22
Larchmont Chronicle
AUGUST 2019
SECTION TWO
Modern bidding allows 10 high card points opening per Rule of 20
Since 1959 License #768437
Bridge Matters by
Grand Slam (called the Rule of 20). With only five losers and 2-1/2 quick tricks and satisfying the Rule of 20, this hand clearly qualifies. So the corollary to this rule is that if your hand is 6-5 and you have enough points to qualify for an opening hand, it is strong enough to reverse. Here’s the layout followed by the bidding: East is dealer: North ♠ AQJ32 ♥ KQ9832 ♦— ♣ K9
But as played at a local bridge club, North opened the bidding out of turn with a conventional Precision opening bid of 1C which shows 16+ HCP and says nothing about clubs. The director was called, and East did not accept the bid so North was advised that when the bidding came around to him he could make a “comparable” call but if he did anything else his partner would be barred for one round. East and South both passed and West opened 1C. North bid 1H, which the director ruled
Plumbing
FAX (323) 463-1259
Inc.
• COMMERCIAL • RESIDENTIAL
SERVING THE LARCHMONT AREA FOR 60 YEARS!
Sun’s Out.... Now’s the Time to Repair Your Gutters and Downspouts!
Grand Slam is the nom de plume for an author of a bestselling book on bridge, an ACBL accredited director and a Silver Life Master.
Kids from preschool on up can learn about insects, lizards, spiders and more when Thor’s Reptile Family visits Memorial branch library, 4625 W Olympic Blvd., Tues., Aug. 6 at 1 p.m. Kids and their caregivers will be taken on a virtual “safari” around the world and learn about various aspects of the amphibians, arthropods and reptiles featured. For more information, call 323-938-2732.
drought tolerant terrarium using succulents at a workshop at Fairfax branch library, 161 S. Gardner St., Mon., Aug. 5 at 4 p.m. Materials, such as glass bowls, rocks, succulents and soil, will be provided. Attendees will learn about sustainability, low maintenance and low water needs when working with drought-tolerant plants. For more information, call 323-936-6191.
B GADDY ELECTRIC since 1978.
Residential • CommeRCial
Local Hancock Park resident for over 35 years, specializes in gutter cleaning and repair.
• Upgrades • Landscape • Pool Lights • Phone & Computer Lines • Security & Emergency Lighting © LC 0717
Brian Brady (213) 910-0980
North East South P P 1C 1H 1NT P 2D 2H 3D 4H 5D All Pass At this point, the director showed up and pulled the boards, saying everyone would get a “No Play” because the next round had already begun. West protested, saying that they had to wait more than five minutes to start the round because NS was slow in playing the previous round and then north’s bid out of turn caused an additional delay of a few minutes while the director was called and had to make a ruling, so EW should not be penalized, but should be protected. He also said that making 5D would be a top board, and a “No Play” would damage EW. The director was not persuaded. After the game, the printout revealed that at all 11 tables the NS were in 4 or 5 hearts, making. No EW was in 5D. 5D is cold. The only problem is the 4-0 trump break to the Jack. But normal play when there are four trump to the Jack missing is to first lead to the hand that has two of the top three honors to discover the distribution of the missing cards because that keeps a two-way finesse in play. When west leads to dummy’s KQ and reveals that South holds all four trump, the finesse is easy to take back to west’s hand to the A-10. West loses only the spade Ace and the club King. Had North had all four diamonds, West could come back to his hand with the
Ace and finesse through the board which would still have the Q-9. Even though it is clear that fairness requires that EW get a top board since all the scores (except one where North bid 6H and went down one) are NS and the delay was clearly not the fault of EW, the director refused to grant EW equity. In a telephone call to the American Contract Bridge League (ACBL), West was advised that once cards are pulled from the board, the hand must be played, either immediately or as a late play, further buttressing the EW claim that they should have been awarded the top score on that hand. The ACBL said that, at the very least, EW should get an average plus, but the director only awarded the average of their game, which was less than an average plus. The ACBL further stated that the director was wrong in ruling that North’s 1H overcall was “comparable” to a Precision 1C opening bid and that his partner should have been barred from bidding for one round. Since his partner passed anyway, that didn’t matter, but she took her unauthorized information (that North had 16+ HCP) to jump to game when she only had 6 HCP, something she’s unlikely to do without knowing that North had a huge hand, which she could not know from the bidding as it existed.
Plant a terrarium Reptiles, spiders at Fairfax library at Memorial library Learn how to create a
3121 W. Temple St., LA 90026
an Handymes, Servic too!
West
South ♠ K65 ♥ JT75 ♦ J865 ♣ J3
PLOTKE
Mario & Lynn (323) 463-9201
was a “comparable call.” This was incorrect (see below), but the bidding went on as follows:
East ♠ T987 ♥ A4 ♦ KQ92 ♣ 872
Service & Repairs
Call Bill 323-462-1023 Licensed & Insured
Local References
LIC #700914
©LC1010
Only 10 high card points (HCP) but 6-5 distribution. Many players who play reverses would open 1D and then rebid 2C because a reverse (opening 1C and rebidding 2D) would promise 17 HCP at least. But if you have 6-5 distribution and an opening hand, you may still reverse by opening 1C and then rebidding the diamonds twice to show that your distribution is 6-5 rather than 5-4. But is this an opening hand? It only has 10 HCP. According to modern bidding practice, this qualifies as an opening hand because it has 10 HCP and 10 cards in its two longest suits
West ♠ 4 ♥ 6 ♦ AT743 ♣ AQT654
©0618
You are West, in third seat. How would you open this hand? ♠4 ♥6 ♦ AT743 ♣ AQT654