Comment
netdaily.net.au
North Coast news daily:
Will Milne’s deal lose green votes?
Volume 28 #27
December 10, 2013
Aunty threatened It is reasonable enough that our national broadcaster the ABC should be held to account for its editorial decisions. Its own program, Media Watch, does just that, sometimes in withering fashion. But it should be allowed to make those decisions without being threatened by third-rate bovver boys. Rather than take responsibility for our spying on our neighbours, PM Tony Abbott found it sorrowful that the ABC should report the news. The Libs then sent in their attack dog, Senator Cory Bernardi, to suggest the ABC’s funding should be cut and its power limited to stop it hurting Fairfax Media and News Corp’s bottom line – read the background at http://bit.ly/abccorey. It’s unusual that free marketers should abandon the law of the jungle so that Rupert Murdoch might flourish, but Bernardi is notorious for suggesting that homosexuality leads on to bestiality, so how much rationality can you expect? Why, that’s as silly as suggesting being a member of the Liberal Party leads on to fascism. Naturally there has been a backlash from ABC supporters. The local branch of Friends of the ABC meets this Saturday December 14 at Bangalow Bowlo at 11am to take up the issue. You could add your voice to theirs, write to MPs and sign various petitions such as GetUp’s. We are fortunate in Australia that the ABC as a government-funded body is no nationalistic mouthpiece but a fine investigator of important issues and disseminator of inspiring, provocative ideas. Not many countries have the privilege of such a service and its independence deserves protection from politicians who can’t handle the truth. Michael McDonald
The Byron Shire Echo Established 1986 General Manager Simon Haslam Editor Hans Lovejoy Photographer Jeff Dawson Advertising Manager Stuart Amos Production Manager Ziggi Browning
Nicholas Shand 1948–1996 Founding Editor
‘The job of a newspaper is to comfort the afflicted and afflict the comfortable.’ – Finley Peter Dunne 1867–1936 © 2013 Echo Publications Pty Ltd – ABN 86 004 000 239 Mullumbimby: Village Way, Stuart St. Ph 02 6684 1777 Fax 02 6684 1719 Byron Bay: Level 1, Byron Community Centre, 69 Jonson St. Ph 6685 5222 Printer: Horton Media Australia Ltd Reg. by Aust. Post Pub. No. NBF9237
Enrol by 20th December to study in 2014 and save up to $800! Check out our Early Bird Prices for Cert III in Aged Care (CHC30212) Cert III in Permaculture (30868QLD) Cert IV in Training & Assessment (TAE40110) Diploma of Vocational Education & Training (TAE50111) Cert IV in Small Business Management (BSB40407) Cert III in Visual Arts (CUV30111)
Limited spaces available
For more information call 02 6684 3374 www.byroncollege.org.au 12 December 10, 2013 The Byron Shire Echo
T
he Abbott government has no shame. This is hardly news but it is good to see it confirmed, yet again, by the deal with the Greens to abolish the debt ceiling in exchange for some largely meaningless and easily avoided undertakings about transparency. This time last year dealing with the Greens in any form was akin to selling your political soul. Julia Gillard’s alliance, first with Bob Brown and then, less comfortably, with his successor Christine Milne, was excoriated, anathematised by Abbott and his colleagues; no sane or decent person could associate with these fanatical destroyers of Australia’s wealth and freedom. Even after Milne formally dissolved the alliance the attacks continued: the Greens had invaded the Gillard government like a malign, alien parasite and were still controlling their hapless and gullible hosts. The Greens were the enemy of all the Australian way of life; it was as simple as that. Any contact, however fleeting and superficial, risked contamination. And dealing with them was invariably and irrevocably lethal. But only, apparently, for a Labor government. The hardy conservatives are immune. And anyway, it is all about outcomes, the end justifies the means. So our dauntless Treasurer Joe Hockey had no real hesitation in following the Faustian example. And the pact he made was almost entirely one-sided; it did not even require his signature in blood. The debt ceiling was no more; never again would he have to go begging to parliament for a rise, or endure the taunting and posturing of an understandably cynical opposition which had endured three years of thundering about the horrors of debt and deficit. The economic crisis was offi-
cially over, and so was the political one which had accompanied it. It was the first real win for the government since its election, and Hockey and Abbott had every right to feel smug about it. Hypocrisy, shmypocrisy. Whatever it takes. There will be no sleepless nights on the government benches. But for the Greens, and for their leader in particular, it may not be quite so simple. Debt in itself has never been a real issue for them; the concept is fine, even desirable if it is used for long term projects, worthwhile purposes like improving infrastructure – sustainable
Australian Democrats, and he turned to their leader, Meg Lees. The Democrats had campaigned in 1998 under the slogan of No GST on Food, and Lees took this as a licence to negotiate, saying she could make a bad tax better. In fact exemptions destroyed the whole point of the tax, the efficiency resulting from its universality. However Lees demanded and received a number of concessions on what she called ‘the necessities of life’, a term which invited ever further widening of its inclusions. Eventually the list was finalised and Lees announced the Democrats
There will be no sleepless nights on the government benches in making a deal with the Greens. by Mungo MacCallum infrastructure that is, and the promises of reporting to parliament and justifying government decisions look, at first glance at least, like a decent sort of quid pro quo. And by sitting down with Hockey, they have thrown off the label of being economic fringe dwellers; they have entered the political mainstream. But that may be exactly the problem; there is, after all, a terrible precedent. In 1999 John Howard was desperate to pass his Goods and Services Tax. His resurrection of the ‘never, ever’ GST had nearly seen him defeated at the 1998 election and his political credibility now depended on getting it through a hostile senate. Labor and the Greens were implacably opposed and to Howard’s dismay the independent Brian Harradine, on whose support Howard had been relying, also opposed it. His only hope was the
would support the new package. But many of her supporters were furious; some were opposed to the tax in any form and others felt Lees should have fought harder for items such as books to be exempted. The parliamentary party split: two of the nine Democrat senators, Natasha Stott-Despoja and Andrew Bartlett, crossed the floor to vote against the GST. Among the rank and file the reaction was wider and more vehement. They called a leadership spill, as the Democrats constitution allowed, and although Lees survived the first attempt, as second in 2001 saw her replaced by Stott-Despoja. A year later she resigned from the party altogether. The dispute was the beginning of the end. In the 2001 election the Democrats only lost one senator, but in 2004, after more leadership turmoil and grass roots disillusionment, they lost three. Of the remain-
ing four, two did not contest the 2007 election and the other two lost their seats. As a viable force the Democrats were finished. In hindsight, it was clear that the trigger for their decline was Lees’s agreement with Howard. He wooed her with the promise that it would make her party relevant, part of the processes of government. But that was precisely what rank and file Democrats did not want. They gloried in the fact that they were outsiders, unsullied by compromise. Their role was, in the words of their old slogan, to keep the (other) bastards honest. Lees should have been frustrating Howard, holding him to his 1996 promise that he would never, ever, introduce a GST. They felt betrayed and although many hoped that StottDespoja could restore the party’s political virginity, when she failed, they threw in the towel. Okay, the parallels are not exact: the Greens have a much more solid base than the Democrats and rather more resilience. And they are no longer pristine; by aligning with Gillard in 2010 they well and truly lost their innocence. But Abbott is not Gillard; he is, unequivocally the enemy. If Milne is to offer him and solace at all (and there will be many on the party who think that she should refuse to piss on him if he was on fire) then the price should be a steep one; after all, look at what Brown extracted from Gillard. At the very least, Milne’s deal will be the cause of a certain amount of dissension in the party, and she is not without rivals who will welcome the chance to undermine her. If she is again to sup with Abbott, she would be wise to take a longer spoon in future. Q See Mungo’s video at
THE ESSENTIAL CALENDAR FOR BYRON SHIRE LOCALS L R E IA FO C TH ENT AR E LO S D ES LEN SHIR CARON BY
Children’s Dentistry Mrs Rachel Andersson, BOralH (OHT) As a Dental Therapist, Rachel provides treatment LQFOXGLQJ ¿ OOLQJV WR FKLOGUHQ DQG DGROHVFHQWV XS WR the age of 18. Childhood is a very important period in a person’s ‘dental life’ and for this reason Rachel has a strong desire to provide children and parents with information about dental issues and help them change behaviours that may be destructive to the health of their mouth.
AL
S
BYRON SHIRE 2014 CALENDAR
GREAT GIFT IDEA!
o’s photogs local life by The Ech Selected slices of day format e on, Monday to Sun
writ listed ets ON BYR SHIR vals, events and mark E 2014 CALENDAR es All Byron Shire festi s and moon phas ays, schoolies date plus school holid
Easy to read and
Cape Byron, Overlooking Julian rocks and Little Wategos Beach. Photo Ziggi Browning
ECHO ANOTHER QUALITY
ONLY $15
Outlaw billy cart gangs infiltrate the Bangalow Billy Cart Derby. Photo Jeff Dawson
A beautiful part of the world – worth protecting. Photo Eve Jeffery
Icecream as facepaint
experimentation. Photo
Jeff Dawson
Beau Young and his board
check the break. Photo
Eve Jeffery
Michael Franti’s hokey-pokey gets out of hand at the Photo Jeff Dawson Bluesfest.
PUBLICATION
Woman’s aura becomes visible in Byron Bay sunset. Photo Ziggi Browning
The inaugural Boomerang Festival was a flaming success. Photo Eve Jeffery
Arrrr! The pirates have landed at the Brunswick Heads Rod Run. Photo Ziggi Browning
‘The Flycycle’ by Roundabout Theatre (www.roundabou getting ready for the Mullum t.net.au) Music Festival. Photo Jeff Dawson
www.echo.net.au
Even pink is permissible at the Living Earth Festival, Mullumbimby. Photo Jeff Dawson
Crop circle aliens overshoot the paddocks at Byron Photo Jeff Dawson Bay.
Rachel is fantastic with kids. Her friendly and sympathetic manner will make your child’s dental experience a positive one.
Selected slices of local life by The Echo’s photographers. Easy to read and write on
Available for treatment under the Child Dental %HQH¿ WV 6FKHGXOH &'%6 FRPPHQFLQJ -DQXDU\
Monday to Sunday format. All Byron Shire festivals, events and markets listed plus school holidays, schoolies dates, moon phases and more!
AVAILABLE NOW FROM THE ECHO OFFICES See it online at www.echo.net.au/ad/echo-calendar-2014
Byron Shire Echo archives: www.echo.net.au