111 Backspace / Reviews XIFSF B HSPVQ PG XPSLFST JT NPWJOH MFGUXBSE BOE CSFBLJOH GSPN B QBSUJDVMBS SFGPSNJTN XF NBZ QBSUJDJQBUF JO TVDI B QBSUZ QPTTJCMZ TUBOE BT B DBOEJEBUF PS HJWF DSJUJDBM TVQQPSU 5IJT JT BMXBZT UIPVHI PO UIF CBTJT PG PQFO DPNNVOJTU QPMJUJDT :PV EP OPU DPOWJODF PUIFST PG UIF XJTEPN PG ZPVS WJFXT CZ EJTHVJTJOH UIFN PS QSFUFOEJOH UP CF TPNFUIJOH PUIFS UIBO ZPV BSF *G BU ¾STU JU TFFNT TPNFXIBU HSBUJGZJOH UIBU UIF MBUF %BOJFM #FOTBuE JO UIF ¾STU DIBQUFS PG UIJT CPPL JT BSHVJOH GPS BO ²JOUSBOTJHFOU BOUJ DBQJUBMJTN³ JU JT EJTBQQPJOUJOH CVU QSFEJDUBCMF UIBU UIJT JOUSBOTJHFOU BOUJ DBQJUBMJTN JT BSHVFE GPS XJUIPVU PODF NFOUJPOJOH SFWPMVUJPO PS XPSLJOH DMBTT QPXFS "MBJO ,SJWJOFµT BSUJDMF BCPVU UIF 'SFODI /FX "OUJDBQJUBMJTU 1BSUZ /1" JT POF PG UIF NPSF JOUFSFTUJOH BOE EFUBJMFE 8SJUUFO BU UIF CFHJOOJOH PG UXP ZFBST BGUFS UIF /1"µT GPVOEBUJPO JU QPJOUT VQ NBOZ PG UIF HSPXJOH QSPCMFNT JO UIF /1" #VU UIFTF BSF MBSHFMZ USFBUFE BT MBSHFMZ PSHBOJTBUJPOBM POFT SBUIFS TZNQUPNT PG B QBSUZ SFRVJSJOH B QPMJUJDBM BOE TUSBUFHJD DIBOHF PG DPVSTF )F EFTDSJCFT JUT GPVOEJOH EPDVNFOU B EPDVNFOU UIBU BSHVFE BHBJOTU BOZ QPTTJCJMJUZ PG ²SFGPSNJOH³ PS ²EFNPDSBUJTJOH³ DBQJUBMJTN CVU SBUIFS EFDMBSFE UIF OFFE UP ²SFWPMVUJPOJTF TPDJFUZ³ )PXFWFS IF UIFO QPJOUT PVU UIBU ²BMM UIF TUSBUFHJD EFCBUF BCPVU UBLJOH QPXFS USBOTJUJPOBM EFNBOET EVBM QPXFS FUD³ XFSF MFGU ²PQFO GPS GVUVSF EJTDVTTJPO³ B EJTDVTTJPO UIBU JU JT DMFBS OFWFS IBQQFOFE B TUSBUFHZ GPS BDUVBMMZ SFWPMVUJPOJTJOH TPDJFUZ BOE UBLJOH QPXFS OFWFS SFTPMWFE )F EFTDSJCFT B MBSHJTI QBSUZ PG NFNCFST BU JUT MBVODI PG XIPN XFSF -$3 NFNCFST CFDPNJOH B WFSZ MPPTF BOE EJSFDUJPOMFTT QBSUZ UIBU XBT VOBCMF FWFO UP FOGPSDF EFNPDSBUJDBMMZ SFBDIFE NBKPSJUZ EFDJTJPOT 8JUI MJUUMF DFOUSBM EJSFDUJPO B QPPSMZ TPME XFFLMZ QBQFS BOE FSSBUJD BUUFOEBODF BU JUT MPDBM NFFUJOHT ²BQBSU GSPN B OFUXPSL PG TFWFSBM IVOESFE NJMJUBOUT XIP QSPWJEF QFSNBOFODF BOE DPOUJOVJUZ³ UIF QBSUZ ESJGUFE "HBJO UIF PCTFTTJPO XJUI FMFDUJPOT BOE NBLJOH FMFDUJPO CMPDT page 46 / permanentrevolution
GPS OBUJPOBM BOE &VSPQFBO FMFDUJPOT EPNJOBUFT UIF EJTDVTTJPO :FU JU XBT WFSZ DPODSFUF QPMJUJDBM QSPCMFNT IPX UP SFTQPOE UP UIF 'SFODI TUBUFµT BUUBDLT PO UIF SJHIUT PG SFMJHJPVT NJOPSJUJFT UIF CBOOJOH PG SFMJHJPVT ESFTT JO TDIPPMT BOE UIF WFJM JO QVCMJD QMBDFT XIJDI UPSF JOUP UIF /1" *U XBT JODBQBCMF PG DPNJOH VQ XJUI BO BHSFFE QPTJUJPO PO UIF SFMBUJPO CFUXFFO SFMJHJPO BOE TUBUF PS FWFO QFSTPOBM SFMJHJPVT CFMJFG BOE CFJOH B NFNCFS PG UIF /1" "T B SFTVMU JU TUBHHFSFE GSPN DSJTJT UP DSJTJT MPTJOH NFNCFST IBOE PWFS ¾TU /POF PG UIJT HFUT B NFOUJPO JO ,SJWJOFµT BDDPVOU NBZCF CFDBVTF UIF EFQUI PG UIF DSJTJT POMZ CFDBNF BQQBSFOU BGUFS JU XBT XSJUUFO "T B SFTVMU ,SJWJOF QBJOUT B SFMBUJWFMZ PQUJNJTUJD QJDUVSF PG UIF EFWFMPQJOH /1" )F MJHIUMZ EJTNJTTFT EJGGFSFODFT PWFS IPX UP SFMBUF UP UIF TQMJU GSPN UIF 4PDJBMJTU 1BSUZ XIBU CFDBNF +FBO -VD .nMFODIPOµT 'SPOU EF (BVDIF 1( ° -FGU 'SPOU FWFO EFDMBSJOH PG .nMFODIPOµT HSPVQJOH ²5SBQQFE CFUXFFO UIF 1$' BOE UIF /1" UIF 1( SJTLT EJTBQQFBSJOH CZ SFNBJOJOH BMPOF ³ 3BSFMZ IBT B QSFEJDUJPO CFFO QSPWFE TP XSPOH TP RVJDLMZ )BWJOH SFNBJOFE ²BMPOF³ JO UIF SFDFOU QSFTJEFOUJBM FMFDUJPOT JU JT UIF /1" XIJDI JT JO EBOHFS PG EJTBQQFBSJOH 5IF POF DIBQUFS UIBU TIJOFT PVU BCPWF UIF PUIFST JT UIF POF CZ 4BMWBUPSF $BOOBWP BCPVU UIF WBSJPVT GBJMVSFT BT IF QVUT JU PG *UBMZµT $PNNVOJTU 3FGPVOEBUJPO 13$ $BOOBWP TFFT UIF GBJMVSF PG UIF 13$ JO QSFDJTFMZ UIF GBJMVSF UP CSFBL GSPN ²CVSFBVDSBUJD NFUIPET ESJWFO CZ CBTF BNCJUJPO³ 5IF BJN PG DPNNVOJTU QPMJUJDT TIPVMEOµU CF UP XJO QPXFS GPS ²B QBSUJDVMBS UZQF PG QFSTPO TFMFDUFE GPS UIFJS MPZBMUZ PWFS ZFBST³ CVU UP XJO QPXFS GPS UIF NBTT PG UIF XPSLJOH DMBTT ° OPU GPS B OFX CVSFBVDSBUJD CPTT UP HJWF UIF NBTTFT PSEFST CVU UP IBWF BO FOE UP CPTTFT 4PDJBMJTN TIPVME CF BCPVU NBYJNVN BVUPOPNZ BOE JOEJWJEVBM GSFFEPN BOE XIFSF EFDJTJPOT OFFE UP CF DPMMFDUJWF BCPVU NBYJNVN EFNPDSBDZ BOE VOJUFE BDUJPO 5IF SFQFBUFE BOE SFQFUJUJWF GBJMVSFT PG TPDJBMJTN IBWF CFFO JO $BOOBWPµT XPSET ²B QPMJUJDBM EJTBTUFS BGGFDUJOH NJMMJPOT PG QFPQMF
BOE JOWPMWJOH UFOT PG UIPVTBOET PG NJMJUBOUT NFNCFST BOE MFBEFST PG TIJQXSFDLFE QBSUJFT ³ 8IBU NBUUFST JT OPU B EJWFSTJUZ PG PQJOJPO PO UIF MFGU CVU UIF DPNQMFUF EJTMPDBUJPO PG UIF MFGU GSPN ¾HIUJOH GPS UIF CVSOJOH OFFET BOE DPODFSOT PG XPSLJOH DMBTT DPNNVOJUJFT CMJHIUFE CZ BVTUFSJUZ PQQSFTTJPO BOE UIF DMBTT XBS PG UIF CPVSHFPJT EFUFSNJOFE UP FYUSBDU QSP¾U 5IF MFGU $BOOBWP PCTFSWFT XSJUJOH PG UIF 13$ CVU QFSUJOFOU UP B NVDI XJEFS DPOTUJUVFODZ IBT ²BO BCTFODF PG B DVMUVSF PG EFCBUF³ MFU BMPOF QSPHSBNNBUJD DMBSJUZ ²5IF QBSUZ SBOL BOE ¾MF XBT UPTTFE BSPVOE OPU SFBMMZ HSBTQJOH XIBU XBT HPJOH PO BOE PGUFO JODBQBCMF PG EFWFMPQJOH B DPVOUFS UFOEFODZ³ UP UIF 13$ MFBEFSTIJQ ²-JUUMF CZ MJUUMF EFDJTJPO NBLJOH CFDBNF EFMFHBUFE VQXBSET UIF OBUJPOBM BOE MPDBM MFBEFST UPPL PO UIF QSFQPOEFSBOU SPMF BOE XFSF PGUFO BU UIF TBNF UJNF UIF JOTUJUVUJPOBM SFQSFTFOUBUJWFT PG UIF QBSUZ 5IF UFSSJCMF UIJOH XBT UIBU UIF DFOUSBM BQQBSBUVT PGUFO LOFX MJUUMF PS OPUIJOH BCPVU IPX UP MFBE B NBTT QPMJUJDBM JOUFSWFOUJPO ³ 5IF EJTVOJUZ PG UIF MFGU NBUUFST BU UIF MFWFM PG BDUJPO *G UIF MFGU IBT UFO PS FWFO B IVOESFE EJGGFSFOU HSPVQT UIJT JT PG OP DPODFSO BT MPOH BT UIFSF JT CPUI VOJUZ JO BDUJPO BOE BO PQFO WJCSBOU DVMUVSF PG EJTDVTTJPO EFNPDSBDZ BOE DPMMFDUJWF EFDJTJPO NBLJOH 6OUJM UIF MFGU VOMFBSOT UIF IJTUPSZ PG CVSFBVDSBDZ QFUUZ TRVBCCMJOH BSSPHBODF BOE CJUUFS JO¾HIUJOH JU XJMM KVTUJ¾BCMZ SFNBJO TNBMM BOE JOFGGFDUJWF 5IJT CPPL HJWFT TPNF JOUFSFTUJOH FYBNQMFT JO IPX UIF MFGU IBT OPU ZFU MFBSOU UIPTF MFTTPOT BOE JO BU MFBTU $BOOBWPµT DIBQUFS TPNF VTFGVM JEFBT PO IPX UP QSPDFFE CZ SFGPVOEJOH B TPDJBMJTU DVMUVSF CBTFE PO HJWJOH QPXFS UP UIF CBTF UP UIF NJMMJPOT UP UIF NJMJUBOUT OPU UIF CVSFBVDSBUT #VU UIF QVSQPTF PG UIF CPPL PWFSBMM JT UP QFEEMF UIF 'PVSUI *OUFSOBUJPOBMµT EJTBTUSPVT TUSBUFHZ PG ²¾MMJOH UIF TQBDF³ UP UIF MFGU PG SFGPSNJTN XJUI NPSF SFGPSNJTU QBSUJFT *U JT BO PQQPSUVOJTU SFDJQF GPS EJTBTUFS NPTU DMFBSMZ EFNPOTUSBUFE CZ UIF *UBMJBO FYBNQMF Jason Travis