlaKrätz,KatrinDischer,MarkusZiegler,GregorGroteschulte,BorisSafner,Bernhard Orben,andJürgenSchwarz(lefttoright).

portsoftheIPCC(IntergovernmentalPanel onClimateChange)andtheirbroadauthorshipshow [5] Figure 1 showsthe evolutionoftheglobalmeansurfacetemperatureoverthepast24,000years.Large differencesarevisible;butthelast10,000 yearshavebeeninaverystableconditionwithvariancesofjust ±0.5 ◦C [6].This epochinearth’shistoryiscalled Holocene Agricultureandadvancedcivilizationsdevelopedduringthisepoch,anditisconsideredthereferencepointofadesirable planet [3]

Itiswellknownthatglobalwarmingis mainlydrivenbyhumanactivities:emissionofgreenhousegases,primarilyCO2 fromtheburningoffossilfuels [7].Other greenhousegases,likemethane,alsocontribute.Theseothergreenhousegasesare

convertedtotheir CO2 equivalent [8],i.e. totheamountofCO2 emissionsthatwould givethesameglobalwarmingeffect.All greenhousegasemissionsarethenaggregatedinanLCAtodeterminetheglobal warmingpotential,measuredinkgCO2 equivalent.

AbioticResourceUse

Humansextractrawmaterials(chemical elementsandcompounds)thatarestored intheearth’scrust,andusethemtobuild thingsthathaveafunctionforthem.This approachcanbeinconflictwiththeprincipleofsustainability,asresourcesare limitedandnon-renewable,i.e.theyarenot continuouslyproducedintheearth.

InanLCA,themetricformeasuringabiotic resourceconsumptionisthe Abiotic

Figure1: GlobalMeanSurfaceTemperature(GMST)changeoverthelast24,000years,reconstructedfrom proxies(blueareas)andtemperaturemeasurements(line)[5].

ECO-DESIGN ENVIRONMENTALIMPACTSOFLEDLUMINAIRES 31 Issue103/May-June/2024 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design

DepletionPotentialoftheElements [9,10,11].Allabioticresourcesusedduring thelifecycleofaproductareassigned aweightingfactor.Thisweightingfactor describesthescarcityofaresourceandis calculatedfromthetotalquantity R inthe earth’scrust(“ultimatereserve”,inkg)and thecurrentextractionrate DR (inkg/year).

Foraresource i itreads:

ADPi = DRi⁄R2 i DRref⁄R2 ref (1) Thereferenceelementisantimony(chemicalsymbolSb).Thus,theunitfortheAbioticDepletionPotentialoftheelementsis kgSbequivalent

Theweightingfactorsdifferbymanyorders ofmagnitude.Forexample,aluminum,the thirdmostcommonelementintheearth’s crust,hasaweightingfactorof ADPAl = 1 09 × 10 9 kgSb−eq./kg. Incontrast,goldhasaweightingfactorof ADPAu = 52kgSb−eq./kg,seereference [9]

LifeCycleAssessment Results

WeperformedLCAsforeightluminaires ofvarioustypesproducedforprofessional applications.Theyhavelifetimes(declared

bythemanufacturer)of 50,000–100,000 h, luminousfluxesbetween 2,200 lmand 26,700 lmandefficaciesbetween 110 lm/W and 179 lm/W.

Someofthemaredimmableandcanbe controlledbymeansoftheDALIprotocol. However,theusephaseforallofthem wasmodelledasaconstantoperationat 100%dimmingleveloverthefulllifetime. Wecalculatedwithastaticelectricitymix (Germany2019).

Backgrounddatawastakenfromthe SpheraLCAforexperts® database.

Packaging,transporttothecustomerand theend-of-lifetreatmenthavebeenconsidered,andwefoundthemtobeofminor relevance.Forthesakeofclarity,theyare omittedinthefollowingpresentationofthe resultsandanalysisofhotspots.

PortfolioOverview

Figure 2 showstheresultsofthelifecycleassessment.Letusfocusourattention ontheabsolutevalues(upperrowofdiagrams)first.

Theglobalwarmingpotentialrangesbetween 470 kgand 5,000 kgCO2-equivalent. Strikingly,theshareoftheproduction phaseisverylow,onlybetween1%and 5%.Includedhereisthecompletesupply

chainuptotherawmaterialmining.The vastmajorityofgreenhousegasemissions occursduringtheusephase,i.e.inorder toproducetheelectricityconsumedbythe luminaire.

Inthediagramontherighthandside,it isdiscerniblethattheabioticdepletion potentialisdominatedbytheproduction phase;morespecificallybytheelectronic components(LEDmodule,controlgear, wiring).Optics(mostlymadefromtransparentplasticslikePMMAorPC)andhousings(mostlysteeloraluminum)haveonly smallcontributions.Fromtheabioticresourceperspective,itseemsthatthelarge amountsofsteeloraluminuminahousing havelessimpactthanthesmallamounts ofcopperortinyamountsofpreciousmetalsintheelectronics.Thereisalsoacontributionoftheusephasetotheabiotic depletionpotential.Thiscomesfromthe electricityconsumption,notfromspare parts.Electricitygenerationalsoconsumes abioticresources,forbuildinginfrastructure,powerplants,solarpanels,andsoon.

Inbothimpactcategories,thehigh-bay luminairestandsoutinparticular.Interms ofglobalwarmingpotential,thisismainly duetothehighpowerandintermsofabioticresourceconsumptionduetothehigh numberofLEDs.Butthatresultsinalot oflight(26,700 lmand 70,000 hlifetime).

Figure2: OverviewoftheLifeCycleAssessmentresults.Theupperrowshowstheabsolutevaluesoftheenvironmentalimpacts;thelowerrowshowsthe environmentalimpactsnormalizedtoequalfluxof1,000lmandequalusetimeof1,000h.

ECO-DESIGN ENVIRONMENTALIMPACTSOFLEDLUMINAIRES 32 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design Issue103/May-June/2024

Therefore,inadditiontotheabsoluterepresentation,standardizedrepresentationsfor identicalluminousfluxandidenticallifetime arealsoveryuseful.Forthisfunctionalunit, wechose 1,000 lmand 1,000 hofoperation.Theresultsareshowninthelower rowof Figure 6

Inthisrepresentation,thehigh-bayluminaireappearsrelativelysustainablecomparedwithotherluminairearchitectures. Nowthewall-mountedluminairehasthe highestimpactsinbothcategories.The wall-mountedluminaireconsistsofalarge LEDmodule(300 mmindiameter)anda bigopalcover.Itsluminousfluxisrelativelylow(2,200 lm)andsoisitsluminous efficacy(110 lm/W).Thisexplainstherelativelylargeenvironmentalimpactsper 1,000 lmand 1,000 h.

Itmaybeusefultodeducean“average” luminairefromtheresults,forexample,to getaroughestimateoftheenvironmental impactsoflightinginacompletebuilding whennodetaileddataisavailable,orto startbuildinganintuitiveunderstandingof luminaireLCAs.Astheselectedluminaires arenotrepresentativeofallexistingLEDluminaires,anexactcalculationofthemean valuemakeslittlesense.Inlightoftheunavoidableinaccuracy,the“smoothest” valuespossiblearethereforeselected,see Table 1

GWP 3 kgCO2−eq.

ADP 6 × 10 6 kgSb−eq.

Table1: Estimatedaverageenvironmentalimpactsofprofessionallightingper1,000lm 1,000h.

Anaveragebreakdownoftheenvironmentalimpactstothedifferentphasesand componentsisshownin Figure 3

Figure3: Averagebreakdownofglobalwarming potential(left)andabioticdepletionpotential (right)foraprofessionalLEDluminaire.

Itisanintriguingquestion,whetherthe globalwarmingpotentialorabioticdepletionpotentialcausedbyaluminaireis “moreimportant”.Obviously,bothmetricsusedifferentunitsandcannotbe compareddirectly.Infact,theydescribe completelydifferenteffects,andanycomparisonisalwayssubjective.However,a comparisonwithnormalizationfactors(NF) providesafirstindication.Thenormaliza-

tionfactorsarerecommendedbytheJoint ResearchCentre(JRC)oftheEuropean Commissionfortheevaluationofenvironmentalfootprintsanddescribetheglobal environmentalimpactofallhumanactivities (determinedfor2010),percapita [12]

Thecomparisonmadein Table 2 shows thattheclimatechangepotentialofan LEDluminairehasahighershareofthe normalizationfactor(13%)thantheabiotic resourceconsumption(3%).However, theproportionsareofasimilarorderof magnitude–LCAresultsoftenshowmuch moredrasticdifferences.Wetherefore concludethatbothenvironmentalimpact categoriesareequallyrelevantandthatthe eco-designofLEDluminairesshouldaimto reducebothenvironmentalimpacts.

Figure4: AbioticDepletionPotentialforLED modulesofdifferentgeometryandwithdifferent LEDtype.

ThustheanalysisincludestwoLEDtypes thatmayrequiremoreexplanation.IntraditionalLEDarchitectures,bondwires,that aremadefromagoldalloy,areusedto contacttheemitterchip.Morerecently, LEDswithflip-chiptechnologyhavebeen introducedtothemarket.Inthem,the emitterchipiscontactedbysolderbumps frombelow,thussavingthegoldforthe bondwire.See Figure 5 foramicroscopy imageofthetwoLEDtypes.

Table2: Comparisonofaverageenvironmental impactsforoneluminairewiththenormalization factorNF.

Detail:LED-Module

Astheportfoliooverview(Figure 2)shows, theLEDmodulecanbethelargestcontributiontotheabioticdepletionpotential.TheLCAofanLEDmoduledepends onthreefactors:Thesurfaceareaofthe printedcircuitboard(PCB),thetypeof LEDs,andtheiramount.

TheresultsforexemplaryLEDmodules areshownin Figure 4.Adistinctionis madebetweendifferentLEDtypes(flipchip /bondwire)andtwoPCBlayoutseither linear(71 9 cmx 2 3 cm,equippedwith96 LEDs)orlargearea(33 6 cmindiameter, equippedwith64LEDs).Thefourpossible combinationsleadtosignificantlydifferent environmentalimpacts.

Acomparisonofthescenarioswithand withoutbondwirein Figure 4 showsthat almosttheentireabioticresourceconsumptionofLEDsiscausedbythebond wire.Materialsforthechip(e.g.gallium)or forthephosphors(e.g.rareearthelements) appeartoplayaminorrole.

Thefollowingconclusiononsustainable LEDmoduledesigncanbedrawn:

Figure6: Correlationoftheglobalwarmingpotential(toprow)andabioticdepletionpotential(bottomrow) fortheproductionofanECGwithitspower,weight,areaandvolume.

ECO-DESIGN ENVIRONMENTALIMPACTSOFLEDLUMINAIRES 33 Issue103/May-June/2024 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design
GWP [kgCO2−eq.] 1,000 7,550 13% ADP [kgSb−eq.] 2 63.3 3%
Luminaire NF Ratio Figure5: Flip-chipLEDontheleftandLEDwith bondwireontheright.

• Flip-chipLEDshaveasignificantlylower abioticresourceconsumptionthanLEDs withbondingwireandaretherefore preferable.

• ThesurfaceareaoftheLEDmoduleis relevantandshouldbekeptassmallas possible.

Detail:ElectronicControlGear

Theelectroniccontrolgear(ECG)ofaluminairehasacomplexstructureandconsists ofaprintedcircuitboardwithalargenumberofelectroniccomponents.Aproperlife cycleassessmentisonlypossibleifthebill ofmaterialsisavailable.IntheSUMATRA project,thiswasthecasebytheclosecollaborationoftheconsortium.

Intheportfoliooverview(Figure 2),we canseethattheproductionoftheECG oftenhasamajorimpactontheabiotic depletionpotential.Whatarethedriving factorsbehindthisresult?

Figure 7 showstheresultfordifferent seriesofECGs.Withinthesameseries (connectedbybluelines),wefindthatthe ADPincreasesonlyslightlywithincreasing nominaloutputpower.Acomparisonofa dimmableandaswitchableECGshows thattheswitchableECGconsumesaround 30%lessresources( → ).Wealso assessedanECGwithsafetyextralow voltage(SELV).Duetotheadditionalinsulationstagesintheinternalstructure,it hasaslightlyhigherabioticresourceconsumptionthancomparablenon-SELVdevices,thedifferenceisapproximately25% ( → ).

Figure7: AbioticdepletionpotentialfortheproductionofdifferentECGs.Outdoordevices( ), dimmableindoordeviceswithalinearformfactor ( ),non-dimmabledevice( )andadevicewith safetyextra-lowvoltage( )wereinvestigated.

parametersthatareusuallypartofthedata sheet.Theresultsareshownin Figure 6

Itcanbeseenthattheenvironmentalimpactdoesnotcorrelatewiththenominal outputpower;otherfactorsappeartobe moreimportant.Thereisalsonostrong correlationwithweight,astheECGmass isdrivenbythehousing,pottingorheavy capacitors,whereastheenvironmentalimpactsaredrivenbythesmall,butcomplex, microelectronicscomponents.Thecorrelationswithareaandvolumearereasonable andcanbeusedforasimplelinearmodel. Forelectronics,scalingwiththebasearea isoftenchosen.Inourcase,however,we usevolumeasaparameterforthefinal model.Foranotherwiseunknowndevice, thevaluesforGWPandADPcanbeestimatedbasedonthevolume V (incm3)of theECGasfollows:

GWP = V 0 0089 kgCO2−eq./cm3 +1 94 kgCO2−eq. (2) ADP =

duetothereductionofcoalandgas-fired powerplants.Ontheotherhand,theabioticdepletionpotentialperkWhincreases, whichisparticularlyinfluencedbytheincreasinguseofphotovoltaics.

Sincethevarianceamongcommercially availableECGsisverylarge,afurthergeneralizationoftheresultsisdesirableinordertoestimatetheenvironmentalimpacts fortheproductionofanunknownECG.To thisend,weanalyzedwhethertheenvironmentalimpactscorrelatewithvarious

Thisresultsinroot-mean-squaredeviationsof ±0 5 kgCO2−eq.and ±8 8 × 10 5 kgSb−eq.respectively,betweenthe regressionlineandthedatapoints(seethin linesin Figure 6).

Detail:UsePhase

Fortheusephaseoftheluminaire,weconsideranoperationat100%dimminglevel overthelifetimeoftheluminaire.Repair andmaintenancearenottakenintoaccount,sincealltheluminairesaredesigned toworkfortheirentirelifetimewithoutany replacementofECGorLEDmodule.

Calculationofthebaselinescenarioofthe usephaseisstraightforward:Takethetotalelectricalenergyconsumed(inkWh), andmultiplyitbytheemissionfactors (kgCO2−eq.perkWhandkgSb−eq.per kWh,respectively).PubliclyavailableemissionfactorsforthegridmixinGermany canbefoundinreference [13],forexample,butonlyforGWP.IntheSUMATRA project,however,westicktothevaluesincludedintheSphera® database,whichwe cannotdisclosehere.

Europeisinthemiddleofanenergytransitiontowardsrenewables.Thecalculation oftheusephaseinsuchascenarioismore complex,becausetheemissionfactors varyovertime.Basedonascenariofor theenergytransitioninGermany,termed “KN50”inreference [14],wecalculated theannualemissionfactors,see Figure 8 TheglobalwarmingpotentialperkWhof electricitydecreasesoverthecomingyears

Figure8: EnergytransitionscenarioinGermany anditsenvironmentalimpacts.

Calculationoftheenvironmentalimpactsof theusephaseintheenergytransitionscenarioisnowfeasible:Foreachyear,take theelectricalenergyconsumedandmultiplyitbytheemissionfactorsvalidforthat year,andsumupallyearsofoperation.

Obviously,theresultingtotalswillnowalso dependontheyearwhentheluminaire wasputintooperation,theannualoperatinghours,anditsusagetimeintheapplication.

Thiscalculationprocesscanbemapped toeffectivevaluesfortheemissionfactors.Theyaresummarizedin Table 3 and correspondtoanaverageovertheperiodofuse.Thefirstsectionof Table 3 definesfourusescenarioswithdifferent annualoperationhours [15].Inthesecondsection,wedemonstratehowlong theperiodofuseofaluminaireactuallyis: Aluminairewith 100,000 hoursassigned lifetimecouldbeusedfor40yearsinan officeapplication–e.g.fromyear2020 toyear2060.Finally,thethirdandfourth sectionsof Table 3 presenttheeffective emissionfactors.Wecanobserveahigh varianceinthevalues,dependingonthe assignedlifetimeandapplicationscenario. Forexample,theglobalwarmingpotential fortheGermanelectricitymixiscurrentlya

ECO-DESIGN ENVIRONMENTALIMPACTSOFLEDLUMINAIRES 34 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design Issue103/May-June/2024
kgSb−eq.
+1
V 1.1 × 10 6
/cm3
9 × 10 4 kgSb−eq. (3)

littlebelow 500 gCO2−eq./kWh,seeReference [13].Foraluminairewith 50,000 h assignedlifetime,beingputintoa24/7operationin2020,wehaveaneffectiveemissionfactorofabout 400 gCO2−eq./kWh duringthe5.7yearsofuse.Incontrast,a luminairewith 100,000 hassignedlifetime, beingputintoanofficeapplication,willonly useaneffectiveemissionfactorofabout 140 gCO2−eq./kWhduringits40yearsof use.

Annualstandardoperationhours

Office Industry Retail 24/7

2,500h/a 4,000h/a 5,000h/a 8,760h/a Periodofuse(years)

Assigned lifetime 2,500h/a 4,000h/a 5,000h/a 8,760h/a

50,000h 20a 12.5a 10a 5.7a 70,000h 28a

EffectiveGWP[kgCO2-eq./kWh]

Assigned lifetime 2,500h/a 4,000h/a 5,000h/a 8,760h/a

Table3: Annualstandardoperationhours,period ofuse,andeffectiveemissionfactorsforglobal warmingpotentialandabioticdepletionpotential (luminairebeingplacedintooperationin2020).

DiscussionandLimitations

Themostintensivelydiscussedenvironmentalimpactisprobablytheglobalwarmingpotential.Wehaveshownthatthe usephaseofaluminairehasthedominantinfluence.Thevalueoftheemitted CO2-equivalentsdependssensitivelyon theelectricitygridmix.Bothregionand timeinfluencetheemissionfactorsofthe gridmix,whichcanvarytoagreatextent. WhencomparingtheCO2-footprintsoftwo luminaires,carefulconsiderationofthegrid mixesisnecessary.

Whenusingsameassumptions(likegrid mixes),theresultsfortheglobalwarmingpotentialarequiterobust.However, wehaveexperiencedlargeuncertainties intheresultsfortheabioticdepletionpotential.ADPresultsarehighlysensitiveto evensmallamountsofpreciousmetals, e.g.inelectronics.Quantifyingtheexact contentofnoblemetalsisdifficult,since theexactmaterialcompositionoftheelectronicscomponentsareoftennotknown bytheluminairemanufacturer;andthe suppliersareofteninterestedinkeeping thisinformationconfidential.Usingestablisheddatasetsforelectronicscomponents,likeSphera® orEcoinvent®,isa feasibleworkaround,butleadstouncertainties.Itcanbeshown,thatthechoice oflifecycleinventorydatabasecanleadto

differenthotspotsintheLCA,especiallyfor otherimpactcategoriesthanGWP [16,17]

Estimatingtheabioticresourcedepletion bymeansoftheADPmetrichaseven morefundamentalchallenges.Forexample,thevaluesfor DR and R arenot fixedonce-and-for-all,butaretimedependent [11].Moreover,itisquestionableifall thedifferentabioticresourcesshouldbe aggregated,asonedepletedresourcecannotnecessarilybereplacedbyanotherone thatisstillavailable.

Anotherlimitationofouranalysisliesinthe selectionofenvironmentalimpactmetrics. Wefocusedontheglobalwarmingpotentialandtheabioticdepletionpotential.This choicewasmadeafterascreeningofthe resultsfor12impactcategories.However, theremightstillberelevantenvironmentalimpactsthatwerenotwithinthescope ofourfirstscreening.Afrequentlyasked questionconcernstheinclusionofthedestructionofnatureduringmaterialmining. Thisverydirectimpactontheplanet,likein open-pitminingformetalores,isneitherincludedintheglobalwarmingpotential,nor intheabioticdepletionpotential.Further metricsonland-useorland-usechange couldbeinvestigatedtoaccountforthis. Forotheraspectslikelossofbiodiversity, thereisnotyetawidelyestablishedindicator.

RecyclingofLuminaires

Recyclingisonespecificformofwaste treatment.Ashortexplanationofthecommontermsseemstobeappropriateto enableprecisecommunication. Waste is asubstanceorobjectthattheholderdiscardsorintendsorisrequiredtodiscard. Wastecanbesentto recovery operations, whereitservesausefulpurpose.Oneform is energyrecovery,i.e.incinerationor processingtofuels,anotherformis materialrecovery.Thelattercanbedivided into(preparingfor) re-use, recycling and backfilling.Thisdefinesrecyclingasarecoveryoperationbywhichwastematerials arereprocessedintoproducts,materials orsubstanceswhetherfortheoriginalor otherpurposes,excludingenergyrecovery orbackfilling [18]

Theterm“recyclability”isevenmoredifficulttograspthantheterm“recycling”. Inliterature,adistinctionismadebetween [19]:

• Theoreticalrecyclability (ofthematerialitself)

• Technicalrecyclability

(thematerialmustalsobeabletobe identifiedandseparated)

• Realisticrecyclability (collectionsystemsandsortingfacilities mustbeavailable,andactualpollution ofthematerialsmustbetakenintoaccount)

Internationalstandards [18,20] require manufacturerstoreporttherealisticrecyclabilityoftheirproductsasanenvironmentalclaim,notthepurelytheoretical recyclability.

ReferenceEnd-of-LifeTreatment Scenario

Thecentralelementofarealisticrecyclabilityassessmentisareferenceendof-lifetreatmentscenario [18].Thereis notyetastandardizedreferencescenarioforluminaires.BasedonthestandardEN45555 [18] andapublication thatcarriesouttheprocedureforsmartphones [21],suchascenariowasdevelopedintheSUMATRAproject,see Figure 9

Inourproposedscenario,luminairesare collectedtogetherwithothersmallorlarge electricalappliances.TheEuropeanWEEE Directive2012/19/EUestablishessome minimumrequirementsfortherecycling, especiallytheselectivetreatmentof [22]

• Printedcircuitboardslargerthan 10 cm2

• Plasticswithbrominatedflameretardants

• Gasdischargelamps

• Batteries

• Externalelectricalcables

• PCB-containingcapacitors.

Inpractice,itappearsthatlamps,componentscontainingharmfulsubstances andbatteriesareremovedmanuallybeforeshredding.FormostLEDluminaires (withoutemergencylightingbatteries,no PCB-containingcapacitors),itcanbeassumedthattheyareshreddeddirectlywithoutmanualtreatment.Therequirement forselectivetreatmentisfulfilledbysubsequentsorting.

Figure 10 showstheresultofshredding andsortingusingtheexampleofaweatherproofluminairewhichwassentthrough theprocess.Itcanbeseenthattheferrousandnon-ferrousmetalsaresortedout well,thenon-ferrousmetalfractioncontainingprintedcircuitboardsfromtheECG andLEDmodule.Onlysmallquantitiesof plasticsareseparatedintoanownfraction. Thelargestproportionofplasticsendsup intheresiduals,whichthenonlygotoincineration,thusescapingmaterialrecovery.

ECO-DESIGN ENVIRONMENTALIMPACTSOFLEDLUMINAIRES 35 Issue103/May-June/2024 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design
17.5a 14a 8.0a 100,000h 40a 25.0a 20a 11.4a
50,000h 0.241 0.312 0.347 0.402 70,000h 0.190 0.262 0.295 0.376 100,000h 0.142 0.207 0.241 0.326
50,000h
70,000h
5.52e-7 5.04e-7
100,000h
EffectiveADP[kgSb-eq./kWh] Assigned lifetime 2,500h/a 4,000h/a 5,000h/a 8,760h/a
5.80e-7 4.82e-7 4.41e-7 3.71e-7
6.62e-7
4.07e-7
7.45e-7 6.32e-7 5.80e-7 4.65e-7

Figure9: Proposedreferenceend-of-lifetreatmentscenarioforrecyclabilityassessmentsofLEDluminairesbasedonEN45555.

Therearetworeasonsforthisloss.Firstly, theshreddingprocessesmaterialslike plastics(butalsoglass)intoverysmallfragmentsthatarealmostimpossibletosort out.Secondly,onlycertaintypesofplastics(targetplastics)aresortedout.The polymersPCandPMMA,whichareprimarilyusedintheluminaires,arepresumablynosuchtargetplastics,astheyoccur ininsufficientquantitiesintheoverallwaste streamofsmallorlargeelectricappliances.

Theseresultsconfirmthedatathatwas determinedinIECTechnicalReport62635 backin2012 [23].Recyclingratesforspecificmaterialgroupsaretabulatedthere. ThedatawascollectedinEuropebetween 2005and2008andrelatestotheproduct groupsofsmallandlargehouseholdappliances,ITandtelecommunicationsequipmentandconsumerelectronics.Here,too, itcanbeseenthattheplasticsPCand

PMMA,whicharerelevantforluminaires, arenolongerrecycledaftershredding. OnlytheplasticsABS,PP,HIPSandPE arerecycledaftershredding.

RecyclabilityAssessment

EN45555usesamass-basedapproach todefinetherecyclabilityrate Rcyc ofa product [18]:

Rcyc = ∑ mk R

where mtot isthetotalproductmass,the sumrunsoverallmaterials k,with mk beingthemassofmaterial k and Rcyc,k beingitsrecyclabilityfactor.Therecyclability factorsforeachmaterialshallincludethe efficiencyofthestepsofthereferenceendof-lifetreatmentscenario [18]

Figure10: Outputoftheshreddingandsortingprocessforonesingleweatherproofluminaire(length1.2m, weight2.3kg,housingmadefromgreypolycarbonateandopticsfromclearpolycarbonate.

Asnomorerecentliteraturevaluesforthe recyclingratesofspecificmaterialgroups couldbeidentified,theratesofIEC/TR 62635:2012 [23] areusedfortherecyclabilityfactors.Materiallossesaretaken intoaccount:forexample,steelisintheory completelyrecyclable,butduetolossesto otherfractionscausedbyimperfectsorting, aneffectiverecyclingrateof94%isused.

Therecyclabilityassessmentrequiresa detailedbillofmaterialsandweightsof theluminaire.Formanymechanicaland opticalparts,thisisquitesimple,asthey consistoffewmaterials.ForECGsand LEDmodules,ontheotherhand,itisquite challenging.Therefore,westudiedthe materialcompositionof2LEDmodules and4ECGsindetail,toderiveexemplary recyclabilityfactorsfortheseparts,see Table 4

Table4: Recyclabilityfactors(percentageby weight)ofvariouselectroniccomponentsof luminaires.

ForLEDmodules,itwasassumedthat theirfinaltreatmentstepisthecopper

ECO-DESIGN ENVIRONMENTALIMPACTSOFLEDLUMINAIRES 36 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design Issue103/May-June/2024
cyc,k mtot (4)
Rcyc,k LEDmodule, epoxyresinsubstrate 11% LEDmodule, aluminumsubstrate 8% ECG, outdoorapplication(potted) 12% ECG, plastichousing 15% ECG, metalhousing 55%
Component

smelter.Therecyclingratesinthecoppersmelterforthevariousmetals(copper, preciousmetals,lead,tin,nickel,antimony) weretakenfromtheliterature [24].The materialcompositionofLEDmoduleswas determinedwithsuppliers,butarenotreproducedhereforreasonsofconfidentiality.TherecyclingratesforLEDmodules rangefrom8%(foraluminumcorePCBs) to11%(forepoxyresinPCBs),whichis evenlowerthanthestandardvaluesfor printedcircuitboardsclassifiedas“poor” inIEC/TR62635:2012.Themainrecyclingyieldcomesfromcopperandtin. RareearthsfromtheLEDs’phosphorsare lostinthecoppersmelter,asisthePCB substrate(whichmakesupthelargestproportionbyweight).However,themetals recoveredfromtheLEDmodulearealso themost“precious”materialsandhavethe highestabioticresourcedepletionpotential.

ForECGs,weassumethatthesteelhousingandprintedcircuitboardareseparated intheshredder,withthehousinggoing tothesteelworksandthecircuitboardto thecoppersmelterforthefinalrecycling. Themaincontributionstotherecyclability factorarethesheetmetalhousingandthe copperfromthePCBandlargercomponentssuchasinductors.PottedECGs, oftenfoundinoutdoorapplications,are critical,astheycannotbeseparatedby shredding.WeassumethattheseECGs aresortedas“non-ferrousmetals”despite theheavypottingcompoundandendup inthecoppersmelter,wherecopperand preciousmetalsarerecoveredwhilethe pottingcompoundburns(i.e.contributes toenergyrecovery,notrecycling).

Anexampleofacompleteluminaireassessmentisshownin Table 5.Inthiscase, theweatherproofluminaireobtainsarecyclabilityof37%.Themainlossesarethe polycarbonateopticsandhousing.Though

Table5: TemplatefortherecyclabilityassessmentbasedonEN45555,completedforaweatherproof luminaire.Thecentralresultisthevalue37%incell Rcyc/sum.Thetwocolumnsontherightrepeatthe assessmentforthetheoreticalbestcase.

theoreticallyrecyclable,beingathermoplast,itiscountedas0%recycledinthe referenceend-of-lifetreatmentscenario. ThisisduetotheinitialshreddingincombinationwiththeliteraturedataofIEC/ TR62635:2012indicatingthatPCisnot recycledaftershredding.

Todemonstratethelargepotentialthat liesinoptimizingtherecyclingprocesses, Table 5 alsoshowsthetheoreticalbest case,basedontherecyclabilityofthematerialitself.Inthisscenario,therecyclability oftheweatherproofluminairerisesfrom 37%(realistic)to91%(bestcase).This scenariocouldbereachede.g.bymanual orroboticdisassemblyandsorting.Incurrentrecyclingpractices,thisseemstobe notviableforeconomicreasons.

Weconductedassessmentsfortenluminaires.Theresultsaresummarizedin Figure 11.Therealisticrecyclabilityvaries between22%and84%,andisprimarily influencedbythecontentsofplasticsinthe opticsandmechanicalstructure.Other majorlossesintherecyclingareglass sheets(e.g.inluminaireC).Theratherlow

recyclabilityofLEDmodulesandECGs haveanimpactontheoverallrecyclability, especiallyforsmallluminaireslikedownlights(luminaireF)orwhentheLEDmodule isrelativelylargeandheavy(e.g.luminaire H).

Discussion

Wepresentedourmethodoftherecyclabilityassessmentindetail,becausewe wanttoenablethelightingcommunityto harmonizethiskindofassessment.This isnecessarytomakefairandcomparable claimsabouttherecyclabilityofluminaires. Averyimportantpartoftheinformationlies withinthemethod;notthereportedvalue alone.Today,luminairemanufacturersare foundtousedifferentmethodstodefine “their”notionofrecyclability,andexamples ofenvironmentalclaimscanbefoundthat areevenmoreeuphemisticthanthe“theoreticalbestcase”presentedin Table 5

Theinternationalstandardsagreethatan assessmentoftherealisticrecyclabilityof aproductisrequired.However,astandardizedreferenceend-of-lifetreatment scenarioandmaterial-specificrecyclability

Figure11: Realisticrecyclabilityresultsfortenluminaires.Theleftcolumnshowsthemassesoftheluminairecomponentsinitsoriginalstate,andtherightcolumn showstheweightofmaterialsrecoveredintherecyclingprocess.Componentsbelongingtothemechanicalstructureareblue(mostlymetals),wiringred,optical componentsorange(mostlyplastics),andelectronicsgray.

Mass Final Rcyc Yield Rcyc Yield [kg] Treatment [kg] theoretical [kg] Mechanics Steel 0.740 Steelworks 0.94 0.695 1.0 0.740 StainlessSsteel 0.014 Steelworks 0.94 0.013 1.0 0.014 PC 0.720 Therm. 1.0 0.720 Other 0.049 Wiring Copper 0.009 CuSmelter 0.85 0.008 1.0 0.009 PVC 0.009 Therm. 1.0 0.009 Other 0.009 Optics PC 0.436 Therm. 1.0 0.436 ECG MetalHousing 0.176 0.55 0.097 0.55 0.097 LEDmodule ResinSubstrate 0.084 0.11 0.009 0.11 0.009 Sum 2.246 37% 0.822 91% 2.033
ECO-DESIGN ENVIRONMENTALIMPACTSOFLEDLUMINAIRES 37 Issue103/May-June/2024 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design

factorsarenotyetestablishedforluminaires.ThestandardEN45555is,infact, nottobeapplieddirectlyfortherecyclabilityassessmentofproducts,butshallserve asamethodforwritingproductorproductgroupstandards [18].IntheSUMATRA researchproject,wetookashort-cut,proposedanend-of-lifetreatmentscenario, andperformedtherecyclabilityassessment directly.

Conclusions

Luminairesandlightingdohavesignificantenvironmentalimpacts.Therelevance fortheglobalwarmingpotentialisobviousfromthestatisticsofenergyusage: 13%ofGermany’selectricityisusedfor lighting [25];andtheenergysectoristhe majoremitterofgreenhousegasesinGermany [26].Ourlifecycleassessmenthas shownthattheabioticresourcedepletionis ofsimilarrelevanceastheglobalwarming potentialwhencomparedtonormalization factors,see Table 2.Thisfindingmightnot correspondwithourintuitionbecauseluminairesseemtobequite“simple”technology.Andofcourse,smartphones,laptops, orelectricvehiclescontaincertainlymore preciousmaterialsthanaluminaire.But thinkabouthowubiquitousluminairesare inourbuiltenvironment.Howmanyluminaires,perperson,areinourhomes,atour workplaces,inthestreets?

Lightisaverycommonproduct,and needscarefulconsiderationtomakeit

assustainableaspossible.Afteryears ofclosecollaboration,theSUMATRAresearchersagreedon9recommendations forlightingindustryandpolicymakerspresentedinthe RecommendationBox below.Someoftherecommendationsare concludedfromresearchactivitiesthat werenotpresentedinthisarticle.

Therecommendationsincludeacallfor moreaccuratelifecycleassessmentdata, especiallyofelectronicscomponentslike theLEDmodules.Thisdataisdifficultto obtainforaluminairemanufacturer,and shouldbecommunicatedalongthesupplychain.Onlythen,reliableLCAresults areachievableandinformeddecisions formoresustainableproductdesignsare possible.Interestinthiskindofdatawill increase,asmoreandmorecompanieswill berequiredtoreporttheirenvironmental impacts,includingscope3(supplychain emissionsandthoseassociatedwiththe useoftheirproducts).

OneoftheoriginalgoalsoftheSUMATRA projectwastodesignaluminairewithits end-of-lifeinfocus.However,thereislittlesenseinoptimizingaluminaireforthe shreddingprocessoftoday’srecycling practices.Recycling,initscurrentform, seemstobeoneoftheleastfavorablecircularityoptions,itisratherthelastresort thanthefirstchoice.Weconcludeourresearchontherecyclabilityofluminaires withacallthatcoordinatedactivitiesbetweenmanufacturersandrecyclersare

RecommendationsfortheLighting IndustryandPolicyMakers

Withtheserecommendations,wewanttoboosttheeffortsofturningthe lightingbusinessintoamoresustainablefuture,evenifsomedetailsare stillunclear.TherecommendationswereagreedonbytheSUMATRA researchersontheirfinalmeetingon27September2023inArnsberg, after28monthsofresearchandintensivecollaboration.

01 Lightmanagementsystemsoffergreat energysavingpotentials,andtheadditional costsarelowcomparedtoanon-managed system.Theyshouldbeemployedaccording tothenecessitiesoftheapplication.

02 LifeCycleAssessmentsofLEDluminaires shouldfocusnotonlyonenergyefficiency, butalsoonresourceefficiency.

03 Theluminaireshouldbedesignedto enablereplacementandupgradesof electroniccomponentssuchasLED modulesandelectroniccontrolgears(ECGs).

04 Sparepartsforluminairesand componentsshouldbeavailableinthelong term.

05 Allcomponentsshouldbedesignedto identicallifetimes,whichshouldmeetthe lifetimerequirementoftheapplication.

06 Informationthatmakesiteasiertoreplace componentsshouldbefoundonthe luminairelabel,electronicallyintheluminaire, orviabuildinginformationmodels(BIM).

07 Luminairesshouldbedesignedtobe separatedintouniformmaterialfractionsin therecyclingprocess,inordertominimize materiallosses.Atthesametime,recycling processesshouldbeoptimized.This requirescoordinatedactivitiesbetween manufacturersandrecyclers.

necessarytomakerealprogressinthis veryrelevantfield.

Inthisarticle,wepresentedthreefacets ofsustainabilityofluminairesindetail:The globalwarmingpotential,theabioticdepletionpotential,andtherecyclability.By usingquantitativemethodstoassessthese threeaspects,differentluminairedesigns becomecomparable.However,wedid notfindasatisfactorysolutionforan“overallsustainabilityrating”.Thischallengeis illustratedinthefollowingexample:Imaginetwoluminaireconcepts,AandB,for thesamelightingpurpose.Amayhavean 8%lowerglobalwarmingpotentialthanB, becauseitreachesahigherluminousefficacybyemployingmoreLEDsandabetter heatsink.ThisleadstoBhavinga17% lowerabioticdepletionpotentialthanA. Furthermore,AsurpassesBby5percentagepointsinrecyclability.Whichconcept, AorB,deservestobecalled“moresustainable”?Wedonotevendaretoraisethe questionwhichluminairewouldbejustifiedtobeclaimed“sustainable”inabsolute terms.

Thoughhavingmadeprogressinquantifying,explainingandinterpretingtheenvironmentalimpacts,westillhavetoconclude thatsustainabilityisnotmeasurable.In viewofthislackofcertainty,weencourage furtherresearchandexpandedeffortsto movethelightingindustrytowardsamore sustainablefuture,asexpressedinour9 recommendations. ■

08 LifeCycleAssessmentdata-setsfor luminairecomponents,especiallyLED modulesandECGs,shouldbecompleted, standardizedandcommunicated transparently.

09 Manufacturersarerecommendedto performLifeCycleAssessmentsduring productdevelopmenttoachievea meaningfuleco-designoftheirluminaires.

ECO-DESIGN ENVIRONMENTALIMPACTSOFLEDLUMINAIRES 38 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design Issue103/May-June/2024

AuthorSebastianKnoche studiedphysics andobtainedadoctoraldegreeinthefield oftheoreticalsoftmatterphysicsfromTU Dortmunduniversity.In2015,hechanged fromacademiatoindustryandstarted workingfortheTRILUXGroup.Since 2017,heisinleadofthelightingresearch teamandorganisestheparticipationof TRILUXinjointresearchprojects.Hiscurrentresearchprojectsarefocussedon sustainability.

AuthorMarinaProske studiedenvironmentalengineeringattheTechnicalUniversityofBerlinandcompletedherdoctorate onthesubjectof“Ecodesignconcepts andenvironmentalassessmentstaking intoaccountproductobsolescence”.She hasbeenworkingatFraunhoferIZMsince 2011,wheresheisleadingthe“LifeCycle Modeling”groupsince2023anddealswith thetopicsofecodesignandlifecycleassessments.From2016to2022shewasa memberoftheresearchgroup“OHA–ObsolescenceasaChallengeforSustainability”.SheworksinnationalandEuropean researchprojectsontheenvironmental impactofelectronics,conductslifecycle assessmentsofICTdevicesandregularly reviewsLCAs.

References

[1] WorldCommissiononEnvironmentandDevelopment,“OurCommonFuture,”OxfordUniversity Press,Oxford,1987.

[2] J.Rockström,W.Steffen,K.J.Noone,Å.Persson, F.S.Chapin,E.F.Lambin,T.M.Lenton,M.Scheffer, C.Folke,H.J.Schellnhuber,B.Nykvist,C.A.d.Wit, T.P.Hughes,S.v.d.Leeuw,H.Rodhe,S.Sörlin,P. K.Snyder,R.Costanza,U.Svedin,M.Falkenmark, L.Karlberg,R.W.Corell,V.J.Fabry,J.Hansen,B. Walker,D.Liverman,K.Richardson,P.J.Crutzenand J.A.Foley,“Asafeoperatingspaceforhumanity,” Nature,vol.461,no.7263,pp.472-475,2009.

[3] W.Steffen,K.Richardson,J.Rockström,S.Cornell, I.Fetzer,E.Bennet,R.Biggs,S.Carpenter,W.de Vries,C.deWit,C.Folke,D.Gerten,J.Heinke,G. Mace,L.Persson,V.Ramanathan,B.Reyersand SörlinSverker,“Planetaryboundaries:Guidinghuman developmentonachangingplanet,”Science,vol. 347,no.6223,2015.

[4] K.Richardsonandetal.,“Earthbeyondsixofnine planetaryboundaries,”ScienceAdvances,vol.9,no. 37,2023.

[5] IPCC,“ClimateChange2023:SynthesisReport. ContributionofWorkingGroupsI,IIandIIItotheSixth AssessmentReport,”Genf,2023.

[6] M.B.Osman,J.E.Tierney,J.Zhu,R.Tardif,G.J. Hakim,J.KingandC.J.Poulsen,“Globallyresolved surfacetemperaturessincetheLastGlacialMaximum,”Nature,no.599,pp.239-244,2021.

[7] IPCC,“GlobalWarmingof1.5°C.AnIPCCSpecial Reportontheimpactsofglobalwarmingof1.5°C abovepreindustriallevelsandrelatedglobalgreenhousegasemissionpathways,”CambridgeUniversity Press,Cambridge,2018.

[8] IPCC,“ClimateChange2021:ThePhysicalScience Basis.ContributionofWorkingGroupItotheSixth AssessmentReportoftheIntergovernmentalPanel onClimateChange,”CambridgeUniversityPress, Cambridge,2021.

[9] L.VanOers,A.deKoning,J.GuinéeandG.Huppes,“AbioticresourcedepletioninLCA,”Roadand HydraulicEngineeringInstituteoftheDutchMinistry ofTransport,PublicWorksandWaterManagement, 2002.

[10] L.VanOersandJ.Guinée,“TheAbioticDepletion Potential:Background,Updates,andFuture,”Resources,vol.5,no.1,p.16,2016.

[11] L.VanOers,J.GuinéeandR.Heijungs,“Abiotic resourcedepletionpotentials(ADPs)forelements revisited—updatingultimatereserveestimatesand introducingtimeseriesforproductiondata,”The InternationalJournalofLifeCycleAssessment,no. 25,pp.294-308,2020.

[12] JointResearchCentre(JRC)oftheEuropean Commission,“EnvironmentalFootprintreference package3.1,”Brüssel,2022.

[13] P.IchaandT.Lauf,“Entwicklungderspezifischen Treibhausgas-EmissionendesdeutschenStrommixin denJahren1990–2022,”Umweltbundesamt,2023.

[14] Prognos,Öko-Institut,Wuppertal-Institut,“KlimaneutralesDeutschland.StudieimAuftragvonAgora Energiewende,AgoraVerkehrswendeundStiftung Klimaneutralität,”2020.

[15] LightingEurope,“EvaluatingperformanceofLED basedluminaires,”Brussels,2018.

[16] J.-C.Reinhold,“Adatabasecomparisonbetween GaBiandEcoinventv3.8–Comparinginventory modelsandresultsbasedonthelifecycleassessmentofthemodularsmartphoneFairphone4,” Master’sThesis,TUBerlin,2023.

[17] E.Pauer,B.WohnerandM.Tacker,“TheInfluence ofDatabaseSelectiononEnvironmentalImpact Results.LifeCycleAssessmentofPackagingUsing GaBi,Ecoinvent3.6,andtheEnvironmentalFootprint Database,”Sustainability,vol.12,no.23,p.9948, 2020.

[18] EN45555:2019–Generalmethodsforassessing therecyclabilityandrecoverabilityofenergy-related products.

[19] R.Pomberger,“ÜbertheoretischeundrealeRecyclingfähigkeit,”ÖsterreichischeWasser-undAbfallwirtschaft,no.73,pp.24-35,2021.

[20] “DINENISO14021:2021-10Umweltkennzeichnungenund-deklarationen–Umweltbezogene

Anbietererklärungen(UmweltkennzeichnungTypII),” Beuth,Berlin,2021.

[21] K.Schischke,A.Berwald,G.Dimitrova,J.Rückschloss, N.F.NissenandM.Schneider-Ramelow,“Durability, reparabilityandrecyclability:ApplyingmaterialefficiencystandardsEN4555xtomobilephonesand tabletcomputers,”ProcediaCIRP,no.105,pp.619624,2022.

[22] Directive2012/19/EUoftheEuropeanParliament andoftheCouncilof4July2012onwasteelectrical andelectronicequipment(WEEE).

[23] IEC,“TR62635:2012Guidelinesforend-of-life informationprovidedbymanufacturersandrecyclers andforrecyclabilityratecalculationofelectricaland electronicequipment,”VDE-Verlag,Berlin,2012.

[24] P.Chancerel,M.Marwede,F.MathieuxandL. TalensPeiro,“Feasibilitystudyforsetting-upreference valuestosupportthecalculationofrecyclability/ recoverabilityratesofelectr(on)icproducts.EUR 27922,”PublicationsOfficeoftheEuropeanUnion, Luxembourg,2016.

[25] AGEBAGEnergiebilanzene.V.,“AnwendungsbilanzenzurEnergiebilanzDeutschland,”2023.

[26] UBAUmweltbundesamt,“EnergiebedingteEmissionenvonKlimagasenundLuftschadstoffen,”1901 2024.[Online].Available: https://www.umweltbundes amt.de/daten/energie/energiebedingte-emissionen# entwicklung-der-energiebedingten-treibhausgas-emi ssionen

AboutTrilux: TRILUXisoneofthe majorinternationalsuppliersofprofessional lightformanyapplications-fromoffice toindustry,fromretailtooutdoor.Ever sincethecompanywasfoundedin1912, TRILUXluminaireshavebeensettingnew standards,forexamplewithtopvaluesin energyefficiency,lightqualityanduserfriendliness.Themedium-sizedfamily businesshasatotalof30subsidiariesand exportsitslightingsolutionsto50countries worldwide.Thecompany’scorevalues includequality,innovation,and sustainability.

www.trilux.com

AboutFraunhoferIZM: Since1993

FraunhoferIZMhasbeenoneoftheworld’s leadinginstitutesforappliedresearchand thedevelopmentandsystemintegration ofrobustandreliableelectronics.Forover 30years,morethan450employeeshave beenfindingtechnologicalsolutionsincooperationwithpartnersfromindustryand academia.Emergingchallengesareaddressedinbranchessuchasautomotive andindustrialelectronics,medicalengineering,ICTandsemiconductor technology.

www.izm.fraunhofer.de

ECO-DESIGN ENVIRONMENTALIMPACTSOFLEDLUMINAIRES 39 Issue103/May-June/2024 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design

Lightnotonlyilluminatesaroom,but alsobooststhemoodofthoseinit. Itisthereforecrucialthatinternal spacesareoptimallylit.Thisapplies notonlytodomesticlivingroomsbut alsototraincompartments.That’swhy SeisenbacherGmbH,amanufacturer ofrailvehicleinteriors,isparticipatinginauniqueproject:theEU-funded H2020researchprojectPHABULOµS, aprojectaimingtorevolutionizethe developmentoffree-formmicro-optics inEurope,providingnewopportunities forlightingtechniques.

WhatareFree-form Micro-Optics?

Free-formmicro-optics(FMOs)areextremelysmallandcomplexopticalelementsthatenableprecisecontroloverlight distributionandintensity.Theseopticsare designedwithnon-symmetricsurfaces,allowingforgreaterflexibilityinshapingthe lightoutput.Inthecontextoflightingfor mobilityinteriors,free-formmicro-optics playacrucialroleincreatinginnovative lightingdesigns,enhancingpassenger comfort,andimprovingsafety.

CloseupfromaGSLLMasterbyJoanneum Research.

AdvantagesofFree-form Micro-optics

FMOsofferseveraladvantagesovertraditionalopticstechnologies.Firstly,FMOs offerenhanceddesignflexibilityastheyenableprecisecontroloverlightdistribution, allowingforthecreationofuniquelighting designsandcustomizedlightingeffects tailoredtospecificrequirementsanddesign aesthetics.

Secondly,FMOsoptimizelightextraction andcontrol,resultinginhigherefficiency andreducedenergyconsumption.Thirdly, theirsmallformfactormakesthemideal forintegrationintocompactmobilityinterior designs,enablingseamlessandunobtrusivelightingsolutions.

TheManufacturingProcess forFree-formMicro-Optics

ThemanufacturingprocessforFMOs differsfromtraditionalopticsproduction methodsinseveralways.Whiletraditional opticstypicallyinvolvegrindingandpolishingflatorsymmetricsurfaces,FMOs requireadvancedfabricationtechniques suchaslithography,additivemanufacturing,orprecisionmolding.

ThemanufacturingprocessforFMOsinvolvesthreestages.Theprocessstarts withthedesignphasewhereopticalsimulationsandmodellingtoolsareemployed tooptimizetheshape,dimensions,and surfacecharacteristicstoachievespecific lightingobjectives.

Simulationandmodellingplayacrucialrole inthedesignandoptimizationofFMOs. Byleveragingadvancedsoftwaretools, engineerscansimulateandanalyzethebehavioroflightwithintheoptics,allowingfor theoptimizationofshape,surfacecharacteristics,andopticalproperties.

Specifically,bysimulatingdifferentdesign iterations,engineerscan

• evaluateandcomparetheperformance ofvariousFMOconfigurations,enabling informeddesigndecisions;

• analyzehowlightpropagatesandinteractswiththeoptics,enablingtheoptimizationoflightdistribution,minimizing losses,andachievingthedesiredlighting effects;

• identifydesignimprovementsthatenhanceefficiency,maximizelightextractionandminimizeunwantedlightscatteringorreflection;and

• predictandvalidatelightingcharacteristics,suchasintensity,colortemperature,andbeamangles.

https://phabulous.eu/

Finally,theprecisecontroloverlightdistributionprovidedbyFMOsimprovessafety byfacilitatingeasynavigationandemergencyexitidentification,andtheabilityto adjustbrightnessandcolortemperature enhancespassengercomfort.

Thesecondstageisfabrication:depending onthechosenmanufacturingtechnique, thefabricationprocessmayinvolveprecisionmachining,etching,or3Dprinting. Thefabricationmethodsusedaretypically capableofproducingintricateandnon-

ThePromisingFutureofFree-form Micro-OpticsinMobilityInteriors
MICRO-OPTICS THEPROMISINGFUTUREOFFREE-FORMMICRO-OPTICSINMOBILITYINTERIORS 40 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design Issue103/May-June/2024

symmetricsurfacegeometriesrequiredfor free-formmicro-optics.

Thethirdstageistesting:toensurethe qualityandperformanceofthefabricated optics,precisemetrologytoolsareused tomeasureandverifytheshape,surface roughness,andopticalpropertiesofthe micro-optics.

StampsusedforS+RUp-scalingbyJoanneum Research.

ChallengesinIntegrating Free-formMicro-Opticsinto ExistingTechnology

Suchsmarttransportationinteriorlighting, combinedwithmicro-optics,canbeutilizedinvariousmodesoftransportation suchasairplanes,trains,buses,andother vehicles.Thisisasignificantgainforthe entireindustry,which,thankstoadvanced LEDtechnology,isalsoenergy-efficient andenvironmentallyfriendly.However,integratingFMOsintoexistingtechnologystill posesseveralchallenges.

Firstly,becauseFMOsinvolveintricatedesignsandprecisefabricationrequirements, theirintegrationintoexistingtechnologyis frequentlycomplexandchallenging.Secondly,themassproductionofFMOswith consistentqualitycanbechallengingdue tothecomplexityoffabricationtechniques andtheneedforspecializedequipment. Finally,thefabricationandintegrationof FMOsusuallyinvolvehighercostscomparedtotraditionalopticstechnologies, especiallyintheinitialstagesofadoption.

ThePHABULOµSProject

Toovercomethesechallenges,collaborationbetweenindustrypartners,research organizations,andtechnologyproviders becomescrucial.Tothisend,in2020,the EUfundedthePHABULOµSproject,that wassetupwiththeaimofdevelopingrobustmanufacturingtechnologiesviaapilot linethatcandeliverhigh-qualityfree-form micro-opticsatscaleandatlowercosts andstreamlinetheintegrationofFMOsinto existingtechnology.

Asamanufacturerofrailvehicleinteriors, SEISENBACHERhasbeenabletobringits considerableexpertiseinlightingsolutions formobilityinteriorstothePHABULOµS project.Theproject’semphasisonestablishingapilotlinefortheentireproduction cycle,fromdesigntothefinishedapplication,hasallowedustocontributeour expertiseandshapethedevelopmentof lightingsolutionsformobilityinteriors.By leveragingtheadvancementsinfree-form micro-optics,ouraimistocreatenewlightingdesignsandenhancethelightingexperienceforpassengers.

Ourexperienceofparticipatinginthe PHABULOµSPilotLineprojecthasbeen highlyvaluableandenriching-particularly thecollaborationwithrenownedresearch organizationsandindustrialpartnerswhich hasprovideduniqueinsightsandopportunitiesforinnovation.

TheFutureofFree-form Micro-Optics

Thefutureoffree-formmicro-opticsholds significantpotentialforadvancementsand innovationsasFMOsaretheonlytechnologycapableofsatisfyingthegrowing demandforcompactandefficientlighting solutions.

Keypotentialadvancementsincludeincreasedminiaturizationenablingtheirintegrationintoincreasinglycompactandslim designsacrossvariousmobilityinteriors, aswellasadvancedfunctionality,suchas

sensorsforoccupancydetectionandadvancedgesturecontrol.Ongoingresearch anddevelopmenteffortswillalsofocuson optimizingtheopticalefficiencyofFMOs, resultinginimprovedlightextraction,reducedenergyconsumption,andlonger lifetimes.

Furthermore,FMOswillincreasinglybe integratedintosmartsystems,allowing forseamlessintegrationwithothertechnologies,suchasInternetofThings(IoT) connectivity,toenableintelligentandadaptivelightingexperiences.Similarly,greater designflexibilitywillenablelightingsolutionsthatarenotonlyfunctionalbutalso aestheticallypleasing,enhancingtheoverallinteriordesignofmobilityspaces.

Finally,theongoingcollaborativeefforts betweenindustryandresearchorganizations,asexemplifiedbyinitiativeslike thePHABULOµSproject,willcontinue todrivetheadvancementsinfree-form micro-opticsandpavethewayfortheir widespreadadoptionintheindustry. ■

ChristianFORSTNER

HeadofSales,Seisenbacher

ChristianFORSTNERisHeadofSalesat SeisenbacherGmbH,withextensiveexperienceintherollingstockindustry.Having obtainedadegreeinElectricalEngineering, heembarkedonasuccessfulcareerthat spansover20yearsinthisspecializedsector.Christian’sexpertiseliesintheareasof design,engineering,andprojectmanagementforrailvehicles.Hehasbeeninvolved inthedevelopmentandimplementationof innovativesolutions,ensuringthehighest qualityandsafetystandardsaremet,and heremainsanactiveparticipantinindustry conferencesandworkshops.

www.seisenbacher.com

MICRO-OPTICS THEPROMISINGFUTUREOFFREE-FORMMICRO-OPTICSINMOBILITYINTERIORS 41 Issue103/May-June/2024 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design
RolltoPlateReplicasbyMorphotonics.
Up-scaledPoly-ShimsbyJoanneumResearch.

TheFutureofScan-to-BIMin LightingDesign

Lightplanningistheartandscience ofstrategicallydesigninglightingsystemstoenhancethefunctionality,aesthetics,andambianceofindoorand outdoorspaces.Whetheritisaresidentialhome,acommercialbuilding, orapublicspace,effectivelightplanningplaysacrucialroleincreating environmentsthatarebothvisually pleasingandfunctional.Atitscore, lightplanninginvolvesunderstanding thepropertiesoflight,suchasintensity,color,direction,anddistribution, andapplyingthisknowledgeincombinationwithcomputer-basedsimulationandanalysistoolstoachieve specificobjectives,includingvisibility andsafety,taskperformance,ambienceandmood,andcost-andenergy efficiency.

Inthisarticle,wefocusonlightplanninginsidebuildingsandhowefficient anduser-friendly3DScan-to-BIMsolutionsbasedonsmartphonetechnology cansimplifyandevenrevolutionize thelightplanningprocess.Wediscuss thevalueof3Ddata,buildinginformationmodelling,standardization,AI, andsmartbuildingtechnologywithrespecttocurrentandfuturepotential forthisfield.Asapracticalexample dedicatedtothelightplanningindustry,weprovideanoverviewofMetaroombyAmrax®,asmartphone-based 3DScan-to-BIMsolution.

Is3DDataAllYouNeed?

Tosimulateandanalyzetheeffectoflight, animportantcriterionontopofthewellstandardizedpropertiesofthelightsources, istoobtainknowledgeoftherealworld, i.e.,thebuildingforwhichthelightsimulationneedstobeperformed.Forlight planning,itisessentialtounderstandboth thelightsourcesandtheilluminatedscene. Certainly,thereexistsimplifiedsolutions basedon2Dfloorplans,orevenmore simplifiedinformationabouttheinteriorof buildings,e.g.,basedontherooms’area only.Foroptimumresults,however,3D modelsofbuildingsareanessentialprerequisite.Beyondgeometry,particularly windowsandmaterials(colors)areimportantpropertiesstronglyinfluencingthelight simulation’soutput(Figure 1).

Forexample,thespatial(3D)positionand geometryofawall,incombinationwith thereflectancepropertiesofthewall’ssurfacematerial,influencehowtheemitting lightisreflectedinsidetheroom.Theexactverticalpositionofawindow(which ispotentiallymissingeveninanaccurate 2D-floorplan)stronglyinfluenceshowthe daylightenterstheroom.Anyobstacles ontopofthebasicroomgeometry,which blockandreflectthelight,areoftennot modeledinsimplified(e.g.,2D)models. Basedontheseexamplesandsincethe worldisthree-dimensional,itisobvious thatlightplanningneedstobeperformed inthreedimensionstoachieveoptimum accuracy.

partofalargerprojectperformedinparallel orsequencewithothertrades.Onlyinteroperabilityfacilitatesthehighestefficiency andcircumventstheredundantgeneration, processing,andstorageofasynchronous data.

BuildingInformation Modeling&IFC

1 MetaroombyAmrax UrsteinSüd19/1/5,5412PuchbeiHallein, Austria. martin.huber@amrax.ai

Fromatechnicalperspective,a3Dmodel thatincludesalltheserelevantproperties needstobeprovidedinanywaythatthe lightplanningtoolcanreadandinterpret thedata(Figure 2).Theoretically,thisdata isallyouneedandtherearenorequirementsforaspecificinterface.However, well-definedstandardsareessentialtoenableseamlessinteractionbetweendifferent toolsandstakeholders.Thisisparticularly thecasesincelightplanningisoftenone

BuildingInformationModeling(BIM)involvescreatingandmanagingdigitalrepresentationsofbuildings’physicaland functionalcharacteristics.ABIMmodel isadigitalrepresentationofabuildingthat includesgeometricshapesandinformationabouttheproject’scomponents,such asmaterials,spatialrelationships,quantities,andpropertiesofbuildingassets.The modelsprovidetheall-encompassingbasis ofinformationonwhichindividualstakeholdersextracttheinformationrelevantto them.Thisinformationisstoredinastructuredway,allowingeachstakeholderto accessanduseitthroughoutthelifecycle ofaproject,frominitialplanninganddesign throughconstruction,operation,andmaintenance.Inthebeginning,duetomissing standards,BIMsoftwaredevelopersmainly createdproprietarydatastructuresintheir software.Therefore,dataandfilescreatedbyonevendor’sapplicationsmaynot workinothervendorsolutions,which,in turn,stronglylimitstheusabilityofsoftwaresolutions.Openstandardsforsharing BIMdataamongdifferentsoftwareapplicationshavebeendevelopedtoachieve interoperabilitybetweenapplications.BIM’s evolutiontracesbacktothe1970s,butit wasnotuntiltheearly2000sthatitgained worldwiderecognition.Progressinopen BIMstandardshasvariedacrossnations. In2013,theIndustryFoundationClasses (IFCs) [4],craftedbybuildingSMART [5], attainedinternationalstandardstatusas ISO16739forthefirsttime.Thespecified fileformatisalsoknownasIFC4.Furthermore,theevolutionofIFCtoversion4.3 (2021)representsanothersignificantmile-

LIGHTINGDESIGN THEFUTUREOFSCAN-TO-BIMINLIGHTINGDESIGN 42 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design Issue103/May-June/2024

stoneintheongoingdevelopmentofBIM technologyandstandards.RecentdevelopmentsindicatethatIFC4.3isbecoming increasinglywidespreadandimportantin thearchitecture,engineering,andconstruction(AEC)industry.Forthenearfuture,ourexpectationisahigheradoption rateofBIMandIFCinthelightingdesign industry.

BuildingSMART

Withthevisionofenablingseamlessinteroperability,BuildingSMART [5] isan internationalorganizationthataimstoimprovetheexchangeofinformationbetween softwareapplicationsusedintheAECindustry.BeyondIFC,whichisthestandard forBIMdatamodels,BuildingSMARThas developedseveralotherstandards.For example,BuildingSMARThasdeveloped BIMCollaborationFormat(BCF),another standardforexchangingcommentsand issueingtrackinginformationbetweendifferentsoftwareapplicationsutilizedinBIM workflows.

CreatingBIMisLaborious andExpensive

Nowadays,standardizedBIMmodelsare typicallyavailablefornewbuildings.However,lightplanningoftenneedstobeperformedinexistingconstructionsdueto highenergyprices,outdatedequipment, technologicalprogress,andnewregulatory requirements.Formostofthesebuildings, up-to-dateopenBIMmodelsareunavailable.ThisispartlybecauseBIMmodels werenotcreated.However,itcanalsobe thecasethataBIMmodelisavailable,but duetoveryrecentestablishmentsinstandardizations,interoperabilityisoftennot given.

“85%ofEUbuildingswere builtbefore2000.” [1]

Forthatreason,thecreationofBIMmodelsfromexistingbuildingsiscurrentlyof highrelevanceinmanyfieldsrelatedto AEC.Thisprocess,however,istypically laboriousandexpensive.Oneapproach todigitizingbuildingsisbasedonmanual measurementfollowedbythemanualcreationofBIMmodelsbasedondedicated CAD/software [1].Despitepowerfuland elaboratesoftwaretools,thisapproachis highlytime-consuminganderrorprone. Particularlyinthecaseofspecialgeometriesandinaccuratelybuiltconstructions

(e.g.,non-planarwallsandinaccurateangles),manualmeasurementcanbehighly challenging,evenforexperts.Anotherapproachreliesondedicatedhardwareincludinghigh-endsensortechnology,such aslasersensors [2].Thishardwareallows thecaptureofrooms,floors,andbuildings byaccuratelyscanningtheinteriorwith depthsensorsincombinationwithcameras.Typicallydedicatedstationaryhardwareisplacedatseveraldistinctpositions insideabuildingtoaccuratelycapturelocal pointcloudsateachposition.Finally,these acquiredlocalpointcloudsaremergedto generateasingleglobalpointcloudrepresentingawholebuildingorapartofa building.Therearealsoportablehardware solutions,whichfacilitateacquisitionwhile

walkingthroughabuilding.Thestrength ofthishigh-endhardwaretechnologyisits extraordinarilyhighvisualqualityandhighly resolvedpointcloudthatcanbeautomaticallyreconstructedbasedonthescan. However,expertsanddedicateddevices mustbepresenton-siteforscanning.Anotherdisadvantageisthefactthatoften, alargepointcloudisnotneededandis evenunwelcomeinworkflows.Formodelingbuildings,aslim&efficientparametric representationbasedonsimplebasicelements(e.g.,planarwalls,planarfloors, planarceilings)isnotjustsmallerandeasiertohandle,butalsomoreappropriatefor computationsandforinteractingwiththe model.Forthatreason,pointcloudsare oftenmanuallyconvertedintoasimplified

Figure1: Lightplanningisbasedon3Dbuildingmodelsandlightsimulation.
LIGHTINGDESIGN THEFUTUREOFSCAN-TO-BIMINLIGHTINGDESIGN 43 Issue103/May-June/2024 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design
Figure2: 3DModelofabuildingcreatedwithasmartphonesolution.

parametricBIMmodel.Despiteautomated pointcloudacquisition,thedataacquisitionandpreparationprocessisstilllaborintensiveandtherebyexpensive.Scanning, aswellasdatapost-processing,requires experts.Thescanningprocessevenrequiresexpertsonsite.Thecostsforscanningandreconstructionrangefromabout EUR1.00(forexceptionallylargesites)to EUR5.00persquaremeter.

EasyScan-2-BIM: SmartphonesasaSolution

Smartphonesnowadayscontainpowerfulcamerasandhardwareforefficiently processingcomputervisionandAIalgorithms.Moderndevicesarealsopartly equippedwithlightdetectionandranging (LiDAR)sensortechnology.Thisallowsthe captureofdepthinformationontopofan RGBcamerasignal,inturnenablingthe acquisitionof3D(pointcloud)datawith smallandportableconsumerdevices.The built-insensorsshowhigherdeviations andaclearlylowerspatialresolutionthan dedicatedexperthardware.Thiscanbe alimitationifthefinestructureshouldbe accuratelyreconstructed.Thegeometry ofbuildings,however,istypicallystrongly constrainedwithplanarwalls,floors,and ceilingscombinedwith(rectangular)cornersandedges.Thisfact,alongwithmodernAIandcomputervisionalgorithms, enablessmartphonestoreconstructtheinteriorofbuildingsaccuratelydespitebeing lessaccurateandhavingordersofmagnitudecheapersensortechnology.

Thistechnologyeliminatesallbarriers, clearlyreducesscanningcosts,andenablesScan-2-BIMforanybody.Assoonas interoperability(e.g.,basedonIFC)isensured,anybodycanperformascan,data canbeprocessedonthephoneorina cloud,andfinally,aBIMmodelcanbeexportedandimportedtobeusedindiverse workflows.

MetaroombyAmrax®: Scan-2-BIM++

MetaroombyAmrax® representsapioneeringScan-2-BIMsolutionbasedon smartphoneLiDARtechnology.Withthe Metaroomapp(Figure 3),auserscansa roomwhilewalkingwithamobilephoneor tabletintheirhandsthrougharoom.The capturedsignalisenhancedbasedonrealtimecomputervisionandAItechnology, andseveraldeepneuralnetworkalgorithmsareusedtocapturethegeometry, doors,windows,3Dobjects,andmaterialproperties.Insteadof(highlyresolved)

pointclouds,thistechnologyallowsthedirectcreationofslimparametricBIMmodels consistingofafewbasicelementswithoutanyneedformanualpost-processing (Figure 2).Sincethedeeplearningmodelsdirectlyrunonthesmartphone,instant feedbackisprovidedtotheuserinthe formofa3Dpreview.

Metaroomallowsadditionalfunctionality ontopofpurescanningandAI-based3D reconstruction.Afterfinishingthescan,the usercanviewandmodifythegenerated sceneonadesktoporlaptopPCusing MetaroomStudio.Theusercanextract andmodifyroommeasurestoensurethat the3Dmodelperfectlycorrespondstothe realroom.Additionalobjectsofinterest canbemanuallyorsemi-automaticallyannotatedinselected2Dframeswiththe

helpofcutting-edgeAIalgorithms [6] (Figure 4).Finally,alldatacanbevisualizedin3Dand2D,andvariousdataformats(suchasIFC)canbeexported.This allowseasyintegrationinlightplanning workflowswithdiverseplanningsoftware likeReluxandDIALux.

“Thispartnershiphasthepotentialto revolutionizethewayexternalfield staffinteractwiththeircustomers. ThepartnershipbetweenAmraxand Reluxisanimportantstepinthedevelopmentofdesignandconstruction technologies.”

–MarkusHEGI,CEOofReluxInformatik AG

Figure3: A3Dmodelisgeneratedbasedonasmartphone’sscan.
LIGHTINGDESIGN THEFUTUREOFSCAN-TO-BIMINLIGHTINGDESIGN 44 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design Issue103/May-June/2024
Figure4: Semi-automatedsegmentationofanyobjectsbasedoncutting-edgeAI.

“InSwitzerland,therenovationand modernizationofluminairesisavery importanttopic.Metaroomsupports oursalesforcebycreatingthebasis forplanningintheshortestpossible time.Forluminairemanufacturers, lightplanningisanimportantelement forclientacquisition.Metaroomhelps ustoreducecosts,gainspeed,and tobeabletoplanourprojectsmore precisely.”

–IvoHuber,CEOofTuluxAG(Interview Light&Building)

“Weprovidestate-of-the-artAItools allowingthecustomerstodetectand model3Dlightsourcesbasedona singlemouseclickonanobjectina2D frame.”

–LucaDEBIASI,ChiefProductOfficer, MetaroombyAmrax®

OptimumTrade-offbetween AccuracyandCostswith Smartphones

Sinceanypersoncanperformthescan withoutanyexpertise(Figure 5),thecosts fordigitizationareapproximately90% lowerwithsmartphoneScan-2-BIMsolutionscomparedtocompetingsolutions withdedicatedhardware.Ontopofthat, theflexibilityisclearlyhighersincescans canbeperformedatanytimewithout longleadtimes.Slightinaccuraciesofthis pipelineinthefinal3Dmodelcreated,do notconsiderablyinfluencetheaccuracy ofthelightplanningprocess.Instead,we obtainanoptimumtrade-offbetweenaccuracy,costs,andflexibilitytoimprovethe lightplanningworkflowwiththissolution.

TheFutureofLightPlanning withAI&VR

Today,smartphonetechnologyhasalready disruptedthemarketfor3Dscanningof buildingsduetothelowcostscombined withthehighsimplicityandflexibility.Due tocontinuousdevelopmentandcontinuouslyenhancedsmartphonetechnology, thisnovelapproachcanevenrevolutionize thefutureoflightplanning.AI,incombinationwithmodernimagingsensors,hasthe potentialtosemanticallycaptureallbuilding detailsthatarerelevantforlightplanning inafullyautomatedway.Forexample, thereflectancepropertiesofanymaterial couldbeestimatedandassignedtothe 3Dmodeltoobtainevenmoreaccurate modelsforevenmoreaccuratesimulations andplanning.ImprovedLiDARtechnology orenhancedAItrainingcanincrementally enhancethegeometricaccuracytocome

closetosolutionsbasedondedicated hardwarewhilekeepingthecostadvantage.

“Deeplearningtechnologyisenormouslypowerfulbuttypicallyinflexible sinceitrequireslarge,labeleddata setsfortrainingmodelscontaininga fixedsetofcategories.Wearecurrentlyestablishingamethodbasedon adeeplargevisionmodeldeveloped byMetaAIin2023.Thiswillallowusto semanticallycaptureanydetailsofany objectcategorybasedononesingle exampleimageoftheobjectsoon.”

–ChristophHOFER,ChiefSolutionsArchitect,MetaroombyAmrax®

Incombinationwithstate-of-the-artvirtualrealityheadsets,thehighlyrealistic 3Dmodel(Figure 6)canevenbeused toprovidethecustomerwitharealistic andcost-efficientpreviewoflight-planned andfurnishedroomsorevenofentirely equippedbuildings.Scan-to-BIMsolutions enablethecaptureandmodelofexisting furniture.Ontopofthat,basedoninteractiveorautomatedAItools,buildingmodels canbe(re)furnished(semi)automatically. Theoretically,lightplanningcouldalsobe apartofa(semi)automatedinteriorplanningpipelinewithrealisticlightsimulation incombinationwithAImodelsgenerating recommendations.

Scanningwithasmartphoneiseasyandcanbeperformedwithoutanyexpertise.

3DRenderingofanindustrialbuildingbasedonascanperformedwithMetaroom.Visualizationis alsopossiblewithVRtechnology.

Figure5:
LIGHTINGDESIGN THEFUTUREOFSCAN-TO-BIMINLIGHTINGDESIGN 45 Issue103/May-June/2024 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design
Figure6:

LightPlanning&Smart Buildings

Smartlightingsystemsofferenhanced energyefficiencythroughfeatureslikeoccupancysensing,daylightharvesting,and adaptivelightingcontrol,reducingelectricityconsumptionandoperationalcosts. Theyfurtherprovideflexibilityandcustomizationoptions,allowinguserstoadjustlightinglevels,colors,andschedules accordingtopreferences,occupancypatterns,andenvironmentalconditionsfor improvedcomfortandproductivity.

Lightplanningcanbemuchmorethana staticsimulationinsuchsmartsettings. Planningcanincorporatethefullpotential ofsmartbuildingfeaturesduringtheoptimizationoftheinfrastructure.However, BIMmodelsandconventionallightplanningdonotincorporatethetimedimension anddynamicalchanges.Toreachthenext level,modelingbasedondigitaltwinswill beneeded.

DigitalTwinsastheNext Level

Basedondigitalscansofbuildingsincombinationwithsmarthometechnology,in thefuture,3DBIMmodelscanbetranslatedinto“alive”digitaltwins.Adigitaltwin representsadynamicmodelofarealentitywithabidirectionalconnectiontothe real-worldcounterpartallowingreal-time synchronizationbetweenthetwins.The digitaltwincanusesmart-homecontrol andIoTsensors,suchaslightsensorsto capturethestateoftherealentityandperformsynchronization.

Basedonsimulationsandcomputations usingthedigitaltwin,foreachsituation (i.e.,eachpointintime)anoptimumsettingcanbecalculatedandassignedto therealentity(building).Thisenablesus tocombinelightplanningwithreal-time smartcontrolofbuildingstooptimizethe lightsituationdependingondynamicparameters.Incorporatingthefourth(time) dimension,lightplanningcanreachthe nextlevel,settingnovelstandardsforcomfortandenergyefficiency. ■

ViewtheNewMetaroom® Video

https://bit.ly/metaroom-video

AboutAmrax®

Amrax® isaleadingtechnologyplatform specializinginthedigitizationanddesign ofspacesusing3Dtechnology.Founded in2020,thecompanyoffersfast,inspiring, anduser-friendlysolutionsforspaceplanning,interiordesign,lightingdesign,radio planning,andfacilitymanagementthrough itsinnovativeMetaroom® app.Amrax’s teamof25expertsincomputervision,AI, softwaredevelopment,andmarketinguse interdisciplinarycollaborationandvirtual realitytocreategroundbreakinginnovations.HeadquarteredinSalzburg,Austria, Amrax® alsooperatesinViennaandthe USA.

MissionStatement

Inaneraofnumerouschallenges,wehave foundcomputersandtechnologytobe empoweringtools,magnifyingourhumanabilitiesandsharingthemwiththe world.AtAmrax®,werecognizethepotentialofthesetoolsandstrivetopushtheir boundarieswithourinnovativeproduct, Metaroom®.Metaroomgoesbeyondthe conventionallimitations,expandingour abilitiesandopeningnewdoorsofpossibilities.Weoffertheabilitynotjusttovisualize buttoreimaginethesespaceswithindividual3Dvisualsupport.Itisatoolthat cultivatescreativity,allowingeveryoneto shapetheirenvironmentaccordingtotheir preferencesandneeds.Moreover,our technologyupholdsourcollectiveresponsibilitytowardstheplanetbypromoting energy-savingsolutionsanddrivingefforts towardsdecarbonizationinbuildingdesign. WhatsetsAmrax® apartisourteamof someofthemostdedicatedandbrilliantAI minds,globally.Theyarethedrivingforce behindthedevelopmentofthistransformativesuperpower,makingitaccessibleto everyone.Joinusinembracingthefuture ofspaceswithMetaroom.

–MartinHUBER,Co-FounderandCEOof Amrax®

Enjoya 30-DayFreeTrial on https://studio.amrax.ai/#pricing Thenusepromocode LED20 atcheckout toreceivea20%discountonyourannual subscriptionforthefirst12months.This offerexpireson31July2024.

MartinHUBER,CEOofMetaroomby Amrax®

MartinHuberisaseasonedleaderinthe techanddeeptechsectorswithasolid productdevelopmentandAItrackrecord. AsCEOandCo-founderofAmrax,he’sat theforefrontof3Dmodelinginnovation. BeforehisroleatAmrax,Martinwasthe CEOandCo-founderoftheDentalManufacturingUnitGmbH(DMU),andfrom September2007toApril2014,heserved asCTOandCo-founderofCADstar.He playedavitalroleintechnologydevelopmentandmanagementinthisHighTechhealthcarecompany.Hisexpertiseis backedbyadegreeinMechanicalEngineeringandstudiesinComputerSoftware Engineering.Hiscomprehensiveexperienceandeducationalqualificationsmake himavisionaryleaderandanauthorityin theintersectionoftechnologyandbusiness.

References

[1] Ali,S.B.M.,Mehdipoor,A.,SamsinaJohari,N., Hasanuzzaman,M.,&Rahim,N.A.(2022).Modeling andperformanceanalysisforhigh-risebuildingusing ArchiCAD:initiativestowardsenergy-efficientbuilding. Sustainability,14(15),9780.

[2] Brenner,C.(2003).Buildingreconstructionfrom laserscanningandimages.InProceedingsofthe ITCWorkshoponDataQualityinEarthObservation Techniques.

[3] EuropeanCommission(2024).EnergyPerformance ofBuildingsDirective. https://energy.ec.europa.eu/to pics/energy-efficiency/energy-efficient-buildings/ene rgy-performance-buildings-directive_en

[4] Justo,A.,Soilán,M.,Sánchez-Rodríguez,A.,& Riveiro,B.(2021).Scan-to-BIMfortheinfrastructure domain:GenerationofIFC-compliantmodelsof roadinfrastructureassetsandsemanticsusing3D pointclouddata.AutomationinConstruction,127, 103703.

[5] BuildingSmart. https://www.buildingsmart.org/

[6] Kirillov,A.,Mintun,E.,Ravi,N.,Mao,H.,Rolland,C., Gustafson,L.,...&Girshick,R.(2023).Segmentanything.InProceedingsoftheIEEE/CVFInternational ConferenceonComputerVision(pp.4015-4026).

Formoreinformation,visit https://amrax.ai

LIGHTINGDESIGN THEFUTUREOFSCAN-TO-BIMINLIGHTINGDESIGN 46 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design Issue103/May-June/2024
Join the Lighting Design Community Subscribe to the monthly Trends in Lighting Newsletter Stay up-to-date www.trends.lighting

Dr.J.NormanBARDSELY,ChiefAnalystatInternational Solid-StateLightingAlliance

Dr.J.NormanBARDSLEY,Founder andSSLAnalyst,BardsleyConsulting Dr.J.NormanBardsley,adistinguished ProfessorofPhysics,hasearnedinternationalacclaimasanexpertinsolidstatelighting(SSL)throughhisadvisory roleswiththeDepartmentofEnergy(DoE) andtheInternationalSSLAlliance(ISA). Renownedforhisextensiveandnuanced understandingofOLEDtechnology,Dr. Bardsleypossessesacomprehensive graspofitsmanufacturingprocesses,cost structures,andongoingresearchendeavors.

jnbard@pacbell.net

Thisthirdarticleonthestatusofthe globalSSLindustrydiscussestherole ofChinainmarketdevelopmentand manufacturingandtheopportunity formarketgrowthinotherdeveloping countriesinAsia.

GovernmentSupportin China

TheestablishmentoftheLEDmanufacturingbaseinChinawasdrivenbystrong supportfromthenationalandlocalgovernments.SubsidiesfromBeijingenabled thestrongestcompaniestobuildlarge factories,whileregionalandcitygovernmentshelpedtoformtheinfrastructure necessarytoturnthenewtechnologyinto products.Demandwasledbytheneedfor slimbacklightsinflatpaneldisplays(FPD). Transformationofthedisplayindustrywas alsoaidedbysubstantialgovernmentsupport,firstinKoreaandtheninChina.

In2007,China’sMinistryofFinance(MOF) cooperatedwiththeNationalDevelopmentandReformCommission(NDRC)to recommend“InterimMeasuresonAdministrationofFinancialSubsidiesforPromoting High-EfficiencyLightingProducts”.Alarge fractionofthesubsidiesofabout2.5B yuan(US$400M)fromthecentralgovernmentinBeijingbetween2008and2012 wasfocusedonMOCVDfacilitiesforLED chips.Thisfundinghadaglobalimpact, forexampleinhelpingAixtronandVeeco developanewgenerationofequipmentfor epitaxy.ThesubsidiesalsohelpedChinese companiestoshowprofitsevenwhilemakinghugeinvestmentsintheearlystages ofmarketgrowth.Thismadeitpossible forthemtoraisefundsontheequitymarket.Forexample,thestockpriceofSanan Optoelectronicsrosefromavalueof0.18

yuaninSeptember2006to43.56yuanin July2021.Thestockpricehasdropped substantiallysincethen,to12.53yuanat theendofApril2024,butthemarketcapitalizationof62.5Byuan(US$8.6B)remains abovethatofAcuityBrands(US7.6B)and ismorethandoublethatofSignify(3.35B euros).

ThestockpriceofSananOptosoaredbetween 2008and2021.

Thestockmarketimpacthasnotbeen completelypositive.Over-enthusiasmfor capitalinvestmentledtofearsofovercapacityandstockpricedeclines,asseen inthechartforSanan.Manysmallmanufacturersdidnotsurvivethroughdifficult periodsandthetotalnumberofSSLsuppliershasfallenfromover4000toabout 2500.

Themajorityofgovernmentfundingfor thelightingindustryhascomefromlocal sources.Regionalmanufacturinghubs werecreatedinseveralprovinces,such asGuangdong,FujianandZhejiang.In 2012Guangdongprovinceissuedan“LED LightingProductImplementationPlan”. Throughacombinationofsubsidies,purchasingcommitmentsbypublicauthorities, technologicalinnovationandstandardsdevelopment,thegoalswereto

• PopularizeLEDlightinginthewhole society.

• Achieveenergysavingsofmorethan50

• DrivetheLEDindustrytoannualsalesof over500Byuan.

ThisinitiativeenabledGuangdongtocap-

Solid-StateLightingMarketReport: ASIA
MARKETREPORT SOLID-STATELIGHTINGMARKETREPORT–ASIA 50 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design Issue103/May-June/2024

turealmosthalfoftheindustry’srevenues inChinaandperhaps25%ofglobalrevenues.

Theselocalsubsidiesstillpersist.Digitimes Researchreportedthatgrantsinthefirst halfof2020amountedto1.05Byuan. OtherareasinChinastillstrivetocaptureashareofthemarket.InFebruary 2024,ChangzhiCityinShanxiProvince announceda5-yearplanentitled“ImplementationMeasuresofChangzhiCityto EncouragetheHigh-QualityDevelopment oftheLEDIndustry”.

Theirplanincludes:

• Factoryconstructionsubsidiesofupto 35%

• Equipmentpurchasingsubsidiesof1550%

• Promotionandapplicationofhighvalueaddedproducts

• Intelligenttransformationoftheindustrial chainwithgrantsupto3Myuan

• Supportfortalentdevelopmentwith salarygrantsofupto300,000yuanper person.

EncouragedbysuccessinthepenetrationoftheglobalSSLmarket,theattention ofthecentralgovernmenthasturnedto otherapplicationsofwide-bandgapsemiconductors(WBS),forexampleinpower electronicsformobiledevices.Industry andacademiahaveresponded,inR&D aswellasinmanufacturing.Since2016, theChinaInternationalForumonSSLhas beenheldjointlywiththeInternationalForumonWBS.

MostofthisactivityhasinvolvedGaNdevices.OnlyfiveChina-basedcompanies boastSiCcrystalgrowthexpertise.However,in2022SananOptoreceivedsubsidiesof1.03ByuanfromBeijing,including 700MyuanforajointventurewithSTMicroelectronicstomanufactureSiCchipson 200mmwaferswhichmaycomeintoproductionbeforetheendof2025.Thiswill complementtheexistingSiC‘megafab’in Changshabasedon150mmwafers.

SSLChinain2023

EachyeartheChinaSolidStateLighting Alliance(CSA)preparesanannualreport onthestatusoftheLEDlightingmarket. Thisdocument,whichisoftenreferred toasthe“BlueBook”,ispublishedright atthebeginningoftheyearandsogives onlypreliminarydataforthepreceding year.Thissummaryisbasedonthe2023 BlueBook,withsomedataupdatedfrom companyreports.

Theoveralldemandin2023wasweak, withhighinventoryandinsufficientcapacity utilization.Thetotaloutputvaluein2023 wasapproximately658Byuan,down2.6% from2022,ofwhichtheupstreamepitaxialchipscalewas29.5billionyuan,the midstreampackagingscalewas78.2billionyuan,andthedownstreamapplication scalewas550Byuan.Thefollowingchart showsthatsaleshavefallenbelowtheprepandemiclevelsof2018and2019.

Revenuesandgrowthrateofeachlinkinthe SSLindustryinChina2011-2023.

Thetotalrevenueof658Byuanclearly includessomedoubleortriplecounting andexceedsmostestimatesoftotalglobal revenuesforSSL.

Althoughtherevenuesoftheleadingchip makershaveincreasedslightly,profitability declinedsubstantially.SananOptosustainedanoperationallossof825Myuan, comparedtoprofitsof125Myuanin2022 and1750Min2021.Profitabilitywasrestoredin2024Q1,partlythroughareductioninexpenses,includinginR&D.Faced withthesechallenges,theleadingchip makershaveformedpartnershipswithdisplaypanelmanufacturers.HuacanOpto andQianzhaoOptoarenowcontrolled byBOEandHisenseVideorespectively, whileSananhasajointventurewithTCL. Oneexceptiontothegeneraldeclinein profitswasJucanOpto,butthecompany attributestheimprovementtoitsother businessareas.

Asimilarsituationwasseeninthepackagingsector,withincreasedsalesbutreducedprofits.JufeiOptowasamongthe exceptions,withimprovedprofitsaswell assales.Consolidationcontinues.The numberofcompaniesengagedinLED packagingnationwidehasfallenfrommore than1,400tojustover200.

Amongapplications,thedeclineinthe generallightingmarketisthemostobvious. Theoperatingincomeandprofitofthe sectorfellby6.1%and14.4%year-onyearrespectively.But,with2023salesof around247Byuan,generallightingremains thedominantapplication.

Oneemergingsectorthathasshownrapid growthismini-LEDsfordisplaybacklights.

GenerallightingisstillthemainstayofSSLChina.

Thepriceofmini-LEDchipsdroppedby morethan50%year-on-year,andtheprice ofdriverICsfellsignificantly,duetothe maturingoftechnologyandimprovement ofyieldrates.DomesticsalesofTVswith mini-LEDbacklightsinthefirsthalfof2023 were380,000units,ayear-on-yearincreaseof188%.Thetotalmini-LEDbacklightmodulemarketisexpectedtogrow from8.5Byuanin2023to26.8Byuanin 2026.

Mini-LEDbacklightmodulemarketsize(100M yuan).

Thepackagingofmini-LEDshelpedMulinsen(MLS)toachievehighersalesand profitsin2023.Itsoverseasoperations throughLEDVANCEwerestableandMLS mayhavejoinedthetop3globallighting companiesinrevenue,alongwithSignify andAcuityBrands.OppleLightingalso reportedgainsinbothrespectsandisexpandingitspresenceinotherAsiancountries.

Outdoorlightingisalsoshowingstrong growthinChina.AccordingtoGuanyan Tianxia,revenuesrosefrom98Byuanin 2018to164Byuanin2022,drivenmostly bypublicspendingonroadwayandlandscapelighting.Nightlightinghasbecome animportantpartof“culturaltourism”.The GuangzhouInternationalLightFestivalresumedin2023andattractedalmost100M visitors.Inthe3rdquarterof2023,over 1.5Byuanwasinvestedin25regionsto boostnightlightingshows [1] LakesidelightingshowsinXianyangandJiujiang.

Overall,thelightingindustryisregaining itsoptimism.Atleast25companieswere involvedinnewconstructionprojectsin

MARKETREPORT SOLID-STATELIGHTINGMARKETREPORT–ASIA 51 Issue103/May-June/2024 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design

2023,withatotalinvestmentofover17.5B yuan.Theseincludetheworld’slargest lightingmanufacturingbasewith192productionlinesbuiltinJiujiangbySignifyata costof2.8Byuan.

SSLinJapan

Japanhastraditionallybeenoneofthe majorglobalbasesforthelightingindustry, particularlyinAsia.Itisdifficulttoassess itsoverallroleinSSLproduction,since themajorproducersareeitherprivateor smallunitsoflargeconglomerates.Some dataisavailablethroughtheJapanLighting ManufacturersAssociation(JLMA).

In2022thevalueofimportsoflighting productstoJapanwas142Byen,farexceedingexportsat12.4Byen.JLMAestimatesthat217MlightingfixtureswereproducedinJapan,withavalueof1030Byen, leadingtototalnationalsalesof224Mfixtureswithavalueof1260Byen(US$8.2B). PenetrationofLEDsinthesefixturesisextremelyhigh,atcloseto98%.

Thesituationregardingreplacementbulbs seemstobeverydifferent.JLMAreports that41Mincandescentbulbsweresoldin 2022alongwith59Mfluorescenttubesand 18Motherdischargelamps.SalesofLED bulbsandtubeswereonly18Mand2.2M, respectively.

Lookingattheperformanceofindividualcompanies,LEDInsidereportsthat globallightingrevenuesatPanasonicwere US$935Minthe6monthsendingSeptember30th,2023,whilethosefromToshiba wereUS$408M.Bothremaininthetopten globallightingcompanies.KoitoManufacturingandStanleyElectricconsolidated theirpositionsamongthegloballeaders inautomotivelighting.Koito’srevenues inFY2024roseby10%to950Byenand profitswereupby20%to56Byen.Substantialsalesgainswereshowninevery globalregionexceptforChina.Stanley Electric’ssalesclimbedby8%to472B yen,whileprofitsroseby3%to36Byen.

Amongthesmallercompanieswithan overseaspresence,EndoLightinghad anexcellentyearingenerallightingand lightingcontrols,withsalesof52Byen forFY2024,upfrom46Byen,andprofits risingby68%to5.2Byen.

SSLinKorea

Koreawasthedominantsupplierofflat paneldisplaysfor17yearsuntil2021,usingbothinorganicandorganicLEDsas lightsources.However,itsdominanceof theOLEDdisplaymarketisbeingchallengedbyChina.Chinaaccountedfor 42.5%oftheglobaldisplaymarketin 2022,whileKoreahelda36.9%share, accordingtotheKoreaDisplayIndustryAssociation.Inresponse,Korea’sdisplayindustryhasunveiledanambitiousplantoinvestover65trillionwon(US$49B)by2027. Thestrategy,whichwasannouncedin May2023bytheKoreanMinistryofTrade, IndustryandEnergy(MOTIE),aimstoincreaseKorea’sglobalmarketshareto50% andwidenthetechnologygapwithcompetitorsbymorethanfiveyears.

TheKoreangovernmentaimstofacilitate theseinvestmentsbyprovidingsupport throughtaxincentives,publicfinancing ofupto900Bwon,andinfrastructure improvements.Strengtheningthesupplychainisanothercrucialaspectofthe strategy.Koreaaimstoincreaseitsselfsufficiencyratioinmaterials,parts,and equipmentfromthecurrent65percent to80percent.Thesupportwillextendto smallbusinessesoperatinginsectorssuch asfinemetalmasks,exposuremachines, andpackagingequipment.Recognizing theimportanceofskilledhumanresources, thepublicandprivatesectorswillcollaboratetotrain9,000talentedengineersover thenextdecade.Thegovernmentwillestablishspecializedgraduateschoolsand introducenewundergraduatemajorsto cultivatemaster’sanddoctorallevelmanpower.

JunghoonLee,CEOofSeoulSemiconductor(SSC),hasexpressedconcernthat morethan99%ofLEDsusedatdomestic lightfestivalsandregionaleventsareimported [2].Hespecificallyrecommends publicsupportformicro-LEDdisplaydevelopment.SSC’ssalesin2023were1033B won,downfrom1109Bwonin2022and 1301Bwonin2021.Operatinglossesrose from33Bwonin2022to48Bin2023. Toreducecosts,SSChasalreadymoved mostofitschipmanufacturingtoVietnam andistransferringmoreofitsdevelopment worktothatcountry.

AmongthesmallerKoreancompanies, SeoulViosysfocusesonUVandmicroLEDs,alongwithIR/VCSELsandseveral LEDproductsystems.Despitea15% growthinsalesin2023to505Bwon,operatinglossesmountedto73Bwonfrom 62Bwonin2022.Lumenswasableto

reportasmalloperatingprofitof3.1Bin 2023withsalesrisingby3%to171B.

SSLinIndia

IndiaisthelargestpotentialmarketforSSL inthenextdecade,withGDPgrowingapprox.8%peryearandapopulationthat nowexceedsthatofChina.Itslightingindustryhasbeenreorientedtomanufacture productsbaseduponimportedchipsand packages.

In2022theIndiangovernmentlauncheda ProductionLinkedIncentive(PLI)Scheme toincentivizelocalmanufacturersbyprovidingfinancialsupportandafriendlybusinessenvironment,witha7-yearbudgetof Rs62Brupees.Onegoaloftheschemeis tofortifyIndia’sroleinglobalsupplychains andpositionIndianmanufacturingindustry asacoreexportingnation.Forlighting,the PLIinitiativeaimstoboostlocalvalueadditionfrom25%to85%by2028,covering 87%oftheLEDsector’sBillofMaterial. AlthoughthescopeofthePLIincludesLED chipmakingandpackaging,thecompaniesseemtoagreethatthisisnotviableat thistime.

Furtherbolsteringdomesticelectronics manufacturingofcomponentsistheupcomingschemebytheMinistryofElectronicsandIndustry,withanallocationof200B rupees,alonglinessimilartothePLI.

CromptonGreavesestimatesthatcurrent salesoflightingproductsareabout150B rupees.PhilipsLightingIndiaisstilladominantsupplier,withonemanufacturingplant andover3200employees.StatistaestimatesthattherevenuesofPhilipsIndiain 2021wereabout24Brupees.Panasonic ElectricWorksmaintainsastrongpresence inIndiaandisplanningtoincreaseexports ofproductsthere.AMS-Osramalsostill hassomeinvolvement.

Amongdomesticcompanies,Syskadescribesitselfasoneofthetop3suppliers, with15-20%ofthemarket,butdoesnot providesalesfigurestoconfirmthis.DixonIndiaclaimstobethe4thlargestmanufacturerofLEDlampsintheworldandto produce50%oftheLEDlampsmadein India,making300Mbulbs,50Mtubesand 18Mdownlightsperyear.

ThefiscalyearinIndiaendsonMarch31st. Therevenuesandoperatingprofitsofthe lightingdivisionsofthemajorpubliccompaniesaresummarizedinthe Table 1

MARKETREPORT SOLID-STATELIGHTINGMARKETREPORT–ASIA 52 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design Issue103/May-June/2024

Table1: LightingSalesandProfitsforFY2024 (BillionRupees).

SSLinIndonesia

SSLhasbeenamixedblessingforthe 280MpeopleofIndonesia.Thecritical needtosaveenergyandreducethedependenceoncoalcausedthegovernment topromotetheadoptionofLEDs.By2019, LEDsaccountedforoverhalfofthestock of680Mlampsandlessthan10%were incandescentorhalogenbulbs.Thisdata comesfromacomprehensivemarketstudy byCLASPandPriceWaterhouseCooper [3]

Upuntil2014,asubstantialnumberof lampsweremanufacturedinIndonesiafor domesticsalesorexports.Butlocalproducershavebeenunabletomatchthe lowcostsofLEDlampsfromChina.So in2018lessthan30%ofthe160Mlamp shipmentswereproduceddomestically. Theproportionvariedbytechnology,from 39%forincandescent,27%forCFL,and 13%forLED.TotallightingexportsfromIndonesiafelldramaticallyfrom56Munitsin 2014to2Min2018.96%oftheimported lampscamefromChina.

DatafromtheAssociationofIndonesiaLightingManufacturers(Gamatrindo) showedthattheyweretryingtoadaptto LEDtechnology.Theirmembershada productioncapacityof58MLEDlampsbut wereabletosellonly6.3Munits.

TheIndonesiangovernmentistakingsteps torebuilditslightingmanufacturingcapabilities.HelpwasprovidedbytheUNin 2020throughthe4-yearprojectADLIGHT [4].Thisinvolvesimplementingregulations, procurementpolicies,newbusinessmodels,andawarenesscampaignstoboost marketpenetrationofenergy-efficient LEDs.EightlocalLEDmanufacturingcompaniesreceivedtechnicalandfinancial assistance.

ThecreationofjobsbasedonnewtechnologiesiscriticaltotheeconomicdevelopmentofallcountriesinAsia.More recentdataontheimpactoftheselighting initiativesinIndonesiaandIndiawillprovide valuableguidancetootherneighboring countries.

Summary

Thisarticleprovidesacomprehensive overviewofthesolid-statelighting(SSL) industryinAsia,focusingonthetransformativeroleofgovernmentinterventions, particularlyinChina.Substantialfinancial subsidiesfrombothlocalandnationalgovernmentshavebeenpivotalinestablishing arobustSSLmanufacturingbaseinChina, drivingsignificantgrowthandenabling Chinesecompaniestogainacompetitiveedgeglobally.Despitethebenefits, theindustryfaceschallengeslikemarket saturationandthesustainabilityofsmaller firmsamidstaggressiveexpansion.Other regionsinAsiaarealsoleveragingsimilar strategies,aimingtoharnessSSL’spotentialforenergysavingsandeconomic growth.TheSSLindustry’sfutureinAsia appearsoptimistic,withongoinginvestmentsandinnovationsexpectedtodrive furtheradvancements.Thisregionalfocus onSSLnotonlyunderscoresthecritical roleofgovernmentalsupportintechnologicaladvancementsbutalsohighlightsthe dynamicnatureofthegloballightingindustry. ■

References

[1] https://www.alighting.cn/news/20231023/175294. htm

[2] https://www.mk.co.kr/en/society/11002197

[3] https://www.clasp.ngo/wp-content/uploads/2021/ 01/Indonesia-Lighting-Market-Study-and-Policy-Ana lysis.pdf

[4] https://indonesia.un.org/en/266443-advancing-ind onesia%E2%80%99s-lighting-market-high-efficient-t echnologies-adlight-factsheet

AdditionalSSLreportsby Dr.Bardsleyalready publishedinthisyear’s LEDprofessionalReview

LpR#102,Mar/Apr2024,p44

Solid-StateLightingReport–TheImpactofLEDsonElectricity ConsumptionandGlobalWarming ThroughtheadoptionofLEDs,thelightingindustryhasmadeasubstantial contributiontothemitigationofglobal warming.Butstocktakingmadein2023 bytheUnitedNationsEnvironmental Program(UNEP)showedthatthetotalglobalefforttoreduceemissionsof greenhousegases(GHG)isfallingfar shortofwhatisneededtoachievethe targetssetintheParisAgreementof 2015.TheWorldMeteorologicalOrganization(WMO)hasjudgedthat2023 wasthehottestyearonrecordandthere seemstobenoslowingintherateof increaseintheglobalmeantemperature. Thepurposeofthisreportistoassess thecontributionoflightinginreaching thesegoalsandtourgetheindustryto maintainitsconcernaboutthisimportant issue.

LpR#101,Jan/Feb2024,p40

Solid-StateLightingReport ThissummaryofthelatestISAreport onSolid-StateLighting(SSL)encompassesacomprehensiveanalysisofthe SSLindustry’sprogression,itsimpact onglobalenergyuse,andfutureoutlooks.Thereportdetailsthesubstantial stridesmadebySSL,emphasizingits potentialinrevolutionizinglightingwhile beingenergy-efficient.Initially,thereport highlightstheimportanceofSSLinthe contextofglobalwarmingandenergy conservation.Itunderscoreslightasa crucialnecessityandtheroleofSSLin providinghigh-quality,affordableartificial lightingworldwide,whichhassignificant implicationsforglobalenergyconsumptionandenvironmentalsustainability. Thereportstressestheindustry’stechnicaladvancesanditsleadershiprolein sustainableresourceutilization.Insummary,thisSSLreportoffersanuanced viewoftheSSLindustry,celebratingits achievementswhilecriticallyanalyzing itschallengesandfutureprospects.It servesasacalltoactionforcontinued innovation,collaboration,andcommitmenttomakingSSLacornerstoneof sustainable,equitable,andhigh-quality lightingworldwide.

MARKETREPORT SOLID-STATELIGHTINGMARKETREPORT–ASIA 53 Issue103/May-June/2024 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design Company LightingSales Profits INRB%ChangeINRB%Change BajajElectric 10.4 -8%0.80 -9% CromptonGreaves 10.0 -6%1.00 5% DixonIndia 7.9 -25%0.59 -35% Havells 16.3 2%2.47 1% SureaRoshni 15.7 2%1.21 28%

Thisphoto,aswellasthecoverofthisissuefeatureArtemide’s luminaire“StellarNebula”.(c)Artemides. www.artemide.com

ExpertTalksonLight–TimeMatters,ShiningLighton

MetabolicHealth

GoodLightGroup,SocietyforLightTreatmentandBiological Rhythms,theDaylightAcademy,andLugerResearch|7thEdition

Dr.CharnaDibner–

Moderation

CharnaDibnercompletedherPhDinMedicalSciencesunderthesupervisionofProfessorDaleFrankintheDepartmentof BiochemistryattheTechnionIsraelInstitute ofTechnology,headedbyNobelLaureate ProfessorAvramHershko.Shenextmoved toGenevawhereshecompletedherpostdoctoraltrainingattheFacultyofScience, UniversityofGeneva,withProfessorUeli Schibler,workingonthemechanismsof transcriptionalandtemperaturecompensationofthemammaliancircadianclocks. In2009,shewasappointedasaGroup LeaderoftheLaboratoryofCircadianEndocrinologyattheFacultyofMedicine, acquiredherPrivateDocentdegree,and wasnominatedAssociateProfessorin 2021.Herworkcentersupontheimplicationofcircadianoscillatorsinregulationof metabolicprocessesinmammals.Inparticular,sheisinterestedinintricateinterplay betweentheisletcellularclocks,andinthe inter-organdesynchronyuponmetabolic diseases,unravelingtherolesofthecircadianclocksinhumanmetabolicdiseases. Charna’sworkhasbeenawardedwith severalprestigiousSwissprizesincluding RocheResearchFoundationprize,Takeda prizefordiabetesresearch,theawardsby FrenchSwissFoundationofDiabetesResearch,andLeenaardsandISRECFoundationawardsfortranslationalresearch.

Dr.KathrynReid–

FromtheRealWorldtothe Lab:WhyLightMattersfor MetabolicHealth

Theimpactoflightisdependentonwhen itoccursrelativetotheinternalbiological clock,andassuchthetimingofwhenwe getlightordarkacross24-hoursmatters. Lightexposurepatternsareamodifiable factorthatcanhavesignificantimpacton healthandwellbeing.Resultsfromreal worldandlaboratory-controlledstudies thatexaminetheimpactoflightexposure onhealthwillbediscussed.Frompregnant womentoolderadults,datafromrealworldmonitoringoflightlevelssuggests thathigherlevelsoflightexposureinthe fewhoursbeforeandduringsleepareassociatedwithpoormetabolichealth.The mechanismunderlyingthesefindingsare supportedbycontrolledlaboratory-based studiesexaminingtheimpactoflighton cardio-metabolicfunction.Togetherthese studiessuggestthatinterventionstooptimizethepatternoflight-darkexposure acrossthe24-hourdaycouldbebeneficial tohealthinvulnerablepopulations.

Dr.Jan-FriederHarmsen–DiabetesintheDaylight: MetabolicBenefitsThrough NaturalOfficeLighting?

Hetalksaboutarecentlycompletedstudy, inwhichhetestedifnaturaldaylightduring officehoursismorebeneficialformetabolic healthoutcomesoftype2diabetespatientscomparedtoconstantartificiallighting. RecordedTalk

https://bit.ly/3V5V53o

https://bit.ly/4bay5pN

youtube.com/c/LpSDIGITAL

Supportedby

LPSDIGITALTALKS DELIGHTEDTALKS 56 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design Issue103/May-June/2024
AllExpertTalks
LPSDIGITALTALKS DELIGHTEDTALKS 57 Issue103/May-June/2024 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design www.LpS-Digital.global

DEADLINES|LpR104

ADCLOSE

June30,2024

MATERIALDUE

June30,2024

DIGITALPUBLICATION

July15,2024

PRINTPUBLICATION

July31,2024

PREVIEW

GoodLight&Eco-Design

TheJuly/August2024issueofLEDprofessionalReviewwillfocusontheverylatest topicsintheworldoflighting.Wewillbe introducingarevolutionaryphosphortechnologythatachieveshighCRIvalues.Areport fromSignifywillrevealthelatesttrendsin3D printedluminaires.Thisissuewillalsoinclude thefirstpublicationofanewwhitepaper fromTheGoodLightGroup.Ontopofall that,wewillbeintroducinganotherexpertto youinourcontinuinginterviewseries withtheCIE.

Itgoeswithoutsaying,thattoroundoutthis issue,therewillbethelatestinternational lightingnewsandanewLpSDigitalTalksas wellasacommentaryfromaleadinglighting authority.

∗ Subjecttochangewithoutnotice.

ENQUIRIES

editors@led-professional.com

QuestionsandComments

Pleasedon’thesitatetosendusyouropinionsoraskquestionsaboutarticlesyouhave read.Weappreciateyourfeedback. editors@led-professional.com

AnnualSubscriptions

LpRDigitalMagazine

• eMagazine(PDFdownload)

• 6IssuesperYear(Bi-monthly)

• FullArchiveAccess (allpreviouseMagazineissues)

• BusinessIssuetoshareandusewithin organizations

• EUR78.80

LpRPrinted&DigitalMagazine

• PrintMagazineincludingshipping

• eMagazine(PDFdownload)

• 6IssuesperYear(Bi-monthly)

Subscribe

https://www.led-professional.com/misc/sub scribe Advertise

https://www.led-professional.com/advertise

• FullArchiveAccess (allpreviouseMagazineissues)

• Shippingcostsincluded

• EUR97.80

CoverPage: StellarNebulaisafamilyof lampsdesignedbyBIGtointerpretand enhancetheartisanalglassblowingwithinnovativePVDfinishingtechniques.Values, roles,andlimitsofindustrialandartisanal productionareatthecoreofthisdesignidea, whichaimstofindasolutionforuniqueness inproduction.

(c)Artemide, www.artemide.com ImageCredits:Artemide.

Imprint

LEDprofessionalReview(LpR) ISSN1993-890X

PublishingCompany

LugerResearche.U.|©2001–2024 InstituteforInnovation&Technology Moosmahdstrasse30,A-6850Dornbirn,Austria,Europe info@lugerresearch.com|www.lugerresearch.com P+435572394489|F+43557239448990

Publisher SiegfriedLuger

Editors

+4369911335570 s.luger@lugerresearch.com

Dr.GüntherSejkora +43557239448970 editors@led-professional.com

TheresaKönig +43557239448970 editors@led-professional.com

ElioA.Farina +43557239448970 editors@led-professional.com

Art&Design SarahLuger +436802305445 hallo@moments-of-aha.com

AccountManager ChristineLuger +4369911335520 c.luger@lugerresearch.com

China,Hong-Kong

LoloYoung +85297922081 lolo@castintl.com

Germany,International ArminWezel +493052689192 armin@eurokom-media.de

India

PriyankaRai +911244787331 priyanka.rai@binarysemantics.com

SouthKorea Jung-WonSuh +8227858222 sinsegi@sinsegimedia.info

Taiwan

LeonChen +886225681786-10 Jeon@jkmedia.com.tw

Benelux,France,Ireland,Scandinavia,UK ZenaCoupé +441923852537 zena@expomedia.biz

USA&Canada

LesleyHarmoning +12186866438 lesley@lhmandco.com

JillThibert +12182802821 jill@lhmandco.com

Copyrights–LugerResearche.U.

Theeditorsmakeeveryreasonableefforttoverifytheinformation published,butLugerResearche.U.assumesnoresponsibilityforthe validityofanymanufacturers,nonprofitorganizationsorindividuals claimsorstatements.LugerResearche.U.doesnotassumeand herebydisclaimsanyliabilitytoanypersonforanylossordamage causedbyerrorsoromissionsinthematerialcontainedherein, regardlessofwhethersucherrorsresultfromnegligence,accident oranyothercausewhatsoever.Youmaynotcopy,reproduce, republish,download,post,broadcast,transmit,makeavailableto thepublic,orotherwiseuseLEDprofessionalReview(LpR)content withoutpriorwrittenconsentfromLugerResearche.U.

©2001–2024LugerResearche.U.–InstituteforInnovation&Technology–VATNo.ATU50928705,EORINo.ATEOS1000046213, CommercialRegisterFN316464p,RegionalCourtFeldkirch,Austria, Europe ■

IMPRINT SUBSCRIPTIONS,PREVIEW&PUBLISHER 58 ©2024LugerResearche.U.|LEDprofessionalReview(LpR)|LightingTechnologies&Design Issue103/May-June/2024
∗ July/Aug2024|LpR104

Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.