CSN-0921 by ensembleiq

W H AT ’ S N E X T I N C O N V E N I E N C E A N D F U E L R E TA I L I N G

WE EVEN CRUSHED THE

BEVERAGE BRANDS #1 NEW PRODUCT PACESETTER

FOR C-STORES IN 2020

SEE YOU AT BOOTH #2134

NACS 2021 | October 5–8 | Chicago For Trade Purposes Only. ZYN is the top ranked new product launch in the convenience store channel in 2020, according to IRI’s New Product Pacesetters. Find us online at ZYN.com. ©2021 Swedish Match North America LLC

SEPTEMBER 2021

MORE CHOICE FOR THEM M E A N S M O R E P R O F I TS F O R YO U MSA Share Recent 26 Weeks*

19%

Brand A 14%

49% Brand B 11%

Brand C 6%

LET YOUR CUSTOMERS CHOOSE

ZYN 3 MG or ZYN 6 MG CALL 800 - 367 - 3677 OR CONTACT YOUR SWEDISH MATCH REPRESENTATIVE FOR ADDITIONAL DETAILS *MSA NP Category Volume Recent 26 wks 4/11/21. For Trade Purposes Only. ©2021 Swedish Match North America LLC

Convenience Store News September 2021

W H AT ’ S N E X T I N C O N V E N I E N C E A N D F U E L R E TA I L I N G

The convenience channel has long been criticized for being a follower rather than a leader when it comes to innovation, but it stands poised to lead once the COVID cloud clears.

BEST NEW PRODUCTS OF THE YEAR Volume 57, Number 9

SEPTEMBER 2021

CSNEWS.COM

Local, State and Federal tobacco taxes and restrictions on the sale of tobacco products can hurt your business. Governments often pass new laws quickly, so you need to stay informed about what is happening in your area. You and your business matter and making your voice heard is crucial to our success in fighting for fair tobacco policies.

Take this survey to learn more about how you can get involved

TAKE SURVEY CLICK HERE

VIEWPOINT

C-stores Moving to Forefront of Business Innovation Convenience retailers are evolving successfully to meet the post-pandemic future A YEAR AGO, the nation’s convenience retailers were facing an uncertain future. Fuel sales had cratered due to the shutdowns enacted nationwide to slow the spread of the COVID-19 virus. Store traffic was down, and foodservice sales were hit particularly hard by pandemic safety restrictions. Yet, I pointed out then that innovation would carry retailers through the crisis.

A year later, business is improving for most c-store retailers, although you cannot say things are back to normal. Despite the availability of vaccines that have proven to be extremely effective against the COVID-19 virus and its variants, infection rates have risen in many regions of the country, and some areas are dealing with a return to difficult-to-enforce mask mandates. Nevertheless, if innovation got the industry through the nadir of last year’s business conditions, I’m convinced it will do likewise in the coming year. Our cover story (see page 32) proves that point. The convenience channel’s ability to innovate was especially visible during the pandemic. Scott Hartman, president and CEO of Rutter’s, told me that the industry did things faster and better than most any other business during COVID-19. He pointed to the changes in regulations, customer habits, and supply chain challenges that faced the industry. “While other industries simply closed, limited hours, cut out inside

seating and sales, we adjusted in ways many thought impossible. Not only did we step up and stay open, but we were a huge winner for our customers and investors,” Hartman noted. The pandemic sped up testing and implementation of technology, too. Check out the 2021 Convenience Store News Technology Study (page 108) to see how retailers are investing their tech dollars today and what they plan to focus on in the near future. From making pandemic-inspired menu changes to utilizing new technology, the nation’s top food-forward convenience retailers also demonstrated remarkable innovation over the past year. Being able to turn on a dime and succeed, during a global pandemic, is the definition of innovation. Check out this year’s CSNews Foodservice Innovators Awards winners and read how they did it (page 76). And although dealt enormous supply chain challenges that continue today, industry suppliers rose to the occasion as well. Brand marketers correctly anticipated that consumers’ thirst for healthier products would only increase during the pandemic. See the innovation exhibited by the 44 products recognized in our 25th annual Best New Products Awards (page 52). As the COVID-19 cloud clears — and operators assess the new normal — the c-store industry stands poised to lead the future of retail, both in-store and on the forecourt. For comments, please contact Don Longo, Editorial Director, at (201) 855-7606 or dlongo@ensembleiq.com.

EDITORIAL EXCELLENCE AWARDS (2013-2021)

EDITORIAL ADVISORY BOARD Brett Atherton Bolla Management

2021 Jesse H. Neal National Business Journalism Award Finalist, Best Infographics, June 2021

2018 Jesse H. Neal National Business Journalism Award Finalist, Best Editorial Use of Data, June 2017

2013 Jesse H. Neal National Business Journalism Award Best Single Issue, October 2012

2013 Jesse H. Neal National Business Journalism Award Finalist, Best Profile, August 2012

2020 Eddie Award, Folio: magazine Business to Business, Retail, Series of Articles, September 2019 2018 Eddie Award Honorable Mention, Folio: magazine Business to Business, Retail, Website Business to Business, Retail, Full Issue, October 2017 Business to Business, Editorial Use of Data, June 2017

Rick Crawford Green Valley Grocery

2017 Eddie Award, Folio: magazine Winner, Business to Business, Retail, Single/Series of Articles, May 2017 Honorable Mention, Business to Business, Retail, Single/Series of Articles, June 2016

Edward Davidson ER Davidson & Associates (7-Eleven Inc., retired)

2016 Eddie Award Honorable Mention, Folio: magazine Business to Business, Retail, Full Issue, October 2015 Business to Business, Retail, Single/Series of Articles, August 2015 2016 American Society of Business Press Editors, National Azbee Awards Gold, Best How-To Article, March 2015 Bronze, Best Original Research, June 2015 2016 American Society of Business Press Editors, Midwest Regional Azbee Awards Gold, Best How-To Article, March 2015 Silver, Best Original Research, June 2015

2015 Eddie Award Honorable Mention, Folio: magazine Business to Business, Retail, Single Article, February 2014

2013 American Society of Business Press Editors, Midwest Regional Azbee Awards Bronze, Best Editorial/Commentary, July 2012

Jim Hachtel Eby-Brown Co.

2014 Eddie Award Honorable Mention, Folio: magazine Business to Business, Retail, Full Issue, October 2013 Business to Business, Retail, Single Article, February 2013

Chris Hartman Rutter’s

2013 Eddie Award Honorable Mention, Folio: magazine Business to Business, Retail, Full Issue, October 2012

Ray Johnson Speedee Mart

2015 American Society of Business Press Editors, National Azbee Awards Silver, Best Profile (long form), February 2014 2015 American Society of Business Press Editors, Midwest Regional Azbee Awards Gold, Best Special Supplement, November 2014 Silver, Best Profile (long form), February 2014

Laura Aufleger OnCue Express

Robert Falciani ExtraMile Convenience Stores Ruth Ann Lilly GPM Investments Vito Maurici McLane Co. Inc. Matt Paduano Lakeport Markets Jonathan Polonsky Plaid Pantries Inc. Greg Scriver Kwik Trip Inc. Bill Stein Core-Mark Roy Strasburger StrasGlobal

Jack Lewis GPM Midwest

2020 Trade Association Business Publications Intl. Tabbie Awards Honorable Mention, Best Single Issue, September 2019 2016 Trade Association Business Publications Intl. Tabbie Awards Silver, Front Cover Illustration, June 2015

S E P T E MB E R

20 21

Convenience Store News

CONTENTS SEPT 21

VOLUME 57 N UMB ER 9

COVER STORY PAGE 32

FEATURES

DEPARTMENTS

COVER STORY

VIEWPOINT

32 Stepping Up The convenience channel has long been criticized for being a follower rather than a leader when it comes to innovation, but it stands poised to lead once the COVID cloud clears. FEATURE

52 A Healthy Dose of Innovation Health and wellness is a common theme among this year’s Best New Products Awards winners. FEATURE

116 The NACS Show Is Back The convenience store industry’s premier expo is ready to resume course.

3 C-stores Moving to Forefront of Business Innovation Convenience retailers are evolving successfully to meet the post-pandemic future.

122 Foodservice First FriendShip Kitchen is making an impact in the competitive Columbus market. INSIDE THE CONSUMER MIND

146 Serving the Customer Fueled by the pandemic, the world of c-store services has significantly expanded.

8 CSNews Online 18 New Products SMALL OPERATOR

25 The Art of the Steal: Part 1 Minimize employee theft by letting your staff know that you’re paying attention to the details. NEW HORIZONS

120 The Myth of the Critical Female Boss Banishing this stereotype is a key step to advancing women to leadership roles.

4 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

STORE SPOTLIGHT

CONTENTS SEPT 21

VOLUME 57 N UMB ER 9

8550 W. Bryn Mawr Ave., Ste. 200, Chicago, IL 60631 (773) 992-4450 Fax: (773) 992-4455 www.csnews.com

BRAND MANAGEMENT Vice President/Group Brand Director Paula Lashinsky (917) 446-4117 plashinsky@ensembleiq.com EDITORIAL Editorial Director (201) 855-7606

Don Longo dlongo@ensembleiq.com

Editor-in-Chief (201) 855-7608

Linda Lisanti llisanti@ensembleiq.com

Senior News Editor (201) 855-7618

Melissa Kress mkress@ensembleiq.com

Senior Editor (201) 855-7619

INDUSTRY ROUNDUP

CATEGORY MANAGEMENT

10 Convenience & Fuel Retailers Begin to See Impact of Outdoor EMV Liability Shift

FOODSERVICE

12 U.S. Senate Passes $1T Infrastructure Bill

76 Overcoming Adversity With Innovation For a third time, Rutter’s leads this year’s slate of Foodservice Innovators Awards winners.

14 Eye on Growth 14 Fast Facts 16 Retailer Tidbits 16 Supplier Tidbits TECHNOLOGY 108 Putting Technology in the Forefront Retailers are making plans to increase their tech investments and improve everything from data security to the customer experience.

FOODSERVICE

84 Barbecue Trends The protein-driven category continues to innovate into new formats and flavors. TOBACCO

88 Oral Testimony C-stores can do more to elevate modern oral products to their full backbar potential.

Angela Hanson ahanson@ensembleiq.com

Managing Editor (201) 855-7604

Danielle Romano dromano@ensembleiq.com

Contributing Editor (303) 741-3377

Renée M. Covino reneek@aol.com

Contributing Editor (201) 280-2614

Tammy Mastroberte tmastroberte@gmail.com

ADVERTISING SALES & BUSINESS Associate Brand Director & Northeast Sales Manager (774) 212-6455

Rachel McGaffigan rmcgaffigan@ensembleiq.com

Associate Brand Director & Western Sales Manager (330) 840-9557

Ron Lowy rlowy@ensembleiq.com

Associate Publisher & Midwest Sales Manager Kelly Fischer (773) 992-4464 kfischer@ensembleiq.com Account Executive & Classified Advertising Terry Kanganis (201) 855-7615 tkanganis@ensembleiq.com Classified Production Manager Mary Beth Medley (856) 809-0050 marybeth@marybethmedley.com EVENTS Executive Vice President, Events & Conferences Ed Several (860) 830-8321 eseveral@ensembleiq.com AUDIENCE List Rental (914) 309-3378

MeritDirect Marie Briganti

Subscriber Services/Customer Care TOLL-FREE: (877) 687-7321 FAX: (888) 520-3608

contact@csnews.com

PROJECT MANAGEMENT/PRODUCTION/ART

GROCERY

98 Remaining Relevant The grocery categories at c-stores benefited from consumers’ pandemic-influenced shopping shifts, but can the momentum last?

Vice President, Production (877) 687-7321 Creative Director (973) 607-1320

Derek Estey destey@ensembleiq.com Colette Magliaro cmagliaro@ensembleiq.com

Advertising/Production Manager (773) 992-4418

Ed Ward eward@ensembleiq.com

Art Director (973) 607-1321

Lauren DiMeo ldimeo@ensembleiq.com

CBD

102 CBD in the C-store While product popularity continues to shift, c-stores are still primed to benefit from this category.

CORPORATE OFFICERS Chief Executive Officer Jennifer Litterick Chief Financial Officer Jane Volland Chief Innovation Officer Tanner Van Dusen Chief Human Resources Officer Ann Jadown Executive Vice President, Events & Conferences Ed Several Senior Vice President, Content Joe Territo

CONVENIENCE STORE NEWS AFFILIATIONS Premier Trade Press Exhibitor

The contents of this publication may not be reproduced in whole or in part without the consent of the publisher. The publisher is not responsible for product claims and representations.

Convenience Store News (ISSN 0194-8733; USPS 515-950) is published 12 times per year, monthly, by EnsembleIQ, 8550 W. Bryn Mawr Ave., Ste. 200, Chicago, IL 60631. Subscription rates: Subscription rate in the United States: $125 one year; $230 two year; $14 single issue copy; Canada and Mexico: $150 one year; $270 two year; $16 single issue copy; Foreign: $170 one year; $325 two year; $16 single issue copy; Digital One year, digital $87; two year, $161. Periodical postage paid at Chicago, IL 60631, and additional mailing addresses. Copyright 2021 by EnsembleIQ. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording, or information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. Reprints, permissions and licensing, please contact Wright’s Media at ensembleiq@wrightsmedia.com or (877) 652-5295. POSTMASTER: send address changes to Convenience Store News, 8550 W. Bryn Mawr Ave. Ste. 200, Chicago, IL 60631.

6 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

No matter what your customers’ lighting needs are, BIC® has you covered. Now, with the innovative BIC® EZ Reach™ and a host of fresh designs, BIC® Lighters are your #1 choice for safety, quality, and sales!1 2

VISIT

NACS SUS AT BOOTH HOW 2110

Source: Lighter A&U, Hanover Research 2020 Source: Information Resources, INC. C-MULO 52 weeks as of 27-JUN-21

BICLIG1002100116_BIC_NACS2021_TradeAds_Profitability_CSN_8x10-75_FNL.indd 1

8/4/21 10:27 AM

CSNEWS ONLINE

SPONSORED CONTENT

PRIMED FOR PICKING:

Crisp Green Apple Joins Escapes Spiked Fall Lineup This September, Seagram’s introduced a new flavor to its line of Escapes Spiked premium malt beverages. Crisp Green Apple joined Jamaican Me Happy®, Blue Razberry and Strawberry Blast flavors — all boasting a customer-pleasing 8% ABV. Convenience Store News dives into the details to show why c-stores should carry these refreshing malt beverages that appeal to consumers who want a higher alcohol product that doesn’t compromise the flavors they love.

GREAT C-STORE PERFORMANCE

FRUIT-FORWARD FLAVORS

The high ABV segment is growing…and Escapes Spiked is primed to help c-stores drive sales in the category.

Flavor is the #1 DRIVER OF PURCHASE for FMB products. These DELICIOUS FRUIT FLAVORS have helped the Escapes Spiked become the #4 high ABV FMB singles brand contributing to growth in the total U.S.4

• 1 in 4 singles going out the door is a traditional FMB at c-store. • Traditional FMB singles are growing 50% faster than the remaining category. • Traditional FMB singles deliver 50% more $ per point of distribution than hard seltzer singles and 100% more than craft singles yet are losing space to those segments.1 • The High ABV FMB segment accounts for 42% of FMB volume in c-store. • It’s a brand extension of the highly popular, lower ABV Seagram’s Escapes drinks — products that have experienced 10 consecutive years of sales growth. • It’s the #6 BEST-SELLING High ABV Brand in the total U.S. convenience channel.2 • Green Apple was the #3 High ABV flavor and is growing 3x faster than the category.3

NEW THIS FALL: Spiked Crisp Green Apple A crisp burst of green apple flavor with a tart, refreshing finish — an electric combination of sweet and sour that’ll keep your customers coming back for more! Spiked Jamaican Me Happy A classic blend of watermelon, guava, lemon and strawberry flavors Spiked Strawberry Blast Jam-packed with juicy strawberry flavors Spiked Blue Razberry A burst of raspberry flavor, with a lingering sweet berry finish — ranked the #2 most preferred flavor among consumers who drank a high ABV FMB in the past three months, coming in at the #1 most preferred flavor among males and #3 most preferred flavor among females in primary research.5 23.5oz cans available nationally. 16oz cans available in FL, LA, MO, MS, & WI

When you carry Escapes Spiked, you can tell your customers… “They’re right inside, go grab one—you’ve earned it.”

For more information on Seagram’s Spiked line, visit www.seagramsescapes.com 1. IRI Unify, Total US MULO, FMB, Sub Brand Family, Brand extension, Total High ABV FMB by Flavor, High ABV FMB 16-24oz Singles, Latest 52 WE 2/2/20, $, $ CYA, $ % CYA, $ Share of Segment 2. IRI Unify, TTL US Conv, Traditional FMB, 7.0-9.9% ABV, Brand Family, Sub Brand Family, Brand Extensions, Vol, Vol CYA, Vol % CYA, Avg Weekly CWD, Avg Weekly CWD CYA, Avg Weekly Vol Per Pt CWD, 2015-YTD 2021 WE 02.28.21 3. Qualtrics Survey March 2020; P3M High ABV FMB Consumers, Total US, Non-rejectors of Seagram’s Escapes Spiked, n=218 4. IRI TTL US CONVENIENCE 26 WEEKS ENDING 8-8-21, HIGH & BOLD ABV $ SALES BY FLAVOR 5. IRI TTL US CONVENIENCE 26 WEEKS ENDING 8-8-21, SINGLES VELOCITY & ROS BY SEGMENT

COVER STORY

in the channel in the future and what’s exciting is that it ultimately expands the addressable market,” he said. “For instance, Choice operates in the c-store, fast-casual and grocery channels, which aggregate more than $1.4 trillion. I think that’s exciting for a retailer that’s in the c-store channel because it’s not seen through the lens of ‘I want to take more pieces of the pie,’ but [rather] ‘I want to grow the pie that me as the operator can address.’” Omnichannel will play a quintessential role in Choice’s future, Fogarty shared with CSNews. This will include new formats, although the retailer isn’t prepared to divulge any specific details yet. In the meantime, Choice recently entered into a partnership with WeStock, whereby customers can scan a QR code and request products. The retailer has a few shelves dedicated to crowd stocking where customers determine what is being stocked there. “The idea of personalization and customization and allowing customers to drive our merchandising decisions is really powerful and is an area of focus we will continue to lead with in the future,” Fogarty said. Because the pandemic forced convenience

46 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

TXB approaches innovation with guest experience as its top priority.

ORGANIC CERTIFIED

Award Winning Fruit & Vegetable Shot

Vitamin A, C, D, B6 and B12 Organic Orange Juice, Organic Erythritol, Organic Coconut Water, Organic Superfood Blend (Organic Apple [Fruit pulp], Organic Beet, Organic Carrot, Organic Spinach, Organic Broccoli, Organic Tomato, Organic Kale, Organic Cabbage, Organic Parsley Leaf,Organic Brussel Sprouts, Organic Green Bell Pepper, Organic Cucumber, Organic Celery, Organic Garlic, Organic Ginger Root, Organic Green Onion, Organic Cauliflower, Organic Asparagus, Organic Pea, Organic Strawberry, Organic Tart Cherry, Organic Blackberry, Organic Blueberry, Organic Raspberry, Organic Banana, Organic Rice), Natural Flavors, Organic Stevia Leaf Extract, Xanthan Gum, Citric Acid, Malic Acid, Sea Salt, Organic Monk Fruit Extract.

AWARDS 2020 & 2021 Runner's Club Featured Product Contact info: Mike Frink, Vice President of Business Development APAX USA, Inc.

Buyer's Choice Award Phone: 303-594-6040 mfrink@apaxbd.com www.feelgoodsuperfoods.com

COVER STORY

retailers to step out of their comfort zones and implement different services and amenities that they may not have considered doing before, Strasburger of StrasGlobal says operators must now evaluate and decide if they will stick with the changes they made by analyzing the data, deciding if more customers were engaged because of these actions, and continuing to find more ways to reach these customers. “As convenience retailing changes, it is going to require a lot of thought and innovation to bring customers into your stores,” she said. Although it is important to know and understand the convenience store business, Strasburger finds that the most innovative retailers are those who look outside the channel and see what operators in other industries, and even other countries, are doing to distinguish themselves. To this end, she cofounded The Vision Group, which has members from different industries who meet regularly to learn from one another with a focus on innovation and disruption. Furthermore, during the COVID-19 pandemic, StrasGlobal recognized that there were areas of its company that needed to be strengthened, so it brought on a vice president of innovation and brand marketing to take its ideas centered on innovation and expand upon them. “We recognized that if we were looking outside our industry for answers, it changed how we categorized our job descriptions and expanded upon differentiators of candidates, especially with upper management and area managers,” Strasburger explained. Like many observers, King-Casey’s Cook believes COVID-19 has forever changed convenience retailing — but not necessarily in a good way for c-stores because the pandemic changed consumers’ expectations of “convenience.” “The restaurant industry was forced to pivot to off-premise sales; it built a new business around delivery, drive-thru, curbside. People got used to that kind of convenience. Going forward, c-stores have to realize they are losing their key advantage of convenience over restaurants,” he cautioned. “They are behind the curve on off-premise sales. So, they’ve improved greatly on their foodservice, but are falling behind on their most important asset: convenience.” 48 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

Cook urges c-store operators to look at different formats in the future. “Size, location, non-traditional sites will all have to play a larger role in a c-store chain’s portfolio,” he said. He also sees technology continuing to play a prominent role, specifically payment technology and mobile apps. C-stores should also more aggressively utilize geofencing technology and other ways to track customers from off-premise to inside the store, he noted. Looking ahead to life after COVID, Powell of Foodservice IP believes it’s too early to be certain of the sweeping statement that the pandemic has forever changed convenience retailing, although he does acknowledge that the pandemic definitely accelerated mobile ordering and third-party delivery in a segment that has been slow to adopt technology.

“We test, we learn, we fail and move on quickly, or we scale with speed.” — Deb Hall Lefevre, Alimentation Couche-Tard Inc.

“In the short term, I expect to see more automation and self-pay as retail employees are scarce and some may never return to the industry after the interaction scare with COVID customers. It will be critical that stores make the transition from fuel destination to electric car charging destinations so that others don’t sneak in and take that position. Finally, with the workforce largely working remotely for two to three days per week, there will be fewer commuters for the morning rush, but more for the snacking rush. The c-store will act more as a ‘break room’ for snacks [for those interested in] taking a walk or ride in the car. This will drive more beverage and food purchases,” Powell predicts. If a c-store retailer is not pursuing innovation right now, they should be, according to TXB’s Smartt, because the COVID-19 pandemic will eventually end and it will leave behind new

COVER STORY

consumer trends and preferences that retailers can’t ignore if they want to succeed. “Innovative retailers are taking the lessons learned and implementing those into regular practice,” Smartt said. “For example, our new TXB store in Georgetown, Texas, has nice, simple, outdoor seating with misting systems to give guests the option to not only enjoy their meal on-site, but also allow them to space themselves appropriately. We also added a hand washing station outside of the restrooms, so guests can wash their hands more conveniently before eating while also preventing the spread of germs.” Talking about practical steps c-store retailers can take to be more innovative, Smartt said his advice includes staying up to date on industry trends, turning to organizations like NACS for guidance, and looking at what competitors are doing. This may include retailers outside the convenience channel and for the foodservice category, can mean everything from restaurants to food trucks. Requesting consumer data from suppliers can also help operators get in touch with what customers are seeking, especially considering regional variations. Most importantly, the NACS chairman says retailers should think about how to make their customers’ experiences better based on their specific stores and capabilities. A proponent of technology, he points to loyalty programs, apps and mobile payment options as tools that can help streamline the guest experience and get consumers to rethink what a c-store can be. “I also believe that adopting tools like EV charging stations really sets retailers apart and puts them ahead of the game in preparing for the future of fuel stops,” he said. “We’re doing this at our new TXB stores as well, and find it to be an important factor that can help encourage consumers to make the switch to EVs down the line.” Smartt is putting his own advice into practice, too, as TXB is rolling out the ability to order fresh food and other in-store items via its mobile app, among other innovations. “We’re looking to add a food locker pickup room for third-party and app orders to enable easy contactless pickup,” he said. “In all new TXB locations, our guests will also have the ability to pay for their e-vehicle charging directly within the TXB app, and we’ll be adding e-vehicle media stations to entertain guests while their vehicle charges to give them a great experience.” Retailers must keep track of and respond to the 50 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

changing demographics in the U.S. as well. “We’ve utilized customer intercepts and surveys in order to get a clear demographic perspective of our customer base across all the different regions we serve,” Smartt said. “We incorporate those insights to form our strategies when it comes to marketing, messaging, promotions, and more. We like to look at these demographics by region as we know Texas is especially diverse.” Smartt offers one final thought on innovation: it doesn’t have to be “crazy” to be impactful. “In the c-store space, it’s a series of small upgrades that really elevate a guest’s experience,” he said. Trial & Error One extra hurdle of innovation is that it takes time for new concepts to become mainstream, and it can be challenging to distinguish between an innovative new concept that is early in its journey and an innovative new concept that will ultimately be unsuccessful. “It’s kind of asking what is a fad and what is a trend. I don’t think any retailers can bat 1,000,” Powell said. “Finding innovative platforms is a balance between staying on top of proven trends — health and wellness, social responsibility, multiple order options, etc.” Fads can also shift unexpectedly based on the current environment and become trends. For instance, Powell noted that while disposable packaging and single-serve packaging were once on their way out, in the age of COVID, they are now in high demand. However, Cook cautions that while retailers need to experiment, they also need to know when to bail on a concept that is not working. “In my experience, you have to get out of the blocks quickly. For example, with a new product, you want to see an initial burst of sales; there needs to be some consumer excitement generated around the new innovation,” he said. “Innovation doesn’t usually start slow and then build. My feeling is that you should fail early before you spend too much time on it.” C-store retailers can increase their odds of identifying a promising innovation early by following social media, joining webinars, and collaborating on research efforts, Smartt added. But ultimately, they need to accept that innovation means taking risks, and success isn’t guaranteed. “If I knew the answer, I would be worth a lot more money,” he joked. CSN

FEATURE

A HEALTHY DOSE OF INNOVATION Health and wellness is a common theme among this year’s Best New Products Awards winners By Susan Durtschi, Past Times Marketing

in product innovation hasn’t slowed down. If anything, consumers’ desire for healthier products enhanced with functional benefits has increased during the COVID-19 pandemic.

THE HEALTH AND WELLNESS TREND

More than any year prior, this year’s Best New Products Awards winners backed up their claims with data showing the success of their new introductions.

From more than 100 entries, judges chose 44 products Many of the winners in the 2021 Convenience Store News Best New Products Awards represent examples of how Americans continue to look for proof of functional benefits in the foods and beverages they consume. Some of the more common product attributes shared among this year’s honorees include low or no sugar or carbs, organic, clean label, and sustainable. On the other hand, this year’s group of winners also includes products that illustrate the fact that while consumers may want to follow healthy diets, that doesn’t mean they don’t like to treat themselves to indulgent sugary and salty snacks on occasion. This creates a tale of two c-stores: healthy products on one side and comforting, fun products on the other. Another trend seen this year is “premium.” Premium brand identification is on the upswing, with many products claiming unique ingredients, presentation and benefits over standard c-store fare. 52 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

new to convenience store shelves for recognition in the 25th annual competition. The Best New Products Awards program recognizes the marketers that introduced the most innovative, high-quality products that meet consumers’ evolving needs and fit a convenience store’s value proposition. Entries were rated and awarded points based on the criteria of taste, value, convenience, healthfulness, ingredients, preparation requirements, appearance and packaging. Judging was supervised and tallied by Past Times Marketing, a New York-based consumer research and product-testing firm. Products honored this year range from enhanced still waters, hard seltzers and indulgent sweet snacks to low-sugar, keto friendly and convenient grab-and-go foodservice items. The 2021 Best New Products Awards winners are:

W E N T BES D U C T S

PRO

AWA R

/ Y D N A C OLATE CHOC

ith the w s t l u res Drive ATIVE

V INNOCKING

SNA

E FIND MAOTRION AT INeNrsOheVySolutions.com H

e s u o h r Powe

FEATURE

2021

ALTERNATIVE SNACKS: ENERGY BARS

2 grams of sugar. Our panelists were impressed with the taste of the Cinnamon Toast Crunch flavor considering its low sugar content.

CLIF Bar Duos were designed based on the insight that for some moments, a standard CLIF Bar can be too big, provide too many calories, or provide too much of one flavor. With its fun, square shape and flavor combinations, CLIF Bar Duos bars deliver nutrition for sustained energy in a smaller, single bar that combines top-selling CLIF Bar flavors, such as Chocolate Brownie + Crunchy Peanut Butter, and Chocolate Brownie + White Chocolate Macadamia Nut. At 190 calories or less and providing 6-7 grams of protein, it’s ideal for times when consumers crave their favorite CLIF Bar flavors, but want less calories.

BEER

CLIF Bar Duos, CLIF Bar & Co.

ALTERNATIVE SNACKS: MEAT SNACKS

Country Archer Footlongs, Country Archer Provisions

Country Archer delivers on the c-store need for a clean version of a larger, individually wrapped 12-inch meat stick made with real ingredients. Featuring grass-fed beef, all-natural pork and a blend of real spices, varieties include Original, Teriyaki and Fuego, serving a fiery mix of red and white peppers, chipotle chiles and chili powder, which was a favorite of our testers. While the meat sticks segment has strong growth of 33.7 percent in the convenience channel, Country Archer’s better-for-you meat sticks are vastly outpacing and leading the way, up 205.4 percent for the 12 weeks ending June 28, 2021, according to SPINS, the supplier noted. ALTERNATIVE SNACKS: PROTEIN BARS

Cinnamon Toast Crunch Protein Bar, General Mills Convenience

General Mills’ new cereal-flavored protein bars meet the demand for a great-tasting protein bar that’s low in sugar. It doesn’t taste like a protein bar with its multilayer texture. Available in two popular flavors that over-index with Gen X and millennials, Cinnamon Toast Crunch and Golden Grahams, the bars have 20 grams of protein and

54 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

Coors Pure, Molson Coors Beverage Co.

USDA Organic certified, Coors Pure light beer fits the bill for different types of beer drinkers. It is perfect for hanging out at an all-day event where you want a beer in hand — at the beach, at a barbecue, or watching the game. Coors Pure has a 3.8 percent ABV with 92 calories, no sugar, and 3.5 grams of carbs per 12-ounce serving. It is made with simple, quality ingredients: organic barley, organic hops, and pure Rocky Mountain refreshing water. Our panel was impressed with the crisp taste of this beer and also lauded the low calories and the can’s clean design. CANDY: CHOCOLATE

Reese’s Big Cup with Pretzels, The Hershey Co.

Reese’s Big Cup with Pretzels takes one of Americans’ favorite salty snacks and stuffs it inside a favorite candy, Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups. This new addition to the Reese’s lineup is a perfect pick-me-up as an afternoon snack, and will satisfy the sweet (and salty) tooth. The Hershey Co. feels so good about this offering that it is making it available in two sizes: standard and king size. Hershey’s newest twist on sweet and salty deliciousness was a big hit with our test panelists who gave the item two thumbs up for taste. CANDY: GUM

ORBIT Mega Pack — Peppermint, Mars Wrigley

Mars Wrigley’s ORBIT gum brand recognized the drastic shift in shopping habits in 2020 and the consumer demand for bulk pack types and larger pack sizes for at-home happenings. The ORBIT Mega Pack is the brand’s first upsize pack, containing 30 pieces so that people can chew more gum whether at home or on the go. It is not only portable, keeping the gum fresh and offering shelf longevity, but it is also the first-ever Mars Wrigley product to partner with How2Recycle, providing consumers in much

FEATURE

2021 of the U.S. with a more sustainable option, including a step-by-step guide on how to recycle the pack. The ORBIT Mega Pack is available in Peppermint and Spearmint flavors. Our testers liked the Peppermint best. CANDY: NON-CHOCOLATE

HARIBO Funtastic Mix, HARIBO of America

HARIBO Funtastic Mix brings a whimsical eating experience to consumers seeking an on-the-go treat with an adventurous twist. With multiple gummi textures and several color and flavor combinations, HARIBO Funtastic Mix is an innovative, fun and compelling product crafted for the c-store shopper. It is the brand’s first U.S. product with this much variety in a single pack. The German HARIBO brand stands for quality and brings with it strong recognition of the gummi candy phenomena and outgrowth.

Hemp Bombs CBD Gummies — Botanical Blend are the first vegan gummies manufactured by the company. Each gummy contains 15 milligrams of premium CBD and a blend of functional ingredients, including Passiflora, Scutellaria and L-Theanine. The packaging for this new Hemp Bombs product differentiates itself from the rest of the line with softer pastel accents, which stand out against Hemp Bombs’ distinctive black pouch color. CBD: JUICE DRINKS

Forth CBD-Infused Juice Drinks, E-Alternative Solutions

CANDY: NOVELTY/SEASONAL

Skittles Shriekers!, Mars Wrigley

Mars Wrigley has unveiled spooky-new Skittles flavors in preparation for this year’s Halloween season. Dubbed “Shriekers!” the new release comes in a vibrant assortment of Spine-Tingling Tangerine, Ghoulish Green Apple, Rattled Raspberry, Citrus Scream, and Shocking Lime. The super-sour variety boasts a bright orange wrapper with a ghoulish skeleton and a warning that reads: BEWARE! TRY IF YOU DARE. According to the company, these candies are so sour, they will make you shriek.

CBD: EDIBLES

Hemp Bombs CBD Gummies, Hemp Bombs

Consumers continue to seek out CBD health and wellness products containing the latest functional ingredients. 56 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

Adult consumers are actively searching for CBD form-factors they are already familiar with, like gummies, baked goods, and drinks. Forth CBD-Infused Juice Drinks are designed to appeal to both new and experienced CBD users. Each drink contains 10 milligrams of full-spectrum CBD in an 8.5-ounce bottle, without compromising flavor. The real fruit ingredients mask the natural flavors from the hemp plant, giving adult consumers delicious flavor in every sip. Of the two flavors, Mango Orange Pineapple was our panelists’ favorite. Since its introduction in stores, Forth CBD-Infused Juice Drinks have proven their viability, quickly becoming the No. 1 selling form-factor in the CBD category, according to company data. CBD: SHOTS

Mad Tasty Wellness Boost, Mad Tasty LLC Mad Tasty Wellness Boost, founded by OneRepublic lead singer and CEO Ryan Tedder, aims to disrupt the CBD category. Stress relief and inflammation relief, plus immunity boosters, are in demand more than ever before. The challenge with CBD shots, however, is getting a great taste without loading up with sugar or artificial sweeteners. According to our testers, Mad Tasty cracks the taste code while staying healthy. The product is zero sugar, vegan, all natural, gluten free, and packed with 50 milligrams of

FEATURE

2021

broad-spectrum hemp extract. The shots are promoted with a creative social outreach and giving-back program that finances the building of drinking water wells. DELI PRODUCTS

Van’s Kitchen 4-Pack Egg Rolls — Chili Lime Chicken, Van’s Kitchen

Demand for ethnic foods is growing alongside the growth of the ethnic population, not to mention the influence of the ethnic population upon the general market. With the rising demand for Asian cuisine, Van’s Kitchen Chili Lime Chicken Egg Rolls are a great opportunity to grow revenue and meet the diverse tastes of c-store customers. Packaged in a microwaveable tray, the four-pack of egg rolls with sauce offers a touch-free, prepared meal solution that customers can heat and enjoy at home for a snack or a meal. The product has a 21-day refrigerated shelf life, and is fully prepared and ready to cook.

FLAVORED MALT BEVERAGES: ORGANIC HARD SELTZER

Michelob ULTRA Organic Seltzer, Michelob

Organic is an attribute that appeals to an ever-widening audience, so it is more important than ever to have options that speak to the wide variety of consumers who seek natural and organic products. Michelob ULTRA Organic Seltzer stands out as a distinct premium offering that delivers on flavor, while being perfectly connected to the trend of health and wellness. The brand’s Signature Collection includes flavors with only 80 calories, zero grams of sugar, and zero carbs. Flavors in its Classic Collection are 90 calories with zero grams of added sugar, 2 grams of carbs, and real fruit juice. Spicy Pineapple was our panelists’ favorite. FOODSERVICE: BAKERY

Rich’s Ready to Finish Dessert Donuts — Banana Cream Pie, Rich Products Corp.

Consumers are seeking unique, indulgent flavors, and the new Filled Dessert Donuts line from Rich’s ticks all the boxes. Bringing a fresh-baked aroma to the store, the process is turnkey: thaw, heat, glaze and serve. C-store operators can order optional topping kits for even more variety. With seasonal colors and holidays, the limited-time-offer possibilities are endless. Once just a breakfast staple, donuts are now an all-day treat. Our panelists tried all four on-trend varieties — Banana Cream Pie, Fudge Brownie, Neapolitan, and Apple Pie. Banana Cream Pie, a banana-flavored yeast donut ring filled with two flavors (vanilla pudding and cookie-flavored buttercream) topped with vanilla cookie pieces was the favorite. FLAVORED MALT BEVERAGES: HARD SELTZER

Truly Punch Hard Seltzer — Berry Punch, Truly Hard Seltzer

As one of the first hard seltzer punch options available nationwide, Truly Punch Hard Seltzer helped open the door to a whole new category of drinkers. Now, it is expanding into a bolder flavor profile with a fuller-bodied, craveable punch with the added benefit of low calories and low sugar. Fruit punch is a nostalgic flavor familiar to nearly all consumers, so delivering a range of hard seltzers in that flavor profile not only gives current drinkers another delicious product option, but also helps bring in new customers by taking a flavor they’re familiar with and reinventing it into a hard seltzer that’s approachable and bold yet familiar. 58 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

FOODSERVICE: BASE INGREDIENTS

Garrett Valley Pork Belly, Wellshire Farms LLC

Innovative, delicious, fully cooked, pre-sliced and offered in 1-ounce portions, Garrett Valley Pork Belly is easy to heat and serve for any breakfast or lunch application. Made with all-natural ingredients (no artificial ingredients or antibiotics), Garrett Valley Pork Belly is a premium offering that can be served as a standalone item, or used as a meat ingredient in any type of application (hamburger topping, pizza topping,

FEATURE

2021

soup, bowls, salads, tacos, etc.). Our testers had it on a breakfast taco and in a salad, and gave it their seal of approval.

FOODSERVICE: BREAKFAST

FOODSERVICE: COLD DISPENSED BEVERAGES

This breakfast sandwich is not your average sausage biscuit. It is made with a fried egg, jalapeno bacon, sausage and cheese on a flaky biscuit. Packed with protein, it is a hearty, tasty breakfast for consumers’ on-the-go lifestyles and a premium sandwich you would expect to get at a coffee shop or diner. E.A. Sween says the product is bringing new life to the breakfast category at c-stores with its high-quality ingredients. Our panelists agreed that the taste is a cut above traditional c-store breakfast fare. Additional varieties include turkey sausage and vegetarian options.

Southern Breeze Ready Sweet Flavor Pak is a new way to brew consistent and profitable flavored and sweetened iced tea. Instead of using messy syrups or granulated sugar, Harris has developed perfectly portioned tea “Paks” that can be brewed using existing equipment, such as a Bunn or Curtis coffee/tea brewer. The Flavor Paks are available in the three most popular tea flavors currently on U.S. menus: Peach, Raspberry and Tropical. Each Pak yields three gallons of tea. Since the pouches are pre-proportioned, there’s zero guessing and very little training needed to brew the product; just place the pouches in a brew basket and go. The product uses no artificial flavors or colors, which consumers are increasingly cutting out.

Market Sandwich — Sausage & Jalapeno Bacon with Egg & Cheese on a Biscuit, E.A. Sween Co.

Southern Breeze Ready Sweet Flavor Pak — Peach, Harris Tea Foodservice

FOODSERVICE: CONDIMENTS

Chester’s Dipping Sauces — Chester’s Sauce, Chester’s International

Consumer data shows that dipping sauces actually drive purchasing behavior, especially with younger consumers. Chester’s now offers several great-tasting sauces that are designed to be the perfect complement to its worldfamous chicken. The dipping sauces feature new recipes made from high-quality ingredients. Five sauces are available: Chester’s Sauce, Honey Mustard, Buffalo Hot Sauce, Ranch and BBQ. All five were deemed “delicious” by our panelists, but the signature Chester’s Sauce took the top prize for taste.

60 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

FEATURE

2021 FOODSERVICE: DINNER/HOME MEAL REPLACEMENT

Smoked Honey & BBQ Sausage, Johnsonville

A recent proprietary study by Johnsonville found that 63 percent of consumers say it’s important to have a unique flavor as part of an offering at a c-store. In addition, 67 percent said items made by a national brand would make them more likely to purchase an item at a c-store. Those are the stats that drove the creation of Johnsonville’s new sausages — a foodservice item that is perfect for diversifying the roller grill, and a great add-on for c-store menus. The sausages come in bold flavors, including Southern Style BBQ, Smoked Honey & BBQ, and Ultimate Queso. Our testers liked the Smoked Honey & BBQ variety best. FOODSERVICE: LUNCH

UNO Pizzeria & Grill Calzones — Chicken Bacon Ranch, UNO Foods Inc.

UNO Pizzeria & Grill Calzones offer an operator three ways to grow sales and profits, and are on trend for today’s convenience yet safety-minded consumers. Handmade with fresh dough and offered in grab-and-go packaging, these calzones are UNO Pizzeria & Grill Restaurant quality. They can be heated right in their packaging and placed in a warmer, or served directly to the customer at 160 degrees. The packaging is designed so that external heat dissipates with no direct risk to the operator or customer. Our testers most liked the generous size and fresh taste of the meats and seasoning in the Chicken Bacon Ranch Calzone.

variety best, and lauded the product’s easy grab-and-go container. FROZEN FOODS

Prairie City Ooey Gooey Molten Lava Cake — Fudge, Prairie City Bakery

Ooey Gooey Molten Lava Cakes are an extremely indulgent dessert snack. With “true indulgence” being the largest and fastest-growing snack segment, according to IRI’s 2020 Snack Survey, these individually wrapped frozen cakes are an on-trend item that can be enjoyed any time of day. Available in three varieties — Fudge, Salted Caramel, and Peanut Butter — the product features a soft cake filled with a decadent, ooey gooey lava icing. The simple thaw-and-sell format is easy to execute for store operators, requiring little to no labor while also boasting an impressive 30-day shelf life from thaw. When placed in a warmer, these 3.2-ounce Molten Lava Cakes release a delightful chocolatey aroma, and with a manufacturer’s suggested retail price of $1.79 each, they also provide incredible value to consumers. FROZEN NOVELTIES

Snickers Peanut Brownie Ice Cream Bars, Mars Wrigley

Snickers Peanut Brownie Ice Cream Bars feature the brand’s newest flavor obsession: brownie-flavored ice cream with brownie inclusions, topped with a layer of luscious caramel and peanuts. As the No. 1 new frozen novelty item, according to a 2020 Nielsen report, Snickers Peanut Brownie Ice Cream Bars offer a delicious brownie flavor that resonates with younger consumers, and delivers on key flavor trends in the category. Snickers’ latest ice cream offering leans into the indulgence trend, with 70 percent of consumers saying the Peanut Brownie Ice Cream Bars are more indulgent than any other frozen novelty, according to Nielsen.

FOODSERVICE: SNACKS

Jimmy Dean Loaded Sausage Bites, Tyson Foodservice

Jimmy Dean Loaded Sausage Bites are a quick, hassle-free option for customers on the go. They offer a filling, protein-packed item for an easy-to-enjoy breakfast or anytime snack from a brand they trust. With 16 grams of protein per serving, these bite-sized and dippable sausage bites are loaded with egg, cheese and bacon. Ready to heat and eat, the fully cooked Jimmy Dean Loaded Sausage Bites can be heated in the microwave. Our testers liked the Turkey Sausage, Egg & Cheese

62 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

GENERAL MERCHANDISE

Scripto Hybrid Jet Flame, Calico Brands Inc. The Scripto Hybrid Jet Flame is the newest refillable lighter available on the market, and is designed to be the perfect crossover of a multipurpose lighter and a pocket lighter. Featuring an eco-friendly refillable tank and a superheated jet flame, it is aimed at providing convenient lighting while keeping hands safely away from the flame. It’s perfectly suited for lighting campfires, barbecues, hookah bowls, and many other

ROLLING OUT THE FLAVOR Southern BBQ Sausage #103992

Smoked Honey BBQ Sausage #103993

Ultimate Queso Sausage #103990

FEATURE

2021

outdoor and indoor activities with reliability and ease. The Scripto Hybrid Jet Flame Lighter appeals to multiple demographics and it’s sized for optimal convenience.

popular among millennial shoppers. The Keto Box was our panelists’ favorite. Packaged in a charming see-through box, it includes a grass-fed beef stick, baby carrots, a hard-boiled egg, whole almonds, and Tessemae’s Buffalo Ranch Dip.

HEALTH & BEAUTY CARE

Headache Man, No More Pills LLC

Headache Man is a convenient 1.7-ounce shot of 650 milligrams of acetaminophen in an organic, lemon-flavored water. Said to work in just minutes, its patented liquid formula allows for acetaminophen to be suspended in an easyto-drink liquid that is waterbased, instead of the alcohol or glycerin-based syrups found in other products. This allows Headache Man to have the flavor and consistency of a great-tasting beverage, while eliminating the bitterness typically found in other over-thecounter medications. With 40 percent of people struggling to swallow pills, this product offers a new alternative that changes the way consumers look at on-the-go pain relief.

HEALTHY SNACKS

OH SNAP! Sassy Bites, GLK Foods

Consumers are continuously looking for healthier and betterfor-you options, packaged for on-the-go convenience. OH SNAP! Sassy Bites are pickle slices that are sweet with just enough heat. Gluten free, fat free and made with non-GMO cucumbers, Sassy Bites are fresh-packed with no added brine — an innovative process that delivers a superior crunch, great taste, and less mess. Sassy Bites are designed to be a delicious snack on their own, or work as a tasty complement to any sandwich/hot dog purchase, driving incremental sales as an add-on to the foodservice portion of c-stores. HEALTHY SNACKS: KITS

Tessemae’s Keto Box, Tessemae’s

Tessemae’s believes the convenience store snacks category is hungry for innovation in the better-for-you space. Consumers are used to seeing hummus cups, yogurt cups and watery eggs in the center cooler, and likely feel uninspired. Tessemae’s new Balanced Boxes present shoppers with a new option that can serve as a healthy light meal or a filling snack, and also meets the dietary lifestyles

64 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

LIQUOR

LIQS — Cinnamon Orange Tequila, E. & J. Gallo Winery

The ready-to-drink alcoholic beverages category continues to grow, and single-serve products continue to drive alcohol sales in the c-store market. Consumers want to take spirit-based products to places where they used to take beer, according to E. & J. Gallo. LIQS is the first premixed cocktail shot, a niche that packs a punch. It features premium spirits, real fruit juice and natural flavors. Offered in a four-pack, each shot is 1.69 ounces, well over the traditional size of a 1-ounce shot. Our testers were impressed with the concept and liked the Cinnamon Orange Tequila shot best. The shot glass is reusable and recyclable. NON-EDIBLE GROCERY

BIC EZ Reach Lighter, BIC Corp.

The BIC EZ Reach Lighter features a 1.45-inch extended wand that helps keep fingers further from the flame. Its body is the size of a pocket lighter, so it fits comfortably in users’ hands, bags and pockets, making it perfect for lighting candles, grilling, and everything in between. The design meets consumers’ requests for a lighter that lights at any angle. Providing up to 50 percent more lights than non-refillable wand pocket lighters, the BIC EZ Reach Lighter gives retailers an opportunity to trade up for profitability. Each lighter undergoes more than 50 quality and safety checks during the manufacturing process to ensure it meets or exceeds all safety standards to keep consumers safe. OTHER TOBACCO PRODUCTS: CIGARS

White Owl Swirl — Chocolate & Vanilla, Swedish Match North America The limited-edition offerings provided by White Owl continue to intrigue consumers and create demand within the c-store market. White Owl Swirl: Chocolate & Vanilla is the first cigar in a planned series. Swirl is a two-color cigarillo featuring an unmistakable and unforgettable wrapper, and a flavor that brings chocolate and vanilla

Tasty Snacks That Are Ready To Travel Hillshire Snacking Small Plates pack a variety of upscale options for your busy customers. Everyone is sure to find a go-to favorite for their on-the-go snacking occasions. ®

Discover our complete lineup of craveable offerings.

Contact your Tyson Convenience Representative, Broker, Distributor Sales Representative or visit tysonconvenience.com for more information.

FEATURE

2021

together in a smooth combination. The series will introduce products that bring an exciting twist that grabs consumers’ attention. OTHER TOBACCO PRODUCTS: PAPERS

Hempire Wraps, Swisher

Vegan, GMO free and pesticide free, Hempire Wraps are the modern “green” take on the traditional tobacco blunt wrap without the tobacco and nicotine. Made with an exclusive U.S. organic, high-quality hemp biomass blend, Hempire Wraps are infused with aromatics and terpenes that are truly unique in the hemp category. The all plant-based lineup includes a variety of blends. While blunt wraps are more well-known in the category, hemp wraps stand apart because of the absence of nicotine. Hemp wraps are realizing tremendous growth in the market. They feel, roll and smoke very similarly to blunt wraps.

66 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

OTHER TOBACCO PRODUCTS: SMOKELESS TOBACCO

Black Buffalo Wintergreen Long Cut, Black Buffalo Inc.

Black Buffalo manufactures and sells a smokeless tobacco alternative that is creating a growth opportunity in the modern oral category for the convenience channel. Black Buffalo’s products provide the same pack, aroma, deep color, flavor and nicotine buzz of traditional moist smokeless tobacco (MST) products, but without the harmful constituents of tobacco leaf

I ,

ﬂ

EMPIRE COM

800.874.9720.

FEATURE

2021 or tobacco stem. With five Long Cut and three Pouches products filed under PMTA with the FDA in September 2020, Black Buffalo remains committed to the highest quality standards in the industry, and claims to be the only known product in this category to file a PMTA. Black Buffalo Wintergreen Long Cut was the top-rated variety among our adult tobacco-using panelists.

offering unique and meaningful ingredients along with outstanding taste in the iconic VOSS bottle, VOSS+ provides an opportunity to trade customers up to a higher dollar ring. VOSS+ Vitamin D has a suggested price of $3.69. PACKAGED BEVERAGES: CARBONATED SOFT DRINKS

Sunkist Berry Lemonade, Keurig Dr Pepper

PACKAGED BEVERAGES: BOTTLED WATER

VOSS+ Vitamin D, Voss USA

Sunkist Berry Lemonade (SKBL) has seen unprecedented success since its launch, with c-stores driving 44 percent of dollar sales due to high turn rates on the product’s 20-ounce single-serve bottle. This momentum is a strong proof point that the product is meeting consumer needs and expectations at both the shelf and post-purchase. After only four months on the market, SKBL is now the fastest-turning Sunkist flavor in c-stores. The product features a unique flavor profile, bright blue color, and vibrant packaging. SKBL has a strong repeat purchase percentage of 28 percent, indicating that more than one in four consumers who tried the product purchased it again.

The VOSS+ line of enhanced waters represents the first premium bottled water brand to bring true benefits to consumers. VOSS+ is designed to help support active lifestyles and enhance the pursuit of health and wellness — trends that became even more sought out during the pandemic. VOSS+ Vitamin D delivers 50 percent of the average person’s recommended daily intake of Vitamin D, along with minerals and electrolytes for taste, in a delightful citrus fruit essence containing zero sugar and zero calories. By

Meet us at NACS Booth 7352

Ventless. Portable. Automatic Solutions.

AutoFry® Offers a complete range of automated, portable, ventless deep-frying systems, from single to double basket, and countertop to floor models.

MultiChef ™ High Speed ovens that reduces cook times, transforming your business into a food preparation powerhouse.

mtiproducts.com

1-800-348-2976

68 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

NEW OVENS!

WARNING: This product contains nicotine. Nicotine is an addictive chemical.

THE BEST NEW PRODUCT OF NACS 2021 IS AT BOOTH 8580.

JOIN THE HERD TOBACCO ALTERNATIVE LONG CUT & POUCHES blackbuffalo.com Black Buffalo Ad.indd 1

8/23/2021 10:08:10 AM

FEATURE

PACKAGED BEVERAGES: JUICE DRINKS

Amarumayu Superfruit Juices, Amarumayu LLC

Amarumayu Superfruit Juices are ready-to-drink, immunity-boosting, exotic, delicious and nourishing. The Buriti and Camu Camu superfruits have been part of the healthy diets of the indigenous peoples of the Amazon for centuries. Camu Camu has the largest natural concentration of Vitamin C on the planet with 50 times as much Vitamin C as an orange. Buriti is rich in Omegas 3, 6 and 9, Vitamins A and C, and minerals such as potassium, calcium and iron. Our panelists were impressed with the taste of the juices, as well as their concentration of nutrients. They also liked the artwork on the product’s colorful aluminum container. PACKAGED BEVERAGES: OTHER

Twang Reserve Cocktail Mixes, Twang Partners Ltd.

A michelada is a Latin-derived beer cocktail that is con-

sidered by many to be a lighter and more approachable version of its American cousin, the Bloody Mary. A michelada is made with beer, lime juice, assorted sauces, spices, tomato juice, and chili peppers. Twang Partners has crafted a family of all-inone mixes that make it as easy as just adding it to beer to create a delicious michelada. Our testers found this niche product very interesting, and Spicy was the preferred flavor. When placed near the beer section, it is an easy consumer add-on item and has cross-cultural appeal. PACKAGED BEVERAGES: RTD COFFEE DRINKS

Community Coffee Expresso + Cream, Community Coffee

Made with Community Coffee’s Signature Blend, Espresso + Cream is a refreshing and creamy ready-todrink coffee-based beverage in a convenient 6.5-ounce can. The beverage is lightly sweetened and balanced with rich cream for a delicious pick-me-up. Made with 100

PPro d uuc c ts rod ts

TRUCKERS WINDSHIELD VALET

No windshield windshield out out ofofreach reach

816-813-3337 | www.forteproducts.com 70 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

New

2021

percent Arabica coffee beans and natural flavors, Espresso + Cream is held to Comnunity Coffee’s rigorous scoring system for body, balance, flavor and aroma. Our panelists found the innovation of the mini expresso beverage very convenient, and they liked its balanced flavor and the fact that Community Coffee gives back through programs such as Cash for Schools and Military Match. PACKAGED BEVERAGES: RTD ICED TEA

POM Pomegranate Orange Blossom White Tea, POM Wonderful

Each bottle of POM Antioxidant Super Tea is powered by the antioxidant goodness of pomegranate juice and is gently brewed to preserve those antioxidants while offering the benefits of tea. POM Pomegranate Orange Blossom White Tea offers a combination of crisp white tea and orange blossom, resulting in a delicious and refreshing alternative to traditional ready-to-drink (RTD) teas. Our panelists liked this health-forward alternative to RTD teas and found its taste “refreshing.” The beautiful, vibrant POM bottle also stood out within the category and impressed our testers.

FEATURE

2021 PACKAGED SWEET SNACKS

7Days Cake Bars, 7Days-EPTA America LLC

Our panelists said 7Days Cake Bars are ideally suited for the convenience channel. They thought these light and sweet layered cake bars are perfect for grab-and-go; a permissible indulgence during the mid-morning and afternoon occasions; and go great with coffee, an important driver of c-store trips. Packed in convenient eight-count, shelf-ready caddie displays, the cake bars come individually wrapped to maintain freshness, and are delivered ambient to retailers. Launched nationally in the fourth quarter of 2020 at 7-Eleven, 7Days Cake Bars already rank in the top half for unit velocity among new items in the $4 billion sweet baked goods and adjacent category sets (cookies, snack bars, toaster pastry) as of Q1 2021, according to IRI. SALTY SNACKS: NUTS & SEEDS

South 40 Snacks Sunflower Seeds, South 40 Snacks Inc.

Each package of South 40 Snacks Sunflower Seeds contains only two ingredients: sunflower seeds and

sea salt. These premium giant sunflower seeds make for a salty snack that fits food and health trends such as natural, vegan, keto, paleo, low carb, good source of protein, and more. The company boasts that they are unlike any other sunflower seeds on the market, and our panelists agreed. In the c-store accounts where South 40 Snacks has distribution, the product typically ranks at or near the top on a dollars-per-store-per-week basis among competitors. SALTY SNACKS: POTATO CHIPS

Pringles Scorchin’, Kellogg’s Co.

The “hot” segment represents 30 percent of the salty snacks business at c-stores, and it grew by 8 percent in the last three years, compared with 3 percent growth for the entire category. Pringles took its three most popular flavors and added additional heat to them to create Pringles Scorchin’. The Pringles Scorchin’

CBD SHOTS & SUPPLEMENTS FOR EVERY OUNCE OF MAD TASTY SOLD, MAD TASTY DONATES THE EQUIVALENT AMOUNT OF CLEAN DRINKING WATER.

72 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

MADTASTY.COM

FEATURE

2021

platform is designed to combine the Pringles flavors that consumers love with the spicy trend they are asking for, attracting the next generation of salty snack consumers. Our testers loved the bold taste and texture of the BBQ variety. SALTY SNACKS: PRETZELS

Dot’s Honey Mustard Pretzels, Dot’s Pretzels

Dot’s Pretzels is a Midwest phenomenon that has seen explosive growth over the past few years and has driven nearly all of the growth in the pretzel category for convenience, according to the company. Dot’s recently introduced its most highly requested flavor yet — a honey mustard seasoned pretzel. Our testers were very impressed with the quality and flavor of the premium pretzel product. Each Dot’s Pretzels flavor is created by Dorothy Henke, also known as Dot, and held to the standard of her own

original seasoning that is so widely known and loved. SALTY SNACKS: READY-TO-EAT POPCORN

Gold Medal Gourmet Popcorn, Gold Medal Products Co.

The most successful snack product selections are those that appeal to shoppers and deliver attractive profit margins. Gold Medal Gourmet Popcorn delivers margins as high as 72 percent. Our testers liked the product’s nostalgic flavor and easy grab-and-go packaging. They were fans of all three “fresh-tasting” varieties, but the Caramel & Cheddar Mix scored the highest. The integrity of Gold Medal Gourmet Popcorn is linked to its thorough process. It is carefully crafted in small batches to create exceptional-quality flavor profiles. One of the distinguishing features is that the popcorn is wet popped, which means the kernels are popped in specially designed oils and seasonings for maximum flavor. CSN

VISIT NOW

IT’S NOT VIRTUAL REALITY...

IT’S THE NEW REALITY

CSNEWS.COM/INTERACTIVE-PRODUCT-SPOTLIGHT-2020

74 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

FASTEST GROWING PLAYER IN SWEET BAKED GOODS

DELIVERED AMBIENT

LONG SHELF LIFE

— KEEP THE 7DAYS MOMENTUM GOING — NEW ITEMS, MORE OCCASIONS, PROVEN INCREMENTAL

New!

New! BEST NEW PRODUCTS AWA R D S

PERFECT FOR SNACKING

INCREDIBLE VALUE

i. Note: Category = Pastry/Doughnuts + Bakery Snacks in IRI ii. Source: IRI US Convenience, data thru Q1 2021

FOODSERVICE

Overcoming Adversity With Innovation For a third time, Rutter’s leads this year’s slate of Foodservice Innovators Awards winners By Don Longo FROM MAKING PANDEMIC-INSPIRED menu changes to utilizing new technology, the nation’s top convenience store retailers have shown remarkable innovation over the past year. Being able to turn on a dime and succeed, during a global pandemic, is the definition of innovation.

Each year, Convenience Store News recognizes c-store retailers that are raising the bar on quality, service and innovation in the foodservice category. Now in its 10th year, the Foodservice Innovators Awards program has been recognizing best-in-class convenience foodservice retailers since 2012. Winners are chosen annually by the CSNews Foodservice Advisory Council, a panel of category experts from the retailer, supplier, wholesaler, research and consulting fields. This year, Rutter’s, the York, Pa.-based regional retailer known for being on the cutting-edge, leads a slate of five Foodservice Innovators Awards winners. Rutter’s has now won the Foodservice Innovator of the Year award a record three times (previously in 2012 and 2018).

FOODSERVICE INNOVATOR OF THE YEAR: Rutter’s Judges on the CSNews Foodservice Advisory Council lauded Rutter’s overall approach to foodservice, from dispensed beverages to fresh prepared foods. “They’ve always been progressive with prepared foods in general, but I think they really lifted their game in cold

76 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

Members of the Convenience Store News Foodservice Advisory Council lauded how well Rutter’s adjusted its menu due to the pandemic.

dispensed beverages with their Spiked Slushies and Xtreme Shakes,” said one judge. It was also noted how well Rutter’s adjusted its menu due to the pandemic (e.g., new comfort-food offerings). And the company’s approach to marketing its offerings to consumers digitally via social media, geofencing and a new loyalty app did not go unnoticed. All in all, Rutter’s paints a picture of a retailer operating on all cylinders despite the global pandemic. Rutter’s introduced Spiked Slushies to the Pennsylvania market before any other chain. Being the leader in this category allowed the retailer to innovate even more. In 2021, Rutter’s introduced limited-time seasonal flavors to further spice up the category.

AWARDED!

BEST NEW PRODUCT OF 2021

FOODSERVICE

Like most retailers, the pandemic forced Rutter’s to adjust its foodservice offering, which it’s done with great success. Customers wanted comfort foods and brands they trust, so Rutter’s introduced a second Beef Traveller option, along with SPAM as a limitedtime offer (LTO) add-on available for breakfast, lunch and dinner items. Both have been huge hits. Rutter’s also introduced Xtreme Shakes, candy-filled shakes that allow customers young and old to add their favorite sweets, like Kit Kat and Reese’s, to their drinks. To add even more fun, the retailer started offering LTO flavors, such as Key Lime Kit Kat, which customers enjoyed. Further, Rutter’s found new ways to reach its customers, primarily through digital media. Platforms such as Twitch and Instagram have offered the retailer ways to reach customers who weren’t on-site as often over the past year. By using these, along with other social platforms, Rutter’s was able to target consumer preferences in a strong way with geofencing and demographic profiles. Like many other retailers, Rutter’s trips have been down overall, but the chain’s baskets have increased dramatically.

“Through our new loyalty platform with Paytronix, launched in 2020, we also have the ability to now survey customers. This has allowed us to determine what’s working and what isn’t,” said Rutter’s Director of Fuel, Forecourt and Advertising Chris Hartman. “We also rolled out menu screens above our foodservice areas, in many of our new stores and remodels, allowing customers to look at all we have to offer in a quick time period.” It is clear that Rutter’s believes innovation isn’t just about having the most creative item, but about adapting to customer needs. “Thriving during a pandemic isn’t something that was expected at the beginning,” said Hartman. “However, our great foodservice team, led by Robert Perkins, took it as a challenge and came out with an improved menu offering and creative flair that fit what Rutter’s customers want.”

PREPARED FOODS INNOVATOR OF THE YEAR: The Spinx Co. The Foodservice Advisory Council cited the way Spinx took its Legendary Fried Chicken, sides and proprietary banana pudding and made it all ready-to-go for shoppers during the pandemic. Customers were able to purchase fried chicken that was prepared the day before, properly and safely chilled to under 40 degrees (24 hours cold), and merchandised cold for sale throughout the day. They were impressed with the process and discipline the stores took in serving the cold chicken the proper way (not leftovers). The returns were great not only in evening business

Judges praised the debut of the Spinx Cluk-Truck in upstate South Carolina as a great way to bring the brand to other areas of the state.

78 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

*We’ll bebe at at the NACS byDairyfood DairyfoodUSA USA Booth # 8574* *We’ll the NACSShow! Show!Please Please stop stop by Booth # 8574*

lsloop@dairyfoodusa.com

FOODSERVICE

(take home and re-therm), but customers also purchased the chicken throughout the day and ate it cold. “Who doesn’t like cold fried chicken?” commented one judge. The offer satisfied the call for more prepared food items with minimal touchpoints or interaction for safety reasons during the pandemic, and turned into an everyday SKU without any cannibalization of Spinx’s traditional Legendary Fried Chicken program. In addition, several side dishes were added, and the retailer’s proprietary banana pudding was sold in quart containers, as well as single-serve. The debut of the Spinx Cluk-Truck in upstate South Carolina was also cited as a major success by the council. The Cluk-Truck was booked for special events throughout the area, serving a limited menu of chicken tenders and fries. Judges thought this was a great way to bring the Spinx brand to other areas of the state.

Other judges lauded Circle K’s launch of its Sip & Save subscription service, which is applicable to hot, cold and frozen dispensed beverages. Customers can enjoy one coffee, tea, fountain drink or slushy of their choice every day for just $5.99 per month. The Sip & Save program debuted May 5, after the program was tested for 90 days at more than 100 stores near Augusta, Ga., and Columbia, S.C. This is the second win in the hot beverages category for Circle K. The company previously took home the title of Hot Beverages Innovator of the Year in 2016.

This is the first-ever win for Spinx in the Foodservice Innovators Awards program.

HOT BEVERAGES INNOVATOR OF THE YEAR: Alimentation Couche-Tard Inc./ Circle K Circle K’s sustainably sourced coffee program is built around three pillars: farm productivity, environmental practices, and social development. The chain’s high-quality coffee beans are sourced from participating farms around the world while providing valuable tools, training and services to the coffee farmers and their communities. “Customers are always looking for differentiation and 100-percent sustainable coffee is certainly that,” one judge remarked. “The current customer base is environmentally conscious, so this appears to be an intelligent move to get that customer into the store.” The new sustainably sourced coffee blends are available through Circle K's bean-to-cup machines in both hot and iced versions. While all coffee beans will now be 100 percent sustainably sourced, the retailer maintains that the quality, taste, aroma and roast profile will all remain the same.

80 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

COLD & FROZEN BEVERAGES INNOVATOR OF THE YEAR: 7-Eleven Inc. This summer, 7-Eleven introduced a new, fruity Slurpee flavor available in an innovative stay-cold cup that was available at participating stores for just $1. The new flavor, Peach Perfect, is made with real juice and provides a perfectly refreshing on-trend taste. “They never rest in this category,” said one judge. “It seems like they’re always doing something new with cold beverages, and it’s not limited to new flavors. The staycold cup was an interesting innovation I haven’t seen elsewhere.” Another 7-Eleven innovation cited by the judges was the LTO offering of a Jones Soda Co. Birthday Cake flavored Slurpee drink in participating stores across the Pacific

Award Winning, Market Proven

Are you onboard? Try the Best New Product for Healthy Snacks at Booth 7331! ohsnappickles.com

FOODSERVICE

Northwest from June through August. The sweet, buttery vanilla Birthday Cake flavor — reminiscent of yellow cake — was introduced to celebrate the retailer’s 94th birthday. Also this summer, the convenience store chain gave its famous lineup of Big Gulp fountain drinks a bold refresh by introducing five new, non-traditional varieties at participating stores. The new varieties are AHA sparkling flavored water, craft lemonade made with real juice and cane sugar, electrolyte-infused vitaminwater zero, and 7-Eleven’s private brand vitamin-infused sports drink Replenish Zero and energy drink Power Berry by Quake. 7-Eleven is a three-time winner in the cold and frozen beverages category, having racked up previous honors in 2014 and 2019.

FOODSERVICE INNOVATOR TO WATCH: Family Express Corp. The Innovator to Watch award recognizes a c-store retailer as an “up-and-comer” that is making a name for itself in the quality and innovation of its foodservice program. This year, the award goes to the regional Family Express chain, based in Valparaiso, Ind. Earlier this year, the retailer began testing new technology that lets customers order fresh, made-to-order food from its Cravin’s menu at the gas pump or car wash. To ensure the safety of customers' 82 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

“Gus and the Family Express team are always looking at new ways to sell products.” — Foodservice Innovators Awards judge personal information, it installed Fiserv's TransArmor data protection system, which safeguards their personal data when they swipe credit cards at the pump. The goal is to make it easier to buy Cravin's food, which is available at approximately a third of Family Express’ 75 stores, while on the go. By placing orders while they're pumping gas, customers don't have to wait in line again to place a food order inside the store. “Gus and the Family Express team are always looking at new ways to sell products,” said one judge. “Testing order-at-the-pump technology certainly fits the bill. Being able to convert more customers from the outside to the inside is key to increasing traffic.” Another judge called the chain’s Curbside at the Pump order technology “groundbreaking” for the convenience store industry, while a fellow council member also applauded Family Express’ safety measures around selling fresh baked goods during the pandemic. All of its doughnuts and muffins (now made in a new square shape) are fitted into individual plastic wrappers as they come off the assembly line at the retailer’s bakery distribution center. This is Family Express’ first win in the CSNews Foodservice Innovators Awards program. CSN

FOODSERVICE F

FOOD I N SIG HT P O W E R E D B Y DATA S S E N T I A L

Barbecue Trends The protein-driven category continues to innovate into new formats and flavors

AS WE MOVE FROM SUMMER TO FALL,

barbecue surely won’t be forgotten. Nearly 60 percent of restaurants feature barbecue on the menu, as it has the versatility to be used for sandwiches, pizza, wings, and even burgers, according to Datassential’s MenuTrends database. Despite the time and labor that goes into authentic barbecue, consumers still have a high affinity for the protein-driven category. While consumers are drawn to the independent barbecue restaurants and willing to wait in line for hours just to get a taste of authenticity and quality, there are plenty of other ways to experience the flavor of barbecue today because it has expanded far beyond its roots. Sweet, honey and spicy are some of the most commonly paired descriptors on barbecue menus. Both regional and global barbecue are pushing the bounds and creating some complex food profiles.

Regional Barbecue Authentic regional barbecue is viewed as more of a specialty item on menus. Each barbecue region in the United States specializes in its own style. Texas barbecue is known for beef-centric menus, while Missouri barbecue is more focused on the sweet, tomato and molassesbased sauce. According to Datassential’s FLAVOR database, Kansas City barbecue is loved by 17 percent of the U.S., and isn’t just known for ribs — the true star is burnt ends. Once ignored by many chefs, burnt ends have now been repurposed as appetizers or used in stew/gumbo to capture the melted-down fat into a smoky, crunchy bark. And whether you are looking for smoked sausages from a Memphis barbecue joint, or blackened chicken from St. Louis, each state has its own method that makes the experience one of a kind.

Global Barbecue Barbecue is all-encompassing and found in cuisine throughout the world. Yaki is the Japanese word for grilled and is used for a variety of street foods, such as okonomiyaki, takoyaki, yakisoba, yakitori, and much more. Yakitori is the preparation of skew meat or vegetables, grilling over charcoal, and smothering it with a sweet soy sauce and mirin glaze known as tare. It’s still a burgeoning trend

Smokestack Sandwich ($4.99) BBQ the way it should be. Slow-smoked pork, tender and juicy, piled high on a buttery brioche bun and topped with zesty chipotle sauce and crispy onion straws.

Unbranded PI: 54% Branded PI: 70% Uniqueness: 39% Frequency: 24% Draw: 53%

SCORE

Superstar Star ratings reflect each item’s performance vs. other menu items within the same category. Top Performer (>90th percentile) Above Average (70 to 90th percentile) Average (30 to 70th percentile)

Sweet, honey and spicy are some of the most commonly paired descriptors on barbecue menus. (in the inception stage of Datassential’s Menu Adoption Cycle), found on less than 1 percent of menus. But yakitori has a high affinity with millennials — the largest segment of the population. Younger generations like Gen Z have a high affinity for Korean barbecue, which has grown on menus by 40 percent in the last four years. This has influenced many trends, such as Asian street tacos with bulgogi, food truck nachos, and Korean-style wings. As we’ve seen throughout the years, barbecue can’t be pigeon-holed into one bucket and continues to innovate into new formats and flavors. CSN

Datassential, a Chicago-based food and beverage industry research and consulting firm, brings clients real-world insights on flavor trends, foodservice and consumer packaged goods, globally. Learn more at datassential.com.

84 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

Quench Consumer Thirst for A new form-factor is poised to drive the CBD category in c-stores. CBD Drinks are making a splash in the market. One brand, Forth™ CBD, is leading the charge and bringing new shoppers to c-store aisles with CBD-Infused Juice Drinks.

CONSIDER THE CONSUMER CBD drink buyers hit the sweet spot for retailers.

ANTICIPATE THE UPSURGE With the market size for CBD drinks expanding rapidly, c-stores have plenty of tasty new revenue.

2024

220

$186.5M

200 180

More than half have an income above

$75k

$131.9M

140

2022

120

$82.0M

100 80 60

$208.4M

2023

160

2025

8 in 10 are between 24 and 44 years old

2018

$2.6M

2019

$17.1M

2021

$32.8M

2020

$18.8M

63%

use CBD products daily

Nearly

2/3

state that “taste” is a key purchase factor

SAVOR THE SALES POTENTIAL Forth™ CBD-Infused Juice Drinks are delivering more than flavor …

selling form-factor in the CBD category* • Showing strong profit margins • High-quality, lab-tested beverages • Contain 10mg full-spectrum hemp derived CBD per serving

Get what adult consumers want. EalternativeSolutions.com/Forth

UNDERAGE SALE PROHIBITED All data applies to Convenience and Gas channel only. *Sourced from Test Chain Sales May 2021. All other data sourced from Brightfield Group.

TOBACCO

Oral Testimony C-stores can do more to elevate modern oral products to their full backbar potential By Renée M. Covino

DOES YOUR TOBACCO backbar reflect today’s positive buzz around oral nicotine?

The alternative smokeless tobacco segment — otherwise known as modern oral products — is rising in sales and category importance within convenience stores. Modern oral nicotine, which consists primarily of pouches, tablets, gum and lozenges, currently has 91 percent distribution in the convenience channel, according to Swisher, which distributes oral nicotine products in partnership with Rogue Holdings. More than 70 percent of adult tobacco consumers in the United States have expressed interest in modern oral products, notes Brittany Lockard, senior manager, brand and innovation communications for Reynolds American Inc. (RAI), which last year bought pouch manufacturer Dryft and

88 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

incorporated it into its VELO oral pouch line. While the convenience channel has embraced modern oral products, there is more that c-store operators can do to elevate this new segment to its full backbar potential.

Continuously Assess Constant evaluation and evolution of the backbar real estate is essential to meet the demands of today’s adult tobacco consumer, according to Matt Domingo, senior director of external relations at Reynolds Marketing Services Co. Be it via product assortment, the impact of merchandising space, or both, choice must be offered to today’s adult tobacco consumer, who is willing to try different options such as oral nicotine to meet today’s societal demands, he explained.

Put the Emphasis on Pouches Industry insiders agree that the modern oral nicotine category is being driven by pouches. According to recent

EXCLUSIVE BRAND PARTNERSHIPS Our mission at Premier Manufacturing is to produce the finest cigarettes in the industry. Premier Manufacturing is the consumer products division of U.S. Tobacco Cooperative Inc., a 500+ farmer-owned marketing cooperative based in Raleigh, North Carolina. Our farmers provide superior flue-cured tobacco which we use to create high quality cigarette products. Our whole-leaf, flue-cured tobacco is valued by adult consumers for its unmatched natural flavor and aroma. From our farmers to our customers, we proudly deliver exceptional service and products made with the finest U.S. tobacco. At Premier Manufacturing we have developed control label brand relationships with national and regional retail chains such as Cumberland Farms/EG America and Circle K. We successfully provided them brand exclusivity and essentially their own private label as a result. In turn our national sales team is able to provide sales and service support, and create sales and merchandising programs with point-of-sale materials to maintain high retail visibility. All of our brands are American owned, American grown and American manufactured - We proudly state “A Product of US Farmers®”. We believe so strongly in our brands that we back our products with a 100% guarantee.

WHO SAID EXCLUSIVE PARTNERSHIPS CAN’T BE FUN?

GOPREMIER.COM

TOBACCO

data from Management Science Associates Inc. (MSA), volume in the category has almost doubled from last year and now accounts for 14 percent of the smokeless volume in c-stores. For the 26 weeks ended Aug. 1, 2021, nicotine pouches made up 98 percent of modern oral dollar sales. ZYN nicotine pouches are driving Swedish Match North America’s business forward, notes Jason Walker, associate brand manager for ZYN Marketing. Since launching in 2014, ZYN has grown to be the top smokeless brand in several states. “[It’s] currently outselling juggernaut moist snuff brands in states like Utah and Oregon,” Walker relayed. “Most exciting, we have yet to find the ceiling; ZYN continues to grow in the face of significant price competition and brand proliferation.”

Highlight It Separately Through both dedicated space and prominent permanent shelving, c-store retailers are growing the modern oral nicotine category and helping consumers identify and differentiate it from other traditional tobacco products.

“More than 70% of adult tobacco consumers in the United States have expressed interest in modern oral products.” — Brittany Lockard, Reynolds American Inc.

“We recommend merchandising nicotine pouches in their own section in a permanent display,” Walker advised. “Visibility to consumers is extremely important and, given the rapid growth of the category, they are actively looking for it at the store.” Now that the category is more established, consumers are also looking for variety in their favorite pouch brands.

2021’s Most Popular Pouches The American market for nicotine pouches has expanded rapidly, with new brands appearing regularly. Vaping360, a global media website started in 2014 with the goal of “helping smokers switch to a cleaner alternative,” recently tested oral products and released a “short list” of the pouches it found to be at the top. Below is an alphabetized roster of those brands and their distinguishing characteristics:

available in nicotine strengths of 3 or 6 milligrams.

FRĒ is one of the many new brands using synthetic nicotine. FRĒ has two nicotine options: 9 and 12 milligrams. The high nicotine levels appear to be aimed at smokers who want to quit, and at high-nicotine vapers. The company says FRĒ pouches last 45 minutes. They come in five different flavors, 20 to a package.

Rogue pouches are sold in four flavors and two nicotine strengths: 3 and 6 milligrams. They are the largest-sized pouch sold in the U.S. — close to twice the size of an on! pouch, for instance. There are 20 Rogue pouches in each metal tin.

FR3SH also uses synthetic nicotine. The product is available in four flavors and two nicotine strengths: 4 and 6 milligrams. Each FR3SH package contains 20 pouches, which the company says last 30 minutes. Lucy is an emerging name in the category (established in 2019) and is available in gums, lozenges and pouches. Lucy pouches are “aimed at flavor chasers that also want that jolt of nicotine,” according to Vaping360. With three flavor options, these pouches are available in a “slim” variety in 4 and 8 milligram options. NIIN, made with synthetic nicotine, is pre-moistened or “primed.” Each can contains 20 pouches, and each pouch lasts about 30 minutes. Five NIIN flavors are

92 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

On! is made in Sweden and sold in the U.S. by Altria subsidiary Helix Innovations. It is one of the most popular and widely distributed pouch brands, available in seven flavors and five nicotine strengths, ranging from 1.5 to 8 milligrams per pouch. Helix says its “very small” pouches provide 20 minutes of flavor.

VELO pouches (available now in mint and citrus flavors only) are packaged 15 to a metal can, and sold in 2- and 4-milligram strengths. Last year, RAI bought American pouch manufacturer Dryft and incorporated all eight Dryft flavors into its VELO line. The new flavors are available in 2-, 4- and 7-milligram strengths. The 7-milligram ones are branded VELO MAX. ZYN is the “original” nicotine pouch, manufactured in the U.S. by snus market leader Swedish Match. Available in 10 flavors, ZYN pouches come 15 to a can and are available in 3- and 6-milligram strengths. ZYN is the most popular pouch brand in the U.S., with flavors lasting 30 minutes, according to the company. Source: Vaping360

MORE CHOICE FOR THEM M E A N S M O R E P R O F I TS F O R YO U MSA Share Recent 26 Weeks*

19%

Brand A 14%

49% Brand B 11%

Brand C 6%

LET YOUR CUSTOMERS CHOOSE

TOBACCO

“We see that the retailers who carry more than 16 SKUs of ZYN outsell retailers who do not — by nearly double,” Walker told Convenience Store News. Chris Dillard, category manager for tobacco at The Spinx Co., a convenience store chain based in Greenville. S.C., shared that the retailer is pleased with its decision to highlight modern oral nicotine and create a designated space that makes it easier for adult tobacco customers to see the different modern oral options within its innovative tobacco products selection. As a result, he believes customers “are starting to be more aware of the nicotine alternatives.”

Understand How Consumers Have Changed “As times change, adult nicotine preferences also shift,” according to RAI’s Lockard. In light of restrictions regarding where certain tobacco products can be consumed, she explained that some adult smokers are looking for smoke-free alternatives, and some adult dippers are looking for spit-free alternatives. “When we talk to nicotine pouch consumers, the thing that they find most appealing is the convenience. They gravitate toward the smoke-free, spit-free and hands-free benefits as key reasons for adoption,” Walker echoed.

“Visibility to consumers is extremely important and, given the rapid growth of the category, they are actively looking for it at the store.” — Jason Walker, ZYN Marketing

At the same time, he added that the entire U.S. population has been reevaluating priorities amidst the COVID-19 pandemic and based on this reevaluation, “we have seen seismic changes in consumer behavior. Nicotine consumers are no different, and consumers’ perceived benefits of modern oral nicotine mirror some of the behavioral changes that we are seeing on a macro level.”

Be Social

C-store operators would be wise to recognize this and educate their staff on these changes and how modern oral products can fit into the post-pandemic tobacco consumer’s world.

There’s no reason why retailers can’t do the same — targeting their adult tobacco consumers with modern oral product and promotion news on social media.

Let Them Reap Rewards

C-store operators that are willing to differentiate and take on new and emerging categories and forms of tobacco are the ones that are leading in oral nicotine to begin with. But that doesn’t mean they should stop now, according to Domingo.

Rewards programs are at the center of loyalty and are now predicted to have a positive effect on modern oral sales. ZYN has jumped on this as a “differentiator,” according to Walker, and introduced “so far, the first and only rewards program in the category.” Like moist snuff can programs, the ZYN program allows consumers to collect codes from cans, which they can redeem for prizes. He reports “great retail support.”

94 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

More convenience channel customers are learning about modern oral nicotine products and availability through social media channels, Lockard notes. “VELO is on Facebook and Instagram, and these channels give us the opportunity to meet adult nicotine consumers where they are at,” she said.

Keep Taking Chances

C-stores that take chances in the category “are typically the ones who end up capturing the bigger slices of the volume that becomes available from market to market,” he said. CSN

REV UP YOUR CURB APPEAL Attract more business with a brand consumers know and trust when you make the switch to Chevron xpress lube® Maintain your independence with full operational control of your business Leverage a program designed to ensure a high level of customer satisfaction Benefit from the business knowledge of our industry experts Pay no franchise or royalty fees

OUR STRENGTHS. YOUR ADVANTAGE.

Learn more at chevronxpresslube.com

Call us to get started today at (866) 354-4476

CIGARILLOS, CHEROOTS AND FRONTIER XL, ALL MADE IN THE DOMINICAN REPUBLIC WITH ALL-NATURAL TOBACCO — NO HTL!

CIGARILLOS

CHEROOTS

• H -m ! • Ec ri C c ic Wr pp r i Nic r g & D mi ic pr mi m b cc fill r • H ,H B rr , R m, R i Cr m, S Ar m ic, W i k fl r • I i i ll c ll p p ck g i -fr r il i f 10 cig r

• P l i Br l f Wr pp r i Nic r g & D mi ic pr mi m b cc fill r • P p l r p r g -c f rm • S Ar m ic, R i Cr m, H , H B rr fl r • P ck g i r - l bl -fr p c i 5 cig r p r p c

FRONTIER XL • Ec ri C c ic Wr pp r i Nic r g & D mi ic pr mi m b cc fill r • R i Cr m S Ar m ic fl r • P ck g i r - l bl -fr p c i 3 cig r p r p c

FRONTIER_version 2.indd All Pages

ADVERTORIAL

Exploring Cigar Smoking’s

NEW FRONTIER A CONVERSATION WITH JOHN GIESE,

b nd d v

m d w

VP of Sales & Marketing, Frontier Cigars

vc f

d n

F n

c m

k dJ

d c

n ’ f c

m k

W ’

m k n

bri g

m ng

l i

x c i

xp r i : 41

i i

g m

ir c r f J

b cc f

i i Lim rick, P

m k

i r

i .

c mp

F n

nd n ’ j

m k

F n

H v ng b

n n

CSN: W

m k fr m

JG: W m f

d c

m k

m rk

m c

g c

f ,

gm n , ff

r li c-

r gr

r i

i rb l f r c-

g k

n b

n A

(NAC ) W b

c ,b

n f C nv

gn w

w d

, c

v n nc g

f D

m mb n fW

r . W ic

(CDA) nd N c

ng b

p p l r

cig r c

nd d f nd N

n d c

dff

g r

f m

d $3 6B f

5 -w k

d nd ng A

3 nd c n n

3, 0

d n d nJ n

n m m

CSN: C i

i -19 c cig r c

- v -

g w

v m n c

m ng g w

d c

N n n mb b ng

i r cig r

pic ll c rr ?

F n

C nv n nc D

d c,

ng w

JG: I d ! R c n nd

b wn w

v w

c nv n nc c g

cig r c-

fl g ,

c nd v n

b c m ?

c n

F n Fr

CSN: D

m n f c

d ,Iw

ng nd

ng w

mcg

imp r

W f

n x n v b ckg

XL nd F n g

nd g n fiv b

F n

dv nc

nd q ck d c v

F n n

d c

ng m

v d

JG: F n

nd b

cig r f r m ?’

John Giese: Af

b c

gn fic n nv n

n w

CSN: T

r. w

m n f c

m c

j m

r bl

r fir JG:

pp i

g &

, ‘T i i

cri

And b fi f

CSN: I

7,000 q

’ M

T b cc

f r

p—

m n

i r

n b

r , 21 f

,C .Y ’

r bl

r ? n

v b

c fr m Fr

r .S

’ n n

p ii

b cc i

n ff d b wd

r ’ b

JG: T

m d

—b

i gf r

d n m n f c-

f c-

i rib

c r

c n

d n b ng ng

m mcg

b c g

k ng

nd d

filli g c-

nf n n

f (HTL), w c

b wn

-f c

OTP c

Convenience Store News: Y

b cc

g -q

v n

W n v

m n-m d c m j

D mnc nR -

b cc

n nd U A P nn

m g nz d

—

b c—c n

v m

b cc

fi b n w f n c m

XL c g

c m

D mnc nR

nd F n

m d n

nd m k

n ’

-n

b c, N c Convenience Store News

x m

m g r ,

ppl ic

T c

FRONTIER, c c J h G (610) 420-4742 Contact@FrontierCigar.com

8/26/21 11:51 AM

GROCERY

Remaining Relevant The grocery categories at c-stores benefited from consumers’ pandemic-influenced shopping shifts, but can the momentum last? By Renée M. Covino AT THE HEIGHT OF THE PANDEMIC,

many consumers who didn’t ordinarily shop at convenience stores got the brilliant idea that they could run in and out and get a few items they desperately needed — such as spray cleaner, a bottle of wine, toilet paper, etc. Fueled by accessibility, c-store grocery shopping became all the rage as customers caught on to the benefits of no lines, reduced human contact, speedy shopping, and in-stock shelves. It was a time when “convenience stores became less about energy drinks and bags of chips on the go and more about getting the day-to-day essentials,” said Anders McGillis, principal at Ontario, Canada-based Jackman Reinvents, a customer engagement firm that helps organizations reinvent their customer experiences.

recently worked with Batavia, Ill.-based Aldi (operator of supermarkets in 37 states) to launch the first Aldi Corner Store, a local, art-infused, urban-oriented small format developed in Sydney, Australia. “A local store not only feels safer, it is safer,” Landini said. Becoming “local grocers” during the pandemic, he observed that c-store operators learned to make “informed decisions and put themselves in their customers’ heads.” He offered up a personal example: “I recently bought individual sticks of celery from a local store. They understood I only needed three stalks, so they didn’t attempt to sell me more. By weight, I may have spent more, but it felt good, less wasteful. I’ll be back.”

A Look at the Numbers

It was also a time when consumers everywhere rallied around supporting local. “The early stages of the pandemic exposed weaknesses in supply chains, alerting people to the value of being able to access goods in their local communities,” McGillis told Convenience Store News. “Faced with empty shelves at big-box stores, people turned to alternatives, both in terms of products and stores, to find what they needed.”

According to research firm NCSolutions, in mid-May of this year (around when the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention lifted indoor mask guidelines) through mid-July, dollar sales for edible grocery collectively across channels were 3.4 percent higher compared to the same period in 2019, while sales for nonedible grocery across channels were 2.6 percent higher compared to 2019 levels.

In turn, c-stores relied on local suppliers to stay in stock. McGillis pointed to family-owned c-store chain Duchess, based in Heath, Ohio, which he said, “leaned heavily into local products when designing and stocking the shelves of its new flagship store.”

Produce sales during this period were also 3 percent higher than 2019 levels, and meat sales were 1 percent higher. “This demonstrates that increased at-home meal preparation is here to stay,” the research firm concluded.

During the pandemic, “community” also became more important than it’s ever been before, noted Mark Landini, creative director at Landini Associates, which

98 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

NCSolutions also pointed out that the growth rate of health-driven categories, such as fruit (up 6 percent over 2019 levels) and vitamins and supplements (up 33 percent), demonstrates a heightened consumer focus on health.

Additionally, cleaning category sales for the period of May 9 through July 17, 2021 were collectively 3 percent higher than 2019 levels. “We are still using more cleaning products than we did pre-pandemic,” the research firm stated. Looking at the top CPG categories with the highest spend, NCSolutions says those with the greatest staying potential moving into the next phase of the pandemic are:

• Beer (up 17 percent compared to the same period in 2019); • Liquor (up 21 percent); • Vitamins and supplements (up 33 percent);

• Isotonic/sports drink beverages (up 17 percent); and • Frozen entrees (up 11 percent).

“While consumers have gotten more comfortable traveling and gathering this summer, overall grocery spend is still elevated compared to 2019 levels, indicating that consumers are continuing to spend more time and prepare meals at home,” Linda Dupree, CEO of NCSolutions told CSNews. “The CPG categories with the highest growth from 2019 levels reflect continued consumer focus on conviviality, health and convenience as they navigate continued uncertainty with the Delta variant.”

The Next Phase Convenience stores can stay ahead of grocery trends by understanding the dietary, environmental and social attributes within their current product assortment, as well as their customers’ ever-changing need states, according to Hannah Polk, RD Solutions consultant at Label Insight, a NielsenIQ company.

Polk identified some food and beverage trends relevant to the c-store space that are growing significantly in search volume vs. the previous six months: natural, electrolytes, low-calorie, pre-made, adaptogenic, sport, green ingredients, dairy-free, weight loss, and vegan. In non-edible grocery, consumers are shifting toward cleaner and more sustainable products, Polk said. Within the personal care space, growing attributes include plastic-free, aluminum-free, reef safe, paraphenylenediamine (PPD) free, and ultra-sensitive. Within the household cleaners space, niche attributes that are growing fast include “naturally derived” and “contains essential oils.” The pandemic-driven rise in frozen foods should also be on c-store radars. A new report from integrated sales and marketing provider Acosta, entitled The Pandemic-Fueled Growth of Frozen Foods, found that produce, pizza, snacks and entrees are the frozen categories purchased more frequently since COVID-19, due to consumers cooking at home more, eating healthier, and adhering to a budget.

Retention Strategies Convenience stores that increased their grocery sales during the pandemic have a new challenge as the nation tries to get back to normal: retention of these shoppers. McGillis of Jackman Reinvents said his firm has seen “significant change” in the c-store space, with existing players going beyond the basics. He praised some players for elevating their assortment by adding organic, gourmet and fresh items. “Adding quality food products that consumers want can turn a convenience store into a grocery destination and part of their routine,” he told CSNews. S E P T E MB E R

20 21

Convenience Store News

GROCERY

Rather than arranging the c-store based on product type, he challenges c-stores to group products based on shopper mindsets. “In the same way many grocery stores are set up, consider carving out a dedicated space for health-forward or wellness products, or those that serve a specific diet or nutrition,” McGillis advised. Unique store design can be a powerful draw, too. With the idea that design has the power to make consumers smile and feel good about where they are shopping, Landini noted that Aldi Corner Store utilizes local art to personalize its store design and help set the brand apart from a typical grocery store experience. “A supermarket used to be two words: an adjective describing a noun. Delivery and operational systems have compromised this and now it’s become unpersonal and somewhat absent of any joy,” he said. “We believe this can be challenged with design in the convenience channel.”

“The early stages of the pandemic exposed weaknesses in supply chains, alerting people to the value of being able to access goods in their local communities.” — Anders McGillis, Jackman Reinvents

Trending Now Grocery trends recently identified by research firm NCSolutions (based on sales data from May 9 through July 17, 2021 compared to the same period in 2019) include: • The popularity of a convenient breakfast — Sales of shelf-stable convenient breakfast grew 251 percent during the period analyzed; refrigerated quiche grew by 40 percent; refrigerated breakfast entrees and frozen breakfast entrees were both up 32 percent; and frozen breakfast sandwiches grew 30 percent.

Along with store design and layout, and paying attention to product trends in the edible and non-edible grocery categories, c-stores can also remain relevant to grocery shoppers beyond the pandemic with some digital marketing ideas.

• Tremendous growth in pet categories — Pet brushes grew by 51 percent; pet repellent by 50 percent; pet medicine by 49 percent; and pet toys by 36 percent.

“Put your business on the map,” urges Devin Schumacher, founder of the digital marketing agency SERP. “With the technological advancements available, consumers rarely visit brick-and-mortar businesses without researching them first. People don’t walk around searching for c-stores; they look them up online.”

• Prep-free beverages in demand — Consumers are gravitating toward convenient beverages that don’t require any prep. Premixed cocktails were up 193 percent, and bottled coffee was up 25 percent.

With that in mind, he advises c-store operators to create a Google My Business profile and then promote it. This will allow that c-store to pop up in Google search engines, social media recommendations, and even GPS navigation apps.

customers generally come from, then incorporate the locations into your next campaigns.”

Location-based businesses like convenience stores should focus their marketing efforts on prospects within their service areas. “Targeting those from a different city will unnecessarily spike your ad spend,” cautioned Schumacher. “Identify where your most frequent

He believes partnering with delivery apps such as Postmates is also a must for c-stores in these times. “If there’s anything the recent lockdowns taught us, it’s that many people will avoid leaving the comfort of their homes as much as possible,” he said. CSN

100 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

www.invenco.com/csn sales@invenco.com

+1 877 515 0939

sick of this yet? Stop settling for non-compliant, outdated and overpriced offerings. Get used to something new, with Invenco outdoor payment terminals and convenience store solutions. Invenco’s top-quality, “off the shelf” terminals are delivered through cost-effective, retailer-minded, rental or ownership plans. Invenco keeps sites running with EMV compliance, a fast “pop and swap” repair model, remote troubleshooting and cloud-delivered software and compliance updates. All Invenco solutions are built on digitally agile, open platform systems.

Experience the Invenco difference today.

Pay-at-Pump Terminals | Outdoor EMV Low-Cost Upgrade Program | Retrofit Kits for all Pump Models iNFX Retail Microservice Softwares | Cloud Services Remote Asset Management Platform | Link High-Speed Ethernet Network

CBD

CBD in the C-store While product popularity continues to shift, c-stores are still primed to benefit from this category By Tammy Mastroberte WHILE CBD LAWS are still not standardized nationwide, consumer products derived from hemp became legal as part of the 2018 version of the U.S. Farm Bill, and 2019 saw explosive growth in the category. At the end of 2019, however, the category suffered slightly when the Food and Drug Administration warned consumers to stop using products with THC and CBD following an outbreak of lung injuries associated with the products.

Many consumers instead turned to topicals and other CBD products as replacements, according to Don Burke, senior vice president of Management Science Associates Inc. (MSA), a Pittsburghbased company focused on analytics and informatics. In fact, sales of topicals soared to No. 1 in the CBD category for a time; they recently dropped to No. 2 with gummies taking the top spot.

102 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

“In 2021, gummies have returned to the best-selling product form in c-stores, followed by topicals and tinctures, and vape is starting to come back fairly strong as well,” Burke told Convenience Store News. Overall, CBD sales in the convenience channel have declined from where they were in 2019, and the COVID19 pandemic drove people online to shop for these products, which hurt c-stores, noted Mike Luce, president of Chicago-based High Yield Insights, a provider of data-driven insights about the cannabis market. The good news, though, is that awareness of CBD and hemp products is higher than ever, and sales projections are still on an upward curve, he said. “None of the spaces are saturated the way mainstream beer is,” said Luce. “There is a lot of competition within individual categories, such as gummies, but there is still room for growth, and CBD drinks are ideal for the c-store industry. Right now, CBD drinks are ranked among the highest categories that CBD consumers are not using but interested in using in the future.”

The World’s Most Trusted Hemp Extract ™ Seven brothers started Charlotte’s Web because they believed in creating a world where good health is attainable for everyone. From our seeds, soil, and hands-on approach to farming, to our FDA-registered facility, our rigorous standards for quality and consistency set Charlotte’s Web products apart.

V EVGEAGNA N

N ONNO-NG-MGOM O

LEARN MORE AT CHARLOTTESWEB.COM

CBD

Looking at the total adult population in the United States, only 16 percent are current CBD users, meaning they used a product within the past three months. The potential for growth in the category is revealed in the 84 percent who are not current users, Luce pointed out. “If you drill down, of that 84 percent, 46 percent expressed interest in trying CBD, and 13 percent are former CBD users that may come back,” he explained. Additionally, once the pandemic has passed and shopping patterns return to normal — with consumers commuting to and from work again — CBD sales are expected to grow once more in the retail space, along with the introduction of new cannabinoids such as CBG and CBN, said Burke. “There is also the emergence of Delta-8, which is a cannabinoid that offers similar effects as THC, but it’s not THC so it’s legal to sell in a c-store — although this is likely to change,” the MSA executive noted. There are some states that have already banned or restricted Delta-8 products, including Alaska, Arizona, Arkansas, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Kentucky, Idaho, Iowa, Michigan, Montana, New York, North Dakota, Rhode Island, Utah, Vermont and Washington. “Connecticut, New York and some other states banned the products completely, and others like Michigan say they will treat it like marijuana,” said Luce.

The CBD Shopper Females are actually the majority of CBD users (60 percent) vs. males, with the bulk falling in the Generation Z age bracket (45 percent), according to research from High Yield Insights. Generation X makes up 28 percent of users, while boomers and seniors represent 26 percent. According to research from Management Science Associates, which surveyed more than 100,000 people in the U.S., the specific age range for male CBD users is between 18 and 49, while female CBD users fall within the 18- to 34-year-old range. “The typical CBD shopper is good news for c-stores because they are typically younger, liberal, and either students or blue-collar workers in skilled trades, such as plumbers, electricians and landscapers,” Burke reported. “It’s also far more likely that a tobacco consumer would be using CBD, which is more good news for c-stores as tobacco users are walking through the door several times per week.” In terms of the reasons CBD users shop for products, as of the research

104 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

conducted in 2019 and 2020 by Management Science Associates, the No. 1 reason is to temporarily relieve minor aches and pains (77 percent). Other reasons include relieving chronic pain (75 percent), helping with anxiety and stress (73 percent), and helping with sleep (71 percent). Additionally, 67 percent cite using it for increased general wellness, and 66 percent use it to improve their physical health, showing there is a wellness component to the product, according to MSA. “Most people think of CBD as a wellness item, so if a c-store has a wellness or healthier options section in the store, it would make sense to market CBD with these items,” Burke advised. In fact, recent research by The Integer Group, a growth marketing agency that offers data-driven insights, suggests that consumers are shifting their CBD usage from ailment-based reasons such as pain and anxiety, to more wellness benefits such as an improved workout, and social occasions. This is especially true among younger consumers, noted Armand Parra, senior vice president of insight and strategy at the company, based in Lakewood, Colo.

“The typical CBD shopper is good news for c-stores because they are typically younger, liberal, and either students or blue-collar workers in skilled trades, such as plumbers, electricians and landscapers.” — Don Burke, Management Science Associates Inc.

CBD

“Quality and trust are the most important decision factors, and consumers are looking for credentials like certifications, grower information and testing results to verify product dosage and efficacy,” Parra pointed out.

What Are They Buying? MSA’s research shows convenience stores as the fourth most-popular retail option for those purchasing CBD, as 29 percent reported shopping for CBD in a c-store. The top choice, at 45 percent, was from a natural or specialty retailer, followed by a smoke or vape shop (39 percent), and direct from manufacturers (29 percent). Within the CBD category, there are many different product forms available. These include edibles, such as gummies; topicals, such as creams and lotions; tinctures and oils; vape pens and smokables; drinks; and even beer. Right now, gummies are the No. 1 product being sold, followed by topicals, tinctures and oils, vape pens and smokables, and drinks, according to Burke. Within the drinks category, which only represents 21 percent of the total space currently, non-carbonated water, fruit drinks, cola and energy/recovery shots make up 74 percent of the beverage dollars. Burke also noted that although topicals account for only 10 percent of the SKUs available, the category accounts for 26 percent of dollars, compared to vape, which accounts for 21 percent of the SKUs available, but only 3 percent of the dollars. “The products that best fit the c-store shopper and environment are edibles, beverages and oils/drops and tinctures,” said Parra. “Vapes/smokables, patches and alcoholic beverages are the CBD product forms that shoppers are currently least interested in purchasing.” While CBD beverages currently fall lower on the list in terms of demand, the category is seeing more products and options and, in some chains, is selling very well. At Betterment Retail Solutions, a West Des Moines, Iowa-based health and wellness company that connects up-and-coming brands with retailers, its No. 1 selling product in the category is flat CBD water. “There is infused coffee, energy drinks, and any type of beverage you can think of with CBD,” said Tony Sparks, the company’s senior vice president of marketing. “In the cold vault, I recommend grouping all CBD into the same space, at least initially. Since vault space for certain categories such as energy and sport are hard to cut into prime shelf space, splitting CBD beverages up by segment will not get them the visibility they need.” Sparks is seeing the smokable CBD segment perform well in c-stores as well, including products that look like actual cigarettes but have no tobacco, such as Vance Global CBD, which tested well for the company in c-stores, he noted.

106 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

The Most Popular Forms of CBD According to data collected in 2019 and 2020 by Management Science Associates Inc., the most popular forms of CBD purchased at retail are: • Edibles, such as gummies (36 percent) • Topicals (32 percent) • Tinctures (29 percent) • Vaporizers/vape pens (22 percent) • Drinks (21 percent)

Best Practices for CBD C-stores that may have tried CBD products but didn’t find success should consider changing their approach and how they are marketing the products in their stores, according to Sparks. Many may have tried a turnkey program from distributors, but he recommends a multivendor approach to CBD. “We take a multi-vendor approach with floor and counter displays that are not just CBD, but may also have other functional products and brands in it as well,” he explained. “It doesn’t have to be all CBD or nothing.” He also suggests retailers “call out CBD” in their marketing so that customers know it’s available there — and do so in a big way. In fact, Betterment Retail Solutions tested neon signs that say CBD, aiming for customers to notice them when they walk up to the cold vault door. Every store with the sign saw an increase in sales, Sparks shared. CSN

TECHNOLOGY

Putting Technology in the Forefront Retailers are making plans to increase their tech investments and improve everything from data security to the customer experience By Angela Hanson

in the convenience store industry and its impact on retailers' future plans continually evolves based on current needs, emerging innovations, and the state of the industry at large.

THE ROLE OF TECHNOLOGY

One year ago, the then-looming EMV liability shift deadline pushed c-store operators to focus on compliance. Today, there is no such singular driving force, yet technology is no less important to convenience retailers, who plan to increase their techrelated investments, according to the findings of the 2021 Convenience Store News Technology Study. Respondents to the annual study listed a broad range of business opportunities when asked about their technology-related priorities for the coming year. Unlike in 2020, when 20 percent of respondents stated that becoming EMV compliant was their single highest priority, no front-runner emerged this year. Rather, operators listed a variety of priorities at roughly equal rates. These priorities include replacing aging point-ofsale (POS) technology, developing greater business intelligence and reporting capabilities, employee training, and compelling customers from the fuel pump to the store. Improving the customer experience is also a high priority, with frictionless/ self-checkout technology, curbside pickup, and

TITLE SPONSOR

108 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

providing better product/service information to customers among the most frequently mentioned options. Over the next year, more than half of respondents (52 percent) plan to direct at least part of their investments toward improving data security, and nearly half plan to invest in technologies to train employees, improve the use of loyalty data, and compel customers from the pump to the store. Operators are willing to spend to make these plans a reality. From 2019 to 2020, 71 percent of study participants reported increasing their technology budget, which encompasses everything from hardware and software to IT staff, cloud subscription fees, consulting and more. In 2021, 83 percent expect to spend just as much or more on technology and automation as they did in 2020. Additionally, four out of every five companies that reported a decreased or unchanged technology budget in 2020 planned to increase it this year.

Current & Future Technologies Much of retailers' current involvement in technology is directly related to customer interaction, such as social media (implemented by 69 percent of study respondents) and consumer-facing

TECHNOLOGY

Changes in Technology Budget: Past vs. Future 2019 to 2020

71%

Increased

Decreased

2021 vs. 2020

17%

75% Will spend more

No Change

8% don't know

Will spend less

% INCREASE IN TECHNOLOGY BUDGET

41%

12%

29%

18%

8% Will spend about the same

8% 0.1% to 4.9%

5% to 9.9%

10% to 14.9%

15% to 19.9%

20% or more

websites (54 percent). Digital monitors in-store (49 percent), as well as mobile apps and digital loyalty programs (both at 46 percent), are also fairly widespread. Retailers most frequently listed text messaging to customers (40 percent), e-mail marketing and GPS/ geolocation alerts (both at 37 percent) as being planned for the future. On the forecourt, 46 percent of respondents report that they have digital monitors, and 31 percent have advertising/couponing. Of those that do not currently have advertising/couponing at the pump, nearly 30 percent plan to add it in the next one to two years. Few operators currently offer merchandise/foodservice ordering at the pump, but more than 34 percent report that they plan to add it in the future.

Don't know

Current vs. Future Involvement in Technology Implemented

Plan to add

69%

Social media

20% 54%

Consumer-facing website

29% 49%

Digital monitors in-store

20%

Digital loyalty program

46% 31%

Mobile app

46% 29%

EMV Compliance Despite being well past the April 2021 deadline that shifted outdoor EMV liability to convenience store and gas station operators, 58 percent of respondents are not yet fully EMV compliant at both their in-store POS and fuel pumps. More operators are EMV compliant in-store (77 percent) than at the pump (42 percent), but a majority of respondents say they have started the process for both. Just 11 percent of retailers say they have not begun the process at the POS, and 23 percent have not begun at their pumps. Among those not yet in full compliance, on average, approximately half of their networks are currently EMV compliant, and 60 percent expect to reach full compliance by the end of 2021. Thirteen percent expect to reach full compliance by the end of 2022, while 27 percent don’t expect to reach full compliance until sometime after 2022.

Digital monitors at pump

17%

40% 37%

Email marketing

37% 29%

Data analytics platform

34% 40%

Text messaging to customers

31% 29%

Advertising/couponing at pump

23%

GPS/geolocation alerts

37%

The Ongoing Impact of COVID-19 The COVID-19 pandemic is commonly cited by industry observers as being a major contributor to increased rollout of contactless shopping options, but the reality is a bit more nuanced. Just 13 percent of retailers report that they sped up expansion and/or enhancement of

110 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

23% 34%

CRM software Merchandise/foodservice ordering at pump

46%

34%

YOUR FUTURE, ADD SOLUTIONS

PERFECT FIT

SOFTWARE SOLUTIONS to make your vision a reality. You can see it. ADD Systems can help you build it. Our software solutions give you the tools to reshape and grow your business. From the ofﬁce to the ﬁeld, from delivery operations to your stores, our staff of industry specialists has the expertise to help you gain a competitive advantage.

BOOTH #4277

PETROLEUM DISTRIBUTION

C-STORES

HVAC

800•922•0972

addsys.com

TECHNOLOGY

existing contactless technology, delivery and curbside pickup options in response to the pandemic. However, 32 percent sped up implementation of new contactless technology, delivery and curbside pickup options; and 24 percent said the pandemic sparked their interest in exploring these options. Thirty-one percent stated that none of those options applied. Small and large operators had significantly different responses to the pandemic, though, possibly due to small operators having more limited resources to allocate to technology development overall. Just 4 percent of small operators sped up the expansion/enhancement of existing technology, compared to 21 percent of large operators; and 24 percent of small operators sped up implementation of new technology, compared to 38 percent of large operators. Additionally, a larger percentage of small operators (44 percent) reported that the pandemic did not impact their technology in any of the specified ways, vs. 21 percent of large operators.

Ordering & Fulfillment

Impact of COVID-19 Pandemic on Technology Development Total

Ninety-two percent of retailers that offer ordering via app also have website ordering, while just 69 percent of respondents that offer website ordering also offer ordering via app.

A third of respondents offer delivery, with 62 percent partnering with third-party delivery service DoorDash and 38 percent partnering with Uber Eats. Forty-seven percent of those without delivery said they plan to offer it in the future, while 53 percent have no plans to add delivery.

112 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

13% 4% 21% 32%

Sped up implementation of new contactless technology, delivery and curbside pickup options

24% 38%

Sparked our interest in exploring contactless technology, delivery and curbside pickup options for the future

24% 28% 21% 31% 44%

None of the above 21%

EMV Compliance Compliance Status At POS

At Pump

Yes

77%

42%

No, but started

11%

35%

No, and not started

11%

23%

Statistical significance at 95% level

Whatever the ordering method, 35 percent of respondents only allow customers to pick up their orders inside the store. Curbside pickup is offered by 41.3 percent of respondents. The availability of pumpside pickup saw a significant decline over the past year, going from 20.5 percent of respondents in 2020 to just 6.5 percent this year. This may indicate that out-of-store pickup options were associated with safety measures during the pandemic rather than standalone convenience, and are considered less necessary now following widespread reopening.

Large Operators

Sped up expansion and/ or enhancement of existing contactless technology, delivery and curbside pickup options

More than a third of convenience retailers currently offer mobile ordering via website, up from 19.6 percent a year ago, while just over a quarter offer mobile ordering via an app. Apps are likely to become the more popular option in the future, as 56 percent of respondents that don't currently offer ordering via app plan to do so in the future, while just 41 percent of those that don't offer ordering via website plan to add that in the future.

Small Operators

Statistical significance at 90% level

Expected Timing of Full EMV Compliance

58%

End of 2022

Currently not fully EMV compliant at both POS and pump

60%

End of 2021

Sometime after 2022

13%

27%

Win Bitcoin & other digital currency prizes at Booth #1224 And while you’re there ... Discover how Coin Cloud machines can increase your bottom line through targeted foot traffic and multiple streams of income. It’s 100% turnkey with zero cost and zero work.

We’re on a mission of

Bringing Digital Currency to All™ including you and your customers!

Partners@Coin.Cloud

TECHNOLOGY

Opportunities Driving Investment in Technologies in Coming Year

Payment Options A majority of retailers offer standard credit/debit and electronic benefits transfer (EBT) payment technologies, but they are increasingly considering alternative options. Looking ahead to the future, frictionless self-checkout technology is considered a top option as retailers look to give customers more control over their experience: 35 percent plan to add frictionless self-checkout using kiosks, 28 percent plan to add frictionless self-checkout using an app, and 35 percent plan to add frictionless self-checkout using AI/sensors.

52%

Improve data security Employee training

48%

Improve use of loyalty data

48%

Compel customers from pump into store

48%

Increase customer payment options

43%

Better management of store labor expense

43%

Employee communications

43%

Mobile/online ordering

43%

75% expect to spend more on technology this year than they did in 2020.

Mobile app

43%

Half of respondents currently offer in-store mobile payment, but this is another option that is expected to increase over the next few years. Retailers significantly favor Near Field Communications (NFC) mobile payments over Quick Response (QR) mobile payments.

Provide better product/service information to customers

30%

Optimize menu boards

30%

Curbside pickup

30%

On the forecourt, third-party mobile payment options such as Apple Pay and Samsung Pay are the second-most utilized payment technology following the ubiquitous credit/debit. A quarter of respondents indicate they plan to add third-party mobile payment in the future. Proprietary mobile payment is currently the least utilized payment technology at the pump, but 38 percent of retailers intend to add it in the future — more than any other option.

Loyalty Programs Just over half of respondents (52 percent) have a loyalty program, a figure that has held steady in recent years. More than seven in 10 of these operators describe their company's loyalty program as proprietary, marking the second straight year that such programs have outpaced those tied to a major oil brand.

114 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

Better management of store level inventory/revenue

39%

Integration of systems

39%

Frictionless/self-checkout technology

39%

Develop greater business intelligence and reporting capabilities

35%

Provide store manager with decision tools

35%

Developing personalized marketing capabilities

35%

Mobile apps associated with loyalty programs continue to rise in popularity. Of the proprietary loyalty programs offered by c-store retailers, 29 percent are supported by a mobile app, 21 percent use a physical card, and 50 percent include both. Store locator is the most popular feature of the mobile apps, followed by money-saving elements such as vendor coupons, limited-time specials, and proprietary product coupons.

Social Media & Customer Feedback Eighty-five percent of convenience retailers utilize social media in their marketing plans. Facebook is by far the most popular platform used, followed by Twitter and Instagram. Companies primarily use social media to share content about promotions (cited by 91 percent) and events (77 percent). Social media posts about new vendor products, contests and community service initiatives are common as well. Despite the widespread use of social media, only 54 percent of respondents track feedback from customers, and most do so manually (64 percent), without the use of tools or programs other than Excel. This suggests that c-stores have room for improvement when it comes to streamlining the feedback pipeline and listening to their most vocal customers. CSN

FEATURE

The NACS Show Is Back The convenience store industry's premier expo is ready to resume course By Don Longo UNLESS THERE IS A MAJOR SETBACK in the fight against the coronavirus pandemic, the 2021 NACS Show will be open for business in October with few changes or restrictions compared to pre-COVID-19 exhibitions.

“Right now, the format and agenda for the 2021 NACS Show will be very similar to previous shows,” Jeff Lenard, vice president of strategic industry initiatives for the industry's trade association, told Convenience Store News. The show is scheduled to be held at Chicago's McCormick Place on Oct. 5-8. Lenard assured CSNews that the association will continue to monitor everything show related, from transportation to hotels to the convention center's safety requirements. He pointed out that ”everything went smoothly” for the recently held World of Concrete show, which was held at McCormick Place June 8-10. ”That show is roughly the same-size expo as ours in both exhibitor space and attendance,” said Lenard. ”That's a really great sign.” One nod to the pandemic will be several COVID-19 related education sessions on the show's agenda. 116 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

To help ensure safety, this year’s expo floor will have wider aisles to minimize traffic congestion and allow for social distancing.

“There's at least one session with 'COVID' in the title, and several other sessions allude to trends, such as home delivery, supply chain efficiency, new last-mile experiences, etc., that developed around the pandemic,” Lenard said. Other sessions will focus on the industry's current No. 1 challenge: the labor shortage. Another positive sign for the expo is that exhibitor space is more than 90 percent filled, and expectations are that show floor space will once again be sold out. Lenard expects more suppliers to sign up as travel restrictions at many companies expire in the third quarter of the year.

Nutrients. Electrolytes. Coconut Goodness.

JOIN CSNEWS AND THE TOP FOODSERVICE C-STORE E XECUTIVES IN COUNTRY FOR A T WO - DAY NE T WORKING E XPERIENTIAL SUMMIT.

NOVEMBER 9 & 10 CHARLOT TE | NORTH CAROLINA

E clusive J O I N E X E C U T I V E S F R O M Y E S WA Y, P A R K E R ’ S , H I G H ’ S , K W I K T R I P, C I R C L E K , 7 - E L E V E N , M AV E R I K & M O R E A T T H I S I N V I T E - O N LY E V E N T !

E perience T H I S I S N ’ T YO U R T Y P I CA L C O N F E R E N C E . E N G A G E W I T H P E E R S A N D PA R T N E R S VIA THE POWER HOUR - CFX’S UNIQUE 1 : 1 C O L L A B O R AT I O N M E E T I N G S , FOOD TREND TOUR HOSTED B Y TA S T E C A R O L I N A A N D A V I S I T T O T H E R E N OW N E D C U L I N A RY S C H O O L J O H N S O N & WA L E S

CONTACT DON LONGO TO REQUEST YOUR EXCLUSIVE INVITATION. dlongo@ensembleiq.com

CFX2021_HA_09.2021_Final.indd 1

8/25/21 11:43 AM

FEATURE

Buyer attendance is tracking ahead of the last time the NACS Show was held in Chicago, which was October 2017. Although domestic buyer registration is up, Lenard said the association expects international attendance to be significantly below previous years' numbers due to the restrictions on international travel from countries still being heavily impacted by the virus.

One nod to the pandemic will be several COVID-19 related education sessions.

“I go to the show, no matter what,” said Jared Scheeler, CEO of Dickinson, N.D.based The Hub Convenience Stores Inc. ”The factors that make me want to be there are that I personally want to be a leading retailer. I also want to be a trailblazer. I want to experiment. It is easy to lose that inspiration. The NACS Show provides me inspiration on where I want to go with my business.” For those who are unable to attend, Lenard said, ”There will absolutely be some sort of post-show digital component,” but he also stated that there are no plans for the event to be a hybrid live/online show. Last year’s NACS Show was entirely virtual.

Commitment to Safety Safety is the top priority. “We have all kinds of protocols in place — even in normal years,” Lenard said. “We do 'what if' scenario planning every year to try to anticipate anything that might happen before it happens.” NACS has already taken steps to help ensure safety by building this year’s expo floor with wider aisles to minimize traffic congestion and allow for social distancing. Meeting rooms, general sessions, education sessions, workshops and public spaces will be configured according to the recommendations at the time of the show in October. As for a policy regarding attendee vaccinations, “we want everyone to be vaccinated, but we won't be asking attendees to provide proof of vaccination,” Lenard said. The facial masking policy is still evolving. NACS is closely monitoring health agency recommendations. Product sampling on the show floor will be slightly different as no self-serve sampling will be allowed.

NACS President & CEO Henry Armour anticipates a successful show.

According to the NACS Show website, as of press time, the association will implement and enforce protocols established by local and federal government agencies, which may include: • Encouraging social distancing in all common areas through signage and floor decals; • Face covering will likely be required; • Enhanced cleaning and sanitization with an emphasis on high traffic and touchpoint areas; and • Hand sanitizer stations located throughout the building and in every booth. NACS President and CEO Henry Armour anticipates a successful show. “Our industry is built upon connections — whether with loyal customers, dedicated coworkers, or suppliers who help us better our businesses,” said Armour. “And the NACS Show delivers those connections to new products and ideas that can help you see the future. I can't wait to see you in Chicago.” CSN

S E P T E MBE R

20 21

Convenience Store News

119

NEW HORIZONS

The Myth of the Critical Female Boss Banishing this stereotype is a key step to advancing women to leadership roles

By Sarah Alter President & CEO Network of Executive Women

THE FORTUNE 500 for 2021 has yet again broken a record of more female CEOs than ever, carrying on last year’s trend in the same direction. Yet women still only make up 8.1 percent of Fortune 500 CEOs, and one has to wonder what old biases might be continuing to contribute to this disparity.

The Myth of the Female Boss

We’ve all heard workplace myths — truths universally acknowledged about working in the corporate world. Based in feelings, not facts, they nestle deeply into workplace cultures and can be very difficult to uproot. Take the myth that remote employees are less productive, for example. Clearly disproven by research time and time again, and put to the ultimate test last year, this “myth” has no basis in fact. But it still has yet to be completely let go of in the wake of the pandemic.

Another possibility is that you expect a woman to manage in a softer way. According to a recent study by the IZA Institute of Labor Economics, both men and women react more negatively to criticism when it comes from a woman.

Another deeply ingrained myth — that women make “toxic” bosses — is also unfortunately still alive and well in our workplaces. Banishing it is a key step to advancing women to leadership roles.

120 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

When critiqued by a woman in management, I sincerely hope your first reaction isn’t to lump her in with this problematic stereotype. It’s true that your boss may have poor management skills, or be unable to offer truly constructive criticism. That’s one possibility.

Your strong reaction to criticism could be rooted, if unconsciously, in old ideas about how women should use their voices.

Knowing how many women we lost from the workplace due to 2020’s “She-cession,” demolishing bias is more important now than it’s ever been. And it can be insidious, affecting our opinions of others even when we think we’re doing everything we can to be a good and supportive ally — and it can affect both women and men.

Fighting Bias First, take your temperature on the feedback itself. Examine how you would feel about it if it came from a male coworker at the same level as the woman who offered it. How would you feel? Would it seem less harsh? More par for the course?

Convenience Store News is pleased to continue this series of educational columns by the Network of Executive Women (NEW), coinciding with the annual CSNews Top Women in Convenience awards given out each fall. Seventy-four female managers, executives and directors who work in the convenience store industry are being honored in our 2021 program. In addition to being a presentation sponsor for the Top Women in Convenience program, NEW and CSNews have partnered to develop this series of columns directed at helping corporate leaders drive more inclusive company cultures. 2021 SPONSORS Founding & Presenting Sponsor:

This isn’t to say that all workplace behavior is appropriate, of course. True toxicity is poison to any workplace, and it’s worth analyzing whether the workplace around you is toxic in and of itself. Self-reflection doesn’t mean you should let bad behavior go unchecked; far from it. It just means a gut check is in order. Your strong reaction to criticism could be rooted, if unconsciously, in old ideas about how women should use their voices. For us all to push the cause of women forward, we must look inward and let go of the preconceptions that limit the potential for women to shine as leaders. CSN

Platinum Sponsor:

Gold Sponsors:

Sarah Alter is president and CEO of the Network of Executive Women, a nonprofit learning, leadership and gender equality advocacy organization of 13,500 members (representing nearly 900 organizations), 300-plus national and regional corporate partners, and 22 regional groups in the United States and Canada. NEW advances gender equality and diversity in the retail, consumer goods, financial services and technology industries. Editor’s note: The opinions expressed in this column are the author’s and do not necessarily reflect the views of Convenience Store News.

Silver Sponsors:

S E P T E MB E R

20 21

Convenience Store News 121

STORE SPOTLIGHT

Foodservice First FriendShip Kitchen is making an impact in the competitive Columbus market By Don Longo

in convenience store foodservice are often focused on the largest chains. However, Tim Powell, managing principal of foodservice consulting firm FoodserviceIP, points out the real opportunity for growth lies among medium-sized chains that are aggressively increasing their foodservice profile and changing the way consumers think about c-store food.

THE GROWTH AND OPPORTUNITIES

At a Glance

FriendShip Kitchen Size: Two formats, 5,000 and 5,500 square feet Location: Columbus, Ohio Unique features: Restaurant-quality food, including FriendShip Famous Chicken; a spacious, modern retail environment; open kitchen; walk-in beer cave; touchfree airportstyle bathrooms

“Where is the growth? Mid-tier concepts that are growing their footprints,” Powell told Convenience Store News during a recent visit to the hypercompetitive Columbus, Ohio, market that includes Duchess Stores, GetGo, United Dairy Farmers, Speedway, Marathon and, most recently, Sheetz, which announced plans to open as many as 50 stores in the area. FriendShip, the retail division of Fremont, Ohio-based Beck Suppliers, represents the type of midsized retailer that is using foodservice and a strong corporate culture to differentiate itself and grow in this heartland market. The company, which also operates a thriving fuel distribution business to hundreds of independent dealers, a propane and heating oil division, a fuel transport

122 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

business and a facilities division that builds and maintains fueling facilities and car washes, introduced its food-first FriendShip Kitchen brand concept in 2018. FriendShip Kitchen features restaurantquality food, including FriendShip Famous Chicken, fuel and a spacious modern retail environment, complete with a walk-in beer cave, open kitchen and touchfree airport-style bathrooms. FriendShip Kitchen now accounts for 15 of the retailer’s 28 stores, which stretch from the shores of Lake Erie, from Toledo to Cleveland. “Culture is the most important thing to our company. The key is getting the culture right,” said FriendShip President Greg Ehrlich, who sat down with CSNews at the company’s store in Lewis Center, about 20 miles north of downtown Columbus. Ehrlich, an industry veteran who previously served in leadership positions with Duchess Shoppes and Certified Oil, said FriendShip is focused on three main things: “Culture, brand, and data analytics.” Note that he listed culture first. Since

FriendShip President Greg Ehrlich presents store manager Kim Branham with the company’s prestigious 2021 Golden Chicken Award.

2012, the company’s mantra has been WACS, short for Wicked Awesome Customer Service. Under its employee recognition program, FriendShip hosts can win tickets to events and prizes valued at up to $1,500 for providing WACS. During CSNews’ visit, Ehrlich presented store manager Kim Branham with the company’s prestigious 2021 Golden Chicken Award. Branham has worked for FriendShip for 21 years, previously serving as general manager at stores in New Haven and Sandusky, Ohio. “Kim’s selflessness to move to Columbus to bring our culture to a new market has led to incredible results,” said Ehrlich. “Our guests rave about our food and service the same in this market as they do across our legacy market in northern Ohio.” Branham proudly showed off hundreds of sneaker stickers on her store’s walls denoting donations made by customers to support the Juvenile Diabetes Research Foundation (JDRF). “There’s a reason our name is FriendShip,” said Ehrlich, noting that the third-generation company’s co-owners Brian and Dean Beck have always placed a high priority on giving back to the community. The Beck family is noted for its philanthropy in the state of Ohio. The company donates and raises more than $500,000 annually, with its showcase event being a JDRF Poker Run, headed up by Kevin Campbell, director of operations. “This is our 12th annual JDRF Poker Run and we will raise over $50,000 this year,” noted Campbell. “We are so proud of all the company employees and their families who donate their time to make this event such a success.”

Building the Brand As Powell pointed out, midsized convenience retailers are really taking a strong position with foodservice. And that’s certainly the case with FriendShip. Through word of mouth and strategic brand marketing, the retailer has established a name for itself and for

its famous chicken (both regular and spicy), thick-cut fries and savory-crust pizza, Ehrlich said. In 2017, the company brought in former Wawa foodservice executive Ed Burcher to develop the FriendShip Kitchen concept. “Originally, we started with a conventional frozen chicken product from a traditional convenience store supplier, but we decided that if we are going to build this concept around FriendShip Famous Chicken, we would sell fresh, hand-battered chicken,” Ehrlich recalled. Kirk Matthews, formerly of TravelCenters of America, succeeded Burcher in April 2020. An established operations executive with a personable and values-driven leadership style, Matthews is now bringing his experience to expanding the Kitchen concept. Adding to the company’s experienced executive leadership team, Justin Jeffers was recently hired as vice president of fuel supply and logistics. Beck Suppliers was founded in 1950 by Virgil Beck, who sold fuel to farmers. Brothers Brian and Dean now run the company with three fourth-generation family members: Olivia Beck, Chelsea Carvalho and Luiz Carvalho, who are learning the business from the ground up. Ehrlich said FriendShip plans to continue its expansion. A new FriendShip Kitchen store is due to open soon in Marysville, a suburb northwest of Columbus. “We want to be Ohio’s No. 1 convenience store,” he said. “That doesn’t mean we want to be the biggest. Our goal is to be Ohio’s best in all of our core business divisions.” Asked about the company’s biggest challenge, Ehrlich is less worried about the intense competition in the market than he is about maintaining the workplace culture. “We don’t want to outgrow the culture,” he said. CSN S E P T E MBE R

20 21

Convenience Store News 123

HOT PRODUCTS SPECIAL ADVERTISING SECTION

ATM’s

124 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

CSN_Class_Sep_2021.indd 2

9/2/2021 9:00:15 PM

HOT PRODUCTS

Digital Smart Labels for C-stores

S E P T E MB E R

CSN_Class_Sep_2021.indd 3

SPECIAL ADVERTISING SECTION

2021

Convenience Store News

125

9/2/2021 9:00:15 PM

HOT PRODUCTS SPECIAL ADVERTISING SECTION

Beef Jerky

126 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

CSN_Class_Sep_2021.indd 4

9/2/2021 9:00:16 PM

HOT PRODUCTS

Car Wash Services

S E P T E MB E R

CSN_Class_Sep_2021.indd 5

SPECIAL ADVERTISING SECTION

2021

Convenience Store News

127

9/2/2021 9:00:17 PM

HOT PRODUCTS SPECIAL ADVERTISING SECTION

CBD Products Services

C-Store Displays

128 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

CSN_Class_Sep_2021.indd 6

9/2/2021 9:00:17 PM

HOT PRODUCTS SPECIAL ADVERTISING SECTION

Gourmet Pet Treats

ATM’s

S E P T E MBE R

CSN_Class_Sep_2021.indd 7

2021

Convenience Store News

129

9/2/2021 9:00:17 PM

HOT PRODUCTS SPECIAL ADVERTISING SECTION

Kiosk Pre- Paid Services

Legal Lean Syrup

130 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

CSN_Class_Sep_2021.indd 8

9/2/2021 9:00:18 PM

HOT PRODUCTS

POS/Equipment/Supplies

SPECIAL ADVERTISING SECTION

General Merchandise

S E P T E MBE R

CSN_Class_Sep_2021.indd 9

2021

Convenience Store News

131

9/2/2021 9:00:18 PM

HOT PRODUCTS

Age Verifier

Spill Response Solutions

Looking for ideas to promote your product or services? Need help creating an ad that fits your needs without spending a fortune with an advertising agency?

We are here to help, whether it be in the classified ad section, an ad in the main pages, or online. Call or email with any questions or for pricing. We can handle all aspects of your ad from conception to print in a fraction of the cost that agences charge!

Our ads get results! CALL TERRY KANGANIS TODAY-

201.855.7615

tkanganis@ensembleIQ.com 132 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

CSN_Class_Sep_2021.indd 10

9/2/2021 9:00:18 PM

CLASSIFIEDS

Credit Card Processing / Merchant Services

S E P T E MBE R

CSN_Class_Sep_2021.indd 11

2021

Convenience Store News

133

9/2/2021 9:00:19 PM

CLASSIFIEDS

Ecigs/Vape Products

134 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

CSN_Class_Sep_2021.indd 12

9/2/2021 9:00:19 PM

CLASSIFIEDS

Credit Card Processing / Merchant Services

S E P T E MB E R

CSN_Class_Sep_2021.indd 13

2021

Convenience Store News

135

9/2/2021 9:00:20 PM

CLASSIFIEDS

Pet Treats

Why not?...

50% of your customers own a dog. Gross profit margins average 40%. Our retail prices are 30-50% below the big box pet stores. Our product variety and quality offers a selection for any type of dog. Our wooden display case is handmade in our Michigan workshop and brings attention to itself. Now Offering: Natural Dog Biscuits in 8 Flavors- Venison, Bison, Elk, Rabbit, Peanut Butter, Ham, Salmon, and Venison Dental. AND a Pig Ear Dump Bin.

IPPING FREE SHOUR ON Y ER! D FIRST OR

It pays to be Different.

3302 Associates Dr. Burton, MI 48529

For more information, call

810-715-4500 136 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

CSN_Class_Sep_2021.indd 14

9/2/2021 9:00:20 PM

CLASSIFIEDS

Cigar/Cigarillos

OTP Products

S E P T E MBE R

CSN_Class_Sep_2021.indd 15

2021

Convenience Store News

137

9/2/2021 9:00:20 PM

CLASSIFIEDS

Services

138 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

CSN_Class_Sep_2021.indd 16

9/2/2021 9:00:22 PM

CLASSIFIEDS

Air Vacs

ATMs

S E P T E MBE R

CSN_Class_Sep_2021.indd 17

2021

Convenience Store News

139

9/2/2021 9:00:22 PM

CLASSIFIEDS

For Sale

of retailers

who read Convenience Store News do so because they want to find out about new products. Reach those important hard to reach retailers by advertising here in the Hot Products Section of Convenience Store News by contacting:

Terry Kanganis EnsembleIQ at:

. 201-855-7615 for more details

Looking for ideas to promote your product or services? Need help creating an ad that fits your needs without spending a fortune with an advertising agency?

Our ads get results! CALL TERRY KANGANIS TODAY-

201.855.7615

tkanganis@ensembleIQ.com

140 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

CSN_Class_Sep_2021.indd 18

9/2/2021 9:00:22 PM

CLASSIFIEDS

Plastics

Air Vacs

S E P T E MB E R

CSN_Class_Sep_2021.indd 19

2021

Convenience Store News

141

9/2/2021 9:00:23 PM

CLASSIFIEDS

ATMs

Age Verifier

ATM’s

142 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

CSN_Class_Sep_2021.indd 20

9/2/2021 9:00:23 PM

CLASSIFIEDS

Petroleum/Equiment

Sunglasses

Credit Card Processing

S E P T E MBE R

CSN_Class_Sep_2021.indd 21

2021

Convenience Store News

143

9/2/2021 9:00:23 PM

CLASSIFIEDS

EMV Compliance Services

Wholesale Refrigeration

ADINDEX Add Systems.......................................111 Altria Group Distribution.................2 Anheuser-Busch LLC.........................37 APAX Group, Inc................................47 Autofry/MTI, Inc.................................68 BIC USA Inc.........................................7 Black Buffalo.......................................69 Calico Brands......................................66 Cash Cloud Inc DBA Coin Cloud....113 CB Distributors Inc............................57 Charlotte’s Web.................................103 Chevron Corporation........................95 Community Coffee Company.........73 Dairyfood USA....................................79 Diebold Nixdorf Inc...........................115 E&J Gallo Winery...............................51 E-Alternative Solutions....................86–87 E.A. Sween Company........................61 EPTA America.....................................75 Essentia Water....................................5 FIFCO USA..........................................45 Forte Products....................................70 Furmano Foods..................................49 Geloso Beverage Group LLC...........42–43 GLK Foods...........................................81 GlaxoSmithKline Consumer Health Care..........................................41 Hemp Fusion, Inc...............................105 Hughes Network Systems................109

Invenco.................................................101 Island Lifestyle Importers................96–97 ITG Brands...........................................147 Johnsonville........................................63 Krispy Krunchy Chicken...................83 Liggett Vector Brands......................89 Living Essentials LLC........................13 Mad Tasty.............................................72 McLane Company..............................148 Molson Coors......................................55 Nestle Professional............................27 Prairie City Bakery.............................71 Premier Manufacturing.....................90–91 Swedish Match North America.......1, 9, 17, 93 Swisher International, Inc................9, 73 The Boston Beer Company..............28–31 The Coca-Cola Company.................11 The Hershey Company.....................53 The Wonderful Company/ Fiji Water.............................................15 Transact Technologies Inc...............85 Tyson Foods........................................65 United Sign Co....................................Outsert Universal Merchant Services...........Outsert Uno Foods...........................................77 Van’s Kitchen......................................59 Vita Coco Water.................................19, 117 VOSS Water.........................................39 WorkJam..............................................107

8550 W. Bryn Mawr Ave, Suite 200, Chicago, IL 60631 Phone 773-992-4450 Fax 773-992-4455 www.ensembleiq.com

144 Convenience Store News C S N E W S . c o m

CSN_Class_Sep_2021.indd 22

9/2/2021 9:00:24 PM

35th ANNUAL

NOVEMBER 11, 2021

PRESENTED BY

DES MOINES, IOWA

ANNOUNCING...

From the most established brand in the convenience store retailer space comes one of the highest honors in the industry: the Convenience Store News Hall of Fame. This is a must-attend gala event with some of the most inﬂuential retailers and suppliers in the c-store industry in attendance, honoring some of the industry’s most admired retailer and supplier executives.

4 REASONS TO SPONSOR THE CSNEWS HALL OF FAME EVENT: • • • •

Strengthen and develop industry relationships Be known as a leader in the industry Gain visibility for your brand and products Reach retail and supplier executives and key decision-makers

Hall of Fame is an intimate awards gala reception, dinner and award ceremony celebrating the induction of outstanding men and women who have exhibited exceptional leadership and provided signiﬁcant contributions to the convenience store industry.

2021 HONOREES

RETAILER HALL OF FAME

Kyle Krause

Founder and CEO Krause Group (Kum & Go)

SUPPLIER HALL OF FAME

Vito Maurici

Senior Vice President of Sales & Trade Relations McLane Co.

RETAILER EXECUTIVE OF THE YEAR

Kevin Smartt CEO TXB (formerly Kwik Chek)

2021 SPONSORS

AND FEATURING OUR EXCLUSIVE

Join us as we help nurture and celebrate the exceptional leaders of tomorrow in the convenience store industry. The Convenience Store News Future Leaders in Convenience program celebrates and develops the next generation of convenience retail leaders by providing a forum for talented young business people to hone their leadership talent while recognizing the achievements of an emerging leaders under the age of 35 at the time of nomination. The CSNews Future Leaders in Convenience program provides a comprehensive workshop and networking program that teaches young convenience store managers and executives how to achieve their full potential as leaders in their organizations and the industry at large.

FLIC Founding and Presenting Sponsor

For more sponsorship information please contact

Paula Lashinsky, VP/Publisher, plashinsky@ensembleiq.com

INSIDE THE CONSUMER MIND

Serving the Customer Fueled by the pandemic, the world of c-store services has significantly expanded “Checking out” used to mean one thing: waiting in line, going up to a register staffed by an employee, and paying for the goods you wanted to purchase. Today, “checking out” has multiple meanings in the convenience store space: it can mean mobile ordering/payment and picking up goods curbside; it can mean online ordering/payment and getting goods delivered; it can mean self-checkout at an in-store kiosk; it can mean contactless checkout powered by sensors placed throughout the store; and the list goes on and on. Fueled by the COVID-19 pandemic, the ways in which c-stores serve the customer have significantly expanded. The 2021 Convenience Store News Realities of the Aisle Study, which surveyed 1,500-plus consumers who shop a c-store at least once a month, uncovered the following insights around c-store services:

Convenience store shoppers are almost equally split when it comes to checkout at a register with human interaction vs.

47% Self-checkout

53% At register with human interaction

Preferred Checkout Method

self-checkout with no interaction. Human interaction gets a slight edge.

59%

of shoppers regularly use at least one expanded service at convenience stores

Usage of Specific Services at Convenience Stores ATM

29%

Bill pay

Car wash

15%

Check cashing

Self-checkout

14%

Curbside pickup 6%

Mobile payment

12%

Video games

Drive-thru

11%

DVD rental

Internet access/Wi-Fi

10%

Pick-up lockers

Mobile ordering

Postal services

Money order

Coin counting

Home delivery

Copy/fax

Nearly six in 10 c-store shoppers regularly use at least one “expanded service” at convenience stores. ATM and car wash continue to be mainstays in the channel, but newer services such as self-checkout, mobile payment and drive-thru round out the top five.

Consumers give strong satisfaction scores to all the services offered at c-stores, with contactless checkout using AI sensors topping the list at 90% very satisfied or satisfied. Very satisfied/satisfied Neutral Very unsatisfied/unsatisfied

146 Convenience Store News CSNEWS.com

Satisfaction Using Service at Convenience Stores Contactless using AI sensors Order online, pickup in-store Mobile coupon/discount

90%

10%

88% 86%

Drive-thru

85%

13%

Home delivery

84%

15%

Order online, pickup curbside

82%

10%

Mobile pay at pump

81%

12%

Mobile pay in-store

80%

Contactless using kiosk

78%

Contactless using app

77%

17% 16% 16%

3% 5% 7%

FOR TRADE PURPOSES ONLY

CIGARS

98188_DutchLeaf_TradeAd-ConvenienceDistribution_FP_V1.indd 1

2021-08-19 9:40 AM

McLANE’S TECHNOLOGY WILL POWER YOU FORWARD McLane understands the competitive advantage technology can provide, and we’ve made substantial investments in building technology solutions to address the specific needs of c-stores. Our hardware and software solutions help our customers improve order accuracy, reduce labor costs, optimize inventory, and increase margins, just to name a few advantages. From the corporate office to the back office, McLane offers the technology solutions that help retailers buy better, sell smarter, and profit more.

To learn more about McLane’s innovative technology solutions for c-stores, visit mclaneco.com/technology

CSN-0921

Articles inside

The Myth of the Critical Female Boss

Foodservice First

The NACS Show Is Back

CBD in the C-store

Remaining Relevant

Barbecue Trends

CSNews Online

Overcoming Adversity With Innovation

New Products

Stepping Up

U.S. Senate Passes $1T Infrastructure Bill

The Art of the Steal

Convenience & Fuel Retailers Begin to See Impact of Outdoor EMV Liability Shift

C-stores Moving to Forefront of Business Innovation