Ivey Business Journal - FEATURE ARTICLE
http://www.iveybusinessjournal.com/article.asp?intPrintable=1...
July/August 2010
JUST ASK LEADERSHIP: WHY GREAT MANAGERS ALWAYS ASK THE RIGHT QUESTIONS by Gary B. Cohen Gary B. Cohen is the founder of CO2 Partners, a Minneapolis, Minnesota-based executive coaching firm. This article is based on his recently published book, Just Ask Leadership (McGraw Hill). The smart, aware executive today is doing something different. He or she is asking questions. Almost like leading itself, “asking” has different techniques and styles. Readers will learn which ones are right and the best fit for them in this article.
Questions are the answer Company leaders today face new and increasingly complex problems. Most of these problems are intractable, if not, in the end, problems without real, lasting solutions. It is an extremely frustrating situation for today’s leaders, who are accustomed to finding answers and whose ability to find the right answers got most of them into leadership positions in the first place. This conundrum leaves leaders with two options: They can try to keep abreast of every issue and make the best possible decision, or they can start to ask more questions.
“Just Ask” leadership Business schools don’t teach courses on question asking, so leaders typically don’t study and analyze questions the way they would a quarterly report or a performance review. The devaluing of questions can be attributed, in large part, to our educational system. During the first and second industrial revolution, when our educational system was designed, we trained our children to be factory workers. Anything the worker needed to know beyond that education could be learned on the job, from the manager. In turn, the manager was responsible for mentoring, coaching, or developing those employees that showed interest, ability, and tenacity. The worker rarely knew more than their boss about how the business worked, since the boss had held and succeeded in most key jobs on his or her way up the organization. The Wharton School of Business opened in 1881 and, with a Masters of Business and Administration, graduates could jump past the factory floor right into management. But even with this development, those at the top of the organization usually had more knowledge than those underneath. The same can’t be said now, at least with any degree of certainty. Technology has put knowledge in the hands of anyone with access to a computer (approximately 76 percent of the U.S. population). In the 21st century, it’s not possible for leaders to be know-it-alls, nor is it in their or the organization’s best interest to try. Leaders need to ask questions that move others to action and answers. The employees that work for you today either know more than you do about their job or at least they should know more than you. As you move up the ranks of an organization or migrate up the ranks by job transfer, you will end up leading people that do things you cannot possibly understand. Rather than using a conventional way of getting up to speed, say reading extensively, leaders should use questions to increase others’ alignment, engagement, and accountability.
1 of 6
8/11/10 4:46 PM
Ivey Business Journal - FEATURE ARTICLE
http://www.iveybusinessjournal.com/article.asp?intPrintable=1...
“Just Ask” Leadership isn’t simply about asking more questions; it’s about asking more and better questions. “Just Ask” leaders are aware of the full range of options, their own question-asking proclivities, and the ways in which they can and ought to trust members of their team.
Moving from knowing to not knowing One of the most difficult challenges you have as a leader is to accept that you may not know what is right, or best, for most situations. You’re accustomed to having the right answers, so it’s hard to let go of the answer-providing habit. However, it’s also important to recognize how much and how fast things change. Even if you’ve spent your entire career with the same organization, it was nearly impossible to have kept up with all the changes. There are different players, different scales and different competing environments. The answers you knew to be true or the best might not even be relevant anymore. Just Ask leaders are comfortable with Not Knowing. When they ask a question, it’s because they are genuinely interested in learning the answer—both in how it meets their expectations and how it diverges. Just Ask leadership is not built around the Socratic Method. Plato suggests that Socrates did not know the answers to the questions he asked. I never bought that argument, nor should you. If you have been using this questioning method at work, please do yourself a favor and stop. Many smart employees can see right through it as just another a technique. They do not like playing cat and mouse with you. If you know the answer that you want them to arrive at, tell it to them. Bear in mind, though, that it’s generally more advantageous to doubt that you know the answer and to ASK. Asking allows others to engage in independent and creative thought. It promotes accountability when your team members are held responsible for their decisions. And your team members will be more engaged in the outcome if they have a hand in decision-making. Keep in mind that if you provide the answer (even if it’s the best one or the one they would have arrived at eventually), team members might not execute the solution as well as they would if they owned the decision. Exceptional leaders today swallow their egos and ask. That’s because exceptional leaders realize that leadership comes from developing others’ egos, not their own.
History is not always a good teacher What we believe to be the truth is often a product of having a bias. There are five biases that can unduly influence leadership and decision-making:
1. Negative bias: When you have a negative experience, it has a larger impact on your
2. 3. 4.
5.
memory and leads you to believe that certain roads are to be avoided, to a greater degree, than a quantitative analysis would demonstrate. Frequency bias: When you hear or see something repeatedly over time, you will be more inclined to believe it. Recent Bias: When making a decision, something you learned just recently will often carry more weight than information you learned a while ago. Attachment bias: Leaders can very easily become overly conservative and avoid making the right decision, simply because they don’t want to disrupt the status quo, which they helped achieve. Escalation bias: When you start down a path, you look for evidence to support your direction and at your peril, choose to ignore warning signs.
While a “Not Knowing” approach can help eliminate many of these biases, what about the questions themselves? How might our questions be biased?
Four styles for asking questions In studying questions—the impetus for them and the results they achieved—I identified four distinct question-asking styles: Professor, Judge, Innovator, or Director. When asking a question, leaders generally attempt to gain knowledge or move others to action, expand their perspective or evaluate
2 of 6
8/11/10 4:46 PM
Ivey Business Journal - FEATURE ARTICLE
http://www.iveybusinessjournal.com/article.asp?intPrintable=1...
what is known, and focus on the present or the future. PROFESSOR
Focus
Value of Style
Knowledge Gaining Perspective Present Time
JUDGE Knowledge Evaluate Present Time
INNOVATOR Action Gaining Perspective Future
Gaining
Analyzing and
Exploring new
knowledge
prioritizing ideas
directions
Expanding insight
Reaching decisions, agreements, or
Identifying
Generating ideas Building broad understanding
commitments Focusing shared understanding
opportunities Improving current methods Innovating solutions Rallying the team
DIRECTOR Action Evaluate Future Motivating the team to achieve specific goal or task Implementing the plan Focusing to accomplish results
to the cause
When to Use
When needing to better understand
When assessing
When setting
alternatives
direction
When implementing
a situation
When determining
When encouraging
clear goals
When going too fast and jumping
priorities
possibilities
When identifying
When new behavior
When needing to achieve specific
key themes
is desired
When refining
When working
ideas
around barriers
When synthesizing
When pushing
information
beyond status quo
When evaluating When defining
When energizing people to reach
options
further
too quickly When exploring new ideas When promoting creativity When brainstorming all potential possibilities
results When identifying next steps (whatwho-by when) When moving the team to act on a plan When creating a task tension to get action moving
When identifying potential factors related to the issue
Business Need
What Happens If Over-Used
Strategy Building
Decision Making
Visioning
Problem Solving
Negotiation
Performance
Motivating
Performance
Preparation
Review/Hiring
Employees
Management
May not reach conclusions (analysis
May stifle creative thinking missing
May change course
May implement the wrong things
best solution
paralysis)
May not get plan
May not initiate
implemented
May rush to action resulting in more time re-doing (“Ready- Fire-Aim�
plan
frequently
well May perpetrate outdated processes
mentality)
Negative of Style
Condescending
Disapproving
Abdicate control
Micro manage
Sample Questions
What's the goal?
Whose decision is it?
What would you do if time and funds
When is a
What are your options?
What's the most important consideration
were unlimited?
Do you understand the key drivers of the
What are the alternative
3 of 6
What is your recommended way
decision due?
8/11/10 4:46 PM
Ivey Business Journal - FEATURE ARTICLE
PROFESSOR
http://www.iveybusinessjournal.com/article.asp?intPrintable=1...
JUDGE
INNOVATOR
DIRECTOR
choices being
here?
forward?
outcome for the
considered? current reality?
sense to you?
How could I support moving forward on that
situation?
What's the
Which option makes the most
What other approaches have
What are the consequences of
you tried?
the choices?
Is there another choice that hasn't been considered
What conclusions have you reached
yet?
Are your choices mutually
How have you taken emotion out of the decision?
so far?
exclusive? What's the biggest risk? Are the risks for each alternative manageable?
decision?
If you make the wrong decision is it easily
Is there anything I can do, add, or absolve you of that will make this easier for you to
reversible?
decide? What does your gut
What needs to happen for that to
tell you to do?
succeed?
What is holding you back from making
Do you feel you have my support and the support of the rest of the
this decision? What will the end result be?
Is this close to a 50 - 50 decision and if so, should we flip a coin?
team?
What decision making process have used to get to the point you're at now? Have you weighed the pros and cons of each option? What is the greatest possible success? Are you struggling because of things that are knowable (info, facts) or unknowable? Will others follow you? What's your biggest fear about making this decision?
Of course, not all leaders fall perfectly into one of the four categories. You may be a cross between a Judge and a Director or, at times, consider yourself more of a Professor. What matters is that you recognize these shifts and your proclivities, and learn how you can address any imbalances. Knowing your predominant style can help you better frame questions, based upon the task and your goals. If you would categorize yourself as a Professor, for instance, and you’re engaging in performance reviews, you ought to put on your Judge hat and ask more Judge-style questions than might not occur to you instinctively. It’s important to know and use questions that will help you and others achieve your respective goals. Bear in mind, though, that the same questions might not work equally well for all team members.
The Seven C’s of trust Chances are that you don’t ask each team member the same set of questions. Based upon their
4 of 6
8/11/10 4:46 PM
Ivey Business Journal - FEATURE ARTICLE
http://www.iveybusinessjournal.com/article.asp?intPrintable=1...
skills and past experience, you customize your questions. Yet you might not be very intentional about the process—since question asking is viewed more as an art than a science. It pays to vary the wording of questions. If you ask a team member the same questions over and over, you’re likely to wind up with the same answers—creating a frustrating cycle for everyone involved. One of the reasons we avoid asking specific team members certain questions or hardly any questions at all is due to trust. If we don’t trust them, what’s the point of asking for their input? It’s a mistake, though, to think of trust in general terms. I’ve identified seven aspects of trust (the 7 C’s) that may explain why your relationships with direct reports is either succeeding or failing:
1. Capability: Has the skill and ability to do their job well 2. Commitment: Has the level of desire and focus toward the team’s efforts 3. Capacity: Has the time, energy, and personal management skills to complete what needs to 4. 5. 6. 7.
be done well and on time Connection: Has the resources to complete the work that needs to be done Commonality: Shares interests that help build and extend the relationship Consistency: Has a strong track record of success and acts in a predictable fashion Character: Has integrity
Questions will come easily when you trust others. Often the issue of trust has little to do with the follower and more to do with the leader. Here’s a way to determine if the problem lies with you: Do all or most of your direct reports share one or more of these 7 C’s? The extent to which this commonality exists likely has more to do with how you perceive the world rather than how these traits show up in the world. If this is the case, you will need to work on correcting underlying assumptions. Trust is essential to Just Ask Leadership. Delve deeply into the level of trust you have with each team member. Work on the C’s that they aren’t excelling in and commend them for the C’s on which you have come to rely. Good questions generate thought, focus, and action from the listener. They also convey respect. Maybe that’s why 95 percent of leaders prefer to be asked questions, rather than be told what to do. And yet, according to a survey I conducted, these same leaders give instructions 58 percent of the time, rather than ask coworkers for their input! It’s time for leaders to practice the type of leadership they most prefer themselves. If you want to lead and motivate others, questions are the answer. Question asking may be an art, but if you approach it as a science, your questions and leadership will improve. Reprint: 9B10TD04 Order a reprint of this article
Comment on this article
Read Responses
About the Author Gary B. Cohen
Gary B. Cohen is the founder of CO2 Partners, a Minneapolis, Minnesota-based executive coaching firm.
Graphical Version
5 of 6
8/11/10 4:46 PM
Ivey Business Journal - FEATURE ARTICLE
http://www.iveybusinessjournal.com/article.asp?intPrintable=1...
Return to Home Adobe Acrobat Reader is required to view articles on this site. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy
Š 2002 Ivey Business Journal
6 of 6
8/11/10 4:46 PM