We would like to thank all our award sponsors
Fort Frances Times
Hydro One
Metro Creative Graphics
Midwestern Newspapers
Ontario Federation of Agriculture
Ontario Journalism Educators Association
Ontario Power Generation
ORP Law
We would like to thank all our award sponsors
Fort Frances Times
Hydro One
Metro Creative Graphics
Midwestern Newspapers
Ontario Federation of Agriculture
Ontario Journalism Educators Association
Ontario Power Generation
ORP Law
It’s wonderful to once again honour the great work of Ontario’s Community Newspapers — and what a lot of great work OCNA members did this year. We received over 1,200 amazing entries for the 2022 Be er Newspapers Compe on, all of which are not only a credit to the reporters, photographers, designers, editorsandpublishersbehindthem,butalsototheindustryasawhole.
Needless to say, I would not have wanted to be one of the judges who had to try and choose the best of the best.
Compe ons like ours are more than just recognizing great work and securing bragging rights; they are excellent opportuni es to learn from the best and the brightest of our industry. A er every awards celebra onIcomeawaywithatleastonegreatideatotryinmypapers.
Of course, none of this would have been possible without three very important groups: the judges, the sponsorsandtheOCNAstaff.
It takes a lot of me and dedica on for our volunteer judges to go through a category’s worth of stories, photos, websites, ads or newspapers. While the process can be quite fun, it’s o en done during evenings or weekends outside of normal working hours. Without that willingness on the part of our judges to give freely of themselves and share their wisdom about newspapers, events like the Be er Newspapers Compe on couldnotexist.Thankyou.
Wewouldalsonotbeabletoholdourannualawardswithoutthegenerosityofourcategorysponsors.Your dona ons arewhatmakeitpossibleforOCNAtoproperlyrewardthebestworkourindustryhas tooffer.Your con nuedsupportisgreatlyappreciatedbyallBe erNewspapersCompe onpar cipants.
And even though we again are unable to celebrate together, Ontario Power Genera on, our Gold Awards Galasponsor,iscon nuingwithitssupport,soahugethankyoutothemaswell.
And I would be remiss if I didn’t thank the OCNA staff for their dedica on and hard work. Having worked in the associa on office at awards me, I know just how much is involved in making things run smoothly year a eryear.Youalldeserveanawardfromthemembership.
Congratula ons to all the winners, and I look forward to seeing all the great work that you’ll be submi ng thisOctoberforthe2023awards.
Gordon Cameron President and Interim Execu ve Director Ontario Community Newspapers Associa on1 2 3
The Independent Serving Petrolia & Central Lambton emerged as No. 1 in this category for its extensive coverage, strong photography, clean design, and effec ve adver sing. The Independent sets the tone with its front page consis ng of one strong photograph and interes ng news stories and con nues that theme throughout the paper. Readers are provided each week with a package of news and feature stories that are supported by numerous photographs. There is a lot of content in the pages of The Independent,providingpeoplewiththeinforma ontheyneedabouttheircommunity.
The Haliburton County Echo draws readers in with a strong front page filled with stories and photos and it doesn’t disappoint as its pages are filled throughout with informa ve and engaging stories, interes ng features, and good photos. The Echo has lots of well-designed, effec ve adver sing to supportthenewsandfeatures.
The Listowel Banner provides extensive coverage of the community, supplemented by good photography, interes ng opinion pages, a variety of features and strong, effec ve adver sing. The paper starts with an engaging, well-designed front page and carries that commitment throughout its pages. There is no doubt that readers an cipate the arrival of the Banner on the newsstand each week.
MINDEN TIMES - The Minden Times includes a lovely mix of hard news and community features covering a breadth of topics, and a strong opinion page with locally relevant pieces. A nice use of photos throughoutthepapertobreakupblocksoftext.
Small in circula on, but mighty in content is the theme for the newspapers in General Excellence Class 1. The entries in this class set a high standard with extensive, engaging content, great design, strong photography, and interes ng, effec ve adver sements. Some great coverage of local governments grappling with vaccine ques ons and how to return to "normal life." Newspapers are going through such a tough me but looking at these papers you would neverknowit.Greatjobbyallcontestants.
CIRCULATION 2,000 - 6,499 1 2 3
May be a li le sen mental now but we remember when most papers were the size of the Eganville Leader. While that didn't factor into the judging, it did certainly help it stand out from the rest somewhat. Liked the use of the colour headlines throughout and can't recall ever seeing it before on every page during 40-plus years in the business. The paper makes effec ve use of photographs, and the adsarewelllaidoutanddesignedtodrawyouin.Thereislotsofgoodlocalcontentandcolumnsand,as a history buff, I really like the Reflec ons of a Century page. It has a strong sports sec on, which is rare now,evenfordailypapers.
The New Liskeard Temiskaming Speaker has a strong front page with no ads, big headlines and a dominant photo. The paper has a clean layout, is easy to read with big headlines, and has a lot of news and sports. It has local editorials, le ers to the editor and strong adver sing indica ng a strong connec on to the community. The one area it could improve is in photography. There are a lot of photos, which is good, but many are posed of people looking straight into the camera. Overall, this is an excellentpaperthatseemstocoveritscommunitywell.
Niagara This Week, Niagara-on-the-Lake Advance is a great example of what a community newspaper can be. The photography stands above many others thanks to great composi on, use of angles and sizing the photos well compared to the ar cles that accompany them. The editorial and op-ed pages feature an assortment of opinions including le ers to the editor, showing the community is engaged. Whiletheyhandlehardnewsextremelywell,theira en ontolocalfeaturesandtocoverageofthearts makes it a publica on that has meaning for the community. Finally, their front page and layout is clean, with strong headlines, well composed photographs, stories with ght leads, and good use of white space. Overall, this is a well-executed community newspaper where a en on to detail, and solid journalism make for a product that is enjoyable to read.
While the number of papers in this category is rela vely small, they represent a diverse offering in terms of style. The entries were all solid, making it difficult to choose the top three. They had a lot of stories and photos, some good special sec ons, and seemed to all cover their communi es well. Overall, it was a pleasure to judge, and we congratulate everyone for not only con nuing to put out a newspaper every week, but also achieving a high standard while doingit.Youareservingyourrespec vecommuni eswell.
This really is the best newspaper package in the group. An interes ng front page, solid repor ng, and excellent coverage of community news. The Highlander has a great sports sec on and a good grasp of the local arts scene. So many people photographs – it's as if you meet the whole community in the pagesofthispaper.Thenewspaperhasasolidandvariedadver serbaseandagoodclassifiedsec on.
TheNiagaraThisWeek,FortEriePosthadagreatamountoflocalnewsfromfronttoback.Almostevery pagehadsomethingthatwasgoingoninFortErie.It’sabusypaper,buteverythingwaseasytoreadand very nice on the eyes. Solid adver sing content throughout and well-designed. The op-ed pages had a nice mix of material as well. A bit of sports content in there, so a li le something for everyone. The bonus was being able to pick up from other papers in the Niagara region and s ll make it relevant. Not hardtodowhenthere’sSt.Catharines,Welland,ThoroldandNiagaraFallsproperinthearea.
GENERAL COMMENT
In this day and age, Covid-19 will always get tongues wagging and that's what the front page photo for this publica on would have done. The Glanbrook Gaze e is effec ve because the reader will almost invariably turn to the page and see what it's all about. It's done its job. Nice op-ed and editorial pages, with plenty of adver sing content, good design of the ads, and the news content is easy to read and is local. A sma ering of sports in there with arts as well.
Re red Publishing
Company President, Past BCYCNA President, Gabriola Island, BC Judges1 2 3
The Elmira-Woolwich Observer was a joy to read, with excellent design elements and plain language principles. The photos were fresh and the wri ng strong. Congrats to Steve Kannon for his great column! It is so rare to read a local column from a community newspaper editor these days. With lots of news, opinions, games and recipes, there is something for everyone in this edi on. It is obvious this crea veandsalesteamputalotofloveeachweekintojournalism.
Strong local stories make for good reading, and the Orangeville Ci zen is good reading. The Orangeville Town Page is a great adver sing idea. And Orangeville 911 was so fun to peruse! Really enjoyed your artsandsportspages,andtherewereplentyofvoicesrepresentedthroughthecolumns.
The Grimsby Lincoln News is a solid newspaper. A strong front page and good use of photography throughout. Adver sing is very strong, with a detailed classified sec on and special sec on adver sing content. It is a good read and very worthy to be a top choice in this category.
MIDLAND/PENETANGUISHENE MIRROR - With strong repor ng by Andrew Mendler, the Midland/Penetanguishene Mirror delivers on local and topical news for the ci zens (the Bu er Tart Fes val looks amazing!). The QR codes on the front page are convenient for the readers to get informa on quickly on their devices. There are lots of municipal and business ads, and the Canada Day sec on is well done. Thepaperreflectsahealthycommunity.
The top four papers really stood out from the rest in this general excellence category. Many of the other newspapers were lacking contentthatmeantitwasimpossibletogivethemavalidscore.Itwas disappoin ng to see so li le sports, arts, and community stories in many of the newspapers. As well, editorial content and le ers to the editor. It would appear that some of these newspapers do not engage wellwiththecommuni esthattheyserve.
1 2 3
The Wellington Adver ser is a classic looking newspaper – with a robust story-filled front that accentuates and draws a en on to the front page art/photo. A resounding favorite of the judges and a well-deservedwinamongstastrongcollec onofnewspaperscompe ngthisyear.Thefirstplacepaper initsclass.Congratula ons!
The Barrie Advance was an overall well wri en and produced newspaper, with a clear focus on providing accurate and interes ng local community news for residents. The Advance had a strong mixtureofnews,sports,photography,featurear clesandafulsomeeditorialandopinionpage–allkey aspects in making a newspaper that community members want to pick up and read. The front page popped from a first glance and each page had a unique and interes ng story to tell and inform people. TheAdvancestaffareclearlypassionateaboutwhattheydo,anditshowsintheproduct.
Niagara This Week, Niagara Falls had the highest page counts in the category – kudos to the adver sing department – and the news team filled these issues adeptly. Community newspapers need to be everything to everyone, and this paper meets that mandate with an appropriate balance of news stories from a range of beats, as well as local features. This paper's a rac vely laid-out pages will invite readers in and the content will keep them around.
LISTOWEL INDEPENDENT PLUS - The Listowel Independent Plus keeps their front page no nonsense, bold and clean, which was an appealinglookforjudges.
A great-looking batch of community newspapers this year. This was an incredibly difficult category to judge, with all submi ed newspapers having a strong product that reflected the ongoing news in each respec ve community. Some mes simply one category lacking, which some mes falls to the luck of the draw in terms of the issue/week selected by the associa on to focus on, would determine the top papers from the bo om. Almost all the front pages featured eye-catching photos and most papers were presented with strong headlines. They each had strong features from editorial and opinion pages to sports, news and the presenta on of each newspaper. The journalists for each outlet work hard and itshows in every newspaper thatwassubmi edforthe2022year.
Just about every page contained valuable community news and plenty of large photos, maybe too large in some cases, but it's great to see lots of artwork. Solid presenta on and a great variety of opinion pieces. Stories were well wri en, and The Chronicle had the strongest sports coverage of the group. Unfortunately,noadver singtobefound.
Local content is the strength of The Interrobang. Pages and pages of good stories that impact the student popula on. Great to see some strong opinion within the pages as well. Addi onal photos of peopleratherthanjustbuildingsorvendingmachineswouldmakethepackageevenstronger,aswould dedica ngali lemorespacetovarsitysportscoverage.Strongestadver singcontentofthegroup.
Photography is definitely the strength of the Loyalist College Pioneer. Strong images on every page. The stories on the Ukraine couple and the special needs hockey league were very compelling. Unfortunately, there were no opinion pieces or adver sing in the final product.
It certainly is a tough me for journalism students, as it appeared the pandemic forced many classes online, which is a difficult way to learn our cra . S ll, the trio of entrants all showed their own strengths and, overall, there are talented reporters and photographers ready to make the jump to the industry. The highlight of all three of these student newspapers was the diversity in the stories and the voices shared with their readers.
ONTARIO COMMUNITY NEWSPAPERS ASSOCIATION
11
1 2 3
A great read! Mul -sourced and well told. Congratula ons Sam! Sugges ons: There is some incorrect punctua on,andIwouldhavelikedtohaveseenanimageofthebandinitsheyday.
Community arts repor ng at its best! Congratula ons Tamara! This ar cle is mul -sourced and demonstrates excellent reader outreach with the show and cket informa on. Some sugges ons: WatchforCPstyleuse, aswellasgrammarandpunctua on.
Well told and a good use of images. Very well done Mark! This is an excellent ar cle that's also very topical and educa onal.
This year’s entries in the Arts & Entertainment category presented topical themes: the impacts of the Covid-19 pandemic; the (slow) return of live music; and First Na ons pride. The winners weaved powerful tales that told of heartbreak and loss, of history and renewal, and of the cultural heartbeat of Canada. The Top 3 winners also snapped their own photos for their ar cles — a testament to their passion in local journalism and to being present to document local history. A few ps to note: The correct usage of spelling, grammar, punctua on, and CP style is appreciated; fresh — not canned — images are preferred (and should be credited); and mul -sourced stories are a must. Congratula ons to all of the reporters who entered this category, as well as the editors who gave room in their print and online edi ons to share the inspira onal stories about crea ve people in our communi es!
Sponsored by: Midwestern Newspapers
Janis Cleugh Reporter, Copy Editor, Paginator & Proofreader, Tri-City News, Coquitlam, BCJanis Cleugh lives and works on the stolen, unceded and ancestral territory of the kʷikʷəƛəm (Kwikwetlem) First Na on, in what is knowntodayasCoquitlam.Janiscoverstheartsandhumaninterest stories for the Tri-City News, where she is also a copy editor, paginator and proofreader. Previously, she worked for the Chilliwack Times (B.C.); Brighton Independent (Ontario); Wokingham Times (England); and Portsmouth News (England). Under the Na onal Council for the Training of Journalists in Britain, Janis interned at North Wales Weekly, Scotland and the Western Morning News. She also spent a year teaching English as a Foreign Language in Japan. Janis has won three repor ng fellowships: two with the Jack Webster Founda on and one with the Hong Kong Economic and Trade Office. Currently, she is a co-secretary with Editors BC, a twig of Editors Canada, and is a na onally cer fied proofreader. In December 2022, she finished the Plain Language cer ficate program at Simon Fraser University; she also holds SFU cer ficates in edi ng; publishing; and business wri ng, public rela ons, and marke ng communica on.
1 2 3
I really enjoyed this story. It had lots of voices and shined a light on virtually all aspects of an industry thatdoesn'tgetatonofmediaa en on.Welldone!
I liked the variety of sources and level of details in this story. The only thing missing was a bit of context on the agribusiness industry as a whole -- what kind of numbers are we talking about here in terms of customers,sales,etc.?Nicepieceoverall.
The reporter showed good ini a ve here to dig behind the headlines and find out how a proposed development could affect local retailers. Nice job.
HAMILTONMOUNTAINNEWS-MARKNEWMAN - The reporter does a good job at pu ng a human face on how the changing retail landscapeisaffec nglong mebusinessowners.
This year's entries tackled a diverse range of subjects and did a good job overall at pu ng a human face on vital business issues such as the impact of COVID-19 labour shortages and other challenges. Unfortunately, too many stories relied on just one or two sources and took only a superficial look at many of these topics. More research and addi onal context would have gone a long way to making more entries stand out.
David Sali Editor & Senior Writer, O awa Business Journal, O awa, ONAn editor and reporter at the O awa Business Journal since 2014, David Sali is a 30-year veteran of the newspaper industry. Before joining OBJ, David began his journalism career as a reporter and editor at several community newspapers in O awa’s east end. He then spent a dozen years as a copy editor at the O awa Sun, where he worked in news, sports, entertainment, and business. When he’s not wri ng or talking about business, David can o en be found at a curling rink in winteroronthetenniscourtinsummer.Therestofthe methe Saskatchewan na ve eats, sleeps and breathes Roughrider football.
1 2 3
ANCASTER NEWS - KEVIN WERNER
Interes ng editorial. It definitely requires an editorial to be able to say what you needed to say. Good jobonusingstatsandquotestobackupyourar cle.
Wellsaid.Andputintermsthattheaveragereadershouldbeabletounderstand.
DUNDAS STAR NEWS - KEVIN WERNER
Yikes - that is a great editorial topic, and good editorial for a call to ac on. I'd like to know if there was anyfall-outtothis.
Sheena Read
Freelance Journalist, Alberta
Every single editorial submi ed was worthy of an award this year. There were some absolutely great issues explained and backed upwithquotesandsta s cs.Itwasavery ghtcontest,andinthe end, it came down to more of an issue of passion for the issue or the ghtness of the editorial. Well done!
Sheena Read has commi ed decades - yikes, yes decades - to communica ons. Based in southern Alberta, she now is involved in contract messaging and promo ons, with a focus and commitment on community building. She ponders the changes in communica ons and media and what the future holds with the twists and turns of social media. Read is a strong supporterofjournalism.
1 2 3
I read this with my mouth open. As an editor of my ownpaper in a smalltownI fully understand the guts andcareforthecommunityrequiredtowriteandpublishthis.Bravo.
PARRY SOUND NORTH STAR - PAMELA STEEL
Such an important message. It is tough to go up against school boards in our small towns. It takes courage.Welldone.
BURKS FALLS ALMAGUIN NEWS - PAMELA STEEL
Braveandimportantpiece.Kudosfortakingiton.
NIAGARA-ON-THE-LAKE, THE LAKE REPORT - RICHARD HARLEYBrave and powerful piece. Good on the paper for taking this one on. Clearlythiseditorialcomesoutofequallybraverepor ng.
It was really inspiring to judge this category. Wri ng an opinion piece with impact week a er week is a near-impossible task. The tempta on is to do quick and easy hot takes that play to our most basic ins ncts. These submissions show that despite challenges in our newsrooms across Canada, folks are taking the me to reflect though ully in their editorials. All the submissions were impressive, and it was tough to choose the top three. I picked the ones that were the bravest and most impac ul, especially considering the smaller popula on/circula on of these papers. Well done, all!
Jennifer Thuncher Editor, The Squamish Chief, Squamish, BCJennifer Thuncher is the editor and a roving reporter at The Squamish Chief. She can be found chasing down the paper's other journalists, local poli cians, or wildlife, depending on the day. She is a Simon Fraser University and Langara journalism grad. She had careers as an English instructor, administra ve assistant, and ice-cream scooper in her life before journalism.
Jennifer is the winner of the inaugural 2022 Jack Webster Founda on Shelley Fralic award for dedica on to community journalism.
1 2 3
Great quotes used and strong quality of wri ng. Ar cle provides details on how the style of teaching face-to-face art is impac ul and helpful towards students in the community. Photos are colourful and helppaintsthepictureofthestory.
Story es in a na onal historic event of the first Na ve American woman traveling to space, and the impact it has on students in the community who are interested in the same field and happy to see Indigenousrepresenta on.Greatrangeofsourcesused.
Story is clear, precise, and informa ve. A variety of different sources were provided which helped strengthenthe'why'andtruthofthestory.
MILTON CANADIAN CHAMPION - KATHY YANCHUS - Great facts and sources used in the story. As well, relevant background informa on helpedexplaintheissueandtheimpactitishavinginthecommunity.
NIAGARA-ON-THE-LAKE, THE LAKE REPORT - EVAN SAUNDERSGreat lede and ending to the story. Ar cle clearly shows the importanceforteachingthemeaningofreconcilia onday.
The entries in the educa on wri ng category covered a diverse range of stories which focused on students taking ini a ve to support people in their communi es, teachers using art and other informa ve ac vi es as a means of teaching as well as a strong focus on reconcilia on in the classroom. The entries submi ed in this category also provided great and colorful photos that matched well with the stories.
Sierra D’Souza Butts
Local Journalism Ini a ve Reporter, The World-Spectator, Moosomin, SK
Sierra D’Souza Bu s works as the Local Journalism Ini a ve Reporter at the World-Spectator. Moving from the city to a smalltown,Sierraenjoysmee ngnewpeopleand hearingtheir views on social issues. Being a 2021 journalism graduate from Carleton University, she’s happy to have a pla orm to share otherpeople’sstoriesandexcitedtolearnmoreaboutthefield.
1 2 3
This is a well-wri en piece about the impact of feeding stale bread to Canada geese. It had all the elements of a strong story, with several civilian and expert sources quoted, and the ability to help changepeople’sbehaviourswhenitcomestotheirrela onshipswithwildlife.
This was a solid story about how farmers are coping with climate change. It answered ques ons that manycommunitymemberswouldhaveaboutthefutureofgrowingfood.
I really liked the wri ng style in this piece, where nothing is a ributed to a source un l the second half ofthestory,givingitamoreeasy-to-readcolumnfeel.
So many community media stories have an environmental focus these days, and the entries in this category covered a huge range of subjects as a result. None of the stories stood out as an obvious winner as is o en the case in these compe ons, but all of them served an important role in educa ng readers and making a posi ve difference in the process.
Gail Sjuberg Editor, Gulf Islands Dri wood & Aqua-Gulf Islands
Living Magazine, Salt Spring Island, BC
Gail Sjuberg has been the editor of the award-winning Gulf Islands Dri wood newspaper in B.C. since 2003 and in the community newspaper business for more than 30 years. She is also the editor of the Dri wood’s Aqua - Gulf Islands Living magazine and other company publica ons. She has been a judge for numerous community newspaper compe ons over theyears.
1 2 3
This incredibly detailed, well-organized and drama c story by reporter Jordan Snobelen about Dale Wideman’s 61 days as a hostage in Hai , a pawn in ongoing violence in that country, stood out among some other very fine entries. Superb journalism. I was par cularly impressed that the story did not portray Hai and its people in a one-dimensional way but recognized all the good people there who are besetbyterriblecircumstances.
This is a very moving story. It is as much a story of hope as it is of loss. Writer Jeremy Grimaldi tells readers about five-year-old Parker Sheahan’s ba le with cancer in such a way that the reader is upli ed bytheyoungboy’sincrediblea tude.
Features can be used to make persuasive cases for changes in a tudes and approaches to important issues. This one by Alexandra Heck, which highlights the struggles 33-year-old Graham Boisvenue underwent,andtheinabilitytoobtainthehelpheneededpromptly,doesjustthat.
GUELPH MERCURY TRIBUNE - GRAEME MCNAUGHTON - This unusual story gives readers a look into the small but important academic researchcommunityandshowstheimportanceofrigorousstandardsin such work. A good, detailed explana on is offered by reporter Graeme McNaughton.
WATERLOO CHRONICLE - BILL JACKSON - Federal clawbacks of funds from poor working seniors are examined in this disturbing report by BillJackson.
There were some superb entries in this category, and all of them told interes ng stories. The top three and the honourable men ons stood outfortheiruniquestories,aswellassomespecialaspectsofeachone of them, to make an overall presenta on that was very reader friendly. In this age of distrac on and mul ple media voices, including social media, that is very important. Congratula ons to all who entered.
Sponsored by: ORP Law
Frank Bucholtz Columnist, Black Press Media and Re red Editor, Langley Times, BCFrank Bucholtz is a re red community newspaper editor, and a freelance writer and blogger with more than 40 years of media experience. He worked for community newspapers in Surrey, Langley,WhiteRockand otherpartsof theB.C.LowerMainlandand FraserValleyfrom1978un lre ringin2015,andcon nuestowrite a column for the Surrey Now-Leader, Peace Arch News and Cloverdale Reporter in B.C. He served as editor of the Langley Times from 1999 to 2015 and the Surrey Leader from 1986 to 1993. He has judged various categories in the annual OCNA awards for the past ten years. He also serves as a judge with the Jack Webster Founda on, which presents annual awards to B.C. journalists in all media. Frank is a past winner of journalism awards from both the CCNA and the BCYCNA.
1 2 3
This look back at a destruc ve 1996 tornado is an excellent feature by Don Rickers, with great photos fromtheeventanddetailedcommentsabouttheurbanmyththatthetornadostruckadrive-injustasit was showing the movie Twister. The first-person account sidebar by Carolyn Mullin, the editor of the Pelham newspaper of the day, along with her photos, put the whole event, its destruc on and how it was covered locally into perfect context.
Thequil ngcommunitylikestogiveback,andbydoingsotheyhavebroughthopeandmorepurposeto Indigenous people affected by the residen al experience. Diane Johnston’s story on Quilts For Survivorsisawell-wri enexampleofreconcilia onandhopeforthefuture.
The many stories which centered around the Mano ck Tea Room were given a full airing in this very interes ng feature. Figures such as Al Capone, J. Edgar Hoover, and Gene Krupa make this story a fascina ngread.
CARLETON PLACE/ALMONTE CANADIAN GAZETTE - TARA GESNERLodi Sculthorpe’s horrific injuries a er being struck by a snowmobile on a recrea on trail have completely changed her life, as related in this moving story by Tara Gesner.
GRAVENHURST BANNER - SARAH LAW - Banner writer Sarah Law produced an excellent and emo onal story about the significant impact co-op student Chris e Leja made in her short life. She died on the day her front-page photo was published in The Banner, and the effort to find people in her life and talk to them about her was significantandpowerful.
As can be expected from newsrooms of varying sizes and writers with many things on their plates, the quality of entries in this category was a li le bit uneven. This was a large category with plenty of entries. Most of the submissions were very good, and some went to great lengths to tell important community stories. The top three and honourable men ons were all excellent. Congratula ons to all who entered.
Sponsored by: ORP Law
Frank Bucholtz Columnist, Black Press Media and Re red Editor, Langley Times, BCFrank Bucholtz is a re red community newspaper editor, and a freelance writer and blogger with more than 40 years of media experience. He worked for community newspapers in Surrey, Langley,WhiteRockand otherpartsof theB.C.LowerMainlandand FraserValleyfrom1978un lre ringin2015,andcon nuestowrite a column for the Surrey Now-Leader, Peace Arch News and Cloverdale Reporter in B.C. He served as editor of the Langley Times from 1999 to 2015 and the Surrey Leader from 1986 to 1993. He has judged various categories in the annual OCNA awards for the past ten years. He also serves as a judge with the Jack Webster Founda on, which presents annual awards to B.C. journalists in all media. Frank is a past winner of journalism awards from both the CCNA and the BCYCNA.
1 2 3
The writer wove together a story with strong quotes, drama c events, and caught the reader's a en on. She drug me immediately into the story and no way could I stop reading un l the end. The informa on she found was placed together in an ini a ve or original way and points were made with melyquotes.Eventssuchasshowingthemanwaswalkingwhenheenteredthehospitalandcouldnot walk when he le moved the reader through the story. Lack of personnel and the need for a new hospital indicated relevance to the community. When you read the story, you wonder how many other pa ents have had similar events. Addi onal sources would make the story even stronger.
If you are looking for a story that will grab your interest, s r emo ons, is filled with informa on and severalgood quotes,andyou keepwonderingwhatisnext, thenreadthisstory.Several mesIjustkept reading because the story was well wri en, showed great research, had info from various people, showed ini a ve and originality, and was relevant to most members of the community. We saw the woman grow from near death of Lyme disease to a new person, now hopefully on her way to a full recovery.Plus,she'squicktosayshewillbetellingotherpeoplewhattheycandotorecover.
While this story may lack the drama found in a few stories, it is a story filled with informa on and has facts and figures presented that are not there in many stories. I have read several stories about the lack of nurses and other personnel, but this story gives data and numbers and shows how there is a shortage. Good job of researching informa on and some great quotes that stand out, such as the one about a single nurse who was so busy, she might not find a way to go to the bathroom. Well wri en, though some edi ng might have been done. No doubt about the ini a ve and originality, and the relevancetothecommunityisobvious.
NIAGARA-ON-THE-LAKE, THE LAKE REPORT - EVAN SAUNDERS
A 10-year-old girl did this? Let's read the story and find what she did and why. The story is well wri en, and informa on included shows solid research. The writer interviewed several people. He used ini a ve and originality in finding informa on and people and then used quotes. The topic involved and the people par cipa ng show relevancetothecommunity.
Thanks for the opportunity to judge this contest. There was a variety of stories, and I enjoyed the chance to read them - some on rereads, as I chose the winners. Aside from the interes ng stories, I encountered some excellent repor ng and wri ng. Many stories grabbed my a en on and involved me so much that at one point my wife returned home and I didn’t hear her come in! That is how interes ng the stories were. Among the key items in a story are the lead, the repor ng that finds the answers to ques ons the readers will be asking, sufficient quotes and a number of sources, and individuals and examples that can illustrate the story. The winning stories have these covered. Great work everyone!
Harry Hix Re red Publisher & Editor, S llwater, OklahomaHarry is a graduate of Oklahoma State University, with a master’s degree from Southern Illinois University-Carbondale. He worked as a newspaper reporter and photographer and owned a weekly newspaper for 16 years. He has received many editorial awards in both daily and weekly composi ons, and his newspaper won awards each year. As a master’s student, he was managing editor of the campus daily that won the Sigma Delta Chi na onal award for news repor ng. He is a member of the Oklahoma and Tennessee Press Associa on, Sigma Delta Chi, the Na onal Newspaper Associa on, and the Interna onal Society of Weekly Newspapers Editors. At Oklahoma University he was first chair of the Engleman/Livermore Chair of Community Journalism and received the Teacher of the Year award. In Tennessee he received the President’s Award for work in educa on and professionalism in the newspaper industry.
1 2 3
CARLETON PLACE/ALMONTE CANADIAN GAZETTE - ASHLEY KULP
Excellent and interes ng story. Heart-warming. Combines human interest with history. Well done! Very deservingwinner!
MANOTICK MESSENGER - JEFF MORRIS
Couldnotpullmyselfawayfromthisstory.Aterrificread.Welldone!
WINGHAM ADVANCE TIMES - CORY BILYEA
Fabulousresearchinthisstory.
An outstanding lot of entries. Exhaus ng job to judge. Ten judges might choose 10 different winners. Ontario can be proud of its writers. Communi es are well-served. Overall wri ng was outstanding. No poor entries. I was impressed with the wide range of stories tackled. Each was interes ng. A joy to judge!
Chris Clegg Editor, South Peace News, High Prairie, AB
Chris Clegg has held the posi on of editor at the High Prairie SouthPeaceNewssinceDecember1988.SouthPeaceNewshas won over 90 AWNA and CCNA awards since his arrival in virtually every judging category. Clegg has also served on the High Prairie and District Museum and Historical Society for about10yearsandhasakeeninterestinhistory.
Sponsored by: Fort Frances Times
This story gave an important voice to a group that was o en misunderstood or not treated fairly by some media outlets and sought to understand their concerns. I thought the writer did great on the ground repor ng and took so many excellent photos. The story had excellent colour throughout the piece. It would've been stronger if it had a voice(s) cri cal of the convoy and details about how the unvaccinated were filling up hospital beds and why the government(s) put in the vaccine mandates. Remember CP style with me if your publica on follows that.
This story on the devasta ng fire went above and beyond the tradi onal news piece on a local fire. It included strong photos, relevant historical context and most importantly several voices from people directly impacted. It illustrated just how devasta ng the blaze was to the community through strong wri ng and quotes and went further by including informa on on how people could help. This kind of storytellingisexactlywhatasmallcommunityneedswhentragedystrikes.
3
There was a lot of good colour in this piece and some strong voices. The wri ng had nice transi ons but could have been ghtened up in a few spots. There were a few quotes that I thought were redundant and didn't need to be included. I think Tyler should have provided his full name and wouldn't have included him if he didn't want to give it. The photos taken by the author helped tell the story. Overall, I thoughttherewasgreatrepor nghere,whichcertainlystoodoutamongthisyear'sentries.
GRIMSBY LINCOLN NEWS - LUKE EDWARDS - This is an excellent story that illustrates how the residents are innocent vic ms of a bureaucra c nightmare. There were a few wri ng errors in the piece.Thestorycameveryclosetowinninganaward.
There were many great submissions this year in the Best News Story category.Ul mately,thestoriesthatstoodouttomeasajudgewere ar cles that included first-hand on-the-ground repor ng with colourful wri ng. It was difficult choosing the final three winners because for each one, there was another great story that was right behindit.Ihadtogolinebylineandnitpickthefinedetailstochoose the three winners. Your communi es are be er served with your dedica on to local journalism. Great job everyone!
Sponsored by: Hydro One
Aus n Grabish is an RTDNA award-winning reporter whose work has been credited with triggering change. He spent over six and a half years working for the CBC in Winnipeg where he was responsible for covering daily breaking and enterprise news for CBC’s TV, radio and digital pla orms. His work ran across the country on The Na onal and on CBC News Network. He won mul ple awards for his repor ng before he le the public broadcaster in December of 2022 to pursue his dream of working in California. Grabish started his career at the Selkirk Record, a Manitoba weekly. He landed his first bylinein the paper just a few weeks before gradua ng high school.
1 2 3
A winning news story, thanks to her embedment with family to find out about their thoughts on the Pope's televised apology to residen al school vic ms in Canada. Gina Gasongi Simon sat with her parents, residen al school survivors, as they listened to the papal apology. Compelling read from this poignant story.
Richard Harley earned runner-up honours for his story on Teresa Wong, who fled the Communist regimecrackdowninHongKongtofindfreedomandsafetyinCanada.Acompellingreadaswell.
A tragic story of a dog owner finding his dog and puppy killed by shotgun blasts heard by the owner while out for a walk with them in a forest copped third-place. Sam Gillet wrote this heart-wrenching newsstorywiththeOPPlookingforthecaninemurderer.
I expected more from the best news story category, but a few stories stood above the rest because of the work being done by the top-three reporters, plus the stories they delivered to their readers. Congratula ons to the winners!
Sponsored by: Hydro One
It has been 38 years since editor Lorne Drury (now re red) offered him his first reporter job at the Brampton Guardian, and he is s ll going like the Energizer Bunny. Currently in Manitoba looking a er the award-winning army newspaper Shilo Stag, which published its first edi on in July 1947, he's kept busy in a two-person newsroom which focuses on army life, including infantry 2PPCLI and ar llery 1RCHA soldiers. Xavier has been with the Stag for nine years and is finally set to re re in July as the 76-year-old Stag’s longest serving editor. He relocated from Vancouver Island following newspaper and radio jobs in Ontario, B.C., and Alberta. Being embedded among soldiers who are honing their figh ng skills for deployment to Ukraine or Latvia is a lot more fun than covering school board or city council mee ngs.
1 2 3
The author's approach to this story sets it apart from most ar cles about road safety when it comes to farm machinery. The reader gains a valuable new perspec ve by seeing the world from the cab of a combine, and the prac cal informa on in the ar cle will hopefully prevent collisions. The author's conversa onal wri ng style is informa ve without being 'preachy' and the design also makes effec ve use of photos in a limited amount of space.
An excellent, well-researched ar cle that highlights a very important issue affec ng producers. One interes ng point that stood out was the fact that it's cheaper for Ontario farmers to use imported fer lizer from Russia than to use fer lizer from western Canada. I'm sure that bit of informa on will s mulate people to ques on current government policies. That's what a good newspaper story should do: present the facts and generate cri cal thinking on the part of the readership.
Theauthorpacksalotofinforma onintoashortar clethateffec velylaysoutthenatureandscopeof a serious problem facing the bee industry in Ontario. The fact that there is no easy, or agreed-upon solu on,isevidentfromthequotesprovided.
I found the stories in this category to be very well wri en. Because there is a wide varia on in subject ma er, ranging from agricultural produc on and marke ng to human-interest and local history, the stories covered a lot of ground and made for very interes ng reading. Top marks were given to those ar cles that provided good solid informa on, were wri en in a straigh orward style, and were mostrelevanttothecommunitythenewspapersserve.
Sponsored by: Ontario Federa on of Agriculture
Terry Pugh is an award-winning reporter-photographer with the Clark's Crossing Gaze e. He has wri en for several community newspapersinSaskatchewansince1976.
1 2 3
EGANVILLE LEADER - GERALD TRACEY & DEBBI CHRISTINCK
This story touched on the difficult situa on of bees and their decima on. Photos were great and the story very relevant. Great job!
GLANBROOK GAZETTE - TARA LINDEMANN
This was a well-researched and a well laid out story. Very well done!
NIAGARA-ON-THE-LAKE, THE LAKE REPORT - JILL TROYER
Uniqueandinteres ng.ThebestphotosandlayoutI'veseenintheen recompe on.
This is the second me I have been approached to judge a newspaper compe on and I must say it was one I truly enjoyed. I have been in this industry for 22 years and rarely am I shocked by anything. The entries in this year's compe on shocked me. Shocked me with the depth of wri ng by so many incredible reporters. I was extremely impressed with the caliber of the submi ed ar cles and the incredible layout of certain submissions only enhanced the read. The technical work is there, but it’s the a en on to detail and layout that surprised me. It’s as if the writers understand the power they wield with the public to make a difference to tell a story. Well done everyone. I have no doubt our industryisingreathandswhenIseesuchqualitywork.
Sponsored by: Ontario Federa on of Agriculture
Lisa Sygutek Publisher, The Pass Herald, Crowsnest Pass, ABLisa graduated from the University of Lethbridge with a Bachelor of Arts in English and then received a second degree with a Bachelor of Management in Human Resources. She started working at the family-owned Pass Herald in 1999 and is now the owner/ publisher. She is a municipal councilor and Vice President of the Alberta Weekly Newspaper Associa on. The Pass Herald is the second oldest business in the Crowsnest Pass and is celebra ngits93rdyear.
1 2 3
This was the clear winner. Excellent mix of ar cles related to food insecurity. Good research; well wri en. First-person accounts added to the emo on of the ar cles. Excellent use of interviews with not only those impacted by food insecurity but also those public administrators/professionals who have a hand in making change.
Consistent layout on all four ar cles ed everything together nicely. Enjoyed the intro in each ar cle explaining the series - only flaw was not italicizing the intro in the last ar cle. Excellent concept of having an accessibility ac vist personally "check out" various places. The writer also brought the accessibilityconcernstoapublicofficialforcommentattheendofeveryar cle-niceclosure.
Appreciated the structure to this series. The intro of the first of three ar cles indicated that this was a three-part series - and also teased the next ar cle. Well wri en using first-person accounts of immigrants' stories upon arrival in Halton. One downfall was referencing a report from 2016 - a lot changesinsixyears-andwithnoreferencetowhatchangesmayhaveoccurredsincethen.
There was a wide diversity of topics with strong wri ng throughout. Itwouldhavebeennicetoseebe eruseofphotostoillustratemany of the ar cles. Also, when possible, le ng the reader know they are readingaseriesonaspecifictopic(morear clesinthefuture)would behelpful.
Sponsored by: Hydro One
Pierre Pelle er is the publisher of the Delta Op mist in Delta, B.C. He has been a newspaper publisher since the late 90s. Prior to beingapublisher,Pierrewasafreelancemagazinewriter,working for such magazines as The Financial Post Magazine, Canadian Business, Harrowsmith Country Life, and CP Airlines (yes, remember them?). Pierre holds a Bachelor of Arts degree (EconomicsandHistory)fromtheUniversityofAlberta.
1 2 3
As a judge from a rural first na ons community, I appreciated the uniqueness and indigenous-based aspect of this feature. I felt the historical aspect with modern elements affec ng today's society were noteworthy and relevant, not just to this community, but to the na on as a whole. Good job!
Wellwri en.Itflowednicelywithgoodsidebars.Acommunityintereststory ofnewsworthyrelevance. Goodjob!
Not just community relevance but na onal. Story is relevant in rural communi es across the country. Goodsolidcoverage.Wri ngflowedeasilyforthereader.
KEMPTVILLE ADVANCE - JENNIFER WESTENDORP - Kept me reading. Nice wri ng style. Very relevant to the community on an important issue. An idea for a follow up ... Are the banks seeing a decline in in-person usage because they are pushing customers to usedigitalandonlineservices-thereforecrea ngtheirownneedto cutin-personserviceandclosebranchesin"costcu ngmeasures?”
I loved judging this category because it shows the issues that are at the heart of community journalism and hold importance to the newspaper’s readers. The journalists have the opportunity to delve a li le deeper, feel a li le more emo on and become true story tellers with their wri en words. The quality efforts of the writers illustrate their ini a ve to scope out the news and stories they are passionateabout.
Sponsored by: Hydro One
K-J Millar Editor, The BCK-J Millar is a mul -media journalist whose specialty is feature wri ng and covering housing issues. She loves mee ng people to capture their stories in ink and images. A tle award winner in photography she got her start in the media (pre-internet, when Tline was s ll a thing) in New Zealand working as a radio broadcaster, news editor, and photographer. Her career has gone full circle around the globe a er working in law, housing and communica ons. She is currently editor of The Northern View in the North Coast of B.C. and is a five- me BC community newspaper award winner as well as new journalist of the year with feature wri ng and photography awards. She works in tandem with her 16-year-old standard poodle Ka e Frou Frou and eight-month-oldcatSawyerwhoeditsoverhershoulder.
1 2 3
KimZarzour’spiecetakesanin-depthlookathousingissuesfacingvulnerablepeopleintheregion.Alot of work obviously went into this piece. Interviews included a caregiver, a neighbor of the problema c residence at the heart of the piece, the owner of another residence who had once led the Ontario Homes for Special Needs Associa on, and the na onal director of a client advocacy organiza on. Also, an a empt to get the problema c residence owner’s side of the story. The focus on Ray Jackson's story and his housing experience brings this home for readers. Reading the story of Mr. Jackson, who overcamemanyhurdlesinhislifeand strugglestolivewithdignityinaNewmarketResidence,no doubt shed a light on the issue for many readers.
This is a solid inves ga ve piece. Some mes those start with a leaked document, as in this case. The newspaper received a copy of a legal opinion provided to the town council regarding renewal of a forestry license that did not include an Independent Forest Audit, which had been completed in 2017 but was not posted to the province’s website un l 2021. Because of the missing audit, a firm was found to be in compliance with its forestry license based on an outdated audit. The newspaper uncovered informa on thatshould havebeenobvioustothelawyersand townadministra on -thatamorerecent forest audit than 2012 should have been available. The work of the newspaper in bringing this to light is importantforthecommunity.
A well wri en and thorough inves ga ve piece. Excellent job. This piece focuses on a hidden town council mee ng. The Ontario Ombudsman found that the council had contravened the municipal act in their ac ons. Through Access to Informa on filings, The Voice obtained emails that showed how one councilor had pushed for the mee ng to be held in camera despite reserva ons expressed by the town clerk. One of the most important roles of local media outlets is to report on local councils and ensure thatwhatshouldbedoneinthepubliceye,isdoneinthepubliceye,foralltosee.GreatJobbytheVoice ofPelham.
Kevin Weedmark Editor and Publisher, The World-Spectator, Moosomin, SKThe quality ranged in this category. From the winners, with solid inves ga ve reports, to several solid news stories that couldn't be considered inves ga ve journalism, to one piece that it's hard to believe was actually published in a newspaper. There is room for inves ga ve journalism. There is a need for inves ga ve journalism. Good inves ga ve journalism shines a light in the darkness, solves problems, moves governments to ac on and serves society. It's good to see some newspapers making a serious effort to serve their communi es with quality inves ga ve journalism.
Kevin Weedmark is editor of the World-Spectator, the Ag News, and the Plain and Valley. He started as a reporter in 1988, a er gradua ng with a Bachelor of Arts from the University of Regina. He became editor in 1990 and purchased the company in 2002. He won the Canadian Interna onal Development Agency Award for ExcellenceinWri ngonInterna onalCo-opera ontwice,andtwice won the Media Human Rights Award presented by the League for Human Rights of B'nai B'rith Canada. Once for "Freedom of Speech vs. Freedom from Hatred," examining the rela onship between the right to free speech and laws against hate speech in Canada. The other for an inves ga on into the history of the Ku Klux Klan in Saskatchewan.
1 2 3
Always nice to have a reporter put themselves in the elements for a story, and Sam Gillet does just that forastoryonthe8HoursofHur n'eventwhichsawcyclistsinvolvedingravelracingforeighthours.
Runner-upBillJacksonhadacoolidea–lookingatthedeclineoftheoutdoorarena,whicharegoingthe wayoftheGreatAukandStegosaurus.
Racisminsports...greattoseesportsreportersrepor ngonit,notignoringit.ThirdplacewenttoBarry &HeatherWrightfortheirlookatafamilydealingwithracistcommentsinminorsports.
Always an easy choice for the winner when a reporter immerses themselves in the story to bring it to their readers. The top three stories were good reads among those submi ed in the Best Rec/Sports story sec on. Good work everyone.
It has been 38 years since editor Lorne Drury (now re red) offered him his first reporter job at the Brampton Guardian, and he is s ll going like the Energizer Bunny. Currently in Manitoba looking a er the award-winning army newspaper Shilo Stag, which published its first edi on in July 1947, he's kept busy in a two-person newsroom which focuses on army life, including infantry 2PPCLI and ar llery 1RCHA soldiers. Xavier has been with the Stag for nine years and is finally set to re re in July as the 76-year-old Stag’s longest serving editor. He relocated from Vancouver Island following newspaper and radio jobs in Ontario, B.C., and Alberta. Being embedded among soldiers who are honing their figh ng skills for deployment to Ukraine or Latvia is a lot more fun than covering school board or city council mee ngs.
1 2 3
You can tell the writer of the headlines had fun with it; it shows in the crea vity and use of allitera ons. And they were fun to read. All of them were a en on-grabbers and reflected the content of the story, although with the first headline, it took a bit longer to get the connec on. Great job.
CHRIS SIMON, JANIS RAMSAY & RICK VANDERLINDE
Great word usage and crea vity. The first headline, however, is too long. What the cluck? would have beenstand-out,withtherestasasub-head,insteadofthequoteusedasthesub-head.
SARAH COOKE
All of the headlines had crea ve word usage and were intriguing enough to catch a reader's a en on, makingthemwanttoreadthear cles.Goodjob.
Good headline wri ng is truly a skill - some say an art - that is not always easy to come by. The headline writer, who o en is not the author of the story, must blend a variety of factors into a small space to create a compelling and accurate headline. What I was looking for was crea vity to a ract the reader's eye, a level of impact to get the reader to look farther than the headline, and of course, the ability to quickly capture the essence of the story in a few words and yet remain accurate and relevant to the content of the story. I was very impressedwiththequalityoftheentries,withmanyskillfullycra ed crea ve and even humourous headlines. Choosing the best was not easy.Bravo.
Marlene Eisner Editor, RENO+DECOR magazine and New Home and Condo Guide, Toronto, ONMarlene Eisner is the editor of RENO+DECOR magazine and New Home and Condo Guide, na onal magazines with local edi ons published in the GTA, Edmonton, Calgary, and Vancouver. Before movingtoTorontoin2014,MarlenelivedinMontrealandworked asareporter,associateeditor,andeditor-in-chiefattheSuburban Newspaper (1994-2007), and freelance writer and editor-in-chief at the NDG Free Press (2011-2014). She has won nine community newspaperawardsinthebestcolumncategory.
1 2 3
The Wilmot-Tavistock Gaze e told the stories of several people who had been forced to cope with the restric ons.Thesestoriesareextremelypersonalandbecauseofthis,theywerememorable.COVID-19 coverage is not just about the news, mandates and restric ons, but about how this pandemic affects people.You'vedoneanadmirablejobofshowingthistoyourreaders.
The Niagara-on-the-Lake Advance also had powerful stories, including one about a woman who was not able to return from Vietnam for nine months. The story about farmers and their efforts to support each other helped to show the psychological effects of the ongoing pandemic. The wri ng is solid here, butmoreimportantly,thestoriesarecompelling.Thisgoesbeyondthelatestrestric onsandmandates tothewaytheongoingpandemicisaffec ngpeopleinthecommunity.
The Manitoulin Expositor told how one woman with serious health problems was affected by the presence of unvaccinated health workers. Over the past couple of years, a lot of discussion around COVID-19 has been on rights and freedoms. This is a refreshing change as it shows that there are some whoareatriskbecauseofthequestforthesefreedoms.
A er three years of COVID-19 coverage, this ongoing pandemic can bewearying.Theentriesinthiscategoryshowjournalistsworkingto keep the stories up-to-date and relevant for their readers. In some cases, the coverage involves the latest restric ons and pandemic challenges. Such coverage is important, and readers need to know the restric ons in place. However, the most compelling stories involvethepeopleaffected.
John Arendt Editor, Summerland Review, Summerland, BCJohn Arendt is the editor of the Summerland Review in Bri sh Columbia. He has been working as a journalist for more than 30 years.
Indigenous horse and indigenous people are presented in a well-wri en story with good background, descrip on,narra veandresponsesforandfromtheyouthfulvisitors.Goodphotos.Theconsciousofa community kindles the conscious of a na on as the story here reflects, inspired by the plight of indigenous Canadian children forced into schools where many died, or were ejected into poverty. Well wri en, limited sourcing, but locally focused. Then, an excep onal story about an Italian author who focused on those of the First Na on saving the Canadian na on. The story focuses on an event that was to feature the author, but who died prior to the scheduled date. The a endees reflected on the inspira on the author and his book provided. Well wri en; well reported. The final story recounts the First Na on frustra on over response to missing women reports. Excellent wri ng/repor ng, focused on the community event of the day.
These stories, collec vely, provide a keen focus of integra ng immigrants within a community. Agency responses, individual responses, and individual experiences provide meaningful details for readers' consump on and an understanding of what integra on means to their lives. Good wri ng and good sourcingremainessen alingredientsforreadercomprehension.TheChronicledidagoodjobhere.
Truly a fine group of stories focusing on inclusiveness and the effect of sharing the history, the meaning, and the lives of those most affected by Canada's "exclusion" policies of the past. Each of these stories sharespersonalexperiences,andthepiecedescribingtheunifica onofpoliceandFirstPersoncultures isexcep onal.Goodwri ng/repor ng;excellentvisuals;reasonablygoodsourcing...buts llabsentof communitybalance.
VOICE OF PELHAM - DAVE BURKET & BRIAN GREEN - Maybe a small, but significant discovery of an overgrown cemetery where the community's Black residents buried their dead hides a diversity issue. The two stories here bring them out for readers to digest and understand. No Blacks now live here, but the Black heritage has placed the village on an interna onal map. With excellent wri ng and repor ng,thecommunity'shiddendiversityisexposed.
Taken collec vely, these entries certainly covered diverse issues within the respec ve communi es. Yet most entries isolated that coverage to the specific focus subject and generally did not engage the community served by the news medium. That engagement could have involved sources affected by the stories beyond the focus source. The same applies to subjects covered. Black folk featured in stories rarely had reflec ve reac on from the general community, whatever the ethnic, gender, culture or race that was factored. Yet the wri ng/repor ng, more specifically applying to each story, was mostly professional: good sourcing, clear language, generally objec ve, and a good focus. This was, indeed, a huge subject to evaluate. Every story was a winner so longasreadersdigestedthecontent.
Frank GarredRe red Publisher, The Leader, Port Townsend, Washington, US
Frank Garred began his Journalism (always a proper noun) career in 1960. He has reported for and edited daily and community newspapers since, un l “re rement” in 2002. That career included ownership of The Leader in Port Townsend, Washington and partner-owner of The Gaze e in Sequim, Washington. Meanwhile, he remains a member of the NNA (president 1993-4 & board member); ISWNE (president & board member); & WNPA (president 1974, interim manager). Since re rement he served as Journalism associate professor at two state colleges and helped found & manage a state non-profit focused on maintaining accountability and transparency among state and local government en es. He livesinPortTownsendandvaca onswithfamilyonKauai,Hawaii... o en.
1 2 3
Kristyn Anthony of the Muskoka Region's paper takes a long look at the kind of story we rarely get any perspec ve on. Six years a er an Inuk man hangs himself in prison an inquest takes place. Such a long wait and a sad, sad story about a man who might have been helped. Powerful, so this series was accorded first place. Change appears to be happening inside the prison system. Stay on the watch Kristyn.
This series covered the trial and convic on of a man deemed responsible for the gruesome murder of a local resident. Senseless loss conveyed with some power. Don Rickers also takes the me to examine theimpactuponthecommunity.Thecaseisclosed,andonemuchlovedmanremainsgonetoosoon.
Sarah Cooke reports on the death of a woman shot by not one, but two Almaguin OPP. The 'why' never comesoutinthereportthismotherwaitedsoverylongtoreceive.Whyistheques oneveryreaderhas toask.
ORANGEVILLECITIZEN–PAULABROWN-Thisstorymusthavebeen such a tough one to cover, but that is what's required of community news.
SMITHSFALLSRECORDNEWS–LAURIEWEIR- This story certainly is not concluded. Such long, long waits for jus ce to convene when four girls are looking for closure. Weir acknowledged the mental healthchallengesinherentinbeingareporter-thankstoherforthat honesty. Bravo for taking it on and finding resources for all reporters thatsufferfromPTSD.
These are not easy stories to write, much less read. So much senseless death and injury in our communi es to o en becomes added to long waits for jus ce. A great group of entries. Keep up the goodwork.
Wendy Elliott
Columnist, Valley Journal Adver ser, Annapolis Valley, NS
An OCNA judge for several years, Wendy Ellio was a reporter and editor in the Annapolis Valley of Nova Sco a for 40 years. She won regional and na onal newspaper awards and is currently a columnist with the Valley Journal Adver ser.
1 2 3
This is an example of column-wri ng 101. The author picks a topic of great interest to the community, iden fies a problem, explains the problem in a clear concise manner, offers a solu on and sums up. The wri ng is crisp and clean, includes some humour, and there are no wasted words. Bravo.
Great advice for our mes. The author of this piece gives us a recipe for coping in an engaging and concisewaywithrelevanceforallpeople.
Suzanne draws the reader in immediately with plain old-fashioned good wri ng, then masterfully pulls ontheheartstringstoinvestthereader.Intheend,shedrawsalifelessonthatallofuscantaketoheart. Greatcolumn.
MANITOULIN EXPOSITOR - HEATHER MARSHALL - Well-wri en, topical and engaging. I wanted to score this higher, but I could not get away from the fact it read more like a regular community ar cle thanacolumn.
NIAGARA-ON-THE-LAKE,THELAKEREPORT-MADDYGORDON- As topical as subject ma er gets and overall, a solid effort. Could not put it into the winner’s circle because it could have been ghter and a bit be er organized, but felt I had to acknowledge it as it was wri enbya15-year-old.
VOICE OF PELHAM - VICTORIA BALFOUR & DAVE BURKET - Really enjoyedreadingthispiecebutcouldnotplaceitintopthreebecause ofsheerlengthandformat.
Overall, there were quite a few strong entries. Unfortunately, I felt someofthestrongeronesdidn’tquitefitthecategory.
Thom BarkerRegional Editor, Northwest BC, Black Press Media, BC
A er gradua ng with a geology degree from Carleton University andtakingadetourthroughthehigh-techbusiness,Thomstarted hisjournalismcareerasafact-checkerforamagazineinO awain 2002. He quickly progressed to wri ng freelance features for various publica ons, but when he landed his first newspaper job with The Interior News in 2005, he knew he had found his calling. Since then, his career has been one of progressive advancement to the posi on of Regional Editor (Bureau Chief) for Black Press in Northwest B.C. He is the winner of numerous journalism awards, perhaps most notably the 2008 CCNA Best Feature Story award for his coverage of the in-custody death of Ian Bush and subsequent coroner's inquest. Thom believes strongly in the value of community news, par cularly in the digital era, and is happy to lend his experience and exper se to judging awards compe onsoutsidehishomeprovinceofB.C.
1 2 3
Very entertaining reads, something I'm sure many readers can relate to. And you'reright,theFlyersareaterribleteam:)
All three were entertaining reads. I'm sure your readers enjoy your work on a weeklybasis.
Great tales that should engage readers well as many have "been there, done that."Greatwork.
Judge
Brian Gilroy General Manager, Swan Valley Star & Times, Swan River, MBAll par cipants had excellent column topics and subjects, o en making me laugh out loud. I was not only encouraged by such great columns but they also made me think of ideas for my own weekly column.Inspiringandgreatreadsfromall.
I am a second-genera on newspaper publisher who, along with my siblings, currently own and operate 5 community newspapers in Manitoba. Growing up in the industry, and delivering papers from a young age, put ink in my veins. I have been working full me in the industry for 30 years now and, despite the challenges that come around frequently these days, s ll love it as much as ever. I live in Swan River, MB and wear many hats - publisher, general manager, adver sing coordinator, columnist, and feature writer for the Swan Valley Star & Times. I’m an idea guy and love to grow and evolve what we do here and have every reason to believe there will con nue to be a place for community newspapers for genera ons to come.
Well-wri en columns that flow extremely well. And the topics are compelling.
Well wri en, crisp and ght, with a really interes ng e-in with Bambi, which in itselfwasinforma ve.
Nice wri ng style - crisp and clean. I really like the COVID-19 column and how the informa on was delivered in a conversa onal way with her doctor via a compellingcolumn.
I love judging the columnist category of the OCNA because it is a category that offers such a diverse selec on of topics and viewpoints. From urban and rural lenses, writers touched on issues that varied from heartbreak to history to humour. The quality of wri ng was, generally, good, but it was also evident some columnists had much more experience than others. And, in these daysoffewerandfewerresources,Iwascognizantofthefactwriters do not have as many editors poring over their copyas they once had. That said, one recommenda on I would offer is for writers to spend a few more minutes on their columns to ensure they align with CP Style and to determine if there aren’t a few more li le darlings that could be killed to ghten up the message. Some columns were far toolongandcouldhaveusedagramma calscalpelappliedhereand there. All in all, the entries were a pleasure to read, with the bonus thatIlearnedalotaboutOntariofrommychairinB.C.
Chris
Christopher Foulds is editor of Kamloops This Week, a newspaper and website published in Kamloops, B.C., a city of 98,000 in the province’s Interior. Foulds has been editor since 2005 and spent 13 years before that as assistant editor and reporter at the Abbotsford News. Foulds won the Columnist of the Year Award in the 2021 BCYCNA Ma Murray Awards, was a finalist in the same category in 2020 and was a finalist in the 2021 Webster Awards forcolumnistoftheyear.
1 2 3
Solid piece about three York residents with concerns a er being bilked out of monies. A great example of journalism that doesn’t rely on court convic ons or press releases from the police. Good job in breaking down the “he said, she said” natureofthelackofsnowremovalstory.Astrongnewsstoryaboutaterriblesubject and topic - the loss of Parker Sheahan. Wri ng is strong, community-related, and impac ul.Tightleads,clearstories.Greatwork.
A wide variety of stories showing a strong knowledge of the different topics and styles of story. Good to see photos. They complete the package in many cases. Goodques onsfortheconvoypeopleaswell.
Lynn Steel’s story is a strong news-based story around the pandemic. Also a good seriesabout housing inthearea,and realconcernsfrommanypointsofviewand perspec ve.Greatini a vedealingwithaprovincialbody.
These are all great writers. There are only five points between first and ninth.Alltoplevelstuff!
Rob Brown is a full- me seven year managing editor who creates and produces each edi on of the Dawson Creek Mirror, Northern Horizon,andPipelineNewsNorth-anddawsoncreekmirror.ca.Prior to this Brown enjoyed a 17-year career as a news journalist and photographer across western Canada – picking up 25 or so awards for journalism, photography, layout/design and more. This includes news story of the year nods in both Alberta and Manitoba, a pair of photography of the year awards, and back-to-back special edi on awards for his work. He appears with his daughter and Dawson Creek Mirror photographer Blake in the 2020 Huey Lewis and the News music video ‘I am There for You’. He has 300 million printed bylines to his name - is a 2005 Alberta Centennial Ci zen of the Year award winner, 2017 Culture Ambassador for Northern BC, and is 2019’sonlyBronzeQuillawardwinnerinBri shColumbiafor20plus years in journalism. He has wri en/directed/produced a full-length mo on picture - Sukunka - before the eyes of film fes val judges around the world right now, and he has a talk/variety show filming now and debu ng on Op kTV in summer 2023.
SOMERVILLE
1 2 3
A powerful, disturbing photo by Steve Somerville that captures both the caring and despair in the moment, and aptly illustrates an element of the story. I understand the restric ons of using photos online but would have loved to see the photo in a larger format - perhaps that happened in the print version.
GEORGETOWN/ ACTON INDEPENDENT & FREE PRESS GRAHAM PAINE
I love the ght composi on of Graham Paine's photo-themassoffaces.Butmostofall,Ilove the colour and the way it makes this photo looklikeapain ng.
HUNT
AsweetimagebyNevilHuntthatgoes ghton the faces of the two children and captures a momentofeyecontactbetweenboyandrat.
The top three photos really stood out among entries, each doing something a li le different and providing striking images. A note: A couple of photos entered in this category were horizontals that would have been be er cropped to ver cals but were in the former format due to restric ons of many websites. This diminished the impact of those photos.
Richard Dal Monte
Freelance Editor & Writer: former Editor, The Tri-City News, Coquitlam, BC
Richard Dal Monte is a freelance writer and editor who worked in community newspapers in B.C. for 34 years — the last 19 years as editor of The Tri-City News — before his termina on during the early days of the pandemic. He has won more than 20 corporate, provincial, na onal and interna onal journalism awards individually and as a team leader and is the recipient of a News Media Canada Silver Quill Award. He now writes and edits for a variety of news organiza ons, universi es, non-profit and corporate clients. He recently began helping teach a class for editorsintheLangarajournalismprograminVancouver.
There's a story in this photo by Reid Masson. The subject at his table, the busy background, the materials of his trade - they all say something about this man and his business. And even though photos that aren't simple, that have depth and breadth o en don't work onnewsprint,thisonedoes.
Desmond Devoy captured a special moment. Thisentry couldhavebeenstrongerifthelight por on in the top le corner wasn't so blown out and if it were a li le sharper. I would have also liked to see this photo played bigger and, as I say every year when judging this category, please, please, please lose the Impac ng Your Community graphic slapped on top of the photo - it takes away from the power of the pic.
Placed and played right, Rob Perry's photo might havewonthiscategory.It's simple and strong but several factorsinthelayoutchoicesworkagainstit:its unfortunate placement buried at the bo om of the page; the cutline needlessly dropped on top of the photo; and the general hodgepodgeofafrontpage.
Outside of the top three entries in this category, there was a great deal of run-of-the-mill photography. I appreciate the demands on journalists at smaller papers – shoot, write, edit, etc. - but I would challenge them to challenge themselves to think of crea ve ways to tell their stories visually and to simplify their photography for maximumimpact.
Richard Dal MonteFreelance Editor & Writer: former Editor, The Tri-City News, Coquitlam, BC
Richard Dal Monte is a freelance writer and editor who worked in community newspapers in B.C. for 34 years — the last 19 years as editor of The Tri-City News — before his termina on during the early days of the pandemic. He has won more than 20 corporate, provincial, na onal and interna onal journalism awards individually and as a team leader and is the recipient of a News Media Canada Silver Quill Award. He now writes and edits for a variety of news organiza ons, universi es, non-profit and corporate clients. He recently began helping teach a class for editorsintheLangarajournalismprograminVancouver.
LISTOWEL BANNER
JANINE MARTIN, DAN MCNEE & MIKE WILSON
Good variety of photos; appropriate and colourful backdrop; though ul layout. Great job.
HERALD TIMES
PAULINE KERR & JANINE MARTIN
Interes ng framing of each photo along with the flowing layout and subtle backdrop make forapleasantsecondplace.
1 2 3
IRENE SCHMIDT-ADENEY, JIMMY BALKWILL, BOB HOWES & HELEN HALL
Good memories of a great day in Ayr. A few more candid photos as opposed to posed wouldhavebeennice.Greatjob.
Judge
Anthony Bonaparte
Features Editor, The Suburban, Montreal, QC
This category offered a good variety of well-done entries to choose from. Some were more elaborately presented than others, but all includedgreatphotosandcompellingstoriestotell.Whatseparated the top er from the rest was not the quan ty of pictures used, but the effort made to produce an eye-grabbing page. To the winners, andtoallpar cipants:Congratula ons!
For the past 17 years, Anthony Bonaparte has been the associate editor as well as the features editor at The Suburban, Quebec’s largest English weekly newspaper. During his almost 25 years in the industry, Anthony has won numerous provincial (QCNA) awards, as well as a North American (SNA/LMA) and Canadian (CCNA) awards for his wri ng, edi ng, and the editorial cartoons createdunderhispenname,Napoleon.
DALLAS PHILLIPS
1 2
The disappointment on the one player’s face in the forefront while the others celebrate speaks to both the jubila on of victory and agonyofdefeat.Greatshot.
THE INDEPENDENT SERVING PETROLIA AND CENTRAL LAMBTON HEATHER WRIGHT
Tough to find a sport that can capture photos like rodeo. Sit back, camera pointed and let theac onbegin.Greatshot.
Thisisalwaysoneofmyfavouritecategoriestojudge.Youcanalways count on good sports related photos, but then comes the great photos, capturing the facial expressions of some of the athletes and even fans on occasion. Great work by all photographers. Congratula onstoeveryone!
This is a fantas c shot. Great ming and great photo.
Brian GilroyGeneral Manager, Swan Valley Star & Times, Swan River, MB
I am a second-genera on newspaper publisher who, along with my siblings, currently own and operate 5 community newspapers in Manitoba. Growing up in the industry, and delivering papers from a young age, put ink in my veins. I have been working full me in the industry for 30 years now and, despite the challenges that come around frequently these days, s ll love it as much as ever. I live in Swan River, MB and wear many hats - publisher, general manager, adver sing coordinator, columnist, and feature writer for the Swan Valley Star & Times. I’m an idea guy and love to grow and evolve what we do here and have every reason to believe there will con nue to be a place for community newspapers for genera ons to come.
1 2
MARY BETH HARTILL
Great, drama c and bold postapocalyp cphoto. Would make a great poster - for people into this sortofthing.Congratula ons.
Judge
There were many great photos to choose from in this lot and quite a few of them could have easily been in the top three. Some mes it was just a ma er of distance, cropping, minor image rota on, or all oftheabove.Therewillbeanext me.Congratula ons!
Sponsored by: Midwestern Newspapers
Anthony Bonaparte
Features Editor, The Suburban, Montreal, QC
For the past 17 years, Anthony Bonaparte has been the associate editor as well as the features editor at The Suburban, Quebec’s largest English weekly newspaper. During his almost 25 years in the industry, Anthony has won numerous provincial (QCNA) awards, as well as a North American (SNA/LMA) and Canadian (CCNA) awards for his wri ng, edi ng, and the editorial cartoons createdunderhispenname,Napoleon.
MARY BETH HARTILL
Mary Beth Har ll tells a story with her photo of a protester showing off a handwri en poster. Excellent use of DOF and filled the frame. Greatjob.
1 2
GRAHAM PAINE
Grahame Paine garnered runner-up honours for his coverage on Remembrance Daylooking into the event from what's normally seen at a cenotaph ceremony. Nice composi on.
GLANBROOK GAZETTE TAMARA BOTTING
Third-place honours go to Tamara Bo ng for her truck/speeding story, grabbing the perfect artwork.
Disappointed with many of the entries in this category for Best News Photo. Lots of lazy photography. Work your news scene, like covering a fire. Look at the scene from 360 degrees. Use DOF. Fill your frame. Include second responders involved in the event. Tell a story with your news photography. Avoid grip 'n grins. Did I say fill the frame?! The winners did just that. Congratulations.
It has been 38 years since editor Lorne Drury (now re red) offered him his first reporter job at the Brampton Guardian, and he is s ll going like the Energizer Bunny. Currently in Manitoba looking a er the award-winning army newspaper Shilo Stag, which published its first edi on in July 1947, he's kept busy in a two-person newsroom which focuses on army life, including infantry 2PPCLI and ar llery 1RCHA soldiers. Xavier has been with the Stag for nine years and is finally set to re re in July as the 76-year-old Stag’s longest serving editor. He relocated from Vancouver Island following newspaper and radio jobs in Ontario, B.C., and Alberta. Being embedded among soldiers who are honing their figh ng skills for deployment to Ukraine or Latvia is a lot more fun than covering school board or city council mee ngs.
DESMOND DEVOY
Greatphoto!Itshowsthe classic grip'n'grin with the presenta on, but does it with ac on, and in a great unique way. It makes people smile and that is alsoakeyfeatureofagrip'n'grin!
RECORD NEWS DESMOND DEVOY 1 2
Niceturnonagrip'n'grin.You havetheclassicpresenta on combined with a unique way of transferring from one party to another. The nice ght photomakesforagoodchoice.
JAMES J. GREEN
This is a great shot - it tells the story of the event and who took part. A great response to the event, as shown by all the kids taking part and all the boxesoffood.
Sheena Read
Freelance Journalist, Alberta
The classic grip & grin is the presenta on of the cheque by a donor to a recipient. Tradi onally it involved the cheque with the handshake, but we can always give that a unique spin. The key behind it is to tell the story, and to convey that sense of community and community ac on. This is a great opportunity to have some fun. Be crea ve. Be abnormal. Find the strange angle. Throw in some ac on in what would ordinarily be a structured and s ll photo.
Sheena Read has commi ed decades - yikes, yes decades - to communica ons. Based in southern Alberta, she now is involved in contract messaging and promo ons, with a focus and commitment on community building. She ponders the changes in communica ons and media and what the future holds with the twists and turns of social media. Read is a strong supporterofjournalism.
Graham Paine is a master photographer whose photos tell a story in crea ve ways. Even seemingly ordinary events are presented in interes ng ways. His feature photo is very powerful and has it all. Colour, composi on, depth of field and expressions. An image that tells the story of campers having fun at their end of the week party. The diagonal of the “Orange Crosswalk” in his news photo adds to a subtle feeling of movement as the drum group moves past. Orange shirts add to the story. The community photo had interes ng composi on with the red sleigh and Santa forming a diagonal with the more monotone colours in the other half of the picture. The dual waving hands add an interes ng element to the photo. The line of bikes leading to a single, dejectedriderisastrongspotnewsphotoonitsown.Whenpairedwith the headline “Car going wrong way on busy Oakville street hits and injures2cyclists”,itmakesitaveryeffec veandnewsworthyphoto.
The Niagara-on-the-Lake community is very fortunate to have Dave Van de Laar share his passion for the region and his love for photography. Whether events, sports, or wildlife, his photos are well composed and give readers a glimpse of what the area has to offer. A very strong community photo with accompanying story shows the determina on of the child par cipa ng in the event. Low angle and good ming to capture the expression and angle of arms and legs add to the impact. A drama c feature photo of a Canada goose on take-off captured the decisive moment with the posi on of the wings adding to the symmetry of the photo, while the water splashes add to movement and breaks up the monotone background. A beau fully composed news photo with subject placement following the rule of thirds and having the swimmer’s torso break up the horizon line. The “Year in the Life” box accompanying the photo provides a nice triangle effect, helping to anchor the photo and give context. A great sport ac on capturing the decisive moment as the Thunderhawks player goeshorizontaltoscoreagoalduringalacrossegame.
Photographs are the eyes of the community. It takes thought, skill and an understanding of your subject to convey your message. Both entries showed amazing talent that is a real benefit to readers of the publica ons they are featured in.
Wayne Shiels is a photographer for Clark’s Crossing Gaze e in Warman, Saskatchewan. Originally a nature and wildlife photographer who was the outdoor photography columnist for the now defunct Western Canada Outdoors and was published regularly in numerous books, magazines, and calendars. In the past he served as a guest judge and provided cri ques for the Saskatoon Camera Club. More recently he has been a judge for the Showcase of the Arts photographycompe onheldyearlyattheSaskatoonEx.In2010he joinedtheCCGaze eteamwherehisloveforphotographyandequal loveforcommunityhaveprovidedtheperfectcrea veoutlet.
1 2 3
Vukovich has an eye catching drawing style. Clean and colourful, his classic cartoon flair delivers the message with clarity and ease, as he putssharpfocusonlocalissues.
Arnold delivers some good concepts in a clean style, somewhat reminiscent of a graphic novel look. His virtual reality concept makes a strong statement on food insecurity. Strong entry, though the lack of a suppor ng le er le me somewhat in the dark regarding some of the issues.
Radda shows good drawing ability and with that, clarity of message. The Darth Vader/mask concept is very funny. This also gives it good impact.
Therequiredemphasisonlocalissueswasstronginallentriesthis year, as was the ar s c level. For judging, it was easier to determine the impact of the cartoon in those submissions that included a suppor ng le er describing the issue to which each cartoon was speaking. This generally helpsclarify its relevance for those of us outside the par cular community. It should also be noted that while colour is not always an op on for cartoonists in their hardcopy papers, (and was not a considera on in judging), an effort to use colour will always make the cartoon more eye catching to the reader if there is an online version of the publica on.
Judge
Bruce MacKinnonEditorial Cartoonist, The Chronicle Herald, Halifax, NS
For more than 35 years, Bruce MacKinnon has been the editorial cartoonist for the Halifax Chronicle Herald. Over his career he has won numerous regional, na onal, and interna onal awards. His work has been published and exhibited across the globe, featured on a Canadian na onal postage stamp, and is part of the permanent collec ons of the Na onal Archives of Canada, the U.S. Library of Congress and the Art Gallery of Nova Sco a among other galleries and ins tu ons. He is a member of the Order of Nova Sco a and the OrderofCanada.
1 2 3
This en re edi on brought tears to my eyes. When there were no other means of communica on available, the team of the Uxbridge Cosmos went above and beyond to bring crucial informa on to its residents. What a unique opportunity for a newspaper to do what it was meant to do. I could go on and on about how outstanding the newspaper edi on is and the folks who made it happen. But just wow. Welldone.
Excellent work organizing a fundraiser for Ukraine to mark the anniversary of the Eganville Leader. Outstanding coverage leading up to and including the event. Thinking outside the borders of Eganville broughtthegenerosityofitsci zenstoagloballevel.Welldone!
Outstanding work organizing a poli cal forum to bring to local residents. Congratula ons on a successfulevent.
The entries for Community Service all went beyond the normal community service mission of the newspaper and were a pleasure toread.Ilikedhowmostentrieshadadifferentcausetosupportand enhance its community. It was also reassuring to see the global impact our smaller communi es can have. Well done and please con nuetoaimhighandthinkoutsideofthebox.
Karen Gibson Freelance Journalist, AlbertaKaren’s journalism career began in the early 1990’s with a wee Southern Alberta community newspaper (The Nanton News) a er gradua ng from SAIT’s Journalism Arts program. Being part of a small team, Karen experienced every aspect of the industry, including covering stories, adver sing sales and design, photography (as well as souping film in the darkroom and prin ng), page layout (complete with light table and wax), edi ng, stuffing flyers and delivering the paper. She le the industry in 2000 to raise her family, but s ll tries to keep her hand in journalism byfreelancing when she can. She currently works as part of a finance and accoun ng team for a large ranching/farm group of companies and is s ll an ac ve member of the small community that welcomed her as a young writer.
1 2 3
A headline that literally has 'bite'! The photo makes the most of what could have been a dull pic by drama cally changing the angle. The ads compete with the editorial content, although they are be er controlled and understated in comparison to other submissions. This story, image and strong design makethemostofwhat'savailable,otherthantheunnecessary"Impac ng"element.
A fairly clean front page, with a func onal photo, and good wri ng around a community issue. The 'Impac ng' banner should be dropped and considera on given to replacing the house ad on the right railwithsomethingofmorereaderinterestandpurpose.
It's hard to compete with major news events for 'best front page.' In this case, this is a very strong fire photo, and good headline/subdeck wri ng. Yet, this entry just missed first place due to outdated and unnecessaryelementsinthedesign.Whyputan"Impac ngyourcommunity"chevronontopofagreat news pic? Scan codes to access news in a print product was an experiment that was quickly abandoned bymostnewsagenciesmanyyearsago.Usethatspaceforthefirestory.
This category featured some great stories, examples of fine photography, and a few instances of bright, descrip ve wri ng. It also encompassed some outdated ill-considered design elements, such as a very heavy black and white "Impac ng your community" chevron commonly laid over strong photos, or on top of headlines clearly capable of delivering impact without the graphic. Also detrac ng from most front page presenta ons were the presence of excessively coloured, dominant ads, along with an quated scan codes for news or bright teaser boxes for online that contain no informa on. As a general rule, editorial departments in this category are doing their best, but are o en unsupported by clean, well-considered design. Ads on the front page are a fact of the print business, but some boundaries should be applied to let the news lead.
Andrew HolotaAndrew Holota recently re red as the editorial director of Black Press Media, the largest independently owned newspaper company in Canada, with more than 150 tles in print and online in Bri sh Columbia, Alberta, the Yukon, Washington, Hawaii, and Alaska. In his role, Andrew oversaw editorial strategies and standards, including print and digital, coordinated hiring, training, and mentoring programs for mul media journalists, and provided first-line legal advice to the chain’s publica ons. Andrew's journalism career began more than 40 years ago as a photographer. He moved into repor ng and was an editor at various B.C. community newspapers. Throughout his career, he haswonnumerousprovincial,na onal,andcon nentalawards.
1 2 3
Niagara-on-the Lake’s Lake Report edged out its nearest rival for top spot thanks to its lively and engaging wri ng. The reporters strove to be more than mere fact-providers; they put effort into their story telling.Nice,crisplayoutaddedtotheappealandallowedforacleanpresenta onofatotaloffive stories, each with reader appeal and adding to the community’s understanding of itself. Photography couldbemorecrea ve,butitsusewass lleffec ve.
The Burks Falls Almaguin News earned second place with its two strong lead stories about the outcome of a police shoo ng of a young mother, covering both the personal and legal aspects of such a tragedy. Using appealing design, the News also adds one more crime story and a story of public interest into the mix.Again,photographycouldbestrongerbuts llcontributedtoapleasingpackage.
The Listowel Banner presented three stories of compelling public interest to earn its third-place win: a major victory for a local sports team, capturing the tension and thrill of the championship game, a heart-warming story about a woman whose cancer death inspires the community to support local healthcare facili es, and a news story about a truck plowing into the side of a building. There were meswhenmoreclarityinwri ngstylewasneeded,butoverall,afineeffort.
It takes a lot to grab a print newspaper reader’s a en on in this age ofdigitalcontentthat’so enaccessiblelongbeforetheinkbeginsto hit the paper’s front page. Stories have to be engaging and offer new informa on, photos have to be eye-catching, and layout has to be crispandclean.
1 2 3
This publica on really hit all the touch points of the qualifica ons for entry: the majority of the ar cles were wri en by the paper's reporters, there were a lot of ads that were relevant to readers, and the ar cles were all relatable not only to the farming community, but also to anyone who would pick up the ver cal to read. They ranged from the prac cal and instruc ve, to stories about local farm families and theexpansionofahome-grownfoodbusinesstoonefarmthatherdsbison.Reallywelldone.
Algonquin Life is a beau ful magazine, laid out on quality ma e paper and filled with excellently photographed images and though ully researched and wri en ar cles. Although the ad-to-editorial ra o is a bit low, all of the ar cles are interes ng, informa ve and highlight the beauty and importance oftheregiontoallwhoventureintoitswildness,andtothosewhohavenotyethadtheexperience.
Cornwall Living is a beau fully laid out magazine, filled with interes ng editorial and a lot of ads. A good readthatisveryrelatabletothecommunity.Whereitlostpointswasinthelackofcopyedi ng.
This is the second year I am judging this category and I must say how impressed I was, once again, with the entries. I read through each and every one of them twice. Choosing "the best" among them was not an easy task, since they all reflected the dedica on and hard work that goes into a print magazine. However, there were a few that truly excelled, and so have been designated as the award winners.
Marlene Eisner Editor, RENO+DECOR magazine and New Home and Condo Guide, Toronto, ONMarlene Eisner is the editor of RENO+DECOR magazine and New Home and Condo Guide, na onal magazines with local edi ons published in the GTA, Edmonton, Calgary, and Vancouver. Before movingtoTorontoin2014,MarlenelivedinMontrealandworked asareporter,associateeditor,andeditor-in-chiefattheSuburban Newspaper (1994-2007), and freelance writer and editor-in-chief at the NDG Free Press (2011-2014). She has won nine community newspaperawardsinthebestcolumncategory.
1 2 3
Eganville Leader was the best in this group thanks to an array of coverage and stronger layout. But s ll could improve its community coverage. Community sports is more than hockey and recapping game scores ... especially when you are not a daily. Add more features, colour in your stories, and good ac on shots,butavoidfillingspacewithteamphotos.Letyoursportspagesbreathe!
Runner-uphonoursgotoSt.MarysIndependent.Yes,theLincolnsdominatethepages-butcommunity sports is more than hockey, and there's no need to give a goal-by-goal descrip on of every game. What about some colour in your stories? Avoid team photos ... include ac on photos! Remember in a weekly paper, your scores are old news. Broaden your audience - high school sports, features on athletes. Lots ofpoten alwiththespaceyoureceiveforsportscoverage.
The Speaker took third spot in a sec on featuring just eight submissions. Try to avoid filling sports space withgrip’n’grinsandteamphotos.Useac onforarttocomplimentthewords.
Having a long career covering daily and community sports, and laying out provincial/na onal award-winning sec ons, judging the best sports sec on always piques my interest when I start perusing the entries. Disappointed in what's happening to our sports sec ons in communitynewspapers-buriedinads,and whytheuseof grip'ngrins andteamphotos?Lazysportscoverage.Justfillspace?!Sportsisabout ac on photography, to enhance the wri en words. Speaking of words. How about some colour in the stories. And more than just hockey coverage. Yes, hockey is Canada's No. 1 sport, but don't ignore your high school sports coverage. And Ontario high schools providea sports scribe with plenty of stories to write - especially feature ar cles.
Xavier Editor, Shilo Stag, CFB Shilo, MBIt has been 38 years since editor Lorne Drury (now re red) offered him his first reporter job at the Brampton Guardian, and he is s ll going like the Energizer Bunny. Currently in Manitoba looking a er the award-winning army newspaper Shilo Stag, which published its first edi on in July 1947, he's kept busy in a two-person newsroom which focuses on army life, including infantry 2PPCLI and ar llery 1RCHA soldiers. Xavier has been with the Stag for nine years and is finally set to re re in July as the 76-year-old Stag’s longest serving editor. He relocated from Vancouver Island following newspaper and radio jobs in Ontario, B.C., and Alberta. Being embedded among soldiers who are honing their figh ng skills for deployment to Ukraine or Latvia is a lot more fun than covering school board or city council mee ngs.
1 2 3
Great sec on! The sec on pages are easy to iden fy with the matching borders and colour theme. Storiesareinteres ngandadslookgreat.
Beau ful magazine print. Very appealing and something people would pick up off the shelf. Something that most magazines include is a table of contents/teaser story list. I thought the 21 things to do was a tableofcontents-oops.Lovethelayoutandideasincluded.
Great -nicewaytocommemoratethisevent.Niceadsandgoodstories.Layoutlackscrea vity.
These are all great sec ons recognizing special occasions. Great job in alldepartments.
Amanda Zimmer is the publisher of the Claresholm Local Press and hasbeeninthecommunitynewspaperbusinessforover20yearsas agraphicdesigner.Shegainedherfirstexperienceworkinginaprint shop as her a er school job in high school. She completed her Prin ng Management Technologies diploma at SAIT. She is involved with many organiza ons within her community, such as the Claresholm & District Chamber of Commerce, the Welcoming Claresholm Commi ee, Skye-Anna Dance society board, and Summer Games Planning Commi ee. She is also on the AWNA board of directors. Amanda loves living in a small community and being a part of the connec on people have to each other through their paper. She believes the newspaper is the hub of their community and loves to see people reading and sharing it.
1 2 3
Wow! Great stuff. Loved the idea. Loved the read. Definitely stood out from the rest. I like that you explain the evolu on of this sec on, too bad you didn't break up that copy with mugs of the copublishers, but that's a minor detail. Stories are interes ng throughout. Love the fact boxes, cheat sheets, pull quotes, and efforts in layout to make the pages appealing, drawing in the readers. Nice clean layout overall. Even loved the different shapes and sizes of pics! Great variety of farming topics, too. Talk about strong ad support, with clean design for ads, too. Like the cover, but a li le disappointed to see a hanging banner on a project like this. Understand the toe lugs, but not the banner ad. Also appreciate efforts through much of it to keep a modular layout. Plus, and this has to be applauded, the kids’sec on,well,allIcansayis:"ACES!"
Very striking cover, KUDOS. Not a fan of the browning of old papers for anniversary issues, but it's not too bad here. Love the simple clear banner across. You didn't try to overload it. Some great and concise stories inside. Good clean layout and good imagery. Looks like some great ad support for the project. Too bad it couldn't be placed in there as a pullout sec on. Thanks for not only looking backwards with yourstories,oldads,andart.Youalsohavesomear clesthatspeaktopresentandfuture,whichiscool. Especially love the inclusion of the o en forgo en end of our industry - the people who get our papers infrontofourreaders-ourcarriers.Welldone!
This Christmas edi on was loaded with lots of great stories and ac vi es for the reader. There's a lot of real good ideas executed here, everything from staff tradi ons to efforts to interact with kids. The message on the front and staff pics along the bo om are nice. Liked the top graphics and most of the headline fonts. A few sugges ons. While it's nice to add in the Christmas history stories (Virginia and T'was), local copy should have lead the special sec on. I like the efforts to reach and involve children and schools, but the large le ers to Santa banners are too big. One per page would have been okay, but even that is a bit much. Graphics in the ads are strong and very fes ve and differ from ad to ad. Well done. Christmas carol pages look nice with headlines and graphics; however the lyrics are hard to read. Inclusionofpoetrywasanicetouch,too.Overall,arealfeel-goodChristmassec on.Reallywelldone.
Thanks to all the contestants in this category for all the extra effort you put in on these special sec ons. Your commitment to your readers and to your industry are apparent – and appreciated. Congratula ons to the papers that reached the remarkable 150, 155, and 160-year marks – that in itself is an incredible feat deserving of kudos. The anniversary edi ons you created helped the readers celebrate that milestone. I also salute staff at the papers who took me to honour our soldiers (past and present) with a special Remembrance Day sec on. A must for any publica on. Hats off to you for your efforts, especially those who included feature stories about locals. I have to say the sec ons that grabbed me as different and unexpected were the 11th annual Irish edi on and the Farms Harvest 2022. Unique ideas that were very well executed. Plus the Carry the Torch was a visually appealing and interes ng read. Thanks for reminding me that every story doesn’t have to be epic to be meaningful. Great design. Kudos all around! And again, thanks for crea ng some really great special sec ons. You shouldallbeproud.
Langley Advance Times, Aldergrove Star & Maple Ridge-Pi Meadows News, Langley, BC
Roxanne Hooper has been in the newspaper industry since age 15, star ng her career right in Langley – at the then Langley Advance. While she has also worked for newspapers in Abbotsford, Mission, MapleRidge-Pi Meadows,andKamloops,shehasastrongpassion for sharing stories about the people in her hometown of Langley. Needless to say, she was excited to return to the local team in 2006, as a reporter. She has since taken over the leadership role in the newsroom as group editor. She’s said she wakes up every day excited about what new challenges will befall this evolving industry and moreover what exci ng stories she and the team will find and share within their community.
1 2 3
This one stood out as a crea ve solu on for all par es. The descrip on no ng it was part of a weekly feature was also a key factor in scoring high. Niceuse of image and editorial to introduce the item with a cleara rac vefrontpage.Thelarge,cleanadsmadethemeasytouseasintended-topulloutandkeep addinglongevitytotheitem.
SMITHS FALLS RECORD NEWS
SMITHS FALLS HONOURS LPGA SUPERSTAR - BROOKE HENDERSON
A crea ve idea with the team element evident. The editorial copy was clearly wri en to the purpose and to the space adver sing allowed for. Ads are large enough and clean enough to have impact, despitesomeofthembeingtextheavy.Designrosetothechallengeonthose.
Excellenteditorial,clearlyintendedforthisusealongsidelarge,clean,andthoughtoutadver sing.
Itwasfantas ctoseesomanytrulyteamprojectsinthiscategory.
Christine van Reeuwyk Senior journalist, Oak Bay News, Oak Bay, BCA er finishing journalism school in 2002, Chris ne van Reeuwyk returned home to Vancouver Island to embark on a career. She has since worked in newsrooms from Victoria to Port Hardy and back again. A mul award winner on the provincial and na onal level, Chris ne has worked as editor of Black Press papers across Greater Victoria and now serves the community of Oak Bay.
1 2 3
You've managed to personalize the business...we get expert advice from Wally, supported by Patch. Consistent design in the three ads for this campaign, with the copy adjusted for that month's advice. Goodeffortforyourmedium.Patchwouldbeproud.
Niceuseofsomestocktemplates...withgoodplacementoftherela vea rac onsoftheevent.
ThetreatmentoftheYOGAwordheadlinegrabsa en on,andthendrawsyouintotheuniqueimageof the"onthedock"yogapar cipants.Imagineifthey'dsprungforfullcolour!
A strong crea ve ad can be put together for your customer with some simple stock images/stock illustra ons, or even a trip out to their business to take some pics (I'm looking at you Patch the Cat). It doesn't have to be expensive in produc on to work. It's going to be a tough market in 2023...let your customers know that you can create eyecatchingadswithina ghtbudget.
Wayne
Aubert Professor,Adver sing and Marke ng Communica ons Management Program, Mohawk College, ON
Wayne is a Professor in the Adver sing and Marke ng Communica ons Management program at Mohawk College. He enjoys reading his weekly Hamilton Mountain News.
1 2 3
The designer at The Lake Report newspaper wanted to celebrate with a bang and that rings loud and clear! Wow. This entry is incredible. A winning effort to highlight the OCNA awards received the previous year. The first three pages are so well planned and designed with gorgeous material showcased within the pages too. This entry is no ques on design excellence, although I feel page 4 was unnecessaryanditdidn'treallyfitintothispar cularpromo on.Reallyincrediblework!
Ilovethisad!It'ssobright,colourfulandfun!The metakenandthoughtbehindeachcommentbubble shows the commitment the designer made to knock this ad straight out of the park! The visual impact is dynamite.Whatagreatjobandfantas cwaytointroducethecommunityofFortFrancestotheteamat theirlocalpaper!ExcellentJob!
Really great job with this In House Promo on. Clean and clear and shows great promo onal pieces for the paper and pride in its community. The designer handled this with obvious skill and care. Nice work by designer and good idea by the Elmira-Woolwich Observer in general for offering local merchandise. Coolidea.
Judge
Andrea Hillo Publisher and Graphic Design, Haiburton, ONThe work produced by the entries for Best In-House Promo on were all effec ve in raising awareness for their papers. However, the top three showed design excellence and ad originality. The top three clearly took me, effort, thought, and incredible crea ve talent and vision. They clearly show pride in their work, paper and the communi estheyserve.Congratula ons!
Andrea’sdesignpassionandcrea vethinkinghaveaffordedherthe privilege of working with some of Canada’s leading forces of art and culture, including ar st Michael Dumas, author Roy MacGregor, ar st/musician Mendelson Joe, and legendary naturalist/ar st Robert Bateman. She is an award winning freelance graphic ar st and independent book publisher who has owned her own community newspaper and is a past OCNA award winner, judge, and member. Andrea has worked in the newspaper/publishing industry for over 30 years.
1 2 3
Veryclassyad!Nicelayoutandcrea veuseofgraphics.Veryeyecatching.
Lovetheuseofthepun.Greatuseofwhitespaceinkeepingthelayoutsimpleandclassic.
Nice ad. Great use of white space. I would have put the discount % in front of the store wide. I think it readsbe er.
Judge
Nice ads! Great work between the sales teams and designers to create clear,comprehensivemessages.
Sponsored by: Metro Crea ve Graphics
Amanda Zimmer is the publisher of the Claresholm Local Press and hasbeeninthecommunitynewspaperbusinessforover20yearsas agraphicdesigner.Shegainedherfirstexperienceworkinginaprint shop as her a er school job in high school. She completed her Prin ng Management Technologies diploma at SAIT. She is involved with many organiza ons within her community, such as the Claresholm & District Chamber of Commerce, the Welcoming Claresholm Commi ee, Skye-Anna Dance society board, and Summer Games Planning Commi ee. She is also on the AWNA board of directors. Amanda loves living in a small community and being a part of the connec on people have to each other through their paper. She believes the newspaper is the hub of their community and loves to see people reading and sharing it.
1 2 3
Lovethisdesign.Greatcolourchoicesforawinterad.Jumpsoffthepage.
Greatad!Veryeyecatchingandstandsoutonthepage.
Great ad for yourselves. Relevant messaging in clear, concise points. Gonna steal this idea for my own paper!
Toughtopickawinnerinthiscategory.Alladsareverygood.
Amanda Zimmer Publisher, Claresholm Local Press, Claresholm, ABAmanda Zimmer is the publisher of the Claresholm Local Press and hasbeeninthecommunitynewspaperbusinessforover20yearsas agraphicdesigner.Shegainedherfirstexperienceworkinginaprint shop as her a er school job in high school. She completed her Prin ng Management Technologies diploma at SAIT. She is involved with many organiza ons within her community, such as the Claresholm & District Chamber of Commerce, the Welcoming Claresholm Commi ee, Skye-Anna Dance society board, and Summer Games Planning Commi ee. She is also on the AWNA board of directors. Amanda loves living in a small community and being a part of the connec on people have to each other through their paper. She believes the newspaper is the hub of their community and loves to see people reading and sharing it.
1 2 3
Excellent example of the colour white bringing life to full colour. Beau ful layout shows the adver ser's products clearlyand instantly. Love the colour swatch bar running up the centre of page. Great balance. Welldone!
Nice use of colour. The bright and light copy works well to balance the black background. I like that they used a gradient yellow and red as the font colour to emphasize the business being fireplaces and grills. Nicejob.Thisadmusthavereallypoppedoffthepage!
Great use of red as spot colour. The solid black starbursts work well with the red and white. I did have to look at their website to see exactly what they sold. The ad didn't makeitreallyclear.Overallgreatuseofcolour.
NIAGARA-ON-THE-LAKE, THE LAKE REPORT - RICHARD HARLEY Crisp and cool! I feel cold looking at this ad! :) Beau fully simple and does call for immediate ac on. The adver ser must have been pleasedwiththisadrepresen ngtheircompany.Nicejob.
The use of colour can o en be tricky. Too much or too li le can make a world of difference especially when prin ng on newsprint. The top four of this category show confidence in their design choices and use colour to enhance their message, not overpower it. I liked the use of white in the winning ad, and black in the second place ad to compliment the colours being used. Nice to see a couple spot colour adstoo!Greatwork.Congratula ons!
Andrea Hillo Publisher and Graphic Design, Haiburton, ONAndrea’sdesignpassionandcrea vethinkinghaveaffordedherthe privilege of working with some of Canada’s leading forces of art and culture, including ar st Michael Dumas, author Roy MacGregor, ar st/musician Mendelson Joe, and legendary naturalist/ar st Robert Bateman. She is an award winning freelance graphic ar st and independent book publisher who has owned her own community newspaper and is a past OCNA award winner, judge, and member. Andrea has worked in the newspaper/publishing industry for over 30 years.
1 2 3
THESPEC.COM/LOCAL-HAMILTON-MOUNTAIN/HOME.HTML
Acleanwebsite.Easytonavigate,withstronglocalcontentandavarietyofothercategories.Localvideo to support stories and reader engagement opportuni es such as polls, or invita ons to contribute, wouldmakethiswinningsitemuchstronger.
CAMBRIDGETIMES.CA
Another clean website design, with content arranged in an easy to find fashion. More photos add to the appealofthislayout.
THESPEC.COM/LOCAL-ANCASTER/HOME.HTML
Third place is based on the same website template as the winners, which offered slightly stronger contentintheirentry.
Almost all of the entries in this category had well-designed websites, with some easier to navigate than others. Local content was good overall but video storytelling is integral to good news websites, so the general absence of that in the entries was surprising. Also, efforts could be made to add more reader interac vity to all the sites, such as polls,quizzesandinvita onstocontributecontent.
Andrew Holota Editorial Director, Black Press Media, BCAndrew Holota recently re red as the editorial director of Black Press Media, the largest independently owned newspaper company in Canada, with more than 150 tles in print and online in Bri sh Columbia,Alberta,theYukon,Washington,Hawaii,andAlaska.Inhis role, Andrew oversaw editorial strategies and standards, including print and digital, coordinated hiring, training, and mentoring programs for mul media journalists, and provided first-line legal advicetothechain’spublica ons.Andrew'sjournalismcareerbegan more than 40 years ago as a photographer. He moved into repor ng and was an editor at various B.C. community newspapers. Throughout his career, he has won numerous provincial, na onal, and con nental awards.
1 2 3
This is a busy website, but it's not so busy that it makes the reader want to leave. The drop-down menus are very detailed, and you can get to wherever it is you want to go quickly. Local content is front and centre, and that's key when you want people to s ck around. I chose this site as the winner because from the moment I visited, something always caught my eye that I wanted to read or learn more about. Simple websites are o en the best, but you want to give the visitor a reason to stay and play. This site doesthat.
For a publica on which depends on dona ons, this is a rather impressive opera on. I like how everything is laid out and there's a good mix of community news with sports sprinkled in. A li le somethingforeveryonewhentheylogon.Itisvisuallypleasingontheeyes,nothingoverpowering.
Really nice local sports coverage and current news that readers will see as soon as they visit. Also like the interac vity of the site where ps can be submi ed for news, community events and le ers. The le ers/opinionpor oniswherethissiteislacking,buttherestmakesupforthat.
LISTOWELBANNER-MIDWESTERNNEWSPAPERS.COM
My favourite part about this website is the amount of local sports coverage. As an old sports editor myself, that is always a big sell in a small community. People like to see that and that's from experience here in Yellowknife. Good local news content in there as well. The onlydrawbackbeingtheopinionpage.Otherthanthat,verynice.
NIAGARA-ON-THE-LAKE,THELAKEREPORT-NIAGARANOW.COM
I don't know what the site used to look like, but this was my first visit to the site and I enjoyed it. Simple is always be er and that's what you get with this site. A nice use of photography with each ar cle andaneasysitemap.Verynice.
All the entries had their own style, which probably works for their region. Some had plenty of good local content in one shot on one day, some had one or two fresh stories per day. A lot of the sites were simple in nature, which is good. The busier it looks; the more things can get lost. Most of the sites were easy to navigate and the informa on was easy to get to. A couple of the sites had news which wasoutofdatebyseveralweeksandthat’sneveragoodsign. Mytopthreeandhonourablemen onsweretheoneswhichstoodout to me as I was visi ng those sites for the very first me. Well done to youallandkeepupthegoodcommunitynewsfight.
James McCarthy Managing Editor, Northern News Services Ltd., Nunavut and NWTJames McCarthy has been with NNSL Media since 2007. He began as the sports editor and performed several other du es on the side before being gently nudged to take on the managing editor's role in August 2022. James is a past OCNA award winner for his work with Nunavut News and has won several other regional and na onal awards for his sports wri ng and event coverage.
1 2 3
Outstanding work in using online and print to cover the civic elec on. The use of podcast was able to reach a younger demographic and liked that the material was used to print opinion pieces. The produc onofthetwoshowsensuredacomprehensivecoveragefortheelec on.
A great way to approach this important & debatable topic with the support of interac ve online maps, makingthedatasupportofthestoryclearandprecise.
Great resources for the music fes vals with showstoppers, videos,and an interac ve map. Opportunity toexpandittoayearroundchannelwithinthewebsite.
All entries are massive projects which require extra prepara on, innova on and using different pla orms to a ract the non-tradi onal print newspaper audience. Shoutout to their me commitment in going that extra mile to build new digital audience, which is essen al fornewsmediaoutletsthesedays.
Alvin Chow Publisher, Richmond News, Richmond, BCAlvin Chow is the Publisher of the Richmond News and Vice President, Na onal Adver sing Sales at Glacier Media Group. He started his newspaper career at the Edmonton Journal in 1993 and over the last 30 years with various sales roles for Southam, Canwest and Postmedia. In 2016 he joined Glacier Media as VP, Na onal Sales, Western Canada and then in 2018 also assumed the Publisher role for the Richmond News. He is a member of the Marke ngCommi eeforNewsMediaCanadaandViceChairofthe Board for NABS West.
1 2 3
HERB GARBUTT, LOUIE ROSELLA & GRAHAM PAINE
First place eventually went to the Milton Canadian Champion for its clear and comprehensive coverage of four local shoo ngs: a police officer killed on break at Tim Hortons, a near-fatal car-jacking nearby, the killing of an auto shop owner and the fatal police shoo ng of the perpetrator. There were many movingpieces in a highly charged atmosphere. What made the coverage so compelling were profiles of twoofthevic ms,whichgaveshapetounderstandingtheeventsleadinguptosuchtragiclossesoflife.
BARRIE ADVANCE
JOHN EDWARDS, FRANK MATYS & SARA CARSON
SecondplacewenttotheBarrieAdvanceforitshighlyresponsiverepor ngonanaccidentthatkilledsix local teenagers. The challenge was piecing together a complicated meline of events and the somewhat bizarre nature of the accident. (The vehicle was not found for hours a er the teens were reported missing because it fell into a deep pit at a closed road construc on site.) By focusing on the vic ms,anda endingthecrashsitememorial,thetruescopeofthetragedywasmadecleartoreaders.
HOLLIE PRATT-CAMPBELL & ASHLEY KULP
The difference between third place and honourable men on was equally ght. Eventually third place went to the Carlton Place/Almonte Canadian Gaze e for its coverage of a weekend storm that downed power lines and caused widespread damage. The repor ng team sourced out a variety of people to interviewinavery melymanner.
SMITHS FALLS RECORD NEWS - LAURIE WEIR, MELISSA
NOVACASKA & HOLLIE PRATT-CAMPBELL - Honourable men on wenttotheSmithFallsRecordNewsforitsquickandcomprehensive coverage of a pre-Christmas fire that destroyed a local fire sta on. Interviewsmadetheimpactrealforreaders.
The top four entries in this category all demonstrated exemplary repor ng of both the news angles of a devasta ng community event and the human impact. Judging seesawed between all four, with narrower and narrower criteria needing to be applied to come up with a ranking. How difficult was it to get informa on? Were reporters on thescene?
1 2 3
Strong interac ve graphics and a map help guide the reader through a complex chain of events in mul ple shoo ngs. Some suppor ng video would have boosted this entry into a higher mark; however, theeffortanddesignthatwentintoenhancingthisstorymakesitthewinner.
RICHARD HARLEY &
A fairly well wri en piece, albeit with too much a ribu on to each bit of informa on. Feature writers can and should take much more narra ve freedom in presen ng facts if there is an obvious and con nuous source throughout the piece. The video is very well done, with different angles, close-ups and quote clips. Some of the segments on mushrooms just begged for descrip ve cap ons, since readerswanttoknowwhatthey'relookingat.
AMANDA PERSICO & KIM ZARZOUR
Solid inves ga ve repor ng, with the use of some slick, interac ve graphics. Video footage of the protest andsomesoundbytesfromsourceswouldhaveaddedtotheappeal.
Andrew Holota Editorial Director, Black Press Media, BCAlthough there were only a handful of entries in this category, several showedgoodcrea veefforttohelpreadersvisualizeandunderstanda story. Timelines and interac ve maps were used effec vely in a few entries, but were not accompanied by video, which would have enhanced the presenta on even more, or vice versa. There's no doubt graphics and videos are me-consuming, but they are vital online elements that invite readers to engage, spend more me with a piece, andleavefeelingwell-informed.
Andrew Holota recently re red as the editorial director of Black Press Media, the largest independently owned newspaper company in Canada, with more than 150 tles in print and online in Bri sh Columbia,Alberta,theYukon,Washington,Hawaii,andAlaska.Inhis role, Andrew oversaw editorial strategies and standards, including print and digital, coordinated hiring, training, and mentoring programs for mul media journalists, and provided first-line legal advicetothechain’spublica ons.Andrew'sjournalismcareerbegan more than 40 years ago as a photographer. He moved into repor ng and was an editor at various B.C. community newspapers. Throughout his career, he has won numerous provincial, na onal, and con nental awards.
Kids having fun can make good community stories, and knowing that video can some mes be an a erthought, I applaud the videographer for their work here. The horizontal pans, pushes, and movement were smooth and though ul, making for a comfortable viewing experience and the angle andligh ngwerewellthoughtoutandcapturedcutechildrenhavingagreat me,whichiswonderful.
Things to watch out for next me. I always look for opportuni es to maximize visual interest, so even without edi ng, it is possible to mix in medium shots and close-ups to your great wide shots. This will add variety and inten on into the video to really see the smiles and fun chaos of children and parents. This could have added some extra elements to keep audiences engaged throughout the dura on of the video.
At one point, I also saw your thumb cover the lens, which some mes happens but is definitely something to think about for next me. However, you recovered quickly, which is great. Nice job and I hopetocon nuetoseeyououttheremakingvideos.
The transition for newsrooms to incorporate video storytelling into the news cycle has been a challenging one for some, but the work in this years’ entries is proof that a great storyteller is a great storyteller,regardlessofthemedium.Congratulations!
Photo and video journalist Arnold Lim directed his first full-length feature film in 2020 and was awarded the Director’s Guild of Canada BC’s Greenlight award in 2022. He’s been a film fes val programmer for the Victoria Film Fes val and the Vancouver Asian Film Fes val and is the Execu ve Director of the Black Press Video Networks in Victoria, Canada, where he has worked for 14 years.
1 2 3
Erin Horrocks-Pope opens up in a brave account of her struggles with loneliness and depression during the pandemic, backed up with solid research and sources on the importance of pet companions in mentalhealth.Welldone.
Nathan Drescher provides a very human look at the "other side" of the war in Ukraine, the effect on dissen ngRussianstryingtomaketheirwayintheWest.Tightlywri en.
Kai Gammage provides an in-depth look at the struggle to rebound from the effects of COVID on a communitybe erknownforhighenergyandrawintensity.Greatresearch.
This was a difficult category to judge - there wasn't a weak entry in the bunch. Congratula ons to all the writers! The winners set themselves apartbythenarrowestofmarginswithjustali le"something"more.
Judge
Terry Myers Editor in chief, North Renfrew Times, Deep River, ONA er gradua ng from the University of Toronto, Terry Myers began his community newspaper career with the North Renfrew Times (NRT) in his hometown of Deep River in 1986. He later worked for the O awa Ci zen and as news editor for the former Pembroke Daily News. He returned to the NRT as editor-in-chief in 1998 and in 2017, along with two other employees, purchased the newspaper from its previous owners, the Deep River Community Associa on. He has won mul ple awards at the provincial and na onal level, including awards for news, feature, and editorial wri ng.
1 2 3
A fine story about an important global issue. I would have liked it if the lede had a stronger personal connec on(ie.men onapar cipantbynameanddescribewhythey'rethere.)
Great story about a drama c rescue with great a en on to detail. Liked that the writer captured the humandramaofinterna onalstudentsmakingadifferencehere.
This was a fun story about a fun topic. I recommend the writer remember Strunk and White's maxim: "Omitneedlesswords."(ie"ci esandtowns"notneededinparagraphone).
There is a lot of talent and poten al in this year’s crop of student journalists. I encourage everyone to never stop reading - both journalism and non-journalism sources - as this is the best way to honeyourcra .
Steve Warburton Editor, The Glengarry News, Alexandria,ON
Steven Warburton has been the editor of The Glengarry News for nearly 20 years. He has worked regularly in Canadian newspapers since 1999.
Excellentcomposi on,ligh ng, andac on.Yourphotosdefinitely tellastoryandareengaging.Welldone.
Greatac onshot.Ilovethefacial expressionsontheplayers.Itcan be difficult to get the ligh ng correct when photographing in an indoor arena, but you nailedit.Welldone.
Thephotowastakenatan intriguingangle.Theligh ngis great,asisthecolour.Veryinteres ng.
The majority of the photos entered were of outstanding technical quality. I would suggest that it is important to remember how you are framing up your photo. It is always a good idea to include more of the background than you think necessary, so when it comes me to crop it you have the ability to do so as a ver cal or horizontal photo without cu ng someone’s foot or hat off. In the cropping stage bear in mind the horizon and the ver cal lines of the buildings or other landmarks. Having a photo slightly crooked is distrac ng and looks unprofessional. That being said, cropping a photo on an inten on angle can be used for a great effect such as in the wrestling photo. Last but certainly not least, always make sure your photos tell a story.
Colleen GreenI began my career in publishing as a graphic designer in 1987. Eventually working my way up to Night Shi Produc on Manager at the Port Perry Star in 2000. In 2006 I went to work for the Scugog Standard newspaper, where I eventually became the General Manager. In 2016 I purchased the company and renamed it The Standard Newspaper. I have done everything from stuffing flyers, delivery, produc on, sales, photography, wri ng, managing and accoun ng. There isn't an area of newspaper publishing that I haven'tdone.Ilovethisindustryandtheprivilegeitaffordsmetobe apartofandpromotemylocalcommunity.
1 2 3
This Interrobang’s design is clean, with a minimalist look. It seems to maintain a posi ve, upbeat voice, with the goal of a posi ve student experience. It doesn't delve into as many serious topics as many other student publica ons do, which could be posi ve or nega ve, depending on the goal of the publica on. It has the biggest social media presence of all the finalists, with the largest number of followers. It engages with its readers, with contests and calls for submissions, including its upcoming Black History Month feature. It uses students, faculty and alumni as sources for stories, and each story comes with a writer bio, giving the reader a personal connec on to the site. There is a strong mul media presence throughout, with the use of podcasts, video and online ar cles, all supported by social media.
Torontoobserver.ca is visually a rac ve and well designed. Its interface is intui ve, and gives users mul ple ways to find each category, so they can easily find the one which suits their preference. A very well-planned, easy to navigate site. The photo choices were striking, though it would have been nice to see less stock imagery, and more from the students. Its coverage is community focused and relevant. The Toronto at 4 a.m. feature was really fascina ng! I couldn't stop reading! The students do a great job of crea ng a mul -media experience. The sports sec on is extensive and does a nice job of diversifying its coverage. Where this entry fell short was in the interac ve categories of this rubric. The school's social media feeds are spo y. The Twi er feed is somewhat ac ve, but the Facebook feed is not. There isnowaytointeractwiththesiteinanyway,otherthanacontactform.
A nice clean site, and easy to navigate for newcomers. Title page has a large number of stories, but the use of borders and categories keeps it from looking too busy or confusing. The image icons used for each story are well-sized. However, the blue italic headlines are a bit difficult to read. Once the reader clicks into a story, the large top photo adds a nice bold introduc on. However, many were missing cutlines, and had no context or source. There appeared to be some elements that would have been great, but didn't work, like the comments feature and star ra ngs. The social media feeds were easy to find, but the access to TV and podcasts were buried at the bo om, and not visible at all in the mobile version. It would be nice to see the cross-pla orm work featured more prominently, because it really adds a lot of value! The features were fascina ng. The Reckoning was a fantas c group project, and I loved reading through the culmina ng projects, to see the students dive deep into topics they're passionateabout.
Colleges and universi es are at the forefront of new technology, using online pla orms to showcase their work in new and innova ve ways. This year's nominees have shown just some of what's possible in merging mul -media and social pla orms for a full experience, capable of reaching a wide variety of users. These sites are definitely worth a look for any newsroom looking for interes ng and innova ve ways to design and u lize their own online pla orm. The future of online media is in good hands, with these nominees.
Megan Walchuk Editor, Fort Frances Times, Fort Frances, ONMegan Walchuk is currently the editor of the Fort Frances Times. She graduated with honours from Sheridan College's Print Journalism course in 2001. A er gradua on, she worked for the Burlington Post, Flamborough Post and Flamborough Review, beforetakingahiatustocareforherfamily.
The OCNA Hall of Fame Award recognizes and celebrates individuals who have made exemplary contribu ons to Ontario’s community newspapers. Inductees are respected community news professionals who have remained passionate about the industry throughout challenges, opportuni es, and changes. They are leaders who have helped community newspapers adapt and grow.
To see the full synopsis of each of our inductees, please go to OCNA’s Hall of Fame.
Michael Atkins began his newspaper career as a reporter at the Fort William Times Journal. He had found his life's work, but he le the paper shortly a er. Following a s nt at The Manitoulin Expositor, he moved to Sudbury in September 1973. At the age of 25, he was editor and publisher of the Sudbury Northern Life. At one me, Northern Life published three edi ons every week and was delivered to more than 40,000 homes, providing serious compe on for readership and adver sing revenue for Sudbury's daily newspaper. In 1980, he launched Northern Ontario Business, a newspaper which bridged northern communi es for the first me. Northern Life and Northern Ontario Business grew into Lauren an Publishing. At one me Atkins owned more than a dozen community newspapers throughout Ontario. Atkins was one of the first community newspaper publishers to embrace digital media, and in 2003 launched Northernlife.ca. The website, which won provincial and na onal awards, was rebranded as Sudbury.com in 2016. It was purchased byVillage Media in 2020. Although he was enthusias cally involved with awards programs for business and community leaders, he discouraged people from nomina ng him for honours. They did not listen. Atkins was a recipient of the Paul Harris Fellow Award fromtheRotaryClubofSudbury,anhonoraryDoctorateofLe ersfromLauren anUniversity,andthepres giousDr.FredSheridan Award from Cambrian College.
ABBAS HOMAYED, Former Publisher, Sudbury Northern Life; Publisher, Sudbury.comAbbas Homayed came to Canada in 1986 with li le money and li le English. He began his newspaper career in 1991, driving a truck delivering the Sudbury Northern Life, a er his IBM career ended in a layoff. Soon a er, he managed the circula on and distribu on departments, and only a few years later, he became publisher of the newspaper. He then became vice president of its parent company, Lauren an Publishing. As publisher of more than a dozen newspapers, magazines and journals, Homayed’s keen business sense and philanthropic ideals help to bridge businesses and non-profit. In both his personal and professional life, he shows his commitment to improving the social condi ons of his community. By harnessing the power of print and digital media as a voice for change, Homayed helped create several transforma ve ventures. He has created mentorship and scholarship opportuni es for youth, as well as several award recogni on programs to honour excellence in business, women of influence, outstanding young professionals, and communityadvancement.HomayedservedontheboardofOCNAfor15years,twoofthosespentaspresident.In2014hebecame the president of the CCNA. His newspaper and community efforts earned him the esteemed Gold Quill Award. A visionary in the evolu on of the publishing industry and a leader in the art of collabora on, Abbas Homayed models for others the hallmarks of a true community builder.
CLASS 1 (CIRC. 1,999 & UNDER)
CLASS 2&3 (CIRC. 2,000 - 6,499)
CLASS 4 (CIRC. 6,500 - 12,499)
NEWSPAPER
CLASS 5 (CIRC. 12,500 - 22,499)
CLASS 6&7 (CIRC. 22,500 & over)
CLASS 8 (College & University)
Before you know it, it will be time for the 2023 BNC Awards. The call for entries will take place October 1st to October 31st, 2023. Entries will be eligible from any member newspaper published from October 1st, 2022, to September 30th, 2023.
Watch the OCNA website and your inbox on October 1st for the 2023 BNC entry rules and criteria.
Start watching for your entries today!
JOIN US at HOCKLEY VALLEY RESORT
ORANGEVILLE, ON
November 3-4, 2023
The Ontario Community Newspapers Association (OCNA) is proud to recognize and celebrate individuals who have made exemplary contributions to Ontario’s community newspapers through our Hall of Fame. Inductees will be respected community news professionals who have remained passionate about the industry throughout challenges, opportunities and changes. They will be leaders who have helped community newspapers adapt and grow.
Nominees are encouraged from all aspects of the industry, including but not limited to editorial, advertising, publishing, production, circulation, finance, sales or design. This Award may also be given posthumously.
For more informa on on these or any other OCNA member services, please go to the OCNA website at www.ocna.org.